California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 16, 2000
Student v. Glendale Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 177-00 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Glendale Unified must reimburse private preschool tuition and mileage for fall 1999; its later special day class offer is upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None for this decision. It notes that the prior consolidated decision (SN 316-99/419-99, Hearing Officer Cote, October 8, 1999; amended after clarification on January 12, 2000) was appealed by the District.
Summary
A five-year-old preschooler's family challenged Glendale Unified School District's program for the 1999-2000 school year. The student is eligible under other health impairment because of a chromosomal abnormality that causes global developmental delays. Her mother had placed her at Discoveryland Preschool, a private preschool for typically developing children, and worked there as her one-on-one aide. An earlier SEHO decision found that the District's fall 1998 IEP, which listed several different placements, denied her a FAPE. The District still relied on that IEP until it held a new IEP meeting in November 1999.
Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim held that collateral estoppel stopped the District from relitigating whether the 1998 IEP was valid, even though the District had appealed. Separately, the Hearing Officer found that this "smorgasbord" of placements violated Union School District v. Smith, which requires one clear written offer. That denied a FAPE through November 17, 1999. The November 18, 1999 IEP offered a preschool special day class at Lincoln Elementary or Cloud Preschool, with 40 to 45 minutes of general education each day. The Hearing Officer found both classes appropriate and the least restrictive environment. The parent's arguments about playground safety, a teacher with an emergency credential, and a need for five hours a week of one-on-one teaching were rejected. The District must pay back Discoveryland tuition at $312 per month, plus mileage, for the first half of the school year. The request to repay the private educational therapist was denied. The extended school year claim was not yet ready for decision.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied collateral estoppel to an earlier hearing decision while that decision was on appeal. It also treated a menu of different placements as an invalid offer under Union v. Smith. Reimbursement covered a reasonable period after a proper offer, giving the parent time to observe the proposed classes.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1 (Part I). Did the District offer a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year — period from the beginning of the school year to November 17, 1999, when the District relied on the October/November 1998 IEP offering multiple placements.
Collateral estoppel barred the District from relitigating the prior SEHO finding that the 1998 IEP denied FAPE; independently, the multiple-placement offer violated Union v. Smith and denied FAPE through November 17, 1999.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1 (Part II). Did the District offer a FAPE in the least restrictive environment from November 18, 1999 to the end of the 1999-2000 school year through placement in a preschool SDC at Lincoln Elementary or Cloud Preschool?
Both SDC options met the student's unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and were the LRE under Rachel H.; claims about playground safety, teacher qualifications, and need for five hours weekly of one-on-one instruction were rejected.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is the parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of attendance at Discoveryland Preschool, including tuition and mileage, and the one-on-one special education instruction provided by Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., during the 1999-2000 school year?
Discoveryland was an appropriate placement, so tuition and mileage are reimbursed for the first half of the school year; reimbursement for the second half and for Dr. Abajian's services, which began after the appropriate offer, was denied.
- Not reachedIEP content
Issue 3. Do the student's unique needs entitle her to extended school year services that would extend the amount of instructional services the District must provide to forty-seven weeks during the 1999-2000 school year?
The issue was not ripe because the IEP team had agreed to defer ESY discussion to a later meeting that had not yet occurred; no findings made.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse the parent for Discoveryland Preschool tuition at $312.00 per month for the first half of the 1999-2000 school year, as determined by the District's school calendar.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse mileage for transportation to Discoveryland Preschool during the same period, at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Rachel H.; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K. v. Longview; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.; Allen v. McCurry; People v. Sims; Hollywood Circle v. Dept. of Alcoholic Beverage Control; Daniel R.R.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified
People named in the decision
- Timothy Walker, Director of special education, Glendale Unified School District
- Pat Kelley, School psychologist (assessor), Glendale Unified School District
- Victoria Dalool, Special education teacher (assessor), Glendale Unified School District
- Catherine Euler, Speech and language specialist (assessor), Glendale Unified School District
- Christina Mikuljian, Preschool SDC teacher, Lincoln Elementary School, Glendale Unified School District
- Michele Yamarone, Teacher specialist, Glendale Unified School District
- Enid Kohn, Teacher specialist overseeing preschool special education programs, Glendale Unified School District
- Susan Melly, Former special education Coordinator I, Glendale Unified School District
- Allyson McBayne, SDC teacher, Cloud Preschool, Glendale Unified School District
- Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., Private educational therapist; witness for Student, Private provider
- Beth Weston, Director and teacher, Discoveryland Preschool; witness for Student, Discoveryland Preschool (private preschool)
- Leann Vinci, Occupational therapist (progress report), Not stated
- Kathryn Sommers, Physical therapist (progress report), Not stated
- Mary Cote, SEHO Hearing Officer in prior consolidated case SN 316-99/419-99, Special Education Hearing Office
- Villa Esperanza, Nonpublic school offered in 1998 IEP, Nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Glendale, California, on March 7 and 8, 2000.
The Glendale Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen Gilyard from the firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo; attorney Adam Newman was present to assist her. Also present on the District's behalf was Timothy Walker, M.Ed., Ed.S., the District's director of special education. STUDENT (the Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham from the Law Offices of Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on the Student's behalf was her mother, MOTHER.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Pat Kelley, the District school psychologist who assessed STUDENT in November 1999; Victoria Dalool, the District special education teacher who assessed STUDENT in November 1999; Catherine Euler, the District speech and language specialist who assessed STUDENT in November 1999; Christina Mikuljian, a preschool special day class (SDC) teacher at Lincoln Elementary School; Michele Yamarone, a District teacher specialist; Enid Kohn, a District teacher specialist; Susan Melly, the District's former special education Coordinator I; and Allyson McBayne, an SDC teacher at Cloud Preschool.
The following witnesses were called by the Student to testify: MOTHER; Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., an educational therapist who has been working with STUDENT since December 21, 1999; and Beth Weston, the director of Discoveryland Preschool and STUDENT's teacher.
Oral and documentary was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED BY THE PARTIES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year?
2. Is the parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Discoveryland Preschool, including costs incurred for tuition and mileage, and the one-on-one special education instruction provided by Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., during the 1999-2000 school year?
3. Do STUDENT's unique needs entitle her to extended school year services that would extend the amount of instructional services the District must provide to forty-seven weeks during the 1999-2000 school year? (Footnote 2)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a five-year-old student who resides in the jurisdictional boundaries of the Glendale Unified School District (District) and is eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impairment. STUDENT's health impairments are caused by a chromosomal abnormality, or, more specifically, an inverted duplication of the long arm of chromosome 15, a condition associated with global delays in all developmental areas.
