California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 22, 2001

Student v. La Canada Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1575-00 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

La Canada Unified provided FAPE for three years; Hearing Officer denies Frostig School tuition, private therapy and assessment reimbursement.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of an eight-year-old second grader filed for due process against La Canada Unified School District. The student was eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment. At Palm Crest School, the student attended general education kindergarten and first grade with speech-language therapy, occupational therapy, adaptive physical education and resource specialist support. In the summer of 2000, a private psychologist, Dr. Esther Sinclair, concluded that the student now had a learning disability and needed a more specialized program. The parents did not give her report to the district. They placed the student at the Frostig School, a nonpublic school, and asked for tuition, compensatory education, and reimbursement for private speech therapy and Dr. Sinclair's assessments.

Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait found for the district on every issue. Each IEP was judged by what was known when it was written, not by later assessments. The parents and Dr. Sinclair had helped write and approved each IEP, and the student made progress. The private speech experts disagreed with each other. The Hearing Officer credited the district therapist's view that two 30-minute sessions a week were appropriate. The continuing December 1999 IEP was an appropriate offer for 2000-2001, and the parents' failure to share the new report kept the district from responding. Assessment reimbursement was denied because the parents never disagreed with district assessments or asked for an independent evaluation. No relief was ordered.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard and the "snapshot" rule from Adams v. Oregon. It weighed the parents' approval of IEPs and the student's documented progress. It also held that not sharing a private assessment before a unilateral placement can undercut claims for tuition and assessment reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District provide Student a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year?

    IEPs developed with the parents and their private psychologist addressed the student's needs, were implemented, and produced progress; later assessments cannot be used to judge them in hindsight.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District provide Student a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?

    Two 30-minute small-group speech sessions per week, plus OT, adaptive PE and resource support, were appropriate; the Hearing Officer credited the district therapist over conflicting private experts.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District offer to provide Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?

    The continuing December 2, 1999 IEP was an appropriate offer; parents never shared the July 2000 private assessment, which kept the district from responding to it.

  4. Issue 4. If the District failed to provide FAPE during any of the three school years, is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Because FAPE was provided and offered in all three years, the Hearing Officer did not need to address compensatory education.

  5. Issue 5. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private speech and language therapy?

    No reimbursement; the district's speech therapy met IEP goals and produced progress, and private services were only a supplement.

  6. Issue 6. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tuition at the Frostig School?

    Because the district offered an appropriate program, it need not pay for the parents' preferred private school, even if it would provide greater benefit.

  7. Issue 7. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private assessments performed by Dr. Esther Sinclair?

    Parents never disagreed with district assessments or asked for an IEE; district assessments were appropriate, and the district had little reason to suspect a learning disability.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education; Gregory K. v. Longview School District

People named in the decision

  • Gail Prody, special education director, La Canada Unified School District
  • Dr. Esther Sinclair, private psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Nancy Low, district speech-language pathologist, La Canada Unified School District
  • Cheryl Larson, private speech-language pathologist, Private
  • Abby Chang, occupational therapist, Center for Developing Kids
  • Center for Developing Kids, contracted occupational therapy provider, Contracted by District
  • Dick Jackson, adaptive physical education teacher/assessor, La Canada Unified School District
  • Ms. Strand, resource specialist (academic testing), La Canada Unified School District
  • Nancy Houlihan, school psychologist, La Canada Unified School District
  • Maggie Landau, kindergarten teacher, Palm Crest School
  • Susanne Horne, first grade teacher, Palm Crest School
  • Curt Chase, adaptive physical education specialist, La Canada Unified School District
  • Suzanne M. Barnes, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student, Speech and Language Associates
  • Lisa Peschel McCann, occupational therapist, District OT provider
  • Christiane Baltaxe, private speech and neuropsycholinguistic assessor; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Frostig School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement), Private
  • Huntington Memorial Hospital, private assessor, Private
  • University of Southern California, private assessor (psychoeducational evaluation), Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This case was heard on February 8 and 9 and March 1 and 2, 2001, in La Canada-Flintridge, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER.

Respondent La Canada Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Trevin Sims. Also present on behalf of District was Gail Prody, special education director.

Documentary evidence and witness testimony were received. The record was left open for receipt of closing briefs. The record was closed on March 22, 2001 and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the l998-1999 school year?

2. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?

3. Did the District offer to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?

4. If the District failed to provide FAPE during any of the three school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide a free appropriate public education during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private speech and language therapy?

6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tuition at the Frostig School?

7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private assessments preformed by Dr. Esther Sinclair?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eight-year-old second-grade student who has a speech and language impairment. She was first assessed by the District in April 1996, and on May 3, 1996, and was determined to be eligible for special education services because of delays in expressive language skills. The District began providing language therapy during the summer of l996. These services were continued until STUDENT was unilaterally place by her parents at the Frostig school for the 2000-2001 school year.

