California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 9, 1996
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 163-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel
Long Beach Unified must fund home Lovaas therapy and reimburse costs for preschooler with autism; speech therapy claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a four-year-old boy with autism filed for a hearing against Long Beach Unified School District. The district had placed him in a preschool special day class for children with severe language disorders, taught by Sherri Levenson. At the same time, the parents paid for home behavioral therapy using the Lovaas method of one-to-one drills. The boy made strong progress, and the main question was which program caused it. Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel found that much of the progress came from the home program. In January 1996 the district refused to fund any home therapy. Without it, the class alone did not meet the boy's needs, so he was denied FAPE for 1995-96. The district must reimburse 20 hours per week of therapy from the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, starting January 24, 1996. It did not have to pay for the extra 15 hours per week the parents added. For 1996-97, the district offered the same special day class. That was not the least restrictive environment, because the boy could now take part in a regular preschool with an aide. The district must fund up to 25 hours per week of the Lovaas Institute program. That means about 10 hours at home and 15 in a regular preschool with an aide. The request for separate one-to-one speech therapy was denied. The district must also pay half the cost of a private speech and language evaluation, because it never did the full assessment it had agreed to.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO decided which program helped a child who got both a district class and private home therapy. Because the home therapy proved crucial to his progress, the class alone did not offer FAPE. It also shows SEHO applying the LRE rules to a preschooler and cutting reimbursement and future hours on fairness grounds.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer Student a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?
The home Lovaas discrete-trial therapy was crucial to Student's progress. When the District refused to fund any home therapy at the January 24, 1996 IEP meeting, its program of the special day class alone was not designed to meet his unique needs, and he was denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If not, must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of private therapy provided by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention since January 24, 1996?
The District must reimburse 20 hours per week of therapy from January 24, 1996, the level that worked alongside the class. On equitable grounds it need not pay for the 15 more hours per week added in January 1996, because the class remained available.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. What is the appropriate placement for Student for the 1996-97 school year?
The District's repeat offer of the special day class was not the LRE and included no one-to-one discrete-trial instruction. The Hearing Officer ordered placement in the LIEI program, but for 25 hours per week (about 10 at home and 15 in a regular preschool with an aide) instead of the 35 requested.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Does Student require individualized speech and language therapy for the 1996-97 school year?
Student's communication needs were met by preschool plus home therapy. No witness testified that he needed one-to-one speech therapy to benefit from special education.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of an independent speech and language assessment by Dr. Susan Fosnot?
The parties agreed in April 1996 that a full speech and language re-evaluation was appropriate, but the District never did one. Because the independent evaluation had limits and the evaluator did not testify, the parents were reimbursed 50% of its cost on equitable grounds.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receipt of proof, District must reimburse the cost of 20 hours per week of Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention therapy from January 24, 1996 through the date of the Decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receipt of proof, District must reimburse 50% of the cost of Dr. Susan Fosnot's May 1996 speech and language evaluation.
- Prospective funding of private placement. District must pay for placing Student in the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention program for not more than 25 hours per week for the 1996-97 school year.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Adams v. Hansen; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; Johnson v. Lancaster-Lebanon Intermediate Unit 13
People named in the decision
- Sherri (also spelled Shelly) Levenson, preschool special day class teacher and credentialed speech therapist, Long Beach Unified School District (Burroughs School)
- Eloise Thompson, director of special education, Long Beach Unified School District
- Rebecca Craft, school psychologist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Sharon Stiles, speech therapist (articulation assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Linda Waltzman, speech and language therapist (1995 assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Patricia Blessing, resource specialist; summer school preschool teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Leslie Jensen, program specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Lara Lee, teacher of neighboring preschool class, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Colleen Jamison, expert witness for District; professor of special education, California State University, Los Angeles
- Dr. Jan Blacher, expert witness for Student; professor of education, University of California, Riverside
- Shannon Rush, senior therapist, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (nonpublic agency)
- Dr. Jackie Wynn, assistant director, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (nonpublic agency)
- Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, nonpublic agency providing home behavioral therapy
- Dr. Melanie Lenington, psychologist who evaluated Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Rick Murray, student therapist who trained parents, UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children
- Firouzeh Cangerlu, student home therapist who observed the class, UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children
- Gloria Critelli, private speech and language therapist (independent evaluation)
- Dr. Susan Fosnot, independent speech and language evaluator
- Kids Works, private regular education preschool
- Janice Emerson, advocate (observer at hearing)
- John Hayashida, attorney in District counsel's firm (observer)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Long Beach, California, on May 22, 23, and 24, and July 1, 2, and 3, 1996. Petitioner was represented by attorneys Ralph and Shelli Lewis. Present on behalf of Petitioner were his parents, PARENTS. Also present as an observer for a portion of the hearing was Janice Emerson, advocate. Respondent was represented by attorney Cynthia Yount. Present on behalf of the District was Eloise Thompson, director of special education. Also present as an observer for a portion of the hearing was John Hayashida, an attorney in Ms. Yount's law firm. The following witnesses were called by Petitioner: PARENTS; Shelly Levenson, special day class teacher; Dr. Jan Blacher, professor of education, University of California, Riverside; Shannon Rush, therapist, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIEI); and Dr. Jackie Wynn, assistant director, LIEI. The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Rebecca Craft, school psychologist; Dr. Colleen Jamison, professor of special education, California State University, Los Angeles; Sharon Stiles, speech therapist; Patricia Blessing, resource specialist; and Leslie Jensen, program specialist. Oral, documentary, photographic, and video evidence was received. At the request of the parties, the record was left open until July 26, 1996 for the receipt of closing briefs. Thereafter the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. ISSUES1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?2. If not, must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of private therapy provided by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention since January 24, 1996?3. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?4. Does STUDENT require individualized speech and language therapy for the 1996-97 school year?5. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of an independent speech and language assessment by Dr. Susan Fosnot? SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCEA. Introduction STUDENT is four years old and lives with his parents, PARENTS, in Long Beach, within the District. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of autism. STUDENT has made excellent progress in a number of areas during the past year, when he attended a public preschool class and received private behavioral therapy at home. The parties disagree as to the extent to which STUDENT's progress is attributable to the public preschool class as opposed to the private home therapy. That dispute was the main subject of this hearing.B. Chronological Summary As a toddler, STUDENT attended a "Mommy and Me" class with his mother. STUDENT did not participate in group activities with the other children and engaged in tantrums when encouraged to do so. He preferred to isolate himself from the group and engage in solitary play. By age two, STUDENT knew all of his numbers and letters and enjoyed counting to 20 and reciting the alphabet (forward and backward). He played with numbers and letters for hours, almost to the exclusion of other toys, and became upset when interrupted. He also created number and letter shapes by arranging other items -- for example, crayons and pieces of chalk. He frequently spelled words he memorized from signs he had seen -- for example, "Toys-R-Us" and "Don't Walk." (P 1, R 34)(Footnote 1) During this time, STUDENT spoke single words and some two- or three-word phrases. He also exhibited some echolalia -- repeating words and phrases he had heard. He did not interact much with other children, and exhibited poor eye contact. When his parents read to him, he would focus on the page numbers and particular letters and would repeat certain phrases, but did not appear to show interest in the content of the story. In March 1995, as STUDENT approached his third birthday, his parents took him to the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute for an evaluation. Psychologist Dr. Melanie Lenington diagnosed STUDENT with autism and noted that he appeared to be "high functioning." (P 2) The evaluation report noted deficits in daily living skills, communication, and socialization. The report recommended, among other things (1) a highly structured, behaviorally oriented, therapeutic preschool with low child-teacher ratio and special attention given to STUDENT's communication and social skill difficulties and (2) speech and language services including a therapeutic play group to enhance appropriate behaviors with same age peers. (P 2) In early April, the parents requested that the Long Beach Unified School District perform a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. (P 2-3) The District prepared an extensive assessment plan, obtained the parents' consent to assess, and obtained the parents' consent to acquire information about STUDENT from UCLA and other sources. (P 3) In late April, the parents received two days of in-home training in a particular type of behavioral modification therapy for preschool-age autistic children from Rick Murray, a student therapist who had been trained by the UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children (CBTC). The therapy (referred to herein as "Lovaas therapy") was developed by UCLA psychologist Dr. Ivar Lovaas. The theory behind the therapy is that preschool-age children with autism do not learn in the normal environment by imitating other children in a classroom setting. Rather, they must initially be taught attention, communication, and socialization skills in one-to-one interaction with a trained adult therapist in a tailored, simplified environment -- typically the child's home. Ideally, Lovaas therapy is provided from approximately age three through five. The therapy covers the following four general categories and proceeds in the following order: (1) basic skills, (2) basic language concepts, (3) advanced language concepts and interactive play and (4) conversations, playing with peers, and attending school with an aide. More specific activities in each category include: early receptive language, reduction of disruptive behavior, non-verbal imitation, matching and sorting, object and behavior labeling, verbal imitation, abstract concepts, sentence structure and descriptions, pre-academics and classroom practice, social language, play skills and peer integration, and self-help in community and school. In the initial stages of Lovaas therapy, the therapist guides the student through an ongoing, extensive series of drills, known as "discrete trials." Each discrete trial involves a command from the therapist, a response from the child, and reinforcement from the therapist. As certain skills are mastered, discrete trials relating to those skills are decreased in frequency from "permanent" to "maintenance."(Footnote 2) In the latter stages of the therapy, the student is gradually introduced to a regular education preschool classroom, with the therapist serving as a one-to-one classroom aide, to generalize skills learned in the home therapy.(Footnote 3) In the classroom, the therapist prompts the student to facilitate his understanding of the teacher's instructions, to encourage him to interact with other children, and to help him stay on task. Gradually, over time, the therapist "fades out." When the child demonstrates he can (1) learn in the regular classroom by observing others without the presence of the therapist and (2) stay on task, despite the existence of classroom distractions and without the need for constant prompting, the Lovaas therapy is completed. The goal of the Lovaas therapy is for the student to attend regular education kindergarten without the need for any special services. The primary research basis for the therapy is a 1987 study in which 47% of subjects who received 35-40 hours of therapy were able to attend regular education kindergarten without the need for any special services. (P42) After receiving the brief training in late April, 1995, the parents began providing Lovaas therapy to STUDENT themselves in the home for ten hours per week. They gave commands ("sit still, look at us"), gave prompts to produce correct responses, rewarded correct responses, and corrected incorrect responses. Almost immediately, they noticed improved compliance, attention, and eye contact. Soon, STUDENT was moving rapidly through other Lovaas therapy "programs" such as objects, matching, yes/no, colors, and prepositions. STUDENT's social interaction in the "Mommy and Me" group improved. For the first time, he began to imitate other children in the class who were playing with trucks and trains instead of isolating himself with his letters. Also during this time, while the District's assessments were pending, the parents obtained an independent speech and language evaluation from Gloria Critelli, a private speech and language therapist. (P 13) She found that STUDENT exhibited delays in (1) attending and auditory processing, (2) language comprehension, (3) expressive language, and (4) speech production. She recommended enrollment in a preschool special day class for students with severe disorders of language which had a: small student to teacher ratio, multisensory modes of instruction, consistent behavior modification programming, and multiple opportunities for language learning including participation in small group settings and the development of symbolic play skills. Ms. Critelli also recommended individual and/or small group speech and language therapy twice per week for thirty minutes per session to increase receptive and expressive language skills, social communication skills, and play skills. In May, District school psychologist Rebecca Craft conducted an assessment of STUDENT. (P 8) She wrote: Possible objectives for home and school might address attendance in small group, responding consistently to structured tasks, following classroom routines, increased communication, increased parallel play and use of social greetings, and toileting on a schedule. Also in May, District speech and language therapist Linda Waltzman conducted an assessment of STUDENT. (P 9) She found he had adequate skills in articulation, voice, and fluency, and difficulties in syntax, pragmatics, morphology, and semantics. She concluded that STUDENT had "receptive and expressive language delays characterized by minimal eye contact, repetition of words and phrases, and lack of use of language for the purpose of social interaction." On June 2, an IEP meeting was held. The IEP document prepared that day included detailed descriptions of STUDENT's then-current levels of performance in class performance, cognitive ability, social adaptive skills, fine/gross motor skills, speech and language, and medical/health. (P 15) The IEP included annual goals with corresponding short-term objectives in the following skill areas: attending/responding, social, toileting, self-help, preacademics, fine motor, pragmatic language, semantics, and syntax. The IEP called for STUDENT to attend a preschool special day class for students with severe disorders of language located at Burroughs School. The class is taught by Sherri Levenson, a credentialed speech therapist and special education teacher. The District indicated that STUDENT's needs in the area of speech and language would be addressed within the class. The IEP did not call for STUDENT to receive one-to-one speech and language therapy.