California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 26, 2003

Student v. Arcadia Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 176-03 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Arcadia Unified must provide daily one-to-one tutoring through high school and a home computer after conceding a denial of FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 3 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes a prior SEHO hearing before the same Hearing Officer that was convened on February 21, 2002 and dismissed with prejudice under a settlement agreement. No later history is noted.

Summary

A 16-year-old with a specific learning disability (severe dyslexia) and ADHD filed for due process against Arcadia Unified School District. Until July 2002 he had been classified as emotionally disturbed. From January 2000 to October 2002 he was in a county special day class for emotionally disturbed students, where his day was cut to two hours, and then received only one hour of home teaching a day for more than a year. His reading scores stayed at about the second-grade level. The District conceded it had denied him a free appropriate public education (FAPE).

First, the Hearing Officer ruled that a 2002 settlement, which dismissed an earlier case "with prejudice," did not bar these claims. The family had only non-attorney advocates and signed the agreement the same day, and it dealt mainly with assessments.

The parties agreed on most of the program going forward. They agreed on a nonpublic school, starting with a reapplication to the Frostig Center. Until then, Student would have a full six-period day at Arcadia High School with aide support available in every academic class. He would also receive speech-language therapy, weekly counseling, a transition plan, assistive technology, ESY, and transportation. The Hearing Officer also required general computer training.

As compensatory education, the Hearing Officer ordered one hour per day of one-to-one tutoring until graduation or age-out, plus a loaned home computer and software. He rejected Student's request for two hours a day.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a settlement that dismissed earlier claims "with prejudice." The Hearing Officer applied a knowing-and-voluntary waiver test rather than ordinary contract rules. It also illustrates compensatory education designed for a student's needs: daily tutoring that runs until graduation and a loaned home computer, ordered after years of shortened days and home teaching.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue Preliminary. Whether the February 21, 2002 settlement agreement, under which the prior hearing request was dismissed 'with prejudice,' bars Student from raising issues about his education before that date.

    Applying the knowing-and-voluntary waiver test of W.B. v. Matula, the Hearing Officer held that the settlement did not bar review of Student's program for the three years before filing. The family had non-attorney advocates, the agreement was signed the same day, it dealt mainly with assessments, and enforcing it would be against the public interest.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. What is an appropriate educational program for Student during the remainder of the 2002-2003 extended year and the 2003-2004 year including the extended year?

    The parties agreed on most of the program: a nonpublic school, and until then a full six-period day at Arcadia High School with aide support in academic classes, speech-language services, counseling, a transition plan, assistive technology, ESY, and transportation. On the disputed point, Student prevailed on the need for general computer training (at least ten 60-minute sessions).

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. What is the appropriate remedy for the District's past failure to provide Student with a FAPE?

    The District conceded it denied FAPE from January 2000 to October 2002. As compensatory education, the Hearing Officer ordered one hour per day of one-to-one tutoring, five days a week, until graduation or age-out, plus a home computer and software on loan. Student won on the duration of tutoring and the home computer. The District won on the daily length of tutoring (Student had asked for two hours a day).

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the IEP team must meet to draft an IEP that conforms to the decision and to review and modify goals and objectives.
  • Placement ordered. The District, Student, and the mother must cooperate in applying to the Frostig Center. If Student is not accepted, they must cooperate to locate and secure admission to another appropriate nonpublic school.
  • Placement ordered. Until Student enrolls in a nonpublic school, he continues at Arcadia High School for a full day: one period of regular physical education, one period of study skills, and four periods of academic instruction set by the IEP team.
  • Order to provide or change services. In each academic class at Arcadia High School, a qualified classroom aide must be available to give Student one-to-one help whenever he needs it.
  • Order to provide or change services. Speech and language services twice a week, 45 minutes each; counseling once a week for 30 minutes, individual or group as the counselor decides; an updated individual transition plan similar to the July 2, 2002 plan; all assistive technology recommended in the June 22, 2002 assessment; transportation; and ESY.
  • Compensatory education. One-to-one tutoring for one hour per day, five days a week, provided whether Student is in a nonpublic or public school, until he graduates from high school or ages out of eligibility under Ed. Code 56026(c), whichever comes first.
  • Compensatory education. The District must loan Student a computer and the software recommended in the June 22, 2002 assistive technology assessment for home use for as long as he is enrolled in the District.
  • Order to provide or change services. The analysis says the program should include at least ten 60-minute sessions of general instruction on using a computer and its operating system. This is not a separately numbered item in the Order.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; W.B. v. Matula (cited as W.B. vs. Matuala)

People named in the decision

  • Christine Blackstock, coordinator of special education, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Marilyn Scherba, school psychologist, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Marti Griffin, program specialist, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Linda Kwan, special day class teacher, Stoneman School (Los Angeles County Office of Education)
  • Dr. Jose J. Gonzales, independent assessor, Assessment requested by Student's advocate
  • Rita Wilkins, speech-language specialist, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Albert (Al) Albo, home teacher, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Edie Klein, home teacher, Arcadia Unified School District
  • Darvin Jackson, special day class math teacher, Arcadia High School
  • Ryan Press, special day class world history teacher, Arcadia High School
  • Michyel Munsell, special day class reading and written language teacher, Arcadia High School
  • Frostig Center, nonpublic school
  • Summit View School, nonpublic school (declined admission)
  • Westmark School, nonpublic school (declined admission)
  • Stoneman School, county special school, Los Angeles County Office of Education

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

The hearing in this case was conducted on April 24, 25, and 29, 2003, in Arcadia, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Benjamin Y. Kim. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER.

