California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 29, 2001

Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1569-01, SN 809-00 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Colton Joint Unified must add a weekly speech session for one year; its special day class offer is upheld over full inclusion.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 7 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

A stay put order was issued January 19, 2001 (placement at D'Arcy Elementary under the September 26, 2000 IEP). The District's July 2001 case was consolidated with Student's case SN 809-00 by minute order on July 18, 2001, with SN 809-00 as the lead case. No remand, vacatur, or correction is noted.

Summary

Parents of a 9-year-old third grader with autism filed for due process against Colton Joint Unified School District in May 2000. The District filed its own case in July 2001, and the two cases were consolidated. The student first qualified for speech and language services and was later found eligible under autism. The parents claimed the District failed to assess him properly, including for a learning disability, and denied him a FAPE from 1998-99 through 2001-02. They also sought reimbursement for an independent behavior assessment by behavior analyst Regina Granados.

The Hearing Officer found the District's assessments appropriate except one: its April 2000 functional analysis assessment lacked the baseline data, antecedents, consequences and records review that state regulations require. A March 2001 assessment by program specialist Laurie Wellner was appropriate, so the District did not have to pay for the independent assessment. The District provided a FAPE in 1998-99. It denied a FAPE in 1999-2000 and 2000-01 because the IEPs had no behavior goals and the District did not show that 30-minute speech sessions once or twice a week were enough. For 2001-02, the Hearing Officer upheld a special day class at Jurupa Vista Elementary as the least restrictive environment, citing frequent classroom disruptions, but found the speech services too low. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and add one 30-minute speech session per week for one year. No compensatory services were awarded for the behavior deficits.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO checked a functional analysis assessment against each element of the state behavior regulation. It treated missing behavior goals and unsupported speech minutes as a denial of FAPE. It also weighed classroom disruption under the Holland test to approve a special day class over full inclusion.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately for the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01, and 2001-02 school years?

    District assessments were appropriate, and a learning disability was not a suspected area of disability, except that the April 2000 functional analysis assessment failed to meet the requirements of Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052, so the 1999-00 behavior assessment was inadequate.

  2. Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Granados?

    Because the District's March 2001 functional analysis assessment by Laurie Wellner was appropriate, the District need not pay for the later independent assessment by Regina Granados.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-99 school year?

    The SDC program with speech and counseling met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit; the regular education teacher's absence from the May 1998 IEP meeting caused no loss of educational opportunity or parent participation.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?

    The May and October 1999 IEPs had no behavior goals, placed him in a severely handicapped SDC that was too low functioning, and the District did not show that 30-minute speech sessions one to two times a week were adequate, which denied a FAPE.

  5. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year?

    The June 2000 IEP lacked behavior goals and an appropriate functional analysis assessment, and the District did not show that the amount of speech therapy met his needs as a student with autism, which denied a FAPE.

  6. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year?

    The self-contained SDC at Jurupa Vista (the school for his new attendance area), with mainstreaming in math, art and PE and the May 2001 BIP, was appropriate and the LRE under Holland, but two 30-minute speech sessions per week were inadequate.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7. If the District did not offer or provide STUDENT with FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

    Awarded one additional 30-minute speech session per week for one year; denied compensatory education for the behavior deficits because the record did not show their effect on educational performance; further assessments are not a compensatory remedy.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to the self-contained SDC placement at Jurupa Vista Elementary School and modify the May 29, 2001 BIP to reflect the change of placement.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District's offered placement in a self-contained SDC at Jurupa Vista Elementary School, with mainstreaming in math, art and physical education, was upheld and is to be written into the IEP.
  • Compensatory education. In addition to the two 30-minute speech and language sessions per week in the IEP, the equivalent of one additional 30-minute session of speech and language therapy per week for a one-year period; the IEP team decides how to deliver it without harming his academic coursework.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District

People named in the decision

  • Regina Marie Granados, independent behavior analyst; expert witness for Student
  • John Lyons, principal, D'Arcy Elementary School
  • Laurie Wellner, program specialist; conducted March 2001 functional analysis assessment, East Valley SELPA / District
  • Dina Yvette Valdez, 1:1 aide / instructional assistant, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Ann Palmatier, resource specialist, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Niki Bell, second grade general education teacher (2000-01), D'Arcy Elementary School
  • Marshall Heaney, special education (SDC) teacher, 1999-00, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Misty Fairchild, occupational therapist; conducted 2001 OT assessment, East Valley SELPA
  • Kaye Sheffield, speech and language therapist; conducted December 2000 assessment, East Valley SELPA
  • Diane D'Agostino, director of pupil personnel services, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Gayle Wray, occupational therapist; conducted February 2000 OT assessment, East Valley SELPA
  • Rick Dischinger, director of administrative services, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Karen Willits, third grade general education teacher (2001-02), D'Arcy Elementary School
  • Donna Swenson, speech and language specialist; assessor, East Valley SELPA / District
  • Wendy Franklin, SDC teacher, 1998-99 (Lincoln), San Bernardino County
  • Cyndi Bachman, school psychologist; triennial assessment and April 2000 functional analysis assessment, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Thomas F. Gross, Ph.D., psychologist; assessor, Inland Regional Center
  • Nick Cook, Ph.D., speech/language pathologist; Diagnostic Center field assessment, California Department of Education Diagnostic Center
  • Kathy Foster, private occupational therapist, Kaiser Permanente
  • Raj Pandita, speech language therapist; May 1999 assessment
  • Melinda Benson, speech language pathologist at June 2000 IEP meeting
  • Steven Boyce, general education teacher at May 2001 IEP meeting
  • Sunni Coleman, instructional aide, 1999-00
  • Mrs. B. Jones, second grade general education (mainstream) teacher
  • Mrs. LaFranco, teacher, small-group reading and math mainstreaming
  • Mrs. Swartz, District staff who read the behavior plan at April 2000 IEP meeting
  • Dr. Leong, private pediatrician

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Bloomington, California, on July 26, 27, August 2, 3, and September 4, 5, 6, 7 and 20, 2001.

STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by advocates Victoria Baca and Raul Wilson of the Mexican-American Education Foundation. PARENT and PARENT, father and mother of STUDENT, also appeared on his behalf. The Colton Joint Unified School District (District) was represented by Gail Lindberg, program manager for East Valley SELPA. Upon agreement of the parties, attorney Rick R. Silva of Lozano Smith acted as an advisor for the District beginning on September 6, 2001. Also present on behalf of the District was Diane D’Agostino, director of pupil personnel services for the District.

Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Regina Marie Granados, behavioral analyst; John Lyons, principal of the D’Arcy school; Laurie Wellner, program specialist for the District; Dina Yvette Valdez, one-to-one aide for the District; Ann Palmatier, resource specialist for the District; Niki Bell, second grade teacher for the District; Marshall Heaney, special education teacher for the District; Misty Fairchild, occupational therapist for the District; Kaye Sheffield, speech and language therapist for the District; Diane D’Agostino, director of pupil personnel services for the District; Gayle Wray, occupational therapist for the District; PARENT, mother of Student; and PARENT, father of Student.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mr. Rick Dischinger, director of administrative services for the District; Ann Palmatier, resource specialist for the District; Mr. John Lyons, principal of the D’Arcy school; Diane D’Agostino, director of pupil personnel services for the District; Karen Willits, third grade teacher at D’Arcy; Donna Swenson, speech and language specialist for the District; Wendy Franklin, severely handicapped teacher for the San Bernardino County school district; Gayle Wray, occupational therapist for the District; Cyndi Bachman, school psychologist for the District; Dina Valdez, instructional assistant; Laurie Wellner, program specialist; Misty Fairchild, occupational therapist;

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately for the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01, and 2001-02 school years?

2. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Granados?

3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-99 school year?

4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?

5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year?

6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year?

7. If the District did not offer or provide STUDENT with FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student contends that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE for the 1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-01 school years, and also failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year, on the basis that the District “could not provide an appropriate educational program during [each] school year because [the District] lacked important diagnostic information.” Student contends that the District did not, for each year, assess Student in an area of suspected disability - a specific learning disability (SLD) - and that the District failed to provide appropriate assessments in the areas of occupational therapy (OT), auditory integration therapy (AIT), speech and language therapy, functional analysis assessment(s), and psychoeducational assessment. Student seeks reimbursement for an independent functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavior intervention plan (BIP) written by Ms. Regina Granados, and also seeks OT, AIT, speech and language, and psychoeducational assessments for use in providing STUDENT with appropriate services in these areas.(Footnote 2)

The District contends that it has conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT in all suspected areas of disability and has conducted all recommended assessments, including psychoeducational, speech and language, OT, Diagnostic Center, and functional analysis assessments. The District also contends that it has provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01 school years, and the District contends it offered STUDENT an appropriate placement and services for STUDENT for the 2001-02 school year at the neighborhood school with a one-to-one aide, OT, consultation regarding sensory issues affecting classroom performance, mainstreaming in an age-appropriate general education class, behavioral intensive case manager (BICM) monitoring, and adjustment of the behavior intervention plan.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

STUDENT, age 9, is a third-grade student at the D’Arcy Elementary School as a child diagnosed with autism. STUDENT has been a student within the District since kindergarten. STUDENT resides with his parents and sisters. According to an October 1997 Language, Speech and Hearing (LSH) report prepared by Donna Swenson of the East Valley SELPA, STUDENT was assessed and enrolled in special education for LSH services in June 1995, and was enrolled in Headstart for the 1995-96 preschool year. (Dist. Exh. 29) In February 1996, STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class (SDC) with LSH and DIS tutor support, and in June 1996, STUDENT continued in the SDC. (Dist. Exh. 29)

On April 22, 1997, psychologist Thomas F. Gross, Ph.D., assessed STUDENT on behalf of the Inland Regional Center to determine whether STUDENT qualified for Regional Center services on the basis of autism or mental retardation. Dr. Gross’s report indicates that

STUDENT’s speech and language development was delayed and that he participated in special education at Grand Terrace Elementary school and received speech and language therapy.

Dr. Gross found that STUDENT did not have autism or mental retardation, finding instead that STUDENT’s “performance on these tests shows him to be functioning within the average range of nonverbal intellectual ability with deficits in adaptive behavior.” Dr. Gross found STUDENT to exhibit a pervasive developmental disorder (NOS), with a number of behaviors that suggested autism. Nevertheless, Dr. Gross recommended that “those working with STUDENT adopt an approach similar to that used when working with children who experience autism.” Dr. Gross recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in special education and speech/language therapy. (Dist. Exh. 34).

Ms. Donna Swenson, speech and language specialist for the District, assessed STUDENT in August and September 1997, and on the Preschool Language Scale 3 (PLS-3), STUDENT’s auditory comprehension score placed him at an age equivalent of one year, 3 months. STUDENT’s expressive communication score placed him at an age equivalent of one year, 7 months. STUDENT’s total language score placed him at an age equivalent of one year, 6 months. Each of the scores placed STUDENT at the 1 percentile rank. In her discussion of test scores and observations, Ms. Swenson found that STUDENT had a difficult time making choices and following directions and that “for more than 50% of the time” STUDENT did not perform the task even after multiple requests.

Neither party submitted evidence indicating that STUDENT was assessed again prior to his annual review IEP meeting held on May 26, 1998, to determine STUDENT’s placement for the 1998-99 school year. (1998-99 school year)(Footnote 3)

At STUDENT’s annual IEP review meeting held on May 26, 1998, the IEP team agreed to the following placement and services for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year: special day class (SDC) five days per week for a total of 23 to 25 hours, LSH services 15 to 30 minutes per day 1 to 2 days per week; and counseling services in 30 minute sessions, once per month. STUDENT was to be mainstreamed into regular education 5 to 7 hours per week. Under the category “primary handicap,” STUDENT was identified as SLD (specific learning disability). A notation under the comments section indicates the following: “Team review STUDENT’s 97-98 school year goals. Parents report STUDENT has just started medication for hyperactivity....STUDENT continues to meet the Title V criteria for SDC, LSH and counseling. Parent concerned about current placement. Options discussed and visitation set. New goals developed for STUDENT. Assignments modified as needed. No Star 9 testing.” STUDENT’s placement school is listed as Grand Terrace and Home School as D’Arcy, for first grade. (Student’s Exh. 19)

Meanwhile, STUDENT had been referred by the District to the California Department of Education Diagnostic Center for an individual speech language assessment. On June 10 and 11, 1998, speech/language pathologist Nick Cook, Ph.D. conducted a “field assessment” of STUDENT. Dr. Cook addressed the following areas in his report: strategies to assist STUDENT with transitioning and staying on task; the use of drawings as a way to increase STUDENT’s understanding of directions; the use of a similar system to make STUDENT’s daily schedule more concrete; and interventions to improve speech and language skills. Dr. Cook emphasized that observation and proper timing are critical and that there is a need for adults to provide the appropriate prompt before the student becomes frustrated. Dr. Cook also recommended providing STUDENT with scripts for situations for which STUDENT has none or for which he gives eccentric or idiosyncratic responses. Dr. Cook also recommended teaching STUDENT turn-taking with games such as Lotto. (Student Exh. 5)

