California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 10, 1998
Student v. Alhambra City Elementary School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1662-97 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman
Alhambra City Elementary must add ESY and an autism expert to the IEP; language special day class upheld, reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Both sides filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. Alhambra City Elementary School District wanted to finish the IEP process using its updated assessments. The parents, who represented their son themselves, challenged his placements, the IEP process, and the assessments. He was four years old, eligible for special education under autism, and had very little speech. His parents had placed him at Wonder World, a private community preschool. They wanted a full-inclusion program there with discrete trial behavior training and aides.
The Hearing Officer ruled that the District had not shown that its September 1997 offer met his needs. That offer was a regular preschool at Elgin Center with a 1:1 aide and 60 minutes of speech therapy a week. The March 1998 offer was appropriate and the least restrictive environment for his needs: a half-day special day class for children with severe language delay at Moor Field School, plus two hours of speech therapy a week. But the District did not prove that the regular preschool part of that offer was appropriate. It also failed to offer extended school year (ESY) services, which he needed. Reimbursement for Wonder World, computer classes, potty training, and private speech therapy was denied. The parent participation and assessment claims also failed. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days, with an autism expert, and offer the special day class, more speech therapy, occupational therapy, and ESY.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed a parent's request for full inclusion against a preschooler's severe language needs. It applied the Rowley and least-restrictive-environment tests to each part of an offer separately. It also denied reimbursement for a private preschool that did not meet the child's needs and was not a certified nonpublic school.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate placements during the 1997-98 school year?
The September 1997 Elgin Center regular preschool offer was not shown to meet the student's needs, and no ESY was offered. The March 1998 language special day class with increased speech therapy was appropriate and the least restrictive environment. The regular preschool part of that offer was not proven. Neither party substantially prevailed.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Are the parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the 1997-98 school year for STUDENT's unilateral placement at a private community preschool named Wonder World, and for computer services, behavior modification potty training, and speech therapy?
Reimbursement was denied. Wonder World did not address the student's critical language and socialization needs. Computer classes gave virtually no benefit. There was no evidence on potty training. Private speech therapy was not reimbursable because the District's March 1998 speech offer was appropriate.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year?
The March 6, 1998 special day class and increased speech services remained appropriate for 1998-99. The regular preschool component and full-day combined program were unproven, and the District did not offer ESY the student needed. The District substantially prevailed.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is the parents' proposed private placement at Wonder World, with an "individualized discrete trials behavior modification program," and "instructional, behavioral and inclusive aides" appropriate for STUDENT in the 1998-99 school year?
Wonder World was inappropriate and could not be ordered because it is not a certified nonpublic school. Requests for aides, RSP, a functional analysis, itinerant instruction, and discrete trial training were not tied to any showing of need.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5. Did the District violate the parents' procedural rights to participate in the IEP process during 1997 and 1998, such that STUDENT was denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?
The parents attended seven IEP meetings and took an active part. Controlling the IEP process is not a right, and there was no procedural denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 6. Has the District performed appropriate and valid assessments of STUDENT between January 1997 and April 1998? If no, is the parent entitled to another assessment at public expense?
Both rounds of District assessments, including the psychoeducational assessments by credentialed school psychologists, met Education Code section 56320. The request for another assessment at public expense was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District must convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the decision to develop an appropriate program for 1998-99. The team must include a qualified expert on autism and the education of autistic children (Ed. Code 56341(c)(2)), and must further consider discrete trial behavior modification and/or regular education preschool (such as Elgin Center or Moor Field) with the expert's input.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include, or provide equivalent services to: a severe language delay/aphasia special day class such as the one at Moor Field School; increased DIS speech-language services of no less than two hours of individual services per week in 30-minute sessions (the order reads "30 minutes each day, four hours per week"; four 30-minute sessions per week appears intended); DIS occupational therapy; and extended school year services.
- All other requests were denied, including reimbursement for Wonder World, computer services, potty training, and private speech therapy; prospective Wonder World placement; another assessment at public expense; and payment to the mother for hearing representation.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed.; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; County of San Diego v. California Special Education Hearing Office (Fox); W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Union School Dist. v. Smith
People named in the decision
- Margaret Azevedo-Ikezaki, special education coordinator, Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Donna Cline, school psychologist (initial 1997 assessment), Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Rachel Fall, school psychologist (November 1997 psychoeducational assessment), Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Sean Early, speech and language specialist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Phyllis Evans, speech-language pathologist / instructional specialist, speech and language program, Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Stephen Bostwick, instructional specialist (preacademic assessment), Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Mona Neter, special day class teacher, Moor Field School, Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Kathy Crane, District assessor, Alhambra City Elementary School District
- Dr. Eva Mauer, physician (health assessment), Pasadena Unified School District
- Yvonne Madera, director, private preschool, Wonder World
- Miss Sarah, preschool teacher, Wonder World
- East Los Angeles Regional Center, regional center (early intervention; funded 1:1 aide)
- Wonder World, private community preschool (unilateral placement)
- Almansor Center, early intervention program
- Scott Developmental Center, special day class program, Pasadena Unified School District
- Elgin ABC Preschool Center, District regular education preschool (Head Start/state preschool)
- Southern California Diagnostic Center, state diagnostic center (offered assessment referral)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Alhambra California, on March 17-18, April 23-24, and June 9-10, 1998.
The Student was represented by his parents, MR. AND MRS. PARENT, who were both present throughout the hearing. The Alhambra City Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Karen Gilyard of Atkinson, Anderson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Ms. Margaret Azevedo-Ikezaki, special education coordinator, was also present on behalf of the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. The arguments were received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate placements during the 1997-98 school year?
2. Are the parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the 1997-98 school year for STUDENT's unilateral placement at a private community preschool named Wonder World, and for computer services, behavior modification potty training, and speech therapy?
3. Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-1999 school year?
4. Is the parents' proposed private placement at Wonder World, with an individualized discrete trials behavior modification program," and "instruction, behavioral and inclusive aides" appropriate for STUDENT in the 1998-99 school year?
5. Did the District violate the parents' procedural rights to participate in the IEP process during 1997 and 1998, such that STUDENT was denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?
6. Has the District performed appropriate and valid assessments of STUDENT between January 1997 and April 1998? If no, is the parent entitled to another assessment at public expense?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a four-year-old boy who was diagnosed with autism by staff at the East Los Angeles Regional Center (ELARC). STUDENT's speech is extremely limited, and he has behavioral difficulties associated with autism. STUDENT is not yet toilet trained. He is currently attending a full day program at Wonder world, a community preschool and day care setting, and receives the assistance of a 1:1 aide through ELARC. He also receives private speech therapy once a week, and occupational therapy (OT) through the District.
STUDENT received early intervention services, including in-home discrete trial training, through ELARC before the age of three when eh became eligible for special education. In January 1997, shortly before this third birthday, ELARC referred STUDENT tot he District. The Alhambra Preschool Assessment Team completed an initial assessment of STUDENT over several days in January, February and March 1997. The team concluded that STUDENT demonstrated cognitive abilities significantly below his chronological age, but noted also that his noncompliant behaviors and speech delays could have reduced the estimates of his intellectual abilities. The team also stated that STUDENT was significantly delayed in overall language development because he was functioning at the six to nine month age level.
On march 13, 1997, an initial IEP team meeting was held, and STUDENT was found eligible for special education services on the basis of autism. STUDENT's parents requested that his discrete trial training and early intervention services through ELARC continue. They also expressed interest in finding a program that would encourage STUDENT's social/emotional growth, and speech and language skill development in an environment with his nondisabled peers. The District agreed to arrange for the parents to visit possible placements, and the IEP team meeting was continued. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT did not sign the IEP document because they wanted to review placements before doing so.
On May 5, 1997, the continued IEP team meeting was held to determine STUDENT's placement after the parents had visited various programs within the West San Gabriel Valley SELPA. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT attend the special day class at the Scott Developmental Center in Pasadena Unified School District with Designated Instruction and Services (DIS) in speech and language and OT. The District began providing STUDENT with individual speech and language services at his neighborhood school after this IEP team meeting. At the request of the PARENTs, the occupational therapist from the Pasadena District and a private occupational therapist who had worked with STUDENT were directed to confer and develop goals and objectives in several specific areas. OT did not begin until October 1997. At the May 1997 IEP team meeting, the PARENTs also requested an updated assessment of STUDENT which was scheduled for September 1997.