Shortly after STUDENT's third birthday on August 26, 1997, she attended a preschool placement at a public school site which had been offered by the District. The placement was a full inclusion program at Cerritos Elementary School (Cerritos), where STUDENT was assigned an individual aide. According to MOTHER's testimony, STUDENT attended the program for approximately ten weeks before MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from the program because of dissatisfaction with how it was being implemented and her perception that STUDENT was regressing in the program. This was the only time STUDENT attended a public school placement.
In October 1998, unable to agree with the District on an appropriate program for STUDENT, MOTHER unilaterally enrolled STUDENT in Discoveryland Preschool (Discoveryland). Discoveryland is a private preschool that serves typically developing children of preschool age. It is licensed by the State of California as a preschool, but is not certified to provide special education instruction or services. Since that time, STUDENT has continued to attend Discoveryland, where MOTHER serves as her one-on-one aide.
On October 29 and November 18, 1999, STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) team met in an attempt to develop an IEP for STUDENT. According to the IEP developed at those meetings, the District offered the following placements for STUDENT for the period November 1998 to November 1999: a special day class (SDC) at College View School in collaboration with nondisabled peer interaction in another setting; an SDC at Lincoln Elementary School (Lincoln) in collaboration with nondisabled peer interaction in a preschool; and Villa Esperanza, a nonpublic school. The District also offered to provide an assistant to support STUDENT at Discoveryland, along with consultation by a special education teacher, pending the District's ability to observe the classroom and school and determine the appropriateness of the placement and whether the IEP could adequately be implemented through the placement. The parent would continue to be responsible for the cost of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland. The District offered STUDENT the following related services for the same period: two fifty-minute individual speech and language therapy (S/L) sessions per week; one fifteen- to thirty-minute S/L therapy session in a small-group setting per week; two fifty-minute clinic-based, individual physical therapy (PT) sessions per week; one fifty-minute clinic-based, individual occupational therapy (OT) session per week; and mileage reimbursement for travel to the clinic-based related services and between home and school. The District also offered extended school year (ESY) services for forty-seven weeks out of the year with a two-week break in winter, a one-week break in spring, and a two-week break prior to the commencement of school (to be determined in accordance with the calendar of the school of attendance).
On December 9, 1999, MOTHER provided consent to portions of the IEP. She agreed with the District's offer regarding S/L, OT, PT, and the accompanying goals and objectives; she also agreed that all services would be provided for forty-seven weeks out of the year and that she would be reimbursed her mileage for transportation to clinic-based therapy sessions and between home and school. She did not agree to any of the District's placement offers.
In March 1999, both MOTHER and the District filed a request for a due process hearing (Case Nos. SN 316-99 and 419-99, respectively). The matters were consolidated, and the consolidated case was subsequently heard by Hearing Officer Mary Cote. On October 8, 1999, Hearing Officer Cote issued a decision in the consolidated case. (Footnote 3) She found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1998-99 school year for a number of reasons. First, she found that of the four placements offered by the District (which included the SDCs at College View, Lincoln, and Cerritos (Footnote 4) and Villa Esperanza), only the Lincoln SDC was appropriate for STUDENT. She also found that the District's offer of multiple placements, the majority of which were inappropriate, was confusing and not legally sufficient to satisfy the mandates of Section 1415(b)(3) of title 20 of the United States Code and Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 15, 19, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). Additionally, Hearing Officer Cote concluded that the District failed to offer STUDENT sufficient OT services. She found that the evidence established STUDENT required two hours of OT per week, but that the District had offered only one hour of services per week. (The District has since appealed this decision.)
On October 27, nineteen days after the decision was issued, the District developed an assessment plan for MOTHER's approval. MOTHER signed and returned the plan to the District on October 29, thereby giving the District consent to assess STUDENT in all areas of development and have one person observe STUDENT in the school setting at Discoveryland. (Footnote 5) The District then conducted and completed its assessment in early November 1999.
On November 18, 1999, the IEP team met to review the assessment results and develop an IEP for STUDENT. The District offered STUDENT placement in a preschool SDC at either Lincoln or Cloud Preschool (Cloud) with participation in the general education program for forty to forty-five minutes per day during lunch, recess, passing periods, school day activities, and the following related services: two fifty-minute individual S/L sessions per week; one thirty-minute S/L therapy session in a small-group setting per week; two thirty- to forty-minute classroom observations by the speech therapist per year; two sixty-minute clinic-based, individual PT sessions per week; two sixty-minute clinic-based, individual OT sessions per week; and mileage reimbursement. The team was scheduled to reconvene later to discuss ESY services for the 2000 summer session. MOTHER deferred making a decision about the District's placement offers at the meeting, opting instead to visit the proposed placements first.
On December 6, 1999, MOTHER developed and signed an IEP addendum which communicated her consent to all portions of the District's proposed IEP except for the proposed placement in the Lincoln or Cloud SDC, the amount of proposed participation with the general education program, and some of the proposed goals and objectives related to increasing STUDENT's social interaction skills. In the addendum, MOTHER also requested that the District provide STUDENT with five hours per week of one-on-one special education instruction by a qualified credentialed special education teacher.
On December 21, 1999, Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., began providing STUDENT one-on-one instruction in the home at her mother's expense. During the first two weeks, Dr. Abajian provided instruction in two one-hour sessions per week. Thereafter, Dr. Abajian's services were increased to three one-hour sessions per week. STUDENT also continues to attend Discoveryland for a half-day program three days per week at her mother's expense, as well as receive clinic-based related services funded by the District.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). "Special education" is specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, provided to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. "Related services" means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), the State's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. (Footnote 6)
The Student's contention that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year is based on several arguments. First, the Student argues the District failed to have an appropriate IEP in place for STUDENT at the beginning of the school year and did not offer a program until November 18, 1999. Second, the Student argues that the programs offered by the District on November 18, 1999, are not appropriate for STUDENT. The Student asserts that the placements offered are not designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and are unsafe for her because of her functional limitations. The Student also asserts that STUDENT requires, inter alia, a placement with typically developing peers and a program that includes one hour of daily one-on-one special education instruction.
The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE during the entire 1999-2000 school year. The District argues that its offer for the beginning of the school year was contained in the IEP proposed in October and November 1998, and that both that IEP and the IEP developed in November 1999 contained offers of appropriate programs.
