California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 26, 2002
Student v. Tustin Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1730-02 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Tustin Unified properly exited student from special education in April 2002 but must make up missed occupational therapy sessions.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a ten-year-old Tustin Unified student filed for due process after the District exited him from special education. The District then filed its own case, and the two cases were consolidated. The student had been eligible under speech or language impairment. His triennial IEP meeting began on November 8, 2001. The team did not decide eligibility or write new goals until April 18, 2002, when it finished the meeting without the parents and found him ineligible. The parents argued he had a specific learning disability. They relied on an independent assessment by Dr. Chris Davidson that put his IQ about 30 points higher than earlier testing. The Hearing Officer found the District psychologist's results (full scale IQ of 98) valid and Dr. Davidson not credible, so no severe discrepancy existed. The student stayed eligible until the April 18 IEP decision and was not eligible after that. The District denied FAPE from November 2001 to April 2002 because his IEP had no current goals and objectives. However, he kept receiving resource services and made academic progress, so 240 hours of educational therapy were denied. The Hearing Officer also denied reimbursement for a summer Fast ForWord program, compensatory vision therapy, and three independent assessments. The District conceded he had missed occupational therapy sessions. Under stay put, it was ordered to provide one make-up session for each session missed from November 8, 2001 through the decision date.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a stalled triennial review. The student stayed eligible until the IEP team actually decided eligibility. The lack of current goals during that time was a denial of FAPE. Still, compensatory education depended on evidence of lost educational opportunity, and stay put required services to continue throughout the hearing.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partEligibility
Issue 1. Has Student been eligible for special education from November 8, 2001, to the present?
Student stayed eligible until the IEP team made its eligibility decision on April 18, 2002. After that date he did not meet the criteria for specific learning disability because the District's IQ score of 98 was valid and showed no severe discrepancy.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE from November 8, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including ESY 2002?
The District denied FAPE from November 2001 through April 2002 because it did not write goals and objectives while eligibility was pending. There was no denial of FAPE after April 18, 2002, because Student was no longer eligible.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Fast ForWord program that they procured during the summer of 2002?
Reimbursement was denied because the program targeted auditory processing, and there was no persuasive evidence that Student had a unique need in that area.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 4. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?
The District must provide make-up OT for every missed session through the decision date under its stay put obligation. The 240 hours of educational therapy were denied because Student kept progressing, and vision therapy was denied because no need was shown for 2001-2002.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments performed by Dr. Davidson, Laurie Cohen and Dr. Ryan?
The District's psychoeducational and OT assessments were appropriate, and vision was not an area of suspected disability, so reimbursement for all three independent assessments was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. Within five days of the order, the District must begin providing one occupational therapy session for each session Student missed from November 8, 2001 through the date of the decision. The District may use its own therapist or contract with an outside therapist. The sessions must not interfere with Student's regular education program.
Key authorities
Rowley; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j)
People named in the decision
- Carol Arnesen, Director of special education, Tustin Unified School District
- Corinne W. Stotereau, Clinical psychologist; conducted triennial psychoeducational assessment, Tustin Unified School District
- Cathy Anderson, Resource specialist teacher, Tustin Unified School District
- Laura Johnston, Regular education fourth-grade teacher, Tustin Unified School District
- Margo Stone, School nurse; administered Quick Neurological Screening Test, Tustin Unified School District
- Teresa Kuhns, Occupational therapist; conducted triennial OT assessment, Tustin Unified School District
- Kathleen MacInnes, Speech-language evaluator, Tustin Unified School District
- Lori Stillings, Program specialist, Tustin Unified School District
- Chris Davidson, Ph.D., Independent psychoeducational assessor; expert witness for Student, Private; former District employee
- Jack Schnel, Ph.D., Expert witness, Not stated
- Laurie Cohen, Private occupational therapist; independent OT assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Julie Ryan, O.D., Private vision therapy assessor, Private
- Lindsay Lamm, Fast ForWord program provider, Tustin Speech and Language Center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Tustin, California, on September 17, 18, 23, 24, 25, and October 8, 2002.
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Graham. Also present on STUDENT¡¦s behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. The Tustin Unified School District (District or Tustin) was represented by attorney Jeffrey J. Riel of the law firm Parker & Covert. Also present on behalf of the District was Carol Arnesen, the director of special education for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on October 24, 2002, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Has STUDENT been eligible for special education from November 8, 2001, to the present?
2. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE), from November 8, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY) of 2002?
3. Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Fast ForWord program that they procured during the summer of 2002?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
5. Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments performed by Dr. Davidson, Laurie Cohen and Dr. Ryan?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the outset of the hearing, the District requested that the Hearing Officer exercise his power pursuant to California Education Code section 56505.1(e), and order that an impartial psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT be conducted for purposes of the hearing, and that he continue the hearing until the assessment was completed. In the alternative, the District requested that it be allowed to fund an independent assessment, but in any event, that the Hearing be continued until the assessment was completed.
