California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 1, 2001

Student v. East Whittier City Elementary School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1638-01, SN 01-01638, SN 01-01735 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

East Whittier City Elementary must provide year-round speech therapy to a kindergartner with autism; placement and behavior offer upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 4 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted.

Summary

The parent of a five-year-old boy with autism disagreed with East Whittier City Elementary School District's offer for the 2001-2002 school year and filed for due process. The District then filed its own case. The two cases were combined into one question: did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE)? The boy had made strong progress in a preschool special day class at Orchard Dale Elementary School. Its staff used discrete trial training and were trained by Autism Partnership, a nonpublic agency. The parent wanted him to stay in a preschool class. She also asked for two and a half hours a day of one-to-one Autism Partnership help and three hours a week of speech therapy from a nonpublic agency, 50 weeks a year.

The Hearing Officer denied the parent's stay put request. The June 2001 IEP was a temporary agreement for the summer only. The Hearing Officer then upheld the District's kindergarten-through-second-grade class at Leffingwell Elementary School. That class was modeled on his preschool class and taught by trained staff. One hour a day of one-to-one help was enough because he needed group time to learn to use his skills in new settings. The District's speech offer was also enough in amount: six 15-minute sessions a week plus a daily oral-motor center. However, the District offered no evidence against the parent's testimony that her son lost skills over school breaks. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to provide speech therapy 50 weeks a year and to hold an IEP meeting within 20 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled stay put when a district agreed to services only for a summer session. It also shows how the district's burden of proof could decide a narrow issue. Here the parent's testimony that her son lost skills went unanswered, and that led to an order for year-round speech therapy.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedStay put

    Issue Procedural I. Student's motion for a stay put order requiring the District to implement the June 19, 2001 IEP during the due process proceedings (and later motion for reconsideration)

    The June 19, 2001 IEP was a temporary agreement expressly limited to the July 2-27 ESY session, so it was not the current educational placement; stay put was the preschool SDC at Orchard Dale. Reconsideration was denied because no new facts or law were offered.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1a. Has the District offered a FAPE for 2001-2002: whether the student requires a preschool placement rather than the offered K-2 severely handicapped special day class

    The K-2 SH-SDC at Leffingwell copied the preschool model class where the student made significant progress, had a trained and experienced teacher, and fit his age and functional levels, so it was appropriate.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Has the District offered a FAPE for 2001-2002: whether one hour per day of one-to-one DTT by Autism Partnership, rather than two and a half hours per day, is sufficient behavior intervention

    One hour per day of one-to-one DTT in a classroom with ABA-trained staff was appropriate because the student needed group instruction to generalize skills; the October 2000 Autism Partnership report was outdated and did not require more school-based one-to-one hours.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1c. Has the District offered a FAPE for 2001-2002: whether the student requires three hours per week of speech therapy by a nonpublic agency, 50 weeks per year

    Six 15-minute sessions per week plus a daily oral-motor learning center was enough in amount and need not come from a nonpublic agency. The District offered no evidence to rebut regression over breaks, so speech must be provided 50 weeks per year.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District shall add to the IEP a provision that it will provide the six 15-minute speech sessions per week during fifty weeks of the calendar year, regardless of the District's regularly scheduled breaks and holidays.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within twenty calendar days of the decision, District shall convene an IEP meeting to revise the IEP to reflect the order.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent Sch. Dist.; Leonard v. McKenzie; Jacobsen v. District of Columbia Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Toni Hudson, Ph.D., assistant superintendent of student services, East Whittier City Elementary School District
  • Darlene Hanson, program specialist (licensed speech-language specialist), WACSEP
  • Lisa Torres, teacher, preschool severely handicapped special day class, Orchard Dale Elementary School, East Whittier City Elementary School District
  • Julie Ton, teacher, K-2 severely handicapped special day class, Leffingwell Elementary School, East Whittier City Elementary School District
  • Billy Beckman, teacher, preschool special day class at Leffingwell Elementary School (parent's requested placement), East Whittier City Elementary School District
  • Doris Soluaga, program supervisor / behavioral consultant, nonpublic agency, Autism Partnership
  • Dorie Glover, Ph.D., clinical associate, author of Behavior and Skill Assessment Report, Behavior Therapy & Learning Center, Autism Partnership
  • Ronald Leaf, Ph.D., director, co-author of Behavior and Skill Assessment Report, Behavior Therapy & Learning Center, Autism Partnership
  • B.J. Freeman, Ph.D., private psychological evaluator, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital, Autism Evaluation Clinic
  • Donna Crandall, M.A., private psychological evaluator, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital, Autism Evaluation Clinic
  • Peggy Bailey, M.A.-CCC, private speech-language pathologist
  • Eve Mancillas, speech-language specialist (2000-2001), District/school speech provider
  • Autism Partnership, nonpublic agency (DTT and staff training)
  • California Psychcare, nonpublic agency providing regional center-funded home program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Whittier, California, on August 28 and 29 and September 5, 2001.

