California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 30, 2004
Las Virgenes Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1603-04 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Las Virgenes Unified's June 2004 IEP moving an autistic fifth grader from a nonpublic school to a district class offered FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Las Virgenes Unified School District filed for this hearing after the parents refused to consent to the June 2, 2004 IEP, as clarified on June 16. The student was 11 years old, in fifth grade and eligible for special education under autism. He had attended the Elliott Institute, a nonpublic school, since 2001 under a series of settlement agreements. The District offered a special day class at Lupin Hills Elementary School. The offer included a six-week gradual transition, supervision of his discrete trial training and applied behavior analysis (DTT/ABA) program, aide support, speech, occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, psychologist consultations, parent training, team meetings and daily communication logs.
The Hearing Officer found that the offer was clear enough under Union v. Smith. An IEP does not need to name individual providers when it describes their qualifications and duties. The present levels of performance did not need numerical baseline data. The goals were challenging enough, and their focus on using skills in different settings was appropriate. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to the District assessors, who knew both programs, than to the Student's experts, who had not looked into the Lupin Hills class. He concluded that the risk of regression did not rule out a move. The class's nearly one-to-one adult-to-student ratio, the transition plan and the parent participation were found appropriate. Hearsay that Elliott would not accept a part-time student did not prove the plan could not be carried out. The parents must make the student available for this IEP if they want a District-funded program.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith: the written offer was read together with what was discussed at the IEP meeting, and an IEP did not have to name providers. It also shows expert opinions on a move between placements losing weight when the experts did not know the receiving program.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue A. Whether the District failed to make a sufficiently clear written offer under Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith because the IEP did not identify who would supervise the DTT/ABA program or provide the clinical psychologist consultation.
An IEP need not name individual providers; the offer described provider qualifications and duties, and the IEP meeting discussion made it clear enough to satisfy Union.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue B.2.a. Whether the goals and objectives were appropriate, given claims that present levels of performance lacked baseline data, goals were not challenging enough or too focused on functional skills, goals mixed skills in a way that made them unintelligible or overly optimistic, and goals were not written for home and community.
Present levels need not include quantified baseline data; the goals were challenging enough, addressed generalization, could be carried out, and did not need to cover home and community.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue B.2.b. Whether the special day class placement at Lupin Hills was inappropriate because the Student's behaviors prevent a move from the Elliott Institute and because the class lacks a 1:1 aide or enough individualized instruction.
The District's assessors were more credible than the Student's experts; any regression would not bar the move, and the class's nearly 1:1 adult-to-student ratio met the Student's needs.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue B.2.c. Whether the offer provided enough parent participation and failed to rebuild trust between the family and the District.
Parent training, planning team meetings and daily communication logs allowed the most practicable parent involvement; no law requires a district to rebuild trust.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue B.2.d. Whether the transition plan from the Elliott Institute to Lupin Hills was appropriate.
The gradual, part-day transition with team supports was designed to meet the Student's needs; the Student's experts knew too little about the receiving program to be persuasive.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue B.3. Whether the proposed program would comport with the IEP, given the claim that the transition plan cannot be implemented because the Elliott Institute will not accept part-time students.
The Mother's hearsay testimony alone could not support a finding; the District was willing and able to implement the plan and make the needed funding arrangements.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. If the parents want a publicly funded program through the District, they must make the Student available for the services in the June 2, 2004 IEP, as clarified by the June 16, 2004 letter. The District must remain ready and able to implement all parts of that IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee
People named in the decision
- Dr. Ronald Leaf, Director, Autism Partnership (nonpublic agency); District witness, Autism Partnership, Inc.
- Dr. Mitch Taubman, Behavior assessor; director of research and consultant, Autism Partnership, Inc.
- Jennifer Styzens, Behavior consultant; District witness, Autism Partnership, Inc.
- Michelle Harding, Program specialist, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, Psychological assessor; professor emerita of psychology; District expert witness, UCLA (emerita)
- Curran Cummings, Special day class teacher; academic assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District, Lupin Hills Elementary School
- Joy Marman Guillory, Occupational therapist; OT assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Mary Schillinger, Director of pupil services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Donald Zimering, Assistant superintendent, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Helen Siemer Bass, School psychologist, Las Virgenes Unified School District
- Marian Peloquin, Speech-language pathologist; speech-language assessor, District assessment team
- Dr. Sandra Kaler, Psychologist; expert witness for Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Dr. Silvertsen, Licensed psychologist and educational psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Dr. Pageen Cronin, Possible clinical psychologist consultant named at IEP meeting
- Alicia Elliott, Administrator, Elliott Institute
- Elliott Institute, Certified nonpublic school (current placement)
- Autism Partnership, Inc., Certified nonpublic agency; behavior consultation and parent training
- George Crook, Student's attorney; testified as witness, Newman, Aaronson, and Vanaman
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Calabasas, California, on July 15, 16, and 20-22, 2004.
Petitioner Las Virgenes Unified School District (“District”) was represented at hearing by attorneys Charles Weatherly and Christy Calbos, law clerk Renae Bailey, and paralegal Gina Farley, all from The Weatherly Law Firm in Atlanta, Georgia. Also present on the District’s behalf were Mary Schillinger, director of pupil services, and Donald Zimering, assistant superintendent. Respondent STUDENT (“Student” or “STUDENT”) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Valerie Vanaman and George Crook and legal assistant Bobbie Westal, all from the law firm of Newman, Aaronson, and Vanaman, and by attorney Natividad Chavira. STUDENT’s parents, MOTHER and FATHER, also were present on his behalf.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Ronald Leaf, director of the Autism Partnership, Inc., a certified nonpublic agency; Dr. Mitch Taubman, director of research and consultant for the Autism Partnership; Jennifer Styzens, behavior consultant with the Autism Partnership; Michelle Harding, program specialist for the District; Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, emerita professor of psychology; Curran Cummings, special education teacher for the District; Joy Guillory, occupational therapist; Mary Schillinger, director of pupil services; and Helen Siemer Bass, school psychologist. The Student called the following witnesses to testify: George Crook; MOTHER; Dr. Silvertsen, licensed psychologist; and Dr. Sandra Kaler, psychologist and assistant clinical professor at the University of California at Los Angeles.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties’ written closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on August 11, 2004. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE FOR HEARING
Was the individualized education program (IEP) that was developed on June 2, 2004, and clarified by letter on June 16, 2004, an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District asserts that it held a procedurally appropriate IEP meeting for STUDENT on June 2, 2004, during which the PARENTS were allowed a full opportunity to participate. Additionally, the District contends that it made STUDENT an offer of a FAPE in its IEP dated June 2, 2004, which was clarified by letter on June 16, 2004. According to the District, STUDENT is an autistic child who requires a placement that enables him to generalize his skills across environments and situations. In the District’s view, the IEP team appropriately identified STUDENT’s educational needs and developed appropriate goals and objectives to meet those needs. Moreover, the District contends that STUDENT needs to be transitioned back to the District, that the transition plan offered is appropriate, and that STUDENT’s needs can be met in Curran Cummings’ special day class (SDC) at Lupin Hill Elementary School with the services offered in the IEP.
The Student asserts that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Procedurally, the Student contends that the District failed to make an appropriate written offer of placement because the IEP does not state with sufficient clarity what program will be implemented in the offered class in accordance with Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). See also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Substantively, the Student asserts that the District’s offer is not designed to meet his needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because the District failed to appropriately identify his educational needs and, therefore, the goals and objectives developed by the District were not designed to meet his true needs. In addition, the Student asserts that the goals and objectives were either too optimistic, insufficiently challenging, or unintelligible. Additionally, the Student contends that the District’s offered transition plan is inappropriate, and the offered program fails to provide for sufficient and appropriate participation by the PARENTS. Moreover, the Student asserts that the offered placement in an SDC at Lupin Hills Elementary School is inappropriate because it does not provide for sufficient individualized attention and because his severe behavioral problems prohibit him from being moved from his current placement at the Elliot Institute. (Footnote 1) Finally, the Student contends that the proposed program would not comport with the IEP because the transition plan offered cannot be implemented.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eleven-year-old fifth-grade student who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with autism. As a factor of his autism, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of gross motor, fine motor, cognition, academics, speech and language, social/emotional functioning, self-help skills, and behavior. STUDENT currently lives at home with his parents and younger brother and attends school at the Elliott Institute, a certified nonpublic school in La Crescenta, California.
