California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 17, 1997
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 166-97 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Long Beach Unified prevails on all twelve issues about a nonpublic school student's IEP and parent comprehension.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a related case (No. 97-97/139-97) and a separate district-filed due process request about placement, but it records no remand, vacatur or correction.
Summary
A non-attorney advocate filed this case for a 17-year-old high school student. He qualified for special education with a specific learning disability in reading and written expression. Under a May 1996 IEP, he attended the Alton School, a nonpublic school, and received transportation, counseling and extended school year services. The advocate told Long Beach Unified that neither she nor the parent would attend the IEP meeting. After the meeting, the advocate signed consent to the IEP. The parent, whose primary language is Spanish, later withdrew consent. She said she could not understand the document. The case raised twelve issues. They included whether the IEP was appropriate and complete, and whether the district had to write an IEP the parent could understand or pay someone else to write one. Other issues were whether the IEP had to list every public and nonpublic option and whether all documents had to be in Spanish. The advocate stopped taking part on the second hearing day after her request for a recess was denied. The district's special education director was the only witness. Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain found that the student received a FAPE under Rowley and that the IEP had all required elements. The law did not require an IEP written at the parent's reading level or a list of every option in the IEP. The district had provided interpreters, a Spanish translation and a list of nonpublic schools. The district won every issue, and all relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated demands that IEPs be written at a parent's reading level or list every placement option. The Hearing Officer looked to the required IEP contents, translation and oral explanation. She stressed that parents who skip IEP meetings lose a chance to understand the document and shape it.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1A. Did the District develop an appropriate and complete IEP? Sub-issue A: Did Student receive a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year?
Services matched the IEP, addressed the student's reading and writing deficits, and he was benefiting, so he received a FAPE under Rowley.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1B. Did the District develop a complete IEP for Student?
The May 1996 IEP contained the elements required by Education Code section 56345, including vocational education, extra time for proficiency tests, and ESY; the Hearing Officer noted it inaccurately described the student's regular education participation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Should the District provide an IEP document that the parent can understand?
Neither federal nor state law requires an IEP written at the parent's reading level, and no evidence showed the parent could not understand it; the parent was urged to attend future IEP meetings.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3. If the District cannot or will not provide an IEP document that the parent can understand, should the District pay to have a private party prepare an IEP document that the parent can understand?
Because no such IEP is legally required, the district need not pay a private party to prepare one.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 4. Should the District provide by law all public and nonpublic options in the IEP document?
Nothing in 34 C.F.R. 300.346 or Education Code 56345 requires listing all public and nonpublic placement options in the IEP.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5. Shall the District recognize Petitioner's claim that parent is primarily Spanish-speaking and learning disabled with a disability affecting her ability to comprehend legalistic documents, small print and handwriting? How?
The district recognized the parent's primary language and provided interpreters and a Spanish IEP; no evidence supported the claimed disability, and the law does not require documents tailored to a parent's functioning level.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 6. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend? Shall parent be subject to Ed. Code 56346(b) as the automatic consequence of refusing to sign documents she does not fully comprehend?
No evidence showed the parent was compelled to sign anything; her authorized advocate reviewed and signed the IEP.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 7. Shall the District comply with 56346 (meaning of 'informed, in writing')? How shall the District comply?
Petitioner neither alleged nor proved any violation of Education Code 56346(a), and the advocate gave written consent to the entire IEP.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 8. Shall the District comply with 56346 regarding 'components'? How shall the District write documents to facilitate disabled parent's right to consent or not consent to components?
Hearing officers resolve disputes and do not instruct districts on how to draft their consent forms.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 9. Shall the District comply with 56506(d) in writing as part of the IEP document? Shall the District require parent to inform District of all options, or shall District take responsibility for informing parent of all options?
Section 56506(d) does not require listing all options in the IEP; the district met its duty to inform through the IEP's continuum of options and a letter listing five nonpublic schools.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 10. Shall the District comply with 56345 (b)(3), (b)(5), (d) in writing as part of IEP documents? Must the parent specifically request District to comply?
The IEP addressed differential proficiency standards (extra time on the proficiency test), and nothing showed more was needed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 11. Shall the District comply with 56342 (transportation)? Must the parent specifically request District to comply?
No violation was alleged; the student received home-to-school transportation and reimbursement for ESY transportation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 12. Shall the District supply all documents for parent in both English and Spanish?
