California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 30, 1999
Student v. Vista Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1768-98 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Vista Unified offered a 5-year-old with autism a FAPE for 1998-99; claim for reimbursement of an in-home program denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
A related district-filed case seeking to assess without parental consent (SN 520-99) was dismissed by minute order on May 10, 1999. The dismissal was upheld on reconsideration by summary order on May 27, 1999.
Summary
A five-year-old boy eligible for special education because of autism filed for due process against Vista Unified School District. He had attended the district's language and behavior training class at California Avenue School, which used one-to-one discrete trial training (DTT), the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), and other methods. In September 1998, his mother removed him and placed him in an in-home DTT program supervised by Jessica Postil of Autism Spectrum Consultants. She asked for reimbursement. The district offered 25 hours a week at school plus 10 hours of in-home DTT, with occupational therapy, adaptive physical therapy, parent training, extended school year services, and transportation.
The Hearing Officer found the offer appropriate under Rowley. Experts Dr. B.J. Freeman and Dr. Ron Leaf, along with the district's data, showed more than minimal progress at California Avenue. That progress included eye contact, attention, functional communication, and imitation. The Hearing Officer rejected Ms. Postil's view that the student was a "reader" who needed special techniques. No evidence showed he needed a set number of hours or a home setting. The district should have coordinated home and school better, but its offer still met his needs. Claimed procedural violations caused no harm. These included mislabeling the program, which the district corrected in writing, and making a second compromise offer. No reimbursement was ordered. Claims about the 1997-98 school year were dismissed because no remedy was available. The family withdrew a separate reimbursement claim for another provider.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard when a family preferred an intensive in-home program for a young child with autism. Documented progress in the district's similar earlier program supported the offer. A promptly corrected mislabeling and a second offer made as a compromise were not treated as procedural violations that denied FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1A. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year? (A. Substantive appropriateness: whether the offer of 25 hours weekly of language and behavior training including one-to-one DTT at school, 10 hours weekly of in-home instruction, OT, adaptive physical therapy, parent consultation and training, ESY and transportation met unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit)
The offer met the student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, based on his documented progress at California Avenue; methodology and hours are left to the district under Rowley, though better home-school coordination was warranted.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1B. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year? (B. Procedural appropriateness: mislabeling the program as DTT rather than language and behavior training, making two offers at the November 18, 1998 IEP, misreporting progress, offer not based on agreed IEP, delayed implementation, and an inaccurate procedural rights notice)
Any error from mislabeling the program was promptly corrected in writing and caused no prejudice; the clear written offer was 25/10 and the 35-hour home offer was a compromise; no procedural violation denied FAPE.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the in-home behavioral program supervised by Autism Spectrum Consultants for the 1998-99 school year?
Because the District offered a FAPE, no reimbursement is owed under Burlington.
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue Dismissed-1. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education/a finding of denial of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
Dismissed because Petitioner disclaimed immediate compensatory education and no remedy could be awarded; deferring services to adulthood was not justified.
- Dismissed / withdrawnUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue Dismissed-2. Reimbursement for the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) program
Petitioner withdrew the CARD reimbursement claim on July 8, 1999.
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue Dismissed-3. Is Petitioner entitled to attorney fees for representation in this due process hearing?
The Hearing Office lacks jurisdiction to award attorney fees absent agreement; fees must be sought in court.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
Key authorities
Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Education Code 56441.2; Education Code 56176
People named in the decision
- Allan Roth, Director of special education, Vista Unified School District
- John Hannaman, District representative at hearing, Vista Unified School District
- Dr. Joseph Schwartzberg, Director, North Coast Consortium for Special Education (NCCSE)
- Linda Aubery, Language and behavior specialist; case manager, Vista Unified School District
- Lee Anderson, Principal, California Avenue School
- Dr. Cynthia Norall, School psychologist, Vista Unified School District
- Richard (Rick) Schroeder, Program supervisor, Autism Partnership
- Jessica Postil, Owner/operator, supervisor of in-home program; witness for Student, Autism Spectrum Consultants
- Dr. Lee Marcus, Expert witness for District; clinical director, Chapel Hill TEACCH center, University of North Carolina School of Medicine
- Laura Elliott, Special education teacher, California Avenue School
- Dr. Mitchell Taubman, Expert witness for District; director of research, Autism Partnership
- Chris Vinceneux, Private occupational therapist
- Dr. Ron Leaf, Expert witness for District; co-director, Autism Partnership
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, Expert witness for District; professor of medical psychology, UCLA
- Diane Tindall, Special day class teacher, California Avenue School
- Drusilla Kent, Special day class teacher, Vista Unified School District
- April Aitken, Assistant to Student's attorney
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Private in-home program provider
- HOPE Infant Family Support Program, Early intervention provider
- San Diego Regional Center, Regional center providing in-home services and shadow aide
