California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 23, 2004

Student v. Mount Diablo Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1701-04, SN-1701-04 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Mount Diablo Unified's special day class placement upheld; Hearing Officer awards two PT sessions and six tutoring hours.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 9 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 says the original decision, issued September 23, 2004, had an incorrect date in its first sentence, and that this version corrects it with no substantive changes. The parent's September 2004 motion to reconsider stay put was treated as moot because this decision resolved the dispute.

Summary

The parent of a six-year-old girl filed for due process without a lawyer and represented her at the hearing. The girl was eligible for special education under speech-language impairment. She had global developmental delays and verbal apraxia, and she spent kindergarten in Mount Diablo Unified's severely handicapped special day class at Strandwood Elementary. The parent sought full-time general education with sign language support, or a nonpublic school for deaf and hard-of-hearing students. She also asked for more speech, OT and PT services and a year-round program.

Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown found that the girl's hearing was normal. Sign language was not her native language, so testing did not have to be given in sign. Teachers and therapists testified credibly that the class's structure and small size, plus the existing speech, OT, assistive technology and PT services, met her needs, and that she made progress. Under the Rachel H. test, the special day class was her least restrictive environment, and the District offered a FAPE for 2004-2005 as well.

The District did fall short in two minor ways. First, it missed two or three PT sessions in November 2003 and never made them up. Second, it offered only four weeks of summer 2004 school (ESY) when she needed six. The Hearing Officer rejected a year-round program. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 30 days and add two 45-minute PT sessions and six hours of one-to-one tutoring. All other claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley and the Rachel H. test when all of a child's teachers, including an outside preschool teacher and an independent neuropsychologist, recommended a special day class. It also shows how witness testimony about a child's actual communication decided whether sign language was her native language for testing.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A(1). For 2003-2004, was the District's program designed to meet Student's unique needs, including assessment in her native language and in all areas of suspected disability (hearing, processing), sign language, OT, speech-language, AT, PT and classroom placement?

    Sign language was not the student's native language, hearing and processing were not areas of suspected disability, and the SH-SDC with existing OT, speech, AT and PT services met her needs.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A(2). Was the 2003-2004 program reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit?

    The student made meaningful progress in class, OT and speech-language, so the program was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

  3. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 1A(3). Did the District provide OT, AT, PT and APE in conformity with the IEP?

    OT co-treatment, AT and APE conformed to the IEP; two or three PT sessions missed in November 2003 and never made up were a minor, de minimis nonconformity.

  4. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1A(4). Was the SH-SDC the least restrictive environment, or did Student require general education with sign language supports?

    Applying Rachel H., the SH-SDC's far greater academic benefits outweighed the limited non-academic benefits of general education, so it was the LRE.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1B. Did the District fail to give prior written notice of its denial of the parent's request for more speech therapy?

    Any lack of separate written notice did not deny FAPE, because the parent knew of the denial and the reasons, and agreed to a compromise written into the IEP.

  6. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 2. For ESY in summer 2004, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide an adequate number of weeks of ESY services?

    The four-week ESY offer was a minor denial of FAPE because she needed six weeks to avoid regression; a year-round program with no break over two weeks was not required.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

    The 2004-2005 offer was essentially the same as the appropriate 2003-2004 program, so it offered a FAPE.

  8. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. For 2004-2005, does Student require placement at a certified nonpublic school that provides deaf/hard-of-hearing services?

    Because the District offered a FAPE and the student has normal hearing, there was no basis to order a nonpublic school placement.

  9. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is Student entitled to compensatory education as a remedy for the District's denials of FAPE?

    She was awarded two 45-minute PT sessions and six hours of one-to-one academic tutoring; all other relief was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must notify IEP team members of an IEP meeting to be held no later than 30 days after the decision date, to add the compensatory services.
  • Compensatory education. Two additional 45-minute physical therapy sessions for sessions missed in November 2003.
  • Compensatory education. Six hours of one-to-one academic tutoring by a certificated teacher or experienced tutor, for possible regression from the shortened summer 2004 ESY offer. The District may provide it directly or contract with a nonpublic school or agency.

Total: 7.5 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Poolaw v. Bishop; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Capistrano Unified School Dist. v. Wartenberg

People named in the decision

  • Carrie Davis, special education teacher (SH-SDC), Mount Diablo Unified School District, Strandwood Elementary
  • Diane Lund, general education kindergarten teacher, Strandwood Elementary
  • Shirlee Jack, speech-language pathologist, Mount Diablo Unified School District (former)
  • Elizabeth (Liz) Wall, occupational therapist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Nell McBeth, physical therapist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Susie Smario, adaptive physical education teacher, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Joyce Teekell, assistive technology consultant, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Corrie Martell, OT/PT supervisor, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Pam Tradup-Mahloch, school psychologist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Colleen Peterson, audiologist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Barbara Scott, program specialist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Sharon Krell, program specialist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Katie Hanau-Gaines, program manager, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Ken Ferro, program specialist / alternative dispute resolution administrator, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Brenda Olsen, special education assistant / sign language interpreter during 2004 ESY, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Jennifer Chop, special education teacher (CH-SDC, 2002-2003), Gregory Gardens Center
  • Theresa Borges, director and preschool teacher, Mary Jane's Preschool & Kindergarten (private)
  • Suzanne Bauer, school bus driver
  • Dr. Corrina Grandison, independent neuropsychologist, Children's Hospital Oakland
  • Lynn Terrill, preschool SDC teacher, Shadelands Preschool
  • Susan Petersdorf, preschool SH-SDC teacher (2003 ESY), Gregory Gardens Center
  • Darlene Harvey, SDC teacher (2004 ESY), Valhalla Elementary School
  • Berry Murray, program specialist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Kathy Egan, speech-language pathologist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Mary Jo Zulli, occupational therapist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
  • Doug Dildine, youth coordinator assisting Student, Independent Living Resource
  • Chad Dickerson, Regional Center case manager assisting Student, Regional Center of the East Bay
  • Elizabeth Estes, attorney for District (first day)
  • Dora Dome, attorney (observer)
  • Barbara Milliff Children's Center, early intervention provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing in Concord, California, on July 22-23, 27-30, and August 4, 6, 10-12, 2004, before Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. FATHER, STUDENT’s father, Doug Dildine, youth coordinator for Independent Living Resource, and Chad Dickerson, STUDENT’s case manager at the Regional Center of the East Bay, each attended the hearing on some days and assisted in representing STUDENT. Several other individuals, including members of STUDENT’s family, also attended the hearing as observers.

Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Mount Diablo Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Elizabeth Rho-Ng. District special education teacher Carrie Davis attended the hearing on behalf of the District. Attorney Elizabeth Estes attended the first day of hearing on behalf of the District. District program specialist Ken Ferro attended the hearing on one day. Attorney Dora Dome attended the hearing for part of one day as an observer.

Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Suzanne Bauer, school bus driver; Theresa Borges, director of Mary Jane’s Preschool; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; STEP GRANDFATHER, STUDENT’s step-grandfather; and Jennifer Chop, special education teacher. (Footnote 2)

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Brenda Olsen, special education assistant; Barbara Scott, program specialist; Colleen Peterson, audiologist; Pam Tradup-Mahloch, school psychologist; Sharon Krell, program specialist; Katie Hanau-Gaines, program manager; and Corrie Martell, occupational therapy/physical therapy supervisor.

Both parties called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Diane Lund, kindergarten teacher; Nell McBeth, physical therapist; Susie Smario, adaptive physical education (APE) teacher; Joyce Teekell, assistive technology consultant; Elizabeth Wall, occupational therapist; Carrie Davis, special education teacher; and Shirlee Jack, speech-language pathologist. (Footnote 3) Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the written briefs on September 8, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. (Footnote 4)

ISSUES (Footnote 5)

1. Did the District deny the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

2. For the extended school year (ESY) in summer 2004, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide an adequate number of weeks of ESY services?

3. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

4. For the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at a certified nonpublic school that provides deaf/hard-of-hearing services?

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a remedy for the District’s denials of FAPE?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Motions for Stay Put

On June 17, 2004, the Hearing Office received from the Student a motion for a stay put order. After receiving the District’s response to the motion, the Hearing Office issued an Order Granting Stay Put dated June 24, 2004. That order held that STUDENT’s last agreed-upon placement for the regular school year was pursuant to her individualized education program (IEP) signed on April 6, 2004, and her last agreed-upon placement for the extended school year (ESY) was pursuant to her IEP dated March 27, 2003.

On September 14, 2004, the Hearing Office received from the Student a motion for reconsideration of the stay put order dated June 24, 2004. The Student argued that the placement was no longer appropriate for her. On September 21, 2004, the Hearing Office received the District’s response to the Student’s motion.

Stay put protections extend to special education students pending resolution of due process hearing procedures. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56500(d).) In the present case, this Decision resolves STUDENT’s due process hearing procedures. Because this dispute is no longer pending, there is no need and no basis for a stay put order.

Matters Re: Hearing Issues and Contentions

The Hearing Officer conducted a prehearing conference in this matter by telephone on July 19 and 20, 2004, and issued the resulting prehearing conference order on July 21, 2004. During the prehearing conference, for the first time the Student indicated that she would be raising issues concerning the denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, although Student’s previous statement of issues had not identified those school years as issues for this hearing. As noted in the Prehearing Conference Order, the District objected to the Student’s addition of issues fewer than ten days prior to the hearing and moved to strike the new issues. The Hearing Officer ruled that, particularly considering that the Student was not represented by an attorney or advocate, the motion to strike was denied. The Hearing Officer ordered that the remedy for the Student’s late addition of issues would be a continuance to allow the District timely notice of the issues. The District indicated that it would consider whether to request a continuance, but was not yet making that request.

On July 21, 2004, the Hearing Office received from the District a written motion to dismiss Petitioner’s issues concerning time periods prior to March 27, 2003, on the grounds of res judicata and collateral estoppel. The basis for this argument concerned the Student’s prior due process filing in 2002, which the Hearing Office had identified as case SN02-01460. In a letter to the Hearing Office dated March 27, 2003, the Student withdrew that request for hearing. In its motion, the District argued that the Student’s withdrawal of the prior due process matter, SN02-01460, precluded the Student from raising any issues in the present matter that could have been raised at that time. At the hearing on July 22, the Hearing Officer heard the Student’s oral argument in opposition to the motion. After hearing arguments from both parties, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion on the grounds that the Student’s withdrawal of SN02-01460 did not constitute a final judgment on the merits which would preclude the Student from relitigating claims that were raised or could have been raised in that matter. Because the Student withdrew SN02-01460 before any hearing ever convened in that matter, there was no basis for finding that prejudice had attached. The parties did not enter into any type of written settlement agreement in that matter, and there was no other indication that the Student had in any way waived her right to litigate those claims. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion to dismiss issues arising prior to March 27, 2003.

In the alternative, the District’s written motion argued that the present matter should be bifurcated so that the hearing regarding the timely-noticed issues could go forward that day while the issues newly identified during the prehearing conference would be heard in a separate, subsequent hearing. When the hearing convened on July 22, 2004, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion to bifurcate on the grounds that such bifurcation would require calling many of the same witnesses twice, would increase the total number of hearing days in this matter, and would be contrary to judicial economy. Instead, the Hearing Officer reiterated that the remedy for late addition of issues would be a continuance to provide ten days notice of the issues. The Hearing Officer ruled that, in light of the Student’s new issues raised during the prehearing telephone conference, good cause existed for a ten-day continuance of the hearing. In response, the Student indicated that she would agree to dismiss with prejudice the issues concerning the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years in exchange for the District’s agreement to withdraw the request for continuance. The District agreed to this proposal. In light of this agreement, the hearing went forward and the Student’s issues concerning the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years were dismissed in accordance with the agreement of the parties.

When clarifying her issues for hearing during the prehearing telephone conference on July 19 and 20, 2004, Student raised claims concerning the use of and need for sign language in her educational program. Student did not specify that she was referring to a particular sign language, such as American Sign Language (ASL) or Signing Exact English (SEE). During the course of the hearing, STUDENT’s mother asserted that sign language refers only to ASL and not to SEE. In response, the Hearing Officer clarified that because the reference to “sign language” in the issues was not specific to a particular sign language, it could refer to either ASL or SEE. The Hearing Officer ruled that, because no claim regarding the appropriateness of ASL over SEE had been included in the Student’s issues, the question of whether STUDENT needs ASL instead of SEE was not at issue and therefore would not be litigated in this hearing.

During the course of the hearing, the hearing participants clarified that Student’s claims concerning the 2004 extended school year (ESY) concerned only an alleged denial of FAPE due to the number of weeks of ESY services the District offered. The parties clarified that Student’s issues for hearing did not include a claim regarding a denial of stay put for the 2004 ESY. Student indicated that she may file a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education concerning stay put for that period, but was not raising a stay put issue for the due process hearing.

On the final day of the hearing in this matter, Student indicated that she was withdrawing two claims previously identified in her issue statement. Student withdrew her claim that the District failed to provide her speech-language therapy in conformity with her IEP during the 2003-2004 school year. Additionally, Student modified the issues to drop her request for prospective placement at California School for the Deaf - Fremont. (Footnote 6) Instead, Student’s sole request for prospective placement is at an unspecified certified nonpublic school that provides services for deaf and hard-of-hearing students. (Footnote 7)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], is a six-year-old student who lives within the boundaries of the District with her parents and her two sisters. STUDENT has been found eligible for special education under the category of speech-language impairment. STUDENT’s most recent placement has been at the District’s Strandwood Elementary School (Strandwood).

When STUDENT was two years old, the Regional Center of the East Bay (Regional Center) determined that she qualified for Regional Center services due to delays in communication, social skills, and adaptive skills. Through the Regional Center, in February 2001 STUDENT began receiving services from the Barbara Milliff Children’s Center. Pursuant to a referral from STUDENT’s doctor, a District speech-language pathologist assessed her speech and language development at the Mount Diablo Therapy Center in July 2001. That report diagnosed STUDENT with severe receptive and expressive language delays and referred her for speech therapy at Children’s Hospital of Oakland.

In September 2001, the District conducted its initial comprehensive assessment of STUDENT in areas including speech, language, social skills, self-help, fine and gross motor skills, health and development. The assessors concluded that STUDENT appeared to function at the developmental level of a twenty-two-month old child, compared to her chronological age of thirty-seven months, and noted significant delays in expressive and receptive language.

On September 25, 2001, STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) team convened to review the results of the initial assessment, determine STUDENT’s eligibility, and offer her an educational program. On September 26, 2001, STUDENT underwent a developmental/behavioral evaluation at Children’s Hospital; the resulting diagnoses included mental retardation, language and communication delays, and sensory integration issues. On September 28, 2001, STUDENT was discharged from the Barbara Milliff Children’s Center in anticipation of her entry into a District school. On October 1, 2001, STUDENT began attending a preschool special day class (SDC) taught by Lynn Terrill for communicatively handicapped (CH) students at the District’s Shadelands Preschool (Shadelands). STUDENT’s program at Shadelands included designated instruction and services (DIS) of speech therapy and occupational therapy (OT). Also in early October 2001, the Regional Center notified STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT continued to be eligible for Regional Center services due to her developmental delays. In November 2001, DIS physical therapy (PT) was added to STUDENT’s program.

