California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 19, 2002
Student v. Moreland Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 1745-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso
Moreland, Cambrian and Santa Clara County Office of Education provided FAPE in county autism class; parents' request for private placement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 10-year-old boy who qualified for special education under autism filed for due process against Moreland Elementary School District, Cambrian Elementary School District and the Santa Clara County Office of Education. The student attended the County Autism Project, a special day class run by the county. The parents argued that he made little or no progress from summer 1999 through summer 2001. They said frequent teacher turnover left him without a stable program and that missed speech and occupational therapy sessions meant his IEPs were not followed. They also argued that the 2001-2002 offer was too academic and not functional enough, and they sought placement at the Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE).
Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso ruled for the districts on every issue. He applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard and found that the student made more than minimal progress each year in communication, reading, writing, math and social skills. He relied on IEP reports, staff testimony and the mother's own admissions. Credentialed substitutes, a steady one-to-one aide, consistent therapists and support from principal Janice Yamamoto and behavior specialist Bill Thieman kept the program stable despite turnover. A few missed hours of speech and occupational therapy did not cost the student educational benefit. The 2001-2002 offer reasonably balanced academics with daily living skills and was the least restrictive environment. He did not reach the PACE question and denied all relief.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO looked at teacher turnover under the Rowley standard. It focused on whether credentialed substitutes, stable aides and consistent services kept the program going. It also treated a few missed therapy hours as harmless when the parents showed no lost benefit. Finally, it weighed academic and functional goals when deciding whether an offer for an autistic student was appropriate.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did Moreland and Santa Clara fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 1998-1999 extended school year by failing to provide him with educational benefit?
The student made more than minimal progress in expressive communication, reading and writing during the summer 1999 ESY and received educational benefit.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1b. Did Moreland and Santa Clara fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 1998-1999 extended school year by failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?
One missed hour of speech therapy and about 1 to 1.5 hours of occupational therapy after a late-ESY assessment caused no shown loss of educational benefit, so the placement conformed to the IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year by failing to provide him with educational benefit?
The student made more than minimal progress toward his communication, reading, math and social/emotional goals despite teacher turnover.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2b. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year by failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?
Credentialed substitutes, a stable 1:1 aide and consistent therapists kept the program stable; two missed hours of speech therapy were harmless, and the records showed occupational therapy was provided in fall 1999.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3a. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year by failing to provide him with educational benefit?
The student met four of six communication goals, progressed on the other two and on his social/emotional goals, and so received educational benefit.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 3b. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year by failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?
Despite turnover across six periods, qualified and credentialed teachers, supported by the principal and a behavior specialist, gave the student a stable environment that conformed to his IEP.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did Moreland's and Santa Clara's offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year provide Petitioner a FAPE?
The goals and the County Autism Project reasonably balanced academics with functional daily living skills, were designed to give educational benefit, and were the least restrictive environment.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. If the offer did not offer Petitioner a FAPE, does Petitioner require placement at the Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE) to receive a FAPE?
Not reached because the 2001-2002 offer provided a FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley; Doe v. Board of Educ. (6th Cir. 1993); Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Renner v. Board of Educ.; Wise v. Ohio Dept. of Educ.; Cleveland Heights-Univ. Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss
People named in the decision
- Nancy Elizabeth Sullivan, Ph.D., psychologist, expert witness for Student
- Sandra F. Reischer (also spelled Sandy Reicher), former chief executive officer, witness for Student, Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE)
- Marilyn Bird, private speech-language pathologist (county-funded), witness for Student
- Janice Yamamoto, special education principal, County Autism Project, Santa Clara County Office of Education
- Gail Gitt, director of student services, Moreland Elementary School District
- Joe Weber, school psychologist, Moreland Elementary School District
- Jan McCalister, assistant superintendent, Cambrian Elementary School District
- Bill Thieman, behavior specialist and later teacher, County Autism Project, Santa Clara County Office of Education
- Joe Fimiani, director of special education, Santa Clara County Office of Education
- Michel Stein, M.D., pediatric neurologist (referral source)
- Linda Lotspeich, M.D., child psychiatrist, private evaluator, Stanford University Medical Center, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic
- Michael Alessandri, Ph.D., child psychologist, private evaluator, Stanford University Medical Center, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic
- Andrea Bush, extended school year teacher, County Autism Project
- Fina Chung, 1:1 aide, County Autism Project
- Leslie Juno, speech-language specialist
- Toni Harrington, registered occupational therapist, assessor
- Marion Tabuchi, occupational/physical therapist
- Teresa Ong, special education teacher, County Autism Project
- Nancy Opiana, speech-language specialist
- Sue McEuwen, speech-language therapist
- Fonda Dodd, speech-language therapist
- Maryam Salehomoum, extended school year speech-language therapist
- Paul McConoville (also spelled McConville), substitute teacher (emergency credential), County Autism Project
- Di Hong, special education teacher, County Autism Project
- Linda Bruton, aide and summer 2001 ESY teacher (emergency credential), County Autism Project
- Jane Goold-Caulfield, private speech-language evaluator, Children's Health Council (stated as Children's Health Counsel), San Jose
- Terry Brown, in-class speech-language specialist, County Autism Project
- Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE), private school sought by parents
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Jose, California, on December 13 and 14, 2001, February 12 and 13, 2002, March 21 and 22, 2002, and April 4, 5 and 23, 2002. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner Student were attorney William Reyes from the Legal Aid Society of Santa Clara County and Petitioner=s parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Appearing on behalf of Respondent Morelend Elementary School District (Moreland) was attorney Chad Graff and Gail Gitt, director of student services for Moreland. Appearing on behalf of Respondents Santa Clara County Office of Education (Santa Clara) and Cambrian Elementary School District (Cambrian) were attorney Eliza McArthur; Janice Yamamoto, special education principal for Santa Clara; Joe Fimiani, director of special education for Santa Clara; and Jan McCalister, assistant superintendant for Cambrian.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner: FATHER, father of Petitioner; MOTHER, mother of Petitioner; Nancy Elizabeth Sullivan, Ph.D., psychologist; Sandra F. Reischer, former chief executive officer of the Pacific Autism Center for Education; and Marilyn Bird, speech and language pathologist.
The following witnesses were called by the Respondents: Janice Yamamoto, special education principal for Santa Clara; Gail Gitt, director of student services for Moreland; Joe Weber, Moreland school psychologist; Jan McCalister, assistant superintendant for Cambrian; Bill Thieman, teacher at the Santa Clara County Autism Project; and Joe Fimiani, director of special education for Santa Clara.
-1-
Oral and documentary evidence were received. Following receipt of the parties= closing briefs on June 21, 2002, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did Moreland Elementary School District (Moreland) and Santa Clara County Office of Education (Santa Clara) fail to provide Petitioner with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with educational benefit and b. Failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?(Footnote 1)
2. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian Elementary School District (Cambrian) fail to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with educational benefit and b. Failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?
3. Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with educational benefit and b. Failing to conform the placement to his agreed-upon services?
4. Did Moreland Elementary School District=s and Santa Clara County Office of Education=s offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year provide Petitioner a FAPE?
5. If Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year did not offer Petitioner a FAPE, does Petitioner require placement at the Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE) to receive a FAPE?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student (STUDENT) is a ten-year-old student who is autistic. He resides with his parents in San Jose, California, which is within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Moreland Elementary School District. When STUDENT was two and one-half years old, he began to receive special education and related services at McKinnon preschool. Today, he attends the County Autism Project at Saratoga Elementary School.
STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. During STUDENT=s first year of life, he met developmental milestones on a normal schedule. He smiled socially as an infant, sat without help at four months, walked alone at eight and one-half months, and spoke his name at about one year. STUDENT stopped speaking at approximately one year of age. By fifteen months, STUDENT=s speech had not reappeared and he avoided making eye contact with people. Thus, STUDENT=s parents sought treatment for him and he began to receive speech and language services when he was two years old.(Footnote 2)
In 1994, STUDENT=s pediatric neurologist, Michel Stein, M.D., referred STUDENT to Moreland to determine his eligibility for special education services. STUDENT was two years and ten months old. After receiving permission from STUDENT=s parents for an initial assessment, Moreland evaluated STUDENT using the Hawaii Early Learning Profile (Hawaii) and the Alpern-Boll assessment. The Hawaii assessment revealed delays in STUDENT=s cognitive skills, his receptive and expressive language skills, his symbolic play, his self-help skills, his social/emotional skills, and his gross and fine motor skills. The Alpern-Boll assessment, which was given to STUDENT=s parents, confirmed delays in STUDENT=s social and communication skills. Finally, the assessment team reported that STUDENT exhibited autistic-like behaviors such as hand flapping, unusual posturing, and limited eye contact.
On June 16, 1994, the IEP team held an initial IEP meeting for STUDENT. Because STUDENT=s delays in his communication and social skills were fifty percent below his chronological age, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services under the qualifying criterion of autism. The IEP team wrote goals and objectives in communication, social/emotional skills, and gross and fine motor skills. The IEP also provided STUDENT with speech and language services.(Footnote 3) Finally, the IEP team placed STUDENT in the County Autism Project at the McKinnon preschool in Moreland. STUDENT attended preschool and kindergarten at McKinnon for the 1994-1995 and the 1995-1996 school years.
In January 1995, STUDENT was evaluated by Linda Lotspeich, M.D., a child psychiatrist, and Michael Alessandri, Ph.D., a child psychologist, at the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, at Stanford University Medical Center in Stanford, California. The examiners administered the Merrill-Palmer Scale of Mental Tests. The evaluation revealed substantial delays in receptive and expressive language, visual perception, visual motor skills, and behavior. Dr. Lotspeich and Dr. Allessandri formally diagnosed STUDENT as suffering from autism because he met 8 of the 12 DSM-IV criteria for the disorder.(Footnote 4) Finally, Dr. Lotspeich and Dr. Alessandri recommended that STUDENT continue to receive occupational and speech and language therapy, that his school curriculum focus on improving his communication and his ability to adapt to transitions, and that he be exposed to normally developing peers with good social and language skills.
For the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years, STUDENT attended the Santa Clara County Autism Project at Latimer Elementary School in the Moreland Elementary School District.(Footnote 5) During this time, the IEP team scheduled regular IEP meetings and wrote goals and objectives to address STUDENT=s needs in receptive and expressive language, academics, gross and fine motor skills, and self-help skills. Finally, STUDENT received speech and language services during these school years.
In January 1999, STUDENT=s parents unilaterally placed STUDENT at the Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE) because they were dissatisfied with STUDENT=s progress in the County Autism Project. In February 1999, STUDENT=s parents filed for a due process hearing. After the parties settled the case, STUDENT left PACE and returned to the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park Elementary School on July 19, 1999. He attended the remainder of the extended school year in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park until August 13, 1999.
For the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years and extended school years, STUDENT also attended the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park. During this time, the IEP team met and wrote goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of communication, academics, reading, writing, math, technology, social skills and behavior. From August 1999 to April 2001, the County Autism Project experienced a turnover in teachers.(Footnote 6) Thus, Ms. Janice Yamamoto, the Autism Project=s Principal and one of it original developers, employed experienced and credentialed substitute teachers until permanent credentialed teachers were hired. The class curriculum, aides, and service providers remained stable. With regard to the class curriculum, Ms. Yamamoto assisted in the classroom at least one day per week. Furthermore, she stayed in weekly and sometimes daily contact with the teacher and staff to ensure that each student=s goals and objectives were implemented. Finally, she hired Mr. Bill Thieman, a behavior specialist and experienced teacher with autistic children, to provide consultation and support in the classroom.
With regard to the aides in the Autism Project, Ms. Fina Chung was STUDENT=s regular one-to-one aide. In April 2000, the IEP team agreed that Ms. Chung, STUDENT=s assigned one-to-one aide, could be faded and his one-to-one support could be rotated among aides because of STUDENT=s academic and behavioral progress. With regard to the services, STUDENT received consistent speech and language and occupational therapy both during school from District speech and language therapists and after school from Ms. Marilyn Bird, a private speech and language specialist. The Santa Clara County Office of education funded Ms. Bird=s services for STUDENT. Finally, STUDENT received occupational and physical therapy from Toni Harrington and Ms. Marion Tabuchi, both of whom were District employees.
