California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 5, 1998

Student v. Burbank Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1592-97 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Burbank Unified offered a FAPE through resource specialist services; parent's reimbursement claim for the Frostig Center is denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A parent filed for due process against Burbank Unified School District after moving her son from Walt Disney school to the Frostig Center, a private school, for the 1997-98 school year. He is a ten-year-old with a specific learning disability. The District's May 1997 IEP offered a regular class plus one hour a day of resource specialist help in reading and language arts. The parent argued that the goals were not tied to his present levels, that he needed speech and language therapy and counseling, and that he had not made progress. She sought reimbursement for Frostig and funding for the 1998-99 school year.

Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait found that the District offered a FAPE. The goals were keyed to the student's first-grade reading level, and resource teacher Victoria Stone used a January 1997 test as the baseline. The student did not meet California's test-score criteria for speech and language services, and he made progress without them. Teachers described a happy, well-adjusted child, and the District had no information suggesting he needed counseling. Test scores, report cards, progress on objectives, and teacher reports all showed progress in 1996-97. A similar program for 1997-98 was therefore designed to provide educational benefit. Because the offer was appropriate, reimbursement was denied. The Hearing Officer declined to set the 1998-99 program and said the IEP team must address it first. All claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "educational benefit" standard by weighing test scores, grades, progress on objectives, and teacher reports together. A private clinician's speech-language recommendation carried less weight because it was not based on California's eligibility criteria. The Hearing Officer also declined to set a future-year program before an IEP team had met.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1A. Did the District offer a FAPE for 1997-98: was the proposed program designed to meet Student's unique and individual needs (goals and objectives tied to present levels; speech and language services; counseling)?

    The goals were tied in practice to Student's first-grade level. He did not qualify for, or need, speech-language services under state criteria. Nothing showed the District had reason to provide counseling.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B. Was the District's proposed program designed to provide Student an educational benefit?

    Test scores, grades, progress on objectives, and teacher testimony showed progress in 1996-97, so the similar 1997-98 program was designed to provide educational benefit.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1C. Did the program conform to Student's IEP?

    The District had no chance to implement the 1997-98 program because the parent removed Student, and no evidence showed it was unwilling or unable to do so.

  4. Issue 2. If the District did not offer an appropriate program, should it be required to reimburse the parent for the cost of Student's education at the Frostig Center?

    Because the District offered an appropriate program, it does not have to reimburse the cost of the Frostig Center. Whether Frostig was better is not relevant.

  5. Issue 3. What is the appropriate program for Student for the 1998-99 school year?

    The Hearing Officer declined to decide the 1998-99 program and said the IEP team must first review present levels and develop an IEP. No one prevailed on this issue.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Education Code section 56363; Education Code section 56333; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, section 3030(c)(4); Education Code section 56345(a)(2); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, section 3040(c)

People named in the decision

  • Darlene Despaard, director of special education, Burbank Unified School District
  • Rick Shaw, school psychologist (prior assessment), Clark County School District, Nevada
  • Dr. Robert Rome, private psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Jennifer Grossman, regular third-grade teacher, Walt Disney school, Burbank Unified
  • Susan Bubb, special day class teacher who provided resource services, Walt Disney school, Burbank Unified
  • Victoria Stone, resource specialist (also a qualified speech pathologist), Walt Disney school, Burbank Unified
  • Lori Waldinger, advocate for parent at December 1996 IEP meeting
  • Judy Pleskus, District-contracted speech and language specialist (assessor), Burbank Unified School District (contractor)
  • Kristin Gilsenan, private speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, Private
  • Lynne Parkhurst, principal, Frostig Center
  • Ms. Paine, special education teacher, Frostig Center
  • Frostig Center, private school (unilateral placement), Pasadena

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1592-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-64337 District: Burbank Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability

Case Details This matter was heard on June 11, August 12, and September 1, 1998, in Burbank, California, before Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner, STUDENT was represented by attorneys Max Lapertosa and Michelle M, Carroll. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his PARENT.