STUDENT’s mother reported that, in November 2001, she gave Ms. Terrill a copy of the Regional Center report that identified STUDENT as mentally retarded. Shortly thereafter, Ms. Terrill recommended that STUDENT transfer to a severely handicapped (SH) SDC at Shadelands. STUDENT’s mother agreed to try the new classroom, but after a few months decided that it was not appropriate for STUDENT. In February 2002, STUDENT’s parents removed her from Shadelands. At an IEP meeting on March 6, 2002, STUDENT’s mother agreed to return her to the Shadelands SH-SDC but for fewer hours per week, to allow STUDENT time to participate in other activities. Also in March 2002, STUDENT began receiving additional speech therapy sessions privately.

In June 2002, STUDENT attended ESY at a different SDC. MOTHER informed the District that she did not agree with this SDC placement and sought to have STUDENT placed with higher-functioning students. In July 2002, STUDENT’s parents filed for due process hearing, which the Hearing Office identified as case SN02-01460. In August 2002, the parties reached an interim agreement in SN02-01460. In September 2002, STUDENT began attending afternoon preschool classes twice a week at Mary Jane’s Preschool & Kindergarten (Mary Jane’s), a private preschool/kindergarten, in which the student population primarily consisted of typically developing children.

After IEP meetings in September and October 2002, STUDENT returned to school in the District and attended a CH-SDC taught by Jennifer Chop at the District’s Gregory Gardens Center (Gregory Gardens). STUDENT resumed her DIS at school and also continued to attend her general education preschool class at Mary Jane’s. STUDENT remained in both Ms. Chop’s SDC at Gregory Gardens and in her preschool class at Mary Jane’s for the rest of the 2002-2003 regular school year.

On March 27, 2003, the IEP team convened and the District offered STUDENT’s placement for the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s mother presented the rest of the team members with a letter requesting an assessment for augmentative communication and a separate letter proposing changes to STUDENT’s services that, if adopted, would resolve the due process dispute in SN02-01460. The IEP participants reached agreement and adopted many of the parent’s requests, including an assistive technology assessment. The parties agreed to the District’s proposed placement in kindergarten at an SDC at the District’s Strandwood Elementary School (Strandwood) with DIS of speech therapy, OT, PT, and adaptive physical education (APE). The IEP document indicated that “STUDENT’s academics will be supported with sign language” and also that the IEP team would meet “within first 5-7 weeks of 2003-2004 school year to determine appropriate amount of GEN ED inclusion for the student.” (Emphasis in original.) STUDENT’s mother signed her consent to the IEP and notified the Hearing Office that she was withdrawing case SN02-01460. In spring 2003, assistive technology consultant Joyce Teekell evaluated STUDENT and thereafter began presenting assistive technology measures for STUDENT, including voice output communication aide (VOCA) devices such as a “talking photo album.”

In a letter dated May 22, 2003, STUDENT’s parents requested an IEP meeting to change STUDENT’s placement to a general education classroom. In a separate letter of the same date, the parents requested an assessment to determine what supports and services STUDENT would need in a general education classroom. In a letter dated July 3, 2003, District program specialist Berry Murray responded that the IEP team had already addressed STUDENT’s placement at the IEP meeting on March 27, 2003, and indicated that the IEP team could reconvene in September once the new school year began.

In July and August 2003, STUDENT attended ESY at Gregory Gardens in a preschool SH-SDC taught by Susan Petersdorf. In September 2003, STUDENT began attending her kindergarten year at the SH-SDC taught by Carrie Davis at Strandwood. STUDENT’s program included her DIS and mainstreaming time that the SDC students had with the general education kindergarten students. This mainstreaming time included recess and work on academic “stations” once a week.

On September 29, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team met to discuss mainstreaming and implementation of DIS. From October to December 2003, STUDENT attended a regular education kindergarten class at Strandwood for 100 minutes per day four days per week, accompanied by Ms. Davis or a classroom assistant from the SDC. During that period, STUDENT’s IEP team convened three times to discuss how to implement this increase in STUDENT’s mainstreaming time. In December 2003, the IEP team members agreed that the additional mainstreaming was not helpful for STUDENT and therefore agreed to return STUDENT to her SDC for the 400 minutes per week that she had previously spent in the general education kindergarten. For the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT continued to attend the SH-SDC as her classroom placement, with mainstreaming during recess and weekly “station time,” and continued to receive DIS of speech-language, OT, PT, APE, and assistive technology.

In December 2003, STUDENT’s mother signed her consent to an assessment plan for STUDENT’s triennial reassessment. In January and February 2004, STUDENT was assessed by her SDC teacher, her speech-language therapist, her occupational therapist, her physical therapist, and her adaptive physical education (APE) teacher. Also during this time, the District staff and STUDENT’s parents agreed to refer STUDENT for a neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Corrina Grandison, a neuropsychologist at Children’s Hospital in Oakland.

The IEP team met on February 20, March 16, and April 6, 2004, to review STUDENT’s three-year reevaluation reports and review her progress and placement. During these discussions, school psychologist Pam Tradup-Mahloch stated that the assessment data supported changing STUDENT’s eligibility category from speech-language impairment to mildly cognitively impaired. On March 16, 2004, Ms. Tradup-Mahloch filled out an Eligibility Criteria Statement form that identified STUDENT as meeting the criteria for the eligibility category of mildly cognitively impaired. STUDENT’s mother expressed reservations about changing STUDENT’s eligibility category and the team agreed to revisit the matter after receiving the results of Dr. Grandison’s assessment.

The IEP document continued STUDENT’s placement in an SH-SDC at Strandwood, noting that she would spend eighty-five percent of her time in a special education setting and fifteen percent of her time in a mainstream setting. The IEP continued to provide DIS including OT, PT, APE, and speech-language therapy. The IEP team members, including STUDENT’s mother, accepted the triennial assessment reports and signed their consent to the IEP on April 6, 2004. However, in a letter dated April 9, 2004, STUDENT’s parents wrote that they revoked their consent to the psychoeducational report, stating that it “does not accurately represent STUDENT’s abilities....STUDENT’s main disability remains in effect which is stated as Apraxia.” (Dist. Exh. 43, p. 204.) The parents’ letter also requested an increase in STUDENT’s speech-language therapy during the school year and additional PT services during the summer. On April 30, 2004, the parents agreed that the District would provide STUDENT with one forty-five-minute PT session during August 2004, and thereafter the District sent the parents a Memorandum of Understanding to that effect.

Dr. Grandison assessed STUDENT in April 2004, and issued her report in May 2004. Dr. Grandison found in part that STUDENT’s diagnoses included severe language impairment of verbal apraxia, mild mental retardation, and significant motor problems. She reported that STUDENT was appropriately placed in her SDC, but that she needed at least half an hour of speech-language therapy per day, additional OT and PT, and a year-round program with a break of no longer than two weeks during the summer.

Dr. Grandison discussed her findings with the IEP team at an IEP meeting on June 2, 2004. The District members of the IEP team indicated that they agreed with Dr. Grandison’s findings about STUDENT’s diagnoses and placement, but disagreed with the recommendations regarding increased speech-language and ESY services. MOTHER did not sign her consent to the IEP. Also during the meeting, MOTHER requested an increase in STUDENT’s services pursuant to Dr. Grandison’s recommendations and indicated that she would be requesting stay put regarding STUDENT’s placement for the ESY. MOTHER also requested that STUDENT’s OT goals be expanded to address self-care skills. In response to this request, STUDENT’s occupational therapist drafted three new self-care goals and sent them to STUDENT’s parents for their review and approval.

On June 14, 2004, the Hearing Office received the Student’s request for due process hearing, and on June 17 received the Student’s request for stay put. In a letter dated June 16, 2004, the District’s alternative dispute resolution (ADR) administrator, Ken Ferro, reiterated the District’s offer of placement and services to STUDENT and denied the parents’ request for a longer ESY with no more than a two-week summer break. The letter offered a six-week ESY program for STUDENT in an SDC at Gregory Gardens beginning June 21, 2004. The letter also denied the parents’ requests for an independent assistive technology assessment by an outside agency and for increased OT and PT services.

In a letter dated June 23, 2004, MOTHER disputed the assertions made in Mr. Ferro’s June 16 letter. In particular, MOTHER wrote that she had received Mr. Ferro’s letter on June 19 and had therefore gotten STUDENT ready to begin her ESY class on the mornings of June 21 and June 22, but asserted that the bus never arrived to pick STUDENT up for school.

On June 24, 2004, the Hearing Office issued an order granting the Student’s request for stay put. The order ruled that STUDENT’s stay put placement for the 2004-2005 school year was the SDC placement and DIS identified in her IEPs dated February 20, 2004, and April 6, 2004, and her stay put placement and services for the ESY was a six-week program in an SDC pursuant to her IEP dated March 27, 2003.

On July 1, 2004, MOTHER went to the District office and spoke with District program manager Katie Hanau-Gaines about finding a 2004 ESY placement for STUDENT. MOTHER indicated that she did not believe the District’s proposed program, a six-week ESY program in an SDC at Gregory Gardens, would be an appropriate placement and therefore she had rejected that proposal. After discussion, MOTHER and Ms. Hanau-Gaines agreed that STUDENT would attend an SDC taught by Darlene Harvey at the District’s Valhalla Elementary School (Valhalla), where an instructional assistant proficient in sign language would also be present. (Footnote 8) On July 2, 2004, STUDENT began attending the Valhalla SDC for four weeks of the 2004 ESY. STUDENT also received DIS of speech-language, OT, PT, and APE during that four-week ESY.

This matter proceeded to hearing beginning on July 22, 2004, and concluded on August 12, 2004. The parties both timely submitted their closing briefs postmarked on September 2, 2004. On September 14, 2004, the Hearing Office received from Student a motion for reconsideration of the current stay put order in this matter, and thereafter received the District’s opposition to the motion on September 21, 2004. According to the allegations contained in those filings, STUDENT did not return to attending school at the District when the new school year began in early September 2004. Instead, STUDENT’s parents indicated that they wish to “home-school” her rather than return her to an SDC at Strandwood.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District deny the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) FAPE is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

The determination of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.)

A. Substantive Appropriateness

Under the IDEA and the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and be in conformity with his or her IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.) To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) The Rowley opinion explained that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208.) However, the District has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it offered an appropriate educational program for the student. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).)

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45; see also Sacramento City Unified School Dist., Bd. of Educ. v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir.1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

To summarize, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley require that an appropriate program: (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. Additionally, the program must be provided in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 893 (9th Cir.1995).)

(1) Designed To Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs for the 2003-2004 school year, this Decision must first ascertain what STUDENT’s unique needs were. As a preliminary determination, the Hearing Officer first considers Student’s claims that the District failed to accurately assess her.

Sign Language

Student argues that the District failed to accurately assess her because District assessors failed to conduct testing in her native language of sign language and English. The District argues that sign language was not STUDENT’s native language and that she did not require the testing to be conducted in sign language.

Tests and other evaluation materials used to conduct a special education assessment of a child must be provided and administered in the child’s native language or other mode of communication, unless it is clearly not feasible to do so. (Footnote 9) (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(1).) There is no dispute that, to the extent that District assessors used language in assessing STUDENT, testing was conducted in English. (Footnote 10)

Student contends that she frequently used sign language to communicate, that ASL and “gestural communication” constituted her native language, and therefore testing should have been conducted in sign language. (Footnote 11) The evidence established that MOTHER and other family members frequently signed in ASL to STUDENT and that MOTHER has been teaching STUDENT to use ASL. (Footnote 12) During both the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, STUDENT’s teachers and service providers used sign language to augment their verbal instruction to her. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Jack, Elizabeth Wall, Jennifer Chop, Nell McBeth, Susie Smario, Theresa Borges, Brenda Olsen; Student Exh. Tab III, p. 79, 81; Dist. Exh. 1, p.1.) Indeed, in discussing STUDENT’s delayed language skills, Dr. Grandison briefly noted that “alternative modalities such as signing and computer devices should be explored to the fullest.” (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 99.)

However, the evidence did not support the Student’s assertion that ASL was her native language. Instead, the various teachers and service providers who worked with STUDENT generally testified that she knew some signs but did not use sign language as her primary means of expressing herself. (Testimony of Ms. Borges, Ms. Davis, Ms. Chop, Ms. Jack, Ms. Olsen, Ms. Teekell, Ms. Smario, Ms. McBeth, Ms. Wall, Ms. Lund.) Moreover, the witness testimony indicated that STUDENT appeared to understand speech as well as or better than sign language. For example, Brenda Olsen, a special education assistant who acted as a sign language interpreter for STUDENT for the 2004 ESY, testified that STUDENT often did not pay attention when Ms. Olsen signed to her, and responded better when Ms. Olsen used her voice instead of sign language. Ms. Olsen, who testified that she is familiar with both ASL and SEE, reported that she had seen STUDENT use a total of four or five signs. Ms. Olsen stated that STUDENT tended to use her voice and gestures, not sign language, as her primary means of communication. (Footnote 13) Similarly, Ms. Davis, STUDENT’s SDC teacher in 2003-2004, testified that she had never seen STUDENT initiate a conversation using sign language, although STUDENT would sometimes imitate sign language when other people used it. Ms. Davis also testified that STUDENT would not necessarily watch when someone was signing to her.

The testimonies of Ms. Olsen and Ms. Davis are also consistent with the testimony of Theresa Borges, STUDENT’s private preschool teacher for the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Borges is a knowledgeable, experienced teacher and was an objective, credible witness. In particular, her credibility was enhanced by the fact that she is not a District employee and, although the Student called her as a witness, did not appear to tailor her testimony to either party’s position. Ms. Borges testified that STUDENT knew a few ASL signs but did not sign expressively, except for sometimes making the sign for “toilet.” Ms. Borges testified that STUDENT’s primary mode of expressive communication was gestures, supplemented by speech. Ms. Borges indicated that STUDENT generally understood verbal instructions better when paired with gestures or signs, although Ms. Borges noted that she tended to use more SEE signs than ASL signs when instructing STUDENT.

Similarly, SDC teacher Jennifer Chop testified that sign language was not STUDENT’s native language. Ms. Chop testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate sign language while she attended Ms. Chop’s CH-SDC for the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Chop explained that she had suggested supporting STUDENT’s academics with sign language so that STUDENT would have an additional means of communication, not because STUDENT needed sign language as her primary way of understanding.

Documentary evidence supported the testimony of the witnesses on this point. For example, in the March 2003 IEP, speech-language pathologist Kathy Egan described STUDENT’s present level of performance in part as “STUDENT communicates using a combination of: single word SEE signs, gestures, facial expressions & vocalizations, which she is gradually shaping into word approximation.” (Dist. Exh. 23a, p. 102a.) The following year, in STUDENT’s triennial speech-language evaluation dated February 5, 2004, speech-language pathologist Shirlee Jack described how STUDENT used vocalizations, gestures and movements to expressively communicate, but did not mention STUDENT using sign language. (Dist. Exh. 32, p. 118-120.)

