California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 11, 2005
Student v. South Pasadena Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 176-05, SN05-00176, SN05-00227 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
South Pasadena Unified must provide six hours of missed counseling; Hearing Officer approves the District's Almansor nonpublic school placement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision refers to an earlier District-filed case, SN04-01217, which ended in an interim mediation agreement on August 8, 2004 and was withdrawn October 7, 2004. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
The parent of a 10-year-old fifth grader filed for due process after South Pasadena Unified recommended expelling him for a January 2005 playground incident. He was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance, with a secondary specific learning disability. The IEP team found the behavior was a manifestation of his disability and put him on home instruction. The District then filed its own case asking approval for a nonpublic school placement, and the two cases were consolidated.
On the first issue, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied the student a FAPE because it provided no counseling from the start of the 2004-2005 school year until January 7, 2005. The parent had declined counseling at the April 2004 IEP. But in September 2004 he barricaded himself in class, which showed a clear need. Even so, the District neither held the IEP meeting promised in mediation nor filed for due process under Education Code section 56346(c). The Hearing Officer added that SEHO had no power to enforce the mediation agreement itself.
On the second issue, the IEP plus a February 3 letter naming Almansor School was a clear enough written offer. Teachers testified that the 450-student campus was too large and lacked needed supports. Almansor's small, structured setting, schoolwide behavior system and mental health staff met his needs. The Hearing Officer ordered placement at Almansor for the rest of the year and twelve 30-minute makeup counseling sessions.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a parent's refusal of a needed service. When a district believes a declined service is necessary for FAPE, it must take action, including filing for due process. The decision also shows that a later letter naming a specific school can complete an IEP placement offer.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through January 11, 2005, by failing to provide him with DIS counseling services?
SEHO could not enforce the interim mediation agreement. But the District denied FAPE because it knew the student needed counseling, saw severe withdrawal in September 2004, and neither held an IEP meeting nor filed for due process under Education Code section 56346(c), so no counseling was provided until January 7, 2005.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue II. To receive a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at Almansor nonpublic school as offered by the District at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting and in the February 3, 2005 clarifying letter?
The January 27, 2005 IEP plus the February 3, 2005 letter naming Almansor was a clear enough written offer. Almansor's small, structured campus, schoolwide behavior system and mental health supports were designed to meet the student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue III. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, what is the appropriate remedy?
The student missed twelve 30-minute counseling sessions from late September 2004 to January 2005 and is entitled to twelve 30-minute compensatory counseling sessions during the 2004-2005 school year; his request to stay at Monterey Hills was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. Student shall be placed at Almansor Nonpublic School for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year to receive a FAPE.
- Compensatory education. Twelve 30-minute sessions of compensatory DIS counseling (6 hours), to be provided during the 2004-2005 school year; these may be concentrated to help with the transition to the new placement if the parties mutually agree.
Total: 6 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56501
People named in the decision
- Jennifer French, Coordinator of special education; District representative, South Pasadena Unified School District
- Louis Cetro, Police detective present at hearing at District's request, South Pasadena Police Department
- Mary Fletcher Marthe, Second grade/RSP teacher and assistant principal, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Sharon Alegria, Third grade teacher, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Dr. Kathee Bautista, Fifth grade special day class teacher; former District coordinator of special education, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Kimberly Kelly, DIS counselor, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Linh Pham, School psychologist (pre-expulsion psychoeducational evaluation), South Pasadena Unified School District
- Lisa Shah, Resource specialist teacher and home instruction teacher, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Joseph Johnson, Principal, Monterey Hills Elementary School
- Trisha Gordon, School psychologist (2004 triennial assessment), South Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Rosman, Student's private psychiatrist, Foothill Family Services
- Foothill Family Services, Private counseling and psychiatric provider, Pasadena
- Mr. Hernandez, Director of nonpublic school, Almansor School
- Almansor School, Nonpublic school offered and ordered as placement, South Pasadena
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in South Pasadena, California, on February 17, and 18, 2005. Student STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was present at the hearing and was represented by his mother, MOTHER. South Pasadena Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by its coordinator of special education, Jennifer French. South Pasadena Police Officer detective Louis Cetro was also present at the hearing on February 17, 2005, until approximately 12:00 p.m. Student testified on his own behalf and also called his mother, MOTHER, as a witness. The District called the following Monterey Hills Elementary School employees as witnesses: STUDENT’s teachers Mary Fletcher Marthe (second grade), Sharon Alegria (third grade), and Dr. Kathee Bautista (fifth grade); his DIS counselor Kimberly Kelly; school psychologist Linh Pham; resource specialist teacher and STUDENT’s current home teacher, Lisa Shah; and principal Joseph Johnson. Oral and documentary evidence was received. On February 22, 2005, the parties presented oral closing arguments to the Hearing Officer in a telephone conference. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Presence of Police Officer Cetro
At the request of the District, Officer Cetro was present when the due process hearing commenced on February 17, 2005. Student’s mother, MOTHER, objected to Officer Cetro’s presence at the hearing. The District’s representative, Ms. French, responded that she had requested police presence at the hearing as a result of a statement made by MOTHER during the February 14, 2005 prehearing telephone conference. According to Ms. French, MOTHER stated that she would not be able to contain herself in the same room with Ms. French unless the police were present. The Hearing Officer confirmed that MOTHER had made this statement during the prehearing conference and allowed Officer Cetro to remain. The Hearing Officer further advised the parties that Officer Cetro’s ongoing presence would be subject to review. Following the morning session on February 17, 2005, the District advised Officer Cetro that he did not need to return to the hearing but should remain on call. Thereafter, there was no need for Officer Cetro to return to the hearing.
Presence of STUDENT
During its opening statement and again during the testimony of STUDENT’s special day class (SDC) teacher, Dr. Bautista, the District expressed its concern regarding STUDENT’s presence at the hearing in light of the sensitive nature of some of the facts pertaining to STUDENT’s life that it needed to present in argument and through witness testimony. The District requested that STUDENT be excluded from the hearing for a limited time period during argument and testimony. MOTHER vehemently opposed excluding STUDENT from the hearing for any period of time. In response to the Hearing Officer’s questioning, STUDENT stated that he wished to remain in the hearing.