During the Spring of l997, STUDENT’s parents obtained a number of assessments of STUDENT from the Huntington Memorial Hospital and the University of Southern California (USC). Those assessments concluded that STUDENT had developmental coordination and speech and language problems. A psychoeducational evaluation was performed by USC in July 1997 at the request of STUDENT’s parents. That evaluation concluded that STUDENT had a verbal I.Q. of 92, a performance IQ of 62, and a full scale IQ of 75. The assessment recommended that STUDENT be retained in preschool for another academic year and that her IEP be changed to reflect her perceptual-motor difficulties.

During the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT attended a private preschool and continued to receive language therapy from the District. In October and November 1997, STUDENT’s parents obtained an educational consultation from psychologist Dr. Esther Sinclair. Dr. Sinclair reviewed previous assessments, observed STUDENT in her preschool classroom, and performed additional testing. Dr. Sinclair administered the Wechsler Preschool Primary Scale of Intelligence (WPPSI-R) Her testing concluded that STUDENT had a verbal IQ of 88, a performance IQ of 81, and a full scale IQ of 83. Dr. Sinclair concluded that “STUDENT’s language delays represent a language-learning disability and a central language processing disorder. In addition, while her fine-motor coordination skills have improved, they are still below age expectancy.” Dr. Sinclair made the following recommendations concerning STUDENT’s placement:

STUDENT is scheduled to enroll in kindergarten in September, 1998 in the local elementary public school program. She should be successful in a program that now has a ceiling of 20 students in the state of California. This small class size increases the opportunity for more individual attention on the part of her teacher. However, STUDENT’s language difficulties will probably spill over into language arts curriculum areas of reading and writing. Because she may require more opportunities for practice, a slower pace of material presentation, and teaching strategies that utilize specific, concrete instructions/directions/explanations, she may benefit from more specialized attention and teaching strategies than can be provided in the regular classroom program. However, the necessity/desirability of special education needs to be evaluated on a yearly basis. It is NOT recommended that she enroll in a special education Kindergarten program but rather that she be given the opportunity to succeed and participate in a mainstream program as a fully-included student.

Dr. Sinclair recommended continued speech and language services and occupational therapy services.

On January 21, 1998, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s IEP. The team recommended STUDENT continue in her preschool program and, in addition, that during the spring she enroll in the District’s kindergarten class during the afternoons to help in her transition from preschool to kindergarten. The IEP team also decided that an occupational therapy (OT) assessment should be performed. The District suggested that in addition to the twice weekly speech and language therapy that was being provided by Nancy Low, STUDENT receive an additional session of speech and language therapy weekly within the afternoon kindergarten class. STUDENT’s parents requested that an additional session with Nancy Low also be provided, and the District agreed to this request. As a result, STUDENT received three small-group sessions per week with Nancy Low and one session of speech and language therapy within her afternoon kindergarten class.

In February 1998, the District contracted with the Center for Developing Kids for an OT assessment. The OT assessment concluded that STUDENT’s “difficulty with praxis (knowing what to do as well as how to do it), is interfering with both fine and gross motor skills as well as bilateral integration which involves using two sides of the body together in a coordinated manner.” The assessment recommended that STUDENT receive occupational therapy two times per week. On May 13, 1998, the IEP team amended STUDENT’s IEP to include OT for a period of six months. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT participate in the Summer Sprout’s program with support in speech/language, social emotional and cognitive development. The District also agreed to provide an additional individual speech and language session weekly during the summer.

The District contracted with the Center for Developing Kids, which provided occupational therapy for STUDENT twice a week and collaborated with her teachers in order to provide additional support.

Speech pathologist Cheryl Larson provided a total of five sessions of speech and language therapy to STUDENT during July of 1998. In a September 1998 report, Ms. Larson recommended continuing speech and language and occupational therapy.

At the beginning of the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT was placed in a specialized kindergarten class at the Palm Crest School. The class included nondisabled students as well as those eligible for special education support. The class had two teachers, one of whom was credentialed special education teacher, and two classroom aides. The class had available resource specialist, OT, and speech and language support.

On October 8, 1998, STUDENT’s parents consented to a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT, including assessment in the areas of pre-academic/academic achievement, speech/language skills, psychomotor/perceptual skills, intellectual/cognitive ability, social emotional, adaptive physical education (APE), and occupational therapy.

On October 16, 1998, an APE assessment was completed by Dick Jackson. He concluded that STUDENT did well on most areas but that she is in need of improving her physical fitness scores.

On October 20, 1998, an OT progress report was prepared by Abby Chang of the Center for Developing Kids. In her report, Ms. Chang stated that STUDENT had achieved three of the objectives set out in the May 1998 IEP. STUDENT had not yet achieved two of the objectives, and Ms. Chang was unable to assess the achievement of one of the objectives because she was not able to observe STUDENT in a school setting. She concluded that STUDENT had made notable gains in the past six months, but recommended that OT services be continued in collaboration with her teachers.

On October 22, 1998, STUDENT completed the Weschsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), which assessed her functioning in specific academic areas. Ms. Strand, the resource specialist, concluded that “there are no obvious strengths or weaknesses in STUDENT’s profile of subtest scores. Her performance was reasonably consistent between the various skill areas assessed. She achieved her highest score on Basic Reading and lowest score on Listening Comprehension. However, her performance across these areas does not differ significantly.” Ms. Strand further concluded that “STUDENT’s overall achievement was in the average range as measured by the WIAT Screener score.”

