California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 26, 2002

Student v. Capistrano Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1772-02 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals

Capistrano Unified must place a student with autism in a high school art class and assess him for music therapy.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 14-year-old student with autism filed for due process against Capistrano Unified School District. He attended Marco Forster Middle School for half the day in general education classes with a one-on-one aide. Home tutoring and discrete trial training from a nonpublic agency filled the rest of the day. He is a highly gifted artist. Seven of ten issues settled before hearing. Three remained: music therapy, a high school art class, and District funding of monthly consultation with psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson.

On music therapy, the Hearing Officer found the IEP did not adequately meet the student's language needs. District witnesses could not say how much progress he had made on goals that were almost two years old. Evidence that he responded better when singing was promising but too limited. The Hearing Officer ordered a music therapy assessment, including up to 90 days of diagnostic music therapy. The IEP team must set the diagnostic questions first. The District must also assess his progress on his academic goals. The decision found that neither party prevailed on this issue.

The student had taken the middle school's eighth grade art class twice and was now in a sixth grade section. The Hearing Officer found he could get nothing more from it. A high school class would support his transition and language goals. The District must place him in Ernie Welke's art class within 45 days. The request to hire Dr. Patterson was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows a SEHO Hearing Officer using a student's strength, here art, to build present levels, transition planning and language goals. Where evidence for a service was promising but thin, he ordered a diagnostic assessment rather than the service. He also held that a district cannot be required to hire a particular professional.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Should the District provide music therapy to assist Petitioner in developing his communication, social and self-regulatory skills?

    The IEP did not adequately meet the student's language needs, but the evidence was too limited to require music therapy. The Hearing Officer ordered a diagnostic music therapy assessment and an assessment of academic progress instead.

  2. Student prevailedCurriculum

    Issue 2. Should Petitioner be enrolled in a high school art class rather than continue in the middle school art classes?

    The student had mastered the middle school art program and could get no further benefit from it. A high school art class supports his transition and language goals, so he must be placed in the high school art teacher's class.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Should the District contract with Dr. Robert Patterson, psychologist, for consultation services with Petitioner for two hours every month?

    The evidence showed no need for more psychologist services to provide FAPE. The IEP team had considered Dr. Patterson's recommendations, and there is no authority to require a district to hire a particular professional.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. The District must arrange a music therapy assessment by a qualified assessor of the District's choice. This includes placing the student in music therapy for diagnostic purposes only, for up to 90 calendar days unless the parties agree otherwise, starting within 20 calendar days of the decision. This is not an educational placement for stay put purposes.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Before the music therapy assessment begins, the IEP team must meet to set the diagnostic questions. These include whether singing generalizes to spoken or written language, whether music therapy can improve functional academic progress, and whether it improves self-esteem and social interaction.
  • Order to assess. The IEP team must decide which assessments are needed to measure whether the student has met his current academic goals. It must arrange for them to be completed so the team can consider the results along with the music therapy assessment.
  • Placement ordered. The District must place the student in a program with high school art teacher Ernie Welke within 45 calendar days of the decision, subject to accommodating his other classes, designated instruction and services, and transportation needs.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1; Cal. Educ. Code § 56595.2; 34 C.F.R. § 300.509(a)(1)

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Ron Lackey, educational consultant (non-attorney) assisting Student, Student
  • G. Robert Roice, educational consultant, non-attorney representative for District, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Diane Lappi, executive director for special education-compliance, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Lillieth Grand, music therapist, witness for Student (private provider, not a certified NPA), Private
  • Dr. Jacqueline Shohet, educational psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private
  • Sharla Pitzen, program specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Aimee Eaves, case carrier and special day class teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Debrah Krogman, occupational therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Haydee Mejia, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Ms. Hewitt, middle school art teacher, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Ernie Welke, high school art teacher, Capistrano Valley High School
  • Dr. Robert Patterson, private psychologist who evaluated the student, Private
  • Verdugo Hills Autism Project, nonpublic agency providing discrete trial training, Certified NPA supervised by District
  • Chapman University music therapy program, music therapy program recommended by the District music teacher, Chapman University

