California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 18, 2002
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1697-02 · Hearing Officer Patrick J. Balucan
Los Angeles Unified must provide up to eight months of assistive technology after late assessment and delivery; other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that the parent filed an earlier due process request (SN01-00269, per the District) and withdrew it on about July 15, 2002 after a continuance was denied. This case was filed on July 24, 2002. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
An 11-year-old with a specific learning disability in written language filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. He raised claims across three school years and sought reimbursement for private school at St. Francis of Assisi. The Hearing Officer refused to dismiss the case over an earlier withdrawn filing. However, occupational therapy (OT) claims before May 24, 2001, were dismissed because a mediation agreement had settled them.
The District finished its assistive technology assessment about four months late. It then took about 120 days after the April 10, 2000 IEP to deliver the recommended computer and software. Both delays denied a FAPE, because the District's own assessment showed the student needed the technology to access his education.
The Hearing Officer rejected the claims about a one-day suspension, IEP meeting notice, goals, present levels, social-emotional needs and the 1:1 aide. Missed daily communication logs to the parent did not deny a FAPE. Neither did a three-to-four-week placement in a resource English class at King Middle School or a 20-day assistive technology gap. The Hearing Officer would not enforce the mediation agreement's OT hours, finding no jurisdiction. All reimbursement was denied: the parent bought no replacement services, and the 2001-2002 program was appropriate. As compensatory education, the District must provide the assistive technology devices for up to eight months. An IEP team that includes St. Francis staff will set the length.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated delays in assessing for and delivering assistive technology as a denial of FAPE when the district's own assessment found the devices necessary. It also limited compensatory relief to what the evidence supported, and it held that mediation agreements must be enforced through CDE compliance complaints rather than due process.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue Motion. District motion to dismiss the case for abuse of process (withdrawal and refiling after a denied continuance), or alternatively to dismiss all issues before the May 24, 2001 partial mediation agreement
Motion to dismiss the case denied; occupational therapy claims before May 24, 2001 dismissed under the mediation agreement; other pre-mediation issues not dismissed.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1a. Did the District deny FAPE in 1999-2000 by failing to conduct an assistive technology assessment until four months after the parent gave consent?
The assessment was completed about four months late, delaying technology the District's own assessment said the student needed, causing lost educational opportunity and a denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1b. Did the District deny FAPE by improperly suspending the student?
A one-day suspension was not a disciplinary change of placement; the Education Code section 48900.5 violation was already remedied through a CDE compliance complaint.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1c. Did the District deny FAPE by convening an emergency IEP meeting (October 27, 1999) without adequate notice?
Eight days' notice was adequate; the parent attended with an attorney and a regional center coordinator and consented to the IEP.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1d. Did the District fail to develop appropriate goals and objectives in the October 27, 1999 IEP?
The goals met legal requirements and the student met them; the Student's expert, who had never met the student, was not persuasive.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 1e. Did the District fail to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by the IEP in 1999-2000?
The District admitted the logs were provided inconsistently, but the logs were a parent communication tool and the student progressed, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1f. Did the District fail to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner (1999-2000)?
Assistive technology called for in the April 10, 2000 IEP was not delivered until October 12, 2000, about 120 days late, which denied FAPE.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2a. Did the District fail to develop adequate goals and objectives in the 2000-2001 IEP (alleged rewording of unmet goals)?
The 2000-2001 goals were new and showed progression from the prior year's goals; they were appropriately developed.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 2b. Did the District fail to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by the IEP in 2000-2001?
The failure to provide the communication logs did not deny the student any part of his program, and he made progress, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 2c. Did the District fail to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner in 2000-2001?
Addressed with Issue 1f; the delay until October 12, 2000 was a denial of FAPE, as reflected in the prevailing-party finding for 2000-2001.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3a. Did the District fail to properly document present levels of performance in the April 3, 2001 IEP?
The IEP contained present levels of performance in language arts and counseling, which met legal requirements.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3b. Did the District fail to develop adequate goals and objectives in the 2001-2002 IEP?
The goals were appropriate and measurable; any lack of progress followed the parent's unilateral private placement.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3c. Did the District fail to develop an IEP that addressed all of the student's areas of need (social-emotional)?
No reassessment was required or requested, and the IEP's counseling goal addressed the social-emotional concerns the parent raised.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 3d. Did the District fail to transfer and properly implement the IEP when the student moved from elementary to middle school?
Placing the student in a resource English class for 3 to 4 weeks instead of general education was an error, but it was corrected promptly and caused no prejudice because the class was reviewing old material.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 3e. Did the District fail to provide assistive technology in a timely manner at King Middle School?
A roughly 20-day gap was not a denial of FAPE: a classroom computer was available and the curriculum was review.
- Not reachedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 3f. Did the District fail to provide occupational therapy services pursuant to a mediation agreement?
The Hearing Office has no jurisdiction to enforce mediation agreements; CDE compliance complaints are the forum. The Hearing Officer also noted the parent had not made the student available for the OT.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 3g. Did the District fail to provide a 1:1 aide as called for in the IEP?
The evidence showed the student had a 1:1 aide at King Middle School during July and August 2001.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for assistive technology and counseling services provided in the 1999-2000 school year?
Denied; the parent testified she bought no assistive technology or counseling in 1999-2000.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for counseling services provided during the 2000-2001 school year?
Denied; no services were procured in 2000-2001.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private school tuition at St. Francis School in the 2001-2002 school year?
Denied; the District provided FAPE in 2001-2002.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4d. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for occupational therapy, assistive technology, Writing Without Tears, counseling, childcare, uniform, materials and books for St. Francis in 2001-2002?
Denied; the District provided FAPE in 2001-2002.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education in the form of assistive technology, counseling, and the Writing Without Tears program?
Up to eight months of continued assistive technology was awarded as compensatory education; counseling and Writing Without Tears were denied for lack of evidence of need, since the student was progressing.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. District shall provide assistive technology as compensatory education, consisting of the devices called for in the April 3, 2001 IEP (computer with keyboard, Earobics, Alphasmart keyboard, write:Outloud, co:Write), for a period not to exceed eight months.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP team meeting, including school staff from St. Francis, to determine the amount of assistive technology services (not to exceed eight months) the student requires based on his current needs. No deadline stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Gregory K. v. Longview; Adams v. Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri
People named in the decision
- Gloria Perez, regional center service coordinator; witness for Student, Lanterman Regional Center
- Dr. Chris Davidson, psychologist; expert witness for Student, California State University, Long Beach
- Donna Mautz, least restrictive environment support (inclusion) facilitator, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Verna Masaki, assistant principal, King Middle School
- Lisa Ruvalcaba, general education teacher, King Middle School
- Lauren Wayne, occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Grace Park-Noh, school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Barbara Burnett, assistant principal, Mayberry Elementary School
- Jocelyn Mull, program specialist for due process (District representative), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Agatha Metichecchia, program specialist for due process (District representative), Los Angeles Unified School District
- David Bloom, assistive technology assessor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Karen Ezaki, assistive technology assessor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Ms. Chavez, 1:1 aide, King Middle School
- Meredith Goetz, parent's attorney at October 27, 1999 IEP meeting
- St. Francis of Assisi School, private school (unilateral parent placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on September 3, 4, 5 and 6, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Scott Ayers from the law firm of Roberts & Adams. Also present on STUDENT’S behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Present on some days of hearing on his behalf were attorneys Paul H. Kamoroff and Michael E. Jewell from the law firm of Roberts & Adams. STUDENT was also present on some days of hearing. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Steven Groode from the law firm of Littler Mendelson. Present on September 3 and 4 on behalf of the District was Jocelyn Mull, a program specialist for due process with the District. Present on behalf of the District on September 5 and 6 was Agatha Metichecchia, a program specialist for due process with the District.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER; Gloria Perez, a service coordinator with the Lanterman Regional Center; and Dr. Chris Davidson, a psychologist with California State University, Long Beach. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Donna Mautz, a least restrictive environment support facilitator with the District; Verna Masaki, assistant principal at King Middle School; Lisa Ruvalcaba, general education teacher at King Middle School; Lauren Wayne, an occupational therapist with the District; Dr. Grace Park-Noh, a psychologist with the District; and Barbara Burnett, assistant principal at Mayberry Elementary School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the 1999-2000 school year by: a. Failing to conduct an assistive technology assessment until four months after the parents gave consent; b. Improperly suspending STUDENT;
c. Convening an emergency IEP without adequate notice;
d. Failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives;
e. Failing to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by his IEP; f. Failing to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner.
