California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 19, 2004
Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1769-04 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel
San Ramon Valley Unified provided and offered FAPE to a nine-year-old with autism; reimbursement and compensatory OT requests denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions an earlier due process case between the same parties (SN03-02197), resolved by a November 13, 2003 settlement agreement.
Summary
The parents of a nine-year-old boy with autism filed for a hearing against San Ramon Valley Unified School District. A November 2003 settlement had waived earlier claims, so the case covered January 17, 2004 onward. The student attended a special day class at Twin Creeks Elementary School with a one-to-one aide from Synergistic Interventions, a nonpublic agency that also ran his home program. The parents claimed the District assessed him poorly, misreported his progress, and kept too little data. They also said his teacher rarely worked with him directly and his occupational therapist acted unprofessionally and unsafely. They challenged the 2004 extended school year (ESY) and the 2004-2005 offers, which the District sent by letter after an unfinished IEP meeting.
Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel ruled for the District on every issue. Slow progress alone did not show the assessments were inadequate. The law does not require one particular method of measuring progress. The goals fit the student's needs, which included significant cognitive impairment. Under Vashon Island, the District could put its offer in writing because it had repeatedly involved the parents and kept seeking agreement. Leaving the goals out of the written offer was a minor error. The 2004-2005 offer left out four weekly hours of school behavioral supervision. The District admitted the mistake, and it was a technical violation that did not deny FAPE. The District was ordered to correct the offer at an IEP meeting within 15 days. Reimbursement and compensatory OT were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard. A student's slow progress alone did not prove a bad assessment or IEP. Data collection was not the only acceptable way to measure progress. A district could send its offer in writing after IEP meetings ran out of time, as long as it had involved the parents and kept seeking agreement.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1-A(1). Did the District fail to assess STUDENT appropriately or to fully identify his needs (2003-2004 school year from January 17, 2004)?
Student did not challenge the 2002 OT assessment or the 2003 triennial assessment. Lack of progress alone does not show an assessment was inadequate, and there is no duty to informally reassess from one session to the next.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1-A(2). Did the District fail to accurately report STUDENT's progress at IEP meetings?
The teacher's overstatement of how much raw data she had was at most an inadvertent error, corrected promptly. It did not cause a loss of educational opportunity or seriously limit parent participation.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1-B(2). Was STUDENT's educational program (including classroom and OT goals) designed to meet his unique needs?
The classroom and OT goals addressed communication, following directions, self-help, fine motor skills and generalization. They were neither too advanced nor too easy, and overlap across settings was appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-B(2)(benefit). Was STUDENT's educational program reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, including whether progress measurement without continuous data collection was adequate?
An IEP is judged as a snapshot, not in hindsight (Adams). The law prefers no single way to measure progress, and the teacher's mix of data and observation produced accurate progress reports.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1-B(3). Did the educational program provided by the District comport with STUDENT's IEP (home/school disparity, teacher interaction, OT provider's professionalism and safety)?
Progress was largely consistent between home and school. The IEP did not require the teacher to deliver one-to-one instruction herself. The OT provider's conduct reflected professional disagreement and was not shown to be unsafe.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2-A(1). Did the District's May 18, 2004 written ESY offer, made by letter after an unfinished IEP meeting, deny the parents the opportunity to participate in developing the program?
Under Vashon Island and Doe v. Maher, the District repeatedly gave the parents chances to participate, kept seeking agreement, and could write up its offer when consensus was not reached.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 2-A(2). Did the District's failure to include classroom and OT goals in its May 18 ESY offer deny a FAPE?
Leaving the goals out of the written offer was at most a minor procedural error. The parents knew the proposed OT and classroom goals and were not prejudiced.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2-B. Was the 2004 ESY program (teacher, classroom, cubicle, home program hours) substantively appropriate?
The ESY offer was likely to prevent regression. The District promptly addressed concerns about the teacher and the cubicle, and two hours a day of home program was sufficient.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3-A. Did the District deny STUDENT procedural rights in developing its 2004-2005 program offer conveyed by letter?
The District sought, received and acted on parent input and kept trying to schedule IEP meetings. Conveying the offer by letter was permissible.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered
Issue 3-B. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year (omission of behavioral supervision and consultation in the school setting)?
The offer continued an appropriate program. The District admitted it inadvertently left out four hours per week of school-based supervision and consultation; this technical violation, corrected within three days of the school year starting, did not deny a FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. If a FAPE was denied, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
No denial of FAPE was found, so no compensatory education (including the 36 requested OT hours) was awarded.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. If a FAPE was denied, are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for costs of a home program, including OT, during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY?
No denial of FAPE was found, so the parents' home program and related costs are not reimbursed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District must convene an IEP meeting no later than 15 days after the decision to correct its 2004-2005 offer by adding the four hours (per week) of consultation and supervision it stipulated were mistakenly left out of the May 18, 2004 offer.
- District must remain ready and able to implement all parts of its 2004-2005 program offer as set out in the corrected May 18, 2004 offer (District Exhibit 41), as further corrected by the order. All of Student's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School Dist.; Amanda J. v. Clark County School Dist.; Ms. S. v. Vashon Island School Dist.; Doe by Gonzales v. Maher; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool
People named in the decision
- Vicki Wells, supervising behavior specialist and co-director, nonpublic agency, Synergistic Interventions
- Kim Stokes, certified massage therapist and co-director, nonpublic agency, Synergistic Interventions
- Erin Matteucci, behavior specialist / 1:1 aide (nonpublic agency), Synergistic Interventions
- Kara Burdett, 1:1 aide (nonpublic agency), Synergistic Interventions
- Synergistic Interventions, certified nonpublic agency providing classroom aide and home program
- Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., expert witness for District; director, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic, University of California, San Francisco (Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute)
- George Anich, special education program manager; IEP chair, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special education, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Julie Burlingame, District behaviorist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Terri Locke, occupational therapist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Jonica McPhail, special day class teacher; academic assessor, San Ramon Valley Unified School District (Twin Creeks Elementary School)
- Eleanor Alperton, occupational therapy provider, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Micky Woodrow, occupational therapist (2002 OT assessment), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Christina Giannini, school psychologist (2003 psychoeducational assessment), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Carol Loflin, principal, Twin Creeks Elementary School
- Ms. Smithwick, ESY special day class teacher, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Regional Center of the East Bay, regional center providing services
- Orange County Regional Center, regional center providing early services
- Behavior Analysts, Inc., private assessor (2001 assessment report)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Danville, California, on August 26, 27, and 31, and September 1, 2, and 3, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorneys Eileen Matteucci and Robert Nuddleman. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER. (Footnote 1) Respondent San Ramon Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Dora Dome. Also present on behalf of the District was Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special education.
STUDENT called the following witnesses: MOTHER; FATHER; Vicki Wells, supervising behavior specialist and co-director of Synergistic Interventions (SI), a certified nonpublic agency (NPA) that provides behavioral and academic support to STUDENT at school and at home; Kim Stokes, certified massage therapist and co-director of SI; and Erin Matteucci, a behavior specialist at SI. (Footnote 2)
The District called the following witnesses: Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., director of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at the University of California, San Francisco; George Anich, special education program manager for the District; Julie Burlingame, behaviorist for the District; Terri Locke, occupational therapist for the District; and Jonica McPhail, special day class teacher for the District.
The Hearing Officer called the following witnesses: Karen Heilbronner and FATHER. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties’ written closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on September 22, 2004. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
After STUDENT’s parents filed their request for hearing, but prior to the first day of the hearing, the District provided them with a revised offer of an educational program for the 2004-2005 school year. The offer was made in a letter dated August 19, 2004, a copy of which was designated as District Exhibit 68. At the hearing, the District decided to withdraw the revised offer rather than present it for consideration as an alternative to its previous program offer for the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 3) Accordingly, the District withdrew Exhibit 68 from its exhibits. (Footnote 4)
Two days before the hearing, the District asked the Hearing Office to issue subpoenas duces tecum (SDTs) to SI and to the Regional Center of the East Bay for documents relating to the services those agencies had rendered to STUDENT. STUDENT filed an opposition to the request. At the hearing, the Hearing Officer granted the request for issuance of an SDT to SI on the ground that the documents were relevant to the hearing and the District had unsuccessfully sought the documents informally. The District withdrew its request for issuance of an SDT to the Regional Center.
At the hearing, STUDENT moved to preclude the District from challenging any of STUDENT’s issues on the ground that the District had failed to file its own issue statement in accordance with California Education Code section 56505. (Footnote 5) The Hearing Officer denied the motion, noting that as the issues at a hearing are framed by the petitioner, no due process concerns arise when the respondent does not file an issue statement.
The District then moved to dismiss several issues in STUDENT’s issue statement on the ground that they related to a prior settlement agreement between the parties, the enforcement of which is outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT’s issue statement did not seek enforcement of the settlement agreement, but instead challenged the adequacy and the implementation of other aspects of his educational program over the past school year, and the adequacy of the program offered for the 2004-2005 school year. Further, the express waivers set forth in the settlement agreement covered claims arising through January 16, 2004, whereas STUDENT’s issue statement sought relief from January 17, 2004 to the present. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to offer and/or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year (beginning January 17, 2004)? (Footnote 6)
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to offer and/or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2004 extended school year (ESY)?
Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year?
Issue No. 4: If a FAPE was denied, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Issue No. 5: If a FAPE was denied, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing him with a home program, including occupational therapy (OT) services, during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT asserts that he was denied a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year because the District failed to properly assess him, to identify and fully document the extent of his deficits, and to provide him with enough academic support to help him learn. Specifically, STUDENT asserts that his classroom teacher, Jonica McPhail, failed to interact with him, to take necessary data to track his progress, to accurately report his progress at individualized education program (IEP) meetings, and to work with his one-to-one aide to ensure a consistent approach to teaching him at school and at home. As a result of these failings, STUDENT asserts that various goals and objectives set for him did not reflect his current levels of functioning. With respect to the 2004 ESY program, STUDENT asserts that he was denied his procedural due process rights to participate in the development of the program, and that the ESY teacher was unsuitable and the classroom inadequate to meet his needs.
STUDENT also contends that the District failed to provide him with appropriate OT services in the 2003-2004 school year because it failed to assess him in all areas of need and to document the extent of his needs. STUDENT asserts that the District’s OT provider, Eleanor Alperton, failed to adequately revise goals and objectives that had not been met, refused to “break down” the goals and objectives into more achievable subparts, made unprofessional remarks, and provided unsafe modes of therapy.
To remedy the alleged denial of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, STUDENT seeks an independent assessment to assist his IEP team in developing his future goals and objectives. He also asserts that he is entitled to compensatory academic instruction, but notes that, “given the number of hours and intensive nature of [his] ongoing program,” compensatory instruction would not be practical. (STUDENT’S Closing Brief at p. 22.) However, STUDENT does seek as compensation thirty-six hours of individual OT services from a provider trained and experienced in working with children who are both autistic and who have severe behavior challenges. (Footnote 7)
Further, STUDENT seeks reimbursement for costs incurred in supplementing his academic program and behavioral support services during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, as well as costs incurred for continuing his home program through the date of this Decision.
Finally, STUDENT contends on both procedural and substantive grounds that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. Procedurally, he alleges that his parents were denied the right to participate in the development of his IEP when, after a May 2004 IEP meeting concluded before discussion had been completed on program proposals for the 2004 ESY and ensuing school year, the District sent a letter to STUDENT’S parents extending a “unilateral” program offer, instead of continuing to collaborate with his parents in developing a final program. Substantively, STUDENT alleges that the written program offer failed to include his educational goals, and failed to provide sufficient hours for consultation and supervision by SI personnel.
