California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 25, 2003
Anaheim Union High School District et al. v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1634-03 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary
Hearing Officer rejects Anaheim Union High and Orange County Health Care Agency's bid to approve an unspecified residential placement offer.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Notes prior case SN03-00671 (Student v. Anaheim Union High School District and Orange County Health Care Agency), which was resolved by a mediation agreement on May 2, 2003, and withdrawn. No remand or correction is noted.
Summary
Anaheim Union High School District and the Orange County Health Care Agency (HCA) filed for due process. The student was 15 and had a long history of missing school. In a May 2003 mediation, the parties agreed that she was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed and learning disabled and that she would go to a residential treatment center (RTC). The mother and student later refused the residential placement and asked for schooling and therapy at home. The District and HCA asked the Hearing Officer to find that their residential offer was a FAPE. The mother represented the student.
Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary placed the burden of proof on the District. She found that the student needed help with auditory and visual processing, classroom accommodations, academic remediation and mental health therapy. The District and HCA presented no evidence on how either proposed facility, Mary's Shelter or Florence Crittenden, would meet those needs. They also did not show how either facility would overcome the student's resistance to therapy. Neither facility had an opening or a start date. Funding ran only through October 2003. Under Union School District v. Smith, the District also failed to make a formal written offer naming a specific placement. Because the offer was not a FAPE, she did not decide educational benefit or least restrictive environment. The Student prevailed, and the relief the District and HCA asked for was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case seeking approval of a placement. The parents had agreed to residential placement at mediation. Even so, the agencies still had to make a specific written offer naming a placement. They also had to prove how the placement would meet each of the student's identified needs and when services would start.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District and HCA offer Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, for the period May 5, 2003, to the present and for the 2003-2004 school year, by making her an offer of placement in a residential treatment center?
The District and HCA did not prove that the residential offer met the student's processing, academic and mental health needs. It named no specific placement, had no start date, and was funded only through October 2003, so it was not a FAPE. The Hearing Officer did not reach educational benefit or LRE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District and HCA's request for a finding that their residential placement offer was a FAPE was denied. No relief was ordered for the Student, who did not file.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist. No. 3; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Norton v. Orinda Union School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Dr. Michael Shelton, director, special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
- Linda Gaston, program administrator, Anaheim Union High School District
- Manual Robles, AB 3632 coordinator, licensed clinical social worker, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Frances Correia, school psychologist; triennial and psychoeducational assessor, Anaheim Union High School District
- Larry Silverman, special day class teacher, Polaris School
- Dr. Kathy Morris, clinical psychologist, AB 3632 assessor and therapist, Magnolia High School / Magnolia Student Guidance Center (HCA)
- Tracey Huie, clinical social worker and therapist, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Tan Vinh, licensed clinical social worker; residential placement search, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Mary Kay Garcia, nurse; proposed witness for Student (testimony excluded), Bridges II
- Jenny McCandless, school psychologist, 2000 psychoeducational evaluation, Magnolia School District
- Kathryn Grayson, MSW, assessment team leader, AB 3632 assessment, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Dr. Rajaratnam, medication evaluation provider, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Jane R. Vogel, vision assessor
- Maria Abramson, audiologist
- Kathleen Wohlgemuth, speech-language pathologist
- Mr. Livingston, witness regarding attendance
- Mary's Shelter, proposed residential treatment center
- Florence Crittenden, proposed residential treatment center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on October 2 and 3, 2003. Anaheim Union High School District (District or Petitioner) was represented at hearing by attorney Nancy Finch-Heuerman of Parker & Covert LLP. Also present on District’s behalf were Dr. Michael Shelton, director special youth services and Linda Gaston, program administrator. Petitioner Orange County Health Care Agency (HCA or Petitioner) was represented at hearing by Orange County Deputy County Counsel Jan Martin. Also present on HCA’s behalf was Manual Robles, AB3632 coordinator and licensed clinical social worker.
STUDENT was represented by her mother.
