California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 23, 2004

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 175-04 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley

Los Angeles Unified must fund two hours weekly of direct speech therapy, 18 compensatory hours, and parent reimbursement.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions an earlier due process case (SN02-01850) that settled at mediation on October 24, 2002, with an addendum on March 10, 2003.

Summary

A 20-year-old 12th grader at Gardena High School filed against Los Angeles Unified School District. He was eligible for special education under the category then called mental retardation, now intellectual disability. He attended a community-based instruction class that teaches functional life skills. He has a severe articulation disorder and dyspraxia (a motor speech disorder), so his speech was often hard to understand. Under a 2002 mediation agreement, he received about two hours a week of direct speech therapy from a nonpublic agency, Lynne Alba Speech Therapy. In November 2003, the District offered no direct therapy, only classroom consultation (15 minutes a month) and collaboration (20 minutes a week). During the hearing, the parties settled separate visual-motor and assistive technology claims.

Hearing Officer Christian Hurley found that the offer denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE). He credited the student's therapist, Andrea Trow, whose reports showed real gains with more intensive therapy. He also credited teachers and an independent living skills instructor who saw improvement. The classroom teachers had no speech training and little one-on-one time. The District's specialists knew the student less well. The Hearing Officer found that the student needed two hours a week of direct therapy plus the classroom services. He ordered the District to fund that therapy at Lynne Alba. He also ordered 18 hours of compensatory therapy and reimbursement of the parents' payments for an extra 30 minutes a week since November 14, 2003.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how the Special Education Hearing Office handled a district's switch from direct speech therapy to classroom consultation alone for a student with an intellectual disability. The Hearing Officer relied on the treating therapist's progress data and on the teachers' lack of training and time. He rejected the district's argument that the student had reached maximum benefit from therapy.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services?

    The District's offer of classroom consultation (15 minutes a month) and collaboration (20 minutes a week) with no direct therapy did not meet the student's unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The student needs two hours a week of direct speech therapy plus consultation and collaboration.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy through Lynne Alba Speech Therapy?

    The student received one hour of therapy a week instead of the two he needed for about 18 weeks after November 14, 2003, so the Hearing Officer awarded 18 hours of compensatory speech therapy at Lynne Alba.

  3. Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for out of pocket expenses incurred for the thirty minutes of NPA speech therapy per week that Petitioner's parents have funded from the date of the District's offer of November 14, 2003 to the date of this Decision?

    The parent-funded 30 minutes a week of therapy with Ms. Trow was appropriate and provided educational benefit, so the parents are entitled to reimbursement from November 14, 2003 to the decision date.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. The District must provide two hours per week of direct speech therapy at the current nonpublic agency, Lynne Alba. This is in addition to the 'classroom consultation' and 'collaborative therapy' the District offered. The order as written says 20 minutes per month of consultation and 15 minutes per week of collaboration, which reverses the offer (15 minutes per month of consultation, 20 minutes per week of collaboration). Lynne Alba is to provide the consultation and collaboration unless the District has qualified personnel.
  • Compensatory education. 18 hours of compensatory direct speech therapy at Lynne Alba.
  • Reimbursement. The District must reimburse the parents' out-of-pocket costs for 30 minutes per week of speech therapy at Lynne Alba from November 14, 2003 to the decision date, within 15 days of receiving proof of costs. No dollar amount was stated.

Total: 18 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education; Daniel R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Adria Bryant, educational advocate for Student
  • Barbara Baum, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Trevin Sims, attorney for District, Lozano Smith
  • Kamera Washington, independent living skills instructor, Giant Steps
  • Whitney (Whitley) Gardiner, special day class teacher, Gardena High School
  • Ms. Carlson, co-teacher, Gardena High School
  • Sidonie Smith, District speech and language specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Andrea Trow, nonpublic agency speech and language therapist, Children's Speech Care Center division of Lynne Alba Speech Therapy
  • Lynne Alba Speech Therapy, nonpublic agency
  • Linda Lerner-Simon, District school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • R. Ljuba, District speech and language therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • K. Jagarlamundi, District speech and language therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Jolene Bowman, District school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Deanna Williams, school psychology intern, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Jean Lee, District resource specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Brooke Felmar, District speech and language therapist (augmentative and alternative communication assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Giant Steps, independent living skills provider (regional center vendor)
  • UCLA Medical Center Speech Pathology Clinic, independent speech assessor

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. The matter proceeded to hearing in Los Angeles, California, on February 19, 20, 24, and 25, 2004.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Linda J. Boyd of the Education Empowerment Program. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and his educational advocate, Adria Bryant. STUDENT and his father, FATHER, attended portions of the hearing as well. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Mary Kellogg of Lozano Smith. Attorney Trevin Sims, also of Lozano Smith, attended the first day of hearing. Also present on the behalf of the District was Barbara Baum, due process specialist.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Kamera Washington, STUDENT’s independent living skills instructor; Whitney Gardiner, STUDENT’s teacher; Sidonie Smith, District speech and language specialist; and Andrea Trow, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist. The District called the following witness: Linda Lerner-Simon, District school psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District offer Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services?

2. Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy through Lynne Alba Speech Therapy?

3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for out of pocket expenses incurred for the thirty minutes of nonpublic agency (NPA) speech therapy per week that Petitioner’s parents have funded from the date of the District’s offer of November 14, 2003 to the date of this Decision?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District did not offer or provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year because the speech and language services offered by the District do not meet his unique needs and do not allow him to benefit from his education. The District offered Petitioner the following speech and language services: speech and language consultation in the classroom once per month for fifteen minutes and speech and language collaboration once per week for twenty minutes. Petitioner contends that he needs a minimum of two hours of direct speech therapy per week. Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to provide STUDENT with two hours of direct speech therapy per week along with the classroom consultation and collaborative therapy offered by the District. In addition, Petitioner seeks an award of compensatory speech and language services from November 14, 2003, when Petitioner disagreed with the District’s offer of speech and language services, to the date of this decision. Finally, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the out of pocket expenses incurred for the one half-hour per week of speech and language therapy at his current NPA from the date of the District’s offer of speech and language services on November 14, 2003 to the date of this Decision.

The District contends that its offer of speech and language consultation and collaboration services were appropriate. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT’s speech is commensurate with his ability and that STUDENT has not made measurable progress in the past year while receiving approximately two hours per week of direct therapy. The District maintains that STUDENT’s cognitive and oral motor limitations hamper his ability to benefit from clinical speech and language therapy and that STUDENT has received maximum benefit from this type of therapy. The District argues that its offer to provide consultation and collaboration within the classroom setting, combined with the use of compensatory strategies such as slowing his rate of speech and open mouth articulation, constitute an appropriate model and level of services for STUDENT.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing, prior to the presentation of evidence, the parties entered into settlement discussions off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. Following these discussions, the parties advised the Hearing Officer that they had resolved two of the three issues set forth in Petitioner’s issue statement relating to Petitioner’s visual motor/processing and assistive technology needs. On February 24, 2004, the third day of hearing, the parties placed a stipulation on the record regarding the parties’ settlement agreement on these issues.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Petitioner STUDENT is a twenty-year-old high school student who has been eligible for special education and related services as a student with mental retardation since age three. He currently resides with his parents. He has been diagnosed with mild to moderate mental retardation. More recently STUDENT has been diagnosed with dyspraxia, (Footnote 2) attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), and functional vision deficits. As a result of these disabilities, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of academics, communication, self-care, social skills, and motor skills and these deficits adversely affect his educational performance.

STUDENT has attended District schools since the age of three and one half. He attended the Sellery Special Education Center (Sellery) for nine years, until he reached the age of twelve. He then attended Fleming Middle School for two years, where he was enrolled in classes including self-care, travel mobility, and functional math, reading, and writing. In 1997, STUDENT enrolled at Gardena High School (Gardena), where he was placed in a special day class (SDC) community-based instruction (CBI) program. STUDENT’s CBI program is designed to teach STUDENT functional life skills with the goal of enabling him to live as independently as possible upon exiting the school system. Specifically, STUDENT is taught skills such as counting coins, telling time, understanding safety and survival words, using public transportation, purchasing food in stores and restaurants, and working at a job. During part of his school day, STUDENT works at the Sellery school cafeteria where he wipes tables, sweeps and mops floors, and picks up trash. At Gardena, STUDENT collects attendance rosters from the different classrooms three days per week. STUDENT also receives designated instruction and services (DIS) in the form of applied physical education (APE) and speech and language therapy, with goals focusing on improving his overall expressive language skills and intelligibility. STUDENT is currently in the 12th grade at Gardena.

In addition to his school-based program, STUDENT receives bi-weekly independent living skills instruction through Giant Steps, a non-profit organization funded by the state and vendored through the regional center. The goal of the program is to help STUDENT become more independent and includes instruction at home as well as instruction in the community. STUDENT’s goals in this program are substantially similar to those in his CBI program.

STUDENT has an articulation disorder. (Footnote 3) During the majority of his education, STUDENT received approximately thirty minutes per week of speech and language therapy per week with the goal of improving his articulation and functional communication skills.

On May 20, 2002, District speech and language therapist R. Ljuba conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. The assessor’s report indicates that STUDENT had difficulty with elevation, side-to-side motion and circular motion of the tongue. Moderate apraxia is noted as physically reducing his ability to find tongue placement for sounds requiring precise placement and the rapid movement required for clear rapid speech. The Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation (GFTA) (Footnote 4) was administered and the results found STUDENT able to produce all English consonants except “f,” “l,” “s,” “z,” “ch,” “sh,” “j,” and inconsistent production of “r” in some words. The assessor notes that STUDENT was difficult to understand at the conversational level. The assessor recommends that STUDENT be dismissed from speech and language services in light of his failure to show progress with respect to the production of the above-referenced sounds over the last few years.

