California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 26, 2002
Anaheim Union High School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1570-02 · Hearing Officer Lina Foltz
Anaheim Union High offered FAPE at Hope High School for the regular year but denied FAPE by identifying no ESY services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Anaheim Union High School District filed for due process. It asked the Hearing Officer to confirm that its April 22, 2002 offer was a FAPE. The offer kept a 15-year-old student at Hope High School (Hope Education Center), a separate special education campus. The student was eligible for special education based on significantly below average intellect. He had serious behavior problems at two comprehensive high schools. His father represented him. The father argued that Hope did not challenge his son and that home tutoring was the least restrictive environment.
The Hearing Officer found that the student's behavior needs were the most pressing when the offer was made. Hope provided a small, structured class, a behavior intervention plan, measurable academic and life-skills goals, speech therapy and a one-to-one aide. Teacher Michael Clark's records showed the student's behavior and learning improved. Applying the Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer held that Hope was the least restrictive environment. At Cypress High School, the student's behavior seriously disrupted his class and kept him from benefiting from nondisabled peers. Home tutoring would be more restrictive. The district therefore offered a FAPE through the end of the regular school year. However, the IEP noted that the student needed extended school year (ESY) services but never identified any. That denied a FAPE for summer 2002. No remedy was ordered because the parents refused district ESY and did not seek a remedy.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. LRE factors when comparing two special education settings: a special day class on a comprehensive campus and a separate special education school. It also shows that checking an ESY box without specifying services was treated as a denial of FAPE, even when parents said they would refuse ESY.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1a. Did District offer Student a FAPE by its April 22, 2002 offer of placement at Hope High School, for the period from April 22, 2002 through the end of the regular 2001-2002 school year, including whether Hope was the least restrictive environment?
The Hope placement, with a behavior intervention plan, measurable goals, speech therapy and a one-to-one aide, met the student's needs, gave him some educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment through the end of the regular school year; home tutoring would be more restrictive.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1b. Did District's April 22, 2002 offer provide a FAPE through the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY)?
The IEP noted the student needed ESY but identified no specific ESY services, so the District denied a FAPE for summer 2002, even though the parents said they would not accept ESY at any District site; no remedy was ordered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- No remedy was awarded for the ESY denial because the parents said they would not accept any District ESY services, removed the student from Hope, and did not seek a remedy at hearing.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Rachel H.; Poolaw v. Bishop
People named in the decision
- John Weber, special day class teacher, Cypress High School
- Mark Stricklin, assistant principal, Cypress High School
- Christy (Christine) Ruiz, speech and language specialist, Hope High School
- Donna Erickson, assistant principal and psychologist, Hope High School
- Rebecca Bush, school psychologist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Michael Clark, special education class teacher, Hope High School
- Marilyn Miller, principal, Hope High School
- Kathleen McLean, program specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Dr. Mike Shelton, director of youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
- Linda Gaston, program administrator of special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
- Brooke Birch, regional center service coordinator, Regional Center of Orange County
- Ms. Wolfe, special education teacher, Cypress High School
- Robert, class aide, Cypress High School
- Speech and Language Development Center of Buena Park, nonpublic school proposed by the parents
- California Diagnostic Center, Los Angeles, state diagnostic assessment center (declined to assess)
- County of Orange Health Care Agency (OCMH), county mental health provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lina Foltz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, at the Anaheim Union High School District offices in Anaheim, California, on October 10, 11 and 17, 2002.
Petitioner, Anaheim Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Cynthia Yount. Also present on behalf of District were Dr. Mike Shelton, director of youth services for the District, and Linda Gaston, program administrator of special youth services for the District.
District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: John Weber, special day class teacher at Cypress High School; Mark Stricklin, assistant principal at Cypress High School; Christy Ruiz, speech and language specialist at Hope High School; Donna Erickson, assistant principal at Hope High School; Rebecca Bush, school psychologist for the District; Michael Clark, special education class teacher at Hope High School; Marilyn Miller, principal at Hope High School; and Kathleen McLean, program specialist for the District.
Respondent, Student, (Student) was represented by his father. Student’s mother attended the first day of hearing. Ms. Brooke Birch, Student’s regional center service coordinator, also attended most of the hearing on behalf of Student. Student’s father represented him and testified as the sole witness for Student.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The matter was submitted following oral closing arguments on October 17, 2002.
ISSUE
Did District offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) by its April 22, 2002(Footnote 1) offer of placement at Hope High School (Hope),(Footnote 2) for the period of April 22, 2002 through the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY).(Footnote 3)
PRELIMINARY MATTERS
The Hearing Officer denied Student’s motion to dismiss District’s action based upon the family’s desire to continue exploring educational placement options. The District seeks a determination that its proposed placement of Student at Hope High School, consistent with his IEP constituted an offer of a FAPE. California Education Code § 56501(a) entitles District to obtain a determination of the issues it has raised in this action. Accordingly, Respondent parent’s motion to dismiss was denied.
CONTENTIONS
District contends that it offered a FAPE to Student on April 22, 2002, by offering him continuing placement at Hope, a dedicated special education campus, in a learning disabled class with approximately 10 students who have similar needs. District asserts that Hope is the least restrictive environment (LRE) for Student because his inappropriate behaviors could not be addressed at his prior comprehensive high school campus at the time of District’s offer. District argues that Student’s needs were appropriately met at Hope.
