California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 23, 1999

Student v. Tamalpais Union High School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1693-99 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Hearing Officer upholds Tamalpais Union High School District's finding that a student's locker-room misconduct was not a manifestation of his disability.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that on October 15, 1999, the Marin County Superior Court granted the District a temporary restraining order, followed by a preliminary injunction on October 28, 1999, allowing the suspension to continue until the expulsion hearing. These orders came before this decision. No later history is noted.

Summary

The parent and Tamalpais Union High School District each requested an expedited hearing to review a manifestation determination. The requests were consolidated. The student, a 17-year-old junior at Tamalpais High School, was eligible for special education because of a learning disability in written language. He had a history of truancy and some earlier discipline incidents. After an October 4, 1999 incident with another student in a locker room, the District suspended him. It then got a court order extending the suspension until an expulsion hearing. On October 14, the IEP team found the conduct was not a manifestation of his disability.

The student argued the District had to finish a functional behavioral assessment and a behavioral intervention plan before making that decision. The Hearing Officer disagreed. No law requires that order, and requiring it would make the manifestation deadlines nearly impossible to meet. The student also argued his IEP was not appropriate because it had no behavior plan. The Hearing Officer found his earlier misconduct did not interfere with learning and was not a "serious behavior problem" under California's Hughes Bill regulations, so no plan was required. District psychologists and his resource teacher testified that his disability did not affect his understanding of or control over his behavior, and no evidence contradicted them. The student's expert had not interviewed anyone or reviewed all the records. The District may discipline him as it would a nondisabled student.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA regulations in an expedited manifestation review. A functional behavioral assessment and behavior plan did not have to come before the manifestation determination. Also, past misconduct that did not interfere with learning did not make an IEP inappropriate because it lacked a behavior plan.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Was the District required to conduct a functional behavioral assessment and implement a behavioral intervention plan prior to making its manifestation determination?

    No law requires a functional behavioral assessment and behavioral intervention plan to come before the manifestation determination; doing so would make the 10-school-day deadline nearly impossible to meet. Any challenge to the District's failure to assess is outside the expedited hearing.

  2. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2.1. Was the student's placement and IEP appropriate, and were the services required by the IEP being provided (including whether the IEP should have contained a behavioral assessment and behavior intervention plan)?

    The student's earlier misconduct did not impede his learning or anyone else's and was not a serious behavior problem under 5 CCR 3001, so no behavior plan was required. The IEP and placement were appropriate and were being implemented.

  3. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2.2. Was the student's alleged misbehavior in October 1999 caused by his disability?

    Unrebutted testimony showed his learning disability did not impair his ability to understand or control his behavior. The pre-expulsion assessment gave the IEP team enough information, and the conduct was correctly found not to be a manifestation of his disability.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District may proceed with its proposed discipline of the student consistent with laws governing discipline of nondisabled students.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

34 CFR 300.520(b); 34 CFR 300.523; 34 CFR 300.346; Education Code section 48915.5; 5 CCR 3001(h) (Hughes Bill); 64 Fed. Reg. 12624 (1999)

People named in the decision

  • John Casey, interim director of student services, Tamalpais Union High School District
  • Cory Demars, school counselor, Tamalpais High School
  • Robin Wein, school psychologist (initial assessment), Tamalpais Union High School District
  • Lisa Fredericks, resource specialist (initial assessment), Tamalpais Union High School District
  • Frank Benson, school psychologist (pre-expulsion assessment and behavior intervention plan), Tamalpais Union High School District
  • Pamela McMullen, resource specialist teacher, Tamalpais High School
  • Billie Johnson, counselor, Tamalpais High School
  • Sue Lillidhal, Healthy Start worker, Healthy Start program
  • Marian Lane Diamond, psychologist, expert witness for Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on November 11 and 12, 1999, at Larkspur, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorneys Abigail Trillin and David Onek. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MRS. PARENT.

Respondent Tamalpais Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Jan E. Tomsky. Also present on behalf of the District was John Casey, interim director of student services.

