California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 9, 1998

Student v. Lodi Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 165-97 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Lodi Unified must reimburse eye-patching costs only; the request to fund the student's private vision therapy is denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A six-year-old girl's family filed for due process against Lodi Unified School District. She qualified for special education because of significant language delays and delays in fine and gross motor skills. Starting in March 1996, a private optometrist, Dr. Eldon Rosenow, diagnosed amblyopia, strabismus, and visual-perceptual problems. He prescribed glasses, patching of the stronger eye, and vision therapy exercises. The family asked to be reimbursed for that therapy through May 1997 and for a six-month program that began in summer 1997. At the family's request, the Hearing Officer did not allow evidence on whether vision therapy works in general. The only question was whether this student needed it to benefit from her education.

Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer found that the District's 1996-97 program gave her educational benefit. Her program included a communicatively handicapped special day class, speech-language services, adaptive physical education (APE), and kindergarten mainstreaming. Teachers and the APE specialist described many classroom activities much like the vision therapy exercises. Both of the family's experts agreed that teachers or family could carry out those activities. An occupational therapist found she did not need occupational therapy. However, all experts agreed she needed eye patching, and the District did not provide it in time. The District was ordered to reimburse the patching costs, upon proof, but no other vision therapy costs. By the 1997-98 school year her vision had stabilized and she no longer needed patching, so the summer 1997 program was not reimbursed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a request to be reimbursed for private vision therapy under Rowley. When classroom and APE activities covered the same motor and perceptual skills, the therapy was not needed for educational benefit. A specific medical need the district left unmet, here eye patching, still supported partial reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1A. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for vision therapy services received from March 1996 through May 1997? (decided under the 1996-97 school year analysis: whether the District's placement provided educational benefit, conformed to the IEP, and met the student's unique needs without vision therapy)

    The District's program gave educational benefit and met the student's motor, language, and vision needs through APE and classroom activities. The one exception was eye patching, which the District did not provide in a timely way, so only the patching costs must be reimbursed.

  2. Issue 1B. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for an additional six-month program of vision therapy which started in summer 1997? (1997-98 school year)

    The student's vision had stabilized, she no longer needed patching, and she had the skills she needed for kindergarten, so no reimbursement was owed for the summer 1997 vision therapy program.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Once Petitioner presents proof, Lodi Unified must reimburse the costs of eye patching provided by Dr. Eldon Rosenow. Reimbursement does not cover any other vision therapy-related services. No dollar amount was stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3051.75; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8); Education Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Wilma Poage, SELPA director (District representative at hearing), Lodi Unified School District / SELPA
  • Eldon Rosenow, private optometrist providing vision therapy; witness for Student, Private practice
  • David Grisham, optometrist; expert witness for Student, School of Optometry, University of California, Berkeley
  • Esther Kim, ophthalmology assistant professor; expert witness for District, Department of Ophthalmology, University of California, Davis
  • Barbara Fineberg, optometrist; expert witness for District, Vision Care
  • Sandra Staples, orientation and mobility / visually impaired instructor; conducted functional vision assessment, Lodi Unified School District
  • Steve Yund, school psychologist (licensed educational psychologist); triennial reassessment, Lodi Unified School District
  • Shelley Banks, occupational therapist; conducted OT assessment for District, Lodi Memorial Hospital
  • Jonathan Grim, adaptive physical education specialist, Lodi Unified School District
  • Doris Salley, kindergarten teacher, Lodi Unified School District
  • Sarah Rouse, speech pathologist and communicatively handicapped SDC teacher, Lodi Unified School District
  • Karen Honkala, program specialist, Lodi Unified School District
  • Doracy Testa, regional center assessor, Valley Mountain Regional Center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer with the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Lodi, California, on August 12, 13, 14, 15, and October 15, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Joyce Carrillo. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Lodi Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jan Damesyn. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Wilma Poage, SELPA director.

Evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. The Hearing Office received closing briefs from both parties, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for vision therapy services received from March 1996 through May 1997, and for an additional six-month program of vision therapy which started in summer 1997?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the outset of the hearing, Petitioner requested that evidence relating to vision therapy be limited to whether STUDENT needs vision therapy for the purpose of benefitting from her education. More specifically, Petitioner asked that the District be prohibited from introducing evidence relating to the validity of vision therapy in general. Petitioner’s request was granted based on California Code of Regulations Section 3051.75, which establishes that vision therapy is an appropriate related service that may be provided to children eligible for special education. Therefore, the question of whether vision therapy, in general, is an effective service is not relevant to this hearing. Rather, the only relevant evidence is whether vision therapy is a necessary related service for STUDENT to benefit from her education.

During Petitioner’s case, evidence was introduced that the Valley Mountain Regional Center has paid for some of the vision therapy services provided to STUDENT. Based on this evidence, the District requested that this matter be dismissed because Petitioner had not paid for the services. The District’s request was denied because there was evidence that Petitioner had paid for at least a portion of the services provided through May 1997, that the payment the Regional Center had made was considered a loan to Petitioner, and that Petitioner was expected to reimburse the Regional Center.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a six-year-old girl enrolled in the Lodi Unified School District. STUDENT’s IEP dated May 26, 1995, states that she was eligible for special education as a result of significant delays in receptive and expressive language and delays in psycho-motor development. At that time, STUDENT was placed in a preschool special day class (SDC) and received adaptive physical education (APE) twice a week for 15-20 minutes per session, and speech and language services in small group sessions for 60-90 minutes. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 1) STUDENT has developmental delays in gross and fine motor development, vision problems, and is hypotonic. (Testimony of MOTHER) When STUDENT started the 1995-96 school year, she continued receiving the same level of services called for in the IEP dated May 26, 1995.

