California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 12, 2005

Student v. Simi Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1548-04 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Simi Valley Unified's 2004 IEP denied FAPE because of inadequate academic goals; partial reimbursement and 55 compensatory hours ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 9 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. During the hearing, the Hearing Officer granted Petitioner's motion to add goals and objectives as an issue and continued the hearing. The District's motions to dismiss Issues 1 and 3 were denied without prejudice. A counseling claim was withdrawn before opening statements.

Summary

A 17-year-old student eligible for special education under specific learning disability challenged Simi Valley Unified School District's 2004 assessment and its May 26, 2004 IEP. The IEP offered special day classes in four core subjects at Simi Valley High School, a one-to-one aide, two general education electives, four hours a week of after-school reading intervention, social skills instruction, and extended school year (ESY) services. His parents instead paid for one-to-one instruction at Yellen & Associates, a nonpublic school and agency.

The Hearing Officer found the reading assessment adequate and saw no need for a sensory or attention assessment. However, the District never followed through on the speech-language assessment it had agreed to at the IEP meeting. The IEP denied FAPE. Its reading, writing and academic math goals did not fit skills six or more years below grade level. The District also failed to show what its added reading and writing instruction or its summer program would involve. The campus placement and special day classes with an aide were appropriate, and Lindamood-Bell instruction was not required.

The parents were reimbursed for two Yellen & Associates instructors, mileage and an algebra book. They were not reimbursed for their consulting psychologist or for other instructors. The District must assess, hold a new IEP meeting by May 26, 2005, and fund 12 hours a week at Yellen & Associates until then. It must also provide compensatory summer services and 55 hours of one-to-one instruction.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The case shows how SEHO handled IEP goals that do not match a student's tested skill levels: weak goals alone were enough to deny FAPE, even though the placement itself was found appropriate. It also shows that a district had to prove what its offered intervention hours would actually involve.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 1. Has the District failed to properly assess Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability from May 2004 to the present? (Petitioner challenged the assessment in reading, sensory functioning/distractibility, and speech and language.)

    The assessment was adequate in reading, and no sensory or attention assessment was needed. But the District failed to timely provide a plan for, and carry out, the speech-language assessment it agreed to at the May 26, 2004 IEP meeting.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2a. Does the May 26, 2004 IEP offer a FAPE: are the goals and objectives inadequate? (issue added by granted motion to augment)

    The single reading comprehension goal, the business-letter writing goal, and the two academic math goals (calculator and algebra) did not address basic skill deficits six or more years below grade level. This alone was enough to deny FAPE.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2b. Is the proposed placement on a comprehensive high school campus inappropriate because Petitioner's sensory deficits and distractibility would prevent educational benefit?

    The student had no significant sensory needs, and his attention needs could be met on the Simi Valley High School campus, so the placement was appropriate.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2c. Is the SDC instructional setting for core subjects inappropriate because Petitioner would not benefit unless instruction is delivered one to one or in a very small group?

    Small-group special day classes with a one-to-one aide met his needs; he did not need exclusively or primarily one-to-one instruction.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2d. Does the IEP fail to provide adequate services to meet Petitioner's needs in sensory functioning, speech and language, reading, and written expression (regular year and 2004 ESY)?

    No sensory or speech-language services were shown to be needed, and Lindamood-Bell was not required. But the District failed to prove that its four weekly hours of reading intervention or its 2004 ESY offer were designed to meet his reading and written expression needs.

  6. Issue 3. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment conducted by psychologist Rhonda Glowalla in October 2004 and January 2005?

    The District's assessment was appropriate except for the missing speech-language assessment, which Glowalla's work did not address. Reimbursement of $1,025 was denied.

  7. Issue 4. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained educational materials and services, including related transportation, provided to him from September 2004 to the present?

    Reimbursement was ordered for the English/math instruction (Maga) and Lindamood-Bell instruction (Sidikaro) at Yellen & Associates, related mileage, and the algebra book. It was denied for history/science instruction and for the literature and history books.

  8. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education?

    Compensatory education was awarded for lost 2004 ESY services and lost history/science instruction, but it is to be provided by the District, not Yellen & Associates.

  9. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 6. Is Petitioner entitled to an order requiring the District to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing and offering a prospective placement?

    Prospective placement at Yellen & Associates, speech-language services, and OT were denied. The District must hold a new IEP meeting and fund 12 hours weekly at Yellen & Associates only in the interim; the Hearing Officer found the District 'substantially prevailed.'

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, the District must provide a proposed assessment plan that includes speech and language. Parents have at least 10 calendar days to give or withhold consent. The parties must cooperate to finish all assessments in time for the May 2005 annual IEP meeting.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Convene an annual review IEP meeting on or before May 26, 2005. The IEP must include appropriate goals and objectives in reading, written expression and math, and appropriate services in reading and written expression, consistent with the decision.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. District must fund continued placement at Yellen & Associates at 12 hours per week until the assessment plan and IEP meeting orders are fulfilled.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving an itemization, reimburse parents for services by Maria Maga and Yaffa Sidikaro from September 2004 to the decision date. Also reimburse mileage to and from Yellen & Associates on those instruction days at the District's mileage rate, plus the algebra book. No dollar amount was stated.
  • Compensatory education. A 2005 summer special education ESY program plus 25 hours of one-to-one intensive instruction in math and language arts. If the student otherwise qualifies for 2005 ESY, this portion may be provided during 2005-2006 or later as the parties agree.
  • Compensatory education. 30 hours of one-to-one direct instruction by a credentialed special education teacher in any core subject(s) the parents request. Hours are to be given immediately after the regular school day, on a schedule the parents agree to, and completed by the end of the 2005-2006 regular school year.

Total: 55 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Adams v. State of Oregon; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Dennis Carter, director of student support services, Simi Valley Unified School District
  • Chris Faucher, principal and teacher at the student's former private school, Countryside Preparatory School
  • Maria Maga, special education teacher (English and math, one-to-one), Yellen & Associates
  • Yaffa Sidikaro, Lindamood-Bell reading instructor, Yellen & Associates
  • Heidi Yellen, supervisor, Yellen & Associates
  • Pete Ferry, history instructor, Yellen & Associates
  • Raznik Galoostian, science instructor, Yellen & Associates
  • Rhonda Glowalla, school and educational psychologist; expert witness for Student, Retained by Petitioner
  • Dr. Gary Katz, clinical psychologist who evaluated the student; witness for Student, The Center for Attention Disorders
  • Jack Schnell, school psychologist (July 2002 assessment), Simi Valley Unified School District
  • Darrel Priebe, school psychologist (May 2004 assessment), Simi Valley Unified School District
  • Susan Roberts, program specialist, Simi Valley Unified School District
  • Martha Feinstein, program specialist / reading specialist; academic achievement assessor, Simi Valley Unified School District
  • Betsy Robinson, special day class science teacher, Simi Valley High School
  • Holly Dolliver, resource specialist; history special day class teacher, Simi Valley High School
  • Ginger DiRuscio, English and math special day class teacher, Simi Valley High School
  • Kristina Comitas, paralegal assisting Student's counsel
  • Yellen & Associates, nonpublic school and nonpublic agency
  • Countryside Preparatory School, private school
  • The Learning Center, private educational program
  • Ventura County Behavioral Health, county mental health agency (referral recommended)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Simi Valley, California, on January 25 and 26, and March 1, 2, 3, and 4, 2005.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrea Tytell, who was assisted at times by paralegal Kristina Comitas. STUDENT’s parents, MOTHER and FATHER, were also present.

Respondent Simi Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew Arczynski. Dennis Carter, the District’s director of student support services, was also present.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT and his parents; Chris Faucher, principal and teacher at Countryside Preparatory School (Countryside), where STUDENT attended school during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years; Maria Maga and Yaffa Sidikaro, two of STUDENT’s teachers at the nonpublic school (NPS) Yellen & Associates (Y&A); Heidi Yellen, a supervisor at Y&A; Rhonda Glowalla, a school and educational psychologist retained by Petitioner; and Dr. Gary Katz, a clinical psychologist who evaluated STUDENT.

The District called the following witnesses: Jack Schnell and Darrel Priebe, District psychologists who assessed STUDENT in July 2002 and in May 2004, respectively; Susan Roberts, a District program specialist who conducted observations of STUDENT’s placements at Countryside and Y&A and participated in individualized education program (IEP) meetings in March and May 2004; Martha Feinstein, a District program specialist who conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT and participated in the May 2004 IEP team meeting; Betsy Robinson, Holly Dolliver, and Ginger DiRuscio, teachers of some of the classes proposed by the District in the May 2004 IEP; and Dennis Carter.

Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing arguments were heard, and the record was closed on March 7, 2005.

ISSUES

Issue No. 1: Has the District failed to properly assess Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability from May 2004 to the present?

Issue No. 2: Does the May 26, 2004 individualized education program offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Issue No. 3: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment conducted by psychologist Rhonda Glowalla in October 2004 and January 2005?

Issue No. 4: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained educational materials and services, including related transportation, provided to him from September 2004 to the present?

Issue No. 5: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education?

Issue No. 6: Is Petitioner entitled to an order requiring the District to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing and offering a prospective placement?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing and prior to the introduction of any evidence, the District made a motion to dismiss Petitioner’s Issues 1 and 3. On the second day of hearing, Petitioner made a motion to augment the issues.

District’s Motion to Dismiss Issue No. 1

The District argued that the scope of the District’s assessment had been agreed upon by the parties as part of the settlement of an earlier due process matter and could not be challenged in this hearing. Petitioner opposed the motion, arguing that, while there was an agreement to assess pursuant to a specific assessment plan, the District had a continuing duty to assess Petitioner and that the data from the District’s assessment should have alerted it to the need for additional assessment. The District replied that it could only be held to the knowledge it had at the time of the IEP meeting on May 26, 2004, and that later developed information is irrelevant.

The Hearing Officer found the District’s argument unpersuasive because there were potential questions of fact regarding the scope of the agreed-upon assessment, changed circumstances, and other matters that could not be decided without the consideration of evidence offered at the hearing. He denied the motion without prejudice.

