California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 31, 2001

Student v. Mountain Empire Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1773-00 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

Mountain Empire Unified must reimburse New Bridge School tuition and fund another year after never offering an eligible student services.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. The decision notes an earlier procedural order on the limitations period and the harm requirement, dated "June 28, 2000," likely meaning June 28, 2001.

Summary

A 10-year-old student's family filed for due process against Mountain Empire Unified School District in September 2000. The District assessed her in 1997 and 1998. Both times the IEP team said she could qualify as mentally retarded, but her mother refused that label. The IEP forms then said she did not qualify, and the team offered no placement or services. Claims based on events before September 18, 1997 were barred by the three-year limitations period.

Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel held that the District could not rely on the mother's refusal because it never made a written offer of placement and services. The student repeated second grade and kept falling behind despite many classroom supports, so the regular program did not meet her needs. He found her eligible and denied a FAPE in 1997-98, 1998-99 and 1999-2000. Dr. Nancy Markel's private testing showed a severe discrepancy in written expression, which supported eligibility for a specific learning disability. Susan Berkowitz's assessment supported a speech or language disorder.

The parent's placement at New Bridge School, a nonpublic school, was appropriate. The District must reimburse $11,750 in tuition, plus mileage and the 2001 summer program. It must also fund New Bridge for 2001-02 as compensatory education. It must pay for the Berkowitz assessment and assess hearing, vision, occupational therapy, assistive technology and attention. Reimbursement for Dr. Markel's evaluation and a vision evaluation was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a parent's refusal of an eligibility label when the district never made a written offer of placement and services under Union School Dist. v. Smith. It also shows a private placement used as compensatory education. And it shows that IEE reimbursement depended on whether each district assessment could be defended.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years because of the District's failure to find her eligible for special education on or after September 18, 1997?

    Student was eligible in all three years: the District found her eligible in 1997 and 1998 but made no written offer of placement and services, so it could not rely on the parent's refusal; modifications to the regular program did not meet her needs, and by 1999-2000 she met the SLD criteria in written expression. Claims based on events before September 18, 1997 were barred by the three-year limitations period.

  2. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 2. Was Student eligible for special education during the 2000-2001 school year?

    Student remained eligible under SLD and also qualified with a speech or language disorder, based on expressive language scores on the CELF-3 and the CASL syntax subtest; the limited vision screening did not establish a visual impairment.

  3. Issue 3. If so, is Student entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and transportation costs for Student's attendance at the New Bridge School during the 2000-2001 school year?

    New Bridge was an appropriate placement, and equities did not support reducing reimbursement even though the parent did not share private evaluations first, because the District twice found eligibility but never offered services. Full tuition of $11,750 and mileage were awarded. Summer program reimbursement was denied as ESY under this issue but granted later as compensatory education.

  4. Issue 4. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments of Dr. Nancy Markel, Susan Berkowitz and Dr. Claude Valenti?

    The parent's 2000 IEEs were causally connected to her disagreement with the District's assessments. The District showed its 1998 psychoeducational and academic testing was appropriate, so Dr. Markel's evaluation was not reimbursed. The District could not show its 1998 speech-language assessment was appropriate, so the Berkowitz evaluation was reimbursed. The vision evaluation was not reimbursed because no vision impairment was suspected before 2000. The District was ordered to assess hearing, vision, OT, AT and attention.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Three years of denied FAPE left Student well behind her peers. As compensatory education, the District must reimburse the 2001 New Bridge summer program and fund New Bridge, including transportation, for 2001-2002, with an IEP meeting to develop goals.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, reimburse $11,750 for New Bridge School tuition for 2000-2001.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, reimburse transportation to and from New Bridge School for 2000-2001: 26,134 miles at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
  • Compensatory education. Reimburse tuition and transportation mileage (at the employee rate) for the 2001 New Bridge summer program. Parent submits proof within 25 calendar days of the decision; the District reimburses within 30 calendar days of receiving proof.
  • IEE at public expense. Reimburse the cost of Susan Berkowitz's speech-language assessment. Proof is due within 25 calendar days of the decision; the District reimburses within 30 calendar days of receiving proof.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. As compensatory education, the District pays all tuition and transportation mileage for New Bridge School for 2001-2002, reimbursing any amounts already paid within 30 calendar days of receiving proof.
  • Order to assess. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must develop an assessment plan covering hearing, vision, occupational therapy, assistive technology, and evaluation for an attention deficit disorder.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 50 days of receiving the parent's assent to the assessment plan, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives at New Bridge for 2001-2002. Any added services must not interfere with the New Bridge program. The decision's body adds that the Markel and Berkowitz assessments serve as the current assessments, New Bridge teachers attend, and an IEP meeting after 2001-2002 considers the 2002-2003 placement and 2002 summer session.