In an annual review speech language report dated June 19, 1998, Ms. Donna Swenson notes that “STUDENT has been enrolled in the Special Day Class with counseling and speech therapy.” Within her report, Ms. Swenson observes the following: “STUDENT has had a goal to orally choose between two activities. STUDENT continues to have difficulty with this task. He generally echoes the last part of the questions. He is learning to choose between two objects however...STUDENT’s other goal has been to answer simple “what” questions. STUDENT is making progress on this goal. He is learning to label more objects.” Ms. Swenson noted that STUDENT “continues to get most of his needs or desires met through grabbing things, fussing and pulling, and some verbalizations. STUDENT’s eye contact continues to be limited.” Ms. Swenson recommended continued speech language therapy in order to increase STUDENT’s communication skills. (Student Exh. 28)

On September 22, 1998, the IEP team met and STUDENT’s placement school was changed to Lincoln. Under the comments section, the following is noted: “Team met to review the [L.A.] diagnostic center...report for STUDENT. Team discussed the techniques identified in the report. Team talked about the SDC program at the Lincoln school. Team and parents agreed to have STUDENT transferred to Lincoln school. Parent requesting to meet at the end of October to review placement and progress. Goals are current. No Star 9 testing.” (Student’s Exh. 19) STUDENT then attended Lincoln’s SDC taught by Wendy Franklin, a credentialed teacher with a master’s degree in special education. (Test. of Ms. Franklin)

The IEP team met again on December 7, 1998, to review STUDENT’s program and placement. STUDENT’s primary handicap is indicated as SLD, and STUDENT’s program is described as follows on the IEP team report: SDC for 276-300 minutes, five days per week; LSH services 30 minutes per day, 1 to 2 days per week; and 30 minutes per day of counseling, 2 to 4 times per month. Under the comments section, the following is noted: “Team met to discuss progress and placement. STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom has greatly improved. Parent states his behavior at home has not improved. Parent is pleased with progress he has made in the classroom, but parents are requesting additional services with behavior modification. Team will investigate options and have a follow up meeting in January to discuss findings and 3-year evaluation. Goals are current. Parent will not sign IEP at this time or assessment plan.” (Dist. Exh. 9)

On December 15, 1998, Kathy Foster, an occupational therapist with Kaiser Permanente, reports on STUDENT’s progress for “approximately 22 months” as follows: “STUDENT has made progress in eye contact, interaction with other children in the group and play skills. His language has really developed, allowing him to communicate better with the other children and perhaps less frustration is exhibited. He does continue to resist when required to participate in a group activity and generally tries to escape the situation. However, he is participating more often and is following directions on a more consistent basis. Behavior has been a concern for his family and is frequently an issue in therapy. He is often very impatient and has much difficulty with delayed gratification. He has also been known to run away to another area of the treatment room when it is time for a group activity and to scream or yell inappropriately.” (Dist. Exh. 32)

On February 3, 1999, Dr. Gross again conducted an assessment of STUDENT for the Inland Regional Center. After administering various standardized tests, Dr. Gross observed that STUDENT “appears to experience an atypical type of autism” and that in this case “the line between autism and PDD is a fine one and I am inclined, at this point in time, to give STUDENT the diagnosis of autism so that he can receive the support and services of the Inland Regional Center.” (Student’s Exh. 3)

According to the testimony of STUDENT’s SDC teacher, STUDENT was removed from the school and no longer enrolled in the District in early February 1999, and returned to the school district “after about a one month or so.” The triennial assessment plan was delayed because of this, and STUDENT’s father called the District on April 7, 1999, and said “it was ok to schedule 30 day and 3 year at the same time” (in mid-May). (Test. of Ms. Franklin)

On May 1, 1999, school psychologist Cindi Bachman issued STUDENT’s triennial assessment report, which was based upon testing that occurred in February, March and April 1999.

On May 27, 1999, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s triennial review and to review the triennial assessment. For the first time, STUDENT’s primary handicap for Title V eligibility is listed as autism (PDD). The box for SLD is not checked, nor is any other eligibility category. The IEP team agreed to the following placement for STUDENT: SDC (with mainstreaming) for 240 to 300 minutes, five days per week; LSH small-group pull out 30 minutes per day, 1 to 2 days per week; counseling in class, in 30-minute sessions, 2 to 4 times per month; and counseling with the school psychologist and a small-group pull out, 30 minute sessions, 2 to 4 times per month. STUDENT’s parents indicated full inclusion in regular education as a long-term education priority. Under the category Behavior Management/Intervention Plan, the box “not needed” is checked. (1999-2000 school year)

On October 25, 1999, an IEP team meeting was held at the request of STUDENT’s parents to review his placement. Under the comments section, the IEP document notes the following: “The team met to review at parent request STUDENT’s placement. The parent feels that STUDENT’s placement is inappropriate. Parent would like to see him in the regular ed. placement with an instructional aide. STUDENT currently is 2 ½ hours mainstreamed - 1 hour with Mrs. LaFranco in a reading and math small group setting. 1 ½ hours is in Mrs. B. Jones’ 2nd grade class with an aide. In Mrs. B. Jones’ room, he is usually working on a hands on project. STUDENT continues to see the speech teacher at least ½ hour once a week. To increase STUDENT’s time in Mrs. B. Jones’ class, the schedule will be worked so that he could be comfortably incorporated into the morning activity time and center time. The team will also investigate lunch schedules so that STUDENT may be at lunch with 2nd grade students. Time will be investigated with scheduling so mainstreaming can be increased 1 to 1 ½ hours more...Parent is requesting an O.T. referral. The psychologist will revise STUDENT’s psych. report to reflect parent concerns. A.I.T. was investigated and there are not services in this area. At this time, further investigation will be done. Parent shared Giant Steps Therapy Program.” STUDENT’s placement was modified by reducing the amount of time spent in the SDC to 180 minutes, five days per week, from the prior IEP. (Student’s Exh. 17)

On January 11, 2000, at the request of STUDENT’s parents, an IEP meeting was held at the Lincoln school. STUDENT’s parents requested a functional analysis assessment and requested information about STUDENT’s progress towards goals and objectives. The IEP document indicates STUDENT’s placement as follows: SDC 60 - 120 minutes per day, 5 days per week; mainstream to regular education 240 minutes per day, 5 days per week; counseling monitor 40 minutes per day, 2 - 4 days per week; and LSH 30 minutes per day, 2 - 4 days per week. (Student’s Exh. 17)

On February 25, 2000, STUDENT was given an OT assessment by Gayle Wray, school occupational therapist for the East Valley SELPA. Ms. Wray recommended that the IEP team consider a referral to a “behavior specialist to develop a behavior intervention plan” and that the IEP team consider use of a wedge “to increase trunk extension when STUDENT sat,” and that “proprioceptive activities be provided to the classroom staff to provide strategies “to encourage redirection when STUDENT is upset.” (Student’s Exh. 7)

On April 26, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held to review a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavioral intervention plan (BIP) prepared by the District. (FAA and BIP at Dist. Exh. 23) The parents did not agree with the FAA and BIP and requested an independent FAA and BIP. The parents also requested speech therapy five times per week on an individual, small group, and consultative basis. Under the District’s proposed placement, STUDENT was to receive 60 to 120 minutes in a self-contained classroom with mainstream to regular education 240 minutes, five days per week. and forty minutes of “counseling monitor” 2 to 4 days per month, with thirty minutes of LSH, 2 to 4 days per week. (Dist. Exh. 5)

On May 9, 2000, the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) received a request for a due process hearing from advocate Victoria Baca of the Mexican American Education Foundation on behalf of STUDENT. The Petitioner named the Colton Joint Unified School District as a respondent and raised a denial of a free and appropriate public education issue, and asserted a request for daily speech & language therapy, auditory integration therapy, and a one-to-one behavioral aide. The Hearing Office designated the case as Case No. SN 809-00.

On June 5, 2000, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s annual review. The IEP indicates that Student requested placement in home school “- full inclusion - yellow track - for grade 2" [and that] STUDENT “will be in a 2-3 combo class, as confirmed on 6/5/00.” The IEP further states that “the existing [BIP] will remain in place.” The team also recommended a 4-hour aide and 2 hours of RSP support. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the placement as follows: In class and pull-out for 90-120 minutes, 5 days per week to start in July 2000, with an aide 240 minutes per week, five days per week, to begin in July 2000, and LSH/individual services, in 30-minute sessions, two days per scheduling to begin July 2000. (Dist. Exh. 4)

(2000-01 school year)

On September 26, 2000, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s program and his goals and objectives. Within the comments section, the team recommended that the behavior plan “be revisited” and that STUDENT’s aide and resource specialist participate in training at the Diagnostic Center on September 28. Additionally, the aide accompanying STUDENT to the cafeteria would need to facilitate interaction with other students. STUDENT’s placement was maintained. The team agreed to have a speech therapist assess STUDENT to determine if STUDENT needed the Lindamood Bell program. (Dist. Exh. 3)

On December 5 and 6, 2000, Kaye Sheffield, a speech language therapist with the East Valley SELPA, assessed STUDENT based upon the September 26 IEP request by STUDENT’s parents. Ms. Sheffield found that STUDENT exhibited “fluent speech throughout testing and observations” and that the “pitch, intensity and quality of his voice is appropriate for his age, size, and sex.” Ms. Sheffield found STUDENT’s receptive language scores to be “extremely low” and his expressive language scores to be “not quite as low.” (Student’s Exh. 10 and Test. of Ms. Sheffield)

On January 16, 2001, Misty Fairchild, an occupational therapist with the East Valley SELPA, began her assessment of STUDENT for OT. Ms. Fairchild issued an initial report on January 16. (Student Exh. 8) Ms. Fairchild re-assessed STUDENT on February 12, 2001, and issued an updated report on March 14, 2001. (Student Exh. 9)

On January 19, 2001, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order, in response to Student’s request, finding that STUDENT’s stay put is at the D’Arcy Elementary School in accordance with the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated September 26, 2000.

On January 30, 3001, the IEP team met “as a result of a mediation held on January 4. OT and LSH assessments were presented and discussed. The OT assessment results indicated 92-100% legibility for handwriting, and STUDENT’s only difficulty as holding his pencil tightly. Ms. Fairchild found that STUDENT did not need OT services, but offered to do further “observation in the classroom when STUDENT comes back on track.” (Test. of Ms. Fairchild and Dist. Exh. 2).

On March 15, 2001, District program manager Laurie Wellner issued an FAA and BIP based upon her observations of STUDENT in the classroom, on recess, and at home. (Dist. Exh. 22)

(2001-02 school year)

On May 23, 2001, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s annual review and to review the BIP and FAA prepared by Laurie Wellner. (Dist. Exh. 1) The District proposed the following placement for STUDENT, which was not agreed to by STUDENT’s parents: a self-contained SDC class at Jurupa Vista Elementary School with mainstreaming in math, art and physical education. Student contends that he should be placed in a regular education classroom with supports and services outlined by behavior analyst Ms. Regina Granados. (Test. of PARENTS and Ms. Granados, and Student Exh. 1)

On June 13 and 23, 2001, Ms. Regina Granados, behavior analyst, conducted behavioral observations of STUDENT to form the basis for an independent FAA at the request of STUDENT’s parents.

On July 5, 2001, STUDENT began third grade in the regular education classroom at the D’Arcy Elementary School based upon the last-agreed upon IEP placement of STUDENT.(Footnote 4)

On July 10, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from Gail Lindberg, program manager, East Valley SELPA, on behalf of the District. The District asserted that it has conducted appropriate assessments of Student and does not need further assessments to determine appropriate placement and services. The District also requested consolidation with Student’s Case No. SN 809-00. The District maintained throughout the hearing that appropriate assessments were conducted of STUDENT and that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01 school years, and offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year. On July 18, 2001, the Hearing Office issued a minute order granting the District’s motion to consolidate and designated Case No. SN 809-00 as the lead case.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately for the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01, and 2001-02 school years?

Student contended throughout the hearing that the District failed to assess STUDENT in an area of suspected disability - a specific learning disability (SLD) - and failed to provide an appropriate functional analysis assessment of STUDENT and an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for STUDENT.(Footnote 5) The District contends that it conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT in all suspected areas of disability and conducted all recommended assessments of STUDENT, including psychoeducational, speech and language, occupational therapy and Diagnostic Center.

The Student did not contend that the assessments conducted by the District failed to comply with California Education Code § 56320.(Footnote 6) The Hearing Officer will examine, for each relevant year, the District’s assessments of the Student to determine their appropriateness.

(1998-99 school year)

Psychoeducational and speech/language assessments

The Hearing Officer notes that the parties provided a limited amount of evidence concerning assessments for the 1998-99 school year. Moreover, at the time of the May 26, 1998 IEP meeting, which was held to discuss STUDENT’s progress and to plan for the next school year, only Dr. Gross’s 1997 assessment for the Inland Regional Center and Ms. Swenson’s 1997 speech/language assessment were available to determine STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT was scheduled for his triennial assessment in January 1999, and the L.A. Diagnostic Center assessment for speech and language was not reviewed by the parties until a September 1998 IEP meeting. Further, Ms. Swenson’s annual review report dated June 19, 1998, for STUDENT’s speech and language was issued after the IEP meeting.

The reports indicate, certainly, and beyond dispute of either party, that STUDENT had significant speech and language deficits and needed speech/language therapy. In her annual review, Ms. Swenson recommended “continued speech language therapy...to increase STUDENT’s communication skills.” (Student Exh. 28) Under the comments section, the May 26 IEP indicates that “STUDENT continues to meet the Title V criteria for SDC, LSH and counseling.”