Student’s father asserts that Hope was not an appropriate placement for Student because Student functions at a higher level than his classmates. Student’s father contends that Student cannot reach his full potential at Hope, in part, because the environment does not challenge Student to behave like his typically developing peers. Student’s parents claim that Student exhibited behavioral impairments that he learned from the students at Hope and that the disabilities of the other students are emotionally disturbing to Student. Student’s father reports that in his home environment, Student functions much like other children his age, and disputes the level of Student’s disability. Student’s parents contend that home schooling is the appropriate placement and LRE for Student until an alternative placement can be agreed upon.(Footnote 4)
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Student is a fifteen-year-old young man who has been varyingly diagnosed by different state agencies. His diagnoses include mild mental retardation, severe mental retardation, autism, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and pervasive developmental disorder (PDD). (See Exhibits 4, 5, 7). Student’s eligibility for special education, as identified in his IEP of October 23, 2001 is “significantly below average intellect.” (Exhibit 16). Student’s is described as displaying “sub-average intellectual functioning manifested during the developmental period with associated deficits in adaptive behavior.” (Id.). On September 8, 2000, Student also was determined eligible for regional center services based upon qualifying developmental disbilities of mental retardation and autism, pursuant to California Welfare & Institutions Code § 4612. (Exhibit 5).
Student has a supportive family with five siblings, a loving home environment and dedicated parents. He is currently receiving home tutoring.
Student’s early educational history was provided in an assessment by the County of Orange Health Care Agency (OCMH) and was not disputed.(Footnote 5) Student exhibited significant delays in socialization, communication and adaptive skills prior to kindergarten. (Exhibit 4, p.2). Student began receiving special education services at the age of five. (Exhibit 4, p.3). He continued to receive special education services into the second grade.
In approximately March 1995, Student and his parents moved to the Middle East, a region described as Palestine in school records and testimony. Student lived with his family in the Middle East during the third, fourth and fifth grades and was tutored at home. (Exhibit 4, p.3).
Student returned to the United States in the sixth grade and enrolled in an elementary school. He reportedly was unable to continue public school placement due to his disruptive behaviors and apparently did not return to public school until the seventh grade. Student attended a special day class at Lexington Junior High School (Lexington) for the 2000-2001 school year.
Student was reported to have poor learning success because of his disruptive behaviors and lack of concentration at Lexington. He received services of a one-to-one aide to facilitate keeping Student on task and to address inappropriate behaviors. Student’s IEP of March 2000 describes a discussion of District’s proposal for Student to attend a “split day” at Hope for the rest of that school year. (Exhibit 1, final page). Student attended a program at Hope that summer and his parents reported that the disabilities of the other students upset him.
In January 2000, Student began receiving mental health services through OCMH. Student was referred to County Youth Service and began a trial of Risperdal and intense behavior modification to “decrease compulsions, obsessions and disruptive behaviors.” OCMH attributed the initially encouraging results, in part, to the introduction of medication. (Exhibit 4, p.3). In June 2000, OCMH identified Student as exhibiting symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder which reportedly resulted from physical abuse he experienced in the Middle East from relatives. Student continues to receive weekly counseling and monthly medication monitoring through OCMH.
In March 2001 Student was described as: “a good worker” who would “occasionally do some stemming but comes right back to his task.” The IEP team observed that Student’s progress had been “slow” and “had digressed in many areas since his medication change.” (Exhibit 9).
At the beginning of his 2001-2002 school year Student began high school at Savanna High School, a comprehensive school site. He only attended for a short period and was transferred to Cypress High School (Cypress) in October 2001, after behavior related difficulties. At Savanna and Cypress, Student was reported to have had confrontations with other students that resulted in Student hitting other students or being hit by them. Student also had confrontations and encounters with school staff at Cypress.
Student was suspended from Cypress in mid-November 2001 after allegedly striking a special education teacher, Ms. Wolfe. Student’s father disputes whether Student struck Ms. Wolfe or any other persons but does not dispute that the events were reported by school administrators.
On or about November 15, 2001, following the incident involving Ms. Wolfe, the Cypress High School Local School Placement Committee convened to determine the disciplinary action to be taken. The Committee decided that Student should be transferred to Hope. (Exhibit 18). District members of Student’s IEP team felt that Hope was the appropriate placement to meet Student’s needs. (Id.). However, Student’s parents argued that Student needed a one-to-one aide, home teaching, or a private school. (Id.). With the Committee’s apparent agreement, Student’s IEP team decided that, for the time being, Student would continue at Cypress with a shortened school day, the addition of a one-to-one aide for his class, and class instruction solely from Mr. John Weber, the male SDC teacher. (Exhibit 20).
Student showed several days of appropriate behavior and improved concentration in late November when he returned to Cypress following suspension. (Exhibit 17, p.4-5). However, on or about December 6, 2001, Student was accidentally struck in the head with a basketball while playing a supervised game in the school gym. When the class aide, Robert, returned with Student to Mr. Weber’s class after the accident, Student fluctuated on the brink of regaining his self-control for some time, but he finally had to be restrained. As a result, Student was admitted for psychiatric hospitalization pursuant to California Welfare & Institutions Code § 5150 for several days.
In January 2002, at an interim IEP meeting, Student’s parents agreed to a 60-day trial period for Student to attend Hope. At the meeting, Student’s parents, through Student’s advocate, also requested that Student undergo assessment at the California Diagnostic Center in Los Angeles (Diagnostic Center) and District agreed to the need for the assessment. (Exhibit 21, p. 2).
