California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 26, 2004
Student v. Antelope Valley Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1757-02 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary
Antelope Valley Union High School District properly found student ineligible for emotional disturbance; residential placement reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a high school student filed for due process against Antelope Valley Union High School District. The student had transferred mid-year to Lancaster High School in January 2002. A prior district had found him eligible for special education for a learning disability in writing, then exited him in 2000. The father asked the District to assess in February 2002. School psychologist Eric Beam found the student not eligible, and the IEP team agreed in November 2002. By then the parents had placed the student at Logan River Academy, a residential treatment center in Utah, and later at Oakley School. They argued he qualified under serious emotional disturbance because of depression and ADHD, and they sought tuition and other costs.
The Hearing Officer ruled for the District on every issue. One month between enrollment and the assessment request was too short to require a child-find referral. The student's symptoms coincided with substance use and family stress. They did not show a long-standing, marked emotional disturbance that hurt his schoolwork. Teachers saw friendships, no behavior problems and no signs of depression. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to private psychologist Dr. Donald Hoagland and found parts of his report exaggerated. The delayed IEP meeting did not harm the student or limit the parents' participation. Because the student was not eligible, no reimbursement was owed. The IEE was not reimbursable because the parents obtained it before the District's report was issued.
Why it matters
Shows how SEHO weighed whether depressive symptoms met the serious emotional disturbance criteria when substance use and family stress offered another explanation. Eligibility was judged on information available to the IEP team at the time. IEE reimbursement was denied because the private evaluation began before the parents could disagree with the District's assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1a. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE from January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing in its child-find obligation to seek out and identify Student as a child with special needs?
The relevant period was the one month between enrollment and the father's assessment request. The District knew of the prior exit from special education, and the student's poor grades were tied to missed classes and missing assignments, so it did not fail in child find.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1b. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE by failing to find Student eligible for special education under the category of serious emotional disturbance?
Student did not meet any of the emotional disturbance criteria. He had friendships, showed no inappropriate behavior across settings, and had no physical symptoms. His depressive symptoms were not long-standing or marked and did not adversely affect his schoolwork; they coincided with substance use and situational and family stress.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1c. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE by failing to find Student eligible for special education because of ADHD under the category of emotional disturbance?
Only Dr. Hoagland diagnosed ADHD, and teachers saw no signs of it. Student did not meet emotional disturbance criteria 2, 4 or 5, so he was not eligible because of ADHD, whether or not it occurred together with depression.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1d. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE by failing to provide an educational program reasonably calculated to meet Student's unique needs (including the claimed need for residential placement and the alleged procedural violation of failing to complete the IEP within 50 days)?
Because Student was not eligible, the District owed no FAPE, and SEHO has no jurisdiction over general education programs. The District should have taken steps to meet the IEP timeline, but the parents tacitly agreed to waive time. The delay to November 1, 2002 caused no prejudice and did not deny FAPE.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2a. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations of Dr. Donald Hoagland in June 2002 and July 2003?
The parents commissioned the IEE before the District's report issued, so they could not have disagreed with it. The District was never asked to reassess before the 2003 re-evaluation, so Education Code section 56041.5 was not satisfied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2b. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement of the tuition costs of Logan River Academy and Oakley School (and related travel, lodging and mileage)?
No tuition or travel reimbursement was owed because Student was not eligible and the District had no FAPE obligation.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2c. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Pillai, the AV Light Foundation, Dr. Johnson, Dr. Hoagland, the escort service, Dr. Danny Levine (educational consultant) and the Brigham Young Independent Study?
No evidence supported these costs, and the District had no FAPE obligation, so there was no basis for reimbursement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's claims denied in their entirety.
Key authorities
Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339
People named in the decision
- Reid Wagner, District director of special education, Antelope Valley Union High School District
- Shauna Place, school psychologist (District representative at hearing), Antelope Valley Union High School District
- Eric Beam, school psychologist, District assessor, Lancaster High School (later Desert Pathways School)
- Fran Beckerman, school counselor, Lancaster High School
- Gretchen Teany, biology teacher, Lancaster High School
- Rick Acuna, physical education teacher, Lancaster High School
- Chris Jensen, technology intern (computer) class teacher, Lancaster High School
- Mary Thurman, special education secretary, Lancaster High School
- Judy Pifer, examiner, academic portion of District assessment, Antelope Valley Union High School District
- Kathy Moore, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Palmdale School District Learning Center
- Jenny Jones, school psychologist intern (1999 assessment), Palmdale School District
- Michael Geisser, supervising school psychologist (1999 assessment), Palmdale School District
- Dr. Donald Hoagland, clinical and forensic psychologist; independent evaluator, treating therapist and expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Jeff Rush, therapist, witness for Student, Logan River Academy
- Dr. Robert Crist, psychiatrist, witness for Student, Logan River Academy
- Dr. D.V. Pillai, private psychiatrist, witness for Student, Private practice
- Dr. Mark Berman, private clinical psychologist (appeared under subpoena but declined to testify), Private practice
- Dr. Agarwal, pediatrician, Private
- Dr. Delrosario, referred provider (possibly psychiatrist), Private
- Dr. Johnson, psychiatrist (costs claimed), Private
- Dr. Killian, psychologist, Oakley School
- Dr. Danny Levine, educational consultant, Private
- Logan River Academy, residential treatment center (unilateral placement), Utah
- Oakley School, step-down residential treatment center (unilateral placement), Utah
- Tarzana Treatment Center, outpatient treatment provider, Private
- Paraclete School, private school previously attended, Private
- AV Light Foundation, private provider (costs claimed), Private
- Brigham Young Independent Study, independent study program (costs claimed), Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Lancaster, California and in El Segundo, California, on January 15, 16, 20, 21, 22, 26, 27, February 3, 4, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19, 26, and March 2 and 3, 2004. Petitioner or Student was represented at hearing by attorney Andrea M. Tytell and his parents. Respondent Antelope Valley Union High School District (District) was represented at hearing by General Counsel Bridget L. Cook. Also present on the District’s behalf was Reid Wagner, District director of special education. On the last two days of hearing, school psychologist Shauna Place was present on behalf of the District. (Footnote 1)
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Student; his parents; Dr. Donald Hoagland, clinical and forensic psychologist; Jeff Rush, therapist at Logan River Academy (LRA); Dr. Robert Crist, psychiatrist at LRA; and Dr. D.V. Pillai, psychiatrist.
The District called the following witnesses who were employed at Lancaster High School: Gretchen Teany, biology teacher; Rick Acuna, physical education teacher; Chris Jensen, technology intern (computer) class teacher; Ms. Fran Beckerman, school counselor; Mary Thurman, special education secretary; and Eric Beam, school psychologist, now located at Desert Pathways School. The District also called Kathy Moore, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher at the Palmdale School District’s Learning Center. (Footnote 2)
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Thereafter, the Hearing Office received written closing arguments from both parties, and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 3)
1. Did the Antelope Valley Union High School District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from the time he entered the District on January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by:
a. Failing in its child-find obligation to seek out and identify Student as a child with special needs; b. Failing to find Student eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance; c. Failing to find Student eligible for special education because of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) under the category of emotional disturbance; and, d. Failing to provide an educational program that was resonably calculated to meet Student’s unique needs?
2. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for:
a. The independent educational evaluation of Dr. Donald Hoagland; b. The costs of tuition at Logan River Academy (LRA) and Oakley School (Oakley); and, c. The treatment and consultation costs of Drs. Hoagland, Johnson, and Pillai; the costs of the AV Light Foundation, escort service to LRA, Dr. Danny Levine (educational consultant), and Brigham Young Independent Study; and the costs of travel, lodging, and mileage to visit Student at LRA and Oakley?
CONTENTIONS
Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly and timely identify him as a student with special needs by failing to find him eligible for special education services. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Petitioner contends that the District should have found him eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance (ED) because of his depression and ADHD. (Footnote 4) Petitioner further contends that the District failed to provide him a FAPE because the program offered him at the November 1, 2002 individualized educational program (IEP) team meeting was not sufficient to meet his unique needs. Petitioner contends that his unique needs required that he be placed in a residential treatment center. Because Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE, Petitioner contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for all privately secured assessments, services, and placements.
The District contends that it met its child-find obligations, that it timely and properly assessed Petitioner in all areas of disability, and that it timely and properly found that Petitioner was not eligible for special education. The District thus contends that it did not deny Petitioner a FAPE and his parents are not entitled to reimbursement.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a seventeen-year-five-month-old student whose family resides within the boundaries of the Antelope Valley Union High School District. In September 2002, Student’s parents unilaterally placed him at Logan River Academy (LRA), a residential treatment center in Utah. In August 2003, Student was placed by his parents in Oakley School (Oakley), a step-down facility and residential treatment center in Utah. Student is currently attending his senior year of high school at Oakley and is expected to graduate in July 2004.