District’s Motion To Dismiss Issue No. 3

The District moved to dismiss Petitioner’s Issue No. 3 on the ground that Ms. Glowalla did not conduct an independent assessment within the meaning of California Education Code section 56329, but merely observed placements for the purpose of offering testimony at the hearing. Petitioner countered that Ms. Glowalla in fact conducted her observation of placements as part of a broad assessment that included a forensic review of psychological and psychoeducational data for the purpose of determining an appropriate educational program for him.

The Hearing Officer also denied this motion without prejudice, again finding that there was insufficient evidence in the record at that time to allow him to determine as a matter of law that the cost of the services of Ms. Glowalla were not reimbursable under California Education Code section 56329.

The Hearing Office informed the parties that they would be allowed to argue the merits of their respective positions on these motions at the conclusion of the case.

Petitioner’s Motion to Augment Issues

On the second day of the hearing, Petitioner made a motion to augment the issues to include a challenge to the adequacy of the goals and objectives in the proposed IEP of May 26, 2004. Petitioner’s second witness, Rhonda Glowalla, sought to state her opinions regarding the adequacy of the proposed goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer sustained the District’s objection to the testimony on the ground that goals and objectives had not been identified as an element of the proposed IEP that was in dispute. Petitioner then made a motion to augment the issues to add goals and objectives to the challenged elements of the IEP. The District opposed the motion on the ground that it had not received proper notice.

The parties to a due process hearing are required to identify for other parties all proposed issues and resolutions at least ten days prior to the hearing. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6).) Petitioner had timely disclosed his claim that the District had denied him a FAPE. On the first day of hearing, Petitioner identified his specific claims in this regard. Goals and objectives were not identified as an element at issue. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer concluded that it was appropriate to allow the augmentation if the District was provided an adequate opportunity to prepare to address the claim. The Hearing Officer confirmed with the parties that no witness would have to be recalled to address the proposed new issue. (Footnote 1) The District indicated that it would request a continuance of the hearing to February 8, 2005, if the motion to augment was granted. The Hearing Officer granted the motion to augment, then continued the hearing to February 8, 2005, to allow the District adequate time to prepare. (Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is seventeen years and six months old. He lives with his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, within the geographical boundaries of the District. He also has an older sister who is currently attending college in Northern California. STUDENT is eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability. STUDENT has been in several different educational placements over the years. Since the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT’s educational program has consisted solely of one-to-one instruction from therapists at Y&A, provided at his parents’ expense.

STUDENT attended public school within the District from kindergarten through seventh grade. His parents report that he had significant difficulties with language arts from the beginning. STUDENT’s parents rejected the District’s offer of a resource specialist program (RSP) to supplement his regular school curriculum and opted to provide private tutoring during the third and fourth grades. According to the parents’ report, this helped considerably. STUDENT continued in a regular education program at a District school until the end of the seventh grade (2000-2001 school year).

Because they believed the District would not meet their son’s educational needs in the future and were concerned that STUDENT was at risk of engaging in drug and/or gang-related activity, the PARENTs withdrew STUDENT from the District school and placed him in a combination private school/home school program at the beginning of his eighth-grade year (2001-2002 school year). His first IEP was developed in August 2002. That IEP is not in evidence and there is little information in the record regarding the funding for STUDENT’s educational program during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years. It is known that until the end of his first ninth-grade semester in approximately December 2002, STUDENT received instruction at The Learning Center in the morning and at home from one of his parents in the afternoon. It is also known that for the next year and one-half, STUDENT attended Countryside and, at least initially, received one-to-one Lindamood-Bell instruction after school at the District’s expense. (Footnote 3)

It is not clear when the Lindamood-Bell instruction was terminated, but STUDENT’s mother testified that he had been doing well while receiving the services and that his attitude and academic performance suffered when the Lindamood-Bell instruction ended. (Footnote 4) By the second semester of STUDENT’s tenth-grade year, Chris Faucher, the principal and one of STUDENT’s teachers at Countryside, advised MOTHER and FATHER that he did not believe Countryside’s program could meet STUDENT’s academic and social needs. Due in part to what he viewed as STUDENT’s difficulty staying on task and following verbal instructions, Mr. Faucher believed that STUDENT needed more individual attention than Countryside could offer him.

There has been at least one prior due process matter between these same parties. Little is known about prior matters except that one of them was resolved by a settlement agreement dated January 28, 2003. That settlement agreement purports to settle all issues through June 2004. Pursuant to that settlement, the District was authorized to conduct a full and complete assessment of STUDENT pursuant to an agreed-upon assessment plan at any time between April 1, 2004 and June 15, 2004. The parties agreed that the District would assess STUDENT in the following areas: (1) pre-academic and academic achievement, (2) social, emotional, and adaptive behavior, (3) psychomotor development, (4) intellectual development, and (5) health.

The District conducted its assessment of STUDENT in April and May 2004. An IEP team meeting was convened on May 26, 2004. The District offered STUDENT placement at Simi Valley High School (SVHS), a comprehensive high school campus. (Footnote 5) He was offered: (1) math, English, science, and history special education classes (four periods), (2) two periods of general education electives in areas associated with his vocational interests, (3) access to individual adult support for the entire school day, including transitions, (4) four hours weekly of additional after-school intervention to support progress toward reading goals, and (5) thirty minutes weekly of social skills instruction. Extended school year (ESY) services were also offered. The District proposed that STUDENT attend special education math and language arts classes during the 2004 ESY session, and offered an additional twenty-five hours of intervention to be provided over the course of the ESY, in addition to the normal ESY session day. Finally, the District recommended additional assessments in the areas of assistive technology and speech and language and a referral to Ventura County Behavioral Health (VCBH) for assessment and consideration of specific mental health services.

STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the proposed IEP. They requested a program that would provide intensive remediation in a very small group or one-to-one setting at an NPS, such as Y&A, with electives provided at a small campus. A few weeks later, Petitioner filed his request for this due process hearing.

Since September 2004, STUDENT has been receiving educational services exclusively through Y&A at his parents’ expense. Since September, Y&A has provided STUDENT Lindamood-Bell instruction for reading and written expression at the rate of three one-hour sessions per week and math and English instruction twice weekly for a total of five hours per week for both subjects. In addition, STUDENT has been receiving instruction at Y&A more recently in history and science.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Has the District failed to properly assess Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability?

Petitioner contends that the District failed to adequately assess him in the areas of reading, sensory functioning/distractibility, and speech and language. The District contends that it properly conducted the assessment and that it was both in compliance with the law and with what was agreed upon between the parties.

The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district in all areas related to that disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h).) The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an assessment to develop an appropriate educational program. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).)

Reading

There is no question that the District was required to assess Petitioner in the area of reading. He was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability (SLD) and has always had difficulty with language arts. Reading was clearly an area related to his suspected disability. Furthermore, according to the settlement agreement entered into between the parties to settle the prior due process matter, the District was to conduct a “full and complete assessment” of STUDENT, including an assessment in the areas of intellectual development and academic achievement. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was required to assess STUDENT in the area of reading.

The District’s assessment conducted by school psychologist Darrel Priebe included a review of records, parent and teacher questionnaires, including the Behavior Assessment Scales for Children (BASC), a student interview, and administration of the Differential Ability Scales (DAS) and portions of the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML). It also included academic achievement testing conducted by Martha Feinstein. The parties stipulated that these were all appropriate standardized measures. In the course of this assessment, reading decoding and comprehension, spelling, and written expression were all identified as areas of need for STUDENT.

At the outset, Petitioner claimed that the District should have assessed his reading skills by using the SCAN-A, a test for auditory processing disorders that, according to the testimony of Mr. Carter, is generally administered by an audiologist. (Footnote 6) No testimony was offered to support Petitioner’s claim. In the course of the hearing, Petitioner inquired of witnesses about other instruments, the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT) and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT). However, no witness testified that these tests were required. Both of the District’s psychologists testified persuasively that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability, including reading.

The District’s reading specialist, Martha Feinstein, testified that she administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement - Third Edition (WJ-III), which included subtests for letter-word identification, word attack, reading vocabulary, passage comprehension, and reading fluency. Petitioner stipulated that this was a valid assessment and offered no evidence to suggest that the results were unreliable. Ms. Feinstein also testified that she administered the Burns and Roe Informal Reading Assessment to STUDENT. In her opinion, the tools used by the District to assess STUDENT provided an accurate picture of his reading skills. Petitioner offered no evidence to effectively rebut the District’s witnesses in this regard. In fact, Petitioner’s own witness, Dr. Katz, agreed that the tools used by the District were appropriate and only questioned the District’s reliance on verbal measures of cognitive ability.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did appropriately assess Petitioner in the area of reading.

Sensory Functioning/Distractibility

Petitioner claims that his sensitivity to visual and auditory distractions causes him to become easily overwhelmed and confused. He alleges that he should have been assessed in the areas of sensory functioning and distractibility, including an occupational therapy (OT) assessment, to determine the nature and extent of his sensory processing needs. (Footnote 7)

STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT is particularly sensitive to light and sound and easily overwhelmed by sensory information. His former teacher, Mr. Faucher, stated that Petitioner at times appeared lost or confused on the Countryside campus, which he thought may have been too large of a social environment for STUDENT. A current instructor at Y&A, Maria Maga, testified that she believes that STUDENT has sensory difficulties because he told her that sound bothers him, that light sometimes bothers him, and that certain tactile sensations, like tight clothing, bother him. None of these witnesses is qualified to assess for sensory deficits. STUDENT testified but made no mention of these problems. In any event, there was no evidence that any of these concerns were communicated to the District or the IEP team prior to the May 2004 IEP meeting or at any time later until the hearing. The District made a reasonable effort to gather information from STUDENT’s parents and the staff who worked with STUDENT at Countryside through the use of questionnaires, including the BASC, a review of records, and the parents’ input prior to and at the time of the May 2004 IEP meeting. Although some of this information indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with focus and attention, there was nothing to suggest that there was a problem with sensory sensitivities. The actions of the District cannot be judged in hindsight. The IEP must be judged on the basis of what was objectively reasonable at the time. (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).)

