California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 23, 2004

Student v. Long Beach Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1624-04 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

Long Beach Unified denied FAPE to preschooler with autism; must reimburse home ABA costs and fund Lovaas Institute supervision.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Long Beach Unified School District filed for due process in June 2004, asking for a ruling that its April 23, 2004 IEP offered a FAPE. The parents of a preschool-age boy with autism filed in July, and the cases were consolidated. The parents were paying for about 40 hours a week of in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) discrete trial training, supervised by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE). The District offered 25 hours a week of in-home ABA and four hours a week of ABA in a special day class at Tincher Elementary. Over the year, class time would grow to 20 hours while home services dropped to nine. The District also offered 10 hours a month of supervision.

The Hearing Officer found that the offer denied a FAPE. The IEP's present levels left out the boy's need for constant prompting and his problem and self-stimulatory behaviors, and the District offered no behavior plan. Many goals were too advanced, too easy, or missing. After two years of therapy he had made little progress. He needed at least 40 hours a week of in-home training and lacked the basic skills to benefit from a classroom. The supervision offered was not based on his needs. The IEP meeting also lacked anyone qualified to provide or supervise ABA, which seriously limited the father's participation. The District must reimburse the parents' ABA costs from June 16, 2004. Through April 23, 2005, it must fund LIFE supervision, with District instructors taking over after an overlap period.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated the IEP team member who must be qualified to provide or supervise instruction under Education Code section 56341(b)(4) when ABA was the core of the offer. It also shows how the certified-nonpublic-agency limit in section 56505.2 shaped the remedy: the Hearing Officer kept the agency's supervision but ordered District staff to replace the instructors the parents had hired.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. For the time period of June 16, 2004, through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005, did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education?

    The April 23, 2004 IEP denied a FAPE. It identified no need for a behavior plan, had inaccurate present levels and deficient goals, offered too little in-home ABA (25 hours when 40 were needed), offered a classroom placement the child could not yet benefit from, and offered supervision not based on his needs. The lack of an IEP team member qualified to provide or supervise ABA seriously infringed on parent participation.

  2. Issue 2. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the applied behavioral analysis (ABA) services they have privately funded from June 16, 2004, through the date of this Decision?

    The LIFE-supervised ABA program directly replaced the services the District failed to offer and was appropriate. The parents are entitled to reimbursement for LIFE supervision and training and for the instructors they hired, from June 16, 2004, through the decision date.

  3. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. If the District did not offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education, what is his appropriate placement for the time period from the date of this Decision through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005?

    The student needs 40 hours a week of in-home ABA/DTT and no classroom placement yet. The District must fund LIFE supervision and training through April 23, 2005. Because the parent-hired instructors are not certified nonpublic agency staff, the District will supply the instructors under LIFE supervision, as the District requested.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. The District must reimburse the parents for the total cost of the ABA program (LIFE supervision and training plus parent-hired instructors) from June 16, 2004, through the decision date. Payment is due within 20 calendar days after the parents submit proof of costs.
  • Order to provide or change services. From the decision date through the anticipated annual IEP date of April 23, 2005, the District must fund LIFE's training and supervision of the in-home ABA/DTT program. The program must continue to address the goals and objectives drafted by LIFE case supervisor Mandy Juarez. District personnel will serve as instructors under LIFE's ongoing supervision and training, after an overlap period with the current instructors whose length LIFE will set.
  • Reimbursement. Through the end of the overlap period, the District must continue to reimburse the parents for the privately provided instructors, within 20 calendar days after the parents submit proof of costs.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must continue to offer and provide OT, speech/language services, and PECS instruction as offered in the April 23, 2004 IEP.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Honig v. Doe; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Cleveland Heights-University Heights City School Dist. v. Boss; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Nettie Miller, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor); District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Susan Yee, special day class teacher; District witness, Tincher Elementary School, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Rebecca Duarte, District autism coordinator; District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Sue Campbell, special education team leader; District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Susan Melly, SELPA administrator (attended hearing for District), Long Beach Unified School District SELPA
  • Tim Prior, proposed District autism supervisor, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Mandy Juarez, LIFE case supervisor; witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Scott Cross, LIFE director of clinical services; witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Dr. Melanie Lenington, clinical psychologist; private assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Dr. Lisa Doi, diagnosing evaluator (autism diagnosis, 2002)
  • Dr. Rita Eagle, Regional Center psychologist, Regional Center
  • Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), certified nonpublic agency; ABA supervision provider
  • Autism Behavior Consultants (ABC), prior ABA provider
  • Autism Spectrum Therapies (AST), private behavioral intervention provider (Regional Center referral)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, the University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Long Beach, California, on October 12, 13 and 14, 2004.

STUDENT was represented by attorney Bruce Bothwell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his father, FATHER. The Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Justin Shinnefield. Also present on the District’s behalf was Susan Melly, SELPA administrator.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Nettie Miller, school psychologist; Susan Yee, special day class teacher; Rebecca Duarte, District autism coordinator; and Sue Campbell, District special education team leader. The Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mandy Juarez, LIFE case supervisor; Scott Cross, LIFE director of clinical services; Dr. Melanie Lenington, clinical psychologist; and FATHER, STUDENT’s father.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the submission of written closing arguments the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing, during the discussion of the issues, the STUDENT argued that the time period at issue extended back to March 26, 2004. The District argued that the parties’ prior settlement agreement had resolved all issues through June 16, 2004, the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year. The STUDENT also raised issues in relation to the District’s offer of occupational therapy (OT), speech/language (S/L) services, and reimbursement for an assessment performed by Dr. Lenington.

Following a discussion between the parties, outside the presence of the Hearing Officer, the STUDENT withdrew all issues relating to the time period from March 26, 2004 through June 16, 2004. The parties agreed that the time period at issue in this case was from June 16, 2004, the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year, through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005. The STUDENT also withdrew all issues relating to the District’s offer of OT and S/L services. It was stipulated on the record that the District’s offer of OT and S/L services contained in the April 23, 2004 IEP was appropriate for STUDENT.

Following the conclusion of the hearing, the STUDENT notified the District and the Hearing Officer that he also was withdrawing the issue of reimbursement for Dr. Lenington’s assessment.

On the basis of the agreements reached on the first day of hearing, and the STUDENT’s subsequent withdrawal of the assessment issue, the following is a statement of the issues presented for hearing.

ISSUES

1. For the time period of June 16, 2004, through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005, did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education?

2. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the applied behavioral analysis (ABA) services they have privately funded from June 16, 2004, through the date of this Decision?

3. If the District did not offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education, what is his appropriate placement for the time period from the date of this Decision through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT was born on [date redacted], and has been diagnosed with autism. STUDENT lives with his parents, who reside within the geographic boundaries of the Long Beach Unified School District. STUDENT is not currently attending a District school. At parent expense, he is receiving approximately forty hours a week of in-home applied behavioral analysis (ABA) therapy in the form of one-on-one discrete trial training (DTT) under the supervision of the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE).