The District argued that such an assessment was necessary because, one week before the hearing, the District first received a copy of an independent psychoeducational assessment conducted by Chris Davidson, Ph.D. Dr. Davidson¡¦s assessment concluded, in pertinent part, that STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability was more than 30 points higher that previous assessments. The Student opposed the District¡¦s request.
The Hearing Officer denied the District¡¦s request because the Student had presented ripe, appropriate issues for hearing, including whether STUDENT remains eligible for special education, and because STUDENT was entitled to resolution of these issues without undue delay. Moreover, the Hearing Officer did not find that the reason for the District¡¦s request, that it lacked a contemporaneous cognitive assessment to rebut Dr. Davidson¡¦s, to be persuasive. The Hearing Officer notes that the District had assessments that it had relied upon to make its decision that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education, and no additional assessments were warranted.
On the fifth day of hearing, after the Student¡¦s expert, Dr. Davidson, had completed her testimony, the Student requested a hearing officer-ordered impartial assessment because he felt that Dr. Davidson appeared biased in favor of the Student and against the District, and that this had ¡§greatly prejudiced¡¨ his case. The Student stated that he did not know about Dr. Davidson¡¦s employment problems while she worked at the District (the source of her apparent bias) when she was hired to assess STUDENT and provide her opinion. The Student did know, however, that she had worked for the District. He proposed that the hearing be continued until after the post-assessment IEP team meeting.(Footnote 2) The District opposed the request.
The Hearing Officer denied the Student¡¦s request for an impartial assessment. He found the Student¡¦s reason, Dr. Davidson¡¦s apparent bias, insufficient to delay the completion of the hearing. Moreover, the request was untimely because it was made on the second to last day of hearing. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer notes that the Student had waived any claim of bias because he knew what Dr. Davidson was going to say before she testified, even if he did not know before he hired her.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old student who lives within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Tustin Unified School District. Before November 8, 2001, STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as a student with speech and language impairment, although in the past, he has also been found eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability (SLD).
STUDENT¡¦s triennial assessment was conducted during October and November of 2001 by the District.(Footnote 3) His triennial assessment included a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment, an occupational therapy assessment, a speech and language evaluation, and a health and development evaluation.
Corinne W. Stotereau, a clinical psychologist, completed STUDENT¡¦s comprehensive psychoeducational assessment on November 1, 2001. She used a variety of assessment tools over a number of days, measuring cognitive functioning, academic functioning, information processing, psycho-motor development and social/adaptive functioning. (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
In the area of cognitive functioning, Dr. Stotereau administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence - Third Edition (TONI-3) and the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC). The TONI-3 is a norm-referenced intelligence test with an administration and response format that eliminates language and reduces motoric and cultural factors. It focuses on a single intelligent behavior, namely a person¡¦s ability to solve novel, abstract problems. On the TONI-3, STUDENT scored in the average range; he received a quotient score of 98, representing a percentile rank of 45 and an age equivalent of 9 years and 3 months. In contrast to the TONI-3 which measures a single intelligent behavior, the WISC-III conceptualizes intelligence as being made up of many different abilities, including perceptual skills, memory, abstract reasoning, and other abilities. The WISC-III provides three IQ scores; verbal, performance and full scale. STUDENT received the following scores:
WISC-III Standard Score Verbal IQ 100 Performance IQ 96 Full Scale IQ 98 (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
To measure STUDENT¡¦s academic functioning, Ms. Stotereau administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), and STUDENT¡¦s resource specialist teacher, Cathy Anderson, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Test Battery ¡V Third Edition (WJ-3) . STUDENT received the following scores on the WIAT:
Standard Score Age Equivalent Reading Composite 101 9.9 Basic Reading 103 10.0 Reading Comprehension 100 9.6 Mathematics Composite 105 10.3 Mathematic Reasoning 111 11.0 Numerical Operations 99 9.6 Writing Composite 94 8.6 Spelling 95 9.0 Written Expression 97 8.9 (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
On the WJ-3, STUDENT received the following scores:
Standard Score Age Equivalent Broad Reading 98 9.5 Letter-Word Identification 98 9.3 Passage Comprehension 96 8.9 Reading Fluency 102 10.0 Broad Mathematics 106 10.3 Calculation 100 9.7 Applied Problems 118 11.11 Math Fluency 85 8.4 Broad Written Language 101 9.9 Spelling 99 9.6 Writing Samples 107 11.3 Writing Fluency 100 9.8 (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