Educational psychologist Rhonda Glowalla, who was retained by the Petitioner to review documents, conduct observations of the pertinent placements, and express her opinions about the offered program, testified at one point that the District did assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. She disagreed with some of Mr. Priebe’s analysis, principally his reliance on the full-scale intelligence quotient (IQ), and with his conclusion about STUDENT’s cognitive level; however, she was generally not critical of the assessment in other respects, characterizing the assessment as a “pretty good assessment,” until later examination on redirect by the Petitioner when Ms. Glowalla observed that the District’s assessment did not encompass the area of attention. This testimony was not persuasive due to both its context and its substance. Ms. Glowalla’s explanation, that her earlier testimony that the scope of the assessment was appropriate had pertained only to the psychological components, was simply not convincing. It appeared to the Hearing Officer that Ms. Glowalla changed her testimony to suit the Petitioner’s needs at hearing. In addition to the changed testimony, Ms. Glowalla offered little more than a conclusory statement and offered nothing of substance to support that opinion. Furthermore, that opinion was inconsistent with the witness’s earlier description of STUDENT’s multiple disabilities; she listed at least eight areas of deficit, and sensory functioning and attention was not among them.

Petitioner also attempted to garner support for his position from Dr. Katz, a clinical psychologist who assessed him on several occasions in 1999, 2001, and 2004. Though Dr. Katz might be expected to have a good understanding of STUDENT’s needs over the years, his report of his February 2004 assessment and his testimony at the hearing regarding the need for an OT or other assessment of STUDENT’s sensory and attention issues were ambiguous, at best. There is no suggestion in Dr. Katz’s assessment report, which had been conducted just a few months before the District’s assessment, that anyone had significant concerns then about attention or sensory issues. There is a reference in Dr. Katz’s report to “modestly elevated scores” on the Connors’ Continuance Performance Test (CCPT), an assessment of attention and arousal, which suggested that the previously documented attention deficit was still a factor; however, Dr. Katz also reported that “STUDENT’s responses produced few . . . atypical findings suggesting serious problems.” There was no mention in the report of a history of sensory issues, and Dr. Katz did not deem it necessary to inquire further regarding either area. He testified at hearing that an OT assessment would have “helped [Petitioner’s] profile.” He did not testify that one was required to identify and meet STUDENT’s needs, and he was not otherwise critical of the District’s assessment on this ground.

It is undisputed that the District was already aware that STUDENT had been diagnosed with attention deficits when it assessed him in 2004. There is a reference to that in Mr. Priebe’s assessment report, which also references comments attributed to STUDENT’s teachers regarding attentional issues. Four of STUDENT’s six teachers mentioned that attention or focus was a problem and one of those also stated that STUDENT could easily be redirected. Mr. Priebe administered the teacher and parent Behavior Assessment Scales for Children (BASC), which, according to his report, showed only moderate elevations by some raters in attention. He testified that there was no clinically significant attention results. The District also had Dr. Katz’s February 2004 report with the results of his assessments of, and his conclusions regarding, STUDENT’s attention issues. (Footnote 8) The District contended that no additional assessment in the area of attention was required because it had already determined that STUDENT had attention deficits and had sufficient information to consider those needs in the course of developing an IEP for him.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s evidence and argument to be more persuasive on this issue. The evidence establishes that the District used the BASC and other questionnaires to diligently gather information regarding STUDENT’s attention deficits from his parents and teachers. It considered the report of Dr. Katz, who had administered the CCPT specifically to assess STUDENT for attention and arousal problems just a few months earlier. All of the information suggested that attention was a factor but not a significant factor for STUDENT’s education. The Hearing Officer finds that no other assessment of attention was required.

The District also asserts that sensory sensitivity has never been suspected as an area related to Petitioner’s disability. Ms. Roberts, who helped to develop the assessment plan, testified that the parents did not express any concerns about sensory issues and did not request an OT assessment. Both Ms. Roberts and Mr. Priebe testified that there had been an OT assessment in 2002 that made no mention of sensory problems that would have necessitated further assessment or services. None of STUDENT’s teachers noted the presence of sensory sensitivity issues. There was no evidence to show that the District should have believed otherwise at any time prior to the hearing. (Footnote 9)

The evidence shows that the IEP team was aware of the history of attention deficits. No further assessment in this area was required. The evidence does not support Petitioner’s claim that he had sensory deficits that required assessment in connection with the educational planning for his 2004-2005 school year. Notably, Petitioner did not call an occupational therapist or any other witness particularly qualified to shed light on his claim regarding sensory functioning. None of the witnesses and none of the documents supports that claim. On the contrary, the evidence supports the District’s contention that this was not an area related to STUDENT’s suspected disability.

Speech And Language

Petitioner contends that the District should have assessed his speech and language needs. However, the settlement of the prior due process matter between these parties included an agreement regarding the scope of the assessment that was to be done. The assessment plan that was agreed upon did not require an assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language needs. The question remains whether or not a school district can rely on an agreement regarding the scope of an assessment to absolve itself from responsibility for identifying and meeting the unique needs of a student. However, the Hearing Officer need not answer that question. The prior agreement between these parties is relevant in that can be viewed as a clear indication of what the parties then believed were areas related to STUDENT’s disability.

According to the testimony of Ms. Glowalla, the results of the District’s assessment should have caused the District to conduct a further assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language needs. Like her testimony regarding the need for an OT assessment, this statement was different from what she had testified to earlier in the day and was conclusory, without any adequate foundation or explanation. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Glowalla described what she believed would be an appropriate instructional program for STUDENT in her November 2004 report, which made no mention of speech and language needs or services. In her January 2005 report and in her testimony, Ms. Glowalla conducted a thorough critique of the District’s proposed IEP goals and objectives. There was no mention of a need for a goal in the area of speech and language.

Aside from this conclusory testimony from Ms. Glowalla, there was no evidence of changed circumstances from the date MOTHER signed the assessment plan on March 16, 2004, to the date of the IEP meeting on May 26, 2004, that should have caused the District to consider a speech and language assessment. Nevertheless, at the time of the May 26, 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team recommended a speech and language assessment. (Footnote 10) According to Mr. Priebe, STUDENT’s parents asked for a speech and language assessment at the meeting and the District granted the request. There was no evidence to demonstrate that the speech and language assessment was necessary, as opposed to having been offered to satisfy STUDENT’s parents. Regardless of the reasons for the assessment, the request was made and granted. The District was required to follow through with an assessment plan and assessment.

The PARENTs should have received an assessment plan that included a speech and language assessment within fifteen days of the referral at the IEP meeting unless the regular term ended that year within ten days of the referral. (Footnote 11) (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).) Susan Roberts sent an assessment plan to the PARENTs on June 11, 2004. It did not include a plan for a speech and language assessment and Ms. Roberts testified that she did not know why that was omitted. There was no evidence that any later assessment plan was provided to STUDENT’s parents or that he was assessed in the area of speech and language. Thus, the evidence shows that the District has not timely proceeded with this assessment.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to properly assess Petitioner in the areas of reading and sensory functioning/distractibility, but has failed to timely proceed with an assessment of his speech and language needs pursuant to his parents’ request on May 26, 2004.

Issue No. 2: Does the May 26, 2004 individualized education program offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education?

The May 26, 2004 IEP offered Petitioner placement at SVHS, a comprehensive high school campus. Specifically, it offered (1) four special day class (SDC) periods daily in math, English, science, and history, (2) two daily periods of general education electives in areas associated with his vocational interests, (3) the services of a one-to-one instructional aide as needed for the entire school day, including transitions, (4) four hours weekly of additional after-school intervention to support progress toward reading goals, (5) thirty minutes weekly of social skills instruction, and (6) an ESY program during the 2004 summer, consisting of participation in special education classes to support progress in math and language arts and an additional twenty-five hours of intervention outside of the regular ESY class day.

Petitioner contends that the May 26, 2004 IEP does not offer him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the following respects:

(a) the goals and objectives are inadequate;

(b) the proposed placement on a comprehensive high school campus is not appropriate because Petitioner’s sensory deficits and distractibility would prevent him from receiving educational benefit; (c) the SDC instructional setting for core subjects is not appropriate because Petitioner would not receive educational benefit unless instruction is delivered one to one or in a very small group; and (d) the IEP does not provide for adequate services to meet Petitioner’s needs in the areas of sensory functioning, speech and language, reading, and written expression. (Footnote 12)

The District asserts that the May 26, 2004 IEP offers Petitioner a FAPE. (Footnote 13)

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student is entitled to a FAPE. A FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, and are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) In addition, an IEP must enable the student to be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), where the student is allowed to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, with the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent appropriate. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.)

An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. (Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994).) Moreover, the focus of the inquiry should not be on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the placement that is preferred by the parents but, rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. (Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982); Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).)

In summary, to be substantively appropriate, the student’s educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. In addition, the IEP must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and provide the student with the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent appropriate. (Footnote 14)

Petitioner’s Needs

Before the Hearing Officer can determine whether or not the District’s offered program is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, he must identify those needs, most of which are not in dispute.

The parties agree that STUDENT has auditory processing and memory deficits that make it difficult for him to take in and retain oral instruction. He needs to have information delivered through a multisensory approach with frequent repetition and checks for understanding. Due to his visual processing speed deficits, he requires extra time to complete pencil-to-paper tasks. Because of his weak reading skills, texts and other peripherals should be geared to his reading level. STUDENT also has an attention deficit. An adequate program requires adequate staff to provide redirection as necessary.

There also was little dispute regarding STUDENT’s level of academic functioning at the time of the IEP meeting in May. The District’s testing, as reported in Mr. Priebe’s May 2004 report, shows that STUDENT performs well below grade level in all academic areas. Reading, writing, and math skills were at the 1st to the 5th percentiles, with reading comprehension being the lowest at the 1st percentile, equivalent to the second- to third-grade level, unassisted. STUDENT needs intensive remediation in all of these areas, particularly in the area of reading.

