California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 27, 2000
Encinitas Union School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1709-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Encinitas Union's assessments were appropriate, and its Learning Center offer gave a 10-year-old autistic student a FAPE for 1999-2000.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that it was amended to correct a typographical error, and that the amendment does not change the substance.
Summary
Encinitas Union School District filed for due process. It asked the Hearing Officer to rule on two questions: whether its assessments of a 10-year-old third grader with autism were appropriate, and whether its 1999-2000 offer gave him a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The parents had requested paid independent evaluations several times, withdrawing and renewing the request each time. They later moved their son to a private school, but they did not seek reimbursement at hearing.
The Hearing Officer ruled that the assessment question was not moot because the parents' demands were likely to come back. The 1997 multidisciplinary assessment by the California Diagnostic Center covered all areas of suspected disability. The 1999 follow-up and the occupational therapy, assistive technology and sensory diet assessments were also appropriate.
On FAPE, the offer kept the student at the Learning Center, a special day class at Capri Elementary School, with 67% of his day in general education. It also included speech-language therapy, occupational therapy, adapted physical education (APE) consultation and extended school year (ESY). The parents' experts said he needed daily one-to-one Lindamood-Bell or FastForWord therapy for auditory processing. The Hearing Officer relied instead on testimony from the Diagnostic Center and his teachers that he had made real gains in reading, math, writing and social skills. Under Rowley, parents cannot dictate methodology. The placement was also the least restrictive environment (LRE). No relief was awarded to the family.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO let a district defend its assessments even after the parents withdrew their request for an independent evaluation, when the demand was likely to recur. It also shows SEHO applying Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard to reject a parent's demand for a specific reading or auditory-processing method.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Were the District's assessments of the Respondent appropriate?
The issue was not moot because the parents had repeatedly made, withdrawn and renewed demands for paid independent evaluations. The 1997 Diagnostic Center assessment, plus the 1999 follow-up and the occupational therapy (OT), assistive technology and sensory diet assessments, were appropriate and covered all areas of suspected disability.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2A. Did the District's offer meet the unique needs of STUDENT through an individually designed program?
The Learning Center offer met the student's needs for social skills, small-group instruction, supported mainstreaming, OT with a sensory diet, APE consultation and speech-language therapy. Parents could not dictate a methodology such as Lindamood-Bell or FastForWord.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2B. Did the District's offer conform to STUDENT's IEP?
It was undisputed that the District had provided, and remained willing to provide, the placement, services and goals in the IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2C. Did the District's offer afford STUDENT some educational benefit?
The student made measurable gains in reading, writing, math, language and social skills at the Learning Center. The program was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and the District was not required to maximize his potential.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2D. Was the District's placement offer in the least restrictive environment?
Continued placement at his neighborhood school's Learning Center with 67% mainstreaming was the LRE. The student received significant social benefit from being with typically developing peers.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Declared that the District's offer of placement at the Learning Center was a FAPE in the LRE for the 1999-2000 school year. The student is not entitled to reimbursement of tuition and related costs for the private school placement that year.
- Declared that the District's assessments were appropriate. The student is not entitled to reimbursement for any independent assessments between the Diagnostic Center's initial evaluation and the hearing date.
Key authorities
Rowley; Honig v. Doe; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Lachman v. Illinois State Bd. of Educ.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Daniel R.R. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Roland M. v. Concord School Comm.
People named in the decision
- Karen Gilyard, attorney for District, Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo
- Dr. Beverly Barrett, director of pupil personnel services, Encinitas Union School District
- Deborah Plotkin, educational consultant representing Student, San Diego Regional Center
- Daniel Florio, advocate (J.D.) representing Student, San Diego Office of Clients' Rights Advocacy
- Gail Roberts, regional center service coordinator, San Diego Regional Center
- Katharin Jones, legal assistant, San Diego Office of Clients' Rights Advocacy
- Michele Guell, speech-language pathologist, Encinitas Union School District
- Dr. Tim Reeve, principal, Capri Elementary School
- Terri Horton, adapted physical education specialist, Encinitas Union School District
- Linda Spaw, speech-language pathologist, follow-up assessor, California Diagnostic Center (Southern California)
- Ruth Johnson, third grade general education teacher; earlier District assessor (1995), Capri Elementary School
- Monique Linster, occupational therapist (sensory diet), San Diego Children's Hospital
- Patricia Webster, occupational therapist, independent OT assessor, San Diego Children's Hospital
- Olivia Ortiz, school psychologist, Encinitas Union School District
- Mary Sundberg-Wealdon, second grade general education teacher, Capri Elementary School
- Sherri Miller, special day class teacher (Learning Center), Capri Elementary School
- Linda Detweiler-Newcomb, private speech pathologist (FastForWord), witness for Student
- Dr. Jennifer Oke, private clinical psychologist, witness for Student
- Patricia Lindamood, speech pathologist and Lindamood-Bell cofounder, witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell
- Dr. Alan Lincoln, private assessor engaged by District
- Kristen Gist, private psychological assessor (1993)
- Jana Birch, assistive technology assessor
- California Diagnostic Center, state diagnostic assessment agency, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
- North Coast Consortium for Special Education, autism specialist consultation
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1709-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: ENCINITAS UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment Designated Instructionand Services Placement CDS Code: 37-68080 District: Encinitas Union Elementary Disability Type: Autism
Case Details
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Long Beach, California, on March 28 and 29, 2000 and April 27, 2000.
Petitioner Encinitas Union School District (hereinafter Encinitas or District) was represented by attorney Karen Gilyard with the law firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Also present on the District's behalf was Dr. Beverly Barrett, the District's director of pupil personnel services.
Respondent STUDENT (hereinafter Respondent or STUDENT) was represented by educational consultant Deborah Plotkin from San Diego Regional Center, and advocate Daniel Florio, J.D. with the San Diego Office of Client's Rights Advocacy. Also present on the Respondent's behalf at various times during the hearing were Gail Roberts, San Diego Regional Center service coordinator; Katharin Jones, legal assistant from the San Diego Office of Client's Rights Advocacy; and FATHER, Respondent's father. Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Michele Guell, speech and language pathologist; Dr. Tim Reeve, principal of Capri Elementary School; Terri Horton, adaptive physical education (APE) specialist; Linda Spaw, speech and language pathologist; Ruth Johnson, regular education teacher; Monique Linster, occupational therapist(OT); Patricia Webster, OT; Olivia Ortiz, school psychologist; Mary Sundberg, regular education teacher; and Sherri Miller, special day class (SDC) teacher.
