California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 6, 2002
Student v. Escondido Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 159-00 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Escondido Union High must reimburse math tutoring and dictation technology after denying FAPE; laptop, science tutoring and assessment claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision. Petitioner withdrew two issues on the last day of hearing: reimbursement for counseling by Dr. Jackie Gang, and transportation to the Jack Schnel assessment.
Summary
A high school student with a specific learning disability transferred into Escondido Union High School District in September 1999 and filed for due process. The District served him under his last signed IEP from Capistrano Unified, which included one period of resource specialist program (RSP) support. The Hearing Officer found this was a proper 30-day interim placement.
After the 30 days ended, the District held no IEP meeting until October 25, 1999. That IEP was unfinished. It had no present levels, no goals and no transition statement. The December 2, 1999 IEP stayed in effect through January 9, 2001. It did not state present levels and had no math goals. Its writing goals did not say how technology would be used. It offered one RSP period instead of the two Student needed, and it set no limit on advanced courses. It also left out preferential seating, a calculator, and dictation tools. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE from October 1, 1999 to January 9, 2001. She found Student did not need extended school year services.
The parent was reimbursed for private algebra and precalculus tutoring and for voice recognition software and a tape recorder. Science tutoring and a laptop were not reimbursed because they did not address an identified need. The parent's private psychological and vision assessments, and travel to them, were not reimbursed. The District had not done an assessment the parent could disagree with, and it had not refused to assess.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled transfer students under Education Code section 56325. It also shows that a late, incomplete IEP that a district never finished can deny FAPE for more than a year. Reimbursement for parent-paid tutoring was limited to services tied to the student's identified needs. Payment for an independent assessment required a district assessment or a district refusal to assess.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District fulfill its obligations under Education Code section 56325(a) to provide Student with a thirty-day interim placement upon his transfer into the District?
The District immediately implemented the last signed and implemented IEP (Capistrano, September 23, 1998), including one period of RSP, so it met section 56325(a).
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer Student a FAPE after the thirty-day interim period through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year, and from the start of the 2000-2001 school year through January 9, 2001?
FAPE was denied from October 1, 1999 to January 9, 2001: the IEP meeting came late, the October 1999 IEP was incomplete, and the December 1999 IEP lacked present levels, math and adequate writing goals, two RSP periods, preferential seating, a calculator and dictation technology. ESY was not required.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement for independent tutorial services furnished to Student from September 1999 to January 9, 2001?
Math tutoring in algebra and precalculus met Student's needs and is reimbursable, excluding the interim period and summer 2000. Science tutoring was not tied to an identified need and is not reimbursable.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement for assistive technology purchased for Student's use between February 2000 and January 9, 2001?
The parent is reimbursed for voice recognition software and a tape recorder, which the District failed to provide. The laptop is not reimbursed because the Alpha SmartPro and RSP computer met Student's needs.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 9, 2001?
No reimbursement: the District had not completed an assessment the parent could disagree with and had not refused to assess. Its proposed October 1999 assessment plan was appropriate.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 6. Is Student's parent entitled to transportation furnished to Student in the course of completing assessments by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 2001?
Because neither assessment is reimbursable, transportation to them is not reimbursable either.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse the parent for tutoring in algebra and precalculus from October 1, 1999 to January 9, 2001, excluding services during the 1999-2000 extended school year. The decision names Tim Steigerwald and Angie Nellos as the tutors.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse the parent for the cost of voice recognition software and a tape recorder bought between October 1, 1999 and January 9, 2001 for Student's use in school.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Union School Dist. v. Smith
People named in the decision
- Sallie Hunt, former special programs coordinator, Escondido Union High School District
- Sue Davis, director of special education, Escondido Union High School District
- Richard Reeves, resource specialist teacher, San Pasqual High School
- Sheryl Eskola, resource specialist teacher, San Pasqual High School
- William McAllister, math teacher, San Pasqual High School
- Larry Carter, chemistry teacher, San Pasqual High School
- Thomas Walsh, AP U.S. History teacher, San Pasqual High School
- Fred Georggin, school counselor, San Pasqual High School
- Phill Vanderschagen, AP biology teacher, San Pasqual High School
- Jack Schnel, licensed psychologist; conducted educational evaluation at District's request, Escondido Union High School District (contracted)
- Mitchel Perlman, licensed clinical psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Julie Ryan, independent vision assessor, Private
- Megan Segal, private tutor (AP biology, anatomy/physiology), Private
- Angie Nellos, private tutor (geometry, algebra, precalculus), Private
- Tim Steigerwald, private tutor (algebra 2), Private
- Janet Davis, private tutor (chemistry), Private
- Paul Dickstein, private tutor (precalculus, algebra 2, AP biology), Private
- Paul Barrows, private tutor (language arts, algebra 2/trigonometry), Private
- Jackie Gang, independent counseling provider (withdrawn claim), Private
- K. Cing, author of teacher report cited in exhibits (apparently English teacher), San Pasqual High School
- Children's Health Council, diagnostic team (1997-1998 assessments), Private agency
- Lindamood-Bell, private reading/phonemic awareness provider, Private agency
- Braille Institute, provider of large-print and taped textbooks, Private agency
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Escondido, California on January 9 and 10, 2001, February 20, 21, 27, and 28, 2001, May 22 and 23, 2001, October 2 and 3, 2001, February 7 and 8, 2002, March 19 and 20, 2002, April 25 and 26, 2002, May 30 and 31, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Leejanice Toback. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER. Petitioner STUDENT was also present on various days of the hearing. Respondent Escondido Union High School District (hereafter District or EUHSD) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski of the Filarsky & Watt LLP law firm. Also present on behalf of the Respondent was Sue Davis, director of special education for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Sallie Hunt, former special programs coordinator for the District; Mitchel Perlman, a licensed clinical psychologist; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Richard Reeves, resource specialist teacher at San Pasqual High School in the District, Sue Davis; Megan Segal, STUDENT’s advanced placement biology and anatomy/physiology tutor; Angie Nellos, STUDENT’s geometry, algebra, and precalculus tutor; Tim Steigerwald, STUDENT’s algebra 2 tutor; William McAllister, STUDENT’s math teacher at San Pasqual High School; Janet Davis, STUDENT’s chemistry tutor; Sheryl Eskola, resource specialist teacher at San Pasqual High School; Paul Dickstein, STUDENT’s precalculus, algebra 2, and advanced placement biology tutor; and STUDENT.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Sheryl Eskola, Richard Reeves, Larry Carter, STUDENT’s chemistry teacher at San Pasqual High School; Thomas Walsh, STUDENT’s advanced placement U.S. History teacher at San Pasqual High School; Jack Schnel, licensed psychologist; Fred Georggin, STUDENT’s counselor at San Pasqual High School; Phill Vanderschagen, STUDENT’s advanced placement biology teacher at San Pasqual High School; and William McAllister.
ISSUES
1. Did the Escondido Union High School District fulfill its obligations under California Education Code Section 56325(a) to provide STUDENT with a thirty-day interim placement upon his transfer into the District?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the time frame after the thirty-day interim period through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year, and from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year through January 9, 2001?
3. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for independent tutorial services furnished to STUDENT from September 1999 to January 9, 2001?
4. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for assistive technology purchased for STUDENT’s use between February 2000 and January 9, 2001?
5. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments provided STUDENT by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 9, 2001, including transportation to the assessments?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nineteen-year-old high school student who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability. Testing results from previous assessments had revealed deficits in STUDENT’s visual/sensory motor integration and attention problems resulting in a severe discrepancy between his superior verbal ability and his academic achievement in written expression, reading, and math. STUDENT transferred to the Escondido Union High School District (District or the EUHSD) in late August 1999, and began attending San Pasqual High School (San Pasqual) on September 1, 1999. STUDENT was previously enrolled in numerous other school districts, the most recent prior district being the Capistrano Unified School District (Capistrano), where he received special education services as a student with a specific learning disability. According to the last signed and agreed-upon Capistrano individualized educational program (IEP) dated September 23, 1998, and by testimony of STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, STUDENT received assistance through the resource specialist program one period each day beginning in September 1998 while enrolled in that district. The Capistrano IEP also indicated that STUDENT demonstrated a deficit in visual motor coordination that resulted in a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement, thus requiring specially designed instruction in the areas of written language and reading.
During the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT had been a student at Gunn High School in the Palo Alto Unified School District (Palo Alto). In September 1998, STUDENT then enrolled in the Capistrano Unified School District, and remained in that district for the 1998-1999 school year until he transferred to the EUHSD in the fall of 1999. The Hearing Officer notes that there was confusing testimony regarding which IEP was in effect while STUDENT attended school in Capistrano. However, the only evidence of a signed and agreed-upon IEP from Capistrano was an administrative placement IEP dated September 23, 1998. (Resp.’s Exh. 30; Testimony of MOTHER.)
Upon his entrance into the EUHSD, STUDENT was immediately placed in the eleventh grade regular education program at San Pasqual, with assistance of one period per day through the resource specialist program (RSP). Supports and modifications to his educational program also were provided based on his last agreed-upon Capistrano IEP. STUDENT’s class schedule during his first semester at San Pasqual included advanced placement U.S. History, Algebra 2/Trigonometry A, Vocal Ensemble A, Chemistry A, English 10A, and RSP support.