Student argues that District staff did not recognize her ASL signs as attempts to communicate because the staff members did not know ASL. This argument was not persuasive because several of the District witnesses indicated that they knew some ASL signs and would recognize if STUDENT were using a sign to communicate, even if they did not know what the particular sign meant. Indeed, except for Ms. Lund, the general education kindergarten teacher, all of the educators testified that they knew at least a few signs, whether ASL or SEE, and that they used some signs when instructing STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Jack, Ms. Olsen, Ms. Smario, Ms. McBeth, Ms. Borges, Ms. Wall.) Hence, if ASL was in fact STUDENT’s “native language,” she would likely feel encouraged to use sign language, whether ASL or SEE, in such an atmosphere; however, her instructors never observed this.

In light of the consistent, credible evidence on this topic, the Hearing Officer finds that gestures and speech were STUDENT’s primary means of communication, not sign language. Hence, ASL was not STUDENT’s native or primary language. Therefore, the testing in her special education assessment did not need to be administered using sign language.

Audiological Assessment

Student alleges that the District failed to conduct an audiological testing every year, contrary to the recommendations of a District audiological assessment conducted in October 2001. The District argues that audiology was not an area of suspected disability and that STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment.

Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted in all areas related to the suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) Thereafter, special education students must be reassessed every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a new assessment and that a new IEP be developed. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.) All pupils being assessed for initial and three-year review for special education services shall have a hearing and vision screening, unless parental permission is denied. (Cal. Code of Regs, tit. 5 § 3027.)

District audiologists conducted audiological assessments of STUDENT on two occasions, once in October 2000 and once in October 2001. (Dist. Exhs. 72-73, p. 326-329.) Both the 2000 and 2001 assessments found that STUDENT’s hearing was within the normal range. (Id.; testimony of Colleen Peterson, Barbara Scott.) The October 2001 assessment report stated that “STUDENT’s mother noted that there is a family history of conductive hearing loss due to ossicular chain ossification; it is recommended that STUDENT be seen on an annual basis or at anytime a significant change in her hearing is noted.” District audiologist Colleen Peterson, who conducted STUDENT’s 2000 audiological assessment, explained that STUDENT did not have the profile of a hearing-impaired child and therefore the audiologist would have no reason to follow up with further audiological testing for STUDENT.

Ms. Peterson further explained that the 2001 report’s recommendation for annual testing meant that, in light of the parent’s concerns about family history of hearing loss, the audiologist recommended the parent bring STUDENT back for annual testing if the parent had any concerns. Ms. Peterson testified that this would have been explained orally to the parent at the time the assessment report was provided. STUDENT’s parents did not contact the District’s Audiological Services Department to schedule any subsequent audiological assessments, and STUDENT did not receive any subsequent audiological assessments from the District audiologists. (Footnote 14) However, STUDENT had further hearing screenings by the District and pursuant to District requirements. For example, a May 2003 health report required for STUDENT’s school attendance indicated that STUDENT had received an audiometric (hearing) screening. (Footnote 15) (Dist. Exh. 75, p. 342.)

STUDENT’s Assessment Plan, dated December 16, 2003, specified a health assessment including “evaluating hearing and vision acuity.” (Dist. Exh. 22, p. 98.) In February 2004, STUDENT received a hearing screening by a District school nurse. In a notice dated February 10, 2004, the school nurse informed STUDENT’s parents that the nurse’s office was “unable to assess” STUDENT during a routine hearing screening, and therefore the parents should contact the District’s Nursing Services to schedule a follow-up hearing test as soon as possible. (Footnote 16) (Dist. Exh. 71, p. 325.) Ms. Peterson explained that it is common for school nurses to be unable to conduct hearing screenings of young children because the test instructions may be too difficult for a young child to follow.

Thus, STUDENT’s hearing was tested several times over the years and never constituted an area of suspected disability. As Ms. Peterson and Ms. Scott established, STUDENT’s hearing was not an area of suspected disability because the 2000 and 2001 audiological assessments found that she had hearing within the normal range. Moreover, other evidence at the hearing likewise demonstrated that STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment. While initially STUDENT’s mother indicated that STUDENT was hearing-impaired, on the last day of the hearing MOTHER testified that the results of a recent hearing examination indicated that STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment. STUDENT’s teachers, service providers, school bus driver and step-grandfather all confirmed that she generally seems to hear noises, sounds and speech without any difficulty. While a Children’s Hospital assessment report noted that STUDENT had “fluctuating hearing loss,” Ms. Peterson testified that this diagnosis indicates a temporary condition, caused by congestion and ear infections very common among young children, which generally does not lead to permanent hearing loss; Ms. Peterson explained that sixty-percent to seventy-percent of all kindergarten students have fluctuating hearing loss. (See Student Exh. Tab V, p. 40-43.)

Given that hearing was not an area of suspected disability for STUDENT, there is no indication that the audiologist’s recommendation for annual follow-up testing created an obligation for the District to conduct annual audiological exams of STUDENT. Ms. Scott persuasively explained that, in light of the parents’ concerns, subsequent annual audiological exams would have been a good idea, but the failure to conduct those exams did not cause any harm to STUDENT because she did not have a hearing impairment. In light of all evidence, the lack of subsequent annual audiological assessments did not constitute a failure to assess in all areas of suspected disability.

Processing Disorder

Student alleges that the District failed to properly assess her for processing disorder. The District argues that a processing disorder was not an area of suspected disability.

As stated above, a special education assessment must assess in all areas related to the suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(f), 56381.) STUDENT’s triennial assessment included extensive testing by both the school psychologist and the outside neuropsychologist in areas such as cognitive ability and academic achievement. Both Ms. Tradup-Mahloch and Dr. Grandison concluded that STUDENT had global developmental delays, including cognitive impairment. Ms. Tradup-Mahloch explained that because STUDENT’s delays were global and her processing was not significantly lower than her cognition, she did not have a processing disorder. (See Dist. Exh. 36, p. 191-194.) Audiologist Colleen Peterson also explained in her testimony that auditory processing is an auditory deficit that assessors will test for after ruling out higher-order disorders such as mental retardation. In light of all evidence, there is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had a processing disorder and there was no failure to assess in this area.

************

Accordingly, there was no failure to conduct STUDENT’s assessment testing in her native language and no failure to assess her in all areas of suspected disability, specifically for an audiological impairment or a processing disorder. Hence, the Hearing Officer can next consider what STUDENT’s unique needs were during the 2003-2004 school year.

Generally, STUDENT’s needs are related to her global developmental delays, including mild mental retardation and delays in speech, language, expressive and receptive communication, academics, motor skills, and self-help/adaptive skills. (Footnote 17) In nearly all areas, STUDENT functioned at the level of a younger child; when she was five and a half, her assessors, teachers and service providers generally observed her to have the skill levels of a three-to-four-year-old child. (Testimony of Ms. Tradup-Mahloch, Ms. Davis; Student Exh. Tab I, p. 93-102.) Due to STUDENT’s delays in cognition and communication, as well as her short attention span, she required a significant amount of structure, consistency and adult attention for her academic instruction. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Chop, Ms. Lund.) While STUDENT had delays in her receptive communication due to limited comprehension, this Decision has already found that she had hearing within the normal range and did not have a hearing impairment.

Given STUDENT’s global delays, she required DIS including OT, APE and PT. STUDENT needed OT because she had delays in her fine motor, visual motor, and adaptive/self-care skills. She needed PT because of her delays in gross motor skills, balance, coordination, and motor planning issues. (Testimony of Ms. McBeth; see Dist. Exh. 36, p. 162-164.) Physical therapist Nell McBeth described how STUDENT’s coordination problems were due to a combination of balance and motor planning issues, related to “knowing where her body is in space.” Related to those deficits, STUDENT also required APE due to some delays in gross motor skills.

More detailed explanations of some specific areas of need are as follows:

Speech-Language and Communication/Sign Language

There is no question that STUDENT had a severe impairment in speech and language and needed DIS of speech-language therapy to address her speech and language skills. She used some speech but had significant delays in her expressive language. She was diagnosed with verbal apraxia, which is a delay in neurons of the brain that limits the speech sounds that the individual can produce. (Testimony of Shirlee Jack; see also testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Chop, Student Exh. Tab I, p. 93-102, Dist. Exh. 5, p. 49, Exh. 36, p. 197.)

Due to delays in cognition and receptive communication, STUDENT had difficulty understanding and following instructions, and therefore required intensive directions with repetition and prompts. (See, e.g., testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Chop, Ms. Jack, Ms. Wall; Dist. Exhs. 25, 27, 28.) There is no dispute that STUDENT was a visual learner and learned best using multimodal strategies, i.e., a combination of visual, verbal, auditory, and/or kinesthetic/physical methods. For example, she responded better to instructions when she was given a verbal instruction paired with either a visual prompt, such as a gesture or sign language symbol, or a physical prompt, such as leading her by the hand to where she was being directed to go. (See testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Jack, Ms. Borges, Ms. Teekell.)

Because STUDENT learned best using multimodal strategies, sign language was a useful visual strategy for STUDENT’s teachers and service providers to employ in reinforcing language and prompting learning. (See testimony of Ms. Chop, Ms. Jack, Ms. Davis, Ms. Olsen.) Ms. Chop explained that she and her aides in the CH-SDC used some signs to emphasize key words to all of the students in the class, as part of a multisensory teaching approach. Because STUDENT understood some signs, sign language - like gestures and pictures - was an effective visual strategy in a multisensory approach for STUDENT. Sign language augmented STUDENT’s communication; however, as discussed above, it was not STUDENT’s primary means of communication, either receptively or expressively. While STUDENT’s teachers and service providers have had success with using limited sign language to reinforce verbal instructions, more extensive use of sign language was not part of STUDENT’s unique needs.

STUDENT’s methods of expressive communication included speech, facial expressions, and gestures, such as pointing. For example, written observations by Ms. Jack and Ms. Davis describing STUDENT’s participation in general education in October 2003 reported several instances of STUDENT turning to another student and saying “hi.” (Dist. Exh. 19.) As noted above, STUDENT rarely used sign language to express herself, and none of her teachers or other instructors ever observed STUDENT attempting to communicate with peers using sign language. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Olsen, Ms. Chop, Ms. Borges, Ms. Jack; Dist. Exh. 19.)

Additionally, Student alleged that she needed her speech-language goals and services to teach her how to control her loud voice. (Footnote 18) However, there was no evidence to indicate that STUDENT’s voice was too loud for any of her educational settings. In her closing argument, Student argued that Dr. Grandison’s report described STUDENT’s voice as “dysfunctional,” but in fact Dr. Grandison’s report merely noted that STUDENT’s “voice quality was somewhat nasal.” (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 95.) Although Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT sometimes used a very loud voice, she acknowledged that she had never heard STUDENT use too loud a voice during the school day and that none of STUDENT’s instructors had ever indicated that STUDENT used too loud a voice. There were no witnesses who indicated that there was any problem with the volume of STUDENT’s voice at school. (Footnote 19) Instead, numerous witnesses who worked with and/or observed STUDENT, including Ms. Davis, Ms. Jack, Ms. Lund, program specialist Barbara Scott, and school psychologist Pam Tradup-Mahloch, all testified that there was no problem with STUDENT having too loud a voice. Therefore, controlling the volume of her voice was not among STUDENT’s unique needs.

Assistive Technology (AT)

Special education law identifies assistive technology (AT) as among the supports and services that may be needed to implement a child’s IEP. (Footnote 20) (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.1; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(2).) There is no dispute that, because of her communication needs, STUDENT could benefit from AT to assist her communication. While STUDENT’s receptive communication skills were delayed, they were stronger than her verbal abilities; hence, Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) measures were a form of AT that could “bridge the gap” between her verbal and receptive skills until her verbal skills developed more. (Testimony of Joyce Teekell.) Audiological Services and Auditory-Verbal Training

Student alleges that she needed both audiological services and auditory-verbal training as part of her educational program in 2003-2004. Regarding audiological services, this Decision has already found that STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment. Given that STUDENT had hearing within the normal range, there was no need for audiological services. Indeed, there was no evidence submitted indicating any sort of need for audiological services.

Similarly, auditory-verbal training was not among STUDENT’s unique needs in 2003-2004. Indeed, there was no evidence whatsoever that auditory-verbal training would have been in any way appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Scott and Ms. Peterson both described how auditory-verbal training is training for hard-of-hearing children who have had cochlear implants and the family members of those children. They noted that auditory-verbal trainers specifically discourage the use of sign language.

STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment and has not received a cochlear implant. Therefore, she did not need audiological services or auditory-verbal training. Behavior, Attention/Distractibility and Flickering Fluorescent Lights

STUDENT was generally well-behaved and was not a disciplinary problem. She had a short attention span, although she could attend for longer periods for preferred activities that interested her. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, MOTHER, Ms. Jack, Ms. Borges.) She was easily distracted and required frequent redirection. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Jack, Ms. Chop, Ms. Wall, Ms. Smario; Dist. Exh. 30, p. 115; Exh. 45, p. 209-210.) Various things would distract STUDENT, such as noises, sights, other people or other activities. (Id.) However, there was no persuasive evidence to support Student’s claim that flickering fluorescent lights were a particular problem beyond the level of an ordinary distraction for STUDENT. Dr. Grandison’s report mentioned second-hand information that “reportedly, bright lights can set off the staring spells, a finding also documented in the neurologist’s report.” (Dist. Exh. 45, p. 209.) However, the underlying information is hearsay and cannot alone be the basis for a finding. (Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3082(b).) Moreover, other than STUDENT’s mother, none of the witnesses ever reported observing STUDENT have a particular difficulty with flickering fluorescent lights, and there were no other medical or educational records reporting such a problem. Rather, Ms. Davis described how she would sometimes keep the lights off in the SH-SDC to keep the room cool, and reported that whether the lights were on or off did not appear to have any effect on STUDENT. Thus, aside from STUDENT’s general distractibility, at this time there is no evidence that STUDENT had a particular need to avoid flickering fluorescent lights.

Social Skills/ Peer Modeling

It was undisputed that STUDENT was a delightful, sociable child, but also that she was immature and socialized at the level of a much younger child compared to peers her chronological age. Ms. Davis and Ms. Chop both reported that STUDENT appeared to prefer adult attention to peer attention, which they described as typical of a younger child. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT enjoyed playing with other children and had preferred peers in the SH-SDC. There is no dispute that STUDENT also benefitted from socialization with typically developing peers and therefore that mainstreaming for socialization needed to be part of her educational program. (See Dist. Exh.36, p. 137.)

Related to STUDENT’s level of social skills was her ability to model and imitate peers. Ms. Borges testified that STUDENT seemed to benefit from interaction with typically developing peers and that she was able to model peers when the teacher prompted and encouraged her to do so. Ms. Davis described how STUDENT would sometimes imitate sign language when others used it. In contrast, Ms. Lund testified that STUDENT was unable to model typically developing peers who were performing academic tasks in the general education kindergarten. Consistent with that testimony, Ms. Jack and Ms. Davis’s written observations of STUDENT in the general education kindergarten in October 2003 report several instances when STUDENT did not follow the classroom activities despite adult prompting, and very few instances when she did. (Dist. Exh. 19.) Thus, considering the descriptions of STUDENT in various settings, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was sometimes able to imitate peers, depending on the setting and the complexity of the activities. (See Dist. Exhs. 14, 19.)