The district translated the IEP into Spanish, and no failure to provide required primary-language documents was proven or alleged.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; 34 C.F.R. 300.346; Education Code 56345; Education Code 56346; Education Code 56506(d); Education Code 56342
People named in the decision
- R.A. Drew, non-attorney advocate for Student
- Cynthia A. Yount, attorney for District, Parker, Covert & Chidester
- Eloise Thompson, director of special education and student support services; sole witness, Long Beach Unified School District
- Leticia Tellez Chevor, Spanish language interpreter
- Ms. Sanders, high school counselor; administrator/designee and SELPA representative at IEP meeting, Lakewood High School
- Alice Thompson, individual and small-group instruction teacher; special education service provider, Long Beach Unified School District
- Nancy Harris, special education teacher; District and SELPA representative at IEP meeting, Long Beach Unified School District
- Alton School, nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 166-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Individual Education Program CDS Code: 19-64725 District: Long Beach Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard on March 11, 1997, and on May 28, 1997, by Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by nonattorney advocate R.A. Drew, who appeared by telephone on both hearing dates. Ms. Drew stated that PARENT, STUDENT's mother, would not participate in this hearing on March 11, 1997. PARENT also did not participate in this hearing on May 28, 1997. However, Spanish language interpreter Leticia Tellez Chevor was present on May 28, 1997, to assist PARENT, had she appeared.
Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Cynthia A. Yount of Parker, Covert & Chidester. Eloise Thompson, director of special education and student support services, also appeared on behalf of the District.
On March 11, 1997, this due process hearing was conducted by telephone conference call, with the Hearing Officer, Ms. Drew, Ms. Yount, and Ms. Thompson on the line. When this hearing reconvened on May 28, 1997, at the District Office in Long Beach, California, the Hearing Officer, Ms. Yount and Ms. Thompson were present and Ms. Drew appeared briefly by telephone.
Petitioner called only Ms. Thompson to testify. The District called no witnesses of its own, calling only Ms. Thompson for cross-examination on May 28, 1997.
By Memorandum of Order dated May 29, 1997, both parties were notified that the Hearing Officer would consider written closing argument bearing either a postmark or facsimile date indicating that it was sent on or before June 13, 1997. The District submitted closing argument; Petitioner did not. After receipt of the District's closing argument, the record was closed.
Procedural Note
On the first day of this hearing, March 11, 1997, the Hearing Officer, Ms. Drew, Ms. Thompson, and Ms. Yount appeared by conference telephone call. On that day, Ms. Ms. Drew made legal argument and called Mr. Thompson to testify.
By letter dated April 23, 1997, the Hearing Office informed the parties and their representatives that this hearing would reconvene on May 28, 1997, at 9:30 a.m.
By letter dated May 22, 1997, Ms. Drew requested, among other things, a "a recess of hearings pending investigation" because "PARENT is considering asking the Hearing Officer, Carin Crain, to step aside on the basis of Prejudice." By letter dated May 27, 1997, the District opposed Ms. Drew's request. On May 27, 1997, the Hearing Office issued an oral order denying Ms. Drew's request. (Footnote 1.)
On May 28, 1997, at 9:30 a.m. the Hearing Officer attempted to reach Ms. Drew by telephone. Unable to reach Ms. Drew at the number she provided, the Hearing Officer next telephoned the Hearing Office to determine whether Ms. Drew or PARENT had requested a continuance or otherwise communicated with the Hearing Office. From this call, the Hearing Officer learned that Ms. Drew had left a voice mail message with the Hearing Office on the morning of May 28, 1997. This message did not indicate whether Petitioner intended to proceed, or request a continuance, but, rather, restated the concerns outlined in the letter of May 22, 1997. In response to Ms. Drew's voice mail message, a clerk from the Hearing Office left a voice mail message for Ms. Drew at approximately 9:20 a.m., which advised her that if she wished to request a continuance in this case she should either telephone the Hearing Officer and request the continuance on the record or submit a written motion to the Hearing Office.
Ms. Thompson reported that neither Ms. Drew nor PARENT had contacted the District.
The Hearing Officer telephoned Ms. Drew again, but no one answered. At approximately 10:30 a.m., however, the Hearing Officer reached Ms. Drew by telephone. During this conversation, Ms. Drew read the letter dated May 22, 1997 into the record. The Hearing Officer explained that a Hearing Officer ruled on this motion on May 27, 1997 and that the Hearing Officer would not reconsider it because Petitioner had produced no new supporting facts. Ms. Drew emphasized that Petitioner considered it improper to proceed with this due process hearing in light of his allegations regarding the Hearing Officer's "prejudice." Ms. Drew asked that the Hearing Officer not contact PARENT regarding this hearing because such contact "makes her anxious and may aggravate PARENT's dangerously high blood pressure." Ms. Drew also pointed out that Petitioner requested a "recess" rather than a "continuance." Although the Hearing Officer asked Ms. Drew to distinguish a motion for a recess from a motion for continuance, she refused to distinguish the two, indicated that she would hang up the phone, and then did so. (Footnote 2.)
After Ms. Drew hung up the telephone, the District stated that it wished to proceed with this hearing by cross-examining the only witness whom Petitioner called, Eloise Thompson. The Hearing Officer found that the parties were duly notified of the time, date, and place of the hearing by letter dated April 23, 1997. The Hearing Officer also found that despite Ms. Drew's knowledge that her motion for a continuance had been denied that she voluntarily absented herself from this proceeding without establishing good cause for doing so. Furthermore, Ms. Drew's warning regarding PARENTS's health prevented the Hearing Officer from telephoning PARENT. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer determined that the hearing would proceed as scheduled notwithstanding the absences of Petitioner, his mother and his representative.