On February 26, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team conducted an annual review of her program. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 2) At that time, STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education as a result of significant delays in syntax and speech articulation, as well as delays in fine and gross motor skills. STUDENT’s placement continued in an SDC. Her speech and language services were reduced to 50-60 minutes per week, and her APE services were set at 20 minutes per week. The IEP team developed goals to address STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills, prereading and premathematics skills, written language (fine motor) skills, and prevocational skills. Three of the five receptive language goals were subsequently met, as well as seven of the ten expressive language goals, two of the four fine motor goals, and the prevocational goal. None of the prereading or premathematic goals was met. The APE instructor also developed gross motor goals to address bilateral coordination, perceptual motor skills, and locomotor skills. The IEP does not indicate whether these goals were met.

On March 11, 1996, Dr. Eldon Rosenow, optometrist, conducted a visual evaluation of STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 8) Dr. Rosenow determined that STUDENT’s visual condition was affecting her coordination and learning abilities and diagnosed her with strabismus, amblyopia, oculomotor dysfunction, and visual perceptual dysfunction. Dr. Rosenow prescribed lenses to improve STUDENT’s eye teaming and focusing skills and also prescribed a 12-month program of vision therapy. The vision therapy prescribed by Dr. Rosenow required monthly office visits, and vision therapy exercises to be practiced at home on a daily basis. The cost of the therapy was expected to be $1,500. STUDENT missed several of the monthly visits because her parents could not afford it. (Testimony of MOTHER) At the time of Dr. Rosenow’s evaluation, STUDENT’s visual acuity was 20/30 in her right eye, 20/80 in her left eye, and 20/30 in both eyes. By April 22, 1996, when STUDENT was seen by Dr. Rosenow again, STUDENT’s visual acuity had equalized to 20/60 in both eyes. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 9)

The vision therapy prescribed by Dr. Rosenow included numerous activities designed to enhance STUDENT’s gross and fine motor skills and to address her visual deficits. These activities included such things as tracking a swinging ball while lying on the floor; responding to taps on parts of her body by raising the body part that was tapped; walking on a balance beam; walking along a tape on the floor; rolling her body while keeping her head and eyes focussed on an object; stringing beads; locating letters on an “alphabet pencil” placed a certain distance from her eyes; and trampoline jumping. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 11)

On May 3, 1996, Sandra Staples, an instructor for visually impaired students, conducted a functional vision assessment of STUDENT for the District. (District’s Exhibit No. 16) Ms. Staples concluded that STUDENT did not have a visual impairment that adversely affected her educational performance. Ms. Staples, however, made several recommendations to enhance STUDENT’s visual attending behavior and participation in readiness activities.

On May 6, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review the functional vision assessment completed by Dr. Rosenow and consider Petitioner’s request for vision therapy. The IEP team decided to have a visual evaluation conducted by a developmental optometrist and to consider vision therapy following completion of that evaluation. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 3)

On June 25, 1996, Dr. Esther Kim, an assistant clinical professor with the Department of Ophthalmology at the University of California, Davis, conducted a visual examination of STUDENT. Dr. Kim determined that STUDENT continued to have “fairly dense amblyopia” in her left eye. Dr. Kim recommended instituting patching of STUDENT’s right eye for 30 minutes per day to help improve the vision in her left eye.(Footnote 1) Dr. Kim examined STUDENT again on July 11, 1996. (District’s Exhibit No. 24) With the patching that Dr. Kim had recommended, the visual acuity in STUDENT’s left eye improved from 20/400 to 20/80. Dr. Kim recommended continuing with the patching until the visual acuity was improved to 20/50, with follow-up, part-time maintenance patching. On July 31, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team determined that vision therapy was not needed based on the recommendation of Dr. Kim. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 4)

On September 12, 1996, Dr. David Grisham, optometrist, completed an eye examination and “partial perceptual skills assessment” of STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 16) At the time, STUDENT’s visual acuity with glasses was 20/60 in both eyes. Dr. Grisham determined that, although STUDENT no longer had any signs of strabismus when wearing glasses, she continued to have ocular motor dysfunction in eye tracking ability, and suppression,(Footnote 2) a condition associated with amblyopia and strabismus. In the areas of perceptual skills, Dr. Grisham concluded that STUDENT had significant delays in visual perceptual skills, visual motor integration, and visual discrimination.

Dr. Grisham recommended that STUDENT continue to wear her glasses and continue with an alternative, part-time patching program to improve her visual acuity. Dr. Grisham also recommended vision therapy exercises to improve various visual skills and “specialized educational procedures at this time that will promote development in several areas of visual perception and fine-motor skill.” Dr. Grisham notes in his report that the training activities recommended by his clinic can be implemented “by a tutor, the parents, the schools, our clinic, or some team effort thereof.”

On September 25, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team met to conduct its annual review of her educational program. STUDENT was assigned to a communicatively handicapped preschool SDC and continued with 50-60 minutes of speech and language services per week, as well as 20 minutes of APE per week. STUDENT was also mainstreamed into a regular kindergarten class education three days per week for one hour each day. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 5) In the Present Levels of Educational Functioning portion of the IEP, STUDENT’s APE instructor noted that STUDENT was now able to do all of the following:

(1) alternate feet while climbing steps holding a hand or rail; (2) walk on balance beam, heel to toe with assistance;

(3) run without falling, but with arms not in opposition;

(4) jump off floor with both feet, but lands with one foot at a time; (5) hop on one foot while holding someone’s hand;

(6) bounce and catch a ball one time;

(7) starting to throw over the top with her right hand.

The APE instructor noted that STUDENT needed to improve her throwing, balance, catching, jumping, hopping, and other activities that include bilateral coordination. STUDENT’s IEP team developed annual goals addressing receptive and expressive language, premathematics, fine motor, visual motor, prereading, and APE goals addressing bilateral coordination, locomotor, and perceptual motor. The IEP does not provide very much information regarding which goals STUDENT met. However, the Hearing Officer notes that this due process hearing began before the completion of one year.

On October 29, 1996, STUDENT was assessed by the Valley Mountain Regional Center. The assessor, Dr. Doracy Testa, found that STUDENT’s intellectual level was in the borderline to low average range. Dr. Testa also found that STUDENT had developmental delays in speech, visual acuity, and motor balance.

