California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 9, 1998
Capistrano Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1627-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
Capistrano Unified's Crown Valley preschool offer denied FAPE to a hard-of-hearing preschooler; ear molds reimbursed, private school request denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Earlier due process request (February 1997) settled March 20, 1997. Parents' September 9, 1997 request was withdrawn December 5, 1997 after a continuance was denied. The District then filed this case on December 19, 1997. A July 9, 1997 stay-put order in SN 894-97 required a SEE signing aide at Rancho Viejo.
Summary
Capistrano Unified School District filed for due process to show that its offer for a 4½-year-old preschooler with bilateral hearing loss provided a FAPE from June 1997 onward. The District offered a Montessori-style deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) class at Crown Valley Elementary School that enrolled both hearing and DHH children. The offer also included speech therapy, audiology, sign language classes for the parents, and a 20-day extended school year (ESY). The parents wanted the private Rancho Viejo School, which the child had attended with District support.
The Hearing Officer found three procedural violations. No teacher attended the July 1997 IEP meeting. The District did not give the parents its audiology report or hold a meeting on it. It also briefly stopped transportation. None of these denied FAPE. The audiology services and 20-day ESY were adequate. However, Crown Valley lacked enough sign-language peers of similar age and ability. Its lead teacher also could not adapt to the child's slow processing style. For those reasons, the offer denied FAPE. Rancho Viejo could not be ordered because it was not a certified nonpublic school. It also could not meet the child's needs without District staff. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and build a program with suitable peers, a suitable DHH teacher, a signing aide, and the listed services. The parents' private audiology evaluation was not reimbursed. The Hearing Officer held that ear molds were assistive technology and ordered the District to reimburse their cost.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied California's requirement that deaf and hard of hearing children have enough language-mode peers of similar age and ability. It treated a specific teacher's poor fit with a child as a FAPE problem. It also treated hearing-aid ear molds as assistive technology the district must fund when the IEP addresses amplification.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(a)(1). Whether the District never offered or made available sign language classes for the parents
The July 15, 1997 IEP offered weekly sign classes, and the District sent written schedules; no violation during the period at issue.
- Not reachedImplementation
Issue 1(a)(2). Whether the District's audiologist failed to implement auditory goals in the June 13, 1996 IEP during 1996-97
Outside the June 1997-forward period at issue, so not relevant.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1(a)(3). Whether the District decided to place the student at Crown Valley without convening an IEP team meeting
The June 24, 1997 letter only proposed the change, and the placement was discussed at the July 15, 1997 IEP meeting; no violation.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1(a)(4). Whether the District failed to implement the last agreed-upon IEP as modified by the March 1997 settlement agreement during summer 1997 and fall 1997 (sign services, signing aide, credentialed DHH teacher, audiology, child care)
The November 1996 IEP and settlement did not provide ESY or specify a DHH teacher; the District implemented the last agreed-upon IEP.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 1(a)(5). Whether the District stopped transporting the student to Rancho Viejo in September 1997
Transportation stopped for five school days and the parents drove the child; the brief lapse did not cause a loss of educational benefit or interfere with parent participation.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1(a)(6). Whether the District failed to offer a full continuum of placements at IFSP meetings and the June 13, 1996 IEP meeting
Outside the June 1997-forward period at issue, so not relevant.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1(a)(7). Whether the District violated IEP team requirements because no teacher attended the July 15, 1997 IEP meeting
The missing teacher was a violation, but a teacher's presence would not have changed either side's position, so there was no loss of educational benefit or participation.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment
Issue 1(a)(8). Whether the District failed to give the parents the July 24, 1997 audiology assessment report and to hold an IEP meeting on it
The District violated Education Code section 56329, but the report contained no new information and would not have changed either side's position on placement.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1(b)-peer group. Whether the Crown Valley placement met the student's need for a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately the same age and ability
One DHH classmate was two years younger and the other rarely communicated; hearing peers were not shown to sign spontaneously, so the class lacked sufficient language mode peers under Education Code section 56000.5(b)(4).
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(b)-instructional approach. Whether the Crown Valley placement met the student's need for instructors who understand and can accommodate her processing difficulties
The lead teacher, though qualified, was shown to be unable to work well with the student or accommodate her processing needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(b)-audiological services. Whether the audiological services offered met the student's needs
The District audiologist was competent to serve a child with hearing aids, and Crown Valley staff could monitor the aids.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1(b)-ESY. Whether a twenty-day extended school year program met the student's needs, or a ten-week summer program was required
The student tolerated a four-week break without significant regression, so a 20-day ESY was enough if delivered in an otherwise appropriate class.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(c). Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to the student?
Without appropriate peers and a suitable instructor, Crown Valley would not provide educational benefit; the District did not provide a FAPE from June 1997 forward.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. If the District did not offer a FAPE, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for the student?
Rancho Viejo was not a certified nonpublic school, so it could not be ordered under Education Code section 56505.2, and it could not meet the student's needs without District staff; the District must revise Crown Valley or find another appropriate program.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3(a). Are the parents entitled to reimbursement of $135 for the Fall 1997 Providence Speech and Hearing Center audiological evaluation and related transportation costs?
The District's audiology assessment was not shown to be inappropriate, and the parents had not objected to it, so the independent evaluation was not reimbursed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(b). Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of ear molds ($150)?
Ear molds are assistive technology devices, and the IEP team had treated amplification as necessary, so the District must pay for them.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate placement. It must include a preschool program co-enrolled with DHH and hearing peers, with a sufficient number of language mode peers of about the student's age and ability, a DHH teacher who is familiar with and can accommodate the student's processing difficulties, and a signing aide.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include three 45-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week; audiological services of up to 1 hour per week to monitor equipment and 1 hour per month to consult with parents and teachers; ear molds as needed; weekly sign language instruction for the family; and ESY with a 20-day classroom program.