On May 29, 2002, District school psychologist Linda Lerner Simon conducted a triennial psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. In her written report, Ms. Lerner- Simon states that STUDENT’s general ability and learning potential appear to be in the significantly below average range of function and potential. She describes his academic achievement in math, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and written language as essentially non-functional. His cognitive ability is well below the average range and his weaknesses include poor social skills and judgment and poor motor skills and communication skills. With respect to speech and language, she notes a severe disarticulation problem and receptive and expressive language skills well below the average range, but commensurate with his ability.

At the triennial IEP meeting of May 31, 2002, the District’s speech and language therapist recommended exiting STUDENT from speech and language therapy on the grounds that he had achieved maximum benefit from pull-out speech and language services. According to the IEP document, the therapist found no measurable improvement in STUDENT’s speech after two and one half years of continuous service. The therapist opined that STUDENT could learn the sounds that he was still having difficulty producing within the classroom rather than during formal pull-out sessions. This recommendation prompted STUDENT’s parents to file a request for due process hearing. This case was assigned case number SN02-01850 and later settled at a mediation, which is discussed below.

On October 16, 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent speech assessment of STUDENT from the UCLA Medical Center Speech Pathology Clinic. The assessment report states that STUDENT presented with very severe impairment of speech intelligibility. According to the report, more than fifty percent of his spontaneous spoken words and phrases were not recognizable. The speech pathologist reported hypotonia (Footnote 5) with reduced range, speed, and precision of oral movements for speech and for chewing and manipulation of food within the mouth. STUDENT’s language skills are described as significantly impaired but far superior to his level of speech intelligibility. The speech pathologist recommended that STUDENT receive an intensive oral motor treatment program.

On October 24, 2002, the parties attended mediation at which a final mediation agreement was reached. The agreement contains five main provisions. First, the District agreed to fund 44 hours of compensatory speech and language therapy to be provided by a district contracted non-public agency provider for the period of one year from the date of the agreement. The focus of these sessions was to be oral muscle strengthening for improved articulation skills. Second, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with thirty minutes per week of individual speech and language therapy at the school site, and further agreed that the District speech and language therapist would schedule two meetings per month, for a total of thirty minutes, with the parents and other members of the IEP team. Third, the District agreed to assess STUDENT’s need for speech and language therapy prior to an IEP to be held by October 24, 2003. Fourth, the District agreed to conduct an occupational therapy assessment. Fifth, the parties agreed to hold an IEP meeting no later than November 22, 2002 to address goals pertaining to attention to task, task completion, and visual matching and discrimination. That same day, an IEP meeting was held for the purpose of amending the IEP of May 31, 2002 and to implement the agreement reached at mediation. At the meeting, two annual goals and four incremental objectives in the area of articulation were generated. These goals and objectives generally called for STUDENT to achieve acceptable phonetic placement using oral motor strengthening for the “k,” “g,” “t” and “d” phonemes and to correctly pronounce content curricular vocabulary. (Footnote 6)

On December 6, 2002, an IEP meeting was held to amend the IEP of May 31, 2002. The IEP team added additional speech and language goals to increase STUDENT’s oral motor strength through oral motor exercises as demonstrated by improvement in targeted initial and final sounds.

In January 2003, STUDENT began receiving speech and language services from Andrea Trow, a speech and language therapist with the Children’s Speech Care Center division of Lynne Alba Speech Therapy (Lynne Alba), the non-public agency selected by Petitioner to provide his speech and language services pursuant to the mediation agreement dated October 24, 2002.

On February 3, 2003, Petitioner filed a special education compliance complaint with the California Department of Education regarding the District’s implementation of the agreement reached at the mediation. With respect to speech and language services, Petitioner alleged that he was forced to wait three months beyond the date of the mediation agreement to begin receiving his compensatory speech and language therapy because only one of the non-public agencies on the list of agencies provided by the District, Lynne Alba, had an opening for him. As a result, Petitioner alleged, his compensatory services did not begin until January 2003. In addition, Petitioner alleged that he did not receive his agreed-upon school-based therapy of 30 minutes per week during the month of January 2003.

On March 10, 2003, Petitioner and the District entered into an addendum to the mediation agreement of October 24, 2002 whereby the District agreed to extend the last date for the funding of the 44 hours of compensatory speech and language services from October 24, 2003 to January 30, 2004. The District further agreed to change STUDENT’s school-based speech and language services to clinic-based services to be provided by an non-public agency (NPA). Finally, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with an additional five hours of compensatory speech and language services to be delivered by a NPA for speech therapy services missed between January 13, 2003 and March 17, 2003. At an IEP meeting on March 20, 2003, the terms of this agreement were incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP.