In response, the District contends that it provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, and has made an offer of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. The District asserts that it has made all reasonable efforts to address the many concerns expressed by STUDENT’s parents, to include them in the planning process, and to resolve their complaints about STUDENT’s teachers, service providers, and classroom environments. The District asserts that the parents’ continued dissatisfaction with STUDENT’s progress arises from unrealistic expectations and from a preoccupation with data collection that is inapplicable to academic assessments.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy who was diagnosed with autism at age two. As a toddler, he received OT, speech and language (S/L) therapy, and other services through the Orange County Regional Center. When STUDENT was four, his family moved to San Ramon, and he began receiving services from the District. He first attended a special education preschool, but seemed anxious there and began to engage in self-injurious behaviors; at his parents’ request he was switched to a home-based program in which his grandmother served as his primary instructor. The District provided OT and S/L therapy to STUDENT at his home, and he received further support, including attempts at toilet training, from the Regional Center of the East Bay. STUDENT’S parents also took him to a behavior program for autistic children to help control his maladaptive behaviors. (S. Exhs. 2, 21; D. Exhs. 3, 7.)
STUDENT’s home-based program continued until 2003, when he was almost eight years old. At this point, STUDENT was still mostly nonverbal and communicated in gestures. His service providers had attempted to train him to use the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), and he was able to use a PECS icon to request a drink with some prompting. He was not toilet trained, and he continued to exhibit many maladaptive behaviors, including grabbing at people, tearing papers and books, and screaming and shouting when upset. A Regional Center report dated March 2003 listed these performance levels and noted, “STUDENT requires constant supervision and care that is extraordinary.” (S. Exh. 21.)
STUDENT’s parents believed he seemed happier at home than he had been in preschool, but they were concerned that he was making little progress in learning basic skills. Further, because of “family dynamics” in the home, it had become impossible to follow a behavior intervention plan. After consultations with the District, STUDENT’S parents agreed to transition him into a special day class (SDC) for disabled students at Twin Creeks Elementary School (Twin Creeks) located in the District. (S. Exh. 21; D. Exh. 7.)
STUDENT’s 2003 assessments
In March of 2003, STUDENT received his triennial assessment. The District psychologist was unable to administer a cognition test to STUDENT due to his failure to cooperate with the testing process. (Footnote 8) She determined that STUDENT’s adaptive skills – including communication, daily living, socialization, and motor skills – were almost all in the very low range, with age equivalencies of one to four years in most areas. (Footnote 9) In her concluding summary, the psychologist noted that STUDENT had “significant symptoms” of autistic spectrum disorder, and that most of his verbalizations were not understandable. She attributed his shouting, flailing, and other resistant behaviors to his difficulty communicating and his difficulties with transitions and certain tasks. (D. Exh. 3.) An academic assessment conducted by District special education teacher Jonica McPhail included observation of STUDENT in an SDC setting and during home tutoring by his grandmother, as well as a one-to-one evaluation. Ms. McPhail noted that the visits to the SDC were “not successful,” because STUDENT made continuous loud vocalizations and attempted to grab items off tables and walls. In his home tutoring, STUDENT’s efforts to match items, shapes, and colors were inconsistent and occurred only with physical and verbal prompting by his grandmother. In her one-to-one evaluation, Ms. McPhail noted she was unable to use standardized assessments with STUDENT due to his inability to understand and follow directions.
Ms. McPhail concluded that for STUDENT to learn, he would need to be placed in a highly structured educational setting with consistent behavior intervention, one-to-one support, development of a functional communication system, generalization of his skills to other settings, and a transition plan to help him move from a home program to a school setting. (D. Exh. 4.)
March – November 2003
In March of 2003, STUDENT began attending the SDC at Twin Creeks for three hours a day while also receiving OT and S/L therapy. STUDENT’s first several months in the SDC were marked by behavior problems. In September of 2003, STUDENT’S parents retained Synergistic Interventions, Inc. (SI), a certified NPA, to provide an intensive home-based behavioral support program. Also in September, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Jonica McPhail, made a written request to the District to provide a one-to-one aide for STUDENT to help with behavior intervention and toilet training. (D. Exhs. 9, 10.)
At an October 14, 2003 IEP meeting, District staff and service providers offered new goals for OT and S/L therapy, and recommended a continuation of academic goals adopted at STUDENT’s March 26, 2003 IEP meeting. STUDENT’S parents presented the District with a written statement expressing their concerns about his progress in language development, life skills, and behavior modification. His parents believed the SI home program had markedly improved STUDENT’s behavior, but that his gains had been slipping since his school day had increased from three to five hours a day in August. STUDENT’S parents requested an integrated school and home behavioral program, a communication system transferable between school and home, and continued development of life skills such as toilet training. (D. Exh. 15.)
STUDENT’S parents asked that an SI aide be provided to STUDENT in the classroom until the District could hire a one-to-one aide for him. The team agreed that STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide, and the District indicated it would discuss the options of an interim District aide or an SI aide until a permanent District aide could be hired. (D. Exh. 13.)
STUDENT’S parents declined to sign the IEP, and filed a request for a due process hearing a few days later (SN03-02197). They alleged that the District had failed to serve STUDENT adequately during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years, when he had been tutored at home, and had failed to offer appropriate services when STUDENT returned to a District classroom for the 2003-2004 school year. (STUDENT’S Statement of Issues, SN03-02197.)
The dispute was resolved by a settlement agreement entered into on November 13, 2003, which provided for STUDENT’s 2003-2004 educational program and indicated that SI would continue to provide STUDENT with a home program, and also would provide him with a one-to-one classroom aide, with gradual transition to a District aide pursuant to a transition plan to be developed by the District and SI. The agreement also waived all of STUDENT’S parents’ claims against the District through January 16, 2004, when the IEP team planned to meet to discuss the transition plan. (D. Exh. 20.)
January 16, 2004 IEP
On January 16, 2004, an IEP meeting was held to review STUDENT’s progress and discuss the proposed transition from an SI classroom aide to a District aide. SI staff reported that STUDENT was doing well in his home program, that his maladaptive behaviors had decreased, and that he was making progress in toilet training.
In the school setting, SI staff reported that STUDENT was participating with the class and was able to respond with minimal prompts to directions presented by classroom staff. He was able to remain focused on a classroom task for three to five minutes, and was beginning to use a PECS symbol to request a walk or other break from a task. With respect to his current IEP goals, the report noted that he followed one-step directions with eighty percent accuracy at home, but less consistently at school. (Footnote 10)
Regarding his functional academic goals, SI staff reported that STUDENT was making progress on identifying body parts (touch head, clap hands) in both the home and school setting. He was matching upper case to lower case letters consistently at home and at school. STUDENT had made partial progress in matching colors and shapes, and could pick up and hold a pencil and trace a horizontal line, but required hand-over-hand prompting to trace a vertical line. The SI report recommended that all of the goals be continued until the next IEP meeting in ninety days.
District behaviorist Julie Burlingame presented a written transition plan, noting that it was a work in progress and that she would work with SI to further its development. The plan included four phases for transition to a District aide that included training, observing the SI aide working with STUDENT, building rapport with STUDENT, collecting data on his behavior to help develop a positive behavior intervention plan, and consulting with STUDENT’s parents. The plan would progress at the rate STUDENT was responding and feeling comfortable with the changes, with the entire process expected to take up to two months to complete. After the progress reports and transition plan had been presented and discussed, FATHER signed the IEP consenting to the goals and services as written. (D. Exh. 24.) January – March, 2004
In January 2004, a District aide began working with STUDENT’s SI aide to gradually assume her responsibilities in accordance with the transition plan. In March, the District aide stopped working for the District, and accepted a position with SI. According to STUDENT’S parents, no back-up District personnel were available to replace her, and STUDENT continued to have an SI aide as his one-to-one aide, at the District’s expense, while the District sought to hire a new aide. (Footnote 11)
On January 30, SI reported that STUDENT’s toilet training program had been implemented at school, and that STUDENT was making progress on in learning to use the toilet. (D. Exh. 25.)
March 25, 2004 IEP
According to special education program manager George Anich, STUDENT’s annual IEP on March 25, 2004, lasted at least two hours. Ms. Alperton reported on STUDENT’s OT goals, noting that he was not yet able to draw a horizontal line between two points. As STUDENT had appeared to master this goal at home, FATHER opined that the goal was not being implemented properly by Ms. Alperton. He asked that it be broken down into more achievable steps, such as (1) picking up the crayon, (2) putting it to paper, and (3) drawing on the paper with specified levels of prompts. Ms. Wells, the SI co-director, agreed with FATHER. According to FATHER, Ms. Alperton was defensive and resistant to the idea, and simply wanted to continue working on the goal instead of breaking it down. (Testimony of Mr. Anich, Ms. Wells, and FATHER.)
STUDENT’s parents testified that they also were concerned about STUDENT’s lack of academic progress. As most of the meeting was spent discussing OT and S/L goals, however, there was no opportunity to discuss the academic goals at the March IEP meeting. The team agreed to meet again on May 12, 2004. (Testimony of FATHER; D. Exh. 29.)
May 12, 2004 IEP
At the May 12 IEP meeting, the team reviewed an SI progress report indicating that STUDENT was making progress on his goals “across settings,” but that his progress was more apparent at home than at school. Specifically, STUDENT appeared to be using requests for toileting breaks at school as an escape from tasks. STUDENT’s loud vocalizations and grabbing were occurring more at school than at home, and SI staff suspected this behavior could be serving multiple functions for STUDENT, including escaping from tasks.
The IEP team discussed possible reasons for STUDENT’s higher level of maladaptive behaviors at school than at home. They agreed that the District should provide STUDENT with a cubicle area, partitioned off from the rest of the class, for STUDENT to use for “time outs” or for working on tasks without distractions. Within a week of the meeting, a cubicle was set up for STUDENT in Ms. McPhail’s classroom.
By the time Ms. McPhail began her report on academic goals, the meeting had run over two hours, and the SI representative had left. FATHER wanted SI present when academic goals were reviewed, so Ms. McPhail did not complete her report. Other team members were beginning to leave, and Mr. Anich felt not enough members were present to convey a program offer for the ESY and coming school year and to obtain the parents’ input, consideration, and consent. Mr. Anich informed STUDENT’s parents that he would prepare the program offer in writing and send it to them for their feedback. The IEP notes prepared by Mr. Anich state:
The May 12, 2004 IEP meeting ended at a point at which an offer of placement by the District for the remainder of the 03-04 and 04-05 school years and the Extended Year program was not able to be completed. The District’s Chairperson for the meeting will provide a complete written offer for the remainder of the year and ESY and the 04-05 year to the family for their review within the week.
(D. Exh. 35; testimony of Mr. Anich and FATHER.)
The District’s written offer (dated May 18, 2004)
On May 18, Mr. Anich faxed to FATHER a three-page written program offer for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, the four-week ESY program (June 21-July 21), an “extended” ESY of four additional weeks (July 21-August 21), and the 2004-2005 school year. The letter did not include the specific OT goals proposed for the coming school year, because those goals already had been presented by Ms. Alperton and discussed at the March IEP meeting. Nor did the letter contain proposed academic goals, because Mr. Anich understood from Ms. McPhail that she would be meeting with FATHER to further develop those goals.
After reviewing the May 18 offer, FATHER called Mr. Anich and pointed out that it contained an “obvious error” in failing to provide for one-to-one supervision by a classroom aide during the ESY program and the 2004-2005 school year. Mr. Anich agreed that was a mistake and faxed a corrected copy to FATHER that provided for the supervision. FATHER told Mr. Anich he had some other problems with the offer, and Mr. Anich said he would be happy to discuss them. FATHER said he would wait to discuss his other concerns at the next IEP meeting, which Mr. Anich was trying to arrange for early June. (D. Exh. 41, pp. 173-175; testimony of FATHER and Mr. Anich.)
May 24 follow-up meeting; proposed classroom goals
FATHER believed more school data needed to be gathered and analyzed to resolve the disparity between STUDENT’s performance at home and at school. On May 14, FATHER wrote to Ms. McPhail asking to review all of the data she and her aides had collected for STUDENT, “including raw data,” to measure his progress on his goals. On May 24, 2004, Ms. McPhail met with FATHER and the SI directors and provided raw data sheets covering December 2003 through March 2004. The data had been taken by the transitional District aide and by STUDENT’s SI aides. Ms. McPhail apologized that more was not available, indicating that she had stopped having data taken in March “because no new goals had been set,” but had believed the SI aides had continued taking some data. (D. Exh. 37; S. Exhs. 111-119; testimony of FATHER.)