I. Beginning of the 1999-2000 School Year to November 17, 1999
The IDEA provides that, "[a]t the beginning of each school year, each local educational agency ... shall have in effect, for each child with a disability in its jurisdiction, an individualized education program." 20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(2)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(a). The District argues that it had an IEP in effect for STUDENT at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. The District points to the IEP developed in October and November 1998, which was expressly meant to remain in effect until November 1999, when the next annual review was due. See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4)(A)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(d).
While it is true that the District had an IEP in effect at the beginning of the year, the IDEA also requires that the IEP in effect constitute an offer of an appropriate program for the child. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(1)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56040, 56345. The District did not have an IEP in effect at the beginning of the year that offered STUDENT an appropriate program.
After holding a four-day evidentiary hearing in Consolidated Case No. SN 316-99/419-99, Hearing Officer Cote specifically found that the IEP developed by the District in October and November 1998 failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE because only one of the multiple placements offered was appropriate for STUDENT and the District failed to make a legally sufficient offer of placement. The doctrine of collateral estoppel precludes the District from re-litigating the issue in this proceeding. Under the doctrine of collateral estoppel, once a court has decided an issue of fact or law necessary to its judgment, that decision may preclude re-litigation of the issue in a suit on a different cause of action involving a party to the first case. Allen v. McCurry (1980) 449 U.S. 90, 94, 101 S.Ct. 411. The doctrine of collateral estoppel, like the related doctrine of res judicata, serves many purposes, including relieving parties of the cost and vexation of multiple lawsuits, conserving judicial resources, and, by preventing inconsistent decisions, encouraging reliance on adjudication. Id.
Courts have recognized that the policies underlying the related doctrines of collateral estoppel and res judicata can be as important to orderly administrative procedure as to orderly court procedure. Hollywood Circle, Inc. v. Dept. of Alcoholic Beverage Control (1961) 55 Cal.2d 728, 732, 361 P.2d 712. On this basis, the California Supreme Court affirmed a finding of res judicata in Hollywood Circle, supra, where the petitioner sought successive proceedings before the same administrative agency. 55 Cal.2d at 732-733. The court recognized, however, that some administrative determinations differ greatly from court decisions and greater flexibility is required in applying the doctrine of res judicata to administrative determinations. Id. For example, the doctrine is not applicable when the Legislature intended that the agency should exercise continuing jurisdiction with power to modify or alter its orders to conform to changing conditions. Id. at 732. On the other hand, "[c]ollateral estoppel may be applied to decisions made by administrative agencies '[w]hen an administrative agency is acting in a judicial capacity and resolves disputed issues of fact properly before it which the parties have had an adequate opportunity to litigate.'" People v. Sims (1982) 32 Cal.3d 468, 479, 651 P.2d 321 (quoting United States v. Utah Constr. Co. (1966) 384 U.S. 394, 422, 86 S.Ct. 1545).
In light of the preceding authorities, the Hearing Officer finds that the doctrine of collateral estoppel precludes the District from re-litigating the issue of whether the IEP it developed in October and November 1998 offered STUDENT a FAPE. First, the previous administrative action was purely judicial in nature and resolved on the merits disputed issues of fact with respect to whether the 1998 IEP offered STUDENT a FAPE. Second, the issue of the appropriateness of the IEP was clearly within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Third, both parties had a full and fair opportunity to litigate any matter within the scope of this issue. See Warga v. Cooper (1996) 44 Cal.App.4th 371, 377-378, 51 Cal.Rptr.2d 684. Finally, there is no indication that the Legislature intended for the Hearing Office to exercise continuing jurisdiction in order to modify or alter its orders to conform to changing conditions. (Footnote 7) To the contrary, the Legislature expressly stated that a decision rendered by the Hearing Office is a final administrative determination and is binding on all parties. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(g). Review of a decision issued by the Hearing Office is generally available only through an appeal to a court of competent jurisdiction and only within ninety days from receipt of the decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
The District argued at hearing that, because Hearing Officer Cote's decision is currently on appeal, it is not a final judgment and not binding on the parties. The District offered neither authorities to support its position nor any evidence that it applied for a stay of enforcement from the court to which Hearing Officer Cote's decision was appealed. However, even if the District's position on this point is correct, the evidence introduced at the hearing in this matter mandates the same conclusion as that reached by Hearing Officer Cote.
The only evidence introduced in this case about the District's program offer for the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year was the IEP document developed in October and November 1998. The IEP document shows the District offered STUDENT three different and varied preschool placements, as well as the services of an assistant at Discoveryland Preschool (Discoveryland) should the parent choose to keep her there.
Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA's procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, __ U.S. __, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated, "We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district's proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id. The courts have continued to vigorously apply Union. See, e.g., Mill Valley Elementary Sch. Dist. v. Eastin, No. C 98-03812 CW, slip op. at __ (N.D. Cal. Oct. 1, 1999).
Here, the District failed to make a specific and coherent written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA. The District's offers included multiple types of classrooms, a number of different school sites, and varying lengths of programs. The placement options were located on a range of campuses, including a segregated school site (College View, with interaction with typically developing peers in another setting), a certified nonpublic school for special needs children (Villa Esperanza), and an integrated school site with typically developing children (Lincoln Elementary School). Although these placement offers were written, they reflect a placement selection process rather than a distinct, coherent offer of placement selected to meet STUDENT's needs and to implement her IEP goals and objectives. While the District's goal probably was to accommodate the parent, it resulted in the parent having to observe and evaluate each classroom site and then determine which one, if any, constituted an appropriate placement. The parent cannot be assumed to have expertise in evaluating educational programs in the brief period of time allotted to observe in each class. Moreover, a smorgasbord approach is contrary to Union, and did not alleviate the District of its responsibility to make a specific written offer of placement that was designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, provide her with educational benefit, and conform with her IEP.
The District unfortunately did not take the final step in the process of clearly identifying an appropriate placement from a range of possibilities. A school district cannot avoid its responsibility to exercise its professional judgment in selecting and offering a specific educational placement which the district's educational experts determine is appropriate to meet a student's unique and individual needs. The parent clearly cannot be required to try to ferret out from multiple placements which placements might be the appropriate placement for the child. The law simply does not impose such a duty on a parent. Moreover, except for Lincoln, the District failed to present "sufficient relevant" evidence to establish the appropriateness of any of the placement options contained in the 1998 IEP, as envisioned by Union, thereby making it impossible for the Hearing Officer to make an independent determination about the appropriateness of the placements offered. 15 F.3d at 1526.
Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's approach in offering a wide range of diverse placements violated the requirement of Union that a clear, coherent offer of placement must be made. The offer should have been detailed and specific enough to demonstrate to the parent that the District had carefully thought through and selected a placement that, in its professional judgment, would meet the unique and individual needs of the child. The District's four varying offers did not alert the parent to the necessity of seriously considering the appropriateness of the offers. Quite the reverse is true. Such an approach suggested that the District did not know its own mind and that it was quite uncertain as to what was appropriate for STUDENT.To result in a denial of FAPE, a procedural violation must seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process or result in the loss of educational opportunity. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. Here, the District's failure to make a legally sufficient offer of placement (by presenting the parent a confusing array of possibly appropriate and possibly inappropriate placements) denied the parent an opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP process and denied STUDENT an opportunity to receive the FAPE she required to address her unique needs and provide her with educational benefit. Consequently, this failure resulted in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to at least November 17, 1999.
II. November 18, 1999 to the End of the School Year
On November 18, 1999, the District developed an IEP that offered STUDENT the option of placement in an SDC located on one of two public school sites, Lincoln Elementary School (Lincoln) or Cloud Preschool (Cloud). The District's proposed IEP also included a number of related services. There is no dispute that the proposed related services, and the accompanying goals and objectives, were substantively appropriate for STUDENT. For this reason, the appropriateness of the related services will not be adjudicated in this decision. Instead, the parent disputed the appropriateness of the proposed instructional program with regard to such factors as the qualification of classroom staff, the amount of interaction with typically developing peers, the safety of the playground environment, and the opportunities for daily one-on-one instruction.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's proposed program would have addressed STUDENT's unique needs, provided her some educational benefit, and comported with her IEP, the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents' preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. The District was also required to offer STUDENT a program that would have educated her in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature or severity of her disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District proposed on November 18, 1999, must have met the following four requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, comport with her IEP, and provide her an education in the least restrictive environment.
A. Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The first step in the analysis is to determine STUDENT's unique needs, as presented by the testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Abajian, Ms. Weston, and the District's assessors, as well as assessment and progress reports written in fall 1999. STUDENT is a five-year-old child with significant global developmental delays due to a chromosomal abnormality. She has scattered strengths and weaknesses in almost all areas, but generally functions in most areas at the level expected for a two-year-old child. Her receptive and expressive language, according to the November speech and language assessment, is at the level of a sixteen-month-old child, with a vocabulary of fifty to sixty words. STUDENT has sensory integration deficits or, as MOTHER described them, difficulty processing stimuli from her environment. The sensory integration deficits cause a number of problems, the most notable of which are connected to feeding. MOTHER testified that, because STUDENT cannot tell how much food is in her mouth, she can overstuff her mouth and easily choke on the food if not watched closely. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs to be fed in a particular position and can only eat food with certain textures. STUDENT also has significant fine and gross motor deficits which cause, inter alia, a somewhat unsteady gait and a need for hand-over-hand guidance or minimal physical cues to motor through most tasks. While STUDENT can remain in a steady posture while seated, she requires some assistance to get into a seated or standing position.
Additionally, STUDENT is easily distracted. Her distractability can exhibit itself in a number of ways, including physically distancing herself from the task at hand, throwing objects, bouncing on her seat, closing her eyes, and looking away from the task or instructor. Because of this, she requires an adult to redirect her to task; an adult generally can refocus STUDENT to the task by employing such techniques as calling her name and redirecting her gaze. STUDENT enjoys being around other children and, while not able to initiate interactions with peers on a consistent basis, has shown an ability to learn appropriate behaviors by imitating peers. Because STUDENT is more distractable than a typical child her age, she needs instruction in shorter segments, redirection by a teacher or teacher assistant to keep her on task, and repetition to learn. She understands the meaning of yes, no, and okay and can follow simple directions with prompts and support. Finally, STUDENT has a number of medical issues, including febrile seizures caused by illness and stress, gastric reflux, and absence seizures. The absence seizures are exhibited by blank staring episodes of varying length, which cause subsequent disorientation and loss of short-term memory. It was not clear from the evidence how often her lack of focus is due to absence seizures rather than attention problems.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs an educational program that consists of a small class with a low student-adult ratio, a significant amount of individual specialized instruction and assistance, lessons presented in short segments, frequent redirection and prompting, repetition of lessons, a focus on pre-academic and basic life/self-help skills (such as feeding, dressing, and toileting), and opportunities to interact socially with typically developing peers.
1. Lincoln preschool special day class
The following evidence presented at hearing established that the SDC at Lincoln is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs. The Lincoln SDC proposed for STUDENT is taught by Christina Mikuljian and consists of five students with exceptional needs ranging in age from three to five years old. (Footnote 8) Ms. Mikuljian has taught the preschool SDC at Lincoln for the past two years and has a bachelor of art's degree in special education and credentials to teach children with learning disabilities and mental retardation. She is assisted in the classroom by an aide who, according to the testimony of teacher specialist Enid Kohn, has passed a lifting test and is trained to work with special needs children. Thus, the Lincoln SDC offers STUDENT a small class taught by a qualified special education teacher, with the assistance of a trained aide, and a low 1:3 adult to student ratio.
Ms. Mikuljian's testimony established that the class also offers opportunities for a significant amount of individual specialized instruction and assistance. The class meets four days per week from 9:00 a.m. to noon. Ms. Mikuljian testified that, throughout the course of the day's scheduled activities, there are opportunities for her to provide one-on-one instruction to students while the others are being supervised by the aide. There is also a period reserved at the end of the day's program for working individually with students, when needed.
Additionally, the class is tailored to work with students who have special needs similar to STUDENT's and can provide the necessary physical assistance and prompts. For example, Ms. Mikuljian reviewed the goals and objectives prepared for STUDENT and testified that they are similar to those of the students already attending her class and that they could be implemented in her classroom. She also testified that the class engages in many speech-intensive activities and she and her aide provide the students with physical assistance with motor tasks such as feeding, where necessary. Although MOTHER testified that she provides STUDENT with a hand-over-hand type of guidance to assist her in performing virtually every task at Discoveryland, the progress reports of the occupational and physical therapists, which MOTHER testified provided accurate accounts of STUDENT's progress in fine and gross motor skills, do not indicate that this level of constant assistance is required for STUDENT to participate in classroom activities. For instance, in a progress report dated October 29, 1999, occupational therapist Leann Vinci reported that STUDENT can perform a number of fine motor tasks independently, such as picking up pellets from a tabletop surface and inserting them into a bottle and grasping objects. Ms. Vinci also reported that STUDENT can hold a sipper cup and drink from it, seldom falls when walking alone, and can retrieve objects from the floor while in a standing position. Physical therapist Kathryn Sommers reported in her progress report dated November 1, 1999, that, although STUDENT requires motivation to initiate any transition independently (such as from a standing to sitting position), she is physically able to perform almost all transitions independently and that her mother noted she is performing more and more transitions independently at home. Ms. Sommers also reported that STUDENT requires only the lightest tactile cues to initiate transitions. Further, Ms. Mikuljian testified that attention problems are dealt with in the class by her and the aide through frequent redirecting by use of physical or oral prompts and spending more time with the child, when necessary to redirect him or her.