The District called the following witnesses: MOTHER; STUDENT; Frances Correia, school psychologist for the District; and Larry Silverman, Polaris School special day class teacher. HCA called the following witnesses: Manual Robles; Dr. Kathy Morris, Magnolia High School clinical psychologist; Tracey Huie, clinical social worker and therapist; and Tan Vinh, licensed clinical social worker.
The Student called no witnesses. (Footnote 1)
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The Special Education Hearing Officer received the closing arguments of HCA and the District (timely) on October 22, 2003. No closing argument was received from Student by October 28 at 5:00 p.m. and at that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. MOTHER’s letter was received on November 3, 2003, but will not be considered because it is untimely.
ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 2)
Did the District and HCA offer Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, for the period May 5, 2003, to the present and for the 2003-2004 school year, by making her an offer of placement in a residential treatment center?
CONTENTIONS
The District contends that its offer(s) of residential placement are appropriate because the only way STUDENT will attend school or receive mental health therapy is if she is in a residential placement. In resolution of a previous due process request by MOTHER, the parties agreed at mediation on May 2, 2003, that STUDENT was to be identified as eligible for special education as specific learning disabled (SLD) and emotionally disturbed (ED). (Footnote 3) The parties further agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a residential treatment center. MOTHER and STUDENT changed their minds thereafter and would not cooperate with the steps necessary to enroll STUDENT in residential placement. The District and HCA then made this request for due process. The District and HCA contend that they have offered STUDENT a FAPE by offering placement in a residential treatment center. MOTHER contends that STUDENT does not need a residential placement and has requested that STUDENT receive schooling and mental health therapy at home.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who resides within the boundaries of Anaheim Union High School District. She was originally identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disabilities (SLD) during the 1999-2000 school year while attending sixth grade at Marshall Elementary School in the Magnolia School District. The psycho-educational evaluation conducted on January 28, 2000, by school psychologist Jenny McCandless apparently established the basis for eligibility. Dr. McCandless reported that STUDENT had been “referred for an assessment due to concerns with poor academic progress and possible medical concerns and to assist in determining the least restrictive educational environment that can best meet her educational needs.” STUDENT was reported as cooperative and very lethargic. Dr. McCandless noted that STUDENT had attended Marshall since kindergarten and had a history of very poor attendance (K: 149/168; 1st: 134/169; 2nd: 125/180, 25 tardies; 3rd: 139/172, 21 tardies; 4th: 146/177, 23 tardies; 5th: 20 absences, 8 tardies.) Dr. McCandless reported that STUDENT was “low” in all academic work, had poor reading and comprehension skills, did not complete assignments, had difficulty staying on task, was very passive, and was frequently absent. Dr. McCandless concluded that STUDENT demonstrated a specific learning disability (SLD) due to the “significant and highly unusual” discrepancy between her tested cognitive ability and her predicted ability in numerical operations and mathematics reasoning. STUDENT was placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) two periods per day for help in English and math.
STUDENT attended seventh grade during the 2000-2001 school year at Brookhurst Junior High School. Her annual IEP team meeting was held on February 13, 2001. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education as SLD. The team also noted that STUDENT’s poor grades were the result of failing to turn in assignments in several classes and poor effort. The District offered a homework lab and summer school for remediation. In March 2001 and again in October 2001, letters were sent home to STUDENT’s mother to advise her of STUDENT’s poor grades and to again offer summer school and weekend remediation courses. STUDENT failed to attend any of the remediation classes offered. From September 10, 2001, through November 29, 2001, Marshall disciplined STUDENT for three dress code violations, for failure to appear for detention, for missing a Saturday make-up class and for defiance of authority.
An IEP team meeting was held on November 7, 2001. STUDENT’s GPA was below the 2.0 required for promotion. An additional class of RSP was added to develop study skills. STUDENT was to attend the homework lab and summer school for remediation. STUDENT was also to improve her attendance. On November 20, 2001, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s lack of progress. RSP was increased to four periods per day. STUDENT was not initially at the meeting but since the team felt STUDENT’s attendance at the meeting was crucial, her mother went home and got her. The team recommended a speech and language evaluation, referral to the school social worker and referral to the Orange County Mental Health for an AB 882 (now AB 3632) assessment. The team also discussed referral to School Attendance Review Board (SARB) but deferred it because STUDENT and her mother agreed to work on attendance. Extended School Year services (ESY) were offered to help STUDENT make up missed grades and failed classes.
