California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 4, 2003
Student v. Poway Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1698-02 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Poway Unified offered a ninth grader FAPE; the Hearing Officer ordered only that a revised occupational therapy goal be added.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Stay put orders were issued during the case, including a January 28, 2003 order for stay put at Westview High School under the August 28, 2001 and December 5, 2001 IEPs. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
A 14-year-old ninth grader, represented by his mother, filed for due process against Poway Unified School District in July 2002. He was eligible for special education under specific learning disability, with auditory and planning processing deficits affecting math, writing, organization and work completion. The parent challenged the September 18, 2002 IEP. It placed him in a resource specialist program (RSP) class at Westview High School for math, study skills and English, with counseling, occupational therapy (OT) consultation, vision therapy, a behavior support plan and assistive technology. She asked for a nonpublic school, a laptop, private counseling, reimbursement for YMCA services, and new OT and adaptive physical education assessments.
Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found no procedural violation that harmed the student or the parent's participation. The team did not need an OT or the private vision therapist at the meeting. Meeting notes did not have to be attached to the IEP. The District could hold the October 2002 meeting after repeated notices and calls the parent did not answer. Teacher testimony showed that reading was a strength, not a need. The behavior plan, organization supports, transition plan, assistive technology and RSP placement were appropriate. Two errors were minor and did not deny FAPE: counseling of 20 instead of 30 minutes, and a missed first week of services. One flaw was found: the IEP left out an OT goal the therapist had revised at the parent's request. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to add that goal. All other relief was denied, including YMCA reimbursement, because there was no evidence about those services.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's absence from an IEP meeting she had requested. Written notices, voicemails and a call when the meeting started met the participation rules. The decision also shows that a revised goal must actually appear in the IEP, and that reimbursement claims need evidence about the services provided.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1A. Did the District deny FAPE for 2002-2003 by failing to have an occupational therapist and the student's vision therapist present at the September 2002 IEP meeting?
The meeting did not focus on OT and OT needs had been addressed in February 2002; a contract vision therapist was available by phone and the team adopted the private vision report's findings, so no lost educational opportunity or harm to parent participation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1B. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to include all pages of the February 19, 2002 IEP meeting notes in the September 18, 2002 IEP?
No law requires meeting notes to be included in an IEP document, and the September team reviewed the February IEP and notes, so there was no procedural error.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1C. Did the District deny FAPE by proceeding with the October 2002 IEP meeting without the presence of the student's mother?
The parent requested the meeting and received two written notices and several voicemails, plus a call at the start of the meeting; the District met its duty to give her the chance to participate.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1D(i). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in behavior (including attendance)?
The behavior support plan and goals addressed work completion, attendance and resistance to supports in a positive way.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1D(ii). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in organization?
Computer access, the Alpha Smart, teacher notes, extended time, a choice of planners and an organization goal met the student's organization needs.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1D(iii). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in auditory processing?
A separate auditory processing goal was not needed; the supports and accommodations on the special factors page addressed the deficit.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 1D(iv). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in vocational and prevocational skills (including individual transition planning)?
The February 2002 individual transition plan reflected the student's interests in computers and independent living and was appropriate for 2002-2003.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1D(v). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in reading?
Teacher testimony and an informal reading inventory showed grade-level reading; reading was a strength, not a unique need.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 1D(vi). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in occupational therapy?
The September 2002 IEP was insufficient because it kept the original OT goal instead of the therapist's revised goal; the level of OT services was appropriate and YMCA reimbursement was denied for lack of evidence.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered
Issue 1D(vii). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in counseling services?
Providing 20 rather than 30 weekly minutes under an unsigned IEP was technically a violation but de minimis; the request for private counseling from the student's psychologist was denied.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 1D(viii). Did the District fail to offer transition services for the student's transition from eighth to ninth grade?
Failing to place the student in special education during the first week of high school had a de minimis effect and was not a denial of FAPE; a separate transition plan was not needed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1D(ix). Did the District fail to offer a program that met the student's needs in assistive technology services?
It was appropriate to address resistance to supports before writing assistive technology goals; school computer and Alpha Smart access were sufficient, and a laptop was not required.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1D (placement). Did the District fail to offer a placement that met the student's needs (parent sought a nonpublic school)?
An RSP placement for math, study skills and English, with general education for other subjects, met the student's needs in the least restrictive environment; nonpublic school placement was denied.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2 (OT). Should the student be assessed in the area of occupational therapy?
The January 2002 OT assessment used valid tools by a qualified therapist and accurately reflected the student's needs; no new OT assessment was required.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2 (APE). Should the student be assessed in the area of adaptive physical education?
There was no evidence that an APE assessment was needed; the student's needs were met with modifications in general physical education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- District shall include in the student's IEP the revised OT goal drafted by occupational therapist Patricia Webster (Pet.'s Exh. A-H). All other requests for relief denied, including nonpublic school placement, YMCA reimbursement, private counseling and reimbursement, and a laptop computer.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16
People named in the decision
- Colleen VanNordheim, resource specialist program teacher, Mesa Verde Middle School, Poway Unified School District
- Michael Giaime, resource specialist teacher, Westview High School, Poway Unified School District
- Terry Heck, assistant principal, Mesa Verde Middle School, Poway Unified School District
- Charlyn Earp, general education teacher (humanities core); reading leader, Mesa Verde Middle School, Poway Unified School District
- Emily Shieh, program specialist; District representative, Poway Unified School District
- Melanie Black, program specialist, Poway Unified School District
- Robin Robinson, area administrator, Poway Unified School District
- Linda Suokko, school counselor, Westview High School, Poway Unified School District
- Patricia Webster, occupational therapist (assessor), Children's Hospital and Health Center, San Diego
- Shelley Fuller, school psychologist, Poway Unified School District
- Kelli Marsaglia, school psychologist, Poway Unified School District
- JoAnn Murphy, executive director of special education, Poway Unified School District
- Theresa Kurtz, director of special education for middle and high school programs, Poway Unified School District
- Janet Barry-Ciapponi, director of special education programs, Poway Unified School District
- Dr. Donald Janiuk, private optometrist and vision therapist (independent assessor), Private, retained by parent
- Dr. Rothchild, contract vision therapist, Contracted by Poway Unified School District
- Dr. Barbara Bytomsky, contract optometrist providing vision therapy, Contracted by Poway Unified School District
- Dr. Charles Hogan, private treating psychologist, Private
- Excelsiar Academy, private school the student attended for one day
- Winston, private school the student previously attended
- YMCA, private provider of services parent sought reimbursement for
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on January 7, 21, 22, 23, and 24, 2003.
STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Poway Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Justin Shinnefield. Also present on behalf of the District on different days were District representative Emily Shieh; JoAnn Murphy, executive director of special education; Theresa Kurtz, director of special education for middle and high school programs; and Janet Barry-Ciapponi, director of special education programs.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Colleen VanNordheim, resource specialist program teacher for the District; Michael Giaime, resource specialist at Westview High School in the District; Terry Heck, assistant principal at Mesa Verde Middle School in the District; Charlyn Earp, teacher at Mesa Verde Middle School; Emily Shieh, program specialist for the District; Melanie Black, program specialist for the District; MOTHER; Robin Robinson, area administrator for the District; and Linda Suokko, counselor at Westview High School.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Patricia Webster, occupational therapist with Children’s Hospital and Health Center; Shelley Fuller, school psychologist for the District; and Kelli Marsaglia, school psychologist for the District.
ISSUES(Footnote 10
1. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year by:
A. Failing to have an occupational therapist and vision therapist present at the September 2002 IEP meeting; B. Failing to include all pages of the February 19, 2002 IEP meeting notes in the September 18, 2002 IEP; C. Proceeding with the October 2002 IEP meeting without the presence of STUDENT’s mother; D. Failing to offer a program, including the placement, that met STUDENT’s needs in the following areas:
i. behavior (including attendance);
ii. organization;
iii. auditory processing;
iv. vocational and prevocational skills (including individual transition planning); v. reading;
vi. occupational therapy;
vii. counseling services;
viii. transition services for Petitioner’s transition from eighth to ninth grade; and ix. assistive technology services
2. Should STUDENT be assessed in the areas of occupational therapy and adaptive physical education?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner makes a number of procedural and substantive allegations that he believes amounted to a denial of a FAPE. Procedurally, Petitioner contends that the District should have had an occupational therapist at the September 2002 individualized education program (IEP) meeting to discuss alleged discrepancies in the occupational therapist’s report, and the District should have invited his vision therapist, Dr. Janiuk, who conducted an optometric assessment of him. Additionally, Petitioner argues that pages from the February 2002 IEP meeting notes should have been included in the September 2002 IEP document so that the IEP team could have considered the assessment data contained in those pages. And lastly, Petitioner contends that the District proceeded with the October 2002 IEP meeting without his parent.
