California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 14, 1999

Student v. San Mateo-Foster City School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1648-98 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

San Mateo-Foster City School District offered FAPE; parents denied reimbursement for conductive education program and transportation mileage.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old boy filed against San Mateo-Foster City School District. He qualified for special education because of a severe orthopedic impairment and a visual impairment caused by cerebral palsy. The parents sought mileage for driving him to his county-run preschool and therapies. They also sought reimbursement for the Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program, a private program they chose in 1997. The Hearing Officer barred claims arising on or before November 20, 1995, three years before the hearing request. The time limit started when the parents knew the facts, not when an advocate later told them about reimbursement. As the district of residence, the District answered for services delivered by the San Mateo County Office of Education. On mileage, the District had offered bus service, which the parents declined. Evidence did not show he needed a bus aide or a parent driver. For 1997-98 and 1998-99, the District offered a county special day class for orthopedically impaired children, plus vision, speech, occupational and physical therapy. The Hearing Officer found the class met his needs and could provide some educational benefit, since he had made slow but real progress in the same program. The parents' own consultant called it appropriate. The 1998 offer of a "range of placements" lacked detail, but the parents knew which class was meant and were not harmed. All claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled four issues under Rowley. The limitations period started when parents knew the facts, not when they learned of a legal right. A declined bus offer defeated mileage reimbursement. A vague written offer caused no harm when parents knew the class. A preference for a "best practice" private program did not establish a denial of FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue Preliminary. Whether Petitioner could add claims for mileage reimbursement for the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years despite the three-year statute of limitations under Alexopulos

    Claims arising on or before November 20, 1995 were barred because the parents knew the underlying facts at the time; the limitations period does not wait until parents learn they have a legal claim. Later claims were added, and the County Office of Education was not an indispensable party because the District, as district of residence, remained responsible.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year, including extended school year, to transport the student to his educational placement and related services?

    The District's offer of bus transportation, which the parents declined, was appropriate. The evidence did not show the student needed an aide on the bus or needed a parent or nanny to transport him because of medical needs or separation anxiety.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred during the 1996-97 school year to transport the student to his related services (speech, vision, occupational and physical therapy)?

    Testimony about the IEP chair's standard practice and the crossed-out 'transpo' on the IEP showed transportation was offered and refused. Not putting the refused offer in writing did not prejudice the parents.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Did the District offer the student a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year?

    The County Office of Education special day class for orthopedically handicapped students, with related services, met the student's unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, would have followed the IEP, and was the LRE. Disputes over augmentative communication and the use of music concerned methodology.

  5. Issue 4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year?

    Because the District offered FAPE for 1997-98, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5a. Did the District offer FAPE for 1998-99: whether the District failed to make an appropriate formal written offer because the July 15, 1998 IEP offered a 'range of placements' without the location of the program

    A 'range of placements' offer generally lacks enough detail, but the parents understood the offer was the same orthopedically handicapped special day class. The lack of detail did not prejudice them or seriously infringe on their participation, so the Hearing Officer found reasonable written notice.

  7. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5b. Did the District offer FAPE for 1998-99: whether the proposed kindergarten special day class for orthopedically handicapped students was appropriate

    The kindergarten special day class on a regular elementary campus met the student's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and was the LRE. Classmates' differing physical and cognitive levels, lost time from the bus stop distance, and uncertainty about the class's future location did not make it inappropriate.

  8. Issue 6. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1998-99 school year?

    Because the District offered FAPE for 1998-99, reimbursement for the unilateral placement is denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's claims for relief are denied in their entirety.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16

People named in the decision

  • Linda Waddell, Ph.D., director of student services, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Alice Parker, Ph.D., former director of student services, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Barbara Hudson, inclusion specialist, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Carol Harriman, program specialist for special education, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Beth Rice, Early Childhood Education preschool special day class teacher (orthopedically handicapped), San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Carol Barraco, education service manager; IEP meeting chairperson, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Linda Pucillo, Early Childhood Education pre-kindergarten/kindergarten special day class teacher (orthopedically handicapped), San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Leah Movillion, Early Childhood Education kindergarten special day class teacher (orthopedically handicapped), San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Michael Moody, teacher of the visually impaired, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Karen Grites, director of school age and adolescent services; educational consultant, expert witness for Student, Children's Health Council
  • Beth Strasser, occupational therapist, Mills Peninsula Health Services
  • Marcella Murray, speech and language pathologist, Associated Learning and Language Specialists
  • Julie Lucchesi, founder and administrator of private conductive education program, Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program
  • Kinga Czegeni, director and conductor, Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program
  • Renata Toth, conductor who attended IEP meeting, Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program
  • James Belotti, former consultant, Special Education Division (nonpublic school monitoring); District witness, California Department of Education
  • Jeffie Gellerman, non-attorney advocate for Student, Families Advocating for Individual Rights (FAIR)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in San Mateo, California, on January 5 and 6, and February 9, 10, 23 and 24, 1999.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma from the law firm of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy, and advocate Jeffie Gellerman from Families Advocating for Individual Rights (FAIR). Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his father, FATHER, and his mother, MOTHER. Respondent San Mateo-Foster City School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Diane Finkelstein from the law firm of Shupe & Finkelstein. Also present on the District's behalf was Linda Waddell, Ph.D., the District’s director of student services.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Beth Rice, STUDENT’s teacher in the San Mateo County Office of Education’s (COE) Early Childhood Education Program (ECE); Barbara Hudson, the District’s inclusion specialist; Carol Barraco, an education service manager for the COE; Alice Parker, Ph.D., the District’s former director of student services; Linda Waddell, the District's current director of student services; Karen Grites, the director of school age and adolescent services at the Children's Health Council (CHC); MOTHER, STUDENT's mother; Beth Strasser, the occupational therapist currently serving STUDENT through Mills Peninsula Health Services (Mills Peninsula); Julie Lucchesi, the founder and administrator of the Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program (the Step-By-Step program) (footnote 1)that STUDENT currently attends; and Kinga Czegeni, the director and conductor at the Step-By-Step program.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Carol Harriman, the District's program specialist for special education students; James Belotti, a former consultant for the Special Education Division of the California Department of Education (CDE) who monitored, approved and reviewed nonpublic schools and agencies; Marcella Murray, a speech and language pathologist currently serving STUDENT through Associated Learning and Language Specialists; Michael Moody, a teacher of the visually impaired currently serving STUDENT on behalf of the COE; Linda Pucillo, the teacher for the ECE preschool class for orthopedically handicapped students; Leah Movillion, the teacher for the ECE kindergarten class for orthopedically handicapped students; and Linda Waddell, the District’s director of student services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES (footnote 2)

1. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year, including the extended school year, to transport STUDENT to his educational placement and related services?

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred during the 1996-97 school year to transport STUDENT to his related services (speech, vision, occupational and physical therapy)?

3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year?

4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for his private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year?

5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year?

6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for his private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1998-99 school year?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On January 5, 1999, the first day of hearing, and in a written brief subsequently received by the Hearing Office on January 12, Petitioner moved to add the following two issues for hearing: (1) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred, during the 1994-1995 school year, including extended school year, from February 18, 1995 to the end of the school year, for transporting STUDENT to his educational and related services placement? and (2) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred, during the 1995-1996 school year, including extended school year, for transporting STUDENT to his educational and related services placement? Petitioner argued that these issues were appropriate for hearing despite the three-year statute of limitations established by Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F.2d 551 (9th Cir. 1987), because STUDENT's parents did not know about a potential right to reimbursement for privately provided transportation until January 1998, when they hired an advocate. Petitioner submitted a declaration from MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, in which she declared that she had attended all of STUDENT's IEP team meetings and had received notice of her due process hearing rights, but had not been informed that she had a right to reimbursement for privately provided transportation services.

In a brief received by the Hearing Office on January 21, 1999, the District opposed Petitioner's motion to amend. The District argued that reimbursement for transportation expenses during the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years was not an appropriate issue for this proceeding because STUDENT received educational services from San Mateo County Office of Education (COE) during those years, not the District, and that COE should be added as a party if reimbursement for that time period is added as an issue for hearing.

