California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 10, 2003
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1703-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Capistrano Unified must reimburse summer autism therapy and two evaluations and must now place 3-year-old in a typical preschool.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision.
Summary
Parents of a 3-year-old with autism filed for due process as he moved from Regional Center early intervention to Capistrano Unified School District. Before age 3, he received about 20 hours a week of in-home behavior therapy from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), plus speech, occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT). The District offered a structured autism special day class with 5 weekly hours of its own intensive behavioral instruction (IBI). It also offered a summer "maintenance" plan that cut CARD to 10 hours a week until August 31.
The Hearing Officer found the District followed the stay put order. The parents caused the delays in therapy, and District IBI was a proper substitute for CARD. The summer plan denied FAPE from July 23 to September 4, 2002, so the District must repay the parents' CARD costs for that period. The District's assessments were adequate, with two exceptions: it never formally assessed oral-motor skills, and it did not finish its PT assessment before the July IEP meeting. The parents were repaid for private speech and PT evaluations. The fall offer was appropriate except that it left out PT. The autism class was the least restrictive environment when offered. But the boy then did well at Country Village Preschool, so the Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting to place him in a typical preschool with support. Private costs for the fall were not repaid.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a Part C to Part B transition. A reduced summer "maintenance" plan was not enough for a toddler who was progressing in intensive therapy. The Hearing Officer also ordered a less restrictive placement for the future based on the child's later success, while still finding the district's original offer appropriate under Adams v. Oregon.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedStay put
Issue 1. Did the District fail to comply with an August 12, 2002 stay put order?
District made timely, continuing offers of stay put OT, PT, speech and IBI services matching the IFSP; delays were caused by the parents, and District IBI was a proper substitute for CARD services.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 2A. For the period commencing July 23, 2002 through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE in the LRE by failing to adequately assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?
Cognitive, behavior, most speech and OT assessments were adequate; failure to formally assess oral-motor skills was a violation without FAPE denial, but failure to properly and timely complete the PT assessment before the July 22 IEP meeting infringed parent participation and denied FAPE in PT.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B. For the period commencing July 23, 2002 through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate program and placement?
The summer maintenance plan cutting CARD to 10 hours/week denied FAPE from July 23 to September 4, 2002, and the 2002-2003 offer denied FAPE only by omitting PT; the autism class, 5 hours of IBI, speech and OT offers were appropriate, and failure to update goals did not deny FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 2C. For the period commencing July 23, 2002 through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate placement in the LRE?
The special day class was the LRE when offered given the behavior history, but the student's later success in a typical preschool makes a typical preschool class his LRE now, so it was ordered prospectively.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3A. As a remedy, are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private assessments?
Parents reimbursed for the private speech-language evaluation (Judy Segal) and PT evaluation (Sky Pediatric Therapy); reimbursement for the neurodevelopmental and OT evaluations denied because those District assessments were appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3B. As a remedy, are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private placement and services?
Parents reimbursed for CARD services, supervision and clinic from July 23 to September 4, 2002; no reimbursement for the 2002-2003 school year because the District's offer was appropriate apart from PT, which stay put services covered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days, IEP team to meet to select a typical preschool class as the LRE placement, with classroom support similar to the CARD aide (an IBI tutor may be used); Country Village Preschool to be given priority consideration, or else a similar class. At the same meeting, amend the IEP for the new placement, reconsider the intensity of IBI, OT, PT and speech services (likely to need significant increase), and draft new present levels and goals.
- Placement ordered. Attendance in a typical preschool class at 4 hours per day, 5 days per week, consistent with the District's prior structured autism class offer.
- Order to assess. Within 20 days, District to submit a written assessment plan for parent consent to assess oral-motor skills.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days, reimburse parents $500.00 for Judy Segal's speech-language evaluation and $250.00 for the Sky Pediatric Therapy evaluation (body of decision states the Sky Pediatric invoice was $265.00).
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of proof of payment or invoices, reimburse parents for CARD services, including CARD supervision and clinic services, from July 23, 2002 through September 4, 2002 (amount not stated).
Total: $750 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Adams v. State of Oregon; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Diane Lappi, executive director for special education, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robert Roice, education advocate for District, Capistrano Unified School District
- Jolie Deatrick, preschool director, Country Village Preschool
- Lailane Cruz, preschool classroom teacher, Country Village Preschool
- Nancy Press, private occupational therapist (independent OT evaluation), Private
- Stacey Kurihara, private pediatric physical therapist (independent PT evaluation), Sky Pediatric Therapy
- Anahita Parsi, CARD case supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Lisa Bancroft, CARD case supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Judy Segal, private speech-language pathologist (independent evaluation), Private
- Abby Rozenberg, private speech-language pathologist, Private
- Christine Majors, Ph.D., psychologist, expert witness for Student (neurodevelopmental evaluation), Private
- Sandra Garrison, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Sharla Pitzen, autism specialist, program specialist and IBI program director, Capistrano Unified School District
- Constance (Connie) Johnson, speech-language pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Jennifer Greenfield, autism specialist and IBI supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Nancy Lin, occupational therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Lois Faist, autism specialist and IBI supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Caroline White, IBI senior tutor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Nicole Woods, physical therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Charlene Lerman, structured autism class teacher and IBI supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Paul Dores, Ph.D., psychologist, District witness
- Denise Yota, occupational therapist (OT records review), Capistrano Unified School District
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private ABA/behavior therapy agency
- Rainbow Kids, early intervention therapy provider (speech, OT, PT)
- Newport Language and Speech Centers, private speech-language provider
- Speech Pathology Associates, speech-language evaluator (December 2001 evaluation)
- Sky Pediatric Therapy, private PT evaluator
- Country Village Preschool, private typical preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on November 5, 6, 13, 14, and 15, 2002, in San Juan Capistrano, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Michael Jewell and Paul Roberts from the law office of Roberts & Adams. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER. Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by education advocate Robert Roice. Also present on the District’s behalf was Diane Lappi, District executive director for special education.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Jolie Deatrick, Country Village Preschool director; Lailane Cruz, Country Village Preschool classroom teacher; Nancy Press, occupational therapist; Stacey Kurihara, pediatric physical therapist; Anahita Parsi, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) case supervisor; Judy Segal, speech and language pathologist; Abby Rozenberg, speech and language pathologist; Lisa Bancroft, CARD case supervisor; FATHER; and Christine Majors, Ph.D., psychologist.
The District called the following witnesses: Sandra Garrison, District school psychologist; Sharla Pitzen, District autism specialist and intensive behavioral instruction (IBI) program director; Constance Johnson, District speech and language pathologist; Jennifer Greenfield, District autism specialist and IBI supervisor; Nancy Lin, District occupational therapist; Lois Faist, District autism specialist and IBI supervisor; Caroline White, District IBI senior tutor; Nicole Woods, District physical therapist; Charlene Lerman, District structured autism class teacher and IBI supervisor; and Paul Dores, Ph.D., psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the receipt of closing briefs by the Hearing Officer on December 9, 2002, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1: Did the District fail to comply with an August 12, 2002 stay put order?
Issue 2: For the period commencing July 23, 2002 and continuing through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE) by:
A. Failing to adequately assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability,
B. Failing to offer an appropriate program and placement, and
C. Failing to offer an appropriate placement in the LRE?
Issue 3: As a remedy for the District having failed to appropriately assess STUDENT and/or having denied a FAPE to STUDENT in the LRE, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to:
A. Reimbursement for private assessments, and
B. Reimbursement for private placement and services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], is eligible for special education under the category of autism. In the summer of 2001, the Regional Center of Orange County (Regional Center) began providing services to STUDENT through an individualized family service plan (IFSP). The purpose of the IFSP was to address deficits and/or delays identified in the areas of gross-motor and fine-motor skills, cognitive development, receptive and expressive language, social and emotional development, and adaptive and self-help skills. Speech and language, physical therapy (PT), and occupational therapy (OT) services commenced in the summer of 2001, and Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) services commenced in November 2001. His most recent IFSP, dated May 6, 2002, provided for one-on-one CARD therapy services, 90 hours per month, plus CARD supervision. The IFSP also provided for one hour of OT at Rainbow Kids, per month, and it provided for one hour of PT and 3 hours of speech and language at Rainbow Kids, per week. In anticipation of STUDENT’s transition to the District at age 3, the IFSP provided that STUDENT would have an assessment completed by the District, and he would have an “individualized education program” (IEP) in place prior to his third birthday. STUDENT continued to receive IFSP services through July 22, 2002, the day before his third birthday.
STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was convened by the District on June 20, 2002. The District recommended and offered a program for the 2002-2003 school year, commencing in September, that would include placement in a special day class (SDC) for 5 hours per day, 4 days per week. Weekly speech and language services would be provided for one 30-minute individual session and one 30-minute group session. The District also offered a summer maintenance/transition plan, to begin on July 23, 2002. The transition/maintenance plan provided that during the 6-week period from July 23 through August 31, STUDENT would receive 10 hours per week of direct CARD services instead of the 90 hours per month that he had been receiving under his IFSP(Footnote 1). CARD services would terminate on August 31. When the new school year commenced on or about September 5, STUDENT would begin receiving intensive behavioral instruction (IBI) program services from the District for 5 hours per week.(Footnote 2)
The June 20, 2002 IEP meeting notes state that assessment in the areas of OT and PT was in progress and the determination of OT and PT services was deferred to the next IEP meeting. Regarding IEP goals and objectives for the overall program, the District had used data obtained by CARD through April 2002, in addition to other sources of information, to draft a set of goals and objectives presented by the District at the June 20 meeting. However, an updated and more extensive set of proposed goals and objectives was submitted at the meeting by Lisa Bancroft, STUDENT’s CARD supervisor. Ms. Bancroft’s set of goals and objectives had been developed using STUDENT’s present levels of performance as ascertained from new CARD data, obtained after April 2002. Due to time constraints, further discussion for determining goals and objectives was deferred to the next IEP meeting. The meeting notes conclude by stating that a “final placement” determination would be made after the mother had visited some SDC options identified by the District, including a structured SDC specifically for children with autism.
On June 24, 2002, STUDENT’s mother viewed the “structured autism preschool” class at Viejo Elementary School (Viejo) and the “non-categorical preschool” program at Barcelona Elementary Preschool (Barcelona). In a July 1, 2002 letter to the District’s program specialist, Sharla Pitzen, STUDENT’s mother expressed her belief that on the basis of her observations neither the Viejo nor the Barcelona situation would be appropriate for STUDENT.