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the 2000-2001 school year by: a. Failing to develop adequate goals and objectives in his IEP; b. Failing to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by his IEP; c. Failing to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner.
3. Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the 2001-2002 school year by: a. Failing to properly document STUDENT’S present levels of performance; b. Failing to develop adequate goals and objectives in STUDENT’S IEP; c. Failing to develop an IEP that addressed all of STUDENT’S areas of need; d. Failing to transfer and properly implement STUDENT’S IEP when he transferred from elementary to middle school; e. Failing to provide assistive technology in a timely manner; f. Failing to provide occupational therapy services pursuant to a mediation agreement; g. Failing to provide a 1:1 aide as called for in his IEP;
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: a. Assistive technology and counseling service provided in the 1999-2000 school year. b. Counseling services provided during the 2000-2001 school year. c. Private school tuition at St. Francis School in the 2001-2002 school year. d. Occupational therapy, assistive technology, Writing Without Tears, Counseling services, childcare and uniform, materials and books for St. Francis in the 2001-2002 school year.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education in the form of assistive technology, counseling, and the Writing Without Tears program?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of hearing, the District made a motion to dismiss this matter, or in the alternative, to dismiss all of Petitioner’s issues prior to May 24, 2001 on the grounds of abuse of process. On or about February 16, 2001, Petitioner had filed another case.(Footnote 2) After several letters from the Hearing Officer requesting the status of this case, and after an Order to Show Cause why this case should not be dismissed, that matter was placed back on calendar and was assigned hearing dates. On or about June 10, 2002, Petitioner made a motion for a continuance. The motion was denied. Petitioner then withdrew that case on or about July 15, 2002. Shortly thereafter, on or about July 24, 2002, Petitioner requested another due process hearing with substantially the same issues to be decided. That case is the matter presently before this Hearing Officer. District argued that Petitioner was abusing the Hearing Office’s procedures by withdrawing the previous request for hearing after obtaining an adverse ruling on their continuance motion and then re-filing approximately one week later with substantially the same issues to be decided. It requested that this case be dismissed.
In the alternative, the District argued that all issues prior to May 24, 2001 should be dismissed pursuant to a settlement reached at mediation. On May 24, 2001, the parties participated in mediation, at which time they reached an agreement on some of the issues for hearing. In sum, the terms of the settlement agreement were that the District would provide 11 hours of school based occupational therapy as compensatory services. The agreement settled “any and all claims to date regarding occupational therapy services for STUDENT,” and indicated that the only issue that remained for hearing was the termination of STUDENT’S 1:1 aide. The District argued that this settlement agreement settled all educational issues between the parties up to that point.
Petitioner responded that he withdrew his case as a courtesy to the District, so that the parties could have an opportunity to settle this matter at mediation. Petitioner indicated there was a mediation date scheduled for August 2002. They further cited Civil Code §581 (b) as support for their right to withdraw their case. As for the May 24, 2001 mediation agreement, Petitioner argued that the agreement was unenforceable and not binding because the District breached its duty to provide the OT services called for in that agreement. He also argued that this was only a partial settlement agreement, and that not all issues were resolved via that mediation.
As to the motion to dismiss the entire case, the Hearing Officer noted that while the Hearing Office strongly discourages the parties from withdrawing cases to circumvent adverse rulings, withdrawing a case is not without its attendant consequences. By withdrawing his case, Petitioner changed the statute of limitations for issues that could be presented at hearing. (See Cal. Educ. Code §56505(j).) Withdrawing his case effectively eliminated several years of STUDENT’S education from being litigated at a due process hearing. Instead of being able to litigate issues that arose since February of 1998 (three years prior to the previous request for due process), Petitioner is limited to only issues that arose since July of 1999 (three years prior to this request for due process). Furthermore, the withdrawal occurred prior to a hearing commencing without any undue burden on the District in preparing for hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denied the motion to dismiss this matter.
As for the motion to dismiss issues prior to May 24, 2001, the Hearing Officer dismissed issues regarding OT prior to May 24, 2001, pursuant to the clear and unambiguous terms of the partial mediation agreement. However, the Hearing Officer declined to dismiss all issues prior to May 24, 2001. As of the date of the mediation, there still remained an issue – the issue of STUDENT’S 1:1 aid. That matter was still proceeding to hearing. The only limitation on Petitioner’s ability to add issues would be to inform the District of those issues 10 days prior to the hearing date. (See Cal. Educ. Code §56505(e)(6).) Because new issues could still be added, the mediation agreement could not fairly be read to have resolved all issues prior to May 24, 2001. Therefore, the District’s motion to dismiss issues was granted with regard to the OT services, and denied with regard to dismissal of all issues prior to the mediation agreement.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eleven-year-old student currently eligible for special education as specific learning disabled. He has been identified as having a discrepancy in the area of written language. According to MOTHER, STUDENT has been eligible for special education since kindergarten. Prior to his current eligibility as specific learning disabled, STUDENT was identified eligible for special education as other health impaired due to pervasive developmental disorder and attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder. He is currently attending school at St. Francis of Assisi, a private school.
During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was in fourth grade and attending the District’s Mayberry Elementary School. On October 6, 1999, STUDENT was suspended from school for using profanity against a yard duty aid, who told him that he could not have Pokemon cards.(Footnote 3) When told by the aid that the Pokemon cards were not allowed at school, STUDENT proceeded to use the obscenity. STUDENT was suspended for one day for habitual profanity.
In light of his suspension, an individualized education plan (IEP) meeting was held on October 27, 1999 to address STUDENT’S use of the profanity and to review his behavior support plan. The IEP team made five additions to the behavior support plan implemented at the January 13, 1999 IEP.(Footnote 4) One of the modifications was that MOTHER’s use of a communication log was increased from a weekly to a daily basis in order to keep her informed of any of STUDENT’S behavioral challenges. The IEP noted that MOTHER was contesting the suspension. It was also noted in the IEP that STUDENT was generally well behaved and progressed well in class. Shortly after the IEP meeting, MOTHER filed a complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) alleging that the District improperly suspended STUDENT from school.