On February 9, 1999, the third day of hearing, the Hearing Officer granted Petitioner’s motion to add issues related to claims arising after November 20, 1995, and denied the motion as to issues related to claims arising on or before November 20, 1995. The Hearing Officer indicated that a further explanation of the ruling would be included in the decision. The following is the further explanation of that ruling.

There is no dispute that a three-year statute of limitations governs the filing of claims brought under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in California pursuant to Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987). The Alexopulos court also held that under federal law a cause of action accrues, and the statute of limitations begins to run, when a plaintiff knows or has reason to know of the facts underlying it. Id. at 555.

The Hearing Officer found that Petitioner's parents had contemporaneous knowledge of the alleged events and omissions that are the basis of the proposed reimbursement issues. First, MOTHER's declaration establishes that she attended all of Petitioner's IEP meetings and was informed of her due process rights. Second, the parents knew that neither the District nor COE was providing transportation to STUDENT during the 1994-95 and the 1995-96 school years. Third, there is no question that the parents knew that they themselves were providing STUDENT with transportation during those years. In light of these facts and since Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing on November 20, 1998, the Hearing Officer found that the statute of limitations barred Petitioner from raising in this proceeding any claims that accrued on or before November 20, 1995.

The Hearing Officer did not find persuasive Petitioner’s argument that the statute of limitations did not begin to run until January 1998, when the parents were informed by their advocate that they had a potential right to reimbursement for transportation expenses. This argument is premised on the faulty proposition that the statute of limitations begins to run only when the claimant realizes that a legal harm has been suffered. The Ninth Circuit has clearly articulated the test of when a statute of limitations begins to run, which does not rely on the question of when the claimant knew he had a claim: “Under federal law a cause of action accrues, and the statute of limitations begins to run, when a plaintiff knows or has reason to know of the injury that is the basis of the action.” Alexopulos, 817 F.2d at 555 (emphasis added). In other words, the statute begins to run when the claimant knows or has reason to know of the facts underlying the claim, not when he discovers that he is entitled to bring a legal claim. Further, these is no dispute that the parents were informed of their right to due process procedures. The Hearing Officer knows of no authority, and Petitioner failed to cite any, which specifically required that notice be given to parents of their right to reimbursement for transportation expenses.

Finally, the Hearing Officer was not convinced by the District's argument that a claim for reimbursement for any expenses incurred after November 20, 1995, could not properly be heard because STUDENT was enrolled in a program operated by the COE during the 1995-96 school year and the COE is not a party to this action. The Hearing Officer notes that the local educational agency ultimately responsible for the provision of special education services to an identified special needs child is generally the school district in which the child's parents reside. Education Code § 48200. In this case, there is no dispute that the District is the Petitioner's district of residence. A county office of education's authority to service a child arises solely out of the delegation of that authority by the child's school district of residence through a local plan agreement or other contract, but does not relieve the district of residence of the responsibility to serve that child. 5 C.C.R. § 3000(c) (“Nothing in this chapter relieves any other agency from an otherwise valid obligation to provide or pay for services for individuals with exceptional needs. Clarification and specificity of responsibilities shall be included in but not limited to interagency agreements.”). Furthermore, the District failed to show that the COE is an indispensable party to this action, i.e., that the District would suffer irrevocable prejudice should the hearing proceed without the COE as a party to the action. (Footnote 3) In contrast, the Hearing Officer notes that the District has remedies available through interagency dispute resolution procedures to resolve disputes of agency responsibility such as the above. See, e.g., Education Code § 56205(d).

In summary, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner’s IDEA claims were subject to a three-year statute of limitations, and that Petitioner was fully aware or should have been fully aware of the underlying facts giving rise to his legal claim at or around the time the injuries occurred. As Petitioner did not request a hearing until November 20, 1998, any claims that accrued on or before November 20, 1995, were barred by the statute of limitations. Based on the foregoing, Petitioner's motion to amend issues was granted with respect to the additional issues insofar as they related to claims arising after November 20, 1995. The motion was denied with respect to the issues insofar as they related to claims arising on or before November 20, 1995. Thus, only the following issue was added: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year, including extended school year, to transport STUDENT to his educational and related services placement?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old student who qualifies for special education due to a severe orthopedic handicap and visual impairment. STUDENT was born on [date redacted], and has been diagnosed with spastic-athetoid quadriplegia due to cerebral palsy, hydrocephalus, seizure disorder, and cortical visual impairment. He has severe motor deficits and spasticity in all four limbs, and is nonambulatory.

In October 1992, at the age of eight months, STUDENT began receiving infant and toddler services under Part C of the IDEA from the COE through its Early Childhood Education Program (ECE). Until March 1994, these services were provided through a home-based program because of STUDENT’s fragile medical condition. The home-based program included two thirty-minute home visits per week by the teacher of the infant program. About this time, STUDENT also began to receive clinic-based occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) from California Children’s Services (CCS), each for one hour per week. A year later, speech and language therapy was added to STUDENT’s program for thirty minutes per week in order to work on augmentative communication skills and articulation.

In March 1994, shortly after STUDENT turned two years old, he was transitioned to the ECE center-based infant program located on Tower Road in San Mateo. He attended the infant program two times per week for three hours each time. About this time, services from a teacher for the visually impaired (VI) were added to STUDENT’s program for thirty minutes each week to improve his ocular motor control.

On January 5, 1995, a month before STUDENT’s third birthday, the individualized education program (IEP) team met to review his placement. The team agreed that STUDENT would slowly transition to the ECE preschool classroom for orthopedically handicapped (OH) students when he turned three years old, attending two days per week and then gradually increasing attendance to full time (i.e., five days per week). The team also agreed that STUDENT required the following related services: speech and language therapy thirty minutes per week; VI services sixty minutes per week; and OT and PT provided by CCS in accordance with a physician’s prescription, which was one hour each per week. Beth Rice taught the preschool OH class, which was located on the same Tower Road site where STUDENT had attended the infant program. STUDENT remained in the ECE preschool OH class with Ms. Rice as his teacher through the end of the 1996-97 school year.

On May 28, 1997, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s program. The District recommended that for the 1997-98 school year STUDENT be placed in a special day classroom in a county-operated program with VI services ninety minutes per week, speech and language therapy sixty minutes per week in a collaborative/consultative model, and transportation to and from school. Both of STUDENT’s parents signed in agreement with the recommended program, but indicated that they were going to enroll STUDENT in a conductive education program during the summer of 1997 to test its effectiveness for him. CCS informed the parents that, per CCS policy, it would suspend the provision of OT and PT during the summer while STUDENT attended the conductive education program. In response, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with OT and PT, each for one and a half hours every week, in addition to VI and speech services, through September 1997 in order to ensure continuation of services. The IEP team agreed to meet again in September 1997 to review the IEP.

On June 3, 1997, STUDENT began attending the Step-By-Step program. By letter dated September 8, 1997, the parents informed the District that at the upcoming IEP meeting they intended to ask the District to place STUDENT at the Step-By-Step program.

The IEP team met on September 22, 1997, to review STUDENT’s program for the 1997-98 school year. At the request of the parents, Renata Toth, one of the conductors at the Step-By-Step program, attended the IEP to discuss the Step-By-Step program and STUDENT’s progress. At the conclusion of the meeting, the District informed the parents that they could only offer placement in the ECE special day class, but would continue to provide related services should the parents wish to unilaterally place STUDENT in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year. The parents disagreed with the District’s proposed placement in the ECE program and unilaterally placed themselves in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year. During this time, the District continued to provide the related services described above.

On July 15, 1998, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s progress and to discuss his program for the 1998-99 school year. The District and the parents again disagreed on the appropriate placement for STUDENT. The parents insisted that the Step-By-Step program was the appropriate placement and formally requested retroactive reimbursement and current funding for the program. Linda Waddell, the District’s director of student services, wrote the following on the IEP document with regard to the District’s offer of placement:

The District continues to offer a range of placements in the San Mateo County Office of Education, ECE program, special day class programs to make progress and meet his goals and objectives. The District continues to offer related services (OT/PT, speech language, and itinerant visual services) subject to the legal limitations contained in the reauthorization of IDEA as it relates to services in private schools and unilaterally placed students.