According to Ms. McPhail, the participants in the meeting discussed the data and agreed that (1) STUDENT’s current goals would be continued for the rest of the school year, but efforts would be made to generalize his skills by having other aides work with him in the classroom, (2) Ms. McPhail would prepare new goals for STUDENT’s ESY program, and (3) the parties would meet in the fall to review STUDENT’s progress over the summer and to reformulate the goals as appropriate for the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. McPhail prepared the revised goals on May 28, and placed them in a packet in STUDENT’s school file for FATHER’s review and signature. She informed FATHER that he would need to sign off on the proposed goals for them to be implemented in the ESY program. (D. Exh. 41, pp. 176-178; testimony of Ms. McPhail.)
The parents’ concerns about Ms. Alperton (May 2004)
On May 13, 2004, SI aides Kara Burdett and Erin Matteucci filed separate incident reports with their SI supervisors regarding Eleanor Alperton, STUDENT’s OT provider. Ms. Matteucci reported that Ms. Alperton was late for STUDENT’s OT session and began to work with STUDENT while still working with another child. At one point, Ms. Alperton had STUDENT step up and down from a metal folding chair. STUDENT was “grabbing at everything” and Ms. Alperton could not control both students at the same time. She was conducting the OT session on a theatre stage, which the children could have fallen from if they had run away. Ms. Matteucci took STUDENT away until Ms. Alperton had completed her session with the other child.
Ms. Matteucci reported that when she brought STUDENT back, Ms. Alperton gave him the Magna Doodle and said, “OK, STUDENT, I heard you can write your name all by yourself. Everyone thinks you can write, so show me.” Ms. Matteucci said he could not write independently, but could do so with hand-over-hand assistance. Ms. Alperton responded, “I can do hand-over-hand with a paralyzed person, too.” She added, “I hope nobody is giving the family false hopes on what he can do.”
Ms. Burdett’s report stated that later the same day, while students were coming in to another SDC for a group OT session, Ms. Alperton said to a classroom aide, “They’re telling the family he can write his name hand over hand. A paralyzed person can write his name hand over hand.” Ms. Burdett told Ms. Alperton that the classroom was not an appropriate place for such a discussion. Ms. Alperton responded that she had not named any names, but was “just frustrated.”
On May 14, SI directors Ms. Wells and Ms. Stokes wrote to STUDENT’s school principal, Carol Loflin, in reference to these reports, stating that Ms. Alperton had engaged in inappropriate and unprofessional acts and had made statements that breached the confidentiality of a student’s IEP. The same day, STUDENT’s attorney, Eileen Matteucci, filed a formal complaint with the District about Ms. Alperton, and FATHER sent an “urgent request” to Ms. Loflin that Ms. Alperton be prohibited from further contact with STUDENT. FATHER’s complaints included the unsafe use of the folding chair, Ms. Alperton’s inadequacy as an IEP team member, the remarks reported by the SI aides, and another instance in which Ms. Alperton reportedly told an aide that STUDENT was misdiagnosed as autistic, and actually was mentally retarded.
The next week, Ms. Loflin met with STUDENT’s parents about their complaints. On May 26, she wrote to them that the matter was being investigated and that the District had assigned a new OT provider, Terri Locke, to work with STUDENT for the rest of the school year. (S. Exhs. 100-110; D. Exh. 42; testimony of Ms. Matteucci and FATHER.) (Footnote 12)
June 2004
In early June, Mr. Anich and FATHER attempted to agree on a date for an IEP meeting at which the District’s May 18 program offer could be discussed. Mr. Anich initially suggested June 11 for the meeting because FATHER had indicated that both he and the SI directors would be available on that date. After Mr. Anich had sent a written notice of the meeting, however, FATHER informed him that STUDENT’s’ attorney, Ms. Matteucci, wouldn’t be available, and he declined Mr. Anich’s offer to meet without attorneys. Mr. Anich proposed June 15 as a potential meeting date. At the hearing, FATHER testified that June 15 would have worked for him, but he never heard back from Mr. Anich. No further IEP meeting was held before the ESY program began on June 21. (Testimony of FATHER and Mr. Anich.) (Footnote 13)
ESY program (June 21—July 21, 2004)
Although STUDENT’s parents had not agreed to the District’s program offer, MOTHER took STUDENT to the ESY class on June 21, the first day of the program. She noted that the two instructional aides in the class seemed very competent, but was concerned to discover that the ESY teacher, Ms. Smithwick, had only been assigned to teach the class the previous Friday, and appeared to have only a general understanding of STUDENT’s IEP goals.
MOTHER believed the cubicle set up in the classroom was inadequate for STUDENT, with distracting items on the walls and partitions that were too low. Ms. Smithwick did not appear to interact well with the children (she consoled them when they were upset instead of trying to find out what they wanted), and when STUDENT had a tantrum, Ms. Smithwick did not try to help the SI aide calm him down. Finally, the SI aide reported that Ms. Smithwick had said that she did not want students working on challenging tasks if they were going to be upset by them; she preferred that the class “stay quiet.” On the second day of the ESY program, MOTHER took STUDENT out of the class.
MOTHER expressed her concerns about the ESY class to Vicki Wells at SI, who left a telephone message for Julie Burlingame about the lack of a proper cubicle and other “very strong” concerns. Ms. Burlingame left a return message, and went to the ESY class the next day to fix the cubicle. She used a bookcase to provide a higher partition, and taped blue paper over the walls to cover the distracting elements. (She knew STUDENT liked to tear at loose paper, so she was careful to tape the paper down securely at the edges.) She explained the purpose of the cubicle to Ms. Smithwick and brought in some materials to provide for positive reinforcement for students. She also made sure that one of her behavior specialists with experience with autistic children would be available to the ESY class to assist with behavioral support. Ms. Burlingame did not receive a return call from Ms. Wells.
On the third day of the ESY program, Ms. Burlingame saw MOTHER and told her she had fixed the ESY cubicle and attempted to address her other concerns. STUDENT’s parents visited the class again a few days later, but remained dissatisfied with Ms. Smithwick’s apparent coddling of some of STUDENTs. They also disapproved of the cubicle as reconfigured by Ms. Burlingame, because it was too far from the teacher’s desk, the bookcase partition might tip over if STUDENT grabbed at it, and the paper Ms. Burlingame had taped over the walls was unacceptable since STUDENT liked to tear at paper. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER, and Ms. Burlingame.)
STUDENT’s parents did not return him to the ESY class. On July 7, 2004, they filed their request for this due process hearing. (Footnote 14)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year (beginning January 17, 2004) and extended school year (ESY)?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of STUDENT. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).
A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the disabled student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201. While this requires an LEA to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). (Footnote 15)
A. Procedural issues
STUDENT asserts that the District made procedural errors in the provision of his 2003-2004 educational program by (1) failing to assess him appropriately or to fully identify his needs, and (2) inaccurately reporting his progress at IEP meetings. Each of these issues is addressed below.
(1) Did the District fail to assess STUDENT appropriately or to fully identify his needs?
Federal and State law require a local educational agency (LEA) to conduct an initial evaluation of a child with a suspected disability to determine whether the child qualifies for special education services, and if so, to determine the child’s educational needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. The LEA shall reevaluate the child when conditions warrant a reevaluation, or upon the request of the child’s parent or teacher, but at least every three years. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a). The evaluation shall be conducted by knowledgeable personnel using a variety of validated assessment tools and strategies, and shall assess the child in all areas of suspected disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.
STUDENT argues that the District failed to assess him appropriately and failed to fully identify the extent of his deficits, both generally and with specific regard to his OT needs. At the hearing, however, STUDENT did not raise a challenge to any particular District assessment. Instead, FATHER testified that the allegation of inappropriate assessment is based on STUDENT’s failure to progress in meeting his goals and objectives. According to FATHER, STUDENT’s failure to progress indicates either that he was inappropriately assessed, or his goals and objectives were inappropriate, or his program was improperly implemented.
An LEA’s obligation to provide a disabled student with meaningful access to education does not include a guarantee of successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, supra, 142 F.3d at 133. Thus, STUDENT’s alleged lack of progress does not, by itself, prove that his assessments were inadequate or that his program was otherwise defective. Instead, the adequacy of STUDENT’s assessments must be reviewed in light of the applicable law set forth above. (a) STUDENT’s 2002 OT assessment
STUDENT’s most comprehensive recent OT assessment was conducted in June of 2002 by Micky Woodrow, an occupational therapist for the District. Ms. Woodrow attempted to administer standardized tests, interviewed STUDENT’s mother and grandmother, and observed STUDENT playing and performing tasks under his grandmother’s direction. Ms. Woodrow evaluated STUDENT’s fine and gross motor skills, and concluded that STUDENT was experiencing “major delays” of three to four years in the development of those skills. (D. Exh. 69.)
There is no evidence to indicate that the June 2002 OT assessment was out of compliance with any State or federal requirement, and STUDENT has not challenged its appropriateness or the validity of its findings. Instead, STUDENT argues that Ms. Alperton, his OT provider from mid-January to mid-May of 2004, failed to adequately assess his needs in his regular OT sessions. (Footnote 16) Specifically, he asserts that Ms. Alperton never consulted with SI about STUDENT’s program, never took notes on his progress, and was unfamiliar with his OT performance in his home program as reported by SI. (Testimony of Ms. Wells and Ms. Matteucci.) STUDENT argues that the concept of assessment applies not only to formal evaluations, but to a service provider’s ability to understand a student’s level of functioning, to track his progress, and to modify his goals in light of that progress. He concludes that the alleged failings of Ms. Alperton described above indicate that she failed to appropriately assess his OT needs.
STUDENT cites no legal authority, and the Hearing Officer is aware of none, to support his assertion that the assessment process requires ongoing consultation with other service providers or an ongoing, informal tracking of progress and modification of goals from one session to the next. Nor does STUDENT’s January 2004 IEP require such a process in his OT program. (Footnote 17) Accordingly, and in light of the fact that STUDENT raises no challenge to his formal OT assessment in 2002, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s OT needs were appropriately assessed by the District.
(b) STUDENT’s triennial assessment
STUDENT’s triennial assessment took place in March of 2003, and consisted of a psychoeducational assessment by District psychologist Christina Giannini and an academic assessment by SDC teacher Jonica McPhail. Both Dr. Giannini and Ms. McPhail used a variety of assessment tools in their evaluations, including review of STUDENT’s medical history and previous evaluations, administration of standardized tests, a questionnaire filled out by STUDENT’s grandmother, and observations of STUDENT in an SDC setting and working with various service providers. The assessments evaluated STUDENT in the areas of speech and language, occupational therapy, and cognitive and adaptive skills, and found him to be significantly impaired in all areas. (D. Exhs. 3,4.)
As with the 2002 OT assessment, there is no evidence indicating that the triennial assessment was out of compliance with any State or federal requirement, and STUDENT has not challenged its appropriateness or the validity of its findings. Nor has STUDENT raised any other issues with respect to the alleged inadequacy of his assessments other than his failure to make progress on his educational goals. As failure to make progress is an insufficient basis for a finding that an assessment was inappropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was appropriately assessed by the District. (Footnote 18) (2) Did the District fail to accurately report STUDENT’s progress at IEP meetings?
Federal and State law provide for the conduct of IEP meetings to review, at least annually, a disabled child’s progress on his or her educational goals, and to revise those goals as appropriate to address any lack of expected progress. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56340 et seq. The law requires regular reports on the child’s progress, but does not specify the methods by which progress should be measured. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(viii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.
STUDENT alleges that his SDC teacher, Ms. McPhail, failed to accurately report on his progress at his IEP meetings. Specifically, FATHER testified that at the May 12, 2004 IEP meeting, Ms. McPhail reported that she had collected “a lot” of raw data on STUDENT’s classroom progress, but when she produced the data at FATHER’s request in a meeting on May 24, she only had data covering a few months, and apologized for not having more.