Evidence was received and the record was left open until November 23, 1999, to allow for submission of closing arguments. On November 23, 1999, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Was the District required to conduct a functional behavioral assessment and implement a behavioral intervention plan prior to making its manifestation determination?

2. Did the District properly conclude that STUDENT's behavior on October 4, l999, was not a manifestation of his disability? (Footnote 1)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seventeen- year-old Junior at Tamalpais High School. He was found to be eligible for special education services during his sophomore year because of a learning disability in the area of written language.

STUDENT entered Tamalpais High School as a freshman in the fall of 1997. Prior to entering high school, he attended a private religious school. During his freshman year, STUDENT developed a pattern of truancy and failure to complete assignments. His school counselor, Mr. Cory Demars, became concerned and began working with STUDENT and his parents to address the truancy problem. He enrolled STUDENT in the Healthy Start program during the second semester. The program provided him tutorial support and helped to track his academic progress. STUDENT's truancy problems persisted and he failed a number of his classes during the spring semester. On May 28, l998, Mr. Demars recommended that STUDENT be assessed to determine whether he was eligible for special education services. STUDENT and his parents refused to consent to the assessment.

STUDENT also had a number of disciplinary problems during his freshman year. Most of the disciplinary incidents involved horseplay and disruption of classes. He was given detentions and counseling for these incidents. One incident involved fighting with another student. STUDENT described the incident as starting when he and another student were pretending to box with each other in the hallway and the other student hit him in the lip. He became angry and started to fight with the other student. Later, while he was on the athletic field swinging a baseball bat, he saw the same student. He approached the student and resumed the fight. STUDENT claimed that he did not use the bat or threaten the other student with the bat. No other witness had any direct knowledge of this event. The school's discipline record states that STUDENT was suspended for 5 days for "fighting and assault with a bat." The record also states that he was suspended for 5 days for possession of a weapon in relation to the same incident. It appears from the disciplinary letter that he was suspended for 5 days for this incident.

In the summer of l998, STUDENT attended summer school. During this time, he received two, one-day suspensions for defiance. Both incidents appear to have been related to STUDENT's cutting classes and wandering the halls without permission.

During the fall semester of his sophomore year, STUDENT continued to have attendance problems. At Mr. Demars' suggestion, STUDENT continued in Healthy Start and enrolled in the STARS program – a program that provides both emotional and academic support for students at risk. STUDENT also participated in counseling with a licensed counselor through the Full Circle program. Toward the end of the fall semester, Mr. Demar had a conversation with STUDENT which Mr.Demar testified was a "turning point." STUDENT seemed to understand that he needed to take advantage of the services offered or he would not be able to graduate with his class. Permission was obtained from STUDENT's parents to perform a special education assessment. In January of l999, an assessment was performed by school psychologist Robin Wein and resource specialist Lisa Fredericks. The assessment concluded that STUDENT had a learning disability in the area of written expression and had "slow processing speed, short-term memory and visual-motor integration problems involving paper pencil output, which have interfered with his acquisition of academic skills."

On March 2, l999, an IEP meeting was held. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services because of a learning disability in the area of written language. Goals and objectives were developed. One goal was to improve classroom responsibilities/time management. This goal appeared to be on a preprinted form along with short-term objectives. All of the short term objectives on the form are checked off, including "attend each class daily and promptly," "keep track of homework assignments," "complete homework assignments on time and turn in promptly," "ask for assistance as needed," and "refrain from disruptive behavior." The form containing this goal and related objectives provides a section to indicate progress during each grading period. For the first four objectives, a notation was made indicating that some progress has been made; but "the objective should be continued" is checked for the 3rd and 4th grading periods. For the last objective concerning disruptive behavior, the notation of "N/A" appears for the 3rd and 4th grading period. Goals and objectives were also developed in the areas of "to improve Vocational/Career Development," "to improve proficiency standards," and "to improve written language skills." The IEP team concluded that STUDENT would receive resource specialist services for one period "per block schedule." STUDENT was to continue to participate in regular education in all academic areas with a variety of modifications to address his learning disability.