To summarize STUDENT’s needs for 2003-2004, she had global developmental delays, including mild mental retardation and delays in speech, language, expressive and receptive communication, academics, motor skills, and self-help/adaptive skills. She needed DIS including OT, PT, APE and speech-language therapy. She required frequent redirection and had a short attention span. She was generally well-behaved but had difficulty understanding and following instructions. She socialized at the level of a younger child and would sometimes imitate peers, which caused her to gain benefit from interaction with typically developing peers. Although STUDENT needed visual strategies as part of her multi-sensory instruction, she did not have a hearing impairment and did not require more extensive use of sign language instruction.

Snack Time

The Student alleged that she needed to eat a snack during kindergarten snack time each day. Given that the kindergarten school day lasts for only a few hours, there was no evidence to establish whether STUDENT had a particular need to eat a snack during the kindergarten school day or whether failure to eat a snack would interfere with her receipt of educational benefit. While STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT needed to eat her snack to avoid seizures, MOTHER also acknowledged that STUDENT’s doctors are only investigating the possibility of a seizure disorder and have not determined whether STUDENT actually has a seizure disorder. Thus, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s need to eat a snack was no different than any other student’s needs in this area.

************

Considering STUDENT’s unique needs, the next step is to determine whether the District’s proposed program was designed to meet those needs. The primary areas of dispute were as follows:

Instruction Using Sign Language

STUDENT alleged that she needed to receive instructions in the form of sign language, not just verbal instructions, when receiving her DIS of OT, speech-language therapy and APE. STUDENT’s respective therapists in these areas, Ms. Wall, Ms. Jack, and Ms. Smario, each generally testified that the methods used to instruct STUDENT included verbal communication, gestures, visual cues, modeling, prompts and simple sign language. Each therapist found that STUDENT appeared to understand the verbal instructions given to her in one-to-one sessions, that STUDENT did not appear to understand sign language better than verbal instructions, and that STUDENT responded the same way to speech without any sign language as she did to speech accompanied by sign language.

This Decision has previously determined that, while sign language is a useful visual strategy as part of STUDENT’s multisensory instruction, she did not need more extensive use of sign language in her instruction. The testimonies of Ms. Wall, Ms. Jack and Ms. Smario were entirely consistent with the observations of other witnesses who reported that STUDENT understood speech at least as well as, or better than, sign language. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT needed her DIS sessions to include sign language instruction beyond the level already provided. Accordingly, there was no failure to meet STUDENT’s unique needs on this basis.

OT and Self-Help/Adaptive Skills

There is no question that STUDENT required OT services and that the District provided her with one hour of direct OT services per week, plus weekly group OT sessions in the SH-SDC and fifteen minutes of weekly consultation solely concerning STUDENT. Student argues that she needed additional goal areas in sign language, dressing, washing, keyboarding and oral-motor needs, and also needed a total of two hours per week of direct OT services.

First, the Student alleged that her OT goals and objectives should have included fine motor training so that she could accurately perform sign language. This Decision has already determined that STUDENT is more reliant upon verbal communication than sign language and therefore did not require sign language interpretation and other extensive sign language supports in her instruction. However, this Decision also concluded that sign language was a useful method for augmenting her communication. STUDENT knew some signs and was exposed to additional signs from the school staff and her family. Dr. Grandison’s report endorsed sign language as a possible alternative modality for STUDENT’s communication.

Given that sign language was not STUDENT’s primary mode of communication but was a useful method to augment her communication, the next question is whether she needed a goal specifically designed to improve her ability to sign. Witness testimony differed somewhat regarding whether STUDENT’s fine motor delays interfered with her ability to sign. (Cf. testimony of Ms. Wall, Ms. Davis, Ms. Martell; Dist. Exh. 36, p. 144-145.) In any event, STUDENT’s OT goals and objectives covered many areas related to fine motor skills. For the period of March 2003 to April 2004, STUDENT’s fine motor goals and objectives included goals and objectives of finger isolation exercises, cutting with scissors, grasping a writing tool, buttoning, manipulating objects, stringing beads, improving shoulder, arm and hand control and improving arm and shoulder strength. (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 144-148; testimony of Ms. Wall.) For April 2004 to February 2005, STUDENT’s OT fine motor goals included goal areas in cutting and writing; at the parents’ request, the occupational therapist later drafted goals and objectives for self-care activities, including using a zipper. (Dist. Exh. 55, p. 241; testimony of Ms. Wall.)

Thus, regardless of whether STUDENT needed to improve her fine motor skills specifically for the purpose of signing, her fine motor goals for 2003-2004 would have likewise addressed the same skills that related to her ability to sign. (Testimony of Ms. Martell, Ms. Wall.) STUDENT’s OT goals and objectives already addressed numerous fine motor skill areas, including finger isolation exercises. Given that such fine motor skills would likely have addressed the fine motor delays that affected STUDENT’s ability to sign, and also considering this Decision’s findings that more extensive use of sign language was not part of STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not need her OT goals to specifically include training designed to improve her ability to expressively use sign language. Accordingly, there was no denial of FAPE on this basis.

Next, Student alleges that her OT goals and objective should have addressed the following additional areas: washing hands and face; getting dressed; keyboarding; and an oral-motor goal to strengthen her mouth. Regarding the proposed goal areas of washing hands and face, Ms. Davis and Ms. Wall indicated that the SH-SDC incorporated washing hands into the classroom routine, and as a result STUDENT practiced washing her hands in that setting. There was no evidence that STUDENT needed a goal to work on washing her face to meet her unique needs. (See testimony of Ms. Wall.)

Regarding dressing, STUDENT’s OT goals included fine motor skills related to dressing, such as buttoning. Additionally, at the parents’ request, occupational therapist Liz Wall drafted dressing goals of using zippers, putting on and taking off a coat or sweater, and putting on shoes and socks. (Dist. Exh. 55, p. 240-242.) Thus, STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives included self-help goals in dressing and there was no evidence establishing that STUDENT’s program needed to include dressing goals beyond those already part of her program.

Regarding a proposed goal in keyboarding, neuropsychologist Dr. Corrina Grandison concluded that STUDENT needed intense OT for many concerns, and recommended that “STUDENT needs help with fine motor skills, such as graphomotor skills. She should be introduced to keyboarding, as a means for writing in the grades to come.” (Dist. Exh. 45, p. 213.) Dr. Grandison discussed this recommendation with the IEP team members on June 2, 2004, but did not testify at the hearing.

District witnesses testified that STUDENT was too young to learn keyboarding and that even general education students do not learn keyboarding in kindergarten or first grade. (Testimony of Ms. Wall, Ms. Martell, Ms. Davis.) Ms. Davis explained that at STUDENT’s young age, it would have been more effective for her to first learn how to use the mouse, which requires less fine motor dexterity and does not require STUDENT to know all the letters on the keyboard. Ms. Davis noted that since STUDENT had not learned her letters yet, using the keyboard would not have been helpful for her.

Notably, Ms. Davis was a particularly credible and informative witness. She was an experienced, credentialed special education teacher who had worked with STUDENT extensively and was very familiar with her needs. On this particular point of evidence, Ms. Davis was knowledgeable because of her years of teaching experience. Regarding the testimony of Ms. Wall and Ms. Martell, this section of the Decision has already noted that they were both credible witnesses. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the witnesses that keyboarding was too advanced for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. While Dr. Grandison is correct that STUDENT should be introduced to keyboarding at some point, a keyboarding goal should likely be incorporated into her program later in her elementary school years.

Additionally, Student argues that she needed an oral-motor goal to strengthen her mouth. Preliminarily, it should be noted that STUDENT’s speech-language goals from March 2003 to April 2004 included an objective that she “will imitate ORAL MOTOR POSITIONS & MOVEMENTS of tongue & lips with at least 50% efficiency.” (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 154 (emphasis in original).) However, Student appears to argue that an oral-motor goal should also have been included in STUDENT’s OT goals. Occupational therapist Liz Wall and OT/PT supervisor Corrie Martell explained that OT incorporates oral-motor work to the extent that oral defensiveness or sensitivity affects a child’s ability to feed or swallow.

In STUDENT’s IEP dated March 27, 2003, the IEP notes state as follows:

“A discussion of oral-motor sensitivity, and strengthening [exercises] was accomplished. The team will consult with the OT regarding constructing a goal and objectives related to oral-motor needs and with approval of team members add to today’s IEP as an addendum.”

However, Ms. Martell testified that she discussed the matter with STUDENT’s occupational therapist at the time, Mary Jo Zulli, and that Ms. Zulli reported that STUDENT’s goals in that area had already been achieved and STUDENT did not require further work on oral-motor needs. Moreover, STUDENT’s SDC teacher and her occupational therapist both testified that STUDENT did not have any particular difficulties with feeding or swallowing. They acknowledged that sometimes saliva would pool in STUDENT’s mouth, but this problem was easily addressed by simply reminding STUDENT to swallow.

There was no persuasive evidence contrary to the testimony of Ms. Martell and Ms. Wall on this point, and this Decision has already recounted how they were credible witnesses who were knowledgeable regarding OT issues. Therefore, STUDENT did not need an OT oral-motor goal to meet her unique needs.

Finally, Student argues that she needed an additional hour of OT per week because she did not make meaningful progress when she received only one hour per week and additional proposed OT goals required additional OT session time. The District argues that one hour per week was sufficient to allow STUDENT to make progress on her OT goals and objectives, including the proposed new self-help goals that the occupational therapist drafted in June 2004 in response to the parents’ request.

For the 2003-2004 school year, the District offered one hour per week of direct OT services and fifteen minutes per week of OT consultation services. The hour per week of direct OT services was delivered during two thirty-minute sessions each week. Pursuant to the March 2003 IEP, STUDENT’s OT goal areas for most of the 2003-2004 school year were: (1) to improve her shoulder, arm and hand strength for greater success with fine motor tasks and manipulatives, and (2) to improve her bilateral coordination and motor planning with fine motor skills. The objectives for the hand strength goal included cutting with scissors, “wheelbarrow walking,” and demonstrating appropriate grasp of a writing tool. The objectives for the fine motor goal included stabilizing paper with one hand while coloring or writing with the other hand, buttoning and unbuttoning, finger isolation tasks, and stringing beads. (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 144-148; testimony of Ms. Wall.)

Ms. Wall explained that an occupational therapist determines how much OT time a child requires based upon the child’s needs and goals. Ms. Wall testified that one hour of direct OT services per week was the appropriate amount for STUDENT in the 2003-2004 school year. She testified that STUDENT’s progress level was commensurate with her developmental level and additional OT time would not have resulted in additional progress on her goals. She explained that because skills are best learned in the natural environment, it is most effective for the occupational therapist to have some one-on-one time to observe what works for the student, and then to convey that information to the teacher who can help the student generalize those skills in the natural environment. Hence, additional one-on-one time would not necessarily have helped STUDENT make greater progress, plus it would have taken away from her instructional time in the classroom.

Regarding STUDENT’s new OT goals and objectives proposed in February 2004 and agreed upon in April 2004, the two new goal areas were in writing and cutting, with three objectives under each goal. (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 168, 190, Exh. 45A, p. 216b.) The District again offered one hour of direct OT services per week. During a subsequent IEP meeting on June 2, 2004, STUDENT’s parents requested additional goals to address self-help areas. (Dist. Exh. 53, p. 233-234.) In response to this request, Ms. Wall sent the PARENTS a letter containing proposed goals and objectives for the self-care activities of using a zipper, putting on and taking off a coat or sweater, and putting on shoes and socks. (Dist. Exh. 55, p. 241; testimony of Ms. Wall.) The PARENTS did not sign their consent to these proposed goals.

Both Ms. Wall and OT/PT supervisor Corrie Martell testified that one hour per week of direct OT services continued to be the appropriate amount to address STUDENT’s OT needs. Both witnesses confirmed that the addition of the three new proposed goals would have taken a negligible amount of time out of STUDENT’s OT sessions, because most of the time on those goals would have been spent in the classroom via the occupational therapist’s consultation with the SDC teacher. Additionally, Ms. Wall explained that they already spent time during the OT session for STUDENT to perform those self-care tasks, such as taking off her shoes, so it would not take much additional time to work on that task as a goal area and measure her progress.

The Hearing Officer also considers that, in addition to the direct OT service and OT consultation time with her SDC teacher, STUDENT also received OT in a group setting once a week in the SH-SDC. (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 2-3, 6-10.) Other than MOTHER’s general statements that STUDENT needed more OT time and did not make progress, there was no evidence contrary to the testimony of Ms. Wall and Ms. Martell. Moreover, both Ms. Wall and Ms. Martell, who had each provided therapy to STUDENT, were knowledgeable, experienced, credentialed therapists who provided reasoned, credible testimony. (Dist. Exhs. 78, 92.) In light of all evidence, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony that one hour per week of direct OT services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

In light of all of the above findings, the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in OT and self-help/adaptive skills.

Speech-Language Therapy

There is no dispute that, and this Decision has already determined that, STUDENT required speech-language therapy. Pursuant to her IEP, the District offered her one and a half hours of speech-language therapy per week during the 2003-2004 school year. However, Student contends that, because of her severe speech and language impairment, she needed three and a half hours of speech-language therapy per week, instead of only one and a half hours. The District argues that the one and a half hours of weekly speech-language therapy was sufficient to address her needs and allowed her to make progress on her IEP goals and objectives in that area.

Dr. Grandison, the neuropsychologist who conducted an independent evaluation of STUDENT, stated in her report that STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills were severely impaired, with test scores indicating language skills at a two-and-one-half to three-and-one-half-year-old level, compared to her chronological age of five years, eight months at the time of testing. (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 96.) Dr. Grandison wrote that “STUDENT’s language and communication needs are tremendous and need daily support. At least half an hour of intense speech and language therapy per day is suggested.” (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 99.) Dr. Grandison explained her recommendation during an IEP meeting on June 2, 2004, but did not testify at the hearing. Dr. Grandison thus recommended a total of two and one-half hours of direct speech-language therapy per week. It is unclear what evidence supports Student’s claim for three and one-half hours

Speech-language pathologist Shirlee Jack testified that an hour and a half was the appropriate amount of direct services for STUDENT. Ms. Jack testified that, in addition to speech-language consultation time, she provided STUDENT with direct speech-language therapy five days a week, with four sessions of fifteen minutes each and one weekly session lasting thirty minutes, for a total of an hour and a half per week. (Footnote 21) (Testimony of Ms. Jack.) Ms. Jack explained that because of STUDENT’s short attention span, the short daily sessions were the most effective way to address STUDENT’s needs in this area, and increased time in speech therapy would have been unlikely to increase her speech progress. Ms. Jack stated that the intent of speech therapy is to teach the child to communicate in the everyday environment. In light of this goal, Ms. Jack described how STUDENT was highly motivated to communicate with her peers and the adult staff in her classroom, and therefore an increase in speech therapy would have taken away from her speech opportunities in the classroom. Ms. Jack also testified that she consulted with STUDENT’s other instructors on a daily basis, and that this consultation time plus the time spent making materials for STUDENT’s sessions often totaled at least one hour per week, although this time was not listed on the IEP. Ms. Jack testified that there were usually so many things to address at STUDENT’s IEP meetings that she did not have a chance, but that she did mention her consultation time at the IEP meeting on June 2, 2004. (Dist. Exh. 53, p. 231.)