Substantively, Petitioner contends that the September 2002 IEP did not appropriately address his needs in the areas of behavior and attendance; organization, including use of a computer and teacher outlines; auditory processing, including use of a methodology such as Fast ForWord, Lindamood Bell or Wilson; vocational and prevocational skills, including the development of an appropriate individual transition plan; reading and reading comprehension; and occupational therapy (OT) to address the development of his upper body strength to counteract his fatigue. Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide appropriate counseling services and failed to properly transition him from eighth to ninth grade, resulting in his not receiving any special education services during the first days of the 2002-2003 school year. Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District should have provided him a laptop computer and included goals and objectives regarding computer use in his IEP. With respect to placement, Petitioner argues that he should be placed in a nonpublic school. However, he also argues that the offered placement in the resource specialist program (RSP) would be appropriate if all of his academic subjects were addressed in that class and if he was also provided with significant accommodations and modifications. Regarding new assessments, Petitioner argues that new adaptive physical education (APE) and OT assessments are necessary in order to alleviate discrepancies that were allegedly found between the two reports conducted by the District. According to Petitioner, the occupational therapist never assessed him in a crowded area and the District never determined whether his behavior was linked to any sensory integration issues.
The District contends that it has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year through its offer of placement reflected in the IEP dated September 18, 2002. Specifically, the District argues that the appropriate individuals were present at the September 2002 IEP meeting and the IEP team drafted goals and objectives that were appropriate for Petitioner. Moreover, the District argues that it was appropriate to go forward with the October 2002 IEP meeting given that the parent has been given numerous opportunities to participate in the IEP process, but she continually refuses to access those opportunities only to later claim alleged procedural violations. Additionally, the District argues that it conducted appropriate assessments and that the September 2002 IEP was based on appropriate information, which led to an appropriate program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.
Petitioner is seeking specific remedies with respect to the placement, counseling and occupational therapy issues. Petitioner has requested that the District be ordered to place him in a nonpublic school. Additionally, Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to reimburse his parent for the services he receives at the YMCA. Petitioner is also requesting that the District provide him one hour of counseling each week from his treating psychologist, Charles Hogan, and reimburse his parent for the sessions that he has had with Dr. Hogan since the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. And finally, Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to provide him with a laptop computer as appropriate assistive technology.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
This case was filed on July 22, 2002. There have been numerous motions and orders issued, and hearing officers have appeared on four different occasions before the current Hearing Officer was assigned to this matter and the case proceeded to hearing. On each of the prior occasions, there were detailed discussions regarding the issues to be addressed at hearing, and an order was issued on each occasion memorializing the issues to be heard. Additionally, on each of these occasions, the presiding hearing officer put the matter over for later determination pursuant to a motion to continue or an off calendar stipulation.
Since the filing of the hearing, three IEP meetings have been held to date: September 18, 2002, October 31, 2002, and January 17, 2003. Of these, Petitioner’s mother attended only the September 18, 2002 IEP meeting, but stayed approximately seven minutes. The parent has not signed any of these IEPs. Additionally, two stay put orders have been issued in this matter, each denying Petitioner’s specific request for a stay put placement. The most recent stay put order dated January 28, 2003, required that the District provide Petitioner with a stay put placement at Westview High School in conformity with his last agreed-upon and implement IEPs dated August 28, 2001, and December 5, 2001. The stay put order required that STUDENT be placed in the resource specialist program to address math, study skills, and writing. The IEP at issue in this case is the IEP dated February 2002, as amended on September 18, 2002.(Footnote 2)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who is a resident of the Poway Unified School District. He currently attends ninth grade through home instruction (not by reason of any IEP), although he attended classes at Westview High School (Westview) in the District very briefly in September 2002.(Footnote 3)
STUDENT has been found eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability due to a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in math and written language, with auditory processing and planning processing deficits. According to STUDENT’s IEPs, the areas of educational deficits that need to be addressed in goals and objectives include organization, math, writing, and work completion.
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended eighth grade at Mesa Verde Middle School (Mesa Verde) in the District. However, by his parent’s decision, he was home schooled for the latter part of his eighth-grade year. While at Mesa Verde, STUDENT was placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) and received designated instruction and services in counseling and OT consultations. STUDENT’s progress in school was inconsistent due to excessive absences, incomplete assignments, and what the District believed was inadequate effort but what STUDENT’s parent believed was lack of an appropriate program. Additionally, STUDENT was resistant to the modifications and accommodations offered in his IEP and he was not receptive to attending counseling sessions. As of February 2002, due to numerous absences and his incomplete work, STUDENT was at risk for failing the second quarter. However, according to STUDENT’s teachers, there was evidence of STUDENT benefiting and producing good quality work when he actively participated in the general education environment. STUDENT attended school at Mesa Verde until May 14, 2002, when his mother removed him from school for approximately six weeks because he had become stressed about his class schedule. MOTHER requested that the District allow STUDENT to be enrolled in the off-campus home instruction program; however, the District never approved the request. MOTHER filed for a due process hearing in July 2002.
Prior to the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, MOTHER contacted Westview to obtain registration information for STUDENT’s ninth-grade year. Westview is a new facility and the 2002-2003 school year is its first year of operation. According to MOTHER, she subsequently registered STUDENT at Westview and obtained his books. STUDENT was very excited about attending high school and started attending Westview on the first day of the 2002-2003 school year; however, he was not immediately enrolled in any special education program. MOTHER testified that STUDENT told her that he could not keep up with the pace of the classes in which he was enrolled. MOTHER contacted the District to inform administrators that STUDENT was not receiving special education services, and program specialist Emily Shieh responded to her by letter stating that STUDENT should have been in special education for thirty-five percent of his school day. MOTHER then pulled STUDENT out of school because she believed STUDENT suffered from suicidal ideation. MOTHER called Dr. Hogan, STUDENT’s treating psychologist; however, he was not available to see STUDENT until October 2002.
An IEP meeting was held on September 18, 2002, to review STUDENT’s then-present placement, his IEP, and assessments. The IEP team also discussed the issue of STUDENT’s suicidal ideation that had been raised by MOTHER. Although MOTHER attended the IEP meeting, she left approximately seven minutes after her late arrival because she believed she was not allowed to question one of the teachers who was present at the meeting. MOTHER did not sign the IEP.
According to MOTHER, she wanted STUDENT to return to school, so an informal meeting was held at the school the next day on September 19, 2002, with STUDENT, his mother, Robin Robinson, Linda Sukko, and Kelli Marsaglia in order to understand STUDENT’s reactions to the events that led to his then-recent suicidal ideation. STUDENT reluctantly returned to school at Westview on September 23, 2002; however, he became upset after attending his first class, which was a special day math class. STUDENT called his mother from school, crying, because he was upset about being placed in a special day class (SDC). MOTHER then removed him from school and requested that STUDENT be placed on home instruction. The District indicated that Excelsiar Academy might be a good placement for STUDENT and he attended that school for one day. According to MOTHER, STUDENT told her that the school was too noisy and that he did not want to return. Therefore, MOTHER kept STUDENT at home and did not return him to Excelsiar Academy or to Westview.
An IEP team meeting convened again on October 31, 2002, to address MOTHER’s request for a change in placement from Westview to an off-campus study placement. MOTHER was not present at the meeting despite three attempts to contact her, including a call made to the home at the beginning of the meeting. Upon review of STUDENT’s past progress under previous IEPs, the IEP team determined that an independent study program would not be an appropriate placement to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs and provide him educational benefit.
Unable to resolve their disputes, this case went to hearing on January 7, 2003, over the above-listed issues.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000.) The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(a)(18).)
ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(25).) The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA >97). The Court determined that a student=s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a Abasic floor of opportunity@ that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District=s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District=s program reflected STUDENT=s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parent preferred another program and even if the parent=s preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT=s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. '' 1412(a)(5)(A) and 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code ' 56031.) .) The IDEA also requires that a student=s educational program be designed to provide the student access to the general curriculum, including extracurricular and nonacademic activities, and prepare the student for movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, employment, and independent living. (20 U.S.C. ''1414(d)(1)(A)(iii) and 1401(30).)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s proposed program must have met the following six requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)
Procedural Appropriateness
The Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al., v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 201 (1982), recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives a free appropriate public education and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student=s individualized educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483.) Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. However, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of FAPE. (Id. at 1484.)