As referred to above, Dr. Gross had concluded on April 22, 1997, that STUDENT did not have autism or mental retardation and that STUDENT’s performance on tests showed him to be functioning “within the average range of nonverbal intellectual ability.” On the Leiter International performance Scale, a nonverbal test of intellectual ability, Dr. Gross gave STUDENT a ratio IQ of 91 for a mental age of 5 years old. Dr. Gross administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale and found that STUDENT received a scaled score of 51 on the Communication Domain, finding that STUDENT’s speech was difficult to understand and that STUDENT was reported to follow object-action directions and commands without difficulty and to recite “some but not all the alphabet” and to print “his whole name.” Dr. Gross determined STUDENT’s scaled score on the Socialization Domain to be 64, and that STUDENT regarded “family members and familiar members as significant others and seeks their attention and regard” and that STUDENT was “reported to show an interest in other children’s activity and will attempt to imitate their activity,” showing a “preference for some children over others...although he has not established any friendships.” (Dist. Exh. 34)

On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-R and the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-R, STUDENT’s scaled scores were below 55, with an age equivalence below 2 years, 6 months. On the Peabody, Dr. Gross observed that STUDENT “was unable to identify any items’ names on this task.” On the Expressive One-Word, the child is asked to name pictures, and STUDENT was “able to name 4 of the first 12 pictured items,” but his words were misarticulated and difficult to understand. On the Autism Screening Inventory for Educational Placement (ASIEP) Autism Behavior Checklist, based upon information provided by STUDENT’s mother, Dr. Gross found that STUDENT’s score of 36 was below the score - above 67 - typical for children previously diagnosed with autism. On the Sensory domain, PARENT reported that “STUDENT exhibits no unusual sensory responses or sensitivity.” On the Body and Object Use, PARENT reported that STUDENT “does not typically exhibit repetitive or stereotyped behavior.” (Dist. Exh. 34) In her speech and language assessment performed in August and September 1997, Ms. Swenson testified that it took five sessions to complete STUDENT’s testing. Ms. Swenson found that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services as a student with exceptional needs in the area of speech/language under Title V regulations, answering “yes” to the question, “does pupil demonstrate difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services?” (California Education § 56333) Ms. Swenson found that “STUDENT’s language needs should be met through a combination of in class and individual support. Areas to be addressed would include improving eye contact, following directions, increasing use of meaningful words, both imitative and spontaneous, and answering concrete questions (such as where an object is or what an object is used for). Lengthening STUDENT’s attention span and increasing his willingness to cooperate will significantly assist STUDENT in meeting goals.” (Dist. Exh. 29)

Notwithstanding Student’s contention that the District failed to assess him in an area of suspected disability - SLD - no credible evidence was presented at the hearing that indicates that SLD was a suspected area of disability for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Officer notes that Student’s concern over the reliability of the District’s assessments may stem from the District’s erroneous designation of SLD as Student’s “primary handicap” within each of the three IEPs held in 1998.(Footnote 7) Ms. Bachman, the district school psychologist who conducted STUDENT’s triennial assessment in the Spring 1999, credibly testified that the reason SLD appears as STUDENT’s primary handicap on each of the three IEPs held in 1998 (May 26, September 28, and December 7) was due to a computer problem: for a specified period of time the computer used by the East Valley SELPA identified the primary handicap designation as “SLD” for each student who qualified for special education and related services with a speech or language impairment. (Test. of Ms. Bachman) The parties do not dispute that STUDENT was first eligible for special education based upon speech and language deficits, and was then found to have a pervasive development disorder (PDD), and finally was determined to have a mild form of autism. (Test. of Ms. Swenson, PARENTS, and Ms. Bachman).

The Hearing Officer finds that the speech language therapist, Donna Swenson, who has a bachelor’s and master’s degree in speech/language pathology and thirteen years’ experience as a language, speech and hearing (LSH) therapist, had the necessary qualifications to assess STUDENT in an area of suspected disability, speech and language. (Test. of Ms. Swenson) Student did not provide any evidence disputing Ms. Swenson’s qualifications or the validity of her assessment of STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately relied on Ms. Swenson’s speech/language assessment in 1997 and her annual review in 1998 to prepare STUDENT’s IEP for the 1998-99 school year.

The credible evidence establishes that the psychoeducational and speech/language assessments relied upon by the District were adequate to prepare STUDENT’s IEP for the 1998-99 school year, when STUDENT was continuing his placement in an SDC with a speech and language disability.

Assessments for Behavioral, OT, and AIT issues

No credible evidence in the record indicated that STUDENT needed to be assessed for OT or AIT (auditory integration therapy) services during the 1998-99 school year. In testimony concerning an OT assessment conducted for STUDENT during the 1999-00 school year, occupational therapist Gayle Wray stated that auditory integration therapy is designed to assist students in dealing with environmental noises in order to help train a student’s ears and auditory processing to deal with sounds and noises. Dr. Gross had previously reported that PARENT had said that STUDENT exhibited no unusual sensory responses or sensitivity. The record indicates that STUDENT was already receiving OT services through Kaiser Permanente. (Student Exh. 6 and Test.of PARENTS) Moreover, the IEP team met in September 1998, to discuss the assessment findings of the L.A. Diagnostic Center, and that IEP report did not indicate a need for further assessment at that time. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to conduct an OT or AIT assessment for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year.

The record does not support the contention that STUDENT’s behavior during the 1998-99 school year warranted an FAA. California Code of Regulations § 3052(b) provides that [a] functional analysis assessment shall occur after the individualized education program team finds that instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective. According to an IEP meeting held on December 7, 1998, under the comment’s section, the following entry is made: “Team met to discuss progress and placement. STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom has greatly improved. Parent states his behavior at home has not improved. Parent is pleased with progress he has made in the classroom, but parents are requesting additional services with behavior modification.” (Dist. Exh. 9) Moreover, STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the 1998-99 school year, Wendy Franklin, credibly testified that STUDENT began the school year with behavioral problems, but improved dramatically as the year went on after she employed techniques referred to in the L.A. Diagnostic Center report and after she began using the PECS system for picture scheduling to improve STUDENT’s ability to transition to other tasks. The Hearing Officer concludes that an FAA was not necessary because the credible evidence demonstrates that the instructional/behavioral approaches employed by Ms. Franklin were effective and had led to a significant improvement in STUDENT’s behavior.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District relied on appropriate assessments conducted of STUDENT by Dr. Gross, Ms. Swenson, and Dr. Cook and that the District was under no obligation to perform an OT or AIT assessment, or to conduct an FAA during the 1998-99 school year. The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District appropriately relied on prior assessments for STUDENT’s 1998 IEPs and that there was no evidence that SLD was a suspected area of disability for STUDENT.

(1999-2000 school year)

Psychoeducational and speech/language assessments

Student contends that the triennial assessment conducted by school psychologist Cyndi Bachman over the period of February, March, and April 1999 was inadequate because Ms. Bachman did not assess STUDENT in an area of suspected disability, a specific learning disability (SLD). The Hearing Officer notes that IEP meetings held on May 26, 1998, September 22, 1998, and December 7, 1998, all give STUDENT’s “primary handicap” as specific learning disability (SLD). As the Hearing Officer has previously noted, school psychologist Cyndi Bachman testified that STUDENT’s SLD designation stemmed from a computer problem that characterized all individuals who qualified for special education and related services under a speech/language impairment as SLD.

The credible testimony is that STUDENT first qualified for special education under a speech and language impairment, and that the designation was changed to PDD and then to autism. (Test. of Ms. Swenson, Ms. Bachman, and PARENTS.)

Ms. Bachman based her assessment on standardized assessments performed in the testing area and classroom; on observations made during structured activities, class time and at recess; and on interviews with STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Lincoln (Wendy Franklin) and STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Bachman found that STUDENT’s scaled IQ score of 82 on the Leiter-R, a nonverbal IQ test, placed him within the average range. However, Ms. Bachman found that STUDENT performed poorly on the TERA-2, which is designed to measure early reading ability. STUDENT’s test score, below 58, is the lowest standard score given for the test. On the Woodcock-Johnson achievement test (WJ-R), STUDENT refused to do the reading and math parts of the test, only completing the pointing items on the social studies, science, and humanities, on which he performed significantly below average. Ms. Bachman acknowledged that the pattern of scores indicated “some of the same patterns” for someone with a learning disability, but also indicated that she did not find signs of a specific learning disability. (Test. of Ms. Bachman and Student’s Exh. 4) Ms. Bachman stated that she did not specifically test for an auditory processing deficit and that students with autism all have auditory and language deficits. Ms. Bachman stated that autism affects “all of those other areas,” including language skills and the ability to communicate, and that the diagnosis of autism explains all of STUDENT’s deficits. Ms. Bachman stated that in her opinion, STUDENT is “high functioning” autistic. Ms. Bachman added that auditory deficits are “explained by autism” and that it is “not like there is going to be a separate learning disability that is going to be different” and that when dealing with autism or with auditory processing deficits, you provide “lots of language” and more visual instruction. Ms. Bachman also stated that there is nothing in evidence that indicates that “there is anything going on beyond the autism,” and that there would be nothing substantially different in programming if one found that STUDENT had an SLD.

The fact that STUDENT’s primary disability was speech and language, and then PDD, and then autism, does not relieve the District of its obligation to thoroughly assess a student and to gather all necessary information concerning a student’s needs so that the IEP team can develop an appropriate educational program. “The services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a [FAPE] must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” 34 C.F.R. Section 300.300(a)(3)(ii). The Hearing Officer further notes that Ms. Bachman testified that STUDENT “definitely has difficulty processing auditory, and that on the Leiter-R ability subtests, “you could see some of the same patterns.” Student does not contend that an SLD exists in the math area, and the parties agree that math is one of STUDENT’s strengths. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Palmatier) Moreover, Student did not call any witnesses qualified to perform psychoeducational assessments to challenge the triennial assessment conducted by Ms. Bachman or to provide direct evidence through testing that STUDENT indeed has an SLD.

Ms. Diane D’Agostino, the District’s director of pupil personnel services, testified that she did not find evidence of a discrepancy between ability and achievement for STUDENT, and that any lowered achievement test results for STUDENT were based upon STUDENT’s language deficits.(Footnote 8) Ms. D’Agostino testified that the Leiter-R test gives the “highest possible score” for a student with a communications disorder because “there are no verbal components.” Ms. D’Agostino also stated that STUDENT’s difficulties with the achievement tests were not reflected in STUDENT’s classroom performance, where there was evidence of stronger skills. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Gross’s prior two psychoeducational assessments did not indicate that SLD was a suspected area of disability for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive and credible the testimony of Ms. Bachman, a credentialed school psychologist, who attested to having conducted over 4,000 psychoeducational assessments, and who stated that in her professional opinion SLD was not an area of suspected disability for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds credible the testimony of Ms. D’Agostino, who also stated that STUDENT did not show evidence of having an SLD.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bachman’s triennial assessment satisfied the relevant provisions of § 56320, and that Ms. Bachman was competent to perform the assessment as a credentialed school psychologist qualified to perform the assessment. Education Code §§ 56322 and 56324.

Ms. Bachman noted that STUDENT’s behavior and social skills were “a primary factor in his handicapping condition” and that he “has difficulty with delayed gratification, wanting to do what he wants immediately.” Ms. Bachman also noted STUDENT’s difficulty in his interactions with peers and with sharing and taking turns, but also that he had demonstrated improvement, even though he continued to have temper tantrums when he didn’t get his way. Ms Bachman observed that STUDENT demonstrated good concentration and attention to task when working on preferred activities, but had difficulty with transition between tasks and had some difficulty when asked to work on nonpreferred activities. (Student’s Exh. 4) Ms. Bachman concluded in her summary that STUDENT should continue to receive special education services “as he would have significant difficulty functioning appropriately in the regular program. He will continue to need intensive special education support, but it appears that he would benefit from additional time spent with regular students in a mainstreamed situation to develop more appropriate social and language skills. He has significant difficulty in social areas, language skills, and academic behavior.” (Student’s Exh. 4)

Section 56327 of the California Education Code provides that personnel who assess the pupil shall prepare a written report, or reports, as appropriate, of the results of each assessment and that the report shall include certain items which are discussed herein.

The Hearing Officer finds that the written reports of the assessments conducted of STUDENT during the triennial assessment complied with the requirements of § 56327 of the California Education Code. Ms. Bachman determined within her report and credibly testified to the following: (a) STUDENT continued to need special education and related services as a student with Pervasive Developmental Disorder (NOS); (b) STUDENT’s continued eligibility for special education was based upon her observations of STUDENT in class, structured activities, recess, and interviews with teacher and mother, together with the prior diagnosis of PDD by Dr. Gross on behalf of the Inland Regional Center; (c) Ms. Bachman noted STUDENT’s behavior during the testing and his ability to demonstrate “good concentration and scanning skills” when provided with “tangible reinforcers, such as crackers, juice, and wind-up toys.” (d) Ms. Bachman noted that STUDENT had difficulty with “any task that had more extensive oral directions, having difficulty with comprehension of task demands..[and his ability] to respond appropriately to short questions and one-two step questions;” (e) STUDENT’s history of pe tubes and chronic otitis media, his mother’s report that STUDENT is sensitive to loud noises, and STUDENT’s diagnosis of “high-functioning autism by his pediatrician, Dr. Leong;” (f) Ms. Bachman found this paragraph not applicable, because SLD was not a suspected area of disability for STUDENT; (g) With regard to the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, Ms. Bachman indicated that “during the period of the assessment, there were events which were occurring at home which are felt to have had an impact on STUDENT and are felt to have affected test results. Although STUDENT appears to understand Spanish, his primary language is English, and bilingual factors do not appear to be significant to his language difficulties;”(h) not applicable since STUDENT did not have a “low incidence disability.” (Test. of Ms. Bachman and Student Exh. 4)

STUDENT’s parents indicated that they had no specific information to support the position that the testing was invalid, nor did they provide evidence challenging the test instruments as valid for the purpose for which they were used. Student also did not provide evidence which helped to identify the “important diagnostic information” that Student alleges in his issue statements was missing in the District’s assessments. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the triennial assessment complied with Section 56327.