STUDENT subsequently enrolled in the Scott Developmental Center program in Pasadena. At the time of his enrollment in early may 1997, STUDENT was assessed by a physician, Dr. Eva Mauer, who was associated with the Pasadena District. Dr. Mauer diagnosed STUDENT as autistic and developmentally delayed. She also noted in her health report that STUDENT should be placed with normal children as much as possible to avoid his tendency to copy inappropriate behavior of other disabled children. (Stu. Exh. AAA.) STUDENT attended the Scott Center for four days before his parents withdrew him. The PARENTs objected to several aspects of the program and requested an emergency IEP team meeting to review STUDENT's placement and services. (Stu. Exh. ZZZZ.) After STUDENT left the Scott Center, his parents returned him to Almansor Center, an early intervention program where he had previously been placed by ELARC. STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class there were with nine to ten other students, including some students with autism and some typically developing peers. His placement at Almansor was sponsored by ELARC.
On June 5, 1997, the IEP team met and the parents "revoked" the Scott Center placement. The parents reiterated their interest in having STUDENT placed in an inclusive program, composed primarily of non-disabled children. Other placement options were discussed, and the team agreed to begin the updated assessment of STUDENT in July, somewhat sooner than had previously had been agreed upon.
On July 16, 1997, Mr. PARENT signed an assessment plan which provided for evaluations in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development and intellectual development. On July 30, 1997, a second assessment plan was signed by Mrs. PARENT providing for testing in academic/preacademic, and language/speech/communication development. A note was included on the second assessment form stating, "This plan covers academic and speech evaluation only. Observations from previous plan will be reviewed by parents as to their appropriateness for inclusion in any subsequent reports." (Dist. Exh. 12.)
On August 15, 1997, the PARENTs moved STUDENT from the Almansor Center to a preschool and day care center called Wonder World because they were dissatisfied with his progress at Almansor. On September 2, 1997, another assessment plan was signed by Mrs. PARENT permitting an adaptive physical education assessment of STUDENT.
On September 4, 1997, the IEP team met to review STUDENT's educational placement and services. The team noted that the July 1997 assessment was not yet completed and that the adaptive physical education assessment would be completed soon. The PARENTs requested that a different District psychologist perform the psychological assessment. At this meeting, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a regular education setting at the Elgin ABC Preschool Center (a child development, Head Start/state preschool program in the District) with the support of a 1:1 aide and DIS speech and language services and OT on site. Although the parents accepted this program at the IEP team meeting, they did not subsequently enroll STUDENT on September 10 as planned.
On September 23, 1997, an IEP addendum was completed indicating the parents' wish to defer STUDENT's enrollment at the Elgin Center until the updated assessments were completed. The PARENTs also asked that STUDENT's DIS services continue and that his program at Wonder World be funded by the District. About one week later, the District notified the PARENTs that STUDENT's attendance at Wonder World would be at the parents' expense as the District believed it had offered STUDENT an appropriate placement at Elgin Center. The District also offered to provide the DIS services to STUDENT at his neighborhood school, Garfield Elementary School. The District provided the PARENTs with the name of the psychologist designated to complete the updated psychological assessment of STUDENT. On October 23, 2997, a second IEP addendum was completed in response to the parents' agreement concerning provision of OT services for STUDENT. (Stu. Exh. G, IIIII).
Over the fall, there were difficulties in completing the updated assessment and in scheduling a follow-up IEP team meeting. The parents and District representatives met on October 17, 1997 and outlined steps for completing the updated assessment. At this meeting, another assessment plan was signed by the parents with specific District staff designated to perform the testing in each area. All assessments were completed and an IEP team meeting was scheduled for December 15, 1997 to review the results and to consider placement alternatives. However, on December 12, 1997, the PARENTs requested that the IEP team meeting be re-scheduled but did not propose a future date. They also requested a new psychological assessment due to their dissatisfaction with the assessment completed by District psychologist Rachel Fall. The District declined to undertake another assessment and offered additional dates for the IEP team meeting. The PARENTs refused to proceed with the IEP team meeting and indicated their desire to file for due process hearing.
On December 22, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing from the District concerning its right to complete the IEP process based upon the updated assessments. On January 9, 1998, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing from the Student concerning procedural issues, STUDENT's need for an aide at his private community preschool program, and completion of a new assessment. On January 16, 1998, the Hearing Office granted Petitioner's request to consolidate the two cases.
On February 11, 1998, an IEP team meeting was held to review the assessments which had been completed by the District since July 1997. The parents again objected to the psychoeducational assessment completed by ms. Fall. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was functioning at a developmental age equivalent score of 13 months and again found STUDENT eligible for special education services due to his diagnosis of autism. The team also determined STUDENT's present levels of performance based on the assessments, and the District presented draft goals and objectives.
On March 6, 1998, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss STUDENT's placement and services. The parents requested that behavior modification and use of a computer be included in STUDENT's program, and that he be placed in a regular education preschool setting with a "trained behavior aide." (Dist. Exh. 41.) The District offered to place STUDENT in a half- day, preschool special day class for children with severe language services and OT, and a regular education preschool program at either Elgin Center or Moor Field for the remainder of the day. The parents and district disagreed as tot he location in which the DIS services should be provided. The parents' request for another psychological assessment by the District was declined, but the District offered to refer STUDENT for assessment at the Southern California Diagnostic Center upon parental consent. The parents' request for a "computer and assistive alternative communication assessment" (Augmentative-Assistive Technology Assessment) was agreed upon and an assessment plan signed. (Dist. Exhs. 45, 50.)
On March 17 and 18, 1998, the consolidated case proceeded to hearing. On March 19, 1998, the PARENTs withdrew STUDENT from his speech and language services because they were dissatisfied with the speech and language specialist, Sean Early, who was working with STUDENT. (Stu. Exhs. RRRR, SSSS.)
In mid April 1998, the Augmentative-Assistive Technology Assessment was completed by Mr. Early and Phyllis Evans, the District's instructional specialist for the speech and language program. On April 20, 1998, an IEP team meeting was held to review the results of that assessment. The PARENTs left the meeting early, and District staff completed the IEP document stating that an icon exchange communication system continued to be the most appropriate system for STUDENT. The District team members also noted that oral language software was not appropriate for STUDENT given his limited expressive language skills, but that he could benefit from some limited use of a computer to develop other language/readiness skill areas.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student states that the District has failed to offer him an appropriate placement since he first became eligible for preschool services in March 1997. The Student claims that the Scott Center special day class which he attended in May 1997 and the Elgin Center regular education preschool offered in September 1997 were both inappropriate for a number of reasons. He states that the District's current offer of the preschool special day class at Moor Field School is too restrictive and that he is entitled to an inclusive setting by law. The Student also contends that he can function in a regular education preschool with appropriate supplemental services such as behavior modification using discrete trial training, classroom aide or aides, resource services program (RSP), itinerant instruction, "functional analysis exam," and parental support, but that these services have not been offered by the District. The Student claims that his parents have been denied full participation in the IEP process and in decision-making regarding his assessments and educational program since he first entered the District's services. Finally, the Student contends that the assessments which he was given in 1997 are invalid and that he is entitled to another assessment for several reasons.
The Student requests retroactive reimbursement to his parents for costs of his attendance at Wonder World during the 1997-98 school year. He also requests reimbursement for other educational services provided by his parents last year, including computer classes, behavior modification potty training, and speech therapy. The Student requests that his mother be paid for "the loss of money and hardship" for six days of hearing representing his interests without legal counsel. He seeks prospective placement at a five-to six-hour regular education preschool such as Wonder World, extending school year services, and DIS services including behavior modification with discrete trial training, instructional, behavioral and inclusive aides, a functional analysis, and supplementary educational aides "acceptable tot he parents." (Stu. Closing Statement, pp. 22-23.) The Student also seeks to have assessments have reviewed by his parents before they are administered and for his parents to be "properly respected as members of the IEP team."
The District contends that its current placement offer of the severe language delayed/aphasia special day class at Moor Field School with DIS speech and language services and OT, and a regular education preschool program at either the Elgin Center or Moor Field for the remainder of the day is appropriate to meet STUDENT's unique needs. The District also argues that Wonder World preschool is not appropriate for STUDENT because the goals and objectives contained in the march 6, 1998 IEP could not be appropriately implemented there. The District states that STUDENT does not need a 1:1 in-home behavior modification program and that such a program would be too restrictive. The District also contends that the six assessments completed during the 1997 were valid and appropriate and that the parents is not entitled to an independent assessment at public expense.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate placements during the 1997-98 school year?