The District convened the next IEP meeting on July 22, 2002. The placement and services offered by the District were essentially the same as at the prior meeting, except an offer was made for OT once per week for one month, beginning at the start of the new school year, and monthly OT consultation thereafter. STUDENT’s parents expressed their objections to the structured autism SDC at Viejo and the non-categorical SDC at Barcelona. According to the meeting notes, the parents also believed that “10 hrs per week of IBI w/ CARD is not sufficient and that doctor’s recommendation of 25 hrs per week during the transition period is necessary.” The parents requested that transition services continue until an appropriate preschool was found. The parents also requested “stay put” pursuant to federal and State law, asserting that when STUDENT became 3 years old on July 23, he was entitled to continue with his current level of services at Rainbow Kids and CARD pending the outcome of due process proceedings. The District’s program specialist planned to obtain a legal opinion regarding the correct stay put placement.(Footnote 3) The parents suggested that a followup IEP meeting be held on August 1, 2002, because Sharla Pitzen, the District’s autism specialist most familiar with STUDENT, had been unable to attend the July 22 meeting.
The Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing and motion for a stay put order were filed at the Hearing Office on July 24, 2002. By letter to the District dated July 24, 2002, attorney Paul Roberts informed the District that his office would be representing STUDENT and the parents. The letter stated that the parents disagreed with the offer for an SDC placement and they had enrolled STUDENT into a private preschool. Notice was given that the parents would seek reimbursement for the private preschool costs. Notice was also given that the parents disagreed with the District’s assessments and the parents were requesting an independent assessment at the District’s expense. The letter stated that independent assessments were currently being scheduled by the parents and request was made for a September 2002 IEP meeting to discuss the independent assessment results.
Ms. Pitzen wrote to the parents on August 7, 2002, and enclosed a copy of a PT record review. The review by District physical therapist Nicole Woods recommended a full evaluation to determine PT services. A parent consent form was enclosed for signature. Also enclosed with Ms. Pitzen’s letter were updates to the present levels of performance and goals and objectives the District had submitted at the June 20 IEP meeting, along with a copy of an OT report previously presented at the July 22 IEP meeting.(Footnote 4) A new offer was made for OT services consisting of one session per week, in a group of not more than 3 students, from September 5 through December 5, with a review by the IEP team to be scheduled for December 5.
On August 12, 2002, the Hearing Office issued a ruling on the Petitioner’s stay put motion. The order stated that “Petitioner’s motion for stay put services in the beginning of the traditional school year is granted with respect to the nature and duration of services requested.
The motion for stay put is denied to the extent that Petitioner requests the specific service providers called for in the IFSP. The motion for stay put to apply during the month of August and prior to the beginning of the traditional school year is also denied.”(Footnote 5)
With the Petitioner’s motion for an order requiring stay put services during July and August having been denied, the Petitioner’s attorney informed the District by letter dated August 21, 2002, that the parents were now in agreement for implementation of the “maintenance and transition services” from July 22 through August 31, as offered at the July 22 IEP meeting. The letter stated the parents’ belief that their August 21 acceptance entitled STUDENT to a 5-week maintenance program of transition support consistent with the transition plan offered at the June 20, 2002 IEP meeting, essentially totaling 5 weeks of CARD at 10 hours per week plus the designated hours of supervision and progress clinic.
Diane Lappi, District executive director for special education, submitted a written response to the parents’ attorney on August 22, 2002. Because the new school year was about to commence, Ms. Lappi wrote that the parents’ consent to the maintenance and transition plan had come too late to avail STUDENT of all the maintenance services specified in the plan. Instead, the District was now offering only the services corresponding to the remaining portion of the initially-stated maintenance and transition period, meaning that maintenance and transition services would be provided only for the period from August 22 to August 31. During that period STUDENT would receive 14 hours of CARD tutoring plus the remaining 1.5 hours of supervision, 4 hours of student progress clinic, and 1 hour of observation by the District IBI supervisor and District classroom teacher.
By letter dated August 29, 2002, Ms. Lappi restated the District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year. The letter noted that the parents had not signed the consent form submitted on August 7 for a PT assessment. The letter itemized the stay put services that the District remained willing to provide upon commencement of the 2002-2003 school year.
On September 25, 2002, the parents’ attorney, Mr. Jewell, and the District’s advocate, Mr. Roice, exchanged faxed letters regarding stay put.(Footnote 6) Mr. Jewell asserted that although the parents had never dissented to having the District provide OT, PT, and speech and language therapy pursuant to the stay put order, the District had failed to provide the services. Mr. Jewell informed the District that, consequently, the parents would seek to obtain those services privately and would seek reimbursement from the District. Mr. Roice responded by asserting that the District had made repeated offers to provide the stay put services and the District remained willing to provide the services.
Several weeks after commencement of the 2002-2003 school year, the District began providing OT and PT services to STUDENT pursuant to stay put, and several additional weeks thereafter the District began providing speech and language services pursuant to stay put. The District has provided STUDENT with no other services. The parents have declined to receive stay put services by District providers in place of CARD. The parents continue to reject the program and placement offer for the 2002-2003 school year, including the proposed placement in an SDC with supporting IBI services. STUDENT has undergone parent-funded assessments, including a neurodevelopmental evaluation by Christine Majors, Ph.D., speech and language evaluation by Judy Segal, PT evaluation by Sky Pediatric Therapy, and OT evaluation by Nancy Press. Through parent funding, he has received speech and language therapy by Abby Rosenberg and by Newport Language and Speech Centers, in-home therapy by CARD, and he attends a regular preschool class at Country Village Preschool, assisted by the services of a one-on-one aide.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District fail to comply with an August 12, 2002 stay put order?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, a special education student shall remain in his or her current educational placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures, unless the parties agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. §1415(j); California Education Code §56346(b), §56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. For purposes of stay put, the current educational placement is typically the placement agreed upon in an individualized education program and implemented by the parties prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education (6th Cir. 1990) 918 F.2d 618.
The August 12, 2002 stay put order required that the District offer STUDENT a stay put placement in conformity with his IFSP.(Footnote 7) The order specified that the District was not required to provide stay put services from STUDENT’s third birthday through August 31, 2002. Instead, stay put services were applicable at the beginning of the traditional school year. The District was required to offer stay put services in conformity with the IFSP in terms of their nature and frequency, although the District was not required to use the specific service providers, i.e. CARD, identified in the IFSP.
The Petitioner asserts that although the District eventually offered OT, PT, and speech and language stay put services, the services were not offered in a timely manner. With respect to CARD-type services, the Petitioner asserts that the services offered by the District were not in conformity with what CARD had provided under the IFSP. Each of the Petitioner’s assertions regarding stay put compliance will now be addressed.(Footnote 8)
OT, PT, and speech and language. The dispute with respect to stay put compliance for OT, PT, and speech and language is whether the services were offered in a timely manner. The Petitioner asserts that the provision of OT and PT stay put services was not made until several weeks after the start of the school year, and no speech and language stay put services were offered until about one or two weeks before the start of the due process hearing.
The evidence shows that prior to issuance of the stay put order, the District’s proposal for stay put services had been described in a July 31, 2002 letter from its education advocate, Robert Roice. The letter stated the District’s acknowledgment of its obligation to provide stay put services in conformity with STUDENT’s IFSP. In his letter, Mr. Roice correctly interpreted the IFSP and stay put law as not requiring the provision of services during the period between the date of STUDENT’s third birthday on July 23 and the commencement of the traditional school year on or about September 5. The August 12, 2002 stay put order confirmed that stay put services would not have to be available until the start of the school year. In her August 29 letter to STUDENT’s attorney, Ms. Lappi restated the District’s willingness to provide stay put services in conformity with STUDENT’s IFSP. Her letter specifically itemized the services, all to be provided in amounts consistent with the IFSP.
The evidence further shows that in his letter dated September 6, 2002, the District’s advocate, Mr. Roice, confirmed to the Petitioner’s attorneys that when the District IBI supervisor, senior tutor, and one-on-one tutor had attempted to meet STUDENT in STUDENT’s home on the prior day, permission was declined. Mr. Roice’s letter did not specifically state that the District was also attempting to implement OT, PT, and speech and language services, but the letter did reiterate the District’s desire to provide services to STUDENT and stated the District’s understanding that STUDENT’s parents and/or his attorney had “decided not to allow the district to serve this student.”
By his letter dated September 25, 2002, the Petitioner’s attorney, Mr. Jewell, brought to the District’s attention the fact that, according to Mr. Jewell, the District had failed to comply with the stay put order even though the parents had never objected to receiving stay put OT, PT, and speech and language services. Mr. Jewell advised the District that the parents would seek those services on their own and request reimbursement from the District. Mr. Roice responded to Mr. Jewell’s letter with his own letter dated September 25, 2002, reminding Mr. Jewell of the District’s repeated offers to provide the stay put services and referring to the above-referenced letters dated July 31, August 29, and September 6, 2002. Mr. Roice concluded his letter by stating that “the District continues to be willing to serve this child and you need only contact me and we can put services into effect.”
The Hearing Officer finds that in spite of letters from the Petitioner’s counsel asserting the contrary, the District made timely and continuing offers for the provision of stay put services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the delays in providing stay put OT, PT, and speech and language services were caused by the Petitioner delaying his acceptance of those services. CARD services. In her August 29 letter to STUDENT’s attorney, Ms. Lappi reiterated the District’s willingness to provide stay put services in conformity with STUDENT’s IFSP, and her letter specifically itemized 90 hours per month of “tutoring” with clinic attendance and clinic supervision in amounts consistent with the CARD services that had been provided through the most recent IFSP. Under the District’s stay put offer, the tutoring would be provided through the District’s IBI program instead of through CARD. The Petitioner asserts that he properly declined the IBI services as part of stay put because the IBI services would not have been an appropriate substitute for CARD services in addressing the Petitioner’s behavior issues. The District asserts that its IBI program would have been in conformity with what CARD had addressed under the IFSP. To resolve this question, an understanding of the CARD and IBI programs is required.
STUDENT’s CARD case supervisor, Ms. Parsi, described the CARD program.(Footnote 9) She testified that pursuant to his IFSPs, STUDENT’s CARD services primarily utilized one-on-one discrete trial training (DTT) wherein STUDENT would undergo repetitive drills to address the goals and objectives in his IFSP, especially as related to the general area of behavior. Data books were kept by his CARD therapists to record his progress. She testified that the CARD program utilizes principles of applied behavior analysis (ABA) whereby STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors are identified, events antecedent and consequent to those behaviors are identified, items are identified that can be used effectively as positive reinforcement, and those positive reinforcement items are used in a behavior modification program designed to reduce the targeted problems and increase the incidence of appropriate behaviors. STUDENT’s program was overseen by his CARD case supervisors who periodically reviewed the data, discussed STUDENT’s progress with the therapists, recommended adjustments to his program as appropriate, and trained the therapists and parents in periodic clinic sessions. Ms. Parsi testified that STUDENT’s 20 hours per week of one-on-one services were provided in his home because STUDENT had problems with distractibility; thus, he needed to taught in a relatively distraction-free environment.