The District agreed to provide the following related services to STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year despite the parents’ unilateral placement: VI services two times per week for thirty minutes each session; forty sessions of OT and PT in sixty-minute sessions, as that was the amount remaining on the District’s contract with Mills Peninsula; and speech and language services two times per week for thirty minutes each session. The parents indicated agreement only with the District’s proposed goals and objectives and the provision of related services.

During the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT has continued to attend the Step-By-Step program at the parents’ expense with the above related services provided by the District.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Education Code § 56363(b). Finally, medical services may also be a necessary related service, but only to the extent that such services are for diagnostic and evaluation purposes. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

1. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year, including the extended school year, to transport STUDENT to his educational placement and related services?

Transportation is a related service that must be provided if necessary for a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). The Code of Federal Regulations defines “transportation” as including travel to and from school and, if required to provide special transportation for a child with a disability, specialized equipment (such as special or adapted buses, lifts, and ramps). 34 C.F.R. § 300.16(b)(14). (footnote 4) Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they procured for their child if the school district failed to provide appropriate services, and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. See School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 370, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985).

Petitioner contended that the parents should be reimbursed for the expenses they incurred to transport STUDENT to his educational placement and related services from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year, including the extended school year, because the District failed to offer STUDENT appropriate transportation services for that period and failed to offer reimbursement for privately provided transportation. Petitioner argued that STUDENT’s medical condition and physical needs made it inappropriate for STUDENT to ride a bus where only one adult, the driver, was present and that STUDENT had extreme separation anxiety which made it necessary for his mother or nanny to accompany him to school. The District opposed the request for reimbursement and contended that the District offered appropriate transportation services to the parents but that they declined the offer. The District also argued that there is no legal requirement that it offer parents reimbursement for privately provided transportation when it offered District transportation.

There is no dispute that for the 1995-96 school year the District offered to transport STUDENT by bus to and from school, which the parents refused, but did not offer to provide aide assistance during transportation or to reimburse the parents for providing transportation. STUDENT’s IEP dated January 5, 1995, stated, “Transportation provided but the parents wish to transport.” This notation is supported by MOTHER’s testimony that she recalled being asked by the IEP team at the meeting held on January 5, 1995, whether she wanted STUDENT to be transported to school by bus or whether the parents would transport him themselves. MOTHER testified that she told the IEP team that the parents would transport STUDENT to school. There is also no dispute that, during the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT received the related services listed on his IEP at the same site where his OH class was located, i.e., the Tower Road ECE site. Finally, there is no dispute that the parents did in fact transport STUDENT to the Tower Road ECE site during the 1995-96 school year. (Footnote 5) The dispute between the parties is whether the District offered transportation as required for STUDENT to be safely transported to school.

According to MOTHER’s testimony, the transportation services offered by the District were not appropriate because, due to STUDENT’s medical condition and needs, it would have been a safety risk for him to travel in a bus in which only one adult, the driver, was present and she feared he would suffer from separation anxiety on the bus, as he did in the classroom. First, MOTHER testified that STUDENT required a substantial amount of adult assistance to transfer and that the driver might not have been able to manage STUDENT by himself. Second, MOTHER, as well as STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Rice, testified that STUDENT exhibited extreme anxiety whenever he was separated from his mother or nanny. While the level of anxiety gradually lessened over the course of his placement in Ms. Rice’s class, it often resulted in either his mother or nanny staying in the classroom or in an adjoining room so that they could alleviate STUDENT’s separation anxiety when necessary and feed him, when appropriate. Ms. Rice testified that while participation in the classroom by the mother or nanny was encouraged by the ECE staff, just as parent participation was encouraged in relation to all preschool students, it was not dictated by the ECE staff. Ms. Rice also testified that, although ECE staff could not tell parents not to remain in the classroom with their children, she tried to dissuade the mother and nanny from staying in the classroom too much, because she believed that the frequent presence of STUDENT’s mother and/or nanny contributed to the prolonged problem STUDENT had with separation anxiety. To deal with STUDENT’s anxiety, the parents and Ms. Rice eventually agreed that either MOTHER or the nanny would drop STUDENT off at school where the buses delivered the other children, and Ms. Rice or one of her aides would bring STUDENT into the classroom.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made an appropriate offer of transportation services for the following reasons. First, it was not established that it was necessary for an aide to accompany the bus driver on the trips either because of STUDENT’s medical condition or his needs. There was no persuasive evidence of any needs that STUDENT might reasonably have had during the course of transportation that could not have been handled by a single adult. For instance, the evidence established that STUDENT required a lot of adult assistance to transfer, but this did not render it unreasonable for a single adult to be present during transportation of STUDENT to school. An adult from STUDENT’s home, such as his mother or nanny, could have helped transfer him into or out of the bus at his house, while an adult from the ECE program, such as Ms. Rice or her aide, could have helped transfer STUDENT into or out of the bus at the school site. Additionally, while there was evidence that STUDENT experienced some seizures during the early part of his life, there was undisputed testimony that STUDENT was on medications to control the seizures during the 1995-96 school year. Furthermore, there was no definite indication that he had any seizures or other problems requiring emergency medical attention while attending the ECE program, except for a single incident in which STUDENT aspirated food while being fed by the VI teacher. Second, regardless of the intensity of the separation anxiety STUDENT experienced during the 1995-96 school year, there is no indication that was a safety risk for him to be transported to and from school by someone other than his mother or nanny, or that it was necessary for his mother or nanny to transport him in order for him to be able to benefit from his education. Moreover, Petitioner failed to establish that the appropriate way to address STUDENT’s separation anxiety was for the mother or nanny to transport STUDENT. In fact, MOTHER acknowledged that her frequent presence in the classroom may have added to STUDENT’s problems with separation.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made an appropriate offer of transportation services for the 1995-96 school year. Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for expenses incurred from November 21, 1995, to the end of the 1995-96 school year to transport STUDENT to his educational placement and related services is denied. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for mileage incurred during the 1996-97 school year to transport STUDENT to his related services (speech, vision, occupational and physical therapy)?

Petitioner contended that the parents should be reimbursed for the expenses they incurred to transport STUDENT to his related services during the 1996-97 school year, because the District failed to offer STUDENT appropriate transportation services for that period and failed to offer reimbursement for privately provided transportation. (Footnote 6) There is no dispute that during the 1996-97 school year STUDENT received the related services listed on his IEP dated April 8, 1996, at the Tower Road site where he attended the ECE preschool program. The grounds upon which Petitioner claims reimbursement for transportation expenses for the 1996-97 school year are the same as those stated for the reimbursement claim with regard to the 1995-96 school year, except for one allegation that is unique to the 1996-97 school year. Petitioner claimed that there was no evidence that the District offered any transportation services for the 1996-97 school year. To support his position, Petitioner pointed to MOTHER’s testimony that she did not think that transportation was discussed at the IEP meeting held on April 8, 1996 (at which time the team was discussing STUDENT’s placement for the 1996-97 school year), and the fact that there was no mention of transportation services, either offered or refused, on the IEP prepared during the meeting held on April 8, 1996, except for the word “transpo” scratched out under the category of needed related services.

In contrast, the District argued that the apparent scratching out of the word transportation from the IEP document shows that transportation was discussed and refused by the parents. To support its position, the District offered the testimony of Carol Barraco. Ms. Barraco, an education service manager for the COE since 1983, was the chairperson at the IEP meeting held on April 4, 1996, and filled out the IEP document. Ms. Barraco testified that transportation services are discussed at every IEP meeting that she attends since it is an option that is provided to all students. She also testified that it is her practice not to list transportation on the IEP if the parents reject the offer of transportation, even to note that it was offered by the COE and rejected by the parents. Upon reviewing the IEP document dated April 8, 1996, that contained her handwriting describing the proposed placement and related services for STUDENT, Ms. Barraco testified that although she did not specifically recall a discussion about transportation at that meeting, she assumes, based on her practice, that the team offered transportation services to the parents and the parents refused it.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made an appropriate offer of transportation services for the 1996-97 school year. First, there is substantial evidence that the District did offer to transport STUDENT to and from school. Ms. Barraco, who has been attending IEP meetings as an education service manager for the District since 1983, testified that it is her standard practice to offer transportation services to parents at every IEP meeting in which placement is discussed and to not indicate on the IEP document when transportation is refused by the parent. This testimony is supported by the fact that the word transportation appears to be crossed out under the category of related services needed by STUDENT. MOTHER’s testimony that she could not specifically recall a discussion about transportation during the meeting does not conflict with Ms. Barraco’s testimony. Second, while it may constitute best practices to specify in writing all the related services being offered to the parent (even those being refused), there is no indication that the District’s failure to offer transportation services in writing prejudiced the parents in any manner. For example, the mother’s testimony indicated that the parents were aware that District transportation was available for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year, as it was for other students, but that they did not want STUDENT to experience problems during transportation that they heard other children did. Further, there was no indication that the parents’ views on the District’s provision of transportation services had changed by the time of the April 1996 meeting such that they would have accepted the District’s offer of transportation had it been presented to them in writing. Finally, the Hearing Officer has already found Petitioner’s other bases for reimbursement (insofar as they duplicate those advanced in support of reimbursement under issue number one) unpersuasive.