On March 20, and May 6, 2003, Ms. Trow prepared written reports regarding STUDENT’s progress in speech and language therapy. (Footnote 7)

On May 21, 23 and 28, 2003, District speech and language therapist K. Jagarlamundi conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT as part of a triennial review. The assessment consisted of two standardized tests, the Oral and Written Language Scales (OWLS) (Footnote 8)and the GFTA, as well as language sample analysis taken from spontaneous speech, teacher reports, and observations. On the OWLS, STUDENT generated a standard score of 45 on the listening comprehension component, which translates to an age equivalency of 4.11 years. STUDENT generated a standard score of 40 on the oral expression component, which translates to an age equivalency of 3.8 years. According to the assessment report, STUDENT’s strengths in oral expression include his ability to label pictures, and use expressions of gratitude and remorse (“thank you,” “sorry”), common greetings (“hi,” “bye”), and descriptive concepts-adjectives (“little,” “tall”). He was also able to use the following morphological forms: present progressive, prepositions (“under,” “on”), plurals, and possessive pronoun (“yours”) although on an inconsistent basis. His weaknesses include difficulty in consistently responding to questions asked, and requiring repetitions and redirectives to attend to task. His overall expressive language consists of one to six-plus word utterances, ranging from single word responses to the consistent use of daily rote phrases and sentences. During spontaneous speech, STUDENT is able to use phrases, simple sentences and some forms of complex sentences (e.g. “She at home. I miss her so much. I call her everyday from my room.”) The therapist states that “although STUDENT has increased in his overall verbal output, his intelligibility is decreased to the unfamiliar listener.”

With respect to the GFTA, the therapist notes that STUDENT demonstrated sound substitutions, omissions, and distortions which moderately to severely impact his overall intelligibility. While STUDENT is able to model correct productions of most sounds in isolation, carryover or generalization is limited. His overall speech output is rapid and slurred, further reducing his overall intelligibility. According to the therapist, the slurred speaking patterns are due to inappropriate placement of articulators (Footnote 9) coupled with weakened oral muscles. Furthermore, his cognitive limitations impede his ability to generalize strategies taught or to use placement to production patterns spontaneously. The therapist states that his intelligibility improves when compensatory strategies such as over-articulation (wide mouth articulation) and verbal cues for clear speech are used. The therapist concludes that STUDENT’s overall receptive and expressive language skills appear to be at the same level as his overall performance levels. She states that he may continue to benefit from a language-based classroom setting with clear speech modeling, routine activities, small group instruction, vocabulary enhancement activities, and activities designed to enhance communication and functional living skills. Finally, she recommends that STUDENT’s speech and language goals can best be met within the classroom setting and that the speech pathologist may informally consult with the classroom teacher and family to facilitate overall expressive language skills and intelligibility.

On June 17, 2003, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was held. The District suggested that STUDENT’s needs in the area of speech and language would best be met in his classroom. STUDENT’s parents disagreed. Also, the District agreed to fund an additional 14 hours of compensatory speech and language services by Lynne Alba to be completed by January 2004. STUDENT’s parents and attorney also requested that the District conduct a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT in order to determine the best placement for him.

On August 12 and 26, 2003, District school psychologist Jolene Bowman and intern Deanna Williams conducted a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. Their written report is dated September 3, 2003. The assessors conclude that STUDENT continues to demonstrate significantly below average intellectual ability and deficits in communication, self-care, and social skills. The report indicates that STUDENT demonstrated significant processing deficits in the areas of attention, auditory processing, verbal processing, and visual motor integration skills. On September 8, 2003, District resource specialist Jean Lee conducted an assessment using the Brigance Comprehensive Inventory of Basic Skills in the Readiness, Word Recognition, and Computational Skills subtests.

On October 16, 17, and 22, 2003, District speech and language therapist Brooke Felmar conducted an augmentative alternative communication (AAC) assessment of STUDENT for the purpose of determining whether he can benefit from specialized equipment for the performance skill area of communication. The OWLS and the Photo Articulation Test-3 (PAT-3) were administered to determine his language and articulation skills. The results were substantially similar to those obtained during the assessment conducted by District speech and language therapist K. Jagarlamundi in May of 2003. Ms. Felmar concluded that STUDENT was most successful using a picture based system and was less successful using voice output devices due to a lack of attention to task and interest in the devices. Ms. Felmar noted that he prefers to communicate with his voice. She recommended that STUDENT continue to receive oral and visual support in the classroom, including over articulation strategies and verbal cues to speak slowly and clearly and that pictures of preferred items, daily routines and safety items be used to support his communication.

On October 10, 24, and 25, 2003, Andrea Trow, STUDENT’s NPA speech and language therapist, conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Her report is dated October 28, 2003. Ms. Trow administered the GFTA, the OWLS, and the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills Revised (TAPS-R). On the GFTA, he demonstrated the following articulation errors, substitutions and omissions: omission of all consonants in the final position in free speech and in testing, substitutions of b/p, d/t, t/k, t/g, t/s, t/sh, t/ch, t/j, f/v, s/z, t/kw, voiceless th/voiced th, t/ks, omission of the “h” sound, t/sp, t/sl, t/sk. Ms. Trow reports that he is beginning to add the final consonant sounds of “m,” “n,” “t,” “d,” “p,” “b,” and “sh” when prompted. He can also produce the “k” and “g” sounds 40% of the time from a baseline of 0%. She reports that he struggles to correctly produce most sounds, although she has noticed progress. His intelligibility is hindered by his rapid rate of speech and the sound substitutions that he has taught himself. According to Ms. Trow, his results on the OWLS indicate delays in both listening comprehension and in oral expression. For the listening comprehension component, STUDENT generated a standard score of 40, which translates into an age equivalency of four years, two months. For the oral expression component, he generated a standard score of 58, which translates to an age equivalency of six years, nine months. Ms. Trow reports that his performance on the TAPS-R indicates auditory processing deficits. In her summary, she notes that there is some improvement in oral motor skills, specifically with repetitions and lip closures on “m,” “p,” and “b,” and that his tongue elevation is getting stronger on “l,” “t,” and “d.”

