California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 16, 1998
Student v. Ventura Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1575-97 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson
Ventura Unified must reimburse a private neuropsychological evaluation, including insurance-paid amounts; all requests for added services denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a six-and-a-half-year-old first grader with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Ventura Unified School District. The student attended a communicatively handicapped special day class (SDC) at Poinsettia Elementary School. The parents asked for more services: one-bus door-to-door transportation, a full-time 1:1 aide, psychological counseling, parent training, more OT for gross motor skills, longer individual speech therapy, and tutoring. They also sought reimbursement for three private evaluations.
Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson denied every service request. The student had met 90% of her goals and was benefiting from her current program. Staff and bus drivers saw no anxiety about the short, supervised bus transfer. Rerouting the buses was not a change in services that required notice. The OT and speech services were already working. The tutoring recommendation came from an advocate who was not qualified to make educational recommendations. A request to repay the advocate's fees was dismissed because the Hearing Office had no authority to award them.
On evaluations, the District's speech assessment was appropriate, so the parents' private speech evaluation was not reimbursed. The District's 1997 reassessment, however, left out motor and OT needs. Dr. Karen Schiltz's neuropsychological evaluation was therefore reimbursable, including amounts insurance paid, minus the copayment the District had already covered. The private Saratoga Clinic OT evaluation was obtained before the District shared its own OT results, so it was not reimbursed. The District also had to add gross motor OT goals to the IEP.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled reimbursement for an independent evaluation. A district assessment that missed a suspected area of need made the private evaluation reimbursable. The district also had to repay amounts covered by the parents' private insurance unless it proved the family would suffer no financial loss, including lost lifetime benefits.
Issues and holdings
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue Preliminary. Request for reimbursement of advocacy services provided by Lynne Merrill
The Hearing Officer ruled the Hearing Office had no authority to award advocacy fees in a due process hearing and dismissed this request.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A. In addition to current SDC services, does Student require door-to-door transportation with no bus change for the 1997-98 school year?
Rerouting buses so Student transferred buses was not a change in her related service requiring notice, and the brief, supervised transfer was appropriate; no showing of anxiety or safety risk preventing benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.B. Does Student require a full-time 1:1 classroom aide?
Student benefited from the class aides in her SDC, meeting 90% of goals; evidence did not show she needed a full-time aide working only with her.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.C. Does Student require psychological counseling to address anxiety and delayed social skills?
Apart from the parents, witnesses described Student as happy and comfortable; early-year anxiety stemmed from lack of an after-school routine, so counseling was not needed for educational benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.D. Does Student require related parent training services to help with anxiety and social skills?
No evidence showed Student could not benefit from her education without parent training.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.E. Does Student require occupational therapy for gross motor skills?
Student benefited from twice-weekly OT, which already spent 35-40% of time on gross motor skills, plus weekly APE; no additional OT required.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.F. Does Student require individual speech therapy twice a week for 30-60 minutes each session?
Student's speech improved with the District's three weekly sessions; no assessor recommended individual sessions of that length, and her therapist said longer sessions would not help.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.G. Does Student require individual tutoring?
Only the parents supported tutoring; the advocate who recommended remediation was not qualified to make educational recommendations, and parents are expected to help with homework.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue II.A. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for a speech evaluation conducted by Cheryl Fletcher in May 1997?
Parents need not give prior notice of disagreement, but the District's speech-language assessment met Education Code section 56320 requirements and was appropriate, so no reimbursement.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue II.B. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for a neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Dr. Karen Schiltz in September 1997?
The District's 1997 reassessment failed to assess all areas of suspected disability because it omitted motor/OT needs; reimbursement ordered, including amounts paid by insurance, because the District did not show the parents would suffer no financial loss.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue II.C. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for occupational therapy provided by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998?
Treated as a request for an independent OT evaluation; parents obtained it before learning the District's OT results, so they could not have disagreed with them, and it did not differ in substance.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse parents for the cost of Dr. Karen Schiltz's September 1997 independent neuropsychological assessment, including any amounts covered by insurance, less any amount the District already paid toward the parents' copayment.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene the IEP team to add appropriate occupational therapy goal(s) and objective(s) in the area of gross motor skills.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Hudson v. Wilson; Letter to Spann (OSEP 1993); Raymond S. v. Ramirez
People named in the decision
- Riccardo W. Nargie, director of pupil services, Ventura Unified School District
- Lynne Merrill, advocate / law student / educational therapist, witness for Student, Private
- Shirley Neil, bus driver, Ventura Unified School District
- John Brown, bus driver, Ventura Unified School District
- Sue Moshayedi, special day class teacher, Ventura Unified School District (Poinsettia Elementary)
- Linda Von Essen, adapted physical education specialist, Ventura Unified School District
- Suzanne Saw, registered occupational therapist, Ventura Unified School District
- Holly Anderson, speech and language specialist, Ventura Unified School District
- Debbie Erickson, school psychologist, Ventura Unified School District
- Lola Parker, SDC classroom aide, Ventura Unified School District
- Paul Safran, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Ventura Unified School District
- Aimee Brody, speech and language specialist (assessor), Ventura Unified School District
- E. Cheryl Fletcher, private speech pathologist (independent evaluation), Private
- Karen Schiltz, neuropsychologist (independent evaluation), Private
- Jan Van Duinwyk, private occupational therapist (independent OT evaluation), Saratoga Clinic
- Saratoga Clinic, private occupational therapy clinic, Private provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1575-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Designated Instructionand Services Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 56-72652 District: Ventura Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Ventura, California, on March 24 and 25, 1998, and by telephone conference on March 27, 1998.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney David R. Ellison. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were her father and mother, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT.
Respondent Ventura Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented at the hearing by District counsel Donald F. Austin. Also present on the District's behalf was Riccardo W. Nargie, District director of pupil services.