The Orange County Health Care Agency (HCA) received the AB 3632 referral on December 3, 2001, assigned a therapist and attempted to provide mental health treatment to STUDENT. On December 13, 2001, STUDENT ceased to attend school at Brookhurst. On January 10, 2002, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s chronic attendance problem. The language evaluation recommended in November had not been accomplished because of STUDENT’s absences. The IEP team referred STUDENT to Polaris School for an Alternative Education program to address absences and missed work. STUDENT was to continue to receive resource coverage for English, math, history and study skills. The speech and language (S&L) evaluation was conducted on January 11 and 14, 2002. STUDENT was found to be sad and depressed but not language impaired. The assessor noted her tooth decay and referred STUDENT to a dental clinic. The AB 3632 assessment was completed January 30, 2002. At an IEP team meeting held January 31, 2002, the team determined from the recent language evaluation that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as language impaired. The team also discussed the AB 3632 assessment. STUDENT’s depression was discussed, as was the referral to SARB by Brookhurst. The team also referred STUDENT to the District’s nurse practitioner for dental services. STUDENT was transferred from Brookhurst to Polaris for a special day class/learning handicapped (SDC/LH) program for “full coverage.”
A SARB panel conference was held February 19, 2002. The panel required MOTHER to provide STUDENT with transportation to school daily and required STUDENT to attend school daily. MOTHER and STUDENT refused to sign the parent/pupil agreement.
At the IEP team meeting held February 27, 2002, STUDENT indicated that she did not wish to participate in AB 3632 services, and MOTHER supported her decision. MOTHER asked that AB 3632 services be terminated and the case was closed. (Footnote 4) MOTHER also asked that STUDENT be dropped from special education. MOTHER and STUDENT were under the impression that STUDENT could be transferred to a “county school” if she was not “special ed.” The IEP team again discussed the mental health assessment report. (Footnote 5) The team was not comfortable with dropping STUDENT from the special education program and continued to recommend that STUDENT attend the Polaris SDC program. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT take advantage of the mental health services and advised MOTHER that the AB 3632 case could be reopened anytime and services would resume.
An IEP team meeting was held March 27, 2002. The team recommended that STUDENT attend the Polaris SDC/LH program one hour per day, Monday through Friday. The team approved transportation but STUDENT’s mother declined. The team discussed a schedule to allow STUDENT to comfortably transition from non-attendance.
From September 8, 2002 to September 22, 2002, MOTHER called Dr. Morris four times to discuss mental health services for STUDENT. The telephone call on September 22, 2002, was apparently in response to MOTHER’s receipt of a letter from the district attorney setting a court date to address STUDENT’s truancies. On September 25, 2002, MOTHER requested that the mental health case be reopened. (Footnote 6) The case was reopened on May 21, 2002. The therapist was not able to reach MOTHER or set an appointment until June 7, 2002. On June 4, 2002, the therapist called MOTHER to confirm the June 7, 2002 appointment. MOTHER told Dr. Morris that if STUDENT would not come to the appointment she should go ahead and close the case. STUDENT and MOTHER did not appear at the appointment and did not call. The mental health services “case” was again closed.
MOTHER apparently called the therapist on September 9, 2002. They discussed MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT refused to go to therapy or to school but visited with friends. MOTHER apparently called the therapist again on September 25, 2002, and asked that mental health services be resumed. The case was reopened October 8, 2002. On October 23, 2002, MOTHER provided written consent for services. She also completed a caretaker intake form and the Child Behavior Checklist (CBC). October 28, 2002, is the only day that STUDENT attended school during the 2002-2003 school year.
