California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 25, 2000
Student v. Whittier City School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1661-98 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Whittier City School District not required to reimburse parents for private Lindamood-Bell clinic program; all claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a 10-year-old boy with high-functioning autism and serious reading and language delays filed for due process against Whittier City School District. They asked the District to pay for an intensive Lindamood-Bell clinic program in Pasadena. The boy attended a learning handicapped special day class and received speech-language therapy, adapted PE, occupational therapy and aide support. Under a January 1999 interim mediation agreement, District staff trained in Lindamood-Bell methods gave him two hours a day of that instruction, one hour one-on-one and one hour in a small group. In summer 1999, the parents skipped the District's extended school year (ESY) program and enrolled him at the Pasadena clinic for four hours a day.
Hearing Officer Judy Hirano found that the District never gave the parents an assessment plan for the Fast ForWord assessment the IEP team had recommended. She called this a technical procedural violation that did not warrant relief, because his language needs were already being addressed. The District had no duty to respond to the parents' summer request for a Lindamood-Bell assessment. She found the District's program met the boy's needs and gave him educational benefit, including gains in reading and spelling. She held that District staff were qualified to use the methods, and that one-on-one-only instruction was not shown to be necessary. The District offered FAPE for 1998-1999, the 1999 ESY, and fall 1999. No reimbursement was ordered, and spring 2000 was not decided.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard to a request for a branded reading program from private providers. Steady progress, and District staff trained in the same methods, defeated the reimbursement claim. A provider's testimony carried less weight when her written recommendations did not support it.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District offer Petitioner an appropriate educational program during the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year?
The District violated Education Code section 56321(a) by never giving parents an assessment plan for the Fast ForWord assessment the IEP team recommended, but this technical violation did not justify relief. The District's LH SDC program, with District-staff Lindamood-Bell instruction and the proposed 1999 ESY, offered FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District offer Petitioner an appropriate educational program during the 1999-2000 school year?
The June 10, 1999 IEP offered FAPE for the first semester of 1999-2000. Because of a lack of evidence, the Hearing Officer made no determination for the second semester.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. If not, did a FAPE require a Lindamood-Bell program provided by Lindamood-Bell staff during the 1998-1999 extended school year?
Because the District offered FAPE, it was not required to fund a Lindamood-Bell program delivered by Lindamood-Bell staff for the 1999 ESY. Exclusive one-on-one instruction might be optimal, but it was not shown to be necessary.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. If not, did a FAPE require a Lindamood-Bell program provided by Lindamood-Bell staff during the 1999-2000 school year?
FAPE did not require a program delivered by Lindamood-Bell staff in the first half of 1999-2000. No determination was made for the second half.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood-Bell program he received from Lindamood-Bell staff during the 1998-1999 extended school year?
No reimbursement for the 1999 summer Lindamood-Bell clinic program, because the District offered FAPE.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood-Bell program he received from Lindamood-Bell staff during the 1999-2000 school year?
No reimbursement for the first semester of 1999-2000, because the District offered FAPE. No determination was made for the second semester.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief denied; no determination made for the second half of the 1999-2000 school year.
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992); Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a)
People named in the decision
- Angelica Dirtadian, clinical director, private provider; witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Newport Beach)
- Marian Rusting, learning handicapped special day class teacher; District witness, Whittier City School District
- Christina Riserbato, speech and language pathologist (communication specialist); District witness, Whittier City School District
- Karen Herbst, director of special education support services; District witness, Whittier City School District
- John Hess, executive director, SELPA; District representative at hearing, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program
- Nancy Nelson, communication specialist (speech-language), Whittier City School District
- B. Orton, resource specialist (assessor), Whittier City School District
- JoAnne Goodman, District staff contacted about assessment request, Whittier City School District
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private provider (Newport Beach and Pasadena clinics)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1661-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Designated Instructionand Services Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-65110 District: Whittier City Elementary Disability Type: Autism
Case Details This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Whittier, California, on September 14 and 15, 1999.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocate Matthew M. Pope. Also present on STUDENT'S behalf were his mother, PARENT, and, on occasion, his father, PARENT. Respondent Whittier City School District (hereinafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Darin W. Barber. Also present on the District's behalf was John Hess, executive director, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP).
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Angelica Dirtadian, clinical director, Lindamood Bell program; and PARENT, Petitioner's mother.
Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Marian Rusting, learning handicapped special day class teacher; Christina Riserbato, District speech and language pathologist; and Karen Herbst, District director of special education support services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
On September 10, 1999, the Hearing Office received Petitioner's motion to approve the telephonic attendance of witness Angelica Dirtadian at the scheduled hearing on September 14 and 15, 1999. The grounds for the motion were that Ms. Dirtadian was involved with the day-to-day operation of the Newport Beach Lindamood Bell office and her travel time would exceed the time she would spend testifying. Also on September 10, 1999, the District filed an opposition to the motion based, essentially, on the right of direct confrontation and the opportunity to observe the demeanor of a witness. On September 13, 1999, the Hearing Office denied the motion based upon Petitioner's failure to present a persuasive reason for the witness's telephonic appearance.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District offer Petitioner an appropriate educational program during the following periods:
a. the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year? b. the 1999-2000 school year?
2. If not, did a FAPE require a Lindamood-Bell program provided by Lindamood-Bell staff during the following periods:
a. the 1998-1999 extended school year?
b. the 1999-2000 school year?
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood-Bell program he received from Lindamood-Bell staff during the following periods:
a. the 1998-1999 extended school year?
b. the 1999-2000 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 10-year-old boy who is eligible for special education because of high-functioning autism. He was diagnosed with autism at approximately age 5-1/2 when he was assessed for Regional Center eligibility. He has an IQ of 107. He also suffers from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and has taken medication for it.
At age three, STUDENT exhibited an oral expressive delay and deficits in social interactions. When STUDENT was diagnosed with high-functioning autism in 1994, his social and communication skills were found to be at approximately the borderline level of functioning. The psychologist who assessed him recommended a speech and language evaluation and class placement in a small-group environment with frequent one-on-one instruction. STUDENT also has low muscle tone and poor upper body and hand strength. Since kindergarten, STUDENT has been enrolled in a special education program and has been receiving speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education services pursuant to an individualized education program.
In kindergarten, STUDENT was in a full inclusion regular education placement with resource specialist and in-class aide support during part of the day. He showed progress in all areas, including language areas. In grade 1, he successfully continued the same placement without curriculum modifications. In grade 2, he continued in a full inclusion placement but with support from a severely handicapped (SH) special day class teacher. His goals and objectives were to improve reading and writing skills and classroom behavior.