In the area of information processing, Ms. Stotereau administered the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML). The WRAML is an assessment tool that evaluates a child¡¦s ability to actively learn and memorize a variety of information; it is not considered a test of intelligence, although memory is one component of intelligent behavior. On the WRAML, STUDENT received a verbal memory index score of 83, a visual memory index score of 95, and a learning index score of 120, and an overall memory index score of 99. According to the report, STUDENT¡¦s scores on the WRAML indicate relative difficulties in his ability to process information auditorially, average ability to process visual information (without a significant motoric component), and a superior ability to learn new material over a process of consecutive trials. (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
In the area of psycho-motor development, Ms. Stotereau administered the Beery Visual-Motor Integration Test (VMI) and the Bender-Gestalt Test. Also, Nurse Margo Stone administered the Quick Neurological Screening Test (QNST). On the VMI, STUDENT received a standard score of 91, an age equivalency of 8.1; however, Ms. Stotereau noted significant distortions on several of the reproductions. On the Bender-Gestalt, a screening device designed to detect the presence of brain damage, STUDENT¡¦s score of 4 placed him at a perceptual age of 8.0 to 8.5, approximately one year below his chronological age, suggesting ¡§a relative weakness in his visual motor integration skills.¡¨ On the QNST, designed to assess possible neurological ¡§soft signs,¡¨ STUDENT earned an overall score of 63, indicating a severe discrepancy within the subtests. However, Ms. Stone reported that STUDENT was ¡§very distractible . . . impulsive . . . did not wait for directions and appeared tired (by yawning frequently).¡¨ (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
In the area of social/adaptive functioning, Ms. Stotereau administered the Piers Harris Children¡¦s Self Concept Scale (Piers Harris), Conner¡¦s Rating Scales (Conner¡¦s), and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (Vineland). On the Piers Harris, a test where the student is asked to self-evaluate attitudes and behaviors which have a bearing on self concept, STUDENT¡¦s reported scores reflected a healthy self concept with high-average perceptions in all domains. (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
The Conner¡¦s Rating Scales were administered to Mrs. MOTHER and STUDENT¡¦s regular education fourth grade teacher, Ms. Johnston. The Conner¡¦s scales identify particular behaviors or patterns of behavior which may be affecting classroom performance. MOTHER¡¦s scores were within the average range, but Ms. Johnston reported borderline significant scores in ¡§hyperactivity,¡¨ ¡§Conner¡¦s Global Index: Restless-Impulsive¡¨ (indicating restlessness, hyperactivity, and inattentiveness), and ¡§DSM-IV: Hyperactive-Impulsive,¡¨ (indicating an above average correspondence with the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for Hyperactive-Impulsive Type ADHD). (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
The Vineland is designed to measure adaptive behavior, which is defined as performance of the day-to-day activities necessary to take care of one¡¦s self and to get along with others. STUDENT¡¦s scores on the Vineland placed him in the average range across all of the adaptive domains. (District¡¦s Exh. 33).
Teresa Kuhns completed an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT on November 1, 2001. Ms. Kuhns administered the Bruininks-Oserestsky of Motor Proficiency (BOMP) and the Evaluation Tool of Children¡¦s Handwriting-Cursive (ETCH-C). She also interviewed STUDENT¡¦s teachers, and observed STUDENT to assess his occupational therapy needs. She determined that STUDENT had significant delays in the areas of visual motor, manual dexterity, bilateral coordination, and motor planning skills. Ms. Kuhns found that these deficits were negatively impacting STUDENT¡¦s ability to develop age appropriate skills that are essential for adequate performance in the school setting such as handwriting and typing. She also found that STUDENT appeared to lack many of the sensorimotor foundations necessary for development of handwriting and typing skills. In her report, Ms. Kuhns determined that STUDENT would benefit from occupational therapy services in the educational setting, and she drafted therapy goals. (District¡¦s Exh. 27).
Kathleen MacInnes completed a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT on November 8, 2001. Ms. MacInnes administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, Third Edition (CELF-3) and the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation. She concluded that STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate language skills in the areas of semantics, syntax, morphology, and pragmatics. In the area of articulation, Ms. MacInnes noted ¡§a few errors¡¨ in the use of ¡§back vowel, dipthongs and the vocalic r,¡¨ and she noted that he had generalized most all the vowels and vocalic r productions into conversational speech. She concluded that the IEP team should determine whether STUDENT¡¦s few articulation errors adversely impacted his education. (District¡¦s Exh. 30).
ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ ÈÍ
STUDENT¡¦s IEP team meeting convened to discuss his triennial assessment on November 8, 2001. The IEP team reviewed Ms. Stotereau¡¦s psychoeducational assessment and the occupational therapy assessment. The IEP team was unable to complete STUDENT¡¦s triennial review, and all team members agreed to reconvene on December 6, 2001. The IEP team did not make a determination regarding STUDENT¡¦s continuing eligibility, nor did it update or draft new goals and objectives. The November 8, 2001 IEP indicates that STUDENT was to spend ¡§0%¡¨ of his total educational day in special education, although STUDENT continued to receive the same resource specialist services and related services that he received prior to the IEP meeting through the end of the school year.(Footnote 4) (District¡¦s Exh. 32.)
The IEP team meeting continued on December 6, 2001. Again, the IEP team did not conclude the meeting or determine if STUDENT was still eligible for special education. The team failed to draft goals and objectives, although STUDENT¡¦s teachers reported progress towards his previous goals and objectives (some were still not met) and updated his present levels of performance. All members of the team agreed to meet again to complete STUDENT¡¦s IEP team meeting on January 17, 2002. (District¡¦s Exh. 34.)
On January 7, 2002, the District received a letter from the PARENTS in which they requested that the District pay for ¡§outside Independent Speech Evaluation and Central Auditory Processing Disorder evaluation at public expense¡¨ and a ¡§more though [sic] complete evaluation in OT.¡¨ Lori Stillings, a District program specialist, testified that she did not immediately respond (either by agreeing to or denying the parents¡¦ requests) because she felt the matter should be discussed at the upcoming January 17, 2002 IEP team meeting. The PARENTS canceled the IEP team meeting. (District¡¦s Exh. 35 and Testimony of Stillings). The District then generated a new IEP team meeting notice scheduling the continued triennial IEP team meeting for January 31, 2002, and forwarded it to the PARENTS on January 17, 2002. The PARENTS signed the notice, indicated that they wanted to reschedule the meeting, and returned it to the District on January 25, 2002. FATHER wrote the following on the returned notice:
The District is late in responding to additional requested testing. No IEP meeting can take place until the issue of requested testing is resolved.
(District¡¦s Exh. 36).
On January 31, 2002, Ms. Stillings, in consultation with Carol Arnesen, the District¡¦s director of special education, responded to the PARENTS¡¦ letter requesting ¡§outside¡¨ assessments. The District agreed to conduct an assessment in the area of ¡§central auditory processing¡¨ because an assessment from August 1999 had indicated ¡§delayed development of CAP skills¡¨ and had recommended testing at a later date. The District denied the request for an occupational therapy assessment. The letter concludes by requesting the PARENTS to sign and return the assessment plan so that the District could ¡§expedite¡¨ the testing in order to complete the triennial assessment and determine whether STUDENT continued to be eligible. Attached to the letter was an assessment plan, which indicates that STUDENT would be assessed in the area of ¡§auditory processing.¡¨ (District¡¦s Exh. 37).
The PARENTS responded in a letter dated February 4, 2002, in which they request that Ms. Stillings ¡§remove [herself] from the IEP team¡¨ if she is ¡§incapable of communicating in a truthful and responsive manner.¡¨ (District¡¦s Exh. 39). The PARENTS never signed and returned the assessment plan to the District.
Thereafter, the District sent the PARENTS multiple IEP team meeting notices in an attempt to finish the triennial assessment; each time the PARENTS responded by generally requesting that the meeting be rescheduled until the assessments were completed. (District¡¦s Exhs. 36, 41 and 42).
On April 18, 2002, the District completed STUDENT¡¦s IEP team meeting without the parents. STUDENT was determined to be ineligible for special education and related services and the District recommended that STUDENT be exited from special education. The IEP team drafted a transition plan which continued STUDENT¡¦s special education services through the end of the 2001-2002 school year. The IEP document was forwarded to the parents on April 26, 2002, by Lori Stillings. (District¡¦s Exh. 43 and 44).
On May 13, 2002, the PARENTS sent a letter to the District indicating that they had now reviewed the assessments completed by the District and determined that they were ¡§incomplete, incorrect, and [that they] inaccurately reflect STUDENT¡¦s achievement and ability.¡¨ The letter concludes that they will be obtaining ¡§independent educational evaluations, at public expense¡¨ in the areas of academic achievement, cognitive development, perceptual motor development, occupational therapy, speech and language, social emotional, as well as a ¡§functional assessment.¡¨
The Student requested a due process hearing on May 28, 2002. STUDENT continued to receive the same resource specialist services through the end of the 2001-2002 school year, as well as the current (2002-2003) school year. The District requested its own due process hearing on July 25, 2002, naming the Student. The matters were subsequently consolidated.
During the summer, the PARENTS placed STUDENT in the Fast ForWord program, where he received instruction designed to address auditory processing issues. Also during the summer, the PARENTS obtained a vision therapy assessment from Julie Ryan, O.D., and a occupational therapy assessment from Laurie Cohen.