STUDENT was first diagnosed as autistic by Dr. Lisa Doi in March 2002, at the age of one year, eleven months. Dr. Doi found that STUDENT exhibited a marked impairment in the use of nonverbal behaviors, had failed to develop age appropriate peer relationships, and had a lack of social and emotional reciprocity. In addition, STUDENT demonstrated a quantitative impairment in communication as evidenced by a lack of development of spoken language, stereotyped and repetitive use of idiosyncratic language, and a lack of make-believe or social imitative play. STUDENT also exhibited restricted, repetitive, and stereotyped patterns of behavior. Dr. Doi was not able to determine STUDENT’s level of cognitive ability.

On the basis of Dr. Doi’s evaluation, the Regional Center referred STUDENT to Autism Spectrum Therapies (AST) for services. AST recommended ten to fifteen hours a week of intensive, naturalistic behavioral intervention, such as pivotal response training. The PARENTS did not agree with the amount of hours recommended or the type of therapy recommended. In November 2002, Autism Behavior Consultants (ABC) began providing STUDENT with twenty hours a week of behavioral intervention in the form of discrete trial training (DTT) funded by the Regional Center. In an assessment dated January 17, 2003, ABC found that STUDENT had made significant progress, but that his overall cognitive functioning was significantly delayed. ABC recommended increasing STUDENT’s treatment to thirty-two hours a week of direct services in addition to eight hours of supervision. STUDENT’s treatment was to primarily involve in home one-on-one intensive behavioral therapy. The Regional Center convened an Individual/Family Service Plan (IFSP) meeting on March 24, 2003. The Regional Center psychologist, Dr. Rita Eagle, reviewed STUDENT’s record and found that STUDENT had not made significant progress. Dr. Eagle compared STUDENT’s baseline from November 2002 with the present levels in January 2003 and concluded that STUDENT had improved very little. Dr. Eagle recommended increasing STUDENT’s ABA hours by nine hours a week for a total of twenty-nine hours a week, twenty-five of which would be one-on-one DTT and fours hours would be in Sunday school to allow STUDENT to interact with typical peers.

In April 2003, the District completed its initial assessment of STUDENT. The assessment concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive ability was in the significantly below average range. The assessor found that STUDENT had virtually no imitation skills. STUDENT’s receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language skills were all significantly delayed with a very limited repertoire of sounds. STUDENT demonstrated significant under registration of sensory input and delayed fine motor skill development. STUDENT was reported to be dependent in all areas of self-help. STUDENT demonstrated severe deficits in behavior. For example, STUDENT did not initiate social interactions, did not respond to the examiner’s voice, made minimal eye contact, only cooperated with maximum prompts and motoring, did not engage in any exploration of his environment, and demonstrated an exceptionally fleeting attention span.

STUDENT’s initial District IEP meeting was held over three days in April, May, and June 2003. The final IEP offered twenty hours a week in a language-based prekindergarten class with ABA therapy, two hours a week of individual speech/language (S/L) therapy, ninety minutes a week of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT) plus an additional sixty minutes a month of consultation by the occupational therapist. The offer also included twelve hours a week of home/school ABA therapy provided by District personnel. The PARENTS declined the District’s offer.

In June 2003, Dr. Lenington, a clinical psychologist, completed an assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Lenington’s report indicates that the PARENTS had sought a private assessment of STUDENT’s skills to help them determine an appropriate treatment program for him. Dr. Lenington found that STUDENT was easily distracted by the environment and by his own self-stimulatory behaviors. STUDENT had a limited ability to attend and was not eager to engage with either the examiner or his parents. In addition, STUDENT was nonverbal, with no reliable communication system. Physical prompts were required for compliance. Furthermore, STUDENT did not display any functional, representational, or imaginary play, and did not have well-developed imitation skills. Dr. Lenington recommended that STUDENT’s program include forty hours a week of one-on-one ABA therapy combined with OT and S/L therapy. In addition, Dr. Lenington suggested the use of the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) to help STUDENT develop a means of communication. Dr. Lenington also recommended the inclusion of treatment team meetings to ensure consistency across all environments. Finally, Dr. Lenington stated that STUDENT would benefit from exposure to typically developing peers in a school setting at some point, but that she believed he was not yet ready for such a placement due to his lack of basic skills.

In September 2003, the PARENTS filed for due process. The PARENTS and the District resolved that matter through a written settlement agreement dated October 16, 2003. Under that agreement, STUDENT was to receive twenty-five hours of in-home ABA therapy provided by ABC. STUDENT would also attend a special day class (SDC) at Tincher Elementary School (Tincher) for two hours a day, two days a week. In addition, ABC would provide an additional nine hours a month of supervision of the ABA services, which would include one hour of monthly clinic meetings to be held at Tincher.

In a progress report dated December 1, 2003, ABC noted that STUDENT was responding to therapy, but that progress had been slow in many areas. STUDENT had shown progress in self-help, identifying body parts, matching, and nonverbal imitations. However, STUDENT had also shown an increase in task avoidance and inappropriate behaviors. As a result, ABC recommended increasing STUDENT’s ABA therapy to forty hours a week.

STUDENT’s next IEP meeting was on February 13, 2004. The team reviewed the terms of the settlement agreement and continued to offer a total of twenty-nine hours a week of ABA services, twenty-five in home and four in the school setting. The offer also provided for two hours a week of S/L, ninety minutes a week of OT, and one hour a month of OT consultation. The team also discussed increasing STUDENT’s classroom time from four hours a week up to a maximum of twenty hours a week by adding two hours a week starting in March. The PARENTS did not accept the District’s offer but agreed to consider it and notify the District within two weeks. STUDENT began attending Ms. Yee’s SDC at Tincher on February 18, 2004. Ms. Yee’s class was a “co-enrollment” class with nine autistic children and seven typically developing children. (Footnote 1) By letter dated February 26, 2004, the PARENTS’ attorney requested that the District amend STUDENT’s IEP to include the nine hours of supervision called for by the settlement agreement, and notified the District that the PARENTS believed it was too soon to discuss increasing STUDENT’s classroom time.

By letter dated March 19, 2004, the PARENTS’ attorney notified the District that the PARENTS intended to change STUDENT’s ABA provider from ABC to LIFE. Three days later, on March 22, 2004, Ms. Yee notified the parents of her students that she was discontinuing the co-enrollment in her class on April 30 due to safety concerns. Ms. Yee’s letter stated that the growing number of autistic children made it unmanageable when combined with the typically developing students. (Footnote 2) FATHER testified that, as a result of Ms. Yee’s letter, he and MOTHER decided to withdraw STUDENT from Ms. Yee's class. FATHER explained that the opportunity for STUDENT to attend a class with typically developing peers was the primary reason they had agreed to placement in Ms. Yee’s class. STUDENT’s last day in Ms. Yee’s class was on March 26, 2004; he had attended a total of nine days.

