California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 16, 2003

Student v. Torrance Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1723-02 · Hearing Officer Heather A. Hoyle

Torrance Unified need not keep providing limousine transportation; the Hearing Officer finds a bus or van appropriate.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's guardian requested this hearing for a 17-year-old student who is eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance. Under his IEP, the student attended Buena Park Speech and Language, a private school. Torrance Unified had paid for door-to-door limousine transportation since 2000. At a June 2002 IEP meeting, the team moved him to a school bus with a bus assistant. The guardian kept her right to stay put with the limousine if busing did not work. The student never rode the bus or the vans the District later sent. The only issue was whether he needed limousine transportation to benefit from his education.

The family's witnesses, the guardian and treating therapist Dr. Deanna Daniels, said he struggled with change, tested new adults, and had misbehaved on buses years earlier. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of his teacher, James Martin, more credible. Martin said the student had adjusted to new aides, rode field-trip buses without incident, and had few behavior problems. Most of the transportation incidents described happened in or before 1999. Citing Rowley, the Hearing Officer held that the District must provide appropriate transportation, not the most convenient kind. The District prevailed. Within 20 days, the District must hold an IEP meeting to choose between a District van and the school's small bus. The team must also decide whether he needs a bus assistant or a transition plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO decided the mode of transportation as a related service. Transportation had to meet the student's unique needs, not keep a long-standing arrangement. Current credible evidence, such as uneventful field-trip bus rides and adjustment to new staff, outweighed older behavior incidents. The Hearing Officer sent concerns about a gradual transition back to the IEP team.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Is the District required to provide STUDENT with transportation by limousine service for him to benefit from his education?

    The student's difficulty with change, testing of new people, and past bus behavior did not require limousine transport; a bus or van, possibly with a transition plan, is appropriate, and Rowley does not require the most convenient transportation.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to choose the mode of transportation (a District-owned van or a small bus provided by the student's NPS placement), decide whether a bus assistant is needed, and address whether the student needs a transportation transition plan. Petitioner's request for relief (continued limousine service) was denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Doe v. Board of Education of Tullahoma City Schools

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Deanna Daniels, treating clinician; witness for Student, Private (treated student since about 1993)
  • Victoria Estrada, director of special education; District witness, Torrance Unified School District
  • James Martin, private school teacher; District witness, Buena Park Speech and Language
  • Martha Berry, program specialist; District representative and witness, Torrance Unified School District
  • Tamala Crawford, aide; District witness
  • Tony, 1:1 aide, Buena Park Speech and Language
  • Buena Park Speech and Language, private school placement

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Torrance, California, on March 25, 26, and 27, 2003.

Petitioner (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Daniel Pinto. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, STUDENT’s mother. Respondent Torrance Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by advocate Robert Roice and Martha Berry, District program specialist.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: STUDENT’s mother and Dr. Deanna Daniels. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Victoria Estrada, director of special education; James Martin, private school teacher; Martha Berry; and Tamala Crawford, aide.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. On April 18, 2002, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)

Is the District required to provide STUDENT with transportation by limousine service for him to benefit from his education?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that his disability requires that he continue to be transported to and from his private school placement each school day by a private limousine because this service has been provided for him for a number of years and he has difficulty accepting any change in his routine. He asserts that a change in his routine is likely to affect his academic progress. In addition, Petitioner argues that he has exhibited inappropriate behavior in the past, and in particular, on a school bus, and that to transport him by means other than limousine service would be dangerous for him, the driver, or other people in the vehicle. Finally Petitioner argues that he tests new people and is more likely to act inappropriately.

The District argues that STUDENT has shown he is able to accept change in classroom personnel and that he could accept a change in transportation as well. The District contends that STUDENT’s behavior has stabilized and that instances of inappropriate behavior are infrequent. The District argues that STUDENT has ridden on several school buses to attend field trips without any behavior incidents. The District argues that STUDENT does not require a private limousine service to transport him to and from school. The District further contends that STUDENT may be appropriately transported by either a small bus or a passenger van, or by a family member, to be reimbursed for mileage at the District’s standard rate.(Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student eligible for special education under the criteria for emotional disturbance. STUDENT’s father and his first wife adopted STUDENT shortly after his birth.(Footnote 3) STUDENT currently resides within the boundaries of the Torrance Unified School District and attends a private school, Buena Park Speech and Language (Buena Park), pursuant to his last agreed-upon IEP. STUDENT began attending school at Buena Park in 2000. At that time, the District offered him door-to-door transportation provided by a limousine service.(Footnote 4)