ISSUES
With the exception of issue one, the Hearing Office has restated the Petitioner's issues verbatim.
1. Did the District develop an appropriate and complete IEP? (Footnote 3.)
2. Should the District provide an IEP document that the parent can understand? (Footnote 4.)
3. If the District cannot or will not provide an IEP document that the parent can understand, should the District pay to have a private party prepare an IEP document that the parent can understand?
4. Should the District provide by law all public and nonpublic options in the IEP document?
5. Shall the District recognize Petitioner's claim that parent is primarily Spanish-speaking, learning disabled, parent having a disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic documents, documents usually presumed "easily understood by the general public" (non- disabled persons), small print and handwriting? How? (Footnote 5.)
6. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend? Shall parent be subject to Ed. Code 56346 (b) as the AUTOMATIC CONSEQUENCE of refusing to sign documents she does not fully comprehend?
7. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner asks for definition of the fullest meaning of the word "informed," and emphasizes the words "informed, in writing"). How shall the District comply? Petitioner asks for specifics.
8. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner emphasizes the instructions regarding "components"). How shall the District write documents to facilitate disabled parent's access to parent's right to "consent to" or "not consent to" "components"?`
9. Shall the District comply with 56506 (d) in writing as part of IEP document? How must District comply? Shall the District require parent to inform District of "all" options public and non- public, or shall, instead, District take responsibility for knowing and informing parent of "all" options?
10. Shall the District comply with 56345 (Petitioner emphasizes 56345 (b) (3)); (b) (5); (d), in writing as part of IEP documents? How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
11. Shall the District comply with 56342 (Petitioner emphasizes the matter of "transportation").
How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
12. Shall the District supply all documents for parent in both English and Spanish?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old high school student who lives with his parents within District boundaries. A severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement in the areas of reading and written expression currently qualifies STUDENT for special education, which he currently receives from the Alton School, a state-certified nonpublic placement. (Footnote 6.)
By letter dated April 23, 1996, Ms. Drew informed the District that neither she nor PARENT would attend STUDENT's upcoming IEP team meeting. Instead, Ms. Drew directed the District to hold the IEP meeting and provide her with a copy of the proposed IEP. (Footnote 7.) The proposed IEP was developed during an IEP team meeting that occurred on May 15, 1996. Ms. Drew gave unqualified written consent for implementation of STUDENT's IEP on June 19, 1996. (Footnote 8.) Pursuant to the IEP of May 15, 1996, STUDENT was placed at the Alton School in September 1996. STUDENT attended the Alton School throughout the 1996-97 school year and has received the related services of transportation, psychological counseling, and extended school year. In March 1997, PARENT withdrew her consent for STUDENT's IEP; nevertheless, STUDENT continues to receive the services specified in his current IEP.
The IEP indicates that the District considers both Spanish and English to be STUDENT's primary languages, but he receives all of his instruction in English. (Footnote 9.)
SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY
Eloise Thompson
The District has employed Eloise Thompson for approximately eighteen years. Ms. Thompson has held several positions within the District and currently serves as the director of special education. Ms. Thompson holds both bachelor's and master's degrees in communicative disorders, has completed course work toward a doctorate and has earned various credentials.
Ms. Thompson stated that she did not attend the IEP team meeting of May 15, 1996, which resulted in STUDENT's placement at the Alton School. Ms. Thompson testified that both Ms. Drew and PARENT were invited to and were aware of the District's intention to convene an IEP team meeting. According to Ms. Thompson, Ms. Drew informed the District that neither she nor PARENT planned to attend the IEP team meeting and directed the IEP to proceed without them. (Footnote 10.) For this reason, STUDENT's IEP team met, developed a proposed IEP for him and mailed the IEP to Ms. Drew.
After Ms. Drew approved of STUDENT's IEP, (Footnote 11.) the District implemented it by placing him at the Alton School for the 1996-97 school year and providing him with the related services of transportation, counseling and extended school year. Ms. Thompson commented that transportation is the first designated instructional service listed on STUDENT's IEP. According to Ms. Thompson, its position on the page suggests transportation was offered to STUDENT rather than requested from the District. Ms. Thompson added that the District reimbursed STUDENT for transportation expenses his parents incurred during the extended school year.
After reviewing the IEP of May 15, 1996, Ms. Thompson concluded that STUDENT's IEP was created by a "properly constituted" IEP team with the exception that neither of STUDENT's parents participated. According to Ms. Thompson, Ms. Sanders, STUDENT's counselor from Lakewood High School, participated as the District's administrator/designee and SELPA representative; Alice Thompson, who was then STUDENT's individual and small-group instruction teacher and special education service provider, participated as STUDENT's then present teacher; and special education teacher Nancy Harris represented the District and SELPA.