During the period between the beginning of his sophomore year and the holding of March 2 IEP meeting, there are two entries on his disciplinary record. He received two detentions for not returning from the bathroom to his English class in November and two detentions relating to an incident in the student center bathroom with a group of students cutting class in February. There is no evidence that the IEP team reviewed STUDENT's disciplinary record during the March 1999 IEP meeting.

During the first semester of his sophomore year, STUDENT received grades of "F" in world history, English, and science; he received a "C-" in Spanish, a "D+" in algebra, and a "C+" in PE. At the end of his spring semester, he received a "B-" in world history, a "D-" in English, a "D-" in science, and "B-" in algebra, a "D" in weight training, and a "C+" in his resource specialist class.

Although his grades improved after he started receiving special education services, he continued to have problems with attendance and tardiness. In May of 1999, STUDENT was referred to the SARB Board for poor attendance and failing grades. On May 20, 1999, the SARB Board suggested that the IEP team recommend San Andreas School as an alternative placement for STUDENT. The Board stated, "It is the Board's belief that the smaller environment would allow STUDENT to be a more successful student."

In May l999, STUDENT was involved in two incidents that led to entries in his disciplinary record. It is not clear whether these incidents occurred on the same day or on different days. The disciplinary record indicated that both incidents occurred on May 25, l999. STUDENT testified that the two incidents occurred on different days. The first incident involved STUDENT slapping and insulting another student in relation to things the other student was saying about his relationship with a girl. The incident took place on the school grounds. The incident was referred to mediation. STUDENT testified that the mediation was successful and that he and the other student had no problems following the mediation. The disciplinary record indicates that STUDENT was suspended; however, the attendance record did not reflect any suspensions.

The second incident involved STUDENT yelling at another student and inviting him to fight because of an incident at a private party during the weekend where STUDENT had a fight with another student. There is no evidence that STUDENT was sanctioned because of this incident. The matter was referred to mediation and successfully resolved.

On June 9, l999, the IEP team met to review STUDENT's program. District witnesses testified that the primary purpose of the meeting was to address his credit deficiency and consider the recommendation of the SARB Board that STUDENT be placed at the San Andreas School. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT's semester grades and progress reports, teacher input, classroom observations, attendance/tardy report, overall credit report, and discipline report. The District members of the IEP team recommended placement at the San Andreas school because it would provide an opportunity for a small, self-contained environment where STUDENT could better achieve success. STUDENT's mother felt that he could make up credits in summer school and that his attitude and grades had improved since he began receiving special education services. While the District members of the IEP team continued to believe that placement at San Andreas for STUDENT's junior year was appropriate, STUDENT was allowed to enroll in summer school at Tamalpias High School. There was no mention in the IEP document concerning disciplinary problems, although his discipline report was reviewed.

During summer school, STUDENT earned eleven of the twelve units attempted. There is no record of discipline problems during summer school. Because of his success in summer school, STUDENT was permitted to continue at Tamalpias. On September 16, 1999, the SARB Board reviewed STUDENT's progress. Prior to this meeting, his counselor, Mr. DeMars, wrote a memorandum to the SARB Board in which he stated that "since his return to school this semester STUDENT has shown an improvement in attendance as well as with homework completion. If he continues in this manner, STUDENT will be able to get himself back on track towards graduation in June 2001. It should be noted that STUDENT has left himself with very little room for error and must pass all classes this year and next to graduate on time." Mr. DeMars made the following recommendations to the SARB Board:

I recommend to the SARB Board that STUDENT be given the opportunity to remain at Tam and complete his Junior and Senior year. I also recommend that he be reviewed by the SARB Board and the IEP Team on a regular basis throughout the year. If STUDENT begins to show signs of poor attendance and/or work inhibition, I recommend that he be referred to San Andreas to avoid the real possibility of delaying his graduation due to loss of credits resulting from failed grades. In addition to this, I urge the SARB Board to clearly define the behavioral parameters and expectations that STUDENT must adhere to remain at Tam. STUDENT has a discipline file consisting of numerous incidents of disruption, defiance, truancy, and harassment. If behaviors of this nature continue, I recommend that a referral to County Community be strongly considered.