The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: FATHER, Respondent's father; Linda Detweiler-Newcomb, speech pathologist; Dr. Jennifer Oke, clinical psychologist; and Patricia Lindamood, speech pathologist.
* This decision was amended to correct a typographical error in the original decision. The amendments do not change the substance of the original decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
This case has a lengthy procedural history that culminated in the hearing proceeding over the Respondent's ninth motion to continue. The procedural background facts are set forth in substantial detail in the Hearing Officer's order dated April 25, 2000. This order denied the Respondent's motion to waive time for the submission of evidence, witnesses and issues. The Respondent made this motion after two days of hearing were completed and it had been agreed that only one additional day was required to conclude the hearing. The Hearing Officer concurrently denied the Respondent's motion for telephonic expert testimony and reminded the Respondent of his prior agreement with the Petitioner to present only rebuttal evidence when the hearing resumed.
On April 26, 2000, the Respondent filed a motion to reconsider the denial of expert testimony by telephone. He argued that the proposed witness would provide rebuttal testimony only and that he had erroneously referred to the witness as an expert. When the hearing resumed on April 27, 2000, the District submitted its written objection to the Respondent's motion to reconsider. Based upon the Respondent's representation at the conclusion of the second day of the hearing that he would provide rebuttal evidence only, (Footnote 1) the Hearing Officer agreed that Ms. Lindamood could provide telephonic testimony regarding STUDENT's unique needs and her therapy sessions with him. The District, the Respondent and the Hearing Officer also agreed to the parameters for testimony to be presented on the Respondent's behalf by Mr. PARENT, Linda Detweiler-Newcomb, Dr. Jennifer Oke, and Gail Roberts.
ISSUES
1. Were the District's assessments of the Respondent appropriate?
2. Did the District provide the Respondent with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old, third-grade boy with a diagnosis of autism. He has attended schools within the Encinitas School District since the age of three. In September 1997, STUDENT underwent a week of assessments at the California Diagnostic Center (hereinafter Diagnostic Center) pursuant to a District referral. The District was seeking information regarding the most appropriate diagnosis for STUDENT, effective educational strategies, and his anticipated learning potential over the next three to five years.
The Diagnostic Center confirmed a primary diagnosis of autism with related problems of attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD) and compulsive symptoms. Educationally, it recommended a highly structured environment with clear expectations for learning and behavior. It was further suggested that a core curriculum be presented to STUDENT with modifications that included visual presentation of information, pictorial cues, awareness of his sensory aversions, decreased work expectations, increased assistance, scheduled breaks, and less reliance on oral directions when providing instruction. The Diagnostic Center also found that STUDENT's school program would need to include setting limits, frequent opportunities for choice, reinforcement, predictable schedules, closure tasks, and pacing systems. Although it was determined that short periods of direct instruction in isolated areas might initially be valuable to STUDENT, he primarily needed to learn to generalize functional skills. STUDENT was able to learn things by rote, mimicry, or memorization without an understanding of the skill or its purpose. Thus, it was necessary for him to practice his skills frequently during meaningful activities and routines to develop an understanding of those skills. Due to STUDENT's decreased social skills, he also needed social skills training that included scripting conversations and behaviors, and short stories describing social situations. In the area of academics, the Diagnostic Center recommended that STUDENT be taught functional reading through whole word, rather than phonological strategies. Writing and mathematics should also focus on the application of those skills to "real-life situations." Teaching functional independent living skills across all environments was also identified as an important component of STUDENT's education. The District incorporated these suggestions into STUDENT's school program.
To gain additional insight into STUDENT's needs, the District obtained an independent OT evaluation from San Diego Children's Hospital (hereinafter Children's) in January 1998. The OT found that STUDENT had difficulties with space visualization, tactile discrimination, performing motor responses following a verbal direction, copying geometric designs with a pencil, imitating movements with his hands and mouth, and tracing designs with a pencil. STUDENT was also hypersensitive to touch, noise, and smell. His muscle tone was hypotonic with decreased upper body muscle strength. The OT recommended occupational therapy to decrease his sensitivities and improve his muscle strength, visual space perception, and visual motor integration. The OT's recommendations were included in STUDENT's Independent Education Program (IEP).
In February 1998, the District referred STUDENT to an independent assessor, Dr. Alan Lincoln, for another educational assessment. Encinitas requested that Dr. Lincoln evaluate STUDENT's current program, suggest methods for incorporating discrete trial training, and recommend strategies for social facilitation and improving mainstreaming participation. Dr. Lincoln reported that overall STUDENT was making good progress in his current placement, but that there were specific areas in which he continued to require assistance. These areas included conversational skills, social skills, problem-solving skills, and comprehension skills. Dr. Lincoln also recommended that the District implement the Treatment and Education of Autistic and Related Communications Handicapped Children (TEACCH) approach to provide STUDENT with a predictable schedule, provide further training to his individual aide in the areas of social skills facilitation and one-on-one instruction, and continue OT to respond to his sensory issues. He further proposed that STUDENT receive one hour per day of one-on-one instruction in the areas enumerated above.
The North Coast Consortium for Special Education (hereinafter NCCSE) provided a consultation from an autism specialist in February 1998. The NCCSE autism resource teacher suggested instructional methods for improving STUDENT's social awareness, interactive skills, conversational abilities, and communicative intent.
STUDENT's parents were generally satisfied with the above assessments and resulting school programs provided by Encinitas until their son was placed at the Learning Center located on the campus of
Capri Elementary School (hereinafter Capri) in late November 1998. The Learning Center is a program that the District has established for high functioning special education students who require an emphasis on social skills and pragmatic language development. It provides mainstreaming opportunities with modifications, support and services as appropriate for each individual student. STUDENT was mainstreamed for 67% of his school day, and participated with his regular education peers in the classroom, on the playground, and at lunch and recess. The Learning Center staff consists of one special education teacher and two aides. A speech and language pathologist, an occupational therapist (OT), and an adapted physical education (APE) specialist are also members of the Learning Center's team. A school psychologist and a special education counselor are also available to provide consultation and services when needed.