(Footnote 4) The IEP also found STUDENT eligible for "extended school year" (ESY) services.(Footnote 5) After the IEP meeting, PARENT visited Ms. Levenson's class and was very pleased with what she saw. At the time, there were 8-10 children in the class and two aides. (R 27) Beginning in June, the parents hired UCLA student therapists to provide Lovaas therapy to STUDENT in their home for twenty hours per week. That month, STUDENT began speaking in short sentences, and made excellent progress in pronouns, "same/different", sizes, and other concepts. At some point in June, following the IEP meeting, school psychologist Ms. Craft visited the family home to observe the home therapy. At the end of the visit, Ms. Craft told the PARENTs that STUDENT seemed to have made progress since her [Ms. Craft's] assessment in early May. In July, in addition to his home Lovaas therapy, STUDENT attended a six-week summer school program, five days per week, three hours per day at Cubberley Elementary School in the District. The parents were dissatisfied with the teachers during the first three weeks, but noted that STUDENT followed the teacher's directions well, sat still for circle time, and stayed in his chair for activities. (R 34) During the next three weeks, STUDENT was assigned to a preschool special day class for students with severe disorders of language taught by Patricia Blessing, who serves as a resource specialist for elementary school children with specific learning disabilities during the regular academic year. The class had thirteen children, one teacher, and one adult classroom aide. Ms. Blessing testified that, for the most part, STUDENT did not acknowledge, interact with, or engage in parallel play with other students around him. At times, he would stay seated at one activity for a long period of time, unable to independently move to the next activity. At other times, he showed a fixation with numbers and letters. Using a suggestion from PARENT, Ms. Blessing often used physical prompts to guide STUDENT through an activity after giving oral direction. In general, STUDENT required a lot of attention, and at times required one-to-one attention. Ms. Blessing testified that the three weeks during which STUDENT attended her class was too short a time in which to notice significant progress. However, she observed that STUDENT made some progress in his ability to participate in activities with prompting from peers and adults. For example, other students took STUDENT's hand and led him to the playground and to the place where the class "lined up", and Ms. Blessing prompted STUDENT to participate in songs and exchange greetings. Regarding STUDENT's participation in Ms. Blessing's class, PARENT wrote: [STUDENT] has a great time and receives an award for "most improved" student. Loves to participate in circle time and singing songs. Loves The Big Bug Book song. He begins to imitate the other children in the playground and learns to go down the slide and climb on the jungle gym. He loves the school bus and when he comes home he plays with his toy bus and recreates the journeys he has to and from school. (R 34) During July, while attending summer school, STUDENT continued in the home program, adding such programs as shapes and opposites. He mastered several programs, which were put on a maintenance schedule. In early August, Dr. Lenington of UCLA, who had previously evaluated STUDENT in March, re-evaluated him. (P 16) Dr. Lenington found that STUDENT was now functioning in the normal range cognitively. She also found that he had made significant improvement in communication and basic attending skills. With respect to communication, he had made 18 months progress in 5 months, and was now functioning in the normal range. She noted that he displayed appropriate verbal communication skills, was able to relay his experiences in simple terms, deliver a simple message, use a sentence of four or more words, use at least 100 different words, and speak in sentences. With respect to attending, she noted that he had improved in his ability to sit in a chair, tolerate transitions and respond to directions. She noted that STUDENT was "able to learn new information very quickly with appropriate cues and feedback," and that "it is clear that the efforts of his parents, teachers and therapists are beneficial and appropriate." Dr. Lenington noted that socialization and daily living skills remained an area of concern (although she did note emerging imitative play). Dr. Lenington wrote: He continues to need intensive 1:1 as well as group treatment to facilitate his pragmatic language skills as well as his syntax and semantics, and to facilitate his ability to stay on track with same age peers. His social skills and daily living skills should receive some additional attention (i.e. toileting, increasing parallel and interactive or reciprocal play) . . . Although STUDENT still clearly meets the diagnostic criteria for Autism, his progress does more clearly suggest that he will be in the high functioning range . . . STUDENT may benefit from a behavioral therapy companion to his school setting or other settings in the service of providing carryover from his multiple environments and generalization of behavior, at the very least close collaboration between all the professionals working with STUDENT is essential. The Lovaas home therapy continued during the break between summer school and the start of the regular academic year in the fall. That month, the therapists introduced the concepts of book questions and "what's missing?" The parents testified that, by the end of the summer, before attending Ms. Levenson's class, STUDENT had demonstrated in his home program that he had accomplished many of the annual goals set forth in the June 1995 IEP. In September, STUDENT began in Ms. Levenson's class, five days per week, three hours per day. The class began with 7-9 students and later grew in size to 12-13 students. There was one teacher (Ms. Levenson) and one aide. The primary difficulty for all of the students was a severe disorder of language. Three children had a diagnosis of autism. For one hour each day, the class joined with a neighboring class taught by Lara Lee to create one larger class with 16-24 students, two teachers, and two aides. When he first entered the class, STUDENT did not participate or interact much. He did not seem to follow the class routine, was unresponsive to directions, and engaged in some tantrums. Infrequently, PARENT was present in the classroom as a parent volunteer. Ms. Levenson and PARENT communicated in writing -- primarily about STUDENT's toileting -- via a daily home-to-school notebook. (P 38) Early in the year, Ms. Levenson visited the family home to observe STUDENT's home therapy program. She testified that she observed that the therapy increased the amount of STUDENT's expressive language and improved his behavioral compliance. However, she had concerns: the therapy lacked group socialization and was not performed by credentialed speech therapists. She believed ten hours of home therapy per week would be more appropriate than the twenty that STUDENT was receiving. During September, PARENT wrote "STUDENT seems to really enjoy going to school and I'm very happy with his placement, except the number of children in the class and STUDENT's tendency to perseverate on things when he is allowed to choose his own activities." (R 34) In late September, Firouzeh Cangerlu, one of the UCLA student therapists participating in STUDENT's home program, observed Ms. Levenson's class. (P 21) Her