In her report dated December 7, 1998, school psychologist Nancy Houlihan reviewed her administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children- Third Edition (WISC-III) to STUDENT. She concluded that STUDENT’s “general cognitive ability, as estimated by the WISC-III, is low average (FSIA = 85). STUDENT’s general verbal abilities were in the average range (VCI = 93), and general nonverbal abilities were in the low average range (PIQ = 84).” Ms. Houlihan compared the results of the intelligence testing to the achievement testing performed by Ms. Strand and concluded that “at this time her academic skills are commensurate with her ability.” Ms. Houlihan also reviewed STUDENT’s social emotional status and stated that “there are indications that STUDENT may be feeling extreme anxiety and insecurity. This may be related to her nonverbal learning disorder.... STUDENT’s emotional and social skills development has probably been delayed by misconceptions which may have caused serious issues of insecurity to evolve. Her behavior and emotional responses serve a purpose and are her way of communicating her understandable fear and insecurity.”

Nancy Low, the District speech pathologist who had been providing services to STUDENT, completed a summary report to be used during the upcoming IEP meeting. She concluded that while STUDENT had made steady progress in all areas of her linguistic development, as well as her social-emotional development, she remained below age-level expectancy in her speech and language development. Ms. Low recommended that STUDENT continue her enrollment in speech and language therapy sessions.

STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher, Maggie Landau prepared a comprehensive individual learning plan for STUDENT for use by the IEP team. She set out her proposed strategies to address STUDENT’s needs. Those strategies included follow-up support to STUDENT’s occupational therapy and support by a special education teacher working thirty minutes each day to help develop lessons that will address her needs. STUDENT’s parents also consented to have Dr. Sinclair provide the reports of her l997 assessment to the District.

On December 10, 1998, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review the reports and assessments and develop a program for the next 12 months. The team developed goals and objectives in the areas of increasing all readiness skills, strengthening receptive and expressive language skills, improving visual perceptual and perceptual motor skills, improving self-care skills, improving praxis, improving fine motor skills, and improving of efforts in physical fitness and motor achievement. The IEP team recommended continuing STUDENT in the regular kindergarten class with designated instructional services including speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and APE. Dr. Sinclair participated in this IEP, and STUDENT’s parents approved the IEP.

On May 27, 1999, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review her progress and plan for the 1999-2000 school year. The team reviewed progress reports from Ms. Landau, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher; Mr. Jackson, the APE teacher; and Ms. Chang, STUDENT’s occupational therapist . The IEP team was also given a report by Cheryl Larson, a speech and language therapist who had been providing home-based private speech and language services to STUDENT. The IEP team, which included Dr. Sinclair and STUDENT’s parents, concluded that STUDENT was making progress in all areas of concern. Ms. Chang stated that STUDENT had accomplished all of the objectives that had been set out during the fall of l998. Ms. Low, the District’s speech and language therapist, observed that STUDENT had conversational speech and growth in spontaneous language, but needed additional help with articulation. Ms. Landau concluded that STUDENT was ready to start the first grade during the l999-2000 school year. Dr. Sinclair also attended the IEP meeting and concluded that STUDENT had made progress in comparison to a year ago. Dr. Sinclair made a number of recommendations concerning strategies to use with STUDENT and emphasized the need to continue to reinforce “process.” The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive services during the summer consisting of one period in the learning center twice weekly. The services would include earobics, occupational therapy once per week, and speech and language therapy once a week. The IEP team further concluded that in the fall of 1999 STUDENT should be enrolled in a regular first grade class with support including small-group speech and language therapy twice a week, occupational therapy once a week, APE twice weekly, and RSP consisting of small-group instruction and/or classroom support. The IEP team also agreed that her instructors should continue to emphasize process for STUDENT. STUDENT’s parent agreed with this IEP.

In the Fall of l999, STUDENT was placed in a regular first grade class taught by Susanne Horne. STUDENT continued to receive the support services set out in the May 27, 1999 IEP, including speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, APE, and resource specialist services.

In preparation for STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting, the District authorized additional assessment in the areas of academic achievement, motor ability, and speech and language. Curt Chase, an APE specialist, conducted a DEVPRO Motor Skills Assessment. He concluded that “STUDENT’s strengths are in locomotor skills, bouncing and catching skills, and body awareness. Weaknesses are evident in the area of balance, jumping rope and throwing skills.” Abby Chang completed an occupational therapy progress report in which she concluded that “STUDENT demonstrates great improvement in visual-perceptual and visual-motor skills since October 1998, however test results indicate that she is still delayed in these areas by more than a year.”

In November 1999, at the request of STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Sinclair performed a further psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. Dr. Sinclair observed STUDENT in Ms. Horne’s class. She administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). When comparing the test results to the WIAT test results administered a year earlier, Dr. Sinclair found that STUDENT had demonstrated modest growth in most academic subjects. In reading, STUDENT progressed from the K:3 to the K:7 grade level. In mathematics reasoning, she progressed from the K:0 to the K:6 grade level. In spelling, she demonstrated her greatest growth, advancing from the K:1 to the 1:4 grade level. In number operations, she progressed from the K:0 to the K:7 level, and the mathematics composite reflected a growth from the K:0 to the 1:0 grade level. STUDENT’s greatest weakness was in listening comprehension, where she did not demonstrate any growth. Dr. Sinclair recommended continued speech and language and resource specialist support. She also indicated concern that STUDENT not miss any academic subjects while she was receiving occupational therapy or APE.