The Hearing Officer denied the District’s request to exclude STUDENT from the hearing. The District cited no authority for excluding a student whose educational rights are at issue from the due process hearing. Under State law, the parent or a guardian has a due process “right to have the pupil who is the subject of the state hearing present at the hearing.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(c)(1). (Footnote 1) To ensure STUDENT’s emotional well-being, however, the Hearing Officer advised STUDENT that he could request a recess at any time. Thereafter, recesses were taken periodically and STUDENT was present throughout the hearing, except for approximately one hour on February 18, 2005, when he received instructional services from his home teacher, Ms. Shah.
STUDENT’s Eligibility Designation
During the prehearing telephone conference convened on February 14, 2005, in response to questioning by the Hearing Officer, MOTHER agreed with the District members of the IEP team’s determination that STUDENT qualifies for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance as a primary disability and a specific learning disability as a secondary disability. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer determined that the issue of STUDENT’s eligibility designation, originally contained in the District’s statement of issues, was not an issue for the due process hearing.
Speech and Language Services During Home Placement
During the prehearing telephone conference, MOTHER expressed her concern that STUDENT was not receiving speech and language services in his home instruction, which was instituted following the January 27, 2005 manifestation determination individualized education program (IEP) team meeting. On the first day of hearing, the District advised the parent and the Hearing Officer that speech and language services, including make-up sessions, would be provided to STUDENT during the home placement. (Footnote 2)
ISSUES (Footnote 3)
I. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through January 11, 2005, by failing to provide him with DIS counseling services?
II. To receive a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at Almansor nonpublic school as offered by the District at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting and in the February 3, 2005 clarifying letter?
III. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, what is the appropriate remedy?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student contends that before the January 12, 2005 behavior incident that resulted in his suspension and recommendation for expulsion, his placement at the District’s Monterey Hills Elementary School was not appropriate because the District had failed to provide him with DIS counseling services. Student acknowledges that the District conducted a manifestation determination and withdrew its recommendation for expulsion after he requested a due process hearing, and that it also recommended a change of placement to a nonpublic school (NPS) designed to address the needs of emotionally disturbed students. Nonetheless, Student asserts that the District failed to convene an IEP team meeting within thirty days of the start of this school year to discuss counseling as required by an interim mediation agreement reached in a prior due process case. In Student’s view, this failure by the District was a cause of the behaviors that resulted in his suspension and threatened expulsion, as well as the District’s current recommendation that he be placed in an NPS. Student asserts that his placement at a nonpublic school is unnecessary because he is currently taking medication to control his behavior. Student requests that he be allowed to return to Monterey Hills to complete fifth grade, and that he be provided with DIS counseling services upon his return.
The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year and, specifically, that it has offered him DIS counseling services since his April 29, 2004 triennial IEP review. The District further contends that MOTHER declined or refused to consent to DIS services for STUDENT until December 16, 2004, and that it promptly provided DIS counseling to him after receiving parental permission to do so. In addition, the District asserts that STUDENT has serious emotional problems that cannot be adequately addressed solely by DIS counseling services at school. The District further asserts that STUDENT’s continued placement at Monterey Hills is not appropriate because his behavior is unpredictable and creates a risk of harm to himself and to others. The District asserts that STUDENT requires a small, specialized nonpublic school campus like Almansor School, which has a school-wide behavior program, specially trained staff, and services to address STUDENT’s unique academic, social, emotional, and behavioral needs. The District requests an order that STUDENT requires placement at Almansor to receive a FAPE for the remainder of the current school year, pursuant to its placement offer of January 27, 2005, and letter dated February 3, 2005.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a ten-year-old fifth-grade student of Hispanic heritage who has resided within the District’s jurisdictional boundaries and attended its schools since kindergarten. STUDENT is eligible for special education as a student with a primary disability of emotional disturbance and a secondary disability of specific learning disability. He is currently receiving home instruction. STUDENT has experienced numerous tragedies in his life, including a three-month premature birth to a drug-addicted mother, placement in foster care, and the death of his mother. STUDENT was placed in the care of his maternal aunt, MOTHER, who adopted him. STUDENT has been diagnosed by his psychiatrist, Dr. Rosman, with both attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and a mood disorder.
Until late January 2005, STUDENT attended a combined fourth and fifth grade special day class (SDC) at the District’s Monterey Hills Elementary School. On January 12, 2005, STUDENT lashed out at two students on the playground during recess. District personnel alleged that STUDENT placed a “clothesline” forearm choke on another male student in an attempt to remove that student from a swing. STUDENT then allegedly forcefully kicked a female student in her hip/thigh area and attempted to choke the same male student again with both of his hands. As a consequence of this incident, STUDENT was initially suspended from school, then recommended for expulsion for causing or attempting to cause physical injury to another person. On January 27, 2005, the IEP team determined that the behavior was a manifestation of STUDENT’s emotional disturbance disability. STUDENT was placed on home instruction five hours a week pending a determination of his appropriate placement, with a recommendation by District IEP team members that he be placed in an SDC class at a nonpublic school.
STUDENT has been eligible for special education since kindergarten. His initial eligibility was based upon a speech and language impairment manifested by delays in articulation, intelligibility, and receptive and expressive language for which he received speech therapy services. In February 2001, a psychological evaluation indicated that STUDENT was within the average range cognitively, but that he struggled in all areas of reading, spelling and language arts and that he had auditory and visual processing deficits. At the April 2001 IEP team meeting, STUDENT’s eligibility was changed to specific learning disability and he began receiving services from the resource specialist program (RSP) in addition to speech services. In November 2001, STUDENT began seeing a psychiatrist, Dr. Rosman, at Foothill Family Services, arranged for by MOTHER.
At an annual IEP on April 26, 2002, the IEP team added weekly DIS counseling services and recommended that STUDENT’s placement be changed to a special day class (SDC) beginning in third grade, in the fall of 2002. The parent consented to these services. The IEP team noted that STUDENT had experienced family losses. Although not specified in the IEP, this was a reference to the shooting death of STUDENT’s older brother, BROTHER, and to the death of his maternal grandmother in his presence. The IEP team expressed concern about the effect of these losses on STUDENT’s school experience. DIS counseling services and continuing speech services were again offered and accepted by the parent at the May 1, 2003 annual review. On October 23, 2003, the District prepared an IEP addendum to the May 1, 2003 IEP that added a DIS counseling goal to “display appropriate responses to non-preferred activities in the classroom setting.” This addendum was not signed, but contained a notation that the parent had given verbal permission to the school counselor in a telephone conversation that date to add the goal. Thereafter, DIS counselor Kim Kelly provided counseling services to STUDENT; however, these services were discontinued in January 2004 due to lack of parental consent to the addendum. (Footnote 4)
During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s behavior problems began to intensify. For example, on March 30, 2004, STUDENT was involved in an incident in which he was out of control and destroyed (“trashed”) materials in the classroom. Students had to be removed from the classroom and Principal Johnson called the South Pasadena Police for assistance.