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on October 22 and 23, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Egon Mittelmann. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf were his mother, MOTHER, and Dr. Ron Lackey, educational consultant. Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Present on behalf of the District was Diane Lappi, executive director for special education-compliance.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER; Lillieth Grand, music therapist; and Dr. Jacqueline Shohet, educational psychologist. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Sharla Pitzen, program specialist; Aimee Eaves, case carrier and special day class teacher; Debrah Krogman, occupational therapist; and Haydee Mejia, school psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Petitioner submitted a list of ten issues pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code §56505(e)(6). The parties resolved seven of the issues before the hearing proceeded to the evidence. The following issues remained:

1. Should the District provide music therapy to assist Petitioner in developing his communication, social and self-regulatory skills?

2. Should Petitioner be enrolled in a high school art class rather than continue in the middle school art classes?

3. Should the District contract with Dr. Robert Patterson, psychologist, for consultation services with Petitioner for two hours every month?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The parties brought several prehearing motions.

1. The Petitioner moved to have the proceedings videotaped. The District objected. The Hearing Officer denied the motion, finding that such activity would be disruptive and could prolong the proceedings. Furthermore, the Petitioner opted for an open hearing. Consequently, observers were able to come in to view the proceedings. Finally, the Hearing Office does not consider an “open hearing” to be necessarily open to cameras of any sort. Such issues are within the discretion of the presiding hearing officer.

2. The Petitioner then moved through Dr. Lackey (a non attorney) to bar Mr. Roice from serving as the representative of the District as a nonattorney. The District objected, stating that the issue was well settled that qualified nonattorneys can represent parties in special education due process hearings. The Hearing Officer denied the motion, on the ground that 34 C.F.R. §300.509(a)(1) allows nonattorneys “with special knowledge or training with respect to the problems of children with disabilities” to assist parties in special education due process hearings.

3. The Petitioner then moved to exclude the District’s written evidence package as not timely under Cal. Educ. Code §56505.1(f). The District objected, asserting that timely service was made. The Hearing Officer reserved ruling, indicting that prior to the District’s case in chief five days would have elapsed. Moreover, most, if not all, of the documents the District presented were in the possession of or had been previously sent to Petitioner.

4. The Petitioner then moved to compel certain district records and tapes concerning the Petitioner as well as child abuse records of District students other than Petitioner. The Petitioner noted that certain tapes of meetings that were previously produced by the District were inaudible. The District objected, indicating that to its knowledge all records of Petitioner had been furnished. The District also had no information about inaudible tapes. The parties agreed to meet and confer on the production of any records concerning Petitioner not already furnished. As to child abuse records that may be in the possession of the Orange County Sheriff, the Hearing Officer indicated that he had no jurisdiction and therefore denied the motion.

5. The Petitioner then moved to disqualify Mr. Roice as the District’s advocate on the basis of conflict of interest. Dr. Lackey indicated that Mr. Roice’s spouse was the District’s director of special education. The District objected, stating that Mr. Roice was the District’s choice to represent it in this matter. The Hearing Officer denied the motion on the ground that conflict of interest, if it existed, was an issue for the Respondent to raise and not the Petitioner.

6. The District then moved to remove certain art work of Petitioner’s displayed around the hearing room and to stop Petitioner from distributing food and beverages during the hearing. The Petitioner objected, stating that the Petitioner’s representative artwork was integral to his case and that the food and refreshments were available to all in the room and were not disruptive. The Hearing Officer granted the motion to remove the artwork as it was not yet in evidence and could be introduced during Petitioner’s case. The Hearing Officer denied the motion as to the food and beverages with the admonition that if this activity interfered in any way with the hearing, it would be stopped.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student in the District eligible for special education services with a diagnosis of moderate to severe autism. His development disability significantly affects his verbal and non-verbal communication and social interaction skills. His reading and other academic skills are at the upper first grade to second grade levels. His verbal skills require prompting. His typical sentence is one to three words. In social situations he often needs prompts to respond to greetings, express feelings, or initiate or complete play activities with peers.

He had no language until age six. He currently is apparently able to understand what is being said to him, but he cannot fully respond orally.