LIFE performed a three-day initial workshop/consultation for STUDENT from March 26 through March 28. LIFE recommended forty hours of in-home one-on-one behavioral intervention and included a behavior plan for reducing inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors. LIFE also recommended weekly or bi-weekly staff meetings to ensure consistency in STUDENT’s program. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT began receiving ABA services supervised by LIFE. (Footnote 3)

An IEP team meeting was convened on April 5, 2004, to discuss the parents’ request that LIFE provide the supervision of the ABA services. The PARENTS stated that they wanted LIFE to provide the supervision because ABC had not been consistently able to cover the entire twenty-nine hours of ABA called for in STUDENT’s IEP and because ABC had changed STUDENT’s supervisor several times. The District offered to provide its own instructors and an autism supervisor to provide STUDENT’s program. The IEP notes state that the District’s proposed autism supervisor was “Lovaas trained.” The PARENTS stated that they would prefer that LIFE provide the supervision. The District reiterated its offer pursuant to the February 13, 2004 IEP, which it believed was an offer of a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). The IEP meeting ended without agreement between the District and the PARENTS.

In April 2004, the District completed an assessment of STUDENT in preparation for his annual IEP meeting. Nettie Miller, a school psychologist, performed the psycho-educational portion of the assessment. In terms of cognitive ability, Ms. Miller concluded that STUDENT was functioning in the significantly below average range. During her assessment, she observed STUDENT to pick up toys for only a few seconds, but not play with them. He only attended to activities momentarily, did not respond to his name, and had fleeting and infrequent eye contact. Ms. Miller found that STUDENT’s pre-academic skills were at an age equivalence of twenty-two months, his self-help skills were at an age equivalence of eighteen months, his social skills were at an age equivalence of twenty months, and his fine/gross motor skills were at an age equivalence of 22 months. Ms. Miller recommended a program that included time in a structured small-group setting and opportunities to be with typically developing peers.

STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was convened on April 23, 2004. The District’s offer was very similar to the offer made in February 2004. The offer included placement in Ms. Yee’s co-enrolled SDC for two days a week, two hours a day, with a transition plan to increase the hours over the duration of the IEP to a maximum of twenty hours a week. ABA services were to be provided by District personnel and included twenty-nine hours a week, twenty-five hours of in-home services and four hours in school. In addition, ten hours a month of supervision were included. Pursuant to the transition plan, as STUDENT’s time in the SDC class increased, his home ABA services would be decreased. At the end of the transition, STUDENT would be in class for twenty hours a week and his home ABA program would be reduced to nine hours a week. S/L, OT, a PECS program and extended school year services were also part of the offer. The need for a behavior plan was discussed, but the District members of the team agreed that such a plan was not necessary. STUDENT’s LIFE case supervisor, who was in attendance, voiced her concern that STUDENT was not yet ready for an in-school program. The PARENTS did not accept the District’s offer.

Following the April 23 IEP meeting, STUDENT continued to receive forty hours a week of in-home DTT supervised by LIFE. STUDENT did not enroll at Tincher for the 2004-2005 school year. In June 2004, the District filed a due process hearing request seeking a determination that it had offered STUDENT a FAPE at the April 23 IEP meeting. In July, the PARENTS also filed a due process hearing request. The two requests were later consolidated and are the subject of this hearing.

In August 2004, Dr. Lenington completed a second assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Lenington found improvements in all areas, but stated that STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of basic self-help skills, attending skills, language processing, and expressive language. She also stated that, since she had first seen STUDENT, he had been diagnosed with a co-morbid seizure disorder. (Footnote 4) While noting many improvements, Dr. Lenington continued to believe that STUDENT was not yet ready for a school-based program and recommended that he continue to receive forty hours a week of in-home ABA therapy.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The STUDENT contends that the District’s offer contained in the April 23, 2004 IEP did not constitute a FAPE either substantively or procedurally. Substantively, the STUDENT argues that the goals and objectives in District’s offer were not appropriate because they did not address all of STUDENT’s unique needs. Furthermore, the amount of hours of ABA therapy offered, twenty-nine hours total, was insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. The STUDENT also argues that the ABA program itself was not appropriate because the offer did not provide for adequate supervision or staff meetings to ensure consistency in the implementation of STUDENT’s program, and that the District failed to establish that its personnel were qualified to implement an appropriate ABA program. In addition, the STUDENT contends that the offer of a classroom placement was not appropriate for STUDENT because he was not able to benefit from such a placement, and that the IEP should have contained a plan for transitioning STUDENT’s program from the LIFE providers to District staff.

Procedurally, the STUDENT contends that the District failed to have the necessary personnel present at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting because there was no one from the District who was qualified to provide or supervise the ABA program, which constituted the majority of the District’s offer. The STUDENT argues that this failure denied FATHER his right to meaningfully participate in the IEP process and amounted to a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 5)

As a result of the District’s alleged denial of FAPE, the STUDENT contends that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the ABA services they have funded, including the supervision by LIFE, during the time period at issue. In addition, the STUDENT argues that the District should be ordered to prospectively fund costs of STUDENT’s ABA program, including the instructors hired by the PARENTS.

The District contends that its offer as set forth in the April 23, 2004 IEP constituted a FAPE. Specifically, the District argues that the IEP team developed goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT’s areas of need and that the level of services offered was calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The District argues that the forty hours a week recommended by LIFE and requested by the PARENTS is beyond what is required by the IDEA. In addition, the District contends that its offer represented placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. In relation to the STUDENT’s procedural argument, the District contends that the April 23, 2004 IEP team included all of the required personnel.

As to STUDENT’s prospective placement, the District makes several alternative arguments: (1) its offer is a FAPE, (2) if its offer is not a FAPE, the proper remedy is to order the District back to an IEP meeting to correct its failure, or (3) with respect to continuing to fund the services from LIFE, the law prohibits the Hearing Officer from ordering the District to fund instructors who are not employed by a certified nonpublic agency. In relation to the third alternative, the District argues that the proper resolution would be to allow the District to use its personnel to provide the ABA; the personnel would be trained and supervised by LIFE.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. For the time period of June 16, 1004, through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005, did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3d Cir. 1988).

In Board of Educ. of Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle School Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the proposed educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum, (3) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, (4) conform with the student’s IEP, and (5) provide placement in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer must consider whether the necessary procedural requirements were adhered to. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. In this case, the STUDENT is alleging that the District’s offer was both substantively and procedurally inappropriate. This Decision will first analyze the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer.

Did the District Substantively Deny STUDENT a FAPE?

Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The first step is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were in April, 2004. There is no dispute that, as a result of his autism, STUDENT had significant deficits in all areas. The assessments of school psychologist Lettie Miller, Dr. Melanie Lenington, and LIFE all agreed that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of behavior/social skills, play skills, maintaining attention to task, pre-academic skills, self-help skills, fine/gross motor skills, imitation skills, receptive language skills, and expressive language skills. More specifically, STUDENT did not seek out interaction with others, had a very limited attention span, did not engage in reciprocal play, did not engage in functional play, was not independent in any self-help activities, was not toilet trained, did not appreciate dangers or discriminate between edible and nonedible items, did not have age appropriate fine or gross motor skills, did not display any consistent verbal or nonverbal imitation skills, did not respond to most verbal commands, and had no consistent means of communication. As a result of these deficits, STUDENT needed S/L therapy, OT, training in some form of communication, and intensive one-on-one researched-based behavioral therapy to improve his basic skills. STUDENT also needed to have a high degree of consistency in the implantation of his program across all environments, and extended school year services to prevent regression. These needs were undisputed. The primary dispute related to the amount of amount of behavioral therapy and whether STUDENT required small group instruction. For reasons that will be discussed more fully later, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require small group instruction to meet his unique needs.

In addition, there was a dispute among the various assessors in relation to STUDENT’s inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors. Ms. Miller did not identify this as an area of deficit for STUDENT. However, Dr. Lenington and LIFE both found that STUDENT displayed inappropriate behaviors in the form of crying, tantruming, physical resistance, slapping, and escape behaviors. In relation to self-stimulation, LIFE noted that STUDENT would slap at surfaces, remove his socks, and put his hands down his pants. Inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors similar to those noted by LIFE had also been observed by ABC during the time period it had been serving STUDENT. In fact, ABC had noted an increase in those behaviors in the later part of 2003. Considering STUDENT’s history as documented by the progress reports from ABC, and the evaluations of Dr. Lenington and LIFE, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors. In order to meet those deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required a behavior plan that focused on eliminating his inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors.

The next question is whether the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. To answer this question, one must look at the District’s offer as contained in the April 23, 2004 IEP. The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988). The IEP must include a statement of the student’s present levels of performance, goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with non-disabled children to the maximum extent possible. Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.

Present Levels of Performance

The IEP noted that STUDENT had some matching, sorting, and sequencing skills and could imitate vertical and horizontal lines from a model. It also stated that STUDENT had limited attention and only fleeting and infrequent eye contact. In relation to self-help, the IEP stated that STUDENT needed assistance to dress, was not toilet trained, eats with a spoon, but not other utensils, and was able to put on a jacket and take off his shoes and socks. It also indicated that STUDENT could make transitions with assistance, but needed maximum prompts to complete a task. In the area of fine/gross motor skills, the IEP noted that STUDENT was beginning to cut, could copy lines, was able to jump and climb, and had good balance and increased tolerance for sensory input. As to communication skills, it was stated that STUDENT could follow some simple commands, responds to approximately twenty signs or gestures, but only used a few gestures to indicate his needs or desires, and had a limited repertoire of sounds. These present levels of performance were consistent with those noted by LIFE and FATHER.

There was disagreement regarding STUDENT’s behavior and social-emotional skills. The IEP indicated that STUDENT would pick up toys, but not play with them and required physical and verbal prompts to sit for a maximum of two minutes. These levels were not disputed. However, the IEP also stated that STUDENT had been able to sit through “circle time” in class without fusing, was able to transition using a picture schedule, engaged in parallel play, participated in small-group activities, and tolerated play with peers. The Hearing Officer finds that these descriptions are not accurate. According to the testimony Ms. Yee, the classroom teacher, STUDENT required physical and verbal prompts, often hand-over-hand prompts, to accomplish each of these actions. Although Ms. Yee had limited experience working with STUDENT—he had only been in her class for a total of nine days—she was the only witness who had had an opportunity to observe STUDENT in class. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Yee’s testimony is credible as to STUDENT’s need for prompting in class. Furthermore, the IEP does not describe any inappropriate or self-stimulatory behaviors. It has already been found that inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors were an ongoing problem for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that the April 23, 2004 IEP did not contain an accurate statement of STUDENT’s present levels of performance to the extent that the IEP failed to state that STUDENT required physical and verbal prompts to participate in classroom activities, and most important, failed to describe any of STUDENT’s inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors.

Goals and Objectives

The District drafted goals involving matching, counting/sequencing, coloring in shapes, nonverbal imitation, returning greetings with appropriate eye contact, task completion, communication, verbal imitation, following commands using prepositions, identifying nouns and verbs in pictures, cutting with scissors, identifying colors, identifying shapes, engaging in imitative toy play, complying with requests to participate in non-preferred activities, turn-taking, and following a toileting routine. Ms. Yee testified that she drafted the majority of the District’s goals. Ms. Yee, Ms. Duarte, Ms. Campbell, and Ms. Miller all testified that they believed that that District had drafted goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT’s areas of deficit.

Mandy Juarez, STUDENT’s case supervisor at LIFE, had drafted her own proposed goals for STUDENT, which she had presented at the April 23 IEP meeting. At the hearing, she testified that some of the District’s goals were addressing skills too advanced for STUDENT, others were at levels STUDENT had already achieved, and some important skills were either under-addressed or not addressed at all. Specifically, Ms. Juarez stated that goals for understanding prepositions and turn taking were too advanced for STUDENT. She explained that turn taking was an interactive play skill, and not an appropriate goal for a child who had yet to demonstrate appropriate independent play. Regarding the District’s goals for identifying nouns and verbs, cutting, and matching, Ms. Juarez testified that the skills addressed were all important for STUDENT, but that the District’s goals were too low. For example, the Districts goal for learning nouns only required STUDENT to learn ten new nouns during the entire year. Ms. Juarez also testified that the District had not properly addressed STUDENT’s ability to maintain eye contact and engage in nonverbal imitation. Ms. Juarez noted that eye contact was important in establishing learning readiness, but the IEP only addressed this skill in relation to greetings. Ms. Juarez also stated that the IEP contained only one goal that involved nonverbal imitation -- goal number four, which required STUDENT to imitate hand and body movements to a song. Ms. Juarez testified that, in her experience, nonverbal imitation was a cornerstone of learning for autistic children and that STUDENT’s IEP needed to more directly address this skill. Ms. Juarez also testified that the IEP contained no goals that directly addressed STUDENT’s need to learn to identify people in his environment, learn to understand instructions, learn categories, learn appropriate independent play, learn appropriate parallel play, reduce inappropriate behaviors, reduce self-stimulatory behaviors, learn independent dressing and undressing, or learn eating skills.

Having reviewed the April 23, 2004 IEP, and considering Ms. Juarez’s experience in working with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Juarez’s testimony regarding the District’s goals and objectives persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to draft goals and objectives to appropriately address all of STUDENT’s areas of deficit. The District’s goals for learning turn taking and prepositions were too advanced for STUDENT. The proposed goals addressing STUDENT’s need to learn to identify nouns and verbs, develop cutting skills, and learn matching skills were too low. The District’s goals also failed to adequately address STUDENT’s need to learn to maintain eye contact, and learn nonverbal imitation skills. Furthermore, the District failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s need to learn to identify people in his environment, learn to understand instructions, learn categories, learn appropriate independent play, learn appropriate parallel play, reduce inappropriate behaviors, reduce self-stimulatory behaviors, learn independent dressing and undressing skills, and learn eating skills.