- Reimbursement. Upon proof of payment, reimburse the parents for ear molds obtained from August 1997 through the date of the decision. No dollar amount is stated in the order; $150 was claimed.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Letter to Seiler, 20 IDELR 1216; Education Code section 56000.5(b)(4); Education Code section 56505.2; Education Code section 56363.1; Education Code section 56329
People named in the decision
- Doreen Lohnes, Director of special education, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robert (Bob) White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
- Bridget Flanagan, District counsel, Miller, Brown & Dannis
- Joan Honeycutt, Attorney for Student
- Patricia Cromer, Attorney present for Student
- Corinne Parker, Legal assistant and child advocate for Student's counsel
- Carolyn Rowland, DHH teacher; Crown Valley lead teacher, South Orange County SELPA
- Dennis Davino, Program aide and SEE signer, Capistrano Unified School District
- Linda Puckett, Speech-language therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Tammi Galley, Speech-language therapist (offered provider), Capistrano Unified School District
- Lisa DeLany, Speech-language therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Maria Abramson, Audiologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Suzanne (Sue) Craik, DHH teacher assigned to Rancho Viejo from November 1997, Capistrano Unified School District
- Cynthia Frazee, District witness; staff who worked with the student before age three, Capistrano Unified School District
- James Blinn, District witness (role not stated)
- Renee Burgayo, Signing aide (June 1997), Capistrano Unified School District
- Carl Kirchner, Founder of TRIPOD program; witness, TRIPOD, Burbank
- Ruth Hiland, Private speech-language therapist; witness for Student, Rancho Viejo School
- Carol Atkins, Private audiologist; witness for Student, Retained by Rancho Viejo School
- Debbie (Debra) Evans-Warkentien, Founder/operator of private preschool; witness for Student, Rancho Viejo School
- Sarmila Mitra, Montessori-certified preschool teacher; witness for Student, Rancho Viejo School
- Kim Huynen, Witness for Student (role not stated)
- Jennifer Gorgone, DHH teacher briefly employed, Rancho Viejo School
- Todd Houser, DHH teacher consultant, Rancho Viejo School (consultant)
- Rancho Viejo School, Private Montessori preschool (not a certified nonpublic school)
- Providence Speech and Hearing Center, Private audiology provider
- R.H. Dana Exceptional Needs Facility, Infant and toddler program
- Broderick Montessori, Private preschool
- Crown Valley Elementary School, District school site of offered DHH preschool class, Capistrano Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing on January 20 and 21, February 5, 6, 17, 18, 19, 20, and March 9, 1998, in San Juan Capistrano and Laguna Niguel, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. This matter was heard concurrently with the matter of Capistrano Unified School District v. STUDENT A, Case No. SN 1628-97, which is the subject of a separate decision.
Petitioner Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Doreen Lohnes, director of special education, and Bob White, director of the South Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA), were also present at various times on the District’s behalf.
Respondent was represented at the hearing by attorney Joan Honeycutt. One or both of Petitioner’s parents, MOTHER and FATHER, were present for all days of the hearing. Also present at the hearing at various times on Respondent’s behalf were attorney Patricia Cromer and Corinne Parker, Ms. Honeycutt’s legal assistant and a child advocate. MOTHER OF STUDENT A and FATHER OF STUDENT A were also present at the hearing on behalf of their daughter STUDENT A.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: Linda Puckett, Maria Abramson, Tammi Galley, Carolyn Rowland, Carl Kirchner, Dennis Davino, Doreen Lohnes, Lisa DeLany, Suzanne Craik, James Blinn, Cynthia Frazee, and Robert White.
Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER OF STUDENT A, MOTHER, Ruth Hiland, Kim Huynen, Maria Abramson, FATHER, Debbie Evans-Warkentien, Sarmila Mitra, and Carol Atkins.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. In the interests of judicial economy, the parties agreed that the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing in the matter of STUDENT B v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN 894-97, would be incorporated into the record for this matter. Closing arguments were received by May 5, 1998. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. Did the District provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for Respondent from June 1997 to the present?
2. If the District did not offer Respondent a FAPE from June 1997 to the present, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for her?
3. Are Respondent’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her audiological evaluation at Providence Speech and Hearing Center in Fall 1997 in the amount of $135.00, the cost of ear molds in the amount of $150.00, and related costs of transportation to and from Providence Speech and Hearing Center?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
Since June 30, 1997, the District has offered STUDENT placement in a deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) special day class at Crown Valley Elementary School. The class is attended by both hearing and DHH preschoolers and is taught by a Montessori-certified, DHH-credentialed teacher (DHH teacher) and a program aide fluent in Signing Exact English (SEE).(Footnote 1) In addition, the District is offering three forty-five-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week by Tammi Galley, audiological services by Maria Abramson consisting of one hour per month for consultation and up to one hour per week to check equipment, one hour per week of sign language classes, parent education classes, and a twenty-day extended school year program at Crown Valley. The District asserts that this placement and related services provide a FAPE for STUDENT.
The Respondent asserts that the Crown Valley class is not appropriate because it does not meet STUDENT’s needs(Footnote 2). The Respondent proposes that the appropriate program to serve all her needs is the Rancho Viejo School, a private Montessori preschool designed to serve both hearing and DHH students, three forty-five-minute speech therapy sessions per week by Ruth Hiland, and fifteen minutes per day of audiological services by Carol Atkins.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, who will turn five years old in August, was diagnosed at the age of ten months with bilateral hearing loss. Over time, it has been determined that STUDENT’s hearing loss is sensorineural and that her loss is moderate to severe in her right ear and moderately severe to profound in her left ear. After her hearing loss was diagnosed, STUDENT was evaluated for amplification with hearing aids. In January 1995, she was fit with Phonak Pico Forte hearing aids on both ears with good results. STUDENT continues to wear that brand of hearing aids. The first Individual Family Services Plan (IFSP) meeting for STUDENT was held on October 24, 1994. At that time, STUDENT began receiving special education services consisting of one hour per week of speech and language services provided at home. In February 1995, STUDENT began to attend the infant and toddler program at R.H. Dana Exceptional Needs Facility, which served children with a wide variety of disabilities, two days per week. STUDENT’s speech and language therapy and audiological services were provided at the R.H. Dana site.
The PARENTS noticed that STUDENT was developing some abnormal behaviors, such as wagging her head back and forth and throwing tantrums. They also were dissatisfied with the progress she was making in language development. They asked the District to increase the services STUDENT was receiving, and on January 23, 1996, the PARENTS agreed to increase STUDENT’s time at R.H. Dana to four days per week.
On June 13, 1996, STUDENT’s transition IEP meeting was held to plan for the services she would receive from the District after she turned three. The District proposed to place STUDENT at the Taft preschool program located in Santa Ana in September. The PARENTS were very concerned about the length of the bus ride from their home in San Clemente to Santa Ana, but agreed to the placement because they did not know of any other preschool options.
During 1996, MOTHER OF STUDENT A and MOTHER OF STUDENT B, the parents of two other DHH toddlers, were actively pursuing the development of a program for DHH preschoolers in the District. During a meeting with District and Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA) representatives to discuss establishing a new program, they asked if their children could be served at Broderick Montessori, a local preschool, until a District program could be established. In June 1996, the District agreed to pay for their children to attend Broderick Montessori three days per week while the parents paid for the other two days. The District also agreed to provide a DHH teacher to help the preschool staff on the three days for which the District was paying and to provide a signing aide for the other two days.