STUDENT (Student) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on his behalf during portions of the hearing was his aunt, AUNT. The East Whittier City Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Darin Barber, counsel for the Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP). Also present on the District’s behalf was Toni Hudson, Ph.D., its assistant superintendent of student services.

The following witnesses were called by the Student to testify: MOTHER and AUNT. The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Dr. Hudson; Darlene Hanson, a WACSEP program specialist; Lisa Torres, the teacher of the preschool severely handicapped special day class at Orchard Dale Elementary School; Julie Ton, the teacher of the kindergarten through second-grade severely handicapped special day class at Leffingwell Elementary School; and Doris Soluaga, a program supervisor for Autism Partnership, a nonpublic agency.(Footnote 1)

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Upon the conclusion of witness testimony, the parties orally presented their closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)

Has the East Whittier City Elementary School District (District) offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

I. Student’s Motion for a Stay Put Order

On August 24, 2001, the Student filed a motion regarding stay put. The Student requested that the Hearing Office order the District to provide him with the placement and services described in his individualized education program (IEP) dated June 19, 2001, during the pendency of the due process proceedings. The Student argued that the June 19 IEP was the last agreed-to IEP that was fully executed prior to the instant dispute arising. On August 27, the District filed an opposition to the Student’s motion regarding stay put. The District contended that the stay put placement was as set forth in the IEP dated April 2, 2001, not in the IEP dated June 19. The District argued that the June 19 IEP constituted a limited agreement to a temporary program that was expressly meant to last only from July 2 to July 27, 2001. On August 28, the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer orally denied the Student’s request for a stay put order requiring the District to provide him with services pursuant to his IEP dated June 19, 2001, during the pendency of the due process proceedings.

Under federal and State law, special education students generally are entitled to remain in their current educational placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures, unless the parties agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of stay put is the maintenance of the status quo in the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District, 695 F.2d 949, 953 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2d Cir. 1982).

However, where a school district has made it clear that its agreement to fund or provide a particular placement or particular services is only temporary (in other words, for a limited time period), that placement or provision of services does not constitute the child’s “current educational placement” for purposes of stay put. See Zvi D., 694 F.2d at 908; Leonard v. McKenzie, 869 F.2d 1558, 1564 (D.C. Cir. 1989); cf. Jacobsen v. District of Columbia Bd. of Educ., 564 F. Supp. 166, 171-172 (D.C. Dist. 1983). To hold otherwise would result in parties refusing to agree to limited placements.

The Hearing Officer noted that there was no dispute that the agreement contained in the IEP of June 19 was expressly limited on its face to the four-week extended school year (ESY) period of July 2 to July 27, 2001. The finding that the June 19 IEP was intended to be an agreement for only temporary ESY services, and not meant to be implemented during the regular school year, was further bolstered by the fact that a dispute had already risen between the parties as to the appropriate placement for the 2001-2002 regular school year session. At an IEP meeting held on April 2, 2001, the parent rejected the District’s original offer of services for the 2001 ESY and for the 2001-2002 regular school year session. Thus, when the IEP team reconvened on June 19 to further discuss ESY services, the District was very careful to limit the intensive nonpublic agency (NPA) services called for by the June 19 IEP to the four-week ESY session. The parties adjourned the June 19 meeting with the understanding that a dispute still existed with regard to what constituted an appropriate placement and services for the regular school year session.

In ruling on the Student’s motion for stay put, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s clear indication that its agreement to fund the NPA services was limited to the four-week ESY period resulted in only a temporary agreement for services. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concluded that the parties’ temporary agreement for services in the June 19 IEP did not constitute STUDENT’s “current educational placement” for purposes of stay put. The Hearing Officer noted that during the pendency of the due process proceedings, STUDENT was entitled to continued placement in his prior agreed-to placement in the preschool severely handicapped special day class at Orchard Dale Elementary School, which he attended during the 2000-2001 school year.

II. Student’s Motion for Reconsideration of Order Denying Stay Put Request

On September 4, the Student filed a motion for reconsideration of the ruling issued on August 28 at hearing that denied his request regarding stay put. The Student argued that the placement outlined in the June 19 IEP provided him with a “more positive placement” and should be continued during the pendency of the due process proceedings, notwithstanding any “legal argument” to the contrary.

On September 5, when the hearing in this matter reconvened, the District orally opposed the motion for reconsideration. The District contended that the Student failed to offer any new or different facts, circumstances, or law to justify reconsideration.

The Hearing Officer orally denied the Student’s motion for reconsideration. The Hearing Officer noted that no new or different facts, circumstances, or law had been offered to justify reconsideration of the order issued on August 28, 2001. Additionally, the Hearing Officer noted that even if sufficient new or different facts, circumstances, or law had been offered to justify reconsideration, the Student’s argument that one placement was more appropriate than the other was misplaced. The Hearing Officer stated that the issue of whether one placement is more appropriate than another generally is not a proper consideration in determining the extent of a school district’s obligations under the stay put provision.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a five-year-old student who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. He is identified as eligible for special education and related services because of significant developmental delays resulting from autism. He was diagnosed with autism near his third birthday.