In August and September 2002, the PARENTS obtained an independent psychoeducational assessment from Chris Davidson, Ph.D. Dr. Davidson administered two tests of cognitive functioning, the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence, Third Edition (TONI-3), and the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI); she did not use any other standardized measure of intelligence, other than a screening tool. Dr. Davidson found STUDENT¡¦s intelligence to be in the superior range. She obtained scores about 30 points higher than previous measures of STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability. Dr. Davidson also assessed STUDENT¡¦s achievement; the scores she obtained fell generally within the average range in the areas of reading, mathematics and writing skills.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education from November 2001 to the present?
The primary dispute between the parties is whether STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services after November 8, 2001 (the first day of STUDENT¡¦s IEP team meeting held to discuss STUDENT¡¦s triennial review). It was not disputed that STUDENT was eligible for special education prior to November 8, 2001; indeed, it was not disputed that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE prior to this date. It is similarly undisputed that the IEP team did not formally exit STUDENT from special education until April 18, 2002, five months after it began the IEP team meeting to discuss STUDENT¡¦s triennial review.(Footnote 5) For purposes of analysis, the Hearing Officer will determine (1) whether STUDENT remained eligible for special education from November 8, 2001 through April 18, 2002, when the District exited STUDENT from special education, and (2) whether STUDENT was eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability after the April 18, 2002 IEP team meeting.
Did STUDENT remain eligible from November 2001 through April 2002?
The District contends that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education beginning November 8, 2001, because the results of the triennial assessment would have revealed that STUDENT did not qualify for special education as of that date, had the IEP team made a timely eligibility determination. The District¡¦s argument is not persuasive. The IEP team had the responsibility to determine whether STUDENT remained eligible for special education; until it made that decision, STUDENT remained eligible. Cal. Educ. Code ¡±56342. Because the IEP team failed to make the eligibility determination until April 18, 2002, STUDENT remained eligible for special education until at least that date.
Was STUDENT eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability after April 18, 2002?
California special education law states that individuals with exceptional needs are students who have a disability pursuant to the definitions in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 1401 of Title 20 of the United States Code, and who require instruction and/or services that cannot be provided with modification to the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code ¡± 56026(a) and (b)). Disabilities identified in federal special education law include mental retardation, hearing, speech, language, visual, orthopedic, and health impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, and specific learning disabilities.
The parties dispute whether STUDENT has a specific learning disability (SLD)(Footnote 6). California Education Code ¡± 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression; (2) Listening comprehension; (3) Written expression; (4) Basic reading skills; (5) Reading comprehension; (6) Mathematics calculation; (7) Mathematics reasoning. (b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(B)), or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists (5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(C)). When standardized tests are considered valid, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:
[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests.
5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(A).
The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), plus or minus 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. This computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when ¡§such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate.¡¨ Id.
As discussed above, Dr. Stotereau found that STUDENT¡¦s full scale IQ on the WISC-III, a comprehensive intelligence test, to be 98. On the TONI-3, a narrower measure of nonverbal and non-motoric intelligence, she also obtained a score of 98. Dr. Stotereau testified that her results were valid, and that they represented a fair and accurate measure of STUDENT¡¦s intelligence. Dr. Stotereau, the Student¡¦s expert witness, Dr. Davidson, and a third expert witness, Dr. Jack Schnel, agreed that if Dr. Stotereau¡¦s score of 98 is used in the formula above, STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in any academic area and would not have an SLD.
Dr. Davidson found STUDENT to have a significantly higher cognitive ability score (approximately 133, according to her testimony), placing STUDENT¡¦s intelligence level in the superior range. Based upon her cognitive ability measure, STUDENT would have a significant discrepancy in all academic areas. (Testimony of Davidson).
The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Stotereau¡¦s estimate of STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability, 98 or in the average range, to be the appropriate and correct measure as compared to Dr. Davidson¡¦s unsupported measure of 133, the superior range. First, Dr. Davidson¡¦s testimony was internally inconsistent. She testified generally that STUDENT¡¦s full scale IQ score obtained on the WISC-III (from the District¡¦s testing) was depressed because, in pertinent part, STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. However, she later testified that STUDENT¡¦s auditory processing scores were in the average range.(Footnote 7) Second, Dr. Davidson primarily relied on one type of measurement, nonverbal tests of intelligence, to measure STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability. In contrast, Dr. Stotereau utilized both a nonverbal test of intelligence (the TONI-3) and the more comprehensive WISC-III. Third, Dr. Davidson¡¦s testimony was generally not credible. In addition to her conflicting testimony, Dr. Davidson testified at length about problems she had with District employees before she left the District in 2001.(Footnote 8) She expressed through Student¡¦s attorney before the second day of her testimony that she felt ¡§emotionally raped¡¨ by the District and was therefore reluctant to testify. Her apparent bias against the District prompted the Student to request an impartial assessment immediately after her testimony was completed. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability during the period at issue to be 98, as measured by Dr. Stotereau. Therefore, STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in any area based on valid standardized tests, and is not eligible for special education because of an SLD. (Testimony of Davidson, Schnel and Stotereau).