The May 27, 1999 IEP document sets forth the speech and language assessment results by speech language therapist Raj Pandita. Within the comments section, the following is noted: The speech therapist assessed STUDENT and found that he had some problems with “r” and “l” and blends. In receptive vocabulary, he is presently 3 years 11 months; expressive language [he] is presently at 4 years 2 months. He produced 2 word sentences. The goal is 3 to 5 word sentences and [to] understand the sentences...The mainstreaming stimulates the language. He needs to be seen by the speech therapist 1 to 2 times a week, 30 minutes a day.” (Student’s Exh. 18) Student did not present evidence challenging the speech and language assessment results. The following speech and language goals, to be implemented by the therapist and the teacher, are set forth in the IEP: goal # 1 - student will improve speech intelligibility 80 % of the time; goal # 2 - student will improve expressive and receptive language skills in 3/5 word sentences 80% of the time. Student did not contest the validity of Mr. Pandita’s assessment, nor did Student call as a witness a speech and language therapist to challenge Mr. Pandita’s qualifications. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language assessment, as reflected in the May 27, 1999 IEP, adequately assessed STUDENT in an area of need -- speech and language.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District, in its triennial assessment of STUDENT in 1999, conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

Behavioral, OT, and AIT assessments

The Hearing Officer notes that the District was aware of STUDENT’s behavioral needs that are described in Ms. Bachman’s triennial assessment report. Dr. Gross’s reassessment report of February 3, 1999 was also available to the District in identifying STUDENT’s behavioral needs for the 1999-00 school year. Within his report, Dr. Gross indicated that since the previous evaluation in April 1997, “PARENT reports that STUDENT’s behaviors have worsened, e.g., more problematic social interactions, more repetitive behaviors, and poor development of communication skills.” Dr. Gross therefore reconsidered the diagnosis of autism. Dr. Gross noted that PARENT reported that STUDENT continued to have “troubled interactions with peers,” and had developed a relationship with only one or two children during childhood. Dr. Gross further noted that since his prior evaluation, STUDENT’s behaviors had not improved and appeared to have become more problematic. Dr. Gross noted that these behaviors “are significantly affecting STUDENT’s ability to progress academically, socially, and to develop independence and self-reliance.”

At an IEP meeting held on January 11, 2000, at the request of STUDENT’s parents, the parents requested an FAA and a BIP. California Education Code § 3052(b) provides that “[a] functional analysis assessment must be conducted by, or be under the supervision of a person who has documented training in behavior analysis with an emphasis on positive behavioral interventions. A functional analysis assessment shall occur after the individualized education program team finds that instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective. Nothing in this section shall preclude a parent...from requesting [an FAA] pursuant to the provisions of Education Code §§ 56320 et seq.” Section 3052 states that the FAA procedure shall include (b)(1) [s]ystematic observation of the (A) occurrence of the targeted behavior for an accurate definition and description of the frequency, duration, and intensity, (B) immediate antecedent events associated with each instance of the display of the targeted inappropriate behavior; (C) [s]ystematic observation and analysis of the consequences following the display of the behavior to determine the function the behavior serves for the individual, i.e., to identify the specific environmental or physiological outcomes produced by the behavior. The communicative intent of the behavior is identified in terms of what the individual is either requesting or protesting through the display of the behavior. The FAA must also include: (D) Ecological analysis of the settings in which the behavior occurs most frequently. Factors to consider should include the physical setting, the social setting, the activities and the nature of instruction, scheduling, the quality of communication between the individual and staff and other students, the degree of independence, the degree of participation, the amount and quality of social interaction, the degree of choice, and the variety of activities; (E) a review of records for health and medical factors which may influence behaviors (e.g. medication levels, sleep cycles, health, diet); and (F) a review of the history of the behavior to include the effectiveness of previously used behavioral interventions.

Section 3052 (2) provides that a written copy of the FAA must be given to the parent and shall include all of the following: (A) A description of the nature and severity of the targeted behavior(s) in objective and measurable terms; (B) A description of the targeted behavior(s) that includes baseline data and an analysis of the antecedents and consequences that maintain the targeted behavior, and a functional analysis of the behavior across all appropriate settings in which it occurs; (C) A description of the rate of alternative behaviors, their antecedents and consequences; and (D) Recommendations for consideration by the IEP team which may include as proposed plan as specified in Section 3001(f). Section 3052(c) provides that an IEP team meeting shall be held to review results [of the FAA] and, if necessary, develop a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) and that the IEP team shall include the behavioral intervention case manager (BICM). Section 3052(c) also provides that the BIP “shall become a part of the IEP and shall be written with sufficient detail so as to direct the implementation of the plan.” School psychologist Cyndi Bachman prepared an FAA and a BIP dated April 26, 2000. The FAA targeted the following maladaptive behaviors: (1) Reduce tantrum behavior to no more than 4 per week and (2) The student needs to arrive at school, on time, each day so he can follow the classroom schedule. The targeted behaviors were based upon the following history of targeted behavior: Tantrums occur when STUDENT is asked to do something he chooses not to do, when his schedule is disrupted or transition from preferred to nonpreferred activities. Ms. Bachman identified the following positive replacement behavior for STUDENT to follow: (1) STUDENT needs a schedule - picture/words - to follow each day; (2) STUDENT will be provided with a consistent cue prior to transitions; (3) When adult anticipates a problem, STUDENT will be verbally redirected to task. Ms. Bachman cites the following ecological factors: (1) Noise and activity level in SDC classroom is agitating; (2) STUDENT appears to be able to follow classroom/campus routines. (3) STUDENT needs to participate in age appropriate play activities; (4) Whether STUDENT STUDENT eat breakfast with age appropriate peers.

On April 26, 2000, the IEP team met to review the FAA and a BIP. The IEP document indicates the following under comments: “Per mom’s request, we are not doing the annual review at this time. Mrs. Swartz read the plan and goals to increase desirable behaviors. Advocate representing parent does not agree with the functional analysis nor the behavioral intervention plan that was developed. Advocate and parents are requesting an independent evaluation for a behavioral functional analysis.” (Dist. Exh. 5) The Hearing Officer will examine the characteristics of the FAA to determine whether the FAA appropriately assessed STUDENT’s behavior during the 1999-2000 school year.

A review of the FAA indicates that the FAA is deficient because it does not adequately provide an operational definition, baseline rate, antecedents, and consequences of the targeted maladaptive behavior or the identified positive replacement behaviors as required by § 3052. The FAA also is inadequate because it does not provide a sufficient record review to include the history of behavior, prior interventions, and health and medical and reinforcement preferences, nor does it identify the persons interviewed or indicate the interview results. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the FAA conducted by Ms. Bachman does not meet the statutory requirements of § 3052. Because the FAA is the basis for an appropriate BIP, it follows that the resulting BIP in this instance was not an appropriate one for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District did not provide an appropriate FAA for STUDENT in an area of need - to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs.

STUDENT was given an OT assessment on February 25, 2000, by Gayle Wray, the school OT for the East Valley SELPA. Ms. Wray noted that STUDENT was referred for an OT evaluation “to determine appropriate intervention for behavior modification.” Ms. Wray noted that STUDENT was reported “to be hard to redirect when he gets upset about something” and that he is “impulsive in his behavior.” Ms. Wray further noted that STUDENT “is mainstreamed into a regular education classroom where it is reported that he would benefit from a behavior program.” Ms. Wray noted that the instructional aide, Sunni, who worked daily with STUDENT, reported that STUDENT acted appropriately “90 % of the time,” and that he only acted out when he did not get his way. The aide also reported to Ms. Wray that STUDENT interacted with peers and “only occasionally” needed redirection to participate in a group activity rather than isolated play. Ms. Wray noted within her report that STUDENT “was observed seeking moderate amounts of sensory information in the classroom during instruction time” and that he would “fidget constantly in his seat and had difficulty listening to instructions” and that his teacher reported “the same types of behaviors throughout the day.” Other behavioral observations included the following: STUDENT was “hard to redirect when he gets upset about something” and that he is “impulsive in his behavior.” Ms. Wray noted that STUDENT would benefit from a behavior program for mainstreaming into the regular education classroom, and Ms. Wray recommended that the IEP team consider a referral to a “behavior specialist to develop a behavior intervention plan,” and that the IEP team consider use of a wedge “to increase trunk extension when STUDENT sat” and that “proprioceptive activities” be provided to the classroom staff to provide strategies “to encourage redirection when STUDENT is upset.” (Student’s Exh. 7) Ms. Wray testified that “proprioceptive” is an “awareness of where we are in space, that we know when we put our arm out [and] know where it is.” Ms. Wray testified that when she observed STUDENT in the classroom, she did not observe any behavioral problems, even when she tried to create situations likely to cause him to be upset, mostly in the regular education classroom, but also in the special education classroom. Ms. Wray further testified that she spoke with STUDENT’s SDC substitute teacher, Mr. Heaney, his aide “Sunni,” and his mainstream regular education teacher, and that they said that his outbursts in class resulted from STUDENT not getting what he wanted.

Ms. Wray testified to training Sunni and STUDENT’s teachers in the use of sensory integration techniques, which include the application of deep pressure and a device “that looks like a surgical brush.” Ms. Wray identified the technique as the “Wilbarger protocol,” and stated that she left a packet that had all of the sensory diet suggestions of protocol at the classroom for use by staff members. Ms. Wray testified that she trained Sunni to use the technique and that Ms. Wray was in the classroom for three hours, with 30 to 45 minutes allocated to talking with Sunni about the technique.

Student did not call any witnesses directly challenging the appropriateness of Ms. Wray’s OT assessment or Ms. Wray’s qualifications. The Hearing Officer finds that the OT assessment conducted by Ms. Wray was adequate to address the OT assessment needs, and appropriate for the AIT needs of STUDENT. Ms. Wray credibly testified to her background and qualifications: Ms. Wray had acted as the school OT with the East Valley SELPA since October 1997, had conducted over 100 OT assessments, held a B.S. degree in OT and a State of California certificate in OT, and had appropriate training in AIT. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wray was qualified to perform an OT assessment and was able to identify AIT needs of STUDENT and provided training and techniques for STUDENT’s aide and SDC teacher to assist STUDENT in remaining on task. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided an adequate assessment of STUDENT in the area of OT and AIT.

On the basis of the credible evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided an adequate psychoeducational assessment, OT and AIT assessment of STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not conduct an appropriate FAA of STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.

(2000-01 school year)

It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have speech and language needs and continued to have behavioral needs throughout the 2000-01 school year.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT was assessed by the District during the 2000-01 school year as follows: an LSH (language, speech, hearing) assessment by LSH specialist Kaye Sheffield on December 6, 2000, while STUDENT was “off-track”; a comprehensive LSH assessment on February 27, 2001, and March 1, 2001, conducted by LSH specialist Donna Swenson as a result of STUDENT’s parents’ request at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting; an updated OT assessment on March 14, 2001, by Misty Melyn Fairchild, OTR, of the East Valley SELPA; and an FAA on March 15, 2001, by Laurie Wellner, East Valley SELPA program specialist. The Hearing Officer will determine whether the assessments listed were adequate and appropriate for STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District provided an appropriate psychoeducational triennial assessment in May 1999, and the record does not support the need for another psychoeducational assessment during the 2000-01 school year.