By June 1999, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT were markedly dissatisfied with STUDENT's progress at the Learning Center. They did not agree with proposed annual IEP goals and objectives, finding them unspecific and not adequately challenging. They also wanted more academic goals. Based upon the cognitive information obtained from the Diagnostic Center, the parents felt that STUDENT had a normal ability level and that, consequently, his academic achievement should be within the normal range. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested independent evaluations at the District's expense from a developmental psychologist and an OT. The District refused this request, stating that further assessments in these areas were not necessary. As partially discussed above, it had previously conducted psychological evaluations as follows: 5/3/93--private assessor, Kristen Gist; 2/24/94--private assessor, Alan Lincoln; 12/5/95--District assessor, Ruth Johnson; 9/25/97±California Diagnostic Center; and 2/3/98--private assessor, Alan Lincoln. The OT evaluations previously provided by the District were: 9/21/94--sensory processing assessment at San Diego Children's Hospital; 9/25/97-- sensory integration and OT assessment at the Los Angeles Diagnostic Center; 1/27/98--sensory integration assessment at San Diego Children's Hospital; and 5/25/99±development of an OT sensory processing report (sensory diet).
The District did agree to provide an adaptive technology assessment, which was conducted during March, April, and May 1999. STUDENT's greatest need was determined to be in the area of communication skills. It was suggested that he work on reading, writing, and language skills with a talking word processor during individual instruction. Because STUDENT had difficulty producing written work, an on-screen keyboard was recommended. This would produce entire words on the screen that he could select, rather than typing out the word letter by letter. The technology consultant also recommended software that could assist with STUDENT's auditory processing weaknesses.
In November 1999, two years after its initial assessment, the Diagnostic Center conducted a follow- up evaluation to assess STUDENT's progress. No evidence was found of the anxiety and sleep problems evident during the initial evaluation. He was found to have developed the ability to make transitions even when it was not his desire to do so. Thus, his demand for a rigid schedule had decreased and he was able to make changes in his routine. The assessor found that the District's staff had established a successful program at the Learning Center which allowed STUDENT to use language to make choices. He was able to accomplish this with content cues. STUDENT continued to require additional time to process language and sometimes found it difficult to remember a correct word. The visualizing and verbalizing programs were deemed successful because STUDENT had learned to focus on details. No sensory behaviors that interfered with his education were observed. STUDENT brushed his teeth and was not disturbed by others working around him, or by the sound of the school bell. It was noted that STUDENT used a significant amount of oral language. The assessor stated that she saw "a very verbal little guy, lots and lots of information, lots of use of language with different forms and content. He comments, he questions, he negotiates." STUDENT now did "lots of questioning and did not in the past." Although STUDENT was not ready for phonics two years before, he had "developed really good phonic skills" and was ready for a combined phonic, sight word approach to language. Good language and social modeling, scripting, rephrasing, and communication reinforcement was utilized in his Learning Center program. Providing STUDENT's designated instructional services (DIS) in his classroom allowed the specific skill to be incorporated into his natural environment, rather than working on a skill in isolation. Although the Diagnostic Center evaluator did not observe it, STUDENT's parents stated that he continued to have sensory aversions to teeth brushing, walking on sand and grass, loud noises, certain items of clothing, and a requirement for frequent movement.
In June 1999, the OT from Children's provided STUDENT's IEP team with a sensory diet. The OT suggested specific activities to be used at school to respond to his sensitivity to rapid movement, specific tactile sensations, light touch, some food textures, and loud or sudden noise.
Between May 13, 1999, and December 3, 1999, the parents and the District met on nine occasions for the purpose of completing STUDENT's annual IEP. The parents were initially only available for two- hour blocks of time on certain week-day mornings. Eventually, they could only meet for a maximum of two hours on Mondays. When the various IEP meetings convened, the parents would frequently insist that school and independent evaluation reports, as well as the parent's procedural rights, be read verbatim into the record of the meeting. It was the parents' position that reading reports aloud would ensure that the District heard and considered the reports. This would consume a substantial portion of the time allotted for the meetings. The meetings were often contentious and all of them ended without agreement on placement, goals, or services for STUDENT. Ultimately, the District offered STUDENT extended school year (ESY) placement for the 1998-99 school year with a continuation of his goals and objectives. It further proposed extensive goals and offered a continuation of STUDENT's placement at the Learning Center for the 1999-2000 school year. Adaptive physical education (APE), speech and language, and OT services were also offered. The Respondent remained at the Learning Center until the 1999 winter break. At that time, he was removed from the Learning Center and placed in a private school by his parents. Information concerning the specifics of the private school was not provided at the hearing, and no claim for tuition reimbursement was made by the Respondent.
Although Mr. and Mrs. PARENT withdrew their demand for reimbursement of the cost of independent evaluations, the District continued to seek a due process determination regarding the appropriateness of its assessments pursuant to California Education Code §56329(b). Its desire for an adjudication of this issue was based upon a history of parental demands for payment of independent assessments, followed by withdrawals, then later renewals of the demands. Because the parties had been unable to agree upon a placement and services for the Respondent for the 1999-2000 school year, the District also sought a decision regarding the appropriateness of its placement offer. Consequently, the District's case proceeded to hearing to determine whether its assessments of STUDENT were adequate, and whether it had offered him a free and appropriate education for the 1999-2000 school year.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District contends that it has appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and should not be required to reimburse the Respondent for any prior independent assessments. It further maintains that it offered the Respondent a free and appropriate public school placement (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year.
The Respondent has withdrawn both its written request to the District and their request to SEHO for a due process hearing on the issue of reimbursement for independent assessments. He did not reassert this claim at the hearing, nor did he seek reimbursement for the costs associated with his unilateral private school placement. The Respondent, instead, contests the District's claim that it offered him a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
DISCUSSION
ISSUE ONE
Were the District's assessments of the Respondent appropriate?
California authorizes a school district to file for a due process hearing to establish that its assessments were appropriate when it does not agree to a parent's request that it fund an independent evaluation. California Education Code §56329(b) provides,
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists . . . if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing . . . to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. (emphasis added)
In this case, the parents withdrew their most recent demand for repayment of the costs associated with all prior independent assessments, and no evidence was presented concerning those evaluations. However, because Mr. and Mrs. PARENT have made and withdrawn multiple requests for reimbursement, the District desires a determination of the appropriateness of its assessments.