A January 30, 1997 IEP sets forth the results of the triennial review when STUDENT was age 8 and in grade 2. He exhibited a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement due largely to a language-processing difficulty. Because his profile was consistent with a child with a learning disability, he required specific remediation of weak areas and classroom accommodations, and the SH inclusion program was no longer appropriate. His weaknesses were in auditory memory and auditory comprehension of language, and his areas of need were identified as auditory perception, expressive language, reading decoding, basic math, gross motor, and classroom behavior. Learning problems and attention and hyperactivity were significant areas for STUDENT. He had been diagnosed with ADHD.
In March 1997, STUDENT'S placement was changed from a full inclusion to a regular education program with resource specialist program (RSP) support. Communication program and APE services, OT, and aide support were to be provided. The IEP states that because his needs were no longer severe and pervasive to require inclusion support in all adaptive and academic areas, he now required remediation in areas of need related to auditory memory and auditory comprehension which affected reading decoding and math difficulties. The goals and objectives were to improve auditory comprehension and decoding skills and reading comprehension.
A May 9, 1997 report by resource specialist B. Orton sets forth assessment results when STUDENT was age 8 and in grade 2. The report states that it was difficult to assess STUDENT due to his lack of concentration, impulsivity and distractibility. On the KTEA, STUDENT achieved math scores in the average range and reading and spelling scores in the low range, but he had not wanted to continue with the reading and spelling portions of the test. The report notes that distractibility and attention problems would affect his academic progress. STUDENT'S placement for his grade 3 school year was changed to an LH SDC with mainstreaming for 35 percent of the time.
1998-1999 SCHOOL YEAR
A January 14, 1998 IEP sets forth STUDENT'S educational program from January 1998 to January 1999. The IEP continues his LH SDC placement, with mainstreaming 40 percent of the time in regular education art, music, science, and math as appropriate. The IEP provides for 60-minute sessions of communication program twice a week and of OT and APE once a week. It provides for an aide one hour per day and for an ESY program. The IEP identifies as his educational needs a small-group setting, decoding, comprehension, practical math, written language, and auditory comprehension. Behavioral concerns were that he was easily distracted and needed constant reminders to focus on tasks. The IEP states that he will be assessed to determine the appropriateness of the Fast ForWord program. The goals and objectives were to improve written language skills, skills related to telling time and counting coins, reading comprehension, sight vocabulary, gross motor skills, and auditory comprehension. A January 12, 1998 OT report sets forth STUDENT'S progress toward OT goals related to sensory processing and self-regulation; neuromotor and gross motor function; fine motor skills; self-care skills; and social, play, and communication skills.
A January 14, 1998 report by STUDENT'S LH SDC teacher M. Rusting sets forth the annual assessment results when STUDENT was age 9 and in grade 3. On the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills, he was reading orally at a preprimer level with 97 percent accuracy and read 50 percent of the words at a primer level. In his class he was working on Reading Mastery Program Level I Unit 125 and was showing more persistence in attempting to sound out words and understand sentences and stories. In written language, he was able to write sentences using inventive spelling but did not always use periods at the end of sentences. He scored 70 percent on a grade 1 spelling list. STUDENT was in a regular education math class, with a one-on-one aide, but most of the time did not complete his work without the teacher's or aide's help. STUDENT was also getting additional math assistance in his LH SDC. He could give the total for sets of pennies, nickels and dimes up to $.50 and was able to count by 5s but was still working on telling time to a 5-minute interval. STUDENT was also in regular education classes, with a one-on-one aide, for science, art and PE but would do nothing if the aide was unavailable. The report states that STUDENT did well in a structured classroom with a specific routine. The suggested placement was an LH SDC with goals in reading, reading comprehension, written language, and practical math.
A January 14, 1998 report by communication specialist Nancy Nelson states that STUDENT participated in a speech group composed of his age- and grade-level peers. He had made limited progress toward his goals. He could identify, with over 90 percent accuracy, items or pictures of items when presented by name and category but could identify items by attribute or function only approximately 50 percent of the time. He continued to have difficulty providing responses to "wh" questions and problem-solving situations. He could answer teacher-initiated questions with approximately 50 percent accuracy. He used appropriate turn-taking conversational skills but was distractible, although he could refocus easily with a prompt. Because of significant delays in auditory perception and receptive language development, he continued to qualify for the communication program. Recommendations were communication program participation twice weekly for a total of 60 minutes, with auditory comprehension as a goal area.
By a July 23, 1998 letter, STUDENT'S mother requested that the District have STUDENT assessed by Lindamood-Bell. She stated that STUDENT continued to show significant delays related to his academic needs and requested that STUDENT be placed in the Lindamood-Bell program.
On August 11, 1998, STUDENT was evaluated at Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes in Newport Beach. A Treatment Description report by Angelica Dirtadian, Ed.M., clinical director, revealed the presence of primary neurophysiological dysfunctions in phonemic awareness, which contributes to a disability in reading and spelling; symbol imagery, which contributes to a disability in word recognition, spelling and contextual reading fluency; and concept imagery, which contributes to a disability in oral and written language comprehension and expression. The DSM-IV diagnosis was Mixed Receptive- Expressive Language Disorder. According to Ms. Dirtadian, STUDENT had a dysfunction in perceiving groups of sounds and conceptualizing when and where a sound is added, substituted, omitted, or shifted in a syllable. He had difficulty holding sequences of letters in visual memory, making it difficult to self-correct reading and spelling errors. Moreover, he processed only parts of the language that he read or heard but not the whole, thereby having difficulty in connecting and interpreting language concepts.
The results of the August 11, 1998 Lindamood-Bell preliminary pretesting, when STUDENT was age 9 years, 6 months, and in grade 4, were, in part, as follows. On the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS), STUDENT had a less than 2 percentile score. His Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude results were a mental age of 5-3 for Verbal Absurdities and a mental age of 7-6 for Visual Attention Span for Letters. On the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude-2, he obtained a 1 standard score, at the .5 percentile, for Oral Directions. His Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-3 results were as follows: Word Opposites, 2 standard score, at the less than 1 percentile; and Design Reproduction, 5 standard score, at the 5 percentile. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test III, STUDENT achieved a mental age of 5-7, at the 1 percentile. On the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, his Word Attack score on Form G was a 6-5 mental age, which was at the 1.2 grade level and 1 percentile. On the Slosson Oral Reading Test-Revised, STUDENT scored a .7 grade level score, at the 1 percentile. On the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised/3, STUDENT obtained the follow scores: reading, grade 1 level, at the 1 percentile; spelling, grade K level, at the 1 percentile; and arithmetic, grade 2 level, at the 13 percentile. On the Gray Oral Reading Test, Revised-3, his standard scores for Rate, Accuracy, and Passage were all 2, at the grade 1.5 level and .5 percentile. On the same test, his Comprehension standard score was 1, at the grade 1.5 level and .5 percentile. On the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test, STUDENT achieved a 42 score. On the Informal Tests of Writing, he obtained scores of 23/32 for Sound/Symbol Associations and 0/3 for Nonsense Spelling.