Petitioner asserts several procedural violations, each of which will be addressed separately below.
1.A. Failing to have an occupational therapist and STUDENT’s vision therapist present at the September 2002 IEP meeting
Occupational therapist
Petitioner contends that the District failed to have an occupational therapist present at the September 2002 IEP meeting. The District argues that the purpose of the September 2002 IEP team meeting was to review the parent’s concerns about STUDENT’s social emotional status and to review an independent vision therapy evaluation, not to specifically address OT concerns. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 7.) Additionally, the District contends that Petitioner had an appropriate level of OT services for the time period in question and that the testimony of Patricia Webster confirmed this.
Occupational therapist Patricia Webster conducted an OT evaluation of STUDENT in January 2002. Although she did not attend any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings, Ms. Webster testified that she met with MOTHER before the February 2002 IEP meeting, spoke with STUDENT’s service coordinator before the February 2002 meeting, and was available by telephone and beeper. Additionally, a few months after the February 19, 2002 IEP meeting, she and JoAnn Murphy from the District met with MOTHER to review her assessment report, recommendations, and recommended OT goals. According to Ms. Webster, MOTHER asked that the OT goal be revised and in response, by letter dated July 5, 2002, Ms. Webster forwarded to MOTHER the testing protocols used in her evaluation of STUDENT, along with a revision of the OT goals. (Pet.’s Exh. A-H.) Although her recommendations did not change, Ms. Webster testified that she revised the wording of the OT goals so that the area of need indicated muscle strength and posture instead of sensory processing. According to Ms. Webster, the goal remained essentially the same and the activity involved did not substantially change because muscle strength and posture are just one aspect of sensory processing. Ms. Webster testified that she believed STUDENT was offered the necessary level of OT services that he required and that he did not require any additional services other than what was listed on the February 2002 IEP in order to address his goals.(Footnote 4)
Petitioner does not offer any convincing evidence that not having an occupational therapist at the September 2002 IEP meeting caused him to lose educational opportunity or seriously infringed on his parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The evidence indicated that the OT services offered in the IEP were the appropriate amount and level necessary to address his muscle strength and posture, a fact that Petitioner did not dispute. The language of the goal was changed so that the parent could better understand its purpose; however, the substance of the goal remained the same. Additionally, the focus of the September 2002 IEP meeting was to review a recent vision assessment and discuss STUDENT’s placement and MOTHER’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s emotional state and suicidal ideation. (Testimonies of E. Shieh, K. Marsaglia, R. Robinson, and C. VanNordheim.) Discussions regarding OT had already taken place at the February 2002 IEP and there was no indication that information about STUDENT’s OT needs required additional input from an occupational therapist at the September 2002 IEP meeting. (Dist.’s Exh. 14, pg. 12.)
For all of the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that not having an occupational therapist at the September 2002 IEP meeting did not cause him to lose educational opportunity, nor did it infringe upon the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP meeting.
Vision therapist
Dr. Donald Janiuk, a private optometrist and vision therapist hired by the parent, performed a developmental visual assessment of STUDENT to determine if visual processing or visual efficiency problems were contributing to STUDENT’s reading difficulties as identified by MOTHER. From his assessment, Dr. Janiuk produced a written report dated August 6, 2002. (Pet.’s Exh. Z-7.) Petitioner contends that the District did not address Dr. Janiuk’s vision assessment report entirely, if at all, at the September 2002 IEP meeting. According to Petitioner, significant data regarding Dr. Janiuk’s findings were left out of the September 2002 IEP discussion. (Pet.’s closing brief, pg. 2.)
The District contends that a qualified individual reviewed Dr. Janiuk’s assessment and based on that assessment, goals and objectives were written. The District accepted the service recommendations in Dr. Janiuk’s report and, therefore, the District believes that it was unnecessary for Dr. Janiuk to be present at the September 2002 IEP meeting. (Dist.’s closing brief, pg. 18.)
Education Code Section 56341(b)(5) requires that IEP program team include an individual who conducted an assessment of the student or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the student, and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. Emily Shieh testified that Dr. Rothchild, a vision therapist on contract with the District, was provided a copy of Dr. Janiuk’s report and was available at the September 2002 IEP meeting via telephone should the IEP team have any questions. Additionally, optometrist Dr. Barbara Bytomsky, who is contracted by the District to provide vision therapy services, had an opportunity to review the proposed vision therapy goals and objectives and indicated that they were appropriate to address STUDENT’s skill levels and that there was no need for any additional goals. (Testimony of E. Shieh.) Michael Giaime testified that Ms. Shieh read Dr. Janiuk’s entire report to the IEP team and felt satisfied that Dr. Rothchild could have interpreted any visual therapy questions that the IEP team members may have had. The IEP team ultimately agreed with Dr. Janiuk’s findings, the vision therapy goals, and the level of service recommended therein. (Dist.’s Exh. 20.)
The Hearing Officer is convinced that not having Dr. Janiuk present at the September 2002 IEP meeting did not prevent the IEP team from discussing his report and findings. Furthermore, the District ultimately agreed to implement his recommended treatment plan and reimburse the parent for the cost of the independent evaluation. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pgs. 13-15.) Neither party disputes the appropriateness of Dr. Janiuk’s report and the recommendations contained therein. Therefore, Dr. Janiuk’s absence from the September 2002 IEP meeting did not cause STUDENT to lose educational opportunity or infringe upon the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP meeting.
1.B. Failing to include all pages of the February 19, 2002 IEP meeting notes in the September 18, 2002 IEP
Petitioner contends that the District did not include meeting notes from the February 19, 2002 IEP in the IEP dated September 18, 2002. According to Petitioner, the District copied certain portions of the February 2002 IEP and pasted the same performance levels information into the September 2002 IEP, without stating recent optometric results in the present levels section. (Pet.’s closing brief, pg. 1.) Petitioner argues that the February 2002 meeting notes include relevant information about STUDENT’s progress and needs and the District attempted to deceive him and “hide meeting notes that showed negative remarks from District employees, and statements that STUDENT was not progressing.” (Pet.’s closing brief, pg. 1.)
The District argues that neither federal nor State law requires it to include meeting notes in an IEP. Moreover, District witnesses testified that the February 2002 IEP was carefully reviewed and discussed by the September 2002 IEP team. (Testimonies of E. Shieh, M. Giaime, and C. VanNordheim.)
District witnesses testified that during the September 2002 IEP meeting, the IEP team, in effect, generated an IEP for the current school year because MOTHER had never signed the February 2002 IEP. Thus, the IEP notes of the September 2002 IEP represent what occurred at that particular IEP meeting and do not necessarily require attachment of a previous meeting’s notes. (Testimonies of E. Shieh and C. VanNordheim.) All of the members of the September 2002 IEP team had been provided a copy of the February 2002 IEP. In addition, Ms. VanNordheim was present at both the February and September 2002 IEP meetings and was able to provide to the IEP team members relevant information about STUDENT’s needs and progress during his eighth-grade year. (Testimonies of C. VanNordheim and M. Giaime.) Moreover, the IEP team included information from the February 2002 IEP because that document contained information that they believed was still current, the most up-to-date, and ongoing. (Testimony of M. Giaime.)
District witnesses convincingly testified that the September 2002 IEP team reviewed the February 2002 IEP, including the meeting notes, and had the benefit of discussing STUDENT’s progress and needs with Ms. VanNordheim, who was familiar with STUDENT’s work during his eighth-grade year. (See Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 15.) There was no convincing evidence that the September 2002 IEP team members neglected to consider any relevant information that may have been contained in the February 2002 IEP meeting notes. The Hearing Officer concludes that there was no procedural error because there is no legal requirement that the meeting notes be included in an IEP document. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Ca. Educ. Code § 56345.) Therefore, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE in this respect.
1.C. Proceeding with the October 2002 IEP meeting without the presence of STUDENT’s mother
On October 31, 2002, an IEP team convened to address the request of STUDENT’s parent to change STUDENT’s placement to an off-campus study placement. (See Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 18.) Neither of STUDENT’s parents was present at the meeting. Petitioner contends that the IEP team meeting should not have convened without his parent present.
The District argues that it provided MOTHER with written notification of the IEP meeting, which was convened at the parent’s request. Additionally, the District argues that MOTHER has a history of not attending meetings and later claiming that the District has not offered an appropriate program because she was not in attendance. (Dist’.s Exh. 3.) According to the District, although afforded the opportunity to participate, the parent chose not to avail herself of that opportunity.