On February 3, 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review the vision therapy services that had been provided. At that time, the IEP team agreed to review psychological and vision reports provided by STUDENT’s mother and respond to STUDENT’s mother by February 14, 1997. The IEP team also agreed to try to expand STUDENT’s integration into the kindergarten class.

In March 1997, Steve Yund, licensed educational psychologist, conducted STUDENT’s triennial reassessment for the District. (District’s Exhibit No. 15) Mr. Yund concluded that STUDENT continued to show mild developmental delays in cognitive, language, adaptive and academic skills, and motor functioning. Mr. Yund stated that the “one area of consistent concern on each measure administered was her development of both fine and gross motor skills.” Mr. Yund recommended educational strategies designed to address her motor development with a gradual shift in emphasis toward eye/hand coordination skills.

On March 26, 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review the triennial assessment. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 7) At that time, STUDENT’s program continued in the preschool SDC with mainstreaming in kindergarten three days per week for three hours each day. STUDENT also was to continue receiving speech and language for 50-60 minutes per week and 20 minutes of APE on a consultation basis. The IEP also noted that STUDENT was expected to transition to kindergarten for the 1997-98 school year. The IEP team adopted goals relating to writing, mathematics, and reading readiness skills; prevocational skills; receptive and expressive language skills; and APE goals, including throwing ability, gross motor ability, and concept skills.

On April 11, 1997, Dr. Barbara Fineberg, an optometrist with Vision Care, observed STUDENT in her classroom. (District’s Exhibit No. 79) Based on that observation, Dr. Fineberg concluded that STUDENT did not need vision therapy because STUDENT’s class had a high teacher-to-student ratio and the activities in the class paralleled the activities Dr. Fineberg implements in vision therapy. Dr. Fineberg also noted that STUDENT was overactive, which would make vision therapy nonproductive, and that her eyes appeared aligned and she was able to track objects and people. Finally, Dr. Fineberg suggested that the most effective treatment would be patching.

On May 20, 1997, Shelley Banks, occupational therapist, conducted an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT for the District. Ms. Banks concluded that STUDENT did not need direct occupational therapy because she had the appropriate skills to function in kindergarten.

On June 28, 1997, Dr. Rosenow summarized the progress STUDENT had made. (Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 12) Dr. Rosenow stated that “she has made significant improvements in her binocular function, making it much easier for her to judge distance, know where she is in space when relating to other objects, and do extended near work especially when the task involves a cognitive task.” STUDENT’s visual acuity with glasses had improved to 20/20 in her right eye, and 20/25 in her left eye. Dr. Rosenow noted that “STUDENT can make many of the developmental milestones that all children go through, it is merely that her time frame is different, and it will take a longer period of time to reach those goals.”

For the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT enrolled in a regular education kindergarten class. At the IEP meeting in March 1997, the parties agreed that during the first month, STUDENT would continue receiving the related services she had received during the previous school year. Then, after the completion of one month in the regular kindergarten class, STUDENT’s IEP team would meet to review her related services and develop new goals and objectives. (Testimony of Karen Honkala and District’s Exhibit No. 1) The IEP meeting was scheduled to take place on October 13, 1997.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Expert Testimony -- Petitioner’s Experts

David Grisham

Dr. David Grisham is a senior lecturer and full clinical professor at the School of Optometry at the University of California, Berkeley. Dr. Grisham is also the chief of the visual skills/binocular vision clinic. Dr. Grisham has specialized in pediatric optometry since 1970.

Dr. Grisham examined STUDENT on August 13, 1996. Dr. Grisham had no contact with STUDENT’s teachers or other service providers. All information regarding STUDENT’s school activities was provided by STUDENT’s mom. According to Dr. Grisham, STUDENT has significant farsightedness with a mild astigmatism; has significantly immature ocular motility and binocular vision;(Footnote 3) and has amblyopia and strabismus.(Footnote 4) Dr. Grisham testified that the strabismus can be very effectively remediated with vision therapy. In addition to a standard vision examination, Dr. Grisham also conducted a perceptual skills assessment to evaluate STUDENT’s visual information processing skills. Dr. Grisham described visual information processing skills as those skills which allow you to get meaning out of what you see and correctly interpreting what you see. Visual information processing skills include spatial vision, visual-motor integration, and visual perception.

Dr. Grisham testified that STUDENT did not have any concept of left and right or the ability to project left and right to others. STUDENT was also quite distractible with poor attention. Dr. Grisham testified that he would consider STUDENT as inattentive rather than hyperactive. On the Beery Visual Motor Integration Test (Beery), STUDENT was only able to complete three-year-old target designs. Her motor execution was very poor. Based on STUDENT’s results, Dr. Grisham testified that STUDENT had problems in both perceptual and motor areas.

STUDENT was also administered the Test of Visual Perceptual skills (TVPS). The TVPS is a two-dimensional visual-perceptual skills test which does not include motor skills in the response, allowing the assessor to see if a student’s primary problem is perceptual. The TVPS evaluates seven perceptual subskills. STUDENT scored below the 10th percentile, showing a severe deficiency, in visual discrimination, spatial relationships, and sequential memory; and mild deficiencies in form constancy and figure ground. Dr. Grisham testified that visual discrimination is a reading readiness skill needed to recognize differences between forms, including letters; that visual sequential memory is needed to remember the order of letters and looking at works in context; that form constancy, the ability to recognize variations in forms, could be a weakness at the beginning stages of reading; and that figure ground, finding figures in a field, could affect reading.

During cross-examination, Dr. Grisham acknowledged that STUDENT’s cognitive level and attention problems may have affected her test scores. Dr. Grisham testified that he would not expect STUDENT to perform at age level on the Beery and that, with her delayed cognitive skills, she may have splintered skills as measured by the TVPS. Dr. Grisham also stated that lower cognitive ability can slow progress in vision therapy.