STUDENT has also had extensive neurological testing. One report from the University of California, San Francisco Medical Center indicates that he suffers from reduced blood flow to the left temporal lobe of the brain with an increased flow to the right hemisphere. Petitioner is awaiting brain mapping and further neuropsychological study at the University of California, Irvine hospital.

This neurological condition may explain in part both his disability and the remarkable artistic talent STUDENT has shown since earliest childhood. He can recreate images he has seen accurately without the scene or object before him. He can portray animals, still life, landscapes, and cartoon characters with minute detail. His mother reports that his technique is to create a drawing freehand in ink without any erasures or changes. In art he has been termed a “savant” by several observers and assessors. His parents have successfully marketed and sold some of his artwork.

His art class in school has been the singular exception in which he excels and maintains top grades. His art teacher has expanded STUDENT’s art skills and repertoire including developing his use of color, shading, and perspective. This teacher believes STUDENT could make a living as an artist. STUDENT has repeated the eighth grade art class at the middle school and is currently in a sixth grade program because of scheduling conflicts with other electives.

STUDENT’s current placement is in the District’s Marco Forster Middle School. He is in the school for one half of the day. Petitioner’s mother is a District biology teacher and has had STUDENT in her general education class. He receives other services provided by the District. After spending the morning at Marcus Forster Middle School, STUDENT goes to a private residence for two hours where he receives tutoring from a parent vendor and instruction provided by Verdugo Hills Autism Project, a certified non-public agency (NPA) supervised by the District. This includes discrete trial training (DTT). STUDENT then participates in different activities at the Boys and Girls Club for an additional two hours until four in the afternoon. The District provides STUDENT a one-on-one aide for the entire day. The District also provides speech and language and occupational therapy services to Petitioner.

During individualized education program (IEP) meetings while STUDENT was in the transition from his elementary school to Marco Forster for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s mother rejected a special day class SDC recommendation in favor of part-time full inclusion with related services furnished during the remainder of the school day. The District agreed to this arrangement for 2001-2002.

After several IEP meetings during the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner’s parent did not accept the team’s repeated recommendation for a SDC. The District then offered to continue the previous services as a stay put placement to include DTT through Verdugo Hills, supervision, and a home tutor.

The last agreed upon IEP for STUDENT is dated June 26, 2001 (Respondent’s Exhibit 13). STUDENT’s mother did not agree with the special day class-severely handicapped (SDC-SH) recommendation for STUDENT, but did accept the goals and objectives from the January 19, 2001 IEP.

The January 19, 2001 goals adopted in the June 26, 2001 IEP included the following (Petitioner’s Exhibit 455-462):

1. Improve skills in social-pragmatics by at least six months from current baseline data.

2. Improve readings skills such as sight vocabulary by fifty words, use of reading strategies to aid in comprehension, and the ability to answer literal comprehension questions with fifty per cent accuracy.

3. Increase social oral language and survival language by fifty per cent; increase writing skills by fifty per cent.

4. Improve calculation, subtraction, practical math survival skills, and problem solving skills by fifty per cent.

5. Improve independent work habits by meeting eight specific objectives..

6. Improve behavioral skills by meeting eight specific objectives.

Several other IEP meetings were set during the 2001-2002 school year. Some were postponed for scheduling conflicts. None of these sessions resulted in parent assent to the IEP team offer. The District and Petitioner’s mother have resolved most of the disputed matters prior to the hearing leaving three remaining issues for determination.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Should the District provide music therapy to assist Petitioner in developing his communication, social and self-regulatory skills?

The District is obligated to provide to Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to meet his unique needs and prepare him for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §56000.

This free appropriate education includes special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)

“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). Under State law related services may include, but are not limited to designated instruction and services (DIS) that are to be available to the student to benefit educationally from his or her educational program. Cal Educ. Code § 56363(a).

The standard which the District’s instruction and services must meet is to provide the Petitioner some educational benefit. Board of Educ. Of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-200. This United States Supreme Court decision, however, does not require the District to provide Petitioner with the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes his abilities. Petitioner is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”

An appropriate public education does not require the absolute best or a “potential maximizing” program for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F. 3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The standard for the school district is whether the proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student, not whether the student may obtain a greater benefit from a placement preferred by the parents. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).