Respondent Burbank Unified School District (District) was represented by Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of Respondent was Darlene Despaard, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties finished presentaion of their cases by the end of the first day. On that day, the Hearing Officer received a large number of exhibits and had no opportunity to review them during the day. The Hearing Officer continued the hearing to allow each side to submit written closing briefs. The Hearing Officer also stated that after he had a chance to review the documents and closing briefs, he might find it necessary to reconvene the hearing to receive additional testimony. On July 14, 1998, the Hearing Officer ordered that the hearing be continued on August 12, 1998, in order to receive testimony concerning three issues. On August 12, 1998, additional testimony was received. The District requested a further continuance to present witnesses who were not available on August 12. The Hearing Officer found good cause to continue the hearing to September 1, 1998. Additional testimony was received on that date and the matter was continued so that the parties could submit further written argument on the issue of speech and language services. The record was closed on September 10, 1998, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year?

2. If the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate program, should it be required to reimburse STUDENT'S PARENT for the cost of his education at the Frostig Center?

3. What is the appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old boy who was determined to have a learning disability while he was attending first grade in Clark County, Nevada. While in the first and second grades in Clark County School District, he received resource specialist services to address his reading and language deficits.

In the latter part of his second grade year, STUDENT'S PARENT asked that he be assessed because she felt that he was not making academic progress. The assessment by Clark County School District psychologist Rick Shaw concluded that STUDENT had made significant progress in reading.

After the assessment by Rick Shaw, the IEP team met on April 12, 1996, to review STUDENT'S IEP. STUDENT'S PARENT requested that resource specialist services be discontinued and that STUDENT receive all of his educational services in his regular classroom with consultation between the resource specialist and the regular classroom teacher.STUDENT'S regular classroom teacher expressed concerns about this approach, as did the other school representatives on the IEP team. They felt that STUDENT needed greater individual attention than could be given in a regular class.

In June 1996, STUDENT AND PARENT moved to Burbank, California. On June 27, 1996, STUDENT'S PARENT filed a request for Special Placement of Transfer-In Special Education Pupil with the Burbank Unified School District and consented to a special education assessment plan.

On September 11, 1996, the Student Study Team met to discuss STUDENT'S enrollment at the Walt Disney school. They discussed the various options available to meet STUDENT'S needs. It was agreed that STUDENT would enroll in a regular third-grade class at Walt Disney with pull out for resource services in reading. It was also agreed that an IEP meeting would be convened within 30 days to complete STUDENT'S IEP.

On October 11, 1996, the IEP team met. It reviewed STUDENT'S current level of performance based upon the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (K-TEA) Brief Form that was administered in September 1996. The test results were as follows:

Subtest Standard Score Grade Equivalent Age Equivalent

Mathematics 85 2.4 7-9

Reading 77 1.6 6-9

Spelling 68 1.2 6-0

The IEP team also reviewed the assessment done by the Clark County School District in March 1996. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for services as having a specific learning disability with "delays noted in short term memory (visual, motor, and/or auditory), sequencing and serial ordering. He performs better in the classroom setting that he does on standardized testing." The IEP team developed a goal that STUDENT "will learn to read, write, spell, and comprehend using a combination of sight words, phonetic analysis and whole language." The team developed four short term objectives in accomplishing that goal. The IEP provided for placement in a regular third grade class with daily resource specialist services in reading and language arts. It also provided that the IEP would be reviewed within 90 school days. There is no evidence that STUDENT'S PARENT agreed to the IEP. There is merely a notation that she requested to review the paper work before signing.

On October 15, 1996, STUDENT was evaluated by psychologist Dr. Robert Rome at the request of STUDENT'S PARENT. Among the tests administered by Dr. Rome was the Wide Range Achievement Test - Revision 3. The results are as follows:

Subtest Standard Score Grade Equivalent

Reading 83 2

Spelling 82 1

Arithmetic 94 2

For two months following the October 11, 1998 IEP, STUDENT continued in Ms. Grossman's regular third grade class and received resource services from Susan Bubb, who was the teacher of a special day class. STUDENT came to her class for the services and worked with other students in Ms. Bubb's class. Ms. Bubb utilized the Herman Method for Reversing Reading Failures. During this time, STUDENT'S PARENT expressed dissatisfaction with STUDENT'S progress and with the Herman Method. On December 16, 1996, the IEP team reconvened to discuss changes to STUDENT'S IEP and to review Dr. Rome's report. It was agreed that STUDENT would continue in Ms. Grossman's class but that the resource services would be provided for one hour daily by resource specialist Victoria Stone beginning on January 13, 1997. Additionally the IEP team modified STUDENT'S goals and objectives. The IEP notes that STUDENT'S PARENT would visit other possible placement alternatives within the District and that she requested a speech and language assessment as recommended by Dr. Rome at this IEP meeting, STUDENT'S PARENT was represented by advocate Lori Waldinger. STUDENT'S PARENT signed the IEP, approving all of its components.

On January 29, 1997, STUDENT was administered the K-TEA comprehensive form resulting in the following grade equivalent scores:

Subtest Grade Equivalent

Reading Decoding 1.9

Spelling 2.4

Reading Comprehension 1.8

The face sheet of this K-TEA was received into evidence as P-2. At the top of the form is handwritten "baseline for RSP." Ms. Stone testified that this test was used as the baseline for her in determining what level of material to use in teaching STUDENT.

On May 29, 1997, a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT was performed by Judy Pleskus, a speech and language specialist. She concluded that "speech and language services are not recommended at this time."

On May 27, 1997, the IEP team met to review the speech and language assessment and to make any needed modifications in STUDENT'S IEP. The IEP team concluded as follows:

Results indicate appropriate articulation skills. Language skills fall within normal limits according to state guidelines which indicate eligibility as at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or below the seventh percentile on two or more standardized tests in 1 or more areas including morphology, syntax, semantic, or pragmatics...STUDENT does not currently qualify for speech and language program according to these tests.

The IEP team decided to continue STUDENT in a regular class with resource specialist support in reading and language arts, and to continue the goals and objectives set forth in the December 16, 1996 IEP. The team agreed that STUDENT should participate in the Title I seminar program during the summer of 1997.

STUDENT'S PARENT did not agree with the present levels of performance, services needed, goals and objectives, or the placement provided in the May IEP. She stated, "I believe the IEP the school has written is inappropriate and is not reasonably calculated to allow STUDENT to receive educational benefit."

STUDENT'S PARENT had him assessed by Kristin Gilsenan, a private speech pathologist on July 2 and 15, 1997. In her report dated July 18, 1997, Ms. Gelsenan concludes that "STUDENT presents with a moderate expressive and receptive language disorder and auditory processing disorder characterized by deficits in vocabulary and ability to process and recall information, and deficits in reading." Ms. Gilsenan suggested that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy.

STUDENT was again evaluated by Dr. Rome on July 21, 1997. He again administered the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revision 3, with the following results:

Subtest Standard Score Grade Equivalent

Reading 84 2

Spelling 84 2

Arithmetic 93 3

At the beginning of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT'S PARENT placed him at the Frostig Center, a private school.

In September, 1997, STUDENT was evaluated using the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (K- TEA)- Comprehensive Form, resulting in the following scores:

Test Standard Score Grade Equivalent

Composite Reading 77 2.3

Composite Mathematics 84 3.2

Subtest Spelling 74 2.3

On December 4, 1997, STUDENT'S PARENT requested a due process hearing stating that "due to the marked decline in his reading and comprehension abilities, I had no choice but to remove STUDENT from Disney and enroll him at Frostig School, a non public school in Pasadena."

In May 1998, after a year at the Frostig School, STUDENT was again administered the K-TEA-Brief Form. His scores were as follows:

Subtest Standard Score Grade Equivalent

Reading 95 3.7

Mathematics 90 3.7

Spelling 86 3.2

LEGAL ANALYSIS

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98?

Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) with special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (A-D) & 1401 (25). A FAPE must be provided in conformity with the child's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (D).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

In order to determine whether STUDENT was offered a free appropriate program and placement for the 1997-98 school year, it is necessary to address three issues. Was the proposed program designed to meet STUDENT'S unique and individual needs? Was the proposed program designed to provide educational benefit? Did the program conform to STUDENT'S IEP?