State law requires that a district ensure that one or both of the parents of the student are present at each IEP meeting or are otherwise afforded the opportunity to participate. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a).) If neither parent can attend the meeting, the district must use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f).) However, a district can hold an IEP meeting without a parent in attendance if the district is unable to convince the parent that he or she should attend. In that event, the district is required to maintain a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time and place. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).)
In response to MOTHER’s request to enroll STUDENT in an off-campus independent study program, two meeting notices informing the parents that an IEP meeting would be held on October 31, 2002, were forwarded to MOTHER on October 15, 2002, and October 17, 2002. (Pet.’s Exhs. A-E and B-K.)(Footnote 5) The second notice was sent because the first notice inadvertently did not include the meeting time. Additionally, a couple of days before the meeting, Ms. Shieh left MOTHER a voicemail reminding her of the date, time, and place of the scheduled meeting. (Testimony of E. Shieh.) Ms. Shieh testified that MOTHER had communicated to her that she did not intend to participate in developing the IEP. Mr. Giaime also testified that approximately one week before the October 31, 2002 IEP meeting, he left a message for the parent, indicating the time and place of the meeting.
On October 31, 2002, the IEP team convened and waited ten minutes after the start time for the parents to arrive. When the parents did not arrive, Ms. Shieh telephoned the parent and left a voicemail asking MOTHER to call her back within ten minutes. When the IEP team did not hear back from MOTHER, they proceeded with the IEP meeting without the parent. (Testimony of E. Shieh.) According to Ms. Shieh, in evaluating MOTHER’s request to enroll STUDENT in the off-campus independent study (OCIS) program, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses and determined that OCIS would not be appropriate for him. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pgs. 18-20.) Ms. Shieh testified that she sent the October 31, 2002 IEP document to the parent within one or two days after the meeting and that MOTHER later complained because the District had held the meeting without her. (Pet.’s Exh. B-J.) In that letter dated November 5, 2002, Ms. Shieh strongly encouraged MOTHER’s assistance in scheduling and attending another IEP meeting.
The District notified the parents on numerous occasions about the meeting, which the parent requested in the first place. (Testimonies of M. Giaime and E. Shieh.) Moreover, there was evidence that the District attempted to contact the parents before the start of the October 31, 2002 IEP meeting when they did not appear. The District also attempted to schedule another IEP meeting after October 31, 2002, to address the parent’s concerns. (Pet.’s Exh. B-J.) However, the mother also refused to attend the noticed meeting subsequently held on January 17, 2003. (Pet.’s Exh. C-G.)
The Hearing Officer finds that by proceeding with the IEP meeting without the parents, the District did not infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds here that the District fulfilled the legal requirement of providing the opportunity for parental participation in the IEP process.(Footnote 6)
Substantive Appropriateness
As previously mentioned, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s program must meet the following four requirements in order to constitute a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP, and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
What are STUDENT’s unique needs?
To determine the appropriateness of the District’s offered program and services, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s needs as of the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.
At the time of the September 18, 2002 IEP meeting, it was undisputed that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services based on his identified specific learning disability that was caused by his auditory processing and planning processing delays. As a result of his disability, the parties agreed that he had deficits in the academic areas of math, study, skills, and English. To address these deficits, the parties agreed that STUDENT requires a setting smaller than the regular education class where the instructor utilizes a multi-sensory teaching approach and can provide some one-on-one instruction in order to engage him. The parties also do not dispute that STUDENT has educational needs in the areas of organization, work completion, and attendance. (Dist.’s Exh. 20.)
STUDENT also requires assistance with dealing with some of the behavioral issues that he has with respect to inattention, socialization, and problem solving. (Dist.’s Exh. 21.) STUDENT requires various assistive technology devices, supports, and program modifications in order to meet his goals and objectives related to the areas above. However, STUDENT also resists new supports and accommodations and therefore requires assistance in overcoming his resistance. Finally, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT needs assistance with improving his motor control, posture and upper body strength, visual memory skills, and copying abilities. (Dist.’s Exh. 9; Pet.’s Exh. Z-17.)
The parties differ, however, as to whether STUDENT has needs in the area of reading. Petitioner argues that the District did not have an accurate understanding of his reading needs at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year because it copied the present levels information from his February 2002 IEP into the September 2002 IEP. MOTHER testified that, on the basis of the results of Dr. Janiuk’s vision assessment, she believed that STUDENT reads at the fourth-grade level and, in addition, that she had not seen STUDENT read a book in four years and his reading log was blank. (Pet.’s Exh. B-F.) Petitioner argues that the District has no evidence that he was progressing and reading at grade level because there was no assessment data used to determine his ability. According to Petitioner, his level of performance in reading had not been updated and therefore, Dr. Janiuk’s report provides an appropriate assessment of his reading ability.(Footnote 7)
However, there was no direct testimony from Dr. Janiuk or any other expert witness about the findings made in his report and no evidence about how that report should be interpreted. For instance, there was no evidence about whether, as a result of Dr. Janiuk’s findings, STUDENT’s reading skills should be addressed directly, rather than addressing his visual deficits, as suggested in his report. Given that MOTHER has no expertise in the interpretation of vision therapy assessments and there was no direct testimony from the report’s author or any other expert, MOTHER’s statements were not persuasive.
STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. VanNordheim and Ms. Earp, however, testified that in eighth grade, STUDENT’s reading comprehension was at grade level.(Footnote 8) STUDENT could read and summarize newspaper articles independently and, according to testing conducted in 2000, reading was an area of strength for him. (Dist.’s Exh. 5, pgs. 2-3.) Charlyn Earp testified persuasively that after witnessing STUDENT read and discussing completed reading assignments with him, she was convinced that STUDENT understood what he was reading and could read at grade level.(Footnote 9) In addition, in social studies class, STUDENT would read the text and raise his hand to ask questions and was able to discuss articles he had read with Ms. VanNordheim. (Testimony of C. VanNordheim.) Mr. Giaime testified that he believed Ms. VanNordheim’s informal testing was a better representation than Dr. Janiuk’s testing of what STUDENT could do in the classroom because she used core curriculum material and also based her assessment on STUDENT’s performance.(Footnote 10)
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers: STUDENT did not have unique needs in the area of reading.
In summary, to address his academic needs in the areas of math, study skills, and English, STUDENT requires a small class, including periodic one-on-one assistance to get him engaged in class. He also needs program modifications, services, and supports that will address his inconsistent work completion, his resistance to offered supports and services, his inconsistent attendance, organization, and behavioral issues. The evidence did not support Petitioner’s contention that he has a unique need in the area of reading.
Was the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated September 18, 2002, designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
Considering STUDENT’s unique needs as identified above, the Hearing Officer must next determine whether the services and placement offered by the District in its IEP dated September 18, 2002, would have appropriately addressed those needs. The parties’ real dispute lies in the types of supports and services STUDENT requires to address his needs and in the specific learning environment STUDENT requires to implement his goals and objectives.
The September 18, 2002 IEP offer from the District provided that STUDENT would spend 39 percent of his time outside the general education classroom for special education services. The IEP provided for STUDENT’s placement in the resource specialist program (RSP) for math, study skills, and English. Goals and objectives were written to address his needs in the areas of visual memory skills, copying abilities, organization, math, writing, work completion, occupational therapy, attendance, problem solving, and social skills. Additionally, STUDENT would receive designated instruction and services in counseling one time each week for 20 minutes; occupational therapy consultations, and 36 sessions of vision therapy, 45 minutes each. Supplemental aids and services, including assistive technology, to be provided included access to teachers’ notes (copy), extended time on written assignments, essays, and projects, access to a computer at school, and use of an Alpha Smart word processor when in general education. And finally, a behavior support plan was drafted to address his resistance to services and supports, work completion, and excessive absences. (Dist.’s Exh. 20.)
Petitioner argues that the District’s offered IEP did not appropriately address his needs in the areas of behavior (including attendance), organization, auditory processing, vocational and prevocational (including individual transition planning), reading, occupational therapy, counseling, and transition services from eighth to ninth grade. Petitioner also contends that he should be placed in a nonpublic school. However, he also contends that he should be placed in the RSP for all of his academics and provided with significant accommodations and modifications.
The District contends that its offer contained in the IEP dated September 18, 2002, appropriately addresses all the areas of concerns identified by Petitioner and constitutes a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer first considers the appropriateness of the September 18, 2002 IEP with respect to the areas Petitioner contends were not appropriately addressed.