The District continued to offer STUDENT door-to-door transportation provided by limousine until the June 13, 2002, meeting of the IEP team. The IEP team determined that STUDENT would ride with a bus assistant on a bus operated by Buena Park, the private school STUDENT attends, and that the parties would revisit transportation in the fall of 2002 if there were any further concerns. STUDENT’s guardian, STUDENT’s mother, signed the IEP agreeing to the transportation but reserving her right to stay put with the limousine service if the busing was not successful. The school bus did arrive to pick STUDENT up during the summer of 2002; however, STUDENT did not ride the bus and, instead, has continued to be transported by limousine service from his house to Buena Park. The parties have met several times since June 2002 to discuss STUDENT’s transportation.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s mother requested the instant due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT via letter dated July 24, 2002.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Pursuant to the IDEA and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Edu. Code §5600. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. §1401(8).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. §1401(25); Cal.Edu.Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

Transportation is a related service which must be provided if necessary for a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). “Transportation” may include travel to and from school and specialized equipment (such as special or adapted buses, lifts, and ramps), if such equipment is required to provide special transportation for a child with a disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(15). The appropriate mode of transportation will depend on the student’s unique needs. See 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, Attachment 1, § 300.24.

In this case, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT will receive transportation to and from his private school placement at the District’s expense. Petitioner contends that STUDENT still requires transportation by limousine because of his inability to accept change and his behavioral problems. However, the District contends that STUDENT is capable of riding to school in either a small bus operated by STUDENT’s private school, a district-owned van, or in a private vehicle driven by a family member to be reimbursed for mileage at the District’s standard rate.

To determine if the District’s offer of transportation is appropriate, it is first necessary to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs are.(Footnote 6) As explained above, Petitioner is identified as emotionally disturbed and has a history of inappropriate behavior. Testimony at hearing generally was that STUDENT’s disability affects his ability to make academic progress. Testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Dr. Daniels was that STUDENT’s behavior and academic progress are affected by abuse STUDENT suffered during his childhood.(Footnote 7) STUDENT’s mother indicated that prior to her late husband taking sole custody of STUDENT, he was apparently subjected to physical abuse. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated after his father’s death in 1998 and that STUDENT has extreme reactions to perceived changes in his schedule. In addition, Dr. Daniels testified that over the years STUDENT has exhibited behavior that has required STUDENT’s mother to call the police and that has resulted in STUDENT being hospitalized.(Footnote 8)

Currently, STUDENT has three “main” drivers from the limousine company who take him to and from school.(Footnote 9) STUDENT’s mother testified that when a new driver was introduced, STUDENT began to behave inappropriately during the ride to school. STUDENT’s mother explained that she would ride with him to help with the transition to another driver and that she would ensure that there were consequences for inappropriate behaviors. Dr. Daniels testified that with a new driver she would expect that for three to six months STUDENT would be less focused on school and might stop making academic progress.

The District’s position regarding STUDENT’s alleged need for stability in his service providers and his resistance to change is STUDENT’s ability to successfully adapt to changes in his routine. The District argues that other changes have been successfully instituted in STUDENT’s educational placement. For example, STUDENT has had several aides over the past few years and, in particular, has an aide named Tony with whom STUDENT feels comfortable. Mr. Martin testified that while there were some problems when Tony first started, STUDENT has adjusted and now works well with Tony.(Footnote 10) In addition, the District’s position is that over the years STUDENT’s drivers have changed as well and that STUDENT was able to continue to make progress in his educational program.

Testimony of Mr. Martin was that STUDENT has been improving in his ability to deal with changes in his educational program. Although Dr. Daniels testified that STUDENT is likely to experience setbacks in his ability to behave appropriately when confronted with new people affecting his ability to make academic progress, no evidence was presented supporting that contention. Mr. Martin testified credibly that STUDENT continues to improve in his behavior, particularly in relationship to changes introduced into his daily routine, as evidenced by his acceptance of Tony, his current one-one aide. Furthermore, Dr. Daniels testified that she did recognize that it is not feasible to maintain the exact same caregivers and educational service providers. While Dr. Daniels testified that she did not think that STUDENT’s current means of transportation should change, when questioned about how change could be implemented successfully for STUDENT, she testified that changes need to be introduced in increments so that STUDENT can feel successful. For example, when questioned specifically regarding transportation, Dr. Daniels indicated that an appropriate way to introduce a new mode of transportation may be to start with one ride on a bus per week and then demonstrate to STUDENT that this is something he can do successfully and then increase the number of trips gradually based on STUDENT’s progress. While it does appear that transitions are difficult for STUDENT, there was no credible evidence presented that STUDENT’s needs require that the District continue to contract with the same individuals to provide his transportation to and from school. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT may require a plan to transition him to using another means of transportation, his resistance to change in his program does not prevent him from being transported to school by a bus or a passenger van, nor require his continued transportation by limousine.