In a letter dated January 28, 2000, the CDE completed its compliance investigation. The compliance investigation concluded that the District was out of compliance with California Evidence Code §48900.5 by failing to use other means of correction before suspension. (Petitioner’s Ex. 8.)
Meanwhile, the IEP team began exploring whether STUDENT would benefit from assistive technology devices. On June 9, 1999, MOTHER consented to an assessment plan to assess for assistive technologies programs such as FastForWord and the Earobics programs. (Petitioner’s Ex. 59.) On October 27, 1999, MOTHER consented to another assessment to test for assistive technology to help STUDENT in the area of reading and writing. (Petitioner’s Ex. 64.) On March 13, 2000, the District issued its assistive technology assessment report, prepared by David Bloom and Karen Ezaki. (Petitioner’s Ex. 66.) The report recommended that STUDENT be provided with, among other things, a desktop computer and printer, a phonics program, and a word generation program.
An annual review IEP meeting was held on April 10, 2000. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT remain in general education with resource specialist program services three times per week, to be increased to five times per week when he began the fifth grade in the fall of 2000. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) Furthermore, STUDENT’S fourth grade teachers reported that he was showing maturity and was developing socialization skills. The IEP noted that STUDENT had met the goals developed at both the January 14, and October 27, 1999 IEPs. The team agreed to gradually phase out STUDENT’S 1:1 aid. The daily communication report logs to MOTHER were to be continued. Additionally, at this IEP meeting, Mr. Bloom presented the need for the assistive technology outlined in his report. MOTHER testified that the consensus with the IEP was that STUDENT required the assistive technology recommended by Mr. Bloom’s report. However, the assistive technology was not immediately provided. MOTHER filed another complaint with the CDE’s compliance unit to obtain the assistive technology and begin the fade-out of the 1:1 aid.
In August of 2000, STUDENT began the fifth grade at Mayberry Elementary School. Via letter dated November 30, 2000, the CDE completed their investigation, and informed the parties of its conclusions and recommendations. (Petitioner’s Ex. 10.) The report indicated that the assistive technology was finally provided to STUDENT on October 12, 2000. The CDE once again found the District out of compliance by failing to provide STUDENT’S assistive technology for approximately 120 days after the April 10, 2000 IEP team recommendation. The CDE further found that the District was implementing the 1:1 aid fade-out as called for in the IEP.
On June 19, 2000, another IEP meeting was convened to amend the April 10, 2000 IEP. The purpose of this IEP meeting was to add a goal for counseling. (Petitioner’s Ex. 35.) During that IEP meeting, a goal was added for STUDENT to improve his adult relationships. He was to be provided with 30 minutes per week of DIS counseling services.
Via letter dated February 6, 2001, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing. (Petitioner’s Ex. 11.) In that letter, MOTHER indicated that her issue for hearing was regarding the services of STUDENT’S aid.(Footnote 5)
On April 3, 2001, the District and Petitioner held an annual review IEP meeting. This IEP meeting was to govern his placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The IEP indicated that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education with a Specific Learning Disability. STUDENT’S educational setting was in the general education classroom with inclusion support. (Petitioner’s Ex. 39.) He was to be provided counseling services once a week for 30 minutes. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT was to continue to receive assistive technology.(Footnote 6) District personnel also made the recommendation to withdraw STUDENT’S 1:1 aid support in his classroom by the end of the 2000-2001 school year, on June 22, 2001. MOTHER disagreed with the fade-out of STUDENT’S 1:1 aid, but agreed to the implementation of the rest of the IEP.
On May 16, 2001, another IEP meeting was held. The purpose of this meeting was to discuss STUDENT’S need for OT. The District did not recommend OT services and indicated that there were no OT concerns identified. MOTHER indicated that she disagreed with the District’s conclusions.
Meanwhile, on May 24, 2001, Petitioner and the District reached an agreement at mediation to partially resolve some issues for the pending due process hearing. Based on the partial mediation agreement, the District agreed to provide 11 hours of OT as compensatory education. The issue of the 1:1 aid was not resolved.
In July of 2001, Petitioner entered the sixth grade. He began attending the District’s King Middle School. Upon entering King, the District originally placed STUDENT in one period of English resource class, with attendance in regular education classes for the rest of the school day. STUDENT remained in the resource English class until his inclusion facilitator, Ms. Mautz, informed administrators at King that STUDENT was to be in a general education class with inclusion support for his entire school day. STUDENT remained in the English resource class for approximately 3 to 4 weeks. King Middle School transferred him out of the resource class and placed him in Ms. Ruvalcaba’s general education classroom for English and History. STUDENT attended Ms. Ruvalcaba’s classroom for the remainder of July and through August. In September, King Middle School went off track. On September 3, 2001, during the time that King was off track, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT in St. Francis of Assisi School. MOTHER did not inform the District that she was enrolling STUDENT in private school.
In January of 2002, MOTHER filed another complaint with the CDE. In her complaint, she alleged that the District failed to provide the occupational therapy services pursuant to the May 24, 2002 mediation agreement, and that STUDENT’S placement in a non-regular education classroom at King Middle School. As of January 2002, the District has not provided the OT services called for in that partial mediation agreement. The CDE completed its investigation, and informed the parties of its conclusions and recommendations via letter dated March 25, 2002. (Petitioner’s Ex. 14.) The CDE found that STUDENT did not receive the eleven hours of OT required under the partial mediation agreement. The CDE further found that STUDENT was not placed in the general education setting with inclusion support for the first 20 days he attended King Middle School. The CDE found the District out of compliance and mandated that the following corrective actions be taken: 1) Within 30 days of this report, the District shall provide evidence that the 11 hours of OT services were provided, and 2) that the District shall provide evidence that it reviewed its procedures with the elementary school regarding the transfer of pupils to middle school.
On July 15, 2002, Petitioner withdrew the prior request for a due process hearing. MOTHER requested this due process hearing via letter dated July 24, 2002.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year?
Pursuant to the IDEA and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Edu. Code §5600. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. §1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. §1401(25); Cal.Edu.Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (Id. at 1484.) Procedural violations may result in a denial of FAPE if they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (Id.)
Therefore, the inquiry in IDEA cases is twofold. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206. The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. Id. The second is whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures is reasonably calculated to enable the student to receive an educational benefit. Id. at 207. The school district has the burden of proving at administrative hearing that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it provided an appropriate educational placement for the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Here, petitioner has alleged that the District has failed to observe the procedural safeguards of the IDEA and failed to offer him an appropriate program.
1. Compliance with Procedural Requirements
The courts have created a two-prong test for determining whether a procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE for a student: 1) whether a procedural protection has been violated, and 2) whether the violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parent’s participation in the IEP process. The alleged procedural violations were that the District failed to conduct an assistive technology assessment in a timely manner, that it improperly suspended STUDENT, that it convened an emergency IEP without adequate notice, and that it failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives in the October 27, 1999 IEP.
a. Failing to Conduct Assistive Technology Assessments in a Timely Manner
Petitioner contends that the District failed to follow the IDEA procedural guidelines when it failed to timely conduct an assessment of STUDENT’S assistive technology needs approximately four months after it was due. The District admits that the assistive technology assessment should have been conducted sooner, but argues that Petitioner suffered no prejudice by the delay in assessing his needs.