STUDENT first entered the District shortly after he turned three years old on February 13, 1996. During the latter part of the 1995-1996 school year through the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT was placed by the District in an educational program within the Conejo Valley Unified School District that was jointly run with that district. In the fall of 1999, STUDENT transferred to Willow Elementary School within the Las Virgenes Unified School District, where he attended school until January 2001. After an IEP meeting for STUDENT in January 2001 in which the team discussed a nonpublic school placement, the PARENTS placed STUDENT at the Elliott Institute. In the months that followed, the parties disagreed over who was responsible for the Elliott Institute placement. Consequently, the PARENTS requested a due process hearing to resolve the matter in May 2001. By July 2001, the parties had entered into a settlement agreement in which the District agreed to fund STUDENT’s nonpublic school placement through the end of the 2000-2001 school year. The underlying due process matter, case SN01-01002, was withdrawn on September 19, 2001.
At July and October 2001 IEP meetings, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would remain at the Elliott Institute through the end of the 2002 extended school year. Although the PARENTS agreed to implement the placement and services contained in those IEPs, they noted on the IEPs that they did not believe the services were sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. To resolve their issues regarding STUDENT’s IEP, the PARENTS requested another due process hearing in November 2001 (i.e., case SN01-02532). Before the matter proceeded to hearing, the parties entered into another settlement agreement on September 17, 2002, that resolved all claims to that date regarding the identification, assessment, evaluation, educational placement, and provision of services to STUDENT and any claims of procedural violations by the District. Pursuant to that agreement, STUDENT’s placement at the Elliott Institute was continued through the end of the 2003 extended school year. The agreement also provided for prospective and compensatory education services (including speech and language services, occupational therapy services, and behavior intervention services) that would be provided to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, in the event that STUDENT attended the Elliott Institute during the 2003-2004 school year.
In August 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to discuss his recent District assessment and his placement for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year. At the meeting, the District discussed its concern that its assessment results and the information provided by the Elliott Institute were “inconsistent.” To address this concern, the District requested the PARENTS’ permission to conduct additional assessments of STUDENT. The IEP team also discussed transferring STUDENT from the Elliott Institute to an SDC at Lupin Hills Elementary School within the District to provide STUDENT opportunities to interact with typical peers. MOTHER disagreed that STUDENT should be moved from the Elliott Institute. Additionally, despite subsequent written requests from the District, the PARENTS also refused consent for the additional assessments. In light of the PARENTS’ refusal of consent, on September 30, 2003, the District requested a due process hearing seeking an order allowing it to assess STUDENT. This third matter between the parties (i.e., case SN03-02057) convened for hearing on May 13, 2004, before another hearing officer. Before evidence was presented or witnesses were called, the parties entered into yet another settlement agreement that resulted again in the dismissal of the underlying matter. Under the agreement, the PARENTS allowed the District to assess STUDENT. Because of the due process filing, STUDENT remained at the Elliott Institute pursuant to the stay put provision. (Footnote 2)
The assessments agreed upon in the settlement agreement were conducted throughout the remaining weeks in May. STUDENT’s behavior assessment was conducted by Dr. Mitch Taubman of the Autism Partnership, and it entailed Dr. Taubman’s review of STUDENT’s educational records, discussions with MOTHER and STUDENT’s teacher and service providers at the Elliott Institute, and observations of STUDENT at home, at school, and during his receipt of related services. (Dist. Ex. 175.) Dr. Betty Jo Freeman conducted STUDENT’s psychological assessment. In conducting the assessment, Dr. Freeman administered formal assessment tools, conducted observations at the Elliott Institute and at home, interviewed MOTHER and STUDENT’s teacher and service providers, and reviewed his educational records. STUDENT’s speech and language assessment, which included observations at the Elliott Institute and the administration of assessment tools, was conducted by speech and language pathologist Marian Peloquin. Additionally, STUDENT was administered an academic assessment by SDC teacher Curran Cummings, and an occupational therapy assessment by occupational therapist Joy Marman Guillory. According to the testimony of Ms. Cummings and Dr. Freeman, the assessment team communicated with each other several times regarding information obtained from the different assessments.
On or about Friday, May 28, 2004, the District faxed to STUDENT’s attorneys a copy of all of the assessment reports. (Footnote 3) On May 31, 2004, one of STUDENT’s teachers at the Elliott Institute passed away. Then, on June 1, 2004, the District faxed STUDENT’s attorneys a copy of its proposed goals and objectives. Per the May 2004 settlement agreement, STUDENT’s IEP team convened on June 2, 2004, to review the recent assessments and to discuss his program for the 2004-2005 school year and extended school year. Although MOTHER and the personnel at the Elliott Institute were affected by the recent death of STUDENT’s teacher, they attended the IEP as scheduled. To be sensitive to the PARENTS, the District offered to reconvene the meeting to another day, but that offer was declined.
At the beginning of the IEP meeting, MOTHER and the Elliott staff wanted additional time to review the proposed goals and objectives. In light of their request, the District agreed to delay the start of the IEP meeting over an hour to allow them that time. Additionally, the IEP team took a long lunch to allow additional time to review the goals and objectives. By the end of the meeting, the District offered STUDENT a placement in an SDC known as the “Learning Center” at Lupin Hills Elementary School, five hours per month of supervision of STUDENT’s “DTT/ABA” program by a behavior support provider, one-to-one instructional aide support during his transition and as needed during the remaining term of the IEP, ninety minutes per week of speech and language services, ninety minutes per week of occupational therapy services, sixty minutes per week of adaptive physical education, six consultations with a clinical psychologist, extended school year services, and transportation services. Additionally, the District offered a plan to transition STUDENT from the Elliott Institute to Lupin Hills during the 2004 extended school year and lasting six weeks after the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. Moreover, the District included in its offer parent training and parent participation through “planning team meetings” occurring at least once per month and daily communication logs.
To further address the PARENTS’ concern over the goals and objectives, the IEP team agreed to allow the Elliott Institute until June 14 to review the goals and objectives as amended during the discussions at the IEP meeting. The team agreed that, if the Elliott Institute staff had any questions or concerns about the goals and objectives, they could notify the District of those questions or concerns during that time and another IEP meeting would be convened to further discuss the goals and objectives. By all indications, the Elliott Institute staff has not provided the District with any additional input regarding the goals and objectives since the IEP meeting on June 2.
On June 4 and 16, 2004, the District sent the PARENTS letters reiterating and clarifying the June 2 IEP offer to STUDENT and requesting consent for the IEP. Disagreeing with the offer, the PARENTS refused consent for the IEP. At an impasse, the District requested the instant special education due process hearing, the fourth between the parties, on June 22, 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).
In guaranteeing disabled children a right to a FAPE, Congress set forth a system of procedural and substantive requirements. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483; Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205. Accordingly, the right to a FAPE includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205 (1982). However, procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
To determine whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314(9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be designed to meet his needs and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also require that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comport with his IEP, and provide an education in the least restrictive environment. (Footntote 4)
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program is substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206?208. At the administrative hearing, the burden of persuasion is on the school district to establish that it complied with the IDEA and Rowley. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). In this case, the Student contends that the District committed procedural violations by failing to make an appropriate written offer of placement pursuant to Union. Additionally, the Student asserts that the IEP is not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because the District failed to appropriately identify his present levels of performance, failed to offer appropriate goals and objectives, placement, and transition plan, and failed to provide for sufficient parent participation. The Student also asserts that the proposed program could not comport with the offered IEP because the transition plan cannot be implemented. (Footnote 5)
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union, 15 F.3d at 1526; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56500.4. In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated, “We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district’s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id.