1.D. Failing to offer a program, including the placement, that met STUDENT’s needs in the following areas:
i. Behavior (including attendance)
Petitioner contends that the behavior plan drafted by the District did not address his unique needs. Moreover, Petitioner argues that he was placed in the juvenile justice system when the District started truancy proceedings, despite the fact that the District was responsible for his excessive absences and changes in his placement. MOTHER testified that the District considered STUDENT’s disability to be a form of laziness and, as a result, never used positive interventions with the behavior support plan.(Footnote 11) Petitioner argues that his IEP should be amended to include goals and objectives in the area of behavior and attendance.
The District argues that it developed a behavior support plan to address STUDENT’s excessive absences and his refusal to utilize the special education supports and services offered. Ms. VanNordheim testified that the IEP team wanted STUDENT to accept his learning disability so that he could then accept the supports that they offered to address his needs. The District members of the IEP team believed that STUDENT’s understanding of his disability would allow his learning to be more manageable.
The IEP dated September 18, 2002, included a behavior support plan designed to address STUDENT’s refusal of supports and services, his work completion, and his excessive absences. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 9.) In addition, goals and objectives were developed to help bolster his 5 to 10 percent work completion rate and to decrease his number of absences from school. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pgs. 5 & 6.) To implement those goals and objectives, the plan called for academic tasks to be broken down into small segments and access provided to assistive technology supports. The plan also provided that staff would supportively interact with STUDENT to encourage him to use the IEP supports and attend school. As an incentive, if STUDENT utilized the supports and attended school, he would earn free time, which could be spent as STUDENT chose (e.g., using the computer or doing homework). The IEP team also planned to remind STUDENT of the reasons behind his need for the supports, and the case manager would contact the parent on a weekly basis to provide updates. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 9.)
The Hearing Officer finds the goals and related objectives, in conjunction with the behavior support plan, appropriately addressed STUDENT’s more specific needs in the areas of task completion, attendance, and resistance to supports and services, and did so in a positive manner. The plan included strategies designed to teach STUDENT about his learning differences and why the supports are necessary for his educational success. Additionally, the positive reinforcements by school staff and the parents, the supports, and the incentives to use the supports, were all reasonably calculated to work together to help alleviate the behavior that impeded his learning.
ii. Organization
MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s assignments should be scanned into the computer and he should be provided with class outlines and assistive technology for use with email. MOTHER also believed that the IEP should have included tools that focused on STUDENT’s strengths in computers and stated that the binder reminders did not work.
Pursuant to the IEP dated September 18, 2002, STUDENT would have been provided with access to a computer in class and the Alpha Smart word processor to type in his notes and spelling tests, and a copy of the teacher’s notes to assist him with organization and writing. Additionally, STUDENT had already been trained on how to use email to send himself his homework assignments and reminders. (Testimony of C. VanNordheim.) The IEP also provided that STUDENT be given extra time to complete assignments and the IEP did not require that he use binder reminders specifically. Rather, STUDENT would be given the choice of three different organizational planners as selected by STUDENT. (Testimony of M. Black.) According to program specialist Melanie Black, the IEP team believed that if STUDENT had more power in choosing supports that he would use, he would be more inclined to use them. So, with STUDENT’s input, the IEP team intended to try different types of organizational tools. (Testimony of M. Giaime.)
Additionally, the IEP dated September 18, 2002, included the following annual goal:
Given teacher selected materials and monitoring STUDENT will try 3 different organizational planners and choose 1 that he will utilize on 4/5 days to record assignments as seen by a completed planner.
The two objectives related to the written expression goal were as follows:
By 11/02, STUDENT will do annual goal with 60% homework completion. By 2/03, STUDENT will record assignments and use the record as a reference to complete 80% of his homework assignments.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP included appropriate supports and assistive technology tools that focused on STUDENT’s strengths in computers. Additionally, the IEP also included an organization goal and objectives that were designed to address STUDENT’s needs with respect to completing his assignments and staying organized. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP dated September 18, 2002, was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of organization iii. Auditory processing
MOTHER argued that STUDENT required specific goals related to his auditory processing deficits, but she did not specify what type of goals she believed he should have. MOTHER stated only that the District should use the Lindamood Bell program for word memory, number memory, and sentence memory, but she did not provide any evidence to support this claim.
Several District witnesses testified that Petitioner’s auditory processing deficits were addressed through accommodations and modifications outlined in the IEP and that no goal for auditory processing was necessary. (Testimony of C. VanNordheim, S. Fuller, and M. Black.) Those accommodations and modifications included access to the computer and the Alpha Smart for note-taking and writing assignments, teachers’ notes, and extended time on tests. School psychologist Shelley Fuller credibly testified that goals are not necessarily written for auditory processing deficits, but, instead, supports are usually put into place to help the student function with the innate deficit. In STUDENT’s case, Ms. Fuller believed that the supports identified on the special factors page of the IEP would accommodate his auditory processing needs.
The Hearing Officer concludes that a specific auditory processing goal was not necessary. Rather, STUDENT required specific supports and accommodations to address the difficulties caused by his auditory processing deficits, which the District appropriately offered on the special factors page of the IEP. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 2.)
iv. Vocational and prevocational skills (including individual transition planning)
MOTHER argued that the IEP should have included goals that she previously proposed, which included utilizing STUDENT’s strength in keyboarding and computers.
The September 2002 IEP has attached to it an individual transition plan (ITP) dated February 2002. Ms. VanNordheim testified that she conducted STUDENT’s ITP interview and determined that STUDENT wanted to live in an apartment with friends after graduating high school and that he had an expressed interest in the computer field. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pgs. 10-11.) On the basis of identified interests, the IEP team decided to draft a goal regarding the residential market so that STUDENT could understand the realities of being out on his own and finding a place of his own to live. (Testimony of C. VanNordheim.) The IEP team also wanted STUDENT to have community experiences so that he could work on socialization issues, so a goal was drafted to address that need. With respect to employment, because STUDENT expressed interest in working with computers, a goal was drafted so that he would use the computer and Internet to determine if certain computer schools were located in his general living area. According to Ms. VanNordheim and Mr. Giaime, the IEP team believed that the ITP was satisfactory.
Beginning at the student’s age fourteen, and updated annually, a student=s IEP must contain a statement of the transition service needs of the student. And beginning at age sixteen or younger and annually thereafter, the IEP must contain a statement of needed transition services, including whenever appropriate, a statement of interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages. (20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345.1(a), (b).) The IDEA also requires that a school district provide transition services to special education students based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(B).)
A review of the ITP shows that the IEP team clearly identified STUDENT=s career and educational goals. The evidence establishes that the ITP clearly took into account STUDENT’s preferences and interests in attending college full time, studying to become a computer technician, and becoming fully independent. STUDENT could have used his keyboarding skills when conducting research on the Internet about his interests in working in the computer industry. Consequently, the ITP dated February 19, 2002, that was attached to the September 2002 IEP was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s vocational/prevocational and ITP needs for the 2002-2003 school year.
v. Reading
As discussed above in the section identifying STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not have a unique need in the area of reading and the evidence demonstrated that reading was actually an area of strength for him. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not need to develop goals and objectives in reading or provide special education instruction to specifically address this area.
vi. Occupational therapy (OT)
Petitioner argues that his IEP should address development of his upper body strength, which is necessary to counteract his fatigue. The District believes that the IEP goals and objectives and services were appropriate for Petitioner. This issue arises because, in response to MOTHER’s misunderstanding of the original goal in the February 2002 IEP and what skills it was intended to address, the occupational therapist reworded the goal but failed to include the revised goal in any subsequent IEP.
STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP includes one OT goal related to STUDENT’s sensory processing needs. According to the IEP, STUDENT demonstrates poor posture, which affects his handwriting legibility. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 7.) The goal states:
Within one year, STUDENT will demonstrate daily independent use [of] at least 2 classroom appropriate exercises or activities that increase his arousal level, improve his posture and improve his attention to tasks such as chair push ups,… arm exercises, stretching & appropriate fidget toys.
Two related objectives were also drafted to assist him in attaining the goal.