On December 2, 1999, the IEP team met for its annual review of STUDENT’s program. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education services because of disorders in speech, language and visual processing. During the IEP meeting, the results of STUDENT’s speech and language assessment were presented. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, STUDENT had a standard score of 83 with an age equivalent of 4 years 6 months, and a percentile rank of 13. On the Expressive One-Word Vocabulary Test, STUDENT had a language age of 4 years, 8 months. On the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills, she scored at the age of 4 years, 1 month, which was in the first percentile rank. The assessment recommended continued enrollment in speech and language therapy sessions. The IEP team formulated goals and short-term objectives in the following areas: increasing receptive vocabulary, strengthening sequential memory skills for auditory directional tasks, increasing verbal expression, improving sound sequencing abilities, improving visual motor integration, improving visual perceptual skills, improving balance, overhand throw, handball and jump rope skills, and increasing listening comprehension. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT should continue in her regular education first grade class with the following support services: speech and language therapy twice a week for thirty minutes each session, APE once a week for thirty minutes, occupational therapy in her class once a week for 45 minutes, and resource specialist services four times a week for fifty minutes each. The District also agreed to investigate additional aide time for STUDENT during language arts and math. STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Sinclair participated in developing the IEP, and STUDENT’s parents approved it. The December 2, 1999 IEP was designed to continue until the next annual IEP, which was scheduled for December 2000.

At the request of STUDENT’s parents, an assessment of STUDENT was performed by Suzanne M. Barnes, a speech and language pathologist, on December 14, 1999. Ms. Barnes recommended that STUDENT receive one hour of speech and language therapy twice a week.

On January 20, 2000, the IEP team met to consider requests by STUDENT’s parents for more services. The District agreed to investigate providing an additional session of speech therapy to emphasize articulation development. The IEP team concluded that the speech therapist would consult with the first grade teacher regarding time schedule for including additional speech therapy and that the parents could than decide based on the schedule and class time.

At the request of STUDENT’s parent, the IEP team met on May 22, 2000, to discuss STUDENT’s progress and the next year’s placement. It appears from the May 22, 2000 IEP that the team spent most of this meeting discussing STUDENT’s behavior. The OT therapist, Lisa Peschel McCann, stated that STUDENT was resisting help both inside and outside the class. STUDENT’s first grade teacher, Ms. Horne, provided writing samples that reflected positive progress, but stated that STUDENT was below grade level in all academic areas. With respect to STUDENT’s behavior, Ms. Horne stated that STUDENT did not appear to believe that there would be consequences for her inappropriate behavior. The IEP team decided to discontinue OT services until June. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the termination of OT services because they wanted to have STUDENT’s normal routine continue in her first grade class with continued speech and language and RSP support.

On June 12, 2000, the IEP team met for further discussions of STUDENT’s behavior. Dr. Sinclair participated in the meeting by telephone and suggested rewarding STUDENT for good behavior by giving her stickers. At the hearing, Ms. Horne testified that after using this strategy, STUDENT’s behavior improved during the last days of the school year. The members of the IEP team agreed to meet at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to review STUDENT’s IEP and make appropriate modifications.

In the last months of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s parents began to consider placing her at the Frostig School, a certified nonpublic school for children with learning disabilities. STUDENT’s mother asked STUDENT’s teachers to complete school questionnaires concerning STUDENT. These questionnaires did not indicate the purpose for which they would be used and did not identify Frostig as the school that was being considered as a placement.

At the request of STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Sinclair performed another psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in June and July 2000. Dr. Sinclair’s report indicates that STUDENT’s parents were considering placing STUDENT in a private school. Dr. Sinclair administered the WISC III with the following results: Verbal IQ = 80, Performance IQ=96, and Full Scale IQ=86. Dr. Sinclair also administered the WIAT using grade norms for comparison with past administrations of the test. The results of the testing as compared to prior testing were as follows:

Standard Scores Grade Equivalent

10/98 11/99 07/00 10/98 11/99 07/00

Basic Reading 112 104 93 K:3 K:7 1:2 Mathematics Reasoning 92 98 67 K:0 K:6 <K:0 Spelling 103 108 92 K:1 1:4 1:7 Reading Comprehension 77 1:0 Numerical Operations 94 95 75 K:0 K:7 K:4 Listening Comprehension 89 78 85 <K:0 <K:0 K:5 Mathematics Composite 90 96 68 K:0 1:0 K:1 Reading Composite 85 1:3

Dr. Sinclair concluded that STUDENT was now learning disabled because of the current discrepancy between her IQ and her academic achievement in the areas of mathematics reasoning, reading comprehension, numerical operations, and mathematics composite. Dr. Sinclair concluded that STUDENT “is now eligible for special education services under the diagnostic criteria for Specific Learning Disabilities and Speech and Language Impairment.” It was her opinion that “STUDENT needs a more specialized educational program than the public school district can provide.” She recommended that STUDENT continue to receive speech and language, RSP, APE, and OT support and that she receive assistive technology support. Dr. Sinclair’s report was not provided to the District until sometime after STUDENT was unilaterally placed a Frostig.