Although there is no provision in special education law that specifically addresses a timeline for completion of an assessment, there are related provisions that provide clear guidance to districts and parents in this regard. An IEP team meeting must be convened upon completion of an initial assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(a).) An IEP required as a result of an assessment must be completed within 50 days of the date of receipt of the parents’ written consent to the assessment.(Footnote 7) (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.) Since at least one purpose of such an IEP would be to discuss the results of the assessment, the assessment must be completed by the time of the IEP meeting.
The undisputed evidence shows that MOTHER gave her consent to assistive technology assessments on June 9 and October 27, 1999. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 59 and 64.) It is further undisputed that the assistive technology assessment report was not issued until March 13, 2000, and that an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment was not convened until April 10, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 66 and 33.) Although the District concedes that the reports were late, it argues that STUDENT did not suffer any prejudice by the delay because even if the assessments had been conducted in a timely manner, the assistive technology devices would not have been provided until slightly before his summer break.(Footnote 8) Since STUDENT was not eligible for extended school year services, the District argued, the devices would have been of little benefit until STUDENT began school again in September of 2000.
The District concedes that the assistive technology assessment was done late and that an IEP was not convened in a timely manner. Whatever the reasons for the delay, the fact remains that the assistive technology assessment was completed approximately four months after it was due. The assessment reported that the programs and devices for which STUDENT was assessed would help him to produce more complex sentences and would help him read faster, and were being provided to aid with his written expression. The fourth-month delay in conducting the assessments resulted in Petitioner not receiving services that the District’s assistive technology assessment indicated he required to access his education. Without being able to fully access his education, STUDENT lost educational opportunity. Therefore, the delay in conducting the assistive technology assessment was prejudicial to STUDENT and resulted in a denial of FAPE.
b. Improperly Suspending STUDENT
Petitioner contends that the suspension of STUDENT in October of 1999 was improper. Petitioner argues that the since the District was found by the CDE to have been in violation of Education Code §48900.5, that this denied STUDENT a FAPE.(Footnote 9) STUDENT was suspended for one day in October of 1999 for using profanity against a yard duty aide.
Pursuant to federal law, a District has broad powers to discipline a special education student in much the same way as a student not eligible for special education. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.520.) The protections for students with disabilities arise only when there is a disciplinary change of placement, which the regulations define as a suspension lasting more than 10 days. (See 34 C.F.R. §300.519.) In this case, it is undisputed that STUDENT was suspended for only one day. This suspension did not rise to the level of a disciplinary change of placement that would require the protections of state and federal law. Thus, the District had broad discretion to discipline STUDENT in the same way they would a regular education student. That the District did so inappropriately, by failing to use other means of correction prior to suspension pursuant to California Education Code §48900.5, did not make his suspension an issue that implicates the protections that State and federal law provide for students with disabilities. MOTHER filed the appropriate complaint against the District with the CDE, and the District was found out of compliance. The CDE required certain corrective actions to be taken by the District. (Petitioner’s Ex. 8.) Petitioner has been provided a remedy for the District’s failure to follow the Education Code in its suspension of STUDENT.
c. Convening an Emergency IEP Without Adequate Notice
Petitioner contends that his mother, MOTHER, was not given adequate notice of the October 27, 1999 IEP. Petitioner argues that because of the short notice provided by the District, she was not given adequate time to prepare and therefore could not meaningfully participate in the IEP. The District responds that MOTHER was able to fully participate in the IEP, that notice was provided pursuant to State and federal law, that adequate notice was provided, and that Petitioner suffered no prejudice due to the shortened notice provided by the District.
When convening an IEP meeting, the District is required to take steps to insure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each individualized education program meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate. (34 C.F.R. §300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a).) Additionally, the parents must be notified of the IEP meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend. (34 C.F.R. §300.345(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).) In this matter, it is undisputed that District sent its notification of the October 27, 1999 IEP meeting on October 19, 1999. MOTHER signed the form on October 22, 1999, and returned it to the District. (Petitioner’s Ex. 27.) On October 27, 1999, MOTHER attended the IEP meeting, along with her attorney, Meredith Goetz, and Ms. Perez, STUDENT’S service coordinator with Lanterman Regional Center. (Petitioner’s Ex. 28.) STUDENT’S aunt also attended on his behalf. (Id.) Moreover, MOTHER consented to the IEP without any indication that she disagreed with the services that were added by that IEP. (Id.) Despite the fact that the District sent notification only 8 days prior to the meeting, MOTHER was able to bring an attorney and a regional center service coordinator to assist her at that IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District gave adequate notice, and MOTHER was able to participate in the IEP meeting.
d. Failure to Develop Appropriate Goals and Objectives in the October 27, 1999 IEP(Footnote 10)
State and federal law requires that an IEP document must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to meeting STUDENT’S needs to enable him to be involved in and progress in the general education curriculum. (20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code §56345(a).) Petitioner contends that the District failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives in the October 27, 1999 IEP. Petitioner argues that goals and objectives developed for that IEP lacked appropriate levels of measurement, did not adequately define terms used in the goals and failed to appropriately state how the goals and objectives were to be implemented and measured. The District responded that the goals were appropriate. In the alternative, the District argued that, even if the goals and objectives were inapprorpriate, Petitioner was not deprived of educational benefit.
The October 27, 1999 IEP contained three goals. The goals were in the areas of language arts, pre-vocational education, and counseling. Each of the three goals had at least two short-term objectives attached to them.(Footnote 11) On its face, it appears that the goals and objective developed by the IEP team satisfied the requirements of State and federal law. Petitioner relies on the testimony of Dr. Davidson, Petitioner’s psychologist, for support of his contention that the goals and objectives were inappropriately developed. Dr. Davidson testified that the goals were vague, that they could not be measured, and that they appeared arbitrary. However, the Hearing Officer does not find the testimony of Dr. Davidson persuasive. Dr. Davidson testified that she has never met STUDENT, never conducted an assessment and was not present at any of the IEP team meetings. At the next annual IEP meeting, held on April 10, 2000, showed that STUDENT met the goals from the October 27, 1999 IEP, indicating that the goals and objectives were able to be implemented as written. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) Thus, the evidence shows that the goals and objectives written in the October 27, 1999 were appropriate.
2. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program is designed to address STUDENT’S unique educational needs, is reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if STUDENT’S parent preferred another program and even if his parent preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) The District was also required to provide STUDENT a program which educates him in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code 56031.) Therefore, under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District’s provided for the 1999-2000 school year must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: be designed to meet STUDENT’S educational needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, comport with his IEP, and provide him education in the least restrictive environment.
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique educational needs, it is necessary to have some understanding of what unique educational needs the District knew or should have known about at the time it made its placement offer. (See Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (stating that review must focus on adequacy of proposed program at time it was drafted).) The District cannot be held responsible for information it had no basis for knowing at the time it developed the IEP. Id. However, “[i]n striving for ‘appropriateness,’ an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable…at the time the IEP was drafted.’” (Id. (quoting Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Educ., 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993)).) District’s are required to review and revise the IEP when necessary to address any lack of expected progress towards goals and objectives. 34 C.F.R. §300.343(c).
A. Designed to meet STUDENT’S Unique Educational Needs
STUDENT has been identified as eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. He has been found to exhibit a disorder in the basic psychological process involving attention, auditory processing, and sensory-motor integration. He displays a severe discrepancy between his achievement and ability in the area of written language. Petitioner did not dispute that his program – participation in a regular education classroom, with resource specialist program services to address his written language deficits and counseling DIS – was designed to meet his unique educational needs.
B. Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
Petitioner did not dispute that the program provided by the District did not offer him educational benefit.
C. Conforms to his IEP
Petitioner argues that the program provided by the District for the 1999-2000 school year did not conform to STUDENT’S IEP because it failed to provide daily work and behavior reports, and it failed to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner as required by the IEP.
a. Failing to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by his IEP
As part of STUDENT’S October 27, 1999 IEP, MOTHER was to receive communication logs in order to keep informed of STUDENT’S behavioral challenges. (Petitioner’s Ex. 28.) The communication log was already in place and supplied to MOTHER on a weekly basis. However, pursuant to the revised behavior support plan developed during that IEP, the log was now to be provided on a daily basis to MOTHER. (Id.) Petitioner argues that although his mother may have received some logs, the logs were not provided on a daily basis and were provided only inconsistently. The District does not dispute that the daily report logs were not consistently provided to STUDENT’S mother. However, the District argues that STUDENT did not suffer any prejudice to his education by the District’s failure to provide the logs to MOTHER consistently.
MOTHER testified that she did not receive logs from September of 1999 through June of 2000, and from September of 2000 through November of 2000. (See Petitioner’s Ex. 100.) She testified that she received the logs for approximately 3 months. Subsequently, the logs were provided only twice a week, and then discontinued altogether. She further testified that she required the logs in order to stay involved in STUDENT’S education. However, the logs were not in the nature of an actual program that was to be provided to STUDENT. Although the District admits that the logs were provided inconsistently to the parent, the evidence before the Hearing Officer showed that STUDENT was able to access and progress in his educational program. At the next annual IEP meeting, the IEP indicated that STUDENT met his goals and objectives, and that he was making progress in his educational setting. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) Moreover, MOTHER did not request the missing logs until a letter to the District dated February 21, 2001, approximately one year after the logs were supposed to by provided. Furthermore, the daily logs were a communication device designed to facilitate MOTHER’s involvement in STUDENT education. The failure to provide these logs on a consistent basis did not deny STUDENT any component of his educational program. Therefore, the failure of the District to provide the daily report logs consistently did not deny STUDENT a FAPE in the 1999-2000 school year.
b. Failing to Provide Assistive Technology in a Timely Manner
It is undisputed that, pursuant to the April 10, 2000 IEP, Petitioner was entitled to receive assistive technology in the form of a desktop computer and printer, and associated software programs to help with his reading and writing. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) It is further undisputed that the assistive technology devices were not provided to Petitioner until October 12, 2000, a delay of approximately 120 days. MOTHER filed a compliance complaint with the CDE. (Petitioner’s Ex. 9.) Via letter dated November 30, 2000, the CDE found that the District was out of compliance. (Petitioner’s Ex. 10.) Petitioner contends that the delay in providing the services resulted in a denial of FAPE. The District responds that the short time that STUDENT was without his assistive technology did not hinder him from receiving educational benefit.
Under State and federal law, the District is required to implement the IEP as soon as possible following a meeting of the IEP team. (34 C.F.R. §300.342(b)(1); 5 C.C.R. §3040(a).) In this case, there is no dispute that assistive technology services called for in the April 10, 2000 IEP were not provided until October 12, 2000. Via letter dated September 17, 2000, MOTHER filed a compliance complaint with the CDE. In that letter, MOTHER requested that the District provide the assistive technology devices. (Petitioner’s Ex. 9.) The CDE found the District out of compliance, indicated that the District had already provided the devices, and ordered the District to submit proof that it had provided the assistive technology. (Petitioner’s Ex. 10.) However, the fact remains that the District failed to provide the assistive technology devices until October 12, 2000, a delay of approximately 120 days. ( See Petitioner’s Ex. 10.) The District’s own assistive technology assessment found that STUDENT needed these services to fully access his education. (See above.) By not having access to the assistive technology devices during that 120-day delay, STUDENT was unable to fully access his educational program. Therefore, by failing to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner, the District has denied STUDENT a FAPE.
D. In the Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner did not dispute that the program provided by the District during the 1999-2000 school year was in the least restrictive environment.
Issue No. 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the 2000-2001 school year?
1. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs
Petitioner alleged that the District did not provide him a FAPE in the 2000-2001 school year. He alleged that the District failed to provide adequate goals and objectives, failed to provide the daily communication logs on a consistent basis to MOTHER, and failed to provide assistive technology in a timely manner.
A. Designed to meet STUDENT’S Unique Educational Needs
It is undisputed that STUDENT’S needs remained the same from the prior school year. STUDENT remained eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. Petitioner did not argue that his educational setting – a general education setting with resource specialist program services to address his language arts needs – was not designed to meet his unique educational needs.
B. Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
Petitioner argues that District’s failure to provide adequate goals and objectives deprived him of educational benefit.
a. Failure to Provide Adequate Goals and Objectives(Footnote 12)
Petitioner argues that when STUDENT failed to meet his goals and objectives, the District reworded the same goals and objectives for the following year, without changing them or instituting new strategies to deal with STUDENT’S unique educational needs. In essence, Petitioner is arguing that his education did not provide him with educational benefit because the goals and objectives were merely carried over from the prior year. The District responded that STUDENT did not fail to meet his goals and objectives, and that the goals and objectives developed for this school year were appropriate.
The goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year were developed at the April 10, 2000 IEP meeting. At that IEP meeting, the team developed goals in language arts and pre-vocational education. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) In addition, a counseling goal was added at the June 19, 2000 IEP meeting. (Petitioner’s Ex. 35.) It is apparent from a review of these documents that the goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year were different from the goals and objectives from the prior year. (See fn. 8.) Moreover, the new goals and objectives indicate a progression from STUDENT’S previous goals and objectives. Where the goal as stated in the October 27, 2000 IEP dealt with sentence structure and reading, the new goal dealt with having STUDENT write a composition of 500-700 words. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) His pre-vocational education goal changed from dealing with sentence structure to being able to follow school and classroom rules. Finally, the counseling goal changed from improving his self-control to improving his relationships with adult peers. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives developed for the 2000-2001 school year were not carried over from the prior year. The goals and objectives for 2000-2001 were appropriately developed and designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.(Footnote 13)
C. Conforms to his IEP
Petitioner argues that the program provided by the District for the 2000-2001 school year did not comport to STUDENT’S IEP because it failed to provide daily work and behavior reports, and it failed to provide the assistive technology in a timely manner as required by the IEP.
a. Failing to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by his IEP
As part of STUDENT’S April 10, 2000 IEP, MOTHER was to continue to receive the daily communication logs. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) The daily log was to document STUDENT’S work habits and behaviors. Petitioner argues that the District did not supply the daily work logs as required by the IEP. The District responds that there was no evidence that MOTHER was denied a significant number of daily logs. It argues further than any failure to provide the logs was not prejudicial to STUDENT.