A few months after the February 2002 IEP meeting, occupational therapist Patricia Webster met with MOTHER and the District’s special education director Joann Murphy to review her OT report, recommendation, and goals, and at that time, MOTHER asked for a revision of the OT goal. (Testimony of P. Webster.) Ms. Webster testified that STUDENT’s area of need was changed to muscle strength and posture from sensory processing because MOTHER did not understand what sensory processing related to and they wanted to be sure that she understood. Consequently, STUDENT’s OT goal was revised to more specifically focus on muscle strength and posture, which is one aspect of sensory processing, instead of sensory processing as a whole. According to Ms. Webster, the revised goal did not substantially change the activity involved. (Pet.’s Exh. A-H.) The goal was drafted, however, because MOTHER did not understand the original goal. The revised goal, however, was not included in the September 2002 IEP; rather, the original goal from the February 2002 IEP was continued in the September 2002 IEP. The revised goal states:
Within one year STUDENT will verbalize and demonstrate independent use of two classroom appropriate exercises or activities so that he sits upright with good posture 50% of the time when writing and attends to fine motor or handwriting activities for 10 minutes with one cue.
(Pet.’s Exh. A-H, last pg.)
Although Ms. Webster testified that the revised goal did not substantially alter the activity involved, the Hearing Officer finds that the wording of the two goals could be reasonably interpreted as addressing different areas of need, and thus, could have created confusion in the parent’s mind about the appropriateness of the offer in this respect. The Hearing Officer notes that stating that the revised goal did not “substantially alter the goal” is not the same as stating that it “did not alter” the goal. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the two goals do differ, the first dealing with STUDENT’s arousal level, posture, and attention to tasks, the second dealing with posture, fine motor, and handwriting activities. Because the occupational therapist found it necessary to revise the goal, then the revised goal should have been included in the IEP, and the District failed to include it. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the September 18, 2002 IEP was insufficient with respect to its failure to include the revised OT goal.
Because Petitioner’s mother did not believe that the IEP addressed STUDENT’s OT needs, she requested reimbursement for the services STUDENT received at the YMCA in the amount of $122, plus $50 per month thus far for services received during the 2002-2003 school year. However, Petitioner provided no evidence regarding the services he received during the 2002-2003 school year from the YMCA or the qualifications of person(s) who provided the service or how these services addressed his OT needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot award reimbursement for services.
vii. Counseling services
Petitioner did not have any specific arguments related to counseling, other than to allege that school psychologist Kelli Marsaglia implemented behavior goals during the first week of the 2002-2003 school year without parental permission. Specifically, Petitioner argues that Ms. Marsaglia implemented an unsigned IEP that, in effect, reduced the amount of counseling from 30 minutes to 20 minutes. Petitioner also requests that he receive private counseling from his treating psychologist, Dr. Hogan.
STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated December 5, 2001, provides for counseling services one time each week for 30 minutes. School psychologist Kelli Marsaglia testified that she had both a signed and unsigned IEP for STUDENT and she provided counseling services based on the unsigned February 2002 IEP, which provided for 20 minutes of counseling each week, rather than the 30 minutes agreed upon in the signed December 5, 2001 IEP. According to Ms. Marsaglia, the counseling services she provided during the current school year were based on discussions that she had with the psychologist previously assigned to STUDENT, Shelley Fuller, about STUDENT’s progress and what services worked best for him.
According to Ms. Fuller, she believed that changing the counseling services in the September 2002 IEP to 20 minutes each week was appropriate given STUDENT’s resistance to counseling and his excessive absences.
The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Marsaglia’s provision of counseling services pursuant to the unsigned IEP, which had a difference of ten-minutes in service time from the signed IEP, although technically a violation, was a de minimis error and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
MOTHER also requested counseling from STUDENT’s private psychologist, Dr. Hogan, presumably for the purpose of addressing his suicide ideation. According to Ms. Marsaglia, she met with STUDENT and he seemed very excited about attending school at Westview and she had no concerns for his social/emotional status. MOTHER presented no corroborating evidence of her statements that STUDENT engaged in suicide ideation after the week at Westview when he received no services. In fact, it is significant that even his doctor did not immediately schedule an appointment with STUDENT at that time and was not available to see him until October of 2002. There is no evidence that the counseling offered by the District is insufficient to address STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, counseling from Dr. Hogan is denied.
viii. Transition services for Petitioner’s transition from eighth to ninth grade
MOTHER contends that as a result of having no transition plan in STUDENT’s IEP to transition him from eighth to ninth grade, the District lost him the first week of the 2002-2003 school year and he received no special education or related services during that week. The District does not dispute that STUDENT was lost in the shuffle of the first week of school and was not enrolled in special education. The District argues that STUDENT did not need a specific transition plan and that had he not been misplaced the first week, his IEP, as written, was sufficient to transition him from eighth to ninth grade.
The Hearing Officer notes that MOTHER's argument is like comparing apples and oranges. Even assuming that STUDENT had had a transition plan in his IEP, the fact remains that the District was unaware that STUDENT even had an IEP the first week of high school. There is no evidence that including a transition plan would have corrected this error by the District.
The Hearing Officer in no way condones the District's failure to recognize that STUDENT was a special education student and that he should have received services immediately upon enrollment in high school. However, the District's testimony on this point was persuasive. According to Mr. Giaime, classes for the 2002-2003 school year began during the last week in August 2002. MOTHER testified that sometime after the first week of school STUDENT told her he could not keep up with his classes, so MOTHER telephoned the District and asked about STUDENT’s class schedule. By letter dated September 3, 2002, Ms. Shieh contacted MOTHER to provide her with STUDENT's revised schedule. (Pet.’s Exh. A-K.) The District immediately responded to MOTHER's concerns and placed him in special education according to his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP. (Testimony of E. Shieh.) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that not providing STUDENT special education placement for the first week of the 2002-2003 school year had a de minimis effect and was not a denial of FAPE.
Further, the District also persuasively argued that STUDENT did not need a transition plan. District witnesses testified that the comprehensive supports and services in his IEP would have been sufficient to assist him with the adjustment to high school. (Testimonies of M. Black and C. VanNordheim.) Further, there was no evidence that STUDENT had difficulty with transitions. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a transition plan was not necessary to provide STUDENT with a FAPE ix. Assistive technology services
Petitioner contends that the District failed to carry over assistive technology goals to his September 2002 IEP, but instead, the District wrote a behavior support plan to address his resistance to the Alpha Smart and different supports, and issues with work completion. Petitioner also argues that the District did not offer assistive technology consultative services to him and his teacher so that they could understand emailing, computer applications and how to save his work on the computer. Petitioner also contends that he requires a laptop computer to use both at home and at school.
The District argues that it offered STUDENT access to a computer with programs downloaded for his use and access to the Alpha Smart. However, no goal was drafted on how to use the devices because it was necessary to first address STUDENT’s avoidance of the supports by drafting resistance and work completion goals.
According to Ms. VanNordheim, assistive technology goals were previously on trial for seven weeks and, based on STUDENT’s resistance, they were later discontinued because he refused to try them. However, the Alpha Smart and the computer in class remained available for STUDENT to use and were included in the September 2002 IEP. The IEP team decided to not continue the assistive technology goals related to how to use the devices and instead, wrote a goal to help STUDENT stop resisting the actual services. The IEP team wanted to help STUDENT better understand his disability and why the team recommended the assistive technology devices. STUDENT still had all of the assistive technology available to him, but until the IEP team was able to get him over the resistance to the services, there was no reason to have a goal in the IEP regarding use of the devices.
Ms. VanNordheim testified that it was unlikely that STUDENT would have used a laptop computer because he would not use an Alpha Smart and did not want to appear to be different from other students. The IEP team also believed that providing STUDENT access to a computer in class and a copy of teachers’ notes was appropriate. No assistive technology goals were drafted to accompany the technological devices because the IEP team believed that just offering use of the technology was sufficient since STUDENT typed fast and knew how to use the computer and its programs. (Testimony of M. Giaime and C. VanNordheim.)
The Hearing Officer finds the District’s strategy in first addressing STUDENT’s avoidance, attendance, and work completion difficulties before it drafted specific goals on how to use the assistive technology devices to be appropriate. Additionally, STUDENT was not denied access to the assistive technology devices because they were still available for him to use at school. From the credible testimony of Ms. VanNordheim and Mr. Giaime, the Hearing Officer concludes that the assistive technology services and devices offered in the September 2002 IEP would appropriately assist STUDENT in meeting his educational goals and objectives. There was no convincing evidence that STUDENT required specific goals in order to access the assistive technology supports or that he required a laptop computer in order to address his educational needs.(Footnote 12)
*** In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP dated September 18, 2002 appropriately addressed all the specific areas of the parent’s concerns. However, the District is required to include the revised OT goal in STUDENT’s IEP. The Hearing Officer now turns her attention to the placement offer made by the District to determine whether it was appropriately designed to address STUDENT’s needs.