Under federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000, et. seq.) The term "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; meet the standards of the State educational agency; include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved; and are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under Sec. 614(d)." (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D).) Special education means specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . ." (20 U.S.C. Sec 1401(25); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.)
Related services are called "designated instruction and services" (DIS) under California law. (20 U.S.C. 1401(22); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) These services are provided when necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Language and speech development and remediation, and audiology services are among those which may be provided by a school district if determined necessary by the IEP team.
The U.S. Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a disabled student under the IDEA in Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the services maximize each child's potential. Rather, "the ‘basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. (Id. at 200.)
The right to a free and appropriate education also includes the right to educational services in the least restrictive environment (20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(A); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) This means that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children who do not have disabilities. (34 C.F.R. 300.550; Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) Special classes, separate schooling or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment can occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56364(a).)
Thus, under the IDEA, Rowley, and state law, an appropriate educational placement must include instruction and services which (1) are designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) provide educational benefit, (3) conform to the student's IEP goals, and (4) are provided in the least restrictive environment.
During the 1997-98 school year, the District offered STUDENT two placements: 1) Elgin Center with a 1:1 aide and DIS speech and language, and OT services on site; and 2) half-day, preschool special day class for children with severe language delay/aphasia at Moor Field School with DIS speech and language services and OT, and a regular education preschool program at either the Elgin Center or Moor Field for the remainder of the day. The Hearing Officer will review each of these proposed placements in the light of the four criteria noted above.
Were the District's placement offers designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
STUDENT's unique needs
As a child with autism and developmental delays, STUDENT has several significant needs which must be addressed in an educational setting. The most pressing is STUDENT's need to develop speech and language. At the time of the District's initial assessment in late January 1997 when STUDENT was almost three-years-old, his receptive and expressive language skills were at the six to nine month level with some emerging skills identified up to the nine to 12 month level. (Dist. Exh. 1.) The PARENTs reported that STUDENT spoke approximately 10-12 words randomly, but no language use was observed by the examiner during the assessment. (Dist. Exh. 1.)In the Transdisciplinary Team Initial Assessment Summary, STUDENT was described to be functioning at the early "Locutionary State of early communication development" as he was beginning to demonstrate intentional communication. (Dist. Exh. 1.) Donna Cline, a school psychologist for the District, testified that she participated in the January 1997 assessment of STUDENT. As part of the assessment process, she observed STUDENT at the PAL preschool which he was attending and saw STUDENT sing and hum, but he spoke no words.
Sean Early is a speech and language specialist with the District who has worked with STUDENT providing individual speech and language therapy one hour per week from May 1997 until April 1998 when the parents removed STUDENT from those services. (Testimony of Sean Early, Mrs. PARENT). Mr. Early is completing a master's degree in communication disorders and has previously taught a special day class serving children with severe language delay/aphasia. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) Mr. Early testified that STUDENT has severe speech delays and needs to establish intentionality in his communication and learn functional language and pragmatics. Mr. Early stated that STUDENT does not use oral language and has not used single words consistently for an extended period of time. STUDENT has responded to certain words in therapy, such as "come," "stop," and "no." (Testimony of Mr. Early.) Mr. Early testified that it is critical that STUDENT develop oral language as soon as possible.
Other District witnesses who testified about STUDENT's educational needs identified speech and language as a primary area of concern. Rachel Fall, a school psychologist with the District who assessed STUDENT in November 1997, testified that STUDENT's communication difficulties are severe. Ms. Fall stated that STUDENT's need to develop language is critical at this stage in his development. He needs intensive services to facilitate and stimulate speech. (Testimony of Ms. Fall.) Phyllis Evans is a speech and language pathologist who is employed as an instructional degree in communication disorders and holds three credentials including one in speech, language and hearing services. (Testimony of Phyllis Evans.) Ms. Evans completed an updated speech and language evaluation of STUDENT in October 1997 which involved observation, interviews and testing. Based on this evaluation, Ms. Evans testified that STUDENT has significant delays in his understanding and use of language, and continues to function in the "Locutionary Stage" showing prelinguistic behaviors and a desire to communicate. Ms. Evans stated that a special day class would be best for STUDENT to help him develop language, especially oral language.
The Student's parents also acknowledged that severe speech delay is a problem for STUDENT, but their testimony tended to minimize the critical nature of STUDENT's speech and language needs. Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT's language at home includes "a couple of signs" and a few words such as "stop," "OK," "I no want," "dog," and "eat." Mr. PARENT stated that he feels STUDENT understands much of what is going on but that his expressive skills "need help." Mr. PARENT also testified that he feels STUDENT's main problem is speech delay. Mrs. PARENT testified that she thinks STUDENT needs more speech services, preferably one to two hours per week and that she believes he has a severe speech delay. Mrs. PARENT also noted STUDENT's speech delays in a written parent questionnaire prepared for a private speech therapist in February 1998. She stated that STUDENT "babbles" and "says vowels and consonants and sings songs." (Stu. Exh. FFFF.) The Student offered no other witness testimony or significant evidence concerning his speech and language needs.
Based on all the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's primary and pressing need is to develop speech and language skills. The evidence shows that, although STUDENT is four-years-old, he continues to function at a prelinguistic stage with limited receptive language skills and only a few words of oral language. As several witnesses testified, this is a critical time for STUDENT's speech and language development. Therefore, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs intensive speech and language services on a daily basis to help him learn to communicate.In the initial assessment of January 1997, the assessment team concluded that STUDENT had delays in preacademic/readiness skills including fine motor and self-help skills, general knowledge and comprehension, and, particularly, social and emotional development. (Dist. Exh. 1.) Although the assessment was based on observation, teacher and parent report, the team noted that due to STUDENT's "limited language and attending behaviors... [the test results] may not accurately reflect skill levels." (Dist. Exh. 1.) In the assessment report, the team also stated that STUDENT needed teacher prompts and motoring approximately 80% of the time in class at both the Almansor Center and PAL preschool program.
An updated assessment of STUDENT's preacademic/readiness skills was done in July, August and November 1997 by Stephen Bostwick, an instructional specialist with the District's learning handicapped and applied physical education program. From this evaluation, Mr. Bostwick concluded that STUDENT's overall school readiness skills were at the 12 to 24 month level. (Dist. Exh. 28.) Mr. Bostwick testified that he observed STUDENT once at home, twice at Almansor Center and twice at Wonder World in order to evaluate STUDENT's skills across various settings. From these observations and other assessment results, Mr. Bostwick testified that STUDENT's self-help and academic skills are delayed compared to typically developing children. Mr. Bostwick also stated that STUDENT did not consistently display social interaction skills in these settings. Mr. Bostwick recommended that STUDENT receive intensive services in the form of "direct instruction in the context of a structured small class environment with the continued support of ancillary services of Speech Therapy and Occupational Therapy." (Dist. Exh. 28.)
In November 1997, Ms. Fall completed the psychoeducational portion of the updated assessment and found that STUDENT's socialization and daily living skills remained at a low level. (Dist. Exh. 30.) In her report, Ms. Fall summarized that STUDENT's socialization skills appeared "to range from below the 1 year to the 1 year, 6 month age-equivalent level," and that his daily living skills appeared "to be within the 1 year, 3 month age-equivalent range." (Dist. Exh. 30) Ms. Fall testified that she observed STUDENT at Wonder World on two separate occasions and saw that he needed "lots of 1:1 assistance" and help from the teacher to "motor through" various class activities. Staff at Wonder World also told Ms. Fall that STUDENT lacked socialization skills, and that he would leave activities and have to be brought back. (Testimony of Ms. Fall.) Ms. Fall testified that STUDENT was functioning at a low developmental level overall based on the information she received from the various sources used for the assessment. She stated that STUDENT needs a language based, special day class environment to provide more intensive assistance and to focus on the socialization skills which he needs. (Testimony of Ms. Fall; Dist. Exh. 30.)