Because Dr. Grandison did not testify, it is somewhat difficult to compare the reasoning of her recommendation with the reasoning of Ms. Jack’s recommendation. From the unofficial transcript of the June 2004 IEP meeting and the testimony of staff members who attended that meeting, it appears that Dr. Grandison’s recommendation was based upon her opinion that STUDENT needed speech-language therapy every day. Ms. Davis testified that, during the discussion at the June 2004 IEP meeting, Dr. Grandison appeared surprised to learn that in fact STUDENT received at least fifteen minutes of speech-language therapy every day. The unofficial IEP transcript reports statements from Dr. Grandison such as “I do say here at least half an hour of intense speech and language therapy per day is suggested, because I can’t imagine a day go without getting her a whole lot of language.” (Footnote 22) (Student’s Exh. Tab IX.) In another exchange, Dr. Grandison explained that she recommended thirty minutes of speech-language therapy a day because “it’s a difference of a daily routine as opposed to every other day routine. Because three days a week is basically...,” at which point another speaker interrupts to state that STUDENT was receiving speech-language therapy five days a week. (Id.)

Thus, it appears that Dr. Grandison’s recommendation of two and one-half hours of speech-language therapy each week was based upon her opinion that STUDENT needed speech-language therapy every day, although in fact STUDENT was already receiving that therapy every day. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Jack’s testimony that lengthening STUDENT’s daily speech-language sessions was not likely to result in greater educational benefit to STUDENT because of her short attention span and because it would have taken time away from opportunities to generalize in the classroom what she has learned in one-on-one speech therapy. Ms. Jack had worked extensively with STUDENT and was a knowledgeable, experienced, credentialed speech pathologist who provided thoughtful, independent testimony. (See Dist. Exh. 84.) Thus, the offer of ninety minutes per week of direct speech-language therapy was sufficient to address her needs.

Accordingly, the speech-language therapy services were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.

Assistive Technology (AT)

In spring 2003, AT consultant Joyce Teekell conducted an AT evaluation regarding STUDENT. Thereafter, Ms. Teekell introduced various voice output communication aide (VOCA) devices for STUDENT to try. STUDENT’s VOCA devices, such as a talking photo album, Hip Talker, and Communication Builder, were all types of electronic devices wherein STUDENT could push a button or say a word to produce recordings of various words. (See testimony of Ms. Teekell; Student Exh. Tab I, p. 74; Dist. Exh. 54, p. 238.) The purposes of these VOCA devices were to increase the amount of her verbalizations, to function as a language model, and to give STUDENT another way to expressively communicate. Ms. Teekell reported that she also introduced a Go-Talk VOCA device and a TechSpeak VOCA device, but the former broke and the latter was too confusing for STUDENT, so these were discontinued and different VOCAs were introduced. (Id.)

Student alleges that her goals and/or DIS should have included how to use the AT devices. However, Ms. Teekell testified that she would always show STUDENT’s instructors how to use the various AT devices, and then would leave the devices with the instructors to use with STUDENT on a daily basis. Ms. Teekell testified that thereafter she visited STUDENT at least once a month to see how the devices were working out and consulted with Ms. Davis and Ms. Jack throughout the school year regarding STUDENT’s use of AT. Speech-language pathologist Shirlee Jack also worked with both STUDENT and her instructors on how to use the AT devices. (See testimony of Ms. Jack, Ms. Teekell; Dist. Exh. 53, p. 232, Exh.60.) STUDENT learned to use the VOCAs but used them more for entertainment than as means to communicate with others. (Testimony of Ms. Teekell; Student Exh. Tab I, p. 74; Dist. Exh. 54, 238.) Nevertheless, in her testimony Ms. Teekell emphasized that STUDENT was able to use and access the devices herself if she chose to. (Id.)

Thus, there was no evidence to support Student’s claim that she needed additional goals, objectives, or services to teach her how to use the AT devices. STUDENT knew how to use the Communication Builder, Hip Talker, and talking photo album. As Ms. Teekell explained, STUDENT did not need to know how to set up or maintain the VOCA devices, including changing the overlays; that responsibility would be beyond the level of a five-year-old and therefore adults took care of those tasks.

Ms. Teekell was a knowledgeable, credible witness who had worked with STUDENT for over a year. (See Dist. Exh. 80.) Her testimony was persuasive and there was no evidence contrary to that testimony. Because STUDENT received sufficient instruction on how to use her AT devices, she did not require goals, objectives, or services in that area.

Student also alleged that the District failed to provide AT, specifically VOCA devices, to her consistently at school and at home. Regarding provision of VOCA devices at school, the testimony of Ms. Teekell, Ms. Jack, and Ms. Davis, combined with reports written by Ms. Teekell and Ms. Jack about STUDENT’s use of AT, demonstrated that Ms. Teekell worked with Ms. Davis and Ms. Jack to try out different AT devices and strategies and find the ones that helped develop STUDENT’s communication. (Dist. Exhs. 54, 60; Student Exh. Tab I, p. 74.) The fact that the trials of the Go Talk and TechSpeak devices were not eventually successful does not indicate any failure to provide the AT to address STUDENT’s needs. Instead, the ongoing consultation and the trials of different devices were part of the process of providing STUDENT with useful AT. (See testimony of Ms. Teekell, Ms. Jack.)

Regarding use of AT at home, Ms. Teekell gave MOTHER the Go-Talk and a “talking photo album” to use at home with STUDENT. (Footnote 23) Although the Go-Talk broke, MOTHER acknowledged in her testimony that the talking photo album was useful for STUDENT.

Student argues that the AT did not meet her needs because the computer software to develop AT overlays for the home was not accessible to the parents. The IEP notes, unofficial IEP transcript, and testimony of Ms. Teekell reflect that Ms. Teekell had spoken with MOTHER about using the software and informed MOTHER that the software was available to her at the school site or at the District’s AT department at the Willow Creek Center. (Footnote 24) (Dist. Exh. 54, p. 232; Student Exh. Tab IX.) In a letter to STUDENT’s parents from District ADR administrator Ken Ferro, the District reiterated that the software would be available for the parent’s use at STUDENT’s school site or at the Willow Creek Center. (Dist. Exh. 56, p. 242-243.) In the Student’s closing argument, the Student argued that requiring her mother to go to the Willow Creek Center was inconvenient, but did not clearly address why MOTHER could not have gone to the school to use the software.

Student alleges that the AT services did not meet her needs because her parents required additional training on AT devices. In March 2004 STUDENT’s mother attended a class taught by Ms. Teekell at the Willow Creek Center about how to use some of the available AT devices. (Testimony of MOTHER; Ms. Teekell.) It is unclear what AT device Student claims her parents should have been trained on. Given that MOTHER received the amount of training necessary to operate the VOCA devices that STUDENT took home, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s IEP was designed to meet her AT needs in this area.

In any event, it was not established that STUDENT needed to use a VOCA at home to meet her unique educational needs. MOTHER testified that the family communicated with STUDENT using speech, gestures, and ASL. Ms. Teekell testified that parents are generally encouraged to bring VOCAs home for the child to use at home, but that STUDENT did not need to use her VOCA at home to access her education. Ms. Teekell elaborated that children tend to communicate best with their parents and noted that MOTHER does a good job of communicating with STUDENT; hence, STUDENT did not appear to need a VOCA at home. Moreover, Ms. Teekell explained that because STUDENT was not choosing to use her VOCA to communicate at school, there appeared to be no point in sending the device home with her.

As noted above, Ms. Teekell was a credible witness who gave persuasive testimony, and there was no evidence contrary to her testimony. In light of all of the above, the provision of AT devices was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.

Physical Therapy (PT)

This Decision has already determined, and there is no dispute that, STUDENT needed PT to address her delays in gross motor skills, balance, coordination, and motor planning issues. (See Dist. Exh. 36, p. 162-164.) The District offered STUDENT one forty-five minute session of direct PT per week, plus fifteen minutes of weekly consultation.

Student contends that her PT goals should have included learning a “parachute response” to help her when she falls, while the District contends that STUDENT did not need this because she did not have a particular problem with falling. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT frequently fell and injured herself. MOTHER pointed to photos of STUDENT’s bruises and similar injuries due to falling. (Student’s Exh. Tab XII, p. 30-35.) STUDENT’s step-grandfather, who lives across the street from STUDENT, also testified that STUDENT was clumsy and fell frequently, and generally used her hands to catch herself.

In contrast, STUDENT’s school instructors all testified that STUDENT did not fall frequently compared to any other child her age. Physical therapist Nell McBeth testified that STUDENT did not need to learn a parachute response because she did not have a particular problem with falling. Ms. Davis testified that she had seen STUDENT fall on three occasions, once apparently due to ill-fitting shoes and the other two times when STUDENT’s mother came to pick her up after school and STUDENT was playing excitedly with her sisters. Ms. Davis testified that these incidents did not indicate that STUDENT had a particular tendency to fall. Ms. Chop, who was STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the 2002-2003 school year, testified that she had never seen STUDENT fall.

The persuasive evidence indicated that, typical of children her age, STUDENT occasionally fell when she was excited and running around, which occurred more frequently when she was at home than when she was at school. Thus, while STUDENT’s physical therapy needs included balance and coordination, she did not have a particular tendency to fall or a need for a parachute response.

Additionally, Student contends that, to avoid regression, she needed ongoing physical therapy throughout the year, including during summer vacation, with no more than a two-week break. The District contends that there was no evidence of STUDENT showing any significant regression after a long break and therefore such an extension of PT services during school breaks was not necessary to address her unique needs.

Regarding regression in PT during school vacations, Ms. McBeth testified that she was STUDENT’s physical therapist for both the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 regular school years, although not for the ESYs. Ms. McBeth stated that she did not find any regression between the end of the 2002-2003 school year and the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. Because STUDENT had not regressed over the 2003 summer, she did not need to work on recouping her skills in fall 2003. Ms. McBeth noted that when she wrote STUDENT’s progress notes in November 2003, she found that STUDENT had met all of her goals.

Dr. Grandison’s independent evaluation generally recommended that STUDENT should have a year-round program. Dr. Grandison wrote that “to be without services for longer than two weeks during the summer would be detrimental in that much of the fall would then be devoted to getting her back to speed and, hence, valuable time for progress would be lost.” (Dist. Exh. 45, p. 213.) Because Dr. Grandison did not testify, it is difficult to evaluate the reasoning behind her opinion. Moreover, the evidence specifically regarding STUDENT’s PT demonstrated that STUDENT did not regress in PT over the summer and therefore did not need to devote the fall to recouping her PT levels. Because STUDENT did not have problems with regression in PT over summer break, she did not need PT services year-round with no more than a two-week break.

Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that, in order to meet her unique needs, STUDENT did not require a PT goal for learning a parachute response and did not require year-round PT with no more than a two-week break.

Snack Time

This Decision has already determined that STUDENT did not have a particular need to eat a snack during kindergarten. In any event, the evidence established that STUDENT did not miss her daily snack due to speech-language therapy. Speech-language therapist Shirlee Jack testified that, on some days, the kindergarten snack time occurred at the same time that Ms. Jack went to STUDENT’s classroom to pick her up for speech-language therapy. Ms. Jack testified that, on those occasions, either she would wait while STUDENT ate her snack or STUDENT would go to speech-language therapy and eat her snack once she returned to the classroom. Similarly, STUDENT’s kindergarten SDC teacher, Ms. Davis, testified that STUDENT was always given the opportunity to eat her snack either before or after speech therapy and never missed her snack due to her attendance at speech-language therapy. Ms. Davis stated that when a student does not want to eat his or her snack, she will send the snack home with the student.

The only evidence to the contrary was MOTHER’s testimony that, on some occasions, Ms. Davis told her that STUDENT had missed her snack due to speech therapy and that Ms. Davis therefore suggested that STUDENT might want to eat her snack after school. Unlike Ms. Davis and Ms. Jack, MOTHER was not at school with STUDENT and did not witness STUDENT’s snack time. Comparing MOTHER’s statements with the version of events reported by Ms. Davis and Ms. Jack, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Davis’ and Ms. Jack’s descriptions of the actual events they observed is more reliable evidence than MOTHER’s recollection of a conversation several months after the fact. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s speech therapy sessions did not cause her to miss her daily snack. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes there was no failure to address STUDENT’s unique needs.

Classroom Placement

The District contends that, because of STUDENT’s delays in cognition and communication, she required a structured SDC with a small class size, small teacher-to-student ratio, frequent repetition, and visual strategies such as sign language support. The Student contends that she did not make meaningful progress in an SDC and instead needed a general education, mainstream setting with supports and services including staff fluent in sign language, hearing impaired peers fluent in sign language, sign language instruction, a sign language interpreter, curriculum provided with sign language support, a means for STUDENT to communicate with staff and peers, and non-fluorescent lights that did not flicker.

During the 2003-2004 school year, the District offered and provided STUDENT placement in an SH-SDC at Strandwood, taught by Ms. Davis with the assistance of two aides. The class consisted of nine special education students, ages five to seven, from kindergarten to second grade. Aside from STUDENT, the other SH-SDC students’ disabilities included autism, Down’s Syndrome and severe cognitive impairment. Ms. Davis stated that some of those students were very verbal and read at grade level; she reported that STUDENT’s skill levels were in the middle of the SH-SDC. At her parents’ request, for several weeks in fall 2003, STUDENT spent one hundred minutes per day during the academic instruction time of Ms. Lund’s general education kindergarten; however, STUDENT’s difficulties with the increased mainstreaming led the IEP team to agree to reduce her mainstream time to approximately fifteen percent of her time at school, where it remained for the rest of the 2003-2004 school year. This remaining fifteen-percent mainstream time included recess, music class, and the weekly “station time” that all Strandwood kindergarten students attended. There is no dispute that at least some mainstreaming was appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs for socialization and peer models.

Several witnesses testified to their opinions regarding why Ms. Davis’s SH-SDC was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Davis testified that her SDC provided STUDENT with the consistency, structure and routine that she needed; the SH-SDC schedule was the same every day so that the students could easily learn the routines, whereas a general education kindergarten program would often have different activities each day. Ms. Davis further described how the SH-SDC had the repetition, attention and intensive, multimodal instruction STUDENT needed. Ms. Davis described how, because of the small class size in an SDC, she had sufficient time to consult with DIS providers and observe them providing services to STUDENT, so that strategies from the DIS providers could be implemented immediately in the classroom. In contrast, Ms. Davis indicated that a general education kindergarten such as Ms. Lund’s would not provide the consistency, routine, and repetition that STUDENT needed, and the pace of instruction went too fast for STUDENT to learn.

The general education kindergarten teacher, Ms. Lund, also testified that she believed an SDC was the appropriate academic setting for STUDENT because of the smaller class size, greater one-to-one attention and greater repetition, as compared to a general education kindergarten. Ms. Lund explained that the regular kindergarten curriculum moves at a fast pace and has become highly academic in recent years, and that STUDENT needed a slower pace, smaller setting and more repetition than was available in the general education kindergarten. Ms. Lund reported that the staff modified STUDENT’s academics, modeled activities for her and encouraged her to participate when she attended the general education kindergarten in fall 2003, but despite those efforts, STUDENT did not meaningfully participate in Ms. Lund’s class.