Kathryn Grayson, MSW and Assessment Team Leader, completed a youth self report form (YSR) with STUDENT. (Footnote 7) Ms. Grayson interviewed STUDENT on November 4, 2002, and November 19, 2002. The AB3632/882/Ch. 26.5 Assessment Report was issued November 19, 2002. Ms. Grayson reported that STUDENT shared that she began missing school in sixth grade but did not know why. STUDENT said she began having problems with peers in seventh grade because of the clothes she wore and her teeth. STUDENT stated that the teasing got worse in eighth grade so that she was uncomfortable at school, worrying about what others were thinking or saying about her, and she began not wanting to go to school. Ms. Grayson concluded that STUDENT demonstrated a problem with anxiety and had limited cognitive abilities to deal with depressive and anxious feelings. Ms. Grayson noted that STUDENT showed neurovegetative signs of depression, such as lethargy.
On November 20, 2002, an IEP team meeting was held and the AB 3632 assessment report was reviewed and discussed. A new IEP was developed. The team determined that STUDENT’s mental health issues were of significant concern and that the focus should be on those issues and a slow transition to school. Ms. Grayson recommended a medication evaluation with Dr. Rajaratnam. She suggested that the team stop their attempts to get STUDENT to attend school until the medication had been given some time to work. The team thus recommended independent study for several months and the team would meet in February for STUDENT’s triennial IEP to review STUDENT’s progress. The team continued to identify STUDENT as eligible due to an SLD. Also at this meeting, STUDENT and MOTHER were introduced to Tracey Huie, MSW, who would be STUDENT’s new therapist through HCA. (Footnote 8)
The County of Orange Probation Department notified MOTHER by letter dated December 30, 2002, that a referral had been made to the department because of STUDENT’s habitual truancy and an interview date of January 13, 2003, had been set.
STUDENT’s triennial evaluation and multidisciplinary psychoeductional evaluation was dated September 2, 2003, and signed by school psychologist Frances M. Correia. Ms. Correia found STUDENT to be eligible for special education under the category SLD in that she exhibited “a significant discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement in written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, math calculation and math reasoning.” Ms. Correia also found that the discrepancy was due to a deficit in auditory processing and was not primarily due to the result of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantages, attendance, or lack of school experience. Finally, Ms. Correia noted that although emotional concerns are noted, STUDENT did not appear to meet state criteria for eligibility as an emotionally disturbed student.
At the IEP team meeting of September 2, 2003, HCA asked that the case be closed due to the lack of STUDENT’s participation. The parent and student agreed so the IEP team terminated mental health services. The team determined that STUDENT remained eligible for special education due to SLD, but not due to emotional disturbance. The team meeting notes also indicated that STUDENT’s non-attendance appeared to be more of a manipulation than a consequence of her dysthymia. (Footnote 9) Therefore the team recommended that STUDENT attend school five days per week, Monday through Friday from 11:40 a.m. to 2:40 p.m. The team noted that students much more “involved” than STUDENT have managed to attend this amount of school.
On September 2, 2003, MOTHER hired an attorney and requested a due process hearing. A SARB conference was held September 7, 2003. The panel drafted a parent/pupil agreement that reflected its requirements that MOTHER was to provide STUDENT daily transportation to school, counseling, and was to make progress reports and weekly calls to the school. The agreement also required STUDENT to attend school, participate in counseling and to also make progress reports. STUDENT and her mother refused to sign the parent/pupil agreement.
On May 2, 2003, MOTHER and her attorney attended mediation and signed a final mediation agreement with the District and HCA and withdrew the request for hearing. The parties stipulated that STUDENT was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed (ED) and specific learning disabled (SLD). HCA agreed to conduct a search for a residential placement and agreed to fund the mental health portion of the placement until October 2003. The District agreed to fund the educational component of the residential placement until October 2003. The District agreed to conduct assessments and the parent agreed to sign the assessment plan and make the student available for assessment. (Footnote 10) An IEP team meeting was held immediately after the mediation on May 2, 2003, with a partial IEP team that wrote an IEP addendum that complied with the mediation agreement. The team recommended the residential placement “per the mediation agreement.” On May 5, 2003, MOTHER signed the mediation agreement and the assessment plan. The assessment plan was to test STUDENT in the following areas: achievement, cognitive ability, language/speech, central auditory processing, social/emotional skills and a functional vision.