In the Student's case, Mrs. PARENT testified that she thinks STUDENT needs "socialization and behavior programs first, then he needs education." Mr. PARENT made brief reference in his testimony to his believe that STUDENT needs "to be with other children" in his preschool program, but the program "need not necessarily involve school activities." No other significant evidence was offered by the Student concerning his needs in the areas of preacademic/readiness, socialization, self-help and daily living skills.
The parents' testimony was generally consistent with testimony by District witnesses concerning STUDENT's need for socialization, self-help and daily living skills. Mrs. PARENT's statement that education should come after socialization and behavior programs appears to be based on her personal beliefs and was not supported by the weight of the evidence. STUDENT's unique needs in all areas– school readiness, socialization, self-help and daily living skills– must be addressed comprehensively without shortchanging any particular area. Thus the Hearing Officer finds from the above evidence that STUDENT needs to develop his overall school readiness skills in order to function effectively in an educational setting. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs to develop socialization, self-help and daily living skills to be able to interact with his typically developing peers at school. Due to STUDENT's needs to be "motored through" many classroom activities, he needs significant individual attention, preferably in a small, structured classroom with a low student-teacher ratio.
There was some evidence from both the District and the Student that STUDENT needs behavior modification services. District witnesses testified that an in-home behavior modification program to assist the parents in handling STUDENT's behaviors in that setting would be helpful. (Testimony of Mr. Early, Ms. Fall.) Both Mr. Early and Ms. Fall emphasized that such a program was not necessary for STUDENT to progress educationally, but was primarily being recommended to assist the parents at home. (Dist. Exh. 30.) The parents testified that, when STUDENT first was found eligible for District Services in March 1997, they requested that he receive a behavior modification program using discrete trial training techniques. The PARENTs continue to believe that such a program is necessary for STUDENT and should be a component of his placement. (Testimony of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT.) However, other than this offer of personal opinion, there was no evidence presented as to how such a program would benefit STUDENT educationally, why it is necessary as to how such a program would benefit STUDENT educationally, why it is necessary at this time, what behaviors must be addressed, and how the program would be designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Thus the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented has not established that STUDENT needs an in-home behavior modification program using discrete trial training techniques in order to benefit from his education.
There was also some evidence presented concerning STUDENT's need for extended school year services. Mr. Early testified that if STUDENT was not receiving speech and language services for one month, the effect on his progress would depend on what was happening at home. If no language stimulation was occurring, then regression would be likely. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) Mr. Early also stated that a speech program at home "would help during breaks." Ms. Fall testified that STUDENT would benefit from an extended school year program. In addition to this testimony, which directly addressed STUDENT's need for extended school year services, the Hearing Officer notes that several witnesses testified to STUDENT's need for intensive services as already discussed above. Considering that evidence along with the testimony of Mr. Early and Ms. Fall, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs extended school year services in order to provide the intensive level of service which he requires.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs to develop speech and language, and requires intensive services on a daily basis throughout the extended school year to help him learn to communicate effectively. STUDENT also needs to develop his overall school readiness skills, socialization, self-help and daily living skills to be able to interact with his typically developing peers at school. Due to STUDENT's needs to be "motored through" many classroom activities, he needs significant amounts of individual attention in a small, structured classroom with a low student-teacher ratio.
The Elgin Center placement offer
On September 4, 1997, the IEP team agreed that agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a half-day, regular education program at the Elgin ABC Preschool Center with a 1:1 aide to assist him. (Dist. Exh. 15.) DIS speech and language services were to be provided on site in individual sessions, two times per week for 30 minutes each time. Likewise, OT services were to be provided on site in individual sessions, but only once a week for 60 minutes. Although the Elgin Center program might have satisfied the parents' demand for an inclusive setting for their son, there was virtually no evidence presented about the educational program or how it would address STUDENT's needs. There was also no evidence presented concerning the proposed aide and what duties this person would have or how the aide would function with STUDENT. A vague reference in the IEP that "one to one support will be provided in the full inclusion classroom to assist STUDENT in meeting his goals and objectives and core curriculum" was never explained in the IEP or at the hearing. (Dist. Exh. 15.)
In addition to the lack of evidence about the District's offer, the Hearing Officer notes that in September 1997, STUDENT needed far more than "one to one support" in a half-day full inclusion classroom with 60 minutes per week of speech and language services. STUDENT's need to develop speech and language was critical and his delays in school readiness, socialization, self-help and daily living skills were significant. The District's offer to provide a mere 60 minutes per week in DIS speech and language services with no other language development activities was clearly insufficient in light of STUDENT's functioning at the prelinguistic level. Further, a half-day regular education preschool program might have provided socialization and language opportunities for STUDENT, but seems an unlikely setting to help him quickly develop the communication skills he so desperately needed.
Thus the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove that the Elgin Center placement offer was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs in September 1997. Therefore, it is not necessary for the Hearing Officer to proceed further with the FAPE analysis, and the Hearing Officer moves next to analysis of the second placement offer on March 6, 1998.
The severe language delay/aphasia special day class placement offer
On March 6, 1998, after the completion of updated assessments, STUDENT was offered placement in the half-day, preschool special day class for children with severe language delay/aphasia at Moor Field with DIS speech and language services and OT, and a regular education preschool program at either the Elgin Center or Moor Field. (Dist. Exh. 41.) The District offered the DIS speech and language services and OT at increased levels over those previously offered in September 1997.
Mona Neter, the teacher of the special day class at Moor Field School, has taught for 19 years with extensive experience in preschool, special day class settings. (Testimony of Mona Neter.) She has a master's degree in child development and four teaching credentials including one for the severely handicapped. Ms. Neter testified that she has training and experience in teaching preschool children with autism, and that she had four students with autism in the special day class during the 1997-98 school year. She testified that the special day class is designed to serve preschool-age children with severe language difficulties who are of average cognitive ability. Her basic approach in the class is developmental. During the 1997-98 school year, there were nine disabled children enrolled with one instructor and one instructional aide. The class meets for three hours, 45 minutes, five days per week. (Testimony of ms. Neter, Ms. Fall.)
Ms. Neter described the programs as "language rich" because language is used in every activity, and modeling and prompting are frequently employed. Each child receives individual speech and language assistance during class. Ms. Neter stated that STUDENT would need an aide when he first enrolled because he needs modeling and prompting by an adult most of the time. Ms. Neter testified that the program is structured to provide for sensory stimulation and activities that can be performed regardless of a child's developmental level. Either Ms. Neter or her aide work 1:1 with each child on specific, individual IEP goals for about 45 minutes each day. Time is also set aside for fine motor activities such as cutting or writing. Snack and lunch times are structured to help students with socialization, language and self-help needs. Group activities involve singing, finger plays, calendar activity, table games, dancing and music. (Testimony of Ms. Neter.) Ms. Neter testified that all of STUDENT's IEP goals could be addressed in the special day class. She described a number of techniques which she uses to handle challenging behaviors and stated that she would use behavior approaches to work with STUDENT as long as he has no language. Ms. Neter stated that a parenting class is available at Moor Field School, and that she sends out a monthly newsletter regarding class activities, and maintains active contact with the parents of her students.
Other District witnesses who testified about STUDENT's educational needs consistently recommended that he be placed in a special day class setting to provide the structure and more intense services which he needs. (Testimony of Phyllis Evans, Stephen Bostwick, Mr. Early, Ms. Fall.) Mr. Bostwick, Mr. Early and Ms. Fall each stated their opinion that the severe language delay/aphasia class at Moor Field School was appropriate for STUDENT and would provide skilled staff with the necessary expertise to handle STUDENT's numerous needs.
The parents testified that a special day class has not worked for STUDENT in the past, particularly because he has imitated the negative behaviors of other children. Mrs. PARENT testified that she did not want STUDENT in "a restrictive program with special education kids" and that it was her perception that a special day class is for children with severe learning or behavior problems. Mrs. PARENT disliked the Moor Field School program because it was "unclean," in a trailer, had too many aides, provided overstimulation, had no computers or augmentative equipment, was not an inclusive setting, and had no trees on the playground. In other parts of her testimony, Mrs. PARENT stated that she wanted classroom aides for STUDENT. She did not explain this inconsistency or testify to why she believed the special day class had too many aides or how this would be inappropriate for STUDENT. Mrs. PARENT also provided no specifics to support her view that the class "provided overstimulation." Thus, the Hearing Officer finds Mrs. PARENT's characterization of the special day class to be less credible than that provided by Ms. Neter and other witnesses. Considering all the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the severe language delay/aphasia special day class at Moor Field School, although perhaps less than perfect in the parents' eyes, is nevertheless designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, particularly his need to develop speech and language.
As noted above, the Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to provide sufficient evidence to describe the regular preschool program at the Elgin Center. The District also presented no evidence concerning the regular preschool at Moor Field School was proposed as an alternative site in the March 6 placement offer. Thus, the evidence is insufficient to determine whether either of these programs is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs.
Further, combining either of these regular preschool programs with the special day class does not necessarily mean that the resulting all day program would effectively meet STUDENT's needs. State law does not permit group services for preschoolers which last longer than four hours per day unless determined necessary by the IEP team. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56441.3(b).) Ms. Fall testified that two programs for a total of six hours per day is a long day for a preschooler. She also stated that STUDENT would not benefit from an inclusive program alone, considering his intense needs at this time. Mr. Early disagreed and testified that the combined special day class and inclusive program would allow STUDENT to progress. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) The Hearing Officer found the testimony of both of these witnesses to be credible but finds Ms. Fall's recommendation to be more persuasive due to the well-documented extent of STUDENT's needs and delays in nearly every area of development.
Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT needs a full-day (i.e. fix- to six-hour), full inclusion program because a three to three and one-half hour program means that STUDENT would have "no constructive outlet for the rest of the day." Both parents testified to their concerns that STUDENT's program fit with his sleeping patterns, the parents' daily schedules, and accommodate STUDENT's difficulties with transitions. They also each stated that attending a half-day program would conflict with the family schedule. This testimony, although indicative of family pressures, was not particularly relevant because it did not address STUDENT's unique educational needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer gives it little weight.
Mrs. PARENT testified that she believes STUDENT needs to be in an inclusive program all day and that he is entitled to such a program by law. In her Closing Statement, Mrs. PARENT cited several cases in support of her contention that STUDENT is entitled to a full inclusion classroom. The cases cited concern full inclusion and mainstreaming issues but in contexts very different from that presented here. Full inclusion, integration and mainstreaming of disabled children is clearly important under both the IDEA and California law, but must be considered within the context of the individual child's needs. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) Here, the Hearing Officer has found that the weight of the evidence indicates that the severity of STUDENT's communication needs and the delays in his other developmental areas require a more intensive approach than is available solely in a full inclusion setting which the parents have requested. (See Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56364(a).)
In addition, based on the entire record in this case, it appears to the Hearing Officer that the District has attempted to accommodate the parents' demands for an inclusive setting for their son by offering regular preschool program alternatives. While efforts to cooperate and work togther are encouraged in special education law, accommodation of the parents' wishes may not occur at the child's expense. The District's primary and overriding concern must be to provide an appropriate program to meet STUDENT's unique needs. It is not clear from the evidence presented that a combined program, including a regular education preschool component, would meet STUDENT's unique needs for speech and language development, school readiness, socialization, self-help and daily living skills.
Mr. Early and Ms. Evans both testified that STUDENT would increase his time in individual speech and language services as proposed in the March 6, IEP. Mr. Early recommended that STUDENT's individual speech therapy be increased to two hours per week, and provided in 30 minute sessions four times per week. This service frequency and duration was offered in the March 6 IEP, but was declined by the parents because the District would not provide the services on site at Wonder World. (Dist. Exh. 41.) However, in her testimony, Mrs. PARENT agreed that STUDENT should receive speech services more than one or two times per week and that he needs a consistent program of one to two hours per week. Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's March 6 offer of increased hours (i.e. two hours per week) and frequency (i.e. four times per week) of DIS speech and language services as a supplement to the language-based special day class program was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs.
In sum, two key components of the District's March 6 placement offer were designed to meet STUDENT's needs, particularly his critical need to develop speech and language. Those components are the severe language delay/aphasia special day class at Moor Field School and the increased DIS speech and language services. Because the Hearing Officer has found that these components of the District's March 6 placement offer were designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, each component will be further analyzed.
Would the severe language delay/aphasia special day class with DIS speech and language services have provided STUDENT with educational benefit?
The first component for further analysis is the severe language delay/aphasia special day class. Ms. Neter testified that the severe language delay/aphasia special day class during the 1997-98 had only nine disabled students with herself and an aide in the classroom. This means that the student teacher ratio was about 4:1 which is a low ration and appropriate to meet STUDENT's needs. Ms. Neter stated that she uses four major modalities, i.e. visual, auditory, tactile and kinesthetic, in working with her students. Considering the Hearing Officer's findings regarding STUDENT's delays and developmental level, use of multiple modalities can be expected to be quite beneficial for him. Further, Ms. Neter has both training and recent experience in working with autistic children, and is also well-qualified to teach preschool-age children due to her numerous years of experience in this area. (Testimony of Mrs. Neter.)
Ms. Neter testified that all nine of her 1997-98 students were language delayed at the beginning of the school year. However, by the end of the year, three students had improved to such an extent that two were enrolling in regular education kindergarten and the third was no longer significantly language delayed. (Testimony of Ms. Neter.) Although other children's needs and abilities are obviously different from STUDENT's, nevertheless this track record strongly implies that STUDENT would progress and receive educational benefit by attending Ms. Neter's special day class.
Ms. Neter also described similar changes and progress in behavior exhibited by her students over the school year. At the beginning of the year, she stated that two of her nine preschoolers had age appropriate behavior, but by the end of the year six children acting in an age appropriate manner. Ms. Neter testified that she believed such progress was due to repetition and modeling, trust, a familiar environment, routine, rules and reinforcement for positive behavior. This positive approach to behavior, along with the structured preschool program provided during the half-day session as described above, would address STUDENT's need for a structured classroom environment.
Most notable is the language focus of the special day class. Ms. Neter testified that language goals are part of the class and that significant individual time is given to each student during class to address specific IEP goals. She stated that language is used in every activity through modeling and prompting. Ms. Neter testified that she is aware of language development and stages, and that she attempts to develop and enhance vocabulary through "language- rich experiences."
Mr. Early, who has previously taught a severe language delay/aphasia special day class, testified that he believed that STUDENT would make progress in Ms. Neter's classroom. Mr. Early knows STUDENT well after nearly one year of individual speech therapy work with him. Mr. Early's opinion and the testimony of Ms. Neter's concerning the educational characteristics of the class were not rebutted or effectively challenged by the Student. As already discussed, the parents testified to their opposition to a special day class setting in general, and Mrs. PARENT stated that her problems with Ms. Neter's classroom in particular. However, none of this testimony in the Student's case indicated that STUDENT would fail to receive educational benefit from the severe language delay/aphasia special day class at Moor Field. Therefore, based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the special day class proposed for STUDENT in the March 6 IEP was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because it offered a small, structured setting with low student/ teacher ratio, significant individual attention, and intensive, daily services focused particularly on development of speech and language skills.
The second component for further analysis is the DIS speech and language services offered at the March 6, IEP team meeting. The District proposed to increase these services to two hours per week, offered in individual, 30-minute sessions over four days each week. In previous speech therapy sessions, Mr. Early testified that STUDENT made some progress using the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) and signing exact English. However, Mr. Early stated that STUDENT became "very resistant" to using the PECS in mid-December 1997 and the approach was discontinued soon thereafter at the parents' request. (Stu. Exh. HHHHHHHH.) Mr. Early also testified that, since speech therapy sessions began in May 1997, STUDENT had missed 15 to 20 sessions due to absence or cancellation.
At the hearing, Mr. Early recommended that STUDENT receive more frequent therapy in shorter sessions to provide more consistent service. Mr. Early also testified that the educational setting of the special day class at Moor Field would benefit STUDENT and provide him with intensive language support which should allow him to move to the next level of development. The evidence indicates that combining increased individual speech and language sessions with the intensive special day class program would allow STUDENT to receive more educational benefit from speech therapy. Evidence presented by the Student did not contest this, but did challenge Mr. Early's continued work with STUDENT as discussed in more detail below. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's offer of increased DIS speech and language service combined with the severe language delay/aphasia special day class was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Did the severe language delay/aphasia special day class with DIS speech and language services conform to STUDENT's March 6 IEP goals?
During her testimony, Ms. Neter reviewed STUDENT's March 6 IEP and stated that the developmental deficits which the IEP team noted in STUDENT's present levels of performance are a focus of the special day class curriculum. She stated that the numerous goals and objectives in the IEP covering self-help skills, fine motor skills, preacademic/readiness skills, and social/adaptive skills could all be implemented in her class. Ms. Neter indicated that these goals are "part of the daily routine" and explained in some detail the steps she would take with STUDENT to address them. (Testimony of Ms. Neter.) As discussed above, Ms. Neter also testified that speech and language goals are a major focus of her program, and STUDENT would receive individual speech and language help in class.
In the March 6 IEP, the team developed nine pages of goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas testified to by Ms. Neter. These goals and objectives were developed with extensive parental involvement, and no testimony was presented by the Student to challenge either their appropriateness or Ms. Neter's testimony concerning classroom implementation. The speech and language goals which the IEP team developed can be addressed in class or in individual speech and language therapy sessions. For example, objective "f" in the March 6 IEP states "STUDENT will demonstrate understanding of the following commands by following them with 80% accuracy on 5 separate occasions: give me, point to, put in, put away, take out, pick up, clean up, and show me." (Dist. Exh. 41, pg. 24 of 28.)The March 6 IEP narrative also discusses STUDENT's needs and the District's determination that a special day class, providing intensive instruction, and increased DIS speech and language services are appropriate for him. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed severe language delay/aphasia special day class with DIS speech and language services conforms to STUDENT's March 6 IEP stated goals and objectives developed by the IEP team.
Are the severe language delay/aphasia special day class with DIS speech and language services provided to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment?
Education Code Section 56364(a) provides that "Special classes and centers that enroll pupils with similar and more intensive educational needs shall be available. The classes and centers shall enroll pupils when the nature or severity of the disability precludes their participation in the regular school program for a majority of the school day. Special classes and centers and other removal of individuals with exceptional needs from the regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily due to the nature or severity of the exceptional need."
The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT's needs are such that he requires intensive services to overcome his speech and language delays and other developmental deficits. Due to his need for more intensive services, STUDENT requires the more restrictive environment of a special day class and individual speech and language therapy sessions to meet his IEP goals and to progress more rapidly so that this critical time in his development is not wasted. Thus the Hearing Officer finds, pursuant to Education Code Section 56364 (a), that the March 6 offer of the severe language delay/aphasia special day class with DIS speech and language services provides the least restrictive environment at this time.
* * *
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that two key components of the March 6 placement offer–the severe language delay/aphasia special day class at Moor Field with DIS speech and language services– are appropriate because they are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, would provide him with educational benefit, conform to his IEP goals and objectives, and are provided in the least restrictive environment. However, there was insufficient evidence presented by the District to show that the regular education preschool component at either the Elgin Center or Moor Park School would meet STUDENT's unique needs. Likewise, there was insufficient evidence to conclude that the combined, full-day program offered by the District would meet STUDENT's needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not foreclose further consideration of these components in the future. The District did not offer STUDENT an extended school year program, which the Hearing Officer has found he needed. Finally, the District presented insufficient evidence of the Elgin Center Program and did not prove that the September 1997 placement offer was appropriate to meet STUDENT's needs.
Issue No. 2: Are the parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the 1997-98 school year for STUDENT's unilateral placement at a private community preschool named Wonder World, and for computer services, behavior modification potty training, and speech therapy?
In Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed. (1983) 471 U.S. 359, the U.S. Supreme Court held that parents of disabled children may receive retroactive reimbursement for the tuition and related expenses of unilaterally placing their child in a private special education program. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide the child with a FAPE and the private placement is determined to be proper under the Act and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (Burlington, supra, at 369-370; see also Rowley, supra, at 207; see also Florence County School District Four, et al., v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 20 IDELR 532.) The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has stated that the phrase "reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child" must be applied by determining whether the child made progress toward his IEP goals as a result of the placement. (County of San Diego v. California Special Education hearing Office; Grossmont Union High School District; Fox (9th Cir. 1996) 93 F. 3d 1458; 24 IDELR 756.)
Wonder World preschool
In August 1997, the PARENTs unilaterally placed STUDENT in a full-day community preschool program at Wonder World where he has opportunities to play and do various activities with typically developing children ages three- to six-years- old. Yvonne Madera, the director of Wonder World, testified that STUDENT was in a class with other three and one-half-year-old children during the 1997-98 school year. The class had approximately 11 to 12 children attending daily with one instructor. Some 45 to 50 preschool-age children also attended other classes at Wonder World. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) After January 1998, ELARC provided STUDENT with an aide for three hours per day.
STUDENT is the only autistic child enrolled at Wonder World and the preschool has never before served a child with this diagnosis. (Testimony of Yvonne Madera.) Ms. Madera testified that she felt unqualified to discuss STUDENT's needs, had no training in the field of autism, and was not aware of self-stimulatory behavior which STUDENT many exhibit. Ms. Madera stated that STUDENT's teacher, "Miss Sarah," does not hold any education degrees other than an Early Childhood Education (ECE) certificate, and does not hold any California teaching credentials. (Testimony of Ms. Madera.) Ms. Madera testified that she has a similar educational background and holds only an ECE certificate, and no California teaching credentials. (Testimony of Ms. Madera.) Wonder World is not a certified nonpublic agency or nonpublic school in California and there are no speech therapists or psychologists on staff. (Testimony of Ms. Madera.)
In January 1998, Ms. Madera prepared two written summaries of STUDENT's progress at Wonder World after his five months of attendance. (Stu. Exh. JJJ, NNN.) She noted that STUDENT had made some mild growth in that he was wandering less, eating food on his own, able to sit at a table with his teacher and do some limited arts and crafts activities such as gluing, able to play alongside his classmates, and able to sit on the toilet without fighting or getting up right away. (Stu. Exh. JJJ.) In the area of speech, Ms. Madera stated that STUDENT "does not speak at school, but does like to make different sounds while playing." (Stu. Exh. JJJ.) She stated that STUDENT was making more sounds than when he first attended and noted that he understood and responded to "No" and his name, used sign language to indicate "more," and was able to follow some directions. (Stu. Exh. JJJ, NNN.) At the hearing, Ms. Madera testified that STUDENT says "stop it," "bye-bye," and "I don't want it," which apparently are words he has begun using since January 1998. In May 1998, Ms. Madera completed another evaluation of STUDENT's progress, but noted relatively minor changes in STUDENT's eating patterns and compliance with the preschool program. (Stu. Exh. DDDDDDDD.)
Several District witnesses observed STUDENT in his class at Wonder World preschool. (Testimony of Mr. Early, Ms. Evans, Ms. Fall, Mr. Bostwick.) Mr. Early testified that during his one-hour observation in February 1998, STUDENT "used toys non-functionally" and had virtually no interaction with other children during free play time. One brief interaction with another child was stopped by STUDENT's ELARC aide and the other child was told to play elsewhere. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) Mr. Early also testified that he observed the teacher's interactions with STUDENT and was surprised when she asked STUDENT to be quiet because he was babbling. Mr. Early stated that STUDENT should be encouraged to babble, and when such behavior occurs in therapy, Mr. Early tries to engage STUDENT. (Testimony of Mr. Early.) Mr. Early commented that he had not seen any notable improvement in STUDENT's speech and language as a result of his enrollment at Wonder World.
Ms. Fall observed STUDENT at Wonder World in September and November 1997 before he had the ELARC aide. She testified that STUDENT needed "lots of 1:1 assistance" and that, without prompts and motoring from the teacher, he would stop and go off-task. She expressed concern that Wonder World provided no speech stimulation, language support or interactive speech facilitation which could meet STUDENT's needs in this area. Staff at Wonder World told Ms. Fall that they felt the preschool could not appropriately meet STUDENT's needs. (Testimony of Ms. Fall.) Ms. Fall testified that Wonder World was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because his needs in language, socialization and preacademic readiness cannot be met there and require a more intensive program. The other two District witnesses who observed the program also testified that it was not an appropriate setting for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Evans, Mr. Bostwick.)
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the Wonder World preschool did not provide STUDENT with a program reasonably calculated to meet his educational needs. Although STUDENT made some minimal progress in a few areas such as eating and sitting still, his critical need to develop speech and language and his need for socialization were not effectively addressed at Wonder World. In fact, according to the testimony of Mr. Early, STUDENT's efforts at speech and socialization were interrupted and even stopped by the Wonder World teacher and ELARC aide. Thus the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's unilateral placement at Wonder World during the 1997-98 school year was not an appropriate placement for him considering his many educational needs. The parents' request for reimbursement for Wonder World costs during the 1997-98 school year is denied.