Based on STUDENT’s deficient visual-perceptual skills, Dr. Grisham testified that STUDENT needs vision therapy. Dr. Grisham recommended continued patching and exercises to address STUDENT’s visual acuity, suppression, binocular skills, and sensory-motor fusion. Dr. Grisham testified that he recommended two levels of therapy. One level would take approximately three or four months and would address binocular coordination, amblyopia and tracking and would involve daily home training exercises and weekly office visits. The other level would take approximately one year and consist of visual perception skills activities which could be conducted by family, tutors, teachers, or others working with STUDENT. Dr. Grisham reviewed the vision therapy services provided by Dr. Rosenow and concluded that the services provided by Dr. Rosenow were consistent with the activities he would have recommended. Dr. Grisham testified that the vision therapy activities provided by Dr. Rosenow addressed fixation, suppression, amblyopia, binocular integration, visual motor integration, fine motor coordination, visual discrimination, and spatial awareness.

Dr. Grisham acknowledged during his testimony that an occupational therapist may provide services that overlap in many of the areas addressed by vision therapy but that a developmental optometrist will take the therapy to “a higher level and truly integrate vision aspects.” Dr. Grisham also agreed that preschools may do a lot of perceptual activities that could help STUDENT. Dr. Grisham also testified that patching is a part of vision therapy but that without the vision therapy exercises, once patching ends, a child is likely to go back to old habits and the vision in the weaker eye would deteriorate.

Regarding the District’s vision assessment, Dr. Grisham testified that STUDENT does have visual impairments which will affect her educational performance, particularly the early stages of reading, writing, and math. Dr. Grisham also stated that the District’s vision assessment did not include any testing and appeared to be meant to evaluate children who are legally blind or close to it. Regarding Dr. Kim’s evaluation, Dr. Grisham testified that, while Dr. Kim addressed basic visual functioning, she did not address visual processing or efficiency.

Eldon Rosenow

Dr. Eldon Rosenow is an optometrist who has provided vision therapy for STUDENT since April 1996. The vision therapy has been provided in two different stages. Initially, Dr. Rosenow saw STUDENT once a month and prescribed vision therapy exercises for STUDENT to work on at home on a daily basis. This stage lasted until May 1997. The second stage of vision therapy started in August 1997. STUDENT sees Dr. Rosenow monthly and his therapist weekly. The program is expected to last six months. The primary focus of the second stage is visual perceptual and visual motor skills. During the office visits, Dr. Rosenow examines STUDENT to determine her progress and then develops new activities. Dr. Rosenow has never observed STUDENT in the classroom or in a school or group setting. Dr. Rosenow has also never discussed STUDENT with her teachers.

Dr. Rosenow first saw STUDENT in March 1996 and again in May 1996. At the time, STUDENT had full movement of her eyes, but had poor tracking skills. STUDENT’s left eye “drifted out occasionally” and was not working in conjunction with her right eye. Dr. Rosenow testified that he treated STUDENT with patching after her initial visit in March 1996, prescribed glasses, and began vision therapy exercises. The vision therapy exercises address such skills as ocular motility, visual acuity, eye-hand coordination, eye-body coordination, and gross motor.

With the patching and vision therapy provided by Dr. Rosenow, STUDENT’s visual acuity reached stability in November 1996 and were normal by April 1997. Dr. Rosenow testified that by April 1997, he saw improvement in eye-hand coordination and gross motor skills. Also the amblyopia had been completely resolved and the strabismus was resolved 90% of the time. Dr. Rosenow testified that, by March 1997, STUDENT’s fine motor skills were within the four-year-old range.

Dr. Rosenow testified that his vision therapy services would help STUDENT develop academic skills. For example, while STUDENT’s teacher would be the best person to teach STUDENT the academic part of reading, vision therapy would help STUDENT learn laterality, directionality and visualization. For gross motor skills, vision therapy would help because a lot of the activities address gross motor activities. Dr. Rosenow testified that if STUDENT does not develop gross motor skills, she will have difficulty maintaining eye alignment and eye skills.

Dr. Rosenow testified that his progress notes indicate that STUDENT has shown progress in motor skills, binocular skills, and acuity. Dr. Rosenow’s opinion regarding progress in these areas is based on STUDENT’s performance in the different activities she participates in. Dr. Rosenow acknowledged that factors outside of vision therapy, including home activities, school, and maturation, could contribute to the progress he has seen. Dr. Rosenow testified that STUDENT has not reached normal milestones, but with occupational therapy, tutoring, and “visual guidance,” she could be expected to reach those milestones within another year.

Dr. Rosenow testified that STUDENT no longer has patching, other than patching during certain vision therapy activities. In addition, STUDENT has the ability to control her eye movements and, as of July 1997, her eyes are working together. Dr. Rosenow testified that, although STUDENT’s eyes are working together, he will continue working on fusion skills for another six months to protect against regression. Dr. Rosenow testified that STUDENT continues to need reinforcement to maintain the skills she has gained. The reinforcement should include practice, close monitoring, support from school, gross motor activities, and work with her parents.

Dr. Rosenow testified that, with glasses, STUDENT’s vision is now normal. However, she continues to have “eyeteaming deficits” which affect depth perception. Poor depth perception could affect reading and “visual comfort” during various activities. Dr. Rosenow’s goals for the weekly, six-month program include firmly establishing eye-teaming skills and developing visual motor and visual perceptual skills to an age appropriate level. Dr. Rosenow testified that to reach these goals, STUDENT needs vision therapy, speech therapy, adapted physical education, occupational therapy, and “academic therapy” to help develop the skills needed in the classroom. Dr. Rosenow testified that the more practice STUDENT has the faster she will make progress.

Dr. Rosenow stated that vision therapy is the most effective method to correct eye teaming and visual perceptual deficits, but that school activities could also correct these deficits. Dr. Rosenow also testified that patching without vision therapy activities would result in regression of acuity because the vision therapy is designed to make acuity improvements permanent. Dr. Rosenow testified that STUDENT’s improvements in amblyopia and strabismus are not permanent.