written report was complementary of Ms. Levenson. However, she believed there were too many children in the class, and that Ms. Levenson therefore was unable to give STUDENT individual prompts to follow instructions/directions and engage in the class activities. As a consequence, at times he did not participate. (Ms. Levenson testified that she did not give STUDENT prompts that day because Ms. Cangerlu was actively engaged with STUDENT. Ms. Cangerlu's report confirmed that she -- Ms. Cangerlu -- prompted STUDENT on at least one occasion.) Ms. Cangerlu noted that STUDENT interacted with another child on the playground, and was doing well in toilet training, but that he engaged in some perseverative play with "Texaco" and "Target" symbols. Ms. Levenson neither provided one-to-one instruction to STUDENT, nor employed a formal behavior management program. She did, however, give him a lot of verbal praise. STUDENT was instructed, along with the other children, with question and answer techniques and teacher modeling of appropriate language. At times, the class involved small group (3-4 students) instruction in language/reading. Throughout the fall, STUDENT continued to receive twenty hours per week of home Lovaas therapy from various student therapists, most of whom had been trained by the UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children. In September, the therapists introduced more conversation questions, and STUDENT mastered object and action labeling. In October, the therapists introduced play skills, and STUDENT mastered "same/different." (R 34) In December, PARENT expressed concern to that, in her opinion, STUDENT had already met some of the annual goals contained in the June, 1995 IEP. The District scheduled an IEP meeting for December 11. (P 25) Ms. Levenson, Ms. Lee, and PARENT attended the meeting. Ms. Levenson described STUDENT's then-current levels of performance as follows: Social Adaptive Behavior: STUDENT is a very cooperative child -- however, he has severe difficulties with focus and attention. He often needs repeated verbal cues and/or a tactile refocusing to gain his attention. His attention span can then range from a few seconds to up to 10-15 seconds. No particular activity holds his attention more than any other. He also has some self-talk and perseveration on numbers and letters due to the autism. STUDENT performs best in small group (3-6 students). Communication: STUDENT's vocabulary appears to be near age appropriate. The frequency and length of his expressive language use is expanding. However, much of his language is robotic and patterned. He uses little spontaneous, self-generated language. He doesn't yet share an experience or approach another child or adult for the purpose of communication. His pragmatic skills are a significant area of delay. Eye contact continues to be limited without a verbal prompt. He appears to respond only when a "key" prompt cues him for a learned response. Otherwise, he is unable to respond to questions. (P 25) At the December 11 IEP meeting, the parties agreed that STUDENT had met most of the annual goals contained in the June, 1995 IEP. (P 26) Some new goals were developed. On December 21, PARENT wrote to the District. (P 27) She asserted that there were ten children in the class and just one aide, and that, because Ms. Levenson could not give one-to-one instruction to STUDENT, he was unable to fully benefit from her background in speech therapy. She also expressed concern about the large number of students during the one-hour overlap with Ms. Lee's class. She asserted that STUDENT's having already met most of his IEP goals was attributable to the home therapy. She asserted that "behavioral modification therapy is an integral part of STUDENT's education." Then she added: Aside from my concerns mentioned above, I am pleased with STUDENT being in Ms. Levenson's class. He very obviously enjoys himself there and I think is making important strides in socialization. He loves all the little songs he learns and often sings them to himself at home. He likes all the crafty projects and books they make and enjoys looking at the ones he has made and brought home. Ms. Levenson has impressed me not only with her skill in the classroom, but with her desire to spend her personal time educating herself about children like STUDENT and her candor with parents like myself. However, I do not think that this classroom alone is enough for STUDENT. I believe that it is crucial that STUDENT continue to receive the Lovaas behavior modification therapy he currently is getting. Given STUDENT's rapid progression with this program, I am convinced it is obviously an appropriate educational therapy for him and is as important as his attendance in a pre-school program. In the December 21 letter, PARENT requested that the District add an aide to Ms. Levenson's class and assume financial responsibility for STUDENT's home therapy which, at the time, still consisted of an average of twenty hours per week. On January 19, 1996, STUDENT became a client of the Lovaas Institute on Early Intervention (LIEI), a nonpublic agency which has been conditionally certified by the state Department of Education to provide services to special education students.(Footnote 6) LIEI is affiliated with, but separate from, the UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children (CBTC). Shannon Rush of LIEI became STUDENT's senior therapist. STUDENT's home therapy was increased to thirty-five hours per week. An IEP meeting was held on January 24, 1996. (P 31) At the meeting, the parents asked about speech and language therapy. Ms. Levenson stated that, with respect to speech, she did not believe STUDENT had an articulation disorder, and that, with respect to language, his needs were being met in the classroom. The District agreed to assess STUDENT "in [the] area of speech." (P 31) The District agreed to add an aide to Ms. Levenson's class (though not assigned specifically to STUDENT) and to limit the class size to no more than twelve students for the remainder of the year. The District did not agree to fund the home therapy program.(Footnote 7) Also on January 24, the District sent the parents a proposed assessment plan for a "speech (artic.[ulation]) assessment." (P 33, 34) On February 21, the parents filed a request for a due process hearing. On February 26, the parents advised the District that they were withdrawing STUDENT from Ms. Levenson's class. (R 18) STUDENT did not immediately enroll in any other preschool class. Ms. Levenson testified that, by the time STUDENT left her class in late February, 1996, she had observed progress in a number of areas. For example, in expressive language, he had a rapid learning rate -- he began speaking more frequently and in longer, complete sentences. Once one got his attention, he could be prompted to exchange greetings. In class discussions about field trips, he enjoyed describing items he had seen. He was able to participate when called upon and to provide the correct answer about a story. On rare occasions he spontaneously used language, without a prompt, to express his needs -- for example, reciting a class rule when engaged in a conflict. An in-class video taken in December showed STUDENT telling the story of the Three Billy Goats Gruff, which the class had been studying. He placed characters on a flannel board and changed voices to represent different characters. He got the sequence and primary parts of the story correct. (On the other hand, this and other in-class videos showed that STUDENT had difficulty responding appropriately to Ms. Levenson's commands.) Ms. Levenson testified that she observed progress in other areas by the time STUDENT left her class. STUDENT responded more often and more accurately to teacher directions -- particularly with repetition -- and rarely engaged in a tantrum in response to a direction. He began to participate somewhat in small group activities and interact somewhat with other children. For example, he began to engage in play in the vicinity of others. His eye contact increased. Several weeks after STUDENT exited her class, Ms. Levenson summarized some of his progress and remaining areas of developmental delay in writing. (R 19) With respect to language, she noted that his vocabulary was age appropriate or above, that he generally spoke in complete sentences of 2-8 words which had good syntax and morphology, and that he often responded appropriately to questions, but that he had very little spontaneous conversational language and had difficulty responding to more complex questions. With respect to social skills, she noted that he generally