California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 8, 1998

Capistrano Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1628-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Capistrano Unified's deaf preschool offer denied FAPE for lack of signing peers; Rancho Viejo placement and evaluation reimbursement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 11 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision references the parents' earlier hearing requests, filed September 9, 1997 and withdrawn December 5, 1997, and a March 1997 settlement of an Office of Administrative Hearings Part C matter.

Summary

Capistrano Unified School District filed for hearing to show that its offer was a FAPE for a 3-year-old girl. She is profoundly deaf, has a cochlear implant, and communicates in Signing Exact English (SEE). The District offered a Montessori preschool class at Crown Valley Elementary that enrolled both deaf and hearing children. The offer also included five hours a week of speech therapy, one hour a month of audiology consultation, family sign classes, and a 20-day extended school year (ESY). The parents wanted her to stay at Rancho Viejo School, a private preschool, with her private speech therapist and audiologist.

Hearing Officer Keltie Jones rejected most procedural claims. No teacher attended the IEP meeting, which was a violation, but it did not deny FAPE. On substance, the Hearing Officer found that Crown Valley lacked enough signing peers of her age and ability, which state law requires for deaf children. Audiology consultation alone was not enough. Services also had to include staff training, weekly contact, and direct help as needed. The District's assigned audiologist was found unsuitable. Speech and audiology services also had to continue all summer, with no more than a two-week break. Rancho Viejo was not ordered because it was not a certified nonpublic school and could not meet her needs without District staff. Reimbursement for a medical evaluation at the House Ear Institute was denied. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to build a compliant program.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's requirement that deaf children be educated with a sufficient number of language mode peers. The Hearing Officer looked closely at the age and signing ability of actual classmates. The decision also shows that SEHO would not order prospective placement at an uncertified private school, even after finding that the district's offer denied FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1(a)(1). Whether the District decided on the Crown Valley placement without an IEP meeting and failed to give written notice of a change in placement

    The June 24, 1997 notice was given, placement was discussed in detail at the June 30 IEP meeting, and no decision was made beforehand.

  2. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1(a)(2). Whether the District failed to implement the last agreed-upon IFSP and the March 1997 settlement during summer 1997 (signing aide, DHH teacher, audiology, sign classes, child care)

    Services before age three were outside SEHO jurisdiction; the settlement ran only to the transition IEP, and no procedural violation occurred in summer 1997.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1(a)(3). Whether the District failed to offer a full continuum of placements and refused to discuss the parents' request for Rancho Viejo at the June 30, 1997 IEP meeting

    The IEP shows that regular class with supports, SDC, and nonpublic school were considered; earlier years were not relevant.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1(a)(4). Whether the District failed to give written and adequate notice of the June 1997 IEP meetings and improperly told Mother the meeting would proceed without her

    District rescheduling letters were adequate written notice, and the meeting waited until Mother's advocate arrived, so participation was not impaired.

  5. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 1(a)(5). Whether the District failed to ensure that regular and special education teachers attended the IEP meeting

    No teacher attended, which violated Ed. Code 56341, but a teacher's presence would not have changed either side's position, so there was no loss of benefit or participation.

  6. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1(b)-peers. Whether the Crown Valley placement met the student's need for a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately the same age and ability

    Under Ed. Code 56000.5(b)(4) and 56001(g), Crown Valley lacked enough signing peers near her age and ability. One deaf peer was a year younger, the other rarely communicated, and hearing children did not sign spontaneously with deaf children.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(b)-audiology. Whether the audiological services offered (one hour per month of consultation by the District audiologist) were appropriate

    Consultation alone was not enough: services must include staff training, direct services as needed, and weekly contact, and the assigned audiologist was not suitable. Fifteen minutes a day of direct services was not required.

  8. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 1(b)-ESY. Whether the twenty-day extended school year program met the student's needs

    Speech therapy, auditory habilitation, and audiology had to continue all summer with no more than a two-week break. A 20-day classroom program was enough.

  9. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(c). Whether the placement was designed to provide educational benefit to the student

    Without appropriate peer interaction, which is central at the preschool level, Crown Valley would not provide educational benefit. The District did not offer FAPE from July 28, 1997.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. If the District did not offer a FAPE, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for the student?

    Rancho Viejo was not a certified nonpublic school, so Ed. Code 56505.2 barred a prospective placement order. Without District staff it also could not meet her needs.

  11. Issue 3. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the House Ear Institute audiological evaluation and related transportation?

    The parents never disagreed with the District's assessment, and the evaluation was a medical follow-up mostly paid by insurance, so no reimbursement was due under Ed. Code 56329(b).

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within fifteen days of the decision, convene an IEP team meeting to develop an appropriate placement including the elements listed in the order.
  • Order to provide or change services. (a) A preschool program co-enrolled with DHH and hearing peers, including a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately the student's age and ability, instruction from a DHH teacher, and a signing aide.
  • Order to provide or change services. (b) Five hours per week of speech and language therapy from an individual experienced with children with cochlear implants.
  • Order to provide or change services. (c) One hour per month of direct and consultative audiological services from an audiologist with demonstrated skill with children with cochlear implants, including training staff to monitor the implant and weekly contact with classroom staff.
  • Order to provide or change services. (d) Weekly sign language instruction for the family.
  • Order to provide or change services. (e) Extended school year services including a twenty-day classroom program, with no more than a two-week break from speech and language and audiological services.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter

People named in the decision

  • Doreen Lohnes, director of special education, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Robert (Bob) White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
  • Linda Puckett, speech-language therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Maria Abramson, district audiologist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Tammi Galley, speech-language therapist (offered provider), Capistrano Unified School District
  • Carolyn Rowland, DHH teacher, Crown Valley preschool teacher, South Orange County SELPA
  • Carl Kirchner, founder of TRIPOD program; witness, TRIPOD, Burbank
  • Dennis Davino, program aide, SEE signer, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Lisa DeLany, speech-language therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Suzanne (Sue) Craik, DHH teacher assigned to Rancho Viejo, Capistrano Unified School District
  • James Blinn, District witness (role not stated)
  • Cynthia Frazee, District witness (role not stated)
  • Kim Huynen, Respondent witness (role not stated)
  • Ruth Hiland, private speech-language pathologist, Rancho Viejo School
  • Debbie (Debra) Evans-Warkentien, founder/operator of private preschool, Rancho Viejo School
  • Sarmila Mitra, Montessori-certified preschool teacher, Rancho Viejo School
  • Carol Atkins, private audiologist, Rancho Viejo School
  • Jan Casteel, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Renee Burgayo, signing aide, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Jennifer Gorgone, DHH teacher (briefly), Rancho Viejo School
  • Todd Houser, DHH teacher consultant, Rancho Viejo School
  • Corinne Parker, legal assistant and child advocate for Respondent
  • Patricia Cromer, attorney present for Respondent
  • House Ear Institute, private medical/audiological evaluator
  • John Tracy Clinic, developmental assessment provider
  • Broderick Montessori, private preschool

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing on January 20 and 21, February 5, 6, 17, 18, 19, 20, and March 9, 1998, in San Juan Capistrano and Laguna Niguel, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. This matter was heard concurrently with the matter of Capistrano Unified School District v. STUDENT A, Case No. SN 1627-97, which is the subject of a separate decision.

Petitioner Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan of Miller Brown & Dannis. Doreen Lohnes, director of special education, and Bob White, director of the South Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA), were also present at various times on the District’s behalf.

Respondent was represented at the hearing by attorney Joan Honeycutt. Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, was present for all days of the hearing. Also present at the hearing at various times on Respondent’s behalf were her father, FATHER, attorney Patricia Cromer, and Corinne Parker, Ms. Honeycutt’s legal assistant and a child advocate. MOTHER OF STUDENT A and FATHER OF STUDENT A were also present at the hearing on behalf of their daughter STUDENT A.

The District called the following witnesses to testify: Linda Puckett, Maria Abramson, Tammi Galley, Carolyn Rowland, Carl Kirchner, Dennis Davino, Doreen Lohnes, Lisa DeLany, Suzanne Craik, James Blinn, Cynthia Frazee, and Robert White.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER, MOTHER OF STUDENT A, Ruth Hiland, Kim Huynen, Maria Abramson, FATHER OF STUDENT A, Debbie Evans-Warkentien, Sarmila Mitra, and Carol Atkins.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. In the interests of judicial economy, the parties agreed that the oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing in the matter of STUDENT B v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN 894-97, would be incorporated into the record for this matter. Closing arguments were received by May 5, 1998. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Did the District provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for Respondent from July 28, 1997(Footnote 1) to the present?

2. If the District did not offer Respondent a FAPE from July 28, 1997, to the present, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for her ?

3. Are Respondent’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her audiological evaluation at House Ear Institute and related costs of transportation to and from House Ear Institute?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Since July 28, 1997, the District has offered STUDENT placement in a deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) special day class at Crown Valley Elementary School (Crown Valley). The class is attended by both hearing and DHH preschoolers and is taught by a Montessori-certified, DHH-credentialed teacher (DHH teacher) and a program aide fluent in Signing Exact English (SEE).(Footnote 2) In addition, the District is offering five hours per week of speech and language therapy by Tammi Galley, audiological services of one hour per month for consultation with parents and teachers by Maria Abramson, one hour per week of sign language classes for family members, parent education classes, and a twenty-day extended school year program at the Crown Valley class. The District asserts that this placement and related services provide a FAPE for STUDENT.

The Respondent argues that the Crown Valley class is not appropriate because it does not meet STUDENT’s need for a sufficient number of language mode peers.(Footnote 3) The Respondent also asserts that the level of audiological services is not appropriate and that Ms. Abramson is not competent to provide those services. The Respondent proposes that the appropriate program to serve all her needs is the Rancho Viejo School, a private Montessori preschool designed to serve both hearing and DHH students, five hours per week of speech therapy by Ruth Hiland and fifteen minutes per day of audiological services by Carol Atkins.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, who will turn four years old in July, was diagnosed before she turned one with profound bilateral sensorineural hearing loss, or profound deafness. The first Individual Family Services Plan (IFSP) meeting for STUDENT was held on July 13, 1995. At that time, STUDENT began receiving special education services consisting of one hour per week of speech and language services at home and audiological services as needed. In November 1995, STUDENT received a set of hearing aids. However, the hearing aids provided little improvement in STUDENT’s ability to perceive sound. At the same time, STUDENT began receiving private speech therapy from Ruth Hiland.

In early 1996, MOTHER and MOTHER OF STUDENT B, the parent of another deaf toddler, began looking into the programs the District offered for deaf toddlers and preschoolers. They observed the District’s program at R.H. Dana Exceptional Needs Facility, which served children with a wide variety of disabilities, and the program offered at Taft School by the Santa Ana School District, which served deaf children. The PARENTS and the PARENTS OF STUDENT B began to ask why the District did not have a program similar to Taft’s. In February 1996, the PARENTS agreed to place STUDENT at the R.H. Dana program because they were told it was the only program the District had for DHH toddlers. (Testimony of MOTHER.) At the same time, Ruth Hiland began a “Language in Motion” program designed to serve STUDENT and STUDENT B. STUDENT attended R.H. Dana two days a week for 2 ½ hours each day and participated in Ms. Hiland’s program two days a week.

In May 1996, the PARENTS refused to sign an IFSP that continued STUDENT’s placement at R.H. Dana. At the same time, MOTHER and MOTHER OF STUDENT B were actively pursuing the development of a program for DHH preschoolers in the District. During a meeting with District and SELPA representatives to discuss establishing a new program, they asked if the children could be served at Broderick Montessori, a local preschool. In June 1996, the District agreed to pay for STUDENT to attend Broderick Montessori three days per week while the parents paid for the other two days. The District also agreed to provide a DHH teacher to help the preschool staff on the three days for which the District was paying and to provide a signing aide for the other two days. STUDENT attended Broderick for five days a week from June through the end of August. In September, she could attend only two days a week because Broderick was full on the other days.