A. Was the proposed program designed to meet STUDENT unique and individual needs?

The program that the District proposed for STUDENT for the 1997-98 year was set forth in the May 29, 1997 IEP. That IEP proposed to continue the goals and objectives developed during the December 16, 1996 IEP meeting. In order to determine STUDENT'S unique and individual needs, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT'S present level of performance in both the May 29, 1997, and the December 16, 1996 meetings. In the December IEP meeting, the team reviewed the K-TEA test results, which showed STUDENT at the 1.6 grade level in reading, 1.2 grade level in spelling, and 2.4 grade level in math. The IEP team also reviewed the assessment done by Clark County in March 1996, and Dr. Rome's assessment performed in October 1996. Based upon those reports and the observations of STUDENT'S regular third-grade teacher and resource teacher, the team determined that STUDENT qualified for special education services because of a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading, written expression, and delays in auditory processing and short-term visual memory.

During the May 29, 1997 IEP meeting, additional information concerning STUDENT'S present level of performance was received by his teachers. His resource specialist indicated that his spelling had improved greatly. He was reading in the second-to-third grade reading book "quite fluently." He was on grade level in math. His regular third grade teacher stated that he functioned well in her classroom. During the May 29 IEP meeting, the team also reviewed a speech and language assessment performed by the District and concluded that STUDENT did not currently qualify for speech and language therapy.

The IEPs of December 16, 1996, and May 29, 1997, provided for pull-out resource specialist services for one hour per day to address STUDENT'S reading and language arts. The rest of STUDENT'S educational program was to be in regular third-and-fourth grade classrooms.

The IEP of May 29 provided for the continuation of the goals and objectives that were developed during the December IEP meeting. The December IEP had two goals. The first goal was to "learn, read, write, spell and comprehend using a combination of sight words, phoentic analysis and literacy based." The short term objective under the goal provided that "STUDENT will read, write, and comprehend the meaning of phonetically regular CVC words using the consonant/vowel digraphs combinations and the commonly used phonemic patterns of English." The procedures used to evaluate progress on this objective included "skill mastery tests, progress charts, work samples and teacher evaluations/observations."

The second goal was "to improve Language Arts." These were three objectives under this goal. The first was that "STUDENT will learn to read , write, and spell phrases, sentences, and stories using the above mentioned skills with 80% accuracy on the weekly final spelling test." The third objective was that " STUDENT will complete the weekly spelling lesson of high frequency words with 75% accuracy." These objectives were to be evaluated through teacher evaluation and, in the case of this last objective, by review of work samples.

All of these objectives were expected to be achieved by "12/97 ongoing"

STUDENT'S attorneys argued that, even though STUDENT'S mother approved the December 1996 goals and objectives, they were inappropriate for STUDENT.

California Education Code Section 56345(a)(2) provide that an IEP contain "the annual goals, including short-term instructional objectives." California Code of Regulations section 3040(c) requires that the IEP show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided.

Dr. Rome testified that, while he did not have problems with the approach stated in the objectives, it was impossible to determine whether the objectives were appropriate because the grade level of the material to be mastered was not stated. Ms. Victoria Stone testified that she had written the goals and objectives in the December 1996 IEP. She further stated that she was intending to use material at the first grade level based upon the IEP teams conclusions concerning STUDENT'S present level of functioning. She testified that after she took responsibility for STUDENT'S resource program in January. She tested him to determine the proper baseline of his performance. The test indicated that STUDENT was functioning at the mid to high first-grade level. The IEP objectives were to be completed by December 1997. She testified that he developed his reading skills rapidly and, by the end of the year, was reading second-grade material with 90% comprehension and third grade material at 60% comprehension. She said that she increased the level of the material as he made progress.

Even though the specific objectives in the IEP of December 1996 were not expressly linked to STUDENT'S existing level of performance, it is logical to assume that the objectives were intended to be keyed to STUDENT'S existing first-grade level of functioning. The IEP specifically sets out the current levels of functioning based both upon the District's and Dr. Rome's assessments. The testing in January demonstrated that STUDENT had progressed since the last testing, and the test results were used to establish the baseline for determining progress. Ms. Stone testified that the materials she used for STUDENT were at the level of his functioning as determined by the IEP team and as later updated by her testing in January. While the link between STUDENT'S present level of performance and his goals and objectives intended by the IEP team carried out in STUDENT'S program were appropriate and tailored to meet his individual needs.

