California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 11, 1999
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 170-98 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Long Beach Unified prevails: gifted seventh grader found ineligible for special education, and parents' independent evaluation is not reimbursed.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old seventh grader in Long Beach Unified's gifted program filed for due process after the IEP team found her ineligible for special education. The District then filed to defend its assessment, and the cases were consolidated. The mother, an attorney, represented the student. She argued that attention deficit disorder and depression qualified the student as having a specific learning disability (SLD) or a serious emotional disturbance (SED).
The Hearing Officer found her ineligible under both categories. An independent evaluation by psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson suggested a discrepancy in dictation, punctuation and capitalization. But the evidence did not show a visual, auditory or ADHD processing disorder. Teachers described her as attentive and not hyperactive. Nothing showed the gaps could not be fixed in regular classes. Her low grades came from missing assignments. For SED, her peer problems, three discipline incidents and disputed depression were not shown to a marked degree over a long period.
The Hearing Officer held that school psychologist Marlyse Linder's assessment was appropriate. It tested auditory processing, and the District had no reason to suspect ADHD. Reimbursement for the independent evaluation and for private counseling was denied, as was a central auditory processing assessment. The District's request to reassess social-emotional functioning was also denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1991 federal policy that attention deficit disorder alone does not create eligibility. A student must also meet SLD, OHI or SED criteria and need special education. It also shows that a district that proves its assessment appropriate at hearing does not have to pay for a parent's independent evaluation.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue I.A. Is Student eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD)?
Even assuming a severe discrepancy in dictation, punctuation and capitalization, Student had no visual, auditory or ADHD processing disorder, and she did not show the discrepancy could not be corrected in regular education.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue I.B. Is Student eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance (SED)?
Student's peer problems, three behavior incidents in three years, and disputed depression were not shown over a long period of time and to a marked degree, so she did not meet SED criteria.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue II. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to appropriately assess Student and by failing to identify Student as a student qualified for special education?
Because Student was not eligible, the Hearing Officer did not need to decide denial of FAPE. The assessment was addressed under Issue III.B, and the District prevailed.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue III.A. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of counseling for Student by Dr. Guerra?
Student was not eligible, and no evidence showed the private counseling was necessary for her to benefit from her education, so reimbursement was denied.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue III.B. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson?
The District's assessment was appropriate. It tested auditory processing and used rating scales, an interview and a records review for social-emotional functioning. It had no reason to suspect ADHD, and it properly determined an ability range. The IEE was not reimbursed.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue IV. Is the District entitled to reassess Student in the area of social/emotional adaptive behavior?
Because Student was found ineligible, the Hearing Officer saw no need for a reassessment, and the District was not entitled to reassess in this area.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue V. Is the District required to assess Student in the area of central auditory processing?
The District's auditory processing testing was appropriate. Student offered no significant evidence of how central auditory processing differs or why she needed that assessment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims were denied.
- The District is not entitled to reassess Student in the area of social/emotional/adaptive behavior.
Key authorities
School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum (1991) 18 IDELR 116; Education Code 56337; Education Code 56339; Education Code 56329(b); Education Code 56320; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, 3030(i); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, 3030(j)(4)(B)
People named in the decision
- Glenn Fait, Hearing Officer (observed part of the hearing), Special Education Hearing Office
- Sheri Torres, Assistant to Student's mother (present at hearing)
- Christopher Russell, Educational advocate for Student (present one day)
- Benton Dorman, School psychologist (District representative at hearing), Long Beach Unified School District
- Judith McBride, Lead psychologist; District representative; witness, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Robert Patterson, Independent psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Steven Jaffe (also spelled Yaffee), Fifth grade teacher, Mark Twain Elementary School
- Marlyse Linder, School psychologist; District assessor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Karen Shatafian, Former school counselor, Mark Twain Elementary School
- Theresa Meyer (also spelled Myer), Speech and language specialist, Bancroft Middle School
- James Hutchinson, Seventh grade English teacher, Bancroft Middle School
- Peggy Chang, Math (algebra-link) teacher, Bancroft Middle School
- Kimberly Holland, Music/band teacher, Bancroft Middle School
- Jack Herman Schnel, Expert witness for District; school psychologist and private practitioner, Palos Verdes Peninsula USD
- Dr. Julio Guerra, Private psychologist who provided counseling
- Dr. Kimura, Student's physician
- Ms. Shaver, Sixth grade teacher, Bancroft Middle School
- Ms. McLean, Sixth grade teacher, Bancroft Middle School
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Long Beach, California, on October 15 and 16, December 1 and 2, 1998, and January 14 and 15, 1999. Hearing Officer Glenn Fait observed the hearing for half of the day on October 15, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by her mother, attorney MOTHER. STUDENT'S father, FATHER, was present on the first day of the hearing. MOTHER's assistant, Sheri Torres, was present throughout the hearing. Additionally, educational advocate Christopher Russell was present on STUDENT'S behalf on December 1, 1998. Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (Long Beach USD or District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Nancy Finch-Heuereman and Cynthia Yount. Also present on the District's behalf was Benton Dorman, school psychologist for Long Beach USD. Judith McBride, lead psychologist for Long Beach USD, was present as the District representative on December 1, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, STUDENT'S father; Dr. Patterson, psychologist; MOTHER, STUDENT'S mother; Steven Jaffe, STUDENT'S teacher at Mark Twain Elementary School; Marlyse Linder, school psychologist for Long Beach USD; Judith McBride, lead psychologist for Long Beach USD; and Karen Shatafian, prior school counselor at Mark Twain Elementary School. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Theresa Meyer, speech and language specialist for Bancroft Middle School; James Hutchinson, STUDENT'S seventh grade English teacher; Peggy Chang, STUDENT'S math teacher; Kimberly Holland, STUDENT'S music teacher; and Jack Herman Schnel, school psychologist for Palos Verdes Penninsula USD and private practitioner. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received on February 11, 1999. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.PROCEDURAL MATTERSI. Motion for telephone testimony. Prior to the hearing, MOTHER submitted to the Hearing Office on behalf of Petitioner STUDENT a motion to allow witness Dr. Julio Guerra to testify by telephone. Petitioner argued that Dr. Guerra was unable to appear in person because he was recuperating from surgery performed months prior to the hearing. Petitioner also contended that Dr. Guerra was unavailable because he could not take time out of his schedule with his patients at his practice to appear at hearing. However, Petitioner asserted that Dr. Guerra would be available to testify by telephone from 12:30 p.m. to 1:00 p.m. on October 15, 1999, and possibly longer if necessary. Respondent District opposed the motion, arguing that it would be unable to adequately cross-examine and assess the witness's credibility if he were allowed to testify by telephone. The District stated that Dr. Guerra was the only person to assess STUDENT as clinically depressed. The District contended that Dr. Guerra had ignored various subpoenas to produce documents of his psychological assessment of STUDENT and that, therefore, the District had nothing on which to base the cross-examination or to determine the witness's credibility. At the hearing on October 15, 1998, the Hearing Officer convened a telephone conference at 12:30 p.m. to discuss Dr. Guerra's availability. After being questioned by Petitioner, the District, and the Hearing Officer, Dr. Guerra stated that he had not learned of the hearing until a week prior to the hearing. (Footnote 1) Additionally, Dr. Guerra stated that he was in fact recuperating from an illness and was busy with his patient schedule, but would be available to appear at a later date if given appropriate notice. Moreover, although the Hearing Officer offered to convene the hearing at his office or to allow him to appear at hearing after his work hours, Dr. Guerra stated that he would not be able to appear during the hearing dates scheduled for October 15 and 16, 1998. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer found that Dr. Guerra's general unavailability for hearing was not a ground to allow his telephone testimony over the District's objection. The Hearing Officer also noted that the hearing was expected to be continued to a later date and that Dr. Guerra's availability would be considered when scheduling the continued hearing. Although the continued hearing was scheduled on December 1 and 2, 1998, so that Dr. Guerra could attend the hearing, Petitioner decided not to call Dr. Guerra as a witness.II. Motion for the Hearing Office's administrative rules and procedures. MOTHER submitted to the Hearing Office a prehearing motion requesting the Hearing Office's administrative rules and procedures. At hearing, MOTHER stated that she was told by another Hearing Officer that the Hearing Office does not always follow the Administrative Procedures Act (APA). Thus, she requested a copy of any administrative rules and procedures that the Hearing Office follows in lieu of the APA. At hearing, the Hearing Officer noted that the Hearing Office follows procedures in federal and State law and regulations. The only procedures the Hearing Office has which may not be found in such laws and regulations are listed in a handout entitled "Notice of Procedural Safeguards." MOTHER acknowledged that she had received the handout prior to the hearing. Hence, Petitioner's motion requesting copies of the Hearing Office's internal administrative rules and procedures was denied on the grounds that she already has access to all applicable rules and procedures.III. Section 504 Claims. After clarifying the issues for hearing at the start of the proceeding, the Hearing Officer noted that one of Petitioner's issues involved Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act. The Hearing Officer also noted that the Hearing Office has consistently ruled that Section 504 claims are outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. In the absence of direct legal authority establishing that the Hearing Office has the jurisdiction to hear Section 504 claims, the Hearing Officer ruled that the Section 504 issue would not be heard in the present case.IV. Petitioner's motions to recuse the Hearing Officer. During the first three days of hearing, Petitioner made five motions to recuse the Hearing Officer. After each of Petitioner's motions, the District responded that it did not object to the Hearing Officer presiding over this case. Education Code 56501(b)(4) provides that parties to a due process hearing have the right to a fair and impartial hearing. Additionally, Education Code 56504.5 requires that hearing officers be "knowledgeable in administrative hearings and laws and regulations governing special education." Section 3084 of the California Code of Regulations provides that receipt of ex parte communications by the Hearing Officer may be grounds for disqualification. Special education law does not specify any other grounds for removing a hearing officer. Petitioner's first motion to recuse the Hearing Officer was on the grounds that the Hearing Officer was not knowledgeable in the area of special education law and that the Hearing Officer was biased in favor of the District. To support her first contention, Petitioner noted that the Hearing Officer was seen chatting with Hearing Officer Fait, which Petitioner asserted showed that the Hearing Officer did not know special education law. However, Petitioner acknowledged that she did not know the content of the Hearing Officer's discussions with Hearing Officer Fait. Petitioner provided no support for her second contention of bias. The Hearing Officer found no basis for Petitioner's motion and denied such motion. Petitioner's second motion to recuse the Hearing Officer occurred after her motion for telephone testimony was denied. Petitioner asserted that the Hearing Officer's ruling showed that the Hearing Officer does not know special education law and was biased in favor of the District. Again, the Hearing Officer found no basis for Petitioner's motion and denied her motion. Petitioner's third, fourth, and fifth motions to recuse the Hearing Officer were made immediately following the Hearing Officer's rulings in favor of the District on procedural objections made by both the District and by Petitioner. Again, in each of these situations, Petitioner alleged that the Hearing Officer's rulings indicated her bias in favor of the District. However, the Hearing Officer's ruling on the objections were based on the facts and the law and not on any alleged bias. Thus, the Hearing Officer denied each of these motions to recuse her.V. District's motion to admit exhibit 35. On February 10, 1999, after the last day of the hearing, but prior to the record closing, the District submitted to the Hearing Office a motion to admit into evidence as District's Exhibit 35 a copy of STUDENT'S final grades for the seventh grade fall semester to rebut Petitioner's Exhibit S. Petitioner's Exhibit S is STUDENT'S fall semester progress report, which reflects preliminary grades for only two of her seven classes. Petitioner submitted Exhibit S into evidence on the last day of hearing. Although Petitioner did not provide the District with five days' notice of the submission of the evidence as is required by law, the Hearing Officer allowed the exhibit to be entered into evidence. Petitioner opposed the admission of the District's Exhibit 35 on the ground that Petitioner was not given five days' notice of such evidence. The main purpose of the five-day-notice rule is to prevent unfair surprise regarding the admission of evidence. Petitioner did not dispute the accuracy of the District's Exhibit 35 or claim that she did not previously receive a copy. Moreover, because Petitioner offered a portion of STUDENT'S fall semester grades into evidence first, there is no unfair surprise or other prejudice in the District's offering STUDENT'S complete fall semester grades. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer granted the District's motion to admit District's Exhibit 35 into evidence. VI. Petitioner's motion to strike portions of the District's closing brief. Following the District's and Petitioner's submission of closing briefs to the Hearing Office, Petitioner made a written motion to strike portions of the District's closing brief. Petitioner asserted that the District mischaracterized the facts in making its closing arguments. To support its motion, Petitioner identified various disputed facts that Petitioner argued were mischaracterized by the District and stated what she believed to be the true facts. In its closing brief, the District is entitled to argue that the evidence established certain facts and then apply those proposed facts to the law. Hence, Petitioner's motion is denied in its entirety.ISSUESI. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or serious emotional disturbance (SED)? (footnote 2)II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to appropriately assess STUDENT and by failing to identify STUDENT as a student qualified for special education?III. Are STUDENT'S parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of: A. counseling for STUDENT by Dr. Guerra, and B. the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson? IV. Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT in the area of social/emotional adaptive behavior?V. Is the District required to assess STUDENT in the area of central auditory processing?POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES Petitioner STUDENT argued that the District failed to appropriately assess her, which resulted in the District failing to qualify her for special education services. Petitioner asserted that the District did not assess her in the areas of social/emotional adaptive behavior and central auditory processing and that the District failed to assess her for attention deficit disorder (ADD). Petitioner also contended that she is qualified for special education services as having either a specific learning disability or a serious emotional disturbance because of her ADD and clinical depression. Based on the above, Petitioner seeks to be found eligible for special education services and seeks reimbursement for the independent assessment performed by Dr. Patterson and for counseling provided by Dr. Guerra. Petitioner also requests that the District be required to assess her in the area of central auditory processing. Respondent District asserted that its assessment of STUDENT was timely and in conformance with special education laws. The District asserted that the assessment was performed by qualified assessors and and that it evaluated all areas of STUDENT's suspected disability. Additionally, the District contended that STUDENT does not meet the eligibility requirements for special education as a student with SLD because she does not have a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement, a processing disorder, or a need for special education services. Respondents also contended that STUDENT does not qualify for special education as a student with an SED. (Footnote 3)Thus, the District requests that all Petitioner's requests for services and reimbursement be denied.BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old who is attending the seventh grade at Bancroft Middle School. She was placed in the "Gifted and Talented Education" program for high academically achieving students when she was in the third grade and has been enrolled in these accelerated and excelled classes up to the present time. She is not currently eligible for special education services. STUDENT's parents testified that STUDENT started to have problems in school during fourth grade at Alvarado Elementary School. On her fourth grade report card, her teacher commented that STUDENT" has difficulty getting along with peers" and that "the quality of her work is not at the level that she can perform at." (Pet. Exh. A.) Her teacher also identified that STUDENT had difficulty with listening attentively, working with others, showing good sportsmanship, respecting the rights and property of others, observing class rules, and observing school, safety, and playground rules. (Id.) Moreover, her teacher noted that STUDENT had many late assignments and rarely turned in her homework. (Id.) Also during this time, STUDENT was suspended from the school bus for kicking a student and interfering with the safety of others on the bus. (Pet. Exh. C.) Despite STUDENT's problems, she received A's and/or B's in every subject, and her class effort in every subject was described by her teacher as "excellent." (Pet. Exh. A.) For her fifth grade year, STUDENT was transferred to Mark Twain School. STUDENT's fifth grade teacher, Steven Yaffee, testified that STUDENT had problems socially interacting with other students. He stated that STUDENT was very "individualistic," was "neutral" towards other students, would "tune them out," and often appeared to prefer to be alone. Additionally, Mr. Yaffee stated that STUDENT did not have many friends and did not work well in groups. However, he attributed her social problems to her being a new student in a new school, and in a class where most of the students had known each other for a very long time. In regard to STUDENT's academics, Mr. Yaffee testified that STUDENT was brilliant compared to other GATE students (and was in the top 10-25% of her class), but that she did not perform to her abilities. On her report card, STUDENT's grades generally ranged from "three" to "five" on a six-point scale. (Footnote 4) (Pet. Exh. D.) In every class where she received a "three," STUDENT was noted as "need[ing] to improve" her classroom effort. (Id.) Additionally, STUDENT's report card indicated that she had twenty-eight absences during her fifth grade year. (Id.) Mr. Yaffee testified that STUDENT had difficulty turning in assignments. He also stated that STUDENT appeared to pick and choose which assignments she wanted to complete. If she felt that the assignment of was of no value, she did not attempt the work or give it her attention. (Testimony of Mr. Yaffee.) Thus, according to Mr. Yaffee, STUDENT's grades were a result of her choice not to do her class work. Concerned with STUDENT's social adjustment and academic problems, Mr. Yaffee referred STUDENT to the school counselor as an "at risk" student at the end of the school year. Karen Shatafian, the school counselor, testified that such an "at risk" determination may be made by any school personnel and is purely subjective. She also testified that no further steps were taken in regards to STUDENT being identified as an "at risk" student. For the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT advanced to the sixth grade at Bancroft Middle School. There, STUDENT was placed in an accelerated academic program. While at Bancroft, STUDENT continued to have trouble turning in her homework. (Pet. Exhs. E, I, and K; Dist. Exh. 13.) Additionally, at the end of November 1997, she was given on-campus suspension for making a racial slur towards another student. (Pet. Exh. F.) Neither party submitted STUDENT's complete grades for her sixth grade year. Based on first-quarter progress reports and second-quarter teachers' reports, it appears that STUDENT's grades ranged from B's to F's. (Pet. Exhs. E, I, J, and K; Dist. Exh. 13.) From the submitted evidence, STUDENT's grades were as follows: 1st Qtr./2nd Qtr. 1st Semester (final) 3rd Qtr. History B/F D D English B+/F+ C+ F Science F/F ? ? Math C/D ? ? Band ?