Having found that STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy based on valid standardized assessments, the next question is whether STUDENT has a severe discrepancy based upon alternative means. Because it has been found that the standardized tests administered by Dr. Stotereau were in fact valid, STUDENT does not meet this criteria. (5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(B)). Finally, because the IEP team determined that a severe discrepancy does not exist between ability and achievement, STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy by decision of the IEP team, and does not meet this criteria. (5 C.C.R. ¡± 3030(j)(4)(C)).
In sum, it has been found above that STUDENT remained eligible for special education and related services from November 8, 2001 through April 18, 2002. Thereafter, STUDENT did not qualify for special education and related services as a child with a specific learning disability.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE), from November 8, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY) of 2002?
It has been determined above that STUDENT remained eligible for special education and related services from November 8, 2001 to April 18, 2002, and that he was not eligible after April 18, 2002. Because STUDENT was not eligible after April 18, 2002, he was not denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). The remaining question is whether he was denied a FAPE from November 2001 through April 2002. Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1400; Cal. Educ. Code ¡± 56000. The term FAPE means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student¡¦s IEP. 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1401(a)(18). Pursuant to the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in the matter Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, an appropriate educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student's unique needs, (2) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (3) conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
Students argues, in pertinent part, that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during this period because the District failed to update STUDENT¡¦s goals and objectives at the November 8, 2001 IEP team meeting, or any of the subsequent IEP team meetings. As a result, STUDENT¡¦s special education team had no guidance regarding STUDENT¡¦s progress, or lack thereof, during this period. Therefore, argues the Student, his program was not designed to meet his unique needs, nor could it comport with his IEP, because an essential element, goals and objectives, were missing. It was not disputed that the District failed to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT during the entire period at issue; his previous goals and objectives in the areas of reading, math, written language, spelling, articulation, occupational therapy and speech and language, all expired on November 8, 2001. (District¡¦s Exh. 21).
The District argues that its failure should be excused. The District argues that because the eligibility determination comes first, and because that decision had not yet been made at the November and December 2001 IEP team meetings, the team did not need to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District¡¦s failure to draft goals and objectives while the eligibility determination was pending constituted a denial of FAPE.(Footnote 9) An IEP must contain goals and objectives; there are no exceptions. Cal. Educ. Code ¡±56345(a)(2). Appropriate long term goals and measurable short-term objectives are a necessary and essential part of a students¡¦ FAPE because they provide a mechanism for a child¡¦s teachers and parents to monitor the child¡¦s progress in special education over the course of the school year. 34 C.F.R. ¡± 300, Appendix A to Part 300 of the Federal Regulations. Because the District failed to develop goals and objectives, STUDENT¡¦s program did not meet his unique needs and did not comport with his IEP. The District denied STUDENT a FAPE from November 2001 through April 2002. 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
Issue No. 3: Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Fast ForWord program that they procured during the summer of 2002?
STUDENT¡¦s parents seek reimbursement for the Fast ForWord program that they provided for STUDENT during the summer of 2002. When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is ¡§appropriate¡¨ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.
It has been found above that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from November 2001 to April 2002 because it failed to draft goals and objectives for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer must now determine whether the Fast ForWord program provided by STUDENT¡¦s parents was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student¡¦s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents¡¦ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district¡¦s must meet, the parents¡¦ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student¡¦s needs and that provides the student educational benefit. Id.
The Fast ForWord program is designed to address deficits in auditory processing skills, according to the individual that administered the program, Lindsay Lamm, from the Tustin Speech and Language Center. The question is then whether STUDENT had a unique need in the area of auditory processing during the 2001-2002 school year.
There was no persuasive testimony that STUDENT had a unique need in the area of auditory processing skills during the period in which the District denied him a FAPE, November 2001 to April 2002. STUDENT received no similar services prior to the November 2001 IEP team meeting; it is not disputed that STUDENT received a FAPE before that date. Moreover, as previously discussed, the Student¡¦s own expert, Dr. Davidson, conceded that STUDENT¡¦s auditory processing was assessed to be in the average range. (Testimony of Davidson). Again, the District witnesses familiar with STUDENT all generally testified that STUDENT does not have an auditory processing disorder. (Testimony of Stotereau, Johnston and Anderson). Because the services procured by the PARENTS failed to address an area of unique need, their reimbursement claim is denied.
Issue No. 4: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is ¡§appropriate¡¨ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. ¡± 1415(i). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to ¡§ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.¡¨ Id.