An October 6, 1998 document entitled "Parental Observations," prepared by STUDENT'S mother, states that STUDENT'S ADHD medication was discontinued because of decreased appetite, insomnia, and other side effects. The report states that STUDENTwas enrolled in an LH class with a teacher, classroom aide, and approximately 15 students. The parent suggested as possible IEP goals and objectives for an upcoming IEP meeting getting STUDENT to perform academically closer to his ability level; addressing reading and reading comprehension, listening comprehension, critical thinking, and following directions; and expanding STUDENT'S comfort level to include friendships beyond his classmates. Desirable elements of an educational program for STUDENT were a one-on-one Lindamood- Bell program four hours daily, five days per week; as much mainstreaming as possible; and speech therapy.
An October 7, 1998 letter from Ms. Dirtadian of Lindamood-Bell recommends an intensive treatment of 4 hours per day for at least 16 weeks. To address STUDENT'S weaknesses in concept imagery, phonemic awareness, and visual memory, she recommended the following programs: Visualizing and Verbalizing for Language Comprehension and Thinking (VV); Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing for Reading, Spelling and Speech (LiPS); Seeing Starts: Symbol Imagery for Sight Words and Spelling (SI), and Drawing with Language.
An October 15, 1998 IEP states that the meeting was requested by the parent to address a concern about increasing STUDENT'S reading and language skills. The IEP team agreed that he required a structured phonics-based program with a visualizing and verbalizing component and also a concentrated approach to auditory processing. His educational needs included a small-group setting and improvement in decoding, comprehension, practical math, written language, and auditory processing. His distractibility and need to be redirected impeded his learning.
The IEP continued STUDENT'S LH SDC placement, with regular education classes in art, science, social studies, and PE comprising 25 percent of his time. Weekly he was to have communication program for 120 minutes, APE for 60 minutes, and OT for 60 minutes. The IEP also provides for a classroom aide one hour a day to redirect him and help him maintain his attention. Supplementary aids and services include access to a computer. Classroom modifications to be provided are a highly structured reading program, use of District SDC curriculum, repetition of directions, and shortened assignments. The IEP states that a highly structured reading program that was used for one semester had resulted in academic reading progress for STUDENT. He required a reading instruction program that included visualizing and verbalizing techniques and symbol and cognitive concepts. The IEP states that the IEP team recommended that school staff be trained in techniques to assist STUDENT in increasing his reading skills. The IEP also states that the parent had requested an intensive metacognitive and reading instruction program of Lindamood-Bell, but that the District had indicated that two of its teachers would be trained in the Lindamood-Bell LiPS and VV programs.
On November 25, 1998, STUDENT'S parents filed for a due process hearing. Their hearing request stated that the District had failed to follow through on a Fast ForWord program and had disregarded the results of the Lindamood-Bell assessment that the parents had obtained. Because STUDENT was a fourth-grader with average intelligence and still could not read, the parents sought the Lindamood- Bell program for their son.
On January 28, 1999, the parties entered into an interim mediation agreement. (Footnote 2) The District agreed to provide the Lindamood-Bell program to STUDENT5 days a week for two hours (1 hour individual and 1 hour small-group instruction). STUDENT would also be provided with the Lindamood- Bell program in the 1999 ESY for four hours per day, 5 days a week, in a small group not to exceed 4 students. If necessary, the District staff would contract directly with Lindamood-Bell for more resources (i.e., materials, people, and training).
A February 10, 1999 report by communication specialist Nancy Nelson states that STUDENT was receiving communications services twice weekly with a small group of age- and grade-level peers. The group worked on producing sounds, using appropriate grammar and syntax, understanding basic concepts, improving listening skills, and developing receptive and expressive language and pragmatics (social language skills). The report states that STUDENT had met several of his communication goals established the prior year. He was able to identify items by name, category, associated items, attribute and function at 80 percent accuracy. He showed growth in providing on- target responses to "wh" questions but still had problems with "why" and "how" questions, which often address a problem-solving situation, an area of difficulty for STUDENT. His accuracy improved when a question was rephrased or explained when necessary.
On the Test of Problem Solving, STUDENT achieved a 41 total standard score, at the 6 percentile and 8-1 age equivalent level. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III, STUDENT had a 75 standard score, at the 5 percentile and 5-8 age equivalent level. His score indicated a continuing significant delay in development of his receptive/listening vocabulary and auditory processing skills. STUDENT'S expressive language ability, including grammar, syntax and articulation, and spoken vocabulary were at age-level expectancies. He used appropriate turn-taking conversational skills during group activities and asked appropriate questions. However, he was distractible and tended to "drift off," although he could refocus easily with a prompt. Because of his continued significant delays in auditory perception and receptive language development, STUDENT continued to qualify for communication program services.
A February 16, 1999 report by LH SDC teacher Ms. Rusting when STUDENT was age 10 and in grade 4, sets forth the assessment results in reading, written language, and math. He was working at a grade
3 level in math and did fairly well with concrete concepts and math problems. The report states that STUDENTwas showing very good progress in reading. He was using phonics and context clues to figure out words and could self-correct. However, in a small-group setting, he needed frequent reminders to focus on the story and words being presented. The results of the reading and written language assessment are essentially summarized in Ms. Rusting's May 7, 1999 report, discussed below. The February 16 report states that STUDENT was mainstreamed, with a one-on-one aide, for science, music and art. Without the aide's assistance, STUDENT was easily distracted and made noises to entertain himself. He had made more friends during the year rather than relying on one friend as he did the previous year. STUDENT needed a structured, predictable setting and was easily distracted and had difficulty with change. He was also working on the "Earobics" computer program requested by his mother. He enjoyed working on the auditory and phonemic awareness activities and had "topped out" on activities including syllables, rhyming words, vowel sounds, and sound sequencing. His suggested placement was a LH SDC with goals in reading, reading comprehension, written language, and practical math.