Was the District’s IEP offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was it reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Before it can be determined if the District is has offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, STUDENT’s needs must be identified. He has been diagnosed with pervasive development disorder with autistic-like symptoms and seizure disorder as a result of Landau-Kleffner syndrome. The record shows that STUDENT was first evaluated in pre-school because of significant delays in language, cognition, socialization, and self-help skills. “Autistic-like” and “oppositional-type” behaviors were noted at this age level.

It is undisputed in the record that STUDENT’s unique needs include social pragmatics, functional academics, and verbal and non-verbal communication skills. His delayed development in these areas have seriously impeded his educational performance.

It is also undisputed that STUDENT’s primary needs are in social pragmatics and communication skills. He still has difficulty responding verbally in complete sentences or in more than a few words. Although he is showing progress in “scripted” social speech, his interaction with peers and adults is still developmentally delayed. The underlying need for STUDENT both in the academic and social skills categories is language.

To meet these needs, STUDENT’s current IEP provides a combination of services from the District including general education elective classes, home tutoring, and specialized therapies. The current goals and objectives address both social and academic performance. The evidence supports the conclusion that the District program has aided STUDENT in making great strides in his social and behavior goals. He no longer needs a behavior intervention plan. He is not as prone to acting out in class or throwing tantrums. The District witnesses point to the occupational therapy utilizing “pressure points” and weighted garments that calm STUDENT and allow him to focus more on task.

As to STUDENT’s progress in the academic goals and objectives, the record is not clear how much progress he has made. What is clear is that his delayed language and communication skills have permitted at best only small progress in such areas as reading, writing, and speaking. The record portrays STUDENT as still struggling with social pragmatics and interaction with his fellow classmates although he is functioning for three periods a day in a general education setting and his mother reports that his prowess in art has encouraged interchange with other students and enhanced STUDENT’s self esteem.

In response to Petitioner’s observations concerning the limited academic progress, the District argued in its closing brief that STUDENT’s growth is to be viewed in the context of his “significant disability.” His progress in the behavior area may belie that assertion. Additionally, the District witnesses point out the lack of current assessment that at the very least leaves open the question of his progress.

Although the evidence establishes that the District has admirably addressed STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the question is whether the current IEP adequately meets his language and communication needs and not just those in the social and behavior categories.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District IEP does not sufficiently meet STUDENT’s unique needs in language. The record simply shows too little or uncertain progress in this vital area.

I music therapy necessary to address STUDENT’s unique language needs?

The Petitioner argues that music therapy is “essential for STUDENT’s well being and to enable him to study reading and acquire communications skills.” The Petitioner contends that the evidence supports the notion that STUDENT has achieved little progress in his academic skills since the last agreed upon goals were stated. He is still approximately at the end of the first grade to the beginning of the second grade in these skills.

The District contends STUDENT does not require music therapy as he “has made significant progress in his placement at Marco Forster Middle School.” The District points to STUDENT’s strong improvement in behavior, social skills, and work habits.

Music only recently has emerged as an area in which STUDENT can succeed. STUDENT’s middle school general education music teacher in an annual review has reported that in a very short two-week period STUDENT could learn and sing some of the literature in the sixth grade music text book. STUDENT also responded positively to the program and was able to participate in answering questions related to the classroom lessons. (Respondent’s Exhibit 23). This progress in music skills had an apparent carry over into developing language skills which is one of STUDENT’s basic unique needs. The fact that STUDENT was responding to classroom questioning during a very limited time in this class suggests that there may be some nexus for STUDENT between music and developing communication skills. In this same annual review, the District music teacher recommends an assessment through the Chapman University music therapy program saying that “STUDENT could benefit.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 23).

The testimony of Lillieth Grand, music therapist, predicts a potential benefit to STUDENT from her music therapy program. Petitioner has requested her organization as the service provider for STUDENT. She differentiates music therapy from music education available to STUDENT in the District program. The therapy uses music as a means to develop communication, cognitive, and social skills rather than teaching music for its own sake. She reported that in her evaluation sessions with STUDENT he was able to perform academic tasks substantially better if the responses were sung as opposed to spoken or read. With minimal cuing, STUDENT could sing long phrases in place tonally in twenty-four trials. This is in stark contrast to STUDENT’s struggle with spoken language with characteristically two-word to three-word utterances.