In January 2000, STUDENT and his family were forced to move from their home in the Moreland School District to a hotel and later a home in the Cambrian School District after their family home caught fire. A new IEP was not written for STUDENT when he transferred into the Cambrian District because both Moreland and Cambrian are members of the same special education local plan area. Since the Autism Project serves students in both districts, STUDENT continued in the Autism Project without any interruption. In January 2001, the repairs on STUDENT=s family home were completed and they moved back into their home in the Moreland school district, where STUDENT and his family remain to date.
In March 2001, the IEP team held an IEP meeting for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year. STUDENT=s parents advised the IEP team that they were obtaining a private evaluation of STUDENT at the Children=s Health Counsel (CHC) in San Jose, California. Because they wanted the IEP team to consider the CHC report, the IEP team continued the IEP meeting until May 30, 2001. At the March 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team also discussed temporarily reinstating direct one-to-one aide support for STUDENT because of STUDENT=s parents concerns about the Autism Project.
In April 2001, Mr. Bill Thiemann became the County Autism Project=s teacher and he remains its teacher to date. At the May 30, 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team discussed the findings of the CHC report. Thereafter, the IEP team wrote goals and objectives in communication, gross motor skills, sensory motor skills, math, reading, writing, daily living skills, and social/emotional behavior. The IEP team also provided for occupational, physical, and speech and language therapy, and a one-to-one aide. Finally, the IEP team recommended continued placement in the County Autism Project at Saratoga. STUDENT=s parents, however, disagreed with the IEP goals and objectives for STUDENT and wanted him placed at PACE. Thus, they did not sign the IEP document. Thereafter, STUDENT=s parents filed for a due process hearing.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did Moreland Elementary School District (Moreland) and Santa Clara County Office of Education (Santa Clara) fail to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with educational benefit and b. Failing to conform his placement to his agreed upon services?
Petitioner brought this action against Respondents pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). In enacting the IDEA, Congress intended Ato ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.@ 20 U.S.C. ' 1400(d)(1)(A). Thus, the IDEA requires public school districts to develop a curriculum Atailored to the unique needs of the [disabled] child by means of an >individualized educational program=@ (IEP). Cleveland Heights-Univ. Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 144 F.3d 391, 397-398 (6th Cir.1998) (quoting Board of Educ. V. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 181-182, 73 L. Ed. 2d 690, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982)).; California Education Code ' 56000. Furthermore, the United States Supreme Court in Rowley addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Supreme Court held that Athe basic floor of opportunity provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.@ (Id. at 201.) The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student=s abilities. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.)
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related educational services. The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22). Furthermore, California Education Code ' 56363 provides that designated instruction and services shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@
Finally, the IDEA requires public school districts to ensure that children with disabilities are educated Ato the maximum extent appropriate@ with nondisabled children. Doe v. Board of Educ., 9 F.3d 455, 460 (6th Cir. 1993), cert. denied, 511 U.S. 1108, 128 L. Ed. 2d 665, 114 S. Ct. 2104 (1994); 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A). Thus, Congress has stated a Avery strong@ preference for Amainstreaming@ disabled children by placing them in regular classes where feasable. Doe v. Board of Educ., 9 F. 3d at 460. However, this Amainstreaming@ requirement is not absolute and the courts have recognized that mainstreaming is not required in every case. Id.; 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); California Education Code ' 56031.
Therefore, the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley required that a District=s offer of a FAPE must be designed to meet the student=s unique and individual needs, be reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, conform with the Student=s IEP, and occur in the least restrictive environment.
1. Appropriateness of District and County Placement
In this case, the parties concurred on STUDENT=s respective delays, strengths, and emerging skills. With regard to his delays, they agreed that STUDENT exhibited moderate to severe weaknesses in receptive and expressive language, reading, writing, math, and behavior. With regard to his strengths, they concurred that STUDENT excelled in his gross motor skills, perception, and eye-hand coordination. Finally, with regard to his emerging skills, the parties agreed that STUDENT exhibited improving skills in reading, math, and writing.
In addition to the parties agreement regarding STUDENT=s delays, strengths, and emerging skills, they also concurred that the 1999 extended school year placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique and individual needs. They agreed that STUDENT=s goals and objectives were appropriate and that placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the extended school year would meet STUDENT=s needs. Moreover, they agreed upon speech and language services for STUDENT. Finally, the parties concurred that STUDENT=s placement in the Autism project was the least restrictive environment.
(a) Did STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park ElementarySchool for the 1998-1999 extended school fail to provide him with educational benefit?
Petitioner, however, disputed whether the 1998-1999 extended school year placement in the Autism Project at Strawberry Park provided STUDENT with educational benefit. In construing the IDEA=s requirement of a free appropriate public education, federal courts have emphasized that public schools are not required to maximize a disabled student=s educational potential. Doe v. Board of Educ., 9 F.3d at 459; see also Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F. 3d 119, 132 (2d Cir. 1998) (noting that IEP need not maximize child=s potential, offer superior opportunities, or provide optimal level of services). Instead, public schools need only (1) comply with the IDEA=s procedural requirements, and (2) develop an IEP that is Areasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefits.@ Renner v. Board of Educ., 185 F. 3d 635, 644 (6th Cir. 1999); see also Wise v. Ohio Dept= of Educ., 80 F.3d 177, 185 (6th Cir. 1996) (noting that the IDEA requires only that public schools Aprovide children with disabilities an appropriate education, not the very best possible special education services@). Furthermore, the courts have held that the IDEA Aprovides no more than a basic floor of opportunity.@ Doe v. Board of Educ., 9 F. 3d at 459 (quoting Board of Educ. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 201, 73 L. Ed. 2d 690, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982)). The Abasic floor of opportunity@ provided by the IDEA should consist of Aaccess to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed A to >confer some educational benefit= upon the disabled child. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 201. However, the educational benefits provided by the school district must be more than Ade minimis.@ Doe v. Board of Educ., 9 F.3d at 459. Thus, the IEP proposed by the school district should provide an opportunity for Ameaningful@ and not merely Atrivial@ advancement. Walczak, 142 F. 3d at 130.
In this case, Petitioner=s parents allege that STUDENT received either a minimal educational benefit or no educational benefit during the 1998-1999 extended school year regarding his expressive communication, reading, and writing needs. Respondents contend that STUDENT received more than a minimal educational benefit and even met some of his goals and objectives in his disputed areas of need. A review of these three disputed areas of need follows.
Expressive communication
STUDENT=s communication goal for the 1998-1999 school year was as follows: ASTUDENT will increase his vocabulary through reading, writing and individual therapy. Vocabulary should consist of functional words in his home and school environments.@ Petitioner contended that the 1999 extended school year did not provide STUDENT with any benefit toward meeting this goal. Furthermore, Petitioner contended that any progress he made toward this goal was the result of after-school speech and language services from Ms. Marilyn Bird that were subsidized by Santa Clara County. Petitioner provided no additional evidence to substantiate his claim.
Respondents Moreland and Santa Clara County countered that STUDENT made progress toward his expressive communication goal and that his educational benefit was a product of the extended school year. Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Andrea Bush, STUDENT=s teacher for the 1999 extended school year, Ms. Fina Chung, STUDENT=s one-to-one aide, and Leslie Juno, STUDENT=s speech and language specialist, implemented STUDENT=s speech and language goal and objectives. Ms. Yamamoto also testified that by the end of the 1998-1999 extended school year STUDENT could combine a verb and a noun for playing, eating and drinking. For example, STUDENT could say Aplay ball,@ Aplay computer,@ Aeat cookie,@ and Adrink juice.@ Ms. MOTHER admitted that STUDENT could put a noun and verb together and say, for example, Asnack, please.@ Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT could verbally ask for help with prompts. For example, STUDENT could say Ahelp toy,@ Ahelp ball,@ Aget toy,@ Aget book.@ Ms. MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT reached this level of progress also and could say, for example, Ahelp, please.@ Ms. Yamamoto testified that by the end of the extended school year, STUDENT could consistently use his communication book to point to pictures to indicate what he wanted. For example, during snack time, STUDENT could point to a picture of a cookie or cupcake and indicate what he wanted to eat. Ms. MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT reached this level of progress. While she insisted that the progress resulted from Ms. Bird=s speech and language therapy and not STUDENT=s program in the County Autism Project, Ms. MOTHER presented no evidence to substantiate her claim.
The weight of the evidence, then, established that STUDENT made progress toward his communication goal during the 1998-1999 extended school year. Furthermore, Moreland and Santa Clara presented evidence with more convincing force that STUDENT=s progress toward his communication goal was, at the very least, equally the result of both his daily education in the extended school program and the services provided by Ms. Marilyn Bird. Thus, Petitioner received more than a minimal educational benefit toward his communication goal in the County Autism Project during the 1998-1999 extended school year.
Reading
Petitioner=s IEP contained the following reading goal: ASTUDENT will read simple sentences and show an understanding of his reading by completing simple sentences (i.e. fill in the blank with words and/or icons) with 80% accuracy.@ Petitioner contended that he did not make progress toward this goal during the 1998-1999 extended school year. Ms. MOTHER testified that by the end of the 1999 extended school year, STUDENT had increased his ability to read and name pictures of common objects by only eight words.
Moreland and Santa Clara contended that STUDENT=s progress toward meeting this goal was more substantial. Ms. Yamamoto testified that her review of STUDENT=s records revealed that by the end of the 1999 extended school year, STUDENT had increased his ability to read and name pictures of common objects by 20 words. For example, STUDENT could point to pictures and say cat, dog, spoon, cup, ball, box, boy etc. While STUDENT=s mother contended that STUDENT had only increased his reading vocabulary by eight words, she admitted that STUDENT had a large vocabulary. For example, he rode horses at an equestrian center and farm named AHidden Villa,@ where STUDENT could name a horse, a cow, a bull, a pig, a chicken, a duck, a goat etc. At the Monterey Bay Aquarium, STUDENT could name a fish, a shark, a sea cow etc. Finally, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could read children=s words such as ABarney@ and Adragon.@
While it was unclear whether STUDENT was able to fill in blanks with words and/or icons by the end of the 1998-1999 extended school year, the weight of the evidence established that STUDENT=s improvement in his vocabulary and reading ability was more than minimal. Thus, STUDENT made progress in his reading and received educational benefit during the 1998-1999 extended school year.
Writing
The IEP contained the following writing goals: ASTUDENT will copy his first and last name independently with 100% accuracy;@ ASTUDENT will copy simple words (e.g. cat, dog, turtle, horse, etc.) given a model and/or picture with 80% accuracy.@ While Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT made no progress toward his writing goals, she provided no evidence to support this contention.
Respondents Moreland and Santa Clara County countered that STUDENT either made progress or met his writing goals during the 1999 extended school year. Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Andrea Bush and Ms. Chung implemented STUDENT=s writing goals and objectives. With regard to copying his first and last name, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT could write his first name without a model and could write his last name with a prompt by the end of the 1998-1999 extended school year. With regard to copying simple words, Ms. Yamamoto noted that STUDENT could write common words such as book, dog, car etc. Finally, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT improved his ability to write. For example, he improved from tracing words to copying them. Thus, both Moreland and Santa Clara presented evidence that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward his writing goals and received educational benefit by the end of the 1998-1999 extended school year.
In summary, the evidence established that the County Autism Project provided STUDENT with a basic floor of opportunity to improve his needs in expressive communication, reading, and writing, that STUDENT made more than minimal toward them, and that he received educational benefit during the 1998-1999 extended school year.
(b) Did STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the 1998-1999 extended school year conform to STUDENT=s IEP?
The parties next disputed whether the County Autism Project conformed to the services provided for in STUDENT=s IEP during the 1998-1999 extended school year. The dispute centered on STUDENT=s speech and language and occupational therapy services. A review of the evidence regarding these disputed services follows.
Speech and language services
Petitioner=s IEP provided for speech and language services two times per week, thirty minutes per session. Ms. MOTHER testified that while STUDENT did not receive one hour of speech and language services during the first week he attended the County Autism Project in July 1999, he received speech and language services for the remainder of the extended school year until August 13, 1999. Although Respondents Moreland and Santa Clara did not dispute that STUDENT did not receive speech and language services for one week in July 1999, they also did not admit to a denial of an educational benefit to STUDENT. Furthermore, Ms. Marilyn Bird testified that during this disputed time period, she provided STUDENT with County-funded speech and language services in her private clinic. The parties also agreed that STUDENT received his speech and language services during the 1998-1999 school year while in both the County Autism Project and at PACE. Finally, neither Ms. MOTHER nor any other witness on STUDENT=s behalf testified that STUDENT was denied any specific educational benefit for failing to attend two speech and language therapy sessions totaling one hour. The evidence established, then, that while Moreland and Santa Clara failed to provide two speech and language sessions totaling one hour of therapy, there was no evidence that the two missed speech and language therapy sessions resulted in the loss of an educational benefit to STUDENT. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services during the 1999 ESY conformed to STUDENT=s IEP.