Because the District made an appropriate offer of transportation services for the 1996-97 school year, Petitioner’s request to be reimbursed for expenses incurred during the 1996-97 school year to transport STUDENT to his related services is denied.

3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year?

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. Special education law also required that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occurred only when the nature or severity of his disabilities was such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for the 1997-98 school year must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with his IEP; and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment. Each of these elements will be addressed in turn.

Designed To Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The first step in the analysis is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT had, and continues to have, intense motor, visual, communication, social-emotional, self-help, and preacademic needs primarily as a result of cerebral palsy. With regard to his motor difficulties, the evidence established that STUDENT has spasticity in all four limbs, is nonambulatory, and has difficulty sitting, standing or walking independently. He has poor head-neck control and, as a result, has difficulty maintaining his head in an upright position, which adversely impacts his ability to visually focus on things and people. STUDENT’s visual skills are further affected by a diagnosed cortical visual impairment, which MOTHER described as a difficulty processing visual stimuli because of brain damage STUDENT suffered at or near the time of birth. STUDENT’s ocular problems include difficulty with eye-hand coordination, maintaining focus, and identifying objects. Cerebral palsy has affected STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills: he cannot articulate words well, tending to miss certain sounds or being unable to say them clearly; his vocabulary is very limited; and, although he appears to prefer to vocalize rather than use augmentative communication devices, his utterances are infrequent, often very soft and low, and often unintelligible except to those working closely with him. As mentioned earlier, STUDENT suffers from significant separation anxiety, which was especially severe in his early years and which results in crying, anxiousness or an inability to attend to a task when he is not able to see either his parents or nanny near him. STUDENT is very adult-oriented and requires a lot of adult assistance to interact with his peers. His self-help skills have always been severely limited. He requires assistance with all the basic activities of living such as feeding, toileting, and dressing. Finally, STUDENT’s progress in preacademic skills, such as sound recognition and problem solving, has always fallen below the level expected for his chronological age, although various assessors have indicated that it is difficult to assess STUDENT with standardized tests because of his limited motor and language skills and visual impairment.

Having determined what STUDENT’s unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District offered STUDENT a program that would have addressed those needs. There is no dispute that for the 1997-98 school year the District offered STUDENT placement in the ECE special day class for orthopedically handicapped children with the following related services: ninety minutes per week of VI services; sixty minutes per week of speech and language services; three hours per week of OT and PT; and transportation to and from school. This offer was reflected in two IEPs dated May 28, 1997, and September 22, 1997. (Footnote 7) Proposed goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year were prepared by the SDC teacher, Ms. Rice; the VI teacher; the speech and language therapist; and the OT and PT therapists, and attached to the IEPs. There is no dispute that the parents understood that the offer was for placement in the ECE pre-kindergarten/kindergarten OH special day class located at Tower Road, which was scheduled to be taught by Linda Pucillo. (Footnote 8)

Petitioner did not contend that the frequency and duration of the related services offered and provided by the District during the 1997-98 school year (i.e., PT, OT, speech and language, and VI services) were inappropriate to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Petitioner also did not contend that the goals and objectives proposed for the 1997-98 school year were inappropriate to address STUDENT’s needs. (Footnote 9) Instead, Petitioner challenged the following portions of the District’s proposed program: (1) the appropriateness of the proposed class and the ability of the classroom staff to meet STUDENT’s needs, (2) the program’s continued focus on the use of augmentative communication devices (ACDs), and (3) the extent that music is used as an instructional tool during the program. Therefore, the following discussion will focus on these three disputed elements of the District’s proposed program.

Regarding Petitioner’s first contention that the proposed class and classroom staff were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer will review the testimony of the teachers of the proposed class. Ms. Pucillo, who taught the classroom proposed by the District for the 1997-98 school year, testified that she received a bachelor of arts degree in sociology in approximately 1972 and a teaching credential in elementary education with a specialty in the orthopedically handicapped. She has approximately ten years’ experience working with OH children, both at the preschool and elementary level. She has spent at least eight years teaching preschool and kindergarten OH children on behalf of the COE in the ECE program. During the two and a half years STUDENT attended Ms. Rice’s preschool class, Ms. Pucillo taught a kindergarten OH class in the classroom next door. During that time, Ms. Rice and Ms. Pucillo conducted joint activities with their classes (i.e., team-taught) on occasion for subjects such as music and art and for outside play activities. Ms. Pucillo testified that she became familiar with STUDENT through the team-teaching activities, although she admits that she has never taught STUDENT in a one-on-one situation.

According to Ms. Pucillo, during the 1997-98 school year, the pre-kindergarten/kindergarten OH class consisted of approximately seven students, one of whom was classified as a pre-kindergarten student and four to five of whom had been diagnosed with cerebral palsy. The degree of the students’ orthopedic handicaps varied. For instance, three of the students were able to walk independently, two could walk with the assistance of a walker, and one of the children used a wheelchair. Ms. Pucillo was assisted in the classroom by two instructional aides. Therapists were frequently in the classroom to either pull out individual students for therapy or to work with students in the classroom in individual or group settings.

Ms. Pucillo described the classroom schedule for that year as follows. The children arrived at school between 9:30 a.m. and 9:50 a.m. and were escorted to the classroom. Toileting needs were taken care of first, either by implementing an established toilet training program or changing the child’s diaper. Then the children were given a few minutes of free time during which they could choose among activities such as playing with toys, working with puzzles in the fine motor area, and cutting and pasting in the art area. At about 10:00 a.m., snacks were given to those children who were hungry and the children were asked questions about what they wanted, the staff requiring the children to answer either orally or by use of low-tech augmentative communication devices (such as pointing to a picture of the desired object). From approximately 10:10 a.m. to 10:40 a.m., the class engaged in “circle time.” During circle time, the children all sat in chairs in a circle (either wooden or adapted chairs -- a wheelchair in the rare case) and they engaged in group activities to develop pre-academic skills such as name recognition and picture recognition of staff and peers, color identification, counting numbers, learning the days of the week and concepts of today, tomorrow and yesterday, and discussions of the class schedule using icons. Circle time also sometimes involved music and song. At the conclusion of circle time, the class separated into two groups, one went to work on art projects in the art area and the other worked on the fine motor goals contained in their IEPs in the fine motor area. At 11:00 a.m., the class went outside for recess. During recess, the staff worked on the gross motor goals listed in the children’s IEPs such as getting in and out of the sandbox, playing with a ball, accessing a play structure, and playing with other children in the sandbox. At approximately 11:30 a.m., Ms. Pucillo read one to two stories to the children in the classroom (or did some music if none had been done that morning) for about fifteen minutes while the aides set up for lunch. Lunch lasted from forty-five minutes to one hour, during which time staff engaged in constant communication with the children to develop their language skills and tried to cover a wide range of concepts with the children. Those children who finished lunch first were allowed to play in the art or fine motor area while waiting for the other children to finish. As the children finished lunch, the classroom aides took care of their toileting needs. At about 1:00 p.m., the class engaged in fine motor, music or computer activities, or went outside to play if the weather permitted. The children then went home at approximately 1:30 p.m.

Ms. Pucillo testified that they worked on language skills throughout the day through talking, modeling and prompting. Fine motor goals were covered at the fine motor table but were also interwoven throughout the day’s activities. Gross motor goals were usually addressed during recess in the playground, as well as in therapy. Ms. Pucillo testified that for social adaptation, she constantly strived to get the children to interact with the staff and other children in an appropriate manner. Self-help goals were addressed mostly through potty training, teaching the children to access their own cubicle and to clear their places after snack and lunch time.