On July 24 and August 20, 1996, District and SELPA representatives met with parents of DHH children and Debra Evans-Warkentien, a friend of MOTHER who was starting a Montessori preschool. The parents advocated the development of a program modeled after TRIPOD in Burbank, which consisted of co-enrollment of DHH and hearing students in a Montessori preschool class taught by a DHH teacher and a Montessori-credentialed teacher. All involved seemed to be enthusiastic about developing such a program in south Orange County, and the District and SELPA staff began to explore a partnership with Ms. Evans-Warkentien’s planned Rancho Viejo School. MOTHER, Ms. Evans-Warkentien, and Carolyn Rowland, a SELPA employee and DHH teacher, began to look for a site for the school. At one point, the District offered a portable that could be moved to the Bergeson Elementary School campus. Ms. Evans-Warkentien rejected that offer because it would cost about $13,000 to move the portable and she believed it would be a costly temporary solution. Because it was taking so long to find a site and because the children could not be served full-time at Broderick, Ms. Evans-Warkentien obtained a home day-care license and started the Rancho Viejo School in her home at the beginning of October 1996 with Ms. Sarmila Mitra, a Montessori-certified teacher. The District provided Ms. Rowland and Dennis Davino, a program aide and fluent SEE signer, to deliver special education services to the DHH children at Rancho Viejo.

During September 1996, STUDENT began evaluation at the House Ear Institute to determine if she was a good candidate for a cochlear implant.(Footnote 4) On October 4, 1996, STUDENT received her cochlear implant. With her cochlear implant, STUDENT became able to perceive sound, but she required intensive auditory habilitation to teach her how to understand the sounds she perceived.

Discussions between the SELPA and Ms. Evans-Warkentien about developing a cooperative program continued. However, disagreements between the parties began to emerge. The SELPA did not want to provide any financial support for the school, other than providing a DHH teacher and a signing aide. Ms. Evans-Warkentien expected at least partial tuition support for the DHH children attending the school. The site search continued, and Ms. Rowland began to express concerns to the District and SELPA about the operation of the school in the home. Ms. Rowland was enrolled in a Montessori certification program and was performing her internship at Rancho Viejo under Ms. Mitra’s supervision. As part of her course, Ms. Rowland obtained the permission of PARENTS OF STUDENT A to conduct a developmental case study of STUDENT A, who was also attending Rancho Viejo. Ms. Rowland also kept a journal in which she wrote her observations of, and her frustrations with, the development of the Rancho Viejo program.

The delay in officially establishing a cooperative program, and other issues, prompted the PARENTS to file a request for a due process hearing with the Office of Administrative Hearings in February 1997.(Footnote 5) On March 3, 1997, the PARENTS had an IFSP meeting at which the level of STUDENT’s speech and language therapy was increased to five one-hour sessions per week, in accordance with the strong recommendation the PARENTS received from the House Ear Institute. The PARENTS also requested that a speech therapist familiar with preschoolers with cochlear implants be assigned to STUDENT. Eventually, Ms. Hiland provided all of STUDENT’s speech therapy at Rancho Viejo and invoiced the District for the services she provided. At that same IFSP meeting, the District indicated its intention to provide a DHH preschool program at a District school site starting in June 1997.

On March 20, 1997, the PARENTS and the District settled the due process matter filed with the Office of Administrative Hearings. The District agreed to reimburse Ms. Evans-Warkentien for certain costs and to continue providing services to STUDENT at Rancho Viejo until her transition IEP, which would take effect when STUDENT turned three years old. This settlement occurred at the commencement of a due process hearing for STUDENT A. At some point during the settlement meetings, the PARENTS OF STUDENT A or the PARENTS picked up a file belonging to the District that contained Ms. Rowland’s journal. The PARENTS OF STUDENT A, the PARENTS, and Ms. Honeycutt, their attorney, discovered the journal and read portions of it during dinner that night. The parents were very upset by the tone of the journal and the fact that Ms. Rowland had shared information from her case study on STUDENT A with the District’s representatives without sharing it with the PARENTS OF STUDENT A. On March 23, 1997, the PARENTS OF STUDENT A withdrew their consent to allow Ms. Rowland to conduct a case study on STUDENT A. On April 7, 1997, Ms. Evans-Warkentien, on behalf of the parents of the DHH children at Rancho Viejo, requested that Ms. Rowland no longer be assigned to Rancho Viejo. Doreen Lohnes asked each set of parents to confirm that they wanted Ms. Rowland removed from the program. The PARENTS responded that they did believe that she had committed an unethical breach of confidentiality and did not want her to serve STUDENT. Ms. Rowland did not return to Rancho Viejo, and the District did not provide a replacement DHH teacher.

From April through June, Mr. Davino was the only District employee working full-time at Rancho Viejo. Ms. Linda Puckett, a District employee, visited three days a week to provide speech therapy to STUDENT A. Ms. Hiland, the private speech therapist, was present on a daily basis to provide speech therapy to STUDENT B and STUDENT.

STUDENT received a battery of assessments in May 1997 in preparation for her transition from the early start program for children under three to the special education program for children over three. Those assessments included an audiology assessment by Ms. Abramson, a developmental assessment by the John Tracy Clinic (a clinic that serves DHH children), a speech assessment by Ms. Puckett, and a psychological assessment by school psychologist Jan Casteel.

On June 13, 1997, at an IEP meeting for STUDENT B that MOTHER attended, the District presented a formal proposal for a District-operated DHH, Montessori preschool at Crown Valley Elementary School taught by Ms. Rowland and a signing aide. The preschool would have hearing and DHH children co-enrolled. On June 24, 1997, the District notified the PARENTS that it was proposing to change STUDENT’s placement to the new District program at Crown Valley. An IEP meeting for STUDENT was scheduled for June 25, 1997, but MOTHER canceled it due to illness. The District then scheduled the meeting for 9:00 am on June 27, the same time that MOTHER had scheduled to observe the Crown Valley program. MOTHER indicated that she would not be able to attend that meeting or observe the program on June 27. The District rescheduled the meeting for June 30 at 9:00 a.m., another time MOTHER had scheduled to observe the Crown Valley program. MOTHER was able to observe the program for about twenty minutes on June 30, and then District staff told her that she needed to come to the IEP meeting or it would proceed without her.