The SARB Board adopted the recommendations of Mr. DeMars in its report of September 16, 1999.. It recommended that STUDENT continue at Tamalpias and stated that "Discipline problems and truancy will lead to referral to County Community School." During the first six weeks preceding the incident on October 4, l999, STUDENT had no unexcused absences. On October 4, l999, STUDENT was alleged to have been involved in an incident in the football locker room in which he pushed another student against the lockers, grabbed the student and held him, and verbally assaulted the student. STUDENT testified that he and another student were merely hazing a freshman student by threatening to throw him into the shower with his clothes on. The District suspended STUDENT for five days for the alleged conduct. On October 12, l999, the District suspended STUDENT for an additional five days pending a manifestation determination. On October 14, l999, the IEP team met to make a manifestation determination. After the alleged conduct on October 4, l999, but prior to the meeting, an assessment was conducted by school psychologist Frank Benson. His assessment included a review of STUDENT's disciplinary and special education files, including previous assessments, interviews with STUDENT's resource specialist, Pam McMullen, his Counselors Cory DeMars, and Billie Johnson, his Healthy Start worker, Sue Lillidhal, and school psychologist Robin Wein. Mr. Benson also interviewed STUDENT and his mother. Mr. Benson prepared a proposed behavior intervention plan. On October 12, l999, the IEP team concluded that in relation to the behavior that was subject to the disciplinary action, STUDENT's IEP and placement were appropriate and the program being provided was consistent with his IEP. The team concluded that STUDENT's behavior was not a manifestation of his disabilty, that his disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior, and that his disability did not impair his ability to control his behavior. The IEP team also adopted the behavior intervention plan prepared by Mr. Benson. The behavior intervention plan set out four strategies to increase STUDENT's appropriate behavior, and three strategies to decrease his inappropriate behaviors. The IEP provided for home teaching until a determination was made concerning his possible expulsion. STUDENT's parents did not agree with the conclusions of the IEP team.

On October 15, l999, the District obtained a temporary restraining order from the Superior Court of Marin County allowing the District to continue the suspension of STUDENT. On October 28, l999, the District was granted a preliminary injunction which permitted it to continue the suspension of STUDENT pending the outcome of the expulsion hearing. On the same day, STUDENT's parents filed a request for an expedited hearing to review the District's manifestation determination. On October 29, l999, the District filed a request for an expedited hearing to review the manifestation determination. (Footnote 2)

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Both federal and State law provide procedures and standards for imposing discipline on a disabled student. These procedures and standards are not completely consistent. Therefore, an analysis of the District's handling of STUDENT's discipline must be analyzed under both federal and State law.

Federal law provides that a disabled student may be disciplined in the same way as a non-disabled student if it is concluded that the behavior which is the subject of the discipline was not a manifestation of his/her disability. 34 CFR 300.523 - 300.528. The law requires that the IEP team meet to review the behavior subject to disciplinary action and all other relevant information. 34 CFR 300.523(c). In order to conclude that the behavior was not a manifestation of the child's disability the IEP team must determine that:

(i) In relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child's IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child's IEP and placement; (ii) The child's disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) The child's disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action. 34 CFR 300.523(c)(2).

If the IEP team determines that any of the standards set out above were not met, it must consider the behavior to be a manifestation of the child's disability. 34 CFR 300.523(d). If the parent of the child disagrees with the manifestation determination, he/she may request a hearing and the hearing authority is required to provide an expedited hearing to review the manifestation determination. 34 CFR 300.525.

Under California law relating to the possible expulsion of a disabled student, a District may not expel a disabled student until all of the following have occurred:

(1) A preexpulsion assessment is conducted.