The Student asserts that the District violated Union by failing to make him an offer in writing that adequately describes his educational program. Specifically, the Student asserts that the District’s offer “did not identify with sufficient specificity to determine what was being offered” (1) the person who would provide him with the supervision services for his “DTT/ABA” program and (2) the provider of the clinical psychologist consultation services. (Footnote 6) Although the Student is correct that the IEP does not state specifically who would be providing these services, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the IEP failed to identify with sufficient specificity what was being offered.
First, the law simply does not require districts to identify the names of the persons who will be providing services under an IEP. None of the law or hearing decisions cited by the Student requires that the written offer be as detailed as the Student suggests. The Hearing Officer notes that in Union, the school district attempted to offer evidence on appeal of the appropriateness of placement offers that had never previously been made to the student or identified at the administrative hearing. Finding that the district had never offered those placements to the student in writing, to avoid unfair surprise on the student, the Court declined to consider those placement offers. No subsequent court case or hearing decision has expanded the findings in Union to impose a generic rule that all service providers must be identified in an IEP.
Rather, the written offer must only be sufficiently clear to satisfy the IDEA, including the three policy reasons articulated by the Union court, such as alerting the parents to consider seriously whether the district’s offer is appropriate. Public policy also would weigh against imposing such an onerous responsibility on school districts. For example, the inclusion of specific names in the IEP would hinder a district’s right to make personnel decisions by obligating the district to employ these specific persons to provide a child with a FAPE. Additionally, a district has little to no ability to control which persons choose to remain employed by it.
In this case, the District’s written offer was sufficiently clear to satisfy the IDEA and the policies identified by the Union court. According to the June 2004 IEP, STUDENT was offered in writing supervision from a behavior support provider to:
“consult with STUDENT’s special and general education providers who serve him, collaborate with staff, and observe STUDENT in his program…. The behavior support provider will have at least two years training and experience working with upper elementary school age students who have autistic like behavior…. The behavior support provider will also possess training and at least two years experience working in ABA/DTT methodology.”
On the face of the IEP, the written offer describes the training and responsibilities of the behavior support provider. Although the Student asserts that the description is “generic” and could describe a classroom aide or someone without a college degree or credentials, the service that was being offered was “supervision” of STUDENT’s applied behavioral analysis program (ABA) within Ms. Cummings’ SDC. Additionally, according to the notes of the IEP, Ms. Cummings described to STUDENT’s attorney, Mr. Crook, that she has a master’s degree in special education, has taught for the District for four years, has participated in ABA training since 1996, has been trained by and involved in consultations with the Autism Partnership for four years, and has taken nine university credit hours in ABA. (Footnote 7) As was discussed at the IEP meeting, the supervisor of the ABA program would, in comparison to Ms. Cumming’s background, be a “very well trained staff.” (Footnote 8) In light of the information provided to the PARENTS at the IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer concludes that the written offer of behavior support supervision services described above was sufficiently clear to satisfy the purposes of Union. Because an IEP is developed from the discussions at an IEP meeting, the written offer cannot be considered in a vacuum. Instead, the determination of whether the written offer was sufficiently clear to the parents must include a consideration of what the parents knew about the offer from discussions at the IEP meeting.
Regarding the clinical psychologist consultation services, the IEP provides that the psychologist will have “extensive experience in working with children with Autism Spectrum Disorder.” Although the IEP does not state specifically who would provide the services, the offer of a “clinical psychologist” clearly identifies the minimum education, licensing, and experience of the consultant. Additionally, at the IEP meeting, Mr. Crook asked the District specifically who would provide the consultation services. The District indicated that Dr. Freeman would likely provide the consultation services or, if she is unavailable, someone with her comparable training and experience (such as Dr. Pageen Cronin, a “compatriot of” Dr. Freeman). (Footnote 9) Thus, in addition to the written description of the offer in the IEP, the Student was provided examples of who could provide the services and their relative training and experience.
In conclusion, districts are not required to state the specific names of the persons responsible for the provision of services under an IEP. In this case, the District made an appropriate written offer pursuant to Union that set clearly set forth the qualifications and functions of the persons who would provide STUDENT his educational services. Accordingly, the District did not violate the Student’s procedural rights in this regard.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
1. What are STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
To determine whether the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. There is no dispute that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. Additionally, the parties agree that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of cognition, behavior, academics, speech and language, social/emotional functioning, gross motor skills, fine motor skills, and self-help skills. Although the Student contended generally that the District failed to identify appropriately his specific educational needs, the record reflects that very few aspects of STUDENT’s needs are actually in dispute. For example, in his closing brief, Petitioner’s descriptions of his needs in the areas of motor functioning, self-help skills, behavior, and cognition were obtained directly from the summary of present levels of performance contained in his June 2004 IEP. Additionally, the testimony of witnesses at hearing, STUDENT’s most recent assessment reports, and other recent documents pertaining to STUDENT’s educational progress all provide substantially consistent information regarding STUDENT’s current needs. (Footnote 10)
a. Cognition
Dr. Kaler and Dr. Freeman both agreed that STUDENT has significant cognitive delays. (Footnote 11) According to Dr. Freeman’s curriculum vitae, she is a professor emerita in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at UCLA, where she had been in residence for over thirty years. Within this department, she worked in the Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and heads the Autism Evaluation Clinic. (Footnote 12) She has lectured on the diagnosis, assessment, treatment, and nature of autism numerous times throughout the United States and abroad. She has written or contributed to over one hundred professional journal articles concerning autism and related subjects. She also has authored and co-authored several books including Autism: Diagnosis, Current Research and Management in 1976. She has consulted with numerous school districts in California and throughout the country. As a professor, she trained psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, and school psychologists in the nature and assessment of autism. She has been licensed as a clinical psychologist in California since 1976. Dr. Freeman assessed STUDENT in May 2004 and attended his August 2003 and June 2004 IEP meetings. The scope of Dr. Freeman’s assessment of STUDENT was described above.
Dr. Kaler is a licensed psychologist, assistant clinical professor at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute, and registered nurse. (Footnote 13) Dr. Kaler has been a licensed psychologist since about 1990 and she did her postdoctoral traineeship in the area of the diagnosis and treatment of developmentally disabled children and adolescents. Dr. Kaler has published seven articles, including one that she co-authored with Dr. Freeman. Additionally, Dr. Kaler has made numerous presentations throughout the country and abroad regarding autism and related areas of psychology. Similar to Dr. Freeman, Dr. Kaler has consulted with school districts and students alike. Dr. Kaler assessed STUDENT in May 2003 and has not assessed him since.
In May 2004, Dr. Freeman assessed STUDENT’s cognitive ability using the Mullen Scales of Early Learning. Dr. Freeman testified that she used the Mullen with STUDENT, even though the test is normed for children younger than STUDENT, because his verbal abilities are not sufficient for age-equivalent measures. Additionally, although Dr. Freeman testified at hearing that the Mullen was not normed on autistic children, she stated that the Mullen is appropriate to evaluate STUDENT’s relative strengths and weaknesses in four domains of cognitive functioning identified in the test (i.e., visual reception, fine motor, receptive language, and expressive language). (Footnote 14) According to the results of the Mullen, STUDENT functions at the thirty-one-month range in “expressive language,” the thirty-four-month range in “receptive language,” the thirty-nine-month range in “fine motor,” and the forty-three-month range in “visual reception.”
Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT’s cognitive results on the Mullen were consistent with the findings of Dr. Kaler, the Student’s witness, on the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence – Third Edition (WPPSI-III) from May 2003. Similar to the Mullen, the WPPSI-III also is normed for children chronologically younger than STUDENT. Thus, like Dr. Freeman, Dr. Kaler did not report STUDENT’s standard score on the test, but administered the test to determine the level of STUDENT’s skills. Both witnesses agreed that this was an appropriate use of their respective tests for STUDENT. Both psychologists found that STUDENT functioned cognitively within the same range in receptive/expressive language and communication, as well as in living skills and socialization on related measures.
b. Behavior
The parties agree that STUDENT also has significant behavioral needs. STUDENT’s behavioral needs were last assessed on behalf of the District by Dr. Mitch Taubman, from the Autism Partnership, in May 2004. Dr. Taubman is a developmental and child psychologist who has worked with the autism population for approximately twenty-five years. Dr. Taubman currently is the director of research and a consultant with the Autism Partnership, an organization that provides consultation and training services to school districts regarding approaches to educating and addressing behaviors in children with autism. Dr. Taubman has taught graduate courses on applied behavior analysis and behavior assessment, among others.