At the IEP meeting, the District proposed to place STUDENT at Crown Valley. The District also offered one hour of individual speech therapy five times a week, audiological services of one hour per month for consultation with parents and teachers, two hours per month of parent education, weekly sign language classes for family members, and extended school year services through July 23 for the classroom program and through July 28 for speech and language therapy. After discussion and modification, the PARENTS agreed that the goals and objectives proposed were appropriate for STUDENT. However, the parents did not agree with the placement being offered and did not sign the IEP. The PARENTS did not agree to place STUDENT at Crown Valley, and she continued to attend Rancho Viejo.

On June 20, 1997, the District removed Mr. Davino from the Rancho Viejo program and assigned him to the Crown Valley program. The District provided Ms. Renee Burgayo as a signing aide in Mr. Davino’s place from June 23 to June 30, but had still not replaced Ms. Rowland. On July 9, 1997, the Hearing Office ordered in the STUDENT B case that the District continue providing a signing aide knowledgeable in SEE to the Rancho Viejo program. In July 1997, Ms. Evans-Warkentien retained audiologist Carol Atkins to provide audiological services at Rancho Viejo two hours per week to check the functioning of the DHH children’s equipment and to consult with the staff and parents. The District did not provide a new signing aide until August 21, 1997, and did not provide a credentialed DHH teacher until November 12, 1997, when it assigned Sue Craik. On September 9, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt filed requests for due process hearings on behalf of STUDENT and STUDENT A.

The District’s sign language classes, which were offered on a weekly basis during the school year, were offered four times during the summer of 1997. MOTHER attended the first two classes and concluded that they were a waste of her time because they were simply review classes covering skills she had already acquired. MOTHER also felt that the summer classes were intended to involve the parents of the hearing children attending the Crown Valley program in sign language rather than to help her communicate with her deaf daughter. In the fall, the sign classes resumed on a weekly basis, with a one-hour class for beginners and a one-hour class for intermediate signers. The PARENTS did not attend any of the classes offered in the fall.

At the beginning of September, Ms. Evans-Warkentien hired Jennifer Gorgone, a credentialed DHH teacher. Ms. Gorgone worked at Rancho Viejo for about two weeks; she left the program due to her dissatisfaction with the implementation of the Montessori curriculum and the location of the program in a home rather than a school. By this time, Ms. Evans-Warkentien had located a new site for the school and construction had begun. Due to various delays, Rancho Viejo did not move to its new site until January 20, 1998.

The hearing for the STUDENT and STUDENT A matters was scheduled to proceed as soon as the STUDENT B hearing concluded during the week of November 17-21, 1997. However, the STUDENT B hearing concluded on November 20, and neither the PARENTS OF STUDENT A nor the PARENTS were able to attend on November 21. Additional hearing dates were set for December 11, 12, 16, and 17, 1997. On November 24, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt requested a continuance of the agreed-upon hearing dates. The Hearing Office denied the motion, and on December 5, 1997, Ms. Honeycutt withdrew the requests for hearing. On December 19, 1997, the District requested this due process proceeding.

On December 4, 1997, STUDENT had an audiological evaluation at the House Ear Institute in conjunction with her one-year follow-up evaluation for her cochlear implant.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for Respondent from June 1997 to the present?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 176, 200. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court’s interpretation of the IDEA provide the following three factors for analyzing whether the placement the District offered for STUDENT from June 30, 1997, forward provided a FAPE:

(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT? (b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? and (c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?(Footnote 6)

In determining whether the District has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314. If the District’s program reflects the child’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. The District has offered a placement for STUDENT that includes the following elements:

1. The Crown Valley Montessori preschool class co-enrolled with DHH and hearing children, taught by a DHH teacher and a signing aide in total communication using both voice and SEE sign. 2. Five one-hour speech therapy sessions per week provided by Tammi Galley.(Footnote 7) 3. Audiological services provided by Maria Abramson one hour per month to consult with parents and teachers. 4. Two hours per month of parent education.

5. One hour per week of sign language classes for family members. 6. A twenty-day extended school year program.

(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT?

In the closing brief, the Respondent argued that several procedural errors in the IEP process were significant enough to amount to a denial of FAPE. Each of the alleged violations will be addressed separately to determine if violations occurred. If a violation occurred, it will be determined whether it resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parents’ participation in the IEP process, resulting in the denial of FAPE.

1. The District made the decision to place STUDENT at Crown Valley without convening an IEP team meeting and did not comply with the written notice requirements for a change in placement.

On June 24, 1997, the District informed the PARENTS in writing that it “proposed a change in location of the preschool special education program for deaf and hard of hearing children.” (Dist. Exh. 21.) An IEP meeting for STUDENT was scheduled for June 26, 1997. When the IEP meeting was ultimately held on June 30, 1997, the proposed placement was discussed in detail and the parents were provided with a copy of their parental rights in conformance with 34 C.F.R. § 300.504-.505. No decision to place STUDENT at Crown Valley was made prior to the IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit this alleged violation.

2. The District failed to implement STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IFSP as modified by the March 1997 Settlement Agreement during the summer of 1997 by failing to provide a signing aide, a credentialed DHH teacher, audiological services, appropriate sign language classes for the PARENTS, and child care services during sign language classes.

The Hearing Office’s jurisdiction is confined to disputes involving children over three years of age. STUDENT turned three on July 28, 1997; therefore, whether the District provided appropriate services before that date is not relevant to this proceeding.