There are two main areas of dispute regarding STUDENT’s needs. The first concerns the level of STUDENT’s needs in the areas of sensory functioning and attention. The second concerns the extent to which STUDENT needs one-to-one direct instruction to benefit from his education. (Footnote 15)

The Hearing Officer has already found that there is inadequate evidence in the record to support a finding that STUDENT has sensory deficits of sufficient severity to require assessment. There is also no evidence to indicate that STUDENT has sensory deficits that negatively impact his learning. (Footnote 16) Ms. Maga’s testimony that STUDENT told her that sound bothers him, light sometimes bothers him, and certain tactile sensations, such as tight clothing, bother him was based entirely on the hearsay report of STUDENT himself. STUDENT could have provided direct support for this argument during his testimony, but he did not. There was no evidence to support Ms. Maga’s testimony other than MOTHER’s conclusory statement that her son is sensitive to light and sound and easily overwhelmed by sensory input. However, MOTHER also testified that STUDENT enjoys riding motorcycles in the desert. Furthermore, STUDENT and others testified that he attends at least two non-academic classes (weight lifting and wrestling) at a local community college and there is no evidence that sensory issues prevent him from enjoying that experience. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has no particular sensory sensitivities that would be expected to adversely impact his education.

The evidence demonstrates that Petitioner has attention deficits. The question is whether or not those deficits are so severe that STUDENT requires an educational environment that is more distraction-free than what the District has offered.

According to the history contained in Dr. Katz’s report, a doctor diagnosed STUDENT with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder when STUDENT was in fifth grade. STUDENT was on medication for this condition for a time but that has been discontinued under medical supervision since 2000. Mr. Priebe’s May 2004 report notes that some of STUDENT’s teachers at Countryside reported that STUDENT had difficulties with attention. Moderate elevations regarding attention were noted on some responses to the BASC, but none of those was clinically significant. During the District’s assessment, no problems with STUDENT’s focus or attention were observed, but during the classroom observation at Countryside that was part of the District’s 2004 assessment, Ms. Roberts and Ms. Feinstein saw some need for redirection and prompting. Mr. Priebe recognizes in his report that attention continues to be a problem for STUDENT. Nevertheless, his and other District IEP team members’ recommendations in the IEP indicate that they do not believe that STUDENT’s attention deficits are severe or that they cannot be addressed in a public school setting.

Ms. Maga testified that STUDENT should not be placed on a comprehensive campus due to his distractibility and his other multiple severe deficits. Heidi Yellen, a supervisor at Y&A, agreed with Ms. Maga. She stated that an SDC environment is too distracting. The testimony of both of these witnesses was conclusory and lacked support elsewhere in the evidence. Neither of them has the expertise to entitle their opinions to much weight. There was no evidence that either of them had observed STUDENT in any educational setting other than the one-to-one environment at Y&A. Neither of them adequately explained the bases for their opinions. Ms. Yellen had never provided services of any kind to STUDENT. Her testimony at hearing was based on what others had told her about STUDENT.

Dr. Katz, who operates his clinical practice as “The Center for Attention Disorders,” states in his report that his most recent examination in February 2004 was specifically to determine STUDENT’s current levels of cognitive and educational functioning and to make recommendations for intervention. As discussed earlier in this Decision, the report notes STUDENT’s history with attention difficulties, then goes on to state that, although Dr. Katz has observed intermittent problems in therapy with STUDENT over the years, neither Dr. Katz’s previous assessment in 1999 nor the February 2004 assessment revealed any significant concerns regarding attention. Dr. Katz did not indicate in his report or testimony that STUDENT’s attention problems were so severe that he could not be educated in a classroom with other students or on a comprehensive campus. In fact, Dr. Katz did not testify regarding attention deficits and his report refers only to STUDENT’s history of attention problems.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has no significant needs in the area of sensory functioning and that his needs in the area of attention can be met through an appropriate placement on a comprehensive campus.

The parties also disagree regarding the amount and type of individual staff attention STUDENT needs to receive educational benefit. The Petitioner contends that he needs more individual and intensive instruction than is available in a typical SDC. The District witnesses believe that the kind and amount of small-group instruction that is typically available in an SDC is all that STUDENT needs to receive educational benefit if the instruction is paired with an instructional aide for him. The instructor-to-student ratio and the instructional aide will be considered together.

According to the evidence, MOTHER consistently stated that she would accept nothing less than a one-to-one instructional environment, like that provided at Y&A. She does not want STUDENT to have a one-to-one aide on a comprehensive campus. Ms. Glowalla supports this view on the ground that STUDENT is too old for an aide. However, Ms. Glowalla, Dr. Katz, and Mr. Faucher generally agreed that STUDENT does not necessarily need exclusively one-to-one direct instruction. They believed one-to-one direct instruction in the core subjects would be ideal and would provide STUDENT the greatest benefit, but they also agreed that STUDENT could benefit from appropriate small-group instruction.

The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s need for individual staff attention arises from a combination of deficits, including his difficulties with distractibility and the processing of information. The evidence also shows that what is most important is that STUDENT’s IEP include adequate staff to provide instruction in various modalities, to help STUDENT stay focused, to provide frequent repetition and checks for understanding, and to otherwise be available to provide encouragement and support. There is nothing in the evidence to show that only a qualified teacher can provide these services. An instructional aide can provide many of them with the support and supervision of a qualified teacher.

Neither MOTHER nor Ms. Glowalla offered adequate reasons why an aide should not be used. The testimony of both witnesses suggests that they are concerned about STUDENT’s embarrassment. That is a legitimate concern, but not one that outweighs all others. There are ways to make an aide more discretely available to STUDENT. He will be in class with other students who are also receiving special assistance. Additionally, as members of the IEP team, STUDENT and his parents play a role in determining the extent to which STUDENT receives the assistance of a one-to-one aide during general education electives and transitions. According to STUDENT’s testimony, he is able to manage quite well in his classes at the community college. It is likely that he will require the special education and related services primarily or exclusively in connection with his core classes and the remedial efforts. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the potential benefit to STUDENT that is likely to result from the services of the one-to-one aide outweigh the concerns of MOTHER and Ms. Glowalla.

There are also some obvious benefits that would be expected to flow from small group instruction that would not be available in a one-to-one environment. At the time of the IEP meeting in May 2004, everyone agreed that STUDENT’s social skills were lacking. Several of his teachers at Countryside commented on his lack of involvement with peers and his frequent aggressive confrontations, and Dr. Katz recommended that STUDENT continue to receive psychotherapy and psychotherapeutic medications to help him with interpersonal and intrapersonal difficulties. Although Petitioner believed that such services were no longer necessary at the time of the hearing, the focus is on what was reasonable at the time of the IEP meeting. (See Adams, supra.) At that time, the parties agreed that STUDENT needed social skills training. He also would have needed to be able to generalize the learned social skills. The District’s proposed placement would have provided STUDENT opportunities to practice social skills.

The weight of the evidence, including the testimony of Petitioner’s consultants, establishes that he does not require one-to-one direct instruction exclusively, or even primarily, to benefit from his education. Rather, he requires significant staff support to augment direct instruction. The support must be adequate to help STUDENT maintain focus, to check for understanding, to facilitate frequent review and repetition, and to provide encouragement and support.

In summary, STUDENT needs to receive instruction in core subjects in a special education environment with small-group instruction delivered using a multisensory approach. The staff must be able to spend a significant amount of time with STUDENT individually to ensure that focus is maintained, that lessons are frequently repeated and reinforced, and that there are adequate checks for understanding. Materials must be geared to STUDENT’s academic levels and he must be allowed extra time, particularly on pencil-to-paper tasks, to accommodate his slow processing. Finally, STUDENT needs significant remediation to improve academic skills that are far behind his peers in most areas, but especially in reading. (Footnote 17)

Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Benefit

Goals and Objectives: An IEP must contain measurable annual goals and intermediate benchmarks or short-term objectives that are related to meeting the student’s educational needs, including those that must be addressed to enable the student to be involved and make progress in the general curriculum. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).) As stated by Susan Roberts in her testimony at the hearing, the goals drive the placement and services. The importance of goals is reinforced in Appendix A to the federal regulations governing special education, which states, in part:

Measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, are critical to the strategic planning process used to develop and implement the IEP for each child with a disability. Once the IEP team has developed measurable annual goals for a child, the team (1) can develop strategies that will be most effective in realizing those goals and (2) must develop either measurable, intermediate steps (short-term objectives) or major milestones (benchmarks) that will enable parents, students, and educators to monitor progress during the year, and, if appropriate, to revise the IEP consistent with the student's instructional needs.

(34 C.F.R. Part 300, App. A, Question 1.) The IEP must also show a direct relationship between the student’s present levels of educational performance, the goals, and the services that are to be provided to meet those goals. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3040(c).)

Petitioner relied upon the testimony of Ms. Glowalla to challenge the proposed goals. Each of her criticisms will be addressed.

Reading Goal: The only reading goal focuses on comprehension. It states that STUDENT will be able to summarize and connect ideas orally with teacher support and then in writing when given a sixth-grade level selection with pre-reading strategies and prompts. The short-term objectives build to that skill, but always using a sixth-grade level selection with teacher prompts and/or pre-reading strategies.

Ms. Glowalla objected to this goal on the ground that testing showed STUDENT’s reading comprehension skill to be at the second- to third-grade level but the goal required the use of sixth-grade material that was beyond his ability. Martha Feinstein, the District reading specialist who administered the WJ-III and the Burns and Roe informal assessment to STUDENT, testified that her testing revealed that his instructional level for silent reading comprehension was between fourth and fifth grade and that she chose a sixth-grade level with teacher prompts and pre-reading strategies as an appropriate instructional level to give the staff and student something to work toward. Furthermore, at the time the goal was proposed, STUDENT was expected to attend an ESY program to support progress in math and language arts, and receive an additional twenty-five hours of intervention during the summer and four hours weekly of reading instruction during the regular school year to support this goal. Finally, Ms. Sidikaro, the Y&A employee who has been providing the only reading instruction to STUDENT at the rate of three hours per week since September 2004, testified that STUDENT should be reading at grade level six to seven by the end of this school year. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds this goal to be appropriate.