played alone or near someone, not necessarily engaging in the same activity, and that he did not seek out other children for play. With respect to following the classroom activity, she wrote: He often required individual instruction to transition to small groups or individual activities . . . [His] attending skills are severely delayed and impaired . . . he is extremely distracted by internal and external stimuli. He needs repetitive reminders to "look" to keep him focused on any activity. He appears unable to make good choices for improving his attention without outside cues, e.g., look, get closer, listen, etc. Prompts and cues generally need to be phrased carefully as he only responds to selected patterned phrasing. But, once his attention is gained and he responds to the prompts, his . . . participation improves. On February 28, District speech therapist Sharon Stiles conducted an assessment of STUDENT's articulation, and concluded that it was within normal limits. (R 20) Shannon Rush, LIEI senior therapist, testified that as of January, 1996, STUDENT was beginning to show the abilities to (a) generalize skills taught in the discrete trials format in the normal environment and (b) learn in the normal environment. However, he still needed assistance and prompting to participate in a back-and-forth conversation, even in the discrete trial format. Gradually, the therapists introduced more complex conversational skills, and, eventually, STUDENT began to engage in reciprocal questions and answers with the therapists. In a report dated February 29, Ms. Rush wrote: STUDENT has demonstrated a high level of success when taught in the discrete trial format. During the months of January and February he mastered numerous programs, and new programs continue to be introduced on a bi-weekly basis. (P 39) More specifically, Ms. Rush noted that STUDENT made progress in the following programs: (1) Conversation (question-answer, reciprocal questions), (2) Drawing, (3) Fine Motor Activities (cutting out shapes and pictures, pasting various materials onto paper, stringing small beads), (4) Functions (of different objects), (5) "Impossible Tasks," (6) Mock Preschool (coloring, circle time, sit quiet and listen, and worksheets),(BODY OF TEXT CONT'D)activity in the room too great, and some of the concepts were over STUDENT's head. STUDENT lacked the social and communication skills to benefit from the group activities to the level he is capable. He received no one-to-one instruction and no prompting to speak. At times he appeared "lost" and "tuned out." Also in February, Dr. Blacher observed STUDENT's home program for 30-60 minutes. She observed that, during the one-to-one interaction, STUDENT demonstrated more social and communication skills than he had in Ms. Levenson's class. He refrained from self-stimulating movements and exhibited better eye contact. In May, Dr. Blacher observed STUDENT at Kids Works preschool for two hours. There were 8 or 9 children and three adults. She stated that one could not tell that STUDENT was a child with special needs. He participated in group activities and showed good socialization skills. He sang with the group and seemed to understand. His aide talked to him, asked him questions, and kept him talking. In Dr. Blacher's opinion, STUDENT is now too high functioning for a special day class, although he requires a one-to-one aide to participate in a regular education preschool class. 2. Dr. Colleen Jamison Dr. Jamison is a professor of special education at California State University, Los Angeles. She has never observed STUDENT. In May 1996, she observed Ms. Levenson's class once at the District's request. STUDENT was no longer attending the class when Dr. Jamison observed. On the day of Dr. Jamison's visit, a substitute taught the class. Dr. Jamison observed that the students were engaged with interesting class materials, and had many opportunities for socialization and communication. The class routine included structure, predictability, and repetition, and a "naturalistic" environment (that is, use of real objects and things in a typical, everyday setting). Dr. Jamison testified that, in her opinion, preschool-age autistic children model other children, more than they model adults. She believes the use of discrete trials is a successful method for gaining such children's attention for purposes of learning and cooperation, particularly in the initial stages. However, she believes Lovaas therapy is not comprehensive. She believes it is important for an autistic child to have many opportunities for discrete trials type learning each day, but that this can be accomplished by a teacher during class. She believes it is important for children to be educated in naturalistic environments. DISCUSSION1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year? Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE) which emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. 1400(c); 1401(a)(18); California Education Code 56000. Children with disabilities include children who have one or more specified impairments, including autism(Footnote 8) and who, by reason thereof, need special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(1)(A); Education Code 56026(a-b). The right to a FAPE begins at age three. 20 U.S.C. 1412(2)(B); Education Code 56001(b); 56026(c)(2); 56440; 56441.11(b). As noted above, a FAPE must emphasize special education and related services. Special education means specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a chid with a disability. It may include instruction in a classroom, in the home, and/or in other settings. 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(16). Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(17); Education Code 56363.(Footnote 9) According to the U.S. Supreme Court in Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200-201, 206-207 an IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The school district is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits to the child, but rather to provide a "basic floor of opportunity." Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. In determining whether the district has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District's program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program is adequate, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program, and even if the parents' preferred program is better (that is, would likely result in greater educational benefit to the child than the District's program). Id. So long as the school district's choice of educational methodology is reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, that choice is entitled to deference. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.(Footnote 10) In this case, the evidence shows that STUDENT made excellent overall progress, particularly in communication/language skills, during the past year. Had he made such progress based solely on attendance in Ms. Levenson's class, there would be no question that he received an appropriate education there. However, STUDENT received home Lovaas therapy before, during, and after his attendance in Ms. Levenson's class, and has progressed steadily throughout. Therefore, it is necessary to determine whether he would have made adequate progress in the District's program had he not received the home Lovaas therapy. This determination requires the difficult process of attempting to isolate Ms. Levenson's class from the home Lovaas therapy to assess how much progress each system helped STUDENT to make.