When STUDENT turned three years old, the District was in a situation in which it did not have an agreed-upon IEP and no request for due process had been filed. Moreover, the Settlement Agreement entered into in March 1997 required the District to provide the services listed in the Agreement and on the current IFSP only through the transition IEP, which would take effect when STUDENT turned three. California Education Code section 56346 prohibits a district from implementing special education services without the parents’ consent and requires the District to request a due process hearing if it deems that the services not consented to are necessary to provide a FAPE for the child. However, in this case, the District was not offering STUDENT any services between July 28, 1997, and the beginning of the 1997-98 school year. Shortly after the commencement of the 1997-98 school year, the parents themselves requested a due process hearing, obviating the need for the District to request such a hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to provide services during the summer of 1997. 3. The District failed to offer a full continuum of placements during her IFSP or IEP meetings and refused to discuss the parents’ request that STUDENT remain at Rancho Viejo at the IEP meeting of June 30, 1997.

The relevant period of time for this hearing is July 28, 1997, forward. Whether the District offered a full continuum of placements during prior years is not relevant. The IEP dated June 30, 1997, indicates that the team considered placements in a regular class with supplemental services, an SDC, and a nonpublic school. (Dist. Exh. 24.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit this alleged violation for the period of time relevant to this hearing.

4. The District failed to provide written notice of the IEP meetings scheduled in June 1997, failed to provide adequate notice of the meeting on June 30, 1997, and informed MOTHER that the meeting would proceed without her if she would not attend.

Several IEP meetings for STUDENT were scheduled and canceled during June 1997. The documents in evidence and the testimony at the hearing establish that MOTHER was aware of all of those meetings. The correspondence from the District setting new meeting dates when a meeting was canceled constitute written notice of the IEP meeting. (Dist. Exh. 22, 23.) Those letters indicated where and when the meeting would occur and who would be present, in conformance with 34 C.F.R. § 300.345. With respect to informing MOTHER on June 30th that the IEP meeting would proceed without her if she refused to attend, the meeting did not in fact do so. That level of pressure to proceed with the meeting may have been unwarranted considering that STUDENT would not turn three until July 28, but it did not interfere with MOTHER’s ability to participate in the IEP process. In fact, the District did not convene the meeting until MOTHER’s advocate, Corinne Parker, and Mrs. Evans-Warkentien arrived to accompany MOTHER to the meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit this alleged violation.

5. The District failed to ensure that regular education and special education teachers attended the IEP meeting.

California Education Code section 56341(2) requires that an IEP team include “the pupil’s present teacher. If the pupil does not presently have a teacher, this representative shall be the teacher with the most recent and complete knowledge of the pupil who has also observed the pupil’s educational performance in an appropriate setting. If no teacher is available, this representative shall be a regular classroom teacher referring the pupil, or a special education teacher qualified to teach a pupil of his or her age.” Ms. Mitra, STUDENT’s current preschool teacher, was not present at the IEP meeting, and, at that point, there was no special education teacher assigned to teach STUDENT. However, Ms. Evans-Warkentien was present at the IEP meeting. Although Ms. Evans-Warkentien did not teach STUDENT, she was occasionally present in the classroom and frequently observed the classroom. Moreover, based on the testimony of those who have taught STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the presence of a teacher would not have affected the District’s position that the Crown Valley program was appropriate for STUDENT or the PARENTS’ position that it was not. (Testimony of Ms. Rowland, Ms. Mitra.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the District violated the requirement that a teacher be part of the IEP team, that violation did not deny educational benefit or deprive the parents of the right to participate in the IEP process.

(b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The testimony at the hearing established that STUDENT needs a preschool program co-enrolled with appropriate DHH and hearing peers, instruction from a DHH teacher, a signing aide, speech and language therapy, audiological services, sign language instruction for her parents, and extended school year services. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins, Mr. Kirchner.) The Respondent asserts that the Crown Valley program does not meet her need for an appropriate peer group or her audiological needs. The Respondent also takes the position that STUDENT needs a ten-week summer program rather than just the four weeks offered at Crown Valley.

Appropriateness of Peer Group

California Education Code section 56000.5(b)(4) provides that “it is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education with a sufficient number of language mode peers with whom they can communicate directly and who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.” California Education Code section 56001(g) further requires that programs for DHH children take into consideration “the individual’s needs for a sufficient number of age and language mode peers.” The legislature has provided no definition of “sufficient number.”

STUDENT’s language mode is SEE sign. She signs throughout the day, and usually uses her voice with her signs. (Testimony of Ms. Hiland, Ms. Craik, Mr. Kirchner, MOTHER.) Except for well-practiced words and phrases (such as the names of her classmates), STUDENT generally would not be understood if she used her voice alone. STUDENT is a bright child whose only disability is her hearing impairment. In May 1997, Linda Puckett reported that, at the age of 2 years 10 months, STUDENT scored in the 3 years 7 months to 4 years 3 months range on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - III, using sign language. At the same age, STUDENT demonstrated receptive language abilities in the 2 ½ to 3 ½ year range and expressive language abilities in the 2 to 3 year range as measured by the Preschool Language Scale - 3. Ms. Puckett concluded that STUDENT’s language skills were age appropriate. (Resp. Exh. 135.) In June 1997, Ms. Hiland reported that STUDENT “uses predominantly simple kernel sentences varying from 1-4 words in length to communicate, with her average mean length of utterance being 2.3 morphemes [parts of words] per utterance.” (Resp. Exh. 138.) In January 1998, when STUDENT was about 3 ½, Ms. Hiland reported that she “continues to use primarily kernel sentences consisting of object + action or familiar phrases” and that the mean length of utterance had increased to 3.2 morphemes. At that point, STUDENT had begun to use the SEE progressive and past tense markers. Ms. Hiland testified in February 1998 that STUDENT used the SEE word endings spontaneously and properly, as well as the conjunctions and and but. Ms. Hiland further testified that STUDENT had recently developed the proper use of the past tense and present progressive ending markers. Ms. Craik, the DHH teacher assigned by the District to Rancho Viejo, testified that STUDENT’s use of the SEE word endings was inconsistent. However, when questioned about STUDENT’s progress on many of the goals and objectives in her IEP, Ms. Craik could not say whether STUDENT had met them. For the same goals and objectives, Ms. Hiland provided detailed testimony about STUDENT’s progress. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Hiland demonstrated more familiarity with STUDENT’s skills than did Ms. Craik, and thus gives Ms. Hiland’s opinion of STUDENT’s skills more weight. The Hearing Officer further finds that, given the level of her development when tested in May 1997 and given the consistent progress STUDENT was making, STUDENT’s sign language skills are at or above her age level. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was 3 ½ years old.