Again, as stated before, the communication logs were made part of the IEP to facilitate communication between the District and MOTHER in order to document STUDENT’S work habits and behaviors. The District’s failure to provide these logs did not deny STUDENT any component of his educational program. Moreover, it appears from the record that STUDENT was able to make educational progress during the time that MOTHER was supposed to receive the logs. At the next annual review of STUDENT’S IEP, on April 3, 2001, STUDENT had met his pre-vocational education and his counseling goals, and had partially met his language arts goal.(Footnote 14) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide these logs on a consistent basis did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
b. Failing to Provide Assistive Technology in a Timely Manner
Again, Petitioner argues that the assistive technology that was to be provided pursuant to the April 3, 2000 IEP was not provided at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. The assistive technology was provided by October 12, 2000, and the failure of the District to provide this service was addressed above.
E. In the Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner did not argue the District failed to provide him an educational setting in the least restrictive environment for the 2000-2001 school year.
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny STUDENT a free, appropriate public education in the 2001-2002 school year?
1. Compliance with Procedural Requirements
Petitioner argues that, for the 2001-2002 school year, the District failed to follow the procedural mandates of State and federal law when it failed to document STUDENT’S present levels of performance, failed to transfer STUDENT into the appropriate classroom when he moved from elementary to middle school, and failed to meet the goals and objectives contained in his IEP.
a. Failing to properly document STUDENT’S Present Levels of Performance
Petitioner argues that the April 3, 2001 IEP did not include present levels of performance, as required by State and federal law. According to state and federal law, an IEP must include the present levels of the pupil’s educational performance, including how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general education curriculum. (20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(1)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. 300.347(a)(1)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) A review of the IEP developed on April 3, 2001 shows that there were present levels of performance included in the IEP. (Petitioner’s Ex. 39.) Indeed, on page 3 and 4 of Petitioner’s Exhibit 39, under pages titled “Section E: Present Levels of Performance,” the IEP team laid out present levels of performance in the area of language arts and counseling.(Footnote 15) Therefore, the IEP has met the requirements of state and federal law.
b. Failure to Develop Adequate Goals and Objectives in STUDENT’S IEP
At hearing, Petitioner argued that STUDENT’S failure to meet his goals and objectives was due to the fact that the District did not include present levels of performance in his IEP. Notwithstanding the fact that there were present levels of performance in STUDENT’S IEP (see above), or that Petitioner did not demonstrate how the lack of present levels would lead to STUDENT’S failure to meet his goals and objectives, STUDENT did not attend the school in the District from September 3, 2001 onward. At that point, STUDENT was placed, at MOTHER’s expense, in St. Francis of Assisi, a private school. At that point the District could no longer work on his goals and objectives, and could no longer ensure that STUDENT was progressing towards meeting his goals. The Hearing Officer thus finds that while STUDENT may not have progressed towards meeting his goals for the 2001-2002 school year, it was through not fault of the District since he was unilaterally placed by his mother in private school.
As developed, the uncontroverted testimony of Ms. Ruvalcaba indicates that the goals and objectives were appropriate. She testified that these were appropriate goals for STUDENT based on his needs, and as written she could implement and measure his progress on the goals and objectives. Therefore, as developed, the goals and objectives met the requirements of state and federal law.
1. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs
A. Designed to meet STUDENT’S Unique Educational Needs
According to the April 3, 2001 IEP, STUDENT remained eligible for special education with a specific learning disability in the area of written language. Petitioner did not dispute that STUDENT’S placement – general education with inclusion support – was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique educational needs. However, Petitioner does argue that the IEP failed to address his social emotional needs for the 2001-2002 school year.
a. Developing an IEP that failed to address all of STUDENT’S areas of need
Petitioner argues that STUDENT was not appropriately assessed in all areas of suspected need. Specifically, Petitioner argues that the District failed to address STUDENT’S needs in the area of social emotional development. It argues that, at the time the April 3, 2001 IEP was developed, it had been over two years since STUDENT’S last psychoeducational assessment.
A reassessment of a pupil shall be conducted once every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant, or if a pupil or a teacher request reassessment. (Cal. Educ. Code §56381.) At the time of the April 3, 2001 IEP, the District was not required to conduct further assessments. Furthermore, Petitioner presented no evidence, and did not argue at hearing, that conditions would warrant reassessment, or that MOTHER or any District personnel requested a reassessment. Dr. Park-Noh, the District’s psychologist who attended the April 3, IEP meeting, indicated that there was a discussion of conducting a triennial assessment in April of 2002, and does not recall that anyone at this meeting believed that triennial assessments were to be conducted sooner.
Notwithstanding the fact that there was no statutory requirement that the District conduct further assessments, the IEP did address STUDENT’S social-emotional needs. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’S social-emotional concerns were over his socialization skills and his ability to ask for help from adults. The April 3, 2001 IEP indicated that STUDENT met a counseling goal that required him to seek adult help. (Petitioner’s Ex. 39.) That IEP also reflected MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT was not seeking adult assistance when experiencing difficulty with peers. Another goal was added for further counseling. (Id.) The counseling goal was that STUDENT would learn to seek adult assistance in his problem solving, and one of the objectives associated with this goal was that STUDENT would seek adult help when there was a conflict with peers. Dr. Park-Noh, who wrote the present level of performance and developed the goals, testified that these were the social-emotional concerns presented by MOTHER at the IEP meeting. Dr. Park-Noh testified that the counseling was written into the IEP specifically because of MOTHER’s concerns over STUDENT’S needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the April 3, 2001 IEP met STUDENT’s social-emotional needs in the 2000-2001 school year.
B. Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
Petitioner did not dispute that the program provided by the District did not offer him educational benefit.
C. Conforms to his IEP
Petitioner argues that the program provided by the District for the 2001-2002 school year did not comport to STUDENT’S IEP because it failed to provide daily work and behavior reports, failed to properly implement STUDENT’S IEP when he transferred into middle school, failed to provide assistive technology in a timely manner, failed to provide mediation services called for in the IEP, and failed to provide STUDENT with the 1:1 aid.
a. Failing to provide daily work and behavior reports as required by his IEP
Petitioner argues that, as part of his April 3, 2001 IEP, he was to receive daily work and behavior reports. Petitioner contends that the District has failed to provide those work and behavior reports as called for in that IEP. During the 2000-2001 school year, MOTHER was to be provided with a daily communication log. (Petitioner’s Ex. 33.) Pursuant to the April 3, 2001 IEP, the daily logs were to be continued until September or October of 2001, at which time the inclusion facilitator would revisit the need for continuation of daily communication logs. (Petitioner’s Ex. 39.) However, there was no evidence that the District failed to provide the logs during the time he attended King in July and August of 2001. Although MOTHER testified that she did not receive logs from April of STUDENT’S fourth grade year to the middle of his fifth grade year, she made no reference to the District’s failure to provide logs in this time period. Moreover, as noted above, the communication log was a tool used to facilitate MOTHER’s involvement in STUDENT’S education. There was no evidence presented that MOTHER’s failure to receive those logs resulted in any significant impact on her involvement in STUDENT’S education, or her ability to communicate with the District. It was not in that nature of an actual service provided to STUDENT. Assuming, arguendo, that the District has failed to provide those logs, that failure would not deprive STUDENT of any aspect of his educational program. Therefore, the failure of the District to provide the work and behavior reports did not amount to a denial of FAPE.
b. Failing to transfer and properly implement STUDENT’S IEP when he transferred from elementary to middle school
Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly implement STUDENT’S IEP when he transitioned from Mayberry Elementary School to King Middle School in the July of 2001. Petitioner argues that this placement was not in the least restrictive environment. After attending Mayberry Elementary School for the fifth grade, STUDENT was to attend King Middle School for the sixth grade. While the District admits that STUDENT was improperly placed into a resource classroom for the first month he was attending King, it argues that that error was corrected as soon as it was discovered, and that there was no prejudice to STUDENT for the time he spent in a resource classroom.
