California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 2, 1999

Student v. Merced City School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1631-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Merced City School District did not deny FAPE through unsafe or unsanitary preschool conditions; request for nonpublic school placement denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A parent filed for due process on behalf of her five-year-old daughter. The child has spina bifida and a latex allergy and attended a District preschool class for students with orthopedic disabilities at Alicia Reyes Elementary School. The parent withdrew her in January 1999. She argued that the classroom was unsafe and unsanitary, which denied her daughter a free appropriate public education (FAPE), and she asked for a nonpublic school placement at District expense. At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer dismissed a racial discrimination and retaliation claim as outside special education due process. She also dismissed a request to enforce an interim mediation agreement. That request had already gone through the compliance complaint process, and the Hearing Office generally lacks power to enforce such agreements.

On the main issue, the Hearing Officer looked at each of the parent's concerns: a fall from an unstrapped chair, an unexplained scratch, possible latex exposure, one day the child was found in a soiled diaper, and ants, roaches, and diaper disposal. She found that the District acted reasonably. Staff stopped using the unstrapped chair after the fall. The school held latex-allergy trainings, removed latex items from the rooms, and kept medication on hand. The child's IEP called for staff to contact the parent rather than change her. Pest and waste problems were addressed. Because there was no denial of FAPE, the request for a private placement was denied, and the District prevailed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated claims that a classroom was unsafe or unsanitary. The Hearing Officer asked whether the district took reasonable steps to meet the child's health needs, such as latex-allergy training and removing latex items. Isolated incidents, without a broader failure, did not amount to a denial of FAPE or support private placement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Preliminary A. Allegations by the parent of retaliatory and racial discrimination by District personnel

    The Hearing Officer dismissed the claim at the start of the hearing because discrimination claims fall outside special education due process issues under Education Code section 56501.

  2. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Preliminary B. Request for enforcement of an interim mediation agreement

    Dismissed because the compliance complaint process had already addressed it and the Hearing Office generally lacks authority to enforce such agreements.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Has the Merced City School District failed to provide a safe and sanitary learning environment that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to Student?

    The District took reasonable steps on the chair fall, latex exposure, diapering and pest concerns, so the classroom conditions did not deny FAPE.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. If so, is Student entitled to placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) at District expense?

    Because there was no denial of FAPE, the student was not entitled to a private school placement at District expense.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District (C.D. Cal. 1998); Education Code section 56501; California Code of Regulations section 4650