The District’s IBI program was described by testimony from District IBI supervisors and autism specialists Jennifer Greenfield and Lois Faist, and by District IBI director and autism program specialist Sharla Pitzen. The program is also described in the District’s IBI training manual. Ms. Pitzen testified that the IBI program was developed to serve children who have autism. The IBI program currently serves over 50 children within the District. The evidence demonstrated that the District’s IBI program utilized substantially the same principles, methodologies, data keeping, and case supervision as the CARD program. Both programs use ABA strategies, use DTT, require data books, and provide for periodic review by a case supervisor to monitor progress, recommend program adjustment, and furnish training as necessary to the “therapists,” as titled by CARD, and the “tutors,” as titled in the IBI program. Ms. Pitzen testified that the IBI program, in general, may be administered to a child at school during the school day or at home. The intensity of IBI services can range from 2 hours to 25 hours per week, depending on the needs of the child.
On the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that for purposes of stay put, the IBI services offered by the District conformed and comported with the CARD services that STUDENT had been receiving under his applicable IFSP. The programs were substantially similar, and testimony showed that the IBI services could have been provided in STUDENT’s home environment to minimize distractions.(Footnote 10)
Issue 2: For the period commencing July 23, 2002 and continuing through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE) by:
A. Failing to adequately assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability.
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. §1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code §56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code §56031.
“Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted.” Cal. Educ. Code §56320. Subsections (a) through (d) state in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; validated for the purpose for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. Section 56320(e) requires that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Finally, pursuant to section 56320(f), a student must be “assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability.”
The Petitioner’s specific contentions regarding assessment are that the District failed to do the following: test STUDENT’s level of intellectual functioning; observe his behavior and his interactions with peers; test STUDENT in the areas of oral-motor skills, apraxia, pragmatics, voice, and articulation; complete OT and PT assessments within 50 days after the parents’ consent to a May 6, 2002 assessment plan; evaluate sensory integration as part of the OT assessment and make recommendations; and formally assess STUDENT in the area of PT instead of performing only a “records review.” The Petitioner asserts that the District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT deprived his parents of information they needed to make informed decisions at his IEP meetings, thereby denying them the opportunity to meaningfully participate in the IEP process.
Intellectual functioning. The Petitioner asserts that the District failed to test STUDENT’s level of intellectual functioning. The Petitioner’s expert witness, Christine Majors, Ph.D., testified she obtained an IQ score for the Petitioner by administering the Leiter International Performance Scale (Leiter-R), a standardized test, in September 2002. Her neurodevelopmental evaluation report, dated October 3, 2002, states that the Leiter-R is a “nonverbal measure of intellectual ability that was designed for use in assessment of children, adolescents, and young adults who cannot reliably and validly be assessed with traditional intelligence tests.” STUDENT obtained a fully-scaled IQ score of 87 on the Leiter-R, placing him in the 19th percentile, or low-average range. Dr. Majors testified that the determination of STUDENT’s IQ and overall level of intellectual functioning was important as baseline information for enabling his IEP team to know STUDENT’s potential for learning and how to address his needs. Relying heavily on information from the Leiter-R, as well as an exhaustive review of STUDENT’s records and observation of him at Country Village Preschool, Dr. Majors concluded that given STUDENT’s cognitive ability, language level, and pattern of cognitive strengths and weaknesses, he should be placed “in a preschool classroom of peers whose development is relatively typical.”
Sandra Garrison, District school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in May and June 2002. Her June 13, 2002 report, co-signed by District speech and language pathologist Connie Johnson, states that the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (Vineland), the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS), the Hawaii Early Learning Profile (HELP), the Psychoeducational Profile - Revised (PEP-R), and Test of Early Language Development (TELD-3) were administered.(Footnote 11) Ms. Garrison testified that the HELP provided baseline data on many different skills. The results of the HELP were memorialized in the June 13 report by lengthy lists of specific skills, with each skill rated either as “demonstrated,” “emerging,” or “being introduced.” Ms. Garrison testified that the format of the HELP data was particularly useful because it would enable STUDENT’s teacher to easily track and update STUDENT’s program in accordance with the particular skills that needed attention. Ms. Garrison testified that the PEP-R included subtests labeled as imitation, perception, fine motor, gross motor, eye-hand, cognitive performance, and cognitive verbal, with scores reported as an age-equivalent. Ms. Garrison testified that on the basis of her testing, plus record review and interviews, she had gained a good understanding of STUDENT’s cognitive skills when she performed her assessment. She believed that his cognitive skills were an “obvious” area of strength as opposed to an area of concern.
With respect to why she did not administer the Leiter-R to STUDENT, Ms. Garrison testified that for children on the autism spectrum, areas of deficit tend to interfere with the suitability of standardized test instruments for assessing strengths and deficits. She noted that because of such interference, Dr. Majors had made some accommodations when giving STUDENT the Leiter-R. Ms. Garrison testified that the Leiter-R manual permits the use of accommodations, but the use of accommodations reduces the validity and usefulness of an IQ score obtained under such conditions. In STUDENT’s case, Ms. Garrison considered the PEP-R to be preferable to the Leiter-R and particularly useful in assessing STUDENT because the PEP-R is specifically used for children on the autism spectrum. Although the PEP-R gives a comparatively general range of age-equivalent scores instead of an IQ score, the information from the PEP-R confirmed to Ms. Garrison that STUDENT’s cognitive level was consistent with what STUDENT’s records had indicated. Thus, she did not believe that further testing was needed in the area of cognition or intellectual functioning.(Footnote 12)
Having considered Ms. Garrison’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment in the areas of cognitive and intellectual functioning was consistent with the requirements of section 56320. As described by Ms. Garrison, the PEP-R was tailored to be used in assessing an array of skill areas commonly affected in children with autism. The HELP provided information that would be of practical daily use to STUDENT’s teachers in the classroom as they addressed specific skills that bore significant correlation to his intellectual ability. The assessment approach by Ms. Garrison conformed with the requirements of section 56320 that testing and assessment materials and procedures be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to STUDENT, a student with impaired speaking skills, the tests produced results accurately reflecting STUDENT’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the tests purported to measure, and not STUDENT’s impaired speaking skills. Ms. Garrison’s testimony and report also confirmed that no single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to obtain an IQ score for STUDENT, and the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s intellectual functioning prior to making a placement offer.
Behavior and interaction with peers. The Petitioner asserts, relying on Dr. Majors’ testimony and the testimony of Abby Rozenberg, speech and language pathologist, that the District should have observed, but did not observe, STUDENT’s behavior and how STUDENT interacted with peers and functioned in a learning setting, such as during his CARD program. As the primary basis for that testimony, Dr. Majors and Ms. Rozenberg referred to the section entitled “Behavioral Observations” appearing on page 2 of the June 13, 2002 assessment report prepared by Ms. Garrison and Ms. Johnson. The relatively brief section states that “STUDENT was seen on several occasions by the multidisciplinary assessment team during which a variety of psychoeducational and speech/language tests were administered on a one-to-one basis.” The section makes no further mention of the observations except for the statement that “STUDENT tended to respond to specific requests following a delay of up to ten minutes rather than immediately upon request. Attention to tasks was adequate in a play-based setting.” Referring to the cursory content of that section, the Petitioner asserts that STUDENT’s behavior and interaction skills were not appropriately observed.
Ms. Garrison testified that STUDENT was appropriately observed by the assessment team, notwithstanding the brevity of the “Behavioral Observation” section in her report. She explained that many of the observations were referenced elsewhere in narrative sections of the June 13, 2002 report, and she testified that detailing those observations in the Behavioral Observation section would have been needlessly redundant.(Footnote 13)
The first six pages of Ms. Garrison’s nine-page report, dated June 13, 2002, refer almost exclusively to information obtained by parent interview during administration of the Vineland, GARS, and HELP. The remaining pages of the report primarily recount the details of STUDENT’s performance on requested tasks during administration of the PEP-R, and TELD-3. Nowhere in the report is there a specific mention of STUDENT’s behavior during the testing, and there certainly is no reference to observations by District personnel regarding how, behaviorally, STUDENT interacts with peers or functions behaviorally in a learning setting.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment team documented none of its own observations regarding STUDENT’s behavior in the June 13, 2002 assessment report. However, Ms. Garrsion testified, and the evidence at the hearing confirmed, that Ms. Garrison and the IEP team did consider significant amounts of behavior-related information in recent CARD and Rainbow Kids reports prior to making a program offer. Testimony and other evidence at the hearing confirmed that both of those sources contained current information from credible and qualified service providers who were most familiar with STUDENT, having provided therapy to him for about nine months. Having considered the above circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the CARD progress reports, Rainbow Kids reports, and other data including the District’s own assessment data, provided sufficient assessment information regarding STUDENT’s behavior to enable the District to make an appropriate program and placement offer prior to the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year. Thus, the District’s failure to document behavioral observations in the June 13, 2002 report did not cause a denial of FAPE.
Oral-motor skills, apraxia, pragmatics, voice, and articulation. The Petitioner asserts that only one test instrument was used in the District’s speech and language assessment. The Petitioner also asserts, citing Ms. Roszenberg’s testimony, that the District’s speech and language assessment was deficient because the District did not assess STUDENT in the speech-and-language-related areas of articulation, oral-motor skills, apraxia, pragmatics, and voice.
The District’s speech and language assessment was incorporated into the June 13, 2002 report authored jointly by Ms. Garrison and Ms. Johnson. The speech and language pathologist, Ms. Johnson, testified that assessment information regarding STUDENT’s speech and language skills was obtained from the HELP, cognitive performance and verbal performance subtests of the PEP-R, the TELD-3, McArthur Communicative Development Inventory: Words and Sentences (McArthur), and the Spontaneous Language Sample. Ms. Johnson’s testimony was consistent with the content of the June 13, 2002 report, and results of all those evaluations were detailed in the report.
Regarding specific areas assessed, Ms. Johnson testified that during her assessment she found STUDENT’s articulation to be age-appropriate. She did not formally test STUDENT’s oral-motor skills or formally test for apraxia. On the basis of her observations, she did not believe that formal testing in those areas was necessary. She acknowledged that pragmatic language is usually a significant area of concern for autistic children, and she stated that although she did not use the word “pragmatic” in her report, STUDENT’s pragmatic language was tested on the PEP-R. She stated that STUDENT was too young to be administered the Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL). She informally tested his prosody, fluency, and voice, finding no concerns in those areas.
Ms. Johnson’s testimony was consistent in many respects with Judy Segal’s September 2002 speech and language evaluation report, obtained at the parents’ request. Ms. Segal, a speech and language pathologist, stated in her report that STUDENT had some developmental articulation delays consistent with his age, but no indication of an articulation disorder. She stated that oral-motor examination was difficult and STUDENT had difficulty following the clinician’s directions to perform a variety of oral-motor movements, but STUDENT’s oral-motor structures appeared intact for normal speech production. Prosody, fluency, and all parameters of voice were observed to be within normal limits.(Footnote 14) Ms. Segal administered the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test for Children (KSPT) to assess STUDENT’s ability to coordinate the oral movements necessary to produce and combine speech sounds to form syllables and words. STUDENT’s performance on all subtests of the KPST was within normal limits, ranging from low average to high average. Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District used more than one test instrument in assessing STUDENT’s speech and language. The evidence also shows that the District’s speech and language assessment was sufficient in the areas of articulation, apraxia, pragmatics, and voice.