On October 25, 1999, an initial IEP meeting was held for the purpose of developing a new IEP for STUDENT. Although the IEP was not completed at the October 25, 1999 IEP meeting, the IEP document indicated that STUDENT’s primary disability category was specific learning disability and the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in the resource specialist program. During that meeting, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Richard Reeves, also recommended that STUDENT enroll in an additional period of RSP support and either drop one of his core classes to lessen his workload or drop one of his elective classes. At that meeting, STUDENT’s math teacher, Mr. McAllister, also recommended that STUDENT see him for individual tutoring before school, during lunch, or after school. The IEP meeting notes also indicated that STUDENT required use of an Alpha Smart Pro for taking notes and that he would benefit from having a peer note taker in class. No goals or objectives were developed during the October 1999 IEP meeting.
After the October 25, 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT and his mother, MOTHER, met with the District’s former special programs coordinator, Sallie Hunt. During that meeting, an assessment plan was drafted, requesting consent that STUDENT be tested for academic achievement and specifically in the areas of English, reading, and math. Additional classroom observations were also proposed. MOTHER did not sign the plan, but took it home with her to review. MOTHER later indicated that she did not want STUDENT assessed by District personnel, but was in favor of using criterion-referenced testing. Ms. Hunt told MOTHER that she did not agree with MOTHER’s request to use individuals outside the District personnel to conduct the assessment, because Ms. Hunt wanted to get a good idea of what skills STUDENT possessed within the context of the classroom so as to determine whether he was prepared to do the work required of him. (Testimony of S. Hunt.) According to Ms. Hunt, extensive formal testing was not necessary because STUDENT had already been tested a great deal. However, the District wanted to get a better idea of his present levels of functioning. Thus, the purpose of the October 1999 assessment plan was to see what, if anything, STUDENT needed regarding language arts support and to determine his algebra skills, because there was some question as to whether he possessed the requisite skills for the Algebra 2 class.
The District later cancelled a previously scheduled November 10, 1999 IEP meeting, reasoning that it needed to complete some assessment before staff could write meaningful goals for STUDENT and that MOTHER had yet not signed the evaluation plan. The District indicated to MOTHER that it would continue to serve STUDENT in its resource program until it heard back from her regarding the evaluation plan.
In November 1999, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Richard Reeves, forwarded questionnaires to each of STUDENT’s teachers, requesting that they provide information regarding STUDENT’s academic skills and progress in their respective classes so as to assist the IEP team in writing educational goals. During November 1999, Mr. Reeves also notified MOTHER that equipment and materials from the Braille Institute, including large print textbooks, textbooks on tape, and a tape player, were available for STUDENT to pick up and take home for his use. These items had been ordered to help address STUDENT’s visual/sensory motor deficits, which caused him to read and complete his work at a slower pace than the average student.
A second IEP meeting was held on December 2, 1999, at which time the District made a permanent offer to continue STUDENT’s placement in RSP for fifteen percent of his school day, and proposed two draft goals and related objectives designed to address his needs in written expression, study habits, and self reliant behavior. During that IEP meeting, STUDENT’s Algebra 2 and Chemistry teachers indicated that STUDENT was failing each of their respective classes, primarily because various test and assignments had not been completed, and therefore, not scored. STUDENT also had failed to turn in all of his work from his English class. Additionally, Mr. Reeves again indicated that it would be helpful if STUDENT took fewer rigorous academic classes simultaneously, since he had five semesters and two summer school sessions during which he could take his required classes. During the December 1999 IEP meeting, MOTHER requested that the District’s written proficiency test be administered to STUDENT with accommodations, as a means of establishing a baseline for future instruction. Neither party presented evidence as to whether the District’s written proficiency test was actually administered to STUDENT.
MOTHER never agreed to the District’s recommended program and services offered in the December 2, 1999 IEP. However, STUDENT continued receiving assistance in the RSP program one period each day, and additional supports and modifications to his educational program for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year.
Sometime in December 1999, after the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother hired licensed clinical psychologist Mitchel Perlman to assess STUDENT’s cognitive needs, to assess his present levels of educational achievement and his adaptive and social-emotional functioning, and to determine whether his then-current academic program had been successful in addressing those needs. As part of his assessment, Mr. Perlman later observed STUDENT in his Chemistry class in May 2000. It was not clear from the record when, or if, the results of his assessment were presented to the IEP team for its review and consideration.
On January 31, 2000, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. Although this case was set for a hearing to be held February 24 and 25, 2000, both parties agreed in February 2000 to take this matter off the hearing calendar.
In September 2000, MOTHER obtained an independent vision assessment for STUDENT. Julie Ryan conducted a visual efficiency and sensorimotor evaluation and a developmental visual perceptual processing evaluation of STUDENT in order to determine if he would benefit from vision therapy. By report dated September 5, 2000, Ms. Ryan concluded that STUDENT needed an individualized program of optometric visual therapy to provide STUDENT with the opportunity to develop the necessary visual abilities for academic achievement. (Pet.’s Exh. 276.)
During the first semester of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT enrolled in Physiology, Pre-calculus, Advanced Placement (AP) Biology, two periods of RSP support and re-enrolled in Algebra 2/Trigonometry A. (Pet.’s Exh 277.) STUDENT also continued to receive the same supports that he had been receiving since he enrolled in the District.
On October 16, 2000, another evaluation plan was prepared by the District and this time approved by MOTHER to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement, psycho-motor development/perceptual functioning, language/speech communication development, cognitive functioning, social/emotional adaptive behavior, occupational therapy, visual perceptual processing, and general health. At the District’s request, Jack Schnel conducted an educational evaluation of STUDENT in October 2000, and a copy of his report was forwarded by the District to MOTHER on December 7, 2000.
The parties met in mediation in October 2000, but the matter was not finally resolved and neither party requested that the matter be placed back on calendar until Petitioner did so in December 2000. The first set of hearing dates in this matter occurred in January 2001, and reconvened in February and May 2001, until the parties again agreed to go off calendar in June 2001 to return to mediation. The matter was not placed back on the Hearing Office’s calendar by either party until Petitioner did so again in September 2001. Reconvened hearing dates were held again in October 2001, and after numerous requests for, and agreements to, continuances by both parties, the hearing reconvened in February, March, April, and May, 2002, after which time the matter concluded.
Through January 9, 2001, the District had not held another IEP meeting after the last IEP meeting of December 2, 1999.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District refused to provide appropriate services or a program that met his needs or rendered him educational benefit. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that since he is a student with academic abilities in the superior range of intelligence, he is entitled to special education supports and services that allow him to enroll in and be successful in courses at his intelligence quotient (IQ) level. Therefore, Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide him with appropriate independent tutorial services in courses at his level. Petitioner also alleges that the District failed to provide him with the following: appropriate assistive technology, namely, a laptop computer instead of the Alpha SmartPro, for writing during his classes; preferential seating; appropriate supplemental textbooks; and extended school year services.
Lastly, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to draft and implement appropriate goals or objectives from September 1999 to January 9, 2001, and failed to hold an IEP meeting in the year 2000. Petitioner argues that because the District failed to provide him with a FAPE from September 1999 to January 9, 2001, his parent is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tutorial services, independent assessments, transportation to assessments, and assistive technology.
The District contends that upon Petitioner’s enrollment in the District, it implemented his existing individualized education program (IEP) and then offered new IEPs in October and December 1999, which it believes included an offer of appropriate placement and services. The District argues that it is not required to provide Petitioner with a “cadillac” education, but, rather, it need only provide an education that meets Petitioner’s needs and allows him to access the curriculum and make educational progress. According to the District, obtaining outside services to maximize a student’s potential is not the District’s obligation.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the Escondido Union High School District fulfill its obligations under California Education Code Section 56325(a) to provide STUDENT with a thirty-day interim placement upon his transfer into the District?
When STUDENT was enrolled at San Pasqual High School in the District on September 1, 1999, the District was required to immediately provide STUDENT with an interim placement. California Education Code section 56325(a) states as follows:
Whenever a pupil transfers into a school district . . . the administrator of a local program under this part shall ensure that the pupil is immediately provided an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days. The interim placement must be in conformity with an individualized education program, unless the parent or guardian agree otherwise. The individualized education program implemented during the interim placement may be either the pupil’s existing individualized education program, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, . . . or a new individualized education program, developed pursuant to Section 56321.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT an immediate 30-day interim placement. The statute envisions that the “administrator of the local program” shall identify and offer an appropriate thirty-day placement, immediately. Former District special programs coordinator Sallie Hunt testified that STUDENT was initially placed in special education on an administrative placement based on an interim IEP from Capistrano.
There was confusing testimony about numerous different IEPs. MOTHER initially testified that there was no agreed-upon IEP from Capistrano and that she believed the Palo Alto IEP that she signed pursuant to a confidential settlement agreement was the valid in-place IEP that should have been implemented by the District. However, the evidence establishes that there was in fact an agreed-upon IEP from Capistrano dated September 23, 1998. MOTHER later testified, in contradiction to her earlier testimony, that the Capistrano IEP dated September 23, 1998, was signed in agreement by her and implemented. (Resp.’s Exh. 30.) MOTHER also stated that although the Capistrano IEP did not state that the Palo Alto IEP was to be implemented, Capistrano nevertheless knew it was required to implement the Palo Alto IEP. However, the records from Capistrano do not indicate that Capistrano developed and implemented anything from any Palo Alto IEP. (See Resp.’s Exhs. 27, 28, 29, and 30.) Finally, Petitioner declined to introduce or submit into evidence a copy of the settlement agreement that he believed to be his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP, stating through his counsel that the document was confidential.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the only signed and implemented IEP received by the District was the Capistrano IEP dated September 23, 1998, which was submitted into evidence at Respondent’s Exhibit 30. MOTHER had not agreed to the placement and services offered in any other Capistrano IEP. (See Resp.’s Exhs. 27, 28, and 29.) Although the evidence established that MOTHER provided the District with an unsigned Palo Alto IEP, that document was only used by the District for informational purposes to assist the IEP team in developing goals and objectives for STUDENT.