Total: $11,750 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Ash v. Lake Oswego School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Bronwyn Lee, Director of special education and school psychologist; District assessor, Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Dr. Nancy Markel, Clinical neuropsychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Susan Berkowitz, Private speech-language pathologist; independent evaluator and witness for Student, Private practice
  • Dr. Claude Valenti, Private vision evaluator (did not testify), Private practice
  • Dr. Donald Janiak, Optometrist; witness for Student, Private practice
  • Laura Zaroff, Private speech-language pathologist who did audiological testing (did not testify), Private practice
  • Steven Mayo, Director of nonpublic school; witness for Student, New Bridge School
  • New Bridge School, Certified nonpublic school (parent placement), Poway, California
  • Marcia McEvoy, Second grade teacher (1998-1999), Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Karen Koon, Second grade teacher (1997-1998), Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Dierdre Carter, First grade teacher and school principal, Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Cora Jensen, RSP teacher; academic achievement assessor, Mountain Empire Unified School District (Descanso School)
  • Robin Lipton, District speech-language pathologist; witness for District, Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • William Dennett, Third grade teacher (1999-2000), Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Mrs. Tanner, Kindergarten teacher, Descanso School, Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Linda Miller, Special day class aide, Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • S. Byrd, District speech-language assessor (1998), Mountain Empire Unified School District
  • Chris McKenzie, Private summer tutor (1998), Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Campo, California, on June 5, 6, and 7, 2001, and July 10, 11, and 12, 2001.

STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael S. Cochrane. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was MOTHER, her mother, UNCLE, her uncle (present only on June 5 and 6) and AUNT, her aunt (present only on June 5). Mountain Empire Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Pamela Dempsey and Rick Silva. Also present on the District’s behalf was Dr. Bronwyn Lee, District director of special education and school psychologist.

STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother; Dr. Nancy Markel, clinical psychologist; Marcia McEvoy, teacher; Dr.

Donald Janiak, optometrist; Susan Berkowitz, speech and language pathologist; Steven Mayo, director of the New Bridge School; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Karen Koon, teacher; Dierdre Carter, school principal and teacher; Cora Jensen, RSP teacher; Robin Lipton, speech and language pathologist; William Dennett, teacher; and Dr. Bronwyn Lee, director of special education and school psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on August 2, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

STUDENT has never been found eligible for special education and related services. The District first assessed STUDENT in April 1997 and convened an individualized education program (IEP) meeting in May 1997. STUDENT did not obtain her own assessments until 2000. This case was filed on September 18, 2000. Education Code Section 56505(j) provides for a three-year statute of limitations for special education due process hearings. The above facts gave rise to two issues during the first days of the hearing. The issues were briefed by the parties and an order issued by the Hearing Officer on June 28, 2000. The issues and resolutions were as follows:

To what extent, if any, can the Hearing Officer consider Mountain Empire Unified School District’s (District) actions in relation to its assessment of STUDENT, referral for Special Education, and IEP meeting which occurred in April and May 1997?

The Hearing Officer found that any claim for relief based upon the District’s actions which occurred outside the three-year limitation (prior to September 18, 1997) is barred by Education Code Section 56505(j). However, the Hearing Officer can look at relevant evidence from the time period before September 1997 as background information to assist him in resolving claims that did arise within the three-year time limitation.