STUDENT'S attorneys also argued that the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT'S unique and individual needs because it did not include the provision of speech and language services.

Pursuant to section 56363, "language and speech development and remediation" is specifically included as a designated instruction and service (DIS). DIS services are required to be made available "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Eligibility criteria for special education services in the area of language and speech disorder are set out in the Education Code section 56333 and include in subsection (d):

Inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language such that the pupil's language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her peers.

The State Board of Education has adopted regulations to further clarify when a student is eligible for special education services in the areas of language and speech. Section 3030(c)(4) provides that:

The pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when he or she meets one of the following criteria:

(A) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development : morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics.

While he was in the first grade, STUDENT was determined to have had a speech and language disability and was provided speech and language services for 20-40 minutes per week.

On October 9, 1995, while STUDENT was in the second grade, the Clark County School District multidisciplinary team, including a speech pathologist, concluded that STUDENT was no longer eligible for speech and language services. The team concluded that STUDENT's speech/language patterns were within normal limits and that there was no significant discrepancy between STUDENT's intellectual ability and his level of linguistic performance. The report also concluded that STUDENT's current speech/language patterns, "although immature, are developmentally appropriate."

A speech and language assessment was performed by a District contracted speech and language specialist, Judy Pleskus, in May1997. She stated that "the results of the evaluation indicated that STUDENT exhibits no sound production errors and his Receptive and Expressive Language Skills are within average ability. His area of weakness is in expressive vocabulary, however, he scores within an acceptable range." She concluded that "speech and language services are not recommended at his time."

The IEP team met on May 29, 1997, to review the speech and language assessment. It concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for speech and language services under the state guidelines.

On July 18, 1997, STUDENT'S PARENT obtained a speech and language assessment from Kristen Gilsenan, a speech and language pathologist. She concluded that "STUDENT presents with a moderate expressive and receptive language disorder and auditory processing disorder characterized by deficits in vocabulary and ability to process and recall information, as well as deficits in reading." Ms. Gilsenan recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy. During her testimony, Ms. Gilsenan stated that she was not aware of the law or the state guidelines for determining eligibility for speech and language services. She said her recommendation was a clinical one, not based on eligibility standards provided by law.

No witness appeared to explain the Districts test results or how the decision was made that STUDENT was not eligible for speech and language services. Ms. Gilsenan was not aware of the state guidelines and was unable to render an opinion concerning STUDENT'S eligibility. A review of the test documents does not support a finding of eligibility under the state guidelines. Ms. Pleskus's report indicates that STUDENT scored from the 16th percentile to the 91st percentile on different portions of the TOLD-P test. On the Expressive one-word vocabulary test (EOWPVT), STUDENT scored at the 9th percentile. In the report by Ms. Gilsenan, STUDENT scored below the 7th percentile in one part of the sub-test. He was at the 5th percentile on the backward portion of the Auditory Number Memory subtest. Therefore, there is only one instance in which he scored below the 7th percentile, and it was only one portion of one subtest.

There was no evidence provided to indicate that a different result would have occurred if the decision had been based on the guideline that provides for using the one and one-half standard deviations below the mean standard. Dr. Rome testified that being one and one-half standard deviations below the mean would be roughly equivalent to the 7th percentile of the population.

Attorneys for the Petitioner contend that the state guidelines in section 3030(c)(4) of the California Code of Regulations are in conflict with the federal law and California statutes, and, therefore, should not be used as a basis for denying services to STUDENT.

Under California law, a person is eligible to receive speech and language services if "the pupil's language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her own peers." In this case, there is conflicting evidence as to whether STUDENT'S language performance is significantly below that of his peers. The report by Ms. Pleskus indicates that his abilities are "average" or "within an acceptable range." The IEP team of May 29, 1997, determined that STUDENT'S language skills fall within "normal limits." This evidence does not support a conclusion that STUDENT is performing significantly below his peers.