As described by FATHER, Ms. McPhail’s representation at the May 12 IEP meeting would appear to be at most an inadvertent error in describing how much raw data was available. The law does not require progress to be measured in any specific fashion, nor did STUDENT’s IEP require that his progress be measured only by data collection. Accordingly, the relative lack of data would not imply that Ms. McPhail’s progress reports were inaccurate. Further, as Ms. McPhail produced what data she had upon FATHER’s request shortly after the IEP meeting, there is no indication that STUDENT’s parents were misled about the amount of data available for any significant period of time.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was appropriately assessed by the District, and that any failure to accurately report the amount of raw data taken in tracking his progress was an inadvertent error that neither resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT nor seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that no procedural violations occurred in the provision of STUDENT’s 2003-2004 educational program that resulted in a denial of FAPE.
B. Substantive issues
A review of the District’s program for substantive appropriateness first requires a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs, as indicated by the nature and scope of his impairment and his then-current levels of functioning. Then, the goals and objectives established for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY will be reviewed to determine if, as drafted and as implemented, they were designed to meet his unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP.
(1) STUDENT’s unique needs (a) Nature and scope of impairment
STUDENT was diagnosed as autistic at age two, and there appears to be no dispute that he shows significant symptoms of autistic spectrum disorder. From an early age, STUDENT had deficits in speech and language, socialization, fine and gross motor skills, attention to task, and self-help skills. He exhibited maladaptive behaviors (loud vocalizations, grabbing at people, tearing at paper) that his assessors and therapists believe were related to his inability to communicate, frustration with tasks, and anxiety over transitions in his routine.
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT’s unique needs included the development of a functional communication system, learning to follow directions and attend to tasks, functional self-help skills (particularly toilet training), fine and gross motor skills necessary to increase his self-help skills and independence, and generalization of his skills across settings. Further, STUDENT needed consistent behavior intervention to reduce his maladaptive behaviors and replace them with new coping strategies.
One aspect of STUDENT’s impairment that had not been expressly determined was his cognitive level. During his 2003 assessments, attempts to administer standardized cognition and academic tests were unsuccessful due to STUDENT’s apparent inability to understand the directions and his lack of cooperation. (D. Exhs. 3, 4.) His psychoeducational assessment did note, however, that his adaptive skills in communication, socialization, daily living, and motor skills were almost all in the very low range. (D. Exh. 3.)
To provide insight into this issue, the District introduced the testimony of Bryna Siegel, Ph.D. Dr. Siegel is an adjunct professor of psychiatry at the Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute, a research, teaching, and patient care facility at the University of California, San Francisco. She also is the director of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at that campus, which she described as one of the largest autism clinics in the State. Dr. Siegel has done extensive research on autism treatment models and has published many papers on the subject, both independently and in conjunction with other experts in the field. She lectures regularly on autism diagnosis and treatment, and has given expert testimony in over thirty due process hearings, in which she has testified for parents and for school districts on an equal basis. (See D. Exhs. 54-63.) (Footnote 19)
Dr. Siegel first noted that, when standardized cognition tests cannot be administered due to a child’s noncompliance, inattention, or impairment, cognitive skills are determined by measuring adaptive skills such as communication, self-help, and socialization. She stated that a child’s ability to dress without assistance, use words, communicate wants and needs, and otherwise relate to his or her environment are reliable indicators of cognitive development. Further, since adaptive skills normally increase with age, disparities between age and skill level become easier to determine as a child grows older.
In STUDENT’s case, Dr. Siegel noted that his 2003 assessments, performed when he was almost eight years old, showed that his adaptive skills all tested in the very low range, with an age equivalency of one to four years in most areas. In reviewing STUDENT’s more recent progress reports and IEPs, she indicated that STUDENT’s individual performance levels with respect to his goals and objectives did not exceed those of an eighteen-month-old child. For example, she noted that STUDENT was unable to dress himself, did not use words spontaneously, did not use reliable gestures to communicate, and could not match simple objects or build simple block designs with consistency.
According to Dr. Siegel, this level of development in a nine-year-old child like STUDENT was consistent with severe mental retardation. She stated that STUDENT’s assessments accurately described him as such, although they did not use the specific term. (Footnote 20) Dr. Siegel further noted that about seventy percent of autistic children have some measure of mental retardation, but that due to the social stigma associated with the term and parental difficulties in accepting such a diagnosis, assessments of autistic children commonly include findings consistent with mental retardation without labeling it as such. Considering STUDENT’s age, assessments, and skill levels, Dr. Siegel asserted that her opinion of STUDENT as severely mentally retarded is “not a close question.” (Footnote 21)
STUDENT disputes Dr. Siegel’s opinion on the ground that she is a “highly paid” witness who has neither assessed nor observed him, nor spoken to any of his IEP team members. However, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Siegel’s testimony persuasive. Dr. Siegel’s experience and expertise in the field of autism are noteworthy, and her regular testimony on behalf of both parents and school districts dispels any intimation of bias. (Footnote 22) In formulating her opinion, she testified that she reviewed all of STUDENT’s most recent assessments and progress reports, none of which have been challenged as inaccurate by his parents.
Further, Dr. Siegel’s opinion was corroborated by evidence indicating that in a variety of contexts, STUDENT was not merely uncooperative or unable to communicate, but did not appear to understand what was expected of him or why. In observing STUDENT’s grandmother directing him to match letters and numbers, for example, the District assessors noted that STUDENT’s periodic successes did not seem to indicate any real understanding of the matching concept. STUDENT’s service providers noted that he was unaware of social boundaries or safety issues. He was not yet toilet trained, despite extensive efforts by SI staff and others, and did not appear to understand the usage of the toilet. Although STUDENT’s hearing is not impaired, his comprehension of simple words and phrases was low – he did not understand verbal references to many objects in his environment, and needed to be directed to them by pointing. (See S. Exhs. 4, 21; D. Exhs. 3, 4.)
Finally, FATHER himself did not strongly dispute Dr. Siegel’s opinion that STUDENT is mentally retarded. While asserting that Dr. Siegel lacked enough information to render the opinion, FATHER acknowledged that her opinion was “not a surprise,” and he agreed that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning is low. (Testimony of FATHER.) STUDENT offered no expert testimony contradicting Dr. Siegel’s opinions. (Footnote 23) For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s deficits include cognitive impairment at a significant level.
(b) STUDENT’s levels of functioning
The parties do not appear to dispute STUDENT’s levels of functioning as described in his March 2003 assessments. STUDENT was essentially nonverbal, and engaged in hand leading behavior to communicate his needs and wants. He did not respond to prompts to say “hi” in response to a greeting. In receptive communication, STUDENT could follow a few one-step directions (sit, stand, come here). He was able to identify some objects and numbers by pointing to them upon request with about fifty percent accuracy, and could match some colors and shapes. In fine motor skills, STUDENT could use a pincer grasp to pick up pennies and put them in a slot, could scribble in a circular motion, and could complete a simple four-piece puzzle, but was unable to lace beads or cut with scissors. In gross motor skills, STUDENT could walk across an obstacle course and could balance on one foot for a few seconds, but was unable to run, sit in a swing while maintaining his balance, or climb on playground structures.
In life skills, STUDENT was not toilet trained, could not dress or undress himself, could not drink from a cup without spillage, and did not consistently use utensils to eat. In terms of his behavior, STUDENT would vocalize loudly, tear at materials, grab at items or people, or engage in tantrums when presented with new tasks or when frustrated with a task. (D. Exhs. 3,4, 9, 12.)
In summary, STUDENT’s level of impairment showed significant delays in all areas, including cognitive development. His unique needs included development of a functional communication system to compensate for his lack of verbal skills, functional self-help skills such as dressing and toilet training, fine and gross motor development to help him achieve those self-help skills, and generalization of skills across settings in order to achieve full mastery of his skills. Further, STUDENT needed consistent behavior intervention to reduce his maladaptive behaviors and to help him focus on learning needed skills.
(2) Was STUDENT’s educational program designed to meet his unique needs?
The Hearing Officer must next determine whether STUDENT’s educational program was designed to meet his unique needs described above. STUDENT’s program was set forth in his January 16, 2004 IEP, and continued without significant alterations through the end of the school year. It consisted of the following:
(A) An SDC providing individual and small-group instruction, language arts, and mathematics five days per week, six hours per day;
(B) A paraeducator to provide one-to-one assistance to STUDENT in the classroom;
(C) Two thirty-minute OT sessions per week (one individual pull-out session and one group session in the classroom), plus sixty minutes of consultation per month;
(D) Two thirty-minute individual S/L sessions per week;
(E) Augmentative communication consultation for ninety minutes per month; and (F) An in-home program provided by SI for five days per week, three hours per day, plus two hours per week of supervision. (Footnote 24)
STUDENT alleges that his classroom and OT goals were inappropriate (see infra). However, he has not challenged the appropriateness of his overall program, and the Hearing Officer finds that it was designed to meet his needs. The program addressed STUDENT’s communicative needs through S/L services and augmentative communication consultation, his fine motor needs through OT services, and his functional and self-help needs through full-day classroom instruction that would also reinforce his communicative and fine motor skill development. Further, the program specifically addressed STUDENT’s need for consistent behavioral intervention by providing for an SI aide to give one-to-one support in the classroom and in the home program. The provision of SI support at school and at home also was intended to help STUDENT generalize skills he was mastering at home in the school setting.
Separate goals and objectives were developed for STUDENT for his SDC class, his OT sessions, and his S/L therapy. STUDENT’s classroom goals were those initially adopted at an IEP meeting held on March 26, 2003. (See D. Exh. 35 (May 12, 2004 IEP, including March 2003 goals and objectives with periodic progress notes).) The preface to the goals notes that STUDENT was unable to communicate his wants and needs, to follow requests, or to participate in activities with others outside the family, and that he needed multiple physical and verbal prompts to complete tasks or comply with requests. STUDENT’s goals were as follows:
(A) to match/identify letters, numbers, body parts, colors, and shapes; (B) to respond to a one-step classroom or safety direction upon initial request (stand up, sit down, stop, wait, walk, come here); (C) to use a tripod grasp to trace a vertical, horizontal, and diagonal line with a writing tool (with partial prompts); (D) to follow an eleven-step morning classroom routine, including removing/putting away coat and backpack and sitting at desk (with partial prompts); (E) to play a turn-taking table game with a peer for up to ten minutes (with partial prompts); (F) to greet peers and staff upon request with a handshake and verbal approximation of “hi”; and (G) to use PECS to communicate a want/need for chips, water, eating, going to the bathroom, taking a break from a task, or taking a walk.
STUDENT’s OT goals for the 2003-2004 school year were directed toward increasing his ability to sit in an academic environment and focus on a task; increasing his fine motor skills, particularly hand function; and increasing self-help skills in the classroom. (D. Exh. 29.) They can be summarized as follows:
(1) to receive sensory motor input, including brushing and deep pressure, for increasing periods of time; (2) to sit in class without vocalizing for increasing periods of time; (3) to manipulate objects with his fingertips (i.e., puzzles, coins); (4) to scribble, draw horizontal and vertical lines, and draw a circle; (5) to put on and remove his coat with decreasing levels of assistance; and (6) to open his backpack with decreasing levels of assistance. (Footnote 25)
STUDENT alleges that his classroom and OT goals were inappropriate in that some were too challenging, some not challenging enough, and some were not suited to the context in which they were applied. For example, FATHER testified that the number matching goal was beyond STUDENT’s current level of functioning, and the letter matching goal was not challenging enough because STUDENT already had met this goal in the home setting, and he wanted STUDENT to move on to word recognition goals that would be useful to him in the future. Further, FATHER felt the line drawing goal should not have been pursued in the classroom because it already was an OT goal, and it related more to OT skills than to functional academics. He also was concerned that the line drawing goal might not be implemented the same way in the two settings, which might interfere with STUDENT’s ability to master the goal.