The following witnesses were called by the Petitioner to testify: Lynne Merrill, advocate/ law student/educational therapist; Mr. PARENT; Mrs. PARENT; and STUDENT.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Mr. Nargie; Shirley Neil and John Brown, District bus drivers; Sue Moshayedi, STUDENT's District special day class (SDC) teacher; Linda Von Essen, District adapted physical education (APE) specialist; Suzanne Saw, District registered occupational therapist (OTR); Holly Anderson, District speech and language specialist; Debbie Erickson, District school psychologist; and Lola Parker, aide in STUDENT's SDC.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Upon receipt of the closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL ITEMS
In the original notice of issues, the Petitioner asked for reimbursement for services provided by Lynne Merrill; however, at the hearing, the Petitioner indicated that this reimbursement request was for advocacy services by Ms. Merrill, not educational therapy services. The Hearing Officer ruled that the Hearing Office had no authority to award advocacy fees as part of a special education due process hearing and dismissed that portion of the Petitioner's issues.
During discussions about documentary evidence, the District stipulated to Dr. Karen Schiltz's expertise as a neuropsychologist.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
I. In addition to the services currently being provided to STUDENT in her District SDC, does STUDENT also require the following for the 1997-98 school year:
1. door-to-door transportation with no bus change;
2. a full-time 1:1 classroom aide;
3. psychological counseling to address anxiety and delayed social skills; 4. related parent training services to help STUDENT with anxiety and social skills; 5. occupational therapy for gross motor skills;
6. individual speech therapy twice a week for 30-60 minutes each session; and 7. individual tutoring?
II. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the following: 1. a speech evaluation conducted by Cheryl Fletcher in May 1997; 2. a neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Dr. Karen Schiltz in September 1997; and 3. occupational therapy provided by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a six-and-a-half-year-old first-grader who is eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability in the areas of conceptualization and expression. STUDENT's first individualized education program (IEP) team meeting was held in February 1996, when she was in preschool. During the 1996-97 school year (kindergarten), the IEP team placed STUDENT in the District's resource specialist program (RSP), and she received speech and language services.
An IEP meeting that was begun on March 10, 1997, was continued until June 2, 1997, to allow the District to reevaluate STUDENT, and in March and April 1997, the District reassessed STUDENT. Paul Safran, District school psychologist, conducted the psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. Mr. Safran concluded that STUDENT did not have a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement, but that she had processing disorders that required her to receive services "as if" she had such a discrepancy. Aimee Brody, speech and language specialist, conducted the speech and language evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Brody concluded that STUDENT continued to have difficulty in overall language and communication skills, although there had been progress in verbalizations and length of sentences. Ms. Brody recommended that STUDENT continue receiving speech and language services or be enrolled in a communicatively handicapped environment to help her continue to grow in this area.
On May 1, 1997, E. Cheryl Fletcher, speech pathologist, prepared a report regarding an independent speech and language evaluation she administered to STUDENT upon the PARENTs' request. Ms. Fletcher concluded that STUDENT was significantly delayed in both receptive and expressive language skills. Ms. Fletcher recommended that an SDC be considered as a placement option and that STUDENT needed an occupational therapy (OT) assessment.
On June 2, 1997, the IEP team reconvened and agreed that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education, and that her placement should be changed from RSP to a special day class (SDC) for the 1997-98 school year (first grade). The IEP document signed June 2, 1997, indicates that the IEP team agreed that STUDENT was to receive speech and language therapy at least once a week for 30 minutes, transportation, and extended school year services.
In September 1997, Dr. Karen Schiltz administered neuropsychological testing, following a referral from STUDENT's pediatrician. Dr. Schiltz concluded that STUDENT exhibited neurodevelopmental delays in the following skill areas: language, attention, concentrational memory, leg coordination, abstract reasoning, concept flexibility, planning, and organization. Dr. Schiltz noted that STUDENT also exhibited strengths in the following skill areas: visual-perceptual, rapid visual-motor tracking, selective fine motor programming/integration, temporal sequencing, and arm coordination. Dr. Schiltz found that STUDENT's overall cognitive ability was within the borderline range, with her performance abilities relatively stronger than her verbal abilities, and that she was functioning at the preschool level in reading recognition, spelling, and arithmetic. Dr. Schiltz also performed social-emotional testing which indicated to her that STUDENT exhibited no signs of psychopathology, although her parents had reported that for approximately a week prior to the parent interview on September 8, 1997, STUDENT had exhibited distress over being separated from them.
In the report of her findings, Dr. Schiltz made the following initial recommendations for STUDENT: educational "remediation" by Lynne Merrill (in amounts to be decided by Ms. Merrill); speech and language, occupational, and physical therapy within the school setting, (although she made no recommendation regarding specific amounts of therapy); assistance by Ms. Merrill to determine what STUDENT's parents can do for her in their home environment (treatment plan to be defined by Ms. Merrill); retesting by Dr. Schiltz in one year, with modification of treatment goals and objectives in the cognitive, physical, adaptive, and emotional areas. Dr. Schiltz also stated that STUDENT's mother "may" need supportive intervention, but that this would be left up to Ms. Merrill.
On October 7, 1997, Lynne Merrill observed STUDENT in her SDC at Poinsettia. In a letter to STUDENT's parents dated October 13, 1997, Ms. Merrill noted that STUDENT worked persistently at letter writing and recognition tasks, she seemed to feel comfortable with the small group with whom she worked on flash cards, and she said liked school and that it was fun. Ms. Merrill also noted that instructors needed to bring STUDENT back on task frequently and that she was unable to recognize the letter "A." Ms. Merrill stated in the letter that Ms. Moshayedi (STUDENT's SDC teacher) told her that the "separation anxiety" STUDENT experienced during the prior month had greatly reduced and that STUDENT's main concern was whether she would be picked up after school by one of her parents or whether she was supposed to take the bus home. At the beginning of the school year, one of STUDENT's parents sometimes picked her up and she sometimes took the bus home after school, so she had no established after-school transportation routine.