Student attended school in the Palmdale School District (Palmdale) from kindergarten through eighth grade. In November of 1998, when Student was in seventh grade, his parents became concerned with his very poor handwriting and poor written language skills. In May of 1999, Student’s father requested a full assessment because of these concerns. A psychoeducational evaluation was conducted in June 1999 by Jenny Jones, school psychologist intern, and Michael Geisser, supervisor. The report was issued June 11, 1999. The Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) indicated that as to visual, non-verbal reasoning, Student functioned within the high average range, at the 81st percentile. Student scored in the average range as regards visual processing skills and fine motor development. Student scored in the average range for reading skills (71st percentile) and above average in math (99th percentile). In the area of written language he scored in the low average range, at the 18th percentile. The assessors found that Student’s written language skills were not commensurate with his assessed overall cognitive learning potential. The report concluded that Student exhibited a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement in writing skills, grammar, punctuation, spelling, and penmanship, which discrepancy was due to a disorder in the basic psychological processing areas of organizational ability, perceptual motor integration, and attention. The report also stated that “[h]is attention span during the assessment was appropriate for a student of his age.”
Based on the Palmdale report, during the IEP team meeting on June 15, 1999, the IEP team found Student eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disabilities (SLD) in writing skills, grammar, punctuation, spelling, and penmanship. The team determined that a resource specialist program (RSP) of thirty to forty-five minutes per day, four to five times per week would meet Student’s needs. The IEP also provided Student with accommodations which included shared note- taking with another student, the opportunity to take exams orally, and the opportunity to give oral presentations of papers and compositions. Student also was allowed to use a laptop in school for writing assignments and was also to receive monitoring to “ensure work organization and completion and effective home to school communication.”
At Student’s annual review on June 7, 2000, Student was exited from special education. The team acknowledged that Student still had a significant discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement in writing skills, grammar, punctuation, spelling, and penmanship due to a disorder in organizational ability, perceptual motor integration, and attention. However, the IEP team determined that Student’s deficits could be addressed in a general education program. The IEP noted that classroom teachers reported that Student was capable of doing “A” and “B” work and was capable of legible handwriting. While four goals were drafted to address spelling, handwriting, organization and written language, no services were included in the IEP to address these areas of need.
While in eighth grade (1999-2000 school year), Student started using marijuana. By the end of eighth grade he was using marijuana daily.
For the 2000-2001 school year, Student’s parents placed him in Paraclete School, a private Catholic school, for his ninth-grade year. Student did not want to attend Paraclete but wanted to attend Highland High School where many of his friends would be attending. Student’s parents did not want him to “hang out” with what they considered to be “bad company.” During his first semester at Paraclete, Student received grades of “B” in Religion and Healthful Living, “C”s in Spanish I and Algebra I, a “D” in English and an “A” in P.E. During his second semester at Paraclete, Student received “B”s in Religion and Computers, and “D”s in Spanish, English, and Algebra. He received an “A” in physical education. During the summer session he received an “A” in Algebra and a “C” in English. During his third and last semester at Paraclete Student received a “C” in Religion, “D”s in Spanish 2, Biology, and World History, and “F”s in English 10 and Geometry. Student used marijuana heavily through his ninth-grade year and at some point began dealing marijuana. Also in ninth grade Student began using methamphetamines. At some point Student was using “meth” daily and began dealing as well. Student remained at Paraclete until mid-tenth grade.
In the summer of 2001, Student’s parents had him attend “SuperCamp,” an academic summer camp in Colorado. The stated objectives of SuperCamp were to teach life skills, and to help students become self-motivated and confident in academic abilities.
On December 19, 2001, Student began treatment with Dr. D.V. Pillai, Diplomate, American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology. In his medical records, and during his testimony, Dr. Pillai reported that Student’s parents sought treatment for Student because of behavioral outbursts, lying, stealing, and poor academic performance. Dr. Pillai reported that Student had been exhibiting unpredictable mood swings with consistent irritability, defiance and hostility and that “[h]is history further indicates unquantified indulgence in substance abuse.” On December 19, 2001, Dr. Pillai diagnosed Student as suffering from a “bipolar disorder, mixed”, and prescribed Wellbutrin and insight therapy. Student’s parents paid for Dr. Pillai’s treatment.
Student began the 2001-2002 school year at Paraclete but on January 28, 2002, Student transferred to Lancaster High School (Lancaster), in the Antelope Valley Union High School District. Student’s parents were personal friends with Fran Beckerman, a school counselor at Lancaster. Student’s parents obtained the unusual mid-year transfer with the hope that Ms. Beckerman could keep a “mother’s eye” on Student and help keep him out of trouble.
By this time, the family was in severe turmoil. Student and his father fought constantly, and Student’s parents had lost control over his activities and conduct. His parents attended parenting classes and attempted to regain control of Student by doing such things as searching his room, administering drug tests, removing the door on his bedroom, taking his personal items, and locking him out of the house when they weren’t home. On February 14, 2002, Student tested positive for the presence of drugs in his system and his parents cleared out his room. Student ran away. His mother later took him to stay with his grandmother for a week.
On February 27, 2002, Student’s parents enrolled him in the Tarzana Treatment Center (Tarzana), an outpatient substance abuse treatment center. Student was to go to Tarzana after school. Student tested positive for drugs on two occasions while at Tarzana.
By letter dated February 28, 2002, Student’s father requested that Lancaster conduct a full assessment of Student because he had not been doing well in school. Father requested that the assessment include an academic assessment and an emotional assessment. He also requested mental health services under AB 3632. Father explained that Student had been on an emotional roller coaster and had been diagnosed as being bi-polar. Lastly, Father requested that Student be assessed under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The letter did not disclose drug abuse.
On March 6, 2002, Student refused to enter Dr. Pillai’s office for treatment. Also on March 6, 2002, the parents signed the District’s assessment plan. On April 2, 2002, Student began treatment with Dr. Mark Berman, a clinical psychologist in private practice. Dr. Berman’s treatment was paid for by the parents’ insurance.
On April 8, 2002, Student’s parents completed a questionnaire as part of the District’s assessment process. On April 16, 2002, the academic portion of the educational evaluation was completed by examiner Judy Pifer. This portion of the testing consisted of a set of tests from the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery, Revised (WJ-R, 1989) and the Kaufman Test of Education Achievement (K-TEA). Student’s scores were well above average in mathematics applications, mathematics computation, and mathematics composite. His scores were above average in reading comprehension. His scores were average in reading decoding and reading composite. However, as Ms. Pifer stated, “[w]hen compared to others at his age level, STUDENT’s performance is low average in Broad Written Language. STUDENT will find the performance demands of age-level tasks involving Broad Written Language very difficult.” Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) questionnaires were obtained from Student’s parents, four teachers, and Student. On April 22, 2002, school psychologist Eric Beam interviewed Student and conducted psychoeducational testing. Mr. Beam conducted testing utilizing the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III), the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), the Incomplete Sentences Test, and the “Draw-A-Person” test.
Also in April, starting on April 23, 2002, psychoeducational testing was conducted by Dr. Donald Hoagland at the request of attorney Andrea Tytell, who had been retained by Student’s parents to represent Student. Dr. Hoagland had provided Mr. Beam with a list of tests he would be conducting, so that the assessors could avoid repetitious testing and prevent a “practice factor.” And, lastly, in late April, over three dates, the school district administered the state-mandated STAR testing. Student participated in two of the three days of STAR testing.
On April 26, 2002, Mr. Beam issued a draft psychoeducational report. Mr. Beam advised Student’s parents that he did not have medical information from Dr. Berman or Tarzana and wished to have this information prior to submitting a final report. However, Mr. Beam also advised the parents that he could not recommend that Student be found eligible for special education based on the information available to him at that time.
Dr. Hoagland conducted testing of Student over several dates from April 23 through May 1, 2002. He became Student’s treating therapist on May 1, 2002. Dr. Hoagland conducted the following neurocognitive testing: Comprehensive Test of Non-verbal Intelligence (CTONI), Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Third Edition, Informal Reading Inventory, Test of Written Language-Third Edition, Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Third Edition, Test of Language Competence-Expanded Edition, Test of Variables of Attention, ADHD Checklist, Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning, Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test, Rey Tangled Lines Test, Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Third Edition, Beery Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, and the Reversal Frequency Test. Dr. Hoagland also conducted the following psychological testing: Reynolds Adolescent Depression Scale, Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-Adolescent, Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory, Rorschach Inkblot Test, Thematic Apperception Test, and the Children’s Sentence Completion Test. Dr. Hoagland obtained neurocognitive and psychological rating scales questionnaires from Student’s teachers and parents, and a Child’s History Questionnaire from Student’s parents.