A February 16, 1999 IEP, signed by the parent, was developed when STUDENT was age 10 and in grade 4. It states that in December STUDENT attended an Auditory Integration Training for eight days. Current teacher reports were that he had made significant academic progress during the past year. The parent's concerns were to increase socialization skills and to track implementation of the Lindamood-Bell program. The IEP states that STUDENT'S math computational skills had improved and the use of "TouchMath" had been beneficial. His regular education teacher reported that he was able to stay focused when the assignment was to read a book but had difficulty attending to the task of journal writing. With assistance in staying focused, STUDENT was able to participate in science and art activities.
The IEP states that pursuant to the January 28, 1999 mediation agreement, STUDENT would receive instruction using Lindamood-Bell techniques (one hour of one-on-one and one hour of small-group instruction per day). A weekly reporting sheet was developed to track the Lindamood-Bell services provided to STUDENT. STUDENT'S mother presented an OT report indicating that STUDENT still exhibited poor upper body strength. The District agreed to refer STUDENT to California Children's Services (CCS) to explore the possibility of providing physical therapy to work on endurance and strengthening.
The IEP states that STUDENT would continue his LH SDC placement, with regular education for 15 percent of the time in modified PE, lunch, recess, school day activities, and academic areas as appropriate. He was to continue to receive communication program and APE services. The IEP provides for classroom aide support for one hour per day, an ESY program, and a CCS referral. The IEP states that STUDENT needed a structured setting and schedule, reminders to focus on the task at hand, seating near the teacher if possible, and positive reinforcement throughout the school day. He was to receive study aids and manipulatives. He also was to receive short instructions with the opportunity for repetition, visual aids, multisensory instruction when appropriate, and minimal distractions. The IEP sets forth goals and objectives for reading comprehension, reading vocabulary, listening comprehension, expressive language, practical math, and gross motor skills. The IEP states that the program and services would continue until June 15, 1999, when the Lindamood- Bell program provided by the District would be reviewed.
A May 7, 1999 report was prepared by LH SDC teacher Ms. Rusting when STUDENT was age 10 years, 4 months, and in grade 4. According to the report, STUDENT was receiving Lindamood-Bell instruction using the LiPS, Seeing Stars, and Visualization-Verbalization techniques. He had a 30-minute small group session with the teacher in the morning and 1-1/2 hours in the afternoon with an aide or speech specialist and teacher-supervised small-group sessions. The report states that STUDENT was showing steady progress in reading. Reading Mastery, a phonetic reading program, was still being used with STUDENT in a small group in addition to the Lindamood-Bell program. On the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills, he had good phonetic skills and could sound out words at a low grade 3 level. He was reading orally at a grade 2-2 level with 97 percent accuracy (compared to a preprimer level in January 1998 and a grade 1-2 level in February 1999). He read 60 percent of the words at the grade 2 level (an improvement from a primer level a year ago). He read 334 out of 400 basic sight words (an increase from 143 in January 1998). In reading comprehension, STUDENTscored 100 percent at the grade 2-1 level and 80 percent at the grade 2-2 level (an improvement from 20 percent at the primer level in January 1998 and 80 percent at the grade 1-2 level in February 1999. On the San Diego Quick Assessment, he scored at the grade 2 level , with no change since February 1999.
STUDENT achieved the following scores on the following tests:
Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised 3 (WRAT-R3)
8/11/98 2/11/99 5/20/99 Reading Grade 1 Grade 3 Grade 3
Spelling K Grade 2 Grade 2
Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised Form G (WRMT-R Form G):
8/11/98 2/11/99 5/25/99 Word Attack Grade 1.2 Grade 2.9 Grade 3.2 Word Identification Grade 1.9 Grade 2.1 Passage Comprehension Grade 2.1 Grade 2.5
In written language, STUDENT was able to write four sentences using 80 percent correct spelling and use correct capitalization and periods at ends of sentences. He achieved a grade 2 level spelling score on the Brigance and WRAT-R. He could print his first and last name and had mastered his address. He was learning cursive writing. The report noted that since February 1999, STUDENT had been receiving instruction using Lindamood-Bell methods. Because he was comfortable with daily structure, it took him a while to adjust to the Lindamood-Bell routine. He had difficulty attending to the vocabulary "Vanilla" activities but used the visualization and verbalization techniques. He had increased his vocabulary using "flash cards" with his own picture and sentences. The report recommended an LH SDC placement with goals in reading, reading comprehension, written language, and practical math.
A June 1, 1999 report by communication specialist Christina Riserbato, M.A., sets forth the results following implementation of the Lindamood-Bell program in the communication program services provided to STUDENT. The Visualizing and Verbalizing (VV) program was the primary focus to improve language comprehension and thinking skills. Ms. Riserbato stated that STUDENT'S difficulties with comprehension skills at his current level in the program had prevented progress. His distractibility and poor retention skills also had significantly interfered with progress. Parts of the Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing program (LiPS), involving tracking sounds in syllables and words, and the Seeing Stars program, using syllable cards, had been incorporated to reinforce STUDENT'S phonics skills. Ms. Riserbato stated that STUDENT'S ability to read words accurately improved when he could focus on a specific word without distracting visual stimuli. The goal in the communication area was that STUDENT would be able to provide appropriate solutions to problems presented orally with visual cues at a 60 percent level as measured by the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS). On a recent administration of the TOPS, STUDENT achieved a 30 standard score, at the 1 percentile and 5-4 age-equivalent level. According to Ms. Riserbato, STUDENT'S TOPS results were at approximately the 45 percent level, and his total test score was much lower than that obtained in February 1999. She noted that distractibility can have a significant adverse effect on TOPS performance.
Ms. Riserbato also stated that STUDENT frequently asked when sessions would end and how much longer the program would continue and stated more than once that he wanted to return to his former communication group. He often was unwilling to participate in specific program tasks. Ms. Riserbato recommended that STUDENT continue in the communication program to address comprehension and problem-solving skills, but that the particular components of the program should be discussed with the IEP team because his comprehension level, attention and retention/recall skills, and lack of motivation hindered progress in the current program design.