Occupational and physical therapy services
The parties next disputed whether STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park during the 1999 extended school year should have provided him with occupational/physical therapy services. Student contended that he was denied an educational benefit because he did not receive any occupational/physical therapy during the extended school year. The evidence at the hearing established that at the July 1998 IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed not to provide STUDENT with occupational and physical therapy services.(Footnote 7) At the May 27, 1999 IEP meeting, when the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT=s transition from PACE back into the County=s Autism Project at Strawberry Park, STUDENT=s parents presented the other members of the IEP team with an occupational/physical therapy report from PACE. The IEP team agreed to refer STUDENT for an occupational/physical therapy assessment and noted that the Aprincipal will explore if assessment can be done during extended year.@
On August 2, 1999, Mr. FATHER signed and consented to the occupational/physical therapy evaluation for STUDENT. On Tuesday, August 3, 1999, Toni Harrington, registered occupational therapist, conducted the assessment. In his report of the same date, Mr. Harrington concluded that Ait is recommended that STUDENT continue to receive occupational therapy for an hour a week to address the areas above.@ Those areas included STUDENT=s gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, and sensorimotor skills. Ten days later, on Friday, August 13, 1999, the 1999 extended school year ended.
Moreland and Santa Clara County, then, were put on notice that STUDENT required continued occupational therapy during the last 10 days of the extended school year and that he did not receive it. However, STUDENT lost, at best, an hour to an hour and a half of occupational therapy during this ten-day period. Furthermore, Petitioner presented no evidence that STUDENT=s failure to receive an hour to an hour and a half of occupational/physical therapy either had an adverse effect upon STUDENT or denied him an educational benefit. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s failure to provide an hour to an hour and a half of occupational therapy to Petitioner during the 1999 extended school year did not result from a failure of County Autism Project to conform to Petitioner=s IEP.
Conclusion
Respondents Moreland and Santa Clara presented evidence with more convincing force that Petitioner received more than a minimal educational benefit regarding his needs in expressive communication, reading, and writing. While STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the 1998-1999 extended school year admittedly did not provide him with a combined two and one half hours of speech and language and occupational therapy, Respondents failure to provide these services did not result in a failure of the extended school year placement to conform to STUDENT=s IEP. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Moreland and the County Office of Education provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 extended school year.
ISSUE 2: Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian Elementary School District (Cambrian) fail to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with more than a minimal educational benefit and b. Failing to conform his placement to his agreed-upon services?
In determining whether Respondents provided Petitioner a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year, one must analyze anew whether Respondent=s offer of a FAPE was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique and individual needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, conformed with STUDENT=s IEP, and ensured that STUDENT=s placement was in the least restrictive environment.
1. Appropriateness of District and County Placement
For the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year, the parties agreed that STUDENT continued to exhibit strengths, weaknesses, and emerging needs in his gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, sensori-motor skills, receptive and expressive language, in his reading, writing, and math, and in his social/emotional skills. The parties also concurred that the goals and objectives to address these needs were appropriate. Furthermore, they agreed that placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year was appropriate. Finally, the parties concurred that speech and language services, occupational/physical therapy services, and a one-to-one aide(Footnote 8) were necessary to address STUDENT=s unique needs.
(a) Did STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school provide STUDENT with more than a minimal educational benefit? For the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year, the parties disputed whether STUDENT received an educational benefit in his expressive communication, reading, math and social/emotional needs. While Petitioner alleged that he received either a minimal educational benefit or no educational benefit at all, Respondents contended that STUDENT received more than a minimal educational benefit and even met some of his goals and objectives for the school year and extended school year. A review of the evidence follows.
Expressive communication
The November 29, 1999 IEP stated that the expressive communication goals were as follows: ASTUDENT will produce 4-5 word phrases to include subject and verb using his communication book as a visual aide in 8/10 occurrences@; ATo encourage safety in the community, STUDENT will answer basic information questions about himself in 4/5 opportunities@; ASTUDENT will gather information from his general surroundings and be aware of his environment by using Awh@ questions during a structured activity or free play in 4/5 opportunities during his school day@; and finally, ASTUDENT will use alternate phrases to indicate needs (not only AI want@) verbally with communication book. STUDENT will take communication book with him to activities.@ Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not meet any of these expressive communication goals because of the turnover of teachers in the class. With regard to the first goal, she testified that STUDENT could only produce two-to-three-word phrases with a subject and verb. However, she did admit that with a prompt, he could produce a four- to five-word phrase with a subject and verb. With regard to the second goal, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not meet it. With regard to the third goal, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could not ask Awh@ questions. Instead, he could only hold up an object and ask Amommy?@ Finally, Ms. MOTHER testified that while STUDENT might have used phrases other than AI want@ at school, she did not hear them at home. Instead, Ms. MOTHER only heard, for example, Amore, please@ at home.
Moreland, Santa Clara and Cambrian countered that despite the turnover of teachers in the County Autism Project, STUDENT=s stable one-to-one aide and speech and language services helped him to make progress in his expressive communication goals during the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year. With regard to STUDENT=s first communication goal, Ms. Yamamoto testified that by the end of the school year and extended school year, STUDENT could say phrases such as AI want cookie, please.@ In the June 6, 2000 IEP, under the present levels of performance for STUDENT=s communication, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT could say AI want more candy, please,@ AI want more Cheetos, please,@ AI want more Play Do, please,@ AI want more Goldfish, please.@ In a progress report dated May 23, 2000, Marilyn Bird, STUDENT=s speech and language therapist, reported that STUDENT could say AI want green box,@ AI want draw dragon,@ AI need a pen to draw a dragon,@ ACan I have crayon,@ and AMarilyn, come see my picture.@ Ms. Bird did note that STUDENT said some of the aforementioned sentences with prompts.
With regard to the second communication goal, Ms. Teresa Ong stated, in her report dated June 2, 2000, that STUDENT could tell his first and last name and the city he lived in. With regard to the third goal, Ms. Ong reported that STUDENT could say Awhere is...@, Awhat is that?@, and Awho is that?@ With regard to the fourth goal, Ms. Bird reported that STUDENT could, with prompting, use the phrase AI need...@ instead of using the phrase AI want...@ Finally, Ms. Bird and Ms. Ong reported that while STUDENT still used his communication book to express himself, he was becoming more verbal and using more words to express himself.
While Petitioner alleged that he made either minimal or no progress toward his expressive communication goal due to the turnover in teachers, Moreland, Santa Clara and Cambrian presented substantial evidence that STUDENT either made more than minimal progress toward or reached his communication goals regarding for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received educational benefit during the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year.
Reading
STUDENT=s November 1999 IEP had two reading goals. While STUDENT=s parents concurred that STUDENT met the reading and comprehension goal, they did not agree that STUDENT met the goal to Aincrease his sight vocabulary by 100 words using the Edmark Reading Program@ by the end of the 1999-2000 extended school year. Petitioner, however, provided no additional evidence to support this contention.
Respondents countered that STUDENT did increase his sight vocabulary of high frequency words by using the Edmark Reading Program. In June 2000, Ms. Teresa Ong, STUDENT=s teacher, reported that STUDENT could point to the following pictures when requested: cat, dog, key, girl, man, airplane, apple, pencil, sock, car, duck, fish, snake, owl. Ms. Ong also reported that STUDENT was able to identify the following body parts: mouth, eyes, nose, feet, hair, head, ears, hands, legs, fingers, stomach, teeth, toes, and chest. Furthermore, Ms. Ong noted that STUDENT could read color words, number words, and common signs such as go, stop, wait and walk. Ms. Yamamoto also testified that STUDENT was using high frequency words such as Aa,@ Aand,@ and Athe.@ The IEP team also reported in its November 1999 IEP meeting that STUDENT made Asignificant progress in his personal quest to improve his communication skills. He has learned to use a sophisticated communication picture book at home and outside of the classroom setting. He is able to find pages based on questions, discuss categories, such as: what did you play today? He will flip to the place section and then look for the pictures. Many of the pictures have been subtitled with the written word and he is able to read these words with comprehension.@ Finally, the IEP team reported that ASTUDENT has strong sight word recognition. He is currently on Lesson 8 in the Edmark program, where he is able to discriminate up to 6 letter words. He reads some high frequency words.@ Finally, while it was unclear whether STUDENT had in fact met the goal to increase his sight vocabulary by 100 words using the Edmark Reading Program, the evidence established that STUDENT increased his sight vocabulary well above the nonexistent level that Ms. MOTHER testified to.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward his reading goals. First, his parents admitted that he accomplished the reading and comprehension goal. Second, Respondents Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian presented evidence that STUDENT=s increase in his sight vocabulary was more than minimal. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner received educational benefit regarding his reading needs for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year.
Math
The November 1999 IEP had two math goals. STUDENT=s parents agreed that STUDENT met the goal to recognize the numbers 1 to 100 and count to 100 by 5's and 10's with minimal verbal prompts. However, they disagreed that he met the goal to tell time to the quarter hour independently and to count coins and match amounts up to a dollar with minimal verbal prompts. Ms. MOTHER testified that by the end of the 1999-2000 extended school year, STUDENT could tell time to the quarter hour but with verbal prompts. Finally, she testified that STUDENT could not count coins to match amounts up to a dollar.
Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian countered that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward the second math goal. With regard to the ability to tell time to the quarter hour, Ms. Yamamoto concurred that STUDENT accomplished this goal. However, she admitted that he could not tell time independently. With regard to his ability to count and to match coins up to a dollar, Ms. Yamamoto testified that by the end of the 1999-2000 extended school year, STUDENT could not match coins to equal a specific amount of money if requested to do so. However, she noted that if STUDENT were given a set amount of money, he could add it up and tell one how much it amounted to.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward his math goals. First, STUDENT=s parents admitted that his math goal was to recognize the numbers 1 to 100 and count to 100 by 5's and 10's with minimal verbal prompts. Second, while STUDENT did not reach his second math goal with regard to telling time independently to the quarter hour and counting and matching coins up to a dollar, he nonetheless made more than minimal progress toward it. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received educational benefit with regard to his math goals for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year.
Social/emotional skills
The November 1999 IEP had two social/emotional goals: AIf STUDENT appears over-stimulated and is hand flapping, he will be redirected to another activity with one verbal prompt or visual cue 80% of the time,@ and ASTUDENT will take turns in a simple table game or academic activity independently 80%.@ With regard to the first social/emotional goal, Ms. MOTHER testified that the goal may or may not have been met depending on the situation and STUDENT=s mood. However, the June 2000 IEP established that the IEP team agreed that STUDENT primarily met this goal: ASTUDENT usually transitions to speech therapy sessions without difficulty. On occasion, he has shown resistance to transition. However, when prompted by a motivating toy or activity, he transitions and participates well.@ The IEP went on to note that if STUDENT wants attention, he will use Apulling and pointing.@ AHowever, he is easily directed back to his communication systems to tell you what he wants.@ Finally, Ms. Yamamoto and Ms. Bird testified that STUDENT met his goal of being redirected with one verbal or visual prompt.
With regard to the second social/emotional goal, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT may have met the goal at school. However, she pointed out that he only exhibited a 20% improvement in turn-taking at home. Respondent=s evidence, however, established that STUDENT made progress toward this goal. In her June 2000 report, Ms. Ong stated that STUDENT Acan usually play cooperatively but there is a need for adult supervision and help. He is able to play in a table game with 4 other children but this requires adult supervision as well.@ Finally, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT progressed from being easily distracted to sitting quietly and waiting for his turn with a visual or verbal cue fifty percent of the time.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward both his social/emotional goals. First, the IEP team, which included STUDENT=s parents, agreed that he made more than minimal progress toward the first social/emotional goal. Second, Ms. MOTHER admitted that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward his second social/emotional goal and depending on the circumstances, even met these goals. Furthermore, the Respondents provided additional evidence to corroborate Ms. MOTHER=s admissions. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received educational benefit with regard to his social/emotional goals for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year.
(b) Did STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year conform to STUDENT=s IEP?
The parties next disputed whether the County Autism Project conformed to STUDENT=s IEP with regard to a stable educational environment, speech and language services and occupational therapy services. A review of each disputed area follows.