On July 24 and August 20, 1996, District and SELPA representatives met with parents of DHH children, including MOTHER, and Debra Evans-Warkentien, a friend of MOTHER OF STUDENT A who was starting a Montessori preschool. The parents advocated the development of a program modeled after TRIPOD in Burbank, which consisted of co-enrollment of DHH and hearing students in a Montessori preschool class taught by a DHH teacher and a Montessori-credentialed teacher. All involved seemed to be enthusiastic about developing such a program in south Orange County, and the District and SELPA staff began to explore a partnership with Ms. Evans-Warkentien’s planned Rancho Viejo School.
At the meeting of July 24, 1996, MOTHER met MOTHER OF STUDENT B and MOTHER OF STUDENT A for the first time and learned of the District’s agreement to serve their children at Broderick Montessori. On July 29, 1996, FATHER sent a letter to the District requesting an immediate meeting to discuss providing a similar program to STUDENT. An IEP meeting was scheduled for August 27, 1996. Before the meeting could be held, the PARENTS discovered that there was no room for STUDENT at Broderick, but she was put on a waiting list. At the IEP meeting, the District offered to provide an in-home program with direct services from a DHH teacher for 2 ½ hours per day, five days per week, until space became available at Broderick. Carolyn Rowland, a SELPA employee and DHH teacher, began serving STUDENT at home. At times, Dennis Davino, a program aide and fluent SEE signer, also served STUDENT at home.
MOTHER OF STUDENT A, Ms. Evans-Warkentien, and Ms. Rowland began to look for a site for the proposed preschool. At one point, the District offered a portable that could be moved to the Bergeson Elementary School campus. Ms. Evans-Warkentien rejected that offer because it would cost about $13,000 to move the portable and she believed it would be a costly temporary solution. Because it was taking so long to find a site and because the children could not be served full-time at Broderick, Ms. Evans-Warkentien obtained a home day-care license and started the Rancho Viejo School in her home at the beginning of October 1996 with Ms. Sarmila Mitra, a Montessori-certified teacher. The District provided Ms. Rowland and Mr. Davino to deliver special education services to the DHH children at Rancho Viejo. STUDENT, STUDENT B, and STUDENT A began attending Rancho Viejo in October 1996.
Discussions between the SELPA and Ms. Evans-Warkentien about developing a cooperative program continued. However, disagreements between the parties began to emerge. The SELPA did not want to provide any financial support for the school, other than providing a DHH teacher and a signing aide. Ms. Evans-Warkentien expected at least partial tuition support for the DHH children attending the school. The site search continued, and Ms. Rowland began to express concerns to the District and SELPA about the operation of the school in the home. Ms. Rowland was enrolled in a Montessori certification program and was performing her internship at Rancho Viejo under Ms. Mitra’s supervision. As part of her course, Ms. Rowland obtained the permission of PARENTS to conduct a developmental case study of STUDENT. Ms. Rowland also kept a journal in which she wrote her observations of, and her frustrations with, the development of the Rancho Viejo program.
The delay in officially establishing a cooperative program, and other issues, prompted the PARENTS to file a request for a due process hearing in February 1997. On March 20, 1997, the PARENTS and the District settled the due process matter. The District agreed to reimburse Ms. Evans-Warkentien for certain costs and to continue providing services to STUDENT at Rancho Viejo through June 30, 1997. This settlement occurred at the commencement of the due process hearing for STUDENT. At some point during the settlement meetings, the PARENTS or the PARENTS OF STUDENT A picked up a file belonging to the District that contained Ms. Rowland’s journal. The PARENTS, the PARENTS OF STUDENT A, and Ms. Honeycutt, their attorney, discovered the journal and read portions of it during dinner that night. The parents were very upset by the tone of the journal and the fact that Ms. Rowland had shared information from her case study on STUDENT with the District’s representatives without sharing it with the PARENTS. On March 23, 1997, the PARENTS withdrew their consent to allow Ms. Rowland to conduct a case study on STUDENT. On April 7, 1997, Ms. Evans-Warkentien, on behalf of the parents of the DHH children at Rancho Viejo, requested that Ms. Rowland no longer be assigned to Rancho Viejo. Doreen Lohnes asked each set of parents to confirm that they wanted Ms. Rowland removed from the program. The PARENTS confirmed that they wanted Ms. Rowland removed from the Rancho Viejo classroom because she had committed a breach of confidentiality. Ms. Rowland did not return to Rancho Viejo, and the District did not provide a replacement DHH teacher.
From April through June, Mr. Davino was the only District employee working full-time at Rancho Viejo. Ms. Linda Puckett, a District employee, visited three days a week to provide speech therapy to STUDENT. Ms. Hiland, the private speech therapist, was present on a daily basis to provide speech therapy to STUDENT B and STUDENT A.
The District notified the PARENTS by voice mail on June 20, 1997 (a Friday), that it had scheduled an IEP meeting for STUDENT for June 24, 1997. On June 23, 1997, the PARENTS indicated that they would not be able to attend that meeting and asked for it to be rescheduled. On June 24, 1997, the District notified the PARENTS in writing that it proposed to change the location of STUDENT’s placement to a District-operated DHH, Montessori preschool at Crown Valley Elementary School taught by Ms. Rowland and a signing aide. The preschool would have hearing and DHH children co-enrolled.
At an IEP meeting held on July 15, 1997, the District again proposed to place STUDENT at Crown Valley. The District also offered three forty-five-minute sessions of individual speech therapy per week, audiological services of one hour per month for consultation with parents and teachers and up to one hour per week to check equipment, two hours per month of parent education, weekly sign language classes for the parents, and extended school year services through July 23 for the classroom program. After discussion and modification of the proposed goals and objectives, the PARENTS agreed that they were appropriate for STUDENT. At this meeting, the District agreed to reimburse the PARENTS for STUDENT’s ear molds for the period from August 1996 through August 1997. However, the parents did not agree with the placement being offered and did not sign the IEP. The PARENTS noted on the IEP that they would view the Crown Valley program to evaluate its appropriateness for STUDENT and that they continued to have concerns about the impact of STUDENT’s placement at R.H. Dana. The PARENTS believed that STUDENT’s placement in that program with severely disabled children affected her development and caused behavior problems. The PARENTS observed the Crown Valley program on July 15 and 22, 1997, and decided that it was not appropriate for STUDENT. During the summer, STUDENT continued to attend Rancho Viejo.
On June 20, 1997, the District removed Mr. Davino from the Rancho Viejo program and assigned him to the Crown Valley program. The District provided Ms. Renee Burgayo as a signing aide in Mr. Davino’s place from June 23 to June 30, but had still not replaced Ms. Rowland. On July 9, 1997, the Hearing Office ordered in the STUDENT B case, SN 894-97, that the District continue providing a signing aide knowledgeable in SEE to the Rancho Viejo program pursuant to the stay put requirements of the IDEA.