Ms. Thompson stated that STUDENT's IEP lacks Spanish language goals, objectives, programs or services because his language of instruction has been English for at least the last five years. Ms. Thompson recalled that STUDENT may have been educated in Spanish five years ago when he attended school in a different district.
In Ms. Thompson's view, the District has complied with Education Code section 56506 (d), which grants parents the right "to be informed of the availability under state and federal law of free appropriate public education and all available alternative programs both public and nonpublic." Ms. Thompson stated that STUDENT's IEP lists all alternative programs that are appropriate for him. Ms.
Thompson added that the District supplied PARENT with a list of additional nonpublic placements. By Ms. Thompson's reading, Education Code section 56505 (d) does not require a district to provide parents with information regarding all public and nonpublic placements (whether within or outside of the District) in the IEP document. However, Ms. Thompson stated that if a parent wishes to have information regarding public and nonpublic placements, it will be provided during an IEP team meeting.
Additionally, Ms. Thompson distinguished placement options from program options. According to Ms. Thompson, Code of California Regulations section 3042 defines a placement as a "unique combination of facilities, personnel, location, or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs," a special day class, resource specialist program, or nonpublic school would be considered an educational program.
Ms. Thompson maintains that the District complied with Education Code section 56435 (b) (3) when it determined that STUDENT needed extra time to complete the District's Proficiency Assessment Requirements (PAR). Ms. Thompson observed that the goal is to have the student pass the PAR with the "fewest number of modifications," and predicted that if STUDENT's IEP team would have determined that he required additional differential standards to pass the PAR, these would have been added. Ms. Thompson noted that STUDENT has already passed the mathematics section of the PAR.
According to Ms. Thompson, STUDENT's IEP team wrote his IEP on the same form that the District uses to create all of its IEPs. Ms. Thompson testified that the District's IEP form was developed through usage to comply with special education law. Ms. Thompson added that when PARENT requested a Spanish translation of STUDENT"s IEP, the District provided one for her.
Ms. Thompson testified that no member of STUDENT's IEP team has proposed to alter his eligibility or to dissent to his program or placement. According to Ms. Thompson, STUDENT's progress reports and information from the Alton School staff indicate that he is "doing fine" and that his placement is appropriate. Ms. Thompson further testified that neither Ms. Drew nor PARENT has asked the District to consider an alternative placement for STUDENT or complained about the implementation of STUDENT's IEP or the type of special education or related services that he is receiving from the Alton School.
Although PARENT withdrew consent for the IEP that placed STUDENT at the Alton School, he continues to attend Alton and receive the related services listed on his IEP. Ms. Thompson could not recall whether the District requested a separate due process hearing to resolve the issue of STUDENT's placement before or after PARENT revoked consent for the implementation of STUDENT's IEP. Depending upon the timing of PARENT's withdrawal, Ms. Thompson speculated that the District may have relied upon Education Code section 56346 (b) as authority for the cross-filing, or may have cross-filed to meet its obligation to provide STUDENT with special education and related services.
The Alton School scheduled an annual meeting to review STUDENT's 1996-97 IEP but the meeting was later canceled because Petitioner indicated that he would not participate. Ms. Thompson commented that Petitioner proposed a mediated IEP team meeting, but the District declined to participate because, in the past, such meetings had proven unsuccessful.
From information conveyed by Ms. Drew, Ms. Thompson learned that PARENT withdrew her consent to STUDENT's IEP because she claimed not to understand the contents of the document. Ms. Thompson stated that she does not know why PARENT may not have understood documents that the District prepared.
Ms. Thompson acknowledged that Spanish is PARENT's primary language, and that she is "not clear" about PARENT's ability to understand English. For instance, Ms. Thompson observed that during the previous hearing, PARENT refused the services of a Spanish language interpreter.
Ms. Thompson also stated that the District has no evidence supporting Ms. Drew's contention that PARENT is learning disabled and functionally illiterate. Ms. Thompson asserted that the District is not in a position to determine PARENT's level of literacy. Moreover, although both PARENT and Ms. Drew, have asserted that PARENT is learning disabled, the District has received no verification of the existence of PARENT's alleged learning disability. Ms. Thompson added that special education law does not require the District to assess a parent's reading comprehension level, but rather to use language that is easily understood by the general public.
Ms. Thompson maintained that PARENT has not been "compelled to sign a document that she does not understand." In fact, Ms. Thompson noted that Ms. Drew, not PARENT, has signed documents pertaining to STUDENT's education, including the IEP of May 15, 1996. Ms. Thompson suggested that PARENT meet with District staff to identify which parts of the IEP she cannot grasp.
While Ms. Thompson is aware of Ms. Drew's proposal that the District create an IEP for PARENT at a third-grade reading comprehension level, she doubts that the District could write a legally adequate IEP at this reading comprehension level. Ms. Thompson pointed out that even if the District used third-grade vocabulary, the concepts that the IEP must communicate might be too sophisticated for a third-grader to understand.