An IEP team meeting was set for May 2, 2002 but was cancelled at the request of both the District and the parents. A May 21, 2002, notation in Dr. Hoagland’s treating notes indicated that Student was “tripping out” and stressed because a detective wanted to meet with him regarding stolen property.
On June 1, 2002, Eric Beam issued his final psychoeducational report. Mr. Beam stated that he felt Student rushed through the testing. Student had acknowledged that some answers were incorrect but declined an opportunity to correct the answers. Mr. Beam thus felt that Student’s cognitive ability was probably higher than the test results indicated. Student scored average as to overall IQ, high average in math, high average in overall reading but poor on written skills because of spelling errors. Mr. Beam concluded that Student did not exhibit a learning disability. The report further concluded that Mr. Beam could not differentiate between Student’s drug use and possible signs of emotional disturbance. Mr. Beam acknowledged that Student showed some signs and symptoms of depression but he could not differentiate depression from depression caused by drug abuse, situational stress from possible arrest, and environmental stress due to severe family conflict.
Lancaster issued grade reports in June 2002. Student received a “B” in Technology Intern (Computers) and “F”s in English, Geometry, Biology, World History and physical education. Student also failed the reading proficiency tests on March 5, 2002. However, during the summer session Student received an “A” in World History.
Dr. Hoagland issued his report on or about June 12, 2002. In his report, Dr. Hoagland stated that he used the CTONI test instead of the WISC-III because the District had just used the WISC-III. (Footnote 5) Dr. Hoagland found that Student’s overall CTONI non-verbal I.Q. of 136 put him in the very superior and gifted range, which is exceeded by only two percent of fifteen-year-olds. Dr. Hoagland administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Third Edition but did not identify the actual date(s) of testing. The doctor’s invoices indicate testing in general terms was done on April 25, 26, 29 and May 1, 2002. Despite concerns of a practice factor, the Woodcock-Johnson testing was repeated after having been conducted on April 16, 2002 by the District. The results of Dr. Hoagland’s testing using the Woodcock-Johnson were as follows: in reading, Student tested in the average to high average range except for phonics which was low-average; math testing was in the very high average range; written language was above average except spelling which was below average; and oral language was above average with some problems in the sub tests of ambiguous sentences and recreating sentences. Dr. Hoagland stated, “a student in California must meet [a standard] to be identified as learning disabled [which] is that there must be a significant discrepancy between his ability and his achievement. This has been legally defined as a 22-point difference between one’s I.Q. scores and one’s standard scores on an individually-administered achievement test.” Dr. Hoagland concluded that, even though Student scored average to high average on most tests, because Student’s cognitive ability was gifted, Student suffered from pervasive learning disabilities. Dr. Hoagland found that Student suffered from learning disabilities in the areas of reading, written language, math, listening comprehension, and oral expression. Because the Petitioner did not assert SLD as a basis for eligibility in this action, this decision will not address SLD further.
Based on Dr. Hoagland’s psychological testing and the interpretive software results by National Computer Systems (NCS), and his clinical interviews, Dr. Hoagland also found that Student was severely depressed and had been depressed since age eight or nine. In addition, Dr. Hoagland found that Student suffered from ADHD. Dr. Hoagland determined under the criteria used to determine emotional disturbance that Student qualified for special education under three of the criteria: he is chronically depressed, he demonstrates inappropriate behaviors, and he is unable to build and maintain relationships. Dr. Hoagland concluded that Student was eligible for special education under the primary category of ED and secondarily as SLD.
Dr. Hoagland’s notes of June 18 and 20, 2002 state that Student had been arrested in relation to receiving stolen property. (Footnote 6)
There appears to have been no attempts to hold an IEP team meeting between May 2, 2002 and the end of the school year. Lancaster was on summer break from June 12, 2002 to September 3, 2002. At Father’s request, an IEP team meeting was scheduled for July 17, 2002. The meeting was cancelled at the last minute because District staff was not available to attend. Student’s parents requested a due process hearing on July 30, 2002.
By letter dated August 21, 2002, Father informed the District that he would be unilaterally placing Student in “Logan River School” for the 2002-2003 school year. On September 3, 2002 Student was admitted to Logan River Academy (LRA), in Logan River, Utah. LRA provided Student individual, group, and milieu therapy regarding “substance abuse, interpersonal relationships and responsibility.” LRA also provided Student medication and medication management for depression and ADHD, but such medical support was not provided under a special education plan. LRA does not provide special education services or programs.
Attempts were made to reschedule the IEP team meeting in September 2002 but the meeting was not convened until October 7, 2002. At the October 7, 2002, IEP team meeting, confusion arose as to whether Dr. Hoagland’s report had been provided to the District. (Footnote 7) The meeting was rescheduled for November 1, 2002. At the November 1, 2002, IEP team meeting, the District members of the team determined that Student was not eligible for special education services because the team could not differentiate the signs and symptoms of possible emotional disturbance from the emotional signs and symptoms caused by Student’s drug abuse, situational stress, and environmental stress. Student’s parents disagreed with the findings.
On July 22, 2003, Dr. Hoagland re-evaluated Student. Dr. Hoagland disagreed with much of the NCS computerized scoring of the testing, stating that the results were contraindicated by Student’s clinical history. However, Dr. Hoagland concluded that, while there was a huge decrease in the scores showing emotional disturbances, there was no similar decrease in the scores related to depression. Therefore, Dr. Hoagland contended, a long history of depression had existed since fourth grade. According to Dr. Hoagland, Student continued to exhibit a very serious degree of depression and anxiety and continued to need a residential treatment center placement. Eric Beam did not re-evaluate Student.
Student attended LRA until August 17, 2003. At that time Student entered Oakley School, in Oakley, Utah. Oakley is described as a “step down” residential treatment center. Oakley’s master treatment plan noted that Student had a history of substance abuse, poor decision-making, and insufficient coping skills. The Oakley records also note a history of drug abuse and criminal behavior leading to problems with the law. Student is to graduate from Oakley, and high school, in July 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1a. Did the Antelope Valley Union High School District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from the time he entered the District on January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing in its child-find obligation to seek out and identify Student as a child with special needs?
Petitioner contends that Lancaster failed in its child-find obligation because Ms. Beckerman, school counselor, knew (via her personal friendship with the parents) the following: Student was struggling academically at Paraclete and was in danger of being asked to leave; that Student had a problem with written expression; that Student was experiencing difficulties at home; that Student had a previous IEP; and that Student had been diagnosed as bi-polar. Therefore, Petitioner contends, Ms. Beckerman should have referred Student for a special education assessment immediately upon his entering Lancaster. Petitioner contends also that Ms. Beckerman talked to Student’s teachers within the first two weeks of Student’s attendance at Lancaster and knew that Student was not doing well. Petitioner contends that, based on this information, Ms. Beckerman should have referred Student for an assessment at that time. The Petitioner goes on to contend that certainly after Ms. Beckerman took Student’s Palmdale records to Eric Beam she had sufficient information to have referred Student for a special education assessment.8 (Footnote 8)
The District contends that Ms. Beckerman had received information in general terms only, as a family friend, not a school counselor, and that such information was not of the sort that would cause Ms. Beckerman to refer Student for a special education assessment.
The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law impose upon each school district the duty actively and systematically to identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301. Under State law, the school district must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system. Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. Identification procedures shall include systematic methods of referrals of students by teachers, parents, agencies, professional persons, and members of the public, and those procedures must be coordinated with school site referral procedures for students with needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.
Student entered Lancaster School on January 28, 2002. Student’s father requested a special education assessment by letter dated February 28, 2002. The District acted immediately on Father’s request, wrote an assessment plan and obtained the parents’ consent to the assessment plan by March 8, 2002. Thus, it would appear that the time frame relevant to Petitioner’s child-find contentions is from January 28, 2002 to February 28, 2002.
Mother enrolled Student at Lancaster on January 26, 2002. On that date she also filled out an emergency contact card. The card indicated that Student was not in a special education program, had no health problems, did not take any medication other than for allergies, and did not suffer from ADD/ADHD. On February 1, 2002, Father asked Ms. Beckerman to follow up to see if Student had a “504 plan” under the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Ms. Beckerman requested that the parents provide copies of any such plan and any past IEPs. Mother provided Ms. Beckerman with the IEP of June 7, 2000, that exited Student from special education. Mother was unable to testify as to the date the IEP was provided. Since Student did not have a current IEP, he was not placed in a special education program.
Progress reports are issued by Lancaster every four and one-half weeks to parents. Ms. Beckerman testified that she spoke to Student’s teachers every two weeks as requested by Father and learned that Student was not progressing well because he was missing too much class and not doing the assignments. Ms. Beckerman testified that she had suspected that Student was abusing drugs when she saw him at synagogue because he did not look well and his hands shook. On February 15, 2002, she learned for certain that Student failed a drug test.