On July 24, 1997, Ms. Abramson performed an audiologic assessment of STUDENT for the District consisting of an electroacoustic analysis of her hearing aids and an assessment of her speech perception abilities. Ms. Abramson concluded that STUDENT’s hearing aids were functioning appropriately and that STUDENT demonstrated excellent auditory comprehension skills when aided.
In July 1997, Ms. Evans-Warkentien retained audiologist Carol Atkins to provide audiological services at Rancho Viejo two hours per week to check the functioning of the DHH children’s equipment and to consult with the staff and parents. The District did not provide a new signing aide for Rancho Viejo until August 21, 1997, and did not provide a credentialed DHH teacher until November 12, 1997, when it assigned Sue Craik. On September 9, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt filed requests for due process hearings on behalf of STUDENT and STUDENT A.
The District’s sign language classes for parents, which were offered on a weekly basis during the school year, were offered four times during the summer of 1997. The PARENTS were not able to attend these classes due to a scheduling conflict. In the fall, the sign classes resumed on a weekly basis, with a one-hour class for beginners and a one-hour class for intermediate signers. The PARENTS did not attend any of the classes offered in the fall. The PARENTS have, on their own, taken several American Sign Language (ASL) classes through a local community college. MOTHER is close to obtaining an interpreter qualification in ASL.
At the beginning of September, Ms. Evans-Warkentien hired Jennifer Gorgone, a credentialed DHH teacher. Ms. Gorgone worked at Rancho Viejo for about two weeks; she left the program due to her dissatisfaction with the implementation of the Montessori curriculum and the location of the program in a home rather than a school. By this time, Ms. Evans-Warkentien had located a new site for the school and construction had begun. Due to various delays, Rancho Viejo did not move to its new site until January 20, 1998.
On October 10, 1997, the PARENTS obtained a private audiological evaluation by Providence Speech and Hearing Center (Providence). Providence performed an audiogram on STUDENT and an electroacoustic analysis of her hearing aids. STUDENT’s aids were again found to be in good working order.
The hearing for the STUDENT and STUDENT A matters was scheduled to proceed as soon as the STUDENT B hearing concluded during the week of November 17-21, 1997. However, the STUDENT B hearing concluded on November 20, and neither the PARENTS nor the PARENTS OF STUDENT A were able to attend on November 21. Additional hearing dates were set for December 11, 12, 16, and 17, 1997. On November 24, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt requested a continuance of the agreed-upon hearing dates. The Hearing Office denied the motion, and on December 5, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt withdrew the requests for hearing. On December 19, 1997, the District requested this due process proceeding.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for Respondent from June 1997 to the present?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 176, 200. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.
Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court’s interpretation of the IDEA provide the following three factors for analyzing whether the placement the District offered for STUDENT from June 30, 1997, forward provided a FAPE:
(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT? (b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? and (c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?(Footnote 3)
In determining whether the District has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314. If the District’s program reflects the child’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. The District has offered a placement for STUDENT that includes the following elements:
1. The Crown Valley Montessori preschool class co-enrolled with DHH and hearing children, taught by a DHH teacher and a signing aide in total communication using both voice and SEE sign. 2. Three forty-five-minute speech therapy sessions per week provided by Tammi Galley.(Footnote 4) 3. Audiological services provided by Maria Abramson up to one hour per week to monitor equipment functioning and one hour per month to consult with parents and teachers. 4. Two hours per month of parent education.
5. One hour per week of sign language classes for the parents. 6. A twenty-day extended school year program.
(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT?
In the closing brief, the Respondent argued that several procedural errors in the IEP process were significant enough to amount to a denial of FAPE. Each of the alleged violations will be addressed separately to determine if violations occurred. If a violation occurred, it will be determined whether it resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parents’ participation in the IEP process, causing a denial of FAPE.
1. The District never offered or made available sign language classes for STUDENT’s parents.
The issue the District presented for hearing was whether the District provided a FAPE for STUDENT from June 1997 to the present. Whether the District offered sign language classes prior to June 1997 is not relevant. In the IEP of July 15, 1997, the District clearly offered one hour of sign language classes per week. (Dist. Exh. 20.) In addition, the District notified the PARENTS in writing on July 10, 1997, of the schedule for the summer sign language classes, and again on September 8, 1997, of the schedule for the classes during the fall. (Dist. Exh. 19, 25.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit this alleged violation during the time period in question.
2. During the 1996-97 school year, the District’s audiologist failed to implement certain auditory goals identified on the IEP dated June 13, 1996.
As stated above, the relevant time period for the issues presented at hearing is June 1997 forward. Therefore, whether auditory goals were not implemented during the prior school year is not relevant.
3. The District made the decision to place STUDENT at Crown Valley without convening an IEP team meeting.
On June 24, 1997, the District informed the PARENTS in writing that it “proposed a change in location of the preschool special education program for deaf and hard of hearing children.” (Dist. Exh. 14.) The District also indicated that it was providing the information about the proposed change in the form of a letter because the PARENTS were unable to attend an IEP meeting on that date. At the IEP meeting held on July 15, 1997, the proposed placement was discussed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not make a final placement decision without convening an IEP meeting and did not commit this alleged violation.
4. The District failed to implement STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP as modified by the March 1997 Settlement Agreement during the summer of 1997 by failing to provide sign language services, a signing aide, a credentialed DHH teacher, audiological services, and child care services during sign language classes.
STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP was dated November 13, 1996. That IEP did not indicate that STUDENT was entitled to extended school year (ESY) services, and the Settlement Agreement did not contain any provisions relating to ESY services. (Dist. Exh. 6, 9.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to implement the last agreed-upon IEP during the summer of 1997. The District did fail to provide a credentialed DHH teacher for STUDENT from the commencement of the 1997-98 school year through November 12, 1997. However, neither the IEP dated November 13, 1996, nor the Settlement Agreement specify that a DHH teacher must be provided. Rather, the IEP states that STUDENT was to be placed in an unspecified “Hearing Impaired Program,” and the Settlement Agreement simply requires the continuation of the services listed in the IEP. At the beginning of the 1997-98 school year, the District was paying for speech and language therapy at the Rancho Viejo school site and was also providing a signing aide. After stay put was invoked by the filing of the due process hearing request, the District also continued its reimbursement to Ms. Evans-Warkentien in accordance with the Settlement Agreement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented the last agreed upon IEP as modified by the Settlement Agreement, and did not commit the alleged procedural violation.