According to Dr. Taubman, STUDENT exhibits off-task behaviors, self-stimulatory behaviors, inattentiveness, noncompliance, task avoidance, and aggression directed at others, himself, and property. STUDENT’s self-injurious behaviors include picking at his lips and skin, poking his eyeball, and hitting his head. Dr. Freeman also identified many of the same behaviors, as well as tantrumming and poor eye contact. Similarly, information from the Elliott Institute indicates that STUDENT exhibits “self stimulatory behaviors and loss of focus.” (Footnote 15) Regarding the self-stimulatory behaviors, STUDENT is reported to touch his lips five to seven times per hour and emit vocal “stims” five to eight times per hour. To address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, Dr. Taubman and Dr. Freeman recommended focusing on functional skills, reinforcing positive behaviors, and teaching generalization and independence. The Student did not significantly dispute the District’s recommendations in this regard.
However, the parties dispute whether STUDENT’s behaviors prohibit him from being moved from his current placement. In other words, the parties dispute whether STUDENT’s behaviors require that he remain in his current placement. The Student asserts that his behaviors prevent him from being moved because he would suffer significant regression and would lose the academic and behavioral gains he has made at the Elliott Institute. The District disputes this contention, stating that, while STUDENT would likely suffer some regression, his difficulty with transitions is not so severe that it prohibits a change of placement.
In support of his contention, Dr. Kaler and Dr. Silvertsen testified that they believed that STUDENT would likely suffer significant regression if he is moved. Dr. Silvertsen is a licensed psychologist and educational psychologist. Dr. Silvertsen has worked with autistic children since about 1960. Currently, Dr. Silvertsen practices both in Norway and in California. As part of her practice, she works with autistic children with a wide range of functioning and she contracts with a number of public school districts to provide services to autistic children. Dr. Silvertsen has published a book on how to “teach autistic children and adults” in Norwegian, and she makes presentations on autism in Norway and the United States. Dr. Silvertsen reviewed some of STUDENT’s educational records, “worked” with him for ten hours on a one-to-one basis, observed him at the Elliot Institute, and interviewed staff at the Elliot Institute. However, according to the Student, Dr. Silvertsen did not assess him.
Dr. Kaler specifically testified that STUDENT was able to transition successfully to the Elliott Institute in the past without a transition plan or any significant regression, but the success was due to the fact that he transitioned into an appropriate program. In her May 2003 report, Dr. Kaler cautioned against transitioning STUDENT into a less restrictive setting. Thus, Dr. Kaler’s testimony was based on the underlying assumption that the Lupin placement is somehow inappropriate or less restrictive than the Elliott Institute. Both Dr. Kaler and Dr. Silvertsen testified they believed that moving STUDENT would cause him to act out behaviorally and his behaviors would impede his learning. According to the witnesses, their opinions are based on their training and experience working with autistic children in general. As for Dr. Kaler, her testimony also is based in part on her assessment from last year. Although both witnesses reviewed portions of STUDENT’s school records, neither witness spoke with any of the District assessors or service providers to inquire about the District assessments or the Lupin placement offer.
The District witnesses acknowledged that any transition would be difficult for STUDENT; Dr. Taubman believed that STUDENT would even suffer some regression. However, Dr. Taubman, Dr. Freeman, and Ms. Cummings all agree that STUDENT would be able to tolerate a change of placement and could recover appropriately. The witnesses based their opinions both on their experience and on their multi-tiered and multi-disciplinary assessment of STUDENT. As described above, their assessment of STUDENT included a review of STUDENT’s records, observations of STUDENT at the Elliot Institute, formal testing, interviews with STUDENT’s teacher and service providers, interviews with MOTHER, and observation of STUDENT at home. Additionally, Ms. Cummings is the teacher of the Lupin Hills placement offered to STUDENT, and both Drs. Freeman and Taubman have observed that placement and spoken to Ms. Cummings about her class.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District witnesses more credible than that of Dr. Kaler and Dr. Silvertsen on this point. Most significantly, neither of Student’s witnesses knew about the Lupin placement in any detail and neither obtained any information on that program offer from the teacher or service providers prior to rendering their opinions about STUDENT’s ability to transition into that program. Thus, their testimony lacked sufficient support. Although they referenced STUDENT’s past behaviors as a basis for believing that STUDENT would suffer irreversible regression, STUDENT’s most recent transition (i.e., his transition into the Elliott Institute in January 2001) was a success. At that time, STUDENT’s behavioral needs were much more intense than they are now. In contrast, the District’s witnesses had detailed knowledge of both programs and knowledge of STUDENT’s needs from their assessments and discussions with the PARENTS and the Elliot Institute staff. Accordingly, the District’s witnesses based their opinion on actual knowledge of all components of the transition plan, including the characteristics of the receiving program at Lupin Hills. Because the testimony of the District’s witnesses is more persuasive, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s behavioral deficits do not require that he remain in his current placement.
c. Academics
Academically, special day class teacher Curran Cummings testified that STUDENT demonstrates a readiness to learn because he is easily redirected, easily reinforced, has good rote skills, and is able to perform many tasks asked of him. Ms. Cummings assessed STUDENT’s academics in May 2004. Referencing her report, Ms. Cummings testified that STUDENT could independently relay personal information and identify family members and major body parts. However, STUDENT required multiple attempts, prompts, or redirection to label correctly some colors, less frequently identified body parts, and capital letters and to recite numbers in the teens. As reported to Ms. Cummings by the Elliott Institute, STUDENT can read about fifty sight words. It is undisputed that he enjoys reading Disney books. Moreover, he is learning to read clocks and he does not currently have any money skills. Among his academic weaknesses, Ms. Cummings described that STUDENT is distracted easily, has difficulty with abstract tasks, has difficulty with generalization of skills, and exhibits significant self-stimulatory behavior. Information from the Elliott Institute on STUDENT’s present levels of performance as of June 2004 reflects similar skills in language arts and math. (Footnote 16) Moreover, an Elliott Institute progress report dated November 2003 also indicates that STUDENT’s ability to learn some academic skills is impacted by his difficulty with generalization. (Footnote 17) Accordingly, both parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires instruction to improve his academic skills in language and math. To address STUDENT’s difficulty with generalization, Ms. Cummings also recommended teaching STUDENT to generalize and independently use his skills. The parties generally do not dispute that STUDENT needs to generalize his skills. (Footnote 18)
d. Speech and Language
STUDENT’s speech and language abilities were assessed by Ms. Marian Peloquin this past May. (Footnote 19) Ms. Peloquin’s findings and the information from the Elliott Institute indicate that, expressively, STUDENT can speak in three-to six-word sentences, answer yes/no questions about a picture, respond to questions in a conversation or greeting, and use some spontaneous speech. STUDENT also can label colors and body parts, among other things. Additionally, STUDENT is able to appropriately use the singular and the plural forms of words. He also is able to understand and follow simple instructions. However, STUDENT is echolalic and has a tendency to repeat statements and questions made by his peers and teachers, which makes it difficult for him to respond to questions or greetings appropriately. According to the Elliott Institute, STUDENT often requires modeling and gestural prompting to elicit language. Ms. Peloquin recommended that STUDENT’s educational program focus on developing independent performance of functional language skills. Additionally, his goals should focus on increasing and expanding his spontaneous language and reducing reliance on others in the use of his language. No evidence was presented to dispute these recommendations.