Finally, the Lincoln SDC offers significant opportunities to interact with typically developing peers, both in the classroom and on the playground. Lincoln is an integrated school site with grades kindergarten to sixth grade, as well as the preschool SDC. Ms. Mikuljian's preschool SDC spends at least thirty minutes per day with a small class of regular education kindergarten students (from six to fourteen students, depending on the absentee rate that day) in group activities and table top tasks. During this period, Ms. Mikuljian and her aide are joined by the child care teacher. The three adults circulate among the groups of students to supervise and to help facilitate interactions between the regular and special education students. Adapted physical education (APE) is also provided with the class of regular education kindergarten students, with instruction and supervision by the APE teacher, Ms. Mikuljian, her aide, and the child care teacher. The preschool SDC also spends its thirty-minute recess with regular education kindergarten students, who are STUDENT's typically developing peers. During recess, the children are always supervised by at least three teachers, and there are never more than fifteen students in the playground at a time.
In light of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lincoln SDC offers STUDENT an appropriate program. This finding is also supported by the testimony of school psychologist Pat Kelley, who assessed STUDENT in November 1999; special education teacher Victoria Dalool, who assessed STUDENT and observed her at Discoveryland in November 1999; and Ms. Kohn, who oversees the District's preschool special education programs and attended a number of STUDENT's IEP meetings. All of these witnesses established that they were familiar with STUDENT and her needs, as well as the Lincoln SDC , and testified that STUDENT's needs could be addressed through placement in the SDC.
The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the parent's argument to the contrary. The parent argued that the Lincoln SDC is not appropriate because the playground is unsafe in light of STUDENT's small size and functional limitations. While STUDENT is the size of a two- to three-year-old child and unsteady on her feet, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that these factors make the playground at Lincoln unsafe for her, given the conditions under which the preschool SDC class utilizes the playground. According to Ms. Mikuljian's testimony, there is always at least a 1:5 teacher-to-student ratio during recess, which provides for constant management and supervision of the five special education students. Additionally, Ms. Mikuljian testified that, before being allowed to play with any of the equipment on the playground, the preschool SDC students are first given a lesson on how to use the equipment and thereafter are given constant reminders about the rules concerning their use. One of the rules is that certain pieces of equipment are off-limits to the children because of safety concerns. Other pieces, such as the monkey bars and slide, are off-limits because school rules dictate that preschool children cannot use them. Further, Ms. Mikuljian testified that none of her SDC students, even those with severe orthopedic impairments, has been injured in the playground by either the equipment or the other students. In short, there appears no reason why the playground at the Lincoln campus would pose a safety risk to STUDENT.
2. Cloud preschool special day class
The evidence presented at hearing also established that the proposed SDC at Cloud is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs. The Cloud SDC consists of six special needs children ranging in age from three to five years old (Footnote 9) and is taught by Allyson McBayne, with the assistance of two trained classroom aides. Ms. McBayne is qualified to teach the SDC because she has a bachelor of art's degree in psychology and an (emergency) special education credential. Additionally, Ms. McBayne has taught the Cloud SDC for the past two school years and has received from the District substantial training on special education issues, including creative curriculum development in the special education setting, autism, attention focusing, maladaptive behaviors, and vision and feeding assessments. Ms. Kohn's testimony established that both of the classroom aides assigned to assist Ms. McBayne are trained to work with children with exceptional needs. Thus, the evidence showed that the Cloud SDC offers STUDENT a small class taught by a qualified special education teacher, with the assistance of two trained aides, and a low 1:2.3 adult to student ratio.
Ms. McBayne's testimony established that the class also offers opportunities for a significant amount of individual specialized instruction and assistance. The class meets four days per week from 8:30 to 11:30 a.m. During the three hours in which the class meets, Ms. McBayne has consistently been able to find opportunities to provide one-on-one instruction to students and has even found time to spend one hour with students individually one to two times per week.
Additionally, the class is tailored to work with students who have special needs similar to STUDENT's and can provide the necessary physical assistance and prompts. For example, Ms. McBayne reviewed STUDENT's goals and objectives and testified she currently has students with similar goals and objectives that are being implemented in her class. She also testified that her class is designed to address the type of goals seen in STUDENT's IEP and the level of most of her students' cognitive functioning approximates that of STUDENT. Additionally, according to Ms. McBayne, she currently has one to two students in her class who require frequent motoric support (e.g., hand-over-hand guidance) like STUDENT. She testified she was trained by occupational and physical therapists on how to provide appropriate physical support to the students and that she, in turn, trained her aides.
Finally, the Cloud SDC offers opportunities to interact with typically developing peers everyday on the playground during outside play time. Cloud is an integrated preschool school site with two SDCs and three regular education classes, each of which have a few special education students fully included. For thirty minutes every day, Ms. McBayne's SDC class spends thirty minutes on the playground with all the other classes. During this time, approximately forty students are on the playground, the majority of whom are typically developing students. The students are supervised by twelve to fourteen adults (six of whom are teachers), making the adult-to-student ratio roughly 1:3. Ms. Kohn testified that should a student's IEP call for additional time in the regular education program, a schedule would be worked out for that student to be included in a general education class during circle activities or music time. Thus, the additional ten to fifteen minutes of placement in the general education program called for by STUDENT's IEP would be implemented during activities such as circle or music time.
In light of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Cloud SDC offers an appropriate program for STUDENT. The Student argued that the SDC is not appropriate because (1) Ms. McBayne is not qualified to provide special education instruction to STUDENT and (2) the number of children and the environment of the playground during outside play time make the playground unsafe for STUDENT. After a review of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer does not find either argument persuasive.