The Student seeks compensatory education for the District¡¦s denial of FAPE from November 8, 2001, through April 18, 2002. The Student seeks (1) 240 hours of ¡§educational therapy¡¨ from a nonpublic agency (NPA); (2) occupational therapy; and (3) vision therapy.
Educational Therapy
The Student argues generally that because the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the period from November 2001 through April 2002, that the District should provide STUDENT with 240 hours of compensatory education in the form of ¡§educational therapy¡¨ to address the areas of reading, writing and mathematics.(Footnote 10)
While it has been found above that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from November 2001 through April 2002 because the IEP team failed to draft goals and objectives, the parties failed to provide persuasive evidence that STUDENT lost educational opportunity during this period. The District presented convincing evidence that STUDENT continued to progress in all academic need areas, despite the fact that the IEP team failed to draft goals and objectives. First, it was not disputed that STUDENT continued to receive the resource specialist services that he received prior to November 8, 2001, including RSP pull-out services, four times per week for 30 minutes, RSP collaboration five times per week for 30 minutes, and speech and language services.(Footnote 11) Second, although STUDENT had no effective goals and objectives, his resource teacher, Cathy Anderson, appropriately modified and implemented STUDENT¡¦s previous goals and objectives by adjusting them to meet the fourth-grade curriculum standards. For example, STUDENT¡¦s previous paragraph writing goal was:
STUDENT will be able to write one paragraph containing 5-7 sentences, each containing at least 5 words, describing a given topic, using correct sentence structure, grammar, word usage and spelling, (with assistance) with 90% accuracy on each component, as measured by performance based assessment.
(District¡¦s Exh. 21).
Ms. Anderson explained that she continued to work on the above goal because STUDENT had not yet met it by December 2001, and that later, she expanded it to multiple paragraph assignments, a skill that is first developed in the fourth grade. Ms. Anderson did the same for STUDENT¡¦s other academic goals and corresponding objectives in his other areas of need. (Testimony of Anderson).
Third, STUDENT¡¦s teachers testified persuasively that he continued to progress in all academic need areas during the period in question. Ms. Johnston, his regular education teacher, testified that STUDENT experienced difficulty organizing his thoughts on writing assignments towards the beginning of the school year. By the end of the year, STUDENT had improved (although STUDENT¡¦s writing skills remained a relative weakness). (Testimony of Johnston). Cathy Anderson similarly testified that STUDENT progressed in all academic areas during the school year.
Again, there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT lost educational opportunity during the period from November 2001 through April 2002. Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education as requested.
Occupational Therapy
It is undisputed that during a significant portion of the period from November 2001 through April 2002, STUDENT did not receive occupational therapy services pursuant to his pre-November 2001 IEP. The District does not dispute that it denied STUDENT a FAPE in that regard, nor that it is required to provide STUDENT with compensatory education in the form of make-up occupational therapy sessions. It was also not disputed that STUDENT has continued to have a need for occupational therapy, although he is not eligible for special education. Accordingly, the District shall provide STUDENT with compensatory education in the form of one make-up session for every session lost, up through the date of this Decision.(Footnote 12)
Vision Therapy
STUDENT also requests one school year of vision therapy, two times each week for sixty minutes. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had a unique need for vision therapy during the period from November 8, 2001 through April 18, 2002, and this request is therefore denied. Dr. Ryan, who conducted the vision assessment of STUDENT in August 2002, testified generally that, although she recommended vision therapy for the current (2002-2003) school year, she could not state that STUDENT required such services to benefit from his education during the 2001-2002 school year. As such, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory vision therapy.
Issue No. 5: Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments performed by Dr. Davidson, Laurie Cohen and Dr. Ryan?
A parent may obtain an independent assessment performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show that its evaluation was appropriate at a due process hearing. 34 C.F.R. ¡± 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code ¡± 56329(b). In the present matter, the Student seeks reimbursement for three independent educational evaluations, conducted by Dr. Davidson, Laurie Cohen and Dr. Ryan, during the summer of 2002. Each will be addressed below.
Dr. Davidson¡¦ psychoeducational assessment
As discussed above, the PARENTS may be entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Davidson¡¦s assessment unless the District shows that its assessment, conducted by Dr. Stotereau in October and November of 2001, was appropriate.(Footnote 13) Student contends that Dr. Stotereau¡¦s assessment was inappropriate because it failed to account for STUDENT¡¦s disability. Specifically, STUDENT contends that the District should have used a nonverbal, nonmotoric assessment of cognitive ability. However, as discussed above, Dr. Stotereau assessed STUDENT¡¦s cognitive ability using both a comprehensive intelligence test (the WISC-III), and a nonverbal, nonmotoric assessment (the TONI-3). It was not seriously disputed that Dr. Stotereau¡¦s comprehensive psychoeducational assessment was otherwise appropriate. Therefore, the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Davidson¡¦s assessment.