In the area of oral-motor skills, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment was deficient. Formal testing of oral-motor skills should have been performed. This finding is supported by a December 10, 2001 speech and language evaluation performed by Speech Pathology Associates in connection with STUDENT’s Regional Center services. After performing an oral-motor examination and interviewing STUDENT’s mother, the examiner concluded that “oral aversions and liquid feeding method appear to be impeding oral motor development and repertoire of food intake.” The report also noted that tongue protrusion was noted intermittently during several utterances, that STUDENT had difficulty blowing, and that “resting open mouth posture [was] noted consistently during the evaluation with intermittent tongue protrusion.” The December 10, 2001 report was available to the District’s assessment team in the spring of 2002, and the District therefore had notice that STUDENT’s oral-motor development was an area of concern. Followup assessment in the area of oral-motor skills should have been performed.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that except for the failure to formally assess in the area of oral-motor skills, the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in speech and language.
Timely completion of OT and PT assessments. The Petitioner asserts that the OT and PT assessments were not completed in a timely manner. The Petitioner asserts that, pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56344, OT and PT assessments should have been completed and STUDENT’s IEP developed within 50 days after his parents signed the District’s May 6, 2002 assessment plan. The Petitioner asserts that because the June and July 2002 IEP meetings had been held and the District’s program offer had been made before the OT and PT assessment information was available, the untimeliness of those assessments seriously infringed upon the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process.
Notwithstanding the Petitioner’s reliance upon section 56344, the rule most applicable to the present inquiry is contained in section 56320. Under section 56320, the District was required to perform an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s educational needs prior to taking “any action with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction.” The District offered a program whereby STUDENT’s initial placement would have occurred on July 23, 2002. Thus, instead of analyzing the parents contentions in terms of the maximum allowable time limits from section 56344, the pertinent inquiry is whether the assessments were untimely because they were completed after the date that STUDENT’s program was scheduled to commence.(Footnote 15)
The fact that assessments were incomplete when the June 20, 2002 IEP meeting was held is not significant. Circumstances emerging during that meeting, such as the agreement to update goals and objectives using the new CARD data and giving the parents an opportunity to view some SDCs, justified deferring decisions on STUDENT’s placement and program to the next IEP meeting. Moreover, STUDENT’s initial placement in a District program was not scheduled to commence until his third birthday. However, at the next IEP meeting on July 22, 2002, one day before STUDENT’s third birthday, his parents were confronted with the choices of either accepting the District’s maintenance plan for the provision of services from July 23, 2002 through August 31, 2002, obtaining private services at their own expense, or having STUDENT forego services. The latter option was particularly troublesome for the parents, as verified by the testimony of the mother, because STUDENT had continuously been receiving services under his IFSP for the past year, and his parents were concerned about regression if services were interrupted.
The District OT assessment report was completed on July 22, 2002, and it was available for consideration at the July 22 IEP meeting. The District PT report, however, was not completed until July 31, more than one week after the July 22 IEP meeting and a full week after STUDENT’s initial placement was to commence under the District’s offer. In her report, the District physical therapist concluded that a record review was not sufficient to determine PT services and additional PT assessment was therefore necessary. An assessment plan for PT, dated August 6, 2002, was submitted for parent consent. The assessment plan remains unsigned by the parents, and the parents obtained a private PT assessment by Sky Pediatric Therapy in October 2002.
Under the above-described circumstances, STUDENT’s parents should have been able to consider District OT and PT assessments prior to making a decision on STUDENT’s program at the July 22 IEP meeting. The OT assessment report was available, but the PT assessment had not been performed.(Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer finds that the failure of the District to complete the PT assessment prior to the July 22, 2002 IEP meeting was a violation of section 56320 that seriously infringed on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process with regard to making decisions about PT services.
Sensory integration. In reliance on the testimony of the Petitioner’s private occupational therapist, Nancy Press, the Petitioner asserts that the District’s OT assessment was inappropriate because it contained no evaluation of sensory integration, an area of significant concern for autistic children, and because the therapist who conducted the assessment had no one-on-one contact with the Petitioner. Ms. Press was also critical of the fact that the District’s OT assessment contained no recommendations.
The July 22, 2002 OT report by District occupational therapist Denise Yota shows that Ms. Yota reviewed STUDENT’s records from Rainbow Kids, spoke with his Rainbow Kids OT, interviewed STUDENT’s mother, and observed STUDENT during a speech therapy session. In accordance with the May 6, 2002 assessment plan that contained consent only for a records review in OT, Ms. Yota administered no tests and performed no one-on-one examination of STUDENT. With respect to information about sensory integration, Ms. Yota’s report mentions that STUDENT likes to play with large, stuffed animals. His mother reportedly stated that STUDENT was “doing well” with tactile input, and was now tolerating taking a bath. Ms. Yota and STUDENT’s mother discussed his food preferences, including his aversion to smooth foods with lumps, such as stews and soups, thick skinned foods such as cherries and grapes, and his propensity for stuffing his mouth to the point of nearly choking. His Rainbow Kids OT therapist was attributed with reporting that STUDENT’s sensory/regulatory skills were delayed for sensory processing, and he would become upset with changes in planned activities.
Information about STUDENT in Ms. Yota’s OT report is sparse in comparison to Ms. Press’s report dated July 26, 2002. However, Ms. Yota did review STUDENT’s Rainbow Kids records, including the detailed 9-page infant/toddler progress report from Rainbow Kids produced in April 2002. The Rainbow Kids report contained comprehensive information about STUDENT’s sensory-integration status, obtained by parent interview, by observation from the Rainbow Kids occupational therapist, and by formal testing. The Rainbow Kids report contained not only recent information from April 2002, but also information that had been gathered over the course of STUDENT’s therapy at Rainbow Kids, commencing in November 2001. The Rainbow Kids report was written by specialists in the areas covered by the report, including a pediatric occupational therapist. The Rainbow Kids report, on its face, appears to be consistent with the requirements for appropriate assessment specified in section 56320. Ms. Yota’s District OT report shows that Ms. Yota spoke with STUDENT’s Rainbow Kids therapist, who had continued providing services to STUDENT through July 22; she also interviewed STUDENT’s mother, and she observed STUDENT before and during a speech session. Given the above, additional assessment by the District in July 2002 in the area OT was not required. The Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of OT, including sensory integration.
Formal PT assessment. In reliance on the testimony of the Petitioner’s private physical therapist, Stacy Kurihara, the Petitioner asserts that the District’s assessment in the form of a “records review” was inadequate because more information was needed regarding STUDENT’s past services and his development.
The July 31, 2002 report by District physical therapist Nicole Woods lists the documents she reviewed. Those documents were the District OT report, the school psychologist/speech pathologist report from June 2002, the CARD report from June 2002, and his IEPs and current IFSP. Omitted from that list was the April 2002 Rainbow Kids progress report. Rainbow Kids had assessed STUDENT using the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales-2 (Peabody). Results from the Peabody and from recent evaluation of muscle tone/range of motion, reflexes/reactions, and gait/ambulation by a Rainbow Kids physical therapist were all discussed in the April 2002 report.(Footnote 17) The Rainbow Kids report, at the time Ms. Woods collected her information, would have provided the most detailed and recent information about STUDENT’s gross-motor skills, but it was not reviewed by Ms. Woods.
Considering the above, the Hearing Officer finds that regardless of whether the May 6, 2002 assessment plan for PT was appropriate, the plan was improperly executed because it did not include a review of the April 2002 report from Rainbow Kids.
Summary and conclusions. The Hearing Officer has found that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s intellectual functioning prior to making a placement offer. The District’s assessment team documented no observations regarding STUDENT’s behavior prior to the initial IEP meeting on June 20, 2002, but the Hearing Officer has determined that the lack of such documentation and/or observations did not cause a denial of FAPE. Except for the failure to formally assess oral-motor skills, the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in speech and language. The Hearing Officer finds that although the District’s failure to assess STUDENT’s oral-motor skills was not such a significant procedural violation as to result in the denial of a FAPE, the District shall be ordered submit to the parents a written plan for assessment of STUDENT’s oral-motor skills. The OT assessment report was completed in a timely and appropriate manner. The May 6, 2002 assessment plan for PT was improperly executed because the review of records did not include the April 2002 report from Rainbow Kids. Furthermore, the District should have completed but failed to complete the PT assessment prior to the July 22, 2002 IEP meeting. The District’s failure to timely and properly assess STUDENT in matters related to PT was a violation of section 56320. The Hearing Officer finds that the violation of section 56320 resulted in the District making an initial program and placement offer without having timely and properly assessed STUDENT’s needs in the area of PT, seriously infringed on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process with regard to making decisions about PT services, and to that limited extent, resulted in the denial of a FAPE.
B. Failing to offer an appropriate program and placement.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.(Footnote 18)
To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.(Footnote 19)
The Petitioner asserts that the District’s program and placement offers were neither designed to met his unique needs nor reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. More specifically, the Petitioner has objected to the District’s maintenance/transition plan for the period from July 23 to August 31, the substitution of the IBI program in place of CARD services, and the proposed placement in an SDC instead of a regular preschool class with typical peers. The Petitioner also asserts that speech and language, OT, and PT services were inadequate. Finally, the Petitioner asserts that goals and objectives were deficient because they were not updated to reflect the most recent CARD data made available at the June 20, 2002 IEP meeting.
Before examining each of the Petitioner’s contentions, it is first necessary to review the Petitioner’s unique needs. Thereafter, the Hearing Officer will examine the District’s program and placement offer to determine whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.
(1) STUDENT’s unique needs.
For purposes of the issues raised in the due process hearing, the evidence showed that STUDENT needed a placement and services to address deficits in the areas of communication, socialization and behavior, self-help skills, sensory processing, fine-motor skills, and gross-motor skills.(Footnote 20) A summary of his levels of performance is provided below.
Dr. Majors and Ms. Garrison both characterized STUDENT’s cognitive and/or intellectual functioning as being in the average to low average range. Dr. Majors’ opinion was derived from the results she obtained on the Leiter-R, and Ms. Garrison’s opinion was derived from her review of STUDENT’s records and the test results obtained during the District assessment performed in May and June 2002.