On November 8, 2003, Ms. Trow submitted a speech and language progress report. On November 14, 2003, an IEP meeting was held to address occupational therapy and speech and language therapy services. The IEP team reviewed Ms. Trow’s reports. The District then offered a combination of collaboration and consultation service delivery models to provide support to STUDENT and the classroom teacher. Specifically, the District offered consultation with the speech therapist for 15 minutes per month and collaboration with the speech therapist for 20 minutes per week. No direct speech therapy was offered. Petitioner rejected this offer and the District has been providing stay put speech and language services in the form of thirty minutes per week of clinical speech and language therapy through Lynne Alba. In addition, since the last IEP meeting, STUDENT has been receiving an additional one-half hour of speech therapy through Lynne Alba paid for by his parents, for a total of one hour per week of speech therapy.

On January 28, 2004, Petitioner filed his request for due process hearing in this matter.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8).) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).) An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345.)

The term “related services,” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code Section 56252 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must first focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F. 3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. section 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE). The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989.))

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following three substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and (3) comport with his IEP. Finally, the District must offer the student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

1. Identification of STUDENT’s Unique Needs

In order to determine whether the speech and language services offered by the District were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language at the time of the District’s offer in November 2003. The parties agree that STUDENT has moderate mental retardation with resulting deficits in the areas of academics, communication, self-care, social skills, and motor skills and that these deficits adversely affect his educational performance. In addition, the parties agree that STUDENT has an articulation disorder and functional communication deficits that impact his ability to speak clearly. Finally, the parties agree that the primary goal of STUDENT’s CBI program is to teach STUDENT functional life skills, including functional communication skills, that will enable him to live as independently as possible upon exiting the school system. Specifically, STUDENT needs functional communication skills that will enable him to benefit from his instructional program, which includes using public transportation, purchasing food at a store or restaurant, interacting safely with strangers, contacting friends or relatives in the event of an emergency, and maintaining employment. The parties disagree as to the nature and level of speech and language services necessary to address STUDENT’s articulation disorder and functional communication needs.

2. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

Petitioner contends that the District’s offer to provide speech and language consultation in the classroom once per month for fifteen minutes and speech and language collaboration once per week for twenty minutes is insufficient to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Petitioner maintains that despite little to no progress with STUDENT’s speech through the years, the District failed to offer more than a limited amount of speech therapy and contends that this therapy was provided on an inconsistent basis. Petitioner argues that in the last 7 to 8 months, STUDENT received two hours per week of speech therapy as a result of the mediation agreement and that STUDENT is now showing improvement in his articulation skills and demonstrating a potential to learn new skills. Petitioner maintains that he needs two hours per week of direct speech therapy in addition to the consultation and collaboration in the classroom offered by the District.

The District contends that STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language can be adequately addressed in his current CBI classroom with consultation and collaboration offered by the District. (Footnote 10) The District maintains that STUDENT’s cognitive abilities limit his ability to generalize learned skills, such as specific and precise articulation strategies and that, as a result, his functional communication needs should be addressed in his classroom by working on compensatory strategies such as slowing his rate of speech and over-articulating in order to improve his overall intelligibility. According to the District, STUDENT has the best opportunity to generalize a skill such as slowing his rate of speech if he is reminded and practices this skill in his classroom environment.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of speech and language consultation and collaboration in STUDENT’s classroom is insufficient to meet his unique needs in this area. Specifically, the evidence establishes that STUDENT was making minimal progress in his speech and language goals while receiving direct services for 30 minutes per week and that STUDENT requires more intensive clinic-based therapy in addition to the consultation and collaboration offered by the District.

Andrea Trow is a speech therapist employed by Lynne Alba, a nonpublic agency who has contracted with the District and STUDENT’s parents to provide speech services to STUDENT since January of 2003. She has been a speech and language pathologist since 1964. She has been employed both as a therapist and in various school administrative positions relating to speech and language services over the years. During this time, she worked extensively with mentally retarded students on their speech and language needs. She has also been employed as a special education consultant and a special education due process hearing officer for the State of Nevada. She testified that she provided STUDENT with two hours per week of speech therapy from January to July of 2003, which was compromised of the 44 hours of compensatory speech and language therapy agreed upon at mediation and the 30 minutes per week of speech therapy that the District agreed to provide through an NPA because there was no District speech therapist available to provide STUDENT’s speech therapy. After the compensatory hours were exhausted in July 2003, the amount of speech therapy decreased to 30 minutes per week. Since the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT has received one hour of speech therapy per week, which is comprised of 30 minutes paid for by the District and 30 minutes funded privately by STUDENT’s parents.