Special Education and Related Services

The District offered ninety minutes a week of OT, sixty minutes a month of OT consultation, sixty minutes a week of S/L services, and forty minutes a week of instruction in PECS. It was undisputed that these services meet STUDENT’s needs for OT, S/L services, and instruction in a system of communication. In addition, the District offered ESY services. The ESY services were for the continuation of STUDENT’s ABA program during the extended school year. Because the issue regarding the ESY program was the same as for the regular school year, the ESY program will not be addressed separately.

The parties’ disagreement involved the District’s offer of ABA/DTT services and class placement. In was undisputed that ABA in general, and DTT specifically, was the appropriate form of instruction to meet STUDENT’s needs. The dispute involved that amount of ABA and the setting for the instruction – home or school. The District offered twenty-five hours of home ABA/DTT instruction and fours hours of classroom ABA therapy in Ms. Yee’s SDC. Pursuant to the IEP, during the one-year duration of the IEP, STUDENT would transition into greater classroom time and reduced home instruction until he was in class for twenty hours a week and receiving only nine hours of home instruction. The District also offered 10 hours of supervision to ensure consistency in the implementation of STUDENT’s program. The Student contends that STUDENT required forty hours of home instruction and that a classroom placement was not appropriate for STUDENT at that time. In addition, the Student contends that the kind of supervision offered was not adequate to ensure consistency. The amount of hours for home instruction, the classroom placement, and the supervision will each be examined separately.

Amount of Home ABA Therapy

The dispute in this area did not involve the type of services, but the amount. Both parties agreed that STUDENT needed some amount of intensive in-home ABA/DTT. The dispute involved the amount of DTT that STUDENT required to meet his needs. Ms. Duarte, the District autism coordinator, stated that the District had offered twenty-five hours of in-home DTT because that level of services is what ABC had been providing and STUDENT had made progress at that level. The Hearing Officer finds that the record does not support Ms. Duarte’s reasoning. Since STUDENT began receiving services, he had made minimal progress. In January 2003, ABC’s assessment found that STUDENT had made little progress and recommended increasing the amount of STUDENT’s in-home one-on-one DTT from twenty hours a week to thirty-two hours a week; however, the Regional Center only approved an increase to twenty-nine hours a week. In April 2003, ABC recommended that STUDENT continue to receive twenty-nine hours of home DTT. In STUDENT’s initial IEP in June 2003, the District had offered only twelve hours of home DTT. In October 2003, in settlement of the prior due process filing, the PARENTS and the District agreed on twenty-five hours of home DTT supplemented by four hours of ABA therapy in a classroom setting. In December 2003, ABC noted that STUDENT had made slow progress in most areas and recommended increasing his home DTT to forty hours a week. ABC’s conclusion that STUDENT had made little progress is supported by comparing Ms. Miller’s April 2004 assessment with Dr. Doi’s March 2002 assessment. In 2002, Dr. Doi noted that STUDENT did not demonstrate functional play, had minimal responsiveness, and a limited attention span. STUDENT did not imitate any tasks modeled by the examiner and had very limited vocalizations. In April 2004, Ms. Miller noted that STUDENT still did not demonstrate functional play, had minimal responsiveness, and had a very limited attention span. During Ms. Miller’s assessment, STUDENT did not display any imitation skills and had limited vocalizations. Although the progress reports from ABC and reports of the PARENTS indicated that STUDENT had made some progress, in particular in the area of matching, the Hearing Officer is struck by the similarity of Ms. Miller’s observations to Dr. Doi’s despite two years of therapy. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had not made meaningful progress at his prior level of twenty-five hours a week of in-home DTT.

The Hearing Officer also notes that, of the District witnesses who testified at the hearing, only Ms. Yee and Ms. Miller had had any significant personal contact with STUDENT. (Footnote 6) Ms. Miller’s opinion is given little weight. Although Ms. Miller had assessed STUDENT, in her report she did not recommend any one-on-one ABA therapy; she only recommended small-group instruction. At the hearing, Ms. Miller admitted that STUDENT required some amount of ABA/DTT, but could not explain why she neglected to make a recommendation for this service in her report. Ms. Yee only had STUDENT in her class of sixteen students for a total of nine days, and had had a very limited opportunity to work with STUDENT on an individual basis. Neither Ms. Yee nor Ms. Miller had observed STUDENT in his home program. In contrast, Ms. Juarez had worked with STUDENT during an intensive three-day workshop in March 2003, and had been supervising his home program since that time. In addition, she had worked with STUDENT during bi-weekly clinic meetings and a monthly workshop meeting. Dr. Lenington has also had significant personal contact with STUDENT, having conducted two extensive evaluations. Furthermore, the opinions of Ms. Juarez and Dr. Lenington were supported at the hearing by the testimony of Scott Cross, the LIFE director of clinical services. Mr. Cross had worked with STUDENT and had attended staff meetings where Ms. Juarez had presented information regarding STUDENT’s program. Mr. Cross also testified to an extensive knowledge of recent research and literature on the subject of early intervention strategies for autistic children. Ms. Juarez, Dr. Lenington, and Mr. Cross all recommended that STUDENT receive forty hours a week of home-based DTT. Dr. Lenington testified that, on the basis of her assessments of STUDENT, and her review of the record, STUDENT was capable of learning, and that DTT was the appropriate methodology to address STUDENT’s needs. Mr. Cross agreed with Dr. Lenington and, on the basis of his review of substantial research on the subject, testified that in-home DTT was the appropriate methodology for addressing the needs of an autistic child such as STUDENT. Dr. Lenington testified convincingly that, on the basis of STUDENT’s age, his slow progress, and his level of impairments in all areas, the amount of DTT was very important.

The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Dr. Lenington, Mr. Cross and Ms. Juarez supports the conclusion that, for STUDENT, more is better. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires forty hours a week of in-home DTT was a minimum level of services to meet his needs and that the District’s offer of twenty-five hours was not designed to meet his unique needs.

Classroom Placement

The District offered four hours a week of ABA in Ms. Yee’s SDC. The District’s offer also contained a transition plan to increase STUDENT’s classroom time to a maximum of twenty hours a week during the one-year duration covered by the IEP. The Student contends that STUDENT was not ready for any classroom placement in April 2004.