In March 2002, Student’s parents agreed that Student would continue at Hope while they and District explored a nonpublic school (NPS) placement for Student at the Speech and Language Development Center of Buena Park (SLD Center), a placement suggested by Student’s family. (Exhibit 24, p.2).(Footnote 6)
On April 5, 2002, through an advocate, Student’s parents notified District that they did not believe Hope was an appropriate placement for Student. (Exhibit 26). Student’s parents’ notice stated that they felt Student needed to be in an NPS, like SLD Center, and requested an IEP meeting. (Id.). An IEP meeting convened on April 22, 2002. District contended that the SLD Center class, where Student’s parents wanted Student placed, did not address Student’s needs or provide services that his parents had asserted he needed. District maintained that Hope was meeting Student’s service needs and offered continuing placement with identified services and updated goals and objectives from the IEP of October 2001. Student’s parents said that Student did not like Hope and asserted their preference for the SLD Center NPS placement.(Footnote 7) Yet, the team agreed that Student would continue at Hope until the IEP team reconvened on June 4, to consider additional anticipated information.
On June 4, 2002, Student’s IEP team met to continue discussions regarding Student’s placement. District reasserted its April 22, offer of placement at Hope. (Exhibit 33). Student’s parents requested that Student be placed at SLD Center and that he return to Cypress in fall of 2002. Student’s parents stated their disagreement with the IEP and placement at Hope. The family also stated that Student would not attend an ESY program at any District site and reportedly indicated that they would file for a due process hearing. The team then agreed to “convene in the fall to write new objectives for the Cypress HS [seriously handicapped, special day class] program . . . and DIS services.” (Exhibit 33, p.2-3).
District requested a due process hearing on July 3, 2002. District did not present evidence that an IEP meeting convened after June 4, 2002 or that District offered a program of identified services to Student for the ESY. Student did not return to Hope after June 2002 and is currently receiving tutoring at home from District.
District cites Student’s behaviors as the primary reason that Student’s needs dictated placement at the smaller self-contained special education campus with the higher staff-to-student ratio available at Hope. District contends that Hope provides the necessary environment for Student to transition back to a comprehensive school site after he is able to maintain appropriate behaviors and academic focus. District claims that Student’s behaviors improved dramatically at Hope between January and June 2002. District also asserts that both Student’s academic needs and his practical skills needs were appropriately met by placement at Hope.
Student’s father asserts that Student has shown exceptional progress since he ceased attending Hope in June and that Student is benefitting more from home tutoring and social activities in his neighborhood than he did attending Hope. Student’s father contends that home tutoring is the LRE for Student, until an appropriate alternative placement can be agreed upon.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free and appropriate education (FAPE) 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); Cal. Ed. Code § 56000. A FAPE means special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision, at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform with the student's individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is specifically designed instruction, provided at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25). Related services are provided in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) to be provided when necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional programs. Cal. Ed. Code § 56363. IDEA and California law also require special education and related services to be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5); see Cal. Ed. Code § 56031.
The Supreme Court, in Bd. of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Ctr. Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), identified the level of services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Rowley Court held that an educational agency satisfies the requirements of IDEA by providing a “basic floor of opportunity” through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually tailored to provide some educational benefit to the child through an IEP that was developed through the IDEA procedures. Id. at 200, 207-208. However, IDEA does not require states to provide an educational program that maximizes a student’s ability or potential. Id. at 198-199.
The Rowley court recognized the requirement for an educational agency to satisfy the procedural requirements of IDEA in providing a FAPE. A failure to comply with IDEA procedural requirements does not automatically result in a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. NO. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). However, procedural defects that cause the loss of an educational opportunity or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. (Id.).
Student does not contend, nor do the facts support a contention, that any procedural defect deprived Student of a FAPE by causing the loss of an educational opportunity or infringement of his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The positions argued by both parties demonstrated that they both understood District’s offer was for Student to continue attending Hope with services identified in the IEP through the end of the extended school year. Student’s contention is that the Hope environment and the program provided to him there were not appropriate and therefore denied Student a FAPE. Therefore, the issue here concerns whether District satisfied the substantive requirements of IDEA.
The IEP team must take into account what was and was not objectively reasonable at the time the IEP was drafted. Id. The District has the burden of proving that it satisfied the requirements of IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Thus, according to the substantive elements of a FAPE identified by the Rowley Court, District is required to show, by a preponderance, that its offer of placement at Hope on April 22, 2002: (1) was designed to meet Student’s unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit; and (3) comported with his IEP.(Footnote 8) District must further establish that the placement at Hope was the LRE for Student.
A. Was District’s Proposed Placement At Hope Individually Tailored To Meet Student’s Unique Needs?
Although Student has had varying diagnoses since 1998, his academic testing and records reveal that his needs correspond to deficits in academic achievement in the areas of reading, writing and mathematics and the inability to maintain appropriate behaviors and social interactions sufficiently to attend to educational tasks. These deficits are undisputed, although the parties dispute the severity of Student’s behaviors and the hierarchy of his needs.
District argues that when the parties agreed to Student’s initial temporary placement at Hope in January 2002, Student’s behavioral needs predominated and prevented him from attending to educational materials. (Exhibit 17, 32, pp. 14–15). District further argues that Student’s behavioral needs required Student’s continued placement at Hope at the time of District’s offer in April 2002 and that his educational needs were met at Hope as well.
Student’s father does not dispute that Student engaged in inappropriate behaviors at school, although he does dispute whether Student struck others. He contends instead that Student’s inappropriate behavior was not at the same level at home and that Hope is an inappropriate educational site that essentially allows District to “warehouse” Student and ignore his need to become a self-sustaining member of society, which requires associating with nondisabled peers at school.