LSH assessments by Ms. Sheffield and Ms. Swenson

Ms. Kaye Sheffield assessed STUDENT on December 5 and 6, 2000, for LSH. Ms. Sheffield testified that she has eleven years’ experience as an LSH specialist with the District and has been a speech and language pathologist since 1970. Ms. Sheffield testified that she administered the Lindamood Auditory Comprehension (LAC) test, the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPT-R), the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R), and a language sample. Ms. Sheffield testified that in her administration of the LAC test, STUDENT had difficulty using blocks in the test. Ms. Sheffield used cut paper rectangles instead, and at that point STUDENT “began to show his ability to listen to sounds and put them together.” (Dist. Exh. 27) Ms. Sheffield testified that her test results are considered valid. Student did not provide any evidence to challenge the results or validity of Ms. Sheffield’s testing or Ms. Sheffield’s qualifications. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Sheffield was appropriately qualified to test STUDENT and that her test results are valid. As a result of Ms. Sheffield’s testing, the IEP team subsequently agreed to implement the Edmark reading program. (Test. of Ms. Sheffield and Ms. Palmatier)

Ms. Donna Swenson assessed STUDENT for speech and language on February 27, 2001, and March 1, 2001, as requested at the IEP team on January 30, 2001, to determine STUDENT’s present levels of speech and language functioning.(Footnote 9) The Hearing Officer has already ruled that Ms. Swenson had the necessary qualifications to perform speech and language assessments, and Student did not challenge Ms. Swenson’s qualifications or provide evidence that she was not qualified to assess STUDENT. Ms. Swenson testified to her administration of the Photo Articulation Test (PAT-3), the EOWPT-R, the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF-III) and a Language Sample. Ms. Swenson testified that test results were valid and that she again found STUDENT to evidence significant delays in the area of communication. (Dist. Exh. 26) Ms. Swenson also testified that STUDENT had made significant gains since she had last seen him in 1998. Student did not provide any evidence to challenge the results or validity of Ms. Swenson’s testing, nor did student challenge Ms. Swenson’s qualifications. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Swenson was appropriately qualified to test STUDENT and that her test results are valid.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in an area of suspected disability, speech and language, during the 2000-01 school year.(Footnote 10)

OT assessment by Ms. Misty Fairchild

Ms. Misty Fairchild, an occupational therapist with the East Valley SELPA, assessed STUDENT for occupational therapy on January 16, 2001, and February 12, 2001. Ms. Fairchild testified that she has B.S. degree in OT and has performed approximately 300 OT assessments. Student did not challenge Ms. Fairchild’s qualifications to perform the OT assessment of STUDENT, nor did Student provide evidence that Ms. Fairchild was not qualified to assess STUDENT. Ms. Fairchild testified to her administration of the Evaluation Tool of Children’s Handwriting (ETCH) and to her observations of STUDENT during testing and to observations she made of STUDENT in the classroom. Ms. Fairchild testified that the results of the ETCH were valid. The ETCH assessed STUDENT’s legibility and speed for classroom tasks and assessed handwriting as a functional skill. Ms. Fairchild found that STUDENT had excellent fine motor grasp and manipulation of the writing tool, that STUDENT did not exhibit sensory behaviors that interfered with classroom activities or functioning, and that STUDENT completed written tasks with “more than adequate legibility.” Ms. Fairchild also found that STUDENT had excellent fine motor grasp and manipulation of the writing tool and that STUDENT had made significant progress in writing in the past two years. Ms. Fairchild recommended “periodic OT consultation with teacher, aides, assistants and other support persons as necessary regarding sensory issues affecting classroom performance” and the use of an adaptive seat wedge to promote writing posture “late in the day.” Student did not provide any evidence to challenge the Ms. Fairchild’s qualifications, or the validity of Ms. Fairchild’s tests and test results. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Fairchild was qualified to test STUDENT and that her test results and observations formed an appropriate OT assessment of STUDENT.

Functional Analysis Assessment by Ms. Laurie Wellner

Ms. Laurie Wellner, program specialist for the East Valley SELPA, prepared a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT and issued a report dated March 15, 2001. Ms. Wellner testified that she has a bachelor’s degree, a master’s degree in special education, and is working towards a second master’s degree. Ms. Wellner stated that she has a California clear single subject teaching credential and a specialist credential in mild to moderate learning handicapped. Ms. Wellner further stated that she has had training in Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA), PECS, and TEACCH. Ms. Wellner previously taught as an SDC teacher for four years and as a regular education teacher for six years. Student did not challenge the qualifications of Ms. Wellner to perform the FAA of STUDENT, nor did Student provide evidence to indicate that Ms. Wellner was not qualified to perform the FAA. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wellner, based upon her education, credentials, and experience, was qualified to perform the FAA of STUDENT.

Ms. Wellner’s FAA report satisfies the requirements of § 3052(2) of the California Education Code. The report indicates in objective and measurable terms the targeted maladaptive behavior, including operational definition (refusal to follow directions either by ignoring or verbalizing “No,” running out of classroom, tantruming, becoming physically agitated, and refusal to participate); baseline rate (two to four times per day based on six days of observation); antecedents (moderate structure, variability in daily schedule, lack of knowledge of expectations), and consequences (anxiety, tantrum behavior, and aggressiveness). The report also identifies positive replacement behaviors, the operational definition (compliance, on-task behavior, participation); the baseline rate (one of four situations when target behavior is exhibited); antecedents (use of TEACCH methods, highly structured and predictable daily schedule, use of social stories and script training); and consequences (reduce anxiety, follow directions, and increase time on task). The report sets forth an ecological analysis in the physical setting and social setting and provides recommendations in the following areas: activities and nature of instruction, scheduling, communication factors, degree of independence, degree of participation, social interaction, degree of choice, and variety of activities. Under review of records, Ms. Wellner notes health and medical factors, indicating STUDENT’s allergies to milk products and some foods. Ms. Wellner lists the following as positive reinforcers: verbal cues, positive reinforcement (verbal, proximity, tangibles), edibles, praise, privileges, and choices for free time (preferred activities). (Test. of Ms. Wellner and Dist. Exh. 22)

The Hearing Officer also finds that Ms. Wellner made a sufficient number of observations of STUDENT in different settings to prepare the FAA. Ms. Wellner testified that she observed STUDENT in the classroom for seventeen hours, and that she observed STUDENT at home for one hour and in transition and in the resource room, for a total of 21 hours of observation.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wellner’s FAA of STUDENT is appropriate and adequate and satisfies the requirements of § 3052 of the California Education Code.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT during the 2000-01 school year. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT was not given any other formal assessments prior to the beginning of the due process hearing in this case.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent FAA written by Ms. Regina Granados?

California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for an independent assessment. On May 29, 2001, PARENT signed the behavioral intervention plan (BIP) that resulted from the FAA prepared by Ms. Wellner that the Hearing Officer has already determined to be appropriate. On June 13 and 23, 2001, Ms. Granados made her observations of STUDENT at home and school and subsequently rendered her FAA report. Because the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s FAA, which was previously prepared by Ms. Wellner, is appropriate, the District is not required to pay for the subsequent independent FAA of Ms. Granados.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1998-99 school year?

In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(D); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56000. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards and conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

To determine whether the District provided or offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide to a child with a disability with a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998).

In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that a child be removed from the regular education environment only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with his IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Hearing Officer will now analyze the application of these requirements to determine whether the District offered a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer notes that the parties presented limited evidence, with the exception of testimony by STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Wendy Franklin, concerning the 1998-99 school year, the 1997 assessment reports of Dr. Gross and speech/language therapist Donna Swenson, and three IEP reports for IEP meetings held in 1998.

Procedural appropriateness

The Ninth Circuit has held that procedural violations of the IDEA do not automatically result in a denial of FAPE unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e., a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992).

Student contends that the District’s failure to have his regular education teacher attend his May 26, 1998 IEP meeting resulted in a denial of FAPE. The IEP indicates that STUDENT was to be mainstreamed from 5 to 7 hours per week and that the regular education teacher, Mrs. B. Jones, was not present for this IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s parents attended the IEP meeting, and there is no evidence to indicate that the parent’s opportunity to participate was compromised by the absence of the teacher. Nor is there evidence that STUDENT suffered a “loss of educational opportunity.” STUDENT continued in his eligibility status, and the IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed upon his placement in an SDC class, with between 5 and 7 hours per week of mainstreaming in the regular education classroom. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the teacher’s absence did not result in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.

Substantive appropriateness (1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

To determine whether the IEP dated May 26, 1998, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. The Student contends that the District could not have provided STUDENT with a FAPE because the District did not have the required assessments or personnel to implement a program to meet his unique needs, particularly his behavior problems. The District contends that STUDENT’s unique needs were met based upon STUDENT’s placement in an SDC with appropriate speech language services as provided within his IEP. The discussion that follows takes into account the Hearing Officer’s determination under Issue No.1 that STUDENT was assessed appropriately for the 1998-99 school year.

A review of the summary of present levels of performance on the May 27 IEP indicates the following: for written expression, STUDENT “writes his first name, copies letters and words [and] can write 2 of his friends’ names”; for language/communication, STUDENT “can identify and name more pictures or common objects, uses 1 to 3 word statements to express his wants and needs, [and] has difficulty expressing himself and answering questions”; for auditory/visual perception, STUDENT “colors within 1/4" to ½” of lines, cuts within 1/4" of lines, will listen to a taped story with headphones (not previously done), and [has] difficulty following directions.” for social behavior, cooperation, attention, social acceptance, responsibility, STUDENT “helps pick up after playtime some of the time, short attention span, enjoys playing with peers at recess, but has difficulty sharing or playing with peers in the classroom.” The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s needs were in the following areas, as reflected by STUDENT’s agreed-upon IEP annual goals and objectives: (1) increase his ability to follow directions; (2) increase math skills; (3) identify alphabet letters; (4) improve his language skills; and (5) be monitored for school progress and adjustment in small group activities by counselor. (Student Exh. 19)

The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the previous psychoeducational test and speech/language assessments indicate no basis for additional testing. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT needed speech and language services. However, Student did not present credible evidence supporting the contention that STUDENT needed more than 1 to 2 thirty-minute sessions of speech and language services per week. It is noteworthy that STUDENT’s pediatric occupational therapist at Kaiser Permanente, Kathy Foster, indicates in a December 1998 report that STUDENT’s “language has really developed allowing him to communicate better with the other children and perhaps less frustration is exhibited.” (Dist. Exh. 32)

The Student did not contend that STUDENT’s placement, within an SDC class, with mainstreaming 5 to 7 hours per week, was inappropriate for STUDENT’s needs. Student did not present evidence that STUDENT needed an FAA and a behavioral intervention plan, nor did Student request an FAA or BIP at the beginning of, or during, the 1998-99 school year. STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Wendy Franklin, testified credibly that her class consisted of nine students and that behavioral goals were not needed since she was able to manage STUDENT’s behavior. Ms. Franklin stated that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior at the beginning of the year dramatically reduced once the PECS (picture schedule) system was in place to help STUDENT with transitions. Moreover, with prompts and cues, Ms. Franklin testified that STUDENT could be redirected and did not need a behavioral intervention plan.

On the weight of the credible evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District IEP offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit

Student did not argue that he his IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, nor did Student present evidence that he did not receive an educational benefit during the 1998-99 school year.

Ms. Franklin credibly testified that STUDENT had received a benefit and that he made progress on goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

(3) Comport with his IEP

This issue was not in dispute. The Petitioner did not raise as an issue the fact that in the past, the District had failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP dated May 26, 1998.

(4) Be provided in the Least Restrictive Environment

Student did not contend or present evidence that STUDENT’s placement was not provided in the least restrictive environment.

The credible evidence establishes that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year.

ISSUE NO. 4 Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-00 school year?

Student contended that the District had not assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, and that the District therefore lacked important diagnostic information to determine STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer has already concluded that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and has assessed STUDENT appropriately in the areas of speech and language, OT, and AIT, but did not provide an appropriate FAA. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will examine the May 27, 1999, and October 25, 1999 IEPs to determine whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE.

Substantive Appropriateness(footnote 11)

(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

Once the IEP team had determined STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services as a student with autism, the District was under an obligation to re-examine STUDENT’s program to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT with appropriate supports and services. Under Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(g) a student is found to be autistic if the student “exhibits any combination of the following autistic-like behaviors, to include but not limited to: (1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness.

(4) Extreme resistance to controls.

(5) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. (6) Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.”

Under federal law, the definition of autism is similar to the definition of “autistic-like behaviors.” Title 34, C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(1)(i) and (ii) provide in pertinent part as follows:

(i) Autism means a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age 3, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences.

(ii) A child who manifests the characteristics of “autism” after age 3 could be diagnosed as having “autism” if [the criteria in (i)] of this section are satisfied.

It is undisputed that as of May 1999, STUDENT exhibited the following characteristics of autism: An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication; a history of relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction; a tendency to maintain sameness and an emerging resistance to controls and to environmental change in daily routines; and a sensitivity to loud noises (sensory experiences). The parties do not dispute that these characteristics became more evident as the 1999-00 school year went on, and that the behaviors culminated in significant behavioral problems in the classroom, and at recess or lunch during spring 2000. (Test. of Ms. Bell, Mr. Lyons, Dina Valdez, and PARENTS)

The Hearing Officer will examine the two IEPs that determined STUDENT’s placement and services during the 1999-00 school year - the May 27, 1999 IEP, and the October 25, 1999 IEP to determine whether the IEPs adequately addressed STUDENT’s characteristics of autism and his needs.

May 27, 1999 IEP

To determine whether the IEP dated May 27, 1999, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to determine STUDENT’s needs at that time. As indicated in the factual background, Ms. Cyndi Bachman, in her psychoeducational report dated May 1, 1999, noted that STUDENT demonstrated the following areas of need associated with his PDD diagnosis: a sensitivity to loud noises; difficulty in language development; delays in expressive vocabulary skills; a need to develop academic skills [which were] significantly below STUDENT’s average ability; a difficulty with behavior such as engaging in tantrums; a difficulty in social interaction with peers; a difficulty in sharing and taking turns; a difficulty with transitioning; and a difficulty with working on non-preferred activities. (Dist. Exh. 3)

The May 27 IEP team agreed to the following placement for STUDENT for the 1999-00 school year: an SDC class 240-300 minutes per day, 5 days per week; LSH 30 minutes per day, 1 to 2 days per week; in-class counseling 30 minutes per day, 2 to 4 days per month; and small group counseling with the school psychologist 30 minutes per day, 2 to 4 days per week. Under rationale for placement in other than regular classroom, the IEP indicates that while STUDENT is making progress socially, emotionally and academically, he “continues to have significant delays in language skills and social and academic.” Under comments, the IEP indicates that STUDENT had met 8 out of 9 goals and partially achieved 1 goal. The IEP also notes that STUDENT is going to recess with regular education students and is being mainstreamed in the second grade in Ms. B. Jones’s class and that he asked questions and picked up cues from the other students as to appropriate behavior. The IEP indicates as follows: “Mainstreaming will continue in the [afternoon and] time will increase according to STUDENT’s focus and program.” The IEP also noted that STUDENT needs continuous prompts for nonpreferred activities. The Ed-mark reading program was recommended.

The following goals and objectives were written into the May 27, 1999 IEP: student will improve speech intelligibility 80% of the time; student will improve expressive and receptive language skills in 3/5 word sentences 80% of the time; student will be monitored for school progress and adjustment in small group and in classroom activities; student will print full name and alphabet letters and participate in interactive writing with 80% accuracy; student will recognize alphabet letters and sounds with 80% accuracy 3/5 trials; student will improve reading skills through early literacy program to level 10 with 75% accuracy; and student will improve simple addition and subtraction facts with 75% accuracy 4/5 trials.

The Hearing Officer notes the following deficiencies with the placement offer and the goals and objectives agreed to by STUDENT’s parents: The main deficiency is the lack of goals and objectives relating to STUDENT’s behavioral needs: his need to reduce tantruming, his need for greater social interaction with peers, and his need to transition better and to engage in non-preferred activities, which are understood by the District’s school psychologist to be ongoing needs for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also notes that the IEP team’s change in STUDENT’s handicapping condition to autism from a speech and language impairment reflects a recognition of behavioral issues commonly associated with PDD or autism, beyond simply the speech and language delays the District had previously been addressing. Moreover, the District was on notice by May 27,as a result of Dr. Gross’s February 3 determination that changed STUDENT’s diagnosis to autism and PARENT’s reports to Dr. Gross regarding STUDENT’s increasing behavioral problems.

Ms. Bachman’s testified to her reliance on the speech language therapist’s report made to the IEP team on May 27. Speech language therapist Raj Pandita, attended the IEP, and the IEP document indicates the following: “mainstreaming stimulates the language. He needs to be seen by the speech therapist 1-2 times a week, 30 minutes a day.” The IEP document does not indicate how Mr. Pandita arrived at the amount of speech and language therapy STUDENT needed, and Mr. Pandita was not called as a witness to testify at the hearing. According to the testimony of Ms. Bachman, STUDENT needed to work on language development so he could understand and work more effectively. Ms. Bachman also testified to the need for “lots of language training.” The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish at the hearing the adequacy of the amount of time given to STUDENT’s area of need crucial for his ability to succeed academically and socially. On this most significant feature of STUDENT’s autistic characteristics, the District’s provision of speech and language therapy 1-2 times per week, 30 minutes per day, is not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as a student with autism.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 26, 1999, IEP was not appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, because goals and objectives were not developed to meet STUDENT’s behavioral needs so that the parties could determine whether STUDENT was making adequate progress in his behavior. The IEP was also deficient in the amount of time allocated to STUDENT for speech and language therapy. October 25. 1999 IEP

The parties met to review STUDENT’s placement at his parents’ request. The parents wanted STUDENT in a regular education placement with an instructional aide. The IEP comment indicates that STUDENT was currently being mainstreamed for 2 ½ hours, 1 hour for reading and math in a small group setting, and 1 ½ hours in Mrs. B. Jones’s second grade regular education classroom.

The IEP team agreed to investigate the matter to mainstream STUDENT an additional 1 ½ hours to 4 hours per day. According to the testimony of STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the 1999-00 school year, Marshall Heaney, Mr. Heaney was in favor of the mainstream request and stated that STUDENT’s instructional aide, Sunni Coleman, accompanied STUDENT to the regular education classroom. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the IEP team again did not establish behavioral goals and objectives for STUDENT at this meeting.

The Hearing Officer notes the testimony of Ms. Bachman, who stated concerns about STUDENT’s placement in Mr. Heaney’s SDC class. Ms. Bachman indicated that STUDENT was “by far the highest functioning student in the class,” and that “most of the other students were non-verbal.” Ms. Bachman stated that “the class he was in was definitely not appropriate because it was too low functioning for him. If he were placed in a class with higher functioning students who were working on similar kinds of academic areas and behaviors, it might conceivably be more appropriate for him than in a regular education classroom with higher expectations.” According to Ms. Bachman, the placement in Mr. Heaney’s SDC with severely handicapped students, annoyed STUDENT, which affected his behavior. Ms. Bachman also testified that STUDENT needed structure in his environment and he needed to have scheduling and routine, because he became very easily confused.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the May 26 and October 25, 1999 IEPs failed to identify goals and objectives for STUDENT to address his behavioral needs at a critical time when he was attempting to be mainstreamed at an increase from 5 to 7 hours per week during the 1998-99 school year to 2 ½ hours, and then up to 4 hours per day per week, for the 1999-00 school year. Given STUDENT’s undisputed difficulties with transitioning and preference for preferred activities and his increasing lack of compliance to staff requests to perform non-preferred activities, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEPs were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs and that his placement in Mr. Heaney’s SDC with severely handicapped students was inappropriate for STUDENT, which contributed to his behavioral problems. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to establish at the hearing that the speech and language therapy of thirty minutes per week for one or two times per week was adequate to address a most significant area of need for STUDENT. The credible evidence establishes that the District’s failure at two IEP meetings to address two fundamental areas of need for STUDENT, behavioral and speech/language, both central to STUDENT’s autism, resulted in a denial of a FAPE for the 1999-00 school year.

(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit

Student did not argue that his IEPs for the 1999-2000 school year were not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, nor did Student present evidence that he did not receive an educational benefit during the 1999-2000 school year. In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the May and October 1999 IEPs were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and led to a denial of a FAPE, this issue will not be addressed.

(3) Comport with his IEP

This issue was not in dispute. The Student did not raise as an issue the fact that the program failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs dated May 27, 1999, and October 25, 1999.

(4) Be provided in the Least Restrictive Environment

Student did not contend or present evidence that STUDENT’s placement was not provided in the least restrictive environment.

On the basis of the credible evidence, that Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year in the area of appropriate goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s emerging behavioral needs and that STUDENT’s placement in Mr. Heaney’s SDC may have exacerbated his behavioral difficulties. Moreover, the evidence also establishes that the District failed to show at the hearing that the provision of speech and language services in thirty-minute sessions, one to two days per week, was adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs in speech and language as a student with autism.

ISSUE NO. 5: Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-01 school year?

Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the assessments conducted by the District during the 2000-01 school year were appropriate and adequate, with the exception of the FAA report dated March 15, 2000, the following analysis refers to the remainder of the agreed-upon IEP for the 2000-01 school year.

Substantive appropriateness(Footnote 12)

(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

To determine whether the placement and services reflected in the June 5, 2000 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT’s needs. There is little dispute over STUDENT’s continuing need for speech and language services. Moreover, the District was aware of STUDENT’s continuing behavioral problems, particularly in the area of compliance, in his difficulty in transitioning from task to task, and in his difficulty in engaging in nonpreferred (i.e., academic) activities.

The IEP team agreed to the following placement for STUDENT: RSP program “in class” and “pull-out” 90 to 120 minutes per day, five days per week; a one-to-one aide four hours per day, five days per week in the regular classroom; individual LSH therapy in thirty minute sessions, two days per week. The IEP indicates that “Melinda Benson” attended the IEP as the speech language pathologist. However, the IEP does not indicate how the IEP team decided on the amount of speech and language therapy STUDENT would receive. Ms. Benson was not called by the District to testify concerning the adequacy of the speech and language therapy, which appears on its face to be inadequate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that the amount of time for speech and language therapy addressed STUDENT’s unique needs as a student with autism.

Student did not challenge the adequacy of the IEP’s speech and language goals and objectives: (1) improve speech intelligibility for r and r blended to greater than 80% of the time in structured activity; (2) improve expressive language skills; (3) improve receptive language skills using classroom required language/activities. Additional academic goals and objectives are as follows: 1) be able to increase his word recognition skills to 180 words at 70% level; 2) be able to apply a beginning sound onto a word ending at a 70% level; 3) be able to dictate 5 word sentences and copy them with correct spacing, spelling and punctuation at 80% accuracy; 4) write 3 to 5 word sentences with correct spelling using the words from his personal dictionary with 80% accuracy; 5) complete math calculations in subtraction and beginning multiplication with 80% accuracy. (Dist. Exh. 3) While the June 5, 2000 IEP appears to adequately address STUDENT’s speech and language needs by identifying appropriate goals and objectives and STUDENT’s needs in other academic areas, appropriate behavioral goals are not identified to address STUDENT’s continuing behavioral needs.

On September 26, 2000, the IEP met to review STUDENT’s placement. STUDENT’s placement school was changed from Lincoln to D’Arcy. The placement services were continued. (Dist. Exh. 3)

Based upon a review of the IEP goals and objectives and Student’s agreement to the June 5, 2000 IEP placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s important behavioral needs, in light of the absence of an appropriate FAA as previously discussed under the assessment issue. The Hearing Officer also finds that in the area of speech and language therapy, the District failed to show at the hearing that the provision of speech and language services in thirty-minute sessions, one or two times per week, adequately addressed STUDENT’s language and communication needs as a student with autism. In all other respects, the June 5, 2000, met STUDENT’s needs. Because the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in two important areas, behavior and speech and language, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year.

(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit

Student did not argue that his agreed-upon IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, nor did Student present evidence that he did not receive an educational benefit during the 2000-01 school year. In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District’s program was not an offer of FAPE because it was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, this issue will not be addressed.

(3) Comport with his IEP

Student does not contend that the services provided by the District did not comport with his IEP, except for the single allegation that Kaye Sheffield, the OT, had stated at the January 30, 2001 IEP meeting that she was only providing speech and language services to STUDENT one time per week in 30-minute sessions, and not two times per week in 30-minute sessions as called for in the September 26, 2000, IEP. (Dist. Exh. 3) Because the Hearing Officer has already determined that the District failed to show that its provision of speech and language therapy was adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs, this issue is moot.

(4) Be provided in the Least Restrictive Environment

Student did not contend or present evidence that STUDENT’s placement was not provided in the least restrictive environment.

The credible evidence establishes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-01 school year because the June 5, 2000 IEP did not adequately address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, and because the District failed to show at the hearing that its provision of speech and language therapy in thirty-minute sessions, one or two times per week, was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as a student with autism.

ISSUE NO. 6: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year?

Before addressing Issue No. 6, the Hearing Officer will address the District’s contention that STUDENT made an intradistrict move and no longer resides within the attendance boundaries of his previous home school of D’Arcy Elementary School and now resides within the attendance boundaries of Jurupa Vista Elementary school. Student stated the following issue on his issue statements: Is Michael D’Arcy STUDENT’s home school?

It is undisputed that STUDENT and his family moved from the attendance boundaries of the D’Arcy Elementary School into the attendance boundaries of the Jurupa Vista Elementary School during the winter break (December 18, 2000, to January 2, 2001). It is also undisputed that STUDENT applied for, and was denied, an intradistrict transfer to the D’Arcy Elementary School based upon the District’s contention that D’Arcy is an “impacted” school with insufficient space for STUDENT. However, STUDENT continues to attend the D’Arcy Elementary school as his last-agreed upon and implemented placement, in accordance with his September 26, 2000 IEP, and the January 19, 2001 stay put order issued by the Hearing Office. Moreover, the Student’s parents appealed the determination to the District, and the District decided to allow STUDENT to continue to attend D’Arcy Elementary School with his two sisters.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT no longer resides within the attendance boundaries of D’Arcy, and that STUDENT now resides within the attendance boundaries of Jurupa Vista. Title 34 of C.F.R. § 300.552(b)(3) and (c) provides, in pertinent part, as follows: “In determining the educational placement of a child with a disability...each public agency shall ensure that the child’s placement is as close as possible to the child’s home [and that] unless the IEP of a child with a disability requires some other arrangement, the child is educated in the school that he or she would attend if nondisabled.” The Hearing Officer finds that Jurupa Vista is the appropriate school for STUDENT because it is the school that he would attend if nondisabled, and Jurupa Vista appropriately addresses STUDENT’s needs, based upon the Hearing Officer’s determination concerning the District’s placement offer for the 2001-02 school year. Accordingly, STUDENT is not a child with a disability who requires some other arrangement.

Procedural appropriateness

Student contends that the District’s failure to have his regular education teacher, Niki Bell, attend the May 23, 2001 IEP meeting resulted in a denial of a FAPE. Niki Bell, credibly testified that she was “off-track” and was unable to attend the May 23, 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Bell further testified that she related her feedback concerning STUDENT to another regular education teacher, Steven Boyce, and that Mr. Boyce attended the meeting in her place. Mr. Boyce’s signature appears on the IEP. The District proposed a change in placement from “full-inclusion” at D’Arcy to a self-contained SDC at Jurupa Vista. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s parents attended the IEP meeting, and there is no evidence to indicate that the parent’s opportunity to participate was compromised by the absence of Niki Bell at the meeting. Nor is there evidence that STUDENT suffered a “loss of educational opportunity.” Ms. Bell testified that she was in favor of the change in placement, and therefore would not have advocated for STUDENT’s continued full-inclusion placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the teacher’s absence did not result in a denial of a FAPE for STUDENT.