Petitioner also objects to the reading goal on the ground that the single comprehension goal is inadequate to address all of his many significant reading needs. The parties agree that reading is a significant area of need. STUDENT’s decoding, comprehension, and fluency skills are all six or more years behind his grade-level peers. Ms. Glowalla believes that STUDENT should have additional reading goals. Ms. Feinstein stated that only a comprehension goal was developed because only that area had not shown improvement and work on the comprehension goal would necessarily include progress in decoding and fluency. Mr. Priebe’s testimony was in agreement. However, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that there had been significant improvement in any of STUDENT’s reading skills at the time this goal was developed and Mr. Priebe stated in his assessment report that decoding should be a focus of intervention. He recommended “intensive direct teaching of phonemic awareness … , sound-symbol relationships … , blending skills and reading fluency,” and stated that, “Systematic, explicit instruction in phonics … is essential.”

Regardless of how STUDENT came to be so far behind and lacking in the most basic academic skills, it was obvious to the IEP team in May 2004 that he would require intensive remediation in reading, among other areas. Although Mr. Priebe testified at hearing that he expected phonemic awareness and decoding skills would necessarily improve with the District’s focus on a single reading comprehension goal, the Hearing Officer could not reconcile his testimony at hearing with the recommendation in his May 2004 report that STUDENT should receive intensive direct teaching of decoding, fluency, and other reading skills. The Hearing Officer finds the recommendation in the report entitled to greater weight because it was offered to guide the development of the IEP and was the information available to the IEP team at the time in question.

Although the IEP team may have had an accurate understanding of STUDENT’s reading deficits at the time placement and services were considered and proposed, the reading goal does not reflect it. Considering the significance of this area of need, and taking into consideration the PARENTS’ view that instruction in the fundamentals of reading was the most important to their son’s remediation and education, the District’s failure to propose adequate reading goals was a critical flaw in the process and one which may well have been responsible for derailing the development and implementation of an IEP for STUDENT. (Footnote 18)

The Hearing Officer finds that the single goal for reading comprehension was inadequate to address Petitioner’s needs in that area. There should have been additional goals in other basic reading skills, including phonemic awareness, decoding, and fluency.

Written Expression: There is a single written expression goal that requires STUDENT to create a business letter with teacher direction using a graphic organizer, prompts, and a rubric. It purports to enable STUDENT to be involved in the general curriculum by improving his organization and focusing skills.

Ms. Glowalla is critical of this goal on the ground that it has no reasonable relationship to STUDENT’s actual skills. In essence, she complains that the District expects a young man who cannot even write a single properly punctuated sentence with words correctly spelled to work on a business letter. Ms. Glowalla states that there should be goals for the basic skills required for written expression, including spelling, vocabulary, punctuation, and grammar. Mr. Priebe identified spelling and written expression as significant areas of need, with STUDENT’s performance in the 1st to 5th percentile range. Ms. Feinstein’s opinion was that STUDENT should be able to work toward the goal with the aids that are incorporated within the goal. Ms. DiRuscio, who would apparently have been at least one of the teachers responsible for working on the writing goal, testified that she believed the goals, including this writing goal, are appropriate.

The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Glowalla to be more persuasive on this point. Her testimony is more consistent with the uncontested evidence regarding STUDENT’s significant needs in the area of written expression, including the report of Mr. Priebe. It also makes sense that the foundation skills for written expression, like those for reading, should be a focus for STUDENT. The District offered no convincing evidence to support its position. Ms. Feinstein did not explain how STUDENT was to learn essential foundational skills and Ms. DiRuscio did not explain why she believed the goal was appropriate or how she would have implemented the goal.

The Hearing Officer finds that the goal for written expression was inadequate to address Petitioner’s needs in that area.

Math: There are four math goals. Two of those are more in the nature of practical math goals and relate to calculations involving money and time. Petitioner does not challenge these two goals. The other two math goals are for academic math. One states that STUDENT will complete the four basic number operations with whole numbers and multiply fractions using a calculator. The other states that he will solve algebraic equations in the four basic number operations.

Petitioner’s objection to the first of these goals is that he should be learning how to add, subtract, multiply, and divide without using a calculator because he has not yet mastered those basic skills. This objection finds support in the assessment data. Mr. Priebe’s assessment showed that STUDENT’s math applications and calculations skills were at the 4th and 5th percentiles, or grade levels 3.8 and 5.3, respectively. Dr. Katz’s assessment results were the same. Mr. Priebe recommended in his report that STUDENT be taught his basic multiplication and division facts.

Petitioner objected to the second goal on the ground that he was not ready for an algebra goal. This position also finds support in all the assessment data. Neither assessor suggests that STUDENT’s algebraic skills should be a focus for his education. Although Ms. DiRuscio stated that the math goals were appropriate, there was nothing to indicate that she appreciated the significant gaps in STUDENT’s knowledge base. Ms. Feinstein testified that the algebra goal was included because the algebra lab teacher at Countryside reported that STUDENT had recently been able to solve one equation with one unknown. There was no evidence that she or anyone else followed up with that teacher to explore the representation. Furthermore, as stated in Mr. Priebe’s assessment report, the same teacher also reported to him that STUDENT was still unable to demonstrate basic math skills.

The Hearing Officer again finds that the views expressed by Ms. Glowalla regarding the math goals are reasonable, logical, and consistent with the assessment data. The parties agree that the focus on practical math is appropriate. But because STUDENT’s math skills are at least six years below his grade level, he needs goals for mastering basic math facts and operations, fractions, and decimals. Goals for using a calculator or solving a basic algebraic equation may come later.

The Hearing Officer finds that the two academic math goals are inappropriate to address Petitioner’s needs in that area.

Study Skills: The Petitioner did not challenge this goal.

Vocational: The Petitioner did not challenge this goal.

Requesting Assistance: The Petitioner did not challenge this goal.

Social/Emotional: The Petitioner essentially concedes that this goal was appropriate when proposed in May 2004. He contends that no social/emotional goal is necessary now, but that claim is outside the scope of this analysis. (See Adams, supra.)

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP does not contain adequate or appropriate goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written expression, and math. Such significant deficiencies in the goals for what are STUDENT’s most important areas of need are alone sufficient bases for a finding that the IEP did not offer a FAPE. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer will analyze the remaining challenged elements.

Proposed Placement On Comprehensive Campus: Petitioner claims that he should not be placed on a comprehensive campus because it is too distracting. The Hearing Officer has already analyzed this argument in connection with the determination of STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer held that STUDENT’s sensory deficits, if any, and attentional problems are not so severe that he cannot be placed on a comprehensive high school campus. Absent justification set forth in the student’s IEP, the law favors placement of the student in the school that he or she would attend if not disabled. (34 C.F.R. § 300.552(c).) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placement on the SVHS campus is appropriate.

Opportunities For Individualized Instruction In Classroom Setting: STUDENT has been offered a mixed SDC/regular education instructional setting with access to a one-to-one aide as necessary throughout the entire day, including during transitions. (Footnote 19) He contends, in essence, that this instructional setting will not provide him adequate one-to-one instruction without sensory distractions.

Betsy Robinson is the credentialed special education teacher of the SVHS science SDC. She testified regarding the class. As with all of STUDENT’s proposed special education classes, his science class was to meet daily for one period. There are approximately ten students in each of her two science SDCs. One classroom aide customarily assists Ms. Robinson. It is a slow-paced learning environment with verbal and hands-on teaching and frequent repetition. The textbook is geared to students with learning disabilities.

Holly Dolliver is a resource specialist for the District and the teacher of the eleventh-grade history SDC that STUDENT would be in if his parents had consented to the IEP. Ms. Dolliver testified that she has about thirteen students in her class and one classroom aide. Some of her students have reading skills as low as STUDENT’s and though she uses the standard history text to guide her instruction, the students are not expected to read from the text. Instead, she uses peripherals such as maps and other visuals, often using an overhead projector. She also uses worksheets that are appropriate for students who read at the third and fourth grade levels.

Ginger DiRuscio, who has a master’s degree and a credential in special education, teaches the eleventh grade English and math SDCs at SVHS. Ms. DiRuscio testified that each these classes have approximately ten students or less. A classroom aide assists Ms. DiRuscio. The students vary in their ability from third to ninth grade instructional levels. They use an interactive reader with other supports in the English class, where most or all of the students decode at the grade four level or higher and approximately three of the students decode at the grade six level or higher. In the algebra class, Ms. DiRuscio and her aide use multiple modalities, including visual aids and manipulatives. She also provides more attention to the students who need it.

All of the teachers credibly testified that they believed STUDENT would be able to access the curriculum and receive educational benefit in their classes. The other District members of the IEP team agreed. MOTHER and FATHER disagreed. According to MOTHER, they had already tried everything that the District is recommending and none of that worked. She explained that STUDENT had made little or no progress on a comprehensive public school campus during his earlier years and he had not done much better on the very small private campus at Countryside. In the PARENTS’ view, the only thing that had proved successful for STUDENT was the one-to-one instruction at Y&A. According to Ms. Roberts and Mr. Priebe, STUDENT’s parents were not willing to consider much else at the IEP meeting.

Rhonda Glowalla’s opinion is that the District’s proposed SDC placement is not appropriate. Ms. Glowalla visited several of the SDCs at SVHS, but only Ms. DiRuscio’s English class was one that STUDENT would actually have been attending. She found Ms. DiRuscio’s class to be inappropriate for STUDENT because of the likely auditory interference from nearby construction noise, the absence of adequate direct instruction in decoding, comprehension, and spelling, and his inability to work independently and to read at a level commensurate with the other students in the class, which would be humiliating for him. (Footnote 20)

The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT does not need as much one-to-one direct instruction from the teacher as he claims. In view of the Hearing Officer’s determinations regarding STUDENT’s sensory and attention issues, the Hearing Officer does not find Ms. Glowalla’s criticism of Ms. DiRuscio’s class to be persuasive. Although little is known about the construction work that was happening during Ms. Glowalla’s visit, Ms. DiRuscio credibly testified that she does not believe that it would prevent STUDENT from accessing the curriculum. Because STUDENT has been offered a one-to-one aide, adequate staff support should not be lacking. Ms. Glowalla’s observations regarding the apparently superior (to STUDENT) reading skills of the students and possibility that the materials used by Ms. DiRuscio would be difficult for STUDENT do not support a determination that STUDENT would not benefit from participation in the English SDC. Ms. DiRuscio testified that she gives more attention to her students with lesser skills. STUDENT fits within the range of instructional levels of students in the class. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer gives significant weight to the testimony of Ms. DiRuscio, a credentialed special education teacher who has observed STUDENT at Y&A as part of the District’s assessment process, as well as participated in the May 2004 IEP meeting. Ms. DiRuscio credibly testified that STUDENT would be able to access the curriculum and benefit from placement in her class.