On December 1, 1997, Ms. Merrill prepared a report summarizing Dr. Schiltz's report regarding STUDENT. Ms. Merrill listed issues that should be addressed by the District, including what she indicated as STUDENT's need for a classroom aide, increased speech and language services, adapted physical education services, individualized occupational therapy services, individualized education intervention services, and a "possible" psychological intervention. Ms. Merrill also concluded in her report that a placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT would be a school program closer to her home.
On December 4, 1997, the IEP team convened to review the results of Dr. Schiltz's evaluation and Ms. Merrill's recommendations. The team noted on the IEP addendum that Ms. Merrill recommended OT and APE assessments, individual speech and language therapy during at least one of the two sessions STUDENT receives, an individual aide, and a reevaluation of the transportation services. The addendum was signed stating that STUDENT would begin receiving speech and language services twice a week for 25-minute sessions (one small-group session and one individual session), with an indication that this addendum resolved the request for individual speech and language therapy. The team noted that it would meet again to further develop an appropriate program.
On December 5, 1997, the District prepared an assessment plan regarding the OT and APE assessments to be conducted. On December 8, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from STUDENT's parents, which initiated the instant case. On December 9, 1997, STUDENT's mother signed her consent for the assessment plan.
On December 11, 1997, the IEP team reconvened to review the PARENTs' request for additional services listed on the IEP dated December 4, 1997. At this second December IEP meeting, the District denied the request for a 1:1 aide and for a change in transportation because District staff indicated that STUDENT had an appropriate level of support in her SDC and that her transportation services were appropriate. The team noted that the request for individual speech and language services had already been addressed and that the OT and APE evaluations were pending. STUDENT's parents refused to sign this IEP, although the document indicates that STUDENT's SDC teacher, Sue Moshayedi, had developed additional goals and objectives that were agreed to by the PARENTs.
On January 5, 1998, Linda Von Essen, APE specialist, conducted the District's APE assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Von Essen concluded in her report that STUDENT was functioning within the average range when compared to other students in her age group, although she scored low in bent knee curl- ups and throwing and catching accurately. Ms. Von Essen concluded that APE services did not appear necessary for STUDENT, but stated that STUDENT could benefit from a physical education program which would provide her with opportunities to improve her strength and be exposed to a wide variety of physical activities. Ms. Von Essen concluded that this program could be provided within her SDC.
On January 8, 1998, Suzanne Saw, registered occupational therapist (OTR), conducted the District's OT assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Saw concluded that while STUDENT demonstrated low muscle tone and mild motor planning difficulties, she scored at age level on repetitive fine motor tasks which did not require duplication of complex shapes. Ms. Saw indicated that STUDENT's fine motor difficulties stemmed primarily from visual integration difficulties. Ms. Saw found that STUDENT had difficulty with visual-motor integration skills, balance, bilateral motor coordination, and response speed, and that processing auditory and visual information was difficult for her. Ms. Saw recommended OT services once a week for three months on a trial basis to determine if it would increase STUDENT's muscle tone and improve sensory processing. She also recommended that STUDENT continue working with her classmates during group OT once a week.
On January 15, 1998, STUDENT's parents obtained an independent OT assessment by the Saratoga Clinic. Jan Van Duinwyk, OTR, conducted this private evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Van Duinwyk concluded that STUDENT required OT twice a week for six months, followed by a reevaluation.
On January 20, 1998, the IEP team convened to discuss the results of the District's APE and OT assessments. The IEP document indicates that the team agreed that STUDENT should receive OT services once a week for 30 minutes at school. However, the team did not agree about APE services -- the PARENTs disputed the District's position that STUDENT did not require APE services.
Since the beginning of first grade, STUDENT has attended a communicatively handicapped SDC at Poinsettia Elementary School in Ventura. For this class of ten (four first-graders and six second- graders), there is at least one aide present at all times, in addition to the SDC teacher. From the beginning of the year, STUDENT has received speech and language therapy once a week with the rest of her classmates, as part of her SDC program. Since early December 1997, STUDENT has received (pursuant to her IEP) speech and language therapy services two more times a week, in a "small group" session (STUDENT and one other student) and in an individual session outside of class. From the beginning of the school year, STUDENT has received OT once a week with her SDC classmates, as part of the class. Since late January, STUDENT has received (pursuant to her IEP) OT once more each week, in an individual session outside of class. Since the beginning of the school year, STUDENT has also received adapted physical education (APE) once a week in a group session with the rest of her SDC as part of the class.
STUDENT lives with her parents in Oakview, which, while within the District, is a considerable distance from her SDC at Poinsettia. The District offered bus transportation to and from school for STUDENT. However, STUDENT's parents take her to school in the morning and she takes the bus in the afternoon. At the beginning of the school year, the District used one bus to transport STUDENT and other students from Poinsettia to Oakview, but within a few weeks, the District changed the routes to increase overall efficiency. As a result, STUDENT and other students now transfer to a second District bus in the "Avenue" area of Ventura, and this bus takes her the rest of the way to Oakview.
The parties dispute whether transferring STUDENT to the second school bus in the "Avenue" area of Ventura is appropriate and whether doing so has caused her to become anxious or upset such that she requires psychological counseling and related parent training services. The parties also dispute whether STUDENT needs a full-time 1:1 aide (in addition to the aides present in her SDC), additional occupational therapy to work on her gross motor skills, additional individual speech and language therapy, and individual tutoring. The parties do not now have a dispute over APE services. The parties further dispute whether STUDENT's parents should be reimbursed for the independent evaluations they obtained.