(Footnote 11) One way to attempt to isolate the benefits derived from each program is to examine the five-month period from May through August 1995. In March 1995, before STUDENT had received any Lovaas therapy or attended any District class, he demonstrated significant delays in communication and socialization skills. In May, STUDENT's parents began providing him with ten hours per week of one-to-one Lovaas home therapy, and immediately observed progress in both of these areas. In June, the parents hired UCLA student therapists to provide therapy for twenty hours per week, and continued to notice dramatic progress. That month, school psychologist Rebecca Craft observed the home program and remarked that STUDENT had progressed since she assessed him in May. STUDENT attended summer school for six weeks, fifteen hours per week. The parents assert that he received little benefit from the first three weeks, and the District offered no contrary evidence. During the latter three weeks, the teacher, Ms. Blessing, stated that while this was too short a time to notice significant progress, he made some progress in tolerating prompts from staff and other children. Ms. Blessing noted that PARENT's suggestions about working with STUDENT, based on the Lovaas therapy, were helpful to her in class, and that STUDENT needed a lot of individual attention. STUDENT continued to receive twenty hours of home therapy while attending summer school. By August, Dr. Lenington of UCLA, who had previously assessed STUDENT in March, noted eighteen months of growth in communication skills in that five month period. Thus, before attending Ms. Levenson's class, he was demonstrating, at home, that he could already accomplish many of the goals set forth as year-long classroom goals in the June, 1995 IEP. It must be concluded, based on the evidence, that this progress was primarily attributable to the home program. In September, STUDENT entered Ms. Levenson's class for fifteen hours per week. When he began he did not participate, interact, or respond much. The instructional method used in class was primarily small-group language instruction. STUDENT received no one-to-one instruction in class. The evidence shows that, with a combination of fifteen hours in Ms. Levenson's class and the twenty hours per week of home Lovaas therapy, STUDENT's steady progress continued. Witnesses for both parties testified that Ms. Levenson is a talented and dedicated teacher, and she impressed the Hearing Officer as such. By the end of his tenure in Ms. Levenson's class in February 1996, STUDENT was able to do a number of things in the classroom that he was not doing in class when he started there. He was beginning to demonstrate some skills in communication and socialization in the classroom setting -- apparently generalizing, to some extent, skills initially learned in the home setting. Based on the evidence, however, it cannot be concluded that STUDENT would have made adequate progress without the Lovaas home therapy as a component of his overall program. When certain factors have proven crucial to a student's success, it is not reasonable to expect that he will make satisfactory progress on his IEP goals and objectives without them. Adams v. Hansen, 632 F.Supp. 858, 863-864 (N.D. Cal. 1985). Ms. Levenson described the great difficulty involved in gaining STUDENT's attention for purposes of learning. Not only Petitioner's witnesses but also the District's witnesses were complementary of the home program in this regard: Ms. Craft, as noted above; , Ms. Levenson,who noted that STUDENT benefitted from the program (although she believed ten hours of home therapy would be sufficient); and Dr. Jamison, who concurred that discrete trials are an effective method of gaining autistic children's attention and cooperation for learning, particularly in the early stages. The parents' position as of December 1995-January 1996 -- that an appropriate program for STUDENT must consist of both fifteen hours in Ms. Levenson's class and some amount of home Lovaas therapy each week -- was both reasonable and correct as of that date. The Hearing Officer concludes that when the District refused to fund the home program as part of STUDENT's overall educational program pursuant to his IEP, it denied him FAPE. The District's program, consisting solely of Ms. Levenson's class and lacking one-to-one discrete trials instruction designed to enable STUDENT to acquire basic attending and learning skills, was not individually designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1525 (9th Cir. 1994). Therefore, the District's program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with adequate educational benefit. Rowley, supra.2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for Lovaas therapy? Under the IDEA, decision-makers have authority to award "appropriate" relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. 1415(e)(2); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1984). Appropriate relief may include reimbursement for private educational expenditures if it is determined that the District's placement was not appropriate and the private expenditures were proper. Id at 369. The reimbursement remedy requires the school district to pay expenses that it should have paid all along. Id. at 370-371. At the hearing, the parents testified that they are requesting reimbursement for home Lovaas therapy since January 24, 1996, the date of the IEP meeting at which the District refused to fund the home program after the parents formally requested that it do so. (On January 19 STUDENT's home therapy had been increased from twenty to thirty-five hours per week.) On February 26, the parents withdrew STUDENT from Ms. Levenson's class. Since early to mid April, about ten hours of STUDENT's thirty-five hour per week program have involved a therapist accompanying STUDENT to the private, regular education Kids Works preschool; the remaining twenty-five hours of therapy have been provided at home. The parents are seeking reimbursement for thirty-five hours of therapist time since January 24, 1996. They are not seeking reimbursement for Kids Works tuition. The evidence showed that STUDENT made steady progress between September 1995 and mid-January 1996, while attending Ms. Levenson's class for fifteen hours per week and receiving twenty hours per week of home Lovaas therapy. On January 24, 1996, the District inappropriately refused to fund any amount of home Lovaas therapy to complement STUDENT's attendance in Ms. Levenson's class. The Hearing Officer finds that the expense which should have been borne by the District is twenty hours per week of Lovaas therapy since January 24, 1996. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the District need not reimburse the parents for the additional fifteen hours of therapist time per week (for a total of thirty-five per week) added in mid-January 1996. Reimbursement is an equitable remedy, and equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374. STUDENT had benefitted from a combination of Ms. Levenson's class and twenty hours of Lovaas therapy, and, even after February 26, Ms. Levenson's class remained available to STUDENT. 3. What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year? The evidence showed that STUDENT is developing rapidly in a number of areas. He is a different child now, in the summer of 1996, from June, 1995, when the District first developed an IEP for him, and even from February, 1996, when he left Ms. Levenson's class. As explained below, the evidence showed that his needs continue to be a preschool class and one-to-one Lovaas therapy. One aspect of a FAPE is that children with disabilities must be educated in the "least restrictive [appropriate] environment" (LRE). 34 C.F.R. 300.550 et seq; Education Code 56001(g); 56031. School districts must ensure that a continuum of placements is available to meet the needs of disabled students. The continuum must include such options as regular classes, special classes, and home instruction. 34 C.F.R. 300.551. The federal LRE mandate provides: to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities . . . [should be] educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services.20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(B); see also Education Code 56364. The federal regulations note that the term "supplementary aids and services" is synonymous with "modifications," and describes what is done to the regular education program to ensure a disabled student's satisfactory participation in that program. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48. Common examples of supplementary aids and services include one-to-one classroom aides. The IDEA's LRE provision reflects Congress' preference for educating disabled students in regular classrooms with their nondisabled peers. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1403 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994) (hereafter referred to as "Rachel H."). Courts have noted that, particularly for very young disabled children, significant benefits of mainstreaming may include having appropriate peer language and behavior role models. Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874, 879 (E.D.Cal. 1992), aff'd sub nom. Rachel H., supra. Based on the statutory presumption in favor of mainstreaming, a school district has the burden of showing that the placement proposed in the IEP provides mainstreaming "to the maximum extent appropriate" for the child. Id. at 880 and n.7. The LRE requirement applies to children with disabilities of preschool age (age 3-5). 