Procedurally, the Hearing Officer determines that the issue of the appropriateness of the District's assessments is ripe for adjudication, even though no parental demand for reimbursement is currently pending. Both parties agreed that the Respondent has made, withdrawn, and reasserted demands for public payment of the same private evaluations. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that there is a reasonable expectation that this same issue will resurface again. An issue that is "capable of repetition, yet evading review" is not moot, and may be determined by the adjudicator. See Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988).
The Hearing Officer next turns to the substantive issue of the adequacy of the District's evaluations of STUDENT. For each of the District's assessments to be appropriate, it must satisfy the following requirements: (1) it must be conducted by a qualified person who possesses the requisite state and federal certifications in the area in which they are assessing; (2) the testing materials cannot have a racial, cultural or sexual bias; (3) the tests must be provided in the student's primary language or method of communication; (4) the test given must be validated for the specific purpose for which it is being used; (5) the assessor must be trained and administer the test in conformance with the test's instructions; (6) intellectual or psychological tests must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist; (7) the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability; and (8) the assessor must be knowledgeable of the student's disability. California Education Code §36320(e).
At the conclusion of the evaluation, the assessor must provide a written report containing the results of the assessment. This report must include all of the following: (1) whether the student may need special education services, and the basis for that determination; (2) the pupil's relevant behavior observed in an appropriate setting, and the relationship between that behavior and the student's social and academic functioning; (3) educationally relevant health, development, and medical findings, if any; (4) if appropriate, a determination of the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage; and (5) the need for specialized services, materials and equipment for pupils with low incident disabilities. California Education Code §56327.
Before discussing the appropriateness of each individual assessment conducted by the District, the Hearing Officer first addresses the broad requirement that the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Pursuant to the testimony of the witnesses presented by the witnesses, STUDENT has a primary diagnosis of high functioning autism with associated learning and attentional problems. He has difficulty with social interaction and pragmatic communication. His language, reading, writing, auditory processing, and math abilities are delayed. Both his fine and gross motor development are reduced. STUDENT also needs to continue to increase his self-help skills, and decrease his sensory sensitivities. Based upon this description of STUDENT's condition, and absent contrary information, the Hearing Officer determines that his areas of suspected disabilities are as follows: (1) cognitive and academic, (2) social/emotional/behavioral, (3) speech and language, including auditory processing, and (4) sensory, gross and fine motor development.
The District caused STUDENT to be assessed by the Diagnostic Center of Southern California (hereinafter Diagnostic Center) in September 1997. A follow-up assessment was done in November 1999. The initial assessment was conducted by a transdisciplinary team that consisted of an educational specialist, a pediatrician, a registered nurse, a school psychologist, and a speech and language pathologist. The parties did not contest the qualifications of these individuals, or their possession of the requisite state and federal certifications. The undisputed evidence established that the testing methods employed by the Diagnostic Center were without bias and administered in STUDENT's primary language, that each assessor was trained and competent to administer the tests he or she utilized, that all evaluators were knowledgeable in the area of autism and its related disorders, and that a school psychologist administered any intellectual or psychological tests. The Diagnostic Center evaluated STUDENT in the areas of cognition, adaptive behavior, social/emotional development, behavior, communication, academics, and motor and sensory development. At the conclusion of its assessment, the Diagnostic Center issued a forty-three-page written report which set forth its findings, conclusions, and recommendations for STUDENT's educational needs in compliance with California Education Code §56327.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the initial Diagnostic Center evaluation alone was comprehensive and constituted an appropriate evaluation that assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Although the initial, comprehensive Diagnostic Center assessment was conducted in September 1997, a follow-up assessment was done in November 1999. Moreover, absent extenuating circumstances, reassessments of students already eligible for special education need only occur once every three years. California Education Code §56381(a). Although it was not required, as discussed below, the District also provided further assessment in the areas of OT and adaptive technology.
Subsequent to the Diagnostic Center's evaluation, the District provided further assessments of STUDENT in the areas of occupational therapy, adaptive technology, and sensory needs. On January 27, 1998, the District obtained an independent occupational therapy assessment from Children's. The Respondent did not dispute the appropriateness of this evaluation, which was conducted by Patricia Webster, OT. Ms. Webster testified that she has a master's degree in occupational therapy. She has been a therapist for more than twenty years, working exclusively with children and young adults. She personally met with Mr. and Mrs. PARENT following her evaluation to discuss her findings and conclusions. She also enhanced her report to address specific issues raised by the parents, who then were in agreement with her report. Ms. Webster administered tests, conducted a clinical observation, reviewed school records, and consulted with STUDENT's teacher. She then made recommendations for OT strategies to decrease STUDENT's sensitivities, and improve his upper body strength, visual space perception and visual motor integration. Ms. Webster also drafted goals and objectives for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that it is undisputed that Ms. Webster's assessment was appropriate and in full compliance with California Education Code §§ 36320 and 56327.
An adaptive technology assessment was conducted by Jana Birch on May 12, 1999. Ms. Birch evaluated STUDENT on four different days, twice interviewed his parents, met with his teacher and speech therapist, and conducted a school observation. Ms. Birch drafted a comprehensive written report describing her evaluation and findings. She also made recommendations for assistance in the areas of communication, keyboarding, writing, use of a computer mouse, auditory filtering, and language software. Again, there was no evidence presented that this was an inadequate assessment, and the Hearing Officer finds it appropriate.
To respond to STUDENT's sensory issues, the District had a sensory diet developed by Children's OT Monique Linster in June 1999. Ms. Linster issued a report which recommended activities to be preformed at school to respond to STUDENT's slight increase in sensitivity to vestibular movement, below average ability to discriminate specific tactile sensations, tactile defensiveness to light touch, oversensitivity to some food textures, and oversensitivity to some noises. No evidence was presented to indicate that this assessment was inappropriate.
The Hearing Officer determines that the aforementioned assessment by the Diagnostic Center appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability in compliance with California Education Code §§36320(e), 56381(a) and 56327. The District also voluntarily provided additional assessments in certain specific areas. Therefore, the Respondent is not entitled to reimbursement for any private assessments occurring before the date of this hearing.