Furthermore, Ms. Thompson maintains that the District affords parents the opportunity to seek clarification of documents. Ms. Thompson testified that if parents speak languages other than English, the District provides interpreters at the IEP team meetings to interpret the proceeding, answer questions, and provide a written translation of the IEP document. Or, if parents are illiterate, District staff explains the contents of the IEP document so that the parents understand it. Ms. Thompson added that District staff typically review placement, related services, present levels or performance, instructional goals and objectives with parents before they sign an IEP. According to Ms. Thompson, parents may also take the IEP document home to review it with an advocate, spouse, or friend before signing it. The District will also arrange for parents to visit a proposed school site when they require more than a verbal description of a proposed placement.
Ms. Thompson explained that if parents cannot attend the IEP team meeting, District staff will draft the IEP, and sent it to them for approval. If parents call with questions, District staff respond.
According to Ms. Thompson, unless a new IEP has been created and approved, the last agreed-upon IEP determines the student's placement. Ms. Thompson then described the role and contents of an IEP. Moreover, Ms. Thompson explained that if parents refuse to consent to all components of an IEP, those to which the parents have consented will be implemented. Parents may indicate the portions to which they consent either on the IEP document on by attaching a supplementary page. If necessary, District staff will help parents draft their dissenting statement. Ms. Thompson doubted that a form which would allow a parent to consent to our dissent from specific portions of an IEP would be more efficient.
DISCUSSION
1. Did the District develop an appropriate and complete IEP?
The Hearing Officer infers that Petitioner wished to have this question broadly construed to examine whether STUDENT received a free, appropriate public education and whether his IEP was legally adequate. For this reason, this issue has been divided into two sub-issues.
A. Did STUDENT receive a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year?
According to 20 United States Code (U.S.C.) section 1401 (a) (18), "free appropriate public education" (FAPE) means special education and related services that conform with the student's IEP. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child..." (20 U.S.C. § 1401 (a) (16).)
In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982) the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be available to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require a student be provided with the best available services or that the services maximize the student's potential. (Rowley, supra, at pp. 203-204.)
Therefore, to determine whether the District has provided a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will consider the following questions: (1) do the special education and related services comply with those stated in STUDENT's IEP, (2) are the special education and related services designed to meet STUDENT's unique educational needs, and (3) did STUDENT derive educational benefit from the placement? With these questions in mind, the Hearing Officer examines whether the District created an appropriate IEP for STUDENT.
First, Petitioner has produced no evidence which suggests that the District has deprived STUDENT of the special education and related services stated in his IEP. To the contrary, the District has established through the testimony of Ms. Thompson that the special education and related services that STUDENT receives comply with those stated in his IEP. Second, STUDENT's special education and related services are designed to meet his unique educational needs because his instructional goals and objectives address his deficits in written expression and reading comprehension. Third, Petitioner has not established that STUDENT is not deriving educational benefit from his placement.
On the other hand, Ms. Thompson testified that information that she received from the Alton School, suggests that he is "doing fine" in his current placement. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year.
B. Did the District develop a complete IEP for STUDENT?
Turning now to the question of whether STUDENT's IEP is complete, Education Code section 56345 (a) specifically describes what at IEP must contain. In relevant part, this section states, (1) Present levels of the pupil's educational performance.
(2) The annual goals, including short-term instructional objectives. (3) The specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil. (4) The extent to which the pupil will be able to participate in the regular education programs.
(5) The projected date for initiation and the anticipated duration of the program and services included in the individualized education program.
(6) Appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least on an annual basis, whether the short-term instructional objectives are being achieved. (b) When appropriate the individualized education program shall also include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(2) Vocational education, career education or work experience education, or any combination thereof, in preparation for remunerative employment, including independent living skill training for pupils in grades 7 to 12, inclusive, or comparable chronological age, who require differential proficiency standards pursuant to Section 51215.
(3) For pupils in grades 7 to 12, inclusive, any alternative means and modes necessary for the pupil to complete the district's prescribed course of study and to meet or exceed proficiency standards for graduation in accordance with Section 51215. (4) For individuals whose primary language is other than English, linguistically appropriate goals, objectives, programs and services.
(5) Extended school year services when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team.
Taking each element singly, the Hearing Officer will determine whether the IEP complies with the above-cited section. First, STUDENT's IEP reflects his present levels of educational performance in the classroom and on standardized tests of academic achievement. (Footnote 12.) Second, STUDENT's IEP contains both annual goals and short term instructional objectives in the areas of reading comprehension, study skills, behavior, and vocabulary improvement which address his educational deficits in the areas of reading and written expression. (Footnote 13.) Third, the specific special education instruction and related services that STUDENT requires are included in his IEP. Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT receives the related services of transportation, counseling, and extended school year. (Footnote 14.) Fourth, with respect to the extent to which STUDENT will participate in the regular education program, the IEP indicates that he will attend a nonpublic school for the entire school day. (Footnote 15.) Regarding this component, the IEP is inconsistent with STUDENT's actual educational program because STUDENT attends two periods of regular education classes at a local high school. Fifth, STUDENT's IEP indicates that May 16, 1996 is the projected date of duration and May 1997 is the anticipated date of evaluation of his programs and services, except for transportation, which the IEP indicates will end on October 30, 1996. (Footnote 16.) Sixth, STUDENT's IEP states objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determinations as to whether he is achieving his annual educational objectives. For example, to determine whether STUDENT is meeting his short-term improvement of reading comprehension objective, the IEP indicates that his teacher will observe him, STUDENT will submit work samples, and he will undergo "curriculum based assessment" and "criterion referenced testing." (Footnote 17.)