According to STUDENT’s last signed and agreed-upon Capistrano IEP, STUDENT was previously placed in one period of RSP, and his IEP called for consultation with his regular education teachers regarding his seating in class, prompting his attention, and assistance available through the resource specialist. (Resp.’s Exh. 30.) MOTHER confirmed that starting in September 1998 at Capistrano, STUDENT received one period of RSP, his teachers were consulted regarding his seating and prompting his attention, and he received assistance in the RSP room.
Escondido provided STUDENT with special education services by placing him in the resource specialist program (RSP) for one period each day. District witnesses testified that the same services indicated in the Capistrano IEP were provided to STUDENT immediately upon his enrollment at San Pasqual. (Testimonies of Sheryl Eskola and Richard Reeves.) MOTHER also informed the District IEP team members that STUDENT needed a distraction-free environment for test-taking. Mr. Reeves stated that this issue was never debated and the District provided it without question by giving STUDENT access to an office in the RSP classroom that was approximately 180 square feet in size with a door that had a window in it.
The District was only required to implement STUDENT’s last signed and implemented IEP, and the only IEP submitted into evidence meeting those specifications was the Capistrano IEP dated September 23, 1998. Therefore, because the District immediately implemented STUDENT’s IEP to the extent possible within existing resources on September 1, 1999, the District complied with the requirements of California Education Code Section 56325(a).
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the time frame after the thirty-day interim period through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year, and from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year through January 9, 2001?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parent preferred another program and even if the parent’s preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT’s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code § 56031.) The IDEA also requires that a student’s educational program be designed to provide the student access to the general curriculum, including extracurricular and nonacademic activities, and prepare the student for movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, employment, and independent living. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii) and 1401(30).)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following six requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment, (5) provided him access to the general curriculum, and (6) prepared him for post-school activities.
There are three time periods relevant to this issue, October 1, 1999, to October 25, 1999, October 25, 1999, to December 2, 1999, and December 2, 1999, to January 9, 2001. The Hearing Officer will consider each of these periods in determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE.
October 1, 1999, to October 25, 1999
Before the expiration of the thirty-day interim period, the District’s IEP team was required to review STUDENT’s interim placement and make a final program recommendation, using, if necessary, information, records, and reports from the school district from which STUDENT transferred. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(b).) STUDENT’s interim placement expired on October 1, 1999, without the District’s having convened an IEP meeting and having made the necessary IEP recommendation. The District did not hold an IEP meeting until October 25, 1999. It was therefore in violation of California Education Code Section 56325(b). Accordingly, from October 1, 1999, to October 25, 1999, the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
October 25, 1999, to December 2, 1999
The IEP document prepared for STUDENT on October 25, 1999, did not include some of the most basic contents that the IDEA and California law require to be included in a student’s IEP. A student’s IEP must be written and include, among other things, present levels of the student’s educational performance; measurable annual goals and short-term objectives; the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the student; and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether the annual goals are being achieved. The IEP must also contain the projected date for the beginning of the services and modifications, anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those servicesand modifications; and at least one year before the student reaches age eighteen, a statement that the student has been informed of his or her educational rights. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.)
Moreover, beginning at age fourteen, and updated annually, a student’s IEP must contain a statement of the transition service needs of the student. And beginning at age sixteen or younger and annually thereafter, the IEP must contain a statement of needed transition services, including whenever appropriate, a statement of interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(a), (b).)
The October 25, 1999 IEP indicates that the District did offer STUDENT placement in RSP; however, the IEP does not indicate the amount of time STUDENT would spend in the RSP classroom and the services that would be provided there. (Resp.’s Exh. 5.) An additional, somewhat illegible “special factors” page of the October 25, 1999 IEP states that STUDENT would be provided the following supplemental services: extended time on tests, calculator, and large print text books from the Braille Institute for all classes except literature, which required books on tape. (Pet.’s Exh. 233.)
The IEP dated October 25, 1999, lacks legal sufficiency in every respect noted above. But most significantly, the IEP document does not indicate STUDENT’s performance levels, nor does it include any goals and objectives designed to address any of his identified needs. (Resp.’s Exh. 5.) Notwithstanding the services that were offered by the District in the IEP dated October 25, 1999, the fact that no goals and objectives were drafted and that STUDENT’s present levels of performance were not identified in the IEP document indicates that the October 1999 IEP was not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the most basic respects, and therefore, was not reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Additionally, the offer to place STUDENT in the RSP program, without an explanation of the extent, if any, to which STUDENT would participate with nondisabled students in regular classes, and without a statement of when the services and modifications would begin and their duration, along with the failure to identify goals and objectives that would be addressed in RSP and in other classes, demonstrates that the District lacked focus and direction in developing STUDENT’s educational program. This lack of focus and direction is further evidenced by the testimonies of Sallie Hunt, Sheryl Eskola, and Richard Reeves, all of whom indicated that the October 1999 IEP was not completed because they ran out of time at the IEP meeting. Furthermore, the October 1999 IEP also failed to include the required statement regarding STUDENT’s transition service needs and a statement of any needed transition services. At the time of the October 25, 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT was already sixteen years of age, and would turn seventeen the following month. Therefore, the IEP team had a duty to determine STUDENT’s preferences and interests so that appropriate transition services could be provided based upon his needs.
Because the IEP dated October 25, 1999, was substantially deficient in that it lacked the basic required elements of an IEP and was, admittedly by District witnesses, incomplete, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to evaluate the other elements of FAPE. Based on the reasons stated above, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 25, 1999, to December 2, 1999.
December 2, 1999, to January 9, 2001.
On December 2, 1999, the IEP team reconvened to review STUDENT’s present levels of performance, review and adopt proposed goals, review STUDENT’s placement, and to determine whether STUDENT required any supplemental materials or services. (Pet.’s Exh. 250.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer now turns to the offer made by the District in the December 2, 1999 IEP to determine whether it constituted an offer of FAPE.
Petitioner contends that the District refused to provide an appropriate program and services that met his needs and rendered educational benefit. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that the offer contained in the IEP dated December 2, 1999, was inappropriate in that it did not contain his present levels of performance, and the proposed goals and objectives were too vague and general to be measurable and did not address all of his needs. Petitioner also alleges that the District failed to provide the following to assist him with the curriculum at his IQ level: supports such as a calculator, tape recorder, computer software programs, phonics instruction, dictation instruction, a note-taker, a reader, a distraction-free setting, instruction in time management, organization, planning, long-term projects and study skills, monitoring of his planning and homework, provision of a laptop computer as opposed to the Alpha SmartPro, preferential seating in the classroom, and independent tutorial support for math, English, and science. Petitioner alleges that the District failed to conduct an IEP meeting in the year 2000, and thus no goals and objectives were ever in place from September 1999 to January 9, 2001. (Pet.’s closing argument.)
The IEP dated December 2, 1999, indicates that IEP services and modifications were to begin immediately and would last for one year. Although the time period in question in this section of the Decision consists of approximately one year and one month, since the District did not conduct any other IEP meeting as of January 9, 2001, the December 2, 1999 IEP constituted the District’s continuing offer of program and services to STUDENT through January 9, 2001. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated December 2, 1999, to determine whether it constituted a FAPE for the time period between December 2, 1999, and January 9, 2001.
As discussed earlier, special education law requires that the District’s proposed program be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comport with his IEP, be provided in the least restrictive environment, provide him access to the general curriculum, and prepare him for post-school activities, such as post-secondary education, employment, and independent living. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A) and 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii).)
What are STUDENT’s unique needs?
To determine the appropriateness of the District’s offered program and services, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s needs as of December 2, 1999. At the time of the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, it was undisputed that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services based on his identified specific learning disability that was caused by his visual/sensory motor processing delays. As a result of his disability, STUDENT worked at a slower pace and required various supports and modifications in order to benefit from his education. Because there were no contemporary assessments of STUDENT when the District convened the IEP meeting on December 2, 1999, and no consent by MOTHER to conduct an assessment of STUDENT, the IEP team relied on the observations and experiences of the teachers who had been educating STUDENT during his first three months in the District, the assessment and recommendations made by the Children’s Health Council (CHC) diagnostic team, IEPs and transcripts from STUDENT’s previous school districts, and STUDENT’s educational file. (Testimony of R. Reeves.)
As indicated earlier, prior to the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, Mr. Reeves sent questionnaires to STUDENT’s teachers, requesting information on STUDENT’s performance and needs in their respective classes. (Resp.’s Exh. 38; Pet.’s Exhs. 241 & 249.) Some of those teachers testified at hearing to their observations of what STUDENT’s needs were in 1999. STUDENT’s teachers indicated that he worked hard in class, and that he was focused and stayed on task during academic class discussion. In fact, all of STUDENT’s teachers, except for STUDENT’s math teacher, testified that STUDENT possessed the requisite knowledge of the content taught in their respective classes. However, STUDENT had difficulties completing his tests and classroom assignments in a timely manner. (Testimonies of Larry Carter, Richard Reeves, William McAllister, Sheryl Eskola, and Thomas Walsh.) Because of STUDENT’s difficulty in completing necessary work, Mr. Reeves and Mr. McAllister both believed that STUDENT needed a time limit placed on the number of days he had to complete his tests, quizzes, and assignments so that he could learn responsible study habits and self-reliant behavior. Extra time, but not unlimited time would force STUDENT to complete his work. (Testimonies of Paul Dickstein, Richard Reeves.)