Although Ms. Beckerman testified that she and the parents were personal friends, she testified that the conversations they had about Student were usually in a group gathering after synagogue and were about generalized topics. Testimony revealed that the Beckermans and the parents socialized in groups but did not go out as two couples. The parents could not testify that they had one-on-one conversations with Ms. Beckerman specifically about Student. In addition, during the summer between eighth and ninth grades, Ms. Beckerman was Student’s bar mitzvah tutor. She testified that Student learned the teachings and Hebrew, and was successful in his bar mitzvah. She testified that he did not seem to have a problem learning, could have worked a little harder, and was a little unfocused and distracted. She testified that his lack of focus was normal and like all teenagers during the summer, Student said he would rather be outside playing with friends. Ms. Beckerman was also Student’s confirmation class teacher during ninth grade. Student quit confirmation class early in the program, which Ms. Beckerman testified was not unusual for a teenager. Ms. Beckerman testified that she felt that Lancaster would be a new start for Student. She testified that she intended to monitor Student and see how he did in the new school.
Mr. Beam testified that the school would monitor Student and would refer him to the Student Study Team if Student’s grades did not improve. Mr. Beam and Ms. Beckerman also testified that the school follows a progressive system of services to assist students in their education.9 (Footnote 9) Mr. Beam and Ms. Beckerman both testified that they did not have much information about Student when he entered Lancaster. Student had been allowed to use a laptop while attending Palmdale to accommodate his difficulty in writing so Lancaster placed Student in laptop classes. Gretchen Teany, Student’s biology teacher, moved him to the front of the room to help him with attention, and to provide him with more help, which he declined. Mr. Beam and Ms. Beckerman both testified that they did not gather sufficient information or have sufficient time in this one-month period to refer Student for any services on that progressive system of services.
It is unreasonable to expect the District to have collected past information, observed Student at his new school, and gathered sufficient information in a month’s time to determine that a special education assessment was in order. This is especially true considering that the District knew that Student had been previously exited from special education and that Student was abusing drugs. The teachers reported that Student’s grades were poor because he was missing class and failing to turn in assignments. The District also knew by reviewing the Palmdale transcripts that Student was capable of learning and knew that Student was able to learn the materials for his bar mitzvah, without special education support. As Mr. Beam and Ms. Beckerman testified, the information gathered by the District did not support a referral for a special education assessment as of February 28, 2002.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Lancaster did not fail in its child-find obligations regarding Student in the period between January 28, 2002 and February 28, 2002.
1b. Did the Antelope Valley Union High School District fail to offer Student a FAPE from the time he entered the District on January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing to find Student eligible for special education under the category of serious emotional disturbance?
A student shall be identified as an individual with exceptional needs if the IEP team determines that the student has a disability and that the degree of impairment requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of a regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026. The eligibility criteria for special education are found at Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations section 3030. Under § 3030(i), if, because of a serious emotional disturbance, a student exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance, that student may qualify for special education services: (1) an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (2) an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (3) inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations; (4) a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (5) a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
Mr. Beam concluded in his report of June 1, 2002, that he could not differentiate possible signs and symptoms of a disability (serious emotional disturbance) from the emotional signs and symptoms generated by environmental and situational stress caused by Student’s drug abuse, severe familial discord, criminal activity and related legal pressures. Mr. Beam testified that the signs and symptoms that Student was exhibiting, such as irritability, mood swings, lack of focus, lack of attention, disorganization, angry outbursts, volatility, constant defiance, and out-of-control behavior (according to his father) can be caused by drug abuse, situational stress and environmental stress, which were known to exist at the time Student entered Lancaster. Mr. Beam considered the fact that the behaviors did not occur in the school environment to be very significant. Mr. Beam determined that there was a lack of documented evidence to establish school failure or problems with mood instability prior to the time Student began experimenting with drugs. Therefore, Mr. Beam could not differentiate the behaviors as an emotional disturbance. He determined that Student’s educational deficits could be addressed in general education and proposed what he called “progressive” actions. Mr. Beam proposed that Student be reviewed by the student study team if he did not improve his grades. He noted that Student was being serviced by a drug treatment center, and a psychologist, which services should be coordinated with school services.10 (Footnote 10)
On the other hand, Dr. Hoagland found that Student suffered severe depression which had existed a long period of time. Dr. Hoagland felt that Student was eligible as a student with ED because he showed had difficulty establishing relationships (criterion (2)), demonstrated inappropriate behavior (criterion (3)) and suffered from chronic depression (criterion (4)).11 (Footnote 11)
On November 1, 2002, the IEP team met and, over the parents’ objection, found that Student was not eligible for special education. The District members of the team based their determination on Mr. Beam’s report and Mr. Beam’s discussion of Dr. Hoagland’s report. Dr. Hoagland was not present at the IEP nor was Ms. Tytell.
Petitioner’s closing argument alleges that he is eligible as a student with ED because he has demonstrated an inability to maintain friendships (criterion (2)), showed a general unhappiness or depression (criterion (4)) and has physical symptoms associated with personal or school problems (criterion (5)). In his closing argument, Petitioner contends that neither he nor his mental health professionals contend that he is eligible for special education under criteria (1) or (3). Petitioner contends that these characteristics have existed over a long period of time to a marked degree and have adversely affected his education.
Does Student demonstrate an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?
Petitioner contends that he has no friends. However, the record is replete with references to Petitioner’s friends. While in the Palmdale School District through eighth grade, there is no dispute that Student was popular and had a lot of friends. Student told Dr. Hoagland that he misses these good old days prior to Lancaster when he had friends. A Palmdale teacher noted in her grade report that Student was talking to friends instead of working. Student indicated that he was forced to break up with a girlfriend after a Palmdale teacher caught them kissing at school. Student referred to “his friends” at Paraclete in testimony and similar references are found in Dr. Hoagland’s notes. Student told Dr. Hoagland that if he were at Highland he would have known 25 people to invite to his birthday party instead of 2 (at Lancaster). He also stated that he knew 250 people at Highland and nobody at Lancaster. Dr. Hoagland’s notes also reflect that Student would hang out with friends and smoke marijuana after school or go to friends’ houses to smoke marijuana after his parents came home. The parents testified that they moved Student to Lancaster to keep him away from bad company and so that Ms. Beckerman could help keep Student out of trouble. Student stayed in his history class at Lancaster to have lunch with some friends because it was quieter than the cafeteria. Additionally, the LRA notes starting in September 2002 and Oakley notes starting in August 2003 indicate that Student has friends.
Finally, teachers Gretchen Teaney, Rick Acuna, and Chris Jensen all testified that they saw Student interacting with other students and thought he had friends at Lancaster. They each testified that they were able to develop a relationship with Student.
Dr. Hoagland’s report states on many occasions that Student has no friends, but, focuses on the time from January 28, 2002 when Student entered Lancaster to the date of his report in June 2002. However, during this time, Student was heavily involved in drugs and his parents were actively seeking to limit Student’s interaction with a number of his friends. Student was supposed to spend his afternoons in Tarzana Treatment Center and stay away from his friends. Dr. Hoagland acknowledges these historical facts, but then concludes that Student has no friends. He does not, however, examine Student’s ability to build or maintain relationships. Dr. Hoagland also does not examine Student’s relationships with his teachers. The only teacher from Palmdale who testified was the RSP teacher Kathy Moore. Ms. Moore did not report an inability to develop a relationship with Student or that Student was unable to develop relationships with his peers.
The Hearing Officer finds it necessary to comment on Dr. Hoagland’s credibility throughout the due process hearing. Dr. Hoagland testified artfully and directly when on direct examination by Ms. Tytell. However, during cross-examination by Ms. Cook, Dr. Hoagland was evasive, non-responsive, and often condescending. He had to be directed on several occasions by the Hearing Officer to answer Ms. Cook’s questions, to stop arguing with Ms. Cook, and to stop asking her questions. Dr. Hoagland would retreat to previous testimony and would avoid answering Ms. Cook’s direct questions. The following example stands out in the Hearing Officer’s mind. Ms. Cook asked Dr. Hoagland to review a document marked Petitioner’s Exhibit 22, page 375. Although the copy was difficult to read, the form clearly contained an unchecked box next to the phrase “impaired social interaction.” Despite persistent questioning by Ms. Cook, Dr. Hoagland claimed that he was unable to read the text. However, minutes later, under re-direct by Ms. Tytell, Dr. Hoagland was asked if Petitioner’s Exhibit 22, page 375 contained a notation that Student was depressed. Dr. Hoagland responded yes, right over the phrase “impaired social interaction.” Realizing what he’d done, Dr. Hoagland then responded it must be easier to read the more one looks at it. Also of concern to the Hearing Officer is the difficulty the District had in obtaining Dr. Hoagland’s records. His records were doled out piecemeal on several occasions to the District. The Hearing Officer ordered Dr. Hoagland to provide the Hearing Officer directly with a copy of his entire file regarding Student. Dr. Hoagland sent a file containing 401 pages, which consisted of his chart notes, testing notes, and protocols. Dr. Hoagland included an exhaustive review of school records in his June 2002 report, but none of those records were produced to the Hearing Officer. Nor were invoices provided.12 (Footnote 12) Other examples of Dr. Hoagland’s biased opinions will be addressed throughout this Decision.