Dr. Rome has reviewed the reports of both Ms. Pleskus and Ms. Gilsenan, and previous reports from Clark County schools. While he is not a speech pathologist, he testified that he is trained and experienced in reviewing speech and language tests and reports. He testified that he believed STUDENT was performing significantly below his appropriate peers. Conversly, Ms. Gilsenan's report states that "STUDENT presents with a moderate expressive and receptive language disorder..." Her characterization of STUDENT'S disorder does not support the conclusion that he is performing significantly below his peers. It should also be noted that STUDENT'S RSP teacher, Ms. Stone was a qualified speech pathologist. She had also more actual contact with STUDENT than any of the other sources mentioned above. Although she did not administer any formal speech and language tests, she stated that she did not believe STUDENT had any speech problem. She said that if she had noticed anything unusual about STUDENT'S speech, she would have taken action to address those needs.

Education Code section 56363 includes speech and language services as a designated instructional service. Designated instructional services are to made available to students when "the instructional services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his program." As will be more fully discussed below, STUDENT did benefit educationally from his program at the Disney school during the 1996-97 school year without the provision of speech and language services. Petitioner has provided evidence that STUDENT made great progress at the Frostig Center without speech and language services.

The weight of the evidence supports the District's conclusion that STUDENT was not eligible for speech and language services under the State regulations; was not eligible for speech and language services under the state law; and did not require such services to benefit from his instructional program.

STUDENT'S attorneys argue that the program proposed for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year was inappropriate because it did not include provision for counseling to address STUDENT'S social and emotional problems.

All of STUDENT'S teachers testified that STUDENT was a happy, well-adjusted child who had friends (especially in his regular class) and who volunteered readily in both his RSP class and his regular class. They testified that he would help other students was never in any fights, and did his homework. Ms. Jennifer Grossman, STUDENT'S regular third-grade teacher, said that STUDENT was a responsible, motivated student whom she loved having in her class. Ms. Stone testified that STUDENT was often the first in the class to volunteer and was popular with the other students. He received the student-of-the-month award in both his RSP and his regular class and helped teach the other students in his class. She said that STUDENT was "one of her favorite people, not just favorite students, but favorite people." Even STUDENT, in his testimony, said that he liked Walt Disney school where he had many friends.

Dr. Rome testified that he felt that STUDENT was having emotional problems because he was failing in his studies. He based his conclusions on his review of documents, his own observation of STUDENT in his office and information given to him by STUDENT'S PARENT. He admitted that he had not talked to any of STUDENT'S teachers. In his report of October 9, 1996, he states: "there does not appear to be symptoms of an emotional or behavioral nature which would necessitate a mental health disorder diagnosis..." In his report dated August 1, 1997, Dr.Rome concludes that " STUDENT displays inappropriate emotional expression and behaviors, which appear very much related to the difficulties he has in school. Individual psychotherapy and/or counseling would seem beneficial to assist him in these areas." His report of his observations of STUDENT during the testing are not unusual and are not much different than those made in the October report. Dr. Rome supports his conclusions by pointing to the fact that STUDENT day dreams, is more interested in sports than in school, and would rather play games than study. If these are indications of the need for mental health counseling, it would appear that most boys STUDENT'S age would be in need of counseling.

The only other evidence supporting STUDENT'S need for counseling was the testimony of Lynne Parkhurst, the principal of Frostig, who said that when STUDENT started attending Frostig he was "enraged." She expressed the opinion that STUDENT'S emotional state was caused by frustration with his lack of progress in the District's program. However, Ms. Parkhurst's opinion is unsupported. It may have been equally logical that STUDENT was enraged at being taken from Walt Disney school and his many friends there.

There is no evidence indicating that the District had any knowledge that STUDENT had any emotional problems at the time of the May 29, 1997, IEP. There is no evidence that the reports by Dr. Rome or the observation of Ms. Parkhurst were made available to the District so that it might consider modifying STUDENT'S IEP. There is no evidence that anyone in the IEP meeting asked for such services or thought that counseling services were necessary. The IEP team concluded that:

[STUDENT] has made friends whom he plays with at recess. Shows pride in his school improvement. Responds to praise from teachers. Likes to help others, especially in art. In RSP, STUDENT is motivated and enthusiastic. STUDENT is an active participant inn group activities within the regular classroom.