When tested by the District in May and June 2002, STUDENT’s Vineland scores were at the first percentile or lower in the areas of daily living skills and socialization. He scored at the seventh percentile in communication and sixteenth percentile in motor skills. His adaptive behavior composite score was at the first percentile. Results from the PEP-R were generally consistent the Vineland, showing an overall developmental age of 26 to 30 months when STUDENT was tested at the age of 35 months. His verbal-imitation and motor-imitation skills, his perception in visual and auditory modalities, and his gross motor skills on the PEP-R were below the 26 to 30 month range, while performance and verbal scores were above that range. According to data from the TELD-3, receptive language was mildly impaired and expressive language was in the average range. On the McArthur, overall grammatical complexity patterns were measured at the 23-24 month level. Mean length of utterance was at the 24-30 month level on the Spontaneous Language Sample.
In addition to its own test data, reports from Rainbow Kids and CARD were also available to the District prior to the July 22, 2002 IEP meeting. On the basis of its observations and testing, Rainbow Kids concluded in its April 2002 report that STUDENT had about a “25 percent delay” in receptive language and about a “35 percent delay” in expressive language, characterized as “significant.” When tested at the age of 33 months, STUDENT’s cognition level was considered to be at the 29-32 month level. The Peabody Developmental Motor Scales-2 (Peabody) showed gross-motor skills at the 18-21 month level, corresponding to the eighth percentile. Fine-motor skills were rated at the 21-month level, social skills at 25-31 months, and self-help at 18 months. Sensory/regulatory areas were characterized as “atypical,” with STUDENT demonstrating “delayed sensory processing abilities in all areas.” His environmental and body awareness were described as moderately low, manifested by frequent tripping, falling, and bumping into objects. Proprioceptive and vestibular sensory information issues were shown by running, jumping, and increased activity levels. Difficulty with task focus was noted, with STUDENT being in motion even while seated for a tabletop task.
The June 2002 CARD progress report lists comparative results from the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development (Brigance) administered in October 2001 and June 2002. Areas measured in the Brigance included “gross motor skills and behaviors, fine motor skills and behaviors, self-help skills, speech and language sills, general knowledge and comprehension, and social and emotional development. Of particular interest in the CARD report is a section entitled “Maladaptive Behaviors.” The section lists STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors that were targeted by the CARD program. The section also lists antecedent and consequent events associated with the behaviors, and recommended interventions. The section contained a chart listing seven categories of STUDENT’s targeted behaviors. For each category of targeted behavior, the chart showed the monthly total of reported behaviors, in selected months, from the baseline month of October 2001 to the most recently reported month of June 2002. The categories of targeted behaviors, number of inappropriate behavior incidents reported in the baseline month, and number of incidents of maladaptive behaviors reported in June 2002 are as follows: non-compliance (476 incidents in the baseline month, 540 incidents in June 2002 ), tantrums (300 in the baseline month, 120 in June 2002), mild aggression (140 in the baseline month, 540 in June 2002), inappropriate eating (56 in the baseline month, 30 in June 2002), running away (256 in the baseline month, 90 in June 2002), self-stimulation (644 in the baseline month, 420 in June 2002), and inappropriate toy play (112 in the baseline month, 30 in June 2002).(Footnote 21)
(2) The District’s program and placement offer.
STUDENT’s IFSP services through the Regional Center were scheduled to cease on July 23, 2002, yet the 2002-2003 school year would not commence until September 5. Under the terms of the stay put order, the District was not required to provide stay put services until the resumption of the traditional school year on September 5. However, the District offered services from July 23 through August 31 as part of a maintenance/transition plan. The plan provided for STUDENT to receive a maintenance program from CARD, meaning that during the 6-week period from July 23 through August 31, STUDENT would receive 10 hours per week of direct CARD services instead of the 90 hours per month that he had been receiving under his IFSP.(Footnote 22) During that period, STUDENT’s participation in his CARD program would be observed a total of 4 hours by a District autism specialist (IBI supervisor) and structured autism class teacher in preparation for the new school year. CARD services would terminate on August 31.
The remaining portions of the District’s program and placement offer were described in the June 20 and July 22, 2002 IEPs, and in Ms. Pitzen’s letters to the parents dated August 7 and 29, 2002. Commencing at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year on September 5, 2002, STUDENT’s program would include placement in an SDC, characterized as a “structured autism class,” for 4 hours per day, 5 days per week, at Viejo Elementary School. Typical peers would participate in the SDC, on average for at least 2 days each week, 4 hours per day. STUDENT would receive IBI program services, 5 hours per week.(Footnote 23) Weekly speech and language services would be provided for one 30-minute individual session and one 30-minute group session. STUDENT would receive OT for one 30-minute session per week in a group session with no more than 3 students, and the level of OT services would be reviewed by the IEP team on December 5, 2002.(Footnote 24) Pending completion of the PT reassessment proposed by the District on August 7, no offer was made for PT.
The Petitioner’s contentions with respect to the District’s program and placement offer will now be addressed.
The maintenance/transition plan. The Petitioner asserts that the District’s proposal for reducing CARD services by 50 percent during the July 23 to August 31, 2002 maintenance period was made arbitrarily, was made without reference to STUDENT’s individual needs, and was not appropriate. The District denies those assertions. On behalf of the District, Ms. Pitzen testified that a maintenance program addressing STUDENT’s needs during the period from July 23 to August 31, particularly with respect to his reported behaviors, would be preferable to having STUDENT receive no services from July 23 until the start of the school year on September 5. She testified that on the basis of her knowledge of STUDENT’s needs, she believed that a 50 percent reduction in STUDENT’s CARD hours would be appropriate for maintenance.
The evidence showed that although the District’s maintenance/transition plan was intended to maintain STUDENT’s levels of performance pending the start of the traditional school year, STUDENT’s unique needs required more than simply a maintenance program. The witnesses presented by both parties were in agreement that up to July 23, 2002, early and intensive intervention by CARD had been successful for STUDENT. The evidence that STUDENT made significant progress with 20 hours of CARD intervention per week was undisputed. The District’s plan would effectively have halted STUDENT’s successful CARD program in favor of a diluted 6-week plan designed to prevent regression. In STUDENT’s case, given the demonstrated success and importance of early and intensive intervention for this child with autism, the District’s maintenance plan was neither designed to meet his unique needs nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period of July 23, 2002, through September 4, 2002.(Footnote 25)
The IBI program. The Petitioner asserts that because of the inadequate training of persons who implement the IBI program, the nature of the IBI program, and the frequency of the program offered at only 5 hours per week, the IBI component of the District’s program would not have met STUDENT’s unique needs. The Petitioner asserts that instead of the IBI program, STUDENT required the CARD program at 20 hours per week.
Regarding the matter of training, Ms. Faist is an autism specialist and one of several IBI supervisors at the District. She testified that she trains all of the IBI tutors who work with the students. Ms. Faist described the content of the District’s IBI training manual and how the tutors are trained to use various behavior intervention strategies and record the data in charts and logbooks. The tutors initially receive about 19 hours of training. Thereafter, the tutors receive ongoing training and feedback from four senior IBI tutors and four IBI supervisors. Ms. Pitzen testified that a masters degree in psychology or a related field for autism is required for IBI supervisors. The District’s witnesses testified about the history of the IBI program’s overall success in providing benefits to children with autism. The testimony of the District’s witnesses regarding these matters was undisputed. The Hearing Officer concludes that the persons implementing the IBI portion of the District’s program to STUDENT would most likely have been properly trained.
Regarding the nature of the IBI program, the Hearing Officer has previously noted the strong similarity between STUDENT’s CARD services and the District’s IBI program.(Footnote 26) The CARD progress reports, the testimony of STUDENT’s CARD supervisors, and the testimony of STUDENT’s mother confirmed that STUDENT had made good progress in the CARD program, especially in the area of behavior and social skills. Except for some varied opinions regarding how to interpret the chart of STUDENT’s behavior incidents contained in the June 2002 CARD progress report, the District’s witnesses agreed that STUDENT had benefitted from the CARD program. His progress with CARD was one of the chief reasons why the District believed the IBI program would be appropriate for STUDENT. Another reason for the District recommending the IBI program, aside from its similarity to CARD and STUDENT’s success with CARD, is that the IBI program was specifically designed and developed by the District as a behavior intervention and modification strategy for preschool children on the autism spectrum, to be used for enabling those children to eventually attend a typical or kindergarten classroom setting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the nature of the IBI program was appropriate for meeting STUDENT’s needs in the area of behavior and socialization skills, and it was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Regarding the frequency or intensity of IBI services, the Petitioner asserts that eliminating STUDENT’s 20 weekly hours of CARD therapy and replacing them with only 5 hours of IBI services would not meet STUDENT’s needs. The Petitioner’s experts testified that because STUDENT was successful in his 20-hour-per-week CARD program, the same level of services should be maintained for the school year. The District asserts that 5 hours of IBI services per week would meet STUDENT’s needs because he would concurrently be receiving the benefits of attending a structured autism class for 20 hours per week. As testified to by Ms. Pitzen, the IBI program and structured autism classes are actually components of the District’s more encompassing program known as the “structured autism program.” Thus, to resolve the dispute regarding intensity of IBI services, the IBI component of the District’s program offer must be evaluated in conjunction with the services STUDENT would receive in the District’s structured autism class.
Placement in a structured autism class. The Petitioner asserts that the offer of an SDC, including any of the District’s structured autism classes, was inappropriate for STUDENT because he needs typical peers available as models in order to achieve progress. The Petitioner’s expert witnesses all agreed that STUDENT should have been offered placement in a typical preschool class, primarily for the reason that he could progress by imitating and modeling the behavior of typical peers. The District asserts that a structured autism class was an appropriate placement offer for STUDENT.
The structured autism program was described by District witnesses.(Footnote 27) Ms. Pitzen testified that about 100 children are served in the District’s structured autism program. About 50 of those children also receive IBI services. As determined by their individual needs, children on the autism spectrum may be placed into structured autism classes. Children with autism may also be placed into non-categorical SDCs, and some are placed into “fee-based” preschool classes. Fee-based preschool classes are located in private schools and are composed of typical peers. Placement of special needs students into fee-based preschool classes occurs pursuant to contract arrangements that the District maintains with selected private schools. Ms. Pitzen testified that 20 fee-based preschool slots had currently been purchased and were available for use by the District. Combinations of preschool placements could also be arranged whereby, for example, a child might attend a non-categorical SDC for 3 days per week and a fee-based preschool class for the other 2 days. IBI and one-on-one aide support is available for all of the preschool placements within the structured autism program, including fee-based preschool classes. IBI services can be rendered at school during the school day, at the student’s home, or both. IBI hours for any particular child in the structured autism program can range from none to 25 hours per week.
Ms. Pitzen testified that the Viejo structured autism class offered for the fall of 2002 was designed to contain 8 children, 1 teacher, and 3 full-time adult assistants. She described it as a language-based program addressing adaptive and maladaptive behaviors, language skills, and cognition skills, with a major emphasis on social skills. Typical-peer volunteers up to kindergarten age were usually present in the class for at least 50 percent of the classroom time each week, participating in structured social-skill and play-skill groups.