District’s Experts

Esther Kim

Dr. Esther Kim is an assistant professor with the Department of Ophthmalogy at the University of California, Davis. Dr. Kim examined STUDENT twice in 1996 -- June 24, 1996 and again on July 11, 1996. Dr. Kim testified that STUDENT was shy and nervous during the first visit and, as a result, was difficult to examine. Dr. Kim’s diagnosis was that STUDENT had amblyopia, astigmatism, astigmatic refractive error, and a history of accommodative esotropia. Dr. Kim testified that she prescribed full-time patching over STUDENT’s right eye to reverse the amblyopia.

By STUDENT’s second visit with Dr. Kim on July 11, 1996, the visual acuity in STUDENT’s left eye had improved from 20/400 to 20/80, while the visual acuity in her right eye had remained stable at 20/40. Dr. Kim attributed the improvement in STUDENT’s left eye to the patching program.

Dr. Kim did not see STUDENT again after July 11, 1996. Dr. Kim testified that if she had continued working with STUDENT she would have recommended part-time patching to prevent a regression. Dr. Kim testified that STUDENT would probably need some patching until she is eight or nine years of age to make sure that her gains are permanent. According to Dr. Kim, by the age of ten, anything that is going to happen with the vision system will have happened.

Dr. Kim testified that she did not recommend vision therapy for STUDENT because her eyes were working together. Dr. Kim testified that, although she saw some evidence of exotropia (“eye going out”), it was small enough for STUDENT’s brain to handle. STUDENT’s eyes were essentially coordinating together. Dr. Kim testified that STUDENT does not need vision therapy to learn to read.

Finally, Dr. Kim testified that, even if STUDENT does not have sensory fusion she would still be able to learn to read. Dr. Kim stated that if STUDENT has learned to block one eye and see the world mainly through one eye, she has learned to function with just one eye. Dr. Kim testified that she saw STUDENT walk, drink from a bottle, and climb onto a chair with no problem. According to Dr. Kim, STUDENT would learn to read with vision in just one eye.

Barbara Fineberg

Dr. Barbara Fineberg is an optometrist in Southern California with a private practice, including the provision of vision therapy. In her private practice, Dr. Fineberg uses vision therapy to address visual sequential memory, visual discrimination, and visual motor integration. However, she does not always use vision therapy and, in many cases, refers children to their school to address such problems. Dr. Fineberg reviewed STUDENT’s records, including the assessments by Dr. Rosenow, Dr. Kim, Dr. Grisham, and Sandra Staples. Dr. Fineberg also observed STUDENT for approximately two hours in her special day class in April 1997.

Dr. Fineberg testified that STUDENT’s teachers were doing a good job of “developmental training” and that STUDENT did not need vision therapy. Dr. Fineberg stated that STUDENT’s visual perceptual deficits can be addressed in a school setting. According to Dr. Fineberg, there were a lot of activities in the classroom that were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, including readiness tasks such as scissors, colors, and gross motor activities; visual discrimination and visual motor tasks; and fine and gross motor tasks. These activities included coloring, cutting, a fishing activity, puzzles, wall decorations involving visual perceptual skills, and imitating the teacher during songs. Dr. Fineberg testified that she does not see any reason why STUDENT could not continue to progress without vision therapy.

Dr. Fineberg also suggested that, because of STUDENT’s poor attention and cognitive skills, the benefit she would receive from vision therapy may be limited. Dr. Fineberg stated that vision therapy is not effective with someone who does not understand why he or she is doing the activities. As a result, it does not make sense to start vision therapy with someone with a mental age below six years.

District’s Assessors

Sandra Staples

Sandra Staples is an orientation and mobility instructor employed by the District. Ms. Staples conducted a visual functional assessment of STUDENT in May 1996 to address two issues, depth perception in classroom situations and whether STUDENT needs vision therapy. Ms. Staples observed STUDENT in her classroom on May 2 and 3, 1996. On the second day of the observation, Ms. Staples served as an aide for STUDENT’s group to observe her more closely.

Ms. Staples testified that STUDENT needed frequent redirection and was easily distracted. Ms. Staples testified that she observed STUDENT participate in a number of near and far activities, including playground activities, slides, and standing in lines, and that STUDENT did not demonstrate any problems with depth perception. Ms. Staples also observed that STUDENT’s “distant vision function” was appropriate in that she visually located desired materials on the playground, imitated teacher gestures, and moved about the classroom safely. STUDENT’s “near vision function” was also appropriate in that she was able to participate in table top activities without bringing objects closer to her eyes or tilting her head.

Regarding reading readiness activities, Ms. Staples observed that STUDENT did have some difficulty. Sorting and matching was a difficult task, and she had an immature pencil grip. However, her self-help skills were, in Ms. Staples words, wonderful. Ms. Staples testified that STUDENT did not meet the criteria for a visual impairment because she did not have visual impairments that adversely affected her educational performance.

Ms. Staples observed STUDENT again in March 1997 in preparation for an IEP meeting. Ms. Staples testified that STUDENT’s visual functioning was consistent with her prior observations and that she did show some progress, particular in how she grasped a pencil. Ms. Staples testified also that STUDENT continued to need frequent redirection but that she was doing very well with the structured activities presented by the teacher.

Regarding the vision therapy activities utilized by Dr. Rosenow, Ms. Staples noted that many of those activities occur naturally in a preschool or kindergarten environment.

Steven Yund

Steven Yund is a school psychologist employed by the District. Mr. Yund conducted STUDENT’s triennial reevaluation in March 1997. The reevaluation included five or six classroom and playground observations. Mr. Yund testified that STUDENT was a fairly typical child except that she tended to avoid gross motor activities. On testing, STUDENT scored in the mildly delayed cognitive range on the Stanford-Binet IQ test, in the mildly delayed range in visual motor integration, and in the low average range in visual perception. Mr. Yund testified that STUDENT’s mild delay in visual motor integration is commensurate with her cognitive level. Mr. Yund also testified that STUDENT’s preacademic skills were at a level consistent with her age and developmental level. Mr. Yund testified that STUDENT’s relative strengths were visual perception, socialization skills, and daily living skills. Her areas of relative weakness were fine and gross motor skills. Based on his evaluation, Mr. Yund recommended an educational program focused primarily on fine and gross motor skills, because those skills were the areas in which STUDENT showed the most deficits. Mr. Yund’s recommendation would include speech and language services, adapted physical education, and either a special day class or pull-out assistance. Mr. Yund testified that he would leave occupational or physical therapy recommendations to persons specializing in those areas.