The same is true of the other offered SDCs. Considering the availability of the one-to-one aide, all are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs for small-group instruction delivered using a multisensory approach with materials geared to STUDENT’s academic levels, and staff available to spend a significant amount of time with STUDENT individually to ensure that focus is maintained, that lessons are frequently repeated and reinforced, that there are adequate checks for understanding, and that additional support and encouragement are available.

The Hearing Officer finds that the offered placement in SDCs for the four core subjects is appropriate. (Footnote 21)

Adequacy/Intensity Of Services During Regular School Year: The Petitioner claims that the IEP does not contain adequate services to address his needs in the areas of sensory functioning, speech and language, reading, and written expression. The District asserts that all required services have been offered.

The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT does not have needs that require special education or related services in the area of sensory functioning.

The Hearing Officer has not identified speech and language as an area of need for STUDENT. The assessment requested by the parents has not yet been conducted. None of the available evidence shows that speech and language services are required. Therefore, there is no evidence upon which the Hearing Officer can base a finding that such services are required.

There is no doubt that STUDENT requires intensive remediation in the areas of reading and written expression. Petitioner contends that he requires one hour of Lindamood-Bell instruction delivered one to three times weekly to adequately address these areas of need. The District contends that the IEP offers adequate services to address Petitioner’s reading and written expression needs.

Generally, absent evidence that a particular methodology is required to provide a FAPE, questions of methodology are left to the school’s discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S., at 208.) The Hearing Officer must focus on the District’s proposed placement and not on the alternative placement selected by the parents. Even if the Lindamood-Bell instruction by Y&A has provided greater benefit to STUDENT than the District’s program would have provided, the District’s proposed program must be found appropriate if it was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).)

In this case there is no evidence that would support a finding that STUDENT requires Lindamood-Bell instruction to receive a FAPE. Although the testimony of several of Petitioner’s witnesses shows that he has apparently made substantial progress in his placement at Y&A, which provides Lindamood-Bell instruction, there was no evidence that STUDENT can benefit only from that methodology. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not specifically require Lindamood-Bell instruction to benefit from his education.

The Hearing Officer must go on to examine the adequacy of the services provided in the IEP to address STUDENT’s reading and written expression needs.

Ms. DiRuscio testified that her daily English SDC would have addressed STUDENT’s needs in language arts, including reading, spelling, vocabulary, and writing. Based upon the descriptions by the witnesses of some of the other classes, STUDENT would have had opportunities to work on these skills in those classes also. But clearly this was not sufficient to meet STUDENT’s reading and written expression needs. Even the District acknowledged this when it offered four hours weekly of intervention focused on reading in addition to STUDENT’s regular school day.

At the time of the May 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT was about to enter the eleventh grade but was functioning academically six to eight grades below that level. He obviously lacked the basic math and language arts skills that most of his peers had mastered. To be educated within the meaning of the IDEA, STUDENT needed an educational program that would prepare him for employment and independent living. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1).) According to the IEP, the parties expected STUDENT to earn a high school diploma and to pass the California High School Exit Exams with some accommodations. This required a program that met STUDENT’s instructional needs in the areas of reading and written expression.

It was the District’s burden to prove that it offered an instructional program and/or services that were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).) It did not do this. The Hearing Officer cannot discern from the evidence what instruction was offered, other than that it consisted of four hours of services weekly in addition to the regular school day. Ms. Feinstein was correct in her testimony that the IEP is not required to describe the specific methodologies that will be used, but it was nonetheless incumbent upon the District to demonstrate to the Hearing Officer that its proposed program was appropriate. The Hearing Officer was given no information regarding the qualifications of the instructor or instructors, the instructional setting, the teacher-to-student ratio, or any other factor that would support a finding that the proposed services were designed to address STUDENT’s reading and written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s offer of instruction and services in addition to the normal school day was not designed to address STUDENT’s reading and written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Adequacy/Intensity Of Services During ESY: Petitioner challenged the summer program on the same grounds relied upon to challenge the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year.

The District offered an ESY program consisting of the usual special education ESY program with its focus on math and language arts and an additional twenty-five hours of one-to-one instruction focused primarily on reading. The regular ESY program would have consisted of at least twenty instructional days. (See Cal. Code Regs. tit 5, § 3043.) According to Ms. Roberts’ testimony, the additional twenty-five hours would have been one-to-one instruction with a focus on reading.

Extended school year services extend educational programming beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months in order to provide the student with a FAPE. (34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b); Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student has unique needs that require special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043.) Students are entitled to an ESY program if they have handicaps that are “likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043.)

Because there are no separate goals and objectives for the ESY program, the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding the inadequacy of the proposed goals and objectives apply equally to the ESY program, including the additional twenty-five hours of instruction. There is no evidence to enable the Hearing Officer to evaluate the program offered during the summer of 2004 except that it was to include a special education ESY program and twenty-five hours of one-to-one instruction. There is no evidence of the qualifications of the instructors, the class sizes, the student-to-teacher ratio in the ESY program, the teaching environment, or the teaching materials and methodologies. There is almost nothing that would permit a reasoned judgment on the extent to which the proposed 2004 summer program was designed to meet STUDENT’s reading and written expression needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

The Hearing Officer finds that the 2004 summer program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading and written expression and were not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

In summary, regardless of the appropriateness of the placement on the comprehensive campus and in the SDCs that were adequately staffed to meet some of his needs, STUDENT was not going to receive the benefit that the law requires unless he was also provided with additional instruction and services that were designed to teach him the basic academic skills that are the essential building blocks of learning. The Hearing Officer has found the May 26, 2004 IEP did not contain adequate or appropriate goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written expression, and math and did not offer him appropriate instruction and services, in addition to that provided during the regular school day, during either the summer 2004 ESY or the 2004-2005 regular school year.

Comports with the IEP

Because Petitioner’s parents did not consent to the IEP, there has been no attempt to implement it. Therefore, this element is not in dispute.

LRE

In this case, Petitioner’s preferred placement in a secluded one-to-one teaching environment for a substantial part of the day is more restrictive than the District’s proposed placement in Petitioner’s home school. Petitioner did not challenge the District’s proposed placement on that basis. No analysis of LRE is necessary.

In summary, the May 26, 2004 IEP did not contain adequate and necessary goals and intermediate benchmarks or short-term objectives that are related to meeting Petitioner’s needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math. It also did not provide required instruction and services in the areas of reading and written expression. The Hearing Officer finds that the May 26, 2004 IEP did not offer a FAPE to Petitioner because it did appropriately address his most significant needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math.

Issue No. 3: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment conducted by psychologist Rhonda Glowalla in October 2004 and January 2005?

Petitioner contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Ms. Glowalla’s assessment on the grounds that they disagreed with the District’s assessment and requested that Ms. Glowalla conduct an independent assessment. He seeks reimbursement to his parents in the amount of $1,025.00. The District contends that its assessment of Petitioner was appropriate and that Ms. Glowalla did not conduct an independent assessment for which reimbursement can be ordered.

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the school district. The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).)

The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s assessment of Petitioner was appropriate with the sole exception of its failure to conduct the speech and language assessment that was requested on May 26, 2004. Ms. Glowalla’s assessment was not done in response to the District’s failure to conduct a speech and language assessment. She is not qualified to conduct speech and language assessments and there was no claim that her assessment was even partially to provide data that a speech and language assessment should provide. Therefore, Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Rhonda Glowalla.

Issue No. 4: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained educational materials and services, including related mileage, provided to him from September 2004 to the present?

Petitioner contends that reimbursement is appropriate because his parents reasonably incurred expenses to meet his educational needs from September 2004 to the present after the District failed to offer him a FAPE in the May 26, 2004 IEP. He seeks reimbursement to his parents in the amount of approximately $10,013.00 for the cost of services rendered by Y&A, $162.97 for the cost of books, and reasonable mileage reimbursement for travel to Y&A. The District asserts that, having offered Petitioner a FAPE, no reimbursement is due.

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placements or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The placement or services chosen by the parents is not required to be the “exact proper placement required under the Act.” (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) However, the placement and services selected by the parents must address the student’s needs and provide the student with educational benefit. (Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).)

The May 26, 2004 IEP did not offer a FAPE. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents were justified in seeking private educational services for STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year. They are entitled to reimbursement for those services that met STUDENT’s needs and provided educational benefit.

The District argued that the certification form offered into evidence by Petitioner does not authorize Y&A to provide services of the kind it provides to STUDENT. Ms. Yellen testified that Y&A is certified by the State of California as both a nonpublic agency (NPA) and a nonpublic school (NPS), and that Y&A is authorized to provide the services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Yellen’s testimony on this point to be credible. The Hearing Officer finds that Y&A is certified by the State as both an NPA and an NPS authorized to provide services to STUDENT.

Ms. Maga possesses a master’s degree in special education and an emergency special education teaching credential that authorizes her to provide special education of the kind provided to STUDENT. Since September 2004, she has been meeting with STUDENT on Tuesdays for two hours and on Wednesdays for three hours to provide instruction in English and math. Instruction has been provided in a one-to-one setting and in a quiet, distraction-free environment. Ms. Maga testified that her informal assessments indicate that STUDENT, who was at the fourth to fifth grade level in math when he began at Y&A, is now at the eleventh grade level in math, though he requires frequent review. Ms. Maga also said that since she began her instruction, STUDENT’s reading comprehension skills have improved from grade level four to grade level eight with seventy percent accuracy.

Several witnesses, including Mr. Faucher, testified that STUDENT needs instruction daily because of his problems with memory and his need for repetition. However, the Hearing Officer was persuaded by Ms. Maga’s testimony that the services rendered to STUDENT by her were designed to meet at least some of STUDENT’s needs and were reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit. Therefore, Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of services rendered by Ms. Maga.