People named in the decision

  • Thomas Grave, director of special education, child welfare, and school records, Merced City School District
  • Katherine Sue Lillard, R.N., school nurse, Alicia Reyes Elementary School
  • Kelly Soernsen, classroom teacher, Alicia Reyes Elementary School
  • Nell Davis, adapted physical education teacher, Merced City School District
  • Robert Storm, principal, Alicia Reyes Elementary School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Merced, California, on August 5 and 6, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Morris Jennings. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother, PARENT. STUDENT was present on the first day of hearing. Respondent Merced City School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Todd A. Goluba. Also present on behalf of the District was Thomas Grave, director of special education, child welfare, and school records. Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (1) Has the Merced City School District failed to provide a safe and sanitary learning environment that resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT? (2) If so, is STUDENT entitled to placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) at District expense? PROCEDURAL MATTERS Petitioner initially presented two additional issues, which the Hearing Officer dismissed at the beginning of the hearing. Appropriate issues for hearing are related to eligibility, placement, services, assessment, and the provision of a FAPE. California Education Code Section 56501. Petitioner's first issue pertained to allegations by Ms. PARENT of retaliatory and racial discrimination by District personnel. This issue does not fall within the issues that may be addressed through special education due process procedures. Petitioner's second issue requested enforcement of an interim mediation agreement. This issue has already been addressed through the compliance/complaint process. Moreover, the Hearing Office generally lacks authority to enforce such agreements. (See Jonathan Wyner, et al. V, Manhattan Beach Unified School District, et al. (C.D. Cal. 1998) ___F.Supp. ___, Case No. CV 97-8344; California Code of Regulations Section 4650(a)(viii)(B).) BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a five-year-old student with spina bifida and related conditions. She has a shunt located in the left side of her forehead. Ms. PARENT described the shunt as a valve to regulate the flow of liquids. STUDENT wears a body brace, which allows her to sit. She also wears leg braces. She cannot walk. STUDENT is allergic to latex. STUDENT wears diapers and requires catheterizing approximately every four hours. Ms. PARENT catheterizes STUDENT. STUDENT's right eye is affected by a neurological problem and, pending surgery, is patched daily for six to eight hours. STUDENT attended a preschool class for students with orthopedic disabilities at Alicia Reyes Elementary School from approximately August1997 until her mother withdrew her in January 1999 because of concerns about the District's ability to provide STUDENT with a safe and sanitary environment. STUDENT's individualized educational program (IEP) also called for occupational therapy (OT) and adapted physical education (APE). On November 18, 1998, the Hearing Office received Ms. PARENT's request for a due process hearing. Ms. PARENT contends that the District has failed to provide a safe and sanitary environment for STUDENT and, therefore, cannot provide her with a FAPE. The District contends that it has taken all reasonable steps to meet STUDENT's needs and to provide her with a safe and sanitary environment. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ISSUE NO. (1): Has the Merced City School District failed to provide a safe and sanitary learning environment that resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT? Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.  1400; California Education Code  56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conforms with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C.  1401(a)(18). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.) Ms. PARENT testified regarding unsafe and unsanitary conditions existing in the classroom that she alleges resulted in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT. Specifically, Ms. PARENT described incidents related to STUDENT's (1) falling off of a chair, (2) having a scratch above her eye, (3) being exposed to latex, (3) sitting in feces, and (4) being exposed to unsanitary conditions in the classroom including soiled diapers and infestations of ants and roaches. Ms. PARENT testified that even after the parties reached an agreement during mediation, the District did not provide sanitary conditions. Ms. PARENT did not raise any concerns related to other aspects of STUDENT's educational program. Each allegation related to unsafe and unsanitary conditions is addressed separately below. Katherine Sue Lillard, R.N., school nurse at Reyes, Kelly Soernsen, STUDENT's classroom teacher, Nell Davis, STUDENT's APE teacher, and Robert Storm, Reyes' principal, testified on behalf of the District. They disputed Ms. PARENT's allegations related to unsafe and unsanitary conditions at Reyes. As to STUDENT, they testified that they took steps to eliminate latex in the environment and to address other concerns raised by Ms. PARENT. STUDENT's falling off the "big girl chair." Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT cannot sit independently and must be strapped to her chair so that she will not fall and to maintain her balance. Ms. PARENT described multiple bruises STUDENT sustained on her face when she fell from a chair on October 8, 1998. (footnote 1) She stated that STUDENT looked like she was in a fight. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT had swelling around her eyes and lips, and marks around her nose. (See Petitioner's Exhibit P, which Ms. PARENT testified show the injuries STUDENT received as a result of her fall.) Ms. PARENT took STUDENT to Golden Valley Medical Center, which is across the street from the school where STUDENT's injury was described as a contusion to the forehead. (See Petitioner's Exhibit P.) Ms. PARENT testified that the District failed in its duty to notify her of STUDENT's fall and to carefully monitor STUDENT for potential additional effects as a result of her injury. Ms. PARENT testified that any blow to STUDENT's head could have damaged her shunt. Ms. PARENT testified that the District placed STUDENT at risk for further injury when an instructional assistant applied ice to her forehead. Ms. PARENT testified that the ice could clog STUDENT's shunt, thereby affecting its proper functioning. Ms. Soernsen described what happened on the day STUDENT fell from the big girl chair. Ms. Soernsen was sitting about three feet in front of STUDENT and an aide was sitting to her side. STUDENT leaned to one side and tipped over the chair. She fell with her hand down and her head hit the floor between the bridge of her glasses. One of the aides then applied an ice pack on the injured spot, which was in the middle of STUDENT's forehead. Ms. Soernsen testified that STUDENT fell about 11:00 a.m. She testified that she did not call Ms. PARENT after STUDENT's fall because Ms. PARENT always came to the class at about 11:00 a.m. to catheterize. STUDENT. Ms. Soernsen testified that Ms. PARENT chose to leave STUDENT at school for the rest of the day and to have her ride the bus home at the end of the day. Ms. Soernsen testified that STUDENT did not look beat up and did not have welts on her face. As to the reason STUDENT was sitting in the big girl chair, Ms. Soernsen testified that Ms. PARENT did not like STUDENT being confined to her wheelchair or sitting strapped in a chair. According to Ms. Soernsen, Ms. PARENT frequently would put STUDENT in a big girl chair when she came to the class. Ms. Soernsen testified that after STUDENT's fall, she did not allow her to sit in the big girl chair and STUDENT did not fall again while in her class. On cross examination, Ms. PARENT denied ever asking that school staff put STUDENT in the "big girl" chair. Clearly STUDENT was in the big girl chair while Ms. PARENT was in the class. (Testimony of Soernsen and Respondent's Exhibit X.) It is unfortunate that STUDENT fell from the chair and sustained an injury; however, there is no persuasive evidence that she suffered a serious injury. The report from the hospital following regarding STUDENT's injury describes only a contusion to the center of the forehead with mild swelling above the nasal bridge. (Petitioner's Exhibit Q and testimony of Ms. Soernsen.) Moreover, Ms. Soernsen testified persuasively that following STUDENT's fall, the classroom staff did not place STUDENT in a chair without restraints or without the chair being safely secured against a table. STUDENT's having a scratch above her eye. Ms. PARENT testified that in early November 1998, STUDENT had a scratch above her eye and that blood had been absorbed into her eye patch. Ms. PARENT stated that no one was able to tell her what had happened to cause the scratch. Neither Ms. Soernsen nor Ms. Lillard knew how STUDENT had received a scratch above her eye. There was no credible evidence that a scratch to STUDENT had occurred at school or, if it did, that the scratch was a result of an unsafe condition at the school. STUDENT's being exposed to latex. Ms. PARENT testified that persons with spina bifida have a propensity to be allergic to latex and that such an allergy was diagnosed in STUDENT in June 1998. Ms. PARENT testified that allergic reactions resulting from exposure to latex range from irritation and breathing difficulties to severe reactions, including death. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT was exposed to latex in her classroom on several occasions even after the District had knowledge of her allergy. Ms. PARENT testified that on at least one occasion, STUDENT suffered an allergic reaction as a result of exposure to latex in the classroom. She had a rash, a rapid heartbeat, heavy breathing, and a runny nose. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT had a latex doll in her lap one day. She stated that this incident occurred after mediation. Ms. Lillard testified that prior to STUDENT's diagnosis of a latex allergy, the District took steps to remove latex from her classroom and to provide the school staff with information regarding latex allergies. (footnote 2) The District received a letter from Shriners Hospital dated February 25, 1998, indicating that children with spina bifida, like STUDENT, have a greater likelihood to develop allergies to latex. Ms. Lillard testified that, in response to that letter, the District held an in-service on identifying items made of latex and the signs and symptoms of latex allergies. Materials provided at the in-service included information from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) identifying products containing latex, types of reactions to latex, treating latex allergies, recommendations, and references. In attendance at the in-service, among others, was STUDENT's teacher, some of the classroom aides, the school principal, and Ms. Lillard. (Testimony of Ms. Lillard and Respondent's Exhibits B and D.) Ms. Lillard testified that the use of latex gloves was then eliminated. Ms. Lillard testified that she did not believe the doll contained latex; however, she removed it from the classroom. A substitute teacher was in the class the day STUDENT had the doll. After receipt of STUDENT's diagnosis of a latex allergy, Ms. Lillard conducted a second in-service (1) to review information about latex allergies, (2) to instruct staff in the use of an epinephrine pen should a student go into epinepherel shock, and (3) to cover administering of general first aid practices. Present at the in-service were STUDENT's teacher and aides. (See Respondent's Exhibit S.) Surveys were conducted of both the classroom and the APE room to ascertain if any there were any items containing latex. The District also obtained benadryl from Ms. PARENT to administer to STUDENT in response to an allergic reaction. Ms. Lillard testified that gloves, the doll, balloons, rubber bands and pencils with erasers were removed from STUDENT's class. Ms. Davis, APE, also surveyed her room for latex items and ensured that she did not use any latex items with STUDENT. Ms. Davis did notice STUDENT breathing heavy one day. Ms. PARENT commented to her when she came to catheterize. STUDENT that the eye patch may have been latex and may have irritated her. Following STUDENT's diagnosis of a latex allergy, there is only one report of STUDENT's potential exposure to latex. Ms. Lillard testified that a substitute teacher was in the classroom the day STUDENT had a doll that Ms. PARENT alleges was latex. Additionally, there is no definitive finding that the doll actually was made of latex. Ms. Lillard could not confirm that the doll was latex; however, she removed it from the classroom to be safe. The testimony of Ms. Lillard, Ms. Soernsen, and Respondent's Exhibits A, B, D, Q, R, S, and W establish that the District provided in-service training to school staff, removed from the classroom items potentially containing latex, took steps to have medication in the event of an allergic reaction and, therefore, took reasonable steps to eliminate the potential for STUDENT to be exposed to latex in the classroom. STUDENT's sitting in feces. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT is susceptible to kidney and other infections. For this reason, it is important that STUDENT be clean and sanitary. Ms. PARENT testified that when she went to the classroom to pick up STUDENT on January14, 1999, she found STUDENT sitting in feces. Ms. PARENT alleges that someone in the classroom had to have been aware that STUDENT's diaper needed changing because her body brace was unvelcroed, which STUDENT could not have done by herself. The feces also were dried and smelled. Ms. PARENT testified that as a result of this incident, STUDENT had a urinary track infection. Ms. Soernsen and Ms. Lillard testified that Ms. PARENT had instructed the staff to call her when STUDENT needed changing rather than change her themselves. In fact, one time when STUDENT had soiled her diapers, Ms. PARENT was called and specifically refused to allow the staff to change STUDENT's diapers. Ms. PARENT also would not allow the staff to catheterize STUDENT. This policy is reflected in STUDENT's IEP. Ms. Soernsen testified that on the specific day in question, school staff was not aware STUDENT had soiled her diapers. The staff provided the same information to Ms. Lillard when she interviewed them following Ms. PARENT's expressing concerns to her. Ms. PARENT additionally testified that during weekly visits to STUDENT's class, she never observed students neglected or students whose diapers were not timely changed. Ms. Lillard testified that Ms. PARENT's concern about finding STUDENT in feces in January 1999 was the only concern related to diapering that Ms. PARENT or anyone else has ever expressed to her. On cross examination, Ms. PARENT denies ever telling school staff that they could not change STUDENT if she had a bowel movement. The Hearing Officer does not find her testimony persuasive. STUDENT's class had facilities to change children and the evidence establishes that classroom staff regularly change other students. There is no persuasive evidence that classroom staff independently concluded that they would not change STUDENT as they do other children. Ms. Soernsen and Ms. Lillard testified similarly regarding the procedure they were instructed to use with STUDENT by Ms. PARENT. Moreover, even assuming Ms. PARENT found STUDENT in need of changing on the day at issue, there were no reports or testimony of similar events while STUDENT was in Ms. Soernsen's class. STUDENT's being exposed to unsanitary conditions. Ms. PARENT described finding soiled diapers falling out of a waste receptacle in the room used to change STUDENT and other children. Ms. PARENT testified that the classroom was infested with ants and roaches. Ms. PARENT testified that the District failed to ameliorate these conditions until she brought them to the attention of the school nurse. Ms. Lillard testified that there were no unsanitary conditions in the classroom that would have constituted a danger to the students. As to Ms. PARENT's concerns related to the lack of proper disposal of soiled diapers, Ms. Lillard testified that she spoke with the janitor who then obtained a second disposal receptacle for soiled diapers Both Ms. Lillard and Ms. Soernsen acknowledged that the classroom occasionally had ants and roaches. They were restricted to kitchen sink area and were not where the children sat or on the carpeted area. They testified that to address ants and roaches, food was discarded and the room was cleaned and sprayed when the students were not present. The testimony of Ms. Lillard and Ms. Soernsen establishes that any problem with ants and roaches was addressed. There is no evidence that there was any danger to the children or that the infestations were chronic. In summary, Ms. PARENT, as a concerned and caring parent, has expressed a number of concerns regarding conditions in the classroom that she considers to be unsafe and/or unsanitary. The evidence discussed above establishes that the District took reasonable steps to address Ms. PARENT's concerns and to address STUDENT's unique and individual needs as a student with spina bifida. In regard to STUDENT's latex allergy, the evidence establishes that the District took affirmative steps to eliminate latex from the classroom environment, to train staff, and to address medical concerns in the event of an allergic reaction. Ms. PARENT raised no concerns as to any other aspects of STUDENT's educational program. Therefore, it is concluded that the concerns raised by Ms. PARENT in regard to the District's providing STUDENT with a safe and sanitary environment, did not result in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT. ISSUE NO. 2: If so, is STUDENT entitled to placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) at District expense? It has been determined above that the concerns raised by Ms. PARENT did not result in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to attend a private school at District expense. (footnote 3) ORDER Petitioner's requests for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code  56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issue heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code  56505(i). DATED: September 2, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1)The chair STUDENT fell from is referred to as the "big girl chair." It is a small yellow plastic child's chair; however, it does not have straps or any other restraining device. 2)STUDENT's allergy was diagnosed on June 26, 1998; however, Ms. PARENT did not receive the results until approximately November 1998. She then provided the information to the District. 3)At the time of the hearing, STUDENT's IEP for the 1999-2000 school year had not been completed. Her IEP was to be reviewed in September 1999. Thomas Grave indicated that STUDENT now is in the John Muir attendance area rather than Reyes. He stated that STUDENT could attend John Muir or Reyes or, if Ms. PARENT preferred, one of the year round schools. The District offered to provide transportation for STUDENT to attend a school other than her neighborhood school or to allow her to receive OT at Reyes.