Regarding the higher ability scores recorded in the assessment conducted by the Valley Mountain Regional Center (VMRC), Mr. Yund noted that the VMRC used the 1967 version of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC) and that the revised WISC, updated in 1989, typically produces lower scores.

Shelley Banks

Shelley Banks is an occupational therapist employed by the Lodi Memorial Hospital. Ms. Banks conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT in spring 1997. As part of the assessment, Ms. Banks observed STUDENT during circle time and worked one-on-one with STUDENT with fine motor activities. Ms. Banks testified that she did not use a standardized evaluation, but instead conducted a functional performance evaluation of prehandwriting skills, fine motor skills, and visual motor skills.

Based on her observations, Ms. Banks testified that STUDENT consistently used her right hand, easily crossed the midline with both hands, demonstrated no hesitation in attempting tasks, and exhibited no signs of hypotonia. Ms. Banks also testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate any depth perception or vision problems. According to Ms. Banks, STUDENT did not have any problems drawing straight lines or drawing within boundaries. Ms. Banks testified that STUDENT exhibited appropriate skills to function in a regular education kindergarten class and that she did not presently need occupational therapy. Ms. Banks testified that peer models would be good for STUDENT and kindergarten activities would address her problem areas.

STUDENT’s Teachers/Instructors

Jonathan Grim

Jonathan Grim is an adaptive physical education (APE) specialist employed by the District. Mr. Grim first met STUDENT in 1994 and she was on his caseload through the 1996-1997 school year. Mr. Grim testified that he provided one-on-one APE services to STUDENT twice per week at the beginning of the 1995-96 school year but she did not adjust well to the one-on-one nature of the therapy. As a result, the IEP team decided in February 1996 that participation with other classmates would be more effective and modified STUDENT’s APE to a consultative model.

Mr. Grim testified that during the past year he had worked with STUDENT and another child once per week. According to Mr. Grim, he spent at least 20-30 minutes in STUDENT’s class each week during the 1996-97 school year. He also regularly talked with STUDENT’s teacher to see how she was doing and to ensure that the teacher was carrying out activities throughout the week. Mr. Grim testified that he also provided materials and equipment for STUDENT’s teacher to use with activities throughout the week. The equipment included a balance beam, stairs, hula hoops, and balls.

Areas in which Mr. Grim observed progress included walking on the balance beam, catching, stair climbing, walking on tiptoes, balancing on one foot, jumping, and throwing. Skills STUDENT needed help with included throwing overhand, running, ball bouncing, and hopping. Mr. Grim testified that many of the activities he has STUDENT do address areas similar to vision therapy, including eye hand coordination (playing catch and throwing at targets); depth perception (playing catch, basketball hoop, throwing bean bags at a waste can placed at different distances); eye foot coordination (balance beam, kicking balls); body image (balance beams, obstacle courses); and laterality and directionality (moving sideways and imitating him or the teacher).

Mr. Grim testified that, by March 1997, STUDENT had partially met the following APE goals listed in the September 1996 IEP: galloping and sliding to the right, jumping (could jump but would land with staggered feet), and throwing a ball. STUDENT had completely met goals relating to catching a ball and walking on stairs, but had not met a goal relating to hopping.

Doris Salley

Doris Salley is a kindergarten teacher employed by the District. STUDENT started spending thirty minutes per day in her classroom in July 1996 and beginning in November 1996, spent up to 1 ½ hours per day in her classroom. STUDENT came to Ms. Salley’s classroom with two other children and an aide. According to Ms. Salley, STUDENT’s time in her class was in the afternoon, and she participated in circle time, and math and counting activities in the kindergarten class.

Ms. Salley testified that STUDENT wanted to be like the other children and did not want to have anything to do with the aide. Ms. Salley testified that STUDENT was able to do the same activities as the other children, although she did make some adaptations because her cutting and writing skills were not quite as good as the other children. Ms. Salley testified that she initiated a perceptual motor program in her class in November designed to hold a “circus” in February. The program was designed to develop motor skills and included obstacle courses, balance beams, jumping patters, rolling and tumbling, and juggling objects with another student.

Ms. Salley testified, based on STUDENT’s involvement in her class, that STUDENT should do well in a regular education kindergarten class. Ms. Salley testified that, although STUDENT’s writing was shaky, it was legible and she could write her own name and trace lines.

Sarah Rouse

Sarah Rouse is a speech pathologist and teacher of a communicatively handicapped special day class in the District. STUDENT was one of her students during the 1996-97 school year. During the 1996-97 school year, Ms. Rouse had twelve students ages three to six years with a primary need in speech and language. Ms. Rouse testified that STUDENT’s biggest weaknesses were speech and language and fine and gross motor skills. Ms. Rouse testified that she typically had only five to eight students at a time.

Ms. Rouse testified that Mr. Grim usually spent about 30 minutes working with the children to whom he was assigned and then would also spend about 30 minutes discussing activities with her. Ms. Rouse testified that once APE was switched to consultation and group activities, STUDENT looked forward to APE and enjoyed the activities.

Ms. Rouse testified that her class schedule included circle time during which the children sang songs and participated in finger play, stories, and rhymes. The children worked on right-left awareness while reading stories; to address depth perception, the children throw objects at targets, run obstacle courses, and pop bubbles; to address visual tracking, the children read story and sentence strips and trace dotted lines with their finger or a pen; to address eye-hand coordination, the children string beads and play with blocks; to address gross motor skills, the children run, walk, skip, run the obstacle course, and play on swings, tricycles and jungle gym; to address visual discrimination, the students work on “same” and “different” activities. Ms. Rouse also testified that many of the vision therapy activities are done in her classroom.