On June 3, 1999, when STUDENT was age 10 years, 4 months, and in grade 4, he was assessed by Lindamood-Bell before he started the Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Clinic. The preliminary pretesting results were as follows. On the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude, STUDENT exhibited a mental age of 5-9 for Verbal Absurdities. On the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-2, he achieved a 2 standard score, at less than 1 percentile, for Oral Directions. On the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-4, he attained a mental age of 6-6 and a 4 standard score, at the 2 percentile, for Word Opposites. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-IIIA, STUDENT achieved a 6-5 mental age, at the 2 percentile. On the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised NU, he obtained a score at the grade 2.0 level and at the 14 percentile, for Word Attack. On the Slosson Oral Reading Test- Revised, he scored at the grade 1.8 level, or 2 percentile. On the Wide Range Achievement Test- Revised/3, STUDENT obtained a spelling score at the grade 2 level, or 10 percentile, and an arithmetic score at the grade 4 level, or 32 percentile. On the Gray Oral Reading Test, Revised-3, for Rate and Passage, he obtained a 4 standard score, at the 2.2 grade level and 2 percentile. For Accuracy, he obtained a 5 standards score, at the 2.5 grade level and 5 percentile, and for Comprehension, he obtained a 4 standard score, at the less than 1.9 grade level and 2 percentile. On the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test, he achieved a 43 score. On the Informal Tests of Writing, his score for Sound/Symbol Associations was 26/32 and for Nonsense Spelling, 1/3. His score on the Symbol Imagery Test was 13/50.
A June 10, 1999 IEP, unsigned by the parent, states that STUDENT had progressed in reading, although there was greater improvement from August 1998 through February 1999 than there was from February through May 1999. Moreover, the IEP states that during the summer session growth would need to continue in the same areas that had been implemented previously. According to the IEP, the school had indicated that STUDENT was resistant to missing out on the regular SDC activities, but his mother believed that this was due to his resistance to change. The IEP provides for continued LH SDC placement, with regular education PE, lunch, recess, and school activities for 30 percent of the time. Speech and language services were to be provided in a small group and one-on-one for five hours weekly and APE for 40 minutes weekly. The IEP provides for a classroom aide and an ESY program. The parent did not sign the IEP but stated that the parents sought funding for the Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Center.
In summer 1999, STUDENT did not attend the District's ESY program. Instead, he started a 16-week Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Clinic. (Footnote 3)
The interim test results reported by Lindamood-Bell on August 11, 1999, after 8 weeks of treatment, are as follows (June 1999 scores are in parentheses). At the time, STUDENT was age 10 years, 7 months, and in grade 5. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III, he achieved a 72 standard score and 7-0 mental age, at the 3 percentile (compared to 68 standard score and 6-5 mental age, at the 2 percentile). On the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude-2, he obtained a standard score of 6, at the 9 percentile, for Oral Directions (2 standard score and less than 1 percentile in June). On the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-NU, he had a 97 standard score, at the 41 percentile ant 4.6 grade level for Word Attack (compared to 84 standard score, at the 14 percentile and 2.0 grade level). STUDENT'S score on the Slosson Oral Reading Test R was a 2.7 grade level, at the 6 percentile (1.8 grade level and 2 percentile in June). On the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test, STUDENT obtained a score of 94+3/100 (compared to 43/100). On the Symbol Imagery Test, his score was 16/50 (13/50 in June).
At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was still attending the Lindamood-Bell program in Pasadena.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did the District offer Petitioner an appropriate educational program during the following periods:
a. the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year? b. the 1999-2000 school year?
Petitioner requests that the District pay for his Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Clinic which started in June 1999 and was still continuing at the time of the hearing in September 1999. The District responds that it has offered Petitioner a free appropriate public education, including a Lindamood-Bell program provided by District staff, and thus he is not entitled to District funding of his program at the Pasadena Clinic. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private education or private services they procured for their child when the District failed to provide a free appropriate public education and the private placement or services are appropriate under the IDEA. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). The initial question is whether the District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the relevant periods.
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student's unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) ("designated instruction and services" shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. According to the Court, the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. See id. at 198-99. The Court stated that the "basic floor of opportunity" provided by the IDEA consists of "access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit." Id. at 200-01.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: "It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard." 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07.
a. The 1998-1999 School Year, Including the Extended School Year (A) Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner contends that although the January 14, 1998 IEP states that STUDENT would be assessed for the Fast ForWord program, he was never assessed for this program. He further contends that although a July 23, 1998 letter from his parent requested that the District conduct a Lindamood-Bell assessment, there is no evidence that the District responded to this request, and the parents had a Lindamood-Bell assessment performed at their expense.
When an assessment for the development or revision of the IEP is to be conducted, within 15 days of the referral for assessment (not counting days between regular school sessions or terms or days of school vacation in excess of five school days), the student's parent must be given a written proposed assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).
Here there is no evidence that STUDENT'S parent was presented with a proposed assessment plan for the Fast ForWord program pursuant to the IEP team's recommendation. STUDENT'S mother testified that she had asked the District to consider the Fast ForWord program to address STUDENT'S receptive and expressive language needs. The District's failure to comply with the IEP team's recommendation that he be assessed for this program violated Section 56321(a). This procedural violation resulted in a potential loss of educational opportunity for STUDENTsince if the assessment showed that he was a good candidate for this program, the assumption is that the District would have offered it to him. STUDENT was never assessed and was never offered this program. However, about a year later, the District provided STUDENT with the Lindamood-Bell program, but only after the parents had him assessed for this program. If the District had assessed STUDENT in a timely fashion for the Fast ForWord program and had provided the program to him, he would have received the program approximately a year earlier than he received the Lindamood-Bell program. Thus, the District's procedural violation could have resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for approximately one year. Little evidence was presented related to the area of suspected disability that a Fast ForWord assessment would have assessed. From the mother's testimony, it appears that it would have assessed STUDENT'S receptive and expressive language ability. However, since at least kindergarten, STUDENT has been receiving speech and language services, and January 1998 and February 1999 speech and language evaluation reports in the record confirm that the services provided were appropriate. Thus, although a technical procedural violation may have occurred, it does not provide grounds for relief.
As for the requested Lindamood-Bell assessment, STUDENT'S mother testified that when she asked the District to assess STUDENT, she spoke to JoAnne Goodman of the District, who said that the District would assess STUDENT but that the assessment kit could not be located. Therefore, according to the mother, the parents had STUDENT assessed by Lindamood-Bell in August 1998. However, the record indicates that the request for a Lindamood-Bell assessment was made during the summer vacation, and thus the District had no obligation under Section 56321(a) to conduct an assessment or even to present the parents with a proposed assessment plan during July or August. Within approximately two weeks of submitting their assessment request, the parents had STUDENT assessed at the Lindamood-Bell center. Thus there is insufficient evidence to determine whether or not the District had no intention of assessing STUDENT for the Lindamood-Bell program. Therefore, related to the Lindamood-
Bell assessment request, the evidence is insufficient to establish that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in a loss of educational opportunity.