Ms. Pucillo further testified that she used a card system to refresh her memory of each child’s individual IEP goals. She wrote a brief description of each child’s goals on a card and kept them easily accessible while working with the children. After reviewing each of STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year at the hearing, Ms. Pucillo testified that she implemented similar goals and objectives for other children and that she could have implemented the goals and objectives written for STUDENT.

Ms. Pucillo left the pre-kindergarten/kindergarten OH class in January 1998 to teach the preschool OH class next door and was replaced by Leah Movillion. Before Ms. Pucillo left the prekindergarten/kindergarten class, she and Ms. Movillion spent three to four days teaching the class together in order to ease the transition for the children. Ms. Movillion has a bachelor of arts degree in liberal studies and, in the mid-eighties, received a multiple subject credential and a specialist in the physically handicapped credential. She has taught orthopedically handicapped classes, ranging from the infant to the elementary level, for the COE since April 1987. Ms. Movillion testified that when she took over the pre-kindergarten/kindergarten class, she kept the classroom physically the same and kept the activities substantially the same. Ms. Movillion also testified that she has implemented goals and objectives that were similar to STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year, and that she could have worked on those goals during the second half of the 1997-98 school year with STUDENT.

After a careful review of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the class and classroom staff proposed for the 1997-98 school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The classroom was specifically designed for orthopedically handicapped children such as STUDENT and was taught by teachers with substantial training and experience in teaching orthopedically handicapped children. All of STUDENT’s areas of need were addressed by the proposed placement. For example, language development, whether through vocalizations or with the assistance of augmentative communication devices, was a constant focus of the class, especially during snack and lunch time. Pre-academic areas were intensely covered during circle time. Gross motor and fine motor goals were addressed through classroom activities, as well as in therapy. Additionally, STUDENT’s goals and objectives addressed all of his areas of need, such as social/emotional (e.g., helping him separate from his family without crying), language (e.g., increasing his ability to effectively use augmentative communication devices and to vocalize), preacademic/cognitive, fine motor, gross motor, self-help, augmentative communication, and ocular motor control. Furthermore, both teachers testified that they had implemented goals and objectives similar to STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year for other children and that they could have implemented them in the classroom that year for STUDENT. Both teachers also testified that they had experience helping children work through their separation anxiety and could have implemented STUDENT’s goal to overcome his separation anxiety at school. Finally, there was no evidence that the classroom staff provided that year, i.e., a teacher and two aides for eight students, would have been insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs and implement his goals and objectives.

The above finding that the class and classroom staff were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs was supported by the testimony of Karen Grites, the educational consultant who testified on behalf of Petitioner. Ms. Grites has been with the Children’s Health Council (CHC) for the last ten years and is currently the CHC’s director of school age and adolescent services. She has a bachelor’s degree in the area of the educably mentally handicapped with coursework in the physically handicapped, a master’s degree in the area of the maladjusted behavioral disordered and the learning disabled, multiple subject credentials K-12 in both regular and special education, a resource specialist certificate of competence, and a K-12 learning handicapped teaching credential. Ms. Grites taught in the public schools for eighteen years in both resource specialist programs and special day classes that included children with learning disabilities and orthopedic handicaps, and the educable and trainable mentally handicapped. Ms. Grites testified that part of her duties with the CHC is to assess educational placements for children using a criterion that looks for best practices.

Ms. Grites reviewed some of STUDENT’s school records and observed both the District’s proposed program for the 1997-98 school year at Tower Road and the parent’s private placement at Step-By-Step. Ms. Grites testified that she has visited the Tower Road site multiple times, but that she observed the District’s proposed class at Tower Road on March 10, 1998, for one to two hours (between 9:00 a.m. and 11:00 a.m.) specifically with STUDENT’s needs in mind. During the observation, Ms. Grites saw seven students with three adults in the class and observed a symbol-sound letter lesson, as well as the class transitioning to the lunch table. Ms. Grites testified that she believed that the program she observed at Tower Road was an appropriate program for STUDENT, although she could not venture an opinion on whether it could have implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives because she was not able to observe STUDENT in the program or see how the program would have implemented his goals and objectives. Ms. Grites further testified that she believed the parents’ private placement was “more appropriate” if the goal was to foster independence, and that she expected that the parents’ placement would produce more dramatic and longer-lasting results than the ECE program.

While it is clear from Ms. Grites’ testimony and report that she preferred the parents’ private placement, she did not waiver in her opinion that the District’s proposed program at Tower Road was generally appropriate for STUDENT. Regardless of whether placement at Step-By-Step would have constituted “best practices” (as found by Ms. Grites), the District was under no obligation to provide more than it did, i.e., a program that was, inter alia, designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314 (“An ‘appropriate’ public program does not mean the absolutely best or ‘potential-maximizing’ education for the individual child.”) School districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 201.

Similarly, the Hearing Officer does not find Petitioner’s second contention that the program’s continued focus on the use of augmentative communication devices was inappropriate persuasive. As mentioned earlier, STUDENT has a difficult time communicating orally because he tends to miss certain sounds or is unable to say them clearly, he has a very limited vocabulary, his vocalizations are often very soft and low, and, although he appears to prefer to vocalize rather than use ACDs, his vocalizations are infrequent and often unintelligible except to those working closely with him. ACDs are frequently used in school settings to assist children like STUDENT who are having difficulty orally communicating. There is no indication that fostering STUDENT’s use of ACDs was in any way inappropriate, even though STUDENT preferred to vocalize rather than use ACDs. According to the testimony of Marcella Murray, the speech therapy provider who has been working with STUDENT since September 1997, she only discontinued the goals and objectives relating to the ACDs after consultations with the family in which they related that they did not like to use the devices at home, and indications from the previous provider that STUDENT only inconsistently used the devices. Furthermore, STUDENT’s ability to communicate orally and his ability to communicate with the assistance of ACDs were both addressed by the program, as he had goals in both areas.

Finally, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Petitioner’s third contention that the District’s proposed program failed to incorporate music into the instructional day, and thereby failed to meet STUDENT’s individual needs. Evidence was presented that STUDENT liked music and that the parents thought STUDENT’s learning could be facilitated with the use of music. However, it was not established that it was necessary for STUDENT to have more music included in his school day to meet his unique needs. Furthermore, the question of the appropriate instructional methodology is an issue uniquely within the province of a school district’s expertise. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207 (“[C]ourts must be careful to avoid imposing their view of preferable educational methods upon the States. The primary responsibility for formulating the education to be accorded a handicapped child, and for choosing the educational method most suitable to the child’s needs, was left by the Act to state and local educational agencies in cooperation with the parents or guardian of the child.”).

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed program for the 1997-98 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996). Of course, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).

Petitioner contended that the program the District proposed for the 1997-98 school year would not have provided STUDENT with educational benefit, because a similar program provided with Beth Rice during the previous two and a half years failed to provide adequate educational benefit. Therefore, it is appropriate to review STUDENT’s performance during the previous years with Ms. Rice to provide insight into whether the District’s proposed program for the 1997-98 school year was, in fact, reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. It is noted, however, that certain factors likely impeded STUDENT’s ability to make progress in Ms. Rice’s class and that those factors would not necessarily have been present during the 1997-98 school year. For example, STUDENT experienced fewer medical problems as he grew older and was able to attend school more regularly and for longer periods. Additionally, as discussed in further detail below, STUDENT’s separation anxiety significantly decreased over the years, leaving STUDENT more able to attend to classroom activities as time wore on.

There is no dispute that STUDENT made some progress during his years in Beth Rice’s ECE preschool OH class, which he attended from February 1995 to the end of the 1996-97 school year. All the witnesses who worked with STUDENT when he was placed in Ms. Rice’s class, including STUDENT’s mother, testified that STUDENT made progress during that time, albeit slow progress. The question, then, is whether STUDENT obtained more than de minimis benefit or made more than trivial advancement while in Ms. Rice’s class. Progress may be measured in a number of ways. Reference to standardized test scores, grades, progress on goals and objectives, and teacher observation may all be used to determine progress.