- Noah's Ark, Private preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Vista, California, on March 2, 3, 4, 5, April 15 and 16, May 4, 5, 6 and 7, and July 6, 7, 8 and 9. (footnote 1) Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorneys Shelli Lewis and Patricia Cromer. (footnote 2) Petitioner's mother, MOTHER, was present on Petitioner's behalf. April Aitken, assistant to Ms. Lewis, was present for one day only. Respondent Vista Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Charles Weatherly of the Weatherly Law Firm in Atlanta, Georgia. Attorneys Eleanor Kattan and Kathleen Sullivan, both of the Weatherly Law Firm, also represented the District on some hearing days. The District was also represented by attorney Maria Gless and on some hearing days by attorney Jack Clarke, both of the Best, Best & Krieger law firm in Riverside, California. (footnote 3) Attorney Christine Dyer, also of the Best, Best & Krieger law firm, was present at the hearing on one day only. Present on the District's behalf was Allan Roth, the District's director of special education. District employee John Hannaman was present on behalf of the District on occasions when Mr. Roth could not attend the hearing. Additionally, Dr. Joseph Schwartzberg, director of the North Coast Consortium for Special Education (NCCSE), was present on behalf of the District for part of one day only. Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Allan Roth, District special education director; Linda Aubery, District language and behavior specialist; MOTHER, Petitioner's mother; Lee Anderson, principal of California Avenue School; Dr. Cynthia Norall, District school psychologist; Richard Schroeder, program supervisor at Autism Partnership; and Jessica Postil, owner/operator of Autism Spectrum Consultants. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Lee Marcus, clinical director of the Chapel Hill TEACCH center at University of North Carolina School of Medicine; Laura Elliott, special education teacher at California Avenue School; Dr. Mitchell Taubman, director of research at Autism Partnership; Chris Vinceneux, occupational therapist; Dr. Ron Leaf, co-director of Autism Partnership; and Dr. B.J. Freeman, professor in the Department of Medical Psychology at UCLA. (footnote 4) Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (footnote 5) (1) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-99 school year?(2) Is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the in-home behavioral program supervised by Autism Spectrum Consultants for the 1998-99 school year? PROCEDURAL MATTERS In Petitioner's due process hearing request and issue statement, received by the Hearing Office on December 29, 1998, Petitioner identified the following three issues for hearing: (1) Is the Vista Unified School District required to reimburse the parents for the costs of the in home behavioral program supervised by Autism Spectrum Consultants for the 1998-99 school year? (2) Is [STUDENT] entitled to compensatory education due to the fact that he received no educational benefit during the 1997-98 school year? (3) [Is] the [Petitioner] entitled to attorney fees for representation in this due process hearing? On the first day of hearing, Petitioner clarified that he also sought reimbursement for the costs of the program provided by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), the program Petitioner had recently begun; the Hearing Officer amended the issues accordingly. The Hearing Officer also informed the parties that Petitioner's attorney fees were not at issue in the due process proceeding because, absent special agreement of the parties, the Hearing Office lacks jurisdiction to order an award of attorney fees to a prevailing party. Petitioner must instead seek any award of attorney fees in court. On or about March 4, 1999, Petitioner and his family moved from Vista, California to neighboring San Marcos, California, outside the boundaries of the Vista Unified School District. Thus, Petitioner was no longer a resident of the District. When the hearing resumed on April 15, 1999, all parties agreed that Petitioner's prospective placement during the 1999-2000 school year was no longer at issue. On April 14, 1999, the Hearing Office received from the District a separate request for due process hearing, case no. SN 520-99. (footnote 6) The District requested the hearing because it sought to assess STUDENT over the objection of his parent. On May 6, 1999, STUDENT's attorneys moved to dismiss case no. SN 520-99, on the grounds that the District had no authority to assess a student who was no longer a resident of the District. On May 10, 1999, the Hearing Office issued a minute order dismissing case no. 520-99. The District moved for reconsideration of the dismissal, arguing that the District needed to assess STUDENT to determine if the District must provide the compensatory education at issue in case no. SN 1768-98. In his opposition to the motion for reconsideration, STUDENT asserted that he no longer sought compensatory education from the District. Based in part on those grounds, the Hearing Office issued a summary order dated May 27, 1999, upholding the earlier dismissal of case SN 520-99. When the hearing resumed on July 6, 1999, Petitioner affirmed that he no longer sought compensatory education from the District. However, discussions at the hearing the following day revealed that Petitioner nevertheless sought a finding that the District denied him a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year, with compensatory services to be provided when he becomes an adult and reaches the end of his special education eligibility period. Petitioner also indicated that he wanted the Hearing Officer to consider any denial of FAPE during the 1997-98 school year as equitable grounds for awarding reimbursement as a remedy for any denial of FAPE during the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Officer indicated doubt that relief could be awarded for the 1997-98 school year, given the legal and factual circumstances. However, in light of the then-approaching end of the hearing days, the extensive evidence already admitted regarding the 1997-98 school year, and the lack of prejudice to the District, the Hearing Officer ruled that the issue of denial of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year would not be dismissed at that time. Instead, the Hearing Officer took the matter under submission, and noted that the parties could include the matter as a topic in their closing arguments. After review of closing arguments and applicable law, the Hearing Officer now concludes that there is no remedy to award for any alleged denial of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year. (footnote 7) First, if the Hearing Officer were to find a denial of FAPE during the 1997-98 school year and were to order compensatory education as a remedy, the District would be ordered to provide the compensatory services immediately or in the near future. Particularly given Petitioner's young age, the Hearing Officer finds no grounds to justify delaying any compensatory services until Petitioner reaches age twenty-one. While Petitioner could have sought compensatory services to be provided immediately and/or in the near future, Petitioner explicitly indicated that he did not seek such an award, and the Hearing Office relied on that representation in dismissing case no. SN 520-99. Second, the Hearing Officer finds unavailing Petitioner's request that any denial of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year be considered in awarding reimbursement for the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Office does not render findings on issues for which no relief can be awarded. Thus, the issue of denial of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year is dismissed. (footnote 8) Additionally, at the hearing on July 8, 1999, Petitioner indicated that he no longer sought reimbursement for services provided by CARD. BACKGROUND FACTS Petitioner STUDENT is a five-year-old boy who is eligible for special education services based on a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT was first diagnosed as autistic when he was approximately two years, nine months old. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. C.) From the time of his diagnosis until his third birthday, STUDENT received services from the HOPE Infant Family Support Program (Testimony of MOTHER; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. N.) After his third birthday in July 1997, STUDENT began attending a District special day class taught by Diane Tindall at the California Avenue School. (Testimony of Ms. Aubery; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. V.) In September 1997, after STUDENT had attended Ms. Tindall's class for one month, MOTHER informed the other members of the IEP team that she believed STUDENT needed a longer school day. The IEP team agreed to increase STUDENT's class time from three hours a day, four days a week, to five hours a day, four days a week. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. HH.) To accommodate this longer schedule, the team determined that STUDENT would transfer from Ms. Tindall's class to a special day class taught by Drusilla Kent. The IEP team also added speech/language therapy two times a week (Ibid.) At the same time, STUDENT was receiving in-home services from the San Diego Regional Center. At the IEP on September 5, 1997, the team discussed the need for consistency between the school and home programs. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. HH, Respondent's Exhs. AJY00171-00172.) Later in September 1997, the IEP team met and made an addendum to STUDENT's IEP, adding adaptive physical therapy goals to his program. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. JJ.) After STUDENT had attended Ms. Kent's class for several weeks, MOTHER expressed to the District her concern that STUDENT did not appear to be making progress. In November 1997, the IEP team agreed to provide services to STUDENT during the extended school year (ESY) so that STUDENT would continue to receive instruction when he went off-track. (Testimony of Linda Aubery; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. KK.) Also in November 1997, the IEP team decided to change STUDENT's placement to Linda Aubery's discrete trial training class at California Avenue so that STUDENT could receive discrete trial training for 20 hours each week. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. LL, p.2.) Ms. Aubery became STUDENT's case manager, and STUDENT's placement was also changed to include a parent/staff meeting twice a month. (Ibid.; Respondent's Exhs. AJY00183, AJY-DT0008 - AJY-DT0010; testimony of Ms. Aubery.) STUDENT began attending the discrete trial training program in November 1997. In that program, the discrete trial therapists began with drills addressing STUDENT's readiness and attention skills. (Testimony of Ms. Aubery.) According to notes from the parent-staff meeting on March 2, 1998, at that time STUDENT was working on nonverbal imitation, matching and functional communication drills. His eye contact was improving, but was still inconsistent. He was also working on self-help skills; he was proficient at using a spoon to eat foods he liked, but had more difficulty with nonfavorite foods. He was not yet toilet-trained. In November 1997, the IEP team referred STUDENT for an occupational therapy assessment; that assessment took place on December 15, 1997. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. PP.) In February and March 1998, STUDENT's mother took him for a private occupational therapy assessment by Chris Vinceneux. (Respondent's Exh. AJY229A-AJY238, Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. SS.) Initially, the District's occupational therapist provided services, but pursuant to MOTHER's request, private occupational therapist Chris Vinceneux became the service provider. On April 23, 1998, the IEP team convened at MOTHER's request and signed an addendum to STUDENT's IEP. The addendum provided that STUDENT would receive two additional hours of discrete trial training for the purpose of coordinating his home and school programs. (Respondent's Exh. AJY00242.) The addendum also added occupational therapy services in thirty-minute sessions twice a week, and reinstated adaptive physical therapy for thirty minutes a week, with a weekly staff/parent consultation. Also at the meeting, MOTHER expressed concern that STUDENT was regressing during his time "off track" from school. In addition to the program provided by the District, STUDENT also began regular attendance at Noah's Ark, a private preschool, accompanied by a shadow aide funded by the Regional Center. In June 1998, the IEP team met for its annual review of STUDENT's program. (Respondent's Exh. AJY00252-256.) MOTHER asserted that the Monday-to-Thursday program was not meeting STUDENT's needs, because he needed instruction on Fridays as well. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. XXX.) The team members discussed that STUDENT had made progress on some goals, such as making eye contact, but had not met other goals, such as those in language and communication. (Ibid.) In the IEP Team Meeting Notes, District special education director Allan Roth noted: "Parent and staff concur that some of the goals and objectives from a year ago were inappropriate from the current perspective, and were therefore not met." (Ibid.; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. CCC.) The IEP team members agreed to the goals and objectives for the 1998-99 school year, and agreed that STUDENT's 1998-99 program would consist of the following: language and behavior training five hours a day, five days per week, except for one Friday per month when STUDENT would not attend school while the school staff received inservice training; occupational therapy twice a week for thirty minutes each session; occupational therapy parent consultation once a month for one hour; adaptive physical therapy once a week for thirty minutes; and "three weeks of Extended School Year for each off-track time." Accordingly, STUDENT went off-track on June 18, 1998,(footnote 9) but began ESY on July 13, and continued with school until the beginning of the 1998-99 school year on August 3. (Respondent's Exh. AJY00439.) By August 1998, MOTHER reported that STUDENT was demonstrating increased negative behaviors at home, including foraging for food, masturbating, spitting, smearing feces and climbing out of his car seat while in the car. (Testimony of MOTHER; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. EEE.) At the parent-staff meeting of September 3, 1998, MOTHER expressed her concern about the increase in these behaviors and about a lack of coordination between the home and school programs. (Respondent's Exh. AJY00331-332.) The District staff suggested a few options for dealing with these problems; for example, to facilitate coordination of the home and school programs, it was agreed that school staff would attend the next clinic meeting of STUDENT's home program staff. STUDENT continued to attend the discrete trial program at California Avenue School through September 25, 1998. By the end of his attendance at California Avenue, STUDENT was able to do nonverbal imitation drills that had chains of up to six tasks. (Testimony of Rick Schroeder.) He was still not toilet-trained, but he could pull down and pull up his pants with prompting. His communication with PECS cards was correct approximately 70-80% of the time. He showed some improvement in receptive labeling; he was able to correctly discriminate about 50% of the time when told to choose among three objects or photos. (Ibid.) On September 2, 1998, MOTHER took STUDENT to be evaluated by Jessica Postil, owner and operator of Autism Spectrum Consultants. Beginning September 28, 1998, MOTHER unilaterally placed STUDENT in a home program supervised by Ms. Postil. Initially, Ms. Postil began with a discrete trial training program of expanded trials and mass trials. Ms. Postil designed STUDENT's program to target negative behaviors that were socially inappropriate and interfering with STUDENT's learning, such as masturbating, climbing and picking at scabs. Ms. Postil's program used drill sheets from the Regional Center's in-home program, and included drills in receptive and expressive labels, receptive directions, matching, compliance, coloring, counting, shapes, eye contact, self-help, fine motor, gross motor, nonverbal and verbal imitation, and sight reading. (Testimony of Ms. Postil; Petitioner's Book #8.) On October 7, 1998, the IEP team met and reviewed a report prepared by Ms. Aubery on STUDENT's progress on his goals and objectives from the June 9, 1998 IEP. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. NNN; Respondent's Exh. AJY00346-353.) MOTHER stated that she disagreed with those goals and objectives because she felt they were not high enough and, instead, presented a new set of draft goals and objectives. (Ibid.; Respondent's Exh. AJY00358-361.) The team members agreed to review those proposed goals and objectives, and to meet again in the near future after that review. MOTHER also expressed concerns about several aspects of the offered school program, including inappropriate discrete trial training services, inadequate supervision of day-to-day elements of the program, training during lunch times and early release from school. MOTHER requested that the District fund an in-home "Lovaas" program for 35 to 40 hours per week and gave notice that she planned to immediately place STUDENT in such a program. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. NNN; Respondent's Exh. AJY00352-353.) In mid-October 1998, Ms. Postil determined that the program she had initially implemented for STUDENT was not resulting in the progress she had anticipated. Therefore, beginning on October 21, 1998, she changed several aspects of the program. (Testimony of Ms. Postil.) Those changes included presenting stimuli vertically instead of horizontally, presenting large printed words along with the stimuli, using books as reinforcers and designing the drills so that STUDENT could move around during the drills instead of sitting still. Ms. Postil reported that after she and the in-home therapists implemented these changes, in a short period of time STUDENT showed dramatic progress, including learning fifty-four receptive labels and becoming toilet-trained. (Ibid.) On November 18, 1998, the IEP team reconvened, this time with Ms. Postil in attendance. During the discussion, Ms. Postil told the team members that STUDENT's baselines were at zero in all areas as of October 7, 1998; the District staff disputed that assertion. (Testimony of Ms. Aubery, Dr. Norall.) The District offered to continue STUDENT in his discrete trial training program at California Avenue School for five hours per day, five days a week, with ten hours per week of 1:1 discrete trial training at home and occupational therapy 1:1 at school for two thirty-minute sessions per week. The District's offer also included adaptive physical therapy, parent training and consultation, extended school year services and transportation. MOTHER did not agree to that offer and, instead, again requested that STUDENT remain in his in-home program for forty hours per week and also receive his occupational therapy at home. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. PPP.) The District staff then held a "caucus" and returned with a new offer: 35 hours per week of in-home discrete trial training provided by District staff. MOTHER did not agree to this new offer. Thereafter, Ms. Postil continued to supervise STUDENT's in-home program until STUDENT was accepted in and switched to the CARD program in March 1999. On December 9, 1998, the District notified MOTHER that District staff wanted to conduct a new assessment of STUDENT, but MOTHER did not agree to this assessment. On December 28, 1998, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner a due process hearing request. On January 25, 1999, the District submitted to the Hearing Office a motion to conduct an assessment of STUDENT; the Hearing Office denied this motion. As detailed in the "Procedural Matters" section, supra, the District subsequently filed a due process request, seeking to assess STUDENT. On February 11, 1999, the District sent notice of an IEP meeting for February 23, 1999. MOTHER's representative informed the District that no parent or parent representative would be in attendance; the IEP team nevertheless convened on February 23, and again recommended a program of twenty-five hours per week at California Avenue School, ten hours per week of in-home discrete trial training, and the designated instructional services offered at the November 1998 IEP. (Respondent's Exh. AJY00442.)On or about March 4, 1999, STUDENT and his parents moved from Vista to San Marcos, California, and thus were no longer residents of the Vista Unified School District. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. 1400(d); California Education Code 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq.; California Education Code 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. 1401(8).) The term "related services" includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." California special education law further provides that for students between the ages of three and five years, special education shall include "specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. To meet this purpose, the program focus is on the young child and his or her family and shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement." (Education Code 56441.2.) (1) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-99 school year? Whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.) A. Substantive Appropriateness In determining whether the District must provide the program STUDENT is requesting, the Hearing Officer must evaluate the adequacy of the program the District offered. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) The U.S. Supreme Court has held that "the 'basic floor of opportunity provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.) Pursuant to Rowley, if the District's offer meets the child's needs, would provide some educational benefit, comports with the IEP and would be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE), the District has offered a FAPE. If the District's offer meets these standards, the District has met its legal obligation to the student, even if the parent prefers another program and even if the parent's preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. As long as a school district provides a FAPE, methodology is left up to the district's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 208.) Given that conformity with the IEP was not at issue for the 1998-99 school year, no analysis regarding conformity is required in this case. Thus, determining whether the District's program offered STUDENT a FAPE requires an analysis of whether the placement would have met STUDENT's unique needs and would have provided him with some educational benefit. 1. Was the District's offer designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs? Regarding STUDENT's unique needs, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT had relative strengths in matching, visual discrimination and nonverbal imitation. (See testimony of Mr. Schroeder, Ms. Postil, MOTHER; Dr. Lee Marcus; Respondent's Exhs. AJYDT00312, 320, 331-332, 408, 464.) Similarly, the evidence is nearly uniform in establishing STUDENT's general areas of need: social skills, play skills, cognition, independence, readiness skills, attending skills, fine and gross motor skills, reduction of problem behaviors, self-help skills including toilet-training, and communication including expressive and receptive language. (See testimony of Ms. Aubery, Mr. Schroeder, MOTHER, Ms. Postil, Dr. Marcus, Dr. Cynthia Norall, Dr. B.J. Freeman and Dr. Ron Leaf; Respondent's Exh. AJY00346-349.) As of September 1998, STUDENT had not yet mastered any expressive labels, but had used expressive labels at the below-mastery level (80%) and was echolalic, so he would often verbally imitate language. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Postil, Dr. Freeman.) As is often the case with autistic children, STUDENT's development was uneven. For example, within areas of need, his social skills were more delayed, while his motor skills were less delayed. (See testimony of Ms. Aubery, Mr. Schroeder, Dr. Freeman, Chris Vinceneux.) As is also characteristic of many autistic children, STUDENT had variability and inconsistency in his development; on some days he could perform a task, but on other days he could not. (See testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Freeman, Mr. Schroeder.) Regarding problem behaviors, while there was no dispute that STUDENT had such behaviors, the parties did not agree on the extent to which these were severe. MOTHER credibly testified that STUDENT's behaviors had escalated by fall 1998. (See also Respondent's Exh. AJYDT00331-332.) Moreover, MOTHER's account was not inconsistent with the testimony of other witnesses who had worked with STUDENT. While Ms. Aubery testified that STUDENT had not demonstrated most of these problem behaviors at school, expert witnesses persuasively explained that it is not uncommon for autistic children to behave better at school than at home. (See testimony of Dr. Freeman, Dr. Leaf.) Thus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by MOTHER's testimony regarding STUDENT's increased behaviors by fall 1998. There is no dispute that STUDENT needed special education services during the 1998-99 school year to address his needs, nor is there any dispute that the services needed to be provided in a structured setting, and needed to include some form of one-to-one discrete trial training (DTT), as well as parent consultation and training, occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, curb-to-curb transportation and extended school year (ESY) services. Rather, the parties' primary disputes center on the nature of the program, such as how the DTT should have been provided, how many hours of services STUDENT needed each week, whether STUDENT needed the program provided at home, and whether his needs could have been met only by a pure discrete trial training program, or perhaps instead by language and behavior therapy, which included discrete trial training, Project TEACCH, Greenspan's Floor Time, Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) and Social Stories. Regarding the type of program STUDENT needed, Petitioner offered the testimony of Jessica Postil of Autism Spectrum Consultants (ASC). Ms. Postil testified that STUDENT was a "reader" and needed a program specifically designed for autistic children who read, in which stimuli are presented in words as well as pictures, and books are used as reinforcers. Ms. Postil explained that STUDENT learned better when stimuli were presented vertically rather than horizontally, and when his drills incorporated movement. Ms. Postil also stated that STUDENT learned new stimuli better with the use of highly expanded trials, with a distractor in between each repetition of the target stimulus, so that he would actually learn and remember the target stimulus rather than merely repeating or imitating the therapist during the trial. Several witnesses explained why Ms. Postil's conclusion was doubtful. Dr. B.J. Freeman, professor of at the UCLA Department of Medical Psychology, reviewed several videotapes of STUDENT in his program, reviewed STUDENT's educational records, including logbooks, and interviewed numerous California Avenue staff members and outside service providers who worked with STUDENT. (Testimony of Dr. Freeman.) Dr. Freeman concluded that, while it was clear that STUDENT could match words, it was not clear that he could read. Dr. Freeman explained that, like STUDENT, many autistic children are able to match words, but it is rare to find an autistic student who is a reader like Ms. Postil described. Dr. Freeman further explained that if STUDENT were actually a reader, he would have acquired more than the 136 expressive labels he learned in his five months in the ASC program. (Ibid.) Similarly, Dr. Leaf expressed doubt that STUDENT was in fact learning from reading in Ms. Postil's program, and likewise asserted that if STUDENT were in fact a reader as Ms. Postil described, one would expect him to have learned far more labels than the 136 that he learned in the ASC program. (Testimony of Dr. Leaf.) In light of all the evidence, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Ms. Postil's assessment that STUDENT was a "reader" in need of the constant use of written words as she recommended. While the Hearing Officer is not swayed by the District's attempts to portray Ms. Postil as unqualified, it is inarguable that Drs. Freeman and Leaf have greater knowledge and experience regarding evaluation of autistic children and the programs they need. While Drs. Freeman and Leaf did not have Ms. Postil's opportunities to evaluate STUDENT in person, they gave informed opinions based on their interviews with STUDENT's instructors and extensive reviews of videotapes and educational records. (footnote 10) Moreover, the only support for Ms. Postil's theory appears to be her own testimony. The Hearing Officer concurs with the opinions of Drs. Freeman and Taubman that it is not clear from the videotape of the ASC drills whether STUDENT was actually reading words or whether he was simply matching the similar orientations of the picture-word cards. Regarding an appropriate program for STUDENT, Dr. Freeman recommended that STUDENT attend a program for five to six hours per day where he would be engaged in a variety of developmentally appropriate activities, including one-to-one instruction, occupational therapy and adaptive physical education. However, Dr. Freeman emphasized that no one methodology is appropriate for an entire program and recommended, instead, that STUDENT be instructed using a combination of methodologies; for example, Dr. Freeman noted that STUDENT responded to PECS, and thus continued use of PECS to develop functional communication would be appropriate. Dr. Freeman recommended that STUDENT receive instruction from staff people who are well-trained in many areas and who are capable of using different methods, depending on which method is appropriate to teach a particular skill. (Testimony of Dr. Freeman.) Based on the testimony and documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer agrees that STUDENT needed a program in a structured setting, utilizing DTT and other methodologies as needed. For example, numerous witnesses testified about STUDENT's use of PECS. Since STUDENT was not yet able to consistently express himself verbally, PECS allowed STUDENT to develop functional communication. Moreover, while it is undisputed that STUDENT needs DTT as a large component of his program, the use of multiple methodologies as appropriate to address his needs appears to be precisely what the Rowley court envisioned in crafting the "designed to meet unique needs" requirement. No persuasive testimony was presented to establish that STUDENT specifically needed a particular number of hours in his program each week, nor did any evidence establish that STUDENT needed his program provided in a particular location. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed both one-to-one DTT and socialization opportunities, but the California Avenue and ASC programs demonstrated that these could be provided via either a home-based or school-based program. Regarding specific techniques employed in DTT, such as highly expanded trials and vertical presentation of stimuli, even Ms. Postil admitted during cross-examination that STUDENT did not necessarily need such techniques, but rather these techniques were just the best way he learned with her. While STUDENT was able to learn utilizing these methods in the ASC program, there was no evidence to indicate that such techniques were necessary for his learning; indeed, Mr. Schroeder and Ms. Aubery, along with the data log books, provided detailed information regarding the progress that STUDENT made using the methods employed in the California Avenue program. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needed a program in a structured setting, utilizing one-to-one DTT instruction and other methodologies as appropriate, to address his needs in the areas of social skills, play skills, cognition, independence, readiness skills, attending skills, fine and gross motor skills, reduction of problem behaviors, self-help skills including toilet-training, and communication including expressive and receptive language. Given the need for multiple methodologies, the program should have a staff well-trained in various methodologies. The program should also include occupational therapy, adaptive physical therapy, parent consultation and training, ESY and transportation. Having determined what STUDENT needed in his program, the Hearing Officer must next determine whether or not the District's offer met these needs. Consistent with STUDENT's needs, the District offered a program with one-to-one DTT and other methodologies, including PECS and TEACCH. (See Petitioner's Book #4, Exhs. PPP, RRR; testimony of Ms. Aubery.) The program was to be provided by a well-trained staff. (See Respondent's Exh. CAS00001-00394; testimony of Dr. Leaf.) Indisputably, the District's offer included the appropriate designated instructional services. (See Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. PPP.) The IEP team agreed upon eight goal areas to address STUDENT's areas of need: expressive language, receptive language, behavior, fine motor, gross motor, pre-academic, self-help and social/emotional; independence, readiness and attending were largely incorporated into the social/emotional area. the IEP's goal areas addressed STUDENT's areas of need. The only questionable area involves whether or not the District's offer was designed to reduce STUDENT's problem behaviors. While the IEP team agreed that behavior was a goal area, the IEP and Ms. Aubery's testimony indicate that the District did not give this area the priority it required in STUDENT's program. Moreover, no evidence contradicted Petitioner's contention that better coordination of the home and school programs was necessary and could address this area of need. (See testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Freeman.) However, the District's offer did include parent consultation and training, which are consistent with reducing STUDENT's problem behaviors at home. (Testimony of Dr. Freeman.) The Hearing Officer finds that while the District's offer should have included better coordination of the in-home and school programs to effectuate a reduction in problem behaviors, overall the District's offer addressed STUDENT's areas of need. Thus, the District's offer of twenty-five hours weekly of language and behavior training, including one-to-one DTT, with the addition of in-home instruction for ten hours per week, occupational therapy, parent consultation and training, adaptive physical therapy, ESY and transportation, was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. 2. Was the District's offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit? As detailed above, the District's offer was designed to address STUDENT's unique needs. Given that the District's offer for 1998-99 was very similar to the program STUDENT received during the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT's progress at California Avenue during the 1997-98 school year and into the beginning of the 1998-99 school year should be considered in determining whether or not he would have made progress there during the remainder of the 1998-99 school year. District language and behavior specialist Linda Aubery, who worked with and observed STUDENT on a regular basis from November 1997 to September 1998, testified regarding progress that STUDENT made during that time period. Ms. Aubery noted that, while at California Avenue, STUDENT had developed some expressive language, which he would sometimes use spontaneously; his language sample from California Avenue listed forty-three words that he had used. When asked "what do you want?" he would sometimes respond with expressive language and/or pointing to objects. He was also beginning to use PECS, words and/or gestures to communicate food requests. Regarding STUDENT's socialization/attention skills as of September 1998, Ms. Aubery testified that he had progressed to playing at some classroom play stations for two to three minutes. His fall 1998 progress report stated that he was "just beginning play activities with one peer." Regarding self-help skills, Ms. Aubery stated that STUDENT could wash and dry his hands when prompted. He could not eat with a fork, but had learned to eat with a spoon. He was not yet toilet-trained, but had learned to pull his pants down and up. (Testimony of Linda Aubery; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. MMM.) Ms. Aubery stated that STUDENT had initially presented some behavioral problems, but that during his time at California Avenue School, the staff had succeeded in extinguishing his biting behavior. Rick Schroeder, program supervisor for Autism Partnership, also testified regarding progress STUDENT had made at California Avenue. Mr. Schroeder visited California Avenue School approximately two full days each month over the course of STUDENT's eleven-month attendance at the school, and tended to focus on STUDENT during his visits. Mr. Schroeder noted that STUDENT initially had self-control problems, but that those problems decreased over the course of STUDENT's time at California Avenue. (Testimony of Mr. Schroeder.) Mr. Schroeder explained that by September 1998, STUDENT could perform a chain of up to six nonverbal imitations in a row, could maintain eye contact with his discrete trial therapist, and could remain seated during drills. STUDENT had also learned to use spontaneous language to communicate, could discriminate among three objects or photos about 50% of the time, and could correctly discriminate among PECS cards about 70-80% of the time. STUDENT had not yet mastered any expressive labels by September 1998, although he used some expressive labels correctly at below-mastery level (below 80% correct). (Testimony of Mr. Schroeder; Respondent's Exh. AJY00737.) STUDENT had also mastered various drills in matching, object manipulation, colors and shapes. Regarding receptive language, "come here" was the only receptive instruction that STUDENT had mastered and would consistently respond to. (Testimony of Mr. Schroeder; Respondent's Exh. AJYDT00509.) Dr. Mitchell Taubman, director of research at Autism Partnership, reviewed STUDENT's educational records, including data and notes from California Avenue, and records from ASC and San Diego Regional Center. Based on his analysis of data collected by California Avenue staff who worked with STUDENT, and his analysis of observational data from videotapes of STUDENT, Dr. Taubman compiled and assisted in compiling graphs and charts depicting STUDENT's progress while at California Avenue from November 1997 to September 1998. (See Respondent's Exh. GRA0003-0113.) Dr. Taubman explained how his graphs showed that STUDENT had made significant progress in several areas, including engagement, making eye contact and reduction of aggression (GRA008), attention and compliance (GRA009), nonverbal imitation/object manipulation (GRA0092), nonverbal imitation/large motor skills (GRA0096), nonverbal imitation/fine motor skills (GRA0094), nonverbal imitation/chaining drills (GRA0111), matching drills (GRA0034, 0082), receptive language (GRA0068), verbal imitation (GRA0014) and functional communication (GRA0049, 0074, 0085). While Petitioner disputes the accuracy of the data, Dr. Taubman testified that he is familiar with the data collection procedures at California Avenue and knows that those procedures are sound and accurate. In contrast, Petitioner offered STUDENT's mother's testimony regarding lack of progress. MOTHER testified that from June