Dr. Siegel reviewed STUDENT’s classroom goals in light of his unique needs and was of the opinion that, overall, they were appropriate and valuable for STUDENT. Specifically, Goals B (safety directions), D (following routine), F (greetings) and G (PECS) were important to help STUDENT learn to negotiate his environment safely and independently, and to increase his social and especially his communication skills. With respect to Goal A (identifying letters and numbers, etc.), Dr. Siegel testified that identifying body parts and distinguishing shapes and colors had some functional value. She observed, however, that letter and number identification seemed less functional, and would be harder for STUDENT to master consistently since he probably saw no purpose to it.
District OT provider Terri Locke, who replaced Ms. Alperton as STUDENT’s OT provider in May 2004, testified that his OT goals were directed toward his needs, and provided him with an appropriate level of challenge. (Footnote 26) Specifically, she noted that OT Goals 1 and 2 (sensory motor input, sitting without vocalizing) helped STUDENT to relax and focus on his tasks, and that his performance in these areas improved while she was working with him. Ms. Locke testified that Goal 3 (manipulating objects with “tip to tip” prehension) helped STUDENT to form an arch with his hand, which would help him master other fine motor skills. Further, Dr. Siegel testified that Goal 4 (line drawing) was both appropriate and useful for the development of leisure skills, so that STUDENT could learn to do art projects for his own enjoyment.
Although STUDENT showed no noticeable improvement in Goals 3 and 4 during the weeks Ms. Locke worked with him, she testified that these were valuable goals that should be continued because they were basic to STUDENT’s ability to master other tasks. She added that using an approach to the line drawing goal in class that differed from the approach used in OT sessions would be beneficial, not harmful, because the important issue was the end result. Ms. Locke indicated that alternative strategies to reach the same goal increase the likelihood that the goal will be reached and a functional skill will be mastered.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s classroom and OT goals were designed to meet his unique needs. Developing a functional communication system and learning to follow directions without resistance or maladaptive behaviors were among STUDENT’s primary needs, and Classroom Goals B, D, and G specifically addressed those needs. With respect to Goal A (identifying letters, numbers, shapes, body parts, etc.), Dr. Siegel found the identifying and matching exercises to have functional value, and Ms. McPhail testified that the letter identification goal was intended to help STUDENT learn to identify simple sight words in the future. Classroom Goal D (following routine) included functional skills such as taking off a coat and putting away a backpack. STUDENT’s OT goals helped him to relax, focus on his tasks, and begin to master the fine motor manipulations that are the foundation of important life skills such as working buttons and zippers on clothing and using utensils for self-feeding. Finally, the fact that some of STUDENT’s classroom goals also were included in his OT and S/L goals was not inappropriate. According to Dr. Siegel, repetition in other settings reinforces and generalizes a skill, and generalization of skills was another primary need identified in STUDENT’s IEP.
Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support the allegation that STUDENT’s goals were either too advanced or not challenging enough. STUDENT’s progress notes report slow progress on most of his goals, which indicates that they were within his grasp. (Footnote 27) The fact that STUDENT would progress on some goals, and then fail to progress any further for weeks at a time, does not appear unexpected in light of his significant global impairments. (Footnote 28) Finally, STUDENT’s mastery of the letter matching goal at home did not indicate that the goal was insufficiently challenging, since it was not yet mastered at school, and mastery across settings was a specific goal of STUDENT’s IEP.
(2) Was STUDENT’s educational program reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit? (3)
STUDENT argues that he failed to make significant progress in achieving his goals in a school setting, and that this failure indicates that his educational program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. However, case law makes clear that individualized educational programs cannot be judged exclusively in hindsight. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). Noting that an IEP is “a snapshot, not a retrospective,” the Adams court indicated that the pertinent question is not whether STUDENT has made progress, but whether the program was designed to convey a meaningful educational benefit to STUDENT. Id. Since an IEP need not guarantee successful results to provide a FAPE, STUDENT’s alleged lack of progress does not, by itself, prove that the District’s program was inadequate. See Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, supra, 142 F.3d 119.
STUDENT also argues that his program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because it failed to provide for sufficient data collection to track his goals and measure his progress. FATHER testified extensively about his belief in data as a measurement of progress, and his frustration and anger at Ms. McPhail’s failure to collect more data on STUDENT’s academic performance. He asserted that the lack of data made Ms. McPhail’s progress reports suspect, left STUDENT’s current functioning levels in doubt, and made it difficult to plan new goals and objectives for STUDENT.
Federal law requires that the IEP for a student with a disability contain, among other things, a statement of “measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives” related to meeting STUDENT’s needs, and a statement of “how the child’s progress toward [these goals] will be measured.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(viii). State law also requires a statement of measurable goals, with “appropriate objective criteria” for determining, “at least on an annual basis,” whether the annual goals are being achieved. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. Neither federal nor State law expresses a preference for any particular system of measurement.
STUDENT’s goals included short-term objectives, and noted that his progress was to be measured by “teacher evaluation, data collection, and/or observation.” (See, e.g., D. Exh. 35.) (Footnote 29) Ms. McPhail testified that she used a combination of these methods to track her students’ performance, but generally used the data to confirm her own observations of a student’s progress. Over time, when she found her observations consistently confirmed by the data, she would rely less on data as a tracking method.
Ms. McPhail expected STUDENT’s one-to-one aide to take periodic data on his performance in relation to his goals, and left data sheets with STUDENT’s materials to facilitate data collection. She testified that the raw data collected on STUDENT’s progress between December 2003 and March 2004 was taken by the SI aide and the District aide-in-training. (See S. Exhs. 111-119.) Since STUDENT’s progress was slow and his goals were continued without significant change, however, it became easier for Ms. McPhail to follow his progress by observation than by data collection, and she did not actively solicit data from his SI aide as the year progressed. Ms. McPhail testified that she did not know why the SI aide stopped collecting the data after March, but acknowledged that, when FATHER requested the data sheets in May, there was no raw data available for April or May 2004.
According to Dr. Siegel, data collection is an appropriate system of measurement, but is not the only way to measure academic progress. She noted that teacher evaluation, data collection, and observation are all appropriate methods. Dr. Siegel stated persuasively that there is no evidence that continual data collection produces more accurate results than periodic collection, and that continual collection actually would interfere with instruction. (Footnote 30) Further, she credibly testified that to the extent data collection was being used to track STUDENT’s performance, collection on a weekly basis probably was appropriate, but that in view of his slow progress, teacher observation also was appropriate.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. McPhail’s methods for measuring STUDENT’s progress were adequate. The applicable laws neither require nor express a preference for one measurement method over another, and Ms. McPhail’s progress reports, drawn from a combination of data and observation, drew conclusions about STUDENT’s progress that were substantially similar to those provided by SI’s periodic progress reports. The data taken from December 2003 through March 2004 was collected on roughly a weekly basis, and as Ms. McPhail’s tracking methods shifted from data collection to observation over the course of the year, the lack of raw data for the final months of the school year did not interfere with her ability to report accurately on STUDENT’s progress.
Based on the earlier findings that STUDENT’s educational program and goals were designed to meet his unique needs, the Hearing Officer also finds that his program and goals were reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Ms. McPhail’s use of methods other than data collection did not affect the accuracy of her progress reports, and the fact that STUDENT made some, albeit slow, progress on his goals over the school year supports the District’s calculations about the potential benefits of the program.
(3) Did the educational program provided by the District comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT’s educational program consisted of an SDC placement, a home program, and OT and S/L services. As STUDENT raises no issues regarding his home program or S/L services, they are not addressed here.
STUDENT’s SDC was taught by Jonica McPhail, who has a teaching credential for severely handicapped children and eleven years experience as a special education teacher. In the 2003-2004 school year, she had seven students in her SDC for severely handicapped children, with disabilities including autism, Down’s Syndrome, and multiple disabilities. The class had one full-time instructional aide (“para-educator”) as well as two one-to-one aides for STUDENT and one other student.
Ms. McPhail testified that she was familiar with STUDENT’s IEP and actively assisted in developing his classroom goals. She implemented her students’ IEPs through a combination of small group and individual instruction throughout the day. A typical school day began with Ms. McPhail and her aides engaging in greetings with students and supervising or assisting their routines for getting ready for class, which in STUDENT’s case included taking off his coat and putting away his backpack. Ms. McPhail then led the group in songs or word activities, while the para-educator and individual aides prompted students as necessary.
Students then rotated through a series of activities at different tables, assisted by the para-educator and aides. Ms. McPhail prepared separate index cards for each student regarding each activity, reflecting their individual IEP goals in relation to the activity. STUDENT’s goals included matching letters, numbers, colors, and shapes, using a writing instrument, playing games with others, and using PECS to communicate requests for breaks, a drink, or a snack. At lunchtime, STUDENTs followed other directions in classroom routines, such as standing or walking in line to the lunchroom. Other class activities might include a trip to another class, pull-out sessions for OT or S/L therapy, or art projects. (Testimony of Ms. McPhail.)
STUDENT’s OT provider from mid-January through mid-May of 2004, Eleanor Alperton, did not testify at the hearing. However, SI aide Ms. Matteucci testified that she took STUDENT to most of his OT pull-out sessions during that period, and observed Ms. Alperton work with STUDENT on his OT goals. Terri Locke, who replaced Ms. Alperton from mid-May to the end of the ESY, testified that she worked with STUDENT on all of his OT goals except those relating to his coat and backpack, since STUDENT did not wear a coat or backpack in the summer.
Based on the above testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s educational program generally comported with STUDENT’s IEP. However, STUDENT alleges that the District failed to implement his educational program appropriately because (1) he made slower progress at school than in his home program; (2) Ms. McPhail failed to interact with him sufficiently; and (3) Ms. Alperton behaved unprofessionally and provided unsafe therapy. These allegations, which in essence allege specific failures to comport with STUDENT’s IEP, are addressed in turn below.
(a) Was STUDENT’s progress slower at school than at home, and if so, does that indicate a failure to comport with his IEP?
There was a great deal of testimony about STUDENT’s performance disparity between home and school settings, but little of it related to progress other than assertions that STUDENT was doing somewhat better at letter matching and line drawing at home. A comparison of Ms. McPhail’s school progress notes and SI’s reports, which cover both home and school performance, reveals only minimal home/school disparity in STUDENT’s progress. (Footnote 31) On the contrary, the central disparity reported by SI in its April 2004 report was STUDENT’s greater use of maladaptive behaviors to escape tasks at school. (Footnote 32) After discussing the problem at the May 12, 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team decided STUDENT should have a cubicle at school to minimize distractions, and a cubicle was provided.
To the extent any disparity in academic performance existed, Dr. Siegel testified that home/school performance disparities are not uncommon among autistic children. Most autistic children are easily overwhelmed by sensory input, and the home presents fewer distractions than a classroom filled with active and noisy peers. Under the circumstances, the IEP team’s decision to put a cubicle in STUDENT’s classroom to allow him to calm down or concentrate on tasks without distractions was an appropriate response to the perceived disparity.
As the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s progress was reasonably consistent across settings, and as any disparity in performance was reasonably addressed by the introduction of a cubicle for STUDENT at school, the Hearing Officer finds no basis for STUDENT’s assertion that a home/school disparity existed as a result of poor implementation of the school program.
(b) Did the District fail to comport with STUDENT’s IEP by failing to provide for more personal interaction between STUDENT and his SDC teacher? STUDENT’s January 2004 IEP provided for “individual and small group instruction” in his special day class (SDC). STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Ms. McPhail, testified that her role was to manage the class, primarily by providing direction and support to the aides working with students. To this end, she provided the aides with index cards explaining how each classroom activity should be undertaken for each student, and also led small group activities, worked directly with students from time to time, and observed students’ progress.