Ms. Grand also observed that STUDENT kept his full attention on the activities in both sessions, the second of which lasted ninety minutes. She also observed none of STUDENT’s documented self-stimulation activities such as toe walking. He maintained eye contact, a skill STUDENT has been working on, while dancing during the evaluation.

Ms. Grand testified to positive results with other autistic children. She indicated, however, that there are no controlled studies documenting results. There are also no norms developed for her tests. Additionally, her program is not certified by the State Department of Education as an approved NPA although she is in the process of applying.

The District’s occupational therapy program as described by District occupational therapist Debrah Krogman has achieved the goals of calming STUDENT and maintaining his alertness on task. STUDENT has a history of acting out, self stimulation, and displaying tantrums. The documents in evidence include the behavioral intervention plan (Petitioner’s Exhibit 369-382) that is no longer needed. These improvements, the Respondent points out, are substantial and will allow increasingly greater time and emphasis on STUDENT’s academic skills.

District special day class teacher Aimee Eaves testified that STUDENT did “wonderfully” last year. She is STUDENT’s case carrier with responsibilities to follow up to be certain that he is participating in his on-site program and receiving his DIS. In STUDENT’s mainstream classes she points to his success in art, in which he serves as a role model for the other students, as well as science, in which he did well. As for reading, she observed that he is working on comprehension skills with his aide. She believes that STUDENT is meeting some of the IEP reading goals and has made progress toward others. In response to a question from Petitioner’s counsel regarding whether STUDENT had met all of his reading goals, Mrs. Eaves replied that she did not know where he was at this time as there had been no testing since January, 2002. She said that the goals and objectives developed by the District team contemplated a school site SDC with more intensive emphasis on these skills.(Footnote 1)

District program specialist Sharla Pitzen, who participated in the IEP meetings and observed STUDENT both in the school and the home tutoring settings, also could not definitively state that STUDENT had achieved his goals. She did, however, speak to the extensive work that Petitioner’s mother had done with the speech and language therapist to foster progress toward the goals in that area.

District psychologist Haydee Mejia, who had observed STUDENT and had participated with the IEP team, noted that accurately assessing STUDENT’s cognitive skills was very difficult because of developmental delays in his language skills. She did indicate that the progress in calming STUDENT as described by occupational therapist Debrah Krogman could facilitate progress in the language skills. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s language skill level limits not only his academic performance but the means to assess his progress as well, as was discussed by District psychologist Mejia.

The testimony of the District witnesses generally indicates that STUDENT’s progress toward what are now almost two-year-old goals and objectives is minimal or uncertain. The IEP must include “Appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the annual goals are being achieved (Emphasis added).” Cal Educ. Code § 56345 (7). The District witnesses could give only general qualitative descriptions of where STUDENT was and how the program is meeting his needs in the academic areas. The District professionals agree that assessing STUDENT’s progress is a challenge and that more assessment is needed. The District witnesses are essentially saying no one knows exactly what progress STUDENT has made since January, 2001. Even without a quantitative measure, STUDENT still needs work on his communication skills to enable him to perform better academically.

The record developed at hearing suggests music therapy as a potentially helpful educational assist to address STUDENT’s need to improve communication skills. Unfortunately, to confirm this approach may be helpful to STUDENT, Ms. Grand’s observations in two limited sessions are insufficient.

There are no empirical data in the record that music therapy will address his specific needs. There is also insufficient evaluation of his performance toward his current goals. Accordingly, further assessment is necessary.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a music therapy assessment as suggested by STUDENT’s middle school music teacher is appropriate for STUDENT. (Footnote 2)

The Hearing Officer further finds that an assessment sufficient to determine STUDENT’s progress toward his academic goals is warranted as the District cannot definitively indicate the level of STUDENT’s academic progress since his IEP goals were last formulated.