through September 1998, STUDENT's negative behaviors were escalating. MOTHER stated that, at that time, STUDENT was "almost out of control," demonstrating an increase in behaviors such as masturbating, foraging for food, playing in the toilet, opening canisters, turning on water faucets, and climbing out of his car seat while in the car. MOTHER testified that when she removed STUDENT from the California Avenue program in September 1998, he had no expressive language; he would sometimes say "I want," but then would not express what it was that he wanted, and he would sometimes learn new words, but would not retain them. MOTHER asserted that STUDENT also had no receptive language, and he would not mind her instructions. He was not toilet-trained and could only "sort of" feed himself, if MOTHER hovered over him and insisted. However, he had developed matching skills, and he imitated words and songs that he heard. Additionally, Ms. Postil stated that when STUDENT first began the ASC program in September 1998, he needed to work on reduction of inappropriate behaviors such as masturbation and picking scabs, was echolalic but did not have any expressive or receptive language, and essentially had no skills other than matching, some fine motor skills and nonverbal imitation of simple actions. To that extent, MOTHER and her attorney informed the IEP team at the meeting on November 18, 1998, that Ms. Postil had found that "there were no baselines as of October 7th," that is, that STUDENT essentially had no skills in any areas when he began the ASC program on October 7, 1998. The Hearing Officer disagrees with the assertion that STUDENT had no skills when he entered the ASC program. Testimony from Mr. Schroeder and Ms. Aubery established that STUDENT had shown improvement in many areas during his time at California Avenue, including readiness skills, eye contact, functional communication, matching, object manipulation and other nonverbal imitation, and spontaneous language. Regarding MOTHER's assertion that STUDENT was not retaining the words that he learned, the Hearing Officer agrees with the expert testimony that such variability is a hallmark of autism, and concludes that such variability does not indicate that STUDENT was not making progress, particularly in light of the documented progress described by Mr. Schroeder and Ms. Aubery. (See testimony of Dr. Leaf and Dr. Freeman.) Regarding STUDENT's increase in negative behaviors, Dr. Freeman noted that STUDENT's program would need to focus more on the home aspects to effectuate a reduction of those behaviors, and stated that parent participation and training was particularly important for that reason. However, Dr. Freeman explained that STUDENT's progress at California Avenue was still meaningful despite the apparent increase in negative behaviors at home. Evidence established that STUDENT had not made progress in all areas while at California Avenue, as evidenced by his increase in problem behaviors at home; additionally, STUDENT did not master areas such as toilet training, expressive labels or receptive instructions. However, overall the progress he did make, in areas including eye contact, engagement, attention, functional communication and nonverbal imitation, constituted more than de minimis progress. While STUDENT's needs had changed somewhat from the 1997-98 school year to the 1998-99 school year, as he learned new skills, in total his areas of need were not significantly different in 1998-99 in comparison with the previous school year. Thus, in light of the finding that STUDENT previously made progress at California Avenue, and in light of the Hearing Officer's previous finding that the District's offer addressed STUDENT's areas of need, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit for the 1998-99 school year. Accordingly, the District's offer for the 1998-99 school year was substantively appropriate. B. Procedural Appropriateness Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley at 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1484.) Procedural violations which do not result in educational loss for the student or an infringement upon parental participation in the IEP process are insufficient to support a finding that the student has been denied a FAPE. (Ibid.) In the present case, STUDENT has alleged that the District committed numerous procedural violations applicable to the 1998-99 school year. First, STUDENT alleges that the District failed to provide his parent with accurate information about his educational program, because at the IEP meeting of November 17, 1998, and in the written IEP document, the District stated that it was offering DTT, when in fact it was offering Language and Behavioral Training (LBT). However, the District immediately corrected this error, in a letter to STUDENT's mother dated November 19, 1998, a letter which further offered MOTHER the opportunity for additional explanation about LBT if she had any questions. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. RRR.) The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has established that parents are entitled to clear written notice of what special education placement the local educational agency is offering the student. (Union School Dist. v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526.) In the present case, the District's misstatement regarding DTT and LBT is of concern primarily because MOTHER, her attorney and Ms. Postil thus had incorrect information at the IEP meeting. However, a review of the transcript of that IEP meeting does not give any indication that those individuals were prejudiced by the error. (See Respondent's Exh. TRA00159-172.) In fact, during the discussion at the IEP meeting, a District staff member commented that STUDENT's California Avenue program is called alanguage and behavior training program because we don't just do discrete trials. (Respondent's Exh. TRA00172.) Also in light of the discussion of PECS at the IEP meeting, and in light of STUDENT's previous use of PECS and other methodologies that MOTHER, her attorney and Ms. Postil were aware had been used with STUDENT by California Avenue staff, those individuals were sufficiently informed about the nature of the District's offer to allow them to participate knowledgeably at the IEP meeting. There is no indication that the mislabeling of the LBT program actually created any misconception regarding what the District was offering at the IEP meeting. Any other prejudice caused by the District's error was negated by the District's immediate written correction of the error. Accordingly, any procedural violation due to the error does not rise to the level of a denial of FAPE. On a related matter, Petitioner argues that the District failed to make a clear written offer when it made two different offers at the November 18, 1998 IEP meeting. At that IEP, the District first offered 25 hours of instruction per week at school, 10 hours per week at home; when MOTHER and her attorney rejected that offer and stated that STUDENT required an in-home program, the District then came back with a second offer of all 35 hours at home. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. PPP.) At the February 1999 IEP, the District's offer was solely the 25/10 program. (Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. TTT.) Under these circumstances, the District did not commit a procedural violation which denied STUDENT a FAPE. The District made a clear written offer of 25/10; the offer of 35 hours at home was obviously made as an attempt to compromise and reach agreement. (See Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. PPP; Respondent's Exh. TRA00105-174; testimony of Allan Roth.) There is no indication from the factual circumstances that MOTHER or her attorney was ever confused about what the District was really offering. State and federal law require that an IEP must include statements of the student's progress and present levels of performance. (Education Code 56345; C.F.R. 300.347.) STUDENT argues that the District misinformed his parents and the rest of the IEP team about his progress at California Avenue, in that he now disputes the District's previous reports that he was making progress. Given the Hearing Officer's finding that STUDENT made some progress while he was at California Avenue, this allegation does not support a finding of prejudicial procedural violation. Petitioner makes similar allegations of procedural violations arising out of substantive claims, such as his allegation that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to identify his unique needs. Again, given the Hearing Officer's finding to the contrary, there is no basis for finding a procedural violation. Petitioner further argues that the District's offer was procedurally invalid because it was not based upon his IEP, as required by C.F.R. section 300.552(b)(2). Petitioner's argument essentially is that because the IEP team's District staff members did not agree with MOTHER about goals and objectives or present levels of performance, the IEP was legally insufficient and the District's offer was therefore invalid. This argument is unpersuasive; the IEP team reached agreement as to eight goal areas, and the District's offer is consistent with those goal areas and with its own proposal for goals and objectives. Moreover, Petitioner's logic is specious. Following this logic, any time a parent and district could not agree on goals and objectives or present levels of performance, the district would therefore be prohibited from making a placement offer because there was no agreement on the underlying IEP. In the present case, the evidence indicates that the District based its offer on its knowledge of STUDENT's present levels of performance as described in the October 1998 progress report, compiled shortly after STUDENT left the California Avenue program. (See testimony of Linda Aubery; Petitioner's Book #4, Exh. MMM.) Moreover, Petitioner argues that the District committed procedural violations in that it unjustifiably delayed implementing STUDENT's June 9, 1998 IEP until July 20, 1998. Given that the 1998-99 school year did not begin until August 1998, no procedural violation occurred in that regard for the 1998-99 school year. Finally, Petitioner argues that the District failed to accurately inform STUDENT's parent of her procedural rights, in violation of Education Code section 56321 and C.F.R. section 300.504(b). While Petitioner does not dispute that MOTHER received the District's notice of procedural rights, Petitioner argues that particular explanations in the notice were incorrect and that certain provisions were omitted. In particular, Petitioner argues that the notice was misleading in its paraphrasing of the potential reduction or denial of reimbursement for parents who fail to give prior notice of unilateral placement in private school, codified in 20 U.S.C. section 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii). (See Respondent's Exh. AJY00407.) The Hearing Officer is in agreement with Petitioner that this requirement was not in effect in California until January 1, 1999, when Education Code section 56176 became operative. Since STUDENT's unilateral placement in private school occurred prior to that date, his parents were not subject to the requirement, and cannot have their reimbursement limited or denied for that reason. Therefore, any misleading language did not result in a procedural violation which resulted in a denial of FAPE. Based on the above, the District did not commit any procedural violations which resulted in a denial of FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.(2) Is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the in-home behavioral program supervised by Autism Spectrum Consultants for the 1998-99 school year? In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses they incur in educating their child. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. (Burlington, supra; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.) In the present case, since the Hearing Officer has found that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE, no award of reimbursement is appropriate. ORDER All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to California Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: (1) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the1998-99 school year? The District prevailed on this issue.(2) Is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the in-home behavioral program supervised by Autism Spectrum Consultants for the 1998-99 school year? The District prevailed on this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code 56505(i).DATED: September 30, 1999 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1)No evidence was received on April 15 because the parties held settlement discussions off the record for the entire day. Similarly, the hearing convened only briefly on March 2, because the parties spent the majority of that day discussing settlement.2)On July 9, 1999, attorney Patricia Cromer notified the Hearing Office that she had withdrawn as Petitioner's attorney.3)The Hearing Officer notes that the large number of attorneys in this case appears due in part to the District's decision to retain attorneys from two different law firms for representation at the hearing. Attorneys for the District explained that such arrangements were necessary because the lead counsel, Charles Weatherly, practices outside California, and thus required local attorneys to advise him on California rules and practices. The Hearing Officer is informed and believes that such joint representation of one party by four attorneys simultaneously is unprecedented in the ten-year period that the Hearing Office has conducted special education hearings for the State of California. Given the numerous qualified attorneys representing school districts in Southern California and the limited resources available to California schools, it is of concern that the District chose to incur the expense of flying in and providing lodging for out-of-state attorneys, particularly when such arrangements apparently necessitated retaining additional local counsel.4)The District's case-in-chief also included the testimony of witnesses listed as Petitioner's witnesses. Pursuant to the request of the Hearing Officer, the District agreed to conduct its direct examination of these witnesses immediately after Petitioner's direct examinations to avoid the necessity of recalling those witnesses. 5) Pursuant to discussions held during the hearing on March 2, April 15, and July 7 and 8, 1999, the Hearing Officer has revised Petitioner's statement of the issues and has dismissed one issue. See "Procedural Matters" section for extended discussion.6)The Hearing Office had also received a due process hearing request from the District on March 3, 1999, for a hearing on identical grounds. 7)However, had equitable factors been at issue in this case, the Hearing Officer would have considered the issue of FAPE for the 1997-98 school year in the Decision's discussion of equitable factors. 8)The Hearing Officer will still discuss and consider the 1997-98 school year to the extent that it sheds light on the appropriateness of the 1998-99 placement offer. 9)During this off-track time, STUDENT and his mother participated in a five-day training program offered by NCCSE. This program was part of MOTHER's parent training. (Testimony of MOTHER; Respondent's Exh. AJY00280.) 10) The Hearing Officer notes that the sole explanation for the District expert witnesses' failure to observe STUDENT in person is Petitioner's refusal to allow any District witnesses to observe him.