The record is clear and the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student did not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was not and is not eligible for special education under category (2).
Did Student express inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations?
Dr. Hoagland concludes that “[b]ecause of the inappropriateness of his behaviors, because Student reports that it is his depression that prevents him from completing any of his work at this time, and because he is unable to build and maintain relationships at this time, it is evident that he meets three of the criteria to be identified as Emotionally Disturbed (ED), and that it is his primary special education eligibility at this time.”
Petitioner’s counsel, in her closing brief, did not contend that Student was eligible under this criterion. She in fact asserts that neither Petitioner nor his mental health professionals believe that Student meets criterion one (1) or (3). District’s counsel contended that Student was not eligible under this category because his behavior was not exhibited in several situations, mostly notably in school. Inappropriate behavior was not seen during Student’s tutoring for his Bar Mitzvah nor during his confirmation classes.
The evidence shows that Student became embroiled in a violent emotional struggle with his father, presumably over his drug use. The record contained testimony and documentary corroboration of emotional fights between Student and his father. However, no evidence was presented that Student exhibited any of these emotional outbursts at school or out in the community. Student’s teachers all reported no disciplinary problems with Student and no disciplinary records were presented at hearing.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances over several situations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is not eligible for special education under category (3).
Did Student exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?
Petitioner contends that all of the mental health professionals who examined him, with the exception of Eric Beam, concluded that he was significantly depressed, “thus meeting criterion four (4).” The District contends that the mental health professionals each come up with a different diagnosis except for the line of doctors who rely on Dr. Hoagland’s report.
Dr. Pillai was apparently the first mental health professional to examine Student. On the same day of his first visit with Student on December 19, 2001, Dr. Pillai diagnosed Student as being bi-polar. Dr. Berman began treating Student on April 2, 2002. Dr. Berman’s diagnosis was DSM-IV 313.81, Oppositional Defiance Disorder. The record reflects that Dr. Agarwal (Student’s pediatrician) was asked to prescribe ADHD medication to Student. She declined as of May 28, 2002. Dr. Agarwal suggested that Student be seen by Dr. Delrosario, who Mother thought was a psychiatrist. No records are provided from Dr. Delrosario and there is no indication that Dr. Delrosario treated Student. Dr. Hoagland refers to a Dr. Johnson and his prescription of medication for Student’s ADHD. However, no evidence regarding Dr. Johnson’s identity, qualifications, treatment and possible medication prescription was presented at hearing. Tarzana Treatment Center listed Student’s problems as “chemical dependency, HIV education, bi-polar, communication with parents, legal.”
Dr. Hoagland began his contact with the parents on April 22, 2002 and became Student’s treating therapist as of May 1, 2002.13 (Footnote 13) Dr. Hoagland concluded many things, amongst them that Student was severely depressed and has been since the fourth grade (or from age eight or nine.) Dr. Crist, the LRA psychiatrist, was provided a copy of Dr. Hoagland’s report but was not provided with Mr. Beam’s report. Dr. Crist stated the following as a diagnosis: major depression, recurrent, moderate; cannabis dependence; polysubstance abuse; ODD. The nursing evaluation for LRA notes that Student has been depressed since the ninth grade. Dr. Killian, the psychologist with Oakley School notes a previous diagnoses of ADHD and dysgraphia. Dr. Killian issued a psychoeducational report on September 22, 2003, which included testing for SLD only.
Throughout Student’s educational career, STUDENT’s parents have been asked to fill out a number of parent questionnaires. The first appears to be for the Palmdale School District assessment. The questionnaire of May 25, 1999 reveals that Student’s only medical problems in the past were a lisp, allergies, eyestrain, and headaches necessitating eyeglasses and tiredness. None of the categories such as sad or moody were circled. The emergency card for Student’s enrollment in Lancaster indicates only that he has allergies. “Not applicable” is marked for ADHD/ADD and the need for medication, or other medical problems. The parent questionnaires for SuperCamp in August 2001 indicate no problems with ADD, hyperactivity, dysgraphia, or “other.” The only problems listed were allergies. The parents filled out questionnaires for the Antelope Valley assessment. The questionnaire dated April 8, 2002 circled: leader, selfish, sad, reckless, tells lies, moody, forgetful, dependent, impatient, wants his way, can’t accept responsibility, motivated for money only, rebellious, dramatic mood swings, failing school.
Eric Beam notes in his report and testified that he did not dispute that Student has some signs and symptoms of depression. However, Mr. Beam could not find sufficient documentary evidence that these signs and symptoms were because Student had an impairment caused by depression. Mr. Beam did find sufficient evidence that Student’s signs and symptoms were caused by his drug use, and extreme situational and environmental stressors. Mr. Beam testified that, in general, he did not dispute Dr. Hoagland’s psychological testing and the findings of some symptoms of depression but Mr. Beam did dispute Dr. Hoagland’s conclusions. Mr. Beam testified that Dr. Hoagland did not analyze whether Student had depressive characteristics of a marked degree, across all environments, and which adversely affected his educational performance. Mr. Beam did not agree that the few incidents of lying in the street were suicidal ideation and thus disagreed with Dr. Hoagland as far as the duration of Student’s depressive symptoms. Mr. Beam testified that Dr. Hoagland’s conclusions were not supported by documented evidence.
All within the same month of April 2002, Student participated in the District’s assessment, Dr. Hoagland’s assessment, and the STAR testing at school. At the same time, Student was still abusing drugs and admitted smoking marijuana on April 20, 2002. Student was involved in criminal and financial misdealings and was facing possible legal consequences. Student was also threatened by a drug dealer and taken out to the desert by knifepoint. His old friends were avoiding him. And his home life was in severe turmoil. Yet, despite all this stress and anxiety, Student was able to participate in all the testing, the results showing that he had average to gifted intelligence, had high average abilities in math, and had average or better abilities in everything but written language. These facts suggest to the Hearing Officer that Student is not suffering from a debilitating depression. Moreover, the teacher witnesses did not see pervasive unhappiness or depression in Student while he was in school.
While the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student showed some signs of depression, the weight of the evidence does not support that Student exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Moreover, for Student to be eligible for special education under this criterion, he must also exhibit this characteristic for a long period of time, to a marked degree, such that his educational performance is affected.
Did Student exhibit a depression over a long period of time?
Petitioner relies on two pieces of information to show that he has been depressed for a long period of time. When angry at his parents, Student would go lie in the street. Dr. Hoagland reported in his evaluation that Student did this in the hopes of being run over by a car. Dr. Hoagland reported that Student did this eight or nine times when he was eight or nine years old. Throughout his report and during his testimony, Dr. Hoagland referred to Student’s long history of depression as evidenced by these incidents, which Dr. Hoagland called “suicidal ideation.” In the section of his report summarizing his interview with Student’s parents, Dr. Hoagland reported that Mother told Dr. Hoagland that Student’s childhood was normal. It was not until she was reminded by Dr. Hoagland that Student had lain in the street that she remembered such an incident at all. At hearing, Mother testified that she did not know it was eight or nine times, she thought it was only two. She also testified that she did not take it seriously, they lived on a quiet cul de sac and she knew Student would move. At hearing, Father testified that Student became angry with him (and Mother) and would go lie in the street and that this happened on two occasions. While it was scary to Father, he let Student do it, went out and watched him, and Student eventually came back in. Father and Mother both testified that they did not seek mental health care for Student because of these incidents because they did not think the incidents were anything more than acting out. Student testified that it only happened “maybe three or four times,” when he was “really, really young” and mad at his parents. He testified that he was probably seven or younger. When asked if his intent was suicidal, he stated, “no, a five year old doesn’t think like that.” Dr. Hoagland’s notes of his conversation with Student indicate that Student told him that he’d lie in the street when mad at his parents and his Dad would leave him out there. Other than this report by Dr. Hoagland, the evidence presented at hearing showed that none of the other medical professionals reported a suicidal ideation. Further, none of the medical professionals, including Dr. Hoagland, reported a recent suicidal ideation. Dr. Hoagland also reported in his evaluative report that Student would hit himself in the head with a baseball bat. But Dr. Hoagland’s note says it was a baseball (the word bat was missing). Dr. Hoagland’s note also stated Student said it hurt so much that he didn’t do it again. Student testified that it hurt too much and he didn’t do it again. Thus, this evidence of early depression appears to be inaccurate and exaggerated.