Issue Number 2: Should Petitioner be enrolled in a high school art class rather than continue in the middle school art classes?

Was the District’s IEP offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was it reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The evidence suggests that STUDENT may have a vocational future in art. His mother testified that he has employment leads from Walt Disney Studios and video game producers. His art work is of a quality that has already motivated members of the public to pay money for it. Art is a potential for STUDENT to achieve employment and some form of independent living.

The IEPs only mention art in passing such as a listed class, noting a class STUDENT enjoys, or that drawing is a means for STUDENT to communicate emotion. There is convincing evidence of how art has helped STUDENT’s self esteem and relationships with peers. STUDENT’s mother testified to the confidence and esteem-building that has resulted from creating his art ant the social experiences of sharing and displaying his work. This suggests that there should be exploration of using art in the IEP to meet STUDENT’s goals and objectives.

The law requires that the IEP include a statement of present levels of performance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345 (a). This required statement includes both strengths and weaknesses and is intended to assist the IEP team in identifying effective goals and strategies. A student’s strengths are often used to assist in developing areas of weaknesses. In this case art has helped STUDENT in his social and personal development. It should be a focal point for developing the IEP goals in all areas, such as a strategy to meet language communication skills. Art should not be in STUDENT’s program merely because he can do well in the subject. This is an opportunity to apply a formidable strength to work on the weaknesses. To address STUDENT’s needs, art should play an integral role in the IEP process.

Is a high school art class necessary to address STUDENT’s unique language needs?

The evidence shows how STUDENT, as a dramatic departure from his other school experiences, is a stand-out in his art classes. The evidence shows development of positive interaction with peers and adults. This should become the basis for developing language communication skills relating to his art work. His classmates admire and look up to STUDENT as a result of his outstanding accomplishments. Ms. Hewitt, his middle school art teacher, describes how other students are “awestruck” by STUDENT’s work. She observed that “they want to sit by him and watch him create.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 923) This should be leveraged into strategies to work on language goals.

The Petitioner seeks STUDENT’s placement in Mr. Ernie Welke’s class at Capistrano Valley High or private art instruction on a higher level than that offered in his middle school. In his current school, he has taken the eighth grade class twice and is now in a sixth grade class because of scheduling conflicts. STUDENT’s mother indicated that the sixth grade placement has STUDENT frustrated and returning to his acting out behaviors an erosion of his self esteem.

The Respondent argues that STUDENT can continue to benefit from the art opportunities at Marco Forster Middle School. The District further argues that was no evidence suggesting or proving that the current art placement could not meet STUDENT’s individual needs. The District also invokes Rowley, arguing that all it needs to provide is a “basic floor of opportunity,” and that it need not “maximize the potential” of STUDENT’s art talents.

It is clear that STUDENT is a gifted artist. He has excelled in his middle school art program and has received top grades consistently. His teacher, Ms. Hewitt, has developed his talents, bringing him to color, shading, and perspective. She describes STUDENT’s handling of her class projects to be at “superior level and beyond.” She believes STUDENT should be exposed to as much as possible and that “there is probably no limit to his artistic ability” (Respondent’s Exhibit 23) Ms. Hewitt has recommended that STUDENT go into the high school program, observing that STUDENT “needs the more advanced high school curriculum, he would probably be impressive and contributory to other students’ artistic perceptions and output” and that he “has some of the highest art ability level I have ever seen in a student and a sophistication level in textures and shading way beyond his years.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 923-924)

High School art teacher Ernie Welke has invited STUDENT in writing to join his class (Petitioner’s Exhibit 925). Mr. Welke has seen his general education students go on to art school. He also is experienced in other media such as bronze sculpture although he teaches this skill at Saddleback College. Mr. Welke has expressed an interest in expanding STUDENT’s work into this and other areas. Mr. Welke lists presenting, matting, framing, and exhibiting art work as topics he teaches in his class. These skills are beyond the scope of the middle school program and have direct application to STUDENT’s ability to sell his work and explore a vocational future. Mr. Welke further indicates that his class also includes another autistic youngster. The Petitioner suggests that with STUDENT in the class both similarly challenged students would benefit.