Respondent Arcadia Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arczynski. Also present on behalf of District was Christine Blackstock, coordinator of special education.

Evidence was received and the matter was continued to receive written closing briefs from the parties. The record was closed on May 19, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. What is an appropriate educational program for STUDENT during the remainder of the 2002- 2003 extended year and the 2003-2004 year including the extended year?

2. What is the appropriate remedy for the District’s past failure to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old young man who has been receiving special education services from the District since he was in the first grade. STUDENT was initially identified as eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability due to processing disorders of auditory processing, auditory interpretation of directions, auditory memory and sequencing skills.

In 1996, after his triennial evaluation, STUDENT’s primary disability was changed to emotional disturbance because of his difficulty in establishing and maintaining satisfactory peer and teacher relationships and his extreme impulsive behavior. He continued to have a learning disability because of discrepancies in the areas of auditory processing, auditory interpretation of directions, and long and short-term memory. Because his primary disabling condition was emotional disturbance, STUDENT was referred to the Los Angeles County Office of Education for consideration of placement in a program for students with emotional disabilities. STUDENT attended a number of county programs for students with emotional disabilities. In September 1999 STUDENT was placed in a special day class for students with emotional disabilities at the Stoneman School in San Marino.

On November 5, 1999, a triennial assessment of STUDENT was performed by school psychologist Marilyn Scherba and program specialist Marti Griffin. Intelligence testing indicated that STUDENT was of average intelligence. Results of the Woodcock Johnson Test of Achievement-Revised resulted in a Broad Reading standard score (SS) of 61 with a percentile rank of 0.5, a Broad Written Language standard score of 58 with a percentile rank of 0.3, and a Broad Math standard score of 78 with a percentile rank of 7. STUDENT scored better in the subtests relating to Science (SS of 108, percentile rank of 70), Social Studies (SS of 89, percentile rank of 23), and Humanities (SS of 85, percentile rank of 16). Although Ms. Scherba testified that she utilized a standardized test for evaluating social/emotional functioning, the results of the test are not in her report. She admitted that her conclusions were primarily based on her observation of STUDENT and input from STUDENT’s teachers at the Stoneman School.

Ms. Scherba’s report concluded:

STUDENT continues to exhibit serious social/emotional/behavioral difficulties that have an adverse effect on his academic performance. He has difficulty establishing and maintaining satisfactory peer relationships, and he demonstrates inappropriate behaviors under normal circumstances. The effects of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (including distractibility, impulsivity, difficulty sustaining attention on tasks, and lack of assignment completion) also have a negative impact on STUDENT’s academic and social [sic]. Additionally, STUDENT’s academic functioning is seriously impaired due to the effects of dyslexia. His reading and writing are most negatively impacted, although his mathematics skills are also impaired.

Ms. Scherba recommended that STUDENT continue his placement in the special day class for students with emotional disabilities.

STUDENT’s IEP team met on November 8, 1999, to review the triennial assessment. The team concluded that STUDENT should continue his placement in the special day class at the Stoneman School, a special school operated by the Los Angeles County Office of Education. The IEP also included counseling once a week for thirty minutes. The IEP also provided for assistive technology in the form of books on tape,and access to word processing, and a calculator. The IEP included a revised reading goal and continued the other goals and objectives that were established in the August 1999 IEP. The IEP did not contain any behavior management plan or goals and objectives relating to social emotional functioning. STUDENT’s mother approved the November 8, 1999 IEP.

In March, 2000, STUDENT’s school day was cut in half because of his behavior problems. There is no IEP document that provides for such a reduction. His revised schedule provided that he would be in school for only two hours per day.

STUDENT’s IEP team met for its annual review of his program on November 1, 2000. The only people to attend the meeting were an administrator, STUDENT’s mother, and STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Ms. Kwan. The IEP that was drafted was almost identical to the prior year’s IEP. It provided for STUDENT to continue in his program at Stoneman. It provided for continuation of weekly counseling and for assistive technology in the form of access to word processing and a calculator. It also provided for a goal and objectives in relation to behavior. In discussing his present levels of performance in relation to behavior, the IEP states that “during his shortened day, he is now able now [sic] to identify his feelings of anger and he deals with his frustration appropriately 60% of the time.” The annual goal was for STUDENT to be able to identify his feelings of frustration and anger with appropriate coping behaviors for a certain percentage of the day. The short-term objectives provided for this goal to be accomplished during increasing percentages of the day (60-80 percent). Other than this goal and objectives, there was no behavior plan included in the November 1, 2000 IEP. STUDENT’s mother consented to this IEP.

A December 15, 2000 addendum to the IEP provided that because of his improved behavior, STUDENT’s school day would be increased from two hours to two and three quarter hours per day starting on January 8, 2001. STUDENT’s mother approved this addendum.