Ms. Trow testified that STUDENT’s primary needs are to improve his articulation and to eliminate some improper speech patterns that he has developed in order to enable him to benefit from his CBI class. She testified that when she began providing therapy to STUDENT, he had a weak foundation of basic speech skills. She begins his speech therapy with oral motor exercises designed to increase the mobility and flexability of his articulators. These exercises include tongue lifts, lip puckers, and consonant repetitions. Ms. Trow reported that STUDENT has gained more mobility in his articulators. Ms. Trow also uses a variety of physical, visual and auditory prompts to aid STUDENT’s articulation of certain sounds. The physical prompts include tongue depressors, lollipops, and STUDENT’s own finger. She also focuses on auditory processing and auditory discrimination for STUDENT—teaching him what the different phonemes in a word are supposed to sound like so that he knows whether he is pronouncing them correctly. She also incorporates STUDENT’s content curricular vocabulary, such as the safety words he is working on in class, into his speech sessions. Ms. Trow persuasively testified that STUDENT has benefited from the increased level of therapy and has demonstrated progress in his articulation and functional communication skills.

Her reports document STUDENT’s progress. As of March 20, 2003, STUDENT could correctly produce the following phonemes: “b,” “p,” “s,” “t,” “d,” “tw,” and “sh,” but with little carryover or generalization into free speech or conversational speech patterns. STUDENT was having more difficulty with the “k” and “g” sounds. In addition, STUDENT was working on the concepts of same/different, positional words, money values, and sentence structure. By May 6, 2003, he could produce all of the sounds in isolation with the exception of the “k” and “g” sounds, for which he still required physical prompting. He could produce “k” and “g” in syllables and words, when given a physical prompt, with 60% accuracy from a baseline of 0%. (Footnote 11) STUDENT was also working on identifying safety signs, which is part of his school curriculum. He was able to correctly identify safety signs 40% of the time from a baseline of 0%. (Footnote 12) Finally, STUDENT’s oral motor skills were improving. Specifically, by that date he could elevate his tongue and place it behind his top teeth from a 0% baseline and he could pucker, smile, and open and close his lips on command with a baseline of under 50%. He could not blow air up in his cheeks, move his tongue laterally side to side, wipe his lips with his tongue, or place his tongue on the roof of his mouth and pull backwards. By October of 2003, he was beginning to add the final consonant sounds of “m,” “n,” “t,” “d,” “p,” “b,” and “sh” when prompted. There was also some improvement in oral motor skills, specifically with repetitions and lip closures on “m,” “p,” and “b,” and his tongue elevation was getting stronger on “l,” “t,” and “d.” In her report dated October 28, 2003, she set forth suggested long term and short goals designed to improve STUDENT’s speech. (Footnote 13)

Ms. Trow testified that STUDENT is making progress in therapy even though that progress is not reflected in the standard scores, percentiles, or language-age equivalents generated through formal assessment instruments. She stated that he has improved in the areas of clarity of speech, ability to stay on task, and effort and motivation. (Footnote 14) The Hearing Officer finds her testimony credible in light of her qualifications and the fact that she has worked with STUDENT extensively for the past year on his speech needs. She testified that STUDENT requires a minimum of two hours per week of direct speech therapy in order to benefit from his CBI program. According to Ms. Trow, the elimination of STUDENT’s direct speech therapy in favor of the District’s consultation and collaboration model would result in no progress, and more likely regression, in STUDENT’s speech skills. Finally, she testified that his inability to communicate effectively is a safety issue because STUDENT may not be able to make himself understood if a crisis occurred.

Other witnesses testified that they have observed an improvement in STUDENT’s articulation and speech intelligibility since STUDENT began receiving an increased level of speech therapy. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that STUDENT has increased the mobility of his articulators and can now move his lips rapidly while repeating sounds such as “ma ma ma” and “ta ta ta.” She stated that STUDENT can now move his tongue side to side and lift his tongue to form the letter “l,” which he could not do before. In addition, STUDENT can now pronounce his name properly as “STUDENT,” rather than “STUDENT.” She testified that members of her family and her coworkers have commented on the improvement in his speech. Whitley Gardiner, one of STUDENT’s classroom teachers, testified that he has noticed improvements in STUDENT’s speech over the past seven years. He testified that STUDENT is becoming more and more comfortable with ordering his own food at restaurants, a task that he used to be reluctant to perform out of concern that the person taking his order might not understand him.

Kamera Washington, STUDENT’s independent living skills instructor, also testified regarding his speech progress during the past year. Ms Washington has a bachelor’s degree in speech pathology and has provided independent living skills instruction to STUDENT for two to three hours per week for the last one and one half years. She testified that STUDENT is now responding in sentence form, rather than “yes” or “no” or “I don’t know” during conversations with her. She testified that she works with STUDENT on his articulation of sounds and that his speech intelligibility is improving.