The only option in the middle school, however, would be to put him into one oif Ms. Hewitt’s classes for the third time.(Footnote 3) This placement cannot meet STUDENT’s needs and certainly will not confer any educational benefit. Ms. Hewitt commendably has taught STUDENT new techniques and has done much to increase his skills. The record is clear, however, that STUDENT can get nothing further from the middle school art program, as he has mastered these beginning classes. Remaining at this level has already led to STUDENT’s losing some of the gains in classroom behavior. This jeopardizes progress toward other goals if STUDENT begins to lose his gains in attention to tasks.

Furthermore, as STUDENT is past the age of 14, the IEP must include a statement of transition services needs of the student. “The statement shall be included under applicable components of the pupil’s individualized education program that focuses on the pupil’s course of study, such as participation in advanced-placement courses or a vocational education program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1 (a). A high school level art program certainly constitutes both an advanced placement course and a potential vocational education opportunity for STUDENT.

In a high school art class, he will continue to be a role model with his peers.(Footnote 4) This will encourage development of his communications skills and further his social goals and objectives in his IEP. He will have the basic opportunity to be challenged and make progress in art as well as with his goals and objectives. He will have the opportunity to function with non disabled peers in a setting in which he can succeed. To make the high school art fit into STUDENT’s program, Petitioner’s mother has volunteered to assist in the transportation for this placement.

Placing STUDENT in high school art will afford him a “floor of opportunity” under Rowley that can assist in preparing him for employment and independent living. The record demonstrates with his art talent even this high school level program will not “maximize” his potential.

Accordingly, the District shall place STUDENT in a program with Mr. Welke.

Issue Number 3: Should the District contract with Dr. Robert Patterson, psychologist, for consultation services with Petitioner for two hours every month?

The Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to retain Dr. Robert Patterson to assess and supervise “STUDENT’s behavioral and educational progress.” Petitioner argues that as the District has not followed Dr. Patterson’s recommendations, STUDENT has not progressed in the academic areas. Petitioner contends that “in order to make STUDENT benefit from his education, Dr. Patterson must be retained by the district and his recommendations followed.”

The Respondent argues that the District is providing adequate supervision and case management services to STUDENT with additional services available. Case carrier Aimee Eaves, program specialist Sharla Pitzen, and the NPA Verdugo Hills Autism Project under District supervision focus on STUDENT’s program. District professionals monitor STUDENT’s progress, compliance with his IEP, and participate on the IEP team. The District further contends that there is no indication what Dr. Patterson could do to assist STUDENT.

Dr. Patterson prepared a fifty page evaluation of Petitioner in December, 2000.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit 318-367). He had counseled him both in the Respondent District and Petitioner’s previous district. Dr. Patterson participated with the IEP team and furnished specific suggestions for the current school year in a three-page document dated April 22, 2002 (Petitioner’s Exhibit 843-845). The record indicates that the IEP team did in fact consider his ten recommendations. The team addressed them and implemented some of them. The assessments by the District and its NPA contractor that addressed some of these issues followed Dr. Patterson’s report in April, May, and June, 2002. (Respondent’s Exhibits 16-22).

He proposed that his recommendations be formatted into annual goals and short-term objectives emphasizing social skills. He praises the language and speech specialists for the progress STUDENT has shown in the area of social scripts and social stories thereby recognizing benefits STUDENT has received from his program in this area.

The District witnesses indicate that many of Dr. Patterson’s recommendations have been incorporated into STUDENT’s program. For example, program specialist Pitzen credits Dr. Patterson for guidelines implemented in STUDENT’s transition to the middle school. Case carrier Eaves points to further suggested implementations of Dr. Patterson’s recommendations in the proposed functional academic and community skills goals.

As to the proposition of the District hiring Dr. Patterson as STUDENT’s counselor, there is no evidence that he is prepared to serve in this capacity or under what terms and conditions he could or would do so. Dr. Patterson is a very busy professional. At first he was to be a witness in this hearing but could not clear his schedule. Psychologist Dr. Jacqueline Shohet did testify and endorsed Dr. Patterson’s findings and recommendations. She did not and likely could not speak to Dr. Patterson’s willingness or availability to serve as Petitioner requests.