Beginning October 31, 2000, and for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended the preschool special day class (SDC) for severely handicapped (SH) students at Orchard Dale Elementary School (Orchard Dale). The class was staffed by a special education teacher and instructional aides trained by Autism Partnership, a nonpublic agency (NPA). In accordance with this training, the classroom staff utilized a discrete trial training (DTT) instructional format. STUDENT also received a number of related services during the 2000-2001 school year, including speech therapy and occupational therapy (OT). Additionally, he attended an afterschool program, where he received one-to-one instruction using the DTT format until March 2001. In March 2001, in addition to attending the SDC at Orchard Dale and receiving related services, STUDENT began receiving a twenty-hour-per-week in-home program funded by the local regional center and provided by California Psychcare, another NPA.

On April 2, 2001, the District held an IEP meeting to discuss placement and services for the 2001 extended school year (ESY) and the 2001-2002 school year. According to the IEP document created during that meeting, the District recommended that STUDENT be advanced to a kindergarten SH-SDC. The District also recommended that STUDENT receive two hours of one-to-one DTT two times per week, six fifteen-minute speech therapy sessions per week, two fifty-minute OT sessions per week, OT consultation one time per month, and ESY services. The IEP also noted that oral-motor exercises would be conducted as a learning center on a daily basis. The parent gave permission for the District to implement the speech therapy, OT, and DTT portions of the IEP at Orchard Dale, but did not consent to the placements proposed for the 2001 ESY and the 2001-2002 school year.

A little over a month later, on May 17, 2001, another IEP meeting was held. At the meeting, the parent requested that a consistent program be developed between the staff from school and the staff of the in-home program funded by the regional center. The parent also requested that the District provide her with a formal written behavior program and provide STUDENT with additional speech therapy. The District agreed that it would provide the parent with a written behavior program by June 21, 2001, and that the school staff would share current goals with the home-program staff in order to ensure consistency. Additionally, the District agreed that starting July 2 to July 27, 2001, STUDENT would receive two twenty-minute speech therapy sessions on a one-to-one basis five days per week.

The parties held another IEP meeting on June 19, 2001. At this meeting, they were able to agree that the District would provide the following services for the four-week ESY period of July 2 to July 27, 2001: a one-to-one DTT program provided by Autism Partnership, two twenty-minute speech therapy sessions per day, and two fifty-minute OT sessions per week at the clinic.

A month later, on July 18, another IEP meeting was convened to discuss STUDENT’s progress in the ESY program and discuss his program for the upcoming school year. At the meeting, the District offered STUDENT the following program for the 2001-2002 school year: placement in the SH-SDC for kindergarten through second-grade (K-2) at Leffingwell Elementary School (Leffingwell); one hour per day of one-to-one DTT by Autism Partnership in the SH-SDC program; one hour per month of supervision of the DTT program by an Autism Partnership supervisor, with an additional four to six hours of supervision during STUDENT’s transition into the new classroom by October 30, 2001; continuation of the two OT clinic sessions per week; monthly OT consultation at school; monthly team meetings between the school and home-program staff; and assignment of a one-to-one aide during the first thirty days of STUDENT’s placement in the SDC in the fall. The District described the K-2 SH-SDC placement offered as a “continuation of the same type of SH SDC program as in 2000-2001" and as a “promotion” to kindergarten. The parent disagreed with the District’s proposed program. She requested that the District provide STUDENT with a preschool SDC program instead.

The next day, on July 19, the parent filed a request for a due process hearing (Case No. SN 01-01638).

By letter dated July 24, 2001, the District reiterated the placement offer stated in the July 18, 2001 IEP. Additionally, the District stated that its offer also included a continuation of the speech therapy services noted in the IEP dated April 2, 2001.

On July 27, the District filed its own request for a due process hearing (Case No. SN 01-01735).

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE: Has the East Whittier City Elementary School District (District) offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, students with disabilities have the right to a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400(d), 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000, 56031. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the student’s IEP.(Footnote 3) 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student.(Footnote 4) Id. at 201.

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate program for the 2001-2002 school year, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). Under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District proposed for the 2001-2002 school year must meet the following requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comport with his IEP.(Footnote 5) If the District’s proposed program meets these requirements, then it must be concluded that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, even if STUDENT’s parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.

The Student alleged that the District failed to offer him a substantively appropriate program for the 2001-2002 school year because it offered him a K-2 placement rather than a preschool placement, and failed to offer him an adequate behavior intervention program and sufficient speech therapy services. The District, in contrast, contended that it offered STUDENT an appropriate program for the 2001-2002 school year in his IEPs dated April 2 and July 18, 2001.

I. Preschool or K-2 Placement

With regard to the proposed K-2 placement, the Student contended that he continues to require a preschool placement because he turned five years old only recently on June 23, 2001, and will not turn six until the end of the 2001-2002 school year, which would make him one of the youngest children in a K-2 class. The Student also contended that he is not ready for the increased academic and behavioral demands that will be placed on him in a K-2 classroom. He requested placement in the preschool SDC at Leffingwell taught by teacher Billy Beckman.