In April 2004, in preparation for his triennial review, STUDENT participated in a psychological evaluation conducted by District school psychologist Trisha Gordon. Due to STUDENT’s language difficulties, Ms. Gordon administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence - Third Edition (TONI-III) to him that confirmed his cognitive abilities were within the average range. On other test instruments, STUDENT did not demonstrate any signs of auditory processing deficits, but he continued to demonstrate significant weakness in his visual processing ability in all areas. Academically, STUDENT continued to demonstrate strength in math and a relative weakness in reading. To assess STUDENT’s social and emotional functioning, Ms. Gordon administered the Behavior Evaluation Scale 2 - Teacher Edition (BES-2) and the Conners Teacher Rating Scale. On the BES-2, STUDENT had scores in the “significant” and “very significant” range in all five subscales of behavior that correspond to the federal and State criteria for emotional disturbance (learning problems, interpersonal difficulties, inappropriate behavior, unhappiness/depression, and physical symptoms/fears). On the Connors, STUDENT’s scores were “very significant” in emotional lability, and “significant” in the areas of oppositional, anxious-shy, and social problems.
From her assessment, Ms. Gordon concluded that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for emotional disturbance due to an inability to learn not related to any physical conditions, a failure to develop and maintain interpersonal relationships, inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances, a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness, and physical symptoms/fears associated with school. She also determined that he continued to meet the criteria for specific learning disability due to the existence of a significant discrepancy between his ability and his achievement in the area of decoding along with deficits in visual processing. Ms. Gordon recommended that emotional disturbance be determined to be STUDENT’s primary disability because it had a greater effect on his educational performance than did his learning disability, due to his noncompliance and withdrawal in the classroom. Ms. Gordon also concluded that STUDENT’s current educational placement was not able to meet his social/emotional needs. She recommended a change of placement to an environment with more individualized attention and monitoring of behavior problems, with a social skills curriculum integrated into the academic curriculum, and with school counseling to help him learn to manage his negative behaviors at school.
On April 29, 2004, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s triennial IEP review. STUDENT’s teacher reported that he was unwilling to participate in mainstream music or drama classes and that he ran away, hid under tables, and enclosed himself in confined places when he was stressed. Following a review of assessments, the District members of the IEP team changed STUDENT’s eligibility for special education to emotional disturbance as a primary disability and specific learning disability as a secondary disability. The IEP team also determined that STUDENT demonstrated “extreme” behavior two to three times a week that impeded learning by “leaving the classroom/campus, hiding under furniture, tantrums w/property destruction, physical aggression.” An individualized behavior support plan (BSP) was prepared to address these behaviors as well the behavior of ignoring teacher directives and “threatening, hitting, kicking, making noise & messing up room.” To address his problem behavior, the IEP team determined that STUDENT should participate in DIS counseling, verbalize his feelings and needs, attempt academic tasks, negotiate reasonable breaks and choices, and follow directives of authority figures. Two specific teaching strategies for new behavior instruction were identified: (1) “DIS counseling services to address social skills, sportsmanship, anger management, identifying/expressing feelings, needs, & options” to be provided once a week, and (2) daily assistance from the teacher in the classroom to help STUDENT “identify and verbally express his feelings, needs, and options.”
The District members of the IEP team also recommended that STUDENT be placed in a school program that addressed both academic and social/emotional issues. Specifically, the District offered STUDENT placement in an SDC class run by the West San Gabriel Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). MOTHER declined this offer of placement. The District advised her that it would not agree to continue STUDENT’s current placement at Monterey Hills beyond the current school year. The District offered STUDENT speech and language services, adaptive physical education (APE), and individual counseling services once a week for thirty minutes. At the conclusion of this IEP meeting, MOTHER gave her consent to the goals and objectives, to the current placement, and to speech and APE services. She declined consent to emotional disturbance eligibility, or to DIS counseling services.
On May 5, 2004, STUDENT was involved in a behavior incident in which he destroyed class property and other students had to be removed from the classroom while staff attempted to calm him down. On May 11, 2004, another incident occurred in which STUDENT refused to comply with a request and eventually threw objects around the room and was unable to regain control. South Pasadena police were called to the campus and MOTHER took STUDENT home. He was suspended for one day for this incident.
On May 14, 2004, Ms. French wrote to MOTHER to reiterate the District’s offer to place STUDENT in the fifth grade SDC classroom at Mission School, described as a highly structured environment with a school-wide behavioral support program not available at Monterey Hills and with teachers and staff with extensive training in behavior interventions.
On May 19, 2004, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing regarding STUDENT’s additional, primary eligibility as emotionally disturbed and requesting a determination that it had offered him a FAPE at the Mission School. A due process hearing in that case, SN04-01217, was scheduled for June 8, 2004.
On August 8, 2004, the parties entered into an interim mediation agreement in SN04-01217 in which they agreed that STUDENT’s eligibility for special education was based upon emotional disturbance as a primary disability and specific learning disability as a secondary disability, that STUDENT would “begin the 2004-2005 school year at Monterey Hills until parties agree otherwise or a hearing officer orders otherwise,” and that “an IEP meeting will be held within the first 30 days to discuss counseling.” (Footnote 5) On October 7, 2004, Case No. SN04-01217 was withdrawn by the District.
In September 2004, STUDENT began fifth grade in Dr. Kathee Bautista’s combined fourth and fifth grade SDC at Monterey Hills. STUDENT continued to exhibit concerning behaviors, including several episodes of barricading himself in a time-out area and nearly pulling bookshelf dividers and books down on himself. Following a behavior incident in November 2004, MOTHER asked Monterey Hill’s principal Joseph Johnson about the status of the IEP for DIS counseling. He had no knowledge of the agreement to convene an IEP meeting.
On November 12, 2004, the District prepared an addendum to the April 29, 2004 IEP to add DIS counseling services once a week for thirty minutes for a period of one year. This addendum was provided to the parent along with a new annual social-emotional goal for STUDENT to express himself in an appropriate manner that displays respect for school rules when he is angry. The evaluation criteria identified for the goal and the objectives was “three out of four trials for two weeks.”