5. The District stopped transporting STUDENT to Rancho Viejo in September 1997.
On August 29, 1997, the District notified the PARENTS that it did not have an agreement from them to provide any services to STUDENT and that they should contact the District by September 3, 1997, if they wished to agree to any of the services offered. (Dist. Exh. 22.) On September 8, 1997, the District stopped transporting STUDENT to Rancho Viejo. On September 9, the PARENTS requested a due process hearing, invoking stay put protections. On September 12, 1997, the District notified the PARENTS that transportation to Rancho Viejo would begin again on September 15, 1997. (Dist. Exh. 27.) Therefore, STUDENT did not receive transportation for five school days. During that time, the PARENTS transported STUDENT to Rancho Viejo themselves. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s brief failure to provide transportation did not result in a denial of educational benefit to STUDENT, nor did it interfere with the PARENTS’ ability to participate in the IEP process.
6. The District failed to offer a full continuum of placements during her IFSP meetings and at her IEP meeting on June 13, 1996.
As discussed above, the relevant period of time for this hearing is June 1997 forward. Whether the District offered a full continuum of placements during prior years is not relevant.
7. The District indicated in the notice of IEP meeting for July 15, 1997, that regular education and special education teachers would be present, but no teachers attended that meeting.
California Education Code section 56341(2) requires that an IEP team include “the pupil’s present teacher. If the pupil does not presently have a teacher, this representative shall be the teacher with the most recent and complete knowledge of the pupil who has also observed the pupil’s educational performance in an appropriate setting. If no teacher is available, this representative shall be a regular classroom teacher referring the pupil, or a special education teacher qualified to teach a pupil of his or her age.” Ms. Mitra, STUDENT’s current preschool teacher, was not present at the IEP meeting, and, at that point, there was no special education teacher assigned to teach STUDENT. However, Ms. Evans-Warkentien and Mr. Davino were present at the IEP meeting. Although Ms. Evans-Warkentien did not teach STUDENT, she was occasionally present in the classroom and frequently observed the classroom. Mr. Davino was an active classroom aide and sign language interpreter for STUDENT through mid-June. Moreover, based on the testimony of those who have taught STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the presence of a teacher would not have affected the District’s position that the Crown Valley program was appropriate for STUDENT or the PARENTS’ position that it was not. (Testimony of Ms. Rowland, Ms. Mitra.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the District violated the requirement that a teacher be part of the IEP team, that violation did not deny educational benefit or deprive the parents of the right to participate in the IEP process.
8. The District failed to provide the PARENTS with a copy of Ms. Abramson’s July 24, 1997 assessment report and failed to convene an IEP team meeting to discuss the results of that assessment.
California Education Code section 56329 provides that “the parent of the pupil shall be provided with written notice that he or she may obtain, upon request, a copy of the findings of the assessment .... This notice may be provided as part of the assessment plan given to parents pursuant to Section 56321.” Section 56329 further requires that an IEP team meeting be held to discuss the assessment and recommendations. Ms. Abramson conducted an audiological evaluation of STUDENT on July 24, 1997, and prepared a report of that evaluation. (Dist. Exh. 29.) However, she did not send a copy of that report to the PARENTS, and an IEP team meeting was never held to discuss the report. (Testimony of Ms. Abramson, MOTHER.) Nor is there any evidence that an assessment plan was given to the PARENTS notifying them of the right to obtain a copy of the report. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did violate this procedural requirement. However, Ms. Abramson’s report provided no new or startling information about STUDENT’s abilities or condition. The recommendations in the report were simply that STUDENT should continue with consistent amplification, consistent audiologic and otologic care, and auditory training. The Hearing Officer finds that there is no evidence that knowledge of these recommendations would have changed either the District’s or the parents’ positions on the appropriate placement for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer further finds that this violation did not deprive STUDENT of educational benefit, nor did it seriously impact the PARENTS’ right to participate in the IEP process.
(b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
The testimony at the hearing established that STUDENT needs a preschool program co-enrolled with appropriate DHH and hearing peers, instruction from a DHH teacher, a signing aide, speech and language therapy, audiological services, sign language instruction for her parents, and extended school year services. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER, Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins, Mr. Kirchner.) The evidence also established that STUDENT’s social/emotional needs include instructors who understand her processing style and who will allow her to have time to process information and will not demand immediate responses from her. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins, Ms. Mitra. Resp. Exh. 200.) The Respondent asserts that the Crown Valley program does not meet her needs for an appropriate peer group and appropriate audiological services. The Respondent further asserts that the teacher at Crown Valley, Ms. Rowland, cannot meet STUDENT’s need for instructors who can accommodate her processing difficulties. The Respondent also takes the position that she needs a ten-week summer program rather than the four weeks offered at Crown Valley.
Appropriateness of Peer Group
California Education Code section 56000.5(b)(4) provides that “it is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education with a sufficient number of language mode peers with whom they can communicate directly and who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.” California Education Code section 56001(g) further requires that programs for DHH children take into consideration “the individual’s needs for a sufficient number of age and language mode peers.” The legislature has provided no definition of “sufficient number.”
STUDENT communicates in both voice and SEE sign. STUDENT usually uses voice in conjunction with signs, but also frequently uses voice only. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Craik, Mr. Kirchner.) Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT has a severe expressive language impairment in both spoken and signed language. STUDENT’s receptive language skills are below normal but are better than her expressive language skills. Ms. Hiland stated that STUDENT’s primary communication mode is SEE, but she does not have as extensive a vocabulary as her DHH peers at Rancho Viejo. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was not using complete sentences in her voiced or signed language. STUDENT also uses “jargon” (nonsense words and signs) to fill in gaps in her sentences. When she is stressed, her use of jargon increases. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins.) At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was 4 ½ years old.
The reports of the sign language skills of the children in the Crown Valley program varied. The DHH girl in the class is about two years younger than STUDENT, and the DHH boy is about the same age as STUDENT. Both children use sign language as their language mode.(Footnote 5) Ms. Rowland testified that the DHH girl in the class had no language at all as of June 1997 but, in January 1998, was able to communicate her wants and needs and have conversations in SEE sign. When asked to identify the strongest signer in the class, Ms. Rowland chose a hearing child whose entire exposure to SEE sign came from her attendance at the Crown Valley program. Mr. Davino testified that this hearing child was able to sign 479 words without prompting. Mr. Davino combined the number of signs she knew with her ability to use the SEE markers to conclude that the child had a SEE vocabulary of approximately 1200 to 1400 words. Speech and language therapist Lisa DeLany testified that the DHH girl had excellent sign skills that were appropriate for her age, which was 2 ½, and was starting to use markers, tenses, prepositions, and pronouns. Ms. DeLany also testified that the DHH boy in the class had sign skills that were below his age level. Ms. DeLany stated that the DHH boy is shy about signing, but that he was starting to use more sign language.