Computer services; behavior modification potty training
The Student requests that his parents be reimbursed for computer services and behavior modification potty training which have been provided since October 1997. (Stu. Closing Statement, pg. 4.) Ms. Madera testified that STUDENT has been in a computer class at Wonder World since December 1997. She stated that the only activity STUDENT has learned to do on his own is to click the mouse after the teacher lines up the arrow on the monitor screen. Even the mouse clicking often required prompting or motoring through. (Stu. Exh. DDDDDDDD.) Once inside the computer game program, STUDENT cannot perform any other functions independently. (Testimony of Ms. Madera.) Mr. Early testified that he did not use computers in speech therapy with STUDENT because STUDENT used the mouse as an object and treated the computer as a toy.
The Student presented no other evidence concerning this claim for reimbursement and has not shown that the computer services which he received assisted him in addressing any of his educational needs. The sole activity which STUDENT performed on the computer was clicking the mouse. From Mr. Early's testimony, it appears that not even this activity was functional or meaningful for STUDENT. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the computer services which STUDENT received provided him with virtually no educational benefit and the reimbursement request is denied.
No evidence was offered concerning the "behavior modification potty training" for which the parents seek reimbursement. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no way to determine if this service provided STUDENT with any educational benefit in accordance with his needs. The parents' request for reimbursement is denied.
Speech therapy
The parents also seek reimbursement for private speech therapy which they have apparently provided since April 1998. The parents unilaterally removed STUDENT from the District's speech and language services on march 19, 1998 due to their dissatisfaction with Sean Early, the staff person providing the service. (Dist. Exh. 46; testimony of Mrs. PARENT. ) The District contends that the parents' action was directly related to Mr. Early's testimony at the hearing on March 17. (Dist. Closing Brief, pg. 52.)
The Hearing Officer found in Issue No. 1 that the District's March 6 offer of increased DIS speech and language services was appropriate. Concerning the parents' objection to mr. Early, the Hearing Officer notes that Education Code Section 56363(a) states that DIS services shall be provided by the "appropriate designated instruction and services specialist" where the teacher or resource specialist is not competent to provide the specific service or it is not feasible for them to do so. Mr. Early is a speech and language specialist whose job is to provide speech and language services to children such as STUDENT. From Mr. Early's testimony concerning his qualifications, background work with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer is satisfied that he is qualified to serve as STUDENT's speech and language therapist. The parents' contention that STUDENT cannot work with a male therapist was not supported by a shred of convincing evidence to that effect. Further, the Hearing Office does not typically order local education agencies to assign or remove specific personnel at the parent's request. Thus because the increased DIS speech and language services offered by the District at the March 6 IEP team meeting were appropriate, particularly as offered in conjunction with the special day class, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Student's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language services which STUDENT has received since April 1998.
Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year?
The last IEP team meeting for STUDENT occurred on April 20, 1998 when the parents and the District met to review the Augmentative-Assistive Technology Assessment results. The District made no changes in its March 6 placement offer at this meeting, and there was no evidence presented of any subsequent IEP team meetings or formal, written offers of placement by the District. Therefore, the District's March 6 placement offer stands as the proposed placement for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year.
As discussed above, two key components of the March 6 offer -- the severe language delay/aphasia special day class at Moor Field and the DIS speech and language services-- would have appropriately addressed STUDENT's needs during the 1997-98 school year. No evidence was presented to indicate that those needs had changed by the end of the hearing. Therefore, based on the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that these two components of the offer would also provide STUDENT with an appropriate placement during the 1998-99 school year.
Although these components can provide the core of an appropriate program for STUDENT, certain troubling questions remain as to what additional services STUDENT may need. Insufficient evidence was presented in many areas, particularly concerning STUDENT's need for behavior modification using discrete trial training and/or regular education preschool such as Elgin Center or Moor Field. The Hearing Officer is concerned that none of the participants or witnesses testifying at hearing had in-depth experience or even self-declared expertise in the field of autism. These deficiencies should be explored and addressed by the IEP team at the next meeting in order to ensure that STUDENT receives all the appropriate services he needs to become as fully functioning as possible.
In sum, two key components of the District's March 6 offer would still be appropriate for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year, based on the evidence presented at hearing. These are the severe language delay/ aphasia special day class at Moor Field School and the increased DIS speech and language services. The parties do not dispute the continued appropriateness of occupational therapy services for STUDENT. As already noted above, there was insufficient evidence presented by the District to show that the regular education preschool component at either the Elgin Center or Moor Park School would meet STUDENT's unique needs. Likewise, there was insufficient evidence to conclude that the combined, full-day program offered by the District would meet STUDENT's needs. Therefore, these components may require further consideration by the IEP team. The District did not offer STUDENT an extended school year program, which the Hearing Officer has found he needed.
Issue No. 4: Is the parents' proposed private placement at Wonder World, with an "individualized discrete trials behavior modification program," and "instructional, behavioral and inclusive aides" appropriate for STUDENT in the 1998-99 school year?
The parents' proposed private placement at Wonder World with an "individualized discrete trials behavior modification program" has already been found to be inappropriate for STUDENT for reasons stated above. Further, even if Wonder World preschool were appropriate to meet STUDENT's needs, the Hearing Officer could not order it as a prospective placement because the program is not a certified nonpublic school as required under California law. (Ed. Code Sec. 56505.2(a).)
The Student has also made other unsupported requests for services including, RSP services, "functional analysis exam," itinerant instruction, and supplementary educational aides. None of these requests was tied to an evidentiary showing of need or otherwise elaborated upon. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student's request for "instructional, behavioral and inclusive aides," RSP services, "functional analysis exam," itinerant instruction, and supplementary educational aides has not been shown to be reasonably calculated to meet STUDENT's educational needs. Each of these requests is denied.
Issue No. 5: Did the District violate the parents' procedural rights to participate in the IEP process during the 1997 and 1998, such that STUDENT was denied a FAPE?
Under state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 5600 et seq. ) This right includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an IEP and placement for a disabled child. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees (9th Cir. 1992) 18 IDELR 1019, 1021; Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982( 458 U.S. 176, 181.) Among the most basic of these is the parents' right to participate in the development of IEPs and placement decisions regarding their child. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56341, 56342; 34 CFR Sec. 300.345, 300.533.) When appropriate, the IEP team must include other individuals who possess expertise or knowledge necessary for the development of the individualized education program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56341(c)(2).) The parents have the right to consent or not consent to all components of their child's program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56346.) The District must also ensure that a continuum of alternative placements is available to meet the needs of disabled children. (Cal. Ed. Code 56361; 34 CFR Sec. 300.551.)
Here, the PARENTs contend that they have been denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process and in decisions regarding their son's education. They contend that they have not been "properly respected as members of the IEP team." (Stu. Exh. VVVV.) From testimony at the hearing and documentary evidence, including numerous faxes, letters and memos of phone calls, it appears to the Hearing Officer that the PARENTs' basic concern is lack of the ability to control the IEP process and make final decisions regarding STUDENT's education. (Stu. Exh. EEEEE.) Neither of these is a "right" under special education law.
As for the issue of participation in the IEP process and decision-making, the evidence overwhelmingly indicates that the PARENTs have participated fully and actively in the IEP process and placement decisions. There were a total of seven IEP team meetings– March 13, 1997, May 5, 1997, June 5, 1997, September 4, 1997, February 11, 1998, March 6, 1998 and April 20, 1998 – attended by the parents over the eleven months after the initiation of special education services for STUDENT. In addition, two IEP addendums were completed, apparently via telephone calls to modify the September 4, 1997 IEP in accordance with the parents' wishes. (Dist. Exh. 17, Stu. Exh. G, IIIII.) The evidence consistently showed that IEP meetings lasted anywhere from one to three hours, that the parents were actively involved offering goals and objectives, commenting on assessments, asking questions and discussing the pros and cons of various placement alternatives.(Testimony of Ms. Cline, Margaret Azevedo-Ikezaki, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT.)