On December 6, 2004, Ms. French wrote to MOTHER expressing the District’s concern that the IEP for STUDENT to receive DIS counseling services was unsigned. The parent was reminded that services could not begin without her consent. MOTHER immediately replied to Ms. French expressing anger that the IEP meeting called for by the interim mediation agreement had not been convened. In addition, MOTHER asked why the DIS counseling was only for two weeks. She attached the November 12, 2004 IEP addendum and goal sheet on which she had circled the evaluation criteria “two weeks.”
On December 13, 2004, the District prepared a new IEP addendum to add DIS counseling services for one year that provided the same information as the previous addendum. A new social emotional goal sheet was attached to the addendum, with an identical goal and objectives and evaluation criteria, but written in a manner that did not highlight the “two weeks.” This addendum was signed by principal Johnson, who dated the form November 12, 2004. MOTHER signed the addendum on December 16, 2004.
Following the winter recess (December 20 through December 31, 2004), DIS counselor Kim Kelly scheduled an individual counseling session with STUDENT pursuant to the signed addendum. The session occurred on January 7, 2005.
On January 12, 2005, STUDENT was involved in a behavior incident in which he was observed to use a “clothesline” forearm choke on another male student to force that student off a swing, to forcefully kick a female student in the leg/thigh, and to then return and attempt to choke the same male student with both hands. That day, a notice of suspension for six school days was issued. Later that day, an amended notice of suspension was prepared that indicated STUDENT was suspended for five school days and that expulsion was recommended. Mr. Johnson delivered these notices to MOTHER’s house.
On January 26, 2005, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on Student’s behalf from MOTHER as a result of the District’s recommendation that STUDENT be expelled. MOTHER alleged that STUDENT’s behavior could have been prevented if the District had provided him with DIS counseling services as agreed to in the interim mediation agreement, which she enclosed in support of the hearing request. As a proposed resolution, Student requested that he remain at Monterey Hills and receive all the special education services to which he is entitled. The case, designated SN05-00176, was placed on the expedited calendar.
In preparation for a scheduled manifestation determination IEP meeting, District school psychologist Linh Pham conducted a “pre-expulsion psycho-educational evaluation” for the manifestation determination. Because STUDENT was not made available for an interview, Ms. Pham conducted her assessment via a records review and an analysis of his social skills and behavior as indicated on rating scales completed by STUDENT’s teacher Dr. Bautista, his DIS counselor, Ms. Kelly, and principal Mr. Johnson. (Footnote 6) From her assessment, Ms. Pham concluded that STUDENT “does not possess the skills to adapt to changes in the environment.” She further concluded that, while STUDENT understands his behavior and is most often able to control it, he is presently a danger to himself and to others, and that his behavior of January 12, 2005 was a manifestation of his disability. She concluded that STUDENT would benefit from “a contained environment with an emphasis on social development and behavior management.”
On January 27, 2005, the IEP team convened for a manifestation determination review following STUDENT’s recommended expulsion. The IEP team reviewed Ms. Pham’s report and agreed that STUDENT’s behavior that precipitated the expulsion recommendation was a manifestation of his disability, because it impaired his ability to control his behavior. As a consequence, the IEP team agreed that expulsion proceedings would not be continued. Due to the absence of counseling services, MOTHER disagreed that STUDENT’s placement was appropriate before the behavior or that all necessary supports and services were in place and being provided prior to or at the time of the behavior. In addition, the team disagreed regarding whether his placement was currently appropriate. While MOTHER expressed her desire for STUDENT to remain at Monterey Hills, District members of the team recommended a change of placement to an SDC class in a nonpublic school “that was more intensive.” STUDENT was placed in an interim placement of home instruction, five hours a week beginning that date, “until placement.” A new behavior support plan (BSP), to address his aggressive behavior on the playground, as well as his withdrawal, was also included in the IEP. At the conclusion of this IEP meeting, MOTHER indicated her disagreement with the IEP.
On January 31, 2005, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on the District’s behalf from Ms. French. The District sought a determination as to whether STUDENT was eligible based upon emotional disturbance as a primary disability and specific learning disability as a secondary disability. The District also sought a determination of whether STUDENT required placement in an SDC at a nonpublic school to receive a FAPE as offered at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting. The District requested that its hearing be expedited due to the unpredictability of STUDENT’s behaviors and its belief that this raised a concern for his well being and that of others at Monterey Hills. The District also requested to consolidate its case, designated SN05-00227, with the Student’s case. In support of its request, the District submitted numerous documents, including the interim mediation agreement.
On February 9, 2005, the Hearing Office granted the District’s unopposed request to consolidate its case with that filed by the Student.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), Students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the Student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the Student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the Student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code section 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Supreme Court further recognized the importance of adherence to IDEA’s procedural requirements. Id. at 205. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U. S.C. § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
To determine whether STUDENT was offered a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year at the April 29, 2004 triennial IEP and when it changed its placement offer at the January 27, 2005 IEP, the hearing officer must determine whether the District’s offer was procedurally appropriate and whether it (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP.
I. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through January 11, 2005, by failing to provide him with DIS counseling services?
Procedural Appropriateness
The uncontradicted evidence established that the District offered STUDENT DIS counseling services once a week for thirty minutes at the April 28, 2004 triennial IEP, but that MOTHER refused to consent to this service. Student did not raise any procedural challenges to the District’s offer of services made at the April 29, 2004 triennial IEP meeting for the 2004-2005 school year. Rather, Student asserts that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to convene an IEP meeting within thirty days after the start of the 2004-2005 school year to discuss counseling as it had agreed in an interim mediation agreement reached in its prior due process case, SN04-01217. In Student’s view, this failure by the District caused delay in the provision of counseling that adversely affected his behavior at school and resulted in the current situation.
As discussed at the hearing, the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to enforce full or partial settlement agreements entered into by the parties. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a). Accordingly, the District’s undisputed failure to comply with this portion of the August 8, 2004 interim agreement does not establish a denial of FAPE on procedural grounds.
Substantive Appropriateness
There Was No Dispute That DIS Counseling Services Were Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Counseling Needs and to Provide Him with Some Educational Benefit
Student raises a very narrow issue of whether the District denied him a FAPE from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to January 11, 2005, by failing to provide him with DIS counseling services. Student does not contest that the DIS counseling services offered to him at the April 29, 2004 IEP meeting were designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Rather, Student’s contention is that the District failed to take appropriate action to implement its offered counseling services in September 2004 to ensure that the services he received comported with those the District believed were necessary for him to benefit from his education. To address Student’s assertion, the Hearing Officer first reviews STUDENT’s uncontested unique need for counseling services.