First, the Student argues that Ms. McBayne's testimony that she has not yet taken any courses to keep her emergency credential shows she is not a qualified teacher. In support of her argument, the Student cites section 44300 of the Education Code and section 80026.6 of title 5 of the California Code of Regulations. Neither section proves her point. Both sections deal with the requirements for the issuance and renewal of emergency teaching permits by the State's Commission on Teacher Credentialing (Commission). There is no dispute that Ms. McBayne has been issued an emergency teaching permit by the Commission under the requirements applicable for such permits, establishing that the State has found her qualified under State standards to teach in the District's school. Whether Ms. McBayne's permit will renewed in the future is a question not to be answered in this forum. What is appropriate for the Hearing Officer's consideration is the experience and training Ms. McBayne has to offer STUDENT in the Cloud SDC. As discussed above, the evidence showed that Ms. McBayne's education, experience, and training have adequately qualified her to provide the specialized educational instruction STUDENT requires. Additionally, none of the decisions issued by the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) that were cited by the Student dictates a contrary result. OCR is charged with the responsibility to ensure that public agencies comply with the requirements of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act, not the IDEA. Thus, the OCR decisions cited by the Student are not persuasive in this context.
Second, more than half the playground is covered by grass, and the children are supervised by a cadre of adults during outside play time. These factors make the outside play time safe for STUDENT, despite her functional limitations. No persuasive evidence was presented to establish otherwise.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that both the Lincoln SDC taught by Ms. Mikuljian and the Cloud SDC taught by Ms. McBayne are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs.
B. Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The evidence presented at hearing established that both the Lincoln SDC and the Cloud SDC were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. As discussed earlier, the teachers indicated during testimony that STUDENT's goals and objectives are similar to those of many of the other students in the Lincoln and Cloud SDCs proposed for STUDENT. The teachers' testimonies also showed that STUDENT's goals and objectives can be implemented in the classes. Additionally, both placements offer significant opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers to enhance STUDENT's social development. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the placements proposed by the District are reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. The Hearing Officer does not find compelling the Student's arguments to the contrary.
The Student argued the proposed placements are not appropriate because STUDENT requires five hours per week of daily one-on-one special education instruction and constant redirection and prompting to benefit from an educational program. First, while there is no doubt that STUDENT requires some amount of individual instruction to benefit from her education, there is no persuasive evidence she requires five hours per week of individual instruction in one-hour daily sessions. The school psychologist and the special education teacher, both of whom assessed STUDENT in November 1999, testified STUDENT requires some amount of individual instruction to benefit from her education and that the proposed placements, both of which offer STUDENT a significant amount of individual instruction, are reasonably calculated to provide her with such benefit.
The Student offered the testimony of Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., a private educational therapist, in an attempt to establish otherwise. Dr. Abajian testified it is "highly unlikely" that STUDENT could meet her goals and objectives without the provision of five hours of one-on-one special education instruction per week. Unfortunately, Dr. Abajian's testimony can be accorded little weight on this issue. Dr. Abajian has never formally assessed STUDENT, and it was not shown that she had even reviewed any of STUDENT's past assessment reports. Further, the Hearing Officer did not find Dr. Abajian's testimony particularly persuasive since she showed no hesitancy in offering conclusive opinions based on only cursory observations of the District's proposed placements. According to her testimony, she observed the Lincoln SDC in the classroom for only fifteen minutes and the Cloud SDC for approximately twenty minutes. Yet, she did not hesitate to draw conclusions on issues such as the ability of the SDC teachers to spend time with individual students during the course of the three-hour daily program or the competence of the aides. Moreover, and perhaps most importantly, Dr. Abajian made conclusory statements, like those above, without offering any reasons to substantiate her conclusions. Finally, Dr. Abajian's testimony was at times contradictory and inconsistent. On the one hand, she testified STUDENT could not meet her goals and objectives without five hours per week of special education instruction but, on the other hand, testified STUDENT had been making good progress after working with her on a one-on-one basis for only two to three hours per week.
Second, as discussed earlier, both of the District's proposed placements can provide STUDENT with the redirection and prompting she requires to focus her. Both placements offer a low student-to-adult ratio, so a significant amount of adult intervention is available for each student. Both placements also offer teachers and aides trained to work with students with special motor and attention needs like STUDENT's.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lincoln and Cloud SDC are both reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit.
C. Comport with STUDENT's IEP
For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placements comport with STUDENT's IEP. The placements are SDC programs, are able to implement the goals and objectives contained in her IEP, and are able to offer forty to forty-five minutes per day in the general education program, all in accordance with the program described in the IEP.
D. Provide an Education in the Least Restrictive Environment
The Student contended the District's proposed program did not offer STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment because STUDENT should be fully included (i.e., mainstreamed) in a general education program. The Hearing Officer does not agree and finds that the proposed program offers STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment in accordance with the IDEA, given the nature and severity of her disabilities. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has adopted a four-factor balancing test to determine whether a disabled student should be placed in a regular education classroom with supplemental aids and services. Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 1207, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994). The test looks to the following four factors: (1) the educational benefits of placement full-time in a regular education class; (2) the nonacademic benefits of such placement; (3) the effect the student has or will have on the teacher and children in the regular education class; and (4) the costs of mainstreaming the student. Id.
Here, the parties disagree on the issue of whether STUDENT should be placed in the general education program for academic instruction, as well as during nonacademic periods such as recess. Balancing the four factors described above in light of the evidence received, the Hearing Officer finds the District has offered STUDENT placement in the least restrictive environment.
1. educational benefits of full-time placement in regular education class
In light of her present needs, STUDENT would most likely receive little or no educational benefit if she were placed full-time in a regular education class. Although STUDENT is five and a half years old, the District's assessors and Dr. Abajian likened her current academic functioning to that of a two-year-old child. The testimony consistently showed that STUDENT's pre-academic skills are very depressed. For example, Dr. Abajian testified STUDENT cannot write the letters of the alphabet and, in fact, cannot even imitate scribble yet. STUDENT just recently learned to recognize the color yellow and is still working on recognizing red and blue. Her goals and objectives indicate she needs full support with such basic self-helps skills as dressing and using the toilet. Thus, because of the disparity between STUDENT's functional levels and those of her typically developing peers, she would simply be present but unable to participate in the regular education class if she were placed there for academic instruction. Compare with DeVries v. Fairfax County Sch. Bd., 882 F.2d 876, 879 (4th Cir. 1989). Additionally, the testimony showed STUDENT requires a significant amount of specialized instruction not typically available in a regular education class to benefit from her education, such as individualized instruction presented in short segments with frequent repetition and prompting. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the necessary specialized instruction could be provided in a regular education classroom through supplemental aids and services.
Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds this factor weighs against fully including STUDENT in a regular education class because STUDENT's disabilities and resulting impairments are so severe that she will receive little or no academic benefit from placement in a regular education class.