On March 14, 2001, the IEP team agreed to reduce STUDENT’s school day back to two hours per day because “he has not been able to manage his anxiety and his behavior on the longer day.” STUDENT’s mother approved this change.

During his time in the special day class at Stoneman, STUDENT’s teacher was Linda Kwan. She had minimal qualifications as a teacher and no training in special education. She testified that while she tried to address STUDENT’s academic goals and objectives, little, if any, progress was made because of his behavior problems. She said that she did not believe there was a behavior plan for STUDENT. She also said that STUDENT did not use assistive technology while he was in her class. She said that STUDENT did receive weekly counseling sessions and that she regularly discussed STUDENT and his behavior problems with the psychologist who provided the counseling.

STUDENT’s IEP team met on September 5, 2001, to review the appropriateness of his placement at Stoneman. The team concluded that “STUDENT has not made significant progress in his current placement in the Special Day Class at Stoneman School (LACOE). He continues to have difficulty functioning appropriately at school for more than two hours per day.” The IEP team concluded that a nonpublic school placement would be appropriate. The team agreed that while they were pursuing an appropriate nonpublic school, STUDENT would receive one hour per day of home teaching. The IEP provided that the goals formulated in STUDENT’s last IEP would be addressed during the home teaching. STUDENT’s mother, who was represented by advocates during the IEP meeting, took exception with STUDENT being designated as emotionally disturbed as his primary disability category. STUDENT’s mother agreed to the proposed placement, but disagreed with the eligibility designation and the goals and objectives.

From September 5, 2001 to October 21, 2002, STUDENT received one hour per day of home teaching while the District and STUDENT’s mother attempted to locate a non-public school that would accept STUDENT and be appropriate to meet his needs. The District recommended nonpublic placements that were oriented to the needs of the emotionally disturbed. STUDENT’s mother did not agree with such a placement and believed that a nonpublic school that specialized in addressing the needs of a learning disabled student would be appropriate.

During this same period, STUDENT’s mother requested a hearing. Prior to the hearing, an IEP meeting was conducted on February 13, 2002. Although she did receive notice of the meeting, STUDENT’s mother did not attend. The IEP team again agreed to a nonpublic school placement and recommended that STUDENT continue to receive one hour a day of home teaching while an appropriate NPS was being sought. The IEP team also noted that “STUDENT has been very cooperative when working with the home teacher. He has arrived on time to his lessons, has complied with his teacher’s directions, and has consistently put forth good effort.”

On February 21, 2002, the hearing was convened in relation to the request filed by STUDENT’s mother. Prior to presenting evidence, the parties attempted to negotiate a settlement. They eventually reached a settlement that provided that the District would assess STUDENT and the Department of Mental Health would conduct an evaluation under AB 3632. It was agreed that the IEP team would meet after the evaluations were completed. It was also agreed that STUDENT’s mother would submit an application to the Frostig Center, a nonpublic school, and the District would agree to provide documentation requested by the Frostig Center. STUDENT’s mother agreed to dismiss the request for due process hearing “with prejudice.”

In April 2002, an assessment of STUDENT was done at the request of STUDENT’s advocate by Dr. Jose J. Gonzales. In his report dated May 30, 2002, Dr Gonzales stated:

STUDENT is a 15-year old adolescent with a history of attention, behavioral, and academic difficulties. The school district has attempted various attempts to remediate these difficulties with little success... The same goals and objective [sic] have been attempted over and over without success. In addition, various placement have been attempted with also limited success. It appears that no attempt has been made to perform and execute behavior support plans or functional analysis of STUDENT’s behavior problems, in order to get a better handle on controlling his behaviors. Academic interventions have shown very little success, until most recently (last two IEP’s have shown some improvement).

Dr. Gonzales recommended that a behavioral support plan be developed to better address STUDENT’s past behavior problems. He also made a comprehensive series of recommendations to address STUDENT’s learning disability.

The District also completed an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the settlement agreement. The assessment was performed by a team that included psychologist Marilyn Scherba, coordinator of special education Chris Blackstock, language and speech specialist Rita Wilkins, and home teachers Al Albo and Edie Klein. The assessment report was dated June 22, 2002.

Academic achievement testing revealed that STUDENT achieved the following standard scores and percentile rank: Broad Reading SS 54, percentile rank 0.1; Oral Language SS 57, percentile rank 0.2; Broad Math SS 81, percentile rank 14; Broad Written Language SS 61, percentile rank 0.5.

The team also assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language and assistive technology. The team recommended the following elements be included in his special education program:

A. Address his serious academic deficits in the areas of reading, written language, and mathematics. B. Provide a high degree of structure and on-going feedback. C. Provide language services to address his deficits in processing, verbal reasoning, and expression. D. Provide counseling services to address the development of appropriate coping skills and to help STUDENT deal with self-control skills to lessen impulsive responses. E. Provide transition services for career/vocational planning F. Provide services in the area of assistive technology.

The IEP team met on July 2, 2002, to review the assessments by the District and Dr. Gonzales. The entire IEP team agreed that “STUDENT’s primary disability category for special education eligibility be changed from SED to Specific Learning Disability.” It concluded that his diagnosis should be “attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and specific learning disability (SLD.Dyslexia).” The team noted that STUDENT did not demonstrate behavior or social-emotional difficulties during the assessments. His home school teacher stated that he did not manifest any behavior difficulties during their one-on-one sessions. The team agreed that STUDENT’s needs would best be addressed in a nonpublic school that specialized in teaching students with severe learning disabilities. The team agreed to apply for STUDENT’s admission to the Frostig Center. The team determined that the home schooling would continue pending placement in a nonpublic school. It also agreed that STUDENT should receive counseling once a week for thirty minutes, and speech and language services twice a week for forty-five minutes. The IEP team also concluded that STUDENT required assistive technology and transition services. The IEP that was prepared on July 2, 2002, also noted that STUDENT’s mother “has opted to decline and exit all AB3632 services at this time.”(Footnote 1) The IEP team also agreed upon goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written language, language arts, math, independent work/study skills, social-adaptive functioning, and language-speech. The IEP also included an individual transition plan. STUDENT’s mother consented to the IEP of July 2, 2002.

The IEP team reconvened on October 10, 2002, to review progress in implementing the July 2, 2002 IEP. The team noted that the District referred STUDENT to the Frostig Center, but it had declined to admit STUDENT. The District sought out other nonpublic schools that specialized in addressing severe learning disabilities, including the Summit View School and the Westmark Schools in Encino and Los Angeles, all of whom declined to enroll STUDENT. The primary reason for the refusal by the nonpublic schools to admit STUDENT appeared to be his prior classification as having an emotional disturbance and the severity of his reading problems.

The IEP team agreed that pending acceptance of STUDENT by an appropriate nonpublic school, he should be provided greater educational opportunities within the District. The team determined that STUDENT should temporarily be placed in special day classes at Arcadia High School for four periods per day. STUDENT’s new IEP also provided that he would receive language and speech services twice a week for forty-five minutes each. STUDENT’s mother declined counseling services that were recommended by the district. STUDENT was also to receive assistive technology in the form of “access to pencil grips or rubberized pens/pencils, day planner, word processor with spell/grammar check, talking word processor, electronic speaking speller, calculator, electronic dictionary.” The goals and objectives of the July 2, 2002 IEP would be implemented with the exception of the D.I.S. counseling objectives. The transition plan from the July 2, 2002 IEP was also continued. STUDENT’s mother consented to the temporary program set out in the October 10, 2002 IEP.

During October 2002, STUDENT began attending four periods of special day classes at Arcadia High School. One of the periods is a math class taught by Darvin Jackson. There are 16 students in the class. There is also an aide who provides assistance to the students. Mr. Jackson testified that at least ninety percent of the aide’s time is spent assisting STUDENT. STUDENT has access to a calculator and computer in the math class. Mr. Jackson testified that STUDENT is making some progress on his goals and objectives and is on task most of the time. He further testified that STUDENT has not been a behavior problem, although he does not regularly return his homework. Mr. Jackson testified that STUDENT would have problems if the aide was not available to help him when he needs help.

Ryan Press is STUDENT’s world history teacher for one period each day. The class has thirteen students and there is one instructional aide. Mr. Press testified that he uses the world history text as a guide but that it is above the level of most of the students in his class. Mr. Press uses supplementary materials and workbooks to assist the students in understanding the material. Mr. Press testified that STUDENT participates in group projects but is somewhat passive. Mr Press said that he believes that the interaction with the other students is beneficial to STUDENT. He further testified that he has not had problems with STUDENT’s behavior. Mr. Press stated that STUDENT is making progress in his class. Mr. Press said that STUDENT has access to a computer in is classroom, but appears to be uncomfortable using it. STUDENT needs the assistance of the classroom aide in taking tests and working on workbooks.

During two periods, STUDENT is instructed by Ms. Michyel Munsell. During the fifth period, STUDENT receives instruction in assisted reading. There are thirteen students in STUDENT’s fifth period. Ms. Munsell has the assistance of instructional aides and the speech and language therapist, Ms. Wilkins, so that there are always three adults available to provide assistance to the students.

During the sixth period STUDENT receives instruction concerning written language. There are nine students in the sixth period and one additional adult to provide assistance. Because there are thirteen computers in the classroom, STUDENT can access a computer whenever necessary. Software for the computers includes an electronic dictionary, a speaking speller and a talking word processor. Ms. Mansell testified that STUDENT is making progress in her classes and that he has not demonstrated behavior problems. She also stated that she believed it is important for STUDENT to be in a class with other students to improve his social interaction. Ms. Mansell testified that STUDENT already has the equivalent of one-to-one instruction in her class, as she or an aide is always available to assist him whenever he needs it.

Speech and language assistance has been provided by Ms. Rita Wilkins. She provides assistance to STUDENT three times per week in his regular classes, once per week in his history class, and twice per week in his reading class. She also works two hours per week with STUDENT’s teachers on how to adapt their teaching to his needs. She testified that he does not have a speech deficiency but has needs in the areas of language processing, verbal reasoning, and verbal expression.

On January 30, 2003, STUDENT’s mother requested this hearing.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, the District moved to limit the scope of the issues to be addressed in the hearing based upon the terms of the settlement agreement that was negotiated on February 21, 2002, the first day of the prior hearing. The District contended that STUDENT’s mother agreed to dismiss the hearing request “with prejudice,” and therefore could not raise issues about STUDENT’s education prior to the date of the settlement agreement.