Student’s Needs
Witness testimony and documentary evidence reveal that Student has had behavioral problems since entering high school.(Footnote 9) In November 2001, Student would randomly yell out in class. (Testimony of Mr. Weber, see also Exhibit 15). Student would stand close to other students repeatedly demanding their response and shaking his hands in their face while yelling. (Id.). Student’s intimidating behavior prompted complaints from a parent of a Down-syndrome child who would cry following multiple confrontations with Student. (Testimony of Mr. Weber, Exhibit 17). At Cypress, Student would jump out of his seat six to seven to ten times per class and also would run to the front of the class to take and smell the marking pens used by the Mr. Weber during class instruction. (Id.). Student was suspended for his aggressive behaviors with Ms. Wolf and had to be admitted for psychiatric care when his behaviors escalated to the point of requiring physical restraint to avoid injury to himself and others. Student continued to need intervention at Hope for his behaviors, which included pushing, grabbing and chest-butting others. (Testimony of Mr. Clark, see also Exhibit 25, Exhibit 32, p. 22).
Additional documentary evidence corroborates witness testimony concerning Student’s inappropriate behaviors at school. Student’s IEP in October 2001-2002 identified inappropriate behaviors as “prevocational skills” that the IEP team agreed were areas of need for Student, including, “pointing, jumping up in face behaviors and verbal phrases.” (Exhibit 16, p. 15). At Cypress numerous incidents flowed from Student’s inability to control his behavior when he was told “no.” (Testimony of Mr. Weber, Exhibit 17). Student’s chest-butting behavior with staff and hanging on staff members’ necks continued to require intervention at Hope. (Exhibit 25). Student also continued to fixate upon objects or people and would yell and tantrum over something he wanted. (Id.). Regional center records confirm Student’s ongoing behavioral problem continued in April 2002, although tantrums were less frequent. (Exhibit 31, pp. 4-5).
In April 2002, Student assaulted staff and had to be held back from a field trip. (Exhibit 32, p.17). A student accidentally bumped Student in class and Student reacted by aggressively poking at the girl until he had to be removed from the class. (Exhibit 32, p. 15-16). Student continued to fixate upon other students and to yell his demands. (Exhibit 32, p. 9-10). The Hearing Officer finds the evidence persuasive to establish that, at the time of District’s offer, Student had predominating behavioral needs which required interventions to extinguish inappropriate conduct and encourage appropriate alternative behaviors.
In addition, District contends that Student needed a smaller, more structured educational setting than Cypress, where Student would not be as likely to be overstimulated and lose control of his behavior. District argues that the Hope setting provided a transition point for Student to learn to manage his behaviors in a less demanding environment before reintroducing him to a busier environment at a comprehensive campus. (Testimony of Ms. Erickson and Ms. Miller). Student’s father does not dispute that Student needed an alternative setting but contends that the Hope setting is counterproductive.
Ms. Kathleen McLean, District program specialist, holds a master’s degree in communications disorders, a credential in clinical rehabilitation services and is licensed as a speech pathologist. She has worked as a program specialist for District for approximately three years. Ms. McLean testified that it is difficult to provide behavior interventions at a large comprehensive campus because stimulation for inappropriate behaviors originated from many varied sources, including large numbers of students passing between classes, lunch time activities and assemblies.
Similarly, Student’s particular behaviors were difficult to mediate in a community setting because of his obsessive-compulsiveness, his resistance to redirection and the safety concerns his behaviors raised. Ms. McLean reported that when she was working at Savanna, Student attempted to climb the flag pole and engaged in inappropriate touching of other students. Ms. McLean testified that Student’s escalating behavior at Cypress could not be addressed on a large comprehensive campus because too many variables were present in the environment that triggered Student’s inappropriate behaviors. Ms. McLean testified that the smaller, dedicated special education campus provided a more therapeutic setting to address inappropriate behavior.
At Cypress, Student frequently reacted to contact with other students by becoming aggressive, poking at the target individual’s face and repeatedly demanding “say sorry.” (Testimony of Mr. Weber, see also Exhibit 17, p.4-5, entry for 12/04/01). Inappropriate behavior was difficult to address during lunch and recess where contact with more students and exposure to stimulation like food options in the cafeteria caused Student to lose control. (Testimony of Mr. Weber).(Footnote 10) Although Student’s behaviors improved from his relative low point in December 2001, similar behaviors continued at Hope in active or less structured settings. (Testimony of Mr. Clark, Exhibit 32).(Footnote 11)
At a large public gathering, Student began sprinting away from staff and was grabbing at the toenails of women who wore open-toed shoes and had to be removed to a van in the parking lot standing ready to remove Student from circumstances that might prompt his inappropriate behaviors. (Id.). Mr. Clark reported that Student grabbed food from another student during recess and would strike or intimidate other students during less structured periods. (Testimony of Mr. Clark, Exhibit 32, p.15-18). Mr. Clark’s observations were consistent with the behaviors Mr. Weber reported.
Student’s father testified that Student did not display behavioral deficits to the same extent at home as those reported at school. (See also Exhibit 15, p. 5). Student’s behavior in the context of the small, familiar family environment supports a conclusion that Student is able to maintain more appropriate behaviors in the smaller, familiar and less variable setting. Thus, the evidence supports the finding that when District made its offer, Student needed the more therapeutic environment provided by a smaller setting and structural consistency, until he could tolerate the more active setting of a comprehensive campus.
In addition, Student had undisputed academic needs. (Exhibit 12). At the age equivalent for eighth grade, Student was able to read at the 2:2 grade level and scored in reading comprehension at the 1:2 grade level. (Exhibit 12, p. 4). Student’s spelling was ranked at the 1:7 grade level. Student had relative strengths in numeric operations, scoring at grade level 3:2. (Id.). However, his ability to use math reasoning, oral and written expression were at the pre-kindergarten grade level. (Id.).
The parties agreed upon Student’s need for services and supports to promote both his academic skills and adaptive skills, like telling time, using currency and accessing public transportation. Student’s need for ongoing services and supports to address deficits in these areas was undisputed. Thus, Student needed educational services to address his academic and adaptive skills deficits.