Can the Hearing Officer grant relief to STUDENT under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) unless it is established by a preponderance of the evidence that the STUDENT was eligible for special education during the time period for which relief is sought?

The Hearing Officer found that, although the District does have the burden of proving it complied with the IDEA, a procedural violation of the IDEA does not automatically lead to relief. There must always be proof of harm before relief is warranted. W.G. v Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th. Cir. 1992). Even when a District has committed procedural violations of the IDEA, if the child in question was not eligible for special education services at the time of those violations, then there has been no showing of harm and no relief is warranted.

ISSUES(Footnote 2)

1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years because of the District’s failure to find her eligible for special education on or after September 18, 1997?

2. Was STUDENT eligible for special education during the 2000-2001 school year?

3. If so, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and transportation costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the New Bridge School during the 2000-2001 school year?

4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments of Dr. Nancy Markel, Susan Berkowitz and Dr. Claude Valenti?

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT argues that STUDENT is, and at all times relevant to this case was, eligible for special education. In addition, STUDENT argues that the District committed procedural violations of the IDEA that prevented STUDENT’s mother from meaningful participation in the IEP process. As a result of the District’s denial of eligibility and procedural violations, STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the years in question. As a remedy, STUDENT seeks reimbursement for tuition and costs associated with STUDENT’s placement at the New Bridge School. In addition, STUDENT seeks compensatory education to make up for the lost educational opportunity that resulted from the District’s denial of services. Finally, STUDENT asserts that the District’s assessments in 1998 were not all valid, and did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, specifically in the area of hearing impairment. Because the District’s assessments were not appropriate, STUDENT’s mother is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments she obtained from Dr. Markel, Ms. Berkowitz and Dr. Valenti.

The District argues that STUDENT was not, and is not, eligible for special education. The District makes two arguments in support of its position. First, none of the testing done in 1997, 1998, or 2000 shows that STUDENT qualifies for special education. Second, even if the test results do show that a potentially qualifying impairment exists, it must also be shown that STUDENT’s needs could not be met with modification of the regular education program. The District argues that it successfully met STUDENT’s needs through modification of the regular program. As to reimbursement for the privately obtained assessments, the District argues that the assessments obtained in 2000 were not the result of STUDENT’s disagreement with the District’s assessments performed in 1997 and 1998, and that, furthermore, the District’s assessments were appropriate. Finally, as to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at New Bridge, the District argues that since there is no evidence on which to base a finding of eligibility for special education, no reimbursement is appropriate.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. She is a ten-year-old student who has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Mountain Empire Unified School District (District) at all times relevant to this case. She has never been identified as eligible for special education and related services. STUDENT was born with microtia of the right ear. She has membranous and boney growth over the external auditory canal. STUDENT’s left ear and right “inner ear” are essentially normal. As a result, STUDENT has normal hearing in her left ear, and is completely deaf in her right ear. STUDENT underwent a series of six operations for cosmetic reconstruction of the right outer ear in 1997 and 1998.

STUDENT attended kindergarten at the Descanso School in the District during the 1995-1996 school year. STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher was Mrs. Tanner. In April 1996 Mrs. Tanner met with STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, to discuss Mrs. Tanner’s concerns about STUDENT. MOTHER indicated that she was interested in any evaluations and extra services that STUDENT might need. After this meeting, Mrs. Tanner requested a STUDENT Study Team meeting. In her request, Mrs. Tanner stated that STUDENT was significantly below grade level in reading, math, and large and fine motor skills. She also noted that STUDENT seemed to have difficulty processing language. Mrs. Tanner recommended that STUDENT be evaluated in the areas of language, motor skills, and auditory and visual perception. Mrs. Tanner completed an evaluation check list on which she noted, in part, that STUDENT demonstrated the following:

• limited memory skills.

• difficulty understanding abstract concepts.

• the need to have oral questions and directions frequently repeated. • difficulty with visual and auditory memory.

• difficulty concentrating.

• visual perception problems.