(B) Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
As discussed above, the Supreme Court in Rowley set forth certain requirements for an appropriate educational program for a child with a disability. Thus, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 ESY, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit; and (3) conformed to his IEP. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT'S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District's proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT'S needs. The assessment reports and other documents in the record reveal that STUDENT has the following needs. He is a high functioning autistic child with a 107 IQ. He suffers from ADHD and has taken medication for it. He is distracted easily and impulsive, lacks concentration, has a short attention span, and requires constant reminders to stay on task. He exhibits a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement, largely due to a language-processing difficulty, which is consistent with a child with a learning disability. STUDENT has a mixed receptive-expressive language disorder, with neurophysiological dysfunctions in phonemic awareness, symbol imagery, and concept imagery. He displays weaknesses in auditory memory and auditory comprehension of language. His areas of need include auditory perception, receptive and expressive language, decoding, reading comprehension, vocabulary, written language, spelling, practical math, and classroom behavior. He requires a highly structured reading program which incorporates visualizing and verbalizing techniques and symbol and cognitive concepts. He also requires a concentrated approach to auditory processing. He has difficulty with oral problem- solving. He has deficiencies in social interactions. STUDENT has decreased muscle tone throughout his body and poor upper body and hand strength. In addition, STUDENT requires a small-group setting with frequent one-on-one instruction. He requires a structured classroom and schedule. He also requires seating near the teacher if possible and positive reinforcement throughout the school day.
The next step in determining whether the District's program was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs is to examine the relevant IEP documents. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student's unique needs and the special education, related services, and supplementary aids and services that will be provided for the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
In this case, several IEPs and a mediation agreement embody the proposed goals, objectives, and educational program that the District offered STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 ESY. The January 14, 1998 IEP covers the period from January 1998 to January 1999, including the fall 1998 semester. The October 15, 1998 IEP essentially continues the program of the January 14 IEP, with a few additional services and modifications. A January 28, 1999 mediation agreement sets forth the parties' agreement related to the Lindamood-Bell program. The February 16, 1999 IEP sets forth the program and services from February 1999 until June 1999. The June 10, 1999 IEP, unsigned by the parent, covers the period from June 1999 to January 14, 2000, including the
1999 ESY.
The January 14, 1998 IEP sets forth goals and objectives to improve STUDENT'S written language skills, skills related to telling time and counting coins, reading comprehension, sight vocabulary, gross motor skills, and auditory comprehension. The written language objectives involve writing his name and address correctly and, given a topic, writing a short paragraph with appropriate capitals, periods and spelling. The reading comprehension objectives address reading a paragraph and answering comprehension questions. The sight vocabulary objectives are designed to improve the ability to read basic sight words. The auditory comprehension objectives address (1) identifying items when orally described by function and attribute, (2) responding appropriately to oral "wh" questions, and (3) providing appropriate solutions to oral problem-solving questions or situations. The January 12, 1998 OT report mentions STUDENT'S OT goals related to sensory processing and self- regulation, neuromotor and gross motor function, fine motor skills, self-care skills, and social, play, and communication skills.
The February 16, 1999 IEP contains goals and objectives for reading comprehension, reading vocabulary, listening comprehension, expressive language, practical math, and gross motor skills. The reading comprehension objectives are designed to improve the ability to read, comprehend, and answer questions based upon a reading selection. The reading vocabulary objectives involve learning to read and identify the meaning of vocabulary words from reading selections. The listening comprehension objectives seek to improve the ability to listen to a paragraph that is read aloud and to comprehend, visualize and verbalize the meaning. The expressive language objectives address orally providing appropriate solutions to problems and situations presented orally with visual cues. All of these goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT'S needs in these areas.
The January 14, 1998 IEP provides for STUDENT'S placement in an LH SDC with mainstreaming for 40 percent of the time in regular education art, music, science, and math as appropriate. The IEP also provides for speech and language therapy, OT, and APE services; classroom aide support; and an ESY program. The October 15, 1998 IEP continues the LH SDC placement but reduces the mainstreaming to 25 percent, in art, science, social studies, and PE. Speech and language therapy, OT, APE services, and classroom aide support were to continue. In addition, the October 15 IEP provides for access to a computer, a highly structured reading program, use of District SDC curriculum, repetition of directions, and shortened assignments. The October 15 IEP also states that two teachers would be trained in the Lindamood-Bell LiPS and VV programs.
Pursuant to a January 28, 1999 mediation agreement, the District agreed to have its staff provide the Lindamood-Bell program to STUDENT five days a week for two hours (one hour individual and one hour small group instruction). The February 16, 1999 IEP states that pursuant to the January 28, 1999 mediation agreement, the District staff would instruct STUDENT using Lindamood-Bell techniques (one hour of one-on-one and one hour of small-group instruction per day). The February 16 IEP states that STUDENT would continue his LH SDC placement, with regular education reduced to 15 percent of the time in modified PE, lunch, recess, school day activities, and academic areas as appropriate. STUDENT was to continue to receive speech therapy, APE, classroom aide support, and an ESY program. The IEP also provides for a CCS referral for physical therapy. According to the IEP, STUDENT was to receive study aids and manipulatives, short instructions with the opportunity for repetition, visual aids, multisensory instruction when appropriate, and minimal distractions. STUDENT'S teacher's February 16, 1999 report also mentions the "Earobics" computer program, on which STUDENT worked on auditory and phonemic awareness activities such as syllables, vowel sounds, and sound sequencing.
The June 10, 1999 IEP provides for a continued LH SDC placement, with regular education PE, lunch, recess, and school activities for 30 percent of the time. It also provides for speech and language services (in a small group and one-on-one), APE, a classroom aide, and ESY. The June 10 IEP states that reading progress during the summer session would need to continue in the same areas previously implemented. The parent did not sign the IEP because the parents sought a District-funded Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Center.
The LH SDC placement, with a small student-teacher ratio, was intended to address STUDENT'S academic and attention deficits in a small, structured setting. According to STUDENT'S mother, there were only about 15 students in the class, and STUDENT has also received classroom aide support for a portion of the day. The evidence is that Ms. Rusting, STUDENT'S LH SDC teacher during the 1998-1999 school year, is a special education teacher with a learning handicapped credential who has the training and experience to assist him in light of his special learning needs. She testified that she had received training in the Lindamood-Bell VV program and taught STUDENT in a small group of 2 to 3 students the VV program with vocabulary development. Moreover, to address STUDENT'S attention and distractibility needs, the classroom aide was intended to provide the necessary support and assistance to redirect his attention to stay on task. From the time that STUDENT'S placement was changed to an LH SDC, he has continued to have regular education classes or lunch, recess, and school activities for a certain portion of the day. While regular education classes may seem inconsistent with his need for a small class setting, his parent had indicated a preference for mainstreaming to the extent feasible, and the regular education setting was consistent with his social needs. Moreover, the OT, APE and CCS referral were intended to address STUDENT'S gross and fine motor skills needs. An ESY program was intended to address his learning handicapped and remedial needs.