In contrast, the District argued that the proposed K-2 SH-SDC at Leffingwell, which is taught by special education teacher Julie Ton, is a continuation of and modeled after the SDC in which STUDENT was placed during the 2000-2001 school year and that his placement in the K-2 class simply represents a promotion to the next grade. The District asserted that STUDENT will receive an individualized program within the K-2 SDC, just as he did in the preschool SDC at Orchard Dale. The District argued that STUDENT benefitted from his placement in the preschool SH-SDC placement during the 2000-2001 school year and will continue to receive benefit in the K-2 placement.

As will be explained below, the evidence produced at hearing established that it would be appropriate for STUDENT to attend the K-2 SH-SDC at Leffingwell for the 2001-2002 school year, in accordance with the District’s proposal. The evidence demonstrated that the proposed K-2 SH-SDC is uniquely tailored to meet the needs of autistic children like STUDENT. According to the testimony of various District personnel and Autism Partnership program supervisor Doris Soluaga, a number of years ago, the District began to contract with Autism Partnership to establish classrooms designed to meet the needs of autistic children. The preschool SDC that STUDENT attended during the 2000-2001 school year represented the first of such classrooms. This “model” classroom was staffed by a District teacher and instructional aides trained by Autism Partnership to use applied behavior analysis (ABA) as the primary teaching principle and DTT as the primary teaching technique. According to Ms. Soluaga, ABA refers to the understanding of how reinforcement, antecedents, and consequences affect behavior. Ms. Soluaga explained that the ABA model seeks to change behavior by analyzing the antecedents and consequences of behavior. Ms. Soluaga also testified that discrete trial training (DTT), sometimes referred to as “discrete trial teaching,” is a teaching technique based on the principles of ABA. According to Ms. Soluaga, DTT teaches skills to autistic children by breaking a skill down into its component parts and teaching the components one at a time.

The teacher of the “model” classroom that STUDENT attended during the 2000-2001 school year, Lisa Torres, testified that she and her aides used the DTT format with STUDENT during the school year. Ms. Torres is in her eighth year of teaching with the District and holds severely handicapped and multiple subject teaching credentials. Ms. Torres testified about the progress STUDENT was able to make by the end of the 2000-2001 school year in his ability to attend to a task, participate in class activities, communicate, and transition between activities. For instance, Ms. Torres testified that when STUDENT began attending her class, he exhibited a high frequency of inappropriate behaviors such as throwing himself on the ground, yelling, scratching, crying, displaying aggression towards adults and peers, and running away from the group or from the classroom. Ms. Torres also testified that STUDENT was not able to sit in a small group of peers and was not able to transition between center times. According to Ms. Torres, by about May 2001, it was documented that STUDENT had only three tantrums a day at the most and that he never had to be removed from a group activity. Ms. Torres testified that he was able to stay with a group for up to forty minutes without an outburst or tantrum, and was able to transition between the fifteen-minute learning center activities. The Annual Specialist Report Ms. Torres prepared in or about April 2001 corroborated her testimony about STUDENT’s progress. According to the report, by April 2001, STUDENT’s self-injurious, aggressive, and tantrumming behaviors had significantly decreased. STUDENT also had met at least three of his IEP goals and made significant progress towards meeting the others.

Ms. Torres’s testimony about STUDENT’s progress in her classroom was further substantiated by Ms. Soluaga. Ms. Soluaga testified that she has a bachelor of arts degree in psychology with a minor in special education, has been employed by Autism Partnership as a behavioral consultant and program supervisor for the past five years, and has been working with autistic children for seven years. According to her testimony, she received her initial training from supervisors working on a team with Dr. Ivar Lovaas, and then later received additional training and supervision from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders before she came to work for Autism Partnership. Ms. Soluaga testified that she has been the behavioral consultant working with Ms. Torres and her “model” classroom for the past two to three years and, in that role, became familiar with STUDENT and his needs. Ms. Soluaga also supervised the program STUDENT received from Autism Partnership during the 2001 ESY. Ms. Soluaga was able to provide specific and credible testimony with regard to the gains STUDENT made by the end of the 2000-2001 school year in the areas of attention to task, participation in group or classroom activities, communication, imitation, and matching. Ms. Soluaga’s testimony also established that STUDENT’s aggressive and self-injurious behaviors and tantrums were substantially decreased by the end of the school year.

According to the testimony of District personnel and Ms. Soluaga, the K-2 SH-SDC proposed for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year is a “replication” of the “model” classroom he attended last year. Like the preschool SDC taught by Ms. Torres, the K-2 SDC at Leffingwell will be taught by a teacher and two instructional aides trained by Autism Partnership to use ABA principles and DTT in a classroom setting. Additionally, like the preschool SDC, the K-2 SDC will receive ongoing supervision and consultation from an Autism Partnership program supervisor throughout the school year. Further, like the preschool SDC, the K-2 SDC will have a low student-to-teacher ratio–according to the testimony of Julie Ton, the teacher of the K-2 SDC, there are currently eight children besides STUDENT enrolled in her class.