ISSUE TWO
Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
"Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the state educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.
In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education, or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child."
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.
Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services: (1) meets the student's unique needs through an individually designed program, (2) conforms to the IEP, (3) affords the student some educational benefit, and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.
A. Did the District's offer meet the unique needs of STUDENT through an individually designed program?
To determine whether the District's offer of placement and services met STUDENT's needs, the Hearing Officer must first identify his unique educational needs. STUDENT has a medical and educational diagnosis of autism. The evidence from the Diagnostic Center established that autism is characterized by "atypical development in the areas of social interaction, communication, and unusual interests and behaviors that can include processing differences." Based upon the assessment report from the Diagnostic Center, STUDENT presents difficulties in each of these areas. STUDENT demonstrates average cognitive abilities on standardized tests, with nonverbal reasoning strengths and auditory processing weaknesses. Developmentally, he can classify and sequence at an age- appropriate level. He has problems understanding cause and effect reasoning. His responses to questions often are only tangentially related to the topic. STUDENT's spontaneous language and academic skills are significantly delayed. Adaptive behaviors are reduced in all domains. STUDENT is hypotonic, which affects his fine motor skills both at home and at school. He also exhibits marked sensory processing difficulties across all environments.
Linda Spaw, a speech and language pathologist from the Diagnostic Center, conducted a four-hour follow-up evaluation of STUDENT in November 1999. Ms. Spaw testified that STUDENT does not acquire logical, sequential and deductive reasoning skills naturally. Consequently, he requires a variety of experiences to develop these abilities. Academically, STUDENT should be provided with the core curriculum with adaptations. These modifications should include the increased use of language when providing explanations, extra time to process information, small groups, reading using phonics and sight words, and multiple practice repetitions when acquiring a new skill. Ms. Spaw stated that STUDENT cannot learn just from listening. He needs the use of manipulatives and a hands-on teaching method to gain new information. Because STUDENT does not generalize well from abstract tasks, his academics should have a practical application to his daily life. According to Ms. Spaw, STUDENT also needs access to normally developing peers for social and pragmatic language development. He requires social skill's training that involves modeling and initiating appropriate interactions for him. This training and support would be most effective if it occurred throughout the day in his natural environments.
Olivia Ortiz is a District school psychologist who has worked with STUDENT as a consultant since he enrolled at Capri in late 1998. She has attended many of his IEP meetings. In the opinion of Ms. Ortiz, STUDENT needs the specialized instruction available in a special day class (SDC). He also needs opportunities for the general application of his emerging skills in general education with a support system available. Ms. Ortiz further testified that STUDENT required DIS speech and language, OT, APE, and goals to enhance social skills.
Sherri Miller was STUDENT's SDC teacher throughout the time he remained at the Learning Center at Capri. She agreed that STUDENT required the support available in a special day class in the form of small groups, the availability of individual instruction when needed, increased structure, and reduced sensory stimulation. She also testified that STUDENT needed social skills training, pragmatic language assistance, a predictable routine, and positive reinforcement. She stated that STUDENT learned best when he was initially taught a new skill in the SDC, then allowed to practice that skill in a general education class. Although his social skills had improved significantly, to be mainstreamed effectively for social and academic goals, STUDENT still needed special education staff available to provide necessary assistance and modifications.
Terri Horton, an adaptive physical education (APE) specialist, testified that STUDENT had shown good growth in his physical abilities and playground skills. He was now aware of game rules and had developed good "game rule social skills." His tracking, eye-hand coordination, foot-hand coordination, and balance skills had greatly improved. She said that as a result of his gains, STUDENT currently requires only monthly APE consultation. He is ready for a general education physical education class, and it is important that he be mainstreamed into that setting.
Monique Linster and Patricia Webster, both occupational therapists from Children's, testified that STUDENT required OT once a week for sixty minutes to work on sensory and self-care issues. One half of each session should be direct therapy and the other half should be small-group therapy. Ms. Linster and Ms. Webster also agreed that a sensory diet was necessary to address STUDENT's tactile processing difficulties. The sensory diet should be created by an OT who would train the school staff to implement the program.
STUDENT's speech and language needs were addressed by Michele Guell, a District speech and language pathologist. Ms. Guell testified that STUDENT should have two hours per week of speech therapy. Each of these hours should provide forty-five minutes of small-group therapy, and fifteen minutes of individual therapy. The small-group sessions should focus on pragmatic speech and social behaviors. During the one-on-one session, STUDENT would work on his articulation and oral-motor development.
Dr. Jennifer Oke is the clinical psychologist who provided an independent assessment and therapy at the request of STUDENT's parents. Dr. Oke testified that it is first necessary to deal with STUDENT's auditory processing deficits. Because he cannot quickly process information presented auditorily, it is difficult for him to learn from a classroom teacher's oral lessons. His auditory delay is compounded by the noise and activity of a group setting. STUDENT is a visual and tactile learner, so he requires instruction utilizing these senses. Dr. Oke stated that STUDENT requires auditory processing remediation methodologies like FastForWord or Lindamood Bell to address his processing delays at the neurological level, combined with visual and tactile exposure. This program must be provided daily for one hour on an individual basis. The program must also be monitored and adjusted daily to ensure the appropriateness of the next day's session. The primary focus should be on enhancing STUDENT's phonemic awareness to overcome his auditory processing delay. This means he must be taught to segregate words, break words into individual sounds, interchange sounds, and put the sounds back together. Academically, Dr. Oke testified that STUDENT should be working on increasing his reading level, fluency and complexity. He should also learn all of the sight words and spelling exceptions to nonphonemically spelled words. Dr. Oke also emphasized STUDENT's need for social skills training to teach him to interact and converse with his peers. Initially, this would require individual modeling for STUDENT during interaction with a single peer. The instructor would show STUDENT correct phrases for back-and-forth conversation and teach him topics that are of interest to his peers. Dr. Oke further testified that STUDENT must have goals to address his sensory deficits. In her opinion, STUDENT's primary sensory difficulty is his inability to sit for extended periods of time. He begins to rock, or leaves his seat. Thus, he requires built-in breaks for movement during his day.