In compliance with section 56345 (6 )(b) (2) and (3), STUDENT's IEP contains vocational education training and "alternative means and modes of instruction" required for STUDENT to complete his course of study and pass the District's Proficiency Assessment Requirements (PAR). Listed as an option on STUDENT's IEP are 10 credits of vocational training through the Regional Opportunity Program. (Footnote 18.) As noted above, the testimony of Ms. Thompson establishes that the District is implementing this option and providing STUDENT with the vocational training stated on his IEP. STUDENT's IEP also indicates that he has already passed the mathematics sections of the PAR but has yet to pass the reading and language sections. STUDENT's IEP states that he "may receive extra time" to complete the reading and language sections of the PAR.
Subsection (4) of 56345 requires an IEP to contain "linguistically appropriate goals, objectives, programs, and services" for students whose primary language is not English. STUDENT's IEP identifies not one but two primary languages, Spanish and English. Although STUDENT's IEP lists Spanish as one of his primary languages, none of STUDENT's instruction takes place in Spanish. Ms. Thompson explained that STUDENT's IEP lacks instruction in the Spanish language because since he entered the District five years ago, STUDENT has been education in English.
Finally, Subsection (5) of 56345 mandates that a student receive extended school year services when the IEP team determines that they are necessary. Here, STUDENT's IEP indicates that he is entitled to extended school year services, and Ms. Thompson's undisputed testimony establishes that he has received such services. (Footnote 19.)
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP of May 16, 1996 complies with the relevant portions of Education Code section 56345. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District created a complete IEP for STUDENT.
2. Should the District provide an IEP document that the can understand?
While both federal and state special education law specify what information an IEP document must contain, neither requires that the document be written at the parents' level of reading comprehension. (34 Code of Federal Regulations (C.F.R.) section 300.364; Education Code section 56345.) Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that the record of this proceeding contains neither documentary evidence nor witness testimony which support Petitioner's contention that his parent could not understand his IEP document.
Therefore, except to the extent that modifications are required to comply with the District's duty, such as, to annually review and modify STUDENT's IEP, the District will not be ordered to otherwise alter it.
Finally, Petitioner's statement of this issue ignores the parent's vital role in the creation the IEP document. Rather than being a recipient of an IEP, both federal and state law consider a parent a necessary member of the team that creates a child's IEP. According to 34 CFR ch. 3, app. C question 60, there are two main parts of the IEP requirement...: (1) the IEP meeting(s) where the parents and school personnel jointly make decisions about a child with a disability, and (2) the IEP document itself, that is, a written record of the decisions reached at the meeting.
By letter dated April 23, 1996, Petitioner's representative advised the district "to proceed with the IEP meeting as scheduled. Neither parent, student, nor rep. will attend." (Footnote 20.) Both the IEP document and Ms. Thompson's testimony confirm that no one appeared at the IEP team meeting on Petitioner's behalf. The failure of Petitioner's mother to participate in STUDENT's IEP team meeting deprived the IEP team of her input and likely compromised her ability to understand the contents of the IEP document. For this reason, the Hearing Officer urges PARENT to participate in STUDENT's future IEP team meetings.
3. If the District cannot or will not provide an IEP document that the parent can understand, should the District pay to have a private party prepare an IEP document that the parent can understand?
Having found that the District is not legally required to provide an IEP document written at the reading comprehension level of a student's parent, the Hearing Officer finds that the District need not pay a private party to create such a document.
4. Should the District provide by law all public and nonpublic options in the IEP document?
34 C.F.R. section 300.346 and Education Code section 56345 detail what an IEP must contain. Nothing in either of these sections requires a District to list all public and nonpublic placement options in the IEP document. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not legally required to list all public and nonpublic placement options in STUDENT's IEP document.
5. Shall the District recognize Petitioner's claim that parent is primarily Spanish-speaking, learning disabled, parent having a disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic document, documents usually presumed "easily understood by the general public" (non- disabled persons), small print and handwriting? How?
Testimony from Ms. Thompson establishes that the District not only recognizes that PARENT is "primarily Spanish-speaking" but also has taken steps to make meetings conducted and documents written in English comprehendible to her. Ms. Thompson's undisputed testimony establishes that the
District provided translators at the IEP meetings which PARENT attended and provided PARENT with a Spanish translation of STUDENT's current IEP.