The speech and language services were intended to address auditory perception, listening comprehension, and expressive language needs. The evidence is that communication specialist Ms. Riserbato is a speech and language pathologist with a master's degree who is qualified to assist STUDENT with his receptive and expressive language needs. She also received Lindamood-Bell training and worked with STUDENT using the Lindamood-Bell VV, LiPS and Seeing Stars programs. Through the Lindamood-Bell program provided by the District, STUDENT received a structured reading program that used visualizing and verbalizing techniques and symbol and cognitive concepts. In the Lindamood- Bell program the District offered STUDENT during the spring 1999 semester, STUDENT received one-on- one instruction in addition to small-group instruction. The program and services set forth in the January 14, 1998; October 15, 1998; and February 16, 1999 IEPs were designed to assist STUDENT to attain the goals and objectives set forth in the IEPs during the fall 1998 and spring 1999 semesters.
A question is whether the proposed program for the 1999 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs. The January 28,1999 mediation agreement signed by the parties states that STUDENT'S Lindamood-Bell program during summer 1999 would be provided for four hours a day, five days a week, in a small group not to exceed four students. It is noted that at the January 28, 1999 mediation, the parents were represented by two advocates. (Footnote 4) The June 10, 1999 IEP, which sets forth the proposed program and services through January 14, 2000, appears to contemplate a continuation of the Lindamood-Bell program, including one-on-one and small- group instruction. However, it is not entirely clear whether the 1999 ESY program at issue here was to provide any one-on-one instruction. Communication specialist Ms. Riserbato testified that the intent with STUDENT'S summer school Lindamood-Bell program was to continue what had already been implemented, which would have included both one-to-one and small-group instruction. In his closing brief, Petitioner relies upon the January 28, 1999 mediation agreement and argues, in essence, that small-group instruction would not have met his needs since Ms. Dirtadian of Lindamood-Bell had recommended one-on-one instruction for him.
At the hearing, Ms. Dirtadian testified that because of STUDENT'S severe deficit and language processing problem, she recommended intensive one-on-one treatment. However, neither her Treatment Description report based upon the August 1998 Lindamood-Bell assessment, nor her follow-up October 7, 1998 letter recommending a 16-week, 4 hours per day intensive treatment mentions one-on-one instruction. If this was an important component of STUDENT'S Lindamood-Bell program, one would assume that Ms. Dirtadian would have stated so in her report or letter. Therefore, because of the absence of this information in her report or letter, her testimony related to this matter is entitled to less weight. Ms. Riserbato testified that small-group, in contrast to one-to-one, instruction might not be appropriate for STUDENT if he was not progressing or performing because of the presence of other students. She further testified, however, that it was not necessarily more difficult to refocus a student who is distractible when other students are present. She also testified that she had worked with STUDENT only one-to-one, not in a small group, and had STUDENT attended the District's summer Lindamood-Bell program, she would have provided the program to STUDENT. It appears that the District's proffered 1999 ESY Lindamood-Bell program was intended to provide both small-group and one-on-one instruction. There is no evidence that STUDENT cannot learn in a small-group setting. Therefore, while exclusively one-on-one Lindamood-Bell instruction may be optimal, the evidence does not establish that it is necessary to meet STUDENT'S needs. Based on the evidence in the record, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed ESY Lindamood-Bell program was designed to meet STUDENT'S needs.
Petitioner further contends, in essence, that the District's Lindamood-Bell program did not meet his needs because the District's staff members were inadequately trained in the program. Ms. Rusting testified that she received two days' training in the VV program. Ms. Riserbato testified that she received four days' training and that, with that level of training, she was able to implement the program, though not train others. Ms. Riserbato is a speech and language pathologist with the requisite education and experience to instruct in the areas of language, sounds, thinking, and comprehension using visualizing and verbalizing techniques. Besides working one-on-one with STUDENT, she supervised the work of the aide who worked with STUDENT one-on-one and in a small group following Ms. Riserbato's example and instructions. Although their level of Lindamood-Bell training may not have the depth of Lindamood-Bell staff, Ms. Riserbato and Ms. Rusting have the education and experience to utilize the Lindamood-Bell techniques effectively, and Ms. Riserbato has the qualifications to oversee an aide's work in the area.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program for the 1998-1999 school year, including its proposed 1999 ESY program, was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.
The May 7, 1999 report of STUDENT'S LH SDC teacher, Ms. Rusting, summarizes his progress. On the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills, he could sound out words at a low grade 3 level. He was reading orally at a grade 2-2 level with 97 percent accuracy (compared to a grade 1-2 level in February 1999). He read 60 percent of the words at the grade 2 level (an improvement from a primer level a year ago) and read 334 out of 400 basic sight words (an increase from 143 in January 1998). In reading comprehension, he scored 100 percent at the grade 2-1 level and 80 percent at the grade 2-2 level (an improvement from 80 percent at the grade 1-2 level in February 1999). On the San Diego
Quick Assessment, he scored at the grade 2 level, with no change since February 1999.
STUDENT'S May 1999 WRAT-R3 scores (compared to his August 1998 scores, in parentheses) were as follows: reading, grade 3 (grade 1); and spelling, grade 2 (grade K). His Brigance spelling score was also a grade 2 level. His May 1999 Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised Form G scores were as follows: Word Attack, grade 3.2 (compared to grade 1.2 and grade 2.9 in August 1998 and February 1999, respectively); Word Identification, Grade 2.1 (grade 1.9 in February 1999); and Passage Comprehension, grade 2.5 (grade 2.1 in February 1999). In written language, STUDENT was able to write four sentences using 80 percent correct spelling and used capitalization and periods correctly. He could print his first and last name and address and was learning cursive writing. On the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS), in February 1999, he achieved a 41 standard score, at the 6 percentile and 8-1 age equivalent level. On June 1, 1999, he had a 30 total TOPS standard score, at the 1 percentile and 5-4 age equivalent level.