• the need for slow, sequential, substantially broken down presentation of concepts. • did not hear all of what is said.

• difficulty differentiating speech sounds heard.

• attended more successfully when close to the source of sound. • the need for eye contact in order to listen successfully.

• difficulty with sound-symbol relationships.

• difficulty with phonic skills when reading.

• difficulty copying letters, words, sentences and numbers from a model. • reversed letters and numbers when writing.

• omitted, added or substituted words when writing.

During the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT’s first grade teacher was Dierdre Carter. After the second quarter, Ms. Carter noted that STUDENT was making slow but steady progress. STUDENT needed one-on-one help in both reading and math. STUDENT was below grade level but “worked very hard” (emphasis in original). In April 1997 Ms. Carter referred STUDENT for special education services. Ms. Carter testified that she referred STUDENT because she had tried significant modifications to the curriculum, but STUDENT still needed more help. Ms. Carter tried the following modifications:

• Had STUDENT sit directly at the front of the room.

• Sat STUDENT next to a student who was always on task.

• Placed STUDENT in a reading group of three and a math group of four where she could receive individual attention. • Geared the instruction to STUDENT’s level.

An assessment plan was developed and signed by MOTHER on April 16, 1997. The plan called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, communication development, intellectual development, health/vision/ hearing screening, and audiology.

Dr. Bronwyn Lee, the school psychologist and director of special education, wrote the psycho-educational assessment report. STUDENT was given the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), Draw-a-Person, Bender Test of Visual Motor Integration (Bender), Peabody Individual Achievement Test - Revised (PIAT-R), Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA), Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), and the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI).(Footnote 3)

On the WISC-III, STUDENT received a verbal IQ of 74, a performance IQ of 70, and a full scale IQ of 70. Dr. Lee stated that the test results were technically valid; however, she felt the scores were falsely depressed by STUDENT’s test-taking behavior and extreme passivity. Dr. Lee noted that STUDENT’s movements were extremely slow and that she was very distractable and very dependent in her work style. On the PIAT-R, STUDENT received a reading recognition score of 85, reading comprehension score of 83, total reading score of 81, mathematics score of 75, spelling score of 91, and written language composite score of 110. On the KTEA, STUDENT received a mathematics applications score of 82, a reading decoding score of 98, a spelling score of 100, a reading comprehension score of 92, and a mathematics computation score of 84. Dr. Lee noted that all of these scores were significantly above what would be expected given STUDENT’s IQ scores. However, the results of both the Bender and the Draw-a-Person were generally consistent with the full scale IQ of 70. The Draw-a-Person was scored at an age equivalent of 4 to 41/2 years old, which was considered “moderately delayed.”

On the TAPS, STUDENT scored in the 9th percentile in auditory memory, in the 2nd percentile in auditory sentence memory, and in the 9th percentile in auditory word memory and auditory interpretation of directions. She also scored in the 50th percentile in auditory word discrimination and in the 37th percentile in auditory processing. STUDENT’s overall percentile ranking was in the 5th percentile. On the VMI, STUDENT received an overall ranking in the 34th percentile, which was slightly below her age equivalent.

In summary, Dr. Lee stated that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services. She added that the most important intervention for STUDENT would be to help her overcome her extremely passive attitude and lack of effort.

In May 1997, the District also performed a speech and language assessment. STUDENT was given the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Revised (PPVT-R), the Test of Language Development -2-Primary (TOLD-P:2), and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Revised (CELF-R) Screening Test. On the TOLD-P:2, STUDENT scored in the 16th percentile on picture vocabulary, oral vocabulary and grammatic understanding. She scored in the 2nd percentile in sentence imitation, the 25th percentile in grammatic completion, and the 63rd percentile in word discrimination and word articulation. The composite scores were 85 in spoken language, 89 in listening, 83 in speaking, 82 in semantics, 76 in syntax and 106 in phonology. Of these composite scores, only the syntax score is below normal limits. On the PPVT-R, which tests receptive vocabulary, STUDENT received a standard score of 84, which is in the low average range. STