California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 7, 1998
Student v. Bellflower Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1686-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Hearing Officer finds Bellflower Unified denied FAPE in speech and social skills services, but orders no relief after compensatory claim was withdrawn.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a seven-year-old girl with autism filed for a hearing against Bellflower Unified School District. Before the hearing, they withdrew their general FAPE claim and their request for compensatory education. That left three questions: did she need a one-on-one aide in 1998-99; did she need individual speech therapy from a provider experienced with autism; and must the district reimburse private speech therapy from Dr. Lauren Franke, who used the Links With Language program?
The Hearing Officer found she did not need an aide in class. Most witnesses, including the district's autism expert, Dr. Charlop-Christy, said a classroom aide would make her rely on adults. But she did need an individualized social skills program, a one-on-one aide at recess and lunch, and math tutoring. The district's failure to provide them denied FAPE in 1998-99. The Hearing Officer also found the district's speech services inadequate in every year reviewed. She needed individual therapy three times a week, and the district missed 19 of her group sessions in 1997-98. District staff were found qualified to work with children with autism.
Reimbursement was denied. The Links program did not address her social language needs, used aversive techniques, and was offered by trained district staff. Because the compensatory education claim had been withdrawn, the Hearing Officer denied all relief. She also ruled the student had not prevailed on the first two issues.
Why it matters
This case shows how dropping a compensatory education claim before hearing can leave a student with no relief, even when the Hearing Officer finds a denial of FAPE. It also shows SEHO denying reimbursement for private therapy that did not fit the student's needs and that the district had offered.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did Student require a one-on-one instructional aide from District staff trained in autism to receive educational benefit during the 1998-99 school year?
A classroom aide was not needed and would have made her dependent on adults. But she needed an individualized social skills program, a one-on-one aide at recess and lunch, and math tutoring, and the lack of these denied FAPE in 1998-99. No remedy was given, and the Hearing Officer stated Student could not be considered to have prevailed.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did Student require individual speech and language therapy from a provider knowledgeable in speech and language services for autistic children from December 1, 1996, through the present?
Student needed individual speech therapy three times a week, and the district's speech services denied FAPE in each year reviewed, including 19 missed group sessions in 1997-98. District staff were qualified to work with children with autism. No remedy was given because compensatory education had been withdrawn, so the Hearing Officer stated Student did not prevail.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language services from December 1, 1996, to the present?
Reimbursement was denied. The private Links With Language therapy did not meet Student's pragmatic language needs, used aversive techniques, had no baseline data, and was offered by trained district staff.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order: all of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied. The Hearing Officer found denials of FAPE but could not order compensatory education because Petitioner withdrew that claim before the hearing. The findings may be considered at the IEP meeting for 1999-2000.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education; Union School Dist. v. Smith
People named in the decision
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, psychologist, director of Autism Services at UCLA; expert witness for Student, UCLA
- Dr. Linda Smedley, director of pupil services, Bellflower Unified School District
- Joanne Pon Rubin, program specialist for special education, Bellflower Unified School District
- Dr. Lauren Franke, private psychologist and speech-language pathologist (Links With Language provider), private practice; Scottish Rite Center
- Susan Barnes Poland (also spelled Barnes-Polland), district speech and language specialist, Bellflower Unified School District
- Ester Schoem, special education aide, Bellflower Unified School District
- Samina Faridani, speech pathologist assigned to Bellflower, Los Angeles County Department of Education
- Phyllis O'Boyle, special day class teacher (1998-99), Bellflower Unified School District
- Angela White, instructional aide, Bellflower Unified School District
- Terri Kirshbaum Taylor, adapted physical education teacher, Bellflower Unified School District
- Barbara Hinds, director of child development / principal, Betsy Ross Pre-School, Bellflower Unified School District
- Sandy Lex, preschool special day class teacher and speech-language pathologist, Bellflower Unified School District
- Ms. Chancy, preschool special day class teacher, Bellflower Unified School District
- Dr. Charlop-Christy, independent autism specialist retained by District; expert witness for District, Claremont Autism Center; Claremont College
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Bellflower, California, on April 20, 22, 23, May 25, 26, 27, and July 7, 8, 9, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Bruce Bothwell with the law firm of Pray, Price, Williams and Russell. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was her mother, MRS. PARENT. Petitioner's father, MR. PARENT, was present for portions of the hearing. Respondent Bellflower Unified School District (hereinafter District or Bellflower) was represented by attorney Bobbie Albanese with the law firm of Lozano, Smith, Smith, Woliver and Behrens. Also present on Respondent's behalf was Dr. Linda Smedley, Bellflower's director of pupil services. For one day of the hearing, Joanne Pon Rubin, a program specialist for the District, acted as the District's representative in place of Dr. Smedley. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. B.J. Freeman, psychologist; Dr. Linda Smedley, director of pupil services for Bellflower; MRS. PARENT, mother of Petitioner; Dr. Lauren Franke, psychologist and speech and language pathologist; Susan Barnes Poland, speech and language specialist; Ester Schoem, special education aide; Samina Faridani, Los Angeles County Department of Education speech pathologist; Phyllis O'Boyle, special day class teacher; and Angela White, instructional aide. The Respondent called the following witness to testify: Joanne Pon Rubin, program specialist; Terri Kirshbaum Taylor, adaptive physical education (APE) teacher; Barbara Hinds, director of child development/principal Betsy Ross Pre-School; Dr. Linda Smedley, director of pupil services; Samina Faridani, speech pathologist; Sandy Lex, preschool teacher; and Dr. Charlop-Christy, psychologist; Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS Before the hearing began, the Petitioner withdrew the general issue of whether the District had offered her a free and appropriate education (FAPE), asserting instead, the specific issues of whether the District had failed to provide individual speech instruction from a therapist familiar with autistic children and whether she required an individual aide throughout her school day. The Petitioner also withdrew the issue of whether she was entitled to compensatory education. The Hearing Officer therefore will not consider compensatory education or the general issue of a denial of a FAPE for the school years of 1995-96 through 1998-99, except to the extent that supplemental services in the form of speech therapy and a one-on-one aide are necessary to provide a FAPE. Although the Petitioner framed her issues in the future tense, no Individual Education Plan (IEP) meeting had yet been convened and STUDENT's placement and services for the 1999-2000 school year had not been determined at the time of hearing. The parties therefore agreed that the Hearing Officer would not decide STUDENT's future program for the 1999-2000 school year, and the issues herein would be confined to STUDENT's past needs and the issue of reimbursement. The parties further agreed that they would convene an IEP meeting following receipt of this decision to discuss the Petitioner's placement and services for the 1999-2000 school year. ISSUES l. Did (footnote 1) STUDENT require a one-on-one instructional aide from District staff trained in autism to receive educational benefit during the 1998-99 school year? 2. Did STUDENT require individual speech and language therapy from a provider knowledgeable in speech and language services for autistic children from December 1, 1996, through the present? 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language services from December 1, 1996, to the present? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a seven-year-old girl who was diagnosed with autism just before her third birthday by Dr. B.J. Freeman at the UCLA School of Medicine. Dr. Freeman found that STUDENT's cognitive verbal skills were within the normal range for her age. However, her social and communication abilities were delayed and she exhibited problem behaviors. Dr. Freeman stated in her report that STUDENT's school placement should be in a highly structured class that stressed appropriate social and language skills. She further recommended that STUDENT receive individual speech therapy three times a week and small-group therapy two times a week. In the latter part of the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT turned three years old and became eligible for services from her school district. She was assessed by Bellflower's Early Intervention Team, which consisted of a school psychologist, a speech pathologist, an APE specialist, and three special education teachers. The assessment team concluded that STUDENT had average nonverbal cognitive abilities and average motor skills, with delays in the areas of social-emotional, adaptive and communication skills. It determined that she was eligible for special education due to her diagnosis of autism. STUDENT was enrolled in a morning preschool special day class (SDC) for children with severe language delays for the remainder of the 1994-95 school year. The class was taught by Ms. Lex, a speech and language pathologist, and emphasized language development as well as social and behavioral skills. MR. and MRS. PARENT agreed with the preschool placement, but requested additional individual speech and language services to augment the preschool class. The District maintained that individual speech therapy was unnecessary because the class was language- based and taught by a speech pathologist. STUDENT remained in Ms. Lex's class for the 1995-96 school year. In addition to attending the morning preschool class, STUDENT was enrolled in a "Mommy and Me" class through the adult education program for two afternoons each week for socialization with normally developing peers. The District provided an aide to assist STUDENT and her mother in this program. STUDENT's annual IEP meeting was convened on May 21, 1996. She had attained all of her IEP goals and objectives. Academically, STUDENT knew the colors, shapes, and alphabet. She could rote count to ten and complete simple puzzles. She was using single words to communicate her needs and responding to "what" questions. Behaviorally, she "enjoy[ed] bothering other children by touching, pushing, etc. [and] sometimes acts aggressively toward peers." STUDENT exhibited a self-stimulating behavior of "snorting" with her nose into her hands and rubbing the mucus on herself and others. She also tantrumed, "flung" herself onto the ground, and displayed perseverative behaviors. She interrupted her peers by rubbing their heads and squeezing their arms. Socially, she would parallel play, but rarely interacted with her peers. MR. and MRS. PARENT had continued to contend that STUDENT required individual speech therapy to address her language needs and the behaviors that interfered with her acquisition of speech. When the District did not provide it, they obtained private therapy from Dr. Lauren Franke, a psychologist and speech pathologist. At the IEP meeting of May 1996, the parents requested funding from the District for STUDENT's private speech therapy with Dr. Franke. They also provided information about the Links With Language program (hereinafter Links) that Dr. Franke had implemented with STUDENT. It was decided that this parental request would be discussed at another meeting to be held on or before June 24, 1996. The meeting to discuss funding for the Links program was actually reconvened on July 3, 1996. The District's staff had reviewed the information concerning Links which MRS. PARENT had provided at the prior meeting and had sent staff to a seminar to be trained to provide the program. Bellflower did not agree to fund STUDENT's private therapy with Dr. Franke. Instead, it offered to provide the Links program to STUDENT through two twenty-minute individual therapy sessions per week, as recommended by the program's developers. The District stated that Links could be provided by either Samina Faridani, a District speech pathologist, or Sandy Lex, STUDENT's teacher/speech pathologist. Both Ms. Faridani and Ms. Lex had attended the training seminar for Links. MRS. PARENT declined the District's offer of the Links program, preferring that STUDENT continue to receive her speech therapy from Dr. Franke. MOTHER stated that STUDENT had established a bond with Dr. Franke, and it would not be in STUDENT's best interest to change her therapist. The District advised MRS. PARENT that the Links program would be available for STUDENT when school resumed in September 1996 and that she could initiate this service by contacting the District if she changed her mind. STUDENT again returned to Ms. Lex's class when the 1996-97 school year began. In January 1997, an IEP meeting was convened and STUDENT was moved to Ms. Chancy's preschool SDC to complete the 1996-97 school year. STUDENT's younger brother had also entered Ms. Lex's language-based class with a diagnosis of autism, and it was determined to be in the best interest of each sibling to be in his or her own classroom. Because Ms. Chancy was not a speech pathologist, the District offered STUDENT small-group speech therapy for twenty minutes sessions two times per week. This offer was accepted, and Ms. Faridani, a county speech pathologist assigned to Bellflower, began providing speech therapy to STUDENT in January 1997. The IEP team also decided that STUDENT would benefit from remaining in the preschool SDC for the 1997-98 school year rather than transitioning to kindergarten. On June 4, 1998, the IEP team met for STUDENT's three-year evaluation. The participants decided that additional time was required to assess all of the information and issues presented at the IEP meeting. The parents agreed to extend the time line for the triennial IEP meeting and reconvene before July 17, 1998. The issues to be determined were the parents' requests for intensive language therapy, reimbursement for Dr. Franke, a behavioral intervention plan, social skills training, an occupational therapy assessment, one-on-one supervision, and a communication system. The IEP team met again on July 13, 1998. Team members reported that STUDENT could identify letters and prepositions, but not other words. She knew some personal information, could write her first and last names and copy letters. She could not identify greater and lesser numbers. STUDENT's volitional expressive speech remained severely delayed. However, her language had increased to simple sentences and she used language for requests and to respond to the questions of others. She continued to play alone and displayed little interest in her peers. The following goals were proposed for STUDENT: to improve her social interaction with peers; increase communication skills; expand reading readiness; develop math readiness; improve written language; increase attending abilities; enhance participation in group activities; improve pragmatic speech; and increase vocal inflection. MR. and MRS. PARENT were very concerned that their daughter had not fully met any of her prior year's IEP goals and wanted additional time to review the assessment reports and the suggested goals. They did agree that STUDENT would be placed in an SDC for first-through third-graders at Thomas Jefferson Elementary School. The team agreed to meet again in September 1998 to continue the IEP meeting. On September 21, 1998, MRS. PARENT sent the District forty-four preliminary goals that she intended to present at the IEP meeting scheduled for September 24, 1998. On that same date, she requested reimbursement for an independent evaluation conducted by Dr. Franke and advised the District that an attorney would be participating in the IEP meeting on the family's behalf. To accommodate the schedule of the District's attorney, the IEP meeting was rescheduled for September 28, 1998. Placement had been agreed upon at the last meeting. At the September IEP meeting, the District offered the following DIS services: (1) individual speech/language two times per week, twenty minutes per session, with once-a-week consultation with the SDC teacher; (2) adapted physical education (APE) in the form of one time per week consultation with the teacher; and (3) occupational therapy collaboration one time per month. The District further agreed that the SDC teacher would provide the Links program twice a week in a small-group setting for twenty minutes per session. This program would also be used in the classroom throughout the day. Mr. and MRS. PARENT agreed to the goals and objectives presented by the District. The meeting was continued until October 7, 1998, at which time the team would discuss reimbursement for Dr. Franke's speech services, a home Links program, recreational therapy with normally developing peers, social skills training at home, a one-to-one aide in the classroom, STUDENT's ability to follow directions, and the proposed speech and language goals. The parties met again as scheduled on October 7, 1998, to discuss the outstanding issues. In addition to the above offer of services, the District agreed to incorporate the parents' speech and language goals into STUDENT's IEP. It did not agree to fund the private provision of the Links program by Dr. Franke. It maintained that it had trained speech pathologists and had offered Links to STUDENT since May 1996. Arrangements were made to minimize STUDENT's transitions and the parents withdrew the request for recreational therapy. A one-on-one aide was deemed unnecessary by the District as STUDENT's teacher stated that STUDENT participated in the class on her own, she was easily redirected, and that an aide would be detrimental to her independence. The District did agree to provide an instructional aide for academic support to STUDENT's classroom until its program was reviewed by a consultant familiar with autism. It also arranged for STUDENT's SDC teacher to provide STUDENT with a half hour of individual instruction each day to reinforce her Links program. The SDC teacher had previously been trained in the first portions of the Links program and agreed to participate in future training. MR. and MRS. PARENT agreed to these proposals and the IEP was signed, with the parents reserving their reimbursement claim for Dr. Franke's services and a one-on-one aide, if required. The Petitioner has now filed for a due process hearing asserting that she required the services of a one-on-one aide throughout her school day, individual speech therapy from a provider with expertise in the language needs of children with autism, and requesting reimbursement for the speech therapy provided by Dr. Franke. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES The Petitioner contends that to benefit from her education, she required a District one-on-one aide throughout the school day who was trained in the needs of autistic children. She further claims that Bellflower failed to provide her with indiviual speech therapy and the behavioral/social intervention required to benefit from speech therapy from a therapist trained in autism since she entered the District's preschool program. As a result, she seeks reimbursement for private speech therapy provided by Dr. Franke. The District's position is that it has consistently provided the Petitioner with appropriate speech services in addition to its attempt to accommodate the parents' request for the Links program by sending its staff to the requisite training seminar and offering to provide the program through its speech pathologists. For these reasons, Bellflower denies any obligation to reimburse the Petitioner's parents for the services of an independent speech therapist. The District also denies that the Petitioner ever needed a one-on-one instructional aide to benefit from her education and claims that, in fact, an aide would have been detrimental to her independence. ISSUE ONE DID STUDENT REQUIRE A ONE-ON-ONE INSTRUCTIONAL AIDE DURING THE 1998-99 SCHOOL YEAR? DISCUSSION Although the Petitioner has dismissed her general claim against Bellflower for its failure to offer her a FAPE, she is claiming that the District's failure to provide a one-on-one aide and individual speech therapy resulted in the absence of a FAPE. As indicated below, depravation of supplemental services can result in the denial of a FAPE. Therefore, in the context of addressing the Petitioner's issues, the Hearing Officer will discuss whether STUDENT had a unique need for an individual aide and speech therapy to receive educational benefit, and whether the District's failure to provide these services resulted in a denial of a FAPE. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. 1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. 1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform to the students individualized education program. Special education law provides that as part of an appropriate education, the child is entitled to "related services." Related services include transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. 1401(22). California Education Code 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, aide assistance, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management. The related services that the Petitioner alleges she was denied are direct speech intervention from a therapist experienced with autism and an individual District aide trained in autism for her entire school day. In determining whether a district has offered the services necessary to make a free, appropriate public education available, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed services. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another type of program, or whether their preferred services would result in greater educational benefit to the child. Services are adequate if they are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987). In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) identifies and addresses the student's unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, and (3) conforms to the IEP. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq. It is the Petitioner's position that she needed an instructional aide assigned to her throughout her school day to provide repeated redirection to help her remain focused on her school work, and to provide facilitation, intervention, and modeling to acquire social skills. She also contends that she required direct aide supervision to respond to the self-stimulatory behaviors that prevented her from attending and interacting with her environment. To determine whether Bellflower was obligated to assign an individual aide to STUDENT, it is first necessary to determine whether STUDENT had a unique need for this supplemental service to benefit from her education. Following a review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner presented scant information that STUDENT required a one-on-one aide from December l, 1966 through the 1997-98 school year. The documentary evidence, and the vast majority of the testimony presented by the Petitioner, focused on STUDENT's need for an individual aide during the 1998-99 school year. For this reason, the Hearing Officer concludes that insufficient evidence was presented to find that STUDENT needed a one-on-one aide during the 1995-96, 1996-97, and 1997-98 school years. Instead, the Hearing Officer will address the evidence that was presented concerning STUDENT's need for her own aide during the 1998-99 school year. Dr. B.J. Freeman was called by the Petitioner to provide her opinion concerningSTUDENT's need for an aide. Dr. Freeman has a PhD in psychology, she is a professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), and she is also the director of Autism Services at UCLA. She testified that she has had twenty-five years of experience with autistic children. Dr. Freeman diagnosed STUDENT with autism and has periodically followed her since STUDENT was three years old. When testifying regarding the specific purpose of an individual aide for STUDENT at the present time, Dr. Freeman clarified that the aide was primarily needed during unstructured activities such as recess, lunch and free times. Dr. Freeman explained that STUDENT has not made appreciable progress with social skills or pragmatic language and she cannot learn social interaction merely by being around other children. She needs to be taught social skills. To accomplish this, she requires a "structured functional social skill curriculum" tailored to STUDENT's specific needs and an aide during social times to facilitate her social interactions. She stated that the aide should be assigned to STUDENT, but not "velcroed on" to her, and should help her incorporate other children into her activities. Dr. Freeman also testified that the social program should be developed and the aide trained and supervised by someone experienced with autism disorders. The goal would be for the aide to be "faded" (incrementally less aide involvement) as STUDENT learns to function independently. Dr. Lauren Franke is a licensed speech and language pathologist and has a PhD in psychology. She works with language-delayed children at the Scottish Rite Center and has a private practice. Approximately 85% of her current practice is with autistic children. Dr. Franke has provided individual speech therapy for STUDENT for several years. She testified that STUDENT requires an aide because the group teaching method used in the classroom she observed during the 1998-99 school year leaves STUDENT "on her own too much and she does not focus." This results in too much "down time" and STUDENT "goes into her own world." She then resorts to self-stemming behaviors that interfere with learning and peer interaction and require an aide's intervention. According to Dr. Franke, the aide should be provided during STUDENT's core academics and recesses. An aide should also individualize STUDENT's program and provide direct instruction so that she can benefit from the entire school day. In Dr. Franke's opinion, STUDENT would not become dependent on the aide if the aide were properly trained and knew that STUDENT should not be given assistance when she did not need it. She also testified that the aide would require training in autism, STUDENT's needs, her program, and the correct way to model social behavior for her. The goal would be to fade the aide and teach STUDENT to be less dependent. Supervision should be provided to the aide one time each week by an autism specialist. Several District employees testified that STUDENT did not require a one-on-one aide. Phyllis O'Boyle, STUDENT's SDC teacher for the 1998-99 school year, testified that STUDENT becomes adult dependent when one is constantly present. She found that this had occurred in the past with her classroom aides, so she had instructed them to no longer "shadow" STUDENT. Ms. O'Boyle described STUDENT as easily redirected with verbal prompts. She stated that STUDENT participates in class activities on her own and rarely daydreams or displays self-stimulating behaviors that interfere with learning. In her opinion, STUDENT does not require a one-on-one aide because she has exceeded her IEP goals, she is making friends, and she is happy and well-adjusted in class. She testified that STUDENT learns better through interaction with other