The parties disagree about whether STUDENT is apraxic. Dr. Kaler testified that apraxia is a problem in which the nerves in the brain have difficulty sequencing information and in which the muscles of the body are slow to react to the information received. Thus, according to Dr. Kaler, a child with apraxia will have difficulty conceptualizing an idea and acting upon it. In support of the Student, Dr. Kaler’s report and testimony indicate that STUDENT has a form of apraxia that makes it difficult for him to formulate an idea and act upon it. Thus, STUDENT is slow to respond when asked a question or given a direction. To deal with his apraxia, according to Dr. Kaler, STUDENT will look to others for a response or a cue to determine if what he is doing is right. Therefore, Dr. Kaler testified that STUDENT requires prompting throughout his school day. She determined that STUDENT has apraxia from her assessment of him in 2003, which included the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (Beery).
Dr. Freeman disagrees that STUDENT is apraxic. Dr. Freeman described apraxia as a problem with speech and language that is characterized by severe articulation difficulties, but testified that STUDENT does not have problems with articulation. Dr. Freeman also testified that there exists a form of motor apraxia that impacts a child’s motor abilities. Although STUDENT has some motor difficulties as described below, STUDENT demonstrates motor activities that would not be possible if he had motor apraxia (e.g., write, scribble, hop on one foot, and hit a baseball). She stated that the diagnosis of apraxia cannot be made by a psychologist, but rather the child must be referred to a speech and language pathologist or an occupational therapist for diagnosis. Additionally, if a psychologist suspects apraxia from scores on the Beery, for example, the test manual states that there must be two more follow-up tests to explore the suspicion. Dr. Kaler did not conduct the two follow-up tests that are required by the test manual prior to a finding of apraxia.
The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Freeman’s testimony persuasive. Dr. Freeman’s testimony regarding the proper personnel and means for diagnosing apraxia is undisputed. There is no indication from the record that STUDENT was diagnosed with apraxia by appropriate personnel or through appropriate testing. In fact, Dr. Kaler’s report is the only item in STUDENT’s entire school records that indicate a problem with apraxia. However, Dr. Kaler’s report did not explain the basis for her diagnosis, but merely stated a conclusion based on some observations. In light of Dr. Freeman’s testimony, the presence of STUDENT’s skills contrary to the diagnosis of apraxia, and the unsubstantiated conclusion of Dr. Kaler, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that STUDENT does not have apraxia.
e. Social/Emotional Functioning
According to Dr. Kaler, STUDENT exhibits a social relatedness in which he will “joint reference” by looking at a person and waiting for them to ask a question. Ms. Peloquin and Dr. Kaler agreed that STUDENT uses his language in a social context and will participate in a conversation to the extent that he can with his language skills. In May 2003, Dr. Kaler also found that STUDENT engages in some “on-looking” in which he will look at other kids. Similarly, Dr. Freeman’s report indicates that STUDENT shows preferences for some friends over others, can inconsistently imitate and watch others, and can participate in games and social activities with step-by-step directions and adult assistance. In light of his developing social skills, the parties agree that STUDENT requires instruction to improve his skills in this area.
f. Gross Motor Abilities
According to Dr. Freeman’s May 2004 psychological report, STUDENT’s gross motor skills level ranges from two years, five months to four years, seven months. STUDENT can climb, run, jump, and stand on one foot. However, he is reported not to pedal a tricycle or pour liquid from a glass. Additionally, the Elliott Institute reported that STUDENT can catch a small ball with a mitt from a distance of fifteen feet with seventy percent accuracy eighty percent of the time. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires adaptive physical education to address his gross motor deficits.
g. Fine Motor Abilities
STUDENT’s fine motor skills were assessed most recently by District occupational therapist Joy Guillory in May 2004. Ms. Guillory is a licensed occupational therapist who has worked for the District since October 2002. Ms. Guillory has assessed and/or treated over a hundred children with autism. Ms. Guillory observed STUDENT in an occupational therapy session at the Elliott Institute in March 2003 and assessed STUDENT in May 2004. According to Ms. Guillory’s testimony and May 2004 assessment report, STUDENT exhibits functional grasp patterns, good bilateral hand skill function on specific tasks, and adequate hand skill development for participating in most school-related fine motor tasks. However, STUDENT has difficulty with independent writing of his name and scissors use for cutting basic shapes. Ms. Guillory also determined that STUDENT has difficulty sustaining attention to task and visually monitoring his hand’s performance during writing, coloring, and cutting. From her assessment, Ms. Guillory concluded that STUDENT needs multiple and clear demonstrations when introducing novel tasks and frequent movement breaks. Additionally, at hearing Ms. Guillory recommended occupational therapy at a duration and frequency of thirty minutes per week each of individual, group, and consultation services. The information regarding STUDENT’s gross and fine motor skills is not significantly disputed.
h. Self-Help Skills
Ms. Guillory and Dr. Freeman also assessed STUDENT’s self-help skills. According to Ms. Guillory’s report, STUDENT can independently dress, put on his shoes correctly when the shoes are set up for right and left, snap and zip his pants, button a polo shirt, tie his shoes, use utensils to eat and drink from a cup, remove material from a backpack, and open doors at school without difficulty. She also determined that, although STUDENT is independent at toileting, he occasionally needs assistance with wiping during toileting. Additionally, Dr. Freeman found that STUDENT has little safety awareness and he requires some assistance with brushing his teeth. The Student does not dispute any of these findings regarding his self-help needs.
****
In summary, STUDENT is an autistic child with deficits in the areas of gross motor, fine motor, self-help skills, behavior, cognition, academics, speech and language, and social/emotional functioning. STUDENT has significant cognitive delays and behaviors that impact his ability to learn. Additionally, although he exhibits a readiness to learn, STUDENT’s academic skills are developing and sometimes inconsistent without the support of prompts. To address his educationally related deficits, STUDENT needs a program that addresses his behaviors, that provides academic instruction in language arts and math, and that enables him to generalize and independently use his skills. Socially, STUDENT’s skills are developing but inconsistent, and he requires adult assistance and direction to improve his social skills. STUDENT’s use of language is impacted by his echolalia, and he often relies on prompts to express his language. Although STUDENT can perform some gross and fine motor skills, he cannot perform other related skills. Accordingly, he requires adaptive physical education and occupational therapy to address his motor related needs. Regarding adaptive functioning, STUDENT needs assistance with brushing his teeth and wiping during toileting.
2. Does the District’s Offer Meet STUDENT’s Needs and is it Reasonably Calculated to Provide Him With Educational Benefit?
To address STUDENT’s needs, the District offered him twenty-two annual goals broken down into two or three short-term objectives each. The goals and objectives covered eight categories: functional academic, community access, communication, social/emotional, recreation/leisure, fine motor, vocational, and health and medical. As described above, the District also offered STUDENT a placement in an SDC at Lupin Hills Elementary School, five hours per month of supervision of STUDENT’s “DTT/ABA” program by a behavior support provider, one-to-one instructional aide support during his transition and as needed during the remaining term of the IEP, ninety minutes per week of speech and language services, ninety minutes per week of occupational therapy services, sixty minutes per week of adaptive physical education, six two-hour consultation sessions with a clinical psychologist, extended school year services, and transportation services. The District also offered a plan to transition STUDENT from the Elliott Institute to Lupin Hills during the 2004 extended school year and lasting six weeks into the 2004-2005 school year. Moreover, the District included in its offer parent training and parent participation through “planning team meetings” occurring at least once per month and daily communication logs.
The Student does not dispute the appropriateness of the level of speech and language, occupational therapy, or adaptive physical education services offered by the District. However, the Student objects to the appropriateness of the goals and objectives, the SDC placement at Lupin Hills, the nature and amount of parental participation, and the transition plan.
a. Goals and Objectives
State and federal law requires that an IEP document include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to meeting STUDENT’s needs to enable him to be involved in and progress in the general education curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). Additionally, California Education Code section 56345(a)(1)(A) requires inclusion of the present levels of performance. See also 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i).