(2) The individualized education program team meets pursuant to subdivision (a). (3) Due process hearings and appeals, if initiated pursuant to Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, are completed. Cal. Ed. Code Section 48915.5

Education Code Section 48915.5 (e) defines the required preexpulsion assessment:

In determining whether a pupil should be expelled, the individualized education program team shall base its decision on the results of a preexpulsion educational assessment conducted in accordance with the guidelines of Section 104.35 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulation, which shall include a review of the appropriateness of the pupil's placement at the time of the alleged misconduct, and a determination of the relationship, if any, between the pupil's behavior and his or her disability.

In addition to the preexpulsion educational assessment results, the individualized education program team shall also review and consider the pupil's health records and school discipline records.

California Education Code Section 48915.5 (a) provides that a special education student may only be expelled if the IEP team "determines that the misconduct was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability" and "determines that the pupil had been appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred."

Was the District required to conduct a functional behavioral assessment and implement a behavioral intervention plan prior to making its manifestation determination?

The only procedural issue raised by Petitioner was that the manifestation determination should not have been made prior to conducting a functional behavioral assessment and implementing a behavioral intervention plan. Federal law provides that no later than 10 business days after removing a child for more than 10 schools days the Local Education Agency (LEA) shall proceed as follows:

(i) If the LEA did not conduct a functional behavioral assessment and implement a behavioral intervention plan for the child before the behavior that resulted in the removal ..., the agency shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan. (ii) If the child already has a behavioral intervention plan, the IEP team shall meet to review the plan and its implementation as necessary to address the behavior. (2) As soon as practicable after developing the [assessment] plan..., and completing the assessments required by the plan, the LEA shall convene an IEP meeting to develop appropriate behavioral interventions to address that behavior and shall implement those interventions. 34 CFR 300.520(b)

The two five-day suspensions of STUDENT coupled with the temporary retraining order and the preliminary injunction issued by the Superior Court resulted in STUDENT's being removed from his placement for more than 10 school days; therefore, the District was required to develop a plan for and conduct a functional behavioral assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan.

The issue is not whether the District must comply with the requirement to assess and develop a behavior modification plan, but whether such an assessment must be done and a plan be developed prior to making the manifestation requirement. There is no express provision of the law that requires that the assessment and plan precede the manifestation determination. There are two persuasive reasons why such an interpretation is not appropriate.

First, it would be nearly impossible to comply with the time requirements set out in the law for the making of the manifestation determination if a District were required to develop an assessment plan, perform the assessment and develop the plan prior to the manifestation determination. The manifestation determination must be conducted no later than 10 school days after the date on which the decision to remove the student from his placement is made. 34 CFR 300.523. The meeting to develop the assessment plan does not need to take place until 10 business days from the end of the 10 school days of suspension. 34 CFR 300.520(b)(1). There would then need to be time to perform the assessment pursuant to the plan and to conduct another IEP meeting to develop the behavior intervention plan. It would be nearly impossible to do all that is required in developing a behavior intervention plan within the time limits prescribed for making the manifestation determination.

The conclusion that the behavior assessment and development of a behavior intervention plan are not required to precede the manifestation determination is also supported by the Department of Education's discussion of comments on the draft regulations. In discussing comments made concerning the regulations relating to the manifestation determination, the Department of Education stated:

If a removal is a change of placement under Section 300.519, a manifestation determination will provide the IEP team with useful information in developing a behavioral assessment plan or in reviewing an existing behavioral intervention plan under 300.520(b). Federal Register Vol. 64, No. 48 at page 12624.

This comment supports the conclusion that the manifestation determination will normally precede the development of an assessment plan and behavior intervention plan.

For the reasons set out above, it is concluded that the law does not require the development of a behavior assessment plan, the performance of the assessment and the development of a behavior intervention plan prior to making the manifestation determination. While the Petitioner may seek a hearing to challenge the failure of the District to develop a behavior assessment plan, perform the assessment and develop a behavior intervention plan, that hearing will not be a part of the expedited hearing required for the review of the manifestation determination.

Did the District properly conclude that STUDENT's behavior on October 4, l999, was not a manifestation of his disability?