Stable educational environment
The dispute regarding Petitioner=s educational environment centers on two distinct time periods. The first time period is from August 30, 1999, the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, to March 22, 2000. The second time period is from March 23, 2000, to the end of the extended school year in August 2000. With regard to the first time period, the evidence at the hearing established that in December 1999, STUDENT=s parents filed a complaint with the California Department of Education because the Autism Project experienced a turnover in teachers. Respondents filed an answer to the compliance complaint and refuted that the Autism Project had not provided STUDENT with appropriate credentialed substitute or full-time teachers. On March 22, 2000, the California Department of Education found Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian in compliance on all issues and ordered no corrective actions. Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT had a consistent one-to-one aide, Ms. Fina Chung. Finally, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT received consistent services. With regard to his speech and language services, STUDENT received consistent therapy in school from Nancy Opiana, Sue McEuwen, and Fonda Dodd. Outside of school, STUDENT received County-funded speech and language services from Marilyn Bird. With regard to his occupational therapy, STUDENT received consistent therapy from Marion Tabuchi. Thus, Petitioner=s allegation that the Autism Project failed to provide him with a stable academic environment from August 30, 1999, to March 22, 2002 had no foundation.
With regard to the second period of time, Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Theresa Ong served as the full-time teacher in the Autism Project until the end of the regular school year on June 14, 2000, and Ms. Andrea Bush served as the ESY teacher for the summer of 2000. STUDENT=s parents did not dispute either Ms. Ong=s or Ms. Bush=s credentials to teach the Autism Project during this second time period. Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Fina Chung continued as STUDENT=s one-to-one aide. STUDENT also continued to receive speech and language services in school from Fonda Dodd during the regular school year, from Maryam Salehomoum during the summer ESY, and from Marilyn Bird after school. Finally, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT received consistent occupational therapy services from Marion Tabuchi.
While Petitioner=s parents contended that the turnover in teachers in the Autism Project did not provide STUDENT with a stable educational environment, the evidence established that the County Autism Project provided STUDENT with credentialed substitute or full-time teachers, qualified aides and service providers. Thus, all the component parts for a stable educational environment for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year were in place. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the County Autism Project conformed to STUDENT=s placement.
Speech and language services
STUDENT=s November 29, 1999 IEP provided for speech and language services two times per week for a total of sixty minutes. Furthermore, the County funded private speech and language services after school with Ms. Marilyn Bird for one to two times per week. Ms. MOTHER testified that for the first two weeks that STUDENT attended the County Autism Project in September 1999, he did not receive any speech and language services at school. Moreland and Santa Clara did not dispute this fact. During this two-week period, Ms. Bird testified that she provided STUDENT with his private speech and language therapy.
While Moreland and Santa Clara did not dispute that STUDENT did not receive four speech and language therapy sessions, for a total of two hours of therapy for two weeks at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, they did not admit to a denial of an academic benefit to STUDENT. During the two week period that STUDENT did not receive speech and language services in school, Ms. Bird testified that she provided STUDENT with his County-funded private speech and language therapy. Furthermore, Respondents witnesses testified, and Petitioner admitted, that Ms. Nancy Opiana, speech and language specialist, provided speech and language services to STUDENT from September 14, 1999, to the end of the regular school year. Finally, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT received his speech and language services during the 1999-2000 extended school year.
Although Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian admittedly failed to provide STUDENT with four speech and language sessions, or two hours of therapy, the Hearing Officer finds that the error was harmless when spread out over the entire 1999-2000 school year and extended school year. Thus, the failure of Respondents to provide STUDENT with two hours of speech and language therapy resulted in neither a failure of the placement in the County Autism Project to conform to STUDENT=s IEP nor a denial of an educational benefit to him.
Occupational/physical therapy services
The parties next disputed whether STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park during the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year provided him with occupational/physical therapy services. Ms. MOTHER contended that STUDENT did not receive these services from September 1999 to the end of the calendar year. Moreland and Santa Clara contended that STUDENT did receive his occupational/physical therapy services during the disputed time period from Ms. Marion Tabuchi. The parties did not dispute that STUDENT received his occupational therapy from January 2000 to the end of the 1999-2000 extended school year.
On May 26, 2000, Ms. Tabuchi wrote an occupational therapy report. In her report, Ms. Tabuchi stated under the heading ASummary@ that ASTUDENT=s motor skills have improved this year.@ In support of this statement, Moreland provided copies of Ms. Tabuchi=s occupational therapy records from September 7, 1999, her first occupational therapy session with STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year, to December 17, 1999, her last physical therapy session with STUDENT for the 1999 calendar year. Both Ms. Tabuchi=s report and the therapy records established that Moreland and Santa Clara provided STUDENT with occupational therapy during the disputed period. Thus, the placement at the County Autism Project conformed to STUDENT=s IEP.
Conclusion
While STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park experienced some turnover in its classroom teachers, the one-to-one aide, speech and language and occupational/physical therapy services were consistent during the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year. As a result of the stable educational environment, STUDENT made progress toward his goals and objectives. Furthermore, his placement in the County Autism Project at Strawberry Park conformed to his IEP. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year provided him with a FAPE.
ISSUE 3: Did Moreland, Santa Clara, and Cambrian fail to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year by a. Failing to provide him with more than a minimal educational benefit and b. Failing to conform his placement to his agreed-upon services.
In determining whether Respondents provided Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year, one must again analyze anew whether Respondent=s offer of a FAPE met STUDENT=s unique and individual needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, conformed with STUDENT=s IEP, and ensured that STUDENT=s placement was in the least restrictive environment.
1. Appropriateness of District and County Placement
The parties agreed that STUDENT continued to exhibit delays in his receptive and expressive language skills, his reading, writing, math, behavior and attention. Furthermore, they agreed that STUDENT exhibited strengths in perception, eye-hand integration, gross and fine motor skills. Finally, the parties concurred that STUDENT had emerging skills in reading, writing, communication, and math.
In addition to agreeing upon STUDENT=s delays, strengths, and emerging skills, the parties agreed that the goals and objectives, placement and services were designed to meet STUDENT=s needs for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year.(Footnote 9) The parties did not dispute that the placement was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
(a) Did the placement in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year provide Petitioner with more than a minimal educational benefit?
While Respondents are not required to maximize Petitioner=s educational benefit, they are required to provide him with more than a minimal benefit. The parties disputed whether Petitioner received an educational benefit in his expressive communication and his social/emotional skills. Petitioner contended that he either did not receive any educational benefit or that the benefit he received was minimal. Respondents countered that Petitioner received more than a minimal benefit in these two areas of need. A review of the evidence follows.
Expressive Communication
STUDENT=s IEP for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year had six communication goals. The parties did not dispute that STUDENT met four of his six goals. However, STUDENT=s parents disputed whether STUDENT made progress in the following two goals: ASTUDENT will use his communication picture system or more complex verbalizations to clarify and elongate sentences spoken or acted out with natural prompts (What did you want?) At least 80% for 10 observations,@ and ASTUDENT will use his verbalization skills to express his wants, needs, and to comment on the world around him at least 10 times per hour throughout his day for 10 days observed.@ With regard to the first goal, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was independently using his communication book less at home but that if prompted, he would use it. She stated that she interpreted this decrease in the use of his communication book at home as an indication that his communication book was not being used in class because of the turnover of the teachers. Ms. MOTHER pointed out that STUDENT=s decreased use of his communication book at home resulted in an increase in his self-stimulation, such as humming and flapping. Finally, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was not using more complex verbalizations and was only slightly more verbal at home. Thus, Ms. MOTHER concluded that the County Autism Project did not provide STUDENT with any educational benefit in the aforementioned two areas of needs.
Respondents countered that STUDENT did increase the use of his communication book and verbalizations. With regard to the use of his communication book, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT used his communication book in class to point to pictures when he was unable to verbally indicate what he wanted. However, Ms. Yamamoto pointed out that because STUDENT was more verbal at this time, he used his communication book less to express himself. This fact was independently confirmed in the May 2001 report from Children=s Health Counsel (CHC).(Footnote 10) Ms. Jane Goold-Caulfield, the speech and language specialist who examined STUDENT, reported that Aalthough STUDENT brought his communication book with him, his expressive communication was characterized by oral verbalizations with some simultaneous use of gestures. His parents report that they encourage his reliance on oral communication and that his communication book is usually only used during moments of frustration.@ Instead of using his communication book to speak or indicate his wants and needs, Ms. Yamamoto testified that STUDENT would say with a prompt >I want help,= >I want ball,= >I want water,= >I see ball,= >I see car,= etc. Ms. Goold-Caulfield confirmed this fact in her report also: ASTUDENT appropriately used a variety of linguistic scripts including, >I want more toys, please,= >I want cards, please,= >it=s all gone.= Thus, the evidence established that as STUDENT=s verbal communication skills improved, he used his communication book less to express himself.
With regard to using his verbalization skills to comments on his wants, needs and the world around him, Respondents contended that STUDENT made progress in this goal also. In the May 30, 2001 IEP, the IEP team reported that STUDENT was able to form four- to five-word utterances both with and without a model and had begun to display the ability to elongate sentences and clarify information for the listener. Furthermore, the IEP team noted that when prompted, STUDENT was able to take a sentence and include attributes and descriptors to elongate his sentences. These findings were confirmed by Ms. Jane Goold-Caulfield in the CHC report: AThrough his use of oral verbalizations and interspersed simultaneous gestures, STUDENT was able to initiate a conversation and appropriately respond on topic during a conversation. With mild cues, he was able to attend to a speaker and take conversational turns on a topic. He is able to make requests and commands regarding actions and assistance. STUDENT made comments to gain joint attention, reject and deny information or actions, indicate non-presence, confirm information, and assert information by stating the obvious about objects, actions, and conditions.@ Finally, Ms. Goold-Caulfield reported that ASTUDENT functionally demonstrated many speech and language abilities while participating in play activities, coloring, and looking through books. He actively attended to a book, responding to questions with single-and multi-word responses. He was able to accurately respond to yes/no questions and >how many,= >where,= >who,= and >what questions.=
By the end of the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year, then, STUDENT accomplished 4 of his 6 communication goals. With regard to the two disputed communication goals, Respondents presented evidence that STUDENT used his communication book less because be relied more on verbal communication, he used longer sentences, and his vocabulary was broad enough to allow him to express himself in many different situations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner made more than minimal progress toward his communication goals and received educational benefit.
Social/emotional skills
The June 2000 IEP had two social/emotional goals: AIf STUDENT appears over stimulated and is hand flapping, he will be redirected to another activity with one verbal prompt or visual cue 80% of the time,@ and ASTUDENT will take turns in a simple table game or academic activity independently 80%.@ Ms. MOTHER contended that STUDENT made no progress toward these two goals.
Respondents countered that STUDENT did make progress toward these goals. With regard to the first goal, the IEP team reported in the May 30, 2001 IEP that ASTUDENT can be a charming and friendly boy who willingly responds to low demand overtures from others....When demands are placed on him that involve activities that are not of high interest, he can become passive, resistive, and simply sit and wait, rather than actively saying >yes= or >no= to instructions. He responds very well to modeled instructions, and, in fact, when he is in a resistive mode, the most effective method for getting him back on track is to offer quiet, low key models of the desired task. STUDENT responds very well to frequent but brief praise and reinforcement for on task behavior....@ Finally, both Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT had little to no problem transitioning from one subject to the next.
With regard to the second goal, Ms. Ong reported in her evaluation dated June 2, 2000, that while STUDENT generally played with adults in the class, she observed him on occasions engaging in pretend play with peers of his age. Furthermore, she noted that he could cooperatively play table games with four other children but required adult supervision as well. In the May 2001 IEP, the IEP team reported that ASTUDENT will participate in parallel work or play, and if an activity is supervised by an adult, he will tolerate cooperative activities.@ Finally, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT played with cousins, children in the neighborhood on the weekend, and successfully partook in equestrian competitions that involved other groups of autistic children.
While Petitioner alleged that he made no progress toward his two social/emotional goals, Respondents presented evidence that STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward these goals. With regard to the first goal, the teaching staff could successfully redirect STUDENT with minimal prompts when he was either overstimulated or did not want to cooperate. With regard to the second goal, STUDENT was developing his skills to interact with other children though he required adult supervision. Thus, STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward his social/emotional goals and received educational benefit during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year.
(b) Did STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year conform to STUDENT=s IEP?