Charlene Lerman, a District IBI supervisor and structured autism class teacher, testified that the 3 full-time adult assistants in her structured autism class were all trained in IBI. The children in her class for the 2001-2002 school year had a full range of skills. Some children were at a 2- or 3-word phrase level, and others were speaking at age-appropriate levels. Similarly wide ranges were present in social skills and preacademic skills. The class schedule consisted of “scheduled individual IBI time” in the classroom from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m., administered by herself, the 3 IBI-trained classroom aides, and other IBI tutors, all providing services in accordance with the individual schedules for each of the children. Each child would come to class for IBI at a time between 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. corresponding to their own individual schedule. The main portion of the school day was from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. The schedule included snack, circle time, recess with the typical peers, lunch, play, inclusion opportunities with the larger, next-door state preschool class, afternoon recess, art, and a thematic group activity. Twice each week for 30 minutes per session, group speech was provided in 2 groups of 4 students, resulting in each student receiving 30 minutes per week. The emphasis for the group speech was social communication in addition to individual communication goals. Once per week for 45 minutes per session, group OT was provided. Three of the children used a PECS system in their communication goals, but the other 5 children did not. Ms. Lerman testified that the goals and objectives proposed for STUDENT by the District and CARD were similar to the goals and objectives of IEPs for other students in her class. She testified regarding how each of STUDENT’s goals and objectives proposed by the Petitioner would be addressed in her structured autism class. The goals and objectives included naming body parts, providing personal information, saying hello when prompted, dramatizing adult activities, combining play activities, using nose tissue, performing toilet and dressing activities, staying focused on activities, decreasing noncompliant behavior, reducing tantrums and aggressive behavior, reducing running away behaviors and self-stimulatory behaviors, following 2-step directions, answering “wh” questions, pronoun use, 4- to 5-word phrases and sentences, using nouns, relating experiences in sequence, responding to yes/no questions to communicate desires, identifying gender, categorizing objects, identifying the function of objects, and many others. For essentially all of the goals and objectives, Ms. Lerman testified that the strategy would be to work on the activities individually during IBI time and then utilize opportunities during particular classroom activities to generalize the skills learned in IBI. A databook was kept on each student to monitor progress on goals and objectives and facilitate modification and updating of the goals and objectives when appropriate. She testified that in the current school year, as many as 5 or 6 typical peers participate daily in her class as volunteer “enrichment peers” from 11:30 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
Ms. Pitzen testified that the District’s recommendation and offer for placing STUDENT in a structured autism class was primarily the result of concern about STUDENT’s reported history of maladaptive behaviors. The previously-referenced behavior chart in the June 2002 CARD progress report was one source of information regarding STUDENT’s behaviors and social skill deficits. As acknowledged by District witnesses, the CARD chart data, listing hundreds of maladaptive behavior incidents each month, could be influenced by factors such as STUDENT reacting to more challenging progressions in his CARD program. However, the data available from CARD and Rainbow Kids, along with information from STUDENT’s mother, strongly indicated that STUDENT’s behavior would likely prevent his successful participation in a typical preschool class, thereby suggesting the most prudent strategy for STUDENT would be an initial placement in the more structured environment of an SDC, especially for his first venture into a classroom setting. For example, a document entitled “Assessment Planning Documentation,” signed by STUDENT’s mother on May 6, 2002, states that STUDENT is “not used to being around same age peers (sees them @ Rainbow Kids)- may become aggressive (hit, pinch, scratch) anytime frustrated or transitioning to less-preferred activity.”
On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the system whereby skills learned during individual IBI sessions were integrated and generalized into the daily activities of the structured autism class resulted in IBI services of appropriate intensity to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide him with some educational benefit. Furthermore, having considered the appropriateness of the structured autism class setting for enabling STUDENT to meet his goals and objectives as proposed by both parties, the pervasive opportunities for interaction with typical peers throughout the school day, and the history of STUDENT’s behavior, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for placement in a structured autism class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
Speech and language. The Petitioner asserts that the speech and language services offered by the District would not have provided for enough hours of service per week. The Petitioner’s experts, Ms. Segal and Dr. Majors, testified that the appropriate amount of speech and language therapy for STUDENT would be 2 individual sessions and 1 group session per week, at one hour per session. Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT needed 3 sessions per week. The Rainbow Kids July 2002 discharge report recommended that STUDENT continue to receive speech and language services from the District at the same frequency that services had been rendered at Rainbow Kids, i.e. 2 individual sessions and 1 group session per week. The Rainbow Kids report emphasized the importance of individual therapy for STUDENT, stating that “progress shown in the area of speech and language has been dependent upon STUDENT’s participation in a one-on-one learning environment with minimal distraction present.”
In support of the District’s position that one 30-minute individual session and one 30-minute group session per week was an appropriate offer, the District presented testimony from Ms. Johnson. She had performed the District’s speech and language assessment on STUDENT, and she had reviewed his prior records in detail. She believed that the offer provided for an appropriate amount of speech and language services because, in addition to the services from the speech and language therapist, STUDENT would also be receiving the benefit of daily individual IBI support on his goals and objectives, including goals and objectives for speech and language. He would also have opportunities throughout the school day for generalizing his speech and language skills in non-clinic settings. She testified that the structured autism class was designed to enhance those opportunities. The structured autism class teacher, Ms. Lerman, testified that she was in daily communication with her students’ speech and language therapist, and the speech and language therapist who provided individual pull-out therapy to her students was the same therapist that came to her classroom twice per week to conduct group therapy.
The evidence showed that although STUDENT’s speech and language deficits are not severe in comparison to other children on the autism spectrum, addressing those deficits at his young age will be a critical factor in his long-term progress. Thus, the Hearing Officer agrees with the Petitioner’s experts to the extent that they have recommended a substantial amount of speech and language therapy to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Having considered the fact that the District would have provided one individual and one group session of speech and language therapy per week, in addition to the above-referenced speech and language component of individual IBI therapy and extensive generalization opportunities in the structured autism classroom as testified to by Ms. Lerman, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the totality of the program and placement offered by the District would have given STUDENT an amount of speech and language services designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
OT and PT. The Petitioner asserts that STUDENT requires two hours of OT services per week, as opposed to the District’s offer of one 30-minute group session per week. In support of the Petitioner’s position, Nancy Press testified concerning her OT evaluation of STUDENT, performed at the parents’ request on July 26, 2002. Ms. Press stated that STUDENT demonstrated approximately a one-year delay in his overall gross-motor skills. He demonstrated “deficient sensory registration in the area of vestibular and proprioceptive processing, as well as in motor planning/praxis skills as evidenced by poor body awareness and control, motor skills, and coordination. He demonstrated hyposensitivity to pain, and would walk through thorny bushes with no pain reaction, even while being scratched. He would engage in mouth stuffing. Other sensory integration difficulties were reportedly manifested by difficulty with transitions to less-preferable activities and perseveration on stuffed animals. Ms. Press believed that to address the above, STUDENT would “benefit” from OT twice per week in 60-minute sessions by a trained therapist in a sensory integration clinic. In its July 2002 progress discharge report, Rainbow Kids recommended that OT at a frequency of 2 sessions per week would be “most beneficial to improve sensory processing and classroom performance, as well as visual motor and fine motor skills.”
STUDENT’s District occupational therapist, Nancy Lin, testified that she had seen STUDENT once per month for two months pursuant to the stay put order. However, on the basis of her knowledge of STUDENT and his observed improvement subsequent to being discharged from therapy at Rainbow Kids, she believes that STUDENT requires OT therapy sessions once per week. The focus of her therapy would be to continue to improve his sensory-motor and fine-motor skills. She would also consult with his classroom teacher. She testified that his required level of service would be influenced by his classroom situation and whether he was exposed to activities in the classroom that would develop his skills. If STUDENT attended a structured autism class, an OT therapist would be visiting his class once per week for a collaborative 45-minute session of group OT involving the OT therapist, classroom teacher, classroom aides, and students, all engaging in activities at various “OT stations” that could involve sensory-motor, fine-motor, or other activities. That system also makes the teacher and classroom aide more aware of appropriate OT strategies for the students, thereby increasing opportunities for incorporating those activities into each school day. Ms. Lin also testified that if STUDENT was attending a structured autism class, she would still recommend seeing him 30 minutes per week for 6-months, with review thereafter, to work on fine-motor and sensory-motor skills, in addition to having him receive the above-mentioned services that are already part of the structured autism class. Finally, Ms. Lin testified that if STUDENT was in a regular preschool program with a one-on-one aide, she would still recommend one 30-minute OT session per week, anticipating that the one-on-one aide or classroom aide or teacher could be trained to work with STUDENT in his areas of OT needs.
Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of 30-minute weekly sessions of OT therapy in combination with the additional activities and services STUDENT would receive in the structured autism class as described by Ms. Lin, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that the initial offer for OT stated in the July 22 IEP, specifically one session per week for one month with only OT consult thereafter, was deficient.
Regarding PT, the District physical therapist, Nicole Woods, acknowledged in her July 31, 2002 report that a records review was insufficient to determine whether STUDENT required PT services. The PT assessment plan thereafter proposed by the District has not been consented to by the parents. However, information pertinent to PT is contained in the October 2002 report written by Stacy Kurihara at Sky Pediatric, obtained at the parents’ request. Ms. Woods testified that she had reviewed the Sky Pediatric report, and she believed the report from Sky Pediatric was sufficient to make further PT assessment by the District unnecessary.
The Sky Pediatric report summary by Ms. Kurihara states that STUDENT has motor-control deficits, sensory-processing difficulties, and muscular weaknesses that cause secondary problems with delayed gross-motor skills, poor balance leading to safety concerns, and postural alignment concerns. She recommended that “individual physical therapy will address the above problems using strategies for strengthening, sensory-motor activities, balance, and coordination.” She recommended individual physical therapy in a clinic setting twice per week for 60-minute sessions, with reassessment to be performed in 6 months.(Footnote 28)
On behalf of the District, Nicole Woods testified that she had been providing PT to STUDENT for one 60-minute session per week for the past 5 or 6 weeks. On the basis of her observations of STUDENT and consideration of the Sky Pediatric report, Ms. Woods believed that an appropriate program for STUDENT would be 30 minutes of direct PT services in a school setting such as at recess. She believed STUDENT would need exposure to peers who had a higher gross-motor-skill level than STUDENT, and she testified that the District’s structured autism class would generally have one or two persons at that level, thereby meeting that particular need. She also believed that 15 minutes of PT consult, per week, would be required to monitor how STUDENT was performing in the classroom setting.