Moreover, Petitioner alleges that PARENT has a "learning disability that affects her ability to fully comprehend legalistic documents, documents usually presumed µeasily understood by the general public' (non-disabled persons), small print and handwriting," but he has produced no evidence of his mother's alleged learning disability. In fact, Petitioner's own representative acknowledged that while PARENT is probably learning disabled, she has not been assessed for a learning disability.
Even if a learning disability prevented PARENT from grasping documents considered µeasily understood by the general public,' small print and handwriting," special education law does not require the District to create documents that conform to the perceived or actual functioning ability of the parent. However the undisputed testimony of Ms. Thompson establishes that, if asked, District staff will read or explain documents to parents who lack the ability to read and comprehend documents considered "easily understood by the general public."
6. Shall the parent be expected/compelled to sign documents she does not fully comprehend? Shall parent be subject to Ed. Code 56346 (b) as the AUTOMATIC CONSEQUENCE of refusing to sign documents she does not fully comprehend?
The record of this proceeding contains no evidence which establishes that the District has compelled PARENT to sign any document that she does not understand. In fact, the letter that instructs the District to hold the IEP team meeting of May 15, 1996 and the IEP itself, both bear the signature of PARENT's representative, Ms. Drew, who presumably understands the document and, as her representative, will explain it to PARENT. (Footnote 21.)
Furthermore, Ms. Thompson credibly testified that parents are not compelled to sign documents that they do not understand. Ms. Thompson asserted that if parents indicate that they do not understand an IEP, the District allows them to review the IEP at home with an advocate, spouse, or friend before consenting to the IEP's implementation. The record reflects that the District followed a similar procedure in the instant case as it sent the proposed IEP document to Ms. Drew, who after reviewing it, consented to its contents and returned it to the District for implementation.
Because Petitioner has set forth no facts which establish that the District has compelled PARENT to sign documents that she does not understand, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
7. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner asks for definition of the fullest meaning of the word "informed" and emphasizes the words "informed, in writing". How shall the District comply? Petitioner asks for specifics.
Based on the Petitioner's statement of the issue, the Hearing Officer infers that he wishes to focus his inquiry on Education Code section 56346 (a), which states:
No pupil shall be required to participate in all of the part of any special education program unless the parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the individualized education program. If the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized education program, then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.
The record of this proceeding contains no evidence establishing that the District failed to comply with this section of the Education Code. Furthermore, Ms. Drew gave her written consent to the entire document, without proposing modifications or expressing dissent.
Petitioner has neither set forth facts which establish nor even alleged that the District has not complied with Education Code section 56346 (a). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
8. Shall the District comply with 56346 (Petitioner emphasizes the instructions regarding "components"). How shall the District write documents to facilitate disabled parent's access to parent's right to "consent to" or "not consent to" "components?
Referring again to the above-cited section of the Education Code, Petitioner apparently wants the Hearing Officer to develop a document on which parents might express their consent to or dissent from components of their child's IEP. Special Education Hearing Officers resolve disputes between parties; they do not instruct districts on how to draft their documents.
9 Shall the District comply with 56506 (d) in writing as part of IEP document? How must District comply? Shall the District require parent to inform District of "all" options public and non- public, or shall, instead, District take responsibility for knowing and information parent of "all" options? (Footnote 22.)
Education Code section 56506 (d) states that the District must extend to parents, (the) right to participate in the development of the individualized education program and to be informed of the availability under state and federal law of free appropriate public education and all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic.
This section does not require that the IEP document list "all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic." As noted above, 34 C.F.R. section 300.346 and Education Code section 56345 detail what an IEP must contain. Nothing in these sections requires a District to list all public and nonpublic placement or program options in the IEP document. For this reason, the Hearing Officer will not require the District to list all public and nonpublic placement or program options in STUDENT's IEP document.
However, Education Code section 56506 (d) clearly obligates the District to inform parents of "all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic." In this case, Petitioner has produced no evidence which establishes that the District has failed to properly inform his parents. To the contrary, the STUDENT's IEP document contains a list of both public and nonpublic placement options and the record of this proceeding includes a letter addressed to PARENT dated July 1, 1996, which lists five nonpublic schools for PARENT to visit and consider. Furthermore, STUDENT's IEP document establishes that the District informed PARENT of a continuum of program options available to STUDENT. STUDENT's IEP indicates that the members of his IEP team considered various programs for him, including regular education summer school, nonpublic school, Special Day Class, and independent study with Resource Specialist Program support. (Footnote 23.)
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with its duty to inform Petitioner's parents of "all available alternative programs, both public and nonpublic."
2. Shall the District comply with 56345 (Petitioner emphasizes 56345 (b)(3); (b)(5); (d), in writing as part of IEP document? How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
The issue of the District's compliance with 56345 (b) (3) and (5) was resolved in the discussion of Petitioner's first issue and will not be addressed again.