The parties disputed whether Petitioner=s placement conformed to his IEP and provided him with a stable educational environment because of a turnover in teachers in the County Autism Project. A review of the evidence follows.
Stable educational environment
The parties= dispute regarding the stability of STUDENT=s educational environment centered on the turnover of teachers in the Autism Project.(footnote 11) The dispute fell into six distinct time periods. The first time period ran from August 24, 2000, the beginning of the school year, to December 20, 2000, the end of the calendar year. During this time, the evidence at the hearing established that Ms. Teresa Ong, who taught STUDENT the prior school year, was the full-time teacher in the Autism Project. She left the class at the end of the 2000 calendar year. STUDENT=s parents did not dispute Ms. Ong=s credentials to teach the class.
The second disputed time period ran from January 3, 2001, to January 31, 2001. During this time, the evidence at the hearing established that Mr. Paul McConoville was the full-time substitute teacher at the Autism Project. Ms. Yamamoto, who was the Principal of the Autism Project, testified that Mr. McConoville possessed an emergency teaching credential from the State of California and provided a copy of it at the hearing. Ms. Yamamoto noted that while she searched for a new full-time teacher, she hired Mr. McConville to serve as a substitute teacher in the Autism Project. She pointed out that Mr. McConville had taught in the Autism Project in the past and had experience teaching autistic children. Ms. Yamamoto also noted that she worked closely with Mr. McConville to develop materials and tasks for the students and also worked with the aides to implement the children=s individual IEP goals and objectives. Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto testified that she employed Mr. Bill Thieman, a behavioral specialist and teacher with the County of Santa Clara, to provide both behavioral and instructional support in the class. Mr. Thieman testified that he has over 20 years of experience both teaching autistic children and developing class curriculum for them. He confirmed that he provided Mr. McConville with weekly lesson plans and materials for the students in the class. In the month that Mr. McConville taught the class, Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT did not experience any behavioral or academic set backs.
The third time period ran from February 1, 2001, to April 6, 2001. During this time, the Autism Project was taught by Ms. Di Hong, the new full-time teacher for the Autism Project. Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Hong held a California Special Education Teaching Credential for Moderate/Severe Disabilities. She noted that Ms. Hong came to the Autism Project with six years of teaching experience, including two years of teaching autistic children. Furthermore, both Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that while Ms. Hong acclimated herself to the new class, they continued to support the class. However, Mr. Thieman and Ms. Yamamoto testified that Ms. Hong experienced difficulty in managing the class and she ultimately was released from her teaching duties. Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT did not experience any behavioral or academic setbacks while Ms. Hong taught the class.
The fourth time period ran from April 7, 2001, to April 20, 2001. During this time, Ms. Yamamoto testified that the class was taught by credentialed substitute teachers. She and Mr. Thieman testified that they continued to support the class. The fifth time period ran from April 23, 2001, to June 13, 2001. Mr. Thieman testified that he took over the Autism Project and was its full-time teacher until the end of the school year. STUDENT=s parents did not dispute Mr. Thieman=s credentials to teach the class. The sixth and final time period ran from July 2001 to August 2001 during the extended school year. Ms Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that Ms. Linda Bruton, an experienced, long-term aide in the Autism Project, taught the summer 2001 ESY class. Ms. Yamamoto pointed out that Ms. Bruton possessed an emergency California Teaching Credential. Finally, Ms. Yamamoto testified that she continued to support Ms. Bruton and the aides throughout the summer.
Although the County Autism Project admittedly experienced a turnover in full-time teachers during the 2000-2001 school year, Respondents provided qualified and credentialed substitute and full-time teachers. Furthermore, both Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman supported the teachers with class materials and weekly lesson plans, and guided the aides in implementing the students= IEPs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that despite a turnover in teachers in the County Autism Project for the 2000-2001 school year, the placement provided STUDENT with a stable educational environment and conformed to STUDENT=s IEP.
Conclusion
During the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year, the County Autism Project admittedly experienced some turnover in its full-time teachers. However, Respondents provided qualified and credentialed substitutes and teachers along with consistent one-to-one aides and service providers. Because STUDENT had a stable educational environment, STUDENT made more than minimal progress toward and accomplished some of his goals and objectives. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT=s placement in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year provided STUDENT with a FAPE.
ISSUE 4: Did Moreland Elementary School District=s and Santa Clara County Office of Education=s offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga Elementary School for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year provide STUDENT a FAPE?
While the prior issues retrospectively focused on whether the placement in the County Autism Project provided Petitioner with minimal educational benefit and conformed to his IEPs, the present issue prospectively focuses on whether the Respondent=s offer provided STUDENT with a FAPE. Petitioner=s parents contended that Respondent=s offer failed to meet Petitioner=s needs because the proposed goals and objectives and structure of the Autism Project did not sufficiently stress functional living skills. While Respondents acknowledged that Petitioner=s program needed to be functional, they also contended that Petitioner needed to continue to establish a solid academic foundation upon which to later broaden his functional living skills. Respondents alleged that both the goals and objectives and the structure of the Autism project offered STUDENT the requisite balance between his functional living and academic needs.
1. Appropriateness of District and County Placement
In this case, the parties agreed that STUDENT exhibited ongoing delays in his receptive, expressive and pragmatic language skills, his reading, writing, math, functional daily living skills and his social/emotional skills. The parties agreed that STUDENT=s strengths lie in visual processing, gross and fine motor skills, art, and self-help skills.
2. Program Designed to meet STUDENT=s needs In determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT=s needs, a review of the April 4, 2001 IEP is required. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. They are developed to meet the student=s unique needs and to provide the special education, related services and supplementary aides that will assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(A)(ii)(iii).
In this case, the April 4, 2001 IEP set forth goals and objectives to address STUDENT=s needs in expressive and receptive language, gross motor, sensory motor, math and math daily living skills, reading, writing, and social/emotional skills. The parties disputed whether the goals and objectives met STUDENT=s needs. Thus, an analysis of the goals and objectives as set forth in the IEP follows.
Goals and objectives (a) Expressive language
The evidence at the hearing established that the expressive language goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to use complex verbalizations to clarify and elongate sentences, to verbally produce 4-5 word sentences with a correct subject and verb, and to encourage safety in the community through the use of AWh@ questions about himself. STUDENT=s parents contended that the expressive language goals and objectives are inappropriate because their focus on STUDENT=s functional living needs is insufficient. However, neither Petitioner=s parents nor witnesses provided specific examples of the daily living skills that the expressive language goals should address to meet STUDENT=s functional living needs.
Ms. Bird testified that at the time the expressive language goals were written, STUDENT was more verbal, used more words, and relied less on his communication book to express himself. Both Ms. Bird and Ms. MOTHER testified that they want to continue to foster STUDENT=s growing verbal fluency. However, Ms. MOTHER wants the expressive language goal to only take a functional approach. Ms. Jan McCalister testified that before one can only take a functional approach to STUDENT=s expressive language skills, STUDENT must first have a solid foundation in the basics of language. Both Petitioner=s and Respondents= witnesses testified that STUDENT does not yet possess this solid foundation in language. Finally, Ms. MOTHER admitted that a solid foundation in his expressive language is an important skill upon which to later build Petitioner=s functional language skills.
The evidence at the hearing established that the District=s expressive language goals and objectives both build upon STUDENT=s present expressive language skills and focus on his functional living needs. First, the goals concentrate upon improving the complexity of STUDENT=s expressive language skills. They emphasize his use of complex verbalizations to clarify and elongate his sentences with minimal prompts, increase the length of his sentences by four or five words, and improve his proper use of subjects and verbs. Ms. Bird and Ms. McCalister testified that these skills are necessary for STUDENT to communicate properly.
The expressive language goals are also oriented toward STUDENT=s functional living skills. With regard to safety, they emphasize STUDENT=s response to AWh@ questions such as Awhat is your name?@ and Awhere do you live?@ The goals also concentrate on STUDENT=s use of corrected verbalizations when he is not understood. Moreover, the goals work on STUDENT=s responses to pictures and questions. Mr. Thieman testified that while these skills might seem simple, they are very important for an autistic child like STUDENT to help him move safely and independently around in his world. Ms. Sandy Reicher, Petitioner=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s expressive language needs.
The weight of the evidence, then, established that the expressive language goal and objectives were designed to improve and build upon STUDENT=s expressive language needs. First, the goal concentrates on improving the complexity of STUDENT=s expressive language skills so STUDENT can properly communicate. Second, the goal concentrates on functional living skills by working on safety, responses to pictures and questions, and the use of corrected verbalizations. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the expressive language goals and objectives were designed to both meet STUDENT=s academic and functional expressive communication needs.
(b) Receptive language
The receptive language goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to increase his understanding of verbs in order to comprehend what a speaker says to him. STUDENT=s parents contended that the goal was not appropriate because it did not serve his functional living needs. While neither Ms. MOTHER nor STUDENT=s experts specifically testified what the receptive language goal lacks to meet STUDENT=s daily living skills, Ms. MOTHER admitted that as STUDENT=s vocabulary, sentence structure, and ability to communicate improve, so does his ability to understand his surroundings and to take care of himself. Ms. Bird confirmed this point. She testified that STUDENT has steadily progressed in his receptive language skills. Furthermore, she explained that he has become very interested in words, had improved his ability to listen to and answer questions and point to pictures, and has learned to enjoy reading. Ms. Bird pointed out that as STUDENT improves his receptive language skills, he will be better equipped to read and to describe situations and objects in his environment around him. Mr. Thieman added that as STUDENT improves his receptive language skills, his ability to take part in society will also improve. Finally, Ms. Sandy Reicher, STUDENT=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet his receptive language needs.
The evidence established, then, that the receptive language goal serves the dual purpose of both increasing STUDENT=s receptive language vocabulary and his readiness to listen and take part in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the receptive language goal and objectives were designed to address STUDENT=s academic and functional living needs.
(c) Gross motor
The gross motor goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to improve his upper body strength. STUDENT=s parents contended that the goal is not appropriate because it does not promote his functional living needs. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT=s upper body strength plays a critical role in his daily life. She described, for example, how STUDENT lifts up large pieces of wood to build his large wood art sculptures, throws a basketball and baseball when he plays with his father, fishes and water skies with the family, and rides a horse to participate in equestrian competitions. Furthermore, Ms. Bill Thieman testified that STUDENT participates on the playground and partakes in different types of physical activities with his peers. All these physical activities described by both Ms. MOTHER and Mr. Thieman require good upper body strength. Finally, Ms. Sandy Reicher, Petitioner=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s gross motor needs.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT=s gross motor skills play a central role in the quality of his life. While the gross motor goal does not specifically target a specific set of functional living skills, the goal will both maintain STUDENT=s already substantial gross motor skills and improve upon his ability to continue to partake in life=s activities around him. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the gross motor goal was designed to meet STUDENT=s ongoing gross motor needs.
(d) Sensory Motor
The sensory motor goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to take in sensory information, modulate his response and act accordingly. While STUDENT=s parents contend that the goal does not meet his functional living needs, they provided no evidence regarding what the goal should include.
Respondent=s contended that the sensory motor goal was designed to meet STUDENT=s needs. Mr. Thieman and Mr. Joe Weber, Moreland school psychologist, testified that continued sensory motor training is critical for STUDENT to learn to make smooth transitions from one activity to another. While they pointed out that STUDENT makes relatively smooth transitions in the classroom and during class community outings to the supermarket, Burger King, the local museum etc., they emphasized that STUDENT needs to practice and reinforce his sensory motor needs because of his autism. If STUDENT does not practice his sensory motor skills, they emphasized that STUDENT could lose them. Finally, Ms. Reicher testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s continued sensory motor needs.
The evidence established, then, that while STUDENT has made progress in transitioning from one activity to another, he still requires improvement in this area. The goal serves the dual purpose of maintaining his past gains while fostering his future progress in this area of need. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the sensory motor goal and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT=s sensory motor needs.
(e) Math
The math goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to continue to develop his basic math skills while emphasizing their interrelation with his daily living needs. The math goal addresses STUDENT=s need to count mixed sets of coins in amounts up to a dollar, use a calculator to add numbers and the prices of items, and tell time on a clock. STUDENT=s parents contend that the goals are not appropriate to meet his daily living needs. With regard to the coin goal, they testified that it is not appropriate because STUDENT has been able to count coins at home to purchase candy and other sweets for two years. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT cannot count dollar bills. Mr. Thieman and Ms. Yamamoto testified that while STUDENT is able to add up a set pile of change or count the same denomination of a coin plus pennies, he can not gather and count a specific amount of change from a pile of mixed coins when requested to do so. They emphasized that STUDENT=s ability to count mixed sets of coins is important when STUDENT goes to the grocery store to buy food, pays for his bus fare, or makes change in general. With regard to the ability to use a calculator, the parties agreed that STUDENT could use a calculator when the goals were written. However, Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT needed to continue to practice and improve upon using a calculator for adding up sums of money when buying things or using large numbers in other situations in life.