The parties participated in mediation, but were unable to resolve their disputes, and the matter was scheduled for hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. In addition to the services currently being provided to STUDENT in her District SDC, does STUDENT also require the following for the 1997-98 school year:
A. door-to-door transportation with no bus change;
B. a full-time 1:1 classroom aide;
C. psychological counseling to address anxiety and delayed social skills; D. related parent training services to help STUDENT with anxiety and social skills; E. occupational therapy for gross motor skills;
F. individual speech therapy twice a week for 30-60 minutes each session; and G. individual tutoring?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA( Footnote 2)) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) "Related services" are defined as transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) In California, related services are known as "designated instruction and services" (DIS). (California Education Code § 56363.)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.) (Footnote 3)
A. Transportation
The Petitioner contends that the District provided no notice of its alteration of the school bus routes, which caused STUDENT to have to ride two buses. The Petitioner asserts that STUDENT's bus transportation must be provided via only one bus because STUDENT is anxious and scared about riding the bus, she has delayed communication abilities, and the area in which she has to transfer is unsafe. The District contends that there is no indication that STUDENT is anxious about riding the bus, and that she is able to communicate better than her parents indicate. The District asserts that the area in which STUDENT and the other students transfer is safe for purposes of the bus transfer.
With regard to the procedural issue of notice, parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)
School districts must notify parents in writing of a change in the program, placement, or related services provided to a child in special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) The IEP team agreed that during the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT required transportation as a related service, and no one disputes that fact. (Pet. Exh. K. (Footnote 4)) There is no evidence that adjusting the overall bus routes constituted a "change" in STUDENT's related service of transportation that would trigger a notice requirement. STUDENT was still being provided transportation, in the same amount and in a timely manner. (Testimony of Mr. Brown and Ms. Neil.) The alteration of the bus route was a minor adjustment of the type that school districts are free to make. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 208.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the alteration of bus routes did not constitute a change in STUDENT's transportation and that the District did not thereby commit a procedural violation.
While the adjustment of school bus routes here does not constitute a change in placement, the larger question of appropriateness of STUDENT's related service of transportation needs to be examined. The parties agree that STUDENT requires home-to-school transportation as a related service. The only area of disagreement is whether STUDENT must be transported via only one bus.
STUDENT's parents testified that she has become anxious because of the bus ride involving the transfer. However, there is ample evidence that STUDENT's anxiety at the beginning of the year was caused by the fact that she had no routine in her after-school transportation. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi; Pet. Exh. D, at p. 40.) Furthermore, other than STUDENT's parents, no one else testified that STUDENT exhibits anxiety over anything, including the bus transfer. Mr. Brown testified that STUDENT seems happy while riding his bus. Ms. Moshayedi testified that she has not found STUDENT to appear anxious about having to transfer to a second bus. It has not been sufficiently shown that the bus transfer has caused STUDENT to be so anxious that she cannot benefit from her education.
It is uncontested that STUDENT has a speech and language disability. However, even if it is true that STUDENT speaks in three- to five-word sentences, the Petitioner has not shown with particularity how this disability renders the use of a controlled bus transfer inappropriate, such that she cannot benefit from her education. On the other hand, evidence was presented showing that no incidents stemming from STUDENT's delayed ability to understand directions have occurred. In fact, no evidence was presented regarding any incidents directly related to the bus transfer. Other than STUDENT's being asked not to hold hands with a little boy on the bus, there has been no need to intervene on her behalf. (Testimony of Ms. Neil and Mr. Brown.) The transfer procedure described by the bus drivers is simple and controlled, and the Hearing Officer notes that having the routine of taking the bus each day for the vast majority of the school year has lessened any possibility that STUDENT may not understand or follow directions relating to her transportation. (Footnote 5)
Furthermore, the Petitioner presented nothing more than anecdotal evidence regarding the allegation that the residential area in which the bus transfer takes place is unsafe. No statistics or testimony by expert witnesses was presented on this question of fact. There is no basis on which to conclude that the area is so unsafe that STUDENT must be transferred at another location in order to benefit from her education. The District has met STUDENT's transportation need by providing transportation as noted in her IEP. Unless the transportation service is shown to be inappropriate in some way, the methodology of providing that service, like teaching methodology, is left up to the discretion of the school district. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 208.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need to be transported door-to-door via one bus for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year.
B. Full-time 1:1 classroom aide
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's abilities are commensurate with those of a younger child (e.g., STUDENT communicates in three- to five-word sentences and does not always understand what is being said to her), and that she needs a full-time 1:1 classroom aide (in addition to the assistance already provided in her SDC). The District contends that STUDENT does not need a full-time 1:1 aide in her SDC because there are already two aides in that class and that such an aide would put STUDENT in an environment that is too restrictive.
The evidence showed that STUDENT was placed in a communicatively handicapped SDC that had an aide assigned to it at all times (two part-time aides), in addition to another aide assigned to work mostly with an autistic child. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi and Ms. Parker.)
The Petitioner did not specifically argue that STUDENT did not receive benefit from the services of the two part-time aides in her SDC. Ms. Moshayedi testified that as of the date of the hearing, STUDENT had met 90% of her goals and objectives. There was no evidence to the contrary on that point. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the services provided by the District provided benefit to STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year.
The evidence showed that STUDENT needs more time than her peers to learn ideas and that she requires repetition and reinforcement of concepts. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT, Ms. Moshayedi, and STUDENT; Dist. Exh. 2, at p. 2. (Footnote 6)) Even in a small classroom, STUDENT requires the assistance of an aide who can step in when needed to reinforce and repeat directions, as well as clarify concepts with her. However, the evidence does not support the Petitioner's contention that she needs such an aide all the time, i.e., that she needs a full-time 1:1 aide who will work only with her, and not with any other children. Dr. Schiltz did not specifically recommend a full-time 1:1 aide for STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. C, at pp. 28-29.) Ms. Merrill testified that Ms. Moshayedi, STUDENT's SDC teacher, told her that STUDENT was the next-to-lowest functioning child in her class and that she took a lot of Ms. Moshayedi's time, but that the District would not provide a 1:1 aide unless a child has a behavioral problem. Ms. Moshayedi denied making this statement and said that STUDENT does not need a full-time 1:1 aide in order to benefit from her education. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi.) Ms. Merrill testified that she saw a need for a full-time 1:1 aide for STUDENT in her observation of the SDC. However, in Ms. Merrill's letter to the PARENTs shortly after she observed STUDENT in October 1997, she indicated only that the services of an aide to accompany STUDENT "might" be beneficial. Ms. Merrill wrote that she otherwise approved of the communication- based SDC and noted that "STUDENT [sic] transitioned well to recess time, with the help of the assistant and teacher." (Pet. Exh. D, at p. 40.)