Substantive appropriateness (a) Is the District’s offer of placement within the May 23,2001 IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?(Footnote 13) In order to determine whether the district’s offer of placement and services within the May 23, 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to determine STUDENT’s needs. It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to need services for his speech and language deficits, that STUDENT continued to have behavioral needs, that STUDENT needed to develop his social skills, and that STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide for mainstreaming. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District’s March 15, 2001 FAA was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s behavioral needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that PARENTS signed the BIP on May 29, 2001 at the school after the District incorporated soothing strategies recommended by PARENTS. The Hearing Officer accordingly finds that the BIP appropriately addresses STUDENT’s behavioral needs and incorporates a “sensory diet” of soothing strategies. (Dist. Exh. 43 and Test. of PARENTS, Ms. Palmatier and Ms. Wellner)

The parties did not come to agreement at the May 23, 2001 IEP meeting regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-02 school year. The District offered placement at the Jurupa Vista Elementary School within a “self-contained SDC” with mainstreaming in math, art, and physical education. The District also offered continuation of an individual one-to-one instructional aide to be continued at current levels. The IEP indicates the following regarding the District’s offer of speech and language services: “LSH presented proposed language goals. She is recommending DIS speech/language services twice weekly with aide present, so that skills could be followed up at other times with one session to be small group and one session to be individual.” The Hearing Officer notes that page one of the IEP indicates that the speech/language therapy would be in thirty minute sessions two days per week. The Hearing Office further notes that under the parent approval block for the IEP, STUDENT’s parents signed the IEP and indicated that they were not in agreement with an SDC placement for STUDENT.

The District’s director of pupil personnel services, Ms. Diane D’Agostino, credibly testified that Jurupa Vista was selected because it was the only elementary self-contained class (SDC) space available designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for structure as a student with a mild to moderate disability. Ms. D’Agostino stated that the reason the District team members decided to recommend the placement change was that STUDENT was “making minimal progress and he continued to experience behavioral problems.” Ms. D’Agostino also testified that the District did not indicate on the IEP the precise amount of time STUDENT would be mainstreamed because the parents rejected any SDC placement. However, the IEP clearly states that mainstreaming is limited to three subjects - math, art, and physical education. Ms. D’Agostino also stated that an SDC placement generally means that the student is in the SDC at least 50% of the day. The SDC placement would therefore be more restrictive than STUDENT’s “full-inclusion” placement at D’Arcy for four hours per day and two hours per day for RSP pull out.

Ms. D’Agostino also testified that Student did not disagree with any of the goals and objectives set forth within the IEP and that they could be implemented within the Jurupa Vista SDC. The Hearing Officer notes that the following goals and objectives to be implemented by the special education staff: goal (1): progress through a sight-based word reading program such as Edmark with 90% accuracy as measured by progress charts and program assessments; goal (2): begin a corrective reading program that focuses on decoding strategies and progress with 80% accuracy as measured by progress charts and program assessments; goal (3) practice reading and comprehension skills by reading leveled books 9-13 with 90% accuracy and answering factual and inferential questions with 80% accuracy; goal (4) solve problems involving place value of whole numbers with 70% accuracy as measured by teacher made tests; goal (5) calculate and solve problems using addition, subtraction, multiplication and division with 80% accuracy on teacher made tests with charts, manipulatives and/or assistance as needed; goal (6) solve math word problems having key words such as “sum,” “all together,” “difference between,” “less than” with 60% accuracy measured by teacher made tests; (7) demonstrate improvement in written communication as measured by dated portfolio samples; (8) practice initiating social contact with peers after behavior is modeled by adults with 70% results measured by observation, tally sheets and/or daily log; (9) begin to develop more effective communication skills and strategies for expressing his needs. The Student did not disagree with these goals, nor did Student offer evidence suggesting that any of these goals were not designed to meet his needs.

The IEP also indicates two goals to be implemented by the speech language therapist and aides and teacher: goal (1): use selected words to create an oral story using correct syntax on five of ten sentences; goal (2) use social communication statements to express needs and wants with no more than one prompt 60% of the time. The Student did not disagree with these goals, nor did Student offer evidence suggesting that these goals were not designed to meet his needs.

Mr. John Lyons, the principal at D’Arcy, testified that STUDENT needed greater structure (found within the Jurupa Vista SDC) to deal with his behavioral needs and that another SDC class for SH students (severely handicapped) at D’Arcy would not meet STUDENT’s needs because students in that program “have very limited functioning” and that STUDENT in contrast is “very sharp” and can “read, add, subtract, and write stories.” Mr. Lyons recounted an incident in spring 2001 to illustrate his concerns about STUDENT’s behavior: Mr. Lyons was called to the cafeteria to calm STUDENT down. STUDENT was tantruming in the cafeteria because he was not allowed to have chicken nuggets due to an allergy to milk and milk products. Mr. Lyons testified that he attempted to employ a technique STUDENT’s father had suggested, by asking STUDENT to look at him two times while lightly holding STUDENT’s face. STUDENT slapped the principal in response. Mr. Lyons testified that STUDENT’s ongoing behavioral problems were well-known to staff member. Mr. Lyons further stated that the Jurupa Vista SDC not only allows more structure for STUDENT, but also allows STUDENT appropriate opportunities for mainstreaming into regular education in accordance with his IEP.

Other District witnesses also testified credibly to STUDENT’s need for greater structure and the fact that a regular education classroom is designed primarily to address academic and not behavioral needs. (Test. of Mr. Lyons, Ms. Palmatier, Ms. Bachman, Ms. D’Agostino, and Ms. Bell) The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the District’s witnesses concerning STUDENT’s need for greater structure, and that a placement within an SDC with mild to moderately handicapped students more appropriately addresses STUDENT’s needs than continued placement in a regular education classroom with pull-out for RSP support. The Hearing Officer will address the District’s lack of success in its effort to mainstream STUDENT under the LRE analysis set forth herein.

The credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of placement at Jurupa Vista is designed to meet his unique needs. The class is structured and small, allowing for greater individual attention to STUDENT’s behavioral needs and academic needs. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the credible testimony of Mr. Lyons that the offer of change in placement at Jurupa Vista addresses STUDENT’s actual need for an SDC with peers who have mild to moderate disabilities, with appropriate opportunities for mainstreaming with nondisabled peers in math, art, and physical education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that continuation of speech and language two times per week in thirty-minute sessions is inadequate to address STUDENT’s significant speech and language deficits and to address STUDENT’s need for developing social communication skills as expressed by goal (2) (to express needs and wants with no more than one prompt 60% of the time).

(b) Is the District’s offer of placement within the May 23, 2001, IEP reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

Student did not argue or provide evidence that the District’s offer of placement within the May 23, 2001 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

(c) Comport with his IEP

Student did not contend that the services to be provided do not comport with his IEP.

(d) Is the District’s offer of placement within the May 23, 2001, STUDENT’s LRE?

The Hearing Officer will determine whether the District’s offer of placement within an SDC for students with mild to moderate handicapping conditions at the Jurupa Vista Elementary School is STUDENT’s LRE.

The LRE requirement is set forth under federal law as follows:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities...are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

(20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; California Education Code § 56364.2.)

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.)

In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in a regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Holland (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert.denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

The parties dispute the types of behavioral support services needed for STUDENT to be mainstreamed. The Student contends that STUDENT’s LRE is full inclusion with RSP services and with appropriate behavioral supports recommended by Ms. Marie Granados, and that the District’s SDC offer is overly restrictive and not STUDENT’s LRE. The District contends that its offer at Jurupa Vista is the LRE, and that the Student’s alternative, with a behavioral aide 30 to 40 hours per week, is more restrictive for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the FAA and BIP offered by the District for the 2001-02 school year as part of the May 23, 2001 IEP are appropriate and adequate for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will apply the four-part test expressed in Holland to determine whether the District’s offer of an SDC placement at Jurupa Vista, with mainstreaming in Math, Art and P.E. and services is STUDENT’s LRE.

1. The Hearing Officer addresses the academic benefits to STUDENT in a regular education classroom, with appropriate aids and services, compared with the academic benefits to STUDENT in an SDC. STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP provides for a one-to-one instructional aide in the regular education classroom, and the IEP also calls for a behavioral intervention plan which was consented to by PARENTS on May 29, 2001, following the IEP meeting held on May 23, 2001.

STUDENT’s regular education classroom teacher for the 2001-02 school year, Karen Willits, who had taught STUDENT for two months (July and August 2001) prior to her testimony in September, stated that STUDENT was in the regular education classroom for the following classes: math, writing, silent reading to himself, and sometimes social studies. Ms. Willits testified that STUDENT only accessed the regular academic curriculum about 5% of the time, and that STUDENT, with modifications, does some math, none of language arts, and some handwriting, and a little bit of social studies (that is highly modified for him). Ms. Willits stated that when STUDENT isn’t participating in the curriculum, he is working with his aide and “they are modifying to the best they can.” Ms. Willits further stated that STUDENT “is never really involved in the direct instruction. He won’t participate. But with his aide, he is working on concepts similar to what we are doing in class.” When asked if she had seen STUDENT make any academic progress, Ms. Willits stated, “The only thing I have seen is math. He is learning new concepts.” Ms. Willits stated that she tested STUDENT in math on the second day of class (July 7), and that STUDENT is “probably at the low second grade level.” Mr. Lyons, the D’Arcy principal, stated that STUDENT “is on task more often” and that on task behavior “would result in improved performance academically” for STUDENT.

STUDENT’s regular education classroom teacher for the entire 2000-01 school year, Niki Bell, testified that STUDENT did not participate in the curriculum that she was teaching.(Footnote 14) When her class was doing math, STUDENT was doing modified math, and when her class was doing writing, STUDENT was doing writing at his level, but not to that of the rest of the class. Ms. Bell stated that she knew STUDENT was autistic, but she also knew he academically could do work. Ms. Bell testified that STUDENT started out in her second grade class in reading at primer level 2, and by the end of the school year, STUDENT was reading at a level 9 or 10 - third trimester, first grade. STUDENT’s reading program, Edmark, was administered by his resource specialist. Ms. Bell testified that STUDENT started out in math being able to add with regrouping with double digits and he could subtract, but he couldn’t do any regrouping with subtraction. At the end of the year, STUDENT was able to add up to three digits with regrouping and he could do subtraction with regrouping (two-digit numbers) and “he was even getting to multiplication facts.” However, in math, Ms. Bell stated that she recalled only three times that STUDENT was doing the actual lesson of her class (on multiplications), and that at no time did STUDENT do class reading, but did participate in “silent reading.”

Accordingly to the testimony of Ms. Bell an SDC is a smaller class size (from 7 to 10 students) versus twenty students in the regular education classroom and an academic benefit is a lower teacher-student ratio, affording STUDENT more individualized attention from the teacher. STUDENT also benefits from greater structure. Moreover, an SDC allows an individual student more freedom to move around the classroom, which is arguably less disruptive for other SDC students who are working on their own individualized IEPs. In contrast, moving around in a regular classroom can be disruptive to classmates who are working together on the same material. (Test. of Ms. Bell and Ms. Willits)

Under the current IEP, STUDENT is pulled out for two hours per day to work with his resource specialist on reading and other subjects. Ms. Palmatier testified that STUDENT does not belong in a regular education classroom and needs structure and an opportunity to concentrate on areas of weakness - communication and social skills. Ms. Palmatier also stated that a self-contained class “is for students who do not learn best in an inclusion model. They need a self-contained, structured format.” Ms. Palmatier stated that she could see STUDENT eventually being included “if he learns appropriate social skills.”

The Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT may gain some incremental academic benefit being fully included within a regular education classroom, STUDENT’s needs may require greater individualized attention, and on balance, STUDENT would likely derive, at this time, a greater academic benefit in an appropriate SDC (with mild to moderately handicapped students).

2. The Hearing Officer addresses the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled. Both Ms. Bell and Ms. Willits testified that STUDENT has difficulty interacting with peers. Ms. Willits stated that STUDENT is “either aggressive or doesn’t interact at all,” notwithstanding the fact that STUDENT’s aide tries to facilitate STUDENT’s interaction with peers “every single day,” but it “doesn’t cause him to interact.” Ms. Willits describes STUDENT as “withdrawn” from his peers. Ms. Bell stated, when referring to modelling and watching other students, that STUDENT “didn’t pick up the cues of other students.” In describing STUDENT’s interactions with peers, Ms. Bell stated that STUDENT “didn’t really have much interaction. He never started a conversation with other students. He would kind of respond if a student came up and talked to him and he would nod or say yes, but he wouldn’t further the conversation.” Ms. Bell described an unsuccessful attempt to have STUDENT learn to play basketball with a fifth-grade student who knew the rules. “It didn’t work very well...It probably only worked five times in three weeks...It was no longer working. He didn’t care.”

STUDENT’s resource specialist during the 2000-01 and 2001-02 school year, Anne Palmatier, testified that she has observed STUDENT during recess and at lunch with a few friends and that STUDENT had begun playing ball in late July 2001. However, Ms. Palmatier also stated that STUDENT does not belong in a regular education classroom because “autistic kids don’t pick up social skills without being taught them in a structured environment.”

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT receives, at this time, only marginal non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled.

3. The Hearing Officer addresses the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom.

Both Ms. Bell and Ms. Willits testified to daily occurrences of tantrum behavior, non-compliance, aggressiveness, and occasionally fighting, hitting, or other incidents which generally lead to disruptions in the regular classroom and which negatively affect the teacher and other children.