With regard to the ability to tell time, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could already tell time on a digital clock but could not do so without a prompt. While Mr. Thieman agreed with Ms. MOTHER, he emphasized STUDENT=s need to learn to read a clock independently. Ms. Jan McCalister testified that it is important for STUDENT to independently tell time because he will not always have a one-to-one aide to help or to prompt him to do so.
While the evidence established that STUDENT already possessed some of the math skills that the math goal and objectives were written to achieve, the goals were designed to reinforce and build upon critical math skills that STUDENT will later need in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the math goal and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT=s mathematic needs while at the same time providing him with practical math skills to function independently in society.
(f) Reading
The reading goals are written to address STUDENT=s need to both develop his foundational reading skills and to emphasize their relation to his daily life. The goals emphasize STUDENT=s need to improve his ability to answer comprehension questions and follow written instructions without prompts, and to improve his Edmark vocabulary. STUDENT=s parents contend that the goals are not appropriate to meet STUDENT=s reading needs. With regard to reading comprehension, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could already comprehend questions when the April 4, 2001 IEP was written. Ms. Yamamoto, Ms. McCalister, and Mr. Thieman testified that while STUDENT can already answer general comprehension questions, he needs to build upon this skill, answer more complex comprehension questions, and do so independently. Finally, Mr. Thieman pointed out that while STUDENT can already answer some basic Awh@ questions such as Awho,@ Awhat,@ and Awhere,@ STUDENT needs to answer a broader range of questions on a more consistent and independent basis.
With regard to the STUDENT=s Edmark vocabulary, neither Mr. nor Ms. MOTHER had any knowledge about STUDENT=s present level in this reading program. Mr. Thieman testified that the Edmark program is a reading program that works on word recognition, matching pictures with words, and matching pictures with phrases. He testified that STUDENT has strong matching skills and that the Edmark program teaches by promoting STUDENT=s visual strengths in reading and matching and de-emphasizes the more traditional phonetic approach that is STUDENT=s weakness. Mr. Thieman pointed out that this program improves STUDENT=s vocabulary, speaking and reading fluency, and reading comprehension, and reinforces old Edmark Lessons that he has already learned. Dr. Sullivan, Ms. Reicher, Dr. McCalister, and Ms. Yamamoto all confirmed this point in their own testimony. By the May 30, 2001 IEP, Mr. Thieman, testified that STUDENT had reached an Edmark level of approximately 50 and he presently has reached a level of approximately 112. Thus, the Edmark program has proven very successful in building STUDENT=s vocabulary.
With regard to STUDENT=s need to read and follow instructions, this goal is written to improve STUDENT=s ability to read and follow a three-step recipe with no more than one prompt. Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT presently can read a recipe and make pancakes, eggs, hot dogs, macaroni and cheese, toast, peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, and pop corn. She also pointed out that STUDENT can read a measuring cup, and use the microwave and that he knows many other cooking items. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that she must remain with STUDENT the entire time he cooks. This reading goal, according to Ms. Yamamoto, was designed to help STUDENT to cook independently. Finally, Mr. Reicher testified that this goal was appropriate to meet STUDENT=s daily living needs.
While the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT already possessed an ability to comprehend simple questions, had started to increase is Edmark vocabulary, and was able to follow cooking instructions with help, Respondents established that he needed to increase his sophistication in these areas while at the same time doing so independently. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the reading goals were designed to meet STUDENT=s need to improve upon his reading capabilities while at the same time providing him with the practical skills to independently take care of his daily needs in life.
(g) Writing
The writing goal is written to address STUDENT=s need to write simple sentences and personal information without help. It emphasizes STUDENT=s need to independently write and type information about an object, action, activity and addresses. Although Ms. MOTHER contends that the goal is not appropriate to meet STUDENT=s daily living needs, she testified that STUDENT can neither write simple sentences or his home address, nor address envelopes to third persons. With regard to writing simple sentences, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT can listen to or read a simple story and write simple four- or five-word sentences, such as Athe car is blue.@ However, they testified that he needs to continue to build upon these skills in order to apply them to many other aspects of his daily life.
With regard to writing personal information, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT is still developing his skills in this area. For example, the goal includes an objective to legibly address an envelope without a model. Furthermore, Mr. Thieman testified that his daily lesson plans include many other tasks to address the need to write about different things in his life. For example, he pointed out that the children, with help, write grocery lists with the dollar amounts of items. Thereafter, he and the aides go with the children to the supermarket to purchase the items on the list. Mr. Thieman noted that the purpose of this activity is to teach the children how to write a grocery list, shop, and buy the products on the list. Mr. Thieman testified that the ability to discern what food one needs, write it down on a piece of paper, take the appropriate money and purchase the product is an important life skill that STUDENT needs to master.
Respondents, then, presented persuasive evidence that the writing goal serves the dual purpose of improving upon STUDENT=s writing skills while at the same time teaching him writing skills that will serve him in his daily life. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the writing goal meets STUDENT=s academic and functional writing needs.
(h) Social/emotional needs
The social/emotional goals are written to address STUDENT=s needs to participate in cooperative work or play activities with peers with and without prompts. STUDENT=s mother testified that this goal is not designed to meet STUDENT=s social needs because similar goals in the past have resulted in little to no improvement in this skill at home when STUDENT played with his brother. However, Ms. MOTHER testified, as outlined earlier, that STUDENT plays with neighborhood children and cousins on the weekend, partakes in equestrian contests on the weekend, and is beginning to take part in groups at church. Mr. Thieman testified that while STUDENT preferred to interact with adults and required additional help when he socialized with peers in class, he concurred that his social skills are improving. He explained that this goal is designed to continue STUDENT=s progress in this area of need and to help him interact with his peers. Finally, Ms. Reicher testified that this goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s social needs.
While the evidence established that STUDENT possesses some social skills, Respondents presented convincing evidence that STUDENT=s social/emotional skills still require improvement for him to successfully interact with typically developing peers in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the social/emotional goals continue to improve STUDENT=s social skills training while at the same time providing him with the opportunity to improve his interpersonal skills with other children of his own age.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives in the April 4, 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT=s needs in expressive and receptive language, math, reading, writing, gross and sensory motor and social/emotional needs while at the same time providing him with the opportunity to improve and broaden his personal, social, and community based skills for daily life.
Specific placement and services
In addition to disputing the appropriateness of the goals and objectives, the parties also disputed whether the placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga Elementary School for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year placed a sufficient emphasis on STUDENT=s functional needs. The parties agreed that the teacher, Mr. Bill Thieman, the occupational therapist, Ms. Marion Tabuchi, the in-class speech and language specialist, Mr. Terry Brown, the County-funded private speech and language specialist, Ms. Bird, and the one-to-one aides in the Autism Project are qualified to teach the class. Furthermore, Petitioner did not dispute that the class environment in the Autism Project is presently consistent, stable, and structured. However, the parties disputed whether the structure of the Autism Project placed enough emphasis on STUDENT=s functional living needs. A review of the evidence follows.
(a) Classroom structure and STUDENT=s functional living needs
While STUDENT=s parents proposed that daily living skills be the primary focus of his educational program, Moreland and Santa Clara contended that STUDENT required a balanced approach between his daily living skills and academics. With regard to the parents= contention that daily living skills should be the primary focus of STUDENT=s program, Dr. Sullivan testified that living skills are an important part of his education and that the class curriculum should be functionally based. However, she also testified that STUDENT=s class should be language-based to provide him with the necessary skills to function in society. Mr. Weber and Ms. McCalister agreed that a purely academic approach to STUDENT=s curriculum was counterproductive. However, Ms. McCalister emphasized that STUDENT needs a Agood mix@ of Aacademic growth@ and Afunctional skills.@ Furthermore, she explained that STUDENT first needs to acquire the foundational academic skills before he can solely pursue only functional life skills. Both Petitioner=s and Respondents= witnesses agreed that STUDENT has not yet mastered his foundational skills in speech, reading, writing, and math.
While STUDENT=s parents contended that STUDENT needs to learn many life skills, the evidence established that STUDENT has already developed many daily living skills that would benefit from a good academic foundation and would promote his independence in the future. Ms. MOTHER described STUDENT=s large repertoire of daily life skills. For example, she described STUDENT=s morning routine. In the morning, STUDENT gets up alone, brushes his teeth with a few prompts, takes care of his own hygienic needs, dresses himself, makes his own bed, and prepares his own sandwich and scramble eggs with supervision. With regard to traveling to school, Ms. MOTHER also pointed out that STUDENT can independently ride the bus to and from school. With regard to his personal safety, she testified that STUDENT can answer AWh@ questions about himself to promote his safety in the community. Finally, Ms. MOTHER described how STUDENT plays with cousins and friends next door on the weekend and partakes in equestrian competitions.
STUDENT=s parents, however, testified that STUDENT needs more work with money, telling time, making grocery lists and buying groceries independently, and developing daily living skills necessary to function in the world and work force. The evidence established that Mr. Bill Thieman works on many of these basic life skills, which are also incorporated in STUDENT=s IEP. For example, Mr. Thieman and the children write individual grocery shopping lists, the class goes to the supermarket, and the children individually practice purchasing items on the shopping list. Furthermore, they practice their money handling skills while at the supermarket. On the way to the supermarket, Burger King, or other stores in the vicinity, the class also practices safety skills and getting from the starting point to the desired end point. Finally, Mr. Thieman also described how the students, pursuant to their individual IEPs, also practice money handling and counting in class, cooking, reading safety signs, etc.
While there was no evidence that Mr. Thieman=s class instructed STUDENT to develop specific skills for employment, Respondents established that the Autism Project will instruct STUDENT on many of the necessary daily life skills that will later serve as the foundation for future employment. The Hearing Officer finds, then, that the County Autism Project can provide STUDENT with a mix of academics and daily life skills that will later facilitate placing a greater emphasis and weight on his daily life skills.
3. Educational benefit
While Petitioner contended that placement in the County Autism Project would not provide him with any educational benefit, both Moreland and Santa Clara countered that it had the elements in place to do so. With regard to STUDENT=s speech and language needs, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that the placement would continue to build upon STUDENT=s ability to read, recognize words, speak, answer reading comprehension questions, and write sentences through both the Edmark Program and the daily speech exercises in those areas. Furthermore, the circle time, art time, recess, physical education, and community outings would provide STUDENT with additional time to practice his language skills with his peers, teachers, and other people in society. STUDENT=s parents and Dr. Sullivan did admit that STUDENT had made progress in his speech and communication and that he should remain with Ms. Bird to continue this progress. Neither Moreland nor Santa Clara indicated any intention to either discontinue Ms. Bird=s services for STUDENT or reduce the amount of speech and language STUDENT received in class.
With regard to STUDENT=s reading and writing needs, the Respondents= witnesses testified that the County Autism Project promotes these two needs through the Edmark Program, the variety in the daily classroom schedule and during community outings. Mr. Thieman testified that in class STUDENT would have specific lessons to work on his reading and writing. He described how in the community the class works on reading traffic signs, reading and writing grocery lists, reading menus at fast food restaurants etc. With regard to STUDENT=s math needs, Mr. Thieman testified that he takes a functional approach to meeting STUDENT=s needs in math by teaching STUDENT to identify and count money, add and subtract on a calculator, buy food and objects in the community, tell time on a digital clock, etc.
With regard to STUDENT=s sensory motor needs, the parties agreed that Mr. Thieman=s class is very structured and helps STUDENT to make transitions. As discussed above, Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s witnesses established that the teacher and staff are stable in the class. This stability also promote STUDENT=s ability to transition easily from task to task. With regard to STUDENT=s social/emotional needs, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that the County Autism Project would continue to provide STUDENT with opportunities to develop these skills. In class, he would interact with his peers during circle time, recess and community outings. During lunch, STUDENT would have the opportunity to interact with both classmates and typically developing peers. Finally, with regard to STUDENT=s daily living skills, Mr. Thieman and Ms. Yamamoto testified that the County Autism Project infused these skills into both his academics and in the community outings throughout the day.