On May 9, 2003, Tan Vinh, licensed clinical social worker, began his attempts to contact MOTHER to obtain her signature on releases so that he could start the search for a residential placement. Mr. Vinh needed to obtain MOTHER’s written consent to be able to provide information to the residential treatment centers about STUDENT. MOTHER missed appointments, failed to return calls and was generally uncooperative. The releases were signed on May 23, 2003. The vision specialist and audiologist made numerous unsuccessful attempts to arrange their assessments. STUDENT was not attending school.
On June 6, 2003, the IEP team met but MOTHER and STUDENT were not present. However, counsel for the Student was present. The team decided to refer STUDENT to SARB. The team reported that two possible residential placements had been identified, Mary’s Shelter and Florence Crittenden. While neither had immediate openings, both had agreed to put STUDENT on a waiting list and both had attempted to contact the mother to arrange visits to the respective facilities. No specific written offer of placement was made.
The vision assessment report was completed June 25, 2003. Jane R. Vogel, M.A. concluded that STUDENT exhibited a visual processing deficit and she made several recommendations for the modification of STUDENT’s classroom. School psychologist Frances M. Correia conducted a multidisciplinary psychoeducational evaluation on July 9, 2003. Dr. Correia found that STUDENT’s measured mental ability and academic achievement were approximately commensurate “at this time” and therefore, STUDENT did not meet state criteria as eligible for special education under the category of SLD. However, Dr. Correia did find that STUDENT was now eligible under the category emotional disturbance (ED) “as she exhibits a general mood of unhappiness or depression. These symptoms have existed for a long period of time and appear to impair school performance to a marked degree.” Maria Abramson, M.S., completed an audiology assessment on July 17, 2003. While Ms. Abramson did not find that STUDENT had a central auditory processing disorder, Ms. Abramson did find that STUDENT had some weakness in sequencing and temporal processing skills. Ms. Abramson recommended accommodations. A speech and language evaluation was conducted by Kathleen Wohlgemuth, M.A., speech-language pathologist. The exam dates were July 15, and 21, 2003. Ms. Wohlegmuth determined that STUDENT was observed to process language effortlessly and efficiently and her apparent weak areas appeared to reflect environmental constraints and lack of school attendance. STUDENT did not present as a language impaired individual.
On July 23, 2003, the IEP team met to discuss the assessment reports. STUDENT was initially not present at the meeting but her mother went home and got her because the rest of the team wanted her to participate. The team continued to offer residential placement because “[I]t appears that this level of service is required in order to meet STUDENT’s emotional and attendance/academic needs.” However, no specific offer of placement was made. STUDENT’s health was reported as appearing normal except for dental decay. Significant depressive symptoms were reported. At the IEP team meeting STUDENT and her mother told the team that they would not agree to a residential placement.
On July 24, 2003, HCA and the District requested a due process hearing. HCA and the District requested a finding that Respondent STUDENT had been offered a FAPE and Petitioners had no further liability to Student.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Did the District and HCA offer Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, for the period May 5, 2003, to the present and through the 2003-2004 school year, by making her an offer of placement in a residential treatment center?
Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services,” includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. Such services include mental health services if necessary to assist a child to benefit from special education. The State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service…shall be responsible for the provision of mental health services….when required in the pupil’s individualized education program (Govt. Code §7576 (a).)
Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Educ. Code § 56031.)
To determine whether the offer made on May 5, 2003, was an offer of a FAPE designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were at that time. (Footnote 11)
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
The parties have agreed by mediation agreement in SEHO case number 03-00671 that STUDENT is eligible for special education as SLD and ED. However, the mediation agreement did not address STUDENT’s unique needs beyond her need for mental health therapy. Thus, the Hearing Officer must also look to the assessments and IEPs to determine whether STUDENT has any other unique needs. While in sixth grade STUDENT participated in a psycho-educational evaluation conducted by Magnolia School District school psychologist Jenny McCandless and was identified as SLD. The assessor suggested several accommodations to help STUDENT overcome her learning disability, such as reading aloud to STUDENT, having her read aloud and tell stories, using high interest and low vocabulary reading materials, relating new words to acquired information, simplifying instructions and directions and having STUDENT repeat them, reducing the amount of material presented to her at one time to encourage concentration and provide reading and writing materials at her ability level. Therefore, in February 2000 STUDENT had unique needs in processing instruction and needed classroom accommodations.