STUDENT was privately provided the FastForWord program by speech pathologist, Lynda Detweiler- Newcomb. Ms. Detweiler-Newcomb stated that STUDENT had a language processing disorder that caused vocabulary deficits, difficulties with irregular verbs, and decreased reasoning and abstraction abilities. STUDENT also needs to increase his phonemic awareness, and the rhythm and sequencing of multisyllable words. It was Ms. Detweiler-Newcomb's testimony that STUDENT requires intensive, one- on-one therapy for two-to-three hours per day to accomplish these goals.
Patricia Lindamood is a speech pathologist and cofounder of the Lindamood-Bell remediation program. She supervised the provision of Lindamood-Bell language remediation therapy to STUDENT. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT's primary problem is a lack of phonemic awareness. Because he lacks phonemic awareness, he cannot understand verbal input and gains nothing from his education. He does not have a conceptual basis of language, so he makes "unphonetic" spelling errors. It was Ms. Lindamood's opinion that STUDENT requires continued therapy to respond to his decreased phonemic awareness and its application to reading and writing. She further stated that STUDENT is unable to form "mind images" of word orders, so he needs imagery therapy. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT's difficulty is a processing problem that will prevent progress in reading, spelling, and writing if it is not remediated. Consequently, until his deficit is dealt with, the emphasis in his education should temporarily shift from the core curriculum to overcoming his processing deficit. Ms. Lindamood testified that only her Lindamood-Bell program, and to a lessor extent, the FastForWord program, offered remediation therapies to address STUDENT's needs. Her program teaches phonemic awareness through the feel of mouth movements, and FastForWord slows down words heard auditorily for easier understanding. Ms. Lindamood recommended that STUDENT receive one-on-one language therapy for a minimum of one hour each day.
Based upon the above testimony, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT has unique needs for social skills training, small-group academic instruction with individual attention when necessary, mainstreaming with special education support, OT with a sensory diet, APE consultation, access to the core curriculum with appropriate adaptations, and speech and language therapy for social language, auditory processing deficits, oral-motor development, and phonemic awareness. The Hearing Officer does not dispute that STUDENT has needs in the area of auditory processing as emphasized by Ms. Lindamood. However, given the evidence (discussed below in greater detail) of STUDENT's progress while at the Learning Center, the Hearing Officer does not accept that the sole way to address this need is through either the Lindamood-Bell or FastForWord programs.
To address STUDENT's needs during the 1999-2000 school year, the District offered to continue his SDC placement at Capri's Learning Center, with mainstreaming for 67% of his school day. It also offered to provide two, one-hour speech and language sessions each week; direct OT for sixty minutes one time per week, with ninety minutes of OT consultation per year; and APE for fifteen minutes once a month. An extended school year program (ESY) was also offered to STUDENT.
Ms. Miller testified that her Learning Center program was designed to accommodate students like STUDENT who have cognitive abilities near or within the normal range but who require additional support with academics, peer interaction and language. The Learning Center focuses on pragmatic language and social skills, which are incorporated into all aspects of the academic day. She further stated that unlike other special day classes, where the students are primarily mainstreamed during nonacademic subjects, the Learning Center provides as much inclusion as is appropriate for each child. A special education staff member accompanies the SDC student to the general education classroom, modifies the class work, and provides the necessary level of support. Additionally, all DIS services are provided within her classroom and the providers are members of the Learning Center's collaborative team.
The District's DIS providers testified that STUDENT received OT, APE, sensory diet implementation, and speech and language services in his SDC. Ms. Miller testified that STUDENT received social skills training throughout his school day. She, or her staff, would practice social and communication skills with STUDENT in the special day classroom. Methods used included social stories, role playing, and modeling. A special education staff member would then accompany him during recesses and lunch to facilitate and practice what he had learned. STUDENT's academics were "pre-taught" in the SDC. He would then be integrated into the regular education classroom, with necessary support and modifications, to participate when that teacher taught the same lesson. In this manner, he received the additional instruction time he required and could better grasp the concept when he was again exposed to it in the general education class. Ms. Miller stated that she provided STUDENT with small-group and individual reading and writing instruction. Reading lessons included work on his auditory processing needs, decoding skills, and phonetic awareness through a multi-modality program. With this program, words are first said aloud, then repeated one phoneme at a time, and then written. Ms. Miller uses flash cards and repetition to enhance STUDENT's short- term memory. STUDENT works on sounding out words, recognizing sight words, and reading aloud to increase his fluency. To enhance reading comprehension skills, STUDENT will retell the story, answer questions, and identify the characters. STUDENT also attended a reading group with his general education peers. Math was a strength for STUDENT, and most of his math instruction took place in the regular education classroom with accommodations. During math, he was provided with manipulatives and a decreased number of math problems.
Ms. Miller also testified that she had been trained in the Lindamood-Bell reading program and she utilized its LIPS program with STUDENT as requested by his parents. Ms. Lindamood discounted the benefit of these school sessions, testifying that only her staff can provide reliable Lindamood-Bell therapy as her staff is trained and supervised by her personally. She also testified that her therapists (clinicians) need only have a high school diploma with no formal education, other than the two weeks of training and subsequent mentoring provided by her company. Ms. Lindamood maintains that good auditory skills are the determinative factor for successful Lindamood-Bell clinicians. Because this skill cannot be taught, it, and not the educational background of her clinicians, is the important factor in determining a good clinician. The Hearing Officer does not find this claim persuasive. Ms. Lindamood markets her training courses to numerous outside persons, including educators. If these individuals cannot benefit from and learn to implement her program, there is no reason to provide her training seminars. Moreover, it is difficult to accept the claim that educational background and experience are not relevant to the implementation of any therapy program. Certainly, teachers, speech and language pathologist, and other pediatric specialists are going to bring enhanced skills to any teaching method in which they participate.