The evidence is contradictory as to when depression might have started. Dr. Hoagland says fourth grade. Student and his parents sometimes report that it was seventh grade and sometimes report ninth grade. No signs of depression are reported in 1999 questionnaires. The school records from Palmdale and Paraclete do not contain any notations from teachers who reported depressive signs. The only Palmdale teacher who testified at hearing, Kathy Moore, the resource specialist, testified that Student did not appear depressed to her. The Lancaster teachers who testified denied seeing any signs of depression in Student. Father and Mother testified that Student’s moods became volatile in eighth grade. The documentary evidence shows that Student’s grades began dropping in eighth grade.
The law requires a school district to make an appropriate determination of eligibility based on information reasonably available at the time the decision is made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041. Thus, the Hearing Officer must consider the information reasonably available to the IEP team on the date on which it made its decision regarding Student’s eligibility.
As of November 1, 2002, the only information available to the IEP team that Student suffered from depression of a long duration was found in Dr. Hoagland’s report. Student’s grades and teacher reports do not substantiate a long period of depression. Student’s depression signs and symptoms coincide with his drug use. Mr. Beam was unable to document pre-existing depressive signs and was able to document severe familial discord, situational and environmental stress that would lead to Student’s depressive symptomology. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that it was reasonable that the District members of the IEP team rely on the majority of the information available to them that showed that prior to his drug use, Student did not show signs of depression over a long period of time.
Petitioner also offers the later reports and testimony of Dr. Crist and Jeffrey Rush of LRA as proof that Student suffered from a long-standing depression. Upon questioning, they admit they base their conclusions on Dr. Hoagland’s report and on what Student’s parents have told them. LRA was never provided a copy of Mr. Beam’s report. Thus, Dr. Crist and Mr. Rush relied on inaccurate and exaggerated reports of suicidal ideation to come to the conclusion that Student suffers from a long history of depression. No LRA reports were provided to the IEP team on November 1, 2002. Therefore, the IEP team did not have this information available to it and under Adams the Hearing Officer gives the statements made by Dr. Crist and Mr. Rush little weight in determining whether the IEP team reasonably determined that Student did not suffer from depression over a long period of time.
Petitioner also offers Dr. Hoagland’s assertions that Student’s use of drugs is proof that Student was depressed. Dr. Hoagland testified that a strong correlation exists between substance abuse as self-medication and undiagnosed (and untreated) ADHD. He takes this a step further to state that twenty-five percent of children with ADHD will also have depression. While it may be Dr. Hoagland’s opinion that Student began using drugs to self-medicate undiagnosed and untreated depression and ADHD, the reason that Student began using drugs is unknown. Student told Dr. Hoagland that he had always wanted to try “bud” when younger. He also told Dr. Hoagland that his parents fought and he hated that. Mr. Beam asserts that Dr. Hoagland’s argument is not sound reasoning. Mr. Beam testified that there was no way of knowing the reason for Student’s drug use and that he could not say that depression made Student start using drugs. Dr. Pillai could not say that Student was depressed and therefore started using drugs. Neither could Dr. Crist nor Mr. Rush draw such conclusions. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Hoagland’s conclusion is not credible because the conclusion is based on inaccurate and exaggerated reports of suicidal ideation, and is fueled by his strong advocacy of Student’s position. The Hearing Officer does find persuasive the statements made by Mr. Beam, Dr. Pillai, Dr. Crist and Mr. Rush that it cannot be stated with medical certainty that Student’s depressive symptoms caused his venture into drug use. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student’s drug use is not proof of a long-standing depressive disorder.
Lastly, Petitioner also seeks to prove that he has been depressed for a long time by contending that his depression continued to exist after his involvement with drugs ceased. Dr. Hoagland re-evaluated Student in June 2003. However, the District was not requested to re-evaluate Student at any time. Dr. Hoagland rejected the NCS computer analysis of the testing in favor of his own opinion. He concluded that Student is still significantly depressed, proof that the depression pre-dates drug use. And he concluded that Student still needs a residential treatment center (now Oakley). The Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Hoagland to be a credible witness and is not persuaded that this testimony establishes that Student was depressed over a long period of time.
Moreover, the LRA records show that Student made great improvement within thirty days. Student’s Art/English teacher reported in an academic progress report dated October 13, 2002 to November 13, 2002, that Student had made great improvement, his grades were going up, he was on task ninety percent of the time, he turned in assignments ninety-five percent of the time and he “does what is required.” Student’s grades improved dramatically when he was free of the influence of drugs and out of his familial home. The Oakley records indicate that Student continued to do well and is doing well to this day. Both sets of records indicate that Student is charming and manipulative and is quick to blame someone else for his problems. But, when confronted and put to task, Student is capable of digging in and doing excellent work. Student took the Scholastic Aptitude Test for college entrance in December 2003. His “SAT” scores were above average. Student has been accepted to the University of Arizona. Moreover, Dr. Crist testified that Student was released by LRA as “euthymic,” that is, with a peaceful, tranquil mood. Dr. Crist indicated that Student’s depression was well managed and he was not showing depressive symptoms.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence of suicidal ideation cited as proof of Student’s long standing depression is inaccurate and exaggerated and is not persuasive. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student’s depressive symptoms coincided with his drug use. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Hoagland’s contentions regarding self-medication and the 2003 testing are not credible and that the information gathered after November 1, 2002 was not reasonably available to the IEP team and does not compel a finding that Student suffered from depression for a long period of time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s depression was not exhibited over a long period of time.
Did Student exhibit depression to a marked degree?
The Petitioner does not make a specific argument that his depression was of marked degree. The District contends that to be of marked degree, Student’s depression must be exhibited in major areas of Student’s life, including school, community, and home. There was no evidence that Student was unhappy at school or in the community (i.e. the Synagogue). Up until Student’s involvement with drugs, Student appeared to be happy, had friends and did well in school. The evidence at hearing showed that Student did not have any disciplinary problems at school. Thus, the emotional outbursts and out-of-control behavior that Student evidenced at home was absent at school. The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit depression to a marked degree.
Did Student exhibit depression that adversely affected his educational performance?
Lastly, to be eligible for special education under the category of ED, Petitioner’s emotional disturbance must affect his educational performance.
The Palmdale records provided showed that, from kindergarten through sixth grade, Student received good grades. He even received “S”s (satisfactory) in writing. In seventh grade, Student’s teacher complained that he was not motivated and his work ethic and desire were a huge concern. Completing assignments was a problem as well and the teacher noted that the parents were not consistently involved which was essential. Student complained that these two team teachers in seventh grade didn’t like him and picked on him. In eighth grade Student became involved in drugs. His grades in eighth grade consisted of four “S”s, an “S-,” a “C,” two “C-”s, a “D+” in English and an “A” in P.E. The first quarter of Paraclete, Student’s grades are average (an A in P.E., two Bs, two Cs and a D.) At Paraclete, Student did not receive special education services or accommodations. Student testified that he struggled at Paraclete because the work was harder and there was no one-on-one help. As his drug use increased and his home life deteriorated, Student’s grades also deteriorated. Student began missing class and assignments and the evidence indicates that this is because he was spending time with friends doing drugs. He didn’t do his homework and he didn’t turn in assignments. While at Lancaster, the teachers noted that Student was missing class and failing to turn in assignments. The failure to do the work drove Student’s grades down. When Student did the work, the work was good. When Student attended summer school and presumably had reduced or ceased his drug use, Student got an “A” grade.
Mr. Beam and the IEP team concluded that Student did not need special education to benefit from his education. The District members of the team, while conceding that Student showed some signs of depression, felt that Student’s drug use and the consequences of that drug use was affecting his educational performance, not the signs of depression. The District members of the IEP team relied on Student’s teachers’ reports that the reason for Student’s poor grades was that he was not turning in assignments and was not attending class. The District members of the IEP team also relied on Student’s teachers’ reports that Student did not appear to be depressed at school.
Dr. Hoagland did an exhaustive review of school records in his evaluative report. Dr. Hoagland infers that Student had many low grades in second through fifth grade which were obscured by the District. Dr. Hoagland tries to explain away Student’s overall good academic progress.14 (Footnote 14) Dr. Hoagland states that the sixth grade teacher made a number of references to “Student’s failure to complete work, his rushing through it when he did so, and his lack of neatness.” Dr. Hoagland paraphrased comments written by the seventh grade teacher that she complained of “failure to complete work, rushing through assignments and a lack of neatness.” Dr. Hoagland’s use of the exact same phrase is suspect to the Hearing Officer. The records that Dr. Hoagland referenced were not provided in his records nor were they provided in any of the Petitioner’s exhibits. It appears from a review of the documents that were provided that did not contain such negative comments, that Dr. Hoagland exaggerated poor grades and comments and also interpreted Student’s grades in a manner to demonstrate long term school failure. The evidence does not support Dr. Hoagland’s conclusions.