Mr. Carl Kirchner, the founder of the TRIPOD program after which both Crown Valley and Rancho Viejo are modeled, observed the Crown Valley program for a day in mid-January 1998. He testified that the DHH girl had age-appropriate sign skills. He also observed at Rancho Viejo and testified that the children at Rancho Viejo signed using longer strings of words and sentences than the children at Crown Valley. While at Crown Valley, Mr. Kirchner saw the hearing children spontaneously sign phrases such as “look at the teacher” and “it’s time to eat.” In February 1998, MOTHER OF STUDENT A, Ms. Hiland, FATHER, and MOTHER observed the Crown Valley program for a day. During that visit, the parents did not see a significant amount of spontaneous sign communication from the hearing children. Based on the one-day observation, FATHER expressed the opinion that the DHH and hearing children at Crown Valley are not appropriate language peers for STUDENT. Mr. Davino testified that on the day the parents observed, the children were not using as much sign language as normal, but there was no evidence that the level of sign used during Mr. Kirchner’s visit was abnormal. Mr. Davino also testified that he was just beginning to see spontaneous sign language from the hearing children in the Crown Valley class.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that Crown Valley would provide a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately the same age and ability as STUDENT. Although the DHH girl has age appropriate skills, she is two years younger than STUDENT. Although STUDENT’s language skills are below age level, no one testified that they were as much as two years below age level. With respect to the DHH boy, the testimony established that he does not communicate frequently, either because he is shy or because his skill level does not allow him to do so. Moreover, even if his skills are at about the same level as STUDENT’s, one appropriate language mode peer is not a sufficient number. Although the evidence established that the hearing children had learned a lot of sign language, no witness testified that they are spontaneously signing in any significant amount with the DHH children in the class. Therefore, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT would have a sufficient number of language mode peers who could help her develop her emerging communication skills.
Instructional Approach
STUDENT is a child who has great difficulty processing information. She does not respond well to directed activities and usually needs extra time to process instructions before being able to give a response. When STUDENT is overwhelmed by the demands being made of her, she will close her eyes, turn her head away, or otherwise “tune out” the instructor. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Mitra, Ms. Puckett, Ms. Frazee, Ms. Atkins. Resp. Exh. 200.) STUDENT needs short directions with minimized auditory stimulation. STUDENT learns through touch and needs to be allowed flexibility in exploring learning materials. (Testimony of FATHER, Ms. Mitra.) This is not a recently discovered feature of STUDENT’s educational needs. The District staff who worked with STUDENT before she turned three years old recognized these learning difficulties. In May 1996, Ms. Puckett noted in her speech and language evaluation of STUDENT that STUDENT does not perform well when she is “expected to perform on demand.” (Testimony of Ms. Puckett, Ms. Frazee. Resp. Exh. 200.)
The testimony and evidence at the hearing established that, although Ms. Rowland is a credentialed DHH teacher and Montessori-certified, she was not able to accommodate these learning needs and was not able to work well with STUDENT. Several individuals who observed Ms. Rowland with STUDENT on a regular basis testified that, of all the adults, Ms. Rowland had the most difficulty working with STUDENT. Ms. Rowland would demand language from STUDENT. When STUDENT became overwhelmed and walked away from Ms. Rowland, she would follow STUDENT and insist on continuing the interaction rather than allowing STUDENT time to absorb the information. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Mitra, Ms. Evans-Warkentien.) Ms. Rowland’s journal describes several situations where she was unable to control STUDENT or had serious difficulties interacting with her. On a few occasions, STUDENT threw things at Ms. Rowland. On others, STUDENT ran away from Ms. Rowland to the upstairs of the house. (STUDENT B Exh. 57, entries for 10/31, 11/5, 11/15, 11/21, 12/3.)
The District attributed STUDENT’s behavior with Ms. Rowland to the adjustment to attending Rancho Viejo. However, one of the most disturbing reports of difficulties Ms. Rowland had with STUDENT occurred while Ms. Rowland and Mr. Davino were serving STUDENT at home, before she began attending Rancho Viejo. MOTHER OF STUDENT A testified that in September 1996 she came to the STUDENT home to take STUDENT on a field trip and found STUDENT hiding from Ms. Rowland in the closet. MOTHER OF STUDENT A convinced STUDENT to come out of the closet, but STUDENT immediately returned to the closet when she saw Ms. Rowland. MOTHER OF STUDENT A testified that she was not able to get STUDENT out of the closet again until Ms. Rowland left. The only other adult who reported similar behavior was Mr. Davino, who is the other instructor at Crown Valley.(Footnote 6)
Ms. Evans-Warkentien testified that she asked Ms. Rowland to work with the older children rather than STUDENT and that STUDENT’s behavior improved after Ms. Rowland stopped focussing on her. Ms. Rowland’s journal entry for December 3, 1996, confirms this testimony, and the subsequent entries support the assertion that STUDENT’s behavior improved. From December 5, 1996, through March 12, 1997, there are few journal references to STUDENT and only two references to her having difficult behavior. (STUDENT B Exh. 57.) No witness, not even Mr. Davino, testified that Ms. Rowland had a good working relationship with STUDENT. Ms. Mitra testified that STUDENT seemed to be afraid of Ms. Rowland. When asked to describe Ms. Rowland’s relationship with STUDENT, Mr. Davino stated that Ms. Rowland strived to give STUDENT the same opportunity as the other children and would always provide the extra effort needed; he specifically did not state that they had a good working relationship. When called for rebuttal testimony, Mr. Davino did testify that STUDENT would sometimes hug Ms. Rowland, but he did not controvert the testimony of the many difficulties Ms. Rowland had with STUDENT.
Although Ms. Rowland is qualified to teach preschool children and demonstrated a genuine caring for the children in her care, the evidence clearly establishes that she was unable to work well with STUDENT and to accommodate her processing needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, with Ms. Rowland as the lead teacher, Crown Valley does not meet STUDENT’s need for instructors who understand and can accommodate her processing difficulties.
Audiological Services
The Respondent contends that the District has not offered adequate audiological services because Ms. Abramson, the District’s audiologist, is not competent to serve STUDENT and the Crown Valley staff are not competent to monitor her hearing aids. The District has offered one hour of audiological services in the form of consultation with parents and teachers, with up to one hour per week to monitor her equipment.
While there was evidence at the hearing that Ms. Abramson was not an appropriate audiologist for children with cochlear implants, the evidence did not establish that she is not competent to serve a child with hearing aids. In fact, Ms. Abramson has had significantly more experience serving children with hearing aids than she has with cochlear implants.