Ms. Duarte and Ms. Campbell, the District’s special education team leader, both testified that the IEP team felt that a school placement was an important part of the District’s offer. Ms. Duarte stated that STUDENT had a need for social and peer interaction and required access to peers in order to address those needs. Ms. Campbell also stated that the District team members believed that a program that consisted entirely of home instruction was too isolating for STUDENT. Ms. Yee, STUDENT’s classroom teacher for nine days, stated that STUDENT had progressed in just the short time he had been in her class. She stated that when STUDENT first entered her class, he had been very withdrawn and hesitant to participate. Ms. Yee testified that, by the end of March, STUDENT was “coming out.” She stated that STUDENT was more aware of his environment, needed fewer prompts, and appeared to be gaining confidence. However, Ms. Yee also stated that, despite the improvement she had observed, STUDENT still only made fleeting and infrequent eye contact, did not initiate any interaction, had a limited attention span, and required prompting, often hand over hand, for any participation. Ms. Yee stated that she believed her class was appropriate for STUDENT because it gave him the opportunity for social interaction. As set forth in the previous section of this Decision, the Hearing Officer notes that the District witnesses had had limited experience with STUDENT and had not observed STUDENT in his home program and therefore their testimony is given little weight.

Ms. Juarez and Dr. Lenington both testified that, in April 2004, STUDENT did not have the necessary precursor skills to benefit from a classroom placement. The precursor skills that STUDENT was lacking included consistent attention, nonverbal imitation skills that would allow him to learn from modeling, the ability to understand and follow instructions, and some system of communication. Dr. Lenington testified that, given STUDENT’s level of impairment and his history of slow learning, he needed to be taught basic skills in a controlled, one-on-one setting before he would be ready to generalize those skills into a small- or large-group setting. She stated that STUDENT would receive little or no benefit from participation in a classroom setting until his skills were better developed. The opinions of Ms. Juarez and Dr. Lenington were also supported by the testimony of Mr. Cross. Mr. Cross noted that research indicated that, for autistic children such as STUDENT, those children who received only an intensive in-home program made better progress than children who were placed in a combined home/school program.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Juarez, Dr. Lenington, and Mr. Cross. The Hearing Officer finds that, as of April 2004, STUDENT did not have the skills necessary to benefit from a classroom setting. Given STUDENT’s history and his lack of skills, STUDENT needed to learn precursor skills in the controlled, intensive environment provided by in-home DTT. Ms. Yee testified that STUDENT would have little opportunity to receive DTT in her classroom.

Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s plan to increase STUDENT’s classroom time over the course of the twelve months covered by the IEP, and decrease his home program, was completely without evidentiary basis. As set forth earlier in this Decision, STUDENT had made little progress over the two years since his therapy had begun in 2002. STUDENT’s service providers had consistently recommended increasing the amount of his home DTT, not decreasing it. There was no evidence to support the idea that STUDENT would suddenly make such remarkable progress that, over the next year, his home program could be reduced to only nine hours a week. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s plan to transition STUDENT to more class time and reduce his home instruction was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Supervision

It is undisputed that consistency is a very important part of STUDENT’s program. Dr. Lenington testified extensively on the need to ensure that all of STUDENT’s service providers were using the same techniques and reinforcers in implementing STUDENT’s program. To provide consistency, the District offered ten hours a month of supervision with at least one one-hour clinic meeting each month. Ms. Duarte testified that STUDENT would not usually be present at the monthly clinic meetings. Ms. Duarte also testified that the District prefers that all of a student’s service providers attend the monthly staff meetings, but that it is not required. LIFE has been providing twelve hours a month of supervision, which includes bi-weekly clinic meetings and monthly workshop sessions. All of STUDENT’s service providers, including STUDENT and at least one parent, are required to attend the bi-weekly clinic meetings. The Student contends that the level and type of supervision provided by LIFE is necessary to ensure consistency in STUDENT’s program.

Comparing the supervision offered by the District and the supervision provided by LIFE, the Hearing Officer notes that the amount of supervision is similar. In fact, Ms. Duarte testified that the ten hours offered by the District was a starting point, and that the amount could be increased if necessary. Therefore, the issue in this case relates to the types of supervision offered – the one hour month clinics offered by the District as opposed to the bi-weekly clinic meetings and monthly workshops provided by LIFE.

The courts have consistently held that the District bears the burden of establishing that it offered STUDENT a FAPE. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District (9th Circ. 1994) 35 F. 3d 1396, 1398; Seattle School District Number One v. B.S., et al. (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F. 3d 1493, 1498. In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to present any evidence to support the conclusion that its offer of supervision was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Ms. Duarte stated that the level of ten hours of supervision with one hour of monthly clinic meetings was what the District offered in these types of cases. Furthermore, the District had not obtained any input from the autism supervisor who would be responsible for STUDENT’s program regarding the level and type of supervision necessary. The Hearing Officer finds that the level and type of supervision offered by the District was not based upon STUDENT’s unique needs. Furthermore, after considering the testimony of Ms. Juarez and Dr. Lenington, reviewing STUDENT’s unique needs, including the number of areas of deficit and the number of service provider’s involved -- OT, S/L therapist, three or four paraeducators, and the PARENTS – and considering the importance of consistency to the success of STUDENT’s program, the Hearing Officer finds that ten hours of supervision, and in particular only one hour a month of clinic meetings was not adequate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Did the District provide for STUDENT to be involved and progress in the general curriculum?

There was no dispute regarding this portion of the standard for FAPE.

Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s placement must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. On the basis of the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. In light of STUDENT’s developmental delays, lack of skills, and slow progress, the District’s offer of only twenty-five hours of home DTT was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with meaningful benefit. In addition, STUDENT did not have the necessary skills to receive any meaningful benefit from the offered classroom placement.

Did the District’s program conform with STUDENT’s IEP?

STUDENT did not receive services pursuant to the April 2004 IEP; therefore, this portion of the standard is not relevant to this Decision.

Was the District’s placement in the least restrictive environment?

Because the District’s offer was not a FAPE, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to address this requirement.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique need for a behavior plan to address his deficits in the areas of inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors. In addition, the April 23, 2004 IEP did not contain an accurate statement of STUDENT’s present levels of performance to the extent that the IEP failed to state that STUDENT required physical and verbal prompts to participate in classroom activities and did not describe STUDENT’s inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors. The IEP also did not contain goals and objectives to appropriately address all of STUDENT’s areas of deficit. The District’s goals for learning turn taking and prepositions were too advanced for STUDENT. The proposed goals addressing STUDENT’s need to learn to identify nouns and verbs, develop cutting skills, and learn matching skills were to low. The District’s goals also failed to adequately address STUDENT’s need to learn to maintain eye contact, and learn nonverbal imitation skills. Furthermore, the District failed to draft any goals to address STUDENT’s need to learn to identify people in his environment, learn to understand instructions, learn categories, learn appropriate independent play, learn appropriate parallel play, reduce inappropriate behaviors, reduce self-stimulatory behaviors, learn independent dressing and undressing skills, and learn eating skills. As to services offered, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of twenty-five hours a week of in-home DTT and four hours of ABA in a classroom setting was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Because of STUDENT’s delays in all areas, lack of precursor skills, and history of slow learning, STUDENT needed forty hours a week of in-home DTT. In addition, STUDENT was not yet ready to benefit from a classroom placement. Furthermore, the District’s plan to increase STUDENT’s classroom time and decrease his home instruction was completely unsupported by any evidence. Finally, the District’s offer of ten hours a month of supervision with one one-hour monthly clinic meeting was not adequate to meet STUDENT unique need for consistency in the implementation of his program.