STUDENT’s unique counseling needs
There was no dispute between the parties that STUDENT had a unique social-emotional need for counseling at the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. As previously discussed, STUDENT has experienced numerous losses in his life. MOTHER testified that she has provided STUDENT with several forms of counseling that were approved as part of her adoption assistance for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that STUDENT and his older brother BROTHER have been receiving psychological counseling on a weekly basis from Foothill Family Services in Pasadena since approximately 1999. In addition, MOTHER testified that STUDENT has been under the care of a psychiatrist, Dr. Rosman, at Foothill since November 2001, and that this has been primarily for medication management for Concerta, his ADHD medication, and most recently, for Trilepta, a mood stabilizer to address his mood disorder. (Footnote 7)
At the April 29, 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s teacher reported that he was not being successful in the mainstream component of his program because he did not participate in mainstream music or drama, that he had difficulty in physical education, and that “when stressed, STUDENT has reacted by running away, hiding under tables, enclosing himself in confined spaces.” As a consequence, his teacher advised the IEP team that STUDENT needed various services, including counseling. The IEP team determined that STUDENT required DIS counseling services once a week over the next year to address the emotional needs that affected his education, particularly his withdrawal from class.
Did the Services Provided Comport with the Services Offered?
As previously discussed, MOTHER refused to consent to the DIS counseling services offered to STUDENT on April 29, 2004. Following that IEP meeting, the District filed a request for a due process hearing to address STUDENT’s placement and the parties reached an interim mediation agreement that STUDENT could begin the 2004-2005 school year at Monterey Hills “until parties agree otherwise or a hearing officer orders otherwise,” and that “an IEP meeting will be held within the first 30 days to discuss counseling.” At the due process hearing, the parties argued about who had culpability for the failure to provide STUDENT with counseling services during the 2004-2005 school. While Student asserted that the District failed to implement the interim mediation agreement to address counseling services in an IEP in September 2004, the District asserted that the parent refused to consent to the April 29, 2004 offer of counseling services, and then did not sign the IEP addendums for DIS counseling services given to her by the District in November and December 2004 until December 16, 2004.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to take appropriate action to ensure that counseling services necessary to address STUDENT’s unique needs were provided to him in a timely manner in the 2004-2005 school year. The evidence established that District was aware of STUDENT’s unique need for counseling and of the parent’s refusal to consent to its counseling services offer at the triennial IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that new facts arose in September 2004 which highlighted STUDENT’s unique need for counseling. Specifically, the undisputed evidence at hearing established that, after his return to Monterey Hills in September 2004, STUDENT engaged in severe withdrawal behavior in Dr. Bautista’s classroom. Specifically, Dr. Bautista and assistant principal Ms. Marthe testified that, on at least two occasions in September 2004, STUDENT barricaded himself in the “safe area” of his SDC class, pulled books down on top of himself, and but for Ms. Marthe’s intervention, would have pulled the bookshelves on top of himself. These witnesses testified to their concern that STUDENT’s behavior posed a risk to himself. The District was aware that no DIS counseling services were in place at this time and yet it failed to take any action to ensure that STUDENT’s unique needs in this area were being addressed.
A school district has an affirmative obligation to offer and to provide a FAPE to all eligible students with disabilities who reside within its jurisdictional boundaries. If a parent does not consent to an IEP or, as in this case declines consent to a specific service, and a district “determines that the part of the proposed special education program to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil, a due process hearing shall be initiated....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(c).
The evidence in this case established that the District took no action to ensure that services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique counseling needs were provided to him in September 2004. Although the District had previously initiated a due process hearing regarding STUDENT’s placement, it withdrew that case in October 2004. After the two barricading episodes in September 2004 described above, the District did not request a due process hearing to ensure that necessary services were provided to him. In fact, the evidence established that the District took no action to address STUDENT’s undisputed unique counseling needs until MOTHER complained to Monterey Hill’s principal Joseph Johnson in November 2004 about the District’s failure to convene an IEP meeting as called for in the mediation agreement. While the District ultimately prepared an addendum for counseling services in mid-November, its failure to do so in an IEP meeting resulted in confusion regarding the offer and an addition month of delay. As a result of its actions, STUDENT did not receive any counseling services until after the winter recess. (Footnote 8) Thus, the counseling services STUDENT received during the 2004-2005 school year did not comport with the services the District offered to him at the April 29, 2004 IEP team meeting.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him counseling services to meet his unique counseling needs from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year until he received his first counseling session on January 7, 2005, just days before the behavioral incident that led to his suspension and threatened expulsion. II. To receive a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, does STUDENT require placement at Almansor nonpublic school as offered by the District at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting and in the February 3, 2005 clarifying letter?
Procedural Appropriateness
Student asserts that the offer made at the January 27, 2005 IEP was procedurally defective because the District failed to identify a specific nonpublic school for his placement. Rather, the IEP offered STUDENT a placement in an SDC class in a nonpublic school described as “specialized” and “more intensive” than his current SDC placement at Monterey Hills. The District contends that the IEP team discussed the key components of the offered NPS placement with the parent at the January 27, 2005 IEP, that these components were similar to those it recommended for STUDENT in April 2004 at the Mission School, and that it subsequently clarified its offer when it identified the NPS as Almansor NPS in South Pasadena in its letter to MOTHER dated February 3, 2005. “The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3). Pursuant to this obligation, a school district must make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of a student with a disability. Referring to the “great importance” the Supreme Court in Rowley placed on such procedural components of the IDEA, the Union court found that “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and ...should be enforced vigorously.” Id. The Court also emphasized that a school district cannot escape its obligation to make a written offer of placement based upon the parents’ unwillingness to accept it.