Placement
Under the District’s proposed placement, STUDENT would receive instruction in the RSP class for math, study skills, and English. He would participate with nondisabled children in the general education environment for physical education, elective, lunch, passing periods, school-wide activities, science, and history. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 2.) Additionally, STUDENT would be provided with supports, accommodations, and modifications to address his math, writing organization, and work completion difficulties and auditory and planning processing deficits. (See Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 2.)
According to RSP teacher Michael Giaime, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT learns best through the use of all of his senses. Therefore, the multi-modal/multi-sensory teaching approach that he used in his class would be helpful in addressing STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits. Specifically, Mr. Giaime stated that he typically writes information on the board, repeats it verbally to the class, and points to the words while he is saying them. He also prints and writes in large letters, which Mr. Giaime believed could help with STUDENT’s difficulties with visual memory and copying from the board, as identified in Dr. Janiuk’s vision assessment report. Mr. Giaime also testified about how he would address STUDENT’s organization and work completion goals, by determining, with STUDENT’s input, the most appropriate organization tool he would like to use and helping him to use it. He would also talk with STUDENT to ensure he understood the assignments and try and determine if STUDENT just did not want to complete his work, which often is the case with high school-level students. The writing goal could also be addressed in his class through different activities that focused on writing introductory paragraphs, body paragraphs, conclusions and transitions. Mr. Giaime believed that STUDENT would be appropriately placed in RSP and could address his goals and objectives in his class, as opposed to a more restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer found persuasive Mr. Giaime’s testimony about the different methods he would use to address STUDENT’s organization, writing, individual transition planning, behavior, and auditory processing needs.(Footnote 13)
Additionally, Ms. VanNordheim and Ms. Earp both generally testified that STUDENT benefited and produced good quality work when he actively participated in the general education environment with accommodations, such as extended time on writing assignments and use of teachers’ notes, and supports such as access to the class computer and the Alpha Smart. Ms. VanNordheim and Mr. Giaime generally testified that based on STUDENT’s skill level and the work he had completed in the previous school year, the RSP is the least restrictive environment (LRE) in which to meet STUDENT’s needs. According to Ms. VanNordheim, STUDENT has the ability to learn and gain skills, but needs additional assistance in math, study skills, and English, which could be accomplished in the RSP setting.
MOTHER provided contradictory testimony regarding the type of placement she believed STUDENT required. MOTHER testified on the one hand that placing STUDENT in RSP would not meet his needs because the District does not know his present levels of performance. She also testified that she believed STUDENT requires one-on-one instruction and a small class size like that of a nonpublic school. On the other hand, however, MOTHER testified generally that placing STUDENT in RSP for all of his academic subjects was fine as long as he receives significant accommodations and modifications when he is in general education that work without singling him out. MOTHER also agreed that the multi-sensory teaching strategies used in Mr. Giaime’s class would be appropriate for STUDENT. According to MOTHER, STUDENT needs someone to follow through with him to make sure he understands the information being presented. MOTHER explained that when STUDENT attended two private schools, Excelsiar Academy and Winston, he complained that the classes were too noisy and that other students in the class had behavior problems.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires the amount and type of RSP services that the IEP dated September 18, 2002, recommends in order to receive a FAPE. This placement and class schedule are necessary to satisfy the IDEA requirements that STUDENT’s educational program be designed to meet his unique needs and provide him educational benefit in the least restrictive environment. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT previously did good quality work in RSP and general education with the offered supports and services. Although MOTHER maintained her argument that STUDENT should be placed in an unidentified nonpublic school, the Hearing Officer finds that considering STUDENT’s disability, the offered placement would address his unique needs and provide him access to the general curriculum in the least restrictive environment. The District made an appropriate offer of placement and therefore, the IEP was sufficient in this respect.
**** The great weight of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT required the program and placement provided in the District’s September 18, 2002 IEP in order to meet his unique needs. The evidence established that appropriate goals and objectives were drafted to address STUDENT’s specific areas of deficit. Additionally, interventions in organization, math, writing, work completion, and attendance would be carried out each day in both the regular education and RSP classes, with the assistance of DIS in counseling, occupational therapy, and vision therapy. Moreover, aids, supports, and modifications to STUDENT’s program would also assist him in meeting his educational goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the proposed placement, program, and services identified in the IEP dated September 18, 2002, were appropriate to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
Was the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated September 18, 2002, reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit?
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996).) Of course, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his/her disability and must be gaged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).)
Key District personnel would provide the District’s proposed program in a coordinated and collaborative manner. Additionally, since the eighth grade, supports and services that were similar to what was offered in the September 2002 IEP were shown to be successful and provide STUDENT some benefit, at least when STUDENT attended school. STUDENT’s former RSP teacher and Mr. Giaime persuasively showed that STUDENT requires the RSP placement, supports and services in order to benefit from his education.
Given that the IEP contained the necessary components for STUDENT to learn, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s placement, program, and services as noted in the IEP dated September 18, 2002 were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Comported with his IEP
Although STUDENT’s program at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year did not comport with his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP with respect to counseling and RSP placement for approximately one week, there was no convincing evidence that this defect affected STUDENT’s education. Additionally, because the District neglected to include the revised OT goal in STUDENT’s IEP, the District is required to include that revised OT goal in STUDENT’s IEP.
Conclusion
Because the District’s offered services, supports, and placement were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, conformed to the IEP (notwithstanding the noted de minimis defects), and would be provided in the least restrictive environment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. (Footnote 14)
2. Should STUDENT be assessed in the areas of occupational therapy and adaptive physical education?
Occupational therapy
Petitioner argues that Ms. Webster’s OT assessment findings were contradictory in and of themselves. However, he does not offer evidence regarding how Ms. Webster’s information is inconsistent.(Footnote 15) Petitioner also alleges that the occupational therapist never assessed him in a crowded area and the District never determined whether his behavior was linked to any sensory integration issues.
The District contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of OT and, therefore, should not be required to conduct another OT evaluation.
Because of an assessment referral, Ms. Webster conducted an OT evaluation of STUDENT for the purpose of looking at his motor planning skills. As part of her assessment, Ms. Webster observed STUDENT in his RSP classroom and on the playground during lunchtime. (Dist.’s Exh. 9.) Ms. Webster testified that she used various testing instruments, including the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency, the Developmental Tests of Visual Motor Integration, the Wold Sentence Copying Test, a sensory questionnaire given to MOTHER and Ms. VanNordheim, a classroom and playground observation, and a teacher interview. (Pet.’s Exh. B-Y.) Ms. Webster indicated that she believed her evaluation is an adequate representation of STUDENT’s skills and needs in the area of sensory integration, i.e., muscle tone and strength. STUDENT was cooperative during the testing and she was able to observe him individually and in class. From her findings, Ms. Webster wrote a goal to address sensory processing issues related to muscle control, muscle strength, and posture. (Dist.’s Exh. 14, pg. 6.) According to Petitioner’s age and the testing materials utilized, Ms. Webster testified that she believed she did appropriate testing.
Ms. Webster testified that she has a master’s degree in occupational therapy and is a California-licensed occupational therapist and a certificated occupational therapist with the National Board of Occupational Therapy. She has worked for approximately thirty years as an occupational therapist and during almost all of those years she has assessed students. Ms. Webster indicated that she conducts OT assessments for twenty other school districts and serves twenty counties through her position as schools service coordinator for Children’s Hospital in San Diego.
Petitioner argues that Ms. Webster should have considered how loud noises, crowded classrooms, instructional staff, and teaching methods may have affected his ability to concentrate and participate in classroom activities. While Ms. Webster did not disagree that auditory processing deficits may affect STUDENT in a louder class of thirty students, as opposed to an RSP classroom, this is not her area of expertise and was not what her assessment was designed to address. The purpose of her evaluation of STUDENT was not to look at his auditory processing, but to look at his muscle tone and strength.(Footnote 16)
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Webster’s testimony that the assessment tools she used were valid and that her findings were an accurate reflection of STUDENT’s skills and needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that another OT assessment in the same OT areas is not necessary.
Adaptive physical education (APE)
Petitioner contends that the District’s APE assessment conducted in November 2000 and the OT assessment conducted by Ms. Webster in January 2002 had major discrepant results with respect to STUDENT’s upper limb speed and dexterity. (Dist.’s Exhs. 4 & 9.) The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Petitioner did not provide any evidence to support this contention.(Foonote 17)
The District performed an APE assessment of STUDENT in November 2000. (Dist.’s Exh. 4.) During the February 2002 IEP meeting, the general education physical education teacher indicated that STUDENT completed the activities, but he did not complete the written portion of the class. Additionally, on physical education conditioning days, STUDENT would walk/power walk instead of running and the teacher graded STUDENT based on his personal ability performance improvement.