STUDENT already has the benefit of the District school psychologist Haydee Mejia and the other educational professionals. Petitioner has questioned how much time these District employees are spending on STUDENT and whether he is getting enough attention. STUDENT’s mother is concerned that during the current school year no one is following up with STUDENT. The District witnesses have demonstrated that STUDENT’s case is properly managed. The key point, however, is that even if additional professional services were determined to be necessary for STUDENT to receive a FAPE, there is no authority to require the District to hire a particular professional.

Dr. Patterson’s December, 2000 evaluation of STUDENT appears to be competent and thorough. The IEP team considered his April, 2002 recommendations. However, he was not available as a witness at the hearing to update his recommendations in light of the later assessments and the several issues that were resolved between the Petitioner and the District. The evidence does not establish a specific need for more attention from a psychologist, whether it be Dr. Patterson or some other professional, to assure STUDENT of a FAPE. The record does not disclose the necessity of further counseling to meet any of his needs or to confer an educational benefit on Petitioner. The District is not required to retain his services.

Therefore, the Petitioner’s request to require the District to hire Dr. Robert Patterson is denied.

ORDER

(1) The District is ordered to arrange a music therapy assessment of Petitioner by a qualified assessor of the District’s choice. Recognizing that there is no empirical evidence to demonstrate that STUDENT’s ability to sing language will generalize necessarily to spoken or written language, the District is ordered to place STUDENT in music therapy for diagnostic purposes only for a period not to exceed, unless the parties agree otherwise, ninety calendar days. This diagnostic assessment shall commence within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision. This is a diagnostic placement for Petitioner and is not an educational placement for stay put purposes should a further dispute arise between the parties.

(2) Prior to the commencement of the music therapy assessment, the District shall convene the IEP team to formulate diagnostic questions to be answered by this assessment. The diagnostic questions shall include, but not be limited to, the following concepts(Footnote 5):

(A) Does STUDENT’s ability to sing sentences generalize to spoken or written language and normal communication?

(B) Do assessment results demonstrate that this will be an avenue for improving functional academic progress?

(C) Do assessment results demonstrate an improvement in self-esteem and social interaction?

(3) The IEP team shall further determine what assessments are appropriate to measure if STUDENT has achieved his current academic goals and arrange these assessments to be completed so that the results can be considered by the team along with the music therapy assessment to determine whether music therapy is a required service.

(4) The District shall place STUDENT in a program with art teacher Ernie Welke, subject to accommodating STUDENT’s other classes, designated instruction and services, and transportation needs within forty-five calendar days after the date of this decision.

(1) The Petitioner’s request to require the District to hire Dr. Robert Patterson is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(2) Neither party prevailed on the first issue.

(3) The Petitioner prevailed on the second issue.

(4) The Respondent prevailed on the third issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 26, 2002 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Petitioner’s written argument indicates that the parties have agreed that STUDENT will remain included in the general education program and will not enroll in an SDC. 2. There is no compelling showing that the District would be limited to the provider selected by the Petitioner if music therapy is demonstrated to be necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Moreover, the musical therapist suggested by Petitioner is not certified. The Hearing Officer cannot order the District to pay for a non-certified NPA. Cal. Educ. Code §56595.2. 3. The Hearing Officer at Petitioner’s request has taken official notice of the California State Board of Education standards in the visual arts for the ninth grade. These guidelines, however, are geared to the general education student. Most of them are not applicable or would require major modification for STUDENT. The emphasis in these standards is for art appreciation and understanding by the average student, and not for the nurturing of a promising artist. For example, the achievement benchmarks include “artistic perception” calling for research, description, and analysis expecting students to “...use the vocabulary of the visual arts to express their observations.” This is inappropriate for STUDENT’s current language skill level. 4. STUDENT was retained at the fifth grade level. Consequently, he is of high school age and would be among peers. 5. The parties may reword these diagnostic questions to be clearer to the assessor. 6. STUDENT’s middle school music teacher last spring reported that STUDENT did well in the class and suggested a music therapy assessment for STUDENT in reference to a Chapman University program. (Respondent’s Exhibit 23)