2. nonacademic benefits of full-time placement in regular education class
The Hearing Officer finds that the second factor weighs in favor of placement in the regular education program. A disabled child may benefit from language and behavior models provided by nondisabled children. Daniel R.R. v. State Bd. of Educ., 874 F.2d 1036, 1049 (5th Cir. 1989). The testimony established that this is true of STUDENT. Her mother, Dr. Abajian, and Beth Weston, STUDENT's teacher at Discoveryland, all testified STUDENT is encouraged by and sometimes attempts to imitate the typically developing peers she sees around her. Additionally, Ms. Dalool noted during her observation at Discoveryland that STUDENT seemed to enjoy being around the typically developing students in her class, watched the students, and seemed stimulated by them. Ms. Dalool testified that students like STUDENT can sometimes learn from watching typically developing peers.
3. effect student has or will have on teacher and children in regular education class
This factor takes into account the possible negative effects of placing a disabled child in a regular education classroom. For instance, the child may be disruptive to other children or may unreasonably occupy the teacher's time to the detriment of other students. Id.Here, it has been found that STUDENT requires a significant amount of individualized instruction, redirection, and prompting to benefit from her education. While some of these functions could be performed by a trained aide, not all of them can. STUDENT requires individualized instruction from a qualified teacher, not an aide, to benefit from her education. Given the size of regular education classes, a regular education teacher cannot be expected to give STUDENT the amount of individualized instruction she requires without unfairly depriving the other children in the class of the teacher's time. Further, even if an aide could be trained to provide the necessary specialized instruction to STUDENT for some lessons, the regular education teacher would still have to provide substantial oversight and direction to the aide to ensure STUDENT is properly instructed. Additionally, the regular education curriculum would have to be dramatically modified to allow STUDENT to participate academically in the regular education program, requiring the teacher to essentially teach two classes in one. This unduly burdensome task could prove impossible for a regular education teacher, while also depriving STUDENT of the sense of belonging to the regular education class that is important to the achievement of nonacademic benefit. See Board of Educ., Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874, 880 (E.D. Cal. 1992). Finally, it is highly likely that, given the amount of prompts and frequency of repetition STUDENT requires to benefit from her education, she would prove to be a disruption in a regular education class.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds this factor presently weighs against full inclusion.
4. costs of mainstreaming
No evidence regarding cost was submitted.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has offered STUDENT an education in the least restrictive placement. Except for the factor concerning nonacademic benefits (which is further discussed below), the factors considered weigh against placing STUDENT in a regular education class on a full-time basis. Additionally, many of the nonacademic benefits of placement in a regular education classroom are provided for in the District's proposed placements, because they call for STUDENT to participate in the regular education program for recess and other nonacademic activities such as circle time or music for forty to forty-five minutes per day, which is appropriate given her level of functioning and needs.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the period November 18, 1999 to the end of the 1999-2000 school year. The proposed program consisting of either the Lincoln or Cloud SDC program, with mainstreaming for nonacademic activities, addresses STUDENT's unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, comports with her IEP, and provides education in the least restrictive environment.
ISSUE NO. 2: Is the parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Discoveryland Preschool, including costs incurred for tuition and mileage, and the one-on-one special education instruction provided by Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., during the 1999-2000 school year?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court's decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an "empty victory." [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if "appropriate relief" in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, "the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete." [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
In light of the conclusion reached in Issue No. 1, that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to November 17, 1999, the Hearing Officer must now determine whether the program provided by STUDENT's parent during the same period was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student's IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents' placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district's must meet, the parents' placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student's needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.
The evidence presented at hearing demonstrated that Discoveryland, in conjunction with the District's provision of related services, was an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. The testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Weston, and Dr. Abajian established that the Discoveryland program, as supplemented by MOTHER's service as STUDENT's one-on-one aide, substantially addresses STUDENT's unique needs and provides her with some educational benefit. Ms. Weston testified that she is the director of Discoveryland and has been STUDENT's teacher since August 1999. Ms. Weston has a bachelor's degree in psychology and is currently working towards a master's degree in child development and an early childhood education certificate. She had previously taught in private preschools and a speech and language therapy center. STUDENT currently attends the three-hour morning class for typically developing two- to three-year-old children, which meets three days per week and consists of six to ten children on a typical day. Ms. Weston testified that she teaches STUDENT's class pre-academic skills (including lessons about letters, numbers, colors, and shapes), engages them in music and movement activities, reads them stories, allows them outside play time, and sets up art and other table-top activities. Ms. Weston also testified that she has a copy of STUDENT's IEP in the classroom and works to implement her goals and objectives in her classroom. According to MOTHER's testimony, Ms. Weston repeats directions and lessons for STUDENT during the course of the class. MOTHER assists STUDENT in all activities, both orally and physically, with hand-over-hand guidance or other physical assistance to motor her through tasks, prompts and cues to redirect her, and facilitates interaction with peers. MOTHER testified that she has been trained by STUDENT's therapists in the proper techniques for performing these functions. Given the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Discoveryland addresses STUDENT's unique needs.
Because STUDENT receives a number of services to address her deficits (including speech therapy, occupational therapy, and physical therapy, as well as the preschool placement at Discoveryland and the individual instruction by Dr. Abajian), it is difficult to attribute her progress to any single component of her program. It is more than likely, however, that a significant portion of her progress is attributable to the Discoveryland placement. MOTHER, Dr. Abajian, and Ms. Weston all provided persuasive testimony about the progress STUDENT has been able to make this school year. Ms. Weston testified that she has seen improvements in STUDENT's compliance, ability to take turns, and focus since August 1999. She also testified that STUDENT has made progress in her pre-academic skills and now knows songs that are sung in class, can move a brush across paper independently, has increased language skills and improved memory, and will follow certain classmates around the classroom and playground. MOTHER's testimony concurred with Ms. Weston's observations. MOTHER also noted that STUDENT generally interacts more with her peers, can sound STUDENT (STUDENT's version of her name) spontaneously while patting her own chest, participates in finger shows, and can wait patiently in line. Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT has made progress due, at least in part, to the Discoveryland placement.
Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Discoverlyland placement constituted an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year in that it addressed her unique needs and provided her educational benefit. Under the circumstances of this case, and in the absence of any argument otherwise, the Hearing Officer does not find that, in granting relief, any equitable considerations require discussion. See Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Alamo, 790 F.2d at 1161. Accordingly, the parent is entitled to reimbursement for the expenses she incurred in providing the Discoveryland placement.