34 C.F.R. 300.552, Comment. The overriding rule is that placement decisions must be made "on an individual basis." Id. While school districts that do not operate programs for nondisabled preschool children are not required to initiate such programs solely to satisfy LRE requirements, they must find and provide suitable alternative placements including, for example, participation in Head Start, private preschools for nondisabled children, private preschools that integrate nondisabled and disabled children, or locating special classes for preschool children with disabilities in regular elementary schools. Id. The regulations state: In each case the public agency must ensure each child's placement is in the LRE in which the unique needs of that child can be met, based upon the child's IEP, and meets all of the other requirements of [related federal special education regulations].Id. In other words, while the District is not required to initiate a public class to meet the preschooler's needs, it must provide the preschooler with the same range of placements to meet the LRE mandate as are available to older students with disabilities. The California legislature has declared that one of the purposes of so-called "early intervention services" for disabled preschoolers age 3-5 is to "reduce the need for special class placement in special education programs once the children reach school age." Education Code 56441(f). As the child approaches the age to enter an elementary school [K-5 or K-6] environment, the child's preparation "shall be geared toward a readiness for kindergarten and later school success." Education Code 56441.1(b). Such services may be provided individually or in small groups and must include various means of delivering the services including the home, community, and regular preschool classes. Education Code 56441.3-4. Related services are specifically included as one of the service options for delivery of early intervention services. Education Code 56441.3(a)(7). If the student needs only a related service -- such as a one-to-one therapy -- the service alone can constitute an appropriate placement, and it can be provided in a variety of settings. Union School District v. Smith, 14 F.3d 1519, 1527 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1994). On the other hand, a preschooler's need for interaction with peers must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. See U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), Policy Letters to Neveldine, 20 IDELR 181 (1993); 22 IDELR 630 (1995). The evidence showed that, presently, the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT has two elements: (1) a preschool class to meet his need for social interaction and practicing conversation skills, and (1) one-to-one, discrete trials instruction in the home to learn certain new skills -- including, for example, responding to more complex questions and interactions.(Footnote 12) Recent evidence from STUDENT's participation at Kids Works in April and May 1996 shows that, at present, STUDENT can benefit from a regular education preschool class with appropriate supplementary aids and services -- specifically, a one-to-one classroom aide familiar with his Lovaas therapy. The District's placement offer for 1996-97 was identical to that for 1995-96 -- fifteen hours per week in Ms. Levenson's class. The Hearing Officer finds, for the reasons described below, that that placement offer for 1996-97 was not individually designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and therefore did not offer STUDENT a FAPE. First of all, the District failed to sustain its burden to show that attendance in 's special day class for disabled students with severe language disorders would provide mainstreaming "to the maximum extent appropriate" for STUDENT." He is now a child with generally age-appropriate communication skills who has begun to demonstrate that he can participate in and benefit from a regular education preschool class with the assistance of a one-to-one aide familiar with his Lovaas therapy. STUDENT would benefit, in terms of socialization and practicing conversation skills, from exposure to the peer role models available in regular education classes. Second, the District's placement offer for 1996-97 provides for neither one-to-one instruction in general nor discrete trials in particular. As noted above, when certain factors have proven crucial to a student's success, it is not reasonable to expect that he will make satisfactory progress on his IEP goals and objectives without them. The evidence shows that, at present, STUDENT still needs, to some extent, to learn certain new skills in the discrete trial format prior to generalizing them in class. Dr. Wynn testified persuasively that, without such instruction to complement his preschool classroom attendance, STUDENT will likely regress. The Education Code states that it is the Legislature's intent, with respect to early intervention services for disabled students age 3-5, that "gains in the special education programs . . . are not lost by too rapid a removal of individualized programs and supports for these individuals." Education Code 56445(b). Because the District failed to offer a FAPE for 1996-97, the Hearing Officer must next examine Petitioner's proposed program.The evidence from the late spring of 1996 shows that STUDENT received proper educational benefit from thirty-five hours per week in the LIEI program, approximately two-thirds of which was devoted to one-to-one home instruction, and approximately one-third of which was devoted to participation in a regular education preschool class with the assistance of the home therapist. Because LIEI offers a program that meets STUDENT's unique, individual needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year is in the LIEI program. See, e.g., Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at 370 (discussing prospective relief); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1994). On the other hand, for the reasons explained below, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate number of hours per week in the LIEI program is twenty-five, rather than the thirty-five sought by Petitioner. As noted above, disabled students are not entitled to the best possible education. Rowley, supra. The evidence shows that STUDENT is no longer experiencing significant delays in communication skills, and that much of the home therapy is presently devoted to teaching more complex and advanced communication skills. While STUDENT still needs home instruction to some extent to learn certain new skills -- for example, responding to more complex questions and instructions -- the evidence did not demonstrate that he presently requires twenty to twenty-five hours in the home per week to accomplish this. Rather, STUDENT's primary special needs at present appear to be for socialization and practicing conversation skills with peers in the regular education preschool. (For example, STUDENT is already spontaneously initiating communication at home with the adult therapists, but is not yet doing so in school with peers.) Based on the evidence presented, and particularly given Ms. Rush's testimony that STUDENT can now learn certain skills in regular education preschool with an aide, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Levenson's opinion that, presently, approximately ten hours per week is a sufficient amount of home therapy for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that that amount of home therapy, when complemented by approximately fifteen hours per week in a regular education preschool class, accompanied by an aide familiar with STUDENT's home therapy, is reasonably calculated to meet STUDENT's present unique, individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate total number of hours per week for the placement in LIEI for 1996-97 is twenty-five. 4. Does STUDENT require individualized speech and language therapy during the 1996-97 school year? As noted above, related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(17); Education Code 56363.(Footnote 13) Related services include speech and language therapy. 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(17); 34 C.F.R. 300.16(b)(13); Education Code 56363(b)(1). The federal regulations use the term "speech pathology," which may include "provision of speech and language services for the habilitation or prevention of speech or language impairments." 