In math, STUDENT did not demonstrate expertise conducive to his Algebra 2 class in that he lacked the Algebra 1 skills necessary for him to be successful. (Testimonies of R. Reeves and W. McAllister.)
With respect to written expression, several of STUDENT’s teachers and at least one administrator who had reviewed his writing, indicated that the content of STUDENT’s written work was at grade level, but that the form and style of his writing was below grade level. STUDENT had difficulties in sentence structure and organization, spelling, grammar, and punctuation. By report, STUDENT’s English teacher indicated that STUDENT had very good ideas, but had trouble expressing his ideas in writing. (Testimonies of R. Reeves, Thomas Walsh, and Sallie Hunt; see also Resp.’s Exh. 38, pg. 144 and Pet.’s Exh. 241f- report of English teacher.) He, therefore, required goals and objectives designed to improve his written language skills. The supports and accommodations recommended by the CHC, not including the phonics instruction, also were necessary so that STUDENT could bypass his learning difficulties to express his ideas and his knowledge, and demonstrate his superior verbal intelligence.
Regarding reading and phonics, in any subject that required extensive reading, STUDENT always took more time to complete assignments, tests, or quizzes than was typical for other students. However, STUDENT did not display any significant problems with phonological processing, decoding, or problems with the content of any of his academic courses. (Testimony of R. Reeves, Pet.’s Exh. 241f - report of K. Cing.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT received approximately three weeks of instruction in the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) sensory-cognitive training in phonemic awareness during the summer of 1998; however, STUDENT did not complete the LMB training because he wanted to start school in Capistrano at the beginning of the 1998-1999 fall semester with his peers. (Pet.’s Exh. 230.) Additionally, as of March 1999, during the summer of 1999 and through September 1999, STUDENT received tutorial assistance and support in language arts, specifically in spelling and decoding, five hours each week by tutor Paul Barrows. (Testimony of MOTHER; see also Resp.’s Exh. 27 and Pet.’s Exh. 305.) Therefore, absent sufficient evidence to the contrary, it must be presumed that the training STUDENT previously received at LMB and through tutorial assistance by Paul Barrows was sufficient to remediate any deficits STUDENT had in the area of phonics and decoding. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers and other documentary evidence did not demonstrate that STUDENT still required phonics instruction, as suggested by the CHC and MOTHER. STUDENT did require, however, text books on tape or large print textbooks and additional time for all classroom reading assignments given his slower rate of reading.
The IEP team also relied on the 1997 and 1998 testing of STUDENT done by the Children’s Health Council and referenced CHC’s findings in the December 2, 1999 IEP. (Resp.’s Exh. 2, pg. 3; Testimony of MOTHER and S. Hunt.) CHC identified similar deficits in the areas of written expression, mathematics, reading, organization, attention, study skills, and test taking, and recommended addressing those deficits by placing STUDENT in two periods of RSP and having him take summer school courses in order to complete high school requirements and qualify for college entry. CHC also reported that STUDENT should have no independent study in any subject because he needed the structure and professional supervision of regular classes with RSP. Additionally, CHC stated that advanced placement (AP) or honors classes were not necessary or recommended for STUDENT in all subjects and that he should choose AP or honors classes carefully, to be consistent with his college and career goals as well as his learning strengths and weaknesses. CHC diagnosticians recommended goals and objectives to improve STUDENT’s skills in mathematics, reading, written language, listening/attention/comprehension, test taking, and organization/management/study skills. (Pet.’s Exh. 225/Resp.’s Exh.13.) STUDENT’s present levels of performance were not written directly into the December 2, 1999 IEP. Rather, the IEP references the reader to the CHC report for that information. (Resp.’s exh. 2, pg. 3.)
According to the 1997 CHC diagnostic report, specific modifications that STUDENT needed in academics were use of a calculator and review of strategies and techniques for solution of applied mathematics problems; books on tape, provision of additional time for reading assignments, and individualized phonic instruction to address issues of decoding accuracy; and for written language, use of a word processor for all formal writing assignments, learning to dictate using assistive technology, and use of a software program for outlining material. For lectures and note taking, the CHC assessors reported that STUDENT required an outline or list of lecture content whenever possible, and provision of a note-taker who had clear handwriting for all lectures. STUDENT needed a reader for all tests that required decoding, someone available to mark his Scantron test forms, well-organized and spaced typed tests, and unlimited time for all tests. Finally, to address his attention, concentration, and executive functioning issues, the CHC report indicated that STUDENT required placement in classes with highly structured and organized teachers, homework assignments provided in writing, preferential seating in all classes, a tape recorder for dictation, and during RSP he needed direct instruction in time management, organization, planning long-term projects and various other study skills, as needed. His planning and homework accomplishment also needed to be closely monitored in RSP. (Resp.’s Exh. 17.)
STUDENT’s mother believed that at the time of the December 1999 IEP, STUDENT needed one-to-one instruction from his teachers in English, math, and chemistry; assistance with outlining, spelling, decoding, and reading due to his slow reading rate; and support with task completion, attention, organization, and concentration. (Pet.’s Exh. 251.) According to MOTHER, STUDENT needed these supports to assist him with curriculum that was not at a remedial level, but at his IQ level, which would include AP and college preparatory courses. MOTHER believed STUDENT needed to take all AP and college preparatory courses because he intended to attend a four-year university. MOTHER testified that her conclusions regarding STUDENT’s needs were based on the CHC report and its recommendations. However, the CHC clinicians highlighted the fact that STUDENT would not be able to take every class that he enjoys and/or wants to take if he were to accomplish high school graduation and be prepared with a satisfactory grade point average (GPA) for entering the college of his choice.
According to the credible testimony of Mr. Reeves and Ms. Eskola, STUDENT required two periods of RSP daily -- one period devoted to completing assigned course work, and the second period of RSP devoted to working on goals and objectives in the areas of math, written expression, study skills, organization, and task completion. Additionally, because of his slower rate of reading and need for extended time to complete course work, STUDENT needed a class schedule that did not include more AP or college preparatory courses taken simultaneously than he could adequately handle given his identified learning strengths and weaknesses. When the CHC clinicians made recommendations regarding STUDENT’s IEP in June 1998, they believed STUDENT would require significant extra help in order to make satisfactory progress in courses required for high school graduation, and therefore, also recommended two periods of RSP daily. (Pet.’s Exh. 225.)
In light of STUDENT’s teachers’ observations and similar information gleaned from the 1997 and 1998 CHC report and IEP recommendations, the Hearing Officer finds that given STUDENT’s superior verbal intelligence and previously identified deficiencies in the areas of math, reading, written language, attention, organization, task completion, and study skills, STUDENT required supports and instruction to address his difficulties in those areas. Specifically, STUDENT needed two periods of RSP support daily to complete assigned course work and to work on goals and objectives in the areas of math, written expression, study habits, and self-reliant behavior. Moreover, STUDENT needed a class schedule that did not include more AP or college preparatory classes taken simultaneously than what he could adequately handle given his identified learning strengths and weaknesses. In this instance, as established by the testimonies of Mr. Reeves and Ms. Eskola and the findings made in the CHC reports, one AP or college preparatory class each semester would have been an appropriate amount of such courses for STUDENT to take. A reduced core academic and increased RSP class schedule would have alleviated any need STUDENT may have had for one-to-one tutorial assistance in subjects, other than math, which at least one previous assessor believed encouraged excessive dependency. (Resp.’s Exh. 18, pg. 5.) Additionally, the supports recommended by the CHC with respect to mathematics, written language, reading (not including the phonics instruction), lectures and note-taking, test taking, and attention were necessary to help STUDENT meet his educational goals and objectives. (Pet.’s Exh. 224.)
The evidence did not support Petitioner’s contention that he had a unique need to be placed in all AP or college preparatory classes with supports and services to allow him to access that specific curriculum. Nor did the evidence demonstrate that STUDENT required one-to-one instruction from his teachers in English, math, and chemistry, or that he needed direct instruction in phonics. Additionally, STUDENT did not require unlimited time for all tests, but needed to have a limit on the number of days given to complete tests in the RSP classroom. The evidence clearly indicates that as of December 2, 1999, STUDENT had difficulties with the amount of work required in each class and the pace of the classes, especially the advanced placement and college preparatory courses. And although STUDENT’s 1998 individual transition plan (ITP) and the December 2, 1999 IEP indicated his desire to attend a four year college and work toward a career in physical therapy or law, both the CHC clinicians and the District correctly concluded that priorities must be set and choices made regarding STUDENT’s class selection. (Resp.’s Exh. 2, pg. 3.) Moreover, according to Ms. Eskola, STUDENT had taken many courses that he did not need in order to graduate from high school.
Was the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated December 2, 1999, designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
In analyzing the District’s offer made in the December 2, 1999 IEP, the Hearing Officer first turns her attention to STUDENT’s present levels of performance. The IEP does not specifically outline STUDENT’s performance levels at that time. Instead, page 3 of the December 1999 IEP document references a May 1998 report, as well as the minutes of that IEP meeting for identification of STUDENT’s present levels of performance in academic/functional skills. A copy of the May 1998 report is not attached to the IEP document; however, witness testimony indicated that the report referred to was one drafted by the Children’s Health Council (CHC). (Testimony of MOTHER.) The CHC report identifies STUDENT’s performance levels in 1997 and 1998, and the IEP notes reflect STUDENT’s teachers’ observations of his performance as of December 1999. However, as will be discussed in detail below, because the District failed to adequately identify and document STUDENT’s present levels of performance, the goals and objectives that were developed pursuant to that information were not appropriately designed to meet his needs.