It is undisputed that STUDENT’S instructional setting, pursuant to the April 3, 2001 IEP, was to be a general education classroom with inclusion support. (Petitioner’s Ex. 39.) When STUDENT entered King Middle School in July of 2001, the District placed him in a resource specialist program classroom for English. Ms. Masaki testified that STUDENT was only in the resource class for one period out of the day, and was in general education classes for the other 5 periods of the day. Ms. Mautz testified that on July 13, 2001, she received a call from MOTHER that STUDENT was not in a general education class. As soon as she learned that STUDENT was in the resource class, she informed administrators at King Middle School of STUDENT’S proper placement. Ms. Masaki testified that by July 24, 2001, STUDENT was in general education for 6 periods a day. He had spent approximately 3 to 4 weeks in the resource classroom. Moreover, STUDENT did not suffer any prejudice by the failure to place him in his proper placement. Ms. Mautz and Ms. Masaki both testified that STUDENT would receive more intensive services in the resource class than in his general education classroom. Ms. Ruvalcaba, STUDENT’S general education English teacher at King, testified that STUDENT would not have missed any new curriculum because the first four weeks of her class were spent reviewing material from fifth grade. Therefore, the failure of the District to properly place STUDENT did not amount to denial of FAPE.
c. Failing to Provided Assistive Technology in a Timely Manner
Petitioner contends that it took King Middle School approximately one month to provide the assistive technology called for in the April 3, 2001 IEP. It is undisputed that STUDENT’S assistive technology devices were available by the time he was taken out of the resource class and placed in Ms. Ruvalcaba’s general education English class. Ms. Ruvalcaba testified that those assistive technology devices were in her classroom and available for STUDENT to use. However, Petitioner contends that those devices were not available during the time that STUDENT spent in the resource classroom.
Petitioner has not provided any evidence to show how a delay of approximately 20 days for the provision of the assistive technology denied him a FAPE. Ms. Mautz testified that the resource class in which STUDENT was placed had a computer, and that the computer was available for him to use. While a classroom computer does not necessarily possess all of the specialized programs that were available to STUDENT through his IEP, the classroom computer would provide STUDENT with at least some of the benefits of the assistive technology that STUDENT required. Moreover, Ms. Ruvalcaba testified that when STUDENT was in her classroom, his assistive technology devices were available to him. Ms. Ruvalcaba also testified that during the time that STUDENT was without the assistive technology devices, the curriculum for sixth grade was geared towards a review of fifth grade material. STUDENT was not harmed, therefore, by not having full access to his assistive technology for 20 days. (Footnote 16) Thus, the failure of the District to provide complete assistive technology for 20 days does not amount to a denial of FAPE.
d. Failing to provide occupational therapy services pursuant to a mediation agreement
The Hearing Office’s jurisdiction for due process hearings arises when there is a dispute regarding the identification, assessment, educational placement or the provision of a free appropriate public education to their child. (Cal. Educ. Code §56501(a).) Nothing in state or federal law grants the Hearing Office jurisdiction to enforce mediation or settlement agreements.(Footnote 17) Therefore, the Hearing Officer declines to address this issue.
Notwithstanding the fact that the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to hear this issue, the evidence shows that MOTHER has not made STUDENT available for occupational therapy services. Since September 3, 2001, STUDENT was no longer attending King; he had already transferred to St. Francis. Lauren Wayne, the District’s occupational therapist, testified that on four occasions, between September 20, 2001 and February 12, 2002, she attempted to reach MOTHER by telephone regarding the scheduling of the OT services. On April 2, 2002, the District sent a letter reflecting that Ms. Wayne was available to provide the 11 hours of OT services required by the mediation agreement. (Petitioner’s Ex. 108.) As of the date of the due process hearing, Ms Wayne testified that Petitioner has not responded to her phone calls or letters.
e. Failure to provide a 1:1 aid as called for in his IEP
Petitioner argues that he was not provided the services of his 1:1 aide while he attended King Middle School. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was not receiving the services of his 1:1 aide. However, Ms. Masaki, the assistant principal at King Middle School, testified that she provided an aid for STUDENT when he entered King.(Footnote 18) Ms. Mautz testified that STUDENT had a 1:1 aide during July and August, the time he was at King. Ms. Ruvalcaba testified that STUDENT 1:1, Ms. Chavez, was available to STUDENT in her classroom. Thus, it is apparent from the evidence provided that STUDENT did receive the services of his 1:1 aide while he was at King.
F. In the Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner argues that STUDENT was improperly placed in a resource class when he transitioned into King Middle School. While Petitioner argues that STUDENT was inappropriately placed in a more restrictive setting when the District failed to implement his IEP, Petitioner does not argues that his educational placement as called for in his IEP – general education with inclusion support – was not in the least restrictive environment.
Issue No. 4: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: a. Assistive technology and counseling service provided in the 1999-2000 school year. b. Counseling services provided during the 2000-2001 school year. c. Private school tuition at St. Francis School in the 2001-2002 school year. d. Occupational therapy, Assistive technology, writing without Tears, Counseling services, childcare and uniform, materials and books for St. Francis in the 2001-2002 school year.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has filed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the District was to provide . (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(10)(C).) The Court in Burlington made a point of distinguishing the right of reimbursement from damages. Reimbursement merely requires the school district to belatedly pay expenses that it should have paid all along and would have borne in the first instance had it developed a proper IEP. (Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370-371.) To qualify for reimbursement the District must have first denied the student a FAPE, and the placement or service provided by the parent must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.)
In this instance, the District denied a FAPE to Petitioner in the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school year when it failed to conduct and then provide the assistive technology assessment in a timely manner. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for assistive technology and counseling services for 1999-2000 and 2000-2001. However, MOTHER testified that she did not provide any assistive technology or counseling during the 1999-2000 or 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, Petitioner has not procured services for STUDENT as a result of the District’s denial of FAPE. The claim for reimbursement for the 1999-2000 school year is denied.
All other claims for reimbursement are denied. The District provided Petitioner a FAPE in the 2001-2002 school year.
Issue No. 5: Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education in the form of assistive technology, counseling, and the Writing Without Tears program?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; See also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i).) Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K Gilhool and the Chester Upland Unified School District (3d Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.
Petitioner was denied a FAPE in the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years when the District failed to conduct an assessment for, and then provide, assistive technology devices in a timely manner. The evidence before the Hearing Officer shows that Petitioner was denied assistive technology for four months when the District failed to conduct their assessment in a timely manner, and then 120 days (or approximately another four months) when the District failed to provide the assistive technology devices. During this time, Petitioner was unable to access and fully progress in his educational program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT will require compensatory education to make up for the District’s denial of FAPE.