34 C.F.R. 300.16(b)(13)(iv). California uses the term "language and speech development and remediation." Education Code 56363(b)(1). The evidence showed that, last year, STUDENT made excellent progress in communication skills, and his speech and language needs were met, with a combination of attendance in a preschool classroom and provision of the related service of home Lovaas therapy. While there was evidence that STUDENT has unusual vocal intonation and that this is a matter that could be addressed by a speech and language therapist, no one testified that STUDENT requires such service in order to benefit from special education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require individualized speech and language therapy in order to benefit from special education.(Footnote 14)5. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for an independent speech and language evaluation by Dr. Susan Fosnot? A parent may be reimbursed for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) when it is determined at a due process hearing that a District assessment was inappropriate and a corresponding IEE was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. 300.503; Education Code 56329.In May, 1995, Linda Waltzman, District speech therapist, conducted a comprehensive speech and language evaluation of STUDENT. (P 9) At the IEP meeting on January 24, 1996, the District, based upon the parents' request, agreed to assess STUDENT "in the area of speech." (P 31) The District then sent the parents an assessment plan for a "speech (artic. [ulation]) assessment." (P 33, 34) The parents provided their written consent. Ms. Stiles, District speech therapist, conducted an articulation assessment and concluded that STUDENT's articulation was within the normal range. (R 20) On April 15, the parties had reviewed Ms. Stiles' report. The parents were surprised that the assessment had covered only articulation, and requested a further, more comprehensive speech and language assessment. The District did not provide the parents with a written assessment plan, and no such assessment ever occurred. The reasons for this were not made entirely clear at the hearing. It was simply noted that, in the several weeks after April 15, the parents went on vacation abroad, and the parties participated in voluntary mediation. On May 3, the parents obtained an independent speech and language assessment from Dr. Susan Fosnot. (P 41) The parties apparently agreed at an IEP meeting on April 15, 1996 that a comprehensive re-evaluation in the area of speech and language would be appropriate. Education Code 56381. The District did not conduct the assessment. (It is noted that Ms. Stiles had previously conducted an appropriate re-evaluation as to articulation only.) On the one hand, Dr. Fosnot's detailed assessment, obtained by the parents, provided the parents with some valuable information in the absence of a District re-evaluation. On the other hand, Dr. Fosnot's assessment had certain limitations in that she did not observe STUDENT in his home program or his preschool class. Dr. Fosnot did not testify at the hearing, and thus the appropriate weight to be given to her conclusions could not be fully determined. Although Dr. Fosnot recommended that STUDENT receive individualized speech and language therapy from a certified speech and language therapist every day for at least fifty minutes, it has been concluded herein that STUDENT does not require such service in order to benefit from special education. Equitable issues are relevant in determining the appropriate amount of reimbursement. For all of the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for fifty percent (50%) of the cost of Dr. Fosnot's assessment. ORDER 1. Within twenty (20) days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse Petitioner for (a) the cost of twenty hours per week of therapy from the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention from January 24, 1996 through the date of this Decision, and (b) fifty percent (50%) of the cost of Dr. Susan Fosnot's May, 1996 speech and language evaluation. 2. The District shall assume responsibility for the cost of placing STUDENT for not more than twenty-five hours per week in the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention program for the 1996-97 school year. All of Petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Issue #1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue. Issue #2: If not, must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of private therapy provided by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention since January 24, 1996? Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue. Issue #3: What is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year? Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue. Issue #4: Does STUDENT require individualized speech and language therapy for the 1996-97 school year? Respondent prevailed on this issue. Issue #5: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of an independent speech and language assessment by Dr. Susan Fosnot? Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent that it was awarded reimbursement for fifty percent (50%) of the cost of the assessment. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).
Dated: August 9, 1996 _____________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:1. Petitioner's exhibits are designated by the letter P followed by numbers 1 through 50. Respondent's exhibits are designated by the letter R followed by numbers 1 through 43.2. Mastery requires that the child demonstrate unprompted correct responses 90% of the time on two consecutive days.3. Generalization is described as exhibiting a response previously taught in the "discrete trial" format in a fashion or environment different from that in which it was taught.4. The parents testified at the hearing that, at the time of the IEP meeting, they believed STUDENT's program would include some one-to-one instruction.5. The purpose of extended school year services is to prevent regression during periods in between regular school sessions. Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3043. As noted above, however, STUDENT had not yet attended school as of the June, 1995 IEP meeting. 6. See Education Code 56365-56366.7. PARENT testified that, at or about the time of the January 24 IEP meeting, Ms. Levenson told her that she intentionally did not use specific prompts from the home program in class. Ms. Levenson testified that she did not say this.8. The federal regulations implementing IDEA define autism as follows: A developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age 3, that adversely affects a child's educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences.34 C.F.R. 300.7(b)(1). Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(g), defines the following behaviors as "autistic-like": (1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness. (4) Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both. (5) Extreme resistance to controls. (6) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns.9. California uses the term "designated instruction and services".10. The federal courts have consistently so held, in a line of cases involving -- as did Rowley -- hearing-impaired students. Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290, 296 (7th Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 925 (1988); Bonnie Ann F. v. Calallen Independent School District, 835 F.Supp. 340, 347 (S.D.Tex. 1993), aff'd, 22 IDELR 615 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1995); Peterson v. Hastings Public Schools, 31 F.3d 705, 707-708 (8th Cir. 1994); Brougham v. Town of Yarmouth, 823 F.Supp. 9, 15-16 (D. Me. 1993); Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District, 797 F.Supp. 753, 760-761 (D. Ariz. 1992), aff'd, 22 F.3d 228 (9th Cir. 1994).11. Courts have used various approaches to isolating the benefit derived from public and private programs. In Johnson v. Lancaster-Lebanon Intermediate Unit 13, 757 F. Supp. 606, 619 (E.D. Pa. 1991), for example, the court found that the fact that a student's speech and language ability regressed during a period when private therapy was halted was a factor in determining that a school district class alone was insufficient to meet the child's needs.12. Dr. Jamison testified that a preschool-age autistic child's need for one-to-one discrete trial instruction could potentially be met within the classroom. Even assuming this is correct, Ms. Levenson testified that she did not employ such methods in her classroom with STUDENT, and the District has never offered to provide him with such instruction in class. 13. California uses the term "designated instruction and services".14. The Hearing Officer understands Petitioner's request for individualized speech and language therapy to involve one-to-one therapy from a credentialed speech and language therapist.