The Student asserts that the District failed to indicate appropriate present levels of performance (PLP) and, therefore, the goals and objectives developed by the District are not designed to meet his true needs. In addition, the Student asserts that the goals and objectives are either too optimistic, insufficiently challenging, or unintelligible. Moreover, the Student asserts that the goals should be written to be implemented in the home and community environments.
i. Inappropriate Present Levels of Performance
Regarding the Student’s first contention, the Student asserts that the goals and objectives appearing at the District’s Exhibit 181 at pages HB01366, 1369-1372, 1375-1382, and 1384 either have no present level of performance accompanying them or modify their descriptions with “nondescriptive words” such as “very limited way,” “much,” “often,” and “inconsistent.” The District contends that the present levels of performance were developed with the input of the PARENTS and STUDENT’s Elliott Institute staff and that the PLPs accurately and appropriately specify STUDENT’s needs.
The evidence supports the District’s position. First, the Student appears to argue that the present levels of performance necessarily require “baseline” information with specific quantitative data on the actual number of times a student exhibits a particular behavior or deficit. Dr. Taubman testified without dispute that true baseline data can be obtained only by placing the child in the proposed placement without any supports. That way, data can be obtained about how the student truly performs in that particular environment. Then, that data could be compared to the student’s progress in that same placement with the supports to determine whether the program was appropriate. The law does not require that this type of baseline data form the basis of a student’s present level of performance. Typically, the data is obtained from assessments and other information available regarding the student’s needs. (Footnote 20) In this case, the evidence established that STUDENT’s present levels of performance were discussed in detail at the June 2004 IEP meeting based on his recent assessments and that his educational providers at the Elliott Institute and his parents had input in the determination of those PLPs.
Although the Student asserts that Dr. Taubman’s and Dr. Freeman’s reports cannot be relied on in determining his needs because they are not thorough, complete, or accurate, he makes no allegation or presents any evidence that either Dr. Taubman or Dr. Freeman failed to comply with the legal standards for appropriate assessments under the law. (Footnote 21) Instead, he objects to the use of “nondescriptive words” in the assessments and the fact that Dr. Freeman conducted her observation of STUDENT while also talking with his Elliott Institute educational providers. These contentions, if true, would not render inappropriate the underlying assessments. Furthermore, the present levels of performance determined at the IEP were not derived from their assessments alone, but also were based on the other assessments, input from the IEP participants, and record reviews. The transcript of the IEP meeting indicates that the District’s proposed PLPs were modified based on the information provided by the Student and his representatives. Additionally, the PARENTS and the Elliott Institute staff also were given two weeks after the IEP meeting to review the IEP goals and objectives and to notify the District of any changes or suggestions. They have not provided the District with any additional input regarding the goals and objectives. Given this extensive opportunity for participation and the fact that the parents also are part of the IEP team responsible for the development of the IEP, it is disingenuous for the Student to now assert that the District failed to identify appropriately his present levels of performance.
Second, the hallmark of autism is inconsistency. (Footnote 22) As was described above, STUDENT has some difficulty with generalization of his skills and he often relies on prompts to exhibit a skill. For a child like STUDENT, actual counts of behaviors in one situation may not reflect his overall deficits in another situation. Therefore, number counts may be misleading as to his actual needs. Additionally, the “nondescriptive words” that the Student refers to in the goals and objectives plainly describe gradients among a continuum. Thus, the words themselves offer specific information about the rate or severity of STUDENT’s needs. In conclusion, the evidence does not support the Student’s contention that the present levels of performance were not identified appropriately.
ii. Goals are overly focused on “functional skills”curriculum
The Student’s other challenge to the offered goals and objectives is that they are overly focused on a “functional skills” curriculum. First, although the parties do not dispute the general premise that STUDENT needs to generalize his skills, they dispute whether STUDENT’s program should emphasize acquiring new and challenging academic skills or on the generalization and independent use of functional skills. Specifically, the District contends that, in light of STUDENT’s academic deficits and difficulty using the skills that he learns, his program needs to be geared towards learning to generalize and use independently skills that are functional in his everyday life. The Student, on the other hand, contends that he can generalize skills once he learns them and that his academics should be sufficiently challenging to increase his knowledge base.
First, when the IDEA was reauthorized in 1997, Congress expressed that the purpose of the IDEA was “to ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A) and (B) (emphasis added); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. As described above, STUDENT’s cognitive skills fall between the thirty-one-month and the forty-three-month range. Although he has shown that he can learn many different skills, including reading sight words, STUDENT presents as a child who is currently dependent on adult assistance to exhibit his skills. According to Dr. Freeman, a child becomes independent with his skills when he generalizes them and can use them in different situations and environments. Thus, the District’s emphasis on generalization of skills is consistent with the purpose of the IDEA to prepare disabled students for independent living.
Next, the Hearing Officer does not find the parties’ positions necessarily inconsistent. The Student’s witnesses, Dr. Silvertsen and Dr. Kaler, testified that STUDENT could generalize a skill once he learned it. Dr. Silvertsen testified that she taught STUDENT new skills and examined whether he could use the new skills in different contexts. Although the District’s witnesses emphasized STUDENT’s difficulty with generalization and independent use of skills, they did not dispute that STUDENT has generalized skills in the past or is able to do so in the future. In fact, their recommendation to develop a program to assist him with increasing his generalization of skills acknowledges the fact that he can do so. Thus, the parties’ actual dispute is over whether or not the offered goals and objectives are sufficiently challenging for STUDENT.
The Student contends that he has already met the goals appearing at the District’s Exhibit 181 at pages HB01365, 1382, and 1384. The District contends that the goals are appropriate because, although STUDENT exhibits some of these skills, STUDENT is not able to generalize the skills and therefore the skills are not useful to him. The evidence supports the District’s position.
The first goal challenged by the Student aims to have him read twenty new functional sight words and to be able to generalize them. As described above, STUDENT can read approximately fifty words by some reports. Hence, the goal would increase his sight word vocabulary by forty percent. Additionally, although he can read certain words, the goal emphasizes his reading of new words. Therefore, the goal appropriately aims at increasing STUDENT’s reading skills and does not merely require demonstration of a skill he already has. The same also can be said about the goal on page HB01382, which relates to STUDENT’s ability to demonstrate knowledge of at least eight people on campus by greeting them by name or answering questions about them. Although the evidence establishes that STUDENT presently can identify eight people in his life, the goal emphasizes greeting skills and STUDENT’s use of descriptors, which the Elliott Institute reported was a skill in development. Additionally, at Lupin Hill, STUDENT would be exposed to many new people. Thus, the goal also would enable him to familiarize himself with new people in his environment. Finally, the goal on HB01384 is aimed at increasing STUDENT’s ability to spontaneously initiate greetings with familiar people. Similarly, although the parties agree that STUDENT can greet people, the evidence as described above indicates that he has trouble initiating social interactions. Hence, this goal includes skills that STUDENT currently possesses but also aims at expanding his skills.
iii. Goals are unintelligible or overly optimistic because they mix and match skills and need areas
Next, the Student argues that the goals inappropriately mix and match skills so as to make them difficult to implement. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are not inappropriate for this reason. Specifically, as Ms. Cummings testified, many of the goals were written so that STUDENT could be provided instruction on the skills in the natural environment during the school day. Ms. Cummings also described in detail how she would be able to implement certain goals. For example, she would implement the goal pertaining to greeting people at natural times during the day when greetings would be appropriate, such as at the bus stop and the office. Although the Student asserts that the goals would be difficult to implement and achieve, Ms. Curran’s testimony provided concrete examples of how they can be met. Therefore, this challenge to the goals and objectives also fails.
iv. Goals are not written to be implemented at home and in the community
Finally, although not argued in his brief, at the beginning of the hearing, the Student contended that many of the goals and objectives were to be implemented solely at school and they should also have been written to include implementation at home and in the community. While it is true that the goals and objectives are not written to be implemented in STUDENT’s home and community, there is no requirement that they must be implemented in these arenas, especially when the program offered is limited to the school environment. Practically, without services or a program in these arenas, the District would not be able to track the progress of those goals and objectives. Additionally, although STUDENT’s goals and objectives were not written to be implemented in the home or community environment, many of his goals are directed at skills he would need in the home. For example, STUDENT had a goal to help with his teeth-brushing skills. To address generalization of skills into the home, the offer provided for parent training, communication, and team meetings. Moreover, there is no legal requirement for a home/community component for an eleven-year-old child and there was no evidence at hearing that one was required for STUDENT. From the above, the Student’s argument fails.