Ms. Spaw testified that she personally observed STUDENT at school over several hours when she conducted the Diagnostic Center's follow-up assessment at the Learning Center in November 1999. She emphasized that because she preforms so many of these types of assessments, she can easily determine when she is observing a typical school day versus "stilted lessons." She stated that her observation at STUDENT's school was clearly during a normal day and his needs were consistently satisfied throughout her observation. Ms. Spaw testified that she observed the teacher working with STUDENT in a small group on visualizing and verbalizing skills. Each student was assigned a peer and instructed to choose an animal. The team would then describe the animal without naming it. The other students would try to guess the correct animal. Questions and the use of descriptive words were encouraged by the teacher. She heard the teacher provide explanations using clear, descriptive words, then pause to accommodate STUDENT's slower processing speed. When outside recess was unexpectedly canceled due to rain, Ms. Spaw said the teacher effectively responded to STUDENT's difficulties with unpredictability by having him and his classmates talk about the reasons they could not go out to play in the rain. This successfully transitioned STUDENT to recess with games and snacks in the classroom. Ms. Spaw also observed STUDENT when he was mainstreamed for math. He was using small tiles to cover a book, then estimating the number of tiles needed to cover an object. STUDENT next went to the library, then out to lunch with his general education peers. Following lunch STUDENT received a language lesson. He was allowed to manipulate items inside a bag, describe what he felt, then try to name the object hidden inside. Ms. Spaw then watched while the SDC students discussed their day with the teacher and each other; then, because it was a minimum day, the student's lined up and left school.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above testimony that the District both identified and responded to STUDENT's unique needs through its offer of ongoing placement and services at the Learning Center. His deficits in social interaction and communication skills had been, and would continue to be, specifically addressed at the Learning Center during his entire school day through facilitation, modeling, role playing, scripting, and small-group speech and language therapy. A large amount of interaction with his typically developing peers was arranged. STUDENT's academics were introduced individually or in a small group in the SDC. They would then be reinforced in the general education class with the level of support and modification he required for each task. STUDENT would continue to be provided with multi-sensory, systematic methods to respond to his reading needs and deficits in auditory processing. Manipulatives were available for his use. A sensory diet had been developed and would be implemented to respond to STUDENT's heightened sensitivity. He was also offered the necessary APE and speech and language services.
B. Did the District's offer conform to STUDENT's IEP?
There is no dispute that the District had previously provided, and remained willing to provide, the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's IEP.
C. Did the District's offer afford STUDENT some educational benefit?
Ms. Spaw from the Diagnostic Center provided compelling, unbiased evidence of the educational gains STUDENT made during his time at the Learning Center. Ms. Spaw testified that in the two years between the Diagnostic Center's first evaluation of STUDENT in 1997 and its reassessment of him in 1999, STUDENT made substantial gains in most areas. When he was first seen at the Diagnostic Center, it was predicted that STUDENT would not learn phonics. Two years later, he was sounding out words phonetically and comprehending at a second grade level. He had developed "engaging language" to negotiate and question. He exhibited an understanding of humor and the nuances of language. Ms. Spaw also noted that STUDENT's language was easily understood, with the only articulation error being the substitution of the "w" sound for "r" and "l" sounds. STUDENT's math skills had increased from a kindergarten to a first grade level. There was no evidence of the anxiety or sensitivity to sound and touch that was previously present.
Ms. Miller testified that while STUDENT was in her class from November 1998 until the winter break of 1999, he showed significant growth. She stated that when he first started in her class, he wanted to play alone at recess on the slide or with the sand. By December 1999, STUDENT was initiating interactions and verbal communications with his peers. Academically, STUDENT initially required full support in the general education classroom. By the end of 1999, he was able to learn his academics in the SDC, then successfully use that information in the regular education class with little adult supervision or prompting. When STUDENT began at the Learning Center, it was necessary to model, role play, and practice all social language for STUDENT. A year later, he was interacting with his peers without assistance. Although reading continued to be difficult for STUDENT, Ms. Miller testified that STUDENT had progressed from an early reader to the second grade level. He had learned to sound out words, and his fluency and comprehension had increased. STUDENT's math abilities improved to the extent that he was receiving his mathematics in the regular education classroom with limited modifications. He had learned to add and subtract using the borrowing and carrying concepts. Ms. Miller also said that when STUDENT entered her class, he could only write one-word answers. By December 1999, he self-generated four to five sentences when given a topic or when asked a question. Ms. Miller also testified that STUDENT's social behavior greatly improved. He usually interacted in an appropriate manner with his peers. Although he first required SDC staff in close proximity when mainstreamed, a year later he required only the reminder of a nod or a pointing prompt.
Mary Sundberg-Wealdon was STUDENT's second grade general education teacher at Capri during the 1998- 99 school year. STUDENT was in her class for math, science, some writing, art, music, and social studies. Ms. Sundberg-Wealdon testified that when STUDENT first started in her class, he was very shy and would not speak or interact without prompting. Eventually, he was a full participant in all of her class activities. He would seek out, and be sought by her other students, both in the classroom and on the playground. When STUDENT was unable to accomplish the specific task required of the other students, the staff would develop a method for him to perform the same project in a different manner. For example, assignments would be reduced or broken into smaller tasks, or he would calculate his math problems with manipulatives rather than with a pencil on paper.
STUDENT's third grade general education teacher at Capri was Ruth Johnson. Ms. Johnson testified that he "definitely" made academic progress while mainstreamed into her class. STUDENT's reading became more fluent and he grew comfortable reading aloud to the other students. During math, he began to raise his hand and provide correct answers to her questions. On math tests, he typically scored slightly below the average, but he was doing third grade work with his peers. It was the opinion of Ms. Johnson that STUDENT showed the most growth socially. At first he was shy, but by December 1999, he was very comfortable and interacted with both adults and peers. He became more active in class, his participation increased, he laughed and displayed happiness when he understood lessons, and he was well-liked by the other students.
Terri Horton, STUDENT's APE teacher, testified that she initially provided APE services two times a week for thirty minutes to address STUDENT's deficits in the areas of social, motor, balance, eye- hand and eye-foot coordination, and playground games. Through her work with him, STUDENT became more aware of the social rules of play, his balance skills increased, his ability to track a ball improved, and he gained eye-hand and eye-foot coordination. Ms. Horton stated that by December 1999, STUDENT no longer required frequent APE services. He was ready to join general education physical education and that was his least restrictive environment.