Petitioner also argues that STUDENT requires transportation by his current limousine drivers because he tests the limits of new people in his life by “acting out” and that he may become dangerous. Testimony at hearing was generally that STUDENT tends to exhibit an increase in inappropriate behavior when new caregivers or other service provides are presented. STUDENT’s mother testified that when new limousine drivers started, STUDENT kicked the back of the driver’s seat. Dr. Daniels testified that it is not the vehicle that she believes is important for STUDENT, but rather, it is the people who drive him. Both STUDENT’s mother and Dr. Daniels testified that they were concerned about STUDENT’s safety on a bus or other form of transportation because STUDENT would be more likely to act out and “test” the new driver. Dr. Daniels’ testimony was that STUDENT needs to feel physically secure,that he seeks to test the limits with new individuals, and that he needs to feel that the new people would be able to physically control or restrain him. In particular, she testified that STUDENT should have male aides or women who are older and present themselves in a fairly stern manner.

The District’s position is that while STUDENT may “test” new people, this behavior does not require that he continue to be transported by limousine to and from school each day. Mr. Martin testified that he has seen STUDENT test new aides and other people that come into contact with him. However, contrary to the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Dr. Daniel, Mr. Martin’s testimony was that this testing of limits has not caused any significant increase in inappropriate behavior affecting his ability to benefit from his education. In addition, Ms. Berry indicated that she has not received any calls from Buena Park regarding significant behavioral issues. Mr. Martin did not recall any incidents or any reports of significant behavior issues regarding transportation. Mr. Martin was candid in expressing that STUDENT has been tough on new one-to-one aides in the past; however, Mr. Martin did not believe that STUDENT’s behavior in relationship to new people would preclude him from riding either a bus or a van to school. In addition, Mr. Martin’s testimony was that when confronted with female aides in the past, STUDENT has conducted himself appropriately.

While it appears from the testimony that STUDENT does engage in inappropriate behavior at times following the introduction of new people into his routine, STUDENT’s current teacher, Mr. Martin, testified credibly that STUDENT has successfully adapted to other changes in his program, including personnel, and that his behavior is not out of control in the classroom. Mr. Martin also testified that he did not recall any significant incidents regarding STUDENT’s behavior while riding on a bus. Mr. Martin testified that STUDENT does take buses for field trips without incident. The Hearing Officer finds that there was insufficient evidence presented regarding STUDENT’s “acting out” when confronted with new people to require that he continue to be transported by limousine to school.

Petitioner argues further that in the past STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate behavior on buses and on other means of transportation. STUDENT’s mother testified that in the past STUDENT would take things from other children on the bus and throw things out of the window. Dr. Daniels also testified that she thinks STUDENT feels he can “take over” a bus and that he enjoys the power. However, STUDENT’s mother also testified that STUDENT has not ridden a bus or transportation other than a limousine to and from school since 1996. The Petitioner argues that behavior on a field trip bus in not comparable to what STUDENT might do if transported by bus or van to school because STUDENT wants to go on the field trip but does not want to go to school.

In addition, the Petitioner contends that it is inappropriate to “teach” STUDENT how to ride public transportation and therefore riding in a bus or van to school is not an appropriate goal for him. At one point, Dr. Daniels was supportive of STUDENT’s becoming more independent and learning skills regarding transportation. However, Dr. Daniels testified that she no longer thinks that STUDENT should learn to ride public transportation and that independence for STUDENT was not an appropriate goal. She testified that STUDENT is a “sexual predator” and that was the reason she had changed her mind regarding STUDENT’s future transportation goals(Footnote 11) .

However, Mr. Martin testified that the majority of his students do not like attending school and STUDENT is not unique in that regard. Testimony provided at hearing also shows that while STUDENT has exhibited behaviors in the past that were inappropriate for a bus or other modes of transportation, those behaviors occurred infrequently. In addition, the majority of the instances of inappropriate behavior regarding transportation that STUDENT’s mother and Dr. Daniels referred to occurred during or prior to 1999. Ms. Estrada testified that independent living is a goal for all special education students and that even assuming arguendo that it is not an appropriate goal for STUDENT to travel alone on a public transportation, at this point that would not preclude STUDENT benefiting from gaining skills regarding transportation. Additionally, none of the District witnesses reported any behavior by STUDENT that they considered to reflect his being a “sexual predator.” Mr. Martin testified that he has not witnessed STUDENT behave in a sexually inappropriate manner with other children or with adults at Buena Park.

The Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT may have exhibited inappropriate behavior in the past, it appears that incidents of inappropriate behavior during transportation were infrequent. In addition, there was credible testimony provided by Mr. Martin, STUDENT’s current teacher, that STUDENT has not exhibited any inappropriate sexual behavior in the classroom or on the bus during field trips. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behavior does not prevent him from riding on a school bus or a District owned van, nor require that he continue to be transported by limousine.

In sum, although there are still concerns over STUDENT’s behavior, those concerns would not prevent STUDENT from riding another mode of transportation other than a limousine. While the limousine service may be an ideal arrangement for STUDENT’s family, the District is not required to provide STUDENT with most convenient form of transportation, but appropriate transportation to address STUDENT’s needs(Footnote 12) . The District has shown that STUDENT’s behavior has improved and that he has successfully managed other changes in his program as well as riding buses to field trips without incident. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that based on the evidence presented, STUDENT does not require transportation by limousine at this time to benefit from his education.

ORDER

1. The District shall convene an IEP team meeting within 20 days from the date of this decision to determine the mode of transportation that will be provided to STUDENT, either by a District-owned van or a small bus provided by STUDENT’s NPS placement; determine the need for a bus assistant for STUDENT; and address whether or not STUDENT requires a transition plan to meet his needs regarding transportation.

2. Petitioner’s request for relief is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).

Date: May 16, 2003 _____________________________ Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This issue is a restatement of the issue Petitioner presented for hearing, based upon the discussion of the issues held at the beginning of the hearing.

2 At the June 13, 2002 IEP team meeting, the District offered transportation by bus from Buena Park with a bus assistant. The District proposed three resolutions to the issue of transportation at hearing, a small bus operated by Buena Park, a small District-operated van, or mileage reimbursement. 3 At some point after STUDENT’s father and his first wife divorced, STUDENT was placed in the sole custody of STUDENT’s father. STUDENT’s father later married STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT’s mother has been involved in STUDENT’s education since that time. After STUDENT’s father died in 1998, STUDENT’s mother became STUDENT’s guardian and began making educational decisions on his behalf. 4. Testimony at hearing was vague regarding why STUDENT was first transported via limousine, but the parties recalled that there was an issue about a private bus service that allegedly refused to transport STUDENT. 5. The parties have met in mediation and the testimony indicates that there was apparently a miscommunication regarding the resolution of the transportation issue. The District purchased two passenger vans and began sending the van to pick up STUDENT in December. STUDENT did not ride in the van and continued to use the limousine service. 6. The issue presented for hearing in this matter was solely that of the appropriate mode of transportation for STUDENT; therefore, this Decision will not address any other aspects of STUDENT’s program or needs except as those needs may relate to determining the appropriateness of the District’s offer of transportation. 7. Dr. Deanna Daniels testified that she has treated STUDENT since approximately 1993 and that his behavior and academic progress has improved dramatically during that time. 8. STUDENT’s mother testified at length regarding STUDENT’s past education and mental health experiences. In particular STUDENT’s mother indicated that STUDENT was hospitalized several times in the past five years and that he has, at times, been placed in residential care and has been the responsibility of other school districts during that time. 9. There was a substantial amount of testimony at hearing regarding STUDENT’s particular drivers to and from school. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s mother’s current husband, drives STUDENT in the limousine most frequently. In addition, there was testimony regarding whether or not STUDENT’s family had a financial interest in the limousine service continuing. The Hearing Officer found this testimony irrelevant in addressing the issue for hearing. 10. Mr. Martin testified that he has been STUDENT’s teacher since he enrolled at Buena Park in 2000. 11. Dr. Daniels testified regarding the following as an example of behavior that concerned her; during the last calendar year there was a female aide in STUDENT’s class that he described as smaller than he was and a “hottie.” Dr. Daniels testified that there was an increase in what she termed “pre-fire alarm” behavior. She indicated the STUDENT’s mother reported an increase in inappropriate masturbation. However testimony of Mr. Martin was that he had not witnessed any incidents of masturbation at school.

12. As the Supreme Court found in Rowley v. Board of Education, 458 U.S. 176 (1982) school districts are not required to maximize potential or provide the “best” education or services for students with disabilities but rather, they must provide an appropriate education. Students with disabilities are not entitled to the “Cadillac” of educational programs but must be provided with what amounts to a “Chevy.” Doe v. Board of Education of Tullahoma City Schools, 9 F.3d 455 (1993). The District is not required to provide the “Cadillac” of transportation service for STUDENT, or in this case a limousine.