As of November 1, 2002, the IEP team had information that showed that Student did well in school until after his eighth-grade year, which coincides with his venture into drug use. The IEP team had information to show that Student became more involved in drugs and his grades deteriorated further. The IEP team knew that Student did very poorly in Lancaster and knew that the reason for the poor grade was that Student was not attending class and not turning in assignments. Mr. Beam testified that Student did not get “F”s in his class assignments but got good grades on what he did and got zeros on the rest. The IEP team also knew that Student had been exited from special education in the past and did not seem to need special education to progress in school. On November 1, 2002, the District members of the IEP team determined that Student was not eligible for special education. The District members of the team determined that if Student had an impairment Lancaster could fashion a general education program that would provide educational benefit to Student.
Based on Student’s successful educational background and the failure of that success which coincided with Student’s drug use, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student’s academics were very strongly affected by his drug use and the stressful consequences of his drug use, not by an emotional disturbance. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is not eligible for special education under criteria (4).
Did Student exhibit a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems?
The Petitioner contends that he was often absent or tardy from school because of physical symptoms or fears associated with school. While there was some tangential evidence presented regarding Student’s poor attendance at Lancaster, there was no evidence presented as to the reasons why Student was absent or tardy. Mother did not testify that Student had stomachaches, headaches, and general malaise. Student did not testify as to physical problems other than heartburn while at LRA. There was no evidence to support this contention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems and is not eligible for special education under criteria (5).
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was not and is not eligible for special education as a student with ED.
1c. Did the Antelope Valley Union High School District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from the time he entered the District on January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing to find Student eligible for special education because of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) under the category of emotional disturbance?
A student is entitled to special education and related services when his or her educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or ADHD and that student demonstrates a need for special education and related services. The student must meet one of the eligibility criteria set forth in Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3030 under the categories of “other health impairments,” “serious emotional disturbance,” or “specific learning disabilities, “ Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a). As such, ADHD does not stand alone as an eligibility criterion.15 (Footnote 15)
Petitioner contends, as above, that because of a serious emotional disturbance (ADHD) he exhibits the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (4) a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; (5) a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
Petitioner also contends that he has ADHD and is depressed (comorbidly) and that ADHD and depression has caused him to use marijuana and methamphetamines for self-medication, leading to the necessity of a residential treatment center.
A close review of the medical record reveals that Dr. Hoagland is the only medical professional who diagnosed Student with ADHD.16 (Footnote 16) Dr. Pillai, Dr. Berman, Dr. Agarwal, Dr. Crist and Dr. Killian did not reach that diagnosis. Dr. Crist prescribed ADHD medication for Student based on a “previous diagnosis.” The medical professionals could not come to a consensus as to Student’s mental health condition. Dr. Hoagland bases his diagnosis on signs and symptoms of ADHD gleaned from school records. He reported that teachers inserted comments throughout the school records indicating that Student would talk excessively in class, was easily distracted, was not focused, and had poor follow-through and organizational skills, all signs of ADHD. These records were not provided to the Hearing Officer and she is skeptical as to Dr. Hoagland’s characterizations of the comments because of his exaggeration of the signs of “suicidal ideation” and his interpretation of Student’s grades as long-term school failure. The teachers who testified at hearing credibly stated that they saw no signs of ADHD in Student. Mr. Beam, who himself has ADHD, did not see signs of ADHD in Student. The earliest reference to ADHD is found in Dr. Hoagland’s report when he writes that Student reported that his attorney told him that his ADHD was very apparent and that he might benefit from Adderal.
Dr. Hoagland also asserts in his testimony that the fact that ADHD medication has resulted in Student’s dramatic turnaround is proof Student has ADHD. Student has been away from home and drugs for almost two years. According to the LRA records, Student showed a great improvement in his attitude and grades within the first four to six weeks at LRA. The records indicate and both Jeff Rush and Dr. Crist testified that Student’s medication was adjusted over time and it took some while to come to the right mix for Student. Thus, the evidence shows that removing the severe stress generated by Student’s drug use and the consequences of that drug use lead to his immediate improvement.
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student does not have an inability to build or maintain relationships and does not qualify under criterion (2). Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that Student may show signs and symptoms of a depressive disorder and/or ADHD but that he does not qualify under criterion (4) because the evidence is not persuasive that such condition is of a long-standing duration, is marked, and adversely affects Student’s educational performance. The Hearing Officer also finds that there was no evidence presented that Student complained of physical symptoms of fears associated with personal or school problems, so that Student does not qualify under criterion (5).
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Student was not eligible for special education services because of ADHD, comorbid or not.
1d. Did the Antelope Valley Union High School District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from the time he entered the District on January 28, 2002 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year by failing to provide an educational program that was reasonably calculated to meet Student’s unique needs?
Petitioner contends that the program offered him by Lancaster High School was inappropriate to meet his unique needs and that he required a residential care program.17 (Footnote 17) The District did not offer a special education program because it found that Student was not eligible for special education. As already decided by the Hearing Officer above, Student was not eligible for special education. Therefore, because Student was not entitled to a FAPE, it is not necessary to analyze whether the “offer” contained in the November 1, 2002 IEP was an offer of FAPE. Moreover, the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over general education programs and the implementation of such. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56501.
Petitioner also contends that procedural violations seriously infringed on the PARENT’s ability to meaningfully participate in the IEP process, which resulted in a denial of FAPE. The procedural violation(s) alleged were the failure of the District to conduct and complete an IEP within fifty days after the assessment plan was signed. The Petitioner alleges that an IEP should have been completed by May 23, 2002.
The parents signed an assessment plan on March 6, 2002 and the signed plan was received by the District on March 8, 2002. A May 2, 2002 IEP team meeting was set and later cancelled. The District sought to reschedule the meeting because Eric Beam had not returned to work from surgery. The parents sought to reschedule the meeting because they wanted Dr. Hoagland’s report considered and the report was not ready. The evidence showed that an IEP team meeting was then scheduled for July 17, 2002 but was cancelled at the last minute when the District realized the appropriate personnel were not available for the meeting during summer break. However, the time frame for completing an IEP is extended by vacation periods, including the summer break months. The District would not have been required to hold an IEP team meeting on July 17, 2002.18 (Footnote 18) The evidence showed that efforts to set a meeting resumed after Labor Day and the parties were unable to convene an IEP team meeting until October 7, 2002. This meeting had to be adjourned and reconvened on November 1, 2002 because District’s counsel believed that the District did not yet have Dr. Hoagland’s report. There is no evidence that any attempts to set an IEP team meeting were made between May 2, 2002 and June 12, 2002 when the District went on summer break. However, Dr. Hoagland’s report was not issued until June 12, 2002 and an e-mail from Father indicated his desire that the meeting not be set until after May 19, 2002. It would appear that the parties tacitly agreed that no meeting would be set until July 17, 2002. It would also appear that the parties mutually took steps to set an IEP team meeting after the school year commenced.
As Petitioner points out, no formal written waivers of time or extensions were obtained by the District. The District should have taken affirmative steps to obtain the PARENT’s participation in an IEP team meeting prior to summer break and to complete the IEP in accordance with the express time lines of California Education Code section 56043(d). However, it does appear that the parents and their counsel tacitly agreed to waive time. In the context of this case, where eligibility is the threshold issue, and where Mr. Beam had informed the parents on April 26, 2002 that he would not recommend Student for special education, the failure to complete the IEP until November 1, 2002 did not result in a loss of educational opportunity for Student. The transcripts of the recordings of both IEP team meetings show that the parents were active participants in all discussions conducted during the meetings and were not denied meaningful participation in the IEP process. Mr. Beam informed the parents April 26, 2002 that he did not find Student eligible for special education and again by his report of June 1, 2002. The parents were fully informed of the District’s position on Student’s eligibility and were not prejudiced by any delay. Further, since the parents had already unilaterally placed Student at LRA by September 2002, the delay in the IEP did not result in any prejudice to Student and his parents. On that basis, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure of the District to complete the IEP until November 1, 2002 was not a procedural violation that resulted in any prejudice to Petitioner nor did it result in a denial of FAPE.
2. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement?
a. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations (IEE) of Dr. Hoagland in June 2002 and July 2003?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational evaluation of the student at public expense if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was “appropriate.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5.