STUDENT’s general education preschool teacher, Ms. Borges, also recommended that STUDENT needed a special education placement. Both at an October 2002 IEP meeting and at the due process hearing, Ms. Borges stated that STUDENT benefitted from her participation in a general education preschool setting, but that the general education setting could not address all of STUDENT’s needs.

STUDENT’s previous SDC teacher, Ms. Chop, also gave her opinion that an SH-SDC was the more appropriate placement to address STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Chop explained that her CH-SDC class was designed to address communication disabilities, but STUDENT has cognitive delays in addition to communicative delays, and therefore a class taught by a special education teacher trained in addressing cognitive delays would be the better setting for STUDENT. Ms. Chop stated that because of the severity of STUDENT’s delays, full inclusion would not have been appropriate for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year, even with a one-to-one aide; Ms. Chop noted that the addition of a one-to-one aide would create other difficulties, because children tend to become dependent on a one-to-one aide.

Documentary evidence was consistent with the witness testimony that the SH-SDC was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in 2003-2004. For example, after conducting an independent assessment of STUDENT, Dr. Grandison found that STUDENT required extensive support to perform academic tasks and was appropriately placed in the SDC. (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 93-102; Dist. Exh. 53, p. 227-228.) Dr. Grandison explained that STUDENT “needs a small classroom where she can receive much one-on-one and small group instruction.” (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 98.)

The evidence supporting the Student’s position regarding placement was limited. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needed teachers and other staff fluent in sign language, hearing impaired peers fluent in sign language, sign language instruction, a sign language interpreter, curriculum provided with sign language support, a means for STUDENT to communicate with staff and peers, and non-fluorescent lights that did not flicker. As discussed above, because sign language was not STUDENT’s primary means of communication, the extensive level of sign language support Student proposes was not part of her unique needs; thus, as Ms. Chop explained, providing a sign language interpreter, peers fluent in sign language and similar sign language supports would make no difference in STUDENT’s education. Therefore, STUDENT did not need a placement with those supports and services. In particular, Student argues that she needed “access to peers and staff who communicate in her mode of communication” and “a class of peers and staff who understand her and speak her language.” (Student’s Closing Brief, p. 3.) Given that STUDENT’s native language was English, and the SH-SDC was conducted in English, to this extent the SH-SDC was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Regarding flickering fluorescent lights, this Decision has already determined that STUDENT did not have a particular need to avoid flickering fluorescent lights. In any event, there was no indication that the lights in the SH-SDC were flickering, and instead Ms. Davis testified that she frequently kept the lights off to keep the temperature of the room cool.

Additionally, Student generally contended that the SH-SDC went too slowly and merely “baby-sat” her, although there was little evidence to support this claim. Ms. Davis’s uncontroverted testimony was that STUDENT’s skill levels were in the middle when compared to the skills of the other SH-SDC students. Ms. Davis and Ms. Lund both described how STUDENT could not keep up with a faster pace. Given Ms. Davis’s description of the academic activities in the SH-SDC and the discussion below regarding STUDENT’s progress in the SDC, there is no indication that STUDENT was merely being “baby-sat” or was not in a placement designed to address her academics.

Thus, the evidence established that the SH-SDC was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. The class provided STUDENT with the repetition, consistency, structure and multi-sensory instruction she needed in light of her delays in areas including cognition, academics, and receptive and expressive communication. Because of the small class size and small teacher-to-student ratio, STUDENT was able to receive the intensive instruction and adult support she needed. Also because of the small class size and ratio, STUDENT’s teacher was able to regularly consult with STUDENT’s DIS providers to implement what STUDENT was doing in DIS into her daily classroom setting; given STUDENT’s needs in motor skills, speech, language, and adaptive skills, such intensity in her DIS services was designed to address her needs. In light of all the factors discussed above, the SH-SDC was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.

*********** Accordingly, this Decision has determined that the District’s program for the 2003-2004 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, including in the areas of OT,self-help/adaptive skills, speech-language, AT, PT, and classroom placement.

(2) Reasonably Calculated to Confer Educational Benefit

As discussed above, the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200.) Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. (Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994).) However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).)

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school system cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight...an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993).) Moreover, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ., 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

As set forth above, the District’s offered program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, in light of the intensive instruction and services offered during the 2003-2004 school year, including the small class size, low teacher-to-student ratio, and generalization of DIS instruction in the classroom, the program was likely to provide her with some educational benefit. While the law does not guarantee that a program reasonably calculated to result in educational benefit will actually have that result, in the present case STUDENT did actually made meaningful progress. STUDENT’s SH-SDC teacher described the progress STUDENT made on her goals and objectives during the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Davis described how STUDENT made progress on her goals and objectives, such as answering questions, recognizing letters, identifying shapes and patterns, and following simple directions. (See Dist. Exh. 36, p. 169-174.)

Other evidence established that STUDENT made progress in her DIS areas. For example, occupational therapist Liz Wall testified that, during the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT made progress on all of the goals and objectives but did not meet them all. The progress reports indicated that STUDENT met her objectives for stringing beads and appropriate grasp of a writing tool, while she partially met the objectives for wheelbarrow walking, finger isolation, and stabilizing paper while coloring or writing. (Id.) STUDENT’s progress on specific tasks was documented in her PT/OT Therapy Chart & Progress Note. (Dist. Exh. 63, p. 276-282; testimony of Corrie Martell.) This Decision has already noted that Ms. Wall and Ms. Martell were credible witnesses, and there was no persuasive evidence contrary to their position that STUDENT made progress in OT.

Similarly, the Student argued that her program was not reasonably calculated to allow progress in speech-language therapy. However, in her testimony and in progress reports, Ms. Jack described how, although STUDENT did not meet her speech-language goals, she had made progress on those goals and on her speech and language skills during the 2003-2004 school year. (Student Exh. Tab I, p. 74; Dist. Exh. 36, p. 154-155, Exh. 53, p. 235I.) Ms. Jack described how, by June 2004, STUDENT was using and/or imitating new words that she had not exhibited earlier and was correctly producing particular sounds - such as /s/ and /sh/ - that she had not had earlier in the school year. (See also testimony of Ms. Teekell, Ms. Davis.) Ms. Jack also described how, by the end of the school year, STUDENT required much less cueing to produce the correct sound than she had required at the beginning of the school year. (See Dist. Exh. 58.) There was no evidence contrary to Ms. Jack’s testimony and documentation of STUDENT’s progress in speech and language, and Ms. Jack’s testimony was persuasive on this point. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, while STUDENT did not meet her speech and language goals, she made progress in speech and language during the 2003-2004 school year.

Moreover, STUDENT’s progress in DIS was related to her classroom placement. Due to Ms. Davis’s regular consultation with the DIS providers and observations of STUDENT receiving her DIS instruction, Ms. Davis was able to help STUDENT generalize those skills on a day-to-day basis in the classroom.

Student also alleges that she failed to make educational progress in the areas of attention and behavior. As discussed in the section of this Decision establishing STUDENT’s unique needs, STUDENT had a short attention span for non-preferred activities; her classroom placement addressed her short attention span by providing a structured classroom with a small class size, low teacher-to-student ratio and frequent redirection. Regarding behavior, this Decision has already determined that STUDENT was a well-behaved child, although her socialization and other behaviors were commensurate with her cognitive delays and were below her chronological age. She did not have specific IEP goals for either attention or behavior. It is unclear what area of behavior Student is now alleging she should have made progress in but did not, and there was no evidence or allegation that STUDENT needed goals in behavior. Regarding attention, both Ms. Davis and Ms. Chop testified that STUDENT did not need a specific goal in attention, but noted that attention was an area they worked on in class. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT’s attention span increased throughout the 2003-2004 school year.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that placement in the SH-SDC was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit for the 2003-2004 school year. (3) Conformity with the IEP

As addressed below, Student argued that the District failed to provide a program in conformity with the IEP in the areas of OT, AT, PT and APE.

Occupational Therapy (OT)

Student alleges that the District failed to provide her OT services in a one-to-one setting in conformity with the IEP because on some occasions the occupational therapist provided STUDENT’s OT services in conjunction with STUDENT’s speech therapist or physical therapist. Ms. Wall explained that this method of “co-treatment” with another instructor consisted of two therapists working with STUDENT at the same time; STUDENT needed to pay attention to only one therapist at a time, while the other therapist worked in a supporting role.

Ms. Wall described how co-treatment increased the educational benefit to STUDENT by allowing the instructors to design activities for STUDENT that reinforced what she worked on in another DIS activity. For example, the speech therapist observed the tasks that STUDENT worked on in OT, then provided the occupational therapist with a list of words relevant to those tasks that the occupational therapist could reinforce during the OT sessions. In another example, Ms. Wall wrote in STUDENT’s OT triennial reevaluation report that “it is recommended that OT continue to co-treat with PT when possible as some of [STUDENT’s] difficulties with fine motor tasks are related to difficulties with trunk stabilization and shoulder stability.” (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 145.) Ms. Wall testified that there is extensive literature in her professional field regarding the benefits of co-treatment. She noted that the co-treatment methodology had been discussed at STUDENT’s IEP meetings, although she did not recall if the parents expressly consented to this method. There was no persuasive evidence contrary to Ms. Wall’s testimony on this topic. Moreover, as noted above, Ms. Wall was a knowledgeable, credible witness.

The relevant IEPs in effect for the 2003-2004 school year, dated March 27, 2003, and April 6, 2004, both provided that STUDENT’s OT DIS would be provided as follows: “1.0 (hours per week) direct/ 0.25 (hours per week) consult.” The IEPs did not specify that the OT service would be provided on a one-to-one basis, although the parents understood that STUDENT would be receiving her OT on a one-to-one basis. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

The District’s provision of OT using the method of co-treatment did not constitute a nonconformity with the IEPs. The co-treatment model of two instructors to one student is not contrary to the IEP’s provision of “direct OT.” While the parents reasonably understood that STUDENT would be receiving OT on a one-to-one basis, the purpose of one-to-one instruction in this instance was to assure STUDENT intensive, individualized instruction wherein the therapist focused solely on STUDENT’s instruction and not on instructing other students. Co-treatment was entirely consistent with this purpose. Hence, while providing STUDENT’s OT in a small group arguably would have failed to comport with the IEP’s requirement of “direct OT,” the occasional use of two therapists during STUDENT’s individual OT session did not. Thus, there was no failure to conform with the IEP on this basis and no resulting denial of FAPE.

Assistive Technology (AT)

Student’s issues generally alleged nonconformity, but Student’s subsequent arguments do not specify how the provision of AT failed to conform to her IEP. The March 27, 2003 IEP provided for an initial AT consultation and there is no dispute that this consultation occurred in spring 2003. The subsequent IEP documents did not provide for any specific or additional provision of AT. Instead, the September 2003 and February/March/April 2004 IEP documents simply indicated that the IEP team had “reviewed current devices/services” regarding assistive devices/services. (Dist. Exh. 11, p. 62; Exh. 36, p. 138.)

The next IEP meeting occurred on June 2, 2004. That IEP document again indicated that the team had reviewed STUDENT’s current AT devices and services. Additionally, next to the document’s statement of review of the AT devices, the notetaker wrote “Communication builder” and “Hip talker,” although there was no specification about how those two devices would be part of STUDENT’s educational program. (Dist. Exh. 53, p. 226.) The IEP notes also reflect discussion about the use and implementation of AT devices, including the parent’s request for an independent AAC assessment, which the District denied. (Dist. Exh. 53, p. 232, Exh. 56, p. 242-243.)

There is no question that the District provided the Communication Builder and Hip Talker devices to STUDENT. Thus, it is unclear what provision of the IEP the Student contends the District failed to implement. Moreover, the parent did not sign her consent to this IEP. (Dist. Exh. 53, p. 226.) California law provides that a special education program cannot be implemented until the student’s parent consents in writing to all or part of the IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).) Because an IEP cannot be implemented without a parent’s signed consent, there can be no denial of FAPE due to nonconformity with an unsigned IEP.

Thus, there is no indication of any failure to conform to the IEP regarding any AT devices, and as a result no denial of FAPE occurred on this basis.

Physical Therapy (PT)

Student alleged that the District failed to provide amounts of physical therapy in conformity with the IEP, because STUDENT missed a total of four weeks of physical therapy due to the physical therapist’s vacations and other time off. STUDENT’s March 2003 IEP provided for PT for forty-five minutes of direct services per week and fifteen minutes of consultation per week. (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 137.) Ms. McBeth testified that she missed two or three of STUDENT’s physical therapy sessions in November 2003 because Ms. McBeth had to take time off work to have surgery. (Student Exh. Tab II, p. 54.) The missed sessions were not made up. Ms. McBeth testified that STUDENT did not regress and continued to make progress in PT, in part because during Ms. McBeth’s absence STUDENT continued to receive APE services, which addressed many of the same skills as PT did.

Ms. Martell testified that STUDENT’s parents never requested that the missed sessions be made up. Moreover, Ms. Martell explained that for STUDENT, compensatory sessions were not necessary because STUDENT was still making very good progress in PT.

Providing a program in conformity with a student’s IEP is one of the components of FAPE. (Rowley at 200.) Because STUDENT did not receive some of her PT sessions in November 2003 and those missed sessions were not made up, to that extent the District’s program was not in conformity with the IEP. However, this nonconformity with the IEP constituted only a de minimis denial of FAPE, when considered in the context of STUDENT’s entire program, including the appropriate placement and services, and the relatively short length of time that this nonconformity occurred.

Adaptive Physical Education (APE) Services

Student alleged that the District failed to minimize distractions during her APE services, as specified in her IEP. The IEP signed on April 6, 2004, listed the following modification to STUDENT’s program: “distractions within the environment will be kept to a minimum.” (Dist. Exh. 36, p. 137.) Ms. Smario testified that she used various techniques to minimize distractions and gain STUDENT’s attention during STUDENT’s APE sessions, such as changing the location of the session if something was distracting STUDENT or moving the session onto the playground so that it was akin to parallel play. Ms. Smario was an experienced, credentialed APE therapist whose testimony appeared to be honest and credible. (See Dist. Exh. 81.) There was no evidence supporting the nonconformity allegation. Accordingly, there was no failure to conform to the IEP regarding minimizing distractions during APE.

************

In summary, the District provided STUDENT’s OT, AT and APE in conformity with her IEP. Regarding PT, the District failed to provide PT in conformity with her IEP to the very limited extent that the District failed to provide her with two or three PT sessions in November 2003. Because of the very limited nature of this nonconformity and the appropriateness of the rest of her educational program, the Hearing Officer found that any resulting denial of FAPE due to the failure to provide those PT sessions was minor.

(4) Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)

The Student contends that her LRE was in a general education, mainstream kindergarten setting with supports and services including teachers and other staff fluent in sign language, hearing impaired peers fluent in sign language, sign language instruction, a sign language interpreter, curriculum provided with sign language support, and a means for her to communicate with staff and peers. The District argued that Student’s LRE was in an SH-SDC, with mainstreaming for approximately fifteen percent of her school day, including recess, music, art, and weekly station time shared with all of the school’s kindergarten students.