Ms. Willits testified to STUDENT’s behaviors in the regular education classroom as very disruptive. STUDENT would sharpen his pencils ten or twelve times per day (when other students did it 2 or 3 times). When Ms. Willits used the overhead projector in class, STUDENT would place his fingers in front of the screen and make shadow finger puppets. STUDENT would often get up from his seat without permission “seven or eight times a day,” and “hardly ever raise[d] his hand” and would yell out even when he was redirected to raise his hand: “He does it out of instinct.” STUDENT takes things from Ms. Willits’ desk such as pencils, tape and stickers “two to three times per day.” Ms. Willits stated that STUDENT frequently disrupted class instruction each day “about 3 to 5 times,” that it generally took, depending on what had happened, 5 to 10 minutes for the class to settle down, which cut into instruction time for the other students. Ms. Willits also testified to several incidents at school assemblies during which STUDENT engaged in inappropriate behaviors. At one assembly, STUDENT kicked students who were sitting in front of him on the floor. At a second assembly, during a PTA presentation, STUDENT interrupted a motivational speaker’s presentation by jumping up and “doing what the man was doing” with little toys on the overhead. The assembly had to be stopped. At a third assembly held to award students for perfect attendance, STUDENT grabbed a little girl’s stuffed animal from her that she had been awarded. The assembly was stopped and STUDENT, who was yelling, had to be removed and the stuffed animal taken back to the little girl. Ms. Willits recounted an incident at the end of August in which STUDENT’s father had returned STUDENT to class following a doctor’s appointment. STUDENT thought he was going home for good, and he became very agitated. No one could talk to him from “about 12:30 to 3:15,” and “he ended up hitting his aide.” The principal was called because STUDENT was yelling and no one could talk to him.

Ms. Bell stated that she attempted to implement the BIP that came with STUDENT from STUDENT’s previous school, Lincoln, but the BIP wasn’t working, and the tantrums were disrupting the whole class. Ms. Bell testified that STUDENT’s tantrums leveled off for a month or so in December, and then returned to his past level of behavior at the beginning of the school year, which continued until June 2001. STUDENT would be pulled out of class because of his negative behavior from “0" to four times per day, and his behavior was random and Ms. Bell could not find a pattern -- “no rhyme or reason.” Some tantrums lasted just five minutes, others up to one half hour or one hour. Ms. Bell also stated that she saw STUDENT slap a student in the face for no apparent reason during silent reading. STUDENT was very apologetic. Ms. Bell also described an incident in which STUDENT attempted to bite her arm during a tantrum. Ms. Bell stated that “most of the time his tantrums came from him not wanting to participate in the activity he was supposed to.” Ms. Bell stated that the tantrums definitely affected her 19 other students and that it took at least five minutes for the class to be redirected after the incidents.

Mr. Lyons testified that while STUDENT’s behavior had improved since implementation of the May 29, 2001 BIP, in that STUDENT’s tantruming was not as prolonged (STUDENT was not engaging in tantrums for 30 or 40 or 50 minute tantrums), STUDENT was still tantruming, which was disruptive to the regular education class and the ability of the teacher to provide the curriculum to the students in that classroom. Moreover, Mr. Lyons stated that he had been called to the classroom four or five times during the two-month period (Mr. Lyons returned to testify in early September 2001) for the following behaviors: (1) STUDENT wanted his blocks (tantrum); (2) STUDENT wanted to have a recess when the other kids were being rewarded for having no citations (for bad behavior); (3) STUDENT was in the class and didn’t want to do his reading but wanted to work on some color page; (4) a “fighting” incident with three other students recorded as a citation. Ms. Palmatier did note that STUDENT’s lengthier tantrums that she had observed during the spring 2001 term were not occurring in July 2001.

Ms. Bell testified that soothing strategies suggested by STUDENT’s parents and incorporated into the May 29, 2001 BIP (per the testimony of Mr. Lyons and Ms. Palmatier) (e.g., use of a brush per the BIP) were used by STUDENT’s aide for a few weeks at the end of the 2000-01 school year but did not appear to have a beneficial effect. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s first BIP was not working at all for STUDENT at the very beginning of the 2000-01 school year, according to Ms. Bell.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behavior in regular education class is disruptive to the teacher and to the other students, and that the frequency of the disruptions adversely affects the students in their attempt to access the curriculum. The Hearing Officer also finds that even as an appropriate BIP was being implemented in the regular education class, STUDENT’s behavior, though improved, continued to adversely affect the class.

4. The Hearing Officer addresses the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child into the regular education setting. Neither party provided evidence on the costs of supplementary aids and services.

The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of placement within the self-contained SDC at Jurupa Vista is the LRE for STUDENT. STUDENT’s behavioral needs are such that STUDENT needs greater structure and individual attention at this time within a self-contained SDC classroom, and that STUDENT does not receive adequate social and academic benefits within a fully-included regular education classroom to support continuation of full inclusion at this time. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the fact that even as an appropriate FAA and BIP was being implemented during July and August, of the 2001-02 school year, STUDENT’s behaviors continued at a level of frequency at D’Arcy that led to frequent classroom disruptions that affected the ability of his classroom peers to access the curriculum, a curriculum that STUDENT only accesses, according to Ms.Willits, “approximately 5% of the time.” The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive Mr. Lyon’s testimony that the offer of placement at Jurupa Vista was based upon STUDENT’s needs, and not upon the issue of home school or attendance boundaries. Mr. Lyons credibly testified that most of the RSP and SDC students currently attending D’Arcy are bussed in from other areas.

The credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-02 school year is a FAPE for STUDENT, except for the amount of speech and language therapy, which will be addressed herein in Issue No. 7.

ISSUE NO. 7: If the District did not offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services.. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1); The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing a day for day replacement for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497.

The Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s failure to respond properly to STUDENT’s behavioral needs during the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years, and its failure to provide an appropriate amount of speech and language therapy during those years, led to a denial of a FAPE for STUDENT for 1999-2000 and 2000-01. The Hearing Officer has also determined that the District failed to offer an appropriate amount of speech and language services for the 2001-02 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer has the authority to award compensatory education to STUDENT to remedy his loss of educational benefit. Since the Hearing Officer has already determined that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT for the relevant school years, STUDENT is not in need of additional assessments as requested by Student. Moreover, as indicated above, further assessments are not a compensatory education remedy.

With regard to the District’s failure to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs adequately for the 1999-00 and 2000-01 school years, the record does not indicate the extent to which such deficiencies impacted STUDENTs’ educational performance. There was credible testimony that STUDENT made progress academically on goals and objectives, both in 1999-00 and 2000-01. (Test. of Mr. Heaney and Ms. Palmatier) There was also credible testimony concerning the District’s efforts during the 2000-01 school year to respond appropriately to STUDENT’s behavioral issues, particularly from his one-to-one aide, Dina Valdez, and from his RSP teacher, Ms. Palmatier. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties appeared to escalate the amount of time STUDENT spent in the regular education classroom. Because the record is unclear and inconclusive on the relationship between the inadequate April 2000 FAA and BIP and lack of behavioral goals and objectives in the IEPs, and STUDENT’s educational performance, the Hearing Officer does not award compensatory education for the District’s failure to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs adequately during the 1999-00 and 2000-01 school years.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT was to receive one to two days per week of speech and language therapy in thirty-minute sessions during the 1999-2000 school year, and that STUDENT was to receive two days per week of speech and language therapy in thirty-minute sessions during the 2000-01 school year. The Hearing Officer has found that the amount of speech and language services provided to STUDENT for the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years, was not designed to meet an area of need for STUDENT who, by the beginning of the 1999-00 school year, had been determined to be a student with autism.

In fashioning an appropriate amount of compensatory speech and language therapy, the Hearing Officer is guided by the following notation made on the January 30, 2001 IEP: “Advocate requested that individual LSH be provided 30 minutes two times per week and another session added to address proposed new goals.” The new goals relate to Ms. Sheffield’s recommendation that “language training be combined with socialization training...LSH services are currently provided one time per week for thirty minutes.” (Dist. Exh. 2.) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was only receiving speech and language therapy one time, and not two times per week for thirty minutes per week for at least part of the 2000-01 school year. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes Ms. Bachman’s testimony that students with autism “need lots of language” instruction.

The Hearing Officer also notes the credible testimony of Ms. Swenson, who stated that STUDENT had shown significant improvements in speech and language since 1998. However, Ms. Swenson also noted within her March 2001 assessment that STUDENT’s test scores in the area of receptive and expressive language place him at the one percentile, and that speech and language continued to be a significant area of need for STUDENT. Accordingly, based upon the totality of circumstances, the Hearing Officer awards STUDENT additional speech and language services for a one-year-period. The IEP team shall provide the equivalent of one additional thirty-minute session per week of speech and language therapy to STUDENT for a one-year period, in addition to the two thirty-minute sessions per week provided in the IEP. The IEP team shall decide the manner in which to provide the additional amount of speech therapy for STUDENT in a manner so as not to result in a detriment to STUDENT’s continuing academic coursework, taking into account his class schedule.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to conform STUDENT’s IEP to the self-contained SDC placement at Jurupa Vista Elementary School. The IEP team shall modify the May 29, 2001 BIP to reflect STUDENT’s change of placement at Jurupa Vista.

2. The IEP team shall provide STUDENT, in addition to the two thirty-minutes sessions of speech and language therapy provided in the IEP, the equivalent of an additional thirty-minute session of speech and language therapy per week for a one-year period as compensatory education. The IEP team shall decide the manner in which to provide the additional speech and language therapy per week so that it will not result in a detrimental effect to STUDENT’s continuing academic coursework, taking into account his class schedule.

3. All other claims for relief made by Student are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately for the 1998-99, 1999-00, 2000-01, and 2001-02 school years?

**The District prevailed substantially on this issue, except for the 1999-00 school year.

2. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational assessment of Ms. Granados? **The District prevailed on this issue.

3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year? **The District prevailed on this issue.

4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-00 school year? **The Student prevailed on this issue.

5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year? **The Student prevailed on this issue.

6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-02 school year? **The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

7. If the District did not offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years, is he entitled to compensatory education? **The Student prevailed on this issue only with regard to Issues 4 and 5. The District prevailed on this issue with regard to Issues 1, 2, 3 and 6.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal.Educ.Code § 56505(i). ___________________________________ Date: November 29, 2001 Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues set forth include changes made for purposes of clarification and to facilitate proper analysis, and also reflect discussions held with the parties on the record on the first day of hearing and subsequently, when Student provided an amended statement of issues and proposed resolutions which specify alleged procedural violations by the District and which identify the types of assessments sought by Student. The Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over Student’s request for monetary damages under IDEA and Section 504, and therefore that request, identified as Issue Five in Student’s amended issues statement, will not be addressed. 2. The Hearing Officer determines that Student’s request for “compensatory education” to be a request for compensatory education, and not for assessments. Assessments are not a compensatory education remedy. 3. Petitioner seeks a determination for a denial of FAPE for the past three school years - 1998-99, 1999-2000, 2000-01, as well as for the year 2001-02. The Student filed his request for due process on May 9, 2000. California Education Code § 56505(j) provides that the request for due process must be filed “within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.” 4. STUDENT’s last agreed-upon placement is reflected in the September 26, 2000 IEP as follows: RSP 90 to 120 minutes, five days per week beginning July, 2000; a one-to-one aide for four hours per day; LSH - individual services in thirty minute sessions, two days per week. Part of time not in regular education: 20 to 40 % of time. 5. Student states as Issue Three that he is entitled to “comprehensive compensatory services in the form of specialized assessments” and specialized programs consistent with recommendations arising from” the assessments. As a proposed resolution, Student seeks the following “specialized assessments”: OT, Auditory Integration Therapy (AIT), Speech and Language Therapy, a Functional Analysis Assessment (which Student later states has “already been completed and paid for” by Student’s parents), and a psychoeducational assessment (to determine whether STUDENT has a specific learning disability). 6. The District established that each assessment conducted in the 1998-99, 1999-00, and 2000-01 school years (psychoeducational assessment, speech/language assessments, and OT assessments) were administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions and were validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. 7. Neither party presented any evidence to show that STUDENT was ever found to have, by assessment and IEP team determination, an SLD. (Test. of PARENTS and Ms. Bachman.) 8. Ms. D’Agostino has a national credential in school psychology and is enrolled in a doctoral program at USC in educational leadership. Ms. D’Agostino also has a California professional clear administrative services credential. 9. Ms. Swenson conducted the assessment because STUDENT was “off-track” at the time Ms. Sheffield’s assessment was conducted. 10. The fact that the District’s assessments for speech and language were appropriate does not mean that the District provided an appropriate amount of speech/language therapy services for STUDENT during the 2000-01 school year. 11. In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-00 school year, Student’s allegations of procedural violations for the 1999-00 school year will not be addressed. 12. In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year, Student’s allegations of procedural violations for the 2000-01 school year will not be addressed. 13. Student contends that he needs a one-to-one nonpublic agency (NPA) behavior aide for 35 to 40 hours per week and 4 to 5 hours per week of weekly NPA behavior supervision to implement a BIP created by Ms. Granados in order to maintain STUDENT’s “full inclusion” in the regular education classroom at D’Arcy. In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District’s placement offer in a “self-contained” SDC at Jurupa Vista is appropriate for STUDENT’s needs at this time and the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District’s FAA and BIP are appropriate for STUDENT’s needs, it is not necessary to evaluate Ms. Granados’ plan, which only addresses STUDENT’s behavioral needs. (Student Exh. 1.) 14. According to the testimony of Ms.Bell, student was off track(not in school) September, January and May.