The Hearing Officer notes that at both the April 29, 2004 and the January 27, 2005 IEP team meetings, MOTHER advised the IEP team that she did not want to hear about any placement offers other than Monterey Hills. Nonetheless, the District has consistently advised her that it believes STUDENT requires an SDC placement with the following essential components: (1) a small structured campus to offer STUDENT safety and emotional support, (2) a school-wide behavioral support program, and (3) teachers and aides who are trained in behavioral interventions. Dr. Bautista persuasively testified that, although a specific NPS was not discussed at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting, the IEP team advised MOTHER of the need for an NPS with these components. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that following the District’s February 3, 2005 letter identifying the NPS as Almansor School, MOTHER, STUDENT, and District RSP teacher and assistant principal Ms. Marthe visited Almansor School and discussed the program with its director, Mr. Hernandez. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the January 27, 2005 IEP document as supplemented by the February 3, 2005 letter specifically identifying Almansor School was a sufficiently coherent written offer for the parent to consider in determining whether to accept or reject the placement for STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
The District asserts that STUDENT requires placement in a highly structured nonpublic SDC at Almansor School to receive a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year due to his increasingly severe behaviors that have impeded his learning and placed him and others at risk of injury. In essence, the District contends that Monterey Hills is simply no longer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique emotional and behavioral needs and that it is for this reason that it recommended a change in placement at the January 27, 2005 IEP, after it determined that STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his emotional disturbance disability. In Student’s view, he should be allowed to complete his school year at Monterey because he is familiar with this environment, he is now on medication for outbursts relating to his mood disorder, and he can receive an appropriate education with the regular provision of DIS counseling services.
The Hearing Officer notes that Student argued that the District could place him in the resource specialist room with Ms. Marke where he will receive individualized help and be occasionally joined in class by RSP students. Student contends that the District implemented this type of placement to address his older brother’s violent outbursts, that the placement was effective, and that it should therefore be effective with him because he is less violent than his brother. In determining whether the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE, however, the Hearing Officer must focus on the placement actually proposed by the District, rather than on the placement that is preferred by the parent. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).
Is the District’s Offer of Placement at Almansor Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
1. What are STUDENT’s unique needs?
Before considering whether the District’s offer of placement at Almansor for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine what his unique needs are.
a. Unique Social-Emotional and Behavioral Needs for Counseling, for Social Skills Development, and for a Small Structured School Environment
As previously discussed, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT has a unique social-emotional need for DIS counseling. Testimony at the hearing established that STUDENT’s unique social-emotional and behavioral needs intensified during the 2004-2005 school year. Specifically, Dr. Bautista testified that STUDENT’s unique social-emotional and behavioralneeds were exhibited increasingly in two primary ways: first, by his withdrawal from the larger student body as well as from his SDC class and, second, by physical aggression that culminated in a serious assault on two students on January 12, 2005. In addition to his unique need for counseling services, the evidence persuasively established that STUDENT has unique social-emotional and behavioral needs for social skills development, including anger management and conflict resolution, and for a small learning environment with an emphasis on social development and behavior management.
First, the evidence established that STUDENT has a unique social-emotional need for social skills development. STUDENT’s need for social skills training was initially identified by his fourth grade teacher at the April 29, 2004 IEP team meeting when she reported his withdrawal from mainstream music and drama classes and his classroom behavior of hiding under tables and enclosing himself in confined spaces. The intensity of STUDENT’s need for social skills development was recognized by the District’s school psychologist, Linh Pham, in her January 2005 psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT completed for the manifestation determination. Ms. Pham reported that, on the BASC rating scales completed by the teacher, DIS counselor and principal, STUDENT’s adaptive skills composite, which includes his social skills, leadership, adaptability and study skills, was ranked in the “clinically significant” range. STUDENT’s social skills deficits were also described by MOTHER, who testified that he is very territorial about toys and rigid in his application of rules to others. Dr. Bautista testified that, after the 2004 Christmas recess, STUDENT had become possessive of the swings and kicked a student because he wanted to save a swing. He later kicked Dr. Bautista when she tried to enforce a consequence of recess restriction for this behavior. The January 12, 2005 behavior incident that led to recommended expulsion was precipitated by the “violation” of a rule limiting the number of swings allowed when other students are waiting to use the swing equipment. STUDENT counted the excess number of swings being taken by the male student and then acted to remove him from the swing.
Despite STUDENT’s social skills deficits, the evidence established that he has a desire to socialize with peers as well as a desire to relate to trusted adult figures. Dr. Bautista testified that STUDENT is a student who has a strong desire to socialize and who wants to have friends and to be a friend. From her knowledge and observation of STUDENT during his fourth and fifth grade years, Dr. Bautista testified that STUDENT needs to learn how to be a friend, and to understand the “give and take” of friendship. The evidence also persuasively established that STUDENT enjoys and responds well to familiar adult figures at school, whom he enjoys assisting. It is also apparent that STUDENT has developed a sense of trust with some adults at Monterey Hills. For example, Dr. Bautista testified that STUDENT was able to tell her that he did not want to participate in school activities in which he would be mixed with students from the larger campus. He was also able to talk things out with her during their private walks that were instituted as part of STUDENT’s April 29, 2004 behavior support plan for the teacher to assist him in identifying, and verbally expressing his feelings, needs, and options. From this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has a unique need for social skills development that includes skill building in anger management and in conflict resolution.
Second, the evidence persuasively established that STUDENT has a unique social-emotional need for a small learning environment and that he is more comfortable in small groups of peers that he knows. Dr. Bautista testified that although STUDENT really wants to be part of a group and participate, he has a fear of interacting with unfamiliar students and in large group activities. As indicated above, STUDENT has demonstrated this fear by not participating in mainstream drama or music classes, or in school assemblies with other children. Rather, he has specifically requested to be assigned other activities rather than attend such events. In addition, STUDENT’s fear is exhibited by acting out on the playground with unfamiliar students.
As indicated in the testimony of Dr. Bautista and Ms. Marthe and as reported to the IEP team in April 2004 and January 2005, STUDENT has increasingly withdrawn from group activities in his small SDC classroom by hiding under tables, and enclosing himself in confined spaces. Dr. Bautista testified that she set up a “safe zone” for the SDC entire class where students could voluntarily go to calm themselves. This area was set up next to the library between two bookcases. Dr. Bautista testified that, once this zone was set up, STUDENT moved his whole desk there as if he was seeking a safe place. Both Dr. Bautista and Ms. Marthe testified about the two episodes of barricading himself into this area that occurred in September 2004. These witnesses testified that STUDENT appears to feel unsafe at Monterey Hills and that his increasingly isolative behaviors seem to be an attempt to communicate this feeling. From this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has a unique social-emotional need for a small learning environment with an emphasis on social development and behavior management.
Third, the weight of the evidence establishes that STUDENT has unique behavioral needs that have escalated since the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. STUDENT has increasingly engaged in withdrawal behavior that District staff believed to be potentially harmful to himself. In addition, the testimony of Ms. Marke, Ms. Kelly, Mr. Johnson, and Dr. Bautista established that STUDENT’s behaviors in the classroom have disrupted his education as well as those of other students, who have had to be removed from class on several occasions while District staff attempted to calm him down. Most recently, in January 2005, STUDENT engaged for the first time in significant aggressive behavior against peers at school.