Laurie Cohen¡¦s occupational therapy assessment
Although Student requested reimbursement for this assessment, there was no dispute that the occupational assessment conducted by Teresa Kuhn was appropriate. The Student¡¦s own expert witness in the area of occupational therapy, Laurie Cohen, testified that the Ms. Kuhns¡¦ occupational therapy assessment was appropriate. Rather, Ms. Cohen disagreed with some recommendations allegedly made by Ms. Kuhns at a subsequent IEP team meeting. Because Ms. Kuhns¡¦ assessment was appropriate, the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Cohen¡¦s assessment.
Dr. Ryan¡¦s vision assessment
The Student failed to provide any evidence that he obtained Ms. Ryan¡¦s assessment because the PARENTS disagreed with the District¡¦s triennial assessment. The PARENTS never requested or indicated in writing to the District their intention to procure a vision assessment. Moreover, there was no persuasive testimony by any member of STUDENT¡¦s IEP team, including his parents, that STUDENT¡¦s vision was an area of concern or suspected disability in October and November 2001. California Education Code ¡± 56320(f) requires that a student be assessed in all areas of ¡§suspected disability.¡¨ Because the assessment team had no reason to suspect that vision was area of potential need, the District was not required to assess STUDENT¡¦s vison needs. The Student is not therefore entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Ryan¡¦s assessment.
ORDER
1. Within five days of the date of this order, the District shall begin to provide STUDENT with one occupational therapy session for each session he has missed since November 8, 2001, through the date of this Decision. The District may use its own occupational therapist, or it may contract with an outside therapist to provide these services. The provision of these compensatory services shall not interfere with STUDENT¡¦s regular education program.
2. All of Student¡¦s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code ¡± 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Has STUDENT been eligible for special education from November 8, 2001, to the present? -The Student prevailed for the period from November 8, 2001 through April 18, 2002; the District prevailed for the period after April 18, 2002.
2. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE), from November 8, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY) of 2002? -The Student prevailed for the period from November 8, 2001 through April 18, 2002; the District prevailed for the period after April 18, 2002.
3. Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Fast ForWord program that they procured during the summer of 2002? -The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
-The Student only prevailed on this issue with regard to all occupational therapy sessions STUDENT missed from November 8, 2001 up through the date of this Decision. The District prevailed with regard to all of Student¡¦s other requests for compensatory education.
5. Are STUDENT¡¦s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments performed by Dr. Davidson, Laurie Cohen and Dr. Ryan? -The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code ¡± 56505(j).
DATED: November 26, 2002 _____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ both in numbering and wording from those noticed by the Student before the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. The District¡¦s issues were substantively the same as the Student¡¦s. 2. The Student proposed that, if the result of the post-assessment IEP team meeting was that STUDENT still was not eligible for special education, the hearing would reconvene. 3. At the time of his triennial assessment, STUDENT was nine years old. 4. Those services included RSP pull-out services, four times per week for 30 minutes, RSP collaboration five times per week for 30 minutes, and speech and language services, and later, STUDENT received occupational therapy services for a period of time. 5. STUDENT¡¦s parents failed to attend this meeting.
6. Although STUDENT previously qualified as a student with a speech and language impairment, it was undisputed that STUDENT no longer qualified under this category. 7. STUDENT¡¦s regular education teacher, Laura Johnston, his resource teacher, Cathy Anderson, and Dr. Stotereau all testified generally that STUDENT did not exhibit significant auditory processing deficits in testing or in the classroom. 8. Although it is unclear whether she was terminated, she testified that she did not have another job when she left the District. 9. The District provided no authority for its contention that appropriate, up-to-date goals and objectives are not required while the IEP process moved forward. 10. It is unclear how the Student arrived at the figure of 240 hours, as there was no testimony or documentary evidence regarding that number. 11. Although there was some confusion on the part of Ms. Johnston, the regular education teacher, regarding how many days each week the resource aide actually came into the classroom to work with STUDENT for the collaboration services, the aid¡¦s supervisor, Ms. Anderson, testified persuasively that STUDENT received the services called for on his pre-November 2001 IEPs. 12. The District is responsible for recompensing STUDENT for every session that he has missed up through the date of this Decision because of its ongoing stay put obligation 20 U.S.C. 1415(j); the fact that STUDENT was no longer eligible beginning April 18, 2002, is immaterial because under their stay put obligation, the District was required to maintain the status quo during the hearing, including occupational therapy services. 13. STUDENT¡¦s parents first requested an ¡§independent¡¨ psychoeducational assessment in May 2002. The District filed for due process in July 2002 stating as an issue, in pertinent part, whether it had appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