The Hearing Officer next addresses the appropriateness of the December 2, 1999 IEP’s goals and objectives. With respect to math, the IEP dated December 2, 1999, failed to include any goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s difficulties in math calculations and applications. STUDENT’s math teacher, Mr. McAllister, testified that during the fall 1999 semester, STUDENT was having problems in his Algebra 2 class, and during the December 1999 IEP meeting, the District members of the IEP team discussed how STUDENT was failing Algebra 2 and recommended that he take advantage of either the afternoon tutorials with various math teachers and tutoring available during lunch with Mr. McAllister. (Testimony of R. Reeves; Pet.’s Exh. 251, pg. 6.) In addition, the 1997 CHC diagnostic team report indicated that STUDENT needed encouragement in the regular use of a calculator, and a review of strategies and techniques for solution of applied mathematics problems. He also needed verbal reinforcement of visual presentations such as charts and diagrams. Having recognized STUDENT’s past and present difficulties in math, the IEP team should have drafted goals and objectives to address his identified deficits in that area.
As to his goal and objectives in written expression, the IEP dated December 2, 1999, included the following annual goal:
Given appropriate technology, STUDENT will produce grade level reports and essays.
The two objectives related to the written expression goal were as follows:
STUDENT will proofread all of his written work.
After proofreading STUDENT will rewrite any assignments [requiring] revision(s). STUDENT will use correct mechanics and descriptive language in his written assignments. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.)
The written expression goal and objectives were inappropriate in that they did not indicate the manner in which the objectives would be accomplished, and whether any program modifications or supports would be provided to assist STUDENT in accomplishing the goal and objectives. As previously noted, the CHC recommended that STUDENT learn to dictate utilizing either a tape recorder, a voice recognition software program, or dictating directly to another person. Moreover, the IEP team knew that STUDENT had difficulty transferring his thoughts into writing, had poor writing mechanics, and had difficulty with handwriting. Therefore, given STUDENT’s needs, the IEP should have developed goals and objectives that specifically identified the recommended technology (such as the Inspiration software, word processor, and dictation devices), and indicated how that technology would be used to assist STUDENT with composing his essays, papers, and other written assignments.
The December 2, 1999 IEP also included one goal and five objectives regarding the development of responsible study habits and self-reliant behavior. The Hearing Officer finds the goal and related objectives appropriately addressed STUDENT’s more specific difficulties with task completion, organization, preparedness, and responsibility with respect to his schoolwork. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.) However, since STUDENT would be receiving assistance in the RSP room, the IEP should have specifically indicated how the RSP instructor would assist STUDENT with strategies to accomplish the goal and objectives. (Resp.’s Exh. 2, pg.2.)
The Hearing Officer now turns to the placement offered by the District. Although the December 2, 1999 IEP notes reflect Mr. Reeves’s recommendation that STUDENT be enrolled in two periods of RSP, the IEP team formally recommended that STUDENT be placed in RSP support for fifteen percent of his school day, which meant one period per day given his six class schedule. (Pet.’s Exh. 251; Resp.’s Exhs. 1-3.) The focus for STUDENT’s educational program should have been on his graduating from high school with a satisfactory GPA, and in order to do that, STUDENT needed two periods of RSP daily and a class schedule that was consistent with his college and career goals as well as his learning strengths and weaknesses. As discussed above, STUDENT did not require individual tutoring in his academic content areas. However, given STUDENT’s difficulty in completing his class tests, quizzes, and assignments in a timely manner, and his need for remediation in math and written language, the District should have made a formal offer to place STUDENT in two periods of RSP, along with an academic class schedule of not more than one AP or college preparatory course during each semester. This placement and class schedule were necessary to satisfy the IDEA requirements that STUDENT’s educational program be designed to provide him access to the general curriculum and prepare him for post-secondary education, employment, and independent living. The District failed to make an appropriate offer of placement and therefore, the IEP was deficient in this respect.
The Hearing Officer finally turns her attention to the supplemental supports, services, and modifications offered in the December 2, 1999 IEP. The District offered to provide STUDENT with a reader, to allow him to use alternatives to Scantrons, and to allow him extended time to complete assignments and tests. In addition, the District offered to provide STUDENT with an Alpha SmartPro, which could be used to take notes in class, and access to a word processor for his writing assignments. The IEP includes an offer to provide STUDENT with the Inspiration computer software, which the CHC had previously recommended to assist him with organizing his written material, text books on tape or large print books for Chemistry, Algebra 2, U.S. History, and most of the tapes for the Literature class. The IEP also states that Mr. Reeves was available to help STUDENT with English assignments, that STUDENT would be provided assistance in monitoring his assignments while in RSP, and that he would be allowed to complete tests and quizzes in the resource room. The offer included the provision of text books on tape and a reader, both of which could have addressed any issue regarding decoding accuracy. (Resp.’s Exh. 17, pg. 25.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the above-referenced supports, services, and modifications would have appropriately assisted STUDENT in meeting his educational goals and objectives. However, the District neglected to also offer STUDENT preferential seating to address any attentional, concentration, or executive functioning issues. It also failed to offer him access to a calculator when necessary for math work, and dictation alternatives, including voice recognition software and/or a tape recorder to assist him with deficits in written expression.
With respect to extended school year services, Petitioner contends that he was eligible for, and should have received, extended school year services during the time frame in question, but that the District never discussed or offered such services. The District argues that aside from repeating Algebra 2, Petitioner actually progressed through the curriculum at San Pasqual during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years and that Petitioner evidenced no loss of educational opportunity and therefore, required no ESY services.
Extended school year services are defined as special education and related services that are provided to a child with a disability, beyond the district’s normal school year, in accordance with the child’s IEP, at no cost to the parents of the child, and meet the standards of the special education agency. (34 C.F.R. §300.309(b).) Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations identifies a district’s obligation to offer and provide ESY services as follows:
Extended school year services shall be provided for each individual with exceptional needs who has unique needs and requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruptions of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
The Hearing Officer finds it probable that an interruption of STUDENT’s educational programming for approximately two consecutive months during the summer break would not cause regression that would render it unlikely that he would attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his handicapping condition. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had always received ESY services in other districts. However, in reviewing both parties’ evidence packets, which included STUDENT’s IEPs from other school districts, the Hearing Officer found no evidence of extended school year servicesbeing an agreed-upon service. The one instance in which it appears that the “Yes” box on the IEP document is marked for ESY services is ambiguous because the “No” box is also checked. (See second version of Pet.’s Exh. 231.) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that according to STUDENT’s IEPs from other school districts, STUDENT’s educational programs at the EUHSD and at other school districts have not included ESY services since 1995, and there was no evidence presented that STUDENT regressed during these interruptions in his educational programming during the summer breaks.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District was not required to provide STUDENT ESY services during the time period in question.
Based on the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the December 2, 1999 IEP did not offer STUDENT a FAPE because it failed to sufficiently identify STUDENT’s present levels of performance and failed to include appropriate goals and objectives in mathematics and written expression. Additionally, although the Hearing Officer found the proposed goal and objectives regarding study habits and self-reliant behavior to be substantively appropriate, the IEP failed to indicate how the RSP instructor would assist STUDENT with strategies to accomplish the goal and objectives. The District also failed to offer an appropriate placement and class schedule that would have met his academic and transition service needs, and provided him access to the general curriculum. And finally, the December 2, 1999 IEP did not include an offer of preferential seating, and access to the appropriate assistive technology, namely, a calculator, tape recorder, and voice recognition computer software. The IEP was appropriate, however, in its determination that STUDENT did not require extended school year services for the 1999-2000 extended school year. In light of the Hearing Officer’s findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE from December 2, 1999, to January 9, 2001, excluding the ESY.
*** In sum, it has been found above that the District has failed since October 1, 1999, to develop an offer of FAPE. This does not include the 1999-2000 extended school year. On September 1, 1999, the District offered STUDENT an appropriate interim placement, which expired on October 1, 1999. As discussed in detail above, the District was dilatory in devising an initial IEP for STUDENT, and when it did develop IEPs on October 25, 1999, and December 2, 1999, they were deficient in several respects and thus were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, from October 1, 1999, to January 9, 2001 (excluding the 1999-2000 ESY), the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE.
3. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for independent tutorial services furnished to STUDENT from September 1999 to January 9, 2001?
Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services they have procured for their child when a school district failed to provide an appropriate education, and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 370 (1985); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c).) Although the parents’ services do not have to meet a standard as high as a school district must meet, the parents’ services must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a service that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).)
Given the Hearing Officer’s decision above that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 1, 1999, to January 9, 2001, not including the 1999-2000 ESY, the Hearing Officer considers whether Petitioner’s parent is entitled to reimbursement for independent tutorial services.
Petitioner argues that his parent is entitled to reimbursement for tutorial services that were provided at his parent’s expense because the District refused to provide him with the one-on-one tutorial assistance in his academic subjects. According to the testimony of psychologist Mitchel Perlman, STUDENT could not make progress in a class of thirty students without one-on-one tutoring, and that even in a small classroom of fifteen students STUDENT would require one-on-one assistance in order to be successful. (Pet.’s Exh. 264.) MOTHER testified that the format of the independent tutorial services she obtained for STUDENT was based on recommendations made by both the CHC and Mr. Perlman.