As stated previously, federal and State law require that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities shall be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56364.2.)

In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled, (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom, and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Rachel H., supra at 1404.)

Notably, when applying the four-part test created in Rachel H., the Ninth Circuit explained that “the question whether to educate a handicapped child in the regular classroom or to place [him or her] in a special education environment is necessarily an individualized, fact specific inquiry. In each case, the apparent tension between the IDEA's clear preference for mainstreaming and its requirements that schools provide individualized programs tailored to the specific needs of each disabled child must be balanced.” (Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 836 (9th Cir. 1995) (citing 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401, 1414(a)(5), Oberti v. Board of Educ. of the Borough of Clementon Sch. Dist., 995 F.2d 1204, 1214 (3d Cir.1993) and Daniel R.R., supra, 874 F.2d at 1044-45).)

In light of these requirements, the Hearing Officer considers the four LRE factors as follows:

(1) The academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom

The evidence indicated that the academic benefits of the SH-SDC were far greater than those available to STUDENT in the general education kindergarten. The SH-SDC provided STUDENT with the consistency, routine, repetition, low teacher-to-student ratio, attention, and intensive, multimodal instruction she needed. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Lund, Ms. Chop.) Ms. Davis described how, because of the small class size in an SDC, she had sufficient time to consult with DIS providers and observe them providing services to STUDENT, so that strategies from the DIS providers could be implemented immediately in the classroom. In contrast, Ms. Davis and Ms. Lund both reported that Ms. Lund’s kindergarten did not provide the consistency, routine, repetition, and attention that STUDENT needed and had instruction at too fast a pace for STUDENT to learn. Both teachers described how STUDENT could not follow Ms. Lund’s instructions and was unable to participate in many of the activities, despite encouragement, support and modifications by Ms. Lund and/or the shadow aide (either Ms. Davis or an SDC aide) who accompanied STUDENT to the general education kindergarten.

STUDENT’s general education preschool teacher, Ms. Borges, also recommended that a general education setting could not address all of STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Grandison and the school psychologist similarly recommended placement in the SDC because of the extensive support STUDENT requires to perform tasks. (Testimony of Ms. Tradup-Mahloch; Student Exh. Tab I, p. 93-102; Dist. Exh. 53, p. 227-228.)

There was less evidence of the general education class’s academic benefits as compared to that of the SH-SDC. Student argued that the general education setting would have better addressed her communication needs because, given her delays in expressive communication, the general education students would have been better able to understand her expressive communication. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT was able to communicate with her peers in the SH-SDC, citing examples such as STUDENT saying “hi,” “bye,” and “no,” gesturing, pointing, giggling, and using body language. Neither Ms. Davis nor any other witness testified specifically about how well STUDENT’s peers in the SH-SDC were able to understand her speech and gestures. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer concurs with Student’s argument that typically developing peers would have been better able to understand STUDENT’s speech and gestures than the SH-SDC students, whose diagnoses included autism, Down’s Syndrome, and severe cognitive impairment.

Similarly, Student argued that typically developing peers would provide better language models than the peers in the SH-SDC. There is no dispute that STUDENT has delayed receptive communication; because she was sometimes able to imitate and model peers, interacting with typically developing peers would appear to have provided her with some benefit towards her language and communication needs. While Ms. Davis testified that some of the SH-SDC students were very verbal, given the range of disabilities among those students it is apparent that typically developing students would likely have provided better language models. Thus, the potential language modeling by typically developing peers in a general education kindergarten would have offered some greater benefit to STUDENT in the areas of language and communication than the language models in the SH-SDC.

Student also argued, in essence, that she deserved to learn what the other kindergarten students were learning and deserved access to the regular kindergarten curriculum. Student is correct that the IDEA entitles a special education student to be able to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).) However, Ms. Davis testified that her SH-SDC teaches the regular kindergarten curriculum and is designed to meet State kindergarten standards. There is no dispute that the general education kindergarten offered more academic instruction at a faster pace; indeed, Ms. Lund testified that kindergarten today is equivalent to what first grade was ten years ago. However, the increased academic instruction and faster pace of a general education kindergarten would not have offered greater academic benefit if, due to her cognitive delays and language impairment, STUDENT could not have academically benefitted from the general education setting despite appropriate supports and services.

Student also contended that in the past she learned more in less restrictive placements, such as the general education preschool class at Mary Jane’s and the CH-SDC taught by Ms. Chop at Gregory Gardens. The primary evidence supporting this contention is the testimony of STUDENT’s mother. MOTHER described how STUDENT made good progress in the CH-SDC and met all of her goals. MOTHER also reported that she observed a decrease in STUDENT’s progress when STUDENT switched from a CH-SDC to an SH-SDC in November 2002. While MOTHER appeared to be sincere and honest in her testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that the contrary testimony from several District employees was more reliable on this point. The numerous District employees who testified that the SH-SDC was STUDENT’s best learning environment were able to observe STUDENT at school over a long period of time, while MOTHER did not observe STUDENT in school. Moreover, even Ms. Borges and Dr. Grandison, who are not District employees and whose opinions MOTHER relies upon in her arguments, both recommended that STUDENT needed a special education placement.

Additionally, Student contended that her placement in the SH-SDC had a negative impact on her attention span because the SH-SDC changed activities frequently and did not require her to concentrate. This claim was not persuasive. As noted above, both witness testimony and documentary evidence, including Dr. Grandison’s report, confirm that STUDENT needed frequent breaks, frequent redirection, and prompting to stay on task for non-preferred activities, like many academic tasks. While there is little question that STUDENT had a short attention span for non-preferred activities, there was no evidence whatsoever indicating that the pace or structure of the SH-SDC contributed to that problem. Instead, it is more likely that, given STUDENT’s short attention span, she would have learned better in a class that changed activities frequently and did not require concentration far beyond her current level. While working to increase STUDENT’s attention span was an important goal, allowing STUDENT to learn despite her short attention span was at least as important.

Comparing and contrasting the academic benefits of each placement, the evidence demonstrated greater academic benefit available to STUDENT in the SH-SDC. While the general education setting would have offered STUDENT better language models and would have provided her with peers better able to understand her speech and gestures, the other academic benefits of the SH-SDC greatly outweigh these factors. Given STUDENT’s cognitive, academic, and communicative delays, she received greater academic benefit in a structured, slower-paced class with consistency, frequent repetition, individual attention and a low teacher-to-student ratio. In contrast, even when she was accompanied by an aide, in fall 2003 STUDENT could not keep up with the instruction in the general education kindergarten. The SH-SDC also allowed the teacher to implement the instruction STUDENT learned in her DIS, because the low teacher-to-student ratio gave the teacher time to consult with DIS providers and observe them providing services to STUDENT. In contrast, a general education teacher with twenty-two students would likely not have the time to participate in a student’s DIS so frequently and would not have as much time to customize STUDENT’s instruction to her needs. Given the evidence regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the academic benefits of the SH-SDC significantly exceeded those available to STUDENT in a general education kindergarten.

(2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled

STUDENT was a sociable child who often enjoyed playing with other children. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Borges, MOTHER.) Ms. Lund reported that she never saw STUDENT interact with the other students in the general education kindergarten, but Ms. Davis, Ms. Borges and MOTHER all gave credible accounts describing how STUDENT played with other children. Moreover, in light of her speech delays, she had a better likelihood of being understood by typically developing peers. (Testimony of MOTHER.) As noted in the prior section, typically developing peers provided STUDENT with more appropriate peer language models.

As determined previously in this Decision, STUDENT was sometimes able to imitate peers, depending on the setting and the complexity of the tasks. (See testimony of Ms. Lund, Ms. Borges, Ms. Davis, Dist. Exh. 19.) To the extent that STUDENT modeled peers, she would have benefitted from the language models provided by typically developing peers. However, the non-academic benefits of the general education kindergarten would have been limited to the extent that STUDENT’s imitation skills were limited. Ms. Lund and Ms. Borges described how they each tried to encourage STUDENT to participate in the classroom activities by modeling the activities themselves and encouraging STUDENT to imitate other children performing those activities. Ms. Borges reported some success with getting STUDENT to imitate in this manner, while Ms. Lund reported that STUDENT generally would not imitate in this manner. Ms. Jack’s and Ms. Davis’s written observations of the general education kindergarten indicated that STUDENT rarely imitated her peers even when encouraged to do so, and that she required frequent adult prompting and instructions to participate in the class activities. (Dist. Exh. 19.) Thus, to the extent that STUDENT did not model peers, the nonacademic benefits available to her in general education were limited accordingly.

(3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom

There is no question that STUDENT was a sweet, likable, well-behaved child whose presence enriched her classroom. However, Ms. Davis’s uncontroverted testimony was that STUDENT could be distracting to the other students; for example, in the written observations of STUDENT in the general education kindergarten in October 2003, during academic tasks she repeatedly said “hi” to peers and otherwise tried to make contact with peers, instead of working on the assigned task. (Dist. Exh. 19, p. 84-89.)

Regarding STUDENT’s effect on the classroom teacher, the evidence was clear that STUDENT’s delays required significant adult attention and instruction, although the amount of attention STUDENT would have required from the teacher would generally have decreased the more that an aide assisted STUDENT. Ms. Lund testified that, when she and Ms. Davis attempted to fade Ms. Davis’s assistance to STUDENT in the general education kindergarten pursuant to the parents’ request, instructing and assisting STUDENT took a great deal of Ms. Lund’s time. Consistent with this testimony, Dr. Grandison’s written evaluation report emphasized that STUDENT required significant adult support to complete academic tasks. (Dist. Exh. 45.)

Thus, the effect of STUDENT’s presence on the other students and teacher in a general education class would have been mixed. STUDENT not display discipline problems and would have had a positive effect to the extent that she was a delightful child. However, STUDENT was occasionally distracting to the other students and generally required significant adult attention and instruction. To the extent that STUDENT would have received assistance from an aide, the amount of attention she required from the teacher would generally be reduced.

(4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom

Neither party presented evidence or argument on this factor, and therefore the Hearing Officer clarified at the hearing that cost would not be considered as a factor in this Decision.

To summarize the three factors at issue in determining STUDENT’s LRE, the academic benefits of the SH-SDC were far greater than those of general education. Regarding non-academic benefits, STUDENT could have benefitted somewhat from the socialization and peer models in the general education classroom, although in fall 2003 she frequently did not imitate peers in that setting. STUDENT’s effect on the teacher and other students in her class would have been mixed; she was well-behaved and enjoyable to be around, but she could be distracting to the other students. She also required significant attention from the general education teacher, although this amount would generally have decreased to the extent she received greater assistance from an aide.

The Student argued that the factual circumstances in Rachel H. supported her argument for a general education placement. In the Rachel H. case, the parents of a moderately mentally retarded girl appealed the school’s decision to place her half-time in general education and half-time in special education, instead seeking a full-time general education placement with appropriate supports and services. (Rachel H., supra at 1398.) In applying the four-part test set out above, the Ninth Circuit Court upheld the district court’s findings that general education placement was the LRE based upon greater academic and non-academic benefits available to Rachel in a general education setting, the positive effect she would have on the other students and teacher in the general education classroom, and the negligible issue of cost. The district court’s findings that Rachel would receive greater academic and non-academic benefits in general education were based upon the persuasive testimony of witnesses, including Rachel’s teacher’s description of how Rachel was making progress on her IEP goals in a general education setting, and the parents’ expert testimony that Rachel had made significant strides in the general education setting. (Id. at 1401-1402.)

In contrast, the nature of the evidence in the present case was entirely different. There was virtually no evidence indicating educational benefit that would be greater in the general education setting compared to the special education setting, and very limited evidence of greater nonacademic benefit. All of STUDENT’s teachers, instructors and assessors, including her private preschool teacher and the independent neuropsychologist from Children’s Hospital, consistently recommended a special education setting for STUDENT. Unlike the facts in Rachel H., STUDENT’s general education teacher testified that STUDENT had not able to meaningfully participate when she was mainstreamed for academics in fall 2003.

Considering all three of the relevant LRE factors, the Hearing Officer concludes that the special education classroom was STUDENT’s LRE. The evidence clearly established that STUDENT would have received greater academic benefit from the SH-SDC. Given the great weight of academic benefits available to STUDENT in the SH-SDC, the mixed nonacademic impact of the general education kindergarten, and the mixed effect of her presence in the general education kindergarten, the SH-SDC was the LRE to address STUDENT’s unique needs. While STUDENT also needed mainstreaming for socialization, her program included mainstreaming for activities such as recess, music, and weekly station time among all of the Strandwood kindergarten students.

Hence, the Hearing Officer has concluded that, in the context of STUDENT’s entire program, the SH-SDC placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit, was in conformity with her IEP, and was in her LRE. Accordingly, the SH-SDC was an appropriate classroom placement for STUDENT and did not deny her a FAPE.

************

Accordingly, this Decision has found that the District’s program for the 2003-2004 school year was substantively appropriate because it was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, was in conformity with her IEP and was offered in the LRE. This Decision determined that a minor nonconformity with the IEP occurred in November 2003 when the District failed to provide a few PT sessions, but this denial was minor and overall did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. Thus, the District’s educational program for STUDENT was substantively appropriate for the 2003-2004 school year.

B. Procedural Appropriateness

Student argues that the District failed to provide her with prior written notice of the denial of the parent’s request for additional speech therapy, in violation of the District’s procedural obligations. Federal law requires the District to provide to the parents prior written notice of its refusal to change the educational placement of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) The notice must include, among other things, an explanation for the refusal; other options considered and rejected and the reasons; and each test, record, or report used as a basis for the refusal. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(c).)

The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Rowley at 201.) Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483.) Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that do not result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do not cause a denial of a FAPE. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.)

In this case, at the IEP meeting on March 27, 2003, STUDENT’s mother presented the other team members with a letter proposing changes to STUDENT’s services, including a request to increase STUDENT’s speech-language therapy from one hour per week to two or two and a half hours per week. (Student Exh. Tab II, p. 25.) After discussion, MOTHER and the other team members agreed instead to increase STUDENT’s speech language therapy to one and a half hours per week; this increase was written into the IEP notes. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 4; testimony of MOTHER.) At the meeting, MOTHER signed her consent to the IEP.

To the extent that the District’s failure to provide written notice beyond the written comments in the IEP document may have constituted a violation of section 1415(c), any such violation did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. There is no question that MOTHER knew that the District had denied the amount of speech-language services she requested and instead had agreed to a smaller increase. The IEP notes indicate that the District team members discussed with MOTHER their rationale for recommending only one and a half hours per week, and MOTHER did not claim to the contrary. Thus, MOTHER was fully informed that her request had been denied, was informed why it had been denied, and agreed to a compromise that was written into the IEP. Considering all relevant facts, any failure to provide written notice in response to the request did not seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process nor cause a loss of educational opportunity to the student, and no procedural denial of FAPE occurred on this basis.

Accordingly, this Decision has determined that the District’s program overall was both procedurally and substantively appropriate for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.

2. For the extended school year (ESY) in summer 2004, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide an adequate number of weeks of ESY services?

Student argued that, because of her severe needs and her tendency to regress, she needed a year-round program with no more than a two-week break from her program. The District argued that its offer of a four-week ESY was appropriate to provide a FAPE to STUDENT and that there was no evidence that STUDENT regressed during breaks of longer than two weeks.