Furthermore, Ms. Merrill has been functioning both as an advocate and provider of "remediation" services in this matter. While Ms. Merrill did short-term substitute teaching in some special education classes, she does not possess a special education credential, nor does she have formal training as a school psychologist or special education teacher, other than that necessary to obtain her bachelor's degree. Ms. Merrill observed STUDENT's class once for approximately an hour. (Testimony of Ms. Merrill.) Ms. Moshayedi is with STUDENT every day; she has a master's degree in special education, with an emphasis on learning disabilities; and she is credentialed to teach special education in California. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi.) Based on the evidence presented that STUDENT is benefitting from the in-class assistance currently provided by the District in her SDC (the two part-time aides assigned to the class), the Hearing Officer finds that for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT does not require a full-time 1:1 aide to work solely with her. (Footnote 7)
C. Psychological counseling
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires psychological counseling to address anxiety caused by riding the bus and delayed social skills. The District contends that STUDENT does not suffer from such anxiety and does not require psychological counseling.
Although STUDENT's parents indicated that she has been anxious about riding the bus after school (since the use of two buses was implemented), all other evidence indicates that STUDENT is happy in general at school and is comfortable with riding the bus. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi, Ms. Brown, and Ms. Neil.) The Hearing Officer noted above that STUDENT's anxiety early in the school year was in response to the lack of a routine in her after-school transportation. STUDENT has made friends with children on the buses, and the bus drivers indicated that she has been friendly and outgoing with those children. (Testimony of Mr. Brown and Ms. Neil.) The evidence did not show that STUDENT suffers from anxiety such that psychological counseling is necessary for her to benefit from her education -- as found above, she has received benefit from her education. Therefore, based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need psychological counseling in order to benefit from her education for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year.
D. Related parent training services
The only information presented specifically regarding STUDENT's need for her parents to receive related parent training services was in conjunction with the Petitioner's allegation that STUDENT needs psychological counseling. No evidence was presented showing that STUDENT could not benefit from her education if her parents did not receive parent training services. (Footnote 8) Therefore, STUDENT does not need related parent training services for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year.
E. Occupational therapy (OT) for gross motor skills
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires additional OT services, specifically for gross motor skills. The District asserts that STUDENT does not need more OT than she is already receiving, which it contends addresses both fine and gross motor skills.
The Petitioner did not argue that STUDENT did not receive benefit from the District's OT services. Ms. Moshayedi testified that the OT services provided to STUDENT have helped her with her school work, including writing tasks. STUDENT has made progress in both her fine and gross motor skills. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi, Ms. Saw, and Ms. Von Essen.) No contradictory evidence was presented. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has received benefit specifically from the District's OT services during the 1997-98 school year.
The parties agree that STUDENT requires occupational therapy for fine motor skills because she is mildly delayed in those areas. (Testimony of Ms. Saw; Pet. Exh. T, at p. 91; Pet. Exh. U, at p. 93.) The evidence also indicated that the amount of occupational therapy that STUDENT needs is twice-weekly therapy. (Testimony of Ms. Saw; Pet. Exh. T, at p. 91.) The District's OTR, Ms. Saw, indicated in her report that STUDENT should not only receive OT outside of class once a week, but that she should also continue working with her classmates in group OT sessions once a week. (Pet. Exh. T, at p. 91.) The OT assessment procured by the Petitioner from the Saratoga Clinic indicates that STUDENT needs OT services encompassing both fine and gross motor skill areas, and that she should receive OT twice a week, including her group OT session with her class. (Pet. Exh. U, at pp. 93-94.)
Throughout the year, the District provided OT services once a week for 30 minutes in the SDC class. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi and Ms. Saw.) As of January 20, 1998, the District provided an additional session of OT once a week in addition to the OT provided with the SDC. (Testimony of Ms. Saw; Pet. Exh. V, at p. 96.) Ms. Saw noted that she works on gross motor skills for 35%-40% of the time, because such gross motor skills work helps out a student's fine motor skills as well. (Testimony of Ms. Saw.) Furthermore, the evidence showed that STUDENT also receives APE services once a week to address gross motor skills specifically, along with her classmates as part of the SDC program. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi, Ms. Saw, and Ms. Von Essen.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 1997-98 school year, because STUDENT has benefitted from the District's OT services, she does not require OT for gross motor skills beyond what the District has already provided.
F. Individual speech therapy
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT needs individual speech and language therapy twice a week for 30 to 60 minutes per session. The District alleges that STUDENT already receives two 25-minute sessions of speech and language therapy per week, one of which is individual.
Holly Anderson, STUDENT's speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT's speech has improved, based on testing she has done. Ms. Anderson also indicated that STUDENT receives peer and adult modeling by receiving some of her speech and language therapy in small and large groups. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT's speech has improved over the school year, and that she uses more words in sentences and more complete sentences. Ms. Moshayedi also testified that she can understand STUDENT better now and that she speaks in longer sentences than she did at the beginning of the school year. Based on unrefuted evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's speech and language services for the 1997-98 school year have provided benefit to STUDENT.