Beth Rice testified that STUDENT made progress in all areas while he was her student, although the progress was less in some areas than in others. (Footnote 10) Ms. Rice testified that it was difficult to definitively ascertain STUDENT’s skill level in certain areas because STUDENT had difficulty visually focusing, was a reluctant performer and often refused to demonstrate his skills, especially in test situations (although she was sometimes able to observe him demonstrating the same skills in an informal setting). According to Ms. Rice, STUDENT’s performance was very uneven depending on the day and his motivation level, and his ability to perform was sometimes affected by health issues. Despite her inability to definitively determine STUDENT’s skill level in certain domains, Ms. Rice did notice that STUDENT made “great strides” over time in dealing with his separation anxiety. Ms. Rice testified that when STUDENT began attending her class, he used to “fall apart” emotionally and weep constantly when his mother or nanny left the classroom, which was the same behavior he had exhibited while attending the infant ECE program. By the end of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT’s separation anxiety had decreased considerably. While he still felt anxious, he was able to separate without weeping or falling apart. According to Ms. Rice, STUDENT also made great progress in learning to cope with his sensitivity to light and noise while in the classroom. Although abrupt noises still startled and distracted him, he learned to deal well with the noise normally found in a preschool classroom and came to enjoy the classroom environment.

Ms. Rice’s testimony that STUDENT progressed in all areas is also supported by her reports on STUDENT’s present levels of performance, which she prepared in anticipation of the IEP meetings held in April 1996 and May 1997 and which were made part of the IEPs. While the reports do not reflect dramatic improvement in any area, they do show that STUDENT made some progress in all areas. For example, between April 1996 and May 1997, STUDENT learned four more body parts; could demonstrate the use of some common objects, especially those involved in the activities of daily living; learned alternative means to express wants and needs, such as using a big mack switch (an augmentative communication device) to answer simple questions, pointing, and eye-gaze; expanded his oral expressive vocabulary; learned to identify one more emotion using symbols; allowed school staff to feed him (rather than only allowing his mother or nanny to feed him); demonstrated increased use of his right hand (his right hand is more involved than his left); increased the frequency and duration in which he was able to make and maintain visual focus on his hands during fine motor activities; demonstrated improved endurance and head control in standing; and learned to actively participate in classroom care routines such as dressing and undressing. A review of STUDENT’s progress on the goals and objectives listed on his IEPs dated January 5, 1995, and April 8, 1996, shows that although STUDENT failed to achieve many of his objectives to the levels indicated on his IEPs, he did make significant progress on a number of them. (Footnote 11) For example, Ms. Rice testified that STUDENT met the communication objective listed on his January 1995 IEP of consistently responding to appropriate questions requiring “yes” and “no” answers by shaking his head, although it was difficult to encourage him to demonstrate the skill in a test situation. STUDENT’s mother testified that he met the following three out of five psychomotor objectives listed on his IEP dated January 5, 1995: use a walker and propel himself ten feet (although not achieved with the frequency listed on the IEP); successfully reach for, grasp and release small objects (one inch or less) into a container in three out of four trials; and activate a variety of switch toys upon request (although she was not certain if STUDENT achieved this with the frequency listed on the IEP). The mother also testified that STUDENT met the following self-help and expressive communication objectives listed on his IEP dated January 5, 1995: wash his face when given a washcloth and wipe the tray when requested to (although she was not sure if this was achieved to the frequency listed on the IEP); and visually focus on a selected photo when two photos were put in front of him. The official school copy of the IEP dated April 1996 indicates that the following goals and objectives were met by May 1997: make wants and needs known using a communication device or vocalizations instead of crying; operate simple computer games on an adapted computer; use a switch to activate a computer and toys; and use a Jelly Bean switch attached to a SpeakEasy to participate in group activities.

As for standardized tests, STUDENT has not been administered any that would be of assistance in the present analysis. He was, however, administered the Hawaii Early Learning Profile (HELP) in February 1996 (when he was four years old) and again in May 1997 (when he was five years and three months old). Ms. Rice described the HELP as a checklist of developmental skills or milestones from birth to five or six years of age that covers all five areas of development . Ms. Rice testified that the HELP is not standardized or normed, but that the range it produces is usually fairly accurate (to plus or minus a few months), although it tends to produce a low estimation of functioning. According to the results from the HELP testing, STUDENT made some progress in the fifteen months between the administrations of the test. The following are the results as stated in the assessment reports:

Skill Area Chronological Age 4.0 Chronological Age 5.3 Cognitive/Learning range 18-30 months range 20-33 months Language/Communication range 18-24 months range 20-32 months Social Adaptation range 24-30 months range 24-33 months Fine Motor range 16-18 months range 16-22 months Gross Motor range 6-9 months range 6-10 months Self-help range 12-18 months range 12-18 months

STUDENT’s results on the HELP, which show some progress but certainly no dramatic improvement, corroborate the testimony of Ms. Rice and MOTHER.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT made some progress while in Ms. Rice’s class from February 1995 to the end of the 1996-97 school year, and that the progress constituted more than de minimis benefit or trivial advancement. The level of progress was established by the observations of both the teacher and his mother and progress on goals and objectives, and it was corroborated by the results of the HELP. While the progress achieved was certainly not what might be expected with a typically developing child, given the severity of STUDENT’s disabilities, his progress amounted to more than de minimis benefit. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT did make progress while attending Ms. Rice’s class, a program similar to that recommended by the District for the 1997-98 school year, and was likely to receive educational benefit from the program proposed by the District for the 1997-98 school year had STUDENT continued his enrollment in the District. This is especially true given that certain problems STUDENT had earlier which had interfered with his ability to benefit from his education, such as the frequency and severity of medical problems that resulted in absences from school, were markedly ameliorated by the 1997-98 school year.

Comport With the IEP

The District did not have an opportunity to provide STUDENT with the program proposed in STUDENT’s IEPs dated May 28, 1997, and September 22, 1997. STUDENT’s parents unilaterally removed STUDENT from the District’s public schools and placed him in the nonpublic Step-By-Step program. The District presented evidence that it was willing and able to provide STUDENT with an educational program as set out in the IEP during the 1997-98 school year, and Petitioner did not present any rebuttal evidence. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s provision of instruction and services would have comported with the IEP.

Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment

The District established that its proposed program would have provided STUDENT with education in the least restrictive environment. Had STUDENT attended the District’s proposed program, he would have been placed in a special day class with other orthopedically handicapped students. However, Ms. Pucillo testified that a daycare or preschool for typically developing children was located onsite, and that her class used to interact with those children during music activities, on the playground, and when they came into her classroom to engage in activities with the OH class (which generally happened one to two times per week). Petitioner did not present any evidence in rebuttal. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program represented the least restrictive environment possible given STUDENT’s unique needs.

*****

As established above, the program that the District proposed for the 1997-98 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, would have conformed to the IEP if the District had been given a chance to carry out the program, and would have occurred in the least restrictive environment. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year.

4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for his private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year?

The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any expenses related to their unilateral placement of STUDENT in the Step-By-Step program for the 1997-98 school year. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i).

5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year?

Petitioner contended that the District failed to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year because (1) the District failed to make an appropriate written offer and (2) even if the District properly offered a program, the proposed program was not appropriate for STUDENT.

Appropriate Written Offer

The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 207-208. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. Id. at 1484. Procedural violations may constitute a denial of a FAPE where they result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. Among the procedural violations that the Ninth Circuit has held may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).

Petitioner contended that the District failed to make a formal written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year, as required by 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3) and Union School Dist., because the offer contained in the IEP dated July 15, 1998, failed to inform the parents of the location of the program being offered. The evidence established that, during the summer of 1998, the kindergarten OH special day class into which STUDENT would have been placed had been relocated from the Tower Road site to the Sandpiper Elementary School. The District argued that there is no dispute that a COE special day class for orthopedically handicapped students was offered for the 1998-99 school year, which is the same class regardless of the location of the class.

There is no dispute that the only IEP for STUDENT that dealt with the 1998-99 school year was the IEP dated July 15, 1998. The District’s offer of placement in the IEP dated July 15, 1998, was contained in the following sentence:

The District continues to offer a range of placements in the San Mateo County Office of Education, ECE program, special day class programs to make progress and meet his goals and objectives.