The testimony of Ms. Torres and Ms. Soluaga established that STUDENT received significant educational benefits from the preschool SDC last year. The fact that STUDENT received significant educational benefit from his SH-SDC placement during the 2000-2001 school year renders it likely that he will receive benefit from the proposed K-2 SDC, since the proposed SDC will use the same ABA principles and the same DTT format used in the preschool SDC. Additionally, the qualifications of the teacher of the proposed SDC further indicate that the placement is reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Ms. Ton’s testimony established that not only does she have the training necessary to work effectively with autistic children, but she also has significant experience working with autistic children. According to Ms. Ton, she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology with a minor in developmental psychology and a specialization in developmental disabilities from the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA), and has worked with autistic children since 1997. Ms. Ton testified that she worked for Applied Behavior Analysis as a senior therapist and tutor for two years, for the UCLA Family Support Program/FACT as a group facilitator and behavioral aide for four years, and for Steve Kaufman & Associates as a behavioral consultant for several months in 2001 before coming to work for the District as the K-2 SDC teacher. She testified that in her prior positions, she employed ABA principles in her behavioral therapy and used discrete trials to teach autistic children in home and school settings. Additionally, she testified that she has worked with children who had many of the same functional skill levels as STUDENT presently has and, in her work with those children, has worked on many of the goals presently contained in STUDENT’s IEP.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the K-2 SH-SDC proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year is an appropriate placement. The K-2 SH-SDC at Leffingwell is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that STUDENT should remain in a preschool class because he will be five years old the entire school year and not persuaded that he lacks readiness for the academic and behavior demands of a K-2 classroom.

First, there was no evidence presented that his age, standing alone, would have any negative impact on the ability of the K-2 classroom to meet his needs or on STUDENT’s ability to benefit from the K-2 classroom. In fact, STUDENT’s age places him within the chronological age range of students placed in the K-2 classroom. More importantly, there was no evidence presented that STUDENT’s functional levels make the K-2 classroom inappropriate for him. Ms. Ton testified that she had reviewed the IEPs of the other students enrolled in the K-2 SH-SDC for the 2001-2002 school year and believed that STUDENT’s functional levels fall within the range of functional levels possessed by those students.

Further, the Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimony of Ms. Torres and Ms. Soluaga that STUDENT could be successfully served in the K-2 SH-SDC during the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Torres taught the K-2 SH-SDC for autistic students during the 1999-2000 school year, and Ms. Soluaga served as her program supervisor during that time. Both testified that given their knowledge of STUDENT and of the K-2 SH-SDC, they believed that the K-2 SDC is an appropriate placement for him. For example, Ms. Soluaga testified that the K-2 SH-SDC is just an extension of the preschool program STUDENT attended last year. She testified that the curriculum would be adjusted based on his age but that the focus of the program would continue to be ABA. According to Ms. Soluaga, whether it is a K-2 or a preschool classroom, the program for STUDENT would have to be individualized to meet his unique needs, including his behaviors and deficits. She testified that even when STUDENT was in a preschool classroom last year, his program was highly individualized in comparison to the programs of the other students. No contrary evidence was presented to demonstrate that STUDENT’s age or functional levels render the K-2 placement inappropriate for him.

II. Behavior Intervention

The Student requested that the District be ordered to provide him with two and a half hours per day of one-to-one behavior intervention services by Autism Partnership. The Student argued that he made “great” progress when this level of services were provided by Autism Partnership during the 2001 ESY. The Student contended that the one hour per day of one-to-one behavior intervention by Autism Partnership that was proposed by the District is insufficient to meet his needs. The Student also contended that District staff are not sufficiently trained or qualified to work with him in this regard. To support his position, the Student cited a Behavior and Skill Assessment Report written on October 22, 2000, by clinical associate Dorie Glover, Ph.D., and director Ronald Leaf, Ph.D., of the Behavior Therapy & Learning Center, Autism Partnership. The report recommended that STUDENT receive a minimum of thirty to thirty-five hours per week of intervention conducted at home and at school.

In response, the District argued that its offer of one hour per day of one-to-one behavior intervention by Autism Partnership is appropriate. The District asserted that STUDENT will receive behavior intervention throughout the school day from a teacher and aides trained in ABA and DTT. The District also asserted that he requires classroom time to generalize skills he learns through direct instruction.