/B ? ? Sometime during the second quarter of STUDENT's sixth grade year, STUDENT's parents requested from the District an assessment for STUDENT. As a result, an assessment plan was developed for STUDENT which was signed by STUDENT's parents on December 2, 1997. (Footnote 5) (Pet. Exhs. G and H; Dist. Exh. 1 and 2.) The assessment plan called for assessments in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement, speech and language, intellectual ability, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, perceptual/processing, and health/physical status. (Pet. Exh. H; Dist. Exh. 2.) After STUDENT's assessment was completed, an Individual Education Program (IEP) meeting convened on February 4, 1998. (Dist. Exh. 9.) At the IEP meeting, the District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not qualified for special education. STUDENT's parents did not agree with that conclusion. (Id.) On February 9, 1998, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner a request for a special education due process hearing. On February 12, 1998, STUDENT's parents brought STUDENT to Dr. Julio Guerra for a psychological evaluation. Dr. Guerra treated STUDENT two to four times a month between February and June, and once in October 1998. Dr. Guerra diagnosed STUDENT as being clinically depressed and referred her to her physician, who prescribed her Prozac. After being notified by MOTHER that she disagreed with both the assessment and the IEP findings, the District filed for a due process hearing on April 15, 1998, to prove that its assessment was appropriate. Subsequently, an independent psychological assessment was performed on STUDENT by Dr. Robert Patterson. (Pet. Exh. M.) Dr. Patterson's report was completed on June 24, 1998. (Id.) Pursuant to Petitioner's motion, the District's case was consolidated with Petitioner's case on June 17, 1998. After numerous continuances, the hearing first convened on October 15, 1998. Between the time when Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing and the time that the hearing first convened, STUDENT successfully advanced to the seventh grade. Her first semester grades include an A in band, a B in English excel, a D in physical education, a C in algebra link, a B in science, a D in history excel, and a "Pass" in a class listed as "AD/HR/PER 7." (Dist. Exh. 35.)FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAWI. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or serious emotional disturbance (SED)? According to STUDENT's parents, STUDENT has been diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder (ADD). ADD is not listed in federal or state law as one of the disabilities that establish eligibility for special education. The United States Department of Education has stated in a policy memo that a student with an attention deficit disorder (ADD) is eligible for special education only if by reason thereof (1) the student meets the eligibility criteria for a listed disability such as SLD, other health impaired (OHI), or SED, and (2) the student needs special education. U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, (1991) 18 IDELR 116; see also 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(1)(A). California law similarly states that a student whose educational performance is "adversely affected" by ADD is eligible for special education if the student demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria in the category of SLD, OHI, or SED. Education Code 56339(a). Because Petitioner's evidence was limited to her eligibility under the categories of SLD and SED, there was no basis to consider whether Petitioner was eligible under the category of OHI. A. Specific Learning Disability (SLD) California Education Code 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability: (a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression; (2) Listening comprehension; (3) Written expression; (4) Basic reading skills; (5) Reading comprehension; (6) Mathematics calculation; (7) Mathematics reasoning. (b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. (c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. In this case, Petitioner relies on Dr. Patterson's independent assessment to support her contention that she qualifies for special education as a student with an SLD. According to Dr. Patterson's report, STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of "dictation skills" and "punctuation and capitalization knowledge." (Pet. Exh. M.) Dr. Patterson based this conclusion on the comparison of STUDENT's scores on various subtests from the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery - Revised (WJ-R), the Peabody Individual Achievement Test - Revised (PIAT-R), and the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT). On the Dictation Subtest of the WJ-R, STUDENT scored in the 78th percentile, performing at almost the ninth grade level. On the Proofing Subtest of the WJ-R, STUDENT scored in the 96th percentile, performing at the thirteenth grade level. On other subtests of the WJ-R, STUDENT performed in the 50th percentile (i.e., mid-average range) when tested on punctuation and capitalization and in the 98th and 95th percentiles on spelling and word usage, respectively. Thus, according to Dr. Patterson's report, STUDENT's test scores reflect a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement in the areas of dictation, punctuation, and capitalization. In addition to a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement, Dr. Patterson reported that STUDENT exhibited characteristics of a child who has a visual processing disorder, a central auditory processing disorder, and ADD. According to Dr. Patterson, visual processing is measured by performance on the Visual Closure Subtest and the Picture Recognition subtest of the WJ-R. On the Visual Closure Subtest, where the student is shown partial or distorted pictures and required to "visually close" the picture to determine the nature of the picture, STUDENT scored in the 77th percentile. On the Picture Recognition Subtest, where a student is shown pictures and later asked to identify the pictures in a field of pictures, STUDENT scored in the 1st percentile, at the kindergarten level. Dr. Patterson interpreted these scores to suggest that STUDENT had a visual processing disorder. In regard to the central auditory processing disorder, Dr. Patterson administered to STUDENT the Sound Blending Subtest and the Incomplete Words Subtest of the WJ-R. On the Incomplete Words Subtest, STUDENT scored in the 24th percentile, at the "cusp between average and low average functioning." On the Sound Blending Subtest, STUDENT scored in the 85th percentile, placing her abilities in the high average range. To further support her contention that she has an auditory processing disorder, Petitioner presented evidence that she often responds with "huh" when spoken to, suggesting that she has problems processing oral information as a result of the auditory processing disorder. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER, and Mr. Yaffee.) Finally, Dr. Patterson diagnosed STUDENT as having Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder of the combined type (ADHD). Dr. Patterson based this diagnosis, in part, on the responses of STUDENT's mother to the Conners' Parent Rating Scale - Revised: Long Form. Assuming, arguendo, that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement in the areas of dictation, capitalization, and punctuation knowledge, STUDENT is still ineligible for special education services for two primary reasons. First, Petitioner has not established that her discrepancy is due to a psychological processing disorder. To begin with, Petitioner has not established that she has a visual processing disorder. In her independent evaluation, STUDENT was given two subtests to assess her visual processing. On the Visual Closure Subtest, STUDENT scored in the high-average range and, in the Picture Recognition Subtest, she scored at the kindergarten level. Dr. Patterson stated in his report that the low score on the Picture Recognition Subtest may be influenced by "visual distractibility as well as visual processing difficulties." However, he never concluded that the score reflected a visual processing disorder rather than just "visual distractibility." Dr. Patterson also does not explain in his report whether environmental factors affected STUDENT's performance on the Picture Recognition Subtest or explain conflicting evidence in STUDENT's file. In the District's assessment, STUDENT scored in the 9th percentile on the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI). But the assessor, Marlyse Linder, attributed her low score to STUDENT's impulsiveness during testing. On the subtest, each successive task becomes more difficult. To support her conclusion of STUDENT's impulsiveness, Ms. Linder testified that STUDENT was able to complete the latter, more difficult tasks, but missed the initial simple tasks. Ms. Linder stated that STUDENT's ability to perform the difficult tasks indicated that STUDENT was able to perform the visual processing tasks without difficulty. According to Ms. Linder, STUDENT received a low score because, according to the test scoring directions, she was unable to take into account STUDENT's correct answers after she missed three consecutive answers. Because STUDENT missed the initial simple tasks, her score did not reflect her successful performance on the difficult tasks. Additionally, none of STUDENT's teachers testified to observing STUDENT's having problems characteristic of a visual processing disorder. Mr. Yaffee, STUDENT's fifth grade teacher, testified that he would be surprised to learn that STUDENT had a visual processing disorder. Furthermore, many of the teachers' reports and witness testimony established that STUDENT spends a great deal of time reading and that she appeared to have no problem processing information that she read. Thus, the evidence does not support Dr. Patterson's suggestion that STUDENT may have a visual processing disorder. Petitioner also did not establish that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. Dr. Patterson's report indicated that STUDENT's test scores warrant another assessment to determine whether she has a central auditory processing disorder. Yet, the District conducted a speech and language assessment a few months earlier in which STUDENT was given the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Revised (CELF-R). STUDENT's scores on the CELF-R led the speech and language specialist to conclude that she does not have an auditory processing disorder. The District also previously tested STUDENT in the area of auditory processing in its psycho-educational assessment. STUDENT was given the Visual Aural Digit Span Test (VADS), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skill (TAPS), and the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML). According to the school psychologist, Ms. Linder, STUDENT's scores on these tests "failed to indicate significant auditory processing deficits." (Dist. Exh. 6.) Petitioner seems to argue that central auditory processing is different from auditory processing; however, no adequate explanation was given for the difference. Although STUDENT's parents and Mr. Yaffee testified that STUDENT tends to respond to oral directions with "huh?" STUDENT's teachers all testified that STUDENT does not have a problem understanding oral directions. Additionally, STUDENT excels in band, where she is required to listen to notes and musical prompts from other students in the class while playing her flute. Petitioner also failed to establish that STUDENT has ADHD, a processing disorder. Petitioner relies on Dr. Patterson's report to support her contention that she has ADHD. However, Dr. Patterson's diagnosis of STUDENT's ADHD in his report lacks substantiation and is not persuasive. According to Dr. Schnel, a diagnosis of ADHD requires that the symptoms of such disorder be present prior to age seven. Yet, Dr. Patterson failed to indicate whether such symptoms were present in his report. Petitioner argued that Dr. Patterson's diagnosis is supported by her parents' testimony that she was inattentive as a child. However, Petitioner's parents did not testify as to the degree of STUDENT's inattentiveness. They also testified that she "did wonderfully" in school up through the third grade, when she was eight years old. Because their testimony is internally inconsistent, it does not serve to support Dr. Patterson's diagnosis. Dr. Patterson also diagnosed STUDENT as having the ADD disorder that is characterized by hyperactivity. However, Mr. Yaffee, Mr. Hutchinson, Ms. Chang, and Ms. Holland all testified that STUDENT was not a hyperactive child. In their reports, her teachers generally rated her hyperactivity as "not at all" or "just a little." Moreover, STUDENT's parents testified that she does not exhibit hyperactive qualities. Although STUDENT is described as inattentive, her conduct does not suggest a global processing disorder. While at times STUDENT's inattentiveness is apparent, at other times, her ability to focus is notable. At hearing, evidence was presented that STUDENT often responds to oral directions with "huh?" Petitioner also presented STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers' reports where two of STUDENT's teachers rated STUDENT's inattentiveness as "pretty much" and "very much." However, STUDENT's band teacher Ms. Holland rated STUDENT's inattentiveness as "not at all" or "just a little." STUDENT's teachers also testified that she does not have a problem understanding oral directions. Ms. Holland testified that she never had to repeat directions to STUDENT because she "pays attention." She also testified that STUDENT rarely loses concentration when playing the flute and she is the second best flautist in the class. Ms. Chang, STUDENT's seventh-grade algebra-link teacher, testified that STUDENT is a "very attentive student" who has a "very high ability" and "no problems with comprehension." Ms. Chang also stated that she was "amazed at [STUDENT's] ability to listen to long lectures." Ms. Chang further testified that she never repeats directions to STUDENT and STUDENT had never asked her to repeat any directions. Of the teachers who reported observing some inattentiveness, they reported that STUDENT appears to choose which assignments she believed had "value" in which to focus her attention. Hence, although some evidence of inattentiveness exists, STUDENT is able to attend to many things in a wide range of circumstances. Moreover, Petitioner did not establish that STUDENT's