Finally, the independent speech assessment of STUDENT from the UCLA Medical Center Speech Pathology Clinic also supports Petitioner’s contention that he needs intensive speech therapy. Specifically, the report states that his language skills are significantly impaired but far superior to his level of speech intelligibility. The UCLA speech pathologist recommended that STUDENT receive an intensive oral motor treatment program.

The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the District’s argument that STUDENT’s speech needs could be met in the classroom with consultation and collaboration between his classroom teachers and the speech therapist. First, it does not appear that the classroom teachers have the appropriate experience or training to provide STUDENT with the speech therapy he needs. Whitley Gardiner, one of STUDENT’s teachers, testified that he has no experience and no training in speech pathology and that Ms. Carlson, with whom he team teaches, has had one speech class at some point in her career. (Footnote 15) While his teachers should certainly continue reminding STUDENT to speak slowly and use wide mouth articulation, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires more intensive speech therapy that should be provided by a qualified speech therapist in a direct therapy setting. Second, it does not appear that the classroom teachers would have sufficient time to work with STUDENT on his speech needs during class time. Specifically, Mr. Gardiner testified that, on average, he is able to provide approximately thirty to forty-five minutes of one to one time per week for each student. Even if he could devote all of this one to one time with STUDENT to working on his speech (an unlikely prospect considering STUDENT’s needs in other areas such as academics and life skills) it would be insufficient for STUDENT’s needs, particularly in light of the fact that STUDENT has made little progress while receiving thirty minutes of direct speech therapy per week. (Footnote 16) This is not to say that the consultation and collaboration model would not benefit STUDENT; rather, that model, by itself, is simply insufficient to meet STUDENT’s significant needs in this area. Third, while the Hearing Officer agrees that STUDENT needs opportunities to generalize the speech skills he learns in environments other than the clinical setting, the elimination of his direct speech services in favor of a classroom based instructional model is not the answer. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT already has significant opportunities to generalize his speech skills in the classroom, on outings with his class, at work at Sellery, at home with his family, and during his sessions with Ms. Washington.

Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s speech and language experts lack the same familiarity with STUDENT’s current speech needs that Ms. Trow demonstrated. Sidonie Smith, the District’s speech and language specialist, has never assessed STUDENT or provided therapy to him. Brooke Felmar, a District speech and language therapist, last provided speech therapy to STUDENT almost three years ago. Finally, according to the District’s records, speech and language therapist R. Ljuba attended a total of four therapy sessions with STUDENT.

For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of speech and language consultation in the classroom once per month for fifteen minutes and speech and language collaboration once per week for twenty minutes is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Rather, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires two hours per week of direct speech therapy as well as the consultation and collaboration offered by the District in order to meet his unique needs and to benefit from his CBI program.

3. Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

As set forth above, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offered speech and language services are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language. The evidence presented at hearing established that STUDENT requires intensive direct speech therapy, along with assistance in generalizing learned skills in other environments, in order to benefit from his CBI program and progress in his CBI goals, which include using public transportation, purchasing food at a store or restaurant, interacting safely with strangers, contacting friends or relatives in the event of an emergency, and maintaining employment. Because appropriate functional communication skills are essential in order for a CBI student to benefit educationally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

4. Comport with IEP

Petitioner only contends that the speech and language services offered by the District were not designed to meet his unique needs or to provide him with educational benefit. Petitioner did not assert any failure to provide services as indicated in STUDENT’s IEPs for the time period at issue.

5. Least Restrictive Environment

In determining whether a placement is the least restrictive environment, the courts have indicated four factors to be considered. Those factors include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. (Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H. (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398.)

Here, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the speech and language services offered by the District are not appropriate in that they are not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs nor are they reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Because the services offered by the District are inappropriate, they are not in the least restrictive environment.

****

The evidence established that the District failed to offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services. Specifically, the District’s program was not designed to meet his unique needs in this area and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in this area. (Footnote 17) Finally, because the services offered by the District are inappropriate, they are not in the least restrictive environment.

Issue No. 2: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy through Lynne Alba Speech Therapy?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy through Lynne Alba as a result of the District’s failure to offer and provide him with a FAPE with respect to speech and language services. The District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to an award of compensatory education because it offered and provided him with a FAPE.

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. (School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358.) Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.) Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See Lester H v. K. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.)

As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services. The Hearing Officer further found that STUDENT requires two hours per week of direct speech therapy in order to meet his unique needs and benefit from his education. The evidence presented at hearing established that STUDENT has been receiving one hour per week of speech therapy at Lynne Alba from November 14, 2003 to the present, with thirty minutes of therapy paid for by the District and thirty minutes of therapy paid for by STUDENT’s parents. As a result, STUDENT has not received the requisite number of hours of speech therapy from November 14, 2003 to the present, a period of approximately eighteen weeks equivalent to eighteen hours of missed therapy. Because this denial of necessary services was relatively recent and there was no indication during the hearing that it has caused sufficient detriment to require more compensatory time than requested by the Petitioner, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of eighteen (18) hours of compensatory speech therapy with Lynne Alba is appropriate.