Did the District Procedurally Deny STUDENT a FAPE by Denying the PARENTS the Opportunity to Participate in the IEP Process?

As stated above, the Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. The PARENTS contend that they were denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process because the District failed to have all of the required personnel present at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting. Specifically, the PARENTS contend that the District should have had one of the District’s autism supervisors present at that meeting. California Education Code section 56341 requires that a student’s IEP team include a representative of the district, special education local plan area, or county office who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, who is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, and who is knowledgeable about the availability of resources of the local educational agency. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(4).

The issue here is whether the District included on its IEP team a member who was qualified to provide or supervise the provision of specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the child. Specifically, the Student argues that the District should have had an autism supervisor present at the IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to have an autism supervisor in attendance was a critical flaw in the makeup of the District’s IEP team. The center of the District’s offer of services for STUDENT was the ABA program. The vast majority of that program was to be provided through in-home DTT. The autism supervisor would have been directly responsible for the supervision of the home DTT and responsible for supervising STUDENT’s entire program to ensure consistency. Furthermore, the autism supervisor would have been responsible for virtually all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. For STUDENT, the autism supervisor would have been the single most important service provider. Despite this, the District had no one at the IEP meeting who was qualified to provide or supervise an ABA program. Ms. Duarte, the District’s autism coordinator, has never designed, implemented, or supervised an ABA program. Ms. Duarte’s duties with the District are primarily administrative -- overseeing and coordinating services. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to satisfy the procedural requirements of the IDEA.

Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990). In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to have an autism supervisor present at the IEP meeting seriously infringed on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. FATHER testified that, in his experience as the parent of an autistic child, he had found that ABA programs, and ABA providers, are not fungible. FATHER stated that it was very important to him to know how STUDENT’s ABA program would be run, and, in particular, how the supervision would be managed, including the frequency and duration of staff meetings. The Hearing Officer finds that FATHER’s concerns were reasonable given his experience with various ABA providers, and that his inability to inquire into those matters with the person who would be most responsible for STUDENT’s program seriously infringed on his opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to satisfy the procedural requirements of the IDEA resulted in a denial of FAPE.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that, for the time period from June 16, 2004, through the date of this decision, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE on the basis of both substantive and procedural violations of the IDEA.

2. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the ABA services they have privately funded?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services replaced services that the school district should have provided and were appropriate under the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369-370 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District , 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C). In this case, because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from June 16, 2004, through the date of this Decision, the first part of this test has been satisfied.

The next question is whether the services the PARENTS procured replaced services the District should have provided and were appropriate. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993), the Court held that parents may receive reimbursement for their unilateral placement even if the placement does not meet certain requirements of the IDEA. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the child’s IEP and need not provide a placement that meets all state education standards. Moreover, the parents’ unilateral placement is not required to be in the least restrictive environment. Cleveland Heights-University Heights City School Dist. v. Boss By and Through Boss, 144 F.3d 391, 400 (6th Cir. 1998). However, while the parents’ placement need not be an exactly proper placement under the IDEA, the placement still must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. Florence, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). In this case, the services the parent provided, ABA services supervised by LIFE and direct instruction provided by aides hired by the PARENTS and trained by LIFE, were a direct replacement for the District’s failure to offer STUDENT an appropriate ABA program. Furthermore, it was undisputed that the ABA program funded by the PARENTS met STUDENT’s unique needs and provided STUDENT with educational benefit. Therefore, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s LIFE supervised ABA program. These costs include the supervision and training provided by LIFE and the cost of the instructors hired by PARENTS for the time period from June 16, 2004 through the date of this decision.

3. If the District did not offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education, what is his appropriate placement for the time period from the date of this Decision through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005?

Having found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from June 16, 2004 through the date of this Decision, the issue remains as to what STUDENT’s placement should be through his anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005. As set forth earlier, there is no dispute regarding the District’s offer of OT, S/L services, and PECS training. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s needs in these areas had changed since the program was offered at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting. Therefore, STUDENT’s prospective placement must include one-on-one S/L services four times a week for thirty minutes each session, clinic based OT twice a week for forty five minutes each session, and PECS instruction twice a week for twenty minutes each session. There also was no dispute that STUDENT requires ESY services.

Regarding STUDENT’s ABA program, the Hearing Officer has found that, as of April 2004, STUDENT required forty hours a week of in-home ABA/DTT and that STUDENT would not benefit from a classroom placement. Ms. Juarez, Dr. Lenington, and FATHER all testified to the progress STUDENT had made since LIFE assumed supervision of his program; furthermore, both Ms. Juarez and Dr. Lenington convincingly testified that STUDENT continues to need this level of services. Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT continues to be very delayed in all areas. STUDENT was still highly distractible, with limited communication skills. STUDENT could respond to some questions with simple signs, but had limited vocalizations. STUDENT also continued to demonstrate perseverative and self-stimulatory behaviors. In addition, Dr. Lenington noted that STUDENT still had few imitation skills and poor self-help skills. Furthermore, Dr. Lenington had had the opportunity to observe Ms. Yee’s SDC. Dr. Lenington testified that, on the basis of her evaluations of STUDENT and her observation of Ms. Yee’s class, she continued to believe that STUDENT would not benefit from a classroom placement at the time of the hearing. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Lenington’s testimony persuasive and finds that STUDENT continues to require forty hours a week of in-home ABA/DTT and, because of a lack of precursor skills including an inability to maintain attention, a lack of well developed verbal and non-verbal imitation skills, and a lack of sufficiently developed receptive and expressive language skills, STUDENT is not yet able to benefit from a classroom placement.

In relation to who should provide STUDENT’s ABA program, the Student contends that the District should be ordered to continue to fund STUDENT’s ABA services from LIFE. The District contends that the appropriate remedy is to order the District and Student back to an IEP meeting; or in the alternative, order that the District provide the ABA instructors under the ongoing training and supervision of LIFE.