Education Code section 56345 (d) states,
Pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 51215, a pupil's individualized education program shall also include the determination of the individualized education program team as to whether differential proficiency standards shall be developed for the pupil. If differential proficiency standards are to be developed, the individualized education program shall include these standards.
STUDENT's IEP indicates that his IEP team developed differential proficiency standards to enable him to pass the PAR. The IEP states that STUDENT may be allowed extra time to take the PAR, and nothing in the record suggests that STUDENT requires more accommodations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with its duty under Education Code section 56345 (d).
3. Shall the District comply with 56342 (Petitioner emphasizes the matter of "transportation"). How shall District comply? Must the parent, on parent's own initiative, specifically request District to comply?
Based on Petitioner's statement of the issue, the Hearing Officer infers that he wishes to focus his inquiry on the bolded portion of Education Code section 56342:
The individualized education program team shall review the assessment results, determine eligibility, determine the content of the individualized education program consider local transportation policies and criteria developed pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 56221, and make program placement recommendations. (Footnote 24.)
Aside from stating this issue, Petitioner has not alleged that the District has failed to comply with this section of the Education Code. This District, however, established by the undisputed testimony of Ms. Thompson that STUDENT received reimbursement for transportation expenses incurred during extended school year and received home-to-school transportation from the District during the regular semester. For this reason, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
12. Shall the District supply all documents for parent in both English and Spanish?
As a preliminary matter, the record contains no evidence establishing that the District has deprived Petitioner's parent of documents written in either English or Spanish. In fact, Ms. Thompson credibly testified that the District provided STUDENT's English-language IEP to PARENTS's representative, and translated STUDENT's IEP into the Spanish language for PARENT.
As for other documents, Education Code section 56321 (b) (2) mandates that proposed assessment plans given to parents "be provided in the primary language of the parent." Moreover, Education Code section 56505 (a) extends the parent the right to receive "written notice...of his or her rights...in the primary language of the parent." Because Petitioner has not proven or even alleged that the District failed to comply with relevant portions of the Education Code with respect to the provision of documents in English and Spanish, the Hearing Officer finds for the District on this issue.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505 (I)
ORDER
All of Petitioner's request for relief are denied.
Dated: July 17, 1997 ________________________________ Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
Footnote l. A written order was issued on May 29, 1997. Footnote 2. Ms. Drew also hung up on the hearing in special education case No. 97-97/139-97 when the Hearing Officer denied her request for a continuance. It should be noted that under amendments to the California Administrative Procedure Act, effective July 1, 1997, hearing officers and administrative law judges, including Special Education Hearing Officers, will have the authority to initiate contempt proceedings and impose fees and costs for frivolous or dilatory tactics. Government Code section 11455.10-11455.30. Conduct that disrupts hearings or demonstrates disrespect for the hearing process will be subject to sanctions in the future. Footnote 3. Ms. Drew stated issue one in her letter of February 12, 1997. Footnote 4. Ms. Drew stated issues two through four on March 11, 1997. Footnote 5. Ms. Drew stated the remaining issues in her letter of March 14, 1997. Footnote 6. Respondent's Exhibit (Resp. Ex.) 1, at p. 1. Footnote 7. Resp. Ex. 2, at p. 1. Footnote 8. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 9. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 10. Ms. Thompson explained that to promote parental participation in the process of developing an IEP, the District sends the parent a written invitation and follows up with a reminder note or telephone call. Ms. Thompson pointed out that the District encourages parent to attend IEP meetings because their participation in the process of developing an IEP enhances their understanding of the IEP document and can provide the other team members with information about a student's nonacademic abilities. Footnote 11. Ms. Thompson testified that in 1993 PARENT informed the District in writing that Ms. Drew was authorized to sign documents such as IEP's on behalf of STUDENT and her other children. According to Ms. Thompson, PARENT has not withdrawn Ms. Drew's authorization. Footnote 12. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 2. Footnote 13. Resp. Ex. 1, at pp. 3-4 Footnote 14. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 15. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 16. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 17. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 3-4. Footnote 18. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 8. Footnote 19. Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1. Footnote 20. Resp. Ex. 2, at p. 1 Footnote 21. Resp. Ex. 1 and 2. Footnote 22. The Hearing Officer could not infer fro Petitioner's legal argument whether this issue concerns his placement or program. For this reason, the Hearing Officer will consider whether the District informed Petitioner of both his placement and program options. Footnote 23. Resp. Ex. 1, at pp. 9-11. Footnote 24. Education Code section 56221 (b) (5) states: (b) The policies shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following: (5) Transportation, where appropriate, which describes how special education transportation is coordinated with regular home-to-school transportation. The policy shall set forth criteria for meeting the transportation needs of special education pupils. The policy shall include procedures to ensure compatibility between mobile seating devices, when used, and the securement systems required by Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 222 (49 C.F.R. 571.222) and to ensure that schoolbus drivers are trained in the proper installation of mobile seating devices in the securement systems.