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires speech therapy to remediate deficits and to help increase the number of words she uses in sentences. They simply disagree as to whether the two additional sessions should be 1:1 (individual) and whether the sessions should be longer than 25 minutes. Dr. Schiltz did not specify that speech therapy must be provided to STUDENT on an individual basis, nor did she indicate the number of times per week STUDENT should receive speech therapy. (Pet. Exh. C, at pp. 28-29.) The independent evaluation by E. Cheryl Fletcher in May 1997 also does not indicate that STUDENT needs individual speech therapy, nor does it indicate that she needs a certain amount per week. (Pet. Exh. FF.) District speech and language specialist Aimee Brody recommended in March 1997 that STUDENT should continue receiving the speech and language services she had been (at least once per week for 30 minutes) or be enrolled in a communicatively handicapped SDC. (Dist. Exh. 3, at p. 46.) Holly Anderson, the District speech and language specialist who works with STUDENT, stated that additional speech and language therapy, beyond the three sessions actually provided to STUDENT, would not be beneficial because she loses STUDENT's attention after much more than about 20 minutes. Based on the finding that STUDENT has received benefit from the speech and language services provided by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that, for the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT does not require individual speech and language therapy twice a week for 30 to 60 minutes each session.
G. Individual tutoring
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's father spends hours each night with her, working on homework and preparation for school and that, therefore, STUDENT requires individual tutoring. The District asserts that STUDENT does not require individual tutoring.
The only witnesses to indicate that STUDENT requires individual tutoring were her parents. Both testified that STUDENT's father, Mr. PARENT, works with STUDENT each school night for several hours to help her with her school work. Mr. PARENT believes that some of STUDENT's success at school is attributable to his working with her. Dr. Schiltz recommended "outside remediation" as deemed appropriate by Lynne Merrill. (Pet. Exh. C, at p. 28.) However, as noted above, Ms. Merrill is not a special education teacher or an educational psychologist; therefore, she is unqualified to make educational recommendations for a special education student such as STUDENT. None of the District witnesses could attribute STUDENT's success to her father's extra help. In fact, STUDENT spends most of her learning time working with District staff, receiving several types of related services, in addition to being in a communicatively handicapped SDC, which all parties agree is appropriate for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Moshayedi.) The Hearing Officer notes that it is impossible to try to ferret out what percentage of benefit to STUDENT's education, if any, is due to the efforts of STUDENT's parents. Mr. PARENT's personal efforts are praiseworthy; however, parents are expected to help their children after school. Therefore, based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require individual tutoring for the 1997-98 school year.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer found above that, for the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT does not require transportation door-to-door via one bus only, a full-time 1:1 aide to work solely with her, psychological counseling, related parent training, additional OT for gross motor skills, individual speech and language therapy twice a week for 30 to 60 minutes each session, or individual tutoring.
II. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the following: A. a speech evaluation conducted by Cheryl Fletcher in May 1997; B. a neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Dr. Karen Schiltz in September 1997; and C. occupational therapy provided by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of a child at public expense when the parent disagrees with an assessment done by the local educational agency, unless that agency shows at a due process hearing that its own assessment was appropriate. (California Education Code § 56329(b).)
A. Independent speech and language assessment by E. Cheryl Fletcher
The Petitioner's attorney did not specifically argue the issue of reimbursement for evaluations in his closing brief, except to state that the District did not appear to know or understand the nature and extent of STUDENT's educational difficulties, and that, for this reason, the PARENTs sought independent evaluations.
The District asserts that the PARENTs never challenged the District's speech and language evaluation by Ms. Brody until the District was presented with the results of the independent speech evaluation by Ms. Fletcher at the hearing, and that, in any case, the results of that assessment did not provide anything new to the District's understanding of STUDENT.
Although the District argued that the independent assessment by Ms. Fletcher did not provide anything new to the District's understanding of STUDENT, the question is whether the District's assessment is appropriate, not whether the independent assessment adds anything. (California Education Code § 56329(b).) Furthermore, although the District argued that the PARENTs did not challenge the District's speech and language assessment until the hearing, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has indicated that parents do not have to notify a school district that they disagree with that agency's assessment before requesting reimbursement for an independent assessment. (Hudson v. Wilson, 828 F.2d 1059, 1065 (4th Cir. 1987).) The fact that the PARENTs obtained an independent speech and language evaluation of STUDENT in May 1997 sufficiently indicates the
PARENTs' dissatisfaction with the District's speech and language assessment to proceed to the analysis of whether the District's assessment was appropriate.
In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that a school district's assessment must be administered by qualified personnel and utilize instruments that are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory and that have been validated for the purpose for which they are used. The school district's assessment must also be provided and administered in the student's primary language, unless clearly not feasible, and in conformance with the test producer's instructions. Furthermore, no single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate program for a student. (California Education Code § 56320.)
The District's speech and language assessment of STUDENT was conducted in January 1997 by Aimee Brody. (Dist. Exh. 1, at pp. 8-9.) The Petitioner did not contend that Aimee Brody was not qualified to administer her assessment, nor is there any evidence that Ms. Brody, a District speech and language specialist, was not qualified to conduct this assessment. Ms. Brody's report indicates that she used versions of the "PPVT," the "PLS," and the "TACL" in her evaluation. (Footnote 9) (Dist. Exh. 1, at p. 8.) Thus, she did not use a single procedure as the sole criterion for her conclusions. The Petitioner did not argue that any of the instruments used by Ms. Brody were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, nor is there any evidence that they suffered from such defects. Ms. Brody's report indicates that the PPVT tests receptive vocabulary, the PLS tests auditory comprehension and expressive communication, and the TACL tests auditory comprehension, using visual and oral stimuli. (Id.) The Petitioner did not assert that any of these instruments were not validated for their stated purposes, nor is there any evidence thereof. STUDENT spoke in English at the hearing, and there is no indication that her primary language is any language other than English. For all the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's speech and language assessment of STUDENT by Ms. Brody was appropriate and that the Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent speech and language assessment by Ms. Fletcher.