FATHER and MOTHER testified that they each made several visits to STUDENT’s class in the spring of 2004. The parents noted that neither Ms. McPhail nor the classroom para-educator appeared to work directly with STUDENT since his one-to-one SI aide had begun working with him in class. MOTHER testified that, during a discussion of STUDENT’s performance on a State test, Ms. McPhail told MOTHER that she “hadn’t worked with STUDENT in a long time.” Erin Matteucci, one of STUDENT’s SI aides, testified that Ms. McPhail did not interact with STUDENT or with the other student who had a one-to-one aide. STUDENT argues that Ms. McPhail’s failure to engage in more personal interactions with him contributed to his slow progress in school.
The Hearing Officer first notes that, as indicated above, the evidence does not support a finding that STUDENT’s educational progress at school was markedly slower than his progress at home. SI’s progress reports show that on many goals, STUDENT made progress consistently across settings, and on other goals, Ms. McPhail’s notes show progress at school consistent with STUDENT’s progress at home.
To the extent STUDENT is arguing that his slow progress overall is attributable to Ms. McPhail’s insufficient personal interactions with him at school, that argument would imply that individual instruction from Ms. McPhail herself, rather than from an aide, was required for his advancement. However, there is nothing in STUDENT’s IEP, the law, or the prevailing practices in SDC instruction to support that argument.
First, STUDENT’s IEP does not specify who was to directly provide his individual or small group instruction at school. Its only specific requirement is for placement in severely handicapped SDC with a full-time one-to-one classroom aide, and the evidence makes clear that an SDC and a full-time aide were provided. The fact that STUDENT’s individual classroom instruction may have been directly conducted primarily by his one-to-one aide does not violate any provision in his IEP. Further, Ms. McPhail was actively involved in STUDENT’s instruction in other ways every day, both by leading his small group sessions and by observing his progress on his classroom goals.
Second, the law does not require a particular amount of individualized instruction by SDC teachers. Federal IDEA regulations require instruction of handicapped children to be performed by “qualified personnel,” defined as personnel certified in the field in which they are providing services. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.23, 300.136. SI co-director Ms. Wells testified that SI’s aides are trained and certified, have a bachelor’s degree or higher in education, psychology, or a related field, and are “trained to do what District instructional aides can do” – that is, provide one-to-one instruction carrying out the academic curricula designed by the teacher. SI’s aides provided academic instruction to STUDENT not only at school, under Ms. McPhail’s direction, but also in his home program, without Ms. McPhail being present, and STUDENT has made no complaints about the quality of his academic instruction at home. (Footnote 33)
Finally, the prevailing practices in SDC instruction do not support STUDENT’s argument. Dr. Siegel, who has lectured extensively on teaching practices for autistic children, testified to these prevailing practices, and noted that SDC teachers generally are “program managers” who do not provide much one-to-one instruction. (Footnote 34) Rather, they circulate in the classroom, supervising the trained instructional aides and making sure activities are being administered in accordance with the curricula devised for each student. This is almost precisely how Ms. McPhail described her teaching methods. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s slow progress, either in school or overall, is not attributable to Ms. McPhail’s failure to engage in more direct interactions with him and did not constitute a failure to comport with his IEP.
(c) Did Ms. Alperton’s alleged unprofessionalism constitute a failure to comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT alleges that Ms. Alperton failed to cooperate at IEP meetings, made unprofessional statements, and used unsafe OT equipment in an unsafe environment. The District responds that STUDENT’s allegations reflect differences of opinion, and that Ms. Alperton performed her services in a professional manner.
Federal and State laws and regulations set forth no express requirements for “professionalism” in the provision of a FAPE. Nevertheless, to the extent professionalism may be at issue, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District on this point. First, Ms. Alperton’s unwillingness to break STUDENT’s OT goals into subparts, as requested by FATHER at an IEP meeting, appears to reflect a professional disagreement rather than a lack of cooperation. Notably, Ms. Alperton later agreed to redraft some of STUDENT’s OT goals, which indicates a desire to cooperate and to find some common ground in this disagreement. Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that the evidence indicates that Ms. Alperton implemented STUDENT’s OT goals as agreed upon by the IEP team. Nor do the remarks attributed to Ms. Alperton in SI incident reports and reported by FATHER appear to constitute unprofessional behavior. In view of the poor opinion of Ms. Alperton held by both STUDENT’s parents and the SI witnesses, it appears to the Hearing Officer that her reported statements were interpreted by them in the most negative light, and are subject to much different interpretation when viewed in context. (Footnote 35)
Further, the concerns expressed by the SI aides about the location and equipment used in some of Ms. Alperton’s OT sessions do not rise to the level of a genuine safety issue. There was no evidence that the conduct of OT sessions on a raised stage is inappropriate in a one-to-one situation when the service provider has control over STUDENT, and Ms. Matteucci testified that the only time she saw Ms. Alperton conduct STUDENT’s sessions with another student present was on the date of her incident report. In fact, Ms. Matteucci said she had never had any concerns about OT sessions being conducted on the stage until that single incident. Ms. Locke, the OT provider who replaced Ms. Alperton and who was mentioned with approval by STUDENT’s parents, testified that she also has conducted OT sessions on the stage without incident.
Finally, the evidence was insufficient to show that Ms. Alperton’s alleged use of a folding chair as a stepping device for STUDENT was inherently unsafe. The SI witness did not describe the workings of the chair or indicate whether or how it would break down if stepped upon incorrectly. MOTHER, who also witnessed an OT session in which Ms. Alperton had STUDENT step up on a chair and walk along chairs lined up together, testified that Ms. Alperton told her she used the chairs regularly in her OT sessions, and there was no evidence presented that STUDENT or any other student suffered any harm from the practice. (Footnote 36)
The Hearing Officer finds that, to the extent any home/school disparity existed in STUDENT’s progress in achieving his educational goals, it was not attributable to any failure by the District to comport with his IEP through the teaching methods of his SDC teacher or the provision of his OT services.
In summary, with respect to the 2003-2004 regular school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District assessed STUDENT appropriately, and that any misinformation it may have provided at IEP meetings was inadvertent, was corrected in a timely fashion, and did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringe on his parents’ participation in the IEP process. Further, STUDENT’s educational program was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and the fact that his progress was tracked through methods other than data collection did not affect the accuracy of his progress reports. Finally, the District implemented STUDENT’s program in a manner that comported with his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE from January 17, 2004 through the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to offer and/or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2004 extended school year (ESY)?
Federal and State regulations provide for extended school year (ESY) services when a disabled student’s IEP team determines such services are necessary to provide a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. In California, ESY services must be provided when interruption of STUDENT’s educational program may cause regression that is unlikely to be recouped in the next school year. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. When an ESY program is provided, it must consist of no fewer than twenty days of instruction. Id.
STUDENT’s IEPs for January, March, and May 2004 all indicate that his IEP team had determined that he should receive ESY services. At the conclusion of the May 12 IEP meeting, however, no decision on the ESY program or on STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program had been reached. On May 18, District program manager Mr. Anich faxed FATHER a written offer of both a 2004 ESY program and a program for the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 37)
The ESY program offer included an SDC at Bollinger Canyon Elementary School for five days per week, three hours and fifty minutes per day, for the period of June 21-July 21. After receiving the offer, FATHER told Mr. Anich in a telephone conversation that it contained an “obvious error” in its omission of a one-to-one classroom aide for STUDENT; Mr. Anich faxed him a corrected copy including provision of the one-to-one aide. The ESY offer also included a home program of “instructional support for academic and social development” for five days per week, two hours per day, with one and one-half hours per week of supervision. In addition, the District offered an “extended ESY” for the period of July 28-August 25 that would continue the ESY home program but increase its duration to three hours per day, with two hours per day of supervision.
A. Procedural issues
STUDENT alleges that the ESY program offer conveyed by Mr. Anich’s May 18, 2004 letter denied his due process rights because (1) it was a “unilateral” effort that denied his parents the opportunity to participate in the development of the program, and (2) it failed to include specific OT and classroom goals. These allegations are addressed in turn below.
(1) Parental participation
The District acknowledges that the May 18 ESY offer was written without the direct participation of STUDENT’s parents. District witnesses testified the March and May IEP meetings ended without completion of their agendas due to lengthy and contentious discussions, the departure of some team members, and an overall “fatigue factor” among those who remained. As the May 12 meeting wound down, Mr. Anich, who was chairing the meetings to ensure that they were productive, expressed his concern that a District offer could not be appropriately conveyed, considered, and agreed to under the circumstances, and informed STUDENT’s parents that he would write up the District offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year and send it to them for their consideration and feedback. (Footnote 38) Mr. Anich testified that he believed the written offer summarized the program elements the IEP team had been “moving toward” and that the parents could support.
FATHER acknowledged that upon receipt of the offer, he engaged in feedback with Mr. Anich, pointing out an error, receiving a corrected copy from Mr. Anich, and indicating further concerns that Mr. Anich invited him to share. FATHER stated that he would do so at the next IEP meeting, but Mr. Anich’s efforts to schedule a meeting in June were unsuccessful. Mr. Anich initially noticed a meeting for June 11, a date FATHER had indicated was agreeable to him and to SI, but FATHER later declined to meet on that date because his attorney was not available. FATHER declined Mr. Anich’s offer to meet without attorneys. Mr. Anich then suggested June 15 for a meeting date, but there is no persuasive evidence that FATHER ever responded to him about that date. The ESY program began shortly thereafter on June 21.
Parental participation in the IEP process is one of the basic procedural requirements of the IDEA. Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072, 1077 (9th Cir. 2003); Amanda J. v. Clark County School District, 267 F.3d. 877, 892 (9th Cir. 2001); see 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(20). The law requires an IEP to be “developed, reviewed, and revised in a meeting in accordance with Secs. 300.341-300.350.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.340(a) (emphasis added). Parental participation in prior IEP meetings, or parental receipt of a copy of a district-created offer for their subsequent approval, is not an adequate substitute for a lack of participation in the creation of the offer itself. As the Shapiro court held, the IDEA “imposes upon the school district the duty to conduct a meaningful meeting with the appropriate parties.” Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, supra, 317 F.3d at 1078 (emphasis in original).
The courts have acknowledged, however, that consensus on development of a program is not always achievable at an IEP meeting. When disputes are unresolved, a school district still has the duty “to formulate the plan to the best of its ability in accordance with information developed at [prior] meetings, but must afford the parents a due process hearing in regard to that plan.” Ms. S. v. Vashon Island School District, 337 F.3d 1115, 1132 (9th Cir. 2003), quoting Doe by Gonzales v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470, 1490 (9th Cir. 1986). In Vashon Island, the court held that where a school district “has repeatedly provided the parents with the opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process,” its preparation of an IEP offer outside of an IEP meeting does not violate its IDEA obligations so long as the district affords the parents a due process hearing regarding the plan. In Doe by Gonzales, the court confirmed that either party has the right to initiate a due process hearing when dissatisfied with the results of IEP discussions or other placement matters.
In this case, it is clear that the March and May IEP meetings were lengthy and contentious, and ended without resolution of all of the parties’ issues. It also appears that the ESY program offer drafted by Mr. Anich was composed of elements that had been under review and discussion by the IEP team for some time. At the annual IEP meeting in March, which lasted at least two hours, the team reviewed STUDENT’s speech and language goals and considered how to link them with augmentative communication devices. Ms. Alperton presented updated OT goals for STUDENT, and there was disagreement about his progress and about whether his goals should be broken down into subparts.
At the May 12 meeting, which focused on STUDENT’s program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year and which lasted over two hours, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s behavioral issues at length, and agreed to provide him with a cubicle in the classroom to help him focus on his tasks. Ms. McPhail began to present her report on STUDENT’s classroom goals, but FATHER asked her to stop her presentation because he wanted the SI directors present and they already had left the meeting. Ms. McPhail agreed to meet separately with FATHER and SI to review STUDENT’s classroom progress and update his goals.
As indicated above, STUDENT’s parents actively participated in the development of his educational program for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year, both in IEP meetings and otherwise. The May 12 IEP notes indicate that discussion of the ESY program was under way, if not completed, and Mr. Anich testified that he drafted the May 18 offer “as [he] had promised” STUDENT’s parents he would do at the May 12 IEP meeting.