The reports of the skills of the children in the Crown Valley program varied. The DHH girl in the class is about one year younger than STUDENT, and the DHH boy is about one year older than STUDENT. Both children use sign language as their language mode.(Footnote 8) Ms. Rowland testified that the DHH girl in the class had no language at all as of June 1997, but in January 1998 was able to communicate her wants and needs and have conversations in SEE sign. Ms. Rowland also testified that, as of January 1998, there were two children in the class who had sign skills equivalent to STUDENT’s in March 1997, ten months earlier. She did not specify whether those two children were DHH or hearing. When asked to identify the strongest signer in the class, Ms. Rowland chose a hearing child whose entire exposure to SEE sign came from her attendance at the Crown Valley program. Mr. Davino testified that that same hearing child was able to sign 479 words without prompting. These, combined with her ability to use the SEE markers, resulted in a vocabulary of approximately 1200 to 1400 words. Speech and language therapist Lisa DeLany testified that the DHH girl had excellent sign skills that were appropriate for her age, which was 2 ½, and that she was starting to use markers, tenses, prepositions, and pronouns. Ms. DeLany also testified that the DHH boy in the class had sign skills that were below his age level. Ms. DeLany stated that the DHH boy is shy about signing, but that he was starting to use more sign language.

Mr. Carl Kirchner, the founder of the TRIPOD program after which both Crown Valley and Rancho Viejo are modeled, observed the Crown Valley program for a day in mid-January 1998. He testified that the DHH girl had age-appropriate sign skills. He also observed at Rancho Viejo and testified that the children at Rancho Viejo, including STUDENT, signed using longer strings of words and sentences than the children at Crown Valley. While at Crown Valley, Mr. Kirchner saw the hearing children spontaneously sign phrases such as “look at the teacher” and “it’s time to eat.” In February 1998, MOTHER, Ms. Hiland, FATHER OF STUDENT A, and MOTHER OF STUDENT A observed the Crown Valley program for a day. During that visit, the parents did not see a significant amount of spontaneous sign communication from the hearing children. Based on her one-day observation, MOTHER expressed the opinion that the DHH and hearing children at Crown Valley are not appropriate signing peers for STUDENT. Mr. Davino testified that the children were not using as much sign language as normal on the day the parents observed, but there was no evidence that the level of sign used during Mr. Kirchner’s visit was abnormal. Mr. Davino also testified that he was just beginning to see spontaneous sign language from the hearing children in the Crown Valley class.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that Crown Valley would provide a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately the same age and ability as STUDENT. Although the DHH girl has age appropriate skills, she is one year younger than STUDENT. There is a significant difference between age-appropriate language skills at 2 ½ and age appropriate skills at 3 ½. With respect to the DHH boy, the testimony established that he does not communicate frequently, either because he is shy or because his skill level does not allow him to do so. Although the evidence established that the hearing children had learned a lot of sign language, no witness testified that they are spontaneously signing in any significant amount with the DHH children in the class. STUDENT’s teachers and service providers testified that she constantly communicates in sign to those around her. Placing her in an environment where her peers could not return that communication at a similar level is not appropriate.

Audiological Services

The Respondent contends that the District has not offered enough audiological services and that Ms. Abramson, the District’s audiologist, is not competent to serve STUDENT. The District has offered one hour of audiological services per month in the form of consultation with parents and teachers. The Respondent asserts that she needs fifteen minutes per day of direct audiological services.

Ms. Atkins testified that she currently provides thirty minutes of audiological services per week to STUDENT at Rancho Viejo for both direct and consultative services. During that time, Ms. Atkins checks STUDENT’s equipment and works on her auditory training goals. Both Ms. Atkins and Ms. Hiland testified that the auditory training Ms. Atkins does with STUDENT is usually performed by a speech and language therapist. Ms. Atkins testified that STUDENT is doing well with the level of services she receives now, but that she would recommend one hour per week to maximize STUDENT’s performance.

Ms. Abramson testified that STUDENT does not need fifteen minutes per day of audiological services and that one hour per month of consultative services would be sufficient. She testified that the staff working with STUDENT should be trained to monitor her cochlear implant and identify problems that require the assistance of the audiologist. Mr. Kirchner also testified that staff who work with DHH children should be trained to monitor equipment and should have that responsibility.

There was no evidence that STUDENT has had any serious problems with her cochlear implant that would require the constant supervision of an audiologist. However, the evidence did establish that if there is a problem with the implant, STUDENT would have no ability to perceive sound. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Hiland, Ms. Atkins.) Thus, it is important for the staff working with STUDENT to be adequately trained to monitor her equipment and to have regular contact with the audiologist. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the services provided by the audiologist must include the training of staff and must allow for direct services to STUDENT as needed. Consultation alone is not sufficient. The Hearing Officer also finds that the audiologist must have regular, weekly contact with the staff serving STUDENT so that the audiologist is made aware of STUDENT’s ongoing audiological needs. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not establish that STUDENT needs fifteen minutes per day of direct audiological services. STUDENT has been progressing well with significantly less than fifteen minutes per day of audiological services. The District is required to provide a basic floor of opportunity for STUDENT, not to maximize her performance.