The District argues that it provided sufficient services and that STUDENT did not require one-on-one tutoring by his instructors and that, additionally, his mother is not entitled to reimbursement for several reasons.
The District alleges that MOTHER refused to consent to an assessment of STUDENT, was uncooperative in working with the District to formulate an appropriate IEP, and was unrelenting in her desire to place STUDENT in several AP and college preparatory courses simultaneously. The District nevertheless was legally obligated to make a formal written offer of placement and services to the parent, and if that offer was not accepted within a reasonable amount of time, the District should have proceeded to hearing. (Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526; (Cal. Educ. Code § 56501.) Moreover, if the District believed that it did not have sufficient information to make an appropriate offer, the District had the right to file for a due process hearing requesting that it be allowed to assess STUDENT. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a)(3).) Mr. Reeves and Ms. Eskola testified that the goals and objectives proposed during the December 2, 1999 meeting were only meant to be a starting point to begin discussions with MOTHER about STUDENT’s educational program. However, this “starting point” lasted for approximately one year and one month because the District continued to allow this matter to stay off calendar without bringing it to hearing. In fact, each time that this case was taken off calendar by agreement of the parties, it was the Petitioner who sought to place it back on the Hearing Office’s calendar, not the District. Although the parent’s behavior could be described as uncooperative at times, it did not rise to the level to bar reimbursement.
According to witness testimony and documentary evidence, STUDENT received various sessions of independent, one-on-one tutorial assistance from September 1999, to January 9, 2001, in AP Biology, Anatomy/Physiology, Chemistry, Algebra 2, and Pre-Calculus. (Pet.’s Exhs. 300-303, 305-306.) STUDENT also received some tutorial support in Geometry during the summer of 2000; however, since that was a time frame which the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not require extended school year services, the Hearing Officer will not consider reimbursement for tutorial services provided during that period. (Testimony of Angie Nellos; Pet.’s Exh. 302.) In addition, STUDENT received tutorial assistance from Paul Barrows in Algebra 2/Trigonometry from September 4, 1999, to September 29, 1999. Since the Hearing Officer found above that the District met the requirements of California Education Code Section 56325(a) for the time period of September 1, 1999, to October 1, 1999, Petitioner is also not entitled to reimbursement for independent services provided during that time frame. (Pet.’s Exh. 305.) Further, the Hearing Officer notes that the tutorial assistance that STUDENT received in Chemistry, AP Biology, and Physiology covered content areas in which the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not require one-on-one tutoring from his teachers as one of his unique needs. However, since the tutorial assistance that MOTHER obtained for STUDENT was rendered during a time period that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will still consider whether that assistance addressed any of STUDENT’s unique needs and provided him educational benefit.
The Hearing Officer first turns her attention to the tutorial assistance that STUDENT received in his science classes. In AP Biology and Anatomy/Physiology, Megan Segal testified that she assisted STUDENT by reviewing with him his study guides and worksheets, using reciprocal reading to cover topic areas, and using spelling tests to help STUDENT learn key science terms. (Pet.’s Exh. 301.) According to Ms. Segal, she and STUDENT usually stayed ahead of the class schedule. The evidence established, however, that in June 1998, CHC diagnosticians specifically recommended omitting from STUDENT’s IEP the practice of mastering science vocabulary lists since that would be achieved with a spell checker, which the District provided STUDENT access to on the computer in the RSP room. (Resp.’s Exh. 13, pg. 3.) Ms. Segal also testified that STUDENT prepared his own notes for his biology classes, which she regularly reviewed, and that his notes were thorough and helped him to work through the class materials. STUDENT also had a large print text book that they regularly used during their tutoring sessions.
In chemistry, Janet Davis testified that she tutored STUDENT from January 2000 until the second or third week in June 2000. (Pet.’s Exh. 302.) Ms. Davis’s tutorial assistance consisted of assisting STUDENT with organization, diagrams, and vocabulary. The documentary evidence demonstrated, however, that during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in chemistry B from January 2000 to June 2000, and that his grade dropped from a B- at the beginning of the semester to a C. (Pet.’s Exh. 294.)
During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in Chemistry A during the fall and Chemistry B during the spring semester. During that time STUDENT was informed of, and had access to, after-school chemistry assistance provided by San Pasqual tutors, and was provided with a class note-taker, written class hand-outs, and a large-print text book. (Testimonies of R. Reeves, S. Eskola, and L. Carter; Pet.’s Exh. 294.) Additionally, the District provided STUDENT other supports and modifications for his various science classes, including the provision of the Alpha SmartPro for his own note taking, enlargement of exams, filling in test Scantron forms for him, extended time to take tests and complete assignments, preferential seating when requested, and direct assistance and a distraction-free setting in the RSP room to complete any course work on which he needed extended time. (Testimonies of R. Reeves, S. Eskola, Megan Segal.)
Although the science tutoring that MOTHER obtained for STUDENT may have provided him some educational benefit, Petitioner is not necessarily entitled to reimbursement. The subject areas were not specific areas of need for STUDENT. There must be some nexus between the services for which a student is seeking reimbursement and the student’s identified need. The fact that a parent obtains tutoring to enhance a student’s grades in a given subject area does not justify reimbursement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tutorial support provided to STUDENT in AP Biology, Chemistry, and Physiology.
With respect to math, the 1997 CHC diagnostic report indicated that STUDENT should be encouraged to use a calculator and should be provided with a review of strategies and techniques for solution of applied mathematics problems. (Resp.’s Exh. 17, pgs. 24-25.) Tim Steigerwald and Angie Nellos both testified regarding their provision of tutorial assistance in algebra and precalculus to STUDENT. As stated earlier, the Hearing Officer will not consider for reimbursement the services provided by Ms. Nellos during the summer of 2000, as the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not require ESY services. However, Ms. Nellos testified that she also tutored STUDENT in algebra and precalculus during the fall of 2000, from August 28, 2000, to October 23, 2000. (Pet.’s Exh. 302.) Ms. Nellos stated that she also tutored STUDENT in November and December 2000, but that her tutorial notes are not reflected in Petitioner’s exhibit 302. Tim Steigerwald also tutored STUDENT in algebra. His tutoring assistance began in December 1999, and continued through May 2000. (Testimony of T. Steigerwald; Pet.’s Exh. 300.)
Both tutors indicated that they assisted STUDENT with learning the course content by giving STUDENT practice questions and exams, reviewing exam material before the actual test dates, repeating to him math concepts, helping him sequence problems properly, teaching him the proper use of graph paper, and teaching him to rely on the notes presented in class. STUDENT did not pass the Algebra 2/Trigonometry A class when he took it during the fall of 1999, and he received a D in Algebra 2/Trigonometry B during the spring 2000 semester. (Pet.’s Exh. 294.) However, when STUDENT repeated Algebra 2/Trigonometry A in the fall 2000, he received a grade of A-. Additionally, when STUDENT took Pre-Calculus in the fall 2000, his grade rose from a C+ to a B-.
The Hearing Officer finds that the tutoring services in algebra and precalculus that were provided to STUDENT during the regular school year between December 1999 and January 9, 2001, adequately addressed STUDENT’s unique needs in math calculations and applications and consequently provided him some educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s parent is entitled to reimbursement for the tutorial services in mathematics provided by Ms. Nellos and Mr. Steigerwald, except for those services provided during the extended school year.
4. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for assistive technology purchased for STUDENT’s use between February 2000 and January 9, 2001?
MOTHER testified that she purchased a laptop computer for STUDENT to use when taking the AP History exam. According to MOTHER, STUDENT used the laptop computer at school to take notes because the Alpha SmartPro (SmartPro) provided by the District was not appropriate to meet his needs. The screen was too small and did not give the user a full view of the document. Additionally, MOTHER testified that ninety percent of the time the information could not be downloaded from the SmartPro to the regular desktop computer. MOTHER also testified that the SmartPro does not work for a student who has problems with grammar and punctuation and, therefore, was not an appropriate tool for STUDENT with respect to language arts and mathematics. Because it would not format an outline and retrieve or display math formulas, the machine frustrated STUDENT. (Testimony of MOTHER.) According to MOTHER, the CHC report states that STUDENT requires a laptop computer for class. In reviewing both the CHC diagnostic report and its IEP recommendations, the Hearing Officer found no indication that STUDENT required a laptop computer to use in class. (Pet.’s Exhs. 224 & 225.) Rather, the CHC diagnostic report makes reference to STUDENT’s being provided an outline or list of lecture content whenever possible and a note-taker who has clear handwriting. The report also states that in proofreading his written work, STUDENT needs a screen reader for editing content. (Pet.’s Exh. 224, pg. 26.)
MOTHER later testified that she purchased the laptop computer for STUDENT because he did not have the Inspiration software available to him, and because Mr. Perlman believed STUDENT needed one to prepare his written documents. However, Mr. Perlman’s report concurs with the CHC’s assistive technology recommendation, which as noted above, did not recommend STUDENT’s use of a laptop computer in class. In addition, Mr. Perlman testified that the SmartPro was actually a much better device than a laptop for a student to use in class.
STUDENT testified generally that the 486 word processor provided by the District was not as advanced as he would have liked, but it was nevertheless functional, except for the occasions when it would not distinguish different homonyms. According to STUDENT, in mid-November 1999, the Inspiration software was loaded onto one of the two computers in the RSP classroom; however, after Christmas break, students were informed that they could no longer use that particular computer.