The testimony from Ms. Woods and Ms. Kurihara established that STUDENT required PT services. The District has not offered PT services, and the District’s failure to offer PT services constituted a denial of FAPE in the area of PT. Having considered the facts that Ms. Woods is familiar with STUDENT through working with him as his therapist, that Ms. Woods is familiar with what STUDENT would encounter in a structured autism class, and that Ms. Woods considered Ms. Kurihara’s Sky Pediatric report to be sufficiently comprehensive as to negate the need for further PT assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the opinions of both witnesses are credible. Having also considered the fact that some of the PT objectives, such as in the area of sensory-motor skills, demonstrate an overlap with some of the OT objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that PT at a frequency of 60 minutes of direct therapy per week, plus 15 minutes of weekly PT consultation to monitor STUDENT’s classroom performance, is required to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of PT. Because STUDENT has received stay put PT services equivalent to that above-described amount, no reimbursement or compensatory education remedy will be applicable to the District’s failure to include PT services in the program offer.
Goals and objectives. The Petitioner asserts that goals and objectives proposed by the District at the June 20, 2002 IEP meeting were deficient because they did not reflect the most recent CARD data. Furthermore, the Petitioner asserts that although the District agreed to use the CARD data to update the goals and objectives, updated goals and objectives were never offered. In their testimony, the District’s witnesses generally acknowledged that the goals and objectives drafted by the District for the June 20, 2002 IEP meeting should have been updated prior to commencement of the 2002-2003 school year to reflect the most recent CARD data.(Footnote 29) On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives proposed by the District required updating at the start of the 2002-2003 school year. However, the evidence showed that updating the goals and objectives would primarily have been for the purpose of documenting STUDENT’s more recent progress, and appropriate updating would not have changed the substance of the goals and objectives offered by the District or the nature and intensity of the services required to implement them.(Footnote 30) Given the circumstances presented in this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to update goals and objectives did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
(3) Summary and conclusions.
With respect to program and placement offers, the District’s maintenance/transition plan offered for the period from July 23 to August 31 was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the period from July 23 through September 5, 2002. The District’s 2002-2003 school year offer for placement in a structured autism class with substantial participation by typical peers was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. Regarding IBI, the evidence established that the persons implementing the IBI portion of the District’s program would most likely have been properly trained. The nature of the IBI program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of behavior and socialization skills and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Given the system whereby skills learned during individual IBI sessions would be integrated and generalized into the daily activities of the structured autism class, the intensity of IBI services offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The District’s offer for speech and language services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The offer for 30-minute weekly sessions of OT therapy offered by the District in its letter dated August 7, 2002, in combination with the additional activities and services STUDENT would receive in the structured autism class, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of OT and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. However, the initial offer for OT stated in the July 22 IEP, specifically one session per week for one month with only OT consult thereafter, was deficient. Physical therapy services at a frequency of 60 minutes of direct therapy per week, plus 15 minutes of weekly PT consultation to monitor STUDENT’s classroom performance, was required to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of PT. The District’s failure to offer PT services constituted a denial of FAPE in the area of PT. The District’s failure to update the goals and objectives did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program and placement offer resulted in the denial of a FAPE for the period from July 23 to September 5, 2002. For the 2002-2003 school year, the District’s program offer resulted in the denial of a FAPE only to the limited extent that the offer for PT was deficient; in all other areas, the District’s program and placement offer for the 2002-2003 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
C. Failure to offer an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment.
Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031. The Petitioner asserts that the LRE placement for STUDENT in the 2002-2003 school year would be a typical preschool or, as characterized by the District, a “fee-based” preschool program. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s offer for placement in a structured autism class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. A primary reason for that finding was STUDENT’s behavior history as reported by CARD and STUDENT’s mother. Behavior issues were also noted in the Rainbow Kids reports from April and July 2002, including STUDENT’s defending his possessions by screaming, hitting, or scratching; regular tantruming at home; perseveration; and frequently talking about hitting family members and therapists. Because of the behavior history, the Hearing Officer further finds that when the District made its placement and program offers for the 2002-2003 school year, the available data showed that placement in a typical preschool class would not have been appropriate. Accordingly, an SDC was properly offered by the District as the LRE placement for STUDENT at that time.
Meanwhile, in September 2002, STUDENT began attending a typical preschool class at Country Village Preschool, accompanied by a one-on-one aide from CARD, all at his parents’ expense. Testimony from Country Village Preschool personnel shows that STUDENT has been successful in the typical preschool class. Jolie Deatrick, the Country Village Preschool director, testified that Country Village Preschool is licensed for 177 children per day. She testified that the school has 14 classes, consisting of preschool and kindergarten classes, with children ranging in age from 2 to 7 years. Preschool children are enrolled either in morning or afternoon sessions. STUDENT was enrolled in the 3-hour afternoon session, 3 days per week, and he attended his classes with an aide. From other testimony, the aide is known to be STUDENT’s CARD therapist. Ms. Deatrick testified that Country Village Preschool’s overall strategy is to utilize activities to enrich children and have them learn in a developmental program. The preschool sessions attended by STUDENT include circle time, language enrichment, art, music, science room, yard time, free play in class, and cooking. Children are offered choices within a structured situation, and the school attempts to balance academics with social development. She testified that she has observed STUDENT in class and on the playground. She believes that he has adjusted well to the school and he participates in all the activities. He has had only one behavior incident reported, and she considered the incident to be normal behavior for a child STUDENT’s age. She has observed him to initiate oral communication with other children and play with other children, but she has not seen him orally initiate play.
Lailane Cruz is STUDENT’s preschool classroom teacher at Country Village Preschool. She testified that between 8 and 12 children attend STUDENT’s class, and STUDENT attends with his one-on-one aide. He is able to “choose his table jobs” and complete them. He sits appropriately for circle time and sings along with the other students. She has seen him initiate play with other children on the playground, and he initiates conversation. He follows the directions that she gives to the class. Behavior has interfered with his classroom participation on only a few occasions. When that occurs, she or the aide talks to STUDENT and the problem is corrected. She testified that most of what STUDENT does is without the assistance of his aide. He follows directions related to clean-up time, hand washing, snack, circle time, and table jobs without assistance from his aide. Ms. Cruz believes that the aide is very helpful because the aide is essentially another adult who can help in the class. She believes that STUDENT would be successful in class without an aide. She testified that behavior has only been a factor during circle time because it is hard for STUDENT to just sit and listen to a song when so many other interesting activities are available in the classroom. She is the person who primarily works with STUDENT, and his aide “just watches.” She has had no formal training with autistic children and has taught no other autistic children. She believes that STUDENT is “a bit behind in speaking” but he understands her well enough to follow her directions and usually answers with one- or two-word responses.
Although the District’s offer for placement in an SDC was found by the Hearing Officer to be the LRE placement for STUDENT at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, the above evidence shows that circumstances have now substantially changed. STUDENT’s success in attending the typical preschool class at Country Village Preschool, revealed by testimony at the hearing, has established that an SDC would no longer be the proper LRE placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 31) Instead, the Hearing Officer finds that at the current time, with support from the District’s IBI program comparable to the classroom support STUDENT currently receives from his CARD aide, a typical preschool class similar to what STUDENT attends at Country Village Preschool would now be the proper LRE placement and program for STUDENT.
The above should not be construed as a finding that a typical preschool placement would be a better placement situation than the District’s structured autism class with its well-integrated support services and typical-peer involvement. However, the evidence has shown that STUDENT can succeed in a typical preschool setting without causing undue disruption to the other students. Therefore, pursuant to the legal mandates of LRE, the Hearing Officer will order STUDENT’s IEP team to meet for the purpose of arranging STUDENT’s placement in a typical preschool class, with appropriate support.
Furthermore, with STUDENT being placed in a typical preschool class instead of the structured autism class, the matter of appropriate IBI, OT, PT, and speech and language services must be revisited by the IEP team. The above findings in this Decision related to IBI, OT, PT, and speech and language services were made within the context of how the District’s overall program and placement offer would meet STUDENT’s needs, and strong consideration was given to the fact that the personnel and activities within the structured autism class would supplement the designated therapy services. Consequently, STUDENT’s therapy services, especially IBI. OT, and speech and language, will likely need to be significantly increased in comparison to what has previously been found appropriate.
Finally, testimony established that the District’s IBI program services could be extended to a student’s attendance in one of the District’s contracted “fee-based” typical preschool classes, thereby implying that a fee-based typical preschool class may be particularly receptive to pupils who are in need of IBI support. However, in selecting a typical preschool placement for STUDENT, the IEP team shall give special weight to the fact that STUDENT’s success at Country Village Preschool has been demonstrated, and Country Village shall be given priority consideration. If Country Village is not selected, then a class situation similar to STUDENT’s preschool class at Country Village shall be given priority consideration.(Footnote 32)
Issue 2: As a remedy for the District having failed to appropriately assess STUDENT and/or having denied a FAPE to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to:
A. Reimbursement for private assessments.
Cal. Educ. Code section 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment be at public expense.
In the present case, STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for private assessments consisting of a neurodevelopmental evaluation by Christine Majors, Ph.D., in August 2002; speech and language evaluation by Judy Segal in September 2002; PT evaluation by Sky Pediatric Therapy in October 2002, and OT evaluation by Nancy Press on July 26, 2002. The Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of speech and language and PT. In all other respects, the District’s assessment was found to be appropriate. Accordingly, the Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Segal’s speech and language evaluation and the PT evaluation by Sky Pediatric Therapy. On the basis of invoices submitted into evidence at the hearing, the reimbursement amount for Judy Segal’s evaluation is $500.00, and the reimbursement amount for Sky Pediatric Therapy’s evaluation is $265.00. All other requests for reimbursement related to assessment are denied.
B. Reimbursement for private placement and services.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for private placement and services procured from July 23, 2002, through the date of this Decision, including tuition at Country Village Preschool, speech and language therapy by Abby Rosenberg and by Newport Language and Speech Centers, and therapy by CARD.
The Hearing Officer has determined that the District failed to offer a FAPE for the period from July 23, 2002, through September 4, 2002. In lieu of accepting the District’s maintenance program for that period, STUDENT’s parents procured CARD services. Testimony showed that those services were in an amount greater than the 10 hours per week offered by the District, but somewhat less than the 20 hours per week sought by the parents. There is no dispute that STUDENT benefitted from CARD services and that the services were designed to address his unique needs.(Footnote 33) Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for CARD services, also including supervisor and clinic services, obtained during the period from July 23 through September 4, 2002.
With respect to the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that, with the exception of the District’s failure to offer PT services, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment at the start of the 2002-2003 school year. Under the circumstances of the present case, the District’s failure to offer PT services does not warrant a reimbursement remedy for the private services procured by the parents. The private placement and services were obtained primarily because of the parents’ refusal to accept components of the District’s program and placement offer that were not directly related STUDENT’s PT needs, and no private PT services were obtained. Furthermore, the evidence showed that the PT services received by STUDENT pursuant to the stay put order were consistent with the PT services that STUDENT required for meeting his needs related to PT; therefore, no compensatory education remedy for missed PT services is warranted.