MOTHER testified that the IEP team did not discuss at the meeting the specific school or classroom that was being offered, so she was not sure at the time whether Ms. Pucillo would be the teacher or whether the class would still be located at the Tower Road site. Prior to enrolling in the Step-By-Step program, STUDENT had attended the OH special day class in the COE’s ECE program at Tower Road for two and a half years. MOTHER did not deny that she understood the offer for the 1998-99 school year to be for an OH special day class in the COE’s ECE program, which was the same program that the District had offered for the previous school year and which STUDENT had attended during the two and a half years prior to enrolling in the Step-By-Step program.

Generally, an offer of a “range of placements” is insufficiently specific to give reasonable notice to a parent of a school district’s offer of placement. Although the terms of the instant offer limited it to a special day class in the COE’s ECE program, it failed to specify some details of the placement, such as the location or the type of special day class being offered. While strict compliance with 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3) requires more specificity, the totality of the circumstances establishes that the written offer afforded the parents reasonable notice of what the District was offering as a placement for the 1998-99 school year.

First, there is no dispute that the parents understood that the District was offering an OH special day class in the ECE program for the 1998-99 school year, the same program that STUDENT had previously attended and the same program that had been offered by the District for the 1997-98 school year. Second, there is no dispute that regardless of the identity of the teacher and the location of the classroom, the substantive components of the OH special day class remained virtually the same. In fact, on page 24 of Petitioner’s closing argument, he stated that the program’s substantive components for the 1998-99 school year were “identical” to the program’s substantive components with Ms. Rice. There was neither evidence nor argument that the location of the school changed any of the elements of the OH special day class that the parents objected to previously. Thus, there was no indication that Petitioner’s views on the appropriateness of the offer would have changed in any manner even if the District’s written offer had been more specific with regard to the location of the ECE special day class being offered. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner was not prejudiced in any manner by any lack of specificity in the District’s offer. Therefore, the District’s failure to fully satisfy the written prior notice requirement of the IDEA did not rise to the level of a procedural violation that seriously infringed on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process or on the parents’ ability to comprehend and evaluate the District’s offer of placement. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District gave reasonable prior written notice to the parents of the placement being offered to STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year.

Appropriateness Of the District’s Offer

As previously discussed, the determination of whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE depends upon the adequacy of the program that the District offered. Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. The following discussion will focus on whether the District’s proposed program for the 1998-99 school year met the following four requirements, as set forth above under issue number three: (1) designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP, and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.

Designed To Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The Hearing Officer discussed in detail above STUDENT’s intense motor, visual, communication, social-emotional, self-help and preacademic needs during the 1997-98 school year. The evidence established that these needs were the same for the 1998-99 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will proceed to the question of whether the District offered STUDENT a program for the 1998-99 school year that would have addressed those needs.

For the 1997-98 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement in the ECE special day class for orthopedically handicapped children. The evidence established that, based on STUDENT’s age at the time, this would have been a kindergarten OH special day class taught by Leah Movillion. Petitioner contended that this class would not have addressed STUDENT’s needs because of the range of the other children’s disabilities and cognitive levels, the amount of instructional time lost due to the classroom’s distance from the bus stop, and the uncertainty of the class’s location for the next year.

As discussed earlier, Ms. Movillion testified that she has a bachelor of arts degree in liberal studies and, in the mid-eighties, received a multiple-subject credential and a specialist in the physically handicapped credential. She has taught orthopedically handicapped classes, ranging from the infant to the elementary level, for the COE since April 1987.

Ms. Movillion testified that, for the 1998-99 school year, the kindergarten OH class consisted of nine children, her and two assistants. The children range in age from five to six years old. The majority of the children have been diagnosed with cerebral palsy, although to varying degrees. For example, about half of the children use wheelchairs and four of the children are able to ambulate independently. A couple of the children are relatively close cognitively to the kindergarten level and are mainstreamed with the regular education program for part of the day. The cognitive range of the others is from about eighteen months to three years old. All children, however, are given an opportunity to interact with the regular education population on campus during recess and assemblies. The class also engages in a buddy reading program with a regular education third grade class in which the third-graders read to the OH students. According to Ms. Movillion, several of the children are nonvocal so the classroom activities focus heavily on augmentative communication and increasing language skills.

She described the daily classroom routine as follows: The students generally arrive at the school between 9:45 a.m. and 10:00 a.m., and the staff teaches them how to put things away in their cubicles and take jackets and hats off, assisting when necessary. From 10:00 a.m. to 10:15 a.m., the staff assists children in donning any specialized equipment (such as standers and walkers) that are necessary and practice walking with those children who are encouraged to walk more during the day. From 10:15 a.m. to 10:30 a.m., the class goes to the playground for recess, during which time the children can interact with regular education students who are also in recess. The class stays on the playground for an additional ten to fifteen minutes after the regular education students’ recess ends at 10:30 a.m. in order to have some undisturbed time with the playground equipment. At about 10:45 a.m., the class returns to the room to work on individual goals and objectives for half an hour to forty-five minutes in either individual or small-group settings, usually involving art or a fine motor activity. The class begins getting ready for lunch at approximately 11:30 a.m. with the students washing their hands and the staff preparing the food. During lunch, the staff work on self-help skills such as independent eating, encourage socialization among the students, and engage in language activities (with some students using augmentative communication devices) that also cover preacademic concepts. By noon, the couple of mainstreamed students leave the room to go to their regular education kindergarten class and the rest clean up or help clean up the lunch items. After the clean up, the children take care of any toileting needs and perhaps have some free choice time until 12:15 p.m. Then the class gathers for circle time, which involves varied activities with a focus on preacademic skills and communication/language skills. During this time, the children are encouraged to use switches and to imitate by vocalizing, to get up and move around the room, and to sing. Near the end of circle time, the teacher or an assistant sometimes reads the class a story. At about 1:00 p.m., the children who had been mainstreamed return to the SDC room and the staff work with them on their individual goals and objectives. Meanwhile, the other children are allowed to engage in structured free-choice activities, such as playing in the playhouse. The day sometimes ends with the class completing an art project from earlier in the day before the children prepare to go home at 1:30 p.m. According to Ms. Movillion, toilet training and bathrooming are done throughout the entire day.

Ms. Movillion also testified that language development is worked on throughout the course of the day, although it is individualized for every student based on his or her ability and goals and objectives. This was supported by the testimony of Marcella Murray, the speech and language pathologist who has been working with STUDENT since September 1997. Ms. Murray observed Ms. Movillion’s classroom for about two hours in January 1999 and spoke with Ms. Movillion. During that time, the class was engaged in a table-top activity with worksheets, naming things in circle time, and doing motoric activities with the adapted physical education (APE) teacher. Ms. Murray testified that STUDENT needs an educational placement that focuses heavily on language acquisition, which is inextricably related to academics, and a language-rich environment. Ms. Murray further testified that, based on her observation of Ms. Movillion’s class and her knowledge of the activities that take place in similar classes, it would have been an appropriate classroom for STUDENT with regard to his language development.

Ms. Movillion testified that the children’s related services are delivered throughout the school day in an individual (pull-out or in the classroom) or small group setting. She testified that she works with the therapy providers to try to mesh the related services with the classroom work. For example, she and the speech and language therapist work as a team during circle time one day every week, and she collaborates with all the providers to try to ensure follow-through in the classroom of the skills the children are learning in therapy. Additionally, the APE teacher joins the class two mornings per week to perform motor activities with the students with the assistance of the classroom staff. Ms. Movillion testified that she informs the therapists when she thinks it is important for the children to stay in the classroom for a particular activity so that they are not pulled out of class during the activity. According to Ms. Movillion, there are two computers in her classroom for the children to use, both with specialized equipment. Ms. Movillion testified that she has implemented goals and objectives similar to STUDENT’s goals and objectives for other children, and that she could have worked on those goals in her classroom.