****
In summary, it was determined above that STUDENT’s present levels of performance did not require “baseline” information to be appropriate. Additionally, the offered goals and objectives were sufficiently challenging and appropriately addressed STUDENT’s need for generalization of skills. Moreover, the goals and objectives were not unintelligible or overly optimistic. Finally, the goals and objectives were not inappropriate because they are written to be implemented only in the school environment.
b. Placement
The Student asserted that the SDC placement at Lupin Hills is inappropriate for two reasons. First, the Student asserts the offered placement is inappropriate because he has severe behavioral problems that prohibit him from being moved from his current placement at the Elliot Institute. Specifically, the Student asserts that he would suffer significant regression if he was removed from the Elliott Institute and placed at Lupin Hill. Because it was found above that STUDENT’s needs do not prohibit him from being moved into a new placement, the Student’s first argument fails.
Additionally, Ms. Cummings’ undisputed testimony establishes that placement in her classroom is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Ms. Cummings testified that, if STUDENT were placed in her class, her class would consist of approximately seven students and six adults. She also testified that four of her current students are autistic. According to Ms. Cummings, she can implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives in her class. For example, she testified that her class focuses on functional skills and teaching independence and generalization, which are required components of STUDENT’s IEP. Further, she testified that she would address his behaviors according to his behavior plan and teach independence by giving STUDENT feedback regarding his behavior.
Second, the Student asserted at the beginning of the hearing that the offered SDC placement is inappropriate because it fails to include a one-to-one aide for mainstreaming or sufficient individualized instruction. The Student’s argument fails. As described above, Ms. Cummings’ class would have seven students (including STUDENT) and six adults in the classroom, including the additional classroom aide provided by STUDENT’s IEP. The IEP states that STUDENT would be provided additional aide assistance during his transition to Lupin Hills and as needed afterwards. (Footnote 23) Thus, the uncontested evidence establishes that the classroom would have an adult-to-student ratio of close to one-to-one and that STUDENT would have access to individualized instruction most, if not all, of his school day. The adult-to-student ratio offered to STUDENT at Lupin Hills is lower than at his current placement at the Elliott Institute, which has a ratio of approximately five adults to nine students. Therefore, the evidence establishes that the Lupin Hills placement offers STUDENT a low adult-to-student ratio that would enable him to receive the individualized instruction that he requires.
In summary, the evidence does not support either of the Student’s contentions for why the SDC placement offer is inappropriate to meet his unique and individual needs. In light of Ms. Cummings’ undisputed testimony that she can implement STUDENT’s IEP and the low student-to-adult ratio offered at Lupin Hills, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
c. Participation of the PARENTS in STUDENT’s education
California Education Code section 56126 states that the superintendent shall encourage the “maximum practicable involvement” of parents of children enrolled in special education programs. As was discussed above, the parties generally agree that STUDENT’s program necessarily includes parental involvement to carry over to the home what STUDENT learns at school. The Student contends that the District’s offer does not provide for sufficient involvement of his parents and fails to “rebuild trust between his family and the District.”
To enable parental participation, the District offered to convene regular planning team meetings. As described above, the team meetings would include STUDENT’s parents, teacher, staff, consultants, and service providers. By all accounts, Elliott Institute staff would also be invited to these meetings or to contribute information. Additionally, the team meetings are for the purposes of discussing STUDENT’s educational progress and making any adjustments to his program. The team meetings are to be held biweekly for the first two months and monthly thereafter. The District also provided for extensive parent training, including collaboration between the Autism Partnership staff and District staff, over the course of twelve weeks. For the first two weeks, the PARENTS would be provided two one-hour sessions per week of “didactic training.” During weeks three to five, they would be provided two two-hour sessions per week on the development, implementation, assessment, and refinement of procedures and programming. During weeks six to eight and weeks ten and twelve, the sessions would be reduced to one, two-hour session per week. Thereafter, the parent training would continue through the monthly team meetings referenced above.
Additionally, the District offered the PARENTS a daily parent/school communication log. The log would enable the PARENTS on a daily basis to request from STUDENT’s educational providers specific information regarding his school day. The logs also are intended to enable the PARENTS to provide to the District staff pertinent information from home, such as STUDENT’s sleep patterns or other matters that might impact STUDENT’s school day.
Although the Student generally objected to the sufficiency of the offers to enable parent participation, he did not indicate specifically why or how the offers were insufficient. Moreover, although the Student contends that the District’s offer fails to rebuild trust between the family and the District, he fails to indicate how this can be done. Furthermore, although the IDEA envisions extensive collaboration between school districts and parents, the Student also fails to establish that the District is required by law to “rebuild” the PARENTS’ trust in the District or that the failure to do so would result in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT. In the absence of any specific contentions or authority, the Hearing Officer determines that the offer is appropriate to provide consistency between the home and school environments and to enable the PARENTS to be involved in STUDENT’s education to the maximum extent practicable.
Viewed together, the offers for parent training and daily logs enable the PARENTS to be involved in STUDENT’s education on a daily basis and in a meaningful way. The daily logs allow for a flow of information between the District and the PARENTS so that the PARENTS can monitor STUDENT’s educational progress. The logs also enable the PARENTS to have their questions and concerns addressed within a short period of time by the people who are working directly with STUDENT. Similarly, the team meetings allow the PARENTS to obtain information, to express their concerns, and to participate in the development of STUDENT’s program. Furthermore, the parent training would enable the PARENTS to obtain expertise in the methodologies implemented in STUDENT’s program so as to be more informed members of the educational team. In addition to enabling the PARENTS to better scrutinize STUDENT’s program, the training would give them the skills to continue STUDENT’s educational gains in the home environment. Although not required by law, the fact that the offers provide for the free flow of information and the intensive involvement of the PARENTS establishes that the District is approaching the PARENTS with openness and is attempting to rebuild the trust between the parties. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of parent participation is appropriate as it pertains to STUDENT’s education.
d. Transition Plan
Finally, the Student contends that the District’s offered transition plan is inappropriate. (Footnote 24) For STUDENT’s transition from the Elliott Institute to the SDC at Lupin Hill, the District proposed that STUDENT’s teacher and service providers from the District observe STUDENT during the ESY at the Elliott Institute five times for up to two hours on each visit. Then, during the first two weeks of the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT would attend Lupin Hill from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. and attend the Elliott Institute for the remainder of the day. During the third and fourth weeks, STUDENT would attend Lupin Hill until noon and the Elliott Institute for the remainder of the school day. Beginning the fifth week, STUDENT would attend school full time at Lupin Hill. The District also offered to either reimburse MOTHER for transporting STUDENT to and from home, Lupin Hill, and the Elliott Institute or to provide STUDENT transportation via taxi accompanied by a District staff member. To address any concerns or issues arising during the transition, the District offered to hold biweekly “team meetings,” which would include his parents, SDC teacher, behavior support provider, speech and language specialist, occupational therapist, consultants, and Elliott Institute staff. The team meetings are intended to allow those involved in STUDENT’s education to discuss STUDENT’s progress and behaviors, the effectiveness of his modifications and accommodations, and any program changes as necessary. The District stated that it would pay for the time STUDENT attends the Elliott Institute during the transition period.
The Student argues that the transition plan is not appropriate because it would require that he be transported one hour each day between the Elliott Institute and Lupin Hills for the first four weeks of school. MOTHER testified that, although the Elliott Institute and Lupin Hills are about thirty miles apart, the traffic during the transition times would lengthen the transit time to one hour. Additionally, the Student presented the testimony of Dr. Kaler, who testified that the transition plan maximizes change in STUDENT’s school day. As discussed above, both parties agree that STUDENT requires structure and consistency. Dr. Kaler stated that enrolling STUDENT in two programs would present him with new people, a new location, and disruptions during the school day that would confuse him. Although Dr. Kaler acknowledged that STUDENT’s placement at the Elliott Institute in January 2001 did not involve a transition plan but he was able to successfully transition, she commented that STUDENT handled the transition well because he was transitioning to an appropriate program. The Student’s other expert witness, Dr. Silvertsen, also testified that the transition would confuse STUDENT.