IEP team meetings were held February 13, 2001, November 7, 2001, and November 20, 2001. The IEPs did not contain statements of present levels of performance. There is no evidence to indicate that, through 2001, STUDENT’s unique needs had changed, but she was falling further behind due to poor attendance.
An AB 3632 assessment was conducted by the Magnolia Student Guidance Center (Kathy Morris, PhD.) and the resulting report dated January 30, 2002, concluded that STUDENT suffered from dysthymic symptoms and sadness, had difficulty in concentrating, had problems in attending and being successful in school. An initial Clinic Services Plan was drafted with goals to defeat STUDENT’s depressive thoughts, reverse her withdrawal from family and friends and school and to help her become more accepting of the deaths of her father and her sister. Thus, in January 2002 STUDENT’s unique needs expanded to include the need for mental health therapy.
At mediation on May 2, 2003, the parties agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education under two categories, ED and SLD, and agreed to place STUDENT in a residential treatment center. An assessment plan was also developed and signed on May 2, 2003. The assessment plan resulted in four assessment reports, a vision assessment, a psychoeducational assessment, an audiology assessment, and a speech and language evaluation. In her July 9, 2003 psychoeducational assessment Ms. Correia found that STUDENT no longer met the eligibility requirements for SLD and concluded that STUDENT does appear to meet state criteria for students with ED as she exhibits a general mood of unhappiness or depression, the symptoms have existed for a long period of time and appear to impair school performance to a marked degree.
The vision evaluation of June 25, 2003 finds that STUDENT does not have a vision related disability but has a visual processing deficit that might affect her education. The assessor suggested accommodations, such as simpler instructions, enlarged materials, a reduction the amount of material introduced to STUDENT at a time, and increased time to complete assignments and tests. The speech and language evaluation of July 17, 2003, found that STUDENT does not have a speech and language disability, but it did find that STUDENT was behind on her vocabulary probably because of missing school. She also needed dental care. The audiology report of July 23, 2003 does not find that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder but would benefit from clear, slow instruction and instructional outlines.
At hearing, Ms. Correia and Ms. Morris testified that STUDENT needed a residential treatment center so she could receive mental health therapy and schooling. Tracey Huie, Tan Vinh, Larry Silverman, and Manual Robles provided the same testimony. The witnesses concluded that the only way to meet STUDENT’s needs was a residential treatment center.
Based on the totality and weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has unique needs in auditory processing and visual processing and in the area of social/emotional skills. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs accommodations in the methods used to deliver instruction, such as clear, simple and slow instruction, the use of simple instructional outlines and enlarged materials. STUDENT needs to be given additional time to complete assignments and tasks and to take tests. The amount of material given to STUDENT at one time needs to be limited. STUDENT also needs significant remediation to make up for the instruction lost when she did not attend school. STUDENT should attend after-school, weekend and summer remediation courses. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has suffered dysthymic symptoms and also suffers from adolescent concerns surrounding self-worth and self-image. Further, the parties have agreed that STUDENT needs mental health therapy in a residential treatment center. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT also has unique social/emotional needs that require mental health therapy.
Did the offer of residential placement address STUDENT’s unique needs?
Evidence was presented at hearing regarding STUDENT’s depression and purported school phobia. However, no evidence was presented as to how the RTC would address STUDENT’s depression. Testimony established that Mary’s Shelter and Florence Crittenden have counselors on site. However, no testimony was presented regarding the type or amount of mental health therapy that STUDENT would receive. No testimony was offered as to how the RTC would overcome STUDENT’s clear resistance to therapy. No evidence was offered as to how the RTC would address STUDENT’s alleged school phobia.