On August 31, 2000, the attorney for STUDENT notified the District that STUDENT was going to be placed at Frostig. On September 5, 2000, the Special Education Hearing Office received a request for hearing in this matter. On September 11, 2000, STUDENT was enrolled at the Frostig School. She continues to attend Frostig.

STUDENT’s parents retained the services of Christiane Baltaxe to perform a Speech and neuropsycholinguistic testing of STUDENT in November 2000. Ms. Baltaxe concluded that STUDENT had a mixed receptive and expressive language disorder, phonological disorder, auditory processing disorder, apraxia and dysarthria. She recommended that STUDENT receive individual speech and language therapy 3 times a week for 45 minutes per session and group therapy 2 times a week for 45 minutes per session.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disability Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code Section 5600. FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56363(a).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonable calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. At 201.

In summary, in order for a program to constitute FAPE it must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide some educational benefit to the student and it must conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Section 1400 et.seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the l998-1999 school year?

Petitioner’s challenge to the appropriateness of STUDENT’s 1998-1999 program is based largely on assessments and testing that were done after that year, including an assessment by Dr. Sinclair in July 2000, which concluded that she could not receive appropriate services in a regular classroom, and a report by Dr. Baltaxe in November 2000 that suggested that STUDENT should have been receiving more speech and language support than she had received in prior years. These reports were not available to the IEP team at the time the team developed STUDENT’s IEP for 1998-1999.

In determining whether a program is designed to address the unique needs of a student and provide educational benefit, it is important to note a recent opinion by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal. In Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), the court citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993) stated:

Actions of the school systems cannot...be judged exclusively in hindsight.... [A]n individualized education program (“IEP”) is a snapshot, not a retrospective. In striving for “appropriateness,”an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.

When STUDENT entered kindergarten in the fall of l998, she was receiving services called for by an IEP that had been developed during the previous year. At the time of the January 21, 1998 IEP meeting STUDENT had been assessed as having delays in expressive language development and an articulation disorder. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services because of her delays in speech and language, and the team developed goals and objectives to strengthen her receptive language skills and increase her expressive language skills. The IEP team recommended continuation of speech and language therapy to address those needs and agreed to the request of STUDENT’s parents to increase from two to three the number of small-group speech and language therapy sessions. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT be enrolled during the afternoon in the kindergarten class in order to help her with the transition from preschool to kindergarten, and agreed to provide additional speech and language therapy in conjunction with that class. The IEP team also agreed to seek an OT evaluation of STUDENT. Following this evaluation, the IEP team, on May 15 1998, amended STUDENT’s IEP to include occupational therapy for a six-month period from May 1998 to October 1998. All of these services were carefully designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT’s parents fully participated in the development of the IEP and agreed to its implementation.

All of the witnesses who testified during the hearing, including STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Sinclair, believed that the IEP prepared in January & May of 1998 addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and were designed to provide educational benefits. In fact, Dr. Sinclair complimented the District for its efforts in addressing STUDENT’s needs. It should also be noted that the evidence established that STUDENT was demonstrating improvement at the time of the December 1998 IEP meeting. During that meeting, Nancy Low, who had been providing speech and language services, concluded that STUDENT was making excellent and steady progress. During the December 10, 1998 annual IEP meeting, the IEP team reviewed the results of comprehensive assessments performed by the District. The team concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education because of disorders in speech, language and visual processing. The IEP team, which included STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Sinclair, developed goals and objectives to address her individual needs, including goals and short-term objectives designed to increase all readiness skills, strengthen receptive and expressive language skills, improve visual and perceptual motor skills, improve self-care skills, improve praxis and fine motor skills, and improve her physical fitness. To address these goals and objectives, the team recommended continuing STUDENT in the regular kindergarten during the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year. The kindergarten class had two teachers, one of whom was credentialed in special education, and two aides. The IEP team decided to continue speech and language therapy, adaptive physical education and occupational therapy.

STUDENT’s parents and their independent psychologist fully participated in the development of the IEP, and her parents approved its implementation. All of the witnesses who testified during the hearing, including Dr. Sinclair, stated that they believed that the program set out in the IEPs in effect during the l998-1999 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and would provide educational benefit to STUDENT. In fact, as mentioned above, Dr. Sinclair complimented the dedicated efforts of the District in addressing STUDENT’s educational needs. Dr. Sinclair testified that she believed that STUDENT should receive services in the regular kindergarten class and, in her 1997 assessment, cautioned against placing STUDENT in a special education class.