Ms. Rouse testified that STUDENT’s strengths were her socialization skills and general knowledge. Ms. Rouse completed language samples each month and observed growth in STUDENT’s length and complexity of utterances. Specifically addressing the goals contained in STUDENT’s IEP dated September 1996, Ms. Rouse testified that STUDENT met one receptive language goal, and partially met three other receptive language goals; and met three expressive language goals, while not meeting three other expressive language goals.

Ms. Rouse testified that the biggest factor for any child to develop reading skills is development of oral language. Ms. Rouse stated that oral language is STUDENT’s primary weakness and that she needs intensive speech and language therapy. The speech and language services STUDENT received consisted of small group speech therapy twice per week with two or three other children. One session was in the classroom while the other session was in the speech and language room.

Ms. Rouse administered the Test of Language Development to STUDENT in March 1997 and based on the results, concluded that STUDENT had made a small amount of progress but she still had a significant delay in language.

Other Witnesses

MOTHER

MOTHER is STUDENT’s mother. MOTHER testified that since March 1996, STUDENT has improved in gross motor areas, including running, hopping on both feet, going up and down stairs, and playing on playground equipment; and in fine motor activities, including use of a pen or pencil, ability to trace lines or draw lines, and ability to color. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is unable to write her name.

MOTHER agreed with Dr. Rosenow’s recommendation for a more intensive vision therapy program because STUDENT had benefitted from the earlier vision therapy and still had delays in fine and gross motor skills.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT would be enrolling in a regular education kindergarten class for the 1997-98 school year and that her IEP team would review her program after one month to determine what level of services she needed.

Karen Honkala

Karen Honkala is a program specialist employed by the District. Ms. Honkala testified that the kindergarten curriculum is a developmental program designed to address gross and fine motor skills; readiness skills, including vocabulary building, name identification, sequencing, manipulatives, sorting, patterning, rote counting, number identification, and developmental reading. Ms. Honkala also indicated that the concept of left and right is taught in kindergarten. Ms. Honkala testified that many vision therapy activities are also done in kindergarten.

Ms. Honkala testified that STUDENT’s IEP team had recommended full inclusion for the 1997-98 school year because STUDENT had been successful with integration during the 1996-97 school year and progressed sufficiently to no longer need support. Ms. Honkala stated that STUDENT demonstrated that she was able to follow the activities and curriculum of a regular education kindergarten and had developed self-esteem and independence. Modifications to STUDENT’s program could include speech and language services, APE, and assistance in the regular education class if necessary.

DISCUSSION

Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for vision therapy services received from March 1996 through May 1997, and for an additional six-month program of vision therapy which started in summer 1997?

To determine whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for a related service obtained at her own expense, it is first necessary to determine whether the District provided an appropriate placement without the related services provided by Petitioner. State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. “Free appropriate public education” means special education and related services, provided at public expense, that conform with the student’s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specifically designed instruction designed to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialist instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 175,200.

Taken together, the IDEA and Rowley provide three factors for analyzing whether the District’s proposed placement is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:

(1) Did the District’s placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit? (2) Did the District’s placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

(3) Did the District’s placement meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The vision therapy STUDENT received occurred primarily during the 1996-97 school year and the beginning of the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, it is necessary to determine the appropriateness of STUDENT’s educational placement during each of these school years.

A. 1996-1997 School Year (1) Did the District’s placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

Ms. Banks testified that STUDENT had the necessary skills to succeed in a regular kindergarten class. Ms. Salley testified that STUDENT integrated well into her kindergarten class. Ms. Rouse testified that STUDENT’s language samples improved over the course of the school year and that she met or partially met most of her receptive and expressive goals. STUDENT’s IEPs, along with the testimony of Mr. Grim, establish that, although STUDENT did not meet every one of her goals and objectives, she did make progress on most of the goals contained on her IEP and substantially met or completely met many of them.

Petitioner contends that, while the District’s placement may have provided similar activities, those activities were not of the frequency or intensity STUDENT needed to benefit from her education. Petitioner contends that STUDENT needed vision therapy to benefit from her education. However, the evidence establishes that the District’s program provided STUDENT with sufficient fine and gross motor activities similar to those provided in the vision therapy that STUDENT would have benefitted even without vision therapy.

It is important to remember the standard adopted by Rowley. The Rowley Court standard is that a school district does not have to maximize a student’s potential. Instead, a school district is required to provide educational benefit. In the present case, based on STUDENT’s acquisition of fine and gross motor skills, as well as her communication and socialization skills during the course of the 1996-97 school year and STUDENT’s progress on her goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement provided STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1996-97 school year. Furthermore, with the amount of fine and gross motor activities provided through the District’s program, STUDENT would have received benefit without the vision therapy that was provided by her parents.

(2) Did the District’s placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no contention that STUDENT’s placement was different from the placement outlined in her IEP. Additionally, the Hearing Officer, upon a review of the record, finds no basis for concern regarding whether the District’s placement conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.

(3) Did the District’s placement meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

Petitioner contends that the District’s program for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year did not meet her needs because it did not provide the comprehensive and intensive activities that she needed. While Petitioner acknowledges that many of the activities in preschool and kindergarten work on skills similar to those in vision therapy, Petitioner contends that, due to STUDENT’s vision deficits, she needed the more intensive program provided by Dr. Rosenow. Petitioner also contends that the District should have provided some form of occupational or physical therapy to address STUDENT’s deficits in fine and gross motor skills. The District contends that its combination of adaptive physical education, placement in the communicatively handicapped SDC, and the preschool/kindergarten curriculum met STUDENT’s needs.