The parties also agreed that Student needed a one-to-one aide to assist him with maintaining his attention to tasks and appropriate behaviors. Accordingly, Student needed a one-to-one aide to address his behavioral and educational needs.
Finally, Student’s IEP documented that Student needed an ESY. (Exhibit 16, p.1). ESY services are provided when interruption of the pupil’s educational program may cause regression based upon the nature of their disability. 5 C.C.R. § 3043, 20 U.S.C. § 56345(b)(3). Accordingly, Student needed ESY services.
Based upon the foregoing identified needs, the Hearing Officer finds that District was required to offer a program that addressed Student’s needs for behavioral interventions, a small structured environment, training to develop his academic and adaptive skills, a one-to-one aide to facilitate attention to task and appropriate behavior and ESY services to maintain appropriate behavior and academic skills.
District’s Program Offer
A FAPE, as mandated through the IDEA, “is tailored to the unique needs of the handicapped child by means of an IEP.” Rowley at 181. Therefore, a program to address Student’s unique needs must be identified through his IEP and offer of placement in order to establish that District offered Student a FAPE.
IDEA requires the IEP team to address behavioral needs when a pupil’s behavior impedes his learning or that of others. A behavior intervention plan (BIP) is a written document which is developed when a pupil exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. 5 C.C.R. § 3001(f).
Student’s IEP on April 22, 2002, included a BIP that identified Student’s behavioral needs. Student’s BIP identified inappropriate behaviors by (1) description of target behaviors to be decreased; (2) antecedents which precede the target behaviors; (3) historic interventions; (4) behavioral goals and objectives; (5) behavior interventions to be employed; and (6) timelines for achieving each goal. (Exhibit 25). District modified Student’s IEP in March and April 2002 to identify behavioral strategies and indicated his current levels of performance in his goals and objectives. (See Exhibit 25, Exhibit 30, p.3-10). The Hearing Officer finds that the BIP was individually tailored to address Student’s unique behavioral needs.
Student’s IEP also contained measurable goals and objectives addressing Student’s academic and adaptive skills needs. (Exhibits 12, & 30, pp. 5-11). For example, Student’s IEP included academic objectives for identifying main ideas in reading; determining sequences of events in reading; locating words in the dictionary; using proper capitalization and punctuation in writing; writing simple sentences of 6 words; addition, subtraction and multiplication calculations; telling time in five-minute increments; identifying measurements in feet/inches and teaspoons/tablespoons; and identifying currency values. (Exhibits 16, pp. 5-10; 30, pp. 5-10). Student’s IEP specified that success in meeting his objectives was to be measured by work samples and teacher observations.
Mr. Clark updated Student’s IEP goals and objectives, documenting Student’s progress in achieving his objectives under each goal. (Exhibit 30, pp. 5-10). These objectives were appropriate and individualized to address Student’s educational and adaptive skills needs. Further, although Student’s IEP only references his request for a one-to-one aide, Student’s one-to-one aide actually was provided as part of his placement at Hope, pursuant to IEP team discussions. (Testimony of Mr. Clark; Exhibits 21 & 22).(footnote 12) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s IEP addresses his unique educational and adaptive skills needs.
The Hope program described in the IEP also included specific elements that provide a setting for Student to receive educational instruction. The appropriateness of the Hope setting is the primary dispute between Student’s family and District. Therefore, a preliminary discussion of that setting is necessary.
Ms. Donna Miller and Ms. Erickson testified that the campus at Hope had approximately 260 students who were between the ages of 12 and 22. Student’s class was one of two self-contained classes with three full-time assistants and one part-time assistant. Student attended Mr. Clark’s class for the entire day,(footnote 13) except for periods when all of the students in Student’s class attended music class and APE outside the self-contained class. (See also Exhibit 22). Student received speech and language therapy from Ms. Christine Ruiz, a speech and language therapist, in a small group with two to three other students.(footnote 14) Mr. Clark’s class was composed of students who had similar needs to those of Student. Mr. Clark confirmed that the students in Student’s class were verbal with similar neurological impairments, including high functioning individuals with Down-syndrome and that the students were 14 and 15 years old. Student was ranked in the middle of the class in cognitive ability.
Mr. Clark, employed the “cool room” in Student’s class to motivate and reward appropriate behaviors. (Testimony of Mr. Clark). Students who achieved appropriate objectives were rewarded with time in the cool room, where they could read magazines, listen to music or watch videos of their choice, rest or engage in individual activities offered as rewards based upon the individual student’s preferences. Mr. Clark also used the cool room to redirect Student by allowing Student to listen to music when he would become fixated upon a social conflict. Mr. Clark’s class took field trips to restaurants and other public locations, where students worked on behaviors as pre-employment skills.
Ms. Miller testified that Hope also operates a program of “reverse inclusion” that provides interaction with typically developing peers through volunteers who visit from a local high school to provide tutoring and participate with Hope students in drama and music presentations. Mr. Clark’s class had approximately nine other students besides Student. None of the students in Student’s class had physical disabilities. Some of Student’s classmates exhibited higher cognitive functioning than Student. Students with more severe cognitive abilities attended classes in a separate fenced area to protect those students from wandering away and being injured. The campus site is substantially smaller than the campus at any comprehensive District high school.(footnote 15)
Further, Ms. Donna Erickson, assistant principal and psychologist at Hope, testified that the smaller, more structured Hope campus offered the necessary transition point for preparing Student to return to a comprehensive high school campus. Consistent with notations in Student’s IEP, multiple witnesses offered testimony that the IEP team’s intention was to use the Hope placement to transition Student back to Cypress for at least part of his school day, depending upon how his behaviors progressed. Therefore, Student’s environment at Hope was intended to aid future planning because of its utility as a transition point for his return to a less restrictive environment as Student’s behaviors warranted. Although the IEP team had not identified Student’s need for planning to transition back to a comprehensive campus at the time of District’s offer, the team did agree to develop those goals and objectives in the fall of the new school year.