1. Was STUDENT's placement and IEP appropriate, and were the services required by the IEP being provided?

Federal law requires that before an IEP team can conclude that behavior was not a manifestation of a child's disability it must first conclude that in relation to the alleged behavior the child's placement and IEP were appropriate and that the child was receiving the services called for in the IEP. 34 CFR 300.523(c)(2)(i). State law requires that the IEP team conclude that the child's placement was appropriate. Cal. Ed. Code Section 48915.5(a)

In this case, STUDENT alleges only one deficiency in his program and placement at the time of his October 4, l999 alleged behavior. He claims that based on his prior discipline record the District should have conducted a functional behavioral assessment and developed a behavior intervention plan to be included in his IEP. The District contends that a behavioral assessment was not called for and that a specific behavior intervention plan was not needed as part of STUDENT's IEP.

Federal law requires that the IEP team consider, if appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports, to address behavior "in the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others...." 34 CFR 300.346.

State law implementing the "Hughes Bill" requires an IEP to contain a behavioral intervention plan, which is defined as:

[A] written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual's IEP. 5 CCR Section 3001(h).

"Serious behavior problems" is defined as:

[T]he individual's behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective. 5 CCR Section 3001(h).

At the time of his initial IEP meeting on March 2, l999, STUDENT had completed over half of his sophomore year with only two relatively minor disciplinary offenses, both apparently involving cutting classes. Robin Wein, the school psychologist who performed the assessment of STUDENT and attended the IEP meeting, testified that no one raised the issue of STUDENT's discipline problems, other than those related to truancy. She said that there was nothing in her testing and interviews that caused her to be concerned about STUDENT's behavior, other than his failure to attend classes. STUDENT's counselor, Mr. DeMars, testified that he was aware of STUDENT's disciplinary problems, but felt that they were not significant except as they related to his attending classes. He testified that STUDENT's behavior during his freshman year was not unusual, especially for a child who has come to a large public high school from a small private school. He said that such behavior normally moderates when the child gains more maturity. He said that STUDENT's increased maturity was reflected in the lessening of disciplinary conduct during STUDENT's sophomore year. Reports by STUDENT's teachers during his freshman year consistently conclude that STUDENT's attitudes and behaviors in class were appropriate, other than his many absences. They report that he was cooperative, had a positive attitude and was respectful towards the teachers and his peers. The teachers all stated that he did not disrupt their classes. Mr. Bensen, who conducted the assessment for the manifestation determination, stated that there was nothing in the testing or in the records that he reviewed that led him to believe that STUDENT's behavior needed to be addressed beyond his missing classes. Mr. Bensen testified that there was nothing in the records (including the disciplinary record) that would have justified doing a functional behavior assessment or developing a formal behavior intervention plan.Ms. Marian Lane Diamond, a psychologist, testified on behalf of STUDENT. She said that a review of the disciplinary record should have triggered a behavioral assessment prior to the March IEP. Her opinion was not convincing. She admitted that she had merely reviewed the assessments done by Ms. Wein and Mr. Benson, the disciplinary report and the March IEP. She did not review the June IEP, did not interview STUDENT, his parents, teachers or other school personnel. She admitted that in determining whether behavior recorded in the discipline report was significant, it would be important to know the facts surrounding the incidents. She did not have or seek more specific information concerning those incidents.

It is also important to point out that the IEP team did address STUDENT's behavior in the March IEP. The IEP team was concerned about his missed classes and tardies. The IEP team developed a specific goal with five specific objectives to address that problem. Although one of those objectives was to refrain from disruptive behavior, it would appear that objective was not of great concern because, in listing progress toward meeting specific objectives, the teacher marked N/A in relation to the objective to refrain from disruptive behavior.