Margaret Azevedo-Ikezaki, the District's coordinator of special education, testified that she handled the PARENTs' questions and concerns in at least 45 phone conversations and numerous faxes received from January 1997 to April 1998. (See Dist. Exh. 54.) If anything, the evidence suggests that the parent's continual questioning and challenging of each step of the process tended to slow down the educational planning for STUDENT. (Stu. Exh. CCCCCCCCC.) The Hearing Officer finds that the parents' participation in their son's IEP process and placement decision-making was active and continuous and did not deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education on procedural grounds during the 1997 and 1998. As for the parents' request to be accorded proper respect as members of the IEP team, it should go without saying that respectful communication and participation is "must" for all involved in planning STUDENT's educational future --District staff and parents alike.
Issue No. 6: Has the District performed appropriate and valid assessments of STUDENT between January 1997 and April 1998? If not, are the parents entitled to another assessment at public expense?
Under Education Code 56329(b), a parent is entitled to a free and appropriate special education assessment of his or her child. If the parent disagrees with the assessment performed by the school district, the parent may obtain an independent educational assessment of the child and seek reimbursement. However, the school district may initiate due process hearing procedures to show that its assessment was appropriate. If the district's assessment is determined to be appropriate, then the parent will not be reimbursed, but the independent assessment results must still be considered by the IEP team. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56329(b).)
Assessments performed by the school district must be administered in the pupil's primary language, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, administered by credentialed school psychologist where intellectual or emotional functioning are being tested or administered by trained personnel in the case of other tests, tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(a)-(c),) Tests must be selected and administered to best ensure that results accurately reflect the pupil's aptitude, achievement level, or other factors, and no single procedure can be used as a sole criterion to determine an appropriate educational program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(d) -(e).) Pupils must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(f).)
Here, the parents have not obtained their own independent assessment, but rather seek to have the district perform another assessment at public expense. They contend that the assessments of STUDENT performed between January 1997 and April 1998 were not appropriate. The primary objections of the parents concern the psychological assessments completed by Ms. Cline in early 1997 and by Ms. Fall in late 1997. (Stu. Exhs. WW, MMMMM, PPPPP, RRRRR.)
The District completed two rounds of assessments during the 1997 calendar year. The initial assessment of STUDENT occurred in January, February and March 1997. The second round was completed, at the parents' request, from July through November 1997. Assessment plans were signed by the parents for each round of assessment and evaluated all areas of suspected disability, including academic/ preacademic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development, intellectual development, adaptive physical education and other areas. (Dist. Exhs. 37, 11, 12, 14, 22, 45.)
The assessments of STUDENT's intellectual and emotional functioning were completed by credentialed school psychologists, Donna Cline and Rachel Fall. Other assessments were completed by District personnel trained to administer those tests. (Testimony of Kathy Crane, mr. Early, Ms. Evans, Mr. Bostwick.) All assessments were completed in English, STUDENT's primary language, and notations were made and cautions were given where STUDENT's communication difficulties may have affected the test results. (Testimony of Ms. Fall.) There was no evidence that any of the tests were racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory, and no single procedure was used as a sole criterion to determine an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. The tests used to assess STUDENT were each validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. (Dist. Exhs. 1, 21, 27, 28, 30, 50.)The parents objected to Ms. Fall's use of certain testing instruments, specifically the Vineland, and claimed that she was on qualified to assess an autistic child such as STUDENT. (Stu. Exhs. PPPPP, RRRRR.) Neither of these objections was supported by the evidence. Ms. Fall testified credibly about her reasons for using the Vineland, and reviewed the steps she took to explain the assessment to the parents and to involve them in the process. Ms. Fall testified that she has used the Vineland consistently, is very familiar with the test, and considers it to have a high degree of reliability. Ms. Fall also testified that she has completed 300 to 500 psychological assessments and has previously assessed children with the diagnosis of autism.
The Hearing Officer notes that the updated assessment completed by the District in late 1997 was extensive, involved interviews and observations of STUDENT, and repeated contacts with the parents to review testing and answer their questions. Extensive discussions of the updated assessment and the initial assessment occurred at the IEP team meetings designated for review of the results. Ms. Cline responded to parental objections and questions by letter soon after she completed STUDENT's first psychological evaluation. (Stu. Exh. JJJJJJJ.) Considering this and all the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the two rounds of assessment completed by the District were appropriate and conformed to all the above-noted requirements under special education law. The parents request for an additional assessment at public expense is denied.
* * *
The Student has also requested that his mother be paid for "the loss of money and hardship" for representing his interests at six days of hearing without legal counsel. No authority exists for such payment, as the Hearing Officer stated at the hearing. Therefore, the Student's request for such payment is denied.
ORDER
1. The District must convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the date of this Decision to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. The IEP team shall include a qualified expert on the subject of autism and the education of autistic children, pursuant to Education Code section 56341(c)(2). At the meeting, the IEP team shall design and offer an appropriate program for STUDENT which shall include the following components or equivalent services to meet STUDENT's unique need as identified in this Decision: a.) A severe language delay/aphasia special day classes such as the one at Moor Field School; b.) Increased DIS speech and language services offering no less than two hours of individual speech and language services per week, for 30 minutes each day, four hours per week; c.) DIS occupational therapy services; and d.) Extended school year services.
The IEP team shall also further consider and determine the appropriateness of behavior modification using discrete trial training, and/or regular education preschool programs such as Elgin Center or Moor Field based on STUDENT's unique needs as identified in this Decision and input from the autism expert.
2. All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finds are made in accordance with this statute.
Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate placements during the 1997-98 school year?
Neither party substantially prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Are the parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the 1997-98 school year for STUDENT's unilateral placement at a private community preschool named Wonder World, and for computer services, behavior modification potty training, and speech therapy?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year?
The District substantially prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: Is the parents' proposed private placement at Wonder World, with an "individualized discrete trials behavior modification program," and "instructional, behavioral and inclusive aides" appropriate for STUDENT in the 1998-99 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 5: Did the District violate the parents' procedural rights to participate in the IEP process during the 1997 and April 1998, such that STUDENT was denied a FAPE?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 6: Has the District performed appropriate and valid assessments of STUDENT between January 1997 and April 1998? If not, is the parent entitled to another assessment at the public expense?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)
DATED: September 10, 1998 ______________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Mrs. PARENT testified that the parents did not consider the September 4, 1998, meeting to be an IEP team meeting.
2. There was testimony that the District also offered an aide to assist STUDENT in both the regular education preschool and the special day class. However, this portion of the offer is not reflected on the written IEP document from the March 6, 1998 meeting, and thus does not satisfy the requirements of Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 20 IDELR 987. (See Dist. Exh. 41.)
3. Although Petitioner has challenged the appropriateness of his first placement at the Scott Developmental Center in Pasadena, he has requested no remedy for the alleged denial of FAPE there. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not adjudicate that issue, but will consider whether there was a denial of FAPE for procedural reasons during the spring of 1997 in accordance with Issue No. 5.
4. The evidence indicates that ELARC agreed to fund the Wonder World preschool program with a 1:1 aide for STUDENT through the completion of due process hearing. (Testimony of MR. AND MRS. PARENT; Stu. Exh. DDDD.)
5. The Student made a number of general requests, specifically that the District "follow IDEA laws and follow the IEP procedures, ... have parental groups or committees to monitor and assist parents with procedural information and guidance in IEP matters, ...provide its staff and parents with current special education workshops and classes as designed in the IDEA laws, ...update and keep current special education plan for their district." (Stu. Closing Statement, pg. 23). As the Hearing Officer indicated at the hearing, none of these general remedies is appropriate considering the issues presented for decision. In addition, some are beyond the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office.
6. The Hearing Officer notes that the PARENTs have challenged this assessment completely by Ms. Fall. Full discussion of the assessment issues rased by the PARENTs is contained in Issue No. 6 and will not be repeated here. Suffice it to say that the Hearing Officer has concluded that the assessment was valid and appropriate and the results reliable
7. No Testimony or argument was presented by either the District or the Student concerning the appropriateness of STUDENT's OT services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not analyze this component of the placement offers as it is not in dispute.
8. The Hearing Officer notes that, at the March 6, 1998 IEP team meeting, the District offered to refer STUDENT for an additional assessment through the Southern California Diagnostic Center. (Dist. Exh. 41.) The parents declined this offer. (Testimony of Mrs. PARENT.)