STUDENT has also received one hour of direct one-to-one Lindamood-Bell instruction from Yaffa Sidikaro, an instructor at Y&A, three times per week from early September 2004 to the present. Ms. Sidikara possesses a bachelor’s degree in child psychology from Indiana State University. She was a credentialed teacher in Israel, but does not hold any California teaching credentials. She has been trained and is qualified to administer various Lindamood-Bell programs. She has also been trained in the Wilson reading method and has ten years experience working with students who have reading disorders. She is currently taking National University courses on line and she has completed seventy-five percent of the coursework required for an award of a master’s degree in special education.

Since September 2004, Ms. Sidikaro has been providing instruction to STUDENT using the Lindamood-Bell program that teaches sound awareness through a multi-sensory methodology. According to Ms. Sidikaro, STUDENT has made substantial progress in the program, having successfully completed approximately fifty percent of the program by the time of the hearing. She credibly testified that STUDENT should be reading at grade level six to seven by June 2005. This is equal to or higher than the comprehension goal proposed by the District.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Sidikaro’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading basics and were reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit. Therefore, Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the services provided by Ms. Sidikaro.

Two other instructors have been more recently involved in providing services to STUDENT at Y&A. According to Ms. Yellen, Pete Ferry has provided instruction in history and Raznik Galoostian has been providing instruction in science. It was not clear from the testimony of any witness when this instruction began, and there is only one document that purports to confirm instruction by either of them. The document states that Mr. Ferry provided two hours of service on December 7, 2004. Neither of these instructors testified at the hearing and no documentary evidence shows that STUDENT received any services from either of these persons other than on December 7, 2004. In effect, there is no evidence that would allow the Hearing Officer to find that these persons rendered any significant services to STUDENT, or even that the services purportedly rendered on December 7, 2004, met any of STUDENT’s needs or provided an educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that no reimbursement is due for the services, if any, rendered by these instructors.

Petitioner also claims reimbursement for the cost of round-trip mileage between home and Y&A and for the cost of books purchased for use in his educational program at Y&A. Because the Hearing Officer has found that only the services rendered by Ms. Maga and Ms. Sidikaro met STUDENT’s needs and provided educational benefit, his parents will be awarded reimbursement only for expenses related directly to the services rendered by Ms. Maga and Ms. Sidikaro to the extent allowed by law.

Transportation is a related service for which reimbursement can be ordered. (34 C.F.R. § 300.024.) Consistent with the above findings, the Hearing Officer awards reimbursement for mileage expense incurred by STUDENT’s parents to transport him to and from Y&A to receive math, English, and Lindamood-Bell instruction only. The District shall reimburse the parents for mileage expense incurred only on those days when STUDENT received instruction from Ms. Maga or Ms. Sidikaro and at the District’s established mileage reimbursement rate.

Finally, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the cost of math, literature, and history books purchased by the PARENTS. The Hearing Officer has not allowed reimbursement for history instruction by Y&A. The claim for that book is denied. According to the testimony, MOTHER wanted Y&A to instruct STUDENT using the math and literature books that he would have been using if he had attended SVHS. MOTHER said she purchased books that she believed were being used to instruct eleventh-grade students in the District, but Ms. DiRuscio testified that the literature and math books that were purchased were for the general education program and not the ones actually used to instruct the students in her SDCs. MOTHER provided the books to Ms. Maga, who testified that she used the literature book for a few months but decided that it was not appropriate so she stopped using it. Ms. Maga also testified that the District’s math book was too advanced for STUDENT in the beginning. Instead, she used her own pre-algebra texts. However, by January 2005, she was using the algebra book purchased by MOTHER to instruct STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer does not know why MOTHER took it upon herself to purchase books for use by Y&A. Y&A was the agency or school that was to provide the instruction and it would seem reasonable that it would also provide the books. When MOTHER took it upon herself to select books for use by Y&A, she assumed the risk if she purchased the wrong books. The testimony of Ms. Maga shows that the literature book was inappropriate for use by STUDENT. It did not address his needs. Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for that book. Ms. Maga uses the math book to instruct STUDENT. It is used to address his needs and, according to Ms. Maga, he is making some, though perhaps minimal, progress using the book. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the algebra book only.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the English and math instruction provided by Ms. Maga and for the cost of the Lindamood-Bell instruction provided by Ms. Sidikaro. In addition, Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for related mileage and the cost of the algebra book. All other claims to reimbursement are denied.

Issue No. 5: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to an award of additional services to compensate him for the educational losses he sustained as a result of the District’s failure to offer him a FAPE on May 26, 2004. He seeks an award of Lindamood-Bell instruction for two hours weekly and additional educational services from Y&A for three hours weekly, both for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. The District contends that a FAPE was offered and no award of compensatory education is due.

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986).) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. (Parents of Student W., supra, 31 F.3d at 497.) Because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in considering and fashioning relief. (See Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Parents of Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.) “The conduct of both parties must be reviewed to determine whether relief is appropriate.” (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1486.)

The Hearing Officer has found the IEP deficient in several respects. Petitioner’s parents have been reimbursed for the cost of educational services obtained by them to address his language arts and math needs from September 2004 to the present which provided a benefit to Petitioner. The evidence supports a finding that STUDENT lost educational opportunities that were not adequately replaced by his parents. The District believed he needed an ESY program and an additional twenty-five hours during the ESY to work on his math and language arts skills. There was no evidence that he received any educational services during the 2004 summer. He should have been receiving instruction in history and science from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the present. The evidence shows that this instruction has started only recently, if at all.

The District argued that STUDENT’s parents would have accepted only a program like that provided at Y&A, with exclusively one-to-one instruction, supplemented with electives on a small campus. In essence, the District suggests that relief should be denied because STUDENT’s losses, if any, are the result of his parents’ unreasonable expectations. Because the evidence was insufficient to support a finding that the parents would not have accepted an offer of a FAPE, their possible motivations cannot impair Petitioner’s right to an award of compensatory education.

The Petitioner asked the Hearing Officer to award compensatory education consisting of two hours of Lindamood-Bell instruction and three hours of other educational therapy per week through Y&A for the remainder of the regular 2004-2005 school year. However, Petitioner offered no specific evidence or argument to justify the amount of the services sought and nothing to show why the services should be provided by Y&A.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District has the experience and staff needed to compensate STUDENT for his educational losses. That compensation shall include a special education ESY program during the 2005 summer. The instruction in this ESY program shall be presented in a manner similar to the District’s proposed SDCs with a multisensory approach to instruction, frequent repetition and checks for understanding, extra time to complete pencil-to-paper tasks, and texts and other materials geared to STUDENT’s reading level. STUDENT’s ESY program shall also have adequate staff to provide redirection as necessary, and STUDENT shall have a one-to-one instructional aide available to assist him at any time if the regular student-to-staff ratio is greater than three-to-one. The award shall include an additional twenty-five hours of one-to-one direct instruction in math and language arts during the 2005 ESY. These two components are to compensate for the loss of services that were not provided during the summer of 2004. If STUDENT is found to be otherwise eligible for an ESY program during the summer of 2005 due to the risk of regression, this portion of the award shall be provided during the 2005-2006 regular school year or thereafter as agreed upon between the parties.

The Hearing Officer does not have evidence that would enable him to award compensation for the loss of instruction specifically in history and science. It is not known whether or not these are courses that are required for graduation or whether the loss will have any impact on STUDENT’s prospects for a timely graduation. As compensation for this loss of educational opportunity, the Hearing Officer awards an additional thirty hours of one-to-one direct instruction through a credentialed special education teacher provided by the District in any core subject area or areas requested by STUDENT’s parents. These hours shall be provided on regular school days, immediately following the regular school day, and completed prior to the end of the 2005-2006 regular school year on a schedule agreed to by STUDENT’s parents.

Issue No. 6: Is Petitioner entitled to an order requiring the District to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of providing for a prospective placement?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to an order requiring the District to provide him an educational program for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year consisting of the following: (a) educational services at Y&A for twelve hours weekly;

(b) speech and language services for one hour weekly if embedded in the services provided by Y&A or for thirty to forty-five minutes three times weekly if provided in a one-to-one context elsewhere; (c) classroom-based OT once weekly for sixty minutes delivered by a nonpublic agency (NPA) with an additional one hour monthly consultation with teachers; and (d) the provision of such other instruction and/or services as may be required to enable Petitioner to graduate with a regular high school diploma.

The District asserts that Petitioner is entitled to no more than is set forth in the subject IEP.

The Hearing Officer has found that the proposed IEP does not offer a FAPE. Either the deficiencies in that IEP must be cured by the IEP team or the Hearing Officer must order that some other appropriate program be provided.

Petitioner wants to continue in his placement at Y&A. However, the Hearing Officer does not believe that Y&A is able to provide a FAPE to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment. There was nothing in the issues presented by Petitioner or in the evidence that supports a finding that he needs to be in an educational environment where he has almost no opportunities to be educated and to participate in other activities with his peers. (Footnote 22) There was also no evidence that Y&A is able to meet STUDENT’s needs for instruction in all required subjects. The Petitioner’s request for a prospective placement at Y&A is denied.

There was no evidence to support a finding that STUDENT requires speech and language services. None will be ordered.

There was no evidence to support a finding that STUDENT requires OT services. None will be ordered.

The Hearing Officer has found that the proposed IEP was deficient because it did not contain adequate or appropriate goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written expression, and math and because it does not offer sufficient instruction and services in the areas of reading and written expression. The Hearing Officer finds that these deficiencies in the subject IEP are curable and that the District will be able to provide a FAPE to Petitioner in the least restrictive environment.