With respect to the staff at Crown Valley, both Mr. Davino and Ms. Rowland have had experience working with children with hearing aids. Both instructors testified persuasively that they know how to check a hearing aid to ensure it is working and to check a child’s ability to perceive sound. FATHER and MOTHER OF STUDENT A testified that, during their visit to Crown Valley, Mr. Davino appeared unaware that the DHH girl was not wearing her hearing aids. However, Mr. Davino and Ms. Puckett testified that the hearing aids had been removed because the girl’s ear was sore. This one instance, about which there was conflicting testimony, does not establish that the Crown Valley staff are not competent to monitor STUDENT’s hearing aids.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the audiological services offered by the District meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Extended School Year Program
The District acknowledges that STUDENT is entitled to receive extended school year services, but asserts that the twenty-day program offered at Crown Valley is sufficient to meet her needs. The Respondent asserts that STUDENT should have no more than a two-week break from special education services during the summer months because of her adverse reaction to change, her need for ongoing language stimulation, and her need to “catch up” from her time in the R.H. Dana program, which the PARENTS assert did not meet her needs.
California Education Code section 56345(b)(5) provides that “(b) [w]hen appropriate, the individualized education program shall also include, but not be limited to, all of the following: ... (5) Extended school year services when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team.” Additionally, California Code of Regulations section 3043(d) requires that an extended school year program consist of at least twenty instructional days including holidays. Section 3043 also provides that a student is eligible for extended school year services if interruption of the educational programming could cause regression that, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, would render it impossible or unlikely that the student would attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of the handicapping condition.
Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT is at high risk for regression if she has a significant break from instruction and therapy. STUDENT needs constant repetition of information to be able to learn it. After the four-week winter break, STUDENT displayed behaviors the staff had not seen for some time, such as spinning in circles and increased use of jargon. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins.) However, the end of the break coincided with the move to the new school, which could also have triggered the behavior. There was also no testimony that STUDENT’s academic or language skills regressed significantly during this four-week break. In fact, Ms. Hiland’s notes of STUDENT’s success in speech and language activities indicate that STUDENT’s skills stayed at the same level or improved over that four-week break. (Dist. Exh. 34.)
The District witnesses who had worked with STUDENT in the past testified that STUDENT did not need a year-round program because she had sign language support at home with her parents. (Testimony of Ms. Puckett, Ms. Frazee, Ms. Rowland, Mr. Davino.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence established that STUDENT does not requires a full academic classroom program for the entire summer. The evidence established that STUDENT can tolerate at least a four-week break in her academic program without regression that could not be reasonably recouped at the commencement of the regular school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a twenty-day instructional program for the extended school year meets STUDENT’s needs, provided that it is offered in a class that otherwise meets STUDENT’s needs.
(c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
In light of the findings that the Crown Valley program did not provide an appropriate peer group for STUDENT and that it could not meet STUDENT’s instructional needs, the Hearing Officer finds that it would not meet her unique needs or provide educational benefit to her. At a preschool level, peer interactions are a significant part of the educational process, especially for a hearing impaired child. Without appropriate peer interactions, STUDENT’s ability to benefit educationally from a program would be markedly compromised. In addition, without an instructor who understands and can accommodate STUDENT’s processing difficulties, it is unlikely that STUDENT would benefit educationally from the Crown Valley class.
***
Based on the above analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide a free appropriate public education to STUDENT from June 1997 to the present because the Crown Valley program does not meet STUDENT’s need for an appropriate peer group, nor does it meet her social/emotional needs.
2. If the District did not offer Respondent a FAPE from June 1997 to the present, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for her?
The Respondent is seeking a finding that the appropriate prospective placement for her is at the Rancho Viejo School, with speech and language services provided by Ms. Hiland and audiological services provided by Ms. Atkins. The Respondent is not asking for reimbursement for expenses incurred in the past due to the District’s failure to provide FAPE. However, it is undisputed that Rancho Viejo School is not a certified nonpublic school pursuant to California Education Code section 56366.1. Therefore, pursuant to California Education Code section 56505.2, the Hearing Officer may not render a decision resulting in a prospective placement at Rancho Viejo School. Although the Supreme Court found in Florence Co. School Dist. Four v. Carter, (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, that such lack of certification did not preclude reimbursement for services provided in the past, that decision does not require an order for prospective placement at an uncertified school when state law otherwise prohibits such an order.
Moreover, the program at Rancho Viejo, without the services currently provided by the District pursuant to stay put in this case, cannot serve STUDENT’s needs. The District is temporarily providing the DHH teacher and the signing aide in the classroom and pays for Ms. Hiland’s speech and language services. Although Ms. Hiland is associated with Rancho Viejo and has indicated that she would remain at the school to provide services, the DHH teacher and the signing aide are employed by the District, not Rancho Viejo. Without the DHH teacher and the signing aide, the only adult in the classroom would be Ms. Mitra. The testimony at the hearing established that Ms. Mitra is a beginning signer; she would not be able to provide the level of signing STUDENT needs to advance her skills. (Testimony of Ms. Mitra, Ms. Craik, Ms. Hiland, Mr. Kirchner, Mr. Davino.) Ms. Mitra also has no training in deaf education and cannot meet STUDENT’s need for a DHH teacher. Ms. Evans-Warkentien testified that she has engaged DHH teacher Todd Houser on a consultative basis to help serve the DHH children at Rancho Viejo. However, Mr. Houser is a full-time teacher in another district and cannot be present in the classroom on a regular basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the program at Rancho Viejo, without the services temporarily provided by the District, cannot meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus is not an appropriate placement for her.
Given the finding that Crown Valley is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT and that Rancho Viejo, by itself, is not an appropriate placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must either include more language mode peers of STUDENT’s age and ability at Crown Valley and provide an instructor who can meet STUDENT’s needs or place STUDENT in another program that meets her needs, as discussed above. The Hearing Officer notes that the District may provide individual or group services to STUDENT in a private preschool or day care center pursuant to Education Code sections 56440 et seq. The District must also continue to provide speech and language therapy, audiological services, sign language instruction, and parent education as stated on the IEP of July 15, 1997.
3. Are Respondent’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her audiological evaluation at Providence Speech and Hearing Center in Fall 1997 in the amount of $135.00, the cost of ear molds in the amount of $150.00, and related costs of transportation to and from Providence Speech and Hearing Center?
The Respondent argues that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the out-of-pocket expense of obtaining an audiological evaluation because the District failed to provide a FAPE. Reimbursement for private assessments is governed by California Education Code section 56329(b), which provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency and the District’s assessment is inappropriate. Ms. Abramson conducted an audiological assessment of STUDENT for the District on July 24, 1997, but she never provided a copy of her assessment report to the PARENTS. The PARENTS did not see the assessment report until it was provided in January 1998 as part of the evidence packet for this hearing. (Testimony of Ms. Abramson, FATHER, MOTHER.) However, the PARENTS were aware that this assessment was performed and were free to ask for a copy of the report before seeking their own private audiological evaluation. In fact, Ms. Abramson testified that she provided a copy of the report to the District to include in STUDENT’s student records, and the PARENTS had the right to review those records. The PARENTS did not ask for the report and did not express any objections to the evaluation.