At the time of District’s offer, the Hope program addressed Student’s unique behavioral needs, as stated above. The Hope placement also provided a key to future program planning. District and Student’s family, as the IEP team, anticipate modifications to Student’s IEP in the future, rather than in April 2002, to address an anticipated need for transition planning. Thus, the Hope program allowed the IEP team to plan for Student’s future needs.
Ms. Marilyn Miller, school principal, testified that Student could not attend a comprehensive campus until he reached certain interim objectives. Ms. Miller holds a master’s degree in special education and a credential in special education for the severely handicapped. She was a special education teacher for over five years and has been principal at Hope for thirteen years. She opined that Student would first need to transition to a departmentalized program, where students attend different classes each period, and would need to demonstrate the ability to maintain appropriate behaviors with a reduction in one-to-one aide support. Further, Student would need to demonstrate an ability to work in small groups. Then he could prepare for a transition, with one to three classes at the comprehensive campus site.
Ms. Miller testified that programs were available at Hope for Student to participate in a departmentalized class structure and programs to develop employment skills. Ms. Miller’s testimony was credible and uncontroverted. It established that the Hope site offered a highly structured class setting initially, which Student’s needs dictated, and a range of progressively more independent class structures that would allow Student to approximate the demands of a regular high school campus in stages. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Ms. Miller is persuasive to establish that the program at Hope was individually tailored to address Student’s then-current needs for a small therapeutic school environment where Student could work toward appropriate behaviors.
In addition, the Hope setting had the benefit of offering services that could address Student’s anticipated need for transition back to the more stimulating setting at Cypress. It was not necessary however for the IEP to have included goals and objectives for Student’s transition back to a comprehensive campus because Student had been attending Hope only for short a short time and his inappropriate behaviors had not abated sufficiently to begin transition planning. Therefore, the need for transition planning was anticipated, not actual, at the time of District’s offer. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP is not defective as a result of the absence of goals and objectives for Student’s transition back to a comprehensive campus at the time of District’s offer. Student’s IEP was individually tailored to address his needs for behavior intervention, a small therapeutic setting, academic and adaptive skills training, and a one-to-one aide.
Student’s IEP failed however to identify his ESY services after his IEP identified his need therefor, as was noted above. (Exhibit 16, p. 1). IDEA requires an IEP to include projected dates for the beginning of specified services, the anticipated frequency, location and duration of services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(vi). However Student’s IEP failed to identify any specific ESY services. Further, the notation that Student required ESY services was entered on October 23, 2001 when Student was at Cypress. Therefore, the bare notation of an “X” cannot be interpreted to identify particular services to address Student’s need for ESY after he had transferred to Hope. Thus, the IEP did not address Student’s individual need for ESY and is defective in that regard.
The Hearing Officer finds that District’s offer of continuing placement at Hope was a program that was individually tailored to meet Student’s unique needs for behavior intervention, a small structured environment, academic and adaptive skills training and a one-to-one aide, as the needs were reasonably understood at the time of District’s offer. However, District’s offer did not address Student’s need for ESY services. It remains however to determine whether Student’s IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in light of his identified needs.
B. Was Student’s IEP reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
Student had been attending Hope for several months when District offered continuing placement. Therefore, District could use the information it acquired during that time to evaluate whether it could expect Student to continue making progress at the Hope placement.
Student’s behavior improved significantly and was documented in the “Communication Home” notes and progress log that Mr. Clark prepared. (Testimony of Mr. Clark; Exhibit 32). The Hope campus, as shown above, provided a small structured environment where Student could work toward his behavioral objectives. In addition, Mr. Clark was able to provide educational instruction consistent with Student’s IEP goals and objectives for reading, writing, mathematics. (Id.). Student was able to be redirected more consistently and his physical confrontations with staff lessened. (Exhibit 32, p. 11-15). Mr. Clark’s testimony was persuasive to show that placement at Hope with services identified in Student’s IEP was providing some educational benefit while Student attended Hope.
Ms. Ruiz testified that she had observed Student in Mr. Clark’s class when she was at Hope to provide speech and language therapy. She observed that when Student first arrived at Hope, he could not sit for five minutes without disrupting the class. After Student had attended Mr. Clark’s class for several months, Student participated in a reading group with other students and listened to a story for fifty-five minutes. (Testimony of Ms. Ruiz). As Student settled into Mr. Clark’s class, his aide no longer had to hover at his side and was able to spend time assisting other students. (Id.).
In addition, Student’s individual program plan (IPP), dated April 22, 2002, prepared by Regional Center of Orange County, provides evidence that Student was working on adaptive skills, including use of currency and learning to count, through his program at Hope. (Exhibit 31, p.5). Student’s parents reported that Student’s concentration and maladaptive behavior had decreased since he began attending Hope, although a change in medication was reported as the reason for Student’s improvement. (Id.).
Student’s ability to attend to educational tasks and master skills had historically fluctuated, independent of placement. Medication, environmental stimulus or the nature of Student’s disability may have caused the fluctuations. Nonetheless, Student’s program at Hope was providing him with the opportunity for some educational benefit. Student was working toward his IEP objectives and was able to receive instruction, corresponding to a decrease in inappropriate behaviors. (Exhibit 32, pp. 28-43). Given Student’s progress at Hope at the time of District’s offer, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s offered was reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.