According to District witnesses, the initial problems experienced with the SmartPro were resolved and the device could have been used to download information into the computer, which STUDENT knew how to do. STUDENT never indicated that he had problems with the device. (Testimonies of R. Reeves and S. Eskola.) The SmartPro was provided to address STUDENT’s poor handwriting and to assist him with taking notes in class. The SmartPro keyboard replicates a computer keyboard and has memory that can hold notes typed into it. The screen is approximately one inch high and six inches long and the user can see about one line of typed text at a time. The device operates with a Windows program and is compatible with the District’s computer. (Testimony of S. Hunt.)
The District also provided STUDENT with access to a word processor/computer to complete his writing assignments that had a spell and grammar check program and the Inspiration software loaded onto it for STUDENT’s use. According to both Ms. Eskola and Mr. Reeves, the Inspiration software was obtained for STUDENT and was loaded onto the computer in the Resource room no later than one month after it was offered in the December 2, 1999 IEP. STUDENT was shown where the Inspiration software was on the computer, but no specific training was provided. Ms. Eskola testified that STUDENT had no impediments to using the computer to produce his written documents. STUDENT knew how to use the spell check and grammar check devices, and he had already become efficient in the use of the Inspiration software, surpassing Mr. Reeves and Ms. Eskola’s knowledge in that regard. Ms. Eskola confirmed STUDENT’s testimony, however, that the computer did not always pick up different homonyms.
The District did not provide, however, a functional tape recorder and the voice recognition software for STUDENT’s use in dictation that was recommended by the CHC diagnostic team. Either the voice recognition software or the tape recorder would have allowed STUDENT to dictate in order to transfer his thoughts into the computer, thus allowing him to bypass his learning difficulties and poor handwriting so that he could express his ideas and his knowledge and demonstrate his superior verbal abilities. The tape recorder that it actually did provide was not functional, according to MOTHER, because the recorded information was inaudible.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District made available to STUDENT the appropriate screen reader -- the Alpha SmartPro -- to use in taking notes in class, and the appropriate computer to use for preparing and editing his written documents. Although the 486 computer may have been less advanced than STUDENT would have preferred, it nevertheless had the word processing functions necessary to allow STUDENT to use the spell and grammar check programs. Although STUDENT testified that he had no knowledge as to whether the 486 computer had the Inspiration software loaded onto it, both Mr. Reeves and Ms. Eskola testified that they specifically discussed the software with STUDENT and showed him where it was located on the computer. The District failed, however, to provide STUDENT with either a functional tape recorder or the voice recognition software that STUDENT needed to adequately prepare his written assignments.
Therefore, Petitioner’s parent is entitled to reimbursement for any voice recognition software or tape recorder she purchased for STUDENT’s use during the time period of October 1, 1999, through January 9, 2001. Petitioner’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the laptop computer purchased for STUDENT because the laptop was not necessary to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Rather, a screen reader, access to a computer and the necessary software were required, which the District provided. The District’s failure to provide the necessary dictation software and/or a tape recorder does not warrant the parent’s purchase of an entire laptop computer, and therefore, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for the cost of the laptop is denied.
5. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments provided for STUDENT by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 9, 2001?
Petitioner contends that his parent should be reimbursed for the independent assessments provided by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan.
When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense, unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. (Education Code § 56329(b).) For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states, in part, that a school district’s assessment must be administered by qualified personnel and utilize instruments that are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory and that must have been validated for the purpose for which they are used. Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.
Perlman assessment
Regarding Mr. Perlman’s psychodiagnostic assessment, Petitioner argues that the October 1999 assessment plan presented to MOTHER by the District did not propose to assess STUDENT in all areas related to the suspected disability and did not include tools and strategies that could provide relevant information which would directly assist persons in determining STUDENT’s current educational needs.
The District argues that it is not obligated to reimburse MOTHER for the Perlman evaluation because there was no District assessment completed with which Petitioner disagreed. The District contends that the sole purpose of the Perlman evaluation was to prepare a case for the due process hearing which Petitioner filed shortly after Mr. Perlman’s evaluation.
In the present case, an evaluation plan dated October 25, 1999, was presented to MOTHER on or about October 25, 1999. (Pet.’s Exh. 234.) MOTHER testified that she did not consent to the assessment plan, which included use of the Jamestown Reader, classroom observations, and criterion referenced and curriculum-based tests, for several other reasons. One, she believed the Jamestown Reader testing instrument did not exist. Two, she would not sign the evaluation plan without disclosure of the name of the instruments so that she could give her informed consent. And three, she did not know specifically what the classroom observation would entail. MOTHER also requested that STUDENT be assessed by individuals other than District personnel. (Testimony of Sallie Hunt.)
The Hearing Officer finds there was persuasive testimony in contradiction to MOTHER’s contentions regarding the inadequacies of the October 1999 evaluation plan. Ms. Eskola testified that the Jamestown Reader is a reading series that measures one’s reading comprehension and reading rate. Ms. Eskola stated that she has the test set, which is commonly used on high school students and she has used it for approximately four to five years. Regarding the curriculum-based test, Ms. Hunt testified that the end-of-the-year Algebra 1 test would have been administered to STUDENT, since he was doing poorly in Algebra 2. Additionally, the classroom observations would have consisted of STUDENT’s teachers’ input regarding his performance in their respective classes, a very common and useful form of alternative assessment that provides information regarding a student’s current functioning levels and ability to do course work in a particular subject area.
California Education Code §56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. In this case, where there was no expressed disagreement with the identification of STUDENT’s disability, and an abundance of information from formal testing already completed upon which the IEP team could rely to develop an appropriate IEP, an evaluation in all areas related to the suspected disability was not warranted.
While there was some question regarding whether all of the tests and procedures described on the assessment plan would be appropriate for STUDENT’s assessment, the testimony demonstrated that those which would probably be used, the Jamestown Reader, criterion referenced tests in English and reading, curriculum based tests in algebra, and classroom observations by the English, algebra, and RSP teachers, were validated and appropriate for the assessment of individuals with specific learning disabilities of STUDENT’s age and who demonstrated difficulties in language arts and math. (Testimony of S. Hunt.)
The evidence demonstrated that the District did not intend to rely on any single test or procedure to determine an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. On the contrary, several procedures would have been used, including a reasoned effort to determine STUDENT’s language arts achievement through the Jamestown Reader and criterion referenced tests, a curriculum-based algebra test to determine his then-current math abilities, and the gathering of indicative data from STUDENT’s teachers and several hours of observation of him in various classroom environments.
While a parent is entitled to have his or her child independently assessed at any time, a district is required to pay for an independent assessment only when the district has refused to conduct an assessment or the parents disagreed with the results of the district’s assessment, the parents pay for an independent assessment, and the parents then prevail in a due process hearing. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56501 and 56329.) When MOTHER retained Mr. Perlman in December 1999 to conduct a psychodiagnostic assessment of STUDENT, there had not yet been an assessment conducted by the District, so there was nothing with which the parent could disagree. Nor was there any evidence that the District had refused to conduct an assessment. Rather, the District had only refused MOTHER’s request that the assessment not be conducted by District personnel. The District, however, has the discretion to determine the testing instruments that will be used during the assessment.
Having failed to meet the statutory requirements for reimbursement, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement of the independent psychodiagnostic assessment by Mitchel Perlman is therefore denied.
Ryan Assessment
With respect to the vision assessment performed by Dr. Julie Ryan, Petitioner contends that the District refused to assess STUDENT in the area of visual processing, which was an area of disability for STUDENT. The District contends that it is not obligated to reimburse Petitioner’s parent for the vision examination because there was no evidence indicating the need for any such evaluation.
MOTHER testified that the psychologist whom she retained, Mitchel Perlman, and other individuals whom she did not identify, referred her to Julie Ryan to obtain a vision therapy assessment since Mr. Perlman believed that STUDENT’s visual processing may affect his reading fluency and speed. The vision therapy assessment was obtained before any other assessments had been conducted by the District. (Pet.’s Exh. 276.) There was no convincing evidence that the District instructed the parents to obtain a vision therapy assessment for STUDENT or that the District refused to conduct a vision therapy assessment. The District developed an evaluation plan on October 16, 2000, which included a full visual perceptual processing evaluation and vision screening. (Resp.’s Exh. 7.) MOTHER signed that evaluation plan on the same date. It was not clear when Ms. Ryan’s assessment was conducted, but documentary evidence established that her report was drafted on September 5, 2000, and thus her assessment must have occurred before that date. (Pet.’s Exh. 276.)
Therefore, Julie Ryan’s assessment was not the result of the parent’s disagreement with the District’s assessment, because the District had not yet conducted a vision assessment. Petitioner’s request, therefore, does not meet the statutory criteria for reimbursement because there was no District assessment with which the parent disagreed and there was no evidence that the District had refused or that it even needed to conduct a vision assessment. Therefore, the parent did not have the right to an independent assessment at public expense.
6. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to transportation furnished to STUDENT in the course of completing assessments by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 2001?
Based on the Hearing Officer’s decision above that Petitioner’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for either the Perlman or Ryan assessment, reimbursement for transportation costs associated with those assessments is not warranted, and is therefore denied.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of receipt of proof from Petitioner, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parent for the cost of tutorial services provided to STUDENT in algebra and precalculus from October 1, 1999, to January 9, 2001, not including services provided during the 1999-2000 extended school year.
2. Within fifteen calendar days of receipt of proof from Petitioner, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parent for the cost of voice recognition software and a tape recorder purchased between October 1, 1999, and January 9, 2001, for STUDENT’s use in school.