STUDENT's father, Mr. PARENT, testified that he did not believe the Learning Center program was challenging enough for his son. He also thought there was too little emphasis on STUDENT's academics, and insufficient documentation was presented to him that STUDENT was meeting his goals. To Mr. PARENT, it appeared as if STUDENT were continuing to do the same things at school that he had done in prior years. He also felt that there was inadequate communication between him, his wife and the Learning Center staff. Upon learning from the Diagnostic Center that STUDENT had normal cognitive ability, he determined that STUDENT's "potential to learn was unlimited" if he were taught correctly. Mr. PARENT said that he had visited his son at school, and with the exception of the OT and math sessions, he did not feel that STUDENT was learning anything. As discussed in the background facts, he did not see any meaningful increase in the difficulty of STUDENT's math homework, nor did he see improvement in his reading abilities. By August of 1999, Mr. PARENT testified that he was no longer satisfied with the Learning Center. Both STUDENT's educational progress and the communication between home and school were insufficient. He believed that the homework was static, that STUDENT was not ready to join the regular education students for physical education, and that there was not enough individual speech therapy or OT. Mr. PARENT and his wife therefore decided to remove STUDENT from the Learning Center and enroll him in a nonpublic school during the winter 1999 school break.
The Respondent's experts, Dr. Oke, Ms. Lindamood, and Ms. Detweiler-Newcomb, all agreed that the District's program was not adequately responding to STUDENT's auditory processing deficit and that consequently it was not providing him with educational benefit. In their opinions, STUDENT could not learn to his potential in a classroom until the auditory processing issue was successfully addressed. They testified that because greater auditory processing skills are required when an individual is in a group, and because STUDENT's processing speed was delayed, he was quickly left behind when taught in a group/lecture environment. Therefore, STUDENT required more individual instruction using his visual and tactile senses. Dr. Oke, Ms. Lindamood, and Ms. Detweiler-Newcomb also agreed that STUDENT's auditory processing deficit could only be remediated at the neurological level through either the FastForWord, or Lindamood-Bell program. The Respondent's experts collectively agreed that STUDENT needed one to three hours of individual therapy through one of the above programs, which he was not receiving at the Learning Center.
STUDENT's parents desire a specific teaching methodology for their son and feel that he will only attain his potential if he receives either the FastForWord or Lindamood-Bell program. Although parents are entitled to independently provide the specific educational program they believe will most enhance their child's abilities, an appropriate public education does not demand the absolute best or "potential-maximizing" education for a special education student. Seattle School District v. B.S.,24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.
Furthermore, parents are not entitled to dictate the educational methodology that will be used by a school district. Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290 (7th Cir. 1988). In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or whether that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987).
The Respondent argues that he can only make academic progress after he receives intensive auditory processing training through either the Lindamood-Bell or FastForWord program. The Hearing Officer does not accept this contention. The testimony established that STUDENT was making academic progress at the Learning Center. His reading, writing, and math abilities had measurably increased. His language was continuing to develop, as were his social skills. Certainly, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT may pursue the education they feel is best for their child. However, as discussed above, the District is not obligated to provide the best education available for STUDENT. It must only offer the "basic floor of opportunity" through a program designed to confer some educational benefit and meet his individual needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District has done this and that STUDENT has received, and would continue to receive, educational benefit from the placement and services at the Learning Center.
D. Was the District's placement offer in the least restrictive environment?
This issue was not specifically addressed by the parties. However, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT's social development is a primary goal. Consequently, it is appropriate to address this issue as a component of a FAPE in light of the parents' decision to transfer STUDENT to a nonpublic school. The Court in the case of Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (1989), held that the law demonstrates "a strong preference for µmainstreaming' which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption." Moreover, it is preferred that handicapped students be provided with an appropriate education within the regular education setting. United States Code §1412(a)(5) provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplemental aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The District's placement of STUDENT was in a neighborhood school with 67% of his day mainstreamed in the general education program. He had lunch, recess, physical education, and a portion of his academics with his age-appropriate regular education peers. Thus, STUDENT spent the majority of his school day with his typically developing peers in an unrestricted regular education environment. The testimony of the general education teachers who worked with STUDENT daily established that he enjoyed and was a full participant in the regular education program. He had general education friends who sought him out. He expressed pleasure at his accomplishments in the regular education class. He ate lunch and played typical playground games with his normally developing peers. He was interacting and developing relationships with adults, and SDC and general education students. As a result, his pragmatic language, play and social skills, and social behavior increased dramatically.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of the District's witnesses that STUDENT was benefitting from his participation in his community school. Unlike academic skills, social development cannot be quantified by a test. However, the benefit to STUDENT from being a participant in his community is invaluable and should not be discounted. In fact, the Courts have consistently found that a program that provides academic superiority does not trump the value of integration with nondisabled peers. This issue was addressed by the district court in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland 786 F. Supp.879 (1992); adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (1994). The court held "the Acts requirement of integration, based on recognition of the nonacademic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom." See also Roland v. Concord School Comm., 910 F.2d 983 (1990). The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was receiving significant social benefit from the Learning Center and that the District's offer of continued placement at that location was the least restrictive environment for him.
CONCLUSION
Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's assessments were appropriate and its placement offer for the 1999-2000 school year complied with its duty to provide
STUDENT with a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Education Code §56505(i).)
ORDER
1. The District's offer of placement at the Learning Center constitutes a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year, and the Respondent is not entitled to reimbursement for tuition and associated costs for his nonpublic school placement during that school year.
2. The District's assessments were appropriate and the Respondent is not entitled to reimbursement for any independent assessments for the period between the Diagnostic Center's initial evaluation and the date of the hearing.
DATED:
_____________________________________ Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
Footnote: * This decision was amended to correct a typographical error in the original decision. The amendments do not change the substance of the original decision. 1. Although the Respondent had not presented any evidence, identified witnesses , or submitted a statement of issues in compliance with the five- and ten-day rules set forth in California Education Code §§ 56505(e)(6)(7), the District offered to stipulate that the Respondent could present rebuttal evidence limited solely to the issue of a FAPE. Proper rebuttal evidence is only that evidence responding to the Petitioner's evidence that could not have been reasonably anticipated when the Petitioner's evidence was initially submitted. Because the Petitioner did not limit its stipulation to only reasonably unanticipated evidence, technically it was agreeing that the Respondent could present evidence contrary to the Petitioner's assertion that it had provided a FAPE, arguably authorizing the reopening of the Respondent's case on this limited issue.