However, the amount of services STUDENT requires is harder to gauge. Petitioner has not provided any evidence of the amount of counseling, or of the type of assistive technology required to remedy the District’s denial of FAPE. Nor has Petitioner presented any evidence of how the Writing Without Tears program would make up for STUDENT lost educational opportunity. The record before the Hearing Officer is that STUDENT was able to make educational progress in his program. Each IEP indicates that he currently functioning at grade level. Ms. Mautz testified that she conducted an academic educational evaluation of Petitioner on April 25, 2001. (Respondent’s Exhibit 45.) Ms. Mautz’s testing indicates that STUDENT is achieving at or above grade level in reading, both in the area of decoding words and comprehension. STUDENT was average or above average in the area of written language. He has some difficulty in the area of spelling and punctuation, but that he was above average in his word usage. She indicated that STUDENT scored slightly below grade level with his writing samples. However, she indicated that his score of 90 was still in the average range, and part of his depressed score in this area was due to STUDENT complacency, which Ms. Mautz described as an inability to follow through and write detailed sentences. Moreover, the testimony of MOTHER was that STUDENT was making excellent progress at his private school placement without assistive technology devices. In sum, despite the failure of the District to conduct an assessment and then provide assistive technology in a timely manner in the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, Petitioner was able to progress in his educational program.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner does not require counseling or Writing Without Tears to compensate for the District’s denial of assistive technology devices. However, the STUDENT will require the continued use of his assistive technology as compensatory education. The IEP team will include school staff from St. Francis, and they will assess the amount of time, not to exceed eight months, that STUDENT would require for assistive technology based upon his current needs. The assistive technology will consist of the devices called for in the April 3, 2001 IEP.
ORDER
1. The District shall provide assistive technology as compensatory education. The District will convene a meeting of the IEP team, to include school staff from St. Francis, to determine the amount of services, not to exceed eight months, that STUDENT will would require, based upon his current needs for assistive technology.
2. The assistive technology will consist of the devices called for in the April 3, 2001 IEP.
3. All other of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided, except to the extent that it denied a FAPE in the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school year when it failed to conduct the assistive technology assessment and provide devices in a timely manner.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).
Date: December 18, 2002 Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
1. These issues are a restatement of the issue Petitioner presented for hearing, based upon the discussion of the issues held at the beginning of the hearing. In his closing brief, Petitioner attempted to argue additional violations by the District that resulted in STUDENT being denied a FAPE for these school years. However, these issues were not presented to the Hearing Officer or to the District on the first day of hearing and will not be decided in this Decision. 2. According to information provided by the District, the Hearing Office assigned case number SN01-00269 to that matter. 3. According to MOTHER, a girl on the playground was teasing STUDENT. When the yard aid intervened, STUDENT called her (the yard aid) a “bitch.” MOTHER stated that STUDENT was more upset with the girl than with yard aid. She also testified that nothing was ever mentioned to her about STUDENT’S prior use of profanity, and she disagrees with the District’s finding that the use of profanity was “habitual.”
4. The January 1999 behavior support plan indicated that STUDENT was having difficulties in dealing with name-calling from his peers, and with speaking to adults about his problems. The behavior support plan, in part, called for STUDENT to be given verbal encouragement regarding his issues within the classroom in order to improve his self-concept. (Petitioner’s Ex. 17.) The changes to the behavior support plan instituted in October 1999 IEP, included increasing his assistant time and more positive reinforcement in recognizing what STUDENT was doing right.
5. In her request for due process, MOTHER stated her issues for hearing as follows: “Services of the special education aide to transition to a regular classroom aide in order to continue to support his full inclusion program.”
6. The IEP team agreed to continue the following assistive technology devices: computer with keyboard, Earobics, Alphasmart keyboard, write:Outloud, and co:Write.
7. As with many of the special education time lines, these are subject to extension for intervening school vacations or by agreement of the parents.
8. The District argues that they were also tardy in actually providing the assistive technology devices after the IEP meeting on April 10, 2002. The District seems to indicate that, even if they had done the assessments on time, because they were late providing the assistive technology devices, STUDENT would only have use of them just prior to the end of the school year. This argument is specious. The District’s subsequent failure to provide the actual assistive technology service cannot serve as an excuse for the delay in actually assessing STUDENT for those services.
9. California Education Code §48900.5 provides, in pertinent part, “Suspension shall be imposed when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct.”
10. At hearing, Petitioner phrased this issue as STUDENT’S failure to meet his goals and objectives. However, a student’s failure to meet goals and objectives does not in itself constitute a denial of FAPE. In their closing brief, and in the testimony at hearing of Petitioner’s expert, Dr. Davidson, Petitioner argues that the goals and objectives were too vague to be implemented. This issue has been rephrased to reflect the issue Petitioner presented at hearing.
11. The language arts goal was as follows: Given list of 40 words with long, short vowels, vowel diagraphs and consonant blends, will read with 90% accuracy 4 of 5 times. The objectives for this goal were: a. write five sentences that shows spelling of words with short vowels and consonant blends with 90% accuracy, and b. writes five sentences that shows spelling of words with long vowels and vowel diagraphs with 90% accuracy. The pre-vocational education goal was as follows: Will write 5 sentences with spaces between the words and uniform letter formation. The objectives for this goal were: Writes 2 sentences with spaces between the words and uniform letter formation, and b. writes 4 sentences with spaces between the words and uniform letter formations. The counseling goal was as follows: To improve self-control and sustain attention for longer periods of time. The objectives for this goal were: a. STUDENT will improve in his ability to think before he acts, will learn to use relaxation techniques to curb impulsive reactions, b. will use techniques to relax and “stop\relax\think,” and c. will continue to reduce inclination to touch peers.
12. Petitioner phrased this issue as STUDENT’S failure to meet his goals and objectives. However, a student’s failure to meet goals and objectives does not in itself constitute a denial of FAPE. In their closing brief, and in the discussion of the issues at hearing, Petitioner’s counsel argued that when STUDENT failed to meet his goals and objectives, the District would reword the same goals and continue them for the next year. This issue has been rephrased to reflect the issue Petitioner presented at hearing.
13. The Hearing officer is also not persuaded by Petitioner’s argument the he did not meet his goals and objectives from the prior year. The April 10, 2000 IEP indicated that STUDENT met his goals and objectives from the prior year. The IEP indicated that STUDENT made good academic progress during the year. MOTHER, with her attorney and Ms. Perez present on her behalf, signed and consented to the IEP. It appears from a review of this IEP that STUDENT did meet his goals and objectives from the prior year, and was making progress in his educational setting.
14. The IEP indicates that STUDENT had been able to write a 2-3 paragraph essay with assistance. However, he was not able to do this on a daily basis. 15. There is no provision in State or federal law that requires that every goal and objective have an attendant present level of performance attached to it. It was clear from the record that STUDENT’S vocational education goal would address his deficits in written language, and that his present levels of performance in this area was addressed in language arts. 16. Additionally, both MOTHER and Ms. Perez testified that STUDENT was making dramatic improvement, growth, and progress in his program at St. Francis. MOTHER also testified that while STUDENT did have access to a computer at St. Francis, he was not receiving assistive technology. STUDENT attended St. Francis for its entire 2001-2002 school year. Considering the progress he has made for an entire school year without assistive technology, a delay of 20 days at the beginning of the District’s school year did not harm STUDENT.
17. The Hearing Officer notes that the proper forum to enforce these agreements is via the compliance complaint procedures with CDE. MOTHER filed with the CDE over the provision of these services, and has in fact obt ained a response from the CDE. (Petitioner’s Ex. 14.)
18. Ms. Masaki testified that she sent Ms. Chavez to be STUDENT’S aid.