Finally, FATHER’s statement that the May 18 offer contained an “obvious error” in its omission of a one-to-one classroom aide indicates that there was enough agreement on the elements of the proposed program that this omission was “obviously” a mistake. Mr. Anich’s prompt faxing of a corrected offer further indicates that the parties were in accord about major elements and were continuing to work together to reach a final agreement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District repeatedly afforded STUDENT’s parents the opportunity to participate in the IEP process, and that its conveyance of the ESY offer by letter did not violate its obligations under the IDEA.
When the parties to an IEP are unable to reach a consensus, the school district may formulate a plan so long as it affords the parents a due process hearing to review the plan. Vashon Island, supra, 337 F.3d at 1132. Here, the District did not immediately seek a due process hearing because it was continuing to seek consensus on the ESY program. Mr. Anich attempted to schedule an IEP meeting to review the May 18 offer on June 11, a date initially approved by FATHER, but FATHER ultimately declined to attend on that date. Mr. Anich suggested June 15 as an alternative date, but there is no persuasive evidence that FATHER responded to this offer. In the meantime, even though the parents had not agreed to the ESY offer, they took STUDENT to the ESY class for the first two days of the program, and the District made immediate efforts to accommodate their concerns about the ESY classroom and teacher. Ultimately, STUDENT’s parents withdrew him from the ESY program, and filed a request for a due process hearing on July 7.
In light of these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met its procedural obligations under the IDEA as described in Vashon Island and Doe by Gonzales. It repeatedly provided STUDENT’s parents with the opportunity to participate in the development of his ESY program, and continued to seek consensus on the program until the parents exercised their right to seek a due process hearing to challenge the program. As due process procedures are equally available to both parties under the IDEA, the fact that the District did not initiate the due process hearing itself did not interfere with the parents’ right of review. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s extension of the ESY offer by letter did not constitute a denial of a FAPE.
(2) Failure to include classroom and OT goals
IDEA procedures require a school district to make a formal, written offer to initiate any change in a student’s placement. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). STUDENT alleges that the District’s failure to include classroom and OT goals in its May 18 ESY offer constitutes a procedural violation that denied him a FAPE.
The parties agree that Ms. Alperton’s proposed OT goals for STUDENT were presented at the annual IEP meeting on March 25, 2004. (Testimony of Mr. Anich and FATHER.) FATHER believed that STUDENT’s lack of substantial progress indicated that the goals should be broken down into subparts, but Ms. Alperton disagreed with that approach. The IEP notes acknowledge that STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the OT goals as written, but indicated that “the offer of service remains.” (D. Exh. 29.) Ms. Alperton offered revised versions of these goals to STUDENT’s parents at the May 12 IEP meeting. (D. Exh. 35.)
Ms. McPhail began to present classroom goals for STUDENT at the May 12 IEP meeting, but her presentation was cut short at the request of FATHER, who wanted SI representatives present to participate in the goals’ development. (Testimony of FATHER.) Ms. McPhail testified that, at FATHER’s request, she met with him and the SI directors on May 24, agreed to draw up proposed academic goals based on their discussions, prepared them on May 28, placed them in STUDENT’s file for review at the next IEP meeting, and informed FATHER that he would need to sign off on the goals if they were going to be implemented in the ESY program. (Footnote 39) FATHER acknowledged that Ms. McPhail revised STUDENT’s classroom goals, but did not recall whether he saw them prior to the beginning of the ESY program.
Mr. Anich testified that his May 18 offer did not include OT or classroom goals because the OT goals had been offered at the March IEP meeting, and he had been informed by Ms. McPhail after the May 12 meeting that she would be meeting separately with FATHER and SI to develop new classroom goals.
Based on the testimony summarized above, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Anich’s failure to attach OT and classroom goals to the District’s May 18 ESY program offer constituted at most a minor procedural error. STUDENT’s parents confirmed that OT goals were offered by the District and discussed at the March IEP meeting. FATHER acknowledged that new classroom goals were developed by Ms. McPhail after he met with her on May 24, and the ESY teacher had STUDENT’s IEP and classroom goals in the ESY classroom. (Testimony of MOTHER; see Dist. Exh. 49.) Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents were fully aware of the OT and classroom goals being proposed, and were not prejudiced by the fact that they were not attached to the District’s May 18 offer. As the failure to attach the goals to the May 18 offer neither infringed on the parents’ participatory rights in developing the ESY program nor resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that this minor procedural error did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
B. Substantive issues
The District’s ESY offer included both a school and home program for four weeks, followed by an extended four-week home program. The school and home programs continued the basic structure of STUDENT’s 2003-2004 regular school year, with revised classroom goals that expanded upon his previous goals, and with a one-to-one SI aide in both settings to continue his functional academic instruction and behavior intervention. (See D. Ex. 41.) Dr. Siegel testified persuasively that at the level of service offered by the District, it was unlikely that STUDENT would experience any regression of his skills before the commencement of the next school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer met STUDENT’s needs for an ESY program.
STUDENT alleges that both the ESY teacher and the classroom were inadequate to his needs. Specifically, he alleges that the teacher, Ms. Smithwick, did not appear to understand his IEP goals in much detail, did not interact well with STUDENTs, and preferred a quiet classroom to a room where student’s behavior issues were addressed. Further, he alleges that the materials were inadequate and the cubicle set up for him was inappropriate and unsafe. Finally, STUDENT alleges that the ESY offer of a home program did not meet his needs because it provided only two hours per weekday of home instruction, with one and one-half hours of supervision, rather than the three hours per weekday of instruction and two hours of supervision SI had recommended at the March 25, 2004 IEP meeting.
In response, the District asserts that STUDENT’s parents’ concerns about Ms. Smithwick were based only on brief and conclusory observations, and that the District promptly addressed their concerns about both the teacher and the cubicle. Further, the District asserts that its offered home program was more than adequate for STUDENT’s needs.
The evidence favors the District on this issue. Although the District had no prior confirmation that STUDENT was going to attend the proposed ESY program, the ESY teacher was aware of STUDENT’s IEP, and the District took immediate steps to implement his IEP after being informed that he would attend the program. With respect to the ESY teacher, MOTHER testified that Ms. Smithwick appeared to have a copy of STUDENT’s goals, and FATHER said Ms. Smithwick appeared to know the goals included work with letters and numbers. Ms. Smithwick’s inability to recite STUDENT’s goals from memory on the day FATHER visited does not indicate that she was unprepared to address those goals.
Further, the parents’ disapproval of Ms. Smithwick’s consoling of other students is no indication of inadequacy on her part, since the parents could not have been aware of other students’ IEP requirements or the preferences of other parents in the treatment of their children. Finally, any deficits in Ms. Smithwick’s understanding of how to deal with behavior issues could have been addressed by the behavioral consultants Ms. Burlingame immediately sent to her class, but STUDENT’s parents never gave this arrangement a chance, because they took STUDENT out of class on the second day.
There is no dispute that, as soon as Ms. Burlingame heard about the parents’ concerns through Ms. Wells, she took immediate steps to remedy them. She spoke with Ms. Smithwick, arranged for her behavior consultants to provide support to the class, brought additional materials for students, and reconfigured the cubicle herself, providing a new barrier, covering distractions, and taking care to tape down the covering paper so STUDENT would not tear at loose edges.
Finally, the District’s offer of a home program with fewer hours than recommended by SI does not constitute a failure to meet STUDENT’s needs. The purpose of an ESY is to make sure a student’s skills do not regress over the summer, and the District already was offering an ESY classroom program for six hours every weekday. Although Ms. Wells testified that SI recommended that it recommended a home program of three hours per weekday to make sure STUDENT didn’t regress, she did not indicate the basis for her recommendation or state why three hours per day was necessary. By contrast, Dr. Siegel testified persuasively that the District’s offer of an ESY home program of two hours per weekday (with one and one-half hours of weekly supervision) was generous, particularly as the District also was offering an extended ESY home program of three hours every weekday through the end of August, and that STUDENT was unlikely to regress with such a program.
In light of all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided a substantively appropriate ESY program to STUDENT. In light of the earlier finding that the provision of the ESY program complied with the District’s procedural obligations under the IDEA, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2004 ESY program.
Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The District’s program offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year, as conveyed in Mr. Anich’s May 18, 2004 letter to STUDENT’s parents, consisted of the following:
(1) An SDC for academic and social development at STUDENT’s current campus, Twin Creeks Elementary School, for six hours per day, five days per week, with small group and individual instruction, a one-to-one aide, and a cubicle to provide a “calm spot” for STUDENT;
(2) S/L services twice a week for thirty minutes per session, focusing on oral communication;
(3) OT services twice a week for thirty minutes per session, focusing on fine motor development;
(4) Augmentative communication services three times a month for thirty minutes per session, focusing on expressive language development; and (5) A home program providing behavioral, academic, and social support and development for five days per week, three hours per day, with an additional two hours per week for supervision. (Footnote 40)
A. Procedural issues
The District’s program offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year was developed under the same circumstances as its 2004 ESY offer, and was conveyed together with the ESY offer in the May 18 letter faxed by Mr. Anich to FATHER. STUDENT raises the same procedural objections to this offer that he raised to the ESY offer. For the reasons set forth in the discussion of the ESY offer, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s conveyance of the 2004-2005 program offer by letter was in compliance with its duty to formulate a plan to the best of its ability when consensus cannot be reached at an IEP meeting. See Doe by Gonzales, supra, 793 F.2d at 1490. As with the ESY offer, the District continued to seek consensus on its 2004-2005 program offer by attempting to schedule IEP meetings in June, but ultimately, the parents exercised their right to challenge the offer by filing a request for a due process hearing in July.
The District continued to seek consensus on STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program offer after his parents filed their request for hearing. On August 16, the District sent out a notice for an IEP meeting to be held on August 24 “to discuss planning and programming for the 2004-2005 school year.” (D. Exh. 64.) STUDENT’s attorney responded that his parents were unavailable on that date, and would be willing to attend an IEP meeting on a mutually agreeable date only if the District had new information it did not possess when it made its May 2004 IEP offer. (D. Exh. 65.) The District responded that the teacher of the SDC offered in its May 18 letter had been reassigned, and it was willing to discuss placement alternatives with the parents. Ultimately, STUDENT’s attorney indicated that his parents were “not willing to resolve the hearing issues at another IEP meeting.” (D. Exhs. 66, 67.)
The evidence makes clear that the District solicited, received, and acted upon the parents’ input regarding STUDENT’s 2004-2005 school program at the March and May IEP meetings and in other contacts, and continued to do so after Mr. Anich conveyed the written offer on May 18. At FATHER’s request, Ms. McPhail met with him and the SI directors to discuss STUDENT’s progress, and agreed to revise his classroom goals in accordance with those discussions. Also at FATHER’s request, Mr. Anich corrected the May 18 offer to reflect the provision of a one-to-one classroom aide. The fact that STUDENT has raised only one relatively minor substantive complaint about the 2004-2005 program offer is a further indication of how much input his parents had in the development of that offer. (See subsection B infra.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT his due process rights in the development of his program offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year.
B. Substantive issues
The District’s offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year essentially continued STUDENT’s 2003-2004 program and services at the same level, with the express provision of a cubicle in the classroom and with Ms. McPhail’s updated classroom goals. The Hearing Officer earlier found that the 2003-2004 program met STUDENT’s needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. As STUDENT’s needs have not changed substantially from the 2003-2004 school year, this continuation of his previous program with some updated goals is appropriate to his needs. Further, as continuing the previous structure will offer stability to STUDENT, and as his level of impairment indicates he will continue to learn slowly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2004-2005 program offer is designed to meet his needs and is reasonably calculated to offer him some educational benefit.