The evidence presented at hearing established that the District’s offer for behavior intervention for the 2001-2002 school year included placement in an SH-SDC staffed by a teacher and aides trained by Autism Partnership to apply ABA principles and to teach using the DTT technique; one hour per day of one-to-one DTT provided by Autism Partnership; one hour per month of supervision of the DTT program by an Autism Partnership program supervisor; and monthly meetings between the SDC teacher, speech therapist, and home DTT therapist to ensure coordination between the school and home programs. To aid in STUDENT’s transition to the K-2 SDC, the District also offered an additional four to six hours of supervision by an Autism Partnership program supervisor to be provided within the first two months of school (specifically, by October 30, 2001) and the assignment of a one-on-one aide during the first thirty days of school. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Soluaga’s testimony particularly informative and credible in evaluating the appropriateness of the District’s offer of behavior intervention services for STUDENT. As noted earlier, Ms. Soluaga’s expertise as a behavior intervention program supervisor for autistic children and her familiarity with STUDENT’s current needs were established at hearing. Ms. Soluaga’s expertise and familiarity with STUDENT were not disputed by either party. Ms. Soluaga testified that STUDENT presently requires exposure to and participation in group activities in a classroom setting, as well as the intensity of one-to-one instruction. She stated that while STUDENT would benefit from the intensity of instruction that he received during the summer (i.e., two and a half hours per day of one-to-one instruction), one-to-one instruction should not be provided at the expense of his school program. According to Ms. Soluaga, one of STUDENT’s primary deficits lies in the generalization of skills. She explained that if STUDENT’s school day consisted only of one-to-one instruction, meaning that skills were being taught only in isolation, he might not be able to generalize those skills to other settings. She testified that he requires some group experience during his school day in order to generalize skills taught in isolation to group settings and also to learn those skills that can be learned within a group setting. Ms. Soluaga reviewed the District’s proposal that STUDENT receive one hour per day of one-to-one DTT from Autism Partnership within the classroom setting and testified that such intensive instruction would be sufficient. Additionally, it is noted that the student-to-adult ratio will be at the most three-to-one given that only nine children are enrolled in the SH-SDC and that those nine children will be served daily by a teacher and two instructional aides.

The Hearing Officer did not find persuasive the Student’s argument that District staff are insufficiently qualified to provide behavior intervention services to him. As noted earlier, Ms. Ton is a trained and experienced behavior therapist who has worked with autistic children since at least 1997 to provide the same one-to-one behavior intervention service that the Student presently seeks from Autism Partnership. Additionally, the testimony of District personnel established that the instructional aides assigned to Ms. Ton’s classroom will be trained by Autism Partnership to provide behavior intervention and will receive ongoing supervision and consultation throughout the year from Ms. Ton and Autism Partnership. The fact that STUDENT was able to progress in his placement last year, where the teachers and aides used DTT as a result of training and supervision received from Autism Partnership, further supports the conclusion that it is reasonably likely that he also will benefit from placement in the K-2 SH-SDC.

The Hearing Officer also did not find persuasive the Student’s argument that the Behavior and Skill Assessment Report (Report) establishes the need for two and a half hours of behavior intervention during the school day. In fact, the Report does not establish at all what services STUDENT requires for the 2001-2002 school year. The Report and the recommendations contained therein were based on an evaluation performed a year ago. As discussed above, STUDENT has made progress in the year following the issuance of the Report, and thus the findings and recommendations contained in the Report are not necessarily relevant to determining STUDENT’s needs at the present. The Report itself expressly states that STUDENT’s progress should be reviewed at the end of the 2000-2001 academic year “to determine to what extent intensive intervention hours can be reduced.”

Morever, even if the recommendations in the Report continue to hold true, the Report provides only general recommendations and does not state that STUDENT requires two and a half hours of one-to-one behavior intervention per day in the school setting. What the Report does state is that STUDENT should receive thirty to thirty-five hours per week of intervention and that these hours should be divided between a home and school program.(Footnote 6) Additionally, the Report does not specify how many of the hours provided to STUDENT in the school setting should be on a one-on-one basis. In fact, the Report states that “many of the fundamental aspects of early intervention, including 1-1 DTT, are more conveniently taught at home when behavior problems (e.g., noncompliance and tantrums) are highly likely. This is the case for STUDENT.” The Report also states that school attendance will allow STUDENT to generalize the skills he learns in the intensive one-to-one DTT to the “more naturalistic classroom setting.” The Report corroborates Ms. Soluaga’s testimony that STUDENT has “tremendous” problems with generalization and that group instruction in a classroom environment is required to address his difficulties with generalization. The Report also corroborates Ms. Soluaga’s testimony that there are some skills that STUDENT may acquire or practice only in a group setting. For example, the Report notes that a classroom environment will teach STUDENT to use good attentional focus in a less than ideal teaching environment, and that his self-management and self-initiated communication will develop because the presence of other children diffuses the availability of adult attention. Finally, the Report states that an observation had been made of the preschool SH-SDC that STUDENT attended last year and that it was found by the assessor to be appropriate for him. As mentioned previously, the K-2 SH-SDC proposed for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year is modeled on the preschool SH-SDC that STUDENT attended last year. With the addition of an hour per day of one-to-one intensive behavior intervention by Autism Partnership, there appears no reason why STUDENT should not benefit from the proposed K-2 SDC.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in the K-2 SH-SDC, where the discrete trial format is used, and one hour per day of one-to-one intervention by Autism Partnership is appropriate.