Finally, STUDENT’s success in attending the typical preschool class at Country Village Preschool, revealed by testimony at the hearing, has established that an SDC would no longer be the proper LRE placement for STUDENT. However, the Hearing Officer has also found that the District’s program and placement offer for the 2002-2003 school year complied with the requirements of LRE from September 5, 2002, through the date of this Decision. Therefore a reimbursement remedy for that period is not warranted. See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1148 (9th Cir. 1999).
ORDER
1. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team shall convene a meeting for the purpose of selecting a typical preschool class as the LRE placement for STUDENT. Classroom support shall be provided to STUDENT, including services similar to those STUDENT has already received from his CARD aide at Country Village Preschool. An IBI tutor may be used for that purpose. In selecting a typical preschool class, the IEP team shall give special weight to the fact that STUDENT’s success at Country Village Preschool has been demonstrated, and Country Village Preschool shall be given priority consideration. If Country Village Preschool is not selected, then a class situation similar to STUDENT’s preschool class at Country Village Preschool shall be given priority consideration.
2. STUDENT’s program shall provide for his attendance in a typical preschool class at a frequency consistent with the District’s prior offer of 4 hours per day, 5 days per week, in a structured autism class.
3. At the same IEP meeting as ordered above, STUDENT’s IEP team shall amend STUDENT’s IEP in a manner consistent with the new factors that will arise from STUDENT’s placement in a typical preschool class instead of a structured autism class. In amending STUDENT’s IEP, the IEP team shall consider the following:
(a) The findings in this Decision related to the intensity of designated therapy services, including IBI, OT, PT, and speech and language, were made within the context of how the District’s overall program and placement offer would have met STUDENT’s needs, and strong consideration was given to the fact that the personnel and activities within the structured autism class would have supplemented the designated therapy services specified in the proposed IEPs.
(b) When STUDENT is placed in a typical preschool class, activities and services to supplement STUDENT’s designated therapy services, especially IBI, OT, and speech and language, will not be available in the manner that they would have been available in a District structured autism class. Therefore, in comparison to what has previously been found appropriate in this Decision for designated therapy services, the intensity of those services will likely need to be significantly increased.
4. At the same IEP meeting as ordered above, STUDENT’s IEP team shall draft new present levels of performance and new goals and objectives consistent with current data available on STUDENT and appropriate to his placement in a typical preschool class.
5. Within 20 days from the date of this Decision, the District shall submit a written assessment plan for the parent’s consent regarding assessment of STUDENT’s oral-motor skills.
6. Within 20 days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents in the amounts of $500.00 for Judy Segal’s evaluation and $250.00 for the Sky Pediatric Therapy evaluation.
7. Within 20 days from the date of this Decision, upon proper proof having been submitted to the District by the parents in the form of invoices and/or proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the CARD services, also including
CARD supervision and CARD clinic services, obtained for the period from July 23, 2002, through September 4, 2002.
8. All of the Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Did the District fail to comply with an August 12, 2002 stay put order? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: For the period commencing July 23, 2002 and continuing through the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE) by:
A. Failing to adequately assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. The Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to oral-motor assessment and PT assessment.
B. Failing to offer an appropriate program and placement. For the period from July 23 through September 4, 2002, the Petitioner prevailed on this issue. For the 2002-2003 school year, the Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to PT services only.
C. Failing to offer an appropriate placement in the LRE? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that a typical preschool class has been ordered as a prospective placement, but the District prevailed to the extent that its placement offer was found to be the appropriate LRE at the time the offer was made.
Issue 3: As a remedy for the District having failed to appropriately assess STUDENT and/or having denied a FAPE to STUDENT in the LRE, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to:
A. Reimbursement for private assessments. The Petitioner prevailed partially on this issue.
B. Reimbursement for private placement and services. The Petitioner prevailed partially on this issue. The Petitioner was awarded reimbursement for private services only for the period from July 23 to September 4, 2002.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).
Dated: January 10, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. STUDENT would also receive 1 hour of CARD supervision per week, and provision would be made for 4 hours of attendance at progress clinics by each of his two CARD tutors. During the remaining weeks of the CARD program, STUDENT would be observed in the CARD program by a District “intensive behavioral instruction” (IBI) program supervisor and District classroom teacher. The IBI supervisor would also be a District autism specialist. 2. STUDENT’s SDC teacher and IBI supervisor would be jointly responsible for the supervision of his IBI program, and a student progress/clinic meeting would be held once per month for one hour. 3. At the IEP meeting, the District offered a 4-day placement through the end of the extended school year, stated to be July 26, 2002, that would involve STUDENT attending the structured SDC for autism and receiving speech and language services. The attendees at the meeting acknowledged that such a program would be disruptive to STUDENT. 4. Whether the updated present levels of performance and goals and objectives were limited to the area of OT or encompassed all prior levels and goals was not made clear at the due process hearing. 5. The effect of the stay put order was that during the pendency of the due process proceedings, the District was obligated to offer services of the same nature and frequency that STUDENT had been receiving pursuant to his latest IFSP, except that the District could use service providers other than CARD and Rainbow. 6. Mr. Jewell and Mr. Roberts are attorneys in the same law office. 7. In the present case, as set forth in the August 12, 2002 say put ruling, STUDENT was transferring from services under “Part C” of the IDEA to “Part B” upon reaching his third birthday. The applicable rule in such situations is analogous to a student’s transition from one district to another within different special education local plan areas (SELPAs). Cal. Educ. Code section 56325 provides that when a student transfers from one district to another district within different SELPAs, the receiving district must immediately provide the child with an interim placement in conformity with an IEP, which can be the student’s existing areed-upon IEP, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, or a new IEP. A similar analysis was applied in the law and motion ruling, and the parties were also in agreement that the IFSP constituted the stay put placement. The disputed aspect of stay put was with respect to how the services described in the IFSP should be implemented by the District. 8. The Hearing Officer notes that the maintenance/transition plan offered for the period from July 23 to August 31, 2002, is not applicable to the question of compliance with stay put. Stay put services were not required during that period. The plan was offered for the purpose of providing maintenance services to STUDENT pending the start of the school year in September. 9. STUDENT’s initial CARD supervisor, Ms. Bancroft, had commenced maternity leave in the summer of 2002, and her duties on STUDENT’s case were assumed by Ms. Parsi. 10. Although the IBI services proposed in the District’s program offer were substantially reduced in intensity from what STUDENT had received by CARD through his IFSP, the intensity of the District’s IBI program offered for stay put was the same as what STUDENT had been receiving through his IFSP. 11. M The GARS, also by parent interview, was more specifically designed for evaluating autistic children in comparison to the more general norms on the Vineland. s. Garrison testified that the Vineland, administered by parent interview, was given to assess adaptive behaviors. 12. Ms. Garrison testified that the Leiter-R IQ score of 87 was “within the ball-yard” of what her own data indicated. 13. Ms. Garrison testified that the reference to STUDENT sometimes responding to specific requests after a delay of “ten minutes” was accurate and not a misprint. 14. Ms. Segal’s report describes “prosody” as stress, intonation, and melody of speech; “fluency” as sound flow; and “parameters of voice” as pitch, quality, and volume. 15. Section 56344 provides, in part, that “an individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension.” (Emphasis by the Hearing Officer.) The 50-day limit is phrased as an upper limit. The statute does not preclude that circumstances in a particular case could require, for purposes of meeting a child’s unique needs, that the time be less than 50 days. 16. The July 22 IEP was devoid of any mention of PT services or assessments, and no physical therapist was present at the meeting to discuss STUDENT’s PT needs. 17. Rainbow Kids also wrote an updated progress and discharge report in July 2002. 18. State and federal law also require that the district’s program conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031; Rowley, supra. Furthermore, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20. U.S.C. §1414(d), 34 C.F.R.. §300.347(a). Neither of the above matters were at issue in the present case. 19. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484. In the present case, the Petitioner has characterized as procedural violations the District’s alleged failure to conduct appropriate assessments, failure to list proper present levels of performance in the IEPs, and failure to offer appropriate goals and objectives. This Decision, however, has already addressed the Petitioner’s assertions regarding assessment in terms of substantive appropriateness. The Hearing Officer will also address the Petitioner’s assertions regarding present levels of performance and goals and objectives in terms of substantive appropriateness. The other allegations by the Petitioner regarding procedural violations will not addressed by the Hearing Officer, as their resolution would not affect the outcome of this Decision. 20. The District’s June 13, 2002 assessment report listed STUDENT’s deficits associated with autism as arising in the areas of communication and socialization, self-help skills, and abstract processing. The report also listed deficits in the areas of fine-motor and gross-motor skills and visual and auditory perception. 21. The Hearing Officer notes that the listing of CARD baseline data from October 2001 contradicts other evidence that the CARD services did not start until November 2001. For purposes of this issue, however, the pertinent point is that hundreds of maladaptive behaviors were still being reported in June 2002. 22. STUDENT would also receive 1 hour of CARD supervision per week, and provision would be made for 4 hours of attendance at progress clinics by each of his two CARD tutors. The District also offered to have STUDENT attend an SDC and receive speech and language services through July 26, corresponding to the 3 days remaining on the 2001-2002 extended school year. 23. STUDENT’s SDC teacher and IBI supervisor would be jointly responsible for the supervision of his IBI program, and a student progress/clinic meeting would be held once per month for one hour. 24. The offer for weekly OT sessions through December 5 was stated in Ms. Pitzen’s August 7, 2002 letter to the parents. The OT offer stated on the July 22, 2002 IEP was for one month of weekly sessions, with only OT consultation to be provided thereafter. The August 7 letter contained no explanation for the change in the offer. 25. This finding is applicable to STUDENT’s needs as addressed by CARD. This finding is not intended to be applicable to STUDENT’s other needs as addressed in the past by a speech and language therapist, occupational therapist, or physical therapist. 26. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that, for purposes of stay put, the IBI program was an appropriate substitute for CARD services. However, further analysis is required for determining whether the IBI program was appropriate for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs. 27. A basic understanding of the structured autism program will be useful in several of the remaining matters to be discussed in this Decision. 28. Ms. Kurihara also recommended OT services to address sensory integration issues, feeding concerns, activities of daily living, and fine-motor delays. 29. Ms. Pitzen did, however, express reservations about making assumptions that STUDENT’s mastery of a particular goal in the CARD setting meant he could perform the same tasks in a classroom setting. 30. To an extent not made clear at the hearing, some form of updated present levels of performance and goals and objectives, possibly related only to OT, was attached to Ms. Lappi’s August 7, 2002 letter to the parents. 31. STUDENT’s success at Country Village Preschool, demonstrated by events occurring after the District made its 2002-2003 school year offer and revealed in testimony at the hearing, will not be used to disturb the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District’s program and placement offer complied with the requirements of LRE through the date of this Decision. See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1148 (9th Cir. 1999). 32. Cal. Educ. Code section 56505.2 precludes a Hearing Officer from ordering placement in a private school that has not been “certified” pursuant to section 563661. At the hearing, the parties did not establish whether Country Village Preschool was certified or not certified. 33. The rule in Burlington, supra, is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