STUDENT’s unique behavior needs were recognized by the IEP team at the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting in a revised behavior support plan (BSP). The BSP established a behavioral goal of having STUDENT participate in recreational activities with increasing independence while sharing games with peers in a safe and respectful manner, measured by the elimination of physically aggressive behaviors. The IEP team noted that STUDENT’s discomfort about participating in large group activities with unknown peers on a comprehensive campus results in his display of territorial behavior, most recently manifested in acts of aggression. Due to STUDENT’s fear of unfamiliar students in the large unstructured playground area at Monterey and the manner in which it escalates his aggressive behavior, the BSP recommended a change in STUDENT’s environment to “a smaller population group.” Dr. Bautista persuasively testified that she has attempted unsuccessfully to find a time and location on the Monterey campus where STUDENT can participate in recreational activities without the presence of a large number of students from other classes. In her opinion, STUDENT’s BSP cannot be effectively implemented on the Monterey campus. From this, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has unique behavior needs, including a need for his behavior support plan to be implemented in an appropriate environment.
b. Unique Academic Needs
STUDENT’s unique academic needs were not disputed by the parties. STUDENT’s cognitive abilities are within the average range and he has significant weakness in his visual processing ability. Academically, STUDENT has consistently demonstrated a strength in math and a relative weakness in reading. STUDENT’s present levels of performance in both the April 2004 and January 2005 IEPs in reading were generally one year to eighteen months below grade level, with some comprehension difficulties. STUDENT’s specific learning disability is based upon a discrepancy between his ability and his achievement in basic reading and written expression
STUDENT’s emotional status has affected his ability to learn, primarily due to his withdrawal in the classroom. It was for this reason that the IEP team determined that emotional disturbance was STUDENT’s primary disability category, with specific learning disability as a secondary disability. As indicated by Dr. Bautista , STUDENT’s greatest academic need is an ability to attend to instruction. She testified that STUDENT’s emotional withdrawal has impeded his ability to attend to instruction, even in his areas of strength such as math. (Footnote 9)
c. Unique Speech Needs
There was also no dispute between the parties that STUDENT has unique speech needs that require ongoing speech and language services to address his articulation difficulties with several phoneme clusters in conversational speech, as well as his language delays in the use of past tense verbs. * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT has unique social-emotional needs for counseling, for social skills development, including in the areas of anger management and conflict resolution, and for a small learning environment with an emphasis on social development and behavior management where his BSP can be implemented. Finally, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT has unique academic needs relating to his specific learning disability, as well as unique speech and language needs for speech therapy.
2. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
At the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting, the IEP team continued to offer STUDENT thirty minutes a week of DIS counseling services, and two thirty-minute sessions a week of both adaptive physical education, and speech and language services. In addition, the IEP team revised STUDENT’s behavior support plan (BSP) to address his withdrawal and his aggressive behavior against other students on playground. Student does not assert that these services are not designed to meet his unique needs. Rather, the sole controversy is with the District’s offer to change STUDENT’s SDC placement from Monterey Hills to a nonpublic school, Almansor School.
District staff familiar with STUDENT’s history and needs testified uniformly that his placement at Monterey Hills was no longer designed to meet his unique needs because the comprehensive campus of 450 students was too large for him and because it lacked the structure, trained staff, and behavioral and emotional supports necessary to address his unique needs. District witnesses also persuasively testified that the program at Almansor is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Evidence regarding Almansor School was elicited primarily from two witnesses: resource specialist program (RSP) teacher and assistant principal, Ms. Marthe, who toured the campus with STUDENT and MOTHER in February 2005, and from fifth grade SDC teacher, Dr. Bautista. The Hearing Officer finds that both Ms. Marthe and Dr. Bautista have extensive experience and understanding of STUDENT’s unique needs based upon their work with him at Monterey Hills over several years. Ms. Marthe testified that she was STUDENT’s RSP teacher in second grade, during the 2001-2002 school year, that she worked with him in Ms. Alegria’s class during the 2002-2003 school year, and that she has had extensive contact with him in Dr. Bautista’s class during the current school year due to his increasing behavior problems and her role as the principal’s designee. It was also apparent from testimony by STUDENT and MOTHER that STUDENT has a rapport with Ms. Marthe and wanted to be placed in her RSP class for the remainder of the school year. Dr. Bautista testified that she was STUDENT’s SDC teacher from September 2004 through January 2005 and that she also was involved with him during his fourth grade year when he had behavioral outbursts that required intervention and calming strategies.
In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that both these witnesses have additional expertise that lends weight to their testimony. First, Ms. Marthe testified that, in addition to her master’s degree in special education, she is a certified educational therapist, and that her training in this capacity is to look at the whole life of a child to determine the appropriate educational setting. Although Ms. Marthe was not acting in the capacity of an educational therapist for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that her training in this discipline, coupled with her knowledge of STUDENT, gives her a greater depth of understanding regarding his placement needs. Second, Dr. Bautista testified that she has a master’s degree in special education, a doctoral degree in educational leadership, and that for the previous four years she worked for the District as the coordinator of special education. She testified that, in this capacity, she was responsible for placing a number of District students at Almansor School, as well as for monitoring their progress, and attending IEP team meetings at the school.
From the undisputed testimony of Ms. Marthe and Dr. Bautista, the Hearing Officer finds that Almansor School is a small structured campus designed to meet STUDENT’s unique social-emotional and behavioral needs. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that Almansor provides an environment where STUDENT’s BSP can be fully implemented. Although there was no testimony regarding the total student population at Almansor, Dr. Bautista testified that there are eight classrooms in a small community. Ms. Marthe testified that, because many of the pupils at Almansor experience difficulty in unstructured recess times, the program incorporates many opportunities for structured physical activities in a smaller population. Ms. Marthe testified that social skills development is emphasized at Almansor in individual and small-group settings, and provides a school-wide behavior system with a reinforcement system designed to monitor specific behaviors in timed increments and to provide a token reward system. According to these witnesses, STUDENT has historically been responsive to token systems. These reinforcement systems would be supplemented by those incorporated into STUDENT’s revised BSP, as well the goals outlined in the IEP.