In light of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the program proposed for the 1998-99 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The classroom was specifically designed for orthopedically handicapped children such as STUDENT, and was taught by a teacher with substantial training and experience teaching orthopedically handicapped children. All of STUDENT’s areas of need were addressed by the proposed placement. For example, language development, whether through vocalizations or with the assistance of augmentative communication devices, was a constant focus of the class, especially during lunch and circle time. Pre-academic subjects and motoric activities were addressed through almost all classroom activities, as well as in therapy. Furthermore, Ms. Movillion testified that she implemented goals and objectives similar to STUDENT’s goals and objectives and that she could have implemented them in the classroom. Ms. Movillion also testified that she had experience helping children work through their separation anxiety, and could have implemented STUDENT’s goal to overcome his separation anxiety at school. Finally, there was unrebutted evidence that the classroom staff would have been sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs and implement his goals and objectives.

The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner’s argument that the placement was inappropriate because of the range of the other children’s disabilities and cognitive levels, the amount of instructional time lost due to the classroom’s distance from the bus stop, or the uncertainty of the class’s location for the next year. First, Petitioner offered no reason why STUDENT needed to be placed in an educational setting with children having only a similar degree of physical involvement. The fact that some of his fellow students were able to walk did not affect the ability of the program to address STUDENT’s needs, especially when Ms. Movillion and her staff were trained to work with orthopedically impaired youngsters and could assist STUDENT when necessary. Further, apart from physical and occupational therapy, activities designed to foster motor development were a significant component of Ms. Movillion’s class, both in the classroom and on the playground. Second, the fact that a range exists in students’ cognitive levels in a classroom does not necessarily mean that a classroom is inappropriate, since a significant range exists in virtually all classrooms. Here, however, any discrepancy was remedied by the time allocated to work on the children’s individual goals and objectives. Third, there was no persuasive evidence of how the loss of any instructional time affected the ability of the program to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Moreover, the students work on areas of need during the time that they wait for the other students to arrive. For example, the students work on self-help skills such as putting things away in their cubicles and on gross motor skills such as walking. Fourth, the exact location of the kindergarten OH class next year is immaterial to the issue of whether the class constituted an appropriate placement for STUDENT for this year.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

Petitioner contended that the program the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year would not have provided STUDENT with educational benefit, because a similar program provided with Beth Rice during the previous two and a half years failed to provide adequate educational benefit. This same argument was made by Petitioner with regard to the proposed program for the 1997-98 school year, and was rejected by the Hearing Officer. Based on the same reasons previously delineated and the character of the 1998-99 proposed placement, the Hearing Officer rejects this argument and concludes that the program the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Comport With the IEP

The District did not have an opportunity to provide STUDENT with the program proposed in the IEP dated July 15, 1998. STUDENT’s parents continued his unilateral placement in the Step-By-Step program. The District presented evidence that it was willing and able to provide STUDENT with an educational program as set forth in his IEP during the 1998-99 school year, and Petitioner presented no rebuttal evidence. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s provision of instruction and services would have comported with the IEP.

Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment

The District established that its proposed program would have provided STUDENT with education in the least restrictive environment. Had STUDENT attended the District’s proposed program, he would have been placed in a special day class with other orthopedically handicapped students. However, Ms. Movillion testified that her classroom was located on the campus of a regular education elementary school and that her class routinely interacts with the regular education students on the playground, during assemblies, and when the regular education third grade class comes into her classroom for the buddy reading program. Petitioner did not present any evidence in rebuttal. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program represented the least restrictive environment possible given STUDENT’s unique needs.

*****

As established above, the program that the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, would have conformed to the IEP if the District had been given a chance to carry out the program, and would have occurred in the least restrictive environment. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-99 school year.

6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for his private placement in the Step-By-Step program for the 1998-99 school year?

The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any expenses related to their unilateral placement of STUDENT in the Step-By-Step program for the 1998-99 school year. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i).

ORDER

Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied in their entirety.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: April 14, 1999 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The Step-By-Step Conductive Education Program was formerly known as Beginning Steps To Independence, Conductive Education Center of Millbrae. For ease of reference, this program will be referred to only as “the Step-By-Step program” in this decision.

2. The issues listed here differ slightly in order and numbering from those noticed by Petitioner. Changes were made to reflect the parties’ settlement of two issues before the hearing, Petitioner’s withdrawal of an issue on the first day of hearing, and the Hearing Officer’s finding that Petitioner was barred from raising any claims that accrued on or before November 20, 1995 (an explanation of which can be found in the section dealing with procedural matters). Changes were also made to enable the Hearing Officer to deal with the remaining issues in chronological order.

3. When specifically asked by the Hearing Officer on February 9 whether the District could establish any irrevocable prejudice that it would suffer were the COE not joined as a party, the District could cite none.

4. This provision has been redesignated 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(15) in the final regulations recently issued by the federal Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services, Department of Education, on March 12, 1999. As the newly issued final regulations do not take effect until May 11, 1999, any references in this decision to the code of federal regulations should be understood to be a reference to the former regulations, unless otherwise specifically noted.

5. MOTHER testified that actually STUDENT did not attend the extended school year session during the summer of 1996, because he was too ill to attend school at that time. She testified that, during the summer of 1996, STUDENT underwent surgery to replace a shunt that had been surgically placed in his head near the time of birth.

6. Petitioner did not specifically include any transportation expenses incurred during the 1996 extended school year (ESY) session in the request for reimbursement. While the ESY following a particular school year is normally considered to be part of that school year, the ESY following the 1996-97 school year will not be considered here because of the following statements made by Petitioner: (1) in his statement of issues, Petitioner stated his proposed resolution to this issue as “Yes. While STUDENT was in a county program the parents transported STUDENT and their request for reimbursement has been denied” and (2) in his closing statement, Petitioner stated, “[T]he Hearing Officer should order that STUDENT [sic] parents be reimbursed for transportation to and from the Tower Road site from November 20, 1995 to the end of STUDENT’s placement at Tower Road after the 1996-97 school year.” These statements make it clear that Petitioner is not seeking reimbursement for transportation expenses incurred during the 1997 ESY because, although STUDENT attended the county program during the 1996-97 school year, he did not attend the county program during the 1997 ESY and none of the related services provided by the District during the 1997 ESY (when STUDENT attended the Step-By-Step program) was provided at the Tower Road site. Accordingly, transportation expenses incurred during the 1997 ESY will not be considered in this decision.

7. Although MOTHER testified that, in addition to visiting Ms. Pucillo’s class, she visited three other placements prior to the IEP meeting in May 1997 (one private school and two regular education classrooms), there is no dispute that these other placements were not offered by the District as a placement for the 1997-98 school year. In fact, not only were these other placements not mentioned on the IEP documents or at the IEP meetings but, according to MOTHER, she asked the IEP team to keep a spot for STUDENT in Ms. Pucillo’s class for the 1997-98 school year even though they intended to try the Step-By-Step program during the summer of 1997.

8. While Ms. Pucillo taught the class at the beginning of the 1997-98 school year, she left in January to teach the ECE preschool OH class. Leah Movillion replaced Ms. Pucillo as the teacher for the ECE pre-kindergarten/kindergarten OH class.

9. In his closing argument, Petitioner did argue that the goals and objectives developed from January 1995 to May 1997 were inappropriate. However, Petitioner did not dispute the appropriateness of the goals and objectives developed for the 1997-98 school year, except to the limited extent that they continued to focus on the use of augmentative communication devices (as will be discussed further).

10. Before leaving the COE’s employment to become an educational consultant for the Department of Education in December 1997, Ms. Rice taught in the ECE program for sixteen years. She received a bachelor of science degree in education in 1974 and a master of arts degree in special education in 1976. At the time she taught STUDENT, she also had the following credentials: elementary multiple subject, learning handicapped, physically handicapped, and severely handicapped.

11. The Hearing Officer notes that a number of the goals and objectives listed in the IEPs dated January 1995 and April 1996 were unrealistic based on the deficits that STUDENT was exhibiting, and could not have been achieved by the times indicated. In fact, a number of the objectives still had not been achieved even after a year in the Step-By-Step program where, according to Petitioner, STUDENT made dramatic progress. For example, according to the IEP dated January 1995, STUDENT was expected to be able to feed himself independently with a spoon stick in three out of four trials if the food was provided by his mother. There was no evidence presented that STUDENT was able to feed himself independently with any kind of utensil even by July 1998. However, as the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years are not in issue, the appropriateness of the goals and objectives for those years will not be explored further.