The IEP team met again in May, 1999, to discuss STUDENT’s needs for the summer and prepare for her enrollment in the first grade in the fall of 1999. The IEP team reviewed her progress since the December IEP meeting. The occupational therapist stated that STUDENT had accomplished all of the objectives set out during the fall of 1998. Ms. Low reported that STUDENT had conversational speech and growth in spontaneous language, but needed additional help with articulation. Ms. Landau concluded that STUDENT was ready for the first grade. Dr. Sinclair reported that STUDENT had made progress in comparison to a year ago. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT should receive services during the summer of l999 consisting of one period in the learning center twice weekly including. Additional support services included earobics, occupational therapy once per week, and speech and language therapy once a week. The team, including STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Sinclair, approved the proposed summer program and STUDENT’s enrollment in the regular first grade with continued support services. No one who testified during the hearing contented that, at the time of the May 27, 1999 IEP meeting, they disagreed with the proposed summer program or any other aspect of the IEP developed at that time.

In sum, the program developed for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year, including summer school, addressed her unique needs and was reasonably formulated to provide educational progress for STUDENT. Additionally, the provisions of the IEP were carried out during the 1998-1999 school year and STUDENT in fact demonstrated educational progress during that year. It is therefore concluded that the District provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year.

2. Did the District provide a free appropriate public education to STUDENT during the l999-2000 school year?

Petitioner again challenged the appropriateness of the 1999-2000 year based on assessments done by Dr. Sinclair in July 2000, which recommended placement in a special class for learning disabled students, and on speech and language assessments completed in December 1999 and December 2000. The speech and language assessments relied upon by Petitioner recommended more speech and language therapy than was provided by the district.

In the fall of l999, STUDENT enrolled in a regular first grade class with the support services provided by her IEP that had been developed in December l998 and amended in May, 1999. As concluded above, this program addressed her unique needs and was reasonably designed to result in educational progress. There was no evidence to suggest that her needs had changed between May 1999 and the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year.

The IEP team held its annual IEP meeting on December 2, 1999. The team again determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services because of disorders in speech, language and visual processing. The team reviewed progress reports in the areas of APE, OT and speech and language, and in the area of academic achievement. The OT progress report concluded that STUDENT “demonstrated great improvement in visual-perceptual and visual-motor skills during the prior year.” However, the test results indicated that she was still delayed in these areas by more than a year. Based on this progress report, the IEP team developed new goals and objectives in the area of improvement of motor integration and visual perceptual skills and decided to continue providing occupational therapy for 45 minutes per week in her first grade class. The speech and language progress report concluded that STUDENT had demonstrated growth in the areas of auditory attention to task, class participation, spontaneous conversational skills, word retrieval, sharing of ideas and sound discrimination. It reported that her areas of weakness were vocabulary development, auditory short/long term memory, grammar and syntax, problem solving, sound sequencing/patterning and articulation. On the basis of this report, the IEP team developed goals and short-term objectives to increase receptive vocabulary and verbal expression by six months, improve sound sequencing abilities and strengthen sequential memory skills for auditory directional tasks. The team concluded that STUDENT should continue to receive thirty minutes of speech and language therapy twice a week. The APE progress report concluded that STUDENT had strengths in locomotor skills, bouncing and catching skills and body awareness, but was weak in the area of balance, jumping rope and throwing skills. Based upon this report, the IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of balance, throwing, playing handball and jumping rope. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT should continue to receive APE once a weak for thirty minutes to address these goals and objectives. The IEP team also determined that STUDENT was eligible for services during the summer of 2000.

At the request of STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Sinclair performed a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT prior to the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting. Her report concluded that STUDENT had made modest growth in most academic subjects. However, Dr. Sinclair reported that STUDENT’s greatest weakness was in listening comprehension, where she had not demonstrated growth. In order to provide additional support in the area of listening comprehension, the IEP team developed a goal and objectives aimed at increasing her listening comprehension by six months, and added four fifty-minute sessions per week of resource specialist time in the area of language arts.

STUDENT’s parent and their independent psychologist, Dr. Sinclair, fully participated in the development of the goals and objectives and the determination of the services that should be provided. They approved the IEP. Dr. Sinclair testified that at the time of the December 2, 1999 IEP, she believed that the program developed by the IEP team appropriately addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and would result in educational gains for STUDENT.

The December 2, 1999 IEP was to remain in effect for 12 months, which would include the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year and the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. It was anticipated that, unless modified, this IEP would be continued when STUDENT advanced to the regular second grade class at Palm Crest.

After the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents asked speech pathologist Suzanne M. Barnes to perform a speech and language assessment. She recommended that STUDENT receive one hour of speech and language therapy twice a week. The IEP team met on January 20, 2000, to review this assessment. The IEP team agreed to investigate providing an additional session of speech therapy to emphasize articulation development. It was decided that the speech therapist would consult with the first grade teacher regarding a time schedule for the inclusion of additional speech therapy and that the parents could than decide based on the schedule and class time whether this additional therapy would be provided. Nancy Low testified that she continued to provide two sessions per week of speech and language therapy, although on at least one occasion she provided three sessions. She also testified that she was not aware that STUDENT’s parent had retained the services of a private speech and language therapist during this time. She did testify, however, that she believed the two sessions per week were appropriate and would provide STUDENT with educational growth. She testified that by the end of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was making appropriate progress toward meeting all of the speech and language goals and objectives set out in the December 2, 1999 IEP. The goals were to continue during the first part of the 2000-2001 school year, and she believed that they would be accomplished by the time of the next annual IEP in December 2000.