children. It is more difficult to keep her on-task when working with her individually, as she relies upon the adult and does not focus on completing the activity herself. Ms. O'Boyle summarized that STUDENT had "made tremendous growth and progress this year" and that an aide would have been detrimental to that development. Ms. Faridani testified that STUDENT did not require an individual aide because she understands her environment and can be given the words she needs to express herself. As a speech pathologist, she believes that STUDENT needs interaction with other children to improve her pragmatic speech with her peers, rather than interaction with a one-on-one adult aide. She also testified that STUDENT does not have self-stimulating behaviors that interfere with her education. Susan Barnes-Polland, STUDENT's current District speech provider, testified that STUDENT never exhibits self-stemming behavior when she works with her, she works well in her seat independently, she stays on-task, and she can be easily redirected by someone speaking to her. It is Ms. Barnes-Polland's opinion that an individual aide is "not beneficial at all" to STUDENT as she has a tendency to cling to adults and become dependent on them. Joanne Pon Rubin, Bellflower's program specialist for special education, testified that one-on-one aides have the potential to cause dependence in a child and must be used with caution. For that reason, she believes aides are best incorporated into the entire classroom while they work on a specific child's IEP goals. In her opinion, this generalization applies to STUDENT. Ms. Pon Rubin did testify that STUDENT might benefit from this type of classroom aide during her math group. The students in STUDENT's math group have varying levels of skills and the teacher must individually assist each child. This results in segments of time when STUDENT is undirected. She then has a difficult time staying on-task or completing her math problems while the teacher is attending to the other students. This was the only classroom activity in which Ms. Pon Rubin observed STUDENT snort and rub her nose. Dr. Charlop-Christy is the independent autism specialist brought in by the District to evaluate STUDENT's school program. Dr. Charlop-Christie has a PhD in child psychology with a sub-specialty in autism. She has extensive experience working with children with autism that includes a Post-Doctoral Fellowship at John Hopkins University School of Medicine, working as a behavioral therapist supervised by Dr. Ivar Lovas at UCLA's autism program, the directorship of the George Washington University Autism Project, and positions as the associate clinical director, then the director, of the Claremont Autism Project. Dr. Charlop-Christy continues to direct the Claremont Autism Center, maintains a private practice, and is a professor of psychology at Claremont College. Based upon her observations of STUDENT in her classroom during the 1998-99 school year, Dr. Charlop-Christy testified that an individual aide in the classroom was "not necessary at all" for STUDENT, and that her teacher can effectively redirect her when necessary. She also stated that the danger of an aide is that the "power would shift to the wrong person, the aide assumes responsibility instead of the teacher." The goal is for STUDENT to pay attention to her teacher. With an aide, she would become "prompt dependent and not attend to the teacher." Dr. Charlop-Christy observed STUDENT to be engaged and functioning in class. Occasionally, STUDENT became inattentive, but she was easily redirected. She concluded that an aide in the classroom was contraindicated for STUDENT. Although Dr. Charlop-Christy did not believe that STUDENT required an individual aide in the classroom, she did find that STUDENT would benefit from one to two hours per week of individual assistance with math and phonics. This help could be provided by a qualified aide, STUDENT's teacher or a resource specialist. Dr. Charlop-Christy also testified that because STUDENT was isolated during recess and lacked appropriate social skills, she should have a social skills program, receive social skills training, and be assigned an individual aide during recesses and lunch. A professional knowledgeable in collecting data and writing social skills plans for children with autism should draft STUDENT's program and periodically supervise her aide. Daily supervision of the aide could be provided by STUDENT's teacher in accordance with the social skills program. In her opinion, the aide should be trained to take STUDENT to her peers, demonstrate appropriate social interactions, fade, observe, and then return to provide positive reinforcement. The goal would be to reduce, then eliminate, the aide as STUDENT acquired the skills to initiate social play, generalize social skills, and decrease her reliance upon prompts from the aide. All of the above witnesses, with the exception of Dr. Franke, agreed that STUDENT did not require an individual aide while she was in the classroom last year. There was further agreement by these witnesses that an aide during the classroom portion of her school day would have been detrimental to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require a one-on-one aide while she was in class during the 1998-99 school year. The evidence established that STUDENT generally focused during instruction and did not routinely engage in self-stimulatory behaviors that interfered with learning. On those occasions when she did not attend, she could be verbally redirected. STUDENT has learned to write her name, add and subtract single digit numbers, read ten words per minute, copy a complete sentence, and answer "who, what, and where" questions ("wh" questions). Thus, STUDENT obtained benefit from her classroom instruction without an aide. The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive the testimony that STUDENT easily becomes adult dependent. This testimony was provided both by the District's witnesses who work with STUDENT on a daily basis and by Doctors Freeman and Charlop-Christy, who emphasized their concern that an individual aide creates dependence in a child. Moreover, interaction with peers is an area of significant deficit for STUDENT. Providing her with her own full-time aide for classroom instruction would have isolated her with her aide and encouraged her tendency to gravitate toward adults. This would have significantly reduced her interaction with other students as she would have been working more with an adult aide, rather than fully participating with her peer group. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not have a unique need for an individual aide for classroom instruction during the 1998-99 school year to benefit from her education and that the District, therefore, did not have a duty to provide one . The Hearing Officer found Dr. Charlop-Christy to be an extremely knowledgeable expert regarding autism and STUDENT's specific needs. Dr. Freeman's testimony was also persuasive. The doctors' explanations for STUDENT's needs for a social skills program and a one-on-one aide during recess and lunch periods of the 1998-99 school year were convincing and supported by other evidence presented regarding STUDENT's continued difficulties with social interaction. When Dr. Charlop-Christy observed STUDENT at school during the preceding year, she saw STUDENT alone in the sand box during recess. She was repetitively scooping sand into her hand and allowing it to flow through her fingers, in what appeared to be a self-stimulatory manner. The District's adaptive physical education (APE) teacher testified that although she did not provide formal APE to STUDENT, she typically asked her to join in group games with the APE students when STUDENT was also on the playground for recess. It was left to STUDENT to decide whether to join in these activities. When STUDENT would leave the group early or not join at all, the APE teacher would notice that she usually was isolated from the other children on the playground. Although STUDENT made some progress in her academic skills and her ability to use language to respond to questions, she made little progress in her ability to initiate and sustain conversations or interact with her peers. This was an area of great difficulty for STUDENT and continues to remain a unique need. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT needed a social skills program and a one-on-one aide during lunch and recesses throughout the 1998-99 school year . The social skills program should have been written by a psychologist, behavioral specialist or other professional with knowledge and experience in autism. This individual needed to collect necessary data concerning STUDENT's socially inappropriate behaviors and appropriate responses thereto, draft a specific program that provided for direct intervention through a structured and consistent program, establish goals, define the benchmarks that would trigger fading of the aide, and train and supervise the aide. (footnote 2) As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a unique need for an individual classroom aide to receive educational benefit, and that such an aide would have denied her an opportunity to fully interact with her peers. However, the Hearing Officer does conclude that STUDENT required a social skills program designed specifically to meet her unique needs, a one-on-one aide during recesses and lunch to implement the social skills program, and twice-a-week tutoring in math during the 1998-99 school year. The District did not identify or address STUDENT's unique needs in these areas, nor did it provide the necessary supplemental services during the 1998-99 school year. Thus, the District did not provide STUDENT with educational benefit in the area of a one-on-one aide for social skills and math during this time period, and thereby deprived her of a free and appropriate education. ISSUES TWO AND THREE DID THE PETITIONER REQUIRE INDIVIDUAL SPEECH THERAPY FROM A THERAPIST EXPERIENCED IN AUTISM, AND ARE HER PARENTS ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR THE PRIVATE SPEECH THERAPY PROVIDED BY DR. FRANKE FROM DECEMBER 1996, THROUGH THE PRESENT? The Individuals With Disabilities Education Act as amended in 1997 (IDEA 1997) codified the previous court decision of School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358, (1985), in which the United States Supreme Court held that the parents of disabled children may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for related services which they unilaterally obtained for their child. Such reimbursement was found to be an appropriate remedy where the school district had failed to provide the child with a free, appropriate education and the private services were determined to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. See also Florence County School District Four, et.al. v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993). From the time STUDENT entered Bellflower School District as a preschooler, through the present, her parents have expressed deep concerns about her speech and the behaviors that interfered with her language. MR. and MRS. PARENT repeatedly requested individual speech therapy for their daughter, including a response to the behaviors that interfered with her social communication. When the parents felt that the District did not adequately respond to their concerns, they obtained the private services of Dr. Franke. To determine whether PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for this private therapy, it is first necessary to determine (1) whether STUDENT had a unique need for direct speech instruction, (2) whether STUDENT received some benefit from the speech therapy that was provided by Bellflower to benefit from her education and the District did not make it available, and (3) whether the therapy the parents obtained was appropriate. Although the Petitioner presented very little evidence regarding her need for a one-on-one aide prior to the 1998-99 school year, the Petitioner provided a great deal of evidence pertaining to her speech needs during each school each year. The Hearing Officer will therefore address STUDENT's need for speech therapy during each relevant school year.A. December 1995 through the end of the 1995-96 school year. From December 1995 (the beginning of the three-year statute of limitations, see Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District, 9th Cir. 1994) through the end of the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in a preschool class taught by Ms. Lex. District witnesses testified that because STUDENT was enrolled in this language-based class taught by a speech pathologist, she received speech instruction throughout her school day and did not require additional individual speech sessions. According to the testimony of Ms. Faridani, who was the participating speech pathologist on the initial preschool assessment team, the team was aware that STUDENT's parents believed STUDENT required individual speech therapy. However, Ms. Faridani said that the assessment team explained to the parents that a language-based SDC would be more beneficial to STUDENT as it would provide language throughout her preschool class, rather than the periodic therapy provided by individual speech sessions. Ms. Lex, the preschool teacher, testified that STUDENT did not need direct speech instruction because, as a speech pathologist, she designed her class to provide both receptive and expressive speech throughout the day. The intent of her class was to help the students build a communication system. Ms. Lex also said that, although she did not schedule one-on-one speech therapy with her students, she made contact with each child daily for an amount of time that would vary from "one to five to ten minutes" per student. Ms. Lex explained that she maintained an ongoing language sample for each child to assist with planning her lesson expectations for each student. Dr. Freeman had been advocating individual speech therapy for STUDENT since she diagnosed her with autism at the age of three. The District was in receipt of Dr. Freeman's report dated March 28, 1995, in which she recommended a structured school setting that emphasized language development. She wrote that, in addition to this type of language-based class, STUDENT required three thirty-minute sessions of individual speech therapy per week with small-group therapy the remaining two days each week. Dr. Freeman testified that an essential characteristic of autism is a problem with communication. For this reason, early intervention with receptive, expressive and pragmatic language is important for all autistic children. STUDENT had an even greater need for intensive speech therapy. When Dr. Freeman initially diagnosed STUDENT, she also determined that STUDENT's nonverbal intelligence quota (IQ) was within normal and her autism fell within the mild range. In her experience, this meant that STUDENT had the "potential to become high functioning" with intensive intervention. However, she also determined that STUDENT had a separate language processing disorder in addition to autism. STUDENT's high potential, combined with the secondary processing problem, made intense, individual speech therapy even more important for her. Dr. Charlop-Christy was also questioned regarding STUDENT's need for individual speech therapy during the 1995-96 school year. She testified that she had not evaluated STUDENT during this time frame, and that, therefore, her opinion was based upon her experience, knowledge and training, her current evaluation of STUDENT's development, and a review of STUDENT's records. In her professional judgement, Ms. Lex's program appeared to have been excellent. However, she believed to a reasonable degree of medical certainty that STUDENT also required individual speech instruction three times a week, for forty-five to sixty minutes per session, while she was in preschool. The Hearing Officer was impressed by the competence of Ms. Lex. She is clearly an experienced teacher with a great deal of general knowledge about a variety of early childhood language disorders. However, as she testified, she "had fifteen students with fifteen different language delays," and a total class time of twelve hours each school week four times a week for three hours per day, with Wednesdays spent on parent training rather than classroom instruction. Although she had the assistance of aides, Ms. Lex was the only speech pathologist in the class. During her testimony she confirmed that, as the classroom teacher, she did not have the time to provide individual therapy. The individual needs of fifteen students with different language delays, divided into twelve hours per week of class time, did not provide Mrs. Lex with an adequate opportunity to address the specific individual speech needs of a child like STUDENT. The District pointed out during the hearing that Doctors Freeman and Charlop-Christy are not speech pathologists. However, they are experts in autism. Speech difficulties are a significant component of autism, and both doctors established their understanding of the speech needs of autistic children. These experts separately concluded that STUDENT required individual speech therapy three times per week while she was in preschool. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the opinions of these two autism experts, and finds that due to the limited individual speech time available for STUDENT from Ms. Lex, and her complex speech needs, STUDENT had a unique need for individual speech therapy three times each week to receive educational benefit. The District was provided with the recommendations of Dr. Freeman, it was aware of STUDENT's severe language needs, and MR. and MRS. PARENT repeatedly requested individual therapy. The District also identified STUDENT's failure to interact verbally with her peers. Testimony was presented that STUDENT's lack of social speech contributed to her inability to establish relationships with other children. Because she did not know how to communicate with other children, she was aggressive and inappropriately touched other students. Her behavioral problems eventually became severe enough that the District requested the parents to sign an authorization to allow school personnel to place STUDENT in a restraining chair or use physical holds on her, if necessary. Despite this information, the District offered twenty to thirty minutes of group therapy to STUDENT instead of direct speech/behavioral services. Bellflower's services were inadequate to meet STUDENT's unique speech and behavioral needs and resulted in a denial of a FAPE from December 1996 to the present.B. 1996-97 school year During the 1996-97 school year, PARENTS stopped requesting that the District provide direct speech services to STUDENT. Instead, they now wanted Bellflower to pay for the Links program that Dr. Franke had implemented. The District refused the parents' request to pay for STUDENT's private speech therapy. It advised MRS. PARENT that it had staff trained in the Links program who could provide it at the recommended frequency of two times per week. MRS. PARENT declined this offer, preferring to remain with her private therapist. She felt STUDENT had "bonded" with Dr. Franke and that the District's speech pathologists had no experience working with the program. (footnote 3) The District responded that its offer to provide Links remained open, and the services could be implemented upon the parents' request. (footnote 4) In January 1997, STUDENT transferred out of the class that was taught by Ms. Lex so that her younger, autistic brother could enter that preschool class. Because her new teacher was not a speech therapist, the District offered STUDENT small-group speech therapy two times per week. PARENTS agreed to these speech services from the District however, MRS. PARENT testified that she also continued to request funding for the individual speech instruction from Dr. Franke. The parents continued to refuse to allow District staff to provide the Links program to STUDENT, preferring Dr. Franke's individual therapy. MRS. PARENT later agreed that Bellflower could provide group speech therapy pursuant to its IEP offer, but she would apparently only authorize a District's speech pathologist to provide articulation therapy. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's need for speech/behavior therapy remained essentially unchanged during the 1996-97 school year. Although her expressive language had increased somewhat, she used it primarily to respond to questions from adults. Because she did not use language to relate to her peers, she resorted to inappropriate behaviors to respond to them. Her spontaneous use of language to communicate with others remained severely delayed. She continued to prefer to isolate herself from the other students. The evidence contained herein in the discussion of the 1995-96 school year therefore remains applicable to this school year, and establishes that STUDENT continued to require individual speech services three times per week for thirty to forty-five minutes per session. STUDENT's speech needs were great and they were exacerbated by, and contributed to, her behavioral and social deficits. It has already been determined that STUDENT did not receive the individual speech services she required in Ms. Lex's class, where she remained during the first portion of the 1996-97 school year, until she transferred to Ms. Chancy's class. When she moved to the preschool class of Ms. Chancy, who was not a speech pathologist, the District acknowledged that STUDENT then required DIS speech services. Bellflower's offer at the time of the classroom transfer in January 1997, of twenty to thirty minutes of small-group therapy, also was inadequate to provide the degree of speech service STUDENT required to address herserious speech and consequent social deficits. STUDENT's inability to communicate permeated all aspects of her education (behavior, academic, social, etc.), and was her single most serious area of need. The District's failure to respond properly to this unique need continued to deprive STUDENT of a FAPE. C. 1997-98 school year During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT could express her needs in simple sentences and respond to some "wh" questions (who, what, where, and why). However, her speech continued to be primarily responsive. She had little self-initiated communication and seldom chose to interact with the other children. Her social play remained parallel rather than interactive. She would seek out adults and avoid other children on the playground. Consistent problems with peer relationships and pragmatic speech were the reasons STUDENT required a social skills program and a one-on-one aide to implement it. Because the District had not adequately addressed these issues in prior years, STUDENT's inability to engage other children and her use of language to appropriately interact with her peers continued. The program utilized by the entire Bellflower School District was entitled "peace builders." The District argued that this program adequately met STUDENT's needs for a social skills program. This social skills program was intended to teach all Bellflower students to interact with each other in a socially acceptable manner. It was not individually designed by the District to meet STUDENT's unique needs to improve her social speech and learn how to interact with other students. Although the peace builders program taught beneficial strategies about social relationships, it did not address the specific interpersonal and speech deficits displayed by STUDENT. STUDENT still received private Links therapy with Dr. Franke during the 1997-98 school year. In addition, the District provided STUDENT with group speech therapy for twenty minutes twice a week. However, based upon attendance records and a school calendar provided by the District, twenty of the therapy sessions were not provided to STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year. Of those twenty sessions, nine were made up on other days. The records show that another eight sessions were missed because there was no speech therapy provided during the four weeks of summer school. Thus, during the 1997-98 regular and extended school year (ESY), STUDENT did not receive nineteen of the group speech sessions to which she was entitled. (footnote 5) The Hearing Officer therefore determines that during this school year Bellflower did not address STUDENT's need for individual speech therapy three times per week, it did not provide the amount of group speech provided for in the IEP, and it did not institute an individualized social skills program with a one-on-one aide during unstructured time to respond to STUDENT's need for better socialization and pragmatic speech. STUDENT's needs in these areas were substantial and the absence of appropriate services to address them resulted in a loss of a FAPE. D. 1998-99 school year Dr. Freeman testified regarding STUDENT's speech and social needs during the 1998-99 school year. Based upon her recent observations and testing of STUDENT, as well as a review of STUDENT's records, Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT continued to have a severe language processing disorder in addition to her autism, and very few social communication skills. Dr. Freeman also stated that although she would not usually recommend individual speech therapy for an autistic child of STUDENT's age, the additional components of a language processing disorder and extremely poor pragmatic language affected STUDENT's ability to function and necessitated direct speech intervention three times per week. Dr. Charlop-Christy concurred with Dr. Freeman's opinion the STUDENT needed individual speech therapy three times per week, and recommended forty-five to sixty minutes per speech session. She stated that STUDENT would continue to require this level of service until she attains the skills of spontaneous speech, asking questions, initiating verbal interactions, and greeting others. In Dr. Charlop-Christy's opinion, this therapy must be in the form of "behavioral speech therapy." She described behavioral speech therapy as a method of therapy which would first require the collection of data regarding STUDENT's areas of need. A task analysis would be conducted to determine the components of the goals established for STUDENT. The therapist would then model the task, prompt STUDENT to perform it herself, reinforce her when she accomplishes it, and fade as she begins to initiate the speech herself. Dr. Charlop-Christy testified that this particular type of therapy is needed because STUDENT does not have problems producing speech. Instead, she needs to learn the use of language as a method of interacting with her environment. The first time the District agreed to provide individual speech therapy to STUDENT was September 28, 1998. She received two twenty-minute sessions each week from a District speech aide or therapist. Consultation to her teacher from the speech therapist was provided one time per week. Even though STUDENT was still receiving Links privately from Dr. Franke, her parents accepted the District's offer to provide the Links program for STUDENT in a small-group setting two times each week. The program was to be provided in her classroom by her SDC teacher. To work on her social skills and social language needs, STUDENT continued to participate in the District's "peace builders" curriculum with the rest of the District's students. She was not provided with an individual social skills program to address either her difficulties in interacting with her peers, or the effects of her decreased pragmatic language that inhibited her social abilities. The District also did not assign a one-on-one aide during recess and lunch periods to assist with STUDENT's poor social skills and her decreased ability to utilize language to relate to the other students. Bellflower did agree to attempt to minimize STUDENT's transitions during the day, and it briefly had the class's instructional aide meet STUDENT to take her to her classroom when she arrived at school. The twenty minutes of direct speech service two times a week provided by the District's speech therapist falls short of the forty-five to sixty minutes of individual speech instruction STUDENT needed three times per week. Bellflower did try to accommodate MR. and MRS. PARENT by agreeing that STUDENT's SDC teacher would augment her private speech therapy by providing her with the Links program twice a week. However, it was apparent from the testimony of Bellflower's witnesses that they did not agree that the Links program met STUDENT's needs. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer also does not find that the Links program was beneficial for STUDENT. Thus, even though the total time STUDENT received speech therapy during the 1998-99 school year was increased over prior years, it was not calculated to meet her individual needs, especially her need for individual therapy. The District also did not develop a social skills program for STUDENT or provide her with a one-on-one aide to facilitate her language and social interactions during recess and lunch. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Bellflower failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.E. Reimbursement for services provided by Dr. Franke The District's failure to address STUDENT's language requirements resulted in a denial of a FAPE during the 1995-96, 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. The absence of an individualized social skills program and a one-on-one aide for social time resulted in a denial of a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year. However, this denial does not, in and of itself, entitle the Petitioner's parents to reimbursement for the Links program provided by Dr. Franke. To receive reimbursement, the parents must establish that the services they obtained were appropriate under the IDEA and that they were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. IDEA 1412 (a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. 300.403(c); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). When considering the appropriateness of the services obtained for their child for purposes of reimbursement, parents are not required to obtain the best possible services to be entitled to reimbursement. However, their choice must be designed to meet the student's unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, (supra) Dr. Franke testified that the purpose of the Links program is to teach the child the "language of school." It is not intended to addresses social or home communication. She also described the philosophy and goals of the Links program. The first portion of Links, entitled "bonding," is intended to establish trust between the therapist and the child, and to challenge any misbehavior that adversely affects the acquisition of speech. This "bond" is established by the therapist requiring the child to perform a specified number of tasks to complete the therapy session. If the child does not comply with each of the demands, he or she must start again with the first task and repeat all of the tasks again, until he or she has systematically completed the total of assigned tasks without misbehaving. The therapist is to continue the session indefinitely until the child has performed all of the requisite tasks. When the child is not attending or is misbehaving, the therapist uses such techniques as pounding the table and raising her voice to "startle" the child into refocusing (Dr. Charlop-Christy observed the therapist do this on a taped session and described it as an aversive.) Once all of the tasks have been completed correctly, the therapy session is over. With this approach, the child is taught to "trust" that the session will end and that the therapist will let him or her go when the assigned tasks are finished. It is also intended that the first stage of Links will eliminate improper behaviors that interfere with speech acquisition and will enable the child to move on to the following stages . Once the child has learned compliance and attention, the Links program focuses on teaching the child syntax (sentence structure) and memory. This next stage is accomplished by the therapist providing a sentence(s) and the child repeatedly mimicking it verbatim. The child is next asked questions and is to provide the memorized responses. Following a consideration of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer concludes that the majority of the Links program did not meet STUDENT's unique needs, nor did it provide educational benefit. Dr. Franke acknowledged, and Dr. Charlop-Christy confirmed, that there has been no empirical data collected, or independent studies published, to establish that the Links program is beneficial to autistic children. In fact, the limited data available on the effectiveness of Links were collected by its originator at a school for the deaf. Moreover, no baseline data were collected by Dr. Franke when she began the Links program with STUDENT, so her progress could not be established. According to Dr. Franke, who is a strong proponent of Links, the program was not intended to teach pragmatic speech. She agreed that STUDENT needed to acquire social language, but testified that STUDENT first needed to have a good knowledge of sentence structure. Dr. Charlop-Christy disagreed. She testified that the Links program teaches syntax, not pragmatics, and is based on the grammatical correctness of language, not on the use of words. In Dr. Charlop-Christy's opinion, STUDENT understands language, but has inadequate use of speech. She either cannot or will not use speech to communicate. STUDENT requires a functional speech approach. She needs to learn how to use language to communicate. Links teaches repetitive speech and focuses on memorizing words, rather than on understanding the meaning of language concepts. Consequently, Links did not address STUDENT's most significant needs -- learning spontaneous speech, how to initiate conversations, and how to use functional language to interact with others. Dr. Charlop-Christy also expressed serious concerns about the use of punishment (aversives) when STUDENT did not respond as requested during the Links therapy. She testified that when she viewed videotapes of STUDENT's speech sessions with Dr. Franke, she observed Dr. Franke "slap the table and yell at STUDENT when she did not respond as requested." Dr. Charlop-Christy testified that she had done research on this "startle effect" form of punishment and that it was not effective for anything other than the most serious behavior problems. The Hearing Officer has the same concerns about the Links program that were articulated by Dr. Charlop-Christy. Links advocates memorized, rote speech and focuses on grammatical correctness. Anecdotally, Ms. Lex testified that she happened to encounter STUDENT, and her mother at a store in 1999. She noticed that STUDENT still did not initiate conversation, and her speech now appeared "robotic." Ms. Faridani found the same robotic speech cadence in STUDENT. Both attributed the robotic speech to the Links program. Dr. Franke acknowledged in her testimony that autistic children have the capacity for rote memorization and this can make them appear to have increased language. The memorization of words is contrary to STUDENT's need to develop pragmatic and interactive language. MRS. PARENT was emphatic that STUDENT required the Links program but refused the District's offer to provide it, maintaining that Dr. Franke must continue the therapy because STUDENT had bonded with her and the District's staff was not qualified to provide the program. She then limited the services to be provided by the District's speech pathologist to articulation therapy as of January 1997. The Hearing Officer does not accept the Petitioner's assertion that the District staff was incompetent to provide the Links program, or that STUDENT could not change therapists because she had bonded with Dr. Franke. The literature, as well as testimonial evidence from the District's witnesses who attended the seminar, makes it clear that the program is marketed to be used by parents, teachers and lay persons. There is no requirement that it only be administered by speech pathologists or other trained educational professionals. Although the Links creators require only minimal education and training to provide the Links program, Ms. Faridani and Ms. Lex had the additional advantage of being trained and experienced speech pathologists who had also received the training recommended by the originators of the Links method. Both testified that Links included elements of other speech therapy methods with which they were familiar and in which they had experience. The District additionally offered to work out a transition plan to transfer STUDENT's speech therapy from Dr. Franke to District personnel. STUDENT already knew and worked with both the District's speech therapists and her teachers. Thus, there was no proposal that she change her provider to an unknown therapist. There was also testimony that STUDENT did not respond well to Dr. Franke when STUDENT encountered her during Dr. Franke's school observation. Although the initial stage of Links is entitled "bonding," the Hearing Officer does not find that convincing evidence was presented that STUDENT had established a bond with Dr. Franke. To the contrary, District witnesses described STUDENT as appearing withdrawn and uncomfortable around Dr. Franke when she visited STUDENT at school. These Bellflower witnesses also spoke of the reemergence of undesirable behaviors during Dr. Franke's visit, which had previously been eliminated, Dr. Charlop-Christy observed a video-taped session of one of Dr. Franke's Links sessions with STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT appeared bored by the repetitive nature of the program and did not respond well to the "punishment" aspects of the Links program. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that it would not have harmed STUDENT to change speech therapists and there was no persuasive evidence to refute this observation. The Petitioner asserts that STUDENT required a therapist who was an expert in autism disorders. Each District witness testified that they had worked with children with autism and periodically attended seminars and in-services that addressed autism. Ms. Faridani testified that she has taught autistic children from the ages of preschool to middle school for ten years. She estimates that she has served at least fifty-five autistic children during these years. Ms. Lex testified that she had thirty years of experience as a special education teacher. Since 1983, she has been a special education preschool teacher. She estimated that as a preschool teacher, she has had one to two autistic children per year. Dr. Charlop-Christy testified that she observed STUDENT in Ms. O'Boyle's class during the 1998-99 school year and she found Ms. O'Boyle to be an extremely competent teacher for STUDENT. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the Petitioner's argument that District employees were unqualified in the area of autism, and finds that the District's speech pathologists, or other personnel, were qualified to work with autistic children. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the Links methodology was inappropriate to respond to STUDENT's language needs. The Links program was also available from the District, had the parents so desired. Consequently, there is no basis for an award of reimbursement for this private therapy. The IEP drafted in May 1996 revealed that STUDENT was aggressive, touched, pushed and otherwise bothered other children. She also exhibited self-stimulatory behaviors such as snorting, blowing her nose into her hands, and rubbing the mucus on herself and others. By September 1996, when STUDENT returned from the summer break, her behaviors were of such concern that the District drafted a behavior intervention plan (BIP). (footnote 6) Bellflower proposed responding to STUDENT's behaviors by using positive reinforcement, physical holds, and placing her in a restraining chair. The first stage of Links mainly addressed bonding and behaviors that interfered with speech development. As discussed above, the behavior modification methods employed by Links in stage one were primarily aversive and therefore inappropriate. However, the District's use of a restraining chair and/or physical restraining holds to prohibit movement as well as the District's failure to comply with the California Education Code in drafting its behavioral intervention plan during this time period was also inappropriate. (See footnote #6) The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that both Links and the District's BIP were unacceptable methods of responding to STUDENT's behavioral needs. The Petitioner's dismissal of the issue of compensatory education, and the Hearing Officer's decision that reimbursement should not be provided for the services of Dr. Franke, prevents the provision of a remedy for this failure to provide STUDENT with a behavior plan that met her unique needs. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the privately obtained Links program, which had questionable value to STUDENT's needs and was offered by, and available from, the District. CONCLUSION The evidence establishes that the District failed to provide appropriate speech services from December 1996 through the present. Because STUDENT has not yet received the speech services she needed, she still requires individual speech therapy three times per week for forty-five minute to one- hour sessions. STUDENT also did not receive the individual social skills program and the one-on-one aide she required for recess and lunch times during the 1998-99 school year. Her social skills program should have been created by a professional who had knowledge of autism, and she should have had an individual aide assigned to implement the program on the playground and at lunch until the aide could fade pursuant to specifically defined criteria. The aide's training needed to be specific to the proper way to implement STUDENT's social skills program in a manner that met her specific needs. Training of the aide needed to be provided initially by the individual who wrote the social skills program. Once STUDENT's teacher was familiar with STUDENT's social skills program, she could have then provided the day-to-day supervision of the aide. If the District had personnel qualified to draft an appropriate social skills program for STUDENT, it did not need to bring in an independent agency to create and supervise the program as requested by the Petitioner. The parties may consider these findings when developing STUDENT's educational plan for the 1999-2000 school year. The above described denial of adequate supplemental services resulted in a denial of a FAPE as it relates to speech therapy for the 1995-96, 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. The failure to provide STUDENT with an individual social skills program and a one-on-one aide during lunch and recess caused a denial of a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year. The District also failed to provide STUDENT with nineteen sessions of speech therapy pursuant to her IEP during the 1997-98 school year. However, the Petitioner specifically dismissed her request for compensatory education before the hearing began. The Hearing Officer therefore cannot provide a remedy for the District's denial of a FAPE. ORDER 1. All of the Petitioner's claims for relief are denied PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: l. Does STUDENT require a one-on-one instructional aide to receive educational benefit? Although the Petitioner established that STUDENT needed an individual aide for recess and lunch periods, there is no remedy available, so she cannot be considered to have prevailed on this portion of the issue. The District prevailed in the area of a one-on-one aide in the classroom. 2. Does STUDENT require individual speech and language therapy from a provider knowledgeable in speech and language services for autistic children. The Petitioner established that STUDENT needed individual speech and language services, but again, there is no remedy available, so she cannot be considered to have prevailed on this issue. 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language services from December 1, 1996 to the present? The District prevailed on the this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
1. The Hearing Officer has changed the issues submitted by the Petitioner from the future "does she require . . .", to the past tense of "did she require . . ." as the parties agreed that the Hearing Officer would not address events which have not yet occurred. The Petitioner also did not specify the time period for which she claims she required a one-on-one aide. However, the evidence presented on this issue related to the 1998-99 school year. 2. The Petitioner argued that this service should have been provided, and all aides supervised, by an independent agency with knowledge of autism. The Hearing Officer does not agree. It is the responsibility of the District to provides competent individuals who are able to meet the unique needs of the child. If such personnel is available within the district, it is not obligated to provide an outside agency's employees or supervisors. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1525 (9th Cir. 1994).3. "Bonding" is the first level of the Links program in which the child is to establish trust with the therapist and deal with the behaviors that interfere with speech acquisition. It is noted that although Dr. Franke had several private patients for which she was providing the Links program, these children began the Links therapy at approximately the same time, and she herself had only recently been trained to provide the program. 4. There is a disagreement between the parties regarding the outcome of this offer. Mrs. Parent testified that she stated at the meeting that she wanted the District to provide the offered twice-a-week speech sessions beginning in September 1996. However, she wanted Bellflower to provide "typical" speech therapy and did not want it to provide the Links program. The District's witnesses testified that Mrs. Parent rejected all speech services from the District, preferring Dr. Franke, and stated that she would contact the District if she decided that she wanted Bellflower to provide any speech therapy, including the Links program.5. This figure is calculated by subtracting the nine make-up sessions from the twenty that were not provided, for a total of eleven missed sessions, then adding the eight sessions which were not provided during the ESY.6. The BIP written for STUDENT was not included in her Cumulative (Cum) file, or any other documents requested by the Petitioner, and until the District located it late in the hearing, the District attempted to discredit Mrs. Parent's testimony that a meeting had been convened to obtain her permission to use physical holds and a restraining chair with STUDENT. (In mitigation, the Hearing Officer also notes that when the BIP became an issue, the District's attorney and Director of Special Education did search for the BIP and immediately produced it when it was located.) District personnel testified that the BIP was never used. Regardless of its actual use, the BIP was created without complying with the requirements of Education Code 3052 and 3001(f); a functional assessment was not conducted, nor was an IEP meeting convened to determine the necessity for a behavior plan, or to arrange for supervision of its implementation. Depending upon STUDENT's response to being confined, the proposed use of a restraining chair may have violated the statutory prohibition against the use of a behavior intervention that causes trauma.