The Hearing Officer, who had also presided at the prior hearing, said that he would limit the effect of the “dismissal with prejudice” to the specific issues that were the subject of the prior hearing. He told the parties that he would ask the Special Education Hearing Office to pull the file from the prior hearing and make copies of the audio record of the first day of the hearing and ask his law clerk to listen to the audio record and make a list of the issues that were to be addressed in the prior hearing.

At the beginning of the second day of the hearing, the Hearing Officer presented to the parties copies of the audio record of the prior hearing, along with a document prepared by his law clerk setting forth the issues to be addressed in the prior hearing. During the prior hearing, the Hearing Officer had ruled that the following six issues would be addressed:

1. Whether the District failed to provide educational records. 2. Did the District perform inadequate testing and assessment of STUDENT in that it did not adequately address ADHD. 3. Whether or not STUDENT should be classified as “emotionally disturbed,” and what his primary disability should be (whether or not it should be “other health impaired”). 4. Whether any retaliation for disclosing alleged sexual harassment interfered with STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his program. 5. Did the District fail to provide a transitional IEP when STUDENT turned fourteen. 6. Did the District fail to develop an appropriate program and goals and objectives to address dyslexia.

The Hearing Officer ruled that there were only two issues (issues five and six) from the prior hearing that might arguably be issues in the current hearing. The Hearing Officer also ruled that he would interpret the terms of the agreement and the effect of that agreement on the current hearing in the way most favorable to STUDENT.

The effect of prior settlement agreements on future claims on behalf of disabled children who have rights under the Individuals of Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) can be determined by using contract rules. A different approach was used by the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. In the case of W.B. vs. Matuala , 67 F. 3d 484 (1995), the court held that “while we do not hold that settlement agreements which include waiver of related claims in the IDEA context are per se invalid, we will apply the more searching standards reserved for waivers of civil rights claims, rather than general contract principles.” The court held that when reviewing the effect of a prior settlement agreement in a dispute concerning a disabled child’s rights under the IDEA, “we will inquire into the totality of the circumstances surrounding execution of the agreement, and we will decline to enforce the agreement unless its execution was knowing and voluntary.” The court went on to say that in making such an inquiry

We consider such factors as whether (1) the language of the agreement was clear and specific; (2) the consideration given in exchange for the waiver exceeded the relief to which the signer was already entitled by law; (3) the signor was represented by counsel; (4) the signer received an adequate explanation of the document; (5) the signer had time to reflect upon it; and (6) the signer understood its nature and scope. (Citation omitted) We may also look to whether there is evidence of fraud or undue influence, or whether enforcement of the agreement would be against the public interest. (Citation omitted)

There is no clear authority in the Ninth Circuit concerning the appropriate standards to utilize in determining the effect of a prior settlement agreement on a claim by a disabled student under the IDEA. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the reasoning of the court in the W.B. vs. Matuala decision should apply in this case. In the W.B. vs. Matuala case, it was asserted that the parents of the disabled child had waived the right of the child to seek damages and attorney’s fees under 42 U.S.C. section 1983 when they signed the settlement agreement. In STUDENT’s case, there is even more justification for using a more expansive review of the terms of the settlement agreement because rather than bringing action in court to secure money damages, he is requesting an administrative hearing to review the appropriateness of his educational program and seeking any modification necessary to ensure that he receives some benefit. Such program reviews and modifications are his right under the IDEA and State special education law, and any waiver of such a right should be viewed critically.

There are a number of reasons why it would be inappropriate to bar STUDENT from raising important issues about his education because of the settlement agreement. While STUDENT and his mother were represented by advocates during the negotiation of the settlement agreement, those advocates were not attorneys and their conduct prior to and during the first day of hearing cast great doubt upon their competence to represent STUDENT’s interests. The District was represented by an attorney, as were the County Office of Education and the SELPA. While the terms “dismissal with prejudice” may have a clear meaning to those attorneys, it is unlikely that STUDENT, his mother or their advocates understood that meaning. STUDENT’s mother stated that she did not understand the meaning of “dismissal with prejudice.” It is fair to say that some degree of special expertise would be needed to understand the intended meaning of those terms. There was no evidence that the meaning of those terms was clearly explained to STUDENT, his mother or their advocates.

The terms of the settlement agreement do not support barring STUDENT from raising concerns about his program. The terms relate primarily to whether or not he had been properly assessed. The parties agreed to perform specific assessments of STUDENT. There was nothing in the settlement agreement that directly addressed the issue of whether STUDENT had been receiving an appropriate program from the district. The agreement was negotiated and executed on the same day, allowing little time for reflection on the part of STUDENT and his mother. Finally, it would be against the public interest to allow the settlement agreement to interfere with developing an appropriate program for STUDENT’s future education.

The District conceded at the beginning of the hearing and in its closing brief that STUDENT had not received an appropriate program during all of the three years prior to his filing his request for hearing. The District made constructive suggestions for modifications of the program and compensatory services to ensure STUDENT the opportunity to make up for lost educational services. It would appear that the District itself would not want to prevail because of an ambiguous settlement agreement, if prevailing meant not fully addressing STUDENT’s educational needs. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the settlement agreement executed on February 21, 2002, should not be a bar to STUDENT’s challenge to the appropriateness of the program he has received from the District during the past three years, nor should it bar him from a remedy that will fully address his needs.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disability Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 5600. FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id at 201.