Evidence also established that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of auditory and visual processing. The offer did not address STUDENT’s auditory and visual processing needs and no evidence was presented as to how the RTC would address these needs. STUDENT’s previous IEPs offered RSP classes in math, English, history and study skills. No evidence was presented to show how the RTC would address STUDENT’s needs in these academic subjects or would provide remediation in these subjects. Further, the mediation agreement called for the RTC to be funded through October 2003. By its own terms, the offer did not address STUDENT’s unique needs for the remainder and majority of the 2003-2004 school year.
Testimony from Tan Vinh showed that the two possible RTC placements, Mary’s Shelter and Florence Crittenden did not have any openings as of May 9, 2003. STUDENT was to be put on a waiting list for future openings, which would occur possibly in July. The RTCs could not give a date certain for STUDENT to enter their respective programs. There is to be no delay in implementing the components of an IEP that a parent has consented to. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56346.) It was clear that the RTC offer could not meet STUDENT’s needs until some unknown date in the future.
Was there a formal written offer as required in Union?
One of the procedural requirements for a school district under the IDEA is to make a formal, written offer of placement. Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519, cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (b)(3). In this Ninth Circuit holding at page 1526, the Court stated: “This formal requirement [of a written placement offer] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.”
As a result of the mediation on May 2, 2003, the District agreed to place STUDENT in a residential treatment center and HCA agreed to conduct a search for an RTC that would accept pregnant teens. A partial IEP team met on May 2, 2003, after the mediation, to recommend RTC placement. However, the IEP team did not make a placement offer that identified a specific placement. At the June 6, 2003 IEP team meeting, HCA identified two possible RTCs, Mary’s Shelter and Florence Crittenden that accept a pregnant teen. Both placements had academic programs, programs in parenting and mental health therapy. However, neither had an opening and neither could provide an actual start date for STUDENT. MOTHER had been requested to visit both possible placements with STUDENT and decide which placement would be appropriate. As of June 6, 2003, no clear written offer of placement had been made. At the IEP team meeting of July 23, 2003, RTC placement continued to be recommended; however, no formal written offer of a specific named placement was made. Under Union, the District did not make an appropriate offer.
Did the District meet its burden of proof?
In 1994, the Ninth Circuit Court in Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, while never squarely addressing the issue, asserted that the "school clearly has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA." Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994) (emphasis added). Although the Puyallup Court's statement was arguably dicta as it was not necessary to support the decision reached by the court on the issues before it, subsequent courts within California and the Ninth Circuit have adopted the Court's statement as legal authority. See Seattle School District, No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996); and Alan Norton v. Orinda Union School District, 29 IDELR 1069 (9th Cir. 1999). Therefore, the trend in California and the Ninth Circuit is to place the burden of persuasion on the District where a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is at issue. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will apply the rule in Puyallup and place the burden of persuasion on the District to prove that it complied with the IDEA.
The District must demonstrate that the RTC placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and comports with STUDENT’s IEP. The District’s evidence shows that STUDENT has unique needs in auditory and visual processing, in academics, and in social/emotional skills. However, as already found by the Hearing Officer, no evidence was presented as to how the RTC would meet these needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet its burden to demonstrate how the RTC placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. It is unnecessary to address whether the District demonstrated that its offer comported with STUDENT’s IEP.
Conclusion
To summarize, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that neither of the proposed RTC placements was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, or in a timely manner. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District did not follow the requirements of Union. And, finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to meet its burden of proof and has not established that its offer was an offer of FAPE.
Was the District’s offer of placement reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?
Because of the above finding, it is unnecessary to address this issue.
Did the District’s offer of placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
Because of the above finding, it is unnecessary to address this issue.
Was the District’s offer provided in the least restrictive environment?
Because of the above finding, it is unnecessary to address this issue.
CONCLUSIONS
The Hearing Officer finds that the RTC placement is not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Further, the District has failed to present sufficient evidence to meet its burden of proof and has therefore failed to establish that the residential placement offer is an offer of FAPE.