All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the Escondido Union High School District fulfill its obligations under California Education Code Section 56325(a) to provide STUDENT with a thirty-day interim placement upon his transfer into the District?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the time frame after the thirty-day interim period through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year, and from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year through January 9, 2001?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue, except that the District was not required to provide STUDENT extended school year services during the 1999-2000 extended school year. 3. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for independent tutorial services furnished to STUDENT from September 1999 to January 9, 2001?
Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue with respect to tutorial services provided in algebra and precalculus, not including services provided prior to October 1, 1999, and during the 1999-2000 extended school year.
The District prevailed with respect to Petitioner’s claim for reimbursement for all other tutorial services.
4. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for assistive technology purchased for STUDENT’s use between February 2000 and January 9, 2001?
Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue with respect to reimbursement for voice recognition software and a tape recorder that his mother purchased for his school use during the time period of October 1, 1999, and January 9, 2001.
The District prevailed on this issue with respect to Petitioner’s claim for reimbursement for the purchase of a laptop computer.
5. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments provided STUDENT by Mitchel Perlman and Julie Ryan between December 1999 and January 9, 2001, including transportation to the assessments?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code §56505(i).)
Dated: August 6, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis. Additionally, on the last day of hearing, Petitioner withdrew two issues – one regarding independent counseling services furnished to STUDENT by Dr. Jackie Gang, and another with respect to transportation to an assessment performed by Jack Schnel.
2. The parties stipulated to the fact of STUDENT’s start date in the District.
3. STUDENT’s enrollment in two periods of RSP was not the result of any formal offer in an agreed-upon District IEP. STUDENT added the second period of RSP on his own.
4. Although a school district is allowed to make an administrative placement of a student upon his transfer into a district without convening an IEP meeting, the record reflects that Capistrano conducted an IEP meeting and developed an IEP for STUDENT. (Resp.’s Exh. 30.)
5. According to Petitioner’s counsel, a Palo Alto IEP was agreed upon and signed by MOTHER pursuant to a confidential settlement agreement on February 21, 1999, and signed by the Palo Alto on March 8, 1999. This information contradicts MOTHER’s testimony that she signed the Palo Alto IEP in either September or October 1998.
6. The Hearing Officer found MOTHER’s testimony inconsistent with respect to the Palo Alto IEP and special education services that STUDENT previously received. MOTHER’s testimony lacked credibility for several reasons, including: one, MOTHER provided the unsigned Palo Alto IEP located at Petitioner’s Exhibit 231 to the District upon STUDENT’s enrollment in the District when, at that time, she and Petitioner’s counsel claim that an executed document already existed; two, MOTHER’s testimony frequently fluctuated between her having a clear recollection of her providing certain IEPs to the District to later stating that she in fact did not provide such documents; and three, MOTHER changed her testimony on several occasions with respect to whether she provided Respondent’s Exhibit 31 to the District upon STUDENT’s enrollment in the District in 1999. Petitioner’s attorney, Leejanice Toback, stated during the hearing that the Palo Alto IEP was attached to a confidential settlement agreement.
7. The first page of the signed and implemented September 23, 1998 Capistrano IEP lists one period of RSP as being “considered,” and the box stating that RSP was actually “recommended” was not checked. MOTHER, however, testified that STUDENT was, in fact, enrolled in one period of RSP during his thirty-day administrative placement at Capistrano from September 1998 through October 1998, and that the District should have checked the box in the “recommended” column to indicate the actual recommendation. Additionally, page 2 of the September 1998 Capistrano IEP indicates that STUDENT’s special education program would account for fifteen percent of his school day, which equates to one period per day with a six-class schedule. (See Pet.’s Exh. 294, pg. 1 - STUDENT’s 10th grade transcript.) Based on these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that Capistrano’s failure to check the “recommended” box for one period of RSP was most likely a clerical error.
8. The notes attached to the October 1999 IEP indicate Mr. McAllister’s recommendation that STUDENT see him for individual tutoring and Mr. Reeves’s suggestion that STUDENT have more RSP support time. The notes also state that STUDENT needed an Alpha SmartPro for taking notes and that he would benefit from having a peer note-taker in class. However, none of this information was included in the pages consisting of the District’s formal offer. The notes of the IEP meeting are simply a summary of what was discussed at that meeting. If the District intended to make the teachers’ recommendations and the discussions regarding what supports STUDENT needed a formal offer of the IEP team, that information should have been listed on the program pages of the IEP document so that the parent had a clear, formal statement of the program being offered by the District .
9. This special factors page was not included in Respondent’s version of the October 25, 1999 IEP. (See Resp.’s Exh. 5.)
10. The Hearing Officer notes that in Petitioner’s closing argument, he alleges for the first time that the District failed to inform him that his rights would transfer at age eighteen, and failed to meet with him to develop an IEP. (Pet.’s closing arg., pgs. 20-21.) However, because these specific procedural allegations were not raised at hearing, the Hearing Officer will not address them in this decision since the District was not provided proper notice or given an opportunity to respond.
11. MOTHER indicated that upon STUDENT’s enrollment at EUHSD, she also provided the District with copies of a psychiatric assessment, an occupational therapy assessment, and a diagnostic team report and IEP recommendations made by the Children’s Health Council. (Pet.’s Exhs. 221, 222, 223, 224, and 225.) MOTHER testified that she also provided the District with a Palo Alto psychologist’s review of STUDENT’s records, a Palo Alto transcript of student’s progress, a speech and language evaluation, and a Lindamood-Bell diagnostic evaluation report. (Pet.’s Exhs. 226, 228, 229, 230, and 231.) Although the District did not deny its receipt of the above-referenced documents from MOTHER, there was no evidence that the District members of the IEP team relied on any information other than that noted in the text above when drafting the December 2, 1999 IEP.
12. The evidence indicates that the District used the findings made in the 1997 and 1998 CHC reports to determine STUDENT’s needs in December 1999. The Hearing Officer also notes that there was direct testimony from witnesses confirming the District’s use of the CHC report.
13. With this belief in mind, MOTHER would not agree to amend STUDENT’s class schedule to reduce the number of AP or college preparatory courses STUDENT simultaneously took during a given semester.
14. STUDENT was a student in Mr. Reeves’s RSP class during the first semester of his eleventh grade, all of twelfth grade, and the second semester of his thirteenth year in high school. Mr. Reeves testified that he received his master’s degree in education, with an emphasis in special education, and is licensed as a resource specialist. Mr. Reeves has taught at San Pasqual High School since 1972, where he has provided resource remedial instruction to students in math, reading, and written expression. Ms. Eskola testified that she has a master’s degree in education and teaching credentials in multi-subject K-12 and special education (learning handicap specialist). In addition, Ms. Eskola has a resource specialist certificate, and a language credential for English as a second language. According to Ms. Eskola, she has been employed by the District for twenty-three years and prior to December 1999 she had attended numerous workshops and trainings related to specific learning disabilities, teaching reading and decoding, and attention deficit disorder. STUDENT was in her RSP class each school day from January 2000 through June 2000
15. The IDEA requires that a school district provide transition services to special education students based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(B).) The services are to be designed within an “outcome oriented process, which promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment (including supported employment), continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(A).) The IDEA also requires a student’s educational program provide for the student’s involvement in the general curriculum. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii).)
16. Petitioner’s exhibit 231 includes two different versions of a PAUSD IEP document, both unsigned. One IEP document has the “No” box clearly marked with a typewritten “X,” and another where the “No” box is marked with a typewritten “X,” and the “Yes” box is also marked, but with a handwritten “X.” The latter document has extensive handwritten notes throughout the typewritten document. None of these discrepancies were explained by Petitioner and the documents are, therefore, unreliable.
17. Mr. Perlman assessed STUDENT in December 1999, after the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, and later observed him in May 2000, during his chemistry class. Mr. Perlman testified that he has a Ph.D. in psychology and since 1988, he has been licensed in the state of California as a clinical psychologist. He is not a licensed school psychologist. According to Mr. Perlman, he is trained in identifying a student’s educational problems; however, his recommendations regarding remediation and the type of curriculum that should be used in a particular placement is not within his area of expertise. In spite of these acknowledged limitations, however, the Hearing Officer notes that Mr. Perlman made numerous such recommendations during his testimony and in his psychodiagnostic assessment report. (See Pet.’s Exh. 264, pgs. 20-21.) Because of this inconsistency, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to the numerous remediation and curriculum recommendations made by Mr. Perlman.
18. MOTHER testified that STUDENT received one on one tutorial assistance in the following subjects: Algebra 2, Pre-Calculus, Chemistry, and Biology. During the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting, MOTHER noticed the District that she intended to hire a tutor for STUDENT in English, chemistry, and algebra. (Resp.’s Exh. 3.)
19. Paul Dickstein testified that he provided tutorial support to STUDENT starting in March 2001, which is outside the time frame being considered by the Hearing Officer in this decision. Therefore, reimbursement for any tutorial assistance provided to STUDENT by Mr. Dickstein will not be considered by the Hearing Officer.
20. The records reflect that MOTHER purchased the laptop computer in February 2000. (Pet.’s Exh. 321.)
21. Although the Hearing Officer found above that the December 2, 1999 IEP failed to offer STUDENT access to a calculator, Petitioner is not requesting reimbursement for a calculator.
22. Additionally, MOTHER testified that she had contacted a professor regarding the Jamestown Reader and was unable to find out anything about the instrument. However, a copy of the email that Petitioner presented as proof of MOTHER’s search for independent information about the testing instrument revealed that she made the inquiry in January 2001, more than one year after the District presented the October 1999 assessment plan to her. (Pet.’s Exh. 235.)