The evidence establishes that STUDENT had language needs and that she had significant delays in both fine and gross motor skills. There is also no dispute that STUDENT has some vision needs. The District’s own expert, Dr. Kim, prescribed a patching program for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that to address STUDENT’s needs, the District’s program must have addressed her language needs, fine and gross motor needs, and her vision needs.

During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was in a SDC for part of the day, a regular kindergarten class for part of the day, and received adaptive physical education and speech and language services. STUDENT’s language needs were met through the speech and language services provided to STUDENT, along with her participation in the communicatively handicapped SDC,

The services provided by the District during the 1996-97 school year provided STUDENT with a wealth of opportunities during her school day to engage in activities remarkably similar to those provided in the vision therapy she received from Dr. Rosenow. The testimony of Mr. Grim, STUDENT’s APE provider, demonstrated that STUDENT participated in activities, both directly from Mr. Grim and through his consultation with STUDENT’s teacher, that were designed to address STUDENT’s gross motor skills. As testified to by Mr. Grim, these activities addressed many of the eye-hand and eye-foot coordination skills worked on by Dr. Rosenow, as well as depth perception and other areas of gross motor skills.

Additionally, STUDENT participated in numerous fine and gross motor activities during the classroom activities in both the SDC and the regular kindergarten class in which she was mainstreamed. Ms. Salley testified that she instituted a perceptual motor program in her class and that, although STUDENT was not there for the entire program, she was able to participate in the activities when she was there and also participate in the circus which concluded the program. Ms. Salley described the program as including obstacle courses, balance beams, jumping patterns, rolling and tumbling, and juggling objects. Again, these activities are similar in nature to those provided in vision therapy and assisted in meeting STUDENT’s needs in fine and gross motor skills.

Finally, Ms Rouse testified regarding the activities which took place in her class, including right-left awareness, depth perception activities, obstacle courses, visual tracking exercises utilizing story and sentence strips, tracing lines, eye-hand coordination activities, and gross motor activities. While these activities may not have occurred with the daily frequency that the vision therapy activities did, the evidence establishes that they occurred with a frequency to meet the vision needs of STUDENT.

Regarding Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT needed occupational therapy, the District had an occupational therapy assessment completed in May 20, 1997. Petitioner’s experts testified that STUDENT needed to improve her fine and gross motor skills for her vision to stabilize and improve. The District’s occupational therapist, Ms. Banks, concluded, however, that STUDENT did not need occupational therapy and that she had the necessary motor skills to succeed in a regular kindergarten class. Based on the fine and gross motor activities STUDENT participated in during the 1996-97 school year and Ms. Banks finding that STUDENT had the necessary skills for kindergarten, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need occupational therapy to address her vision or motor needs. It is also important to note that both of Petitioner’s experts, Dr. Grisham and Dr. Rosenow, acknowledged that the vision therapy exercises involve activities that frequently take place in preschool and kindergarten classes. Those experts also acknowledged that those activities do not have to be performed by a “vision therapy” specialist or an occupational therapist, but can be implemented by a teacher, aide, family member, or other individual who works with the child.

Taken together, the activities that STUDENT participated in during the 1996-97 school year were sufficient to meet her needs. As already stated, STUDENT’s school day included numerous activities which addressed her fine and gross motor needs. Furthermore, the nature of her SDC class as designed for communicatively handicapped students and the additional speech and language services met her communication needs. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program met STUDENT’s fine and gross motor needs.

The District’s program did fail to meet STUDENT’s needs in one area. The experts agreed that STUDENT needed patching to improve the vision in her left eye. There is little reason to believe that, without patching, STUDENT’s needs could have been met by the program the District provided. she did. The expert testimony established that, without patching, STUDENT’s vision difficulties would have significantly impacted her ability to benefit from her education. The expert testimony establishes that patching provided STUDENT with an important opportunity to acquire improved and stable vision. Dr. Rosenow was the first professional to prescribe patching for STUDENT. That patching continued for some time. Because the District did not provide, in a timely manner, patching necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs and Petitioner was forced to unilaterally obtain the patching, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with patching.

Regarding the remainder of Dr. Rosenow’s vision therapy, however, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the 1996-97 school year. The evidence establishes that the District’s program for STUDENT provided her with educational benefit as evidenced by her progress on her goals and objectives, progress in her motor skills, progress in her language skills, and her achievement of the skills necessary to function in a regular kindergarten. The evidence further establishes that the District’s placement met STUDENT’s language, motor, and vision needs, with the exception of the eye patching, by providing a combination of language services and activities designed to enhance her motor development.

(B) 1997-98 School Year

The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s vision had stabilized in both eyes and by the beginning of the 1997-98 school year, she no longer needed eye patching. There is no evidence to suggest that STUDENT’s condition had changed from the prior school year. Based on the finding above that STUDENT did not need vision therapy exercises to benefit from her education during the 1996-97 school year, the fact that STUDENT no longer needed eye patching, and that STUDENT had obtained the skills necessary for kindergarten, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the additional vision therapy provided by Dr. Rosenow beginning during summer 1997.

ORDER

Upon presentation of proof by Petitioner, the Lodi Unified School District shall reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with eye patching provided by Dr. Eldon Rosenow. Petitioner’s right to reimbursement does not include any costs associated with vision therapy-related services, with the exception of the eye patching.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed only to the extent that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with eye patching.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 9, 1998 _____________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Patching is a program in which the stronger eye is covered by a patch for certain periods of time to force the brain to use the weaker eye. The anticipated result is an equalization of vision in both eyes. 2. Suppression occurs when the brain rejects a portion of a visual image when the visual acuity is significantly weaker in one eye. The brain cannot integrate the weaker image with the stronger image so the brain suppresses the weaker image and relies on the image from the stronger eye. Patching is a technique which can remedy suppression. 3. Dr. Grisham described ocular motility as the ability to move and focus the eyes accurately, to track moving objects, and to fixate on objects rapidly at different distances. Binocular vision is the ability of the eyes to work together. 4. Dr Grisham defined amblyopia as the developmental loss of visual acuity and strabismus as “one eye turning out.”