The District had no reason to believe that counseling should have been a component of his 1997-98 program, and the Hearing Officer did not see any convincing evidence that such services should be included in STUDENT'S IEP.

The District considered STUDENT'S current levels of performance, developed goals and objectives to address his deficits, proposed continuing the resource specialist program to address those needs, and, therefore, provided STUDENT with a program that met his unique and individual needs.

B. Was the District's proposed program designed to provide STUDENT and educational benefit?

STUDENT'S attorneys contend that the program proposed for STUDENT for the 1997-98 year was not designed to provide progress because it was almost identical to the program that was in effect during the 1996-97 year. They contend that STUDENT did not make progress during the 1997-98 year, but, instead, regressed during that period.

Progress can be measured in a number of ways. Reference to standardized test scores, grades, progress on goals and objectives and teacher observation can all be used to determine progress.

STUDENT'S most serious deficits were in the areas of reading and spelling. In October 1997, shortly after the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was tested by Dr. Rome at the request of STUDENT'S PARENT. Dr. Rome also tested STUDENT in July 1997, after he had completed his year at the Walt Disney school. On each occasion, he administered the Wide Range Achievement Test- Revision 3 in the areas of reading, spelling and math. In October, STUDENT had a standard score of 83 in reading with a grade equivalent of 2. In July, he had a standard score of 84 with a grade equivalent of 2. In October, STUDENT had a standard score of 82 in spelling with a grade equivalent of 1, as compared to the July standard score of 84 with a grade equivalent of 2. STUDENT'S math standard score in October was 94 with a grade equivalent of 2, compared to a July score of 93 with a grade equivalent of 3. Dr. Rome testified that there was a margin of error of three points. Therefore, the tests indicate that STUDENT'S scores were nearly identical at the beginning of the year and at the end of the year (as compared to his age peers). Dr. Rome testified that such scores reflect that he has made a year's progress equal to that made by his peers. Dr. Rome testified that although these tests do show progress, he believed that STUDENT should have made progress in narrowing the gap between his performance and those of his age peers.

The District administered the K-TEA test to STUDENT in September 1996 and January 1997. the same test was given to STUDENT at the beginning of his 1997-98 year at Frostig. STUDENT'S scores of these two tests were as follows:

Sub-test Standard Scores Grade Equivalents Sept.96 Jan.97 Sept.97 Sept.96 Jan.97 Sept.97

Reading 85 77 1.6 1.9 2.3

Spelling 68 74 1.2 2.4 2.3

The evidence does not reflect the standard scores for the January 1997 test. The September 1996 test was the brief form, and the January 1997 and September 1997 tests used the comprehensive scores. Dr. Rome testified that, while it is difficult to make exact comparisons of the scores, they have rough equivalence for the purposes of comparison. These results reflect progress during the year in both reading and spelling. Although the standard score in reading is lower in September 97 than in September 96, the grade equivalent scores show that STUDENT advanced from the 1.6 grade level to the 2.3 grade level, a gain of seven months. In spelling, both the standard score and the grade equivalency increased. STUDENT appears to have made 11 months progress during that period. Although it does appear that STUDENT made progress in reading during the year, he lost ground in comparison to his age peers. It also shows that he made gains on his age peers in spelling.

STUDENT'S report cards for the 1996-97 year was also report progress. In each of the three grading periods, he was noted by his resource program teacher to be "making progress but still below grade average" in all of his language arts programs. He was given excellent for his work habits. He received "satisfactory," "satisfactory +," or "excellent" in all of the subject addressed by the regular classroom teacher.

As mentioned above, STUDENT had goals related to reading and language arts with short-term objectives to bring him to grade level within the year. All of his teachers testified that he was making progress toward meeting those objectives. Ms. Bubb, who provided resource services during the first few months of the 1996-97 year, testified that by December STUDENT had met the first objective contained in the October 1996 IEP. Dr. Rome and Ms. Paine, a special education teacher at the Frostig Center, testified that the first objective was lower than his ability at the time it was established. Ms. Paine said that the objective was at the primer or pre-primer level. Ms. Bubb agreed that the objective was at the primer or pre-primer level but explained that she was using the Rene Herman method, which required that all students start at the beginning of the program and work through the material. She said that STUDENT rapidly progressed through the early material, which was why he had met the objective in two months.