Meetings of the IEP team were held on May 22, 2000, to discuss STUDENT’s progress. STUDENT’s first grade teacher, Ms. Horne, reported that STUDENT was making progress, although she was below grade level in all academic areas. She also expressed concern about STUDENT’s behavior. The OT therapist, Ms. McCann, reported that STUDENT was resisting OT therapy because she did not want “extra help” and wanted to be treated like her classmates. Ms. McCann recommended that OT services be discontinued for the rest of the school year. The IEP team agreed to discontinue OT services for the rest of the 1999-2000 school year but to continue all of the other services. This meeting was a good example of the sensitivity of the District’s members of the IEP team to STUDENT’s individual needs and its willingness to make necessary changes to address those needs.

Another meeting of the IEP team was conducted on June 12, 2000, to address STUDENT’s behavior problems. The team decided to institute a positive behavior strategy (rewarding good behavior with stickers.) STUDENT’s first grade teacher testified that this strategy resulted in improvement in STUDENT’s behavior during the last days of the 1999-2000 school year.

STUDENT’s attorney argues that STUDENT’s program was not appropriate during the 1999-2000 school year because STUDENT was not given an appropriate level of speech and language therapy. The evidence concerning the appropriate level of speech and language therapy was greatly conflicting. Three speech and language therapists testified on behalf of STUDENT. They all had different opinions concerning the necessary amount of speech and language therapy. Ms. Baltaxe, who assessed STUDENT in November 2000, testified that STUDENT should receive three forty-five-minute sessions per week of individual therapy and two forty-five minute sessions of group therapy. Suzanne Barnes, whose firm Speech and Language Associates assessed STUDENT in December 1999, testified that STUDENT should receive two one-hour sessions per week. She also testified that the amount of speech and language therapy recommended by Ms. Baltaxe was excessive. Cheryl Larson, who had provided private speech and language therapy to STUDENT, testified that STUDENT should have three, forty-five- minute sessions each week. She also felt that the recommendation by Ms. Baltaxe was excessive. The District’s speech and language therapist, Ms. Low, testified that two thirty-minute sessions per week of small-group therapy was appropriate and that STUDENT had demonstrated appropriate progress while receiving this level of services. It is difficult to reach a firm conclusion in the face of such conflicting opinions, other than to conclude that reasonable experts can differ on the amount of speech and language therapy that STUDENT needed. It is likely that the experts who testified on behalf of STUDENT were basing their opinions on what they considered to be the best program for STUDENT. As mentioned above, the law does not require a school district to provide the best program or one that will maximize a student’s progress. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony and opinion of Ms. Low convincing. She worked with STUDENT for a longer period than the others and testified that her therapy had resulted in educational progress for STUDENT.

Based on the testimony of all of the members of the IEP team who testified during the hearing, it is concluded that throughout the 1999-2000 school year, the District addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and any changes in those needs by developing goals and objectives to address those needs and providing services to accomplish the goals and objectives. At the time of the various IEP meetings, the participants, including STUDENT’s parents and their independent psychologist, agreed that the proposed goals and objectives and services were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Moreover, the evidence supports the conclusion that she did, in fact, make progress toward the accomplishment of the goals and objectives. It is further concluded that the services provided in the IEP were provided by the District. For these reasons, it is concluded that the District provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the l999-2000 school year.

3. Did the District offer to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?

The program that the District offered to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year was the program contained in the IEP of December 2, 1999, which was to have continued into the 2000-2001 school year when STUDENT enrolled in the second grade class at Palm Crest. The goals and objectives of that IEP were to be continued during the first months of the 2000-2001 school year. The services to be provided included speech and language services for thirty minutes twice per week, APE for thirty minutes once per week, OT for forty-five minutes once a week, and resource specialist services for fifty minutes four time per week.

The IEP team anticipated convening an IEP meeting at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to review the IEP and make appropriate modifications. Ms. Low testified that she was preparing to recommend to the IEP team that speech and language services be increased by providing an additional thirty-minute session per week of individual therapy. The IEP team was going to review the method by which OT services would be provided. While these changes to the IEP had not yet occurred, the testimony of District witnesses concerning their plans to modify STUDENT’s IEP at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year was persuasive because it was consistent with their prior pattern of addressing STUDENT’s unique individual needs and their willingness to supplement the IEP as needed.

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the IEP of December 2, 1999 was an appropriate plan for the provision of FAPE. Absent additional information, it is concluded that the same IEP was an appropriate offer of FAPE for the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. There is no reason be believe that the District would not have made appropriate modifications to the IEP during the 2000-2001 school year as new information became available.