However, because the District offered STUDENT a FAPE on November 18, 1999, the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the Discoveryland placement beyond the first half of the school year. While the offer of FAPE was made before the end of the first half of the school year, the parent could not reasonably have been expected to pull STUDENT out of the Discoveryland program as soon as the District made its offer. MOTHER needed a reasonable amount of time to observe the District's two proposed placements and make an independent determination about their appropriateness for STUDENT. Additionally, in light of the District's failure to have a FAPE in place for STUDENT at the beginning of the school year (see discussion of Issue No. 1), the parent cannot be required to change STUDENT's program so close to the end of the semester simply because the District chose that time to finally make its placement offer. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds it appropriate to award the parent reimbursement for expenses incurred for STUDENT's placement at Discoveryland for the first half of the school year. The beginning and end of the first half of the school year shall be determined by the District's school calendar. The District shall reimburse MOTHER for the Discoveryland placement at the rate of $312.00 per month for tuition, in accordance with Ms. Weston's testimony, as well as for transportation (in the form of mileage reimbursement).
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Abajian's services. Dr. Abajian did not begin providing services to STUDENT until December 21, 1999, by which time the District had already made an appropriate offer of placement for STUDENT. Further, the parent has been awarded reimbursement for the Discoveryland placement and, thus, has already been awarded an appropriate remedy for the District's failure to offer an appropriate program for STUDENT until November 18, 1999
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the parent is entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for the Discoveryland placement, consisting of tuition and transportation, during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year. The beginning and end of the school year is to be determined by the District's school calendar. The parent is not entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for the one-on-one special education instruction provided by Dr. Abajian during the 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE NO. 3: Do STUDENT's unique needs entitle her to extended school year services that would extend the amount of instructional services the District must provide to forty-seven weeks during the 1999-2000 school year?
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2).
The District contends that this issue is not ripe for hearing. The District argues that, when the IEP team adjourned the November 18, 1999 meeting, it agreed to reserve discussion about ESY services until the next IEP meeting and the meeting had not been held yet by the time the hearing took place on March 7 and 8, 2000. The District points out that in the parent's lengthy written dissent, which was subsequently attached to the IEP, she did not indicate disagreement with reserving the ESY issue for a future meeting. The Student offered no argument or evidence on this issue.
The Hearing Officer agrees with the District on this point. Although the evidence seemed to suggest a need for instructional services during forty-seven weeks of the school year, this issue was not ripe at the time this matter went to hearing. The IEP team agreed to reserve the discussion about ESY services until the next IEP meeting and the discussion had not yet taken place by the time the hearing in this matter convened. Further, the fact that the District had not made an offer for ESY services by March 7 (when the hearing began) does not, standing alone, make the issue ripe for hearing. On March 7, months still remained before the ESY for the District to convene an IEP meeting to discuss ESY services for STUDENT. (Footnote 10)
Consequently, because this issue was not ripe at the time this matter went to hearing, the Hearing Officer declines to make any findings with regard to this issue.
ORDER
1. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof, the Glendale Unified School District shall reimburse MOTHER for the following expenses incurred:
a. Tuition for Discoveryland Preschool at the rate of $312.00 per month for the first half of the 1999-2000 school year (the beginning and end of the first half of the school year shall be determined by the District's school calendar); and b. Transportation for STUDENT to attend Discoveryland Preschool during the period described in paragraph (a) in the form of mileage reimbursement at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
2. The Student's remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year? * The Student prevailed on this issue with respect to the beginning of the school year until November 17, 1999. The District prevailed on this issue with respect to the remainder of the school year.
2. Is the parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Discoveryland Preschool, including costs incurred for tuition and mileage, and the one-on-one special education instruction provided by Wendy Abajian, Ed.D., during the 1999-2000 school year? * The Student prevailed on this issue with respect to the expenses incurred for Discoveryland during the first half of the school year. The District prevailed with respect to the expenses incurred for Discoveryland during the second half of the school year and Dr. Abajian's services.
3. Do STUDENT's unique needs entitle her to extended school year services that would extend the amount of instructional services the District must provide to forty-seven weeks during the 1999-2000 school year? * Neither party prevailed on this issue. The Hearing Officer declined to make any findings with regard to this issue because it was not ripe for hearing.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: May 16, 2000 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed differ slightly in wording from those noticed by the parties before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. Additionally, the Student had identified two separate issues regarding STUDENT's need for one-on-one instruction and whether the parent should be reimbursed for one-on-one instruction she procured for STUDENT, neither of which are listed here. The issues regarding one-on-one instruction will not be dealt with as separate issues but will be discussed in Issues Nos. 1 and 2, where appropriate.
2. The District stipulated at the beginning of the hearing that it would continue to provide STUDENT with the related services (i.e., designated instructional services) specified in her individualized education program dated November 18, 1999, for forty-seven weeks. (There was no dispute that the District had been providing these related services during the 1999-2000 school year.) The Student accepted this stipulation. Consequently, this decision will not deal with the issue of whether related services must be provided during forty-seven weeks of the school year.
3. On January 12, 2000, Hearing Officer Cote granted requests for clarification of the decision filed by the parties and subsequently issued an amended decision. The decision was amended in ways not relevant to the instant proceedings and, therefore, will not be mentioned further.
4. The SDC at Cerritos Elementary School was offered in negotiations held between the parties in early 1998.
5. According to the evidence, MOTHER included the proviso that only one person observe STUDENT in the school setting because Beth Weston, the director of Discoveryland and STUDENT's teacher, thought additional observers might disrupt the class.
6. In California, State law specifically provides that the Legislature did not intend to set a higher substantive standard for educating individuals with exceptional needs than that established by Congress under the IDEA. Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.
7. Under very limited circumstances, none of which are applicable here, the Hearing Office does have jurisdiction to reconsider or modify recently issued decisions.
8. According to Ms. Mikuljian's testimony, two of the students are mentally retarded (one of the two also has a speech disorder), two of the students have cerebral palsy (one of which has a speech disorder), and the fifth student has a speech disorder.
9. Ms. McBayne testified that two of the students are orthopedically impaired (one due to cerebral palsy), one has Down's Syndrome, another is autistic, the fifth student has a speech and language delay, and the sixth qualifies for special education under the category of other health impairment.
10. It is expected, however, that the District has since convened an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT's ESY services. Should the parties now have a dispute with regard to the 2000 ESY issue, they are not precluded from filing a request for a due process hearing on the issue since it was not resolved on the merits in this decision.