Ms. Stone, STUDENT'S RSP teacher, testified that in January, STUDENT had reading comprehension at the mid to high first grade level while in April, he had reading comprehension of 90% of the second- grade material and 60% of third-grade material. He had 100% success in second-grade word recognition and 60% in third-grade word recognition. He was mastering CVC (consonant/vowel/consonant), CCVC, CVCV and CVV words. Ms. Stone testified that in regard to his objective to complete the weekly spelling lesson, he started with word 41 and advanced to word 141. She said that the third-grade level would have been words 131 to 265.

In relation to all of STUDENT'S objectives, Ms. Stone said he had made significant progress, but had not yet met them completely. She noted that the IEP called for the objectives to be met in December, 1997, and that he was making good progress toward meeting those objectives within the time frame provided.

All of STUDENT'S teachers testified that based on their observations, STUDENT was making good progress and was benefiting from his educational program. Ms. Grossman, STUDENT'S regular third- grade class teacher, said that STUDENT'S writing samples and tests show that he made definite progress. Ms. Bubb, STUDENT's resource teacher during the fist part of the year, testified that STUDENT made excellent progress during the time she taught him. By the time he left her class he had been introduced to 16 consonant sounds and 4 vowel sounds.

Ms. Stone, who took over as STUDENT'S resource teacher in January 1997, testified that STUDENT learned things faster than her other students, and that he was making such good progress that she allowed him to help teach the other students. She said that her reading program had a regular and a fast cycle. She put STUDENT on the fast cycle because he was so quick. By the end of the year, he was learning from context, drawing inferences, and predicting what would happen in the reading material. By the end of the year, she said that STUDENT was reading at the end of second and beginning of third grade material. In the "comments section" of STUDENT'S report card for the second period, Ms. Stone wrote, "STUDENT'S performance in the RSP language arts has been remarkable. He has improved at a very rapid rate."

By any of the standards for determining whether a student is making progress, STUDENT made progress during his 1996-97 program. The standardized testing showed STUDENT making progress at the same rate as his age peers. His grades were uniformly good. He made significant progress on his goals and objectives, and his teachers all testified to his progress. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT'S program for the 1996-97 year was successful, and the District's program for the 1997-98 year which was patterned after the prior years program was designed to ensure that STUDENT benefited from his educational program.

C. Did the program conform to STUDENT'S IEP?

In STUDENT'S case, the District did not have an opportunity to provide STUDENT'S program for the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT'S PARENT unilaterally removed him from the District's schools and placed him at the Frostig Center. There is no evidence to support the conclusion that the District was unwilling or unable to provide the program set forth in STUDENT'S IEP. Based upon the discussion above, it is concluded that the District did offer an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 year.

2. If the District did not offer an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year, should it be required to reimburse STUDENT'S PARENT for the cost of his education at the Frostig Center?

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District offered an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. Whether the Frostig Center provided a better education for STUDENT is not relevant. The law does not require that a District provide the best possible program. Therefore, the District is not required to reimburse STUDENT'S PARENT the cost of his placement at the Frostig

Center.

3. What is the appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year?

The parties asked the Hearing Officer to rule on the issue of the appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. STUDENT'S attorneys requested that the Hearing Officer order the District to pay for his placement at the Frostig Center. The District requested the Hearing Officer to order a program similar to the one proposed by it for the 1997-98 year.

It would not be appropriate for the Hearing Officer to rule on such a question at this time. The subject of the appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year should first be addressed by the IEP team, which should review his present levels of educational performance, prepare appropriate goals and objectives, and then design a program necessary to accomplish these goals and objectives. If STUDENT'S PARENT wants the District to provide a program for STUDENT, and IEP team meeting should be scheduled to prepare an appropriate IEP. After such a meeting, if either party is dissatisfied with the IEP, that party will have the right to petition the Special Education Hearing Officer for a hearing.

ORDER

All of Petitioners claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

The District prevailed on the first two issues and no one prevailed on the third issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competant jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I)

Dated: October 5, 1998-Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer.

Footnotes