Under federal law, an IEP team is required to consider, when appropriate, behavioral interventions when the child's behavior impedes his or her learning or the learning of others. 34 CFR 300.346. There is no evidence that any of STUDENT's behavior impeded his learning or the learning of others, except for his failure to attend classes. That failure was addressed by the IEP team in the March IEP. Under state law, a formal behavioral assessment and a behavior intervention plan are required when a student exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with his ability to meet his goals and objectives. 5 CCR Section 301(h). Although some of STUDENT's behavior during his freshman year may be termed "assaultive," there is no evidence at the time of the March IEP that this behavior continued into his sophomore year. Even if the assaultive behavior could be classified as serious, there is no evidence that it significantly interfered with his education or would interfere with inplementing his goals and objectives. For these reasons, it is concluded that at the time of the March IEP it was not necessary to perform a behavioral assessment or develop a behavioral intervention plan.

STUDENT contends that even if there was no need for a behavioral assessment at the time of the March IEP meeting, there was clearly a need for one prior to the October incident because of two instances of misbehavior by him in May. In May, STUDENT was involved in two incidents of misbehavior which were recorded on his disciplinary record. One involved slapping another student because of what that student had said concerning STUDENT's relationship with a girl. The other concerned use of profanity and inviting another student to fight. This incident related to a fight which had occurred at a private party on the previous weekend. In both cases, the matters were resolved successfully through student mediation.

The June 6 IEP states that among the matters considered at the IEP meeting was his discipline report. While there was some disagreement among the witnesses concerning how much time was spent discussing STUDENT's recent misbehavior, it appears clear that the IEP team was not greatly concerned with the incidents. Ms.Wein, who attended the June IEP meeting, said that she was aware of the incidents and that they were being successfully resolved with mediation, which she called a successful behavior intervention. She did not feel that these incidents were significant enough to trigger the need for further assessment or the creation of a formal behavioral intervention plan. Mr. DeMars, STUDENT's counselor, stated that the primary purpose of the meeting was to deal with STUDENT's continuing problem with attending classes. His only concern with STUDENT's misbehavior was the effect it might have if he were suspended and missed classes. STUDENT's attendance report does not reflect that he missed any classes because of the May incidents. Ms. Pamela McMullen, STUDENT's resource specialist teacher, testified that STUDENT's behavior in class was appropriate. He got along well with her and his peers. Her primary concern related to the number of classes that STUDENT had missed. Ms. Diamond stated that she believed the two incidents in May should have triggered a behavioral assessment; however, she admitted that she believed a knowledge of the details of the incidents was necessary to determine their significance, and she did not have such detailed knowledge of what happened.

As discussed above, under federal law, appropriate behavioral interventions should be considered when the behavior impedes a students ability to learn. There is no evidence that the two incidents of misbehavior by STUDENT in May interfered in any way with his ability to learn.

State law requires a behavioral assessment when a serious behavior problem significantly interferes with a student's ability to implement his goals and objectives. The two incidents of STUDENT's misbehavior in May were neither serious nor did they interfere with his ability to implement his goals and objectives. Therefore, it is concluded that the District was not required to perform a behavior assessment or prepare a behavior intervention plan because of the May incidents of misbehavior by STUDENT.

STUDENT contends that the memorandum by Mr. DeMars to the SARB Board reflected the District's awareness of the seriousness of STUDENT's behavior problems and supports the conclusion that a behavior assessment should have been performed and a behavior intervention plan developed. Mr. DeMar testified that he does not have responsibility for discipline. He said that he was mainly concerned with STUDENT's attendance problems and wanted the SARB Board to reinforce his view that STUDENT needed to continue his improved attendance and not become involved in any conduct which might cause him to miss classes.

The mere fact that Mr. DeMars was concerned about STUDENT's disciplinary record does not mean that a behavioral assessment needed to be conducted or a behavior intervention plan developed. The law only calls for such an assessment and behavior intervention plan when the behavior significantly interferes with implementation of the student's goals and objectives. In his memorandum, Mr. Demars also comments that STUDENT's attendance had improved and that he had completed a significant number of units during the summer. There is no evidence that incidents of misbehavior were in any way interfering with the implementation of the goals and objectives in his IEP. While there were behavior problems, they did not rise to the level that would justify a major intervention such as a formal behavior intervention plan.