On August 26, the first day of the hearing, STUDENT’s attorney clarified that STUDENT’s substantive complaint about the 2004-2005 program offer was limited to the District’s failure to offer behavioral supervision and consultation in the school setting, which had been a part of the 2003-2004 program at a level of four hours per week. On September 2, Mr. Anich testified that this omission was inadvertent, and the District then stipulated that the 2004-2005 offer should have included four hours per week of supervision and consultation in the school setting.
The District is required to have an offer in place before the start of the school year, and the 2004-2005 school year began on August 31, 2004. As the District’s stipulation indicates that its 2004-2005 offer was not complete, the offer’s lack of the supervision/consultation provision constitutes at least a technical violation of its obligations under the IDEA. As previously indicated, however, STUDENT has many needs, the vast majority of which were addressed in the District’s program offer. Moreover, there was no evidence that STUDENT’s parents refused to accept the 2004-2005 program offer because of this omission, and the District’s ready admission of its error indicates that the omission was inadvertent and was not a point of contention between the parties. As the omission was corrected before three days of the new school year had passed, the Hearing Officer finds that this technical violation does not constitute a denial of FAPE.
To correct its technical violation, the District shall convene an IEP meeting no later than 15 days after the date of this decision, as set forth in the Order below.
In summary, and in light of the prior finding that the District did not violate its procedural obligations in the provision of the 2004-2005 program offer, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year.
Issue No. 4: If a FAPE was denied, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE in order to ensure that STUDENT is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). As the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE, he is not entitled to compensatory education.
Issue No. 5: If a FAPE was denied, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing him with a home program, including OT services, during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY?
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, STUDENT is entitled to appropriate relief, including reimbursement for educational service obtained at private expense, in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369-370 (1985). As the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE, his parents are not entitled to reimbursement for their itemized costs incurred in providing him with educational services during the 2004 ESY, nor for other costs incurred after the ESY through the date of this Decision.
ORDER
1. STUDENT’s requests for relief are denied.
2. The District shall convene an IEP meeting no later than 15 days after the date of this Decision in order to correct its offer for the 2004-2005 school year by including the four hours of consultation and supervision that it has stipulated were erroneously omitted from its May 18 offer. 3. The District shall remain ready and able to implement all portions of its program offer for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year, as set forth in the corrected May 18, 2004 offer set forth in District Exhibit 41, and as further corrected in accordance with this Order.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all of the issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).
Date: October 19, 2004 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
MOTHER was present only on the first two days of the hearing.
2 Erin Matteucci is the daughter of STUDENT’s attorney, Eileen Matteucci.
3 STUDENT initially opposed the District’s request to withdraw the exhibit, but withdrew his objection upon the Hearing Officer’s determination that he would be allowed to argue that the District’s extension of a second offer supported a finding that the District’s first offer did not constitute a FAPE. Ultimately, STUDENT did not raise this issue in his arguments.
4 All other District exhibits were admitted into evidence. All of STUDENT’s exhibits were admitted into evidence except number 145 and the right half of number 142 (a Staples receipt), both of which were withdrawn by STUDENT.
5 Both this motion and the District’s motion to dismiss certain of STUDENT’s issues, discussed infra, were first raised in pleadings filed with the Hearing Office shortly before the first day of hearing. 6 In a settlement agreement dated November 13, 2003, the parties waived all claims relating to STUDENT’s educational program through January 16, 2004, the date of the next anticipated individualized education program (IEP) meeting. (See Dist. Exh. 20 [Settlement Agreement]). Accordingly, STUDENT’s allegations and claims for relief relating to the 2003-2004 regular school year are limited to that portion of the school year occurring after January 16, 2004.
7 At the hearing, STUDENT stated that his remedies should include one year’s worth of academic instruction from a credentialed special education teacher (with the instruction provided over the course of two years, as a supplement to the regular school day), and one year’s worth of OT services through a nonpublic agency. In his closing brief, STUDENT retracted his earlier request for compensatory academic instruction, and clarified his request for OT services as a request for thirty-six hours of individual instruction to be concluded by September 1, 2005.
8 The psychologist had attempted to administer the Leiter-Revised, a test designed to assess nonverbal intelligence, memory, and attention through processes such as having STUDENT look at a figure and then attempt to find a similar figure hidden in a picture. She was unable to test STUDENT because he repeatedly attempted to tear up the test cards and otherwise resisted the testing process.
9 STUDENT’s adaptive skills were measured through the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, a questionnaire that seeks information in the areas of communication, daily living skills, socialization, and motor skills, and measures the reported skills against age-based norms. The questionnaire was filled out by STUDENT’s grandmother, who was his primary instructor in his home program.
10 The “current IEP goals” referred to in the SI progress report were those that had been adopted at the March 26, 2003 IEP, and continued since that time. (See D. Exhs. 13, 29).
11 To keep STUDENT from becoming overly dependent upon one person, the one-to-one aide position was filled by different SI staff from time to time.
12 In his testimony, FATHER noted that STUDENT missed four to six half-hour OT sessions during the transition from Ms. Alperton to Ms. Locke. However, neither STUDENT’s issue statement nor his argument identified these missed sessions as an issue for which a remedy was sought.
13 Also in June of 2004, SI sued the District for nonpayment of amounts due on its contract for services to several of the District’s special education students. The District filed a cross-complaint against SI, alleging fraudulent billing practices and breach of contract. In addition, the District’s special education local plan area (SELPA) filed a complaint against SI with the Department of Education, asserting that SI was regularly adversarial in the IEP process. SI and the District agree that their ongoing litigation has no specific relationship to the due process dispute between STUDENT and the District regarding STUDENT’s educational program. (Testimony of Ms. Wells and Ms. Heilbronner; see D. Exhs. 28, 53.)
14 Although the evidence was unclear on this point, it appears that since his parents withdrew STUDENT from the ESY class on June 22, he has been receiving a home program from SI at his parents’ expense. STUDENT continued to receive OT services from Ms. Locke through July 21, the end of the ESY, but it is unclear who paid for these services after June 22. The 2004-2005 school year began on August 31, 2004.
15 Federal and State law also require that LEAs educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular educational environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. As STUDENT has raised no LRE-related allegation in this hearing, this Decision does not include an analysis of the District’s 2003-2004 program and ESY or its 2004-2005 program offer in light of LRE requirements.
16 Ms. Alperton had been the District’s provider of OT services to STUDENT since September of 2002. In light of the liability waiver set forth in the parties’ November 2003 settlement agreement, however, only those District services post-dating January 16, 2004, are at issue in this hearing.
17 The January 2004 IEP provided for sixty minutes per month of “consultation” by the OT provider, which appears to refer to consultation between the provider and STUDENT’s parents and/or his teacher. The IEP does not require consultation between the OT provider and SI. (D. Exh. 24.) Moreover, STUDENT did not identify the District’s compliance with the consultation provision as an issue at the hearing.
18 The fact that private assessments obtained by STUDENT’s parents in 2001 and 2002, and an SI evaluation in 2003, do not differ significantly from the District assessments of STUDENT described above is a further indication that the District assessments were appropriate and accurate. (Compare D. Exhs. 3 and 4 with D. Exh. 9 and S. Exhs. 2-19.)
19 To prepare for her testimony, Dr. Siegel reviewed STUDENT’s 2003 assessments, his IEPs, and the rest of the documentary evidence introduced by the District, as well as a 2001 assessment report by Behavior Analysts, Inc., introduced into evidence by STUDENT. (S. Exhs. 2-19.) She has not met STUDENT and did not personally observe or assess him.
20 See, e.g., D. Exh. 7 (August 2003 assessment noting STUDENT “has difficulty with cognitive skills apropos for age”).
21 Dr. Siegel stated that the discomfort clinicians feel in making a diagnosis of mental retardation, coupled with the increased recognition of symptoms of autism spectrum disorder in mentally retarded children, have contributed to statistics showing a rising level of reported autism cases corresponding with a declining level of reported cases of mental retardation.
22 See D. Exh. 56 (list of thirty-three cases in which Dr. Siegel has provided expert testimony since 1998, indicating she testified on behalf of parents seventeen times and on behalf of school districts or other public agencies sixteen times).
23 SI director Ms. Wells testified that she believed STUDENT’s cognitive skills were improving, but acknowledged that his assessments indicated that his functioning level was low.
24 According to the November 2003 settlement agreement, the SI home program was to be phased out and replaced by a school program, “length to be discussed,” pursuant to a transition plan to be developed by the District in collaboration with SI.
25 Although STUDENT’s written IEP goals make no reference to toilet training, witnesses for both parties confirmed that toilet training was included in his home and school programs. STUDENT’s IEP also included S/L goals and objectives, but as they were not placed at issue by STUDENT they are not discussed here.
26 Ms. Locke testified that she provided OT services to STUDENT for the last few weeks of the regular school year and through the duration of the ESY program. Since STUDENT did not wear a coat or use a backpack during her work with him, she did not address Goals 5 and 6.
27 See D. Exh. 29 (March 25, 2004 IEP – Alperton progress notes); D. Exh. 35 (May 12, 2004 IEP – McPhail progress notes).
28 Dr. Siegel testified persuasively that skill development in autistic children is particularly difficult since they lack an “affiliative drive” and do not respond to praise or similar incentives.
29 STUDENT’s line drawing goal was to be measured by “writing samples, teacher evaluation, and/or observation.”
30 By contrast, Dr. Siegel noted that continual data collection for behavior intervention purposes was appropriate, because the purpose of behavior intervention is to closely track the antecedents to maladaptive behaviors in order to extinguish them and replace them with better coping methods.
31 Compare D. Exh. 35 (McPhail notes from March 2003 - May 2004) and D. Exhs. 25, 34 (SI reports from January and April 2004). Although SI’s January 2004 report notes that STUDENT responded to one-step directions with eighty percent accuracy at home but less consistently at school, Ms. McPhail’s March 2004 report indicated STUDENT was responding to all one-step directions in the current goals “almost all the time.”
32 Ms. Wells testified that she did not know why this behavioral disparity was occurring, since the same SI aides worked with STUDENT at home and at school, pursuing the same IEP goals with the same instructional methods.
33 SI’s contract with the District provides that the District will give SI a copy of the IEP of each student for whom services are contracted, and SI “shall provide pupils a program of educational instruction and services . . . consistent with each pupil’s IEP.” (D. Exh. 53.)
34 See D. Exh. 55 (list of Dr. Siegel’s lecture topics from 1998-2004). STUDENT provided no contrary evidence as to prevailing practices in SDC instruction.
35 For example, Ms. Alperton’s observations to Ms. Matteucci that “a paralyzed person can write his name with hand-over-hand assistance,” and that she hoped no one was giving STUDENT’s family false hopes, appear to have been intended not as an insult to STUDENT, but as a pointed critique of SI’s report that STUDENT could write his name “with assistance,” when the assistance required was not a mere prompt but total control of his hand. Similarly, Ms. Alperton’s reported observation to another staff member that STUDENT was mentally retarded, considered offensive by FATHER, appears to have been no more than an honest, if unwelcome, expression of opinion.
36 MOTHER testified that she was troubled when she saw Ms. Alperton direct STUDENT to step on the chair, but instead of asking Ms. Alperton to stop, MOTHER left the room because she “couldn’t bear to watch.”
37 Although the District’s 2004 ESY offer was made together with its offer for the 2004-2005 school year, an ESY generally is considered a part of the preceding school year. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(c).
38 FATHER testified that he did not recall whether Mr. Anich stated at the May 12 IEP meeting that he would put the offer in writing and send it to the parents, but did recall receiving the May 12 IEP notes indicating Mr. Anich’s intention to do so.
39 See D. Exh. 41, pp. 176-178. The revised classroom goals expanded on STUDENT’s previous goals by increasing the range of objects and numbers to be matched and one-step directions to be mastered, and added goals of matching items with pictures and learning to follow two-step directions.
40 The provision for a one-to-one classroom aide for both the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was omitted from the initial offer Mr. Anich faxed to FATHER on May 18. After FATHER pointed out the error, Mr. Anich faxed him a corrected copy providing for a one-to-one classroom aide for both the ESY program and the coming school year. (D. Exh. 41.)