ESY services are provided to individuals with special needs who require special education services in excess of the regular academic year when interruption of their regular education program may cause regression. (Cal. Code. Regs, tit. 5, § 3043(a); see Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.2d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir.1992).) An ESY program shall provide for a minimum of twenty instructional days, not including holidays. (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 5, § 3043(d).) For purposes of reimbursement by the State to local educational agencies, ESY for individuals in severely handicapped classes may last for a maximum of fifty-five instructional days, excluding holidays. For all other eligible pupils needing ESY, ESY may last for a maximum of thirty instructional days.

For 2004 ESY, at the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting the District offered STUDENT a four-week ESY program, with placement in an SDC and her usual DIS of OT, PT, APE and speech-language. Dr. Grandison’s independent evaluation recommended that STUDENT should have a year-round program, stating that “to be without services for longer than two weeks during the summer would be detrimental in that much of the fall would then be devoted to getting her back to speed and, hence, valuable time for progress would be lost.” (Dist. Exh. 45, p. 213.) While, as discussed below, the evidence did not support that contention, Ms. Davis and other District witnesses generally acknowledged that a four-week ESY would create a fairly long break without services for STUDENT, and that a student with STUDENT’s needs would tend to have regression after such a long break. (Testimony of Ms. Davis, Ms. Chop, Ms. Jack.) Considering this persuasive testimony, and in light of the extensive evidence regarding STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer finds that a four-week ESY would not have addressed STUDENT’s needs because such a long interruption of her educational program was likely to have caused regression. Considering all of the testimony and documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s severe needs required an ESY program lasting a total of six weeks for summer 2004.

The Student contends that she required a year-round program with breaks of no longer than two weeks. As noted above, Dr. Grandison’s report recommended such a year-round program. However, STUDENT’s SDC teachers and service providers testified that they did not see any significant regression in STUDENT after long breaks, such as when she returned from the winter holiday break in January. (Testimony of Ms. Chop, Ms. Davis, Ms. McBeth.) Indeed, Ms. McBeth testified that she provided STUDENT’s PT for both 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, and did not see regression when STUDENT returned after the summer break. While the Hearing Officer gives consideration to Dr. Grandison’s report, the testimony of Ms. Chop, Ms. McBeth and Ms. Davis is more persuasive on this point because STUDENT’s instructors testified at the hearing and formed their opinions after actually observing STUDENT return to school after breaks.

Additionally, Ms. Davis persuasively testified that a year-round program would not be beneficial because STUDENT needed to “recharge her batteries” during summer break. As noted previously in this Decision, Ms. Davis was an experienced, credentialed special education teacher who had worked extensively with STUDENT and therefore was very familiar with STUDENT’s educational needs. Ms. Davis consistently provided thoughtful, informative, credible testimony and was persuasive on this point.

Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that, in order to receive a FAPE, STUDENT did not require a year-round program with breaks no longer than two weeks. This Decision has determined that the District’s offer of a four-week ESY did not constitute a FAPE because STUDENT required a six-week ESY in order to avoid regression over the summer vacation. However, because the additional two weeks constituted only a minor part of STUDENT’s overall program, and because this Decision has already found that the remainder of STUDENT’s program was appropriate, the number of weeks offered in ESY constituted only a minimal denial of FAPE.

3. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

Both parties concur that the program the District has offered for the 2004-2005 school year is essentially the same as the program offered for the previous school year: continued placement in Ms. Davis’s SH-SDC at Strandwood, with the same amounts of DIS pursuant to the IEPs of April 6, 2004 and June 2, 2004. There was no evidence of any notable change in STUDENT’s needs from the prior school year, other than some educational progress as discussed above.

Given the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the program offered for the 2004-2005 school year likewise constitutes a FAPE.

4. For the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at a certified nonpublic school that provides deaf/hard-of-hearing services?

Because the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, there is no basis to order STUDENT’s prospective placement at a certified non-public school.

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a remedy for the District’s denials of FAPE? Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).) In fashioning appropriate equitable relief the conduct of both parties should be reviewed, along with the nature of relief requested, to determine whether an award of compensatory education is appropriate. (Id.) Courts have explained that the purpose of compensatory relief is to replace lost educational services and ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. (Student W. at 1497; Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991); Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996).) There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. (Student W. at 1497.)

In the present case, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District failed to provide STUDENT with two or three PT sessions in conformity with her IEP and did not make up those missed sessions. While STUDENT continued to make progress in PT and met her PT goals, there is no dispute that she continued to have extensive needs related to PT and required her weekly PT sessions to address those needs. While day-to-day replacement of services is not required, given STUDENT’s needs and the small number of missed sessions, in the present case replacement of two sessions is the most feasible and most appropriate means to remedy the nonconformity and ensure that STUDENT is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Thus, the District shall provide STUDENT with two additional forty-five-minute PT sessions to make up for any sessions that she missed.

Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the very limited extent that it offered her a four-week ESY program instead of a six-week ESY program. Given STUDENT’s needs and the limited period of time that she was denied services, an award of compensatory education is an equitable and appropriate remedy in this instance. To account for the remaining two weeks (out of a six-week program) wherein the District did not offer STUDENT any academic instruction, the District shall provide STUDENT with an additional six hours of one-to-one academic tutoring as compensatory education for any regression which may have occurred when she returned to school in fall 2004. The tutoring shall be provided by a certificated teacher or experienced tutor, and the District may provide the tutoring itself or may contract with a non-public school or non-public agency.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen days of the date of this Decision, the District shall notify the IEP team members of an IEP team meeting, to be held no later than thirty days of the date of this Decision. At that IEP team meeting, the team shall do the following:

a. Add a provision for two additional forty-five-minute physical therapy sessions, as compensatory education for failure to provide those sessions in November 2003;

b. Add a provision for six hours of one-to-one academic tutoring as compensatory education for any regression which may have occurred due to a shortened ESY offer for summer 2004.

2. All of Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. Did the District deny the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

The District generally prevailed on this issue. The Student prevailed only to the very limited extent that the District failed to provide some physical therapy sessions in conformity with her IEP in November 2003.

2. For the extended school year (ESY) in summer 2004, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide an adequate number of weeks of ESY services?

The Student prevailed only to the limited extent that a minor denial of FAPE occurred because the District offered her four weeks of ESY services instead of the six weeks that she needed. The District otherwise prevailed on this issue.

3. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

4. For the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at a certified nonpublic school that provides deaf/hard-of-hearing services?

The District prevailed on this issue.

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a remedy for the District’s denials of FAPE?

The Student prevailed on this issue only to the limited extent that she is entitled to compensatory education of two forty-five minute physical therapy sessions and six hours of one-to-one academic tutoring. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: September 23, 2004 __________________________________

1. original Decision, issued on September 23, 2004, contained an incorrect date in the first sentence. No substantive changes were made to the Decision.

2. Ms. Chop testified by telephone from her residence in northern California.

3. Ms. Jack is no longer a District employee and testified by telephone from her residence in Arizona.

4. To the extent that the Student’s written closing argument raises new claims not previously identified at the hearing, this Decision does not address those new claims.

5. To facilitate a clear organization of this Decision, the issues identified in the Prehearing Conference Order dated July 21, 2004, have been clarified and consolidated. However, the substance of the hearing issues remains the same, except where, as noted in this Decision’s Procedural Matters section, Student withdrew issues during the hearing.

6. In her written closing brief, Student indicated that she “may have been hasty in eliminating California School for the Deaf as an option” and thereafter requested that placement. In preparing its closing brief, the District was entitled to rely on Student’s stated dismissal of this remedy, and therefore this Decision will not consider prospective placement at California School for the Deaf as part of the issues. In any event, the evidence established that STUDENT would not meet the admission requirements of California School for the Deaf, because she does not have a severe hearing impairment. (Testimony of Barbara Scott; Dist. Exh. 74, p. 332, 334.)

7. During her testimony on the final day of hearing, MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT is not hearing-impaired and instead has normal hearing.

8. Because the Valhalla SDC was a four-week program, they agreed that the details about the remaining two weeks of the ESY would be worked out later. In a letter dated August 2, 2004, program specialist Sharon Krell wrote that the District was offering STUDENT an additional two weeks of DIS in August 2004 to provide STUDENT with a six-week ESY program.

9. During the time period at issue, California Education Code section 56320(b)(1) specified that tests and other evaluation materials must be provided in the child’s primary language. Recent legislation changed the language of section 56320(b)(1) from “primary language” to “native language,” to conform with the IDEA. The IDEA regulation, Code of Federal Regulations title 34, section 300.532(a)(1), has consistently specified that tests and other evaluation materials must be provided in the child’s native language.

10. Because of STUDENT’s delays in receptive communication, some testing was conducted nonverbally. (Testimony of Ms. Tradup-Mahloch; Dist. Exh. 36, p. 192.)

11. The IDEA regulations at Code of Federal Regulations, Title 34, section 300.19 state as follows: (a) As used in this part, the term native language, if used with reference to an individual of limited English proficiency, means the following: (1) The language normally used by that individual, or, in the case of a child, the language normally used by the parents of the child, except as provided in paragraph (a)(2) of this section. (2) In all direct contact with a child (including evaluation of the child), the language normally used by the child in the home or learning environment.

12. MOTHER testified that STUDENT began learning sign language at age two when she attended the Milliff Center.

13. At the time of Ms. Olsen’s testimony on July 28, 2004, she had worked with STUDENT for approximately three and a half weeks during the 2004 ESY.

14. Ms. Peterson described how audiological assessments are different from hearing screenings by a school nurse, which are required for all students in kindergarten, first, third, fifth, seventh, and tenth grades. Both Ms. Peterson and Ms. Scott described how the school nurses provide the mandatory hearing screening as a matter of course, and if a student fails that screening or the nurse is unable to conduct the screening, then the student is referred to a District audiologist.

15. MOTHER also reported to the October 2002 IEP team that STUDENT had passed a hearing test by a private audiologist in August 2002. (Student Exh. Tab VII, p. 31; testimony of MOTHER.)

16. It appears that no follow-up testing ever took place.

17. STUDENT’s doctors have been investigating the possibility of a seizure disorder, but have made no formal diagnosis or determination on that question. Additionally, on the final day of hearing, MOTHER testified that the results of STUDENT’s recent MRI scan were consistent with cerebral palsy (CP). MOTHER further testified that she did not know how this would affect STUDENT’s education. Because the District had no knowledge of a CP diagnosis during the 2003-2004 school year, the District could not have addressed STUDENT’s needs relating to this condition during the 2003-2004 school year. (See Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).) Moreover, because only limited information was admitted into evidence about a possible CP condition, and it had not been presented to the District until the last day of hearing, the assessors and District staff could not consider how the possible condition might affect STUDENT’s needs for the 2004-2005 school year. Considering these circumstances, the Hearing Officer does not have sufficient information to consider CP as part of STUDENT’s needs in this Decision. Notably, the District will likely need to obtain further information about whether STUDENT has CP to offer her a FAPE in the future.

18. Alternatively, Student argued that her deaf/hard-of-hearing services should teach her how to control her loud voice. However, given the findings that STUDENT did not have a hearing impairment, she did not need deaf/hard-of-hearing services.

19. An unofficial transcript of the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting indicates that someone at the meeting raised a concern about STUDENT using a loud voice in public. (Student’s Exh. Tab IX, p. 13.) The context of the discussion suggests that it was MOTHER who raised this topic, although that is not for certain.

20. The District correctly raises the point that AT is not a DIS, pursuant to the definition of DIS in California Education Code section 56363(a). (See Dist. Exh. 53, p. 232 (IEP notes state that AAC “is not a DIS service...Assistive Technology works with the team to provide instruction for STUDENT across all environments.”).)

21. In contrast, the unofficial transcript of the June 2004 IEP meeting quotes an unidentified team member who states that STUDENT received twenty minutes of speech and language therapy per day, five days a week. (Student Exh. Tab IX.)

22. The unofficial IEP transcript does not identify the speakers by name. However, the substance and context of the statements indicate that the statements may safely be attributed to Dr. Grandison.

23. In her testimony, Ms. Teekell noted that MOTHER had never asked to bring home the Communication Builder device (one of STUDENT’s subsequent VOCA devices).

24. Ms. Teekell testified that she would have agreed if the parent had asked to use the software at home. The IEP notes state that “if software is needed @ home to support STUDENT it will be provided. Mrs. MOTHER is requesting material to support STUDENT @ home.” (Student Exh. Tab VI, p. 138.)

25. Both the Student and the District concur that STUDENT made progress in PT and on her PT goals and objectives over the course of the 2003-2004 school year.

26. Additionally, it is unclear whether Dr. Grandison, who is a neuropsychologist, has any expertise in the area of PT. In contrast, Ms. McBeth has a Bachelor of Science degree in PT and has worked as a physical therapist since 1974. (Dist. Exh. 77; testimony of Ms. McBeth.)

27. In Student’s written closing argument, she appears to raise this denial as a new issue and requests an independent AT assessment. Because Student did not identify this request as an issue prior to the hearing, this Decision cannot address the new claim.

28. Aside from MOTHER, the only witness who did not specifically recommend an SDC placement for STUDENT was STUDENT’s step-grandfather, STEP GRANDFATHER, who instead testified that STUDENT needed a “one-to-one teacher.” STEP GRANDFATHER stated that he has been successful teaching tasks to STUDENT on a one-to-one basis and that STUDENT learns best that way.

29. As this Decision discussed in the section regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, the variations in the reports from these teachers are not particularly inconsistent and can be reconciled. There is no dispute that preschool is less demanding than kindergarten, and therefore STUDENT was likely better able to meet the demands of the preschool setting compared to the kindergarten setting.

30. When MOTHER informed the District staff members that she intended to file for a due process special education hearing with the Hearing Office, the District then offered a six-week ESY placement as a stay put placement, because STUDENT had attended a six-week ESY placement in summer 2003 pursuant to an agreed-upon IEP. The parties eventually reached an agreement otherwise solely regarding STUDENT’s attendance at ESY for summer 2004. Because STUDENT’s parents would not accept the classroom offered as part of the proposed six-week placement, the parties agreed to an ESY placement at a different classroom that met for only four weeks.

31. The Hearing Officer notes that many of the District’s SDC classes lasted only for four weeks. Thus, if a six-week classroom placement was not available, the remaining two weeks of STUDENT’s ESY could have consisted solely of her DIS plus a limited amount of one-on-one academic tutoring, such as three hours per week, as a substitute for a classroom placement.

32. Notably, the District later offered a six-week ESY to comply with stay put, although STUDENT’s mother did not accept that offer. Instead, the parties reached an agreement otherwise that STUDENT would attend an SDC at the District’s Valhalla Elementary School. (Testimony of Katie Hanau-Gaines.) Because the Valhalla SDC lasted for only four weeks of summer 2004, STUDENT could attend the class for only four weeks. The District offered to provide STUDENT with an additional two weeks of DIS, for a total of six weeks, plus an additional three sessions of PT. STUDENT’s mother rejected the offer for the additional two weeks of DIS, but STUDENT did receive two additional sessions each of OT and PT during the four-week ESY. (Testimony of Sharon Krell, Ms. Martell.)