Based on the discussion above, it is determined that the IEP team properly concluded that STUDENT's IEP and placement were appropriate and that he was receiving the services required by his IEP at the time of the October incident of alleged misbehavior (a finding required by federal and state law) prior to making a determination as to whether his disability was the cause of his behavior.

2. Was STUDENT's alleged misbehavior in October l999 caused by his disability?

On October 14, l999, STUDENT's IEP team concluded that, under state law, his alleged misbehavior of October 4, l999, was not a manifestation of his disability. The team also concluded that, pursuant to federal law, STUDENT's disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of behavior, nor did it impair his ability to control his behavior. All of the District's witnesses agreed with these conclusions.

Mr. Benson, the school psychologist who conducted the assessment prior to the manifestation determination, testified that his review of earlier testing revealed that STUDENT had average ability for abstract conceptual reasoning and had a good general fund of information. He said that STUDENT's average scores on the Comprehension and Picture Completion subtests indicate that he is knowledgeable of what to do in social situations and is able to read social cues and dynamics. He noted that STUDENT is a socially popular student who conducts himself while in class with self-control. He said that during an interview STUDENT stated that "he did not feel his learning disabilities had a direct bearing on his behavior in harassing the student in the locker room." During the interview STUDENT expressed remorse about his conduct and indicated that he knew it was wrong. In his report, Mr. Benson concluded that "STUDENT has the ability to control his behavior and that he is able to discern right from wrong."

Ms. Wein, the school psychologist who did the initial evaluation of STUDENT, testified that there was no indication that STUDENT had attentional problems. He had good attention and focusing abilities and was quite disciplined. He has good ability for abstract reasoning and understands concepts. She said that her testing revealed a marginal discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of written expression and felt that it was a close call as to whether he was eligible for special education services. She expressed the opinion that he was able to control his conduct.

Ms. Pamela McMullen, STUDENT's resource specialist, testified that STUDENT's behavior in class was appropriate. In the face of some teasing by other members of his class, STUDENT shrugged it off. He was making good progress toward his goals and objectives and greatly improved his attendance in class. In her opinion, STUDENT had a social conscience. He expressed remorse for his inappropriate behavior. She related one instance in class in which STUDENT mentioned seeing a Jewish student who was beaten up by Muslim students. He said he felt bad that he had done nothing to help the student. She did not believe that STUDENT's disability impaired his ability to control his behavior.

No evidence was presented to contradict the opinions of the District's witnesses, nor was any evidence presented to support the conclusion that STUDENT's behavior on October 4 was caused by, or was a manifestation of his disability. No evidence was presented that indicated that STUDENT's disability impaired his ability to understand the consequences of his behavior or impaired his ability to control his behavior. The only argument provided by STUDENT was that there was not sufficient information available to the IEP team to make those decisions because a behavior assessment had not been completed. An assessment was done following the alleged conduct and prior to the manifestation determination by Mr. Benson. It included a review of records and a number of interviews with educational personnel and with STUDENT and his mother. The assessment by Mr. Benson was an assessment of STUDENT's behavior and provided much important information to the IEP team and satisfied the requirements of Education Code Section 48915.5(e).

For the reasons set out above, it is concluded that the IEP team had sufficient information to make the manifestation determination at the IEP meeting on October 14, l999, and that they concluded correctly that STUDENT's misbehavior was not a manifestation of his disability under federal and state law.

ORDER

The District may proceed with its proposed discipline of STUDENT consistent with laws governing discipline of nondisabled students.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).

Dated:

Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This hearing is being held pursuant to expedited hearing procedures provided for the review of manifestation determinations pursuant to 34 CFR Sections 300.523 - 300.528. The issues are limited to review of the procedures used in making that determination and the conclusions concerning whether the behavior in question was a manifestation of the Petitioner's disability. It is not within the Hearing Officer's jurisdiction to determine other issues such as whether the alleged conduct occurred or whether the proposed discipline is appropriate.

2. The requests for expedited hearings by the Petitioner and the District were consolidated on the first day of the hearing.