With respect to the Respondent’s contention that Ms. Abramson is not competent to provide audiological services to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that there is some cause for concern. Ms. Abramson was the audiologist assigned to provide one hour per month of consultative services for STUDENT after she received her cochlear implant. By her own report, the only contacts Ms. Abramson has had with the STUDENT family since implantation were four home visits in December 1996 and January 1997. Ms. Abramson also sent the PARENTS parent handouts and invitations to parent education classes. (Dist. Exh. 15.) There is no evidence that Ms. Abramson consulted with the school staff to see if her services were needed. Moreover, much of the information she has provided to the family has been in the form of brief, superficial “contact sheets” that were not tailored to serve STUDENT’s unique needs and provided information that these well-informed parents had already obtained on their own. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dist. Exh. 45.) In the May 1997 evaluation, Ms. Abramson recommended audiologic consultation with the classroom teacher, but there was no evidence that she has ever consulted with STUDENT’s current teachers. (Dist. Exh. 15.)

Moreover, there is cause for concern about Ms. Abramson’s ability to monitor and assess the functioning of STUDENT’s cochlear implant. On cross-examination, Ms. Abramson was questioned about the services she provided to address a problem with another child’s cochlear implant. Ms. Abramson testified that the other child was having inconsistent responses to sound starting in September. This child was attending an aural/oral program where no sign language was used; without a functioning cochlear implant, the child could not understand what was being said to her. Ms. Abramson’s response to this problem was to discuss it with the teacher, but she did not call the child’s parent about the problem until January. The final result was a determination that the internal portion of the child’s cochlear implant had failed and needed to be replaced. Ms. Abramson testified that she did not believe that it was necessary to contact the parents for four months because she believed the teacher, who was not a trained audiologist, was discussing the problem with them. Ms. Atkins and Ms. Hiland, both of whom have extensive experience with children with cochlear implants, testified that if a student was not responding to sound while all the external parts of the implant were working, they would immediately contact the parents and the implant’s manufacturer to identify the problem.

Given Ms. Abramson’s past performance as the audiologist serving STUDENT and her demonstrated error of judgment in serving another child with a cochlear implant, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Abramson is not a suitable audiologist for STUDENT.

Extended School Year Program

The District acknowledges that STUDENT is entitled to receive extended school year services, but asserts that the twenty-day program offered at Crown Valley is sufficient to meet her needs. The Respondent asserts that STUDENT should have no more than a two-week break from special education services during the summer months.

California Education Code section 56345(b)(5) provides that “(b) [w]hen appropriate, the individualized education program shall also include, but not be limited to, all of the following: ... (5) Extended school year services when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team.” Additionally, California Code of Regulations section 3043(d) requires that an extended school year program consist of at least twenty instructional days including holidays. Section 3043 also provides that a student is eligible for extended school year services if interruption of the educational programming could cause regression that, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, would render it impossible or unlikely that the student would attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of the handicapping condition.

Ms. Hiland testified that there is a critical window of opportunity for language learning during the first three years after a child receives a cochlear implant. During that time, the child must have intensive, continuing speech therapy and auditory habilitation without any significant breaks. Although Ms. Craik testified that STUDENT did not regress during a four-week break in December 1997 and January 1998, Ms. Hiland testified that she met with STUDENT during the break to help her maintain her language skills. The District witnesses who disagreed with Ms. Hiland’s recommendation testified that STUDENT did not need a year-round program because she had sign language support at home with her parents. (Testimony of Ms. Rowland, Mr. Davino.) However, the District did not put on any evidence to contradict Ms. Hiland’s testimony about the special needs of children who have recently received cochlear implants, and STUDENT’s unique needs as a child with a cochlear implant. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Hiland’s opinion of STUDENT’s needs is more compelling than that of the District witnesses. Ms. Hiland is the professional who has had the most consistent contact with STUDENT, as well as the witness who has had the most experience working with preschoolers with cochlear implants. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs to receive speech therapy, including auditory habilitation, for the entire summer, with no more than a two-week break.

The evidence also established that STUDENT needs constant monitoring of her cochlear implant because, if it is not working, she gets no sound signal at all. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs audiological services for the entire summer, with no more than a two-week break. The evidence did not establish, however, that STUDENT requires a full academic classroom program for that same time period to ensure that she would not have regression that could not be reasonably recouped at the commencement of the regular school year. Therefore, the District is not required to provide a full academic program for the entire summer.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District placement does not meet STUDENT’s extended school year needs to the extent that it does not provide for speech and language therapy and audiological services to continue through the summer with no more than a two-week break.

(c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?

In light of the finding that the Crown Valley program did not provide an appropriate peer group for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that it would not meet her unique needs or provide educational benefit to her. At a preschool level, peer interactions are a significant part of the educational process. Without appropriate peer interactions, STUDENT’s ability to benefit educationally from a program would be significantly compromised.

***

Based on the above analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide a free appropriate public education to STUDENT from July 28, 1997, to the present because the Crown Valley program does not meet STUDENT’s need for an appropriate peer group, the audiological services offered were not appropriate, and the extended school year program did not provide for speech and language therapy and audiological services to continue through the summer with no more than a two-week break.

2. If the District did not offer Respondent a FAPE from July 28, 1997, to the present, is the Rancho Viejo program an appropriate program and placement for her ?

The Respondent is seeking a finding that the appropriate prospective placement for her is at the Rancho Viejo School, with speech and language services provided by Ms. Hiland and audiological services provided by Ms. Atkins. The Respondent is not asking for reimbursement for expenses incurred in the past due to the District’s failure to provide FAPE. However, it is undisputed that Rancho Viejo School is not a certified nonpublic school pursuant to California Education Code section 56366.1. Therefore, pursuant to California Education Code section 56505.2, the Hearing Officer may not render a decision resulting in a prospective placement at Rancho Viejo School. Although the Supreme Court found in Florence Co. School Dist. Four v. Carter, (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, that such lack of certification did not preclude reimbursement for services provided in the past, that decision does not require an order for prospective placement at an uncertified school when state law otherwise prohibits such an order.