In STUDENT’s case, the District conceded that STUDENT had not received a free appropriate education during portions of the three years prior to STUDENT’s filing a request for hearing in this matter.(Footnote 2) Although the District concedes this failure, it is appropriate to review the deficiencies in STUDENT’s program in determining STUDENT’s future educational program and any appropriate compensatory education to which STUDENT may be entitled.

STUDENT had three different placements and programs during the three-year period between January 30, 2000, and January 30, 2003.

From January 30, 2000, to September 2001, STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class for children with emotional disturbances at the Stoneman School. His program at Stoneman was inadequate in a number of respects. His teacher, Ms. Kwan, had little if any experience or training as a teacher. She had no training or experience in the field of special education. She admitted that she spent little time working on STUDENT’s goals and objectives related to his severe learning disabilities. She said that STUDENT made little or no progress in that area because of his misbehavior. She testified that he would run around the classroom screaming, laughing and generally disrupting the class. While Ms. Kwan admitted that she gave little attention to his learning disabilities because of his behavior problems, she further acknowledged that the IEP did not contain any behavior management plan. Although the IEP was amended in November 2000 to include a rather generic behavior goal with equally generic short term objectives, the principal approach used by the school to address STUDENT’s behavior problems was to reduce the length of his school day. In March 2000, the school cut STUDENT’s school day in half to two hours. There is no documentation to establish that this reduction was recommended or approved by STUDENT’s IEP team. Later, in December 2000, the IEP team agreed to increase his school day by three quarters of an hour. This longer school day lasted only three months. In March 2001, the IEP team agreed to cut the school day back to two hours because of STUDENT’s continuing behavior problems. However, there is no evidence that the IEP team considered or developed an appropriate behavior management plan. The end result of all of these deficiencies in STUDENT’s program at Stoneman is that he made no progress on the goals and objectives related to his severe learning disabilities.

From September 2001 to October 2002, STUDENT’s program consisted of one hour a day of home teaching. His home school teacher, Albert Albo, is a skilled and experienced teacher with thirty year’s experience in teaching students with learning disabilities. He addressed the goals and objectives in the IEP and testified that he made limited progress. However, Mr. Albo testified that one hour a day of instruction would not be adequate for any student, let alone a student like STUDENT who has severe learning disabilities. The home instruction was intended to be temporary while the district located an appropriate nonpublic school for STUDENT--the program continued for over a year.

In October 2002, the IEP team agreed to continue searching for an appropriate nonpublic school but decided that STUDENT’s educational needs were not being properly met in the one hour home teaching program. The IEP team agreed to temporarily place STUDENT for four periods per day at Arcadia High School. This temporary placement has continued through the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year. All of STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT is participating in their classes, is making progress, and is not demonstrating behavior problems. They also testified that it is very important for STUDENT to be in a class with other students. Although he needs a great deal of one-to-one assistance, he is able to benefit from group projects and other interactions with other students.

The temporary program was working well enough that in early 2003, the special education coordinator, Christine Blackstock, recommended increasing the school day to six periods. The attorney for STUDENT declined the proposal pending a decision from the Hearing Officer in this case.

Another way of evaluating the success of a special education program is to examine whether progress is made by the student during the program. The evidence established that STUDENT made little or no progress in relation to reading, writing and math during the three years prior to his request for hearing. In November 1999 he had a standard score of 66 in reading that placed him at .5% for his age. In May 2002, his Broad Reading standard score was 54, which placed him at .1% for his age. His Broad Writing standard score in 1999 was 61, which placed him at .3% of his age group. In 2002, he had a standard score of 61 and a percentile score of .5%. The Broad Math standard score in 1999 was 78, or 7% of his age, compared to a standard score of 81 at 14% in 2002. These assessments demonstrate that STUDENT has made little or no progress in his areas of weakness and is still reading at the second grade reading level. The testimony of all of the witnesses also supported the fact that STUDENT has made little or no progress in meeting his goals and objectives in relation to his severe learning disabilities during the three years leading up to the filing of the hearing request.

The evidence demonstrates that for the period from January 2000 to October of 2002, STUDENT’s program was not appropriate. Although his program at Arcadia High School was a great improvement over prior programs, both STUDENT and the District agreed that the program was not sufficient.

The District proposed a program for STUDENT for the remainder of the 2002-2003 extended school year and the 2003-2004 school year including the extended school year. STUDENT agrees with many aspects of their recommendations, but disagrees with others. Both the District and STUDENT agree that some form of compensatory education is appropriate, but they disagree on the extent and form of such compensatory education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will first address the appropriate program for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years and then will address the issue of compensatory education.

What is the appropriate educational program for STUDENT during the 2002-2003 extended school year and the 2003-2004 school year including the extended school year?

The parties agree on many of the aspects of an appropriate program for STUDENT. The specific elements of the program shall be examined below.