In summary, Respondents presented persuasive evidence that the County Autism Project is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because it works on all his areas of need, employs various educational vehicles both in and outside the class to work on those needs, and also has a functional living approach that is practical. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement in the County Autism Project is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
4. Least restrictive environment
In this case, the parties agreed that STUDENT could not take part in a regular education class because of his autism. However, the parties disputed whether the County Autism Project or PACE was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. STUDENT=s parents testified that he needed the more restrictive environment at PACE. However, the evidence at the hearing indicated otherwise. First, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT=s social skills are his strength and he benefits from interacting with other children and adults. Ms. MOTHER pointed out that STUDENT plays with his cousins and neighborhood children on the weekend, partakes in equestrian competitions with other autistic children, and participates in various physical activities in public with both adults and non-autistic children. Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT interacts well with both the autistic children in the County Autism Project and the regular education students on campus during lunch, recess, and events on campus such as a recent concert. Finally, STUDENT=s parents admitted and the evidence has established that he has made progress in the past at the County Autism project.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT possesses the social and emotional skills to take part in a school environment that promotes social interaction between himself and other students, and the community. A school environment that does not maximize these social interactions STUDENT=s peers and the community would be too restrictive and not serve his needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the County Autism Project is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
Conclusion
In this case, Petitioner expressed a deep concern that his educational program must take a functional approach for him to successfully integrate into, contribute to, and function in society at a later date. While Petitioner argued that Respondent=s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year placed an inadequate emphasis on STUDENT=s functional life skills, the totality of the evidence on this issue established that Respondents offered a program with a reasonable balance between both STUDENT=s ongoing academic and functional living needs. First, the goals and objectives strove to build upon STUDENT=s emerging expressive and receptive language, gross motor skills, sensory motor skills, math, reading, writing, and social/emotional skills while infusing functional living skills. Second, the placement in the County Autism Project was structured to promote both STUDENT=s academic and functional living needs. Third, the teachers and services of the Autism Project were designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Finally, the class is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT because it offers him the opportunity to interact and learn with classmates, typically developing peers, and other people in society. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s offer of placement and services at the County Autism Project offered STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year.
ISSUE 5: If Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, does Petitioner require placement at the Pacific Autism Autism Center for Education (PACE) to receive a FAPE?
The Hearing Officer does not reach this issue because Moreland and Santa Clara County offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Moreland Elementary School District, Santa Clara County Office of Education, and Cambrian Elementary School District prevailed on each issue in this case.
ORDER
All of Petitioner=s requests for relief are denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code ' 56505(i).
Dated: July 19, 2002 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
In determining whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT=s needs, a review of the April 4, 2001 IEP is required. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. They are developed to meet the student=s unique needs and to provide the special education, related services and supplementary aides that will assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(A)(ii)(iii).
In this case, the April 4, 2001 IEP set forth goals and objectives to address STUDENT=s needs in expressive and receptive language, gross motor, sensory motor, math and math daily living skills, reading, writing, and social/emotional skills. The parties disputed whether the goals and objectives met STUDENT=s needs. Thus, an analysis of the goals and objectives as set forth in the IEP follows.
Goals and objectives (a) Expressive language
The evidence at the hearing established that the expressive language goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to use complex verbalizations to clarify and elongate sentences, to verbally produce 4-5 word sentences with a correct subject and verb, and to encourage safety in the community through the use of AWh@ questions about himself. STUDENT=s parents contended that the expressive language goals and objectives are inappropriate because their focus on STUDENT=s functional living needs is insufficient. However, neither Petitioner=s parents nor witnesses provided specific examples of the daily living skills that the expressive language goals should address to meet STUDENT=s functional living needs.
Ms. Bird testified that at the time the expressive language goals were written, STUDENT was more verbal, used more words, and relied less on his communication book to express himself. Both Ms. Bird and Ms. MOTHER testified that they want to continue to foster STUDENT=s growing verbal fluency. However, Ms. MOTHER wants the expressive language goal to only take a functional approach. Ms. Jan McCalister testified that before one can only take a functional approach to STUDENT=s expressive language skills, STUDENT must first have a solid foundation in the basics of language. Both Petitioner=s and Respondents= witnesses testified that STUDENT does not yet possess this solid foundation in language. Finally, Ms. MOTHER admitted that a solid foundation in his expressive language is an important skill upon which to later build Petitioner=s functional language skills.
The evidence at the hearing established that the District=s expressive language goals and objectives both build upon STUDENT=s present expressive language skills and focus on his functional living needs. First, the goals concentrate upon improving the complexity of STUDENT=s expressive language skills. They emphasize his use of complex verbalizations to clarify and elongate his sentences with minimal prompts, increase the length of his sentences by four or five words, and improve his proper use of subjects and verbs. Ms. Bird and Ms. McCalister testified that these skills are necessary for STUDENT to communicate properly.
The expressive language goals are also oriented toward STUDENT=s functional living skills. With regard to safety, they emphasize STUDENT=s response to AWh@ questions such as Awhat is your name?@ and Awhere do you live?@ The goals also concentrate on STUDENT=s use of corrected verbalizations when he is not understood. Moreover, the goals work on STUDENT=s responses to pictures and questions. Mr. Thieman testified that while these skills might seem simple, they are very important for an autistic child like STUDENT to help him move safely and independently around in his world. Ms. Sandy Reicher, Petitioner=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s expressive language needs.
The weight of the evidence, then, established that the expressive language goal and objectives were designed to improve and build upon STUDENT=s expressive language needs. First, the goal concentrates on improving the complexity of STUDENT=s expressive language skills so STUDENT can properly communicate. Second, the goal concentrates on functional living skills by working on safety, responses to pictures and questions, and the use of corrected verbalizations. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the expressive language goals and objectives were designed to both meet STUDENT=s academic and functional expressive communication needs.
(b) Receptive language
The receptive language goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to increase his understanding of verbs in order to comprehend what a speaker says to him. STUDENT=s parents contended that the goal was not appropriate because it did not serve his functional living needs. While neither Ms. MOTHER nor STUDENT=s experts specifically testified what the receptive language goal lacks to meet STUDENT=s daily living skills, Ms. MOTHER admitted that as STUDENT=s vocabulary, sentence structure, and ability to communicate improve, so does his ability to understand his surroundings and to take care of himself. Ms. Bird confirmed this point. She testified that STUDENT has steadily progressed in his receptive language skills. Furthermore, she explained that he has become very interested in words, had improved his ability to listen to and answer questions and point to pictures, and has learned to enjoy reading. Ms. Bird pointed out that as STUDENT improves his receptive language skills, he will be better equipped to read and to describe situations and objects in his environment around him. Mr. Thieman added that as STUDENT improves his receptive language skills, his ability to take part in society will also improve. Finally, Ms. Sandy Reicher, STUDENT=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet his receptive language needs.
The evidence established, then, that the receptive language goal serves the dual purpose of both increasing STUDENT=s receptive language vocabulary and his readiness to listen and take part in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the receptive language goal and objectives were designed to address STUDENT=s academic and functional living needs.
(c) Gross motor
The gross motor goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to improve his upper body strength. STUDENT=s parents contended that the goal is not appropriate because it does not promote his functional living needs. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT=s upper body strength plays a critical role in his daily life. She described, for example, how STUDENT lifts up large pieces of wood to build his large wood art sculptures, throws a basketball and baseball when he plays with his father, fishes and water skies with the family, and rides a horse to participate in equestrian competitions. Furthermore, Ms. Bill Thieman testified that STUDENT participates on the playground and partakes in different types of physical activities with his peers. All these physical activities described by both Ms. MOTHER and Mr. Thieman require good upper body strength. Finally, Ms. Sandy Reicher, Petitioner=s expert from PACE, testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s gross motor needs.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT=s gross motor skills play a central role in the quality of his life. While the gross motor goal does not specifically target a specific set of functional living skills, the goal will both maintain STUDENT=s already substantial gross motor skills and improve upon his ability to continue to partake in life=s activities around him. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the gross motor goal was designed to meet STUDENT=s ongoing gross motor needs.
(d) Sensory Motor
The sensory motor goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to take in sensory information, modulate his response and act accordingly. While STUDENT=s parents contend that the goal does not meet his functional living needs, they provided no evidence regarding what the goal should include.
Respondent=s contended that the sensory motor goal was designed to meet STUDENT=s needs. Mr. Thieman and Mr. Joe Weber, Moreland school psychologist, testified that continued sensory motor training is critical for STUDENT to learn to make smooth transitions from one activity to another. While they pointed out that STUDENT makes relatively smooth transitions in the classroom and during class community outings to the supermarket, Burger King, the local museum etc., they emphasized that STUDENT needs to practice and reinforce his sensory motor needs because of his autism. If STUDENT does not practice his sensory motor skills, they emphasized that STUDENT could lose them. Finally, Ms. Reicher testified that the goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s continued sensory motor needs.
The evidence established, then, that while STUDENT has made progress in transitioning from one activity to another, he still requires improvement in this area. The goal serves the dual purpose of maintaining his past gains while fostering his future progress in this area of need. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the sensory motor goal and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT=s sensory motor needs.
(e) Math
The math goal and objectives are written to address STUDENT=s need to continue to develop his basic math skills while emphasizing their interrelation with his daily living needs. The math goal addresses STUDENT=s need to count mixed sets of coins in amounts up to a dollar, use a calculator to add numbers and the prices of items, and tell time on a clock. STUDENT=s parents contend that the goals are not appropriate to meet his daily living needs. With regard to the coin goal, they testified that it is not appropriate because STUDENT has been able to count coins at home to purchase candy and other sweets for two years. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT cannot count dollar bills. Mr. Thieman and Ms. Yamamoto testified that while STUDENT is able to add up a set pile of change or count the same denomination of a coin plus pennies, he can not gather and count a specific amount of change from a pile of mixed coins when requested to do so. They emphasized that STUDENT=s ability to count mixed sets of coins is important when STUDENT goes to the grocery store to buy food, pays for his bus fare, or makes change in general. With regard to the ability to use a calculator, the parties agreed that STUDENT could use a calculator when the goals were written. However, Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT needed to continue to practice and improve upon using a calculator for adding up sums of money when buying things or using large numbers in other situations in life.
With regard to the ability to tell time, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could already tell time on a digital clock but could not do so without a prompt. While Mr. Thieman agreed with Ms. MOTHER, he emphasized STUDENT=s need to learn to read a clock independently. Ms. Jan McCalister testified that it is important for STUDENT to independently tell time because he will not always have a one-to-one aide to help or to prompt him to do so.
While the evidence established that STUDENT already possessed some of the math skills that the math goal and objectives were written to achieve, the goals were designed to reinforce and build upon critical math skills that STUDENT will later need in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the math goal and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT=s mathematic needs while at the same time providing him with practical math skills to function independently in society.
(f) Reading
The reading goals are written to address STUDENT=s need to both develop his foundational reading skills and to emphasize their relation to his daily life. The goals emphasize STUDENT=s need to improve his ability to answer comprehension questions and follow written instructions without prompts, and to improve his Edmark vocabulary. STUDENT=s parents contend that the goals are not appropriate to meet STUDENT=s reading needs. With regard to reading comprehension, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could already comprehend questions when the April 4, 2001 IEP was written. Ms. Yamamoto, Ms. McCalister, and Mr. Thieman testified that while STUDENT can already answer general comprehension questions, he needs to build upon this skill, answer more complex comprehension questions, and do so independently. Finally, Mr. Thieman pointed out that while STUDENT can already answer some basic Awh@ questions such as Awho,@ Awhat,@ and Awhere,@ STUDENT needs to answer a broader range of questions on a more consistent and independent basis.
With regard to the STUDENT=s Edmark vocabulary, neither Mr. nor Ms. MOTHER had any knowledge about STUDENT=s present level in this reading program. Mr. Thieman testified that the Edmark program is a reading program that works on word recognition, matching pictures with words, and matching pictures with phrases. He testified that STUDENT has strong matching skills and that the Edmark program teaches by promoting STUDENT=s visual strengths in reading and matching and de-emphasizes the more traditional phonetic approach that is STUDENT=s weakness. Mr. Thieman pointed out that this program improves STUDENT=s vocabulary, speaking and reading fluency, and reading comprehension, and reinforces old Edmark Lessons that he has already learned. Dr. Sullivan, Ms. Reicher, Dr. McCalister, and Ms. Yamamoto all confirmed this point in their own testimony. By the May 30, 2001 IEP, Mr. Thieman, testified that STUDENT had reached an Edmark level of approximately 50 and he presently has reached a level of approximately 112. Thus, the Edmark program has proven very successful in building STUDENT=s vocabulary.