Moreover, the program at Rancho Viejo, without the services currently provided by the District pursuant to stay put, cannot serve STUDENT’s needs. The District provides the DHH teacher and the signing aide in the classroom and pays for Ms. Hiland’s speech and language services. Although Ms. Hiland is associated with Rancho Viejo and has indicated that she would remain at the school to provide services, the DHH teacher and the signing aide are employed by the District, not Rancho Viejo. Without the DHH teacher and the signing aide, the only adult in the classroom would be Ms. Mitra. The testimony at the hearing established that Ms. Mitra is a beginning signer; she would not be able to provide the level of signing STUDENT needs to advance her skills. (Testimony of Ms. Mitra, Ms. Craik, Ms. Hiland, Mr. Kirchner, Mr. Davino.) Ms. Mitra also has no training in deaf education and cannot meet STUDENT’s need for a DHH teacher. Ms. Evans-Warkentien testified that she has engaged DHH teacher Todd Houser on a consultative basis to help serve the DHH children at Rancho Viejo. However, Mr. Houser is a full-time teacher in another district and cannot be present in the classroom on a regular basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the program at Rancho Viejo, without the services temporarily provided by the District, cannot meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus, by itself, is not an appropriate placement for her.

Given the finding that Crown Valley is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT and that Rancho Viejo by itself is not an appropriate placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must either include more language mode peers of STUDENT’s age and ability at Crown Valley or place STUDENT in another program that meets her needs, as discussed above. The Hearing Officer notes that the District may provide individual or group services to STUDENT in a private preschool or day care center pursuant to Education Code sections 56440 et seq. The District must also provide audiological services from an audiologist who will make consistent contacts with STUDENT’s family and teachers and who has adequate experience in monitoring and assessing the functioning of cochlear implants. The District must continue to provide speech and language services from an individual with experience working with children with cochlear implants, family sign language classes, and parent education.

3. Are Respondent’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her audiological evaluation at House Ear Institute and related costs of transportation to and from House Ear Institute?

Reimbursement for private assessments is governed by California Education Code section 56329(b), which provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. There was no evidence presented at hearing that the parents expressed disagreement with Ms. Abramson’s audiological assessment of STUDENT conducted in May 1997. Moreover, the House Ear Institute assessment was not performed for educational purposes. Rather, it clearly states that it is part of a follow-up exam that was medical in nature. In fact, the PARENTS’ medical insurance paid for the bulk of the assessment’s cost. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the House Ear Institute evaluation.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team shall develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT, including but not limited to the following elements:

(a) a preschool program co-enrolled with DHH and hearing peers, including a sufficient number of language mode peers of approximately STUDENT’s age and ability, instruction from a DHH teacher, and a signing aide, (b) five hours per week of speech and language therapy from an individual with experience working with children with cochlear implants, (c) one hour per month of direct and consultative audiological services from an audiologist with demonstrated skill in working with children with cochlear implants, including training of staff to monitor her cochlear implant and weekly contact with classroom staff, (d) weekly sign language instruction for her family, and (e) extended school year services including a twenty-day classroom program with no more than a two-week break from speech and language and audiological services.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue 1: To the extent that the Crown Valley SDC, the nature of the audiological services, and the lack of speech and language therapy and audiological services during the summer were found to be inappropriate for STUDENT, the Respondent prevailed on this issue. To the extent that twenty days of a classroom program during the extended school year were found to be appropriate, the District prevailed.

Issue 2: To the extent that the Crown Valley SDC as it existed at the time of the hearing was inappropriate for STUDENT, the Respondent prevailed on this issue. To the extent that the program at Rancho Viejo was found to be inappropriate for STUDENT, the District prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: July 8, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The Hearing Office has jurisdiction over disputes involving children with disabilities who are three years of age and older. STUDENT turned three years old on July 28, 1997. Therefore, the relevant period of time for this hearing is July 28, 1997, forward. 2. SEE is a form of signing in English that varies significantly from American Sign Language (ASL), which is recognized as a separate language because of its unique word order and tense formations. SEE uses many signs from ASL and also modifies those signs to make a separate sign for each word. For example, one sign in ASL means both "part" and "some," while SEE modifies that sign to make separate signs for those two words. In addition, SEE uses special signs for prefixes, markers, and endings that indicate plurals and verb tenses. Signs in SEE are presented in English word order, not ASL order. Some of the witnesses at the hearing referred to what is described above as "SEE-2," distinguishing it from Seeing Exact English, in which each phonemic element of a word has a sign. Because most of the witnesses referred to the language used by STUDENT as simply SEE, that term shall be used in this decision. 3. In the closing brief, the Respondent also asserted that Crown Valley program is at maximum enrollment because ten children are enrolled and California Education Code section 56441.5 requires a 5:1 child-to-adult ratio in SDCs for DHH children. The evidence at hearing did not support this assertion. Ms. Carolyn Rowland, the Crown Valley teacher, testified that ten children are enrolled, but about eight are present each day because some of the children do not attend every day. Because the program has both a teacher and a program aide, there is no evidence that the program would exceed the required 5:1 ratio if STUDENT attended. 4. A cochlear implant is a device that is implanted inside the ear with an electrode array that is placed inside the cochlea. There is an exterior headpiece that is held in place by a magnet implanted behind the ear. The headpiece picks up sound and transmits it through a cord to a microprocessor carried on the body. The microprocessor encodes the sound into electrical impulses that are transmitted back to the headpiece. The headpiece then transmits the electrical impulses to the implant by an FM signal, and the implant stimulates the auditory nerve through the cochlea with the electrical impulses. The result is that the brain perceives the electrical impulses as sound. 5. The Office of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction over disputes involving children under three years old. 6. Whether a placement conforms to the student's IEP is typically part of the analysis of whether a school district provided a FAPE. However, that issue will not be examined in this decision because STUDENT does not have a current, agreed-upon IEP. 7. Prior to January 1998, the speech and language therapy would have been provided by Ms. Lisa DeLany. 8. From September through November 1997, there was a hearing child of deaf parents in the class who also used sign language as her primary mode of communication. However, because that child was no longer present in the class at the time of this hearing, her skills will not be considered in determining if Crown Valley provides a sufficient number of language mode peers for STUDENT.