In this case, Petitioner contacted Dr. Hoagland and requested an independent evaluation on April 22, 2002. At the point Dr. Hoagland was requested to conduct the evaluation, the parents had not yet received Mr. Beam’s report and could not have disagreed with Mr. Beam’s findings. Mr. Beam’s draft report was not issued until April 26, 2002, and his final report was not issued until June 1, 2002. Dr. Hoagland began testing April 23, 2002, and issued his report on June 12 or 13, 2002. Thus, the District did not have an opportunity to provide their assessment report and the parents did not disagree with the District’s assessment prior to obtaining their own. The District was never requested to re-evaluate Student. Student’s parents obtained Dr. Hoagland’s second report without notice to the District that Dr. Hoagland would be re-evaluating Student. Thus, Student’s parents did not satisfy the requirements of Section 56041.5 and are not entitled to reimbursement for the IEE reports of Dr. Hoagland.
b. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement of the tuition costs of LRA and Oakley?
Where the District has failed to provide FAPE, the parent may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private school education, if it is determined that the parent’s placement was appropriate. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F. 3d 1489.
As discussed above, the District did not have an obligation to provide Student a FAPE since he was not eligible for special education services. Therefore, Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition. Student’s parents are also not entitled to reimbursement for travel, lodging and mileage to visit Student in Utah from August 12, 2002 to February 4, 2004.
c. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Pillai, the AV Light Foundation, Dr. Johnson (psychiatrist), Dr. Hoagland, the escort service, Dr. Danny Levine (educational consult) and the Brigham Young Independent Study?
No evidence was presented at hearing regarding these costs or why these costs might be subject to reimbursement. Because the District did not have an obligation to provide Student a FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis for reimbursement of these costs.
CONCLUSION
The District did not fail in its child-find obligations, and timely and properly assessed Petitioner for special education services. Petitioner was properly found ineligible for special education services. Because he was not eligible for special education, the District did not have an obligation to provide Petitioner a FAPE from January 28, 2002 through July 2004. Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claims are denied in their entirety.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: the District prevailed as to the issues adjudicated in this hearing.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: April 26, 2004 ______________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
Ms. Place was present on one occasion when Mr. Wagner was unable to attend. Ms. Place attended with Mr. Wagner on the other occasion, over Petitioner’s objection.
2 A subpoena duces tecum was issued for the treatment records of Dr. Mark Berman. Dr. Berman responded personally by appearing at the hearing but refused to testify and refused to provide a copy of his treatment notes.
3 The issues have been restated to reflect the results of the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. The issues have been reorganized for ease of analysis. There were no substantive changes. In his closing argument, Petitioner included a request for compensatory education. Compensatory Education was not requested in Petitioner’s statement of issues nor during the issues discussion at the start of the hearing. In fact, Petitioner’s counsel asserted that Petitioner was not seeking compensatory education. Therefore, this remedy will not be addressed in this Decision.
4 During the discussion of issues at the start of the hearing, Petitioner’s counsel asserted that she was not seeking to have Student found eligible for special education under the category “other health impairment.” This issue was revisited after several days of hearing and counsel again asserted that she was not seeking to have Student found eligible under OHI but would assert that the District should have explored OHI as part of its child-find obligation. However, in Petitioner’s written closing argument, Petitioner asserts that he should be found eligible for special education under OHI. Because of the assertions of counsel at hearing that OHI was not being asserted as a category of eligibility, the Hearing Officer will not address the issue.
5 However, at hearing, Dr. Hoagland testified that the reason he used the CTONI was that since the CTONI was not timed and due to the nature of the CTONI, the CTONI would more accurately measure the aptitude and abilities of a student with ADHD. Dr. Hoagland testified that the WISC-III was timed and would be difficult for someone with an attention problem. However, no evidence was presented to indicate that Student needed more time to complete testing because of ADHD.
6 At hearing Dr. Hoagland testified that he was in error, that Student had only been detained. He learned of his error at hearing from Student’s parents and attorney.
7 The District’s counsel indicated at the October 7th meeting that she did not have a copy of Dr. Hoagland’s report. According to Father, the District later admitted that the report had been delivered to counsel’s office. Mr. Beam admitted that he had had an opportunity to review Dr. Hoagland’s report prior to the IEP team meeting.
8 Ms. Beckerman testified that Mother brought her Student’s June 2000 exit IEP from Palmdale, which she took to Mr. Beam. Neither Ms. Beckerman nor Mother could testify as to the date the exit IEP was provided to Ms. Beckerman. Neither Mother nor Ms. Beckerman testified that Ms. Beckerman took Palmdale records to Mr. Beam. Ms. Beckerman testified that she did not collect Student’s records because obtaining previous school records would be done by the special education secretary. Ms. Beckerman testified that it was her belief that Mr. Beam did have Student’s Palmdale school records as of February 22, 2002. Ms. Beckerman indicated that she was responsible for 500 students.
9 Mr. Beam described that progression as follows. If a student is not progressing well, a discussion is held with the student’s teachers to determine if classroom interventions would be of benefit to the student. Classroom interventions may be as simple as moving the student to the front of the class. An intervention is attempted, and if not successful, the student would be referred to the Student Study Team. The SST convenes to determine if the student needs more aggressive accommodations, needs a 504 plan, needs a special education referral, or needs any other services to benefit from the student’s education. If the SST, or a teacher or parent, requests special education, an assessment plan would be developed, consent to assess would be sought, and the assessment conducted. Then an IEP team meeting would be held to determine eligibility.
10 Mr. Beam graduated from Northeastern University, Bouvé College of Health Sciences in 2000. He obtained a certificate of advanced graduate study (C.A.G.S.) in applied educational psychology in school psychology in June 2000. He obtained a Master of Science in applied educational psychology in school psychology in June 1999. His areas of concentration were ADHD and crisis intervention. He has been a school psychologist since August 1999. He interned in the Psychological Services Office of Brookline High School in Massachusetts from September 1998 through June 1999.
11 Dr. Hoagland received a Ph.D. in clinical psychology in 1984 from the Fuller Graduate School of Psychology in Pasadena, California. He received additional undergraduate study in psychology from 1976 through 1977 from Purdue University, Fort Wayne, Indiana. Dr. Hoagland has been in private practice from 1986 to the present. His specialities include forensics, neurocognitive and psychological evaluation and child and adolescent treatment. His forensic services have included evaluation and/or testimony in child abuse, child custody, educational and disability rights, criminal, personal injury, Workers’ Compensation and other disability cases. His curriculum vitae indicates that he has provided independent evaluations and program consultations to school districts.
12 However, a multi-page letter from Dr. Hoagland addressed to the Hearing Officer was attached to the records. The records and letter were set aside and not reviewed by the Hearing Officer. The matter was addressed when the hearing reconvened. Ms. Cook moved to strike the letter from the record as an impermissible ex-parte communication. Ms. Cook also moved to strike Dr. Hoagland’s testimony in its entirety. Ms. Cook’s motion to strike the letter was granted and the letter was given to Ms. Tytell. Ms. Cook’s motion to strike Dr. Hoagland’s testimony in its entirety was denied in the interests of justice.
13 Dr. Hoagland’s notes indicate his first contact with FATHER was a phone conference on April 22, 2002, the purpose of which was to obtain a private assessment according to “A.T.”. Dr. Hoagland’s notes of that contact contain the phrase “dy(sic?) as bipolar + ADHD.” A “5-7” note indicates that Student wants Addera, then states: “[e]xplain for ADD.” On page 41 of Dr. Hoagland’s report of June 2002 is the following: “[b]ecause his attorney, Ms. Tytell, thought his ADHD was very apparent, she, according to Student, suggested that he might benefit from Adderall. Consequently, he has been very invested in obtaining a prescription for it…”
14 Dr. Hoagland wrote at page three of his report that Palmdale failed to provide progress reports for the second, third and fourth and fifth grades. “Because the ratings recorded on his transcript for the first grade are from the final trimester, it can be inferred that those from the second throughout fifth grades also represent his progress at the end of each of those years.” Then, on page six, Dr. Hoagland states that “…unlike previous years on which only the final trimester grades were reported….those for sixth grade represented an average of all three trimesters. By employing averages, the district obscured many low grades that Student received throughout the year.” The Hearing Officer finds this as another example of Dr. Hoagland’s advocacy on behalf of Student. As pointed out in Mr. Beam’s testimony, the evidence does not support Dr. Hoagland’s conclusion.
15 During the clarification of issues, Petitioner indicated that he would seek eligibility under the category of ED but not OHI or SLD. Therefore this decision will not address these other two eligibility categories.
16 Dr. Hoagland testified at hearing that he was the one who diagnosed Student as ADHD. However, under questioning later in his testimony as to whether he was qualified to provide a medical diagnosis, Dr. Hoagland would not answer the direct question and testified that his report did not contain a “DSM-IV diagnosis.”
17 Much of Petitioner’s closing argument surrounds the failure of Palmdale to provide an appropriate educational program for Student. Palmdale is not a party to this action so that this information is considered as background only. This Decision does not contain an analysis regarding Student’s educational programs prior to his enrollment in Lancaster High on January 28, 2002.
18 See Cal. Educ. Code section 56344.