STUDENT’s parents argue that the assessment performed by Dr. Sinclair established that the IEP was not appropriate because it did not address STUDENT’s specific learning disability that had been diagnosed by Dr. Sinclair. They believed that based on that report additional services, including placement in a private school, were necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. Unfortunately, STUDENT’s parents did not see fit to share this report with the District. Instead, they unilaterally placed STUDENT at the Frostig School and requested a hearing to force the District to pay for that placement. Special education law envisions a collaborative effort between parents and school authorities to share information and work together to develop an appropriate program for a child with special needs. By failing to provide this new information to the District and by unilaterally placing STUDENT in a private school, STUDENT’s parents prevented the District from addressing the new information and modifying STUDENT’s IEP as necessary. Based upon the information that the District had at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, including the prior assessments performed by Dr. Sinclair that concluded that STUDENT had a low average IQ and was not learning disabled, it is concluded that the program proposed by the District addressed STUDENT’s unique individual needs and provided a reasonable likelihood that she would make educational progress and, therefore, constituted an offer of FAPE.

4. If the District failed to provide FAPE during any of the three school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide a FAPE during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?

It has been concluded that the District has provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the l998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years and offered a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, it is not necessary to address the issue of compensatory education.

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private speech and language therapy?

It has already been concluded that the District provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the l998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years and offered a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. An important part of the program that was found to constitute FAPE was the provision of speech and language therapy throughout that period of time. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT made progress in relation to her speech and language goals and objectives throughout the period that she was receiving services from the District. Moreover, STUDENT’s parents participated in the development of the goals and objectives contained in each IEP and approved of the IEPs. It is true that STUDENT’s parents obtained additional private services to supplement the services provided by the District, and it is likely that those services assisted in her progress. But a District is only required to provide services designed to address a students unique needs and to provide educational growth. The District’s speech and language therapist was working on the specific goals developed by the IEP team, and STUDENT was progressing toward meeting those goals and objectives. Therefore, it is concluded that the District is not required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private speech and language therapy.

6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tuition at the Frostig School?

As mentioned above, a school District is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits and opportunities. The school district must provide a basic floor of opportunity that addresses the child’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (See Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 458.) If the District’s program meets these requirements, it is not required to provide the program preferred by the parents even if such a program would provide greater benefit. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (1987).

It is clear from the record that STUDENT’s parents are loving, involved parents who want the best for STUDENT. This has been demonstrated by their active involvement in formulating STUDENT’s program, their willingness to provide additional educational services, and their decision to place STUDENT at the Frostig School. However, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District has offered and appropriate program and stands ready to modify that program as necessary to continue to meet STUDENT’s educational needs. Therefore, it is not appropriate to require the District to pay for STUDENT’s placement at the Frostig School.

7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private assessments preformed by Dr. Esther Sinclair?

School districts are required to perform assessments of individuals with exceptional needs in all areas a suspected disability prior to the initial placement in a special education program. Cal.Ed. Code Section 56320. Reassessment of a pupil must be conducted at least once every three years, or mor frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56381. A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of a child at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessments performed by the public educational agency. However, the educational agency may initiate a due process hearing to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the decision of the hearing officer concludes that the educational agencies assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent educational assessment. Education Code Section 56329(b).

In this case, the evidence is uncontradicted that STUDENT’s parents did not disagree with the assessments performed by the district, did not notify the District of their unhappiness with any of the assessments, and did not request the District to perform additional assessments or pay for an independent assessment prior to requesting this hearing. In addition, the evidence establishes that the District’s assessments were appropriate. The December 1998 assessment by the District’s psychologist, Ms. Houlihan, and Dr. Sinclair’s 1997 and 1999 assessments are quite consistent. They both concluded that STUDENT is of low average intelligence and that her academic achievement was consistent with her intelligence. They both concluded that STUDENT had a speech and language impairment.

Moreover, there is no evidence that the District had an obligation to further assess STUDENT. There was no persuasive evidence of a change in STUDENT’s condition since the prior assessments were performed. The triennial reassessment of STUDENT was not due until December 2001.

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. STUDENT’s parents contend that the District should have suspected that STUDENT had a learning disability because STUDENT was performing at the bottom of her first grade class. The District believed that STUDENT’s performance was not inconsistent with her low average intelligence.

It is true that Dr. Sinclair’s July 2000 assessment concluded that STUDENT now has a learning disability. However, if such a report had been provided to the District prior to the unilateral placement of STUDENT at Frostig, the District would have had an opportunity to do additional assessments of its own. There was little reason for the District to suspect the existence of a learning disability in the summer of 2000. Dr. Sinclair’s assessment conducted eight months earlier had not identified such a disability.

The attorney for STUDENT contends that the District’s assessments were inappropriate because they did not perform an academic testing. However, the record reflects that Mrs. Strand performed academic testing of STUDENT on October 22, 1998, prior to the annual IEP meeting conducted in December 1998. The results of that academic testing were also quite consistent with the testing performed by Dr. Sinclair.

Petitioner did not raise any other objections to the appropriateness of the assessments performed by the District.

It is concluded that the District is not required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the assessments performed by Dr. Sinclair because they did not disagree with any of the testing performed by the district, did not request the district to perform additional assessments or pay for an independent assessment. It is also concluded that the District did not have any information that would justify further testing at the end of the 1999-2000 year, and the assessments performed by the District prior to that time were appropriate.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all of the issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).

Dated:

Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office