On STUDENT'S Progress Report of Annual Goals for the 1998-1999 school year, in February 1999, STUDENT had met goals 2 (tell time to a 5-minute interval), 4 ( read a paragraph at the 1-1 level and answer four out of five comprehension questions), and 5 (read 250 out of 400 basic sight words). His rating for goal 3 (add sets of coins up to $1.00) was that, although he had made progress, he might not meet this goal by the time the IEP was reviewed. He had no rating for goal 1 (write his name and address and also a paragraph containing 3-4 sentences when given a topic sentence). Thus, he met 3 out of 5 goals for the prior year.
On the Progress Report of Annual Goals for the February 1999 to February 2000 school year, on June 10, 1999, STUDENT had met goal 1 (read a selection at the 2-2 level and answer four out of five questions). He received the rating that he had made progress and it appeared that the goals would be met when the IEP was reviewed in February 2000 for these goals: 2 (read and give the meaning of grade 2 vocabulary words with 80 percent accuracy); 3 (demonstrate listening comprehension at the grade 3.2 level with 80 percent accuracy); and 5 (give totals for sets of coins up to $1.00 and $2.00). However, his rating for goal 4 (orally provide appropriate solutions at a 60 percent level to situations presented on TOPS) was that although he had made progress, he might not meet this goal by the time the IEP was reviewed.
Petitioner argues that the District's test results show that he made little progress during implementation of the District's Lindamood-Bell program from February to June 1999, whereas the Lindamood-Bell center's testing showed significant gains from June to August 1999 following the Pasadena Clinic's intensive treatment. The results of the Lindamood-Bell center's selective testing following eight weeks of treatment show substantial progress. However, the clinic treatment was for four hours per day, five days per week, whereas the District's spring 1999 semester Lindamood-Bell program was for only two hours per day, five days per week, as part of a comprehensive language arts program which included reading and written and expressive language development. Although the District's testing showed that STUDENT'S WRAT-R3 reading and spelling scores showed no change from February to May 1999, his scores on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised Form G did show improvement.
Overall, STUDENT'S standardized test scores showed improvement in reading and spelling during the 1998-1999 school year. From his teacher's report, he also had achieved progress in written language and math. Although his TOPS score went down from February to June 1999, communication specialist Ms. Riserbato's report stated that distractibility and poor retention skills had interfered with STUDENT'S progress and that distractibility could affect TOPS performance. Ms. Riserbato also stated in her report and testified that in the Lindamood-Bell program, STUDENT missed his former communication small group and had expressed a desire to return to it. STUDENT'S mother corroborated this in her testimony. Thus other factors could have affected his June 1999 TOPS score, and the evidence is that STUDENT is still working on improving his oral problem-solving ability. Moreover, no evidence was presented that he would not be advancing to grade 5 the following year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program during the fall 1998 and spring 1999 semesters of the 1998-1999 school year did bestow educational benefit on STUDENT. In addition, no evidence was presented that the District's program during the 1999 ESY would not have continued to do so.
(3) Conformity with IEP
The District's educational program for STUDENT was also in conformity with his January 14, 1998; October 15, 1998; and February 16, 1999 IEPs and the parties' January 28, 1999 mediation agreement.
In conclusion, the District's program for the 1998-1999 school year, including its proposed program for the 1999 ESY, provided STUDENT with a FAPE.
c. The 1999-2000 School Year
As discussed above, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit; and (3) conformed to his IEP. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT'S Unique Needs
The June 10, 1999 IEP contains the District's proposed program for STUDENT during fall 1999 through January 2000, when the annual IEP meeting is to be convened. STUDENT'S parent did not sign the June 10, 1999 IEP for the sole reason that the parents sought a District-funded Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Center. The June 10 IEP states that the previously developed goals and objectives would be continued. As discussed above, this IEP document, including the incorporated goals and objectives, sets forth a placement and services which were designed to meet STUDENT'S identified needs. No evidence was submitted related to the District's program for the remainder of the school year. Thus, that time period is outside the scope of this decision, and no determination is made related to the remainder of the school year at this time.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The proposed program for STUDENT through January 2000, embodied in the June 10, 1999 IEP, includes an LH SDC placement and speech therapy, APE, classroom aide support, and ESY. The Lindamood-Bell program provided by the District is also part of STUDENT'S proffered educational program. As discussed above, a similar program previously implemented had conferred upon STUDENT educational benefit and thus the program was reasonably calculated to provide such benefit during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. As stated above, because of the lack of evidence, no determination is made at this time related to the second semester of the school year.
(3) Conformity with IEP
The District did not have the opportunity to carry out the June 10 IEP because the parents unilaterally placed STUDENT in the Lindamood-Bell program at the Pasadena Center. There is no indication that the District would not have provided STUDENT with a program in conformity with the IEP. It is concluded that the program for fall 1999 would have been in conformity with the IEP. In conclusion, the proposed program for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year provides STUDENT with a FAPE. Moreover, if the proposed program for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year is similar to the first semester program, it likely will also provide STUDENT a FAPE.
ISSUE 2: If not, did a FAPE require a Lindamood-Bell program provided by Lindamood-Bell staff during the following periods:
a. the 1998-1999 extended school year?
b. the 1999-2000 school year?
Because it was determined above that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 ESY, and during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year, the District was not required to fund the Lindamood-Bell program STUDENT received during these periods. No determination is made related to the second half of the 1999-2000 year.
ISSUE 3: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood-Bell program he received from Lindamood-Bell staff during the following periods: a. the 1998-1999 extended school year?
b. the 1999-2000 school year?
As discussed above, the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 ESY, and during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood-Bell program during these periods. Because of the lack of evidence, no determination is made regarding the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year.
ORDER
All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied. This order makes no determination related to the second half of the 1999-2000 school year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: January 25, 2000 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
Footnotes 1)The order of the issues has been altered and the issues have been clarified to facilitate the analysis. 2)Unless all parties consent, a party to a special education mediation has a privilege to prevent the disclosure of (1) any evidence, whether oral or written, arising from a mediation or (2) any reference to a mediation or mediation-derived evidence under Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3086(b)(1) and (2). In this case, the lack of any objections to the proffered exhibit containing the parties' interim mediation agreement or any other evidence related to the mediation is deemed to be a consent to disclosure or a waiver of any objections. 3)STUDENT'S mother testified that the Pasadena Lindamood-Bell center was uncertified. Ms. Dirtadian of Lindamood-Bell also testified that the Pasadena office was not yet certified by the State as a nonpublic agency. 4)In the due process hearing, the parents are now represented by a different advocate.