The standard established by the Court in Rowley does not require District to provide Student with his best opportunity to progress educationally. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the program District offered at Hope on April 22, 2002, was reasonably calculated to provide a “floor of opportunity” for Student to derive educational benefit sufficient to satisfy the requirements of IDEA through the end of Student’s regular school year.
However, as discussed above, Student’s IEP did not identify or offer specific ESY services for Student. Therefore, it did not conform with IDEA requirements and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit for a summer program through the end of Student’s ESY.
Student’s parents’ “indication” at the IEP meeting that they would not utilze an “ESY program at any [District] campus” does not relieve District of the obligation to offer an ESY program because Student’s need for an ESY was identified by his IEP team and the need was undisputed. (Exhibit 33, p.2). Accordingly, although District’s offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit through the end of the regular school year, it was not during the ESY. Despite that defect, District’s offer on April 22, 2002, must be evaluated further to consider whether District’s offer of placement at Hope was consistent with his IEP.
C. Was District’s Offer Of The Hope Program Consistent With Student’s IEP?
Student’s teacher at Hope documented the educational instruction that he provided to Student and the progress Student made toward his IEP objectives. (Exhibit 32, pp. 28-43). Mr. Clark also implemented the behavioral interventions specified in Student’s BIP and developed appropriate supplements to the BIP as necessary. (Id., pp. 11-27). The Hearing Officer finds that the educational services Mr. Clark provided conformed to Student’s IEP.
Further, the consistency of Student’s program at Hope with his IEP goals and objectives was not disputed. The evidence supports a finding that the program District offered to Student at Hope was based upon Student’s individually tailored IEP goals and objectives and was implemented consistent with his BIP. Thus, The Hearing Officer finds that District’s offer to place Student at Hope was individually tailored to meet Student’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and comported with Student’s IEP, excepting the period of Student’s ESY.
D. Was Placement at Hope The Least Restrictive Environment For Student?
Federal law mandates that participating states ensure “to the maximum extent appropriate” that children with disabilities are educated with children who are not disabled, and separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5). California law similarly declares that special education provides interaction between children with disabilities and children who are not disabled in a manner that is appropriate to the needs of both. Cal. Ed. Code § 56031.
A comparison of the restrictive nature of the SDC at Hope, on a dedicated special education site, to the SDC at Cypress is necessary here because District’s offer of continuing placement at Hope would change Student’s placement from Cypress to a new placement at Hope.(footnote 16) A review of pertinent factors considered by the Ninth Circuit in determining the LRE provide guidance here even though the comparison is between two special education class locations.
Student’s class at Cypress did not afford Student the same opportunities for interacting with nondisabled peers as would a regular education class with support services. Nonetheless, IDEA mandates the same inquiry when a district proposes separate schooling or other removal of a pupil from the regular education environment as is required when removing a child from a regular education class to a special education class. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5). Therefore, the educational and non-educational benefits of Student’s placement at Cypress and the effect Student had on his class are the determinative inquiries, based upon the rational employed by the Ninth Circuit. See Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); see also Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 835 (9th Cir. 1995).
At Cypress, Student attended a special day class program for his entire day, except for the time when Student was escorted to APE. (Testimony of Mr. Weber). Student’s class was segregated in one corner of the campus. (Id.). Student initially attended Mr. Weber’s SDC for seriously handicapped and multi-handicapped students during the first three periods of the day. Student would then transfer to Ms. Wolf’s SDC for his final three classes each day. Student moved to Mr. Weber’s class exclusively after Student allegedly struck Ms. Wolfe.
Student stayed with students from his class during lunch and was supervised. (Undisputed testimony of Mr. Weber). Student generally did not interact with typically developing peers during lunch, recess or assemblies. (Id.). Student had negative experiences when he was outside his class because he reportedly was unable to maintain appropriate behaviors with others and would become involved in confrontations. The testimony of Mr. Weber is persuasive to establish that Student was not benefitting from the opportunity to interact with nondisabled peers at Cypress because of his inappropriate behaviors.
Student also caused significant disruption to the learning environment in Mr. Weber’s class. The BIP that District developed at Savanna in October 2001 identified Student’s problem behaviors, including “jumping in other’s space or face while pointing and rocking back and forth while making repetitive comments.” (Exhibit 15, p. 1). He spoke loudly and made very audible noises. (Id.). Student engaged in the behavior five to seven times per class and during passing periods, approximately 60 times per day, continuously until interrupted by staff. (Id.). Cypress staff characterized Student’s behavior as creating a risk of physical injury to students or others and noted that staff were concerned for their safety and that of other students, who were fearful and upset. (Id.). Student’s inappropriate behaviors severely disrupted Student’s educational experience and that of his classmates at Cypress. (Testimony of Mr. Weber).
The children in Mr. Weber’s class were sensitive to disruptions and Student’s behaviors substantially impaired the ability of the other children to receive instruction. (Testimony of Mr. Weber). Mr. Weber recounted circumstances when other children became afraid and cried. Student’s behaviors interfered significantly with Mr. Weber’s ability to devote time and attention to the other students. (Id.). Even after a one-to-one aide was added, Student’s behaviors continued to created chaos that interfered with Student’s ability to access his education and the ability of the other students to receive educational instruction. (Id.). The evidence is persuasive to establish that the negative impact Student’s behaviors had on the other students and Mr. Weber’s ability to teach the other students at Cypress warranted a more restrictive setting for Student until his behaviors improved sufficiently.