The Hearing Officer also finds that Almansor School has mental health and behavioral components that are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique counseling and behavioral needs. Dr. Bautista testified that Almansor School has a strong mental health component, that it has psychological and behaviorial aides on staff, and that it that can address STUDENT’s unique emotional needs that have manifested increasingly in his withdrawal and isolation. As previously discussed, both Dr. Bautista and Ms. Marthe testified that STUDENT’s isolative behavior strongly suggested that he did not feel safe at a comprehensive campus and that he required more structure, consistency, and frequent reinforcement. Following the January 12, 2005 behavior episode, for example, STUDENT was described as pulling his jacket completely over his head and cinching it up so that he was totally closed in. Dr. Bautista described Almansor as providing a community of adults who are experienced in working with students who need emotional support. During her tenure as coordinator of special education, Dr. Bautista testified that she had extensive contact with the staff at Almansor, and observed that its staff members were consistently interested in and participated in ongoing educational development, including attending staff development sessions offered by the District.
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that Almansor is designed to work with students of various cognitive abilities and that it can meet his unique academic needs. Contrary to a concern expressed by MOTHER, the evidence established that STUDENT would be placed in a classroom with students of a cognitive range similar to the students in his SDC at Monterey Hills. Dr. Bautista testified that, in her experience, Almansor has worked very successfully with students of STUDENT’s cognitive ability. She also noted that STUDENT had classmates in his SDC at Monterey Hills who were lower functioning than he.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered to STUDENT at Almansor is designed to meet his unique needs.
Is the District’s Offer of Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT Some Educational Benefit?
The Hearing Officer finds that the placement at Almansor School is reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit. In particular, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Bautista concluded that STUDENT’s greatest academic need was an ability to attend to instruction that was, in her opinion, being hindered by the lack of behavioral and emotional supports at Monterey Hills. This opinion was shared by STUDENT’s current home teacher, Ms. Shaw. The Hearing Officer has concluded that those supports will be provided at Almansor, and therefore finds that it is reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.
Does the District’s Offer Comport With The Services Actually Provided?
Because STUDENT has not begun attending Almansor, it is not necessary to address this component of the FAPE analysis.
* * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District made a coherent written offer to place STUDENT at Almansor nonpublic school, and that this placement is substantially designed to meet his unique social emotional, behavioral, and academic needs. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT requires placement at Almansor for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year to receive a FAPE. (Footnote 10)
III. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, what is the appropriate remedy?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy and there is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour relief. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.
In this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to address his unique counseling needs from the start of the 2004-2005 school year through January 7, 2005, when STUDENT received his first counseling session. Although the only remedy sought by the Student for this denial of FAPE was continuing placement at Monterey Hills, the Hearing Officer has also determined that STUDENT requires a placement at Almansor School to receive a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year.
To remedy this violation of FAPE, the Hearing Officer now finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory DIS counseling services from the District. From the end of September 2004, through his initial counseling session in January 2005, STUDENT missed a total of twelve thirty-minute counseling sessions. The Hearing Officer finds that twelve thirty-minute compensatory counseling sessions is an appropriate remedy. These compensatory counseling services may be provided within a concentrated period of time to assist STUDENT’s transition to the new placement if mutually agreed to by the parties; however, they shall be provided during the 2004-2005 school year.
ORDER
1. STUDENT shall be placed at Almansor Nonpublic School for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year to receive a free appropriate public education.
2. The District shall provide STUDENT a total of twelve thirty-minute sessions of compensatory DIS counseling services that shall be provided during the 2004-2005 school year.
3. All other requests for relief by Student and by the District are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
On Issue One, the Student prevailed.
On Issue Two, the District prevailed.
On Issue Three, the Student prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 11, 2005 ________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. In opposing the District’s motion, MOTHER also asserted that the District excluded STUDENT from IEP team meetings. The Hearing Officer notes that both federal and State law authorize a student’s presence at an IEP team meeting “whenever appropriate.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(vii), Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(7).
2. Unless the District and the parent agree otherwise, a student is entitled to remain or to “stay put” in his current educational placement under federal and State law, except where the student has engaged in offenses involving weapons or illegal drugs/controlled substances. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(1)(A)(ii), Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a). In this case, except for the parent’s request for speech and language services, no request for a stay put order was made.
3. The issues contained in the February 16, 2005 prehearing conference order were reorganized following discussion with the parties at the first day of hearing and for clarity of analysis.
4. The relationship between the parent and Ms. Kelly deteriorated during the 2003-2004 school year. MOTHER testified that Ms. Kelly had not read STUDENT’s file and thus lacked familiarity with the difficult circumstances of STUDENT’s life. As a consequence, MOTHER believed her not to be qualified to counsel STUDENT. Ms. Kelly testified that MOTHER had become so verbally abusive in a telephone conversation discussing counseling for STUDENT that she ended the call and asked Mr. Johnson to act as a liaison with the parent in the future. DIS counseling that had initially begun with a verbal authorization to Mr. Johnson in December 2003 was discontinued in January 2004 due to lack of written consent to the October 2003 IEP addendum.
5. Both parties consented to the admission of the interim settlement agreement. Cal. Code Regs. § 3086(b)(1).
6. The Behavior Assessment Scale for Children or BASC was completed by all three reporters. Only Dr. Bautista completed the Social Skills Rating Systems-Teacher or SSRS.
7. Student also submitted two letters from Dr. Rosman that corroborated this treatment. Dr. Rosman’s February 8, 2005 letter indicates that STUDENT has a mood disorder which has caused aggressive or destructive outbursts and that it was too soon to determine whether a prescribed mood stabilizer, Trilepta, is effective.
8. Ordinarily, when a parent refuses to consent to a particular offered service in an IEP, such as the April 29, 2004 IEP at issue in this case, there is nothing to prohibit the parent from later deciding to accept that service and to sign the IEP document to authorize the provision of the service initially rejected. The events which occurred after the April 29, 2004 IEP–specifically, the District’s due process filing and the interim mediation agreement-- created confusion and a reasonable belief by MOTHER that she could no longer simply consent to DIS counseling services by signing the April 29, 2004 IEP, but that she had to await a new IEP meeting to discuss counseling services.
9. Although the IEP team has determined that STUDENT’s specific learning disability is a secondary disability, his IEP must address the needs arising from each of his disabilities, as well as any other educational needs resulting from his disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(1)(A).
10. Because the Hearing Officer has determined that Almansor is an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is not necessary to address the placement preferred by the parent. The Hearing Officer notes that placement in a resource specialist class is generally less restrictive than placement in a nonpublic school. In this case, however, Student is proposing that he be placed essentially in a classroom by himself for one-to-one instruction with the occasional addition of RSP students. This proposal is clearly more restrictive than that offered by the District.