III. Year-Round Speech Therapy

With regard to speech services, there was no dispute that the District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year consisted of six fifteen-minute sessions per week with the speech therapist (for a total of one and a half hours) and the inclusion of a daily learning center focusing on oral-motor exercises.(Footnote 7) The District proposed to provide these services through a District speech-language specialist during the regular school year.

The Student requested that the District be ordered to provide him with three hours per week of speech therapy by an NPA during fifty weeks out of the calendar year. The Student argued that because he continues to be nonverbal at the age of five, he requires intensive and consistent speech therapy by a provider who can serve him fifty weeks out of the year, regardless of the District’s scheduled holiday breaks. In support of her position, the Student presented a Psychological Evaluation Report dated September 28, 2000, signed by B.J. Freeman, Ph.D. and Donna Crandall, M.A. from the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital, Autism Evaluation Clinic. The Student also presented a Speech and Language Consultation Report dated May 15, 2001,(Footnote 8) by speech-language pathologist Peggy Bailey, M.A.-CCC.(Footnote 9)

The District contended that its offer is appropriate because STUDENT currently lacks the foundational skills necessary to allow him to benefit from increased speech therapy, such as the ability to maintain attention to a task and the ability to control the body functions necessary to physically produce speech. The District also asserted that the speech therapy recommendations made by Dr. Freeman and Ms. Bailey in their reports were unreliable. The District argued that neither of the evaluations conducted by Dr. Freeman and Ms. Bailey is reliable because neither was based on any school-related data, such as observations in the school setting, interviews with school personnel, or a review of school records. The District also argued that Dr. Freeman is not a speech-language specialist and therefore is not qualified to make specific recommendations regarding the frequency and duration of speech services.

Initially, it must be noted that the District’s offer to provide six fifteen-minute sessions with the speech therapist per week, as well as a fifteen-minute learning center devoted to oral-motor exercises every day, amounts to a total of two hours and forty-five minutes devoted to speech issues per week–only fifteen minutes less than the Student’s request for three hours per week. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the fifteen-minute difference between the District’s offer and the parent’s request rendered the District’s offer inappropriate. In fact, the evidence was to the contrary.

In determining the appropriateness of the District’s offer for speech services, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony provided by WACSEP program specialist Darlene Hanson credible and persuasive. Ms. Hanson has been the program specialist assigned to STUDENT’s case for the past year and a half, and in that role has attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings and has consulted with his classroom teacher and related service providers on his behalf. Although Ms. Hanson is currently employed as a program specialist, her education was in speech-language. She received a bachelor’s degree in communicative disorders and a master of arts degree in speech and language, is a licensed speech and language specialist, is credentialed to work in the public school system as a speech and language specialist, and holds a certificate of clinical competence.

Ms. Hanson testified that speech and language consists of two distinct areas, actual speech and communication. She explained that speech refers to the act of speaking, which involves oral motor skills, and that communication involves language development or the use of speech. According to Ms. Hanson, speech is worked on by focusing on how the student is learning to actually produce speech – through exercises and imitation of oral motor skills. Ms. Hanson testified that speech is often worked on through the use of learning centers, especially at the preschool level. Ms. Hanson stated that the communication part is discretely worked on through trials and, once it is learned, is worked into the curriculum as the student’s mode of communication.

With regard to STUDENT, Ms. Hanson testified that the IEP team determined that discrete fifteen-minute sessions would be appropriate for STUDENT because of his difficulty sustaining attention to speech or oral-motor tasks and because of his need for frequent breaks. Ms. Hanson also testified that the overall frequency and duration of the speech services offered is appropriate because STUDENT is not yet ready to benefit from additional services. According to Ms. Hanson, STUDENT still requires a number of foundational skills that must be worked on by other disciplines before he can benefit from increased speech services. Ms. Hanson testified that STUDENT needs to first develop good tone and good motor control and develop his proprioceptive system before he can receive any benefit from additional speech services. She explained that until STUDENT has developed the ability to control the parts of his body that are required to produce speech, additional speech services will be meaningless. She noted that the communication aspect is more important for STUDENT at this stage in light of his behaviors, and that communication can and should be addressed within the scope of STUDENT’s school day by the teacher, the behavior intervention person, and the speech therapist. Ms. Hanson testified that STUDENT simply does not need to spend three hours per week on specific speech-oriented instruction that, at this stage, would consist of work on his oral motor skills. Ms. Hanson’s testimony is in this regard was corroborated by the reports of speech-language specialist Eve Mancillas, who worked with STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year.

According to a Speech and Language Assessment Report prepared by Ms. Mancillas in March 2001, STUDENT is a nonverbal student who functions below the typical one-year-old in terms of receptive language, expressive language, and speech development. Ms. Mancillas stated the following about STUDENT’s speech abilities:

STUDENT’s spontaneous speech production consists of crying, screaming and occasional laughing. He appears to have severe problems with the volitional control of his speech mechanism as he does not spontaneously produce vocal play (vocalizations) nor babbling sounds with regularity - skills demonstrated by infants and babies from 2 months (vocalizations) to 6 months of age (babbling: consonants /b/ and /m/ combined with vowel sounds, e.g., bababa). ... The ability to sustain one’s breath stream is an underlying motor speech skill necessary to support speech production. ... He is beginning to blow briefly into the therapist’s hand help up to him (this behavior had been modeled for him), and this indicates that he might be beginning to gain some control over his air stream. The therapist has also imitated STUDENT’s coughing sounds and laughing sound, STUDENT reproduced the sounds again, another indicator that he might be gaining some control over the speech mechanism. [¶] STUDENT does not imitate vowel sounds, indicating that he does not have control over his vocal cords (sound source), jaw (for opening mouth) and tongue (for shaping the sound in the mouth).