In contrast the Hope campus provided the opportunity for Student to reach behavioral and academic objectives and to interact with typically developing peers through the music program that he attended. (Testimony of Mr. Clark). Student had the opportunity to participate also in a theater arts program and mentor tutoring provided by local high school students. Ms. Ruiz and Mr. Clark also provided persuasive testimony that, contrary to Student’s parents’ reports, Student enjoyed the Hope environment. Student was enjoying playing frisbee with his one-to-one aide and participated in music class where he could interact with nondisabled peers.
Student’s propensity to engage in inappropriate behaviors continued at Hope. However, Hope staff observed that the Hope setting allowed Student to reduce inappropriate behaviors more successfully, thereby gaining access to educational instruction and reducing his disruption of his classmates’ education. The evidence established that the nature of Student’s disability warranted the more restrictive placement at Hope at the time of District’s offer because Student continued to display emotional outbursts and inappropriate behavior even in the controlled environment at Hope. (Exhibit 32, pp. 17-21). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Hope was Student’s LRE when District offered placement at Hope on April 22, 2002.
Student’s father argued that the LRE for Student was home tutoring. However, assuming that Student’s parents requested home tutoring before the end of the ESY period, such placement would not be supported by the evidence as Student’s LRE. Providing educational instruction in isolation, as is the case when Student is tutored at home, is more restrictive than education at Hope. Student would necessarily have less access to nondisabled peers if he was educated at home. He would have little if any opportunity to interact with others in the education setting. The evidence did not support a finding that Student required the more restrictive setting of home tutoring. Thus, home tutoring would not be his LRE.
Student’s father is properly concerned that Student should not remain at Hope without goals to successfully attend school in a more challenging environment. However, ample evidence shows that at the time of District’s offer, Student’s behaviors presen(footnote 17)ted an obstacle to his constructive participation in a class on the comprehensive campus at Cypress. Student must be able to “walk” socially before he can run with his peers, disabled and nondisabled, in a more challenging educational setting.
CONCLUSION
Considering the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that District offered Student a FAPE in the LRE, on April 22, 2002, until the end of the regular school year, by its offer of placement at Hope. District did not offer Student a FAPE for the ESY in Summer 2002. However, no remedy is awarded here because Student’s parents expressly stated that they would not accept any ESY services from District, removed Student from Hope, and did not seek a remedy at hearing.
ORDER
Except for District’s failure to identify ESY services, for which no remedy was awarded, District offered Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the following findings are made: District has prevailed upon the issue of whether it offered a FAPE on April 22, 2002 and continuing through the end of the regular school year. Respondent prevailed on the denial of a FAPE during the extended school year ending in summer of 2002.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Ed. § 56505(i).
DATED: November 26, 2002
Lina Foltz, Hearing Officer
1. The IEP considered here originally was drafted on October 23, 2001 for the 2001-2002 school year. It was amended several times by addenda after interim IEP meetings. On June 4, 2002, Student’s parents withdrew their provisional consent to the placement and IEP established on April 22, 2002. District’s offer here is considered to be the April 22, 2002 IEP because it contained all material components of District’s offer and District asserted at hearing that IEP constituted its offer. The result here would be the same if June 4, 2002 was considered as District’s offer date. 2. Hope High School is actually named “Hope Education Center,” but was referred to by the parties as Hope High School. (Exhibit 36). 3. District requested a determination of whether it offered FAPE and identified its offer as the placement at Hope pursuant to the IEP for the 2001-2002 school year as it had been amended through April 22, 2002. District did not present evidence that it made a new offer of placement for the 2002-2003 school year. Accordingly, the sufficiency of District’s offer of FAPE is evaluated here through the end of the extended school year in 2002. 4. Prior to hearing and at the time of District’s offer, Student’s family asserted that placement at the NPS, Buena Park Language Development Center was Student’s alternative appropriate placement. Student’s father does not argue now that the placement was appropriate and Student never attended the NPS. 5. Documents underlying the OCMH report were not provided as part of the hearing record. The facts concerning Student’s early development are not material to the determination herein but provide background information. 6. District referred Student for assessment by the Diagnostic Center. (Exhibit 29). However, the Diagnostic Center later rejected the request to assess Student. (Exhibit 34). 7. At hearing, Student’s father did not contend that SLD Center was an appropriate placement. 8. Amendments to the IDEA in 1997 added the requirement for the IEP to include a statement of measurable annual goals related to meeting the child’s needs which arise from their disability “to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii). That component of a FAPE is not discussed because it is not at issue here. 9. Student also had behavioral problems prior to high school but his behavior allegedly became more extreme after entering high school. 10. Mr. Weber testified that Student would become excited and run through the lunch line handling all open food items 11. When Mr. Clark took his students on a field trip to California State University, Fullerton, to observe athletic games, Student became very excited, allegedly because Student becomes overstimulated from being in a crowd. (Testimony of Mr. Clark, Exhibit 32, p. 18). 12. The staff support for Student’s class at Hope was modified to provide three full-time aides, rather than the two originally described by District when the IEP team met to consider temporary placement. 13. Hope also offered a “departmentalized” program in which students attended six different classes, replicating the structure of typical high school classes. But Student’s program was not that type 14. Student also received one-to-one aide services at Hope and additional staff support. 15. In contrast, the campus at Cypress had approximately 2000 students. 16. Student was attending Hope as a temporary agreed-upon placement. However, his permanent placement for the 2001-2002 school year continued to be at Cypress and a stay-put order was in effect. 17. The Hearing Officer notes however that Student’s IEP team agreed to develop goals and objectives for Student’s 2002-2003 school year. (Exhibit 33). The plan presumably would be realized in Student’s IEP for that year and would include a description of transition service. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(vii)(I). Moreover, the Diagnostic Center’s refusal to conduct further assessment of Student does not establish that further assessment would not be needed to appropriately plan for Student’s long-term educational needs.