1. Placement of STUDENT in an appropriate nonpublic school. Both prior to and during the hearing, the parties agreed that STUDENT should be placed in an appropriate nonpublic school. Both sides agreed that the Frostig School would be appropriate. The Frostig School declined to accept STUDENT primarily because of his prior classification as emotionally disturbed. It is possible that the Frostig School may reconsider its decision in relation to STUDENT. STUDENT has now been successfully attending classes at Arcadia High School for nearly a full school year. He is no longer classified as emotionally disturbed and he has not demonstrated behavior problems in his Arcadia High School classes. The District should assist STUDENT’s parents in reapplying to the Frostig school and, if they are unsuccessful, should pursue other appropriate nonpublic schools.

2. Placement of STUDENT pending acceptance at a nonpublic school. Both STUDENT and the District agreed during the IEP meeting of October 10, 2002, that STUDENT should be placed at the Arcadia High School temporarily while an appropriate nonpublic school is located. The evidence demonstrated that he is making progress in all of his classes at Arcadia High School and has not demonstrated significant behavior problems. The District has recommended increasing STUDENT’s school day to a full six periods. STUDENT and the district believe that one of the additional periods should be for regular physical education. The district recommends that the other additional period be set aside for a study skills class. The testimony of the special education coordinator, Ms. Blackstock, supported STUDENT’s enrollment in such a class. There was no evidence to the contrary. Therefore, it is concluded that pending placement of STUDENT in an appropriate nonpublic school, STUDENT should be placed at Arcadia High School for a full six-period day, one of which will be regular physical education and the other of which will be a study skills class. He should continue in his other classes, including one period of history, one period of math and two periods of reading and written expression, until the IEP team determines that a different class should be provided during those periods. This temporary placement should continue during this summer’s extended school period and during the 2003-2004 year, including the extended school year, until an appropriate nonpublic school that will accept STUDENT is located.

3. One-to-one assistance by aides within the classroom. The testimony of the teachers of STUDENT’s classes at Arcadia High School emphasized the importance of providing STUDENT with individualized assistance during the class. Mr. Jackson, STUDENT’s math teacher, testified that 90 percent of the classroom aide’s time is spent in providing assistance to STUDENT. Mr. Press, STUDENT’s history teacher testified that STUDENT needs assistance from the classroom aide when taking tests and that STUDENT would need help in working with workbooks. Ms. Munsell, STUDENT’s reading and written language teacher, testified that she had enough assistance from aides in her class to give STUDENT the equivalent of one-to-one services when he needed such attention. The evidence establishes that STUDENT can barely read and will need individualized assistance in all academic classes. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that there must be available to STUDENT the assistance of aides on a one-to-one basis, to the extent necessary to allow him to fully participate in the educational program. While it is not necessary to assign a full-time aide to STUDENT at all times, it is necessary to have enough adult aides in all of STUDENT’s academic classes at Arcadia High School so that he can be given full-time individual assistance when necessary.

4. Speech and Language services. STUDENT’s current IEP provides that he should receive speech and language services twice a week for 45 minutes per session. Both STUDENT and the District agree that this service should be provided in the future whether STUDENT is in a nonpublic school or in his temporary placement at Arcadia High School.

5. Counseling. During the IEP meeting of October 10, 2002, the District recommended that STUDENT receive individual or small group counseling once a week for 30 minutes. STUDENT’s mother declined to approve this service. In his closing brief, the attorney for STUDENT recommends that STUDENT receive individual counseling “to address learning disability based needs, e.g., self-esteem, self-advocacy.” Although both sides agree that counseling is an appropriate service for STUDENT, there appears to be some disagreement concerning the scope of such counseling. The evidence establishes that STUDENT would benefit from counseling. Although his behavior appears to be appropriate in school, he still has problems with relating to others and self esteem. The testimony of the witnesses also supports the conclusion that STUDENT is benefitting from interaction with other students in his classes at Arcadia High School. Therefore, counseling once per week for 30 minutes per session should be a part of STUDENT’s program, but the determination of whether the counseling is individual or in a small group and the content of the counseling should be left to the counselor.

6. Transition Services. STUDENT’s current IEP includes an individual transition plan. STUDENT’s attorney claims that transition services have not been provided. The District’s witnesses testified that the transition services are normally provided in the latter part of the school year and will be provided to STUDENT. In any case, both parties agree that STUDENT should receive appropriate transition services.

7. Assistive Technology. Both parties agree that STUDENT should receive assistive technology equipment and services as recommended in the assistive technology assessment completed by the District on June 22, 2002. There was some disagreement as to whether STUDENT had been provided the services recommended by the assessment and incorporated into his IEP, but both sides agree that such services should be provided as part of any future program for STUDENT. STUDENT’s attorney argues that in addition to the services set out in the IEP, STUDENT should be provided specific training on the use of the computer and other assistive technology equipment and programs. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers at Arcadia High School supports the conclusion that he has received assistance in relation to the individual software programs used in the classrooms, but has not received any general training in the use of a computer. STUDENT does not have a computer at home and has had limited experience with a computer. The evidence does support the conclusion that STUDENT should be given general training in the use of the computer as well as training in the use of specific programs. Such instruction will be important to ensure that he can make the greatest use of assistive technology in addressing his severe learning disabilities. Therefore, STUDENT’s future educational program should include at least ten 60-minute sessions of generalized instruction on how to use the computer and its operating system.

8. Extended School Year and Transportation. Both parties agree that STUDENT’s IEP should include provision services during the extended school year and transportation to and from his school.

What compensatory educational services is STUDENT entitled to receive?

A child with a disability may be awarded compensatory educational services when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate education (FAPE). Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al, v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et al., 471 U.S. 359 (1985) In Burlington the Supreme Court held that equitable consideration should be used in determining the appropriate award of compensatory education.

In STUDENT’s case, both the District and STUDENT agree that some compensatory education is appropriate to remedy the District’s past failure to provide a FAPE. The District suggests that one hour per day of one-to-one tutoring, five days per week through the end of the 2003-2004 school year, would be appropriate compensatory educational services. STUDENT’s attorney recommends two hours per day of one-to-one tutoring, five day per week for the next five years. The Hearing Officer is of the opinion that two hours per day of one-to-one tutoring on top of a full six periods of classroom instruction would be difficult for STUDENT to absorb. As mentioned by educators during the hearing, some times more is not necessarily better. In the program outlined above, STUDENT will be in five periods of academic instruction with enough aides to give him one-to-one instruction when he needs it. The addition of one hour of one-to-one tutoring should provide him the assistance necessary to make up for much of what he has lost in the past few years.

As to the duration of the one-to-one tutoring, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that this form of assistance will be necessary until STUDENT graduates from high school or until he reaches an age that he is no longer eligible for services under Cal. Education Code section 56026(c). His reading impairment is so severe and his lost opportunities so great that he will need individualized tutoring for the rest of his time in high school. This provision of one-to-one tutoring should be available to STUDENT whether he is in a nonpublic school or continues at a public school program.

STUDENT also requests that the District be ordered to provide him with assistive technology at home in the form of a computer and software similar to that provided for in the assistive technology assessment of June 22, 2002. Ms. Munsell testified that the assistive technology is available to him in her classroom and he can complete his homework at school using that assistive technology. However, STUDENT’s math teacher, Mr. Jackson, testified that STUDENT does not return his homework. STUDENT’s IEP team agreed about the importance of providing assistive technology to STUDENT because of his severe reading problems. STUDENT does not currently have a computer to use at home. It seems logical to assume that providing STUDENT with the same assistive technology at home that is made available to him in school will only increase his ability to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer concludes that it would be appropriate to provide to STUDENT, as compensatory education, the same assistive technology at home that he has access to in school.

ORDER

Within 20 calendar days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet to draft an IEP that conforms with the program set out in this Decision. It will review STUDENT’s goals and objectives and make appropriate modifications and additions. It will include the provision of the following services for the remainder of the 2002-2003 extended year and the 2003-2004 school year including the extended school year:

1. The District, STUDENT and STUDENT’s mother will cooperate in applying for STUDENT’s admission to the Frostig Center. If STUDENT is not accepted at the Frostig Center, the District, STUDENT and STUDENT’s mother shall cooperate in locating another appropriate nonpublic school and take the actions necessary to secure STUDENT’s admission to such school.

2. Pending STUDENT’s enrollment in an appropriate non public school, STUDENT will continue to receive educational services at the Arcadia High School. Those services will include one period of regular physical education, one of study skills, and four periods of academic instruction determined by the IEP team to be appropriate for STUDENT.

3. In each of STUDENT’s academic classes at Arcadia High School, there shall be available the assistance of a qualified classroom aide who can provide one-to-one assistance to STUDENT whenever he needs such assistance.

4. Speech and language services will be provided to STUDENT two times per week for forty- five minutes each as is currently set out in his IEP.

5. STUDENT shall receive counseling once each week for thirty minutes in an individual or group setting as determined by the counselor.

6. The IEP team shall include an individual transition plan similar to the one in STUDENT’s July 2, 2002 IEP, but updated as appropriate.

7. The IEP shall provide for all of the assistive technology recommended in the assistive technology assessment dated June 22, 2002.

8. The IEP shall provide for transportation and extended school year services.

9. As compensatory educational services, the IEP shall include the provision of a one-to-one tutor five days a week for one hour per day. This tutor shall be provided whether STUDENT is placed in a nonpublic school or continues in the public school. The provision of tutoring shall continue until STUDENT graduates from high school or reaches an age that would disqualify him from eligibility for special education services under Cal. Educ. Code section 56026(c), whichever occurs first.

10. As compensatory education, the IEP shall require that the District loan STUDENT a computer and the computer software recommended by the assistive technology assessment dated June 22, 2002, to use at home so long as he is enrolled in the District.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: As to the matters in dispute, STUDENT prevailed on the issues of the need for general computer training, the length of time the tutoring would be provided, and the provision of a computer and software for STUDENT to use at home. The District prevailed on the issue of the length of the daily tutoring sessions.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this Decision. Education Code section 56505(i).

Dated: June 26, 2003 Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. It should be noted that during this hearing, neither STUDENT’s mother nor the district requested further behavior assessments or mental health services.

2. The law requires that a due process hearing request be filed within three years of the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of facts upon which the hearing request is based. Cal. Educ. Code § 56043(p). Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider any matters earlier than three years prior to January 30, 2003, the date the hearing request was filed.