ADHD caused her discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of dictation, capitalization, and punctuation. In his report, Dr. Patterson listed STUDENT's ADHD Global Assessment Functioning score as 65, indicating that she has a mild disorder at best. According to Dr. Schnel, a score of 55 or below indicates a more serious impairment. Although Dr. Patterson diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD, he failed to state how, and the degree to which, the ADHD affected STUDENT's education. Instead, he stated that the ADD "combined with the characteristics of... Central Auditory Processing Disorder" significantly impacts STUDENT's ability to learn. Additionally, rather than recommending STUDENT for special education due to the impact STUDENT's ADD has on her education, Dr. Patterson suggested that STUDENT simply be provided with a 504 accommodation plan. In sum, Dr. Patterson's diagnosis of STUDENT with ADHD was unsubstantiated and not supported by the evidence. Furthermore, although STUDENT may have inattentive qualities, evidence of her attentiveness establishes that she does not have a global ADHD disorder. Moreover, Petitioner failed to establish that the ADHD caused her discrepancy. For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have an ADHD processing disorder. Additionally, because STUDENT also does not have a visual or an auditory processing disorder, STUDENT is not found to have any psychological processing disorders. Thus, she does not qualify for special education or related services on this basis. The second reason why STUDENT does not qualify for special education and related services is because it has not been established that her discrepancy can not be corrected within the regular education classroom. Petitioner's asserted discrepancy is in the areas of dictation, capitalization, and punctuation. Petitioner contended that interventions have been in place for years, but have not been successful in correcting her discrepancy. Yet, all of the evidence Petitioner presented regarding interventions address STUDENT's problems completing her homework or class work and not her problems with dictation, capitalization, or punctuation. It is undisputed that STUDENT's low grades are attributable to her missing class assignments. Mr. Yaffee, STUDENT's fifth grade teacher, testified that he implemented a number of informal interventions to ensure that STUDENT understood the directions to the assignments. STUDENT's parents testified that STUDENT was placed on a homework plan during the sixth grade with the cooperation of her teachers, Ms. Shaver and Ms. McLean. According to Mr. Yaffee and STUDENT's parents, STUDENT continued to miss class and homework assignments despite the informal interventions. Petitioner has offered no evidence to establish that STUDENT's low grades resulted from her dictation, punctuation, or capitalization problems. In addition, Petitioner has presented no evidence to establish that interventions were in place to address these deficits. Interventions to assist STUDENT with turning in assignments is quite different from interventions to assist her with her dictation, punctuation, and capitalization problems. Moreover, there is no indication that STUDENT's problems with dictation, capitalization, and punctuation can not be addressed in a regular classroom. For the foregoing reasons, Petitioner has failed to establish that her discrepancy can not be remedied within the regular education classroom. Because Petitioner does not have a processing disorder and because Petitioner has not established that her discrepancy could not be corrected in a regular education classroom, she is not qualified for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. B. Serious Emotional Disturbance (SED) California Code of Regulations, Title 5, 3030(i) provides that a student qualifies for special education services as seriously emotionally disturbed if the pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. (5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. Of the five criteria, Petitioner presented evidence only on three criteria: the inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, the exhibition of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations, andthe expression of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Although Petitioner presented evidence that STUDENT has problems maintaining relationships with her peers, her teachers testified that she was able to maintain satisfactory relationships with them. (Testimony of Ms. Holland, Ms. Chang, and Mr. Yaffee.) Furthermore, STUDENT's problems with her peers were not to a marked degree. Mr. Yaffee testified that STUDENT's relationship with her peers was "neutral." According to Dr. Patterson's report, STUDENT's responses to the Personality Inventory for Youth indicated that she is "comfortable with her relationship with peers and defines such relationships as a source of satisfaction." Mr. Hutchinson, her current English teacher, testified that STUDENT gets along with students well, that she works well in groups, and that her social skills seemed age appropriate. Ms. Chang, STUDENT's current Algebra teacher, also testified that STUDENT worked well in groups. Additionally, she stated that STUDENT appeared social and would talk to students seated near her in the class. Finally, Ms. Holland, STUDENT's band teacher, testified that STUDENT has more friends this year than she did last year. Additionally, she observed that STUDENT made a new friend this year with whom she appeared close. Based on the above, STUDENT is not qualified for special education services as a seriously emotionally disturbed student with the inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. Petitioner also presented evidence that STUDENT would behave inappropriately at school. For example, Mr. Yaffee testified that STUDENT stood in front of his class and called the whole class a "dork." Petitioner also presented evidence that she was suspended from the school bus in the fourth grade for kicking a student and interfering with the safety of others on the bus. (Pet. Exh. C.) Additionally, while in the sixth grade, Petitioner was given on-campus suspension for making a racial slur towards another student. (Pet. Exh. F.) Although STUDENT may have acted inappropriately in the school environment, Petitioner presented no evidence that STUDENT behaved inappropriately in any other situation, such as at home or in public away from school. In fact, Petitioner only presented minimal and insignificant evidence regarding STUDENT's behavior at home in general. Moreover, STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors were not to a marked degree. Three such situations in three years are insufficient to qualify STUDENT for special education under this criterion. Furthermore, Petitioner presented no other significant evidence of inappropriate behaviors during this time. Finally, Petitioner presented evidence that STUDENT was diagnosed by her psychologist as being clinically depressed. However, in the independent assessment report procured by Petitioner, Dr. Patterson wrote that STUDENT's responses to the Personality Inventory for Youth and the Draw-A-Person test do not indicate clinical levels of depression. The District's psycho-educational assessment also did not result in a conclusion that STUDENT was clinically depressed. Even if STUDENT has exhibited symptoms of depression, her depression is not pervasive or to marked degree. STUDENT's parents testified that she currently is "happier" and in a "much better mood." Additionally, Mr. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT appears happier and more comfortable at school than she did at the beginning of the year. Because STUDENT does not exhibit a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, she is not eligible for special education services as a seriously emotionally disturbed student under this criterion. Moreover, because STUDENT does not meet any eligibility criteria under this section, STUDENT does not qualify for special education as a student with an SED.II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to appropriately assess STUDENT and by failing to identify STUDENT as a student qualified for special education? Because STUDENT has been found to be ineligible for special education services, there is no need to determine whether STUDENT was denied a FAPE. The issue of the appropriateness of the District's assessment will be discussed below when determining whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment performed by Dr. Robert Patterson.III. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for services provided for STUDENT? A. Counseling for STUDENT by Dr. Guerra Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and adjudicators have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994). As STUDENT is not qualified for special education, she is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her counseling with her psychologist, Dr. Guerra. Even assuming, arguendo, that she was qualified for special education, Petitioner has not established that her counseling was necessary for her to benefit from her education. Dr. Guerra was the only person to assess STUDENT as clinically depressed. In a letter by Dr. Guerra submitted into evidence by Petitioner, Dr. Guerra states that "STUDENT's performance at school, both socially and academically is being impacted by her depression." Yet, Dr. Guerra did not detail to what degree the depression has affected her education. He also did not state, and Petitioner presented no evidence, that his counseling has assisted STUDENT with her education. Rather, he reported that MOTHER related to him that STUDENT's behavior had improved through the use of anti-depressant medication prescribed by her physician, Dr. Kimura. Based on the above, Petitioner's request for reimbursement of her counseling expenses with Dr. Guerra is denied. B. Independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson California Education Code 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent assessment. Id. For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code 56320 and U.S.C. 1414(b), which generally states that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. The student must also be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. Additionally, pursuant to subsection (g) the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Moreover, psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Petitioner asserted that the District's assessment was inadequate for three primary reasons. First, Petitioner contended that the District did not assess STUDENT for central auditory processing and failed to diagnose her with ADD. Second, Petitioner alleged that the District's social/emotional/adaptive assessment was inadequate because it lacked "formal" testing procedures, failed to uncover her clinical depression, and lacked classroom observation by someone other than Petitioner's regular teacher. Third, Petitioner claimed that the psycho-educational assessment failed to accurately determine STUDENT's ability and, therefore, failed to properly identify a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement for SLD eligibility purposes. The District, on the other hand, contended that it assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability based on information available to them prior to assessment. The District asserted also that its assessment was timely, complete, and in accordance with all federal and State laws. 1. Testing for Central Auditory Processing and ADD Petitioner's first claim, that the District failed to assess STUDENT's auditory processing, is not supported by the evidence. On the signed assessment plan submitted by Petitioner, "perceptual/processing" was identified as an area in which STUDENT was to be assessed. (Pet. Exh. H.) Specifically, "Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills" (TAPS) was underlined, indicating that auditory processing needed to be tested. In the District's psycho-educational assessment, STUDENT was administered the TAPS in addition to the Visual Aural Digit Span Test (VADS) and the WRAML to evaluate STUDENT's auditory processing. (Dist. Exh. 6.) Moreover, in the District's speech and language assessment, STUDENT was given the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Revised (CELF-R), which tested STUDENT's processing of oral information. Both assessments concluded that STUDENT did not have an auditory processing disorder. Although Petitioner claimed that STUDENT should have been tested in the area of "central" auditory processing rather than auditory processing, Petitioner did not present significant evidence differentiating the two processes or why it was significant to test in one area and not the other. (Footnote 6) Thus, based on the above, the District adequately tested STUDENT in the area of auditory processing. Petitioner also asserted that the District should have been on notice of ADD as an area of suspected disability based on information from her cumulative file and communications with her parents. The District asserted that it had no knowledge of the need to assess STUDENT for ADD or ADHD. Again, Dr. Patterson assessed STUDENT for ADHD, a disorder which includes hyperactivity. As was discussed above, STUDENT's parents and teachers testified that STUDENT was not a hyperactive child. A number of STUDENT's teachers also testified that STUDENT did not have any attention problems. Of the teachers that observed STUDENT's inattentiveness, they reported that STUDENT appeared to make a conscious decision not to focus her attention. Furthermore, they reported that STUDENT's problems in school were not due to her inattentiveness, but rather they were due to her inability to turn in her assignments. Because STUDENT's conduct was within the range of normal children, the District had no reason based on STUDENT's educational history to suspect STUDENT as having ADHD.The District also asserted that Petitioner's parents did not communicate to them that they suspected STUDENT of having ADHD. STUDENT's mother testified that she indicated her suspicions of ADD to District personnel. The nurse's report for STUDENT's health evaluation also indicated that STUDENT's mother suspected that STUDENT had ADD. (Dist. Exh. 7.) However, the nurses report was completed weeks after the assessment plan was developed and days after the psycho-educational assessment had begun. In addition, speech and language specialist Theresa Myer testified that she was present at the meeting to develop STUDENT's assessment plan and she does not recall MOTHER's indicating ADD as an area of concern. Furthermore, Marlyse Linder testified that MOTHER was concerned only with central auditory processing assessments and did not mention ADD or behavioral problems. Moreover, it was found above that STUDENT does not have ADHD. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not told by STUDENT's parents of their suspicions that STUDENT had ADHD. Because it is found that the District did not have adequate grounds (either from STUDENT's educational history or from discussions with STUDENT's parents) to suspect ADHD as an area of disability, the District had no responsibility to assess STUDENT in this area. 2. Testing in the social/emotional/adaptive area Petitioner's second claim, which alleged that the District's social/emotional/adaptive assessment was inadequate, was not supported by the evidence. Petitioner set forth three grounds why she believed the District's social/emotional/adaptive assessment to be inappropriate: it lacked "formal" testing procedures, failed to uncover her clinical depression, and lacked classroom observation by someone other than Petitioner's regular teacher. Petitioner appears to assert that such testing is inappropriate because no "formal" testing was used. However, it is clear that Ms. Linder used teacher rating scales, a formal assessment tool, in her assessment. According to the District's psycho-educational assessment, STUDENT's social/emotional/adaptive assessment included teacher rating scales, an interview with STUDENT, observations of STUDENT during the assessment, and a review of STUDENT's school records and teacher's reports. Moreover, Dr. Schnel testified that such a broad examination into a student's behavior at school yields more information than "formal" tests. Petitioner also contended that the District's social/emotional/adaptive assessment was inappropriate because it failed to uncover STUDENT's clinical depression. Although Petitioner's psychologist, Dr. Guerra, diagnosed her as being clinically depressed, her independent assessment contradicts such a diagnosis. In his report, Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT's scores on the Personality Inventory for Youth (PIY) did not indicate that STUDENT was clinically depressed. Dr. Patterson's assessment clearly puts into question whether STUDENT is in fact clinically depressed. The mere fact that the District did not diagnose STUDENT as being clinically depressed, particularly when such diagnosis is in dispute, is not a ground to find the District's assessment inappropriate. Finally, Petitioner contends that the social/emotional/adaptive assessment must include classroom observations by someone other than the regular teacher. However, the provision Petitioner relies on is a proposed regulation which has not been adopted into law. See 34 C.F.R. 300.542. Here, Ms. Linder testified that she did not observe STUDENT in class. Furthermore, no evidence was presented by the District to establish that STUDENT was ever observed in class by an appropriate person as part of the assessment. Although the District's assessment did not include classroom observations by someone other than the regular teacher, it is not required to include this information under existing law. 3. Testing to determine STUDENT's academic ability Third, Petitioner's assertion that the District's assessment failed to adequately determine STUDENT's ability is not supported by the evidence. Petitioner asserted that the District inappropriately relied on general standardized testing in determining STUDENT's ability. However, the District's determination of STUDENT's ability was based on a plethora of information. Although the District did not conduct a standardized intelligence test, STUDENT was given the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) and various subtests of the WJ-R and WRAML. Ms. Linder, testified that she considered STUDENT's scores on these tests in addition to her grades, former intelligence test score, general standardized test scores, report cards, and teacher reports to determine STUDENT's ability range. Regardless of Petitioner's claims to the contrary, IEP teams may use this ability range to determine ability/achievement discrepancies under California Code of Regulations 3030(j)(4)(B). In sum, the District's assessment was appropriate in all areas. Because the District's assessment was appropriate, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for her independent assessment. IV. Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT in the area of social/emotional adaptive behavior? It has been found above that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services because she does not meet the eligibility requirements for SLD or SED. Thus, the Hearing Officer fails to see the need for a reassessment of STUDENT in the area of social/emotional adaptive behavior. Therefore, the District is not entitled to assess in these areas.V. Is the District required to assess STUDENT in the area of central auditory processing? Petitioner asserted that the District failed to provide STUDENT a central auditory processing (CAP) assessment and should be required to do so. It has been found above that the District's assessment of STUDENT in the area of auditory processing was appropriate. Petitioner has presented no significant evidence setting forth the difference between auditory processing and CAP or why STUDENT requires a CAP assessment instead of (or in addition to) her auditory processing assessment. A CAP assessment at this point is not necessary. Thus, the District is not required to assess STUDENT in the area of central auditory processing.ORDER All Petitioner's claims are denied. Additionally, the District is not entitled to reassess STUDENT in the area of social/emotional/adaptive behavior.PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:I. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or serious emotional disturbance (SED)? The District prevailed on this issue.II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to appropriately assess STUDENT and by failing to identify STUDENT as a student qualified for special education? The District prevailed on this issue.III. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of: A. counseling for STUDENT by Dr. Guerra, and The District prevailed on this issue. B. the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson? The District prevailed on this issue. IV. Is the District entitled to reassess STUDENT in the area of social/emotional adaptive behavior? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.V. Is the District required to assess STUDENT in the area of central auditory processing? The District prevailed on this issue.RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).DATED: March 11, 1999 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes: 1. The parties mutually agreed to schedule the hearing for October 15 and 16, 1998, during mid-August, two months prior. The Hearing Office sent to the parties confirmation of the hearing dates on August 28, 1998.2. Petitioner's statement of issues presents as an issue for hearing whether STUDENT should be qualified for special education services, but does not set forth the eligibility category under which Petitioner should qualify. At hearing Petitioner's evidence focused solely on SLD and SED. Thus, the decision will address whether STUDENT is qualified for special education as a student with SLD or SED.3. The District made no mention in its closing statement of Petitioner's claim that Petitioner is qualified for special education as a student with an SED.4. Instead of letter grades, students at Mark Twain School were scored on a six point scale: 1=Emergent, 2=Limited, 3=Developing, 4=Competent, 5=Strong, and 6=Exceptional.5. The parties agree that two assessment plans were drafted for approval by STUDENT's parents. However, the Hearing Officer notes that four different exhibits of assessment plans (i.e., each party had a set of two assessment plans) were submitted by the parties. Because the parties agree to the contents of the final, signed assessment plan, it is unnecessary to determine the contents of the first assessment plan.6. In her closing brief, Petitioner claimed that Ms. Linder "failed to address" STUDENT's low scores on various subtests for auditory processing. However, the scores she cited relate to testing for visual processing and not auditory processing.