The required speech and language assessment will need to be conducted before the IEP meeting is convened. The District will be ordered to provide a proposed assessment plan, which must include the area of speech and language, to STUDENT’s parents within ten calendar days of the date of this Decision. STUDENT’s parents shall have at least ten calendar days within which to arrive at a decision to give or withhold consent to the plan. The results of the assessment or assessments will be considered by the IEP team at the annual IEP meeting that shall be convened on or before May 26, 2005, for the purpose of offering a FAPE to Petitioner, including appropriate goals and objectives to address Petitioner’s needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math and appropriate services in the areas of reading and written expression consistent with this Decision. Because the evidence indicates that Petitioner has made substantial progress in some academic areas and because Petitioner will be due for an annual review of his IEP in May 2005, the IEP team will be required to gather all required information for the purpose of that review.

Petitioner requires an educational program until an appropriate program can be provided at a District site. In the interim, Petitioner will continue to receive educational services from Y&A at the rate of twelve hours per week at District expense until the IEP meeting has been convened and a revised IEP has been offered to Petitioner.

The Hearing Officer is unable to order the District to provide such other instruction and/or services as may be required to enable Petitioner to graduate with a regular high school diploma as part of a prospective placement. There was no evidence regarding what is required to enable Petitioner to graduate and no way for the Hearing Officer to know whether it is feasible to order the District to provide such instruction and/or services so late in the school year.

ORDERS

1. The District shall provide a proposed assessment plan, which must include the area of speech and language, to STUDENT’s parents within ten calendar days of the date of this Decision, and STUDENT’s parents shall have at least ten calendar days within which to arrive at a decision to give or withhold consent to the plan.

2. The District shall convene an IEP meeting on or before May 26, 2005, for the purpose of an annual review and to develop and offer an IEP to STUDENT that includes appropriate goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math and appropriate services in the areas of reading and written expression, consistent with this Decision.

3. The parties shall cooperate to complete the speech and language assessment and all other required assessments of STUDENT, if any, an adequate time before the annual IEP meeting in May 2005 to enable the IEP team members to fairly consider the results of the assessment(s).

4. The District shall fund STUDENT’s continued placement at Y&A at the rate of twelve hours per week until Orders 1 and 2 are fulfilled.

5. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of an itemization, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the educational services rendered by Maria Maga and Yaffa Sidikaro from September 2004 to the date of this Decision, including related expenses for mileage and the cost of the algebra book.

6. The program and services offered in the IEP for the summer of 2005 and the 2005-2006 regular school year shall include the following as an award of compensatory education for the District’s denial of a FAPE:

(a) A special education ESY program and an additional twenty-five hours of one-to-one intensive instruction to support STUDENT’s progress in math and language arts during the summer of 2005. If the IEP team determines that STUDENT requires an ESY program and/or additional services during the summer of 2005 in order to receive a FAPE, this portion of the compensatory education award can be provided during the 2005-2006 regular school year or thereafter as agreed upon between the parties; and (b) an additional thirty hours of one-to-one direct instruction through a credentialed special education teacher in any core subject area or areas requested by STUDENT’s parents. These hours shall be provided on regular school days, immediately following the regular school day, and completed prior to the end of the 2005-2006 regular school year on a schedule agreed to by STUDENT’s parents.

7. All other claims to relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1: Has the District failed to properly assess Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability from May 2004 to the present?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that a speech and language assessment was ordered. The District prevailed on all other contentions under this issue.

Issue No. 2: Does the May 26, 2004 individualized education program offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 3: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment conducted by psychologist Rhonda Glowalla in October 2004 and January 2005?

The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 4: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained educational materials and services, including related transportation, provided to him from September 2004 to the present?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent the Hearing Officer ordered reimbursement for services rendered by Maria Maga and Yafa Sidikaro, the cost of an algebra book, and related mileage only.

Issue No. 5: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue, although services were not ordered through Y&A.

Issue No. 6: Is Petitioner entitled to an order requiring the District to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing and offering a prospective placement?

The District substantially prevailed on this issue in that the Hearing Officer concluded that prospective placement at Y&A was appropriate only pending review and revision of the IEP and that the Y&A placement was not required to include OT, speech and language services, or any other instruction or services.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 12, 2005 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Only Maria Maga, one of Petitioner’s teachers at Y&A, had completed her testimony.

2 The hearing was continued again for good cause on the motion of Petitioner to March 1, 2005.

3 The Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Lindamood-Bell) is a proprietary teaching methodology that includes a system for teaching the basics of the language arts, including phonemic awareness, spelling, reading, and writing.

4 Although it is not clear when the Lindamood-Bell instruction ended, it was apparently some time during STUDENT’s tenth grade year when the agreed-upon funding was exhausted.

5 There was testimony from MOTHER suggesting that she was not sure where the District was proposing to place STUDENT, but the IEP states that the services would be provided at his home school, SVHS, and, in any event, Petitioner never placed the clarity of the offer at issue.

6 According to the documents, the SCAN (A or C) was administered to STUDENT by an audiologist as part of the District’s 2002 assessment and helped to confirm his auditory processing deficit.

7 From the evidence and the arguments it was clear that this claim regarding sensory deficits related to alleged hypersensitivities to light, sound, and other sensory input and was not related to a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD), which was not in dispute.

8 MOTHER indicated on her consent to the March 16, 2004 assessment plan that she wanted the District to consider Dr. Katz’s report that had been provided to the District on March 11, 2004. Mr. Priebe also testified that he had reviewed Dr. Katz’s 2004 assessment data and his reports from 1999 and 2001.

9 The Hearing Officer is not suggesting that the testimony at the hearing was sufficient to require an assessment of STUDENT’s sensory sensitivities.

10 The District also recommended an assistive technology assessment and a referral to Ventura County Behavioral Health for a mental health assessment.

11 There was no evidence to show when the 2003-2004 regular school year ended.

12 Petitioner initially challenged the IEP on the additional ground that it failed to adequately address his need for individual psychological counseling. This claim was withdrawn before opening statements.

13 Although none of the evidence specifically addressed the services that were to be provided during the 2004 summer, the Hearing Officer notes that the May 26, 2004 IEP contains offers for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. The Hearing Officer will address Petitioner’s contentions as they apply to both programs offered in the May 2004 IEP.

14 There are also procedural elements of a FAPE, which are not at issue here.

15 A significant amount of time and energy was spent at hearing on the parties’ views of STUDENT’s cognitive ability. The District’s witnesses, including school psychologists Jack Schnell and Darrel Priebe, testified that STUDENT’s overall cognitive ability is best determined by combining measures of his areas of nonverbal strength, such as spatial reasoning, with measures of his areas of weakness, such as verbal and sequential reasoning. Following the District’s analysis, one would conclude that STUDENT’s cognitive ability is in the below average to low-average range. Petitioner’s witnesses, most notably Ms. Glowalla and Dr. Katz, opined that the correct way to determine STUDENT’s cognitive ability and educational potential is to focus on his areas of strength, his nonverbal and spatial skills. Following this analysis, STUDENT’s cognitive ability is average. Although this difference of opinion may be philosophically important in that it reveals the bases for divergent views of STUDENT’s potential as a student, it has less practical importance here. What is practically important is that the parties agree that STUDENT has strengths in non-verbal/spatial areas and weaknesses in verbal/sequential areas. As stated by District psychologist Jack Schnell, who holds a doctorate in education and has been a licensed psychologist for nineteen years, when eligibility is not at issue, the assessment results should be viewed as clues to how the student learns. The focus should be on the student’s skills so that the educational program can be designed to efficiently deliver instruction to the student. There did not appear to be any dispute regarding that proposition.

16 It is known that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. Petitioner did not mention this disorder in connection with this aspect of the dispute.

17 Although there is nothing in the record to indicate that STUDENT had any speech and language needs when the IEP was developed, the parents requested and the District agreed to an assessment in that area. It is possible that the assessment will identify such needs.

18 There was some suggestion in the evidence that the PARENTS would not have agreed to any program for STUDENT that did not include Lindamood-Bell instruction specifically. For example, FATHER testified that all he and his wife wanted for STUDENT was Lindamood-Bell instruction and if the District had offered that, there would have been no due process hearing. However, the evidence was insufficient to establish that the PARENTS were not sincerely interested in a public school placement that met STUDENT’s unique needs, even if it did not include Lindamood-Bell instruction.

19 Although the IEP actually refers to “access to additional adult support” throughout the school day, there was testimony from those who participated at the IEP meeting, including MOTHER, that this referred to a one-to-one aide. Petitioner did not allege otherwise and did not claim that the IEP offer was fatally unspecific in this regard.

20 There were similar criticisms of the several other SDCs that were observed by Ms. Glowalla, but those are not addressed here because they were not classes proposed by the District and there was no evidence that they were sufficiently comparable to provide constructive information.

21 Petitioner does not challenge the proposed general education elective courses. Ms. Glowalla testified that mainstreaming (placement in general education courses) for vocational electives was a good idea.

22 There was evidence in the documentary record suggesting that STUDENT had, and possibly still has, significant social and emotional issues and that these issues may still have an adverse impact on STUDENT’s education. Mr. Faucher testified that STUDENT had social and emotional issues while attending Countryside during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years. In Mr. Faucher’s opinion, STUDENT had difficulties reading social clues and even the small Countryside campus, with a total of only sixty students, appeared to present a challenge for STUDENT, who was easily frustrated. STUDENT’s frustration would lead to anger and acting out. STUDENT also acknowledged to Mr. Faucher that he was unhappy and tended to be withdrawn. According to clinical psychologist Gary Katz, STUDENT experienced social and emotional difficulties over the years, particularly since the spring of 1999. In his February 2004 assessment report, Dr. Katz refers to a single incident of vague suicidal and homicidal ideation, the latter directed toward his mother, when STUDENT was eleven years old (1999). He was also hospitalized briefly in July 2000 after what Dr. Katz describes as “several episodes of increasing violent and aggressive behaviors toward his parents.” STUDENT was discharged on mood stabilizing drugs, in addition to previously prescribed anti-depressant medication and a stimulant to address his attention deficits. Within months, STUDENT was experiencing visual and auditory hallucinations and his behaviors became more problematic. After a course of additional medication and frequent psychotherapy, STUDENT was reported to have improved to the point where he was continuing to take only a mood-stabilizing drug at the time of Dr. Katz’s 2004 assessment. Because Petitioner chose not to present social and emotional issues for consideration, the Hearing Officer considers such evidence to be outside the scope of this Decision.