The District witnesses testified that the District’s plan is appropriate to address STUDENT’s difficulty with change and transitions. Dr. Taubman, the psychologist who assessed STUDENT’s behaviors on behalf of the District, agreed that the transition to public school will be difficult for STUDENT. Specifically, he said that the transition would involve a new setting, new staff, and a new approach to instruction. However, Dr. Taubman stated that the transition plan would provide greater comfort to STUDENT by easing him into the new placement rather than changing the entire placement all at once. In any event, Dr. Taubman testified that the supports are in place for STUDENT, but they are not essential for him to transition to Lupin Hill.
Ms. Cummings, the teacher of the SDC, testified that she has already observed STUDENT at the Elliott Institute, has assessed him, has spoken to his teacher, and has participated in discussions with his IEP team regarding his educational needs. Thus, she testified that she already has a lot of information regarding STUDENT that would enable her to facilitate his transition into her class. Additionally, Ms. Cummings pointed out that the IEP provides for additional support for the transition, including team meetings with all of STUDENT’s educational providers, parents, and Elliott Institute staff to facilitate and monitor the transition. The supports also would include consultations with the clinical psychologist and the daily communication logs between the school and the PARENTS. Finally, Ms. Cummings testified that STUDENT’s transition into her class would occur at natural breaks in the daily class schedule.
Similarly, Dr. Freeman testified that the offered transition plan provides for STUDENT to transfer from one school to the other during the natural breaks in the school day. She also testified that the supports in place would enable the entire team to monitor STUDENT’s progress and promptly make alterations to the transition plan as needed. Although Dr. Freeman was of the opinion that STUDENT could transition to Lupin Hills successfully without a gradual transition so long as there are supports in place to address any difficulty he might experience, she testified that the transition plan offered by the District is appropriate for STUDENT.
For the same reasons articulated above, the Hearing Officer does not find the testimony of Dr. Kaler and Dr. Silvertsen persuasive regarding STUDENT’s transition to Lupin Hills. Specifically, neither witness observed the Lupin Hills placement or had any significant information regarding the placement on which to base their opinion about STUDENT’s transition into the class. Because the District witnesses all assessed STUDENT, observed him at Elliott, spoke with his educational providers, and have detailed knowledge of the Lupin Hills placement, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony more persuasive as to STUDENT’s transition between the two programs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offered transition plan is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
****
In conclusion, the District’s offer to STUDENT included goals and objectives, placement, and transition plan that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Additionally, the offered IEP included sufficient parental participation to carry over STUDENT’s instruction into the home environment and actively involve the PARENTS as members of STUDENT’s educational team.
3. Would STUDENT’s Program Comport With the District’s Offer?
Finally, the Student contends that the transition plan cannot be implemented because the Elliott Institute does not allow students to attend part-time. At hearing, MOTHER testified that she spoke with Alicia Elliott, an administrator at the Elliott Institute, regarding whether it was possible to enroll STUDENT on a part-time basis. According to MOTHER, she was told that the Elliott Institute would not contract with the District for funding of STUDENT’s part-time attendance. Particularly, the District cannot simply pay for the hours that STUDENT attends the Elliott Institute. No other evidence was presented at hearing to either corroborate or contest MOTHER’s statements. Although MOTHER’s testimony was not disputed, her testimony is hearsay evidence. Pursuant to section 3082 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, a hearing officer cannot make a finding based solely on hearsay evidence that would not otherwise be admissible over objection in a court of law. Thus, the Hearing Officer cannot rely on MOTHER’s testimony alone to support a finding that the District’s transition plan cannot be implemented.
Moreover, at hearing, the District asserted that it was willing and able to implement the proposed program. There is no dispute that STUDENT may attend the Elliot Institute during the transition period under different funding arrangements. Even if true, MOTHER’s testimony fails to establish that the offered program cannot be implemented if the funding issue is resolved. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is willing and able to implement the June 2004 IEP. In offering part-time placement to STUDENT for the period during which he transitions to Lupin Hills, the District has agreed to make whatever financial arrangements are necessary with the Elliot Institute to implement the proposed program.
****
In conclusion, it was found above that the District made STUDENT a written offer of placement consistent with special education law, including the requirements set forth in Union. Additionally, it was found above that the District’s offer contained appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, placement, and transition plan. Additionally, the District’s proposed program, including the transition plan, can be implemented. Accordingly, it is found above that the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and would comport with his IEP. Hence, the District’s June 2004 offer is an offer of FAPE.
ORDER
1. If STUDENT’s parents want him to be provided a publicly funded educational program through the Las Virgenes Unified School District, they must make him available for the special education services outlined in the District’s June 2, 2004 IEP, as clarified by the June 16 letter.
2. The District shall remain ready and able to implement all portions of the June 2, 2004 IEP, as amended by the June 16 letter, if the PARENTS to wish avail themselves of an education for STUDENT through the District.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: August 30, 2004 Van T. Vu, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
Although the Student raised a number of other contentions for the first time in his closing brief, those contentions were not raised in his statement of issues or at the beginning of the hearing during the issue clarification. Because the contentions were not raised at either of these times, they will not be considered in this Decision.
2 Under State and federal law, a special education student is entitled to remain in his or her present educational placement pending the completion of a due process procedure unless the parents and the public educational agency agree otherwise. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d); 20 U.S.C. § 1415; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District, 695 F.2d 949, 953(5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Ambach, 694 F.2d 904(2d Cir. 1989). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.”
3 Pursuant to paragraph G of the May 13, 2004 settlement agreement, the District agreed to provide the PARENTS with the assessment reports by May 29, 2004. Mr. Crook testified at hearing that, according to the “best of [his] recollection,” the reports were faxed to his office the Friday before Memorial Day, which was May 28, 2004.
4 The 1997 Amendments to the IDEA also included other requirements that are not at issue in this case. For example, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).
5 The Student made no allegation that the District’s offer was not in the least restrictive environment. Accordingly, this Decision will not analyze this requirement of FAPE as it pertains to STUDENT. In fact, the Student contends that his behaviors prohibit him from being moved from the Elliott Institute, a nonpublic school that serves only children with special needs. (Dist. Ex. 200.) Therefore, in comparison, the District’s proposed placement at Lupin Hill,s is a comprehensive elementary school with opportunities for interaction with nondisabled children, is less restrictive than the preferred placement of the Student.
6 Student Closing Brief at page 41.
7 Dist. Ex. 181 at p. HB01395.
8 See IEP transcripts at Dist. Ex. 202 at p. HB01669.
9 See IEP transcripts at Dist. Ex. 202 at p. HB01671.
10 See Student Ex. A13, A16-A18, 225, 226, 256, and 258-262; Dist. Ex. 160, 172, 175-179; Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Silvertsen, Dr. Kaler, Dr. Taubman, Dr. Freeman, Ms. Cummings, and Ms. Guillory.
11 See Testimony of Dr. Freeman, Dist. Ex. 175 at p. HB01356, and Student Ex. 13 at p. 69.
12 Dist. Ex. 195.
13 Student Ex. C.
14 Dr. Kaler, the Student’s witness, testified that she found the information on STUDENT from Dr. Freeman’s administration of the Mullen “helpful.”
15 Student Ex. A18 at pg. 87.
16 Student Ex. A18 at p. 87.
17 Student Ex. 161 at p. 1.
18 However, as is discussed below, the parties dispute whether the goals and objectives are sufficiently challenging. The Student asserts that his goals and objectives are not sufficiently challenging because they emphasize generalization and independent use of functional skills rather than the acquisition of new skills and general knowledge.
19 Ms. Peloquin did not testify at hearing.
20 Testimony of Dr. Taubman.
21 See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56322, 56324.
22 See testimony of Drs. Leaf, Taubman, and Freeman.
23 Dist. Ex. 183 at p. HB01406; testimony of Ms. Cummings.
24 The Student also contends that the transition plan cannot be implemented. The Hearing Officer evaluates this contention under subsection B(3) below.