In progress notes dated May 15, 2001, Ms. Mancillas reported that STUDENT had made gains in being able to control his jaw and continued gains in control of his breath support, and had increased the amount of vocalizations. She noted that he still could not imitate vocally on command. Ms. Mancillas’ reports show the profound delays STUDENT still experiences with regard to the mechanisms that control the production of speech.

The Student did not present any persuasive evidence to refute Ms. Hanson’s testimony. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the reports cited by the Student. First, Dr. Freeman’s report recommended that STUDENT receive only two and a half hours of speech services per week, not the three the Student requested. Additionally, Dr. Freeman did not perform any formal speech testing or gather information from the school before making her recommendations, such as through interviews with the classroom teacher or speech-language specialist, a review of school records, or an observation of STUDENT in the school setting. Finally, whatever data Dr. Freeman was able to draw on for her recommendations were data obtained a year ago. As discussed earlier, STUDENT has made progress in that year and, therefore, Dr. Freeman’s recommendations do not necessarily carry the same weight when evaluating STUDENT’s needs for the 2001-2002 school year.

A number of the same concerns also apply to Ms. Bailey’s evaluation. Specifically, Ms. Bailey did not perform any formal speech testing or gather information from the school before making her recommendations. Additionally, Ms. Bailey noted in her report that because STUDENT had had a cold and had not slept well, he was unusually fussy the day of the consultation and the parent felt that STUDENT was responding even less than usual during the consultation. Ms. Bailey also noted that STUDENT was “highly uncooperative” throughout the hour-long consultation and started to pinch and bite towards the end of the consultation.

As for the issue of whether the speech services should be provided during fifty weeks out of the calendar year, it is noted that the District provided neither evidence nor argument to refute the Student’s claim that he required speech services to be provided for fifty weeks. The school district has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered appropriate services for the child with disabilities. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). MOTHER testified that she believed that STUDENT required continued speech services during the District’s regularly scheduled extended breaks and holidays because of the severity of his deficits and his tendency to regress without continued instruction. Specifically, MOTHER testified that STUDENT regresses significantly and has a very difficult time readjusting to a routine after an extended break. According to MOTHER, because STUDENT had not received any speech services from the District since July 27, 2001, he was no longer able to blow breath without something in his mouth by August 28, 2001. She testified that this was a skill that he had only recently been able to demonstrate because of speech therapy. Given the District’s complete lack of evidence in this regard, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires speech services to be provided during fifty weeks out of the year, regardless of the District’s regularly scheduled breaks and holidays.

However, there is no indication that the District is required to hire an NPA to provide the speech services, unless an NPA is required in order to provide STUDENT with speech services during the District’s regularly scheduled breaks and holidays. The evidence did not demonstrate that an NPA would be any more qualified to provide services to STUDENT than a qualified District speech-language specialist. The Student did not dispute the qualifications of the District speech-language specialist assigned to provide services to STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in its IEPs dated April 2 and July 18, 2001, except to the extent that it failed to offer to provide STUDENT with speech services during fifty weeks out of the calendar year.

ORDER

1. The District shall add to STUDENT’s program a provision that it will provide STUDENT with the six fifteen-minute speech sessions per week during fifty weeks of the calendar year, regardless of the District’s regularly scheduled breaks and holidays. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to revise STUDENT’s IEP to reflect the mandate of this order.

2. All of the Student’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided, except with regard to the provision of speech services during fifty weeks of the year.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: October 1, 2001 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Ms. Soluaga testified that she has recently been promoted from her position as a program supervisor but had not yet been assigned a new title. 2. Because of the commonality of the issues noticed by the parties for hearing, the issues were consolidated into the single issue set forth above. This change was made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. 3. “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

4. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. In this case, the Student did not allege that the District committed any procedural violations. Therefore, only the substantive aspects of a FAPE will be discussed.

5. The District was also required to offer STUDENT a program which educated him in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature or severity of his disabilities was such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. However, because neither party put the issue of LRE in dispute, this Decision will not address any LRE issues

6. In fact, the Report states that it would be ideal if twenty-five hours were provided through a home program. According to the evidence, STUDENT has been receiving a twenty-hour-per-week home program provided by the local regional center since March 2001.

7. According to Ms. Torres’s testimony, learning center activities typically last fifteen minutes.

8. Although dated May 15, 2001, the consultation actually occurred on December 18, 2000.

9. “CCC” refers to certificate of clinical competence.