Occupational therapist Patricia Webster testified that she did not believe STUDENT needed a referral for adaptive physical education because his program was already adapted so that he did not have to run as far or as fast as others in the regular education physical education class due to his decreased muscle tone and strength.
Petitioner provided no convincing evidence that he required an APE assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a new APE assessment because when he was attending school he was successfully receiving general education physical education where his needs were being met with modifications to the program.(Footnote 18)
ORDER
1. The District shall include in STUDENT’s IEP the revised OT goal drafted by Patricia Webster (See Pet.’s Exh. A-H.).
2. All of student’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided, except with respect to Issue 1.D.vi in that the September 18, 2002 IEP was insufficient with respect to its failure to include the revised OT goal.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code §56505(i).)
Dated: March 4, 2003 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis. 2. Petitioner alleged that the IEP dated September 18,2002, was labeled an “annual review” rather than as an “addendum.” Other references in the IEP and testimony from District witnesses, however, support the fact that the District considered this IEP to be a continuation of the February 2002 IEP. (Testimonies of E. Shieh, M. Giaime, and C. VanNordheim; See also Dist.’s Exh. 20, pgs. 5-11 – goals and objectives, behavior support plan, and individual transition plan all continued from February 2002 IEP.) 3. As stated above, a stay put order was issued during the course of this hearing on January 28, 2003. However, it was not clear if Petitioner ever returned to school at Westview pursuant to that stay put order. 4. The same level of OT services offered in the February 19, 2002 IEP was offered in the September 18, 2002 IEP. (Dist.’s Exhs. 14 & 20.) 5. Documentary evidence confirmed that MOTHER received notice of the scheduled October 31, 2002 IEP meeting, but had no intention of attending any IEP meeting at Westview (See Pet.’s Exhs. A-O, A-Q, A-T, and A-U.) In addition, in her letter dated October 28, 2002, to Mr. Giaime, MOTHER questioned why the District would be holding an IEP meeting on October 31, 2002, when there was a due process hearing scheduled “to deal with the altered IEP.” (Pet.’s Exh. A-U.) 6. MOTHER testified that she did not attend the IEP meeting because a due process hearing had already been requested, she felt totally left out of the process, and did not want to meet with the same team members. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by this testimony. The October 31, 2002 IEP meeting was conducted in direct response to MOTHER’s request to change STUDENT’s placement. MOTHER’s failure to attend the meeting essentially thwarted the District’s attempt to address her concerns in a timely manner. In addition, District witnesses persuasively testified that, on occasion, MOTHER had difficulty staying with the issues and that it was necessary to bring her back to the IEP agenda and not permit her to interact with the teachers on any topic, at inappropriate times during the IEP meeting. (Testimonies of E. Shieh, M. Giame, and C. VanNordheim.) The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that MOTHER was denied the opportunity to participate in any IEP meeting or that having the same staff members present from one IEP meeting to the next prejudiced her participation in any way. 7. Petitioner argues that the September 2002 IEP does not indicate his visual processing deficits as identified in Dr. Janiuk’s report. However, as indicated in the discussion of alleged procedural violations, the Hearing Officer notes that the District does not dispute the findings made in Dr. Janiuk’s August 6, 2002 report and, in fact, the District members of the September 2002 IEP team agreed with the findings and the recommendations made by Dr. Janiuk and agreed to implement Dr. Janiuk’s recommended services as a part of STUDENT’s IEP. (Dist.’s Exh. 20, pg. 15.) There is no dispute that STUDENT demonstrates some visual deficits. The real dispute with respect to Dr. Janiuk’s report is in its interpretation of STUDENT’s reading level. Moreover, the provision of vision therapy was not an issue to be considered in this hearing. 8. Ms. VanNordheim conducted an informal reading inventory evaluation of STUDENT in eighth grade that demonstrated STUDENT was reading efficiently at an eighth-grade level in both decoding and comprehension. STUDENT’s decoding skills were at a 97 percent accuracy level. An error analysis of the grade-level social studies book demonstrated one error out of one hundred words and comprehension of ninety percent, with adequate fluency. An error analysis of the science book indicated STUDENT made three errors out of one hundred two words and comprehension of one hundred percent, with adequate fluency. (Dist.’s Exhs. 14 and 20; Testimony of C. VanNordheim.) 9. Ms. Earp testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in humanities core writing and reading and a master’s degree in educational theory. She has taught eighth grade for the past twenty years and has trained teachers for three years in bilingual education in social studies. For the past four years at Mesa Verde, Ms. Earp has been the reading leader, which requires her to train teachers how to incorporate reading into all subject areas. Ms. Earp testified that her experience in this capacity, along with the fact that STUDENT had been in her humanities core classes from the second week of the 2001-2002 school year to April 2002, gave her a good basis from which to form her opinion about STUDENT’s needs. 10. Ms. VanNordheim testified that she has nearly twenty years of experience teaching special education and this was her second year as a resource specialist at Mesa Verde, although she had previously worked at other school districts as a resource specialist, both at the elementary and high school levels, and as a teacher in a self-contained classroom of educably mentally retarded students. Ms. VanNordheim stated that she has a liberal studies degree and a resource specialist certificate from San Diego State University, and a master’s degree in curriculum and instruction from the University of Southern Mississippi. She also maintains multi-subject and learning handicapped specialist credentials from the State of California. 11. MOTHER argued that instead of using positive interventions, the District called a Student Attendance Review Board meeting (SARB) and that the SARB proceedings were a negative intervention to STUDENT’s attendance issues. However, the Hearing Officer notes that the SARB proceedings were initiated after MOTHER removed STUDENT from school altogether and that these proceedings are separate and distinct from the District’s behavior support plan. The behavior support plan was drafted to address STUDENT’s work completion, attendance, and resistance to supports and services; however, STUDENT was not in school to implement the plan. In contrast, the SARB proceedings relate to the District’s duty with respect to enforcing the compulsory attendance laws. 12. Although STUDENT may have had a preference for certain computer equipment, the evidence demonstrated that the District provided STUDENT with a variety of assistive technology tools and also showed him how to use those devices. 13. Mr. Giaime testified that this was his fourth year as an RSP teacher at Westview. He also coaches the football and baseball teams. He has a bachelor of science degree in elementary education and special education from Northern Arizona University and is currently obtaining his final credits for a master’s degree in special education. He has a level 1 education credential and has finished the level 2, which is a higher level of special education credential. 14. The Hearing Officer is aware that during the January 17, 2003 IEP team meeting that the parent did not attend, the IEP team concluded that it needed to update STUDENT’s assessments to establish baselines and present levels in order to provide a FAPE offer for the following year. (Pet.’s Exh. C –G.) Accordingly, the IEP team proposed to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement, his psychomotor development and perceptual function, his intellectual development, his social emotional/adaptive behavior (with a consult from the occupational therapist for Asperger’s), a clinical OT observation, and his health. (Pet.’s Exh. C-G.) The Hearing Officer makes no judgment about these proposed assessments. The Hearing Officer’s consideration of the issues in this case requires her to consider the information that the IEP team had at the time it made its offer on September 18, 2002. However, the fact that the Hearing Officer has determined that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE does not limit the IEP team’s ability to review and revise the IEP based upon the proposed assessments and any other relevant and new information at the upcoming annual review. 15.Petitioner also contends in his closing brief that he should have been observed in his regular education classroom so as to reveal the degree to which he is being affected by environmental factors, such as noise level, commotion, pace of class activity, visual clutter, nature of instructional staff and the method of instruction. (Pet.’s closing brief, pg. 10.) However, Petitioner never raised this specific argument during hearing and, if he had, there was no evidence that these issues are necessarily an occupational therapy matter. 16. The referral information at the time Ms. Webster conducted her assessment indicates that her assessment was appropriate at the time. The Hearing Officer’s conclusion, however, does not prevent the IEP team from making a decision to assess STUDENT in this area should it determine it necessary to do so. 17. A review of both the 2000 APE assessment report and the 2002 OT report indicates that both assessors used the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency. In the area of upper limb speed and dexterity, the 2000 report indicates that STUDENT performed at the 12 years, 11 months age level and the 2002 report indicates he performed at the 10 years, 2 month age level. Having received no evidence on the interpretation of these score differentials, the Hearing Officer cannot make a finding as to whether the different scores warrant a new APE assessment. 18. The Hearing Officer’s conclusion does not prevent the IEP team from making a decision to assess STUDENT in this area should it determine it necessary to do so.