With regard to STUDENT=s need to read and follow instructions, this goal is written to improve STUDENT=s ability to read and follow a three-step recipe with no more than one prompt. Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT presently can read a recipe and make pancakes, eggs, hot dogs, macaroni and cheese, toast, peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, and pop corn. She also pointed out that STUDENT can read a measuring cup, and use the microwave and that he knows many other cooking items. However, Ms. MOTHER testified that she must remain with STUDENT the entire time he cooks. This reading goal, according to Ms. Yamamoto, was designed to help STUDENT to cook independently. Finally, Mr. Reicher testified that this goal was appropriate to meet STUDENT=s daily living needs.
While the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT already possessed an ability to comprehend simple questions, had started to increase is Edmark vocabulary, and was able to follow cooking instructions with help, Respondents established that he needed to increase his sophistication in these areas while at the same time doing so independently. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the reading goals were designed to meet STUDENT=s need to improve upon his reading capabilities while at the same time providing him with the practical skills to independently take care of his daily needs in life.
(g) Writing
The writing goal is written to address STUDENT=s need to write simple sentences and personal information without help. It emphasizes STUDENT=s need to independently write and type information about an object, action, activity and addresses. Although Ms. MOTHER contends that the goal is not appropriate to meet STUDENT=s daily living needs, she testified that STUDENT can neither write simple sentences or his home address, nor address envelopes to third persons. With regard to writing simple sentences, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT can listen to or read a simple story and write simple four- or five-word sentences, such as Athe car is blue.@ However, they testified that he needs to continue to build upon these skills in order to apply them to many other aspects of his daily life.
With regard to writing personal information, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT is still developing his skills in this area. For example, the goal includes an objective to legibly address an envelope without a model. Furthermore, Mr. Thieman testified that his daily lesson plans include many other tasks to address the need to write about different things in his life. For example, he pointed out that the children, with help, write grocery lists with the dollar amounts of items. Thereafter, he and the aides go with the children to the supermarket to purchase the items on the list. Mr. Thieman noted that the purpose of this activity is to teach the children how to write a grocery list, shop, and buy the products on the list. Mr. Thieman testified that the ability to discern what food one needs, write it down on a piece of paper, take the appropriate money and purchase the product is an important life skill that STUDENT needs to master.
Respondents, then, presented persuasive evidence that the writing goal serves the dual purpose of improving upon STUDENT=s writing skills while at the same time teaching him writing skills that will serve him in his daily life. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the writing goal meets STUDENT=s academic and functional writing needs.
(h) Social/emotional needs
The social/emotional goals are written to address STUDENT=s needs to participate in cooperative work or play activities with peers with and without prompts. STUDENT=s mother testified that this goal is not designed to meet STUDENT=s social needs because similar goals in the past have resulted in little to no improvement in this skill at home when STUDENT played with his brother. However, Ms. MOTHER testified, as outlined earlier, that STUDENT plays with neighborhood children and cousins on the weekend, partakes in equestrian contests on the weekend, and is beginning to take part in groups at church. Mr. Thieman testified that while STUDENT preferred to interact with adults and required additional help when he socialized with peers in class, he concurred that his social skills are improving. He explained that this goal is designed to continue STUDENT=s progress in this area of need and to help him interact with his peers. Finally, Ms. Reicher testified that this goal is appropriate to meet STUDENT=s social needs.
While the evidence established that STUDENT possesses some social skills, Respondents presented convincing evidence that STUDENT=s social/emotional skills still require improvement for him to successfully interact with typically developing peers in society. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the social/emotional goals continue to improve STUDENT=s social skills training while at the same time providing him with the opportunity to improve his interpersonal skills with other children of his own age.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives in the April 4, 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT=s needs in expressive and receptive language, math, reading, writing, gross and sensory motor and social/emotional needs while at the same time providing him with the opportunity to improve and broaden his personal, social, and community based skills for daily life.
Specific placement and services
In addition to disputing the appropriateness of the goals and objectives, the parties also disputed whether the placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga Elementary School for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year placed a sufficient emphasis on STUDENT=s functional needs. The parties agreed that the teacher, Mr. Bill Thieman, the occupational therapist, Ms. Marion Tabuchi, the in-class speech and language specialist, Mr. Terry Brown, the County-funded private speech and language specialist, Ms. Bird, and the one-to-one aides in the Autism Project are qualified to teach the class. Furthermore, Petitioner did not dispute that the class environment in the Autism Project is presently consistent, stable, and structured. However, the parties disputed whether the structure of the Autism Project placed enough emphasis on STUDENT=s functional living needs. A review of the evidence follows.
(a) Classroom structure and STUDENT=s functional living needs
While STUDENT=s parents proposed that daily living skills be the primary focus of his educational program, Moreland and Santa Clara contended that STUDENT required a balanced approach between his daily living skills and academics. With regard to the parents= contention that daily living skills should be the primary focus of STUDENT=s program, Dr. Sullivan testified that living skills are an important part of his education and that the class curriculum should be functionally based. However, she also testified that STUDENT=s class should be language-based to provide him with the necessary skills to function in society. Mr. Weber and Ms. McCalister agreed that a purely academic approach to STUDENT=s curriculum was counterproductive. However, Ms. McCalister emphasized that STUDENT needs a Agood mix@ of Aacademic growth@ and Afunctional skills.@ Furthermore, she explained that STUDENT first needs to acquire the foundational academic skills before he can solely pursue only functional life skills. Both Petitioner=s and Respondents= witnesses agreed that STUDENT has not yet mastered his foundational skills in speech, reading, writing, and math.
While STUDENT=s parents contended that STUDENT needs to learn many life skills, the evidence established that STUDENT has already developed many daily living skills that would benefit from a good academic foundation and would promote his independence in the future. Ms. MOTHER described STUDENT=s large repertoire of daily life skills. For example, she described STUDENT=s morning routine. In the morning, STUDENT gets up alone, brushes his teeth with a few prompts, takes care of his own hygienic needs, dresses himself, makes his own bed, and prepares his own sandwich and scramble eggs with supervision. With regard to traveling to school, Ms. MOTHER also pointed out that STUDENT can independently ride the bus to and from school. With regard to his personal safety, she testified that STUDENT can answer AWh@ questions about himself to promote his safety in the community. Finally, Ms. MOTHER described how STUDENT plays with cousins and friends next door on the weekend and partakes in equestrian competitions.
STUDENT=s parents, however, testified that STUDENT needs more work with money, telling time, making grocery lists and buying groceries independently, and developing daily living skills necessary to function in the world and work force. The evidence established that Mr. Bill Thieman works on many of these basic life skills, which are also incorporated in STUDENT=s IEP. For example, Mr. Thieman and the children write individual grocery shopping lists, the class goes to the supermarket, and the children individually practice purchasing items on the shopping list. Furthermore, they practice their money handling skills while at the supermarket. On the way to the supermarket, Burger King, or other stores in the vicinity, the class also practices safety skills and getting from the starting point to the desired end point. Finally, Mr. Thieman also described how the students, pursuant to their individual IEPs, also practice money handling and counting in class, cooking, reading safety signs, etc.
While there was no evidence that Mr. Thieman=s class instructed STUDENT to develop specific skills for employment, Respondents established that the Autism Project will instruct STUDENT on many of the necessary daily life skills that will later serve as the foundation for future employment. The Hearing Officer finds, then, that the County Autism Project can provide STUDENT with a mix of academics and daily life skills that will later facilitate placing a greater emphasis and weight on his daily life skills.
3. Educational benefit
While Petitioner contended that placement in the County Autism Project would not provide him with any educational benefit, both Moreland and Santa Clara countered that it had the elements in place to do so. With regard to STUDENT=s speech and language needs, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that the placement would continue to build upon STUDENT=s ability to read, recognize words, speak, answer reading comprehension questions, and write sentences through both the Edmark Program and the daily speech exercises in those areas. Furthermore, the circle time, art time, recess, physical education, and community outings would provide STUDENT with additional time to practice his language skills with his peers, teachers, and other people in society. STUDENT=s parents and Dr. Sullivan did admit that STUDENT had made progress in his speech and communication and that he should remain with Ms. Bird to continue this progress. Neither Moreland nor Santa Clara indicated any intention to either discontinue Ms. Bird=s services for STUDENT or reduce the amount of speech and language STUDENT received in class.
With regard to STUDENT=s reading and writing needs, the Respondents= witnesses testified that the County Autism Project promotes these two needs through the Edmark Program, the variety in the daily classroom schedule and during community outings. Mr. Thieman testified that in class STUDENT would have specific lessons to work on his reading and writing. He described how in the community the class works on reading traffic signs, reading and writing grocery lists, reading menus at fast food restaurants etc. With regard to STUDENT=s math needs, Mr. Thieman testified that he takes a functional approach to meeting STUDENT=s needs in math by teaching STUDENT to identify and count money, add and subtract on a calculator, buy food and objects in the community, tell time on a digital clock, etc.
With regard to STUDENT=s sensory motor needs, the parties agreed that Mr. Thieman=s class is very structured and helps STUDENT to make transitions. As discussed above, Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s witnesses established that the teacher and staff are stable in the class. This stability also promote STUDENT=s ability to transition easily from task to task. With regard to STUDENT=s social/emotional needs, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that the County Autism Project would continue to provide STUDENT with opportunities to develop these skills. In class, he would interact with his peers during circle time, recess and community outings. During lunch, STUDENT would have the opportunity to interact with both classmates and typically developing peers. Finally, with regard to STUDENT=s daily living skills, Mr. Thieman and Ms. Yamamoto testified that the County Autism Project infused these skills into both his academics and in the community outings throughout the day.
In summary, Respondents presented persuasive evidence that the County Autism Project is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because it works on all his areas of need, employs various educational vehicles both in and outside the class to work on those needs, and also has a functional living approach that is practical. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement in the County Autism Project is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
4. Least restrictive environment
In this case, the parties agreed that STUDENT could not take part in a regular education class because of his autism. However, the parties disputed whether the County Autism Project or PACE was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. STUDENT=s parents testified that he needed the more restrictive environment at PACE. However, the evidence at the hearing indicated otherwise. First, Ms. MOTHER testified that STUDENT=s social skills are his strength and he benefits from interacting with other children and adults. Ms. MOTHER pointed out that STUDENT plays with his cousins and neighborhood children on the weekend, partakes in equestrian competitions with other autistic children, and participates in various physical activities in public with both adults and non-autistic children. Furthermore, Ms. Yamamoto and Mr. Thieman testified that STUDENT interacts well with both the autistic children in the County Autism Project and the regular education students on campus during lunch, recess, and events on campus such as a recent concert. Finally, STUDENT=s parents admitted and the evidence has established that he has made progress in the past at the County Autism project.
The evidence established, then, that STUDENT possesses the social and emotional skills to take part in a school environment that promotes social interaction between himself and other students, and the community. A school environment that does not maximize these social interactions STUDENT=s peers and the community would be too restrictive and not serve his needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the County Autism Project is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
Conclusion
In this case, Petitioner expressed a deep concern that his educational program must take a functional approach for him to successfully integrate into, contribute to, and function in society at a later date. While Petitioner argued that Respondent=s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year placed an inadequate emphasis on STUDENT=s functional life skills, the totality of the evidence on this issue established that Respondents offered a program with a reasonable balance between both STUDENT=s ongoing academic and functional living needs. First, the goals and objectives strove to build upon STUDENT=s emerging expressive and receptive language, gross motor skills, sensory motor skills, math, reading, writing, and social/emotional skills while infusing functional living skills. Second, the placement in the County Autism Project was structured to promote both STUDENT=s academic and functional living needs. Third, the teachers and services of the Autism Project were designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Finally, the class is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT because it offers him the opportunity to interact and learn with classmates, typically developing peers, and other people in society. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s offer of placement and services at the County Autism Project offered STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year.
ISSUE 5: If Moreland=s and Santa Clara=s offer of placement and services in the County Autism Project at Saratoga for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, does Petitioner require placement at the Pacific Autism Autism Center for Education (PACE) to receive a FAPE?
The Hearing Officer does not reach this issue because Moreland and Santa Clara County offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Moreland Elementary School District, Santa Clara County Office of Education, and Cambrian Elementary School District prevailed on each issue in this case.
ORDER
All of Petitioner=s requests for relief are denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to