In closing briefs, the Respondent asserted that Ms. Abramson’s evaluation is inappropriate because she concluded that STUDENT had excellent auditory discrimination and auditory comprehension skills. The Respondent asserts that this conclusion was contradicted by the testimony at the hearing that these are areas of difficulty for STUDENT. Ms. Abramson’s conclusions were based on the administration of the NU-Chips, a test that measures the child’s ability to understand spoken words with and without visual cues. Ms. Abramson administered this test in STUDENT’s home, with no other children around. STUDENT recognized 80% of the words used without visual cues, and 92% with visual cues. (Dist. Exh. 29.) Contrary to Respondent’s assertion that these results were inaccurate, this performance is consistent with other observations of STUDENT’s skills and her processing difficulties. The testimony established that STUDENT’s difficulties surface when there is background noise or distractions, not during quiet, one-to-one interactions. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that the District’s assessment was inappropriate. Thus, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for their independent evaluation.
Respondent is also seeking reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s ear molds, which are devices used with amplification systems. With hearing aids such as STUDENT’s that sit behind the ear, the ear mold holds the tube that carries the amplified sound from the hearing aid to the inside of the ear. The fit of the ear mold must be sufficiently snug to prevent feedback. As a child grows, the ear molds must be replaced to ensure a snug fit. Respondent asserts that ear molds are an assistive technology device under the IDEA and that the District must provide them because they are necessary for STUDENT to function in the classroom. The District concedes that ear molds would be an assistive technology device if they were necessary to provide FAPE and the IEP specifies that they were necessary. However, the District argues that STUDENT’s IEPs do not specify that her hearing aids and ear molds are necessary for FAPE, and thus they are medical equipment rather than assistive technology. As such, the District asserts that it is not obligated to provide ear molds.
The IDEA defines assistive technology device as “any item, piece of equipment, or product system, whether acquired commercially off the shelf, modified, or customized, that is used to increase, maintain, or improve functional capabilities of a child with a disability.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(1). California Education Code section 56363.1 provides that school districts are not required to purchase medical equipment for students, but excludes assistive technology devices as defined in the IDEA from the definition of medical equipment. Section 56363.1 also states that school districts are “responsible for providing other specialized equipment for use at school that is needed to implement the individualized education program.” The federal Office of Special Education Policy (OSEP) has expressed the opinion that school districts are required to pay for hearing aids when a student’s IEP team determines that the hearing aids are necessary for a FAPE and the IEP requires the hearing aids. Letter to Seiler, 20 IDELR 1216.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ear molds are devices that increase, maintain, or improve her functional capabilities. Without the ear molds, STUDENT’s hearing aids do not work and STUDENT is unable to perceive sound within the normal voice range. Therefore, the ear molds qualify as assistive technology. Furthermore, STUDENT’s IEPs refer to her amplification system, including her ear molds. The IEP of June 13, 1996, requires the District to provide audiological “services and equipment as needed” and includes a goal of maintaining consistent amplification at home and school. (Resp. Exh. 203.) The IEP of November 13, 1996, continued those goals and objectives. (Resp. Exh. 217.) At the IEP meeting of July 15, 1997, the District agreed to pay for the ear molds obtained for STUDENT from August 1996 through August 1997. (Resp. Exh. 242.) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP team determined that her ear molds were necessary for her to receive an appropriate education and that the District is obligated to pay for the ear molds.(Footnote 7)
ORDER
1. Within fifteen days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team shall develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT, including but not limited to the following elements:
(a) a preschool program co-enrolled with DHH and hearing peers, including a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately STUDENT’s age and ability, instruction from a DHH teacher who is familiar with and can accommodate STUDENT’s processing difficulties, and a signing aide;
(b) three forty-five-minute sessions per week of speech and language therapy;
(c) audiological services up to one hour per week to monitor equipment functioning, one hour per month to consult with parents and teachers, and provision of ear molds as needed;
(d) weekly sign language instruction for her family; and (e) extended school year services with a twenty-day classroom program.
2. Upon presentation of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of ear molds obtained for STUDENT from August 1997 through the date of this decision.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue 1: Respondent substantially prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: To the extent that the Crown Valley SDC as it existed at the time of the hearing was inappropriate for STUDENT, the Respondent prevailed on this issue. To the extent that the program at Rancho Viejo was found to be inappropriate for STUDENT, the District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3: To the extent that the audiological evaluation was found to be appropriate, the District prevailed on this issue. To the extent that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for ear molds, the Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: July 9, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. SEE is a form of signing in English that varies significantly from American Sign Language (ASL), which is recognized as a separate language because of its unique word order and tense formations. SEE uses many signs from ASL and also modifies those signs to make a separate sign for each word. For example, one sign in ASL means both “part” and “some,” while SEE modifies that sign to make separate signs for those two words. In addition, SEE uses special signs for prefixes, markers, and endings that indicate plurals and verb tenses. Signs in SEE are presented in English word order, not ASL order. Some of the witnesses at the hearing referred to what is described above as “SEE-2,” distinguishing it from Seeing Exact English, in which each phonemic element of a word has a sign. Because most of the witnesses referred to the language used by STUDENT as simply SEE, that term shall be used in this decision. 2.. In the closing brief, the Respondent also asserted that Crown Valley program is at maximum enrollment because ten children are enrolled and California Education Code section 56441.5 requires a 5:1 child-to-adult ratio in SDCs for DHH children. The evidence at hearing did not support this assertion. Ms. Carolyn Rowland, the Crown Valley teacher, testified that ten children are enrolled, but about eight are present each day because some of the children do not attend every day. Because the program has both a teacher and a program aide, there is no evidence that the program would exceed the required 5:1 ratio if STUDENT attended. 3.Whether a placement conforms to the student’s IEP is typically part of the analysis of whether a school district provided a FAPE. However, that issue will not be examined in this decision because STUDENT does not have a current, agreed-upon IEP. 4.Prior to January 1998, the speech and language therapy would have been provided by Ms. Lisa DeLany 5. From September through November 1997, there was a hearing child of deaf parents in the class who also used sign language as her primary mode of communication. However, because that child was no longer present in the class at the time of this hearing, her skills will not be considered in determining if Crown Valley provides a sufficient number of language mode peers for STUDENT. 6. The PARENTS testified that, while she was being toilet trained, STUDENT sometimes went to her closet while soiling her diaper. However, finding a secluded spot to relieve herself is not the same as hiding from an adult and refusing to come out. 7. This finding is based upon the criteria set forth by OSEP. However, policy letters by OSEP are not binding precedent. It may not be necessary for a device to meet the OSEP criterium of being on the IEP to be an assistive technology for which the school district must pay if a hearing officer or court finds that the device is necessary for FAPE.