ORDER
The relief requested by the District and HCA is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The Student is the prevailing party on the issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: November 25, 2003 ______________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
MOTHER had requested that Mary Kay Garcia, a nurse with Bridges II, accompany Student to the hearing for the purpose of making a statement on STUDENT’s behalf. Ms. Garcia was to explain why STUDENT did not belong in a residential treatment center. Ms. Garcia had not been disclosed as a potential witness prior to hearing. The District and HCA objected to her testimony. The Hearing Officer ordered that the statement of the witness was not admissible; however, should the witness testify later at hearing, the grounds for objection could possibly be cured. Ms. Garcia left and declined to return to testify. MOTHER was asked if she wished to have a chance to present Ms. Garcia as a witness at a later date but she declined to do so.
2 The issue has been restated to reflect the results of the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. The issue has been reorganized for ease of analysis. There were no substantive changes.
3 STUDENT v. Anaheim Union High School District and Orange County Health Care Agency, SN03-00671.
4 From December 17, 2001 through February 27, 2002, HCA attempted to provide mental health services to STUDENT. Because STUDENT would not go to new places, the therapist, Kathy Morris, agreed to provide therapy at MOTHER’s home and set weekly visits. During this time frame, eleven visits were scheduled but STUDENT only attended four sessions, three of which were very short. The therapist traveled to MOTHER’s home twice to find that STUDENT and MOTHER were not home for the prescheduled appointment. The therapist was forced to make several attempts to reschedule missed appointments. MOTHER had varying excuses for STUDENT’s lack of attendance, such as STUDENT was sick, MOTHER had to take her uncle to the hospital, they were stuck in traffic, or they forgot. It took two or three visits before STUDENT would come out of her room.
5 The report did not set forth a diagnosis but stated that STUDENT was depressed. The report recommended ongoing therapy, the focus of which would be improving communication between STUDENT and her mother, increasing school attendance and improving concentration. The report also recommended that STUDENT be evaluated for medication.
6 From March 4, 2002 to June 13, 2002 STUDENT attended school only twenty-three days. She had forty truancies, and four sick days. She was thus retained in the eighth grade for the 2002-2003 school year. Mr. Livingston testified that he believed that MOTHER accompanied STUDENT to class on these twenty-three days. MOTHER then quit attending and so did STUDENT. Neither one was able to explain why at hearing.
7 Kathy Morris had originally requested MOTHER to fill out the CBC in December 2001. She had requested STUDENT fill out the YSR at the same time. MOTHER and STUDENT failed to do so, both saying that they were unable to concentrate enough to fill out the forms. Ms. Grayson set four different appointments before she could complete the assessment. MOTHER and STUDENT were caught in traffic and failed one of the appointments. They simply did not show up or call for another appointment.
8 From November 26, 2002 through March 4, 2002, Ms. Huie could only set eleven of the planned sixteen appointments for mental health therapy for STUDENT. STUDENT and her mother attended four times and one of these times appeared twenty minutes late for the appointment. The appointments were set weekly on Fridays at 10 a.m. Ms. Huie’s notes reflect her frustration with the excuses provided and with the family’s resistance to therapy. Ms. Huie was also frustrated that STUDENT would not meet with her without her mother present and was basically non-verbal during the sessions. Ms. Huie required the MOTHER and STUDENT to sign a contract to attend therapy appointments on February 20, 2003. STUDENT was to attend 100 percent of the appointments between February 20, 2003 and September 17, 2003. STUDENT attended only one more session after she and her mother signed the contract. Ms. Huie’s notes reflect that STUDENT failed to attend three scheduled appointments with Dr. Rajaratnam for the medication evaluation.
9 Dysthymia is defined in Stedman’s Medical Dictionary, 25th Edition as “any disorder of mood.”
10 At hearing, the parties waived the confidentiality of the mediation agreement. All parties wished to have the agreement entered into evidence. Because the issue of this hearing is whether the District and HCA offered a FAPE after the mediation, the Hearing Officer will admit the mediation agreement under paragraph 10 of the agreement for purposes of implementation of the agreed upon residential placement.
11 The mediation was May 2, 2003, as was the IEP team meeting but MOTHER did not sign the mediation agreement or IEP team meeting notes until May 5, 2003. Thus, the Hearing Officer will use May 5, 2003 as the date of the offer.