B. Independent neuropsychological evaluation by Dr. Schiltz
The Petitioner contends that the District did not fully understand STUDENT's needs and that, therefore, the PARENTs procured Dr. Schiltz's neuropsychological evaluation. The District contends that it conducted an appropriate reassessment of STUDENT in March and April 1997. The District further asserts that it has already paid the out-of-pocket expenses incurred by the PARENTs in connection with Dr. Schiltz's neuropsychological evaluation, as the District volunteered to pay the PARENTs' insurance co-payment for the testing.
In March and April 1997, following the speech and language assessment by Ms. Brody, the District conducted psychological testing of STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 2.) The District's assessor, Paul Safran, Ph.D., is a school psychologist; therefore, he was qualified to conduct the psychological portion of the District's assessment. (Dist. Exh. 2, at p. 6; California Education Code § 56320(b)(3).)
Mr. Safran reviewed previous testing of STUDENT done in January 1996, including the Developmental Profile II, the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, the Preschool Language Scale-3 (receptive and expressive forms), and the Expressive One-Word Vocabulary Test. (Dist. Exh. 2, at p. 2.) Other testing Mr. Safran reviewed was done in September 1996, including the home and school versions of the Attention Deficit Disorders Evaluation Scale, as well as a hearing test. (Dist. Exh. 2, at p. 3.) Mr. Safran reviewed STUDENT's health and developmental history and, in March 1997, administered his own testing instruments, including the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence, the Leiter International Performance Scale, the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration, and the Woodcock Johnson-Revised. (Dist. Exh. 2, at p. 7.) Therefore, the District's assessor used more than one procedure to determine his conclusions. The Petitioner did not argue that any of the instruments used by Mr. Safran were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, nor is there any evidence that they were inappropriate in that manner. Furthermore, there is no indication that the tests used by Mr. Safran were not validated for their purposes.
A school district's evaluation must also assess the student in all areas of suspected disability. (California Education Code § 56320(f).) Dr. Schiltz's neuropsychological evaluation in September 1997 indicated that STUDENT required occupational therapy, and eventually the District agreed, after doing its own OT assessment in January 1998. (Pet. Exh. C, at p. 28; Pet. Exh. T; testimony of Ms. Saw.) The District's assessment in March and April 1997 did not include an OT assessment. (Dist. Exh. 2.) The question becomes whether STUDENT's motor skills were an area of suspected disability at the time of the District's assessment in March and April 1997. There is no evidence that the PARENTs requested an OT assessment prior to their request at an IEP meeting held December 4, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 1.) The District indicated at the March/June 1997 IEP meeting that STUDENT's fine and gross motor skills were age appropriate and that she had a good pencil grip. (Dist. Exh.1, at p.
2.) The speech and language assessment by E. Cheryl Fletcher, dated May 1, 1997, recommended that an OT assessment be conducted of STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. FF.) The PARENTs indicated to Dr. Schiltz that STUDENT was having problems with fine coordination. (Pet. Exh. C, at p. 14; Dist. Exh. 1.) Even though the speech and language assessment by Ms. Fletcher was not provided to the District in a timely manner, the recommendation indicates that the District's assessors should have been able to notice that an OT evaluation was necessary. Some months later, the District conducted such an OT evaluation and recommended OT services, verifying the need for such an assessment. In fact, the District's director of pupil services, Riccardo Nargie, testified that the reason the District decided to pay the PARENTs' insurance copayment for Dr. Schiltz's assessment was that her report pointed out the need for an OT assessment, which the District had not yet dealt with in its own assessments. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's assessment in March and April 1997 failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, because it did not either include an OT evaluation or indicate a need to do such an evaluation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's assessment in March and April 1997 was inappropriate.
All special education assessments must be conducted by qualified personnel. The evidence showed that Karen Schiltz, Ph.D., is a psychologist, specializing in the area of clinical neuropsychology. (Pet. Exh. B, at p. 2; testimony of Ms. Merrill.) In fact, the District stipulated to Dr. Schiltz's expertise as a neuropsychologist. However, Dr. Schiltz is not a school psychologist, and she works primarily in the medical, not educational, field. (Pet. Exh. B.) Dr. Schiltz's assessment was done "as part of an overall medical diagnostic evaluation." (Pet. Exh. C, at p. 13.) On the other hand, Dr. Schiltz noted that the purpose of her assessment of STUDENT was to assess her current cognitive, behavioral, and social-emotional functioning levels. Although special education law does not require school districts to pay for solely medical evaluations, it is clear that this assessment was not solely medical/neurological, in that it attempted to understand STUDENT's language and other skills, as those relate to neuropsychological and other factors. Dr. Schiltz used many testing instruments used by school psychologists, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children- III, the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised, and the Wide Range Achievement Test- III, to name just a few. (Pet. Exh. C, at p. 20.) Therefore, because the District failed to appropriately assess STUDENT, and because Dr. Schiltz is qualified to conduct a neuropsychological evaluation which covers educational areas in detail, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the neuropsychological evaluation by Dr. Schiltz.
The District contends that it has already paid the copayment for the PARENTs' insurance regarding Dr. Schiltz's independent assessment and that, therefore, the District is not responsible for any other costs related to the assessment. However, the Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) has stated that school districts may use a parent's private insurance benefits to pay for educationally necessary special education related services only if the parent would not incur a financial loss. OSEP said that the district must follow certain steps as well, including obtaining parental consent and informing the parent of rights, which includes the potential loss of lifetime insurance benefits. (OSEP 1993, Letter to Spann, 20 IDELR 627.) A district court has followed this line of reasoning by not requiring a parent to use private insurance to pay for private evaluations when it would result in financial loss to the parent. (Raymond S. ex rel. Joseph S. v. Ramirez, 918 F.Supp. 1280 (N.D. Iowa 1996).) The Hearing Officer finds the reasoning in the OSEP letter and the district court opinion logical and persuasive.