The Hearing has found that the LIFE program privately funded by the PARENTS meets STUDENT’s need for forty hours a week of in-home ABA/DTT. In addition, given the progress STUDENT has made in this program and the testimony of Dr. Lenington and Ms. Juarez, the Hearing Officer finds that it is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. However, as argued by the District, California Education Code section 56505.2 provides, in part, that a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in the placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a nonpublic, nonsectarian school, or that results in a service for an individual with exceptional needs being provided by a nonpublic, nonsectarian agency, unless the hearing officer issues a written finding that the district's program or program offer has not complied with legal requirements. In this case, the Hearing Officer has found that the District program was not an offer of FAPE. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not established that it has the resources to provide an appropriate program for STUDENT. The District’s goals and objectives were found to be deficient in many areas. Regarding the District’s proposed autism supervisor, Tim Prior, Ms. Duarte testified only generally as to his qualifications. She stated that he has a master’s degree from UCLA and had worked with the Lovaas Institute for two years. However, no evidence was presented as to the similarity to STUDENT of the student’s Mr. Prior had worked with in the past or currently works with through the District. In addition, no evidence was presented that Mr. Prior has had any experience in designing or supervising a forty-hour a week in-home DTT program. Given the finding that Life is providing a program that is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide him with educational benefit, and because of the District’s failure to establish that it has the resources to provide STUDENT with an appropriate in-home ABA/DTT program, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must continue to fund the Life supervision of STUDENT’s ABA program through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005. Because the District’s proposed goals and objectives were seriously deficient, the ABA program supervised by LIFE shall continue address the goals and objections drafted by Ms. Juarez.

However, California Education Code section 56505.2 also provides that a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in services for an individual with special needs being provided by a nonpublic agency if that agency has not been certified pursuant to Education Code section 56366.1. In this case, it is undisputed that LIFE is a properly certified nonpublic agency. However, the instructors, though trained and supervised by LIFE, are privately hired by the PARENTS and are not certified under section 56366.1. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot order the District to continue to fund the cost of the STUDENT’s current instructors. FATHER testified that STUDENT’s current instructors all have some college education and past experience working with autistic children. Ms. Duarte testified that the District’s personnel have similar qualifications. She stated that the District’s ABA instructors are required to forty-five units of college education and at least one-year experience in working with autistic children. Given Ms. Duarte’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has established that its personnel are qualified to serve as STUDENT’s instructors under the training and supervision of LIFE. However, because of the need for consistency in the provision of STUDENT’s program, the Hearing Officer finds that there must be a period of overlap during the transition from STUDENT’s current instructors to the District’s instructors. The duration of the overlap period shall be determined by LIFE.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District shall continue to fund the training and supervision by LIFE of STUDENT’s ABA program through his anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has personnel who are qualified to serve as STUDENT’s instructors, and shall provide STUDENT’s in-home ABA/DTT instructors under the training and supervision of LIFE.

CONCLUSION

For the time period from June 16, 2004 through the date of this decision, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE on the basis of both substantive and procedural violations of the IDEA. Substantively, the District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique need for a behavior plan to address his deficits in the areas of inappropriate and self-stimulatory behaviors and failed to draft goals and objectives that appropriately addressed all of STUDENT’s areas of deficit. Furthermore, the District’s offer of twenty-five hours a week of home DTT and four hours of ABA in a classroom setting was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In order to meet his unique needs, STUDENT required forty hours a week of in-home DTT. In addition, the District’s offer of a classroom placement was not appropriate because STUDENT was not yet ready to benefit from such a placement. The District’s plan to increase STUDENT’s classroom time and decrease his home instruction was completely unsupported by any evidence. The District also failed to offer an appropriate level of supervision to meet STUDENT’s need for consistency in the implementation of this program.

Procedurally, the District failed to have all of the statutorily required persons present at the April 23, 2004 IEP team meeting by not having an IEP team member who was qualified to provide or supervise the provision of STUDENT’s ABA program. This failure resulted in a denial of FAPE because it seriously infringed on FATHER’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

As a result of these failures the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s LIFE supervised ABA program. These costs include the supervision and training provided by LIFE and the cost of the instructors hired by PARENTS for the time period from June 16, 2004 through the date of this decision.

For the time period from the date of this Decision through STUDENT’s anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005, the District failed to establish that it has the resources to provide STUDENT with an appropriate in-home ABA/DTT program. Therefore, the District shall continue to fund the training and supervision by LIFE of STUDENT’s ABA program. Because of the deficiencies in the District’s proposed goals and objectives, LIFE’s program shall continue to address the goals and objectives drafted by Ms. Juarez. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has personnel who are qualified to serve as STUDENT’s instructors, and shall provide STUDENT’s in-home ABA/DTT instructors under the training and supervision of LIFE. To ensure consistency in the provision of STUDENT’s program, there will be a period of overlap during the transition from STUDENT’s current instructors to the District’s instructors. The duration of the overlap period shall be determined by LIFE.

ORDER

1. The District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the total cost of STUDENT’s ABA program for the time period from June 16, 2004 through the date of this decision. Reimbursement shall be made within twenty calendar days of submission to the District by the PARENTS of proof of those the costs. The costs shall include the cost of the supervision and training by LIFE as well as the cost of the instructors hired by the PARENTS for the time period at issue.

2. For the time period from the date of this decision through STUDENT’s anticipated annual IEP date of April 23, 2005, the District shall continue to fund the training and supervision of STUDENT’s in-home ABA/DTT program through LIFE. LIFE’s program shall continue to address the goals and objectives drafted by Ms. Juarez. The District shall provide the instructors using District personnel who will provide the in-home ABA program under the ongoing supervision and training of LIFE. To ensure consistency in the provision of STUDENT’s program, there will be a period of overlap during the transition from STUDENT’s current instructors to the District’s instructors. The duration of the overlap period shall be determined by LIFE.

3. For the time period from the date of this Decision through the end of the overlap period in the transition from STUDENT’s current instructors to the District’s instructions, the District shall continue to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of the privately provided instructors. Reimbursement shall be made within twenty calendar days of submission to the District by the PARENTS of proof of those the costs.

4. The District shall continue to offer and provide the OT, S/L services, and PECS instruction as offered in the April 23, 2004 IEP.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. For the time period of June 16, 1004 through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005, did the District offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

2. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the ABA services they have privately funded?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

3. If the District did not offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education, what is his appropriate placement for the time period from the date of this Decision through the anticipated annual IEP meeting date of April 23, 2005?

The Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that it was found that LIFE should continue to provide STUDENT’s in-home ABA/DTT program. However, the District prevailed to the extent that it would provide the ABA instructors using District personnel under the ongoing training and supervision by LIFE.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code ' 56505(i).

Dated: November 23, 2004 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The typically developing children only attended Ms. Yee’s class on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.

2 At the hearing, Ms. Yee testified that, due to the response she received from parents, she later changed her mind and continued the co-enrollment for the entire school year.

3 Under LIFE’s “workshop” model, LIFE provides a case supervisor and training for the instructors who provide the weekly ABA therapy. The instructors are hired by the child’s parents. In STUDENT’s case, STUDENT, his parents, and three instructors hired by the PARENTS attended the initial three-day workshop.

4 “Co-morbid” refers to a medical condition existing simultaneously with and usually independently of another medical condition.

5 MOTHER was not present at the April 23, 2004 IEP meeting.

6 Ms. Campbell, the District special education team leader, had observed STUDENT’s class for approximately one hour. The purpose of her visit had been to observe the entire class, not STUDENT in particular.