Issue No. 3: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for out of pocket expenses incurred for the thirty minutes of NPA speech therapy per week that Petitioner’s parents have funded from the date of the District’s offer of November 14, 2003 to the date of this decision?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for speech therapy provided through Lynne Alba as a result of the District’s failure to offer and provide him with a FAPE with respect to speech and language services. The District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement because it offered and provided him with a FAPE.

As set forth above, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA.

The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer or provide a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services. In addition, the Hearing Officer found that the speech and language therapy currently being provided by Ms. Trow is meeting his unique needs and providing him with educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech services procured by STUDENT’s parents, in the form of thirty minutes per week of direct speech therapy with Ms. Trow, are appropriate and that Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for their out of pocket expenses for such therapy from November 14, 2003 until the date of this decision.

ORDER

1. The District shall provide Petitioner with two hours per week of direct speech therapy per week at his current NPA, Lynne Alba, in addition to the 20 minutes per month of classroom consultation and fifteen minutes per week of collaborative therapy offered by the District. The consultation and collaboration shall be provided by Lynne Alba unless the District has qualified personnel to do so.

2. The District shall provide Petitioner with eighteen (18) hours of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy at his current NPA, Lynne Alba.

3. The District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parents for out of pocket expenses incurred for the thirty minutes per week of speech therapy at Lynne Alba for the period from November 14, 2003 to the date of this decision. Reimbursement shall be made within fifteen days from the receipt of proof of such costs.

4. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year with respect to speech and language services?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of direct speech therapy through Lynne Alba Speech Therapy?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for out of pocket expenses incurred for the thirty minutes of NPA speech therapy per week that Petitioner’s parents have funded from the date of the District’s offer of November 14, 2003 to the date of this decision?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Date: March 23, 2004 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The issues are not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing. They have been reorganized for this Decision to facilitate analysis.

2 Dyspraxia or apraxia is a motor speech disorder that is neurologically based. A person with dyspraxia has difficulty producing sounds, syllables and words because they cannot consistently find the correct placement for the structures of speech (e.g. lips, tongue, jaw). This affects their ability to say certain sounds and/or sound combinations and sequence the sounds into words and sentences. Individuals with dyspraxia often have speech that is unintelligible or they have difficulty producing the intended word.

3 Sidonie Smith, the District’s speech and language specialist, generally described a person with an articulation disorder as someone who doesn’t use accepted phonemes in the production of a word in isolation, syllable, word, or sentence. A phoneme is a specific sound in a word such as “sh.”

4 The GFTA assesses a student’s ability to produce all phonemes correctly at the word level via picture stimuli.

5 Hypotonia is a condition of decreased muscle tone.

6 Content curricular vocabulary refers to the words that STUDENT is being taught in the classroom setting.

7 The substance of these reports is discussed infra in the Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law section of this decision.

8 The OWLS is an assessment of receptive (listening comprehension), expressive (oral expression), and written language for individuals aged 3 to 21 years.

9 According to Ms. Trow, articulators include the tongue, throat, teeth, lips, gum ridge, and palette.

10 According to Sidonie Smith, the District’s speech and language specialist, the consultation and collaboration model is designed to help STUDENT’s teachers to develop strategies to help him with his intelligibility, such as reminding him to use open mouth articulation and a slower rate of speech.

11 A baseline of zero means that he could not produce “k” and “g” in syllables and words at all when she first began providing therapy to him in January 2003.

12 The signs include “no dogs” “poison,” “restrooms,” “red light=stop,” “green light=go,” “no smoking,” “restricted access,” “no walking,” and “first aid.”

13 The long term goals are as follows: 1) STUDENT will increase flexibility of articulators by 50% as measured by per session check-off lists; 2) He will correctly and consistently produce all final consonants in words, phrases, and sentences to an accuracy level of 80% with prompting, and to 65% without prompting; 3) He will increase understanding vocabulary by 100 words as measured by his ability to correctly use words in phrases and/or sentences; 4) He will increase his ability to formulate syntactically correct sentences including adjective + subject + verb + object; 5) He will correctly use pronouns, plurals, comparatives, when speaking or writing 70% of the time; 6) He will increase intelligibility to 80% by slowing his rate of speech and producing correct sounds; 7) He will improve auditory processing/discrimination skills to a 70% accuracy level by assigned tasks in the therapy session.

14According to Ms. Trow, STUDENT’s short attention span impacts his ability to receive benefit from his speech services. By using motivators and techniques specific to his interests, she has been able to increase his ability to attend to task for an entire fifty-minute speech session.

15 Mr. Gardiner was unable to provide additional details regarding the nature of the class taken by Ms. Carlson.

16 It should also be noted that STUDENT’s instructional day in the classroom is fairly short. He works at Sellery four days a week in the afternoon, performs his attendance roster collection duties three days a week, and attends adaptive physical education classes three days per week for a total of approximately four hours per week.

17 In its closing brief, the District argued that California Education Code section 56252, which states that related services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program,” is the governing statute and that a traditional FAPE analysis is not necessary in this case. The Hearing Officer has found, however, that the speech services at issue are necessary for Petitioner to benefit educationally from his CBI program and that the District’s offer of consultation and collaboration services does not constitute a FAPE.