Because it is a district's burden to provide a FAPE and to advise parents of their rights regarding potential loss if the district attempts to use parental insurance to pay for FAPE-related services, the Hearing Officer notes, therefore, that it is appropriate for the District in this matter to bear the burden of proving that no financial loss (including potential loss of lifetime benefits) to the PARENTs would occur. Here, the District provided no evidence that STUDENT's parents would not suffer financial loss because of the use of insurance to pay for the independent assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for Dr. Schiltz's assessment should not be reduced by any amount which was covered by insurance.
C. Independent OT by the Saratoga Clinic
The Petitioner contends that the PARENTs should be reimbursed for OT services provided by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998. The District contends that it conducted appropriate OT and APE assessments in January 1998. The District also alleges that the PARENTs obtained the independent OT assessment at the Saratoga Clinic before the report from the District's OTR was completed and that, therefore, they could not have been in disagreement with results that were not yet available.
First, the Hearing Officer notes that although the Petitioner is asking for reimbursement for OT "services" provided by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998, there is no indication that STUDENT has received OT services from this outside provider, other than the OT evaluation in evidence. (Pet. Exh. U.) Therefore, the Petitioner's request is viewed as a request for reimbursement for another independent evaluation.
The District completed its OT evaluation in January 1998. The report by Suzanne Saw is dated January 8, 1998. (Pet. Exh. T; testimony of Ms. Saw.) Following the commencement of that District assessment, STUDENT's parents obtained a private OT evaluation by the Saratoga Clinic, conducted on January 15, 1998. (Pet. Exh. U.) The IEP team met on January 20, 1998, to discuss the results of the District's OT assessment (as well as an adapted physical education assessment). (Pet. Exh. V.) In fact, Ms. PARENT acknowledged that she did not see the results of the District OT assessment prior to the IEP team meeting in January 1998. She stated that the reason she and her husband obtained the independent OT assessment was that an OT assessment had not yet been done by the District. However, the Hearing Officer notes that following the request for OT and APE assessments at the IEP meeting held December 4, 1997, the PARENTs signed the District's assessment plan for those evaluations on December 9, 1997. (Pet. Exh. M, at p. 65.) Another IEP meeting was held on December 11, 1997, and the IEP document notes that both the OT and APE assessments were pending. Furthermore, on January 9, 1998, the District sent a written notice of the IEP team meeting to be held on January 20, 1998. The District indicated that both the District's APE specialist, Ms. Von Essen, and the OT specialist, Ms. Saw, would be attending the meeting. (Dist. Exh. 3, at p. 170.) Therefore, the PARENTs' assumption that the District had not done the OT assessment was unreasonable, and STUDENT's parents could not have disagreed with the results of the District's assessment until they first heard of them at the IEP team meeting, held after they had already procured an independent OT assessment. Furthermore, the independent OT assessment did not differ in substance from the District's OT assessment. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent OT assessment by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998.
ORDER
1. The District is ordered to reimburse the PARENTs for the cost of the independent assessment by Karen Schiltz, conducted in September 1997, including any amounts covered by insurance, less any amount already paid toward the PARENTs' copayment.
2. The District is ordered to convene the IEP team to add to STUDENT's IEP appropriate occupational therapy goal(s) and objective(s) in the area of gross motor skills.
3. All the Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. In addition to the services currently being provided to STUDENT in her District SDC, does STUDENT also require the following for the 1997-98 school year:
A. door-to-door transportation with no bus change The District prevailed on this issue.
B. a full-time 1:1 classroom aide The District prevailed on this issue.
C. psychological counseling to address anxiety and delayed social skills The District prevailed on this issue.
D. related parent training services to help STUDENT with anxiety and social skills The District prevailed on this issue.
E. occupational therapy for gross motor skills The District prevailed on this issue.
F. individual speech therapy twice a week for 30-60 minutes each session The District prevailed on this issue.
G. individual tutoring The District prevailed on this issue.
II. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the following:
A. an independent speech evaluation by Cheryl Fletcher in May 1997 The District prevailed on this issue.
B. a neuropsychological evaluation by Dr. Karen Schiltz in September 1997 The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
C. independent occupational therapy by the Saratoga Clinic in January 1998? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: June 16, 1998 ____________________________________ Kathleen Peterson Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. The Petitioner's issues were worded slightly differently than presented here and were reorganized for purposes of appropriate factual and legal analysis. 2. Amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997. 3. The Hearing Officer notes that there is no indication in the amended IDEA that this philosophy has changed. 4. Pet. Exh." refers to the Petitioner's exhibits, lettered A through Z, and AA through JJ, admitted into evidence. 5. Mr. Brown's bus (the bus to which STUDENT transfers) pulls up behind Ms. Neil's bus (the bus on which STUDENT arrives). Once both buses have parked and the flashing red lights are on, three students (including STUDENT) file out of Ms. Neil's bus and enter Mr. Brown's bus (directly behind Ms. Neil's bus), walking a very short distance. Both drivers watch the three students during the transfer, which takes approximately 30 seconds. Students are not allowed off the first bus until the second bus is there and ready to accept them. (Testimony of Ms. Neil and Mr. Brown.) 6. "Dist. Exh." refers to the District's exhibits, numbered 1 through 3, admitted into evidence. 7. Because STUDENT does not need her own 1:1 aide, the Hearing Officer need not address the District's allegation that providing such an aide would create a more restrictive environment for her. 8. The Hearing Officer notes that if the provision of such services might assist in relations between the District and STUDENT's parents, District staff may want to consider providing such services, despite the findings herein. 9. Presumably referring to the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R), the Preschool Language Scale (PLS), and the Test of Auditory Comprehension of Language-Revised (TACL-R). (Dist. Exh. 3, at p. 12; Assessment, 6th ed., Salvia and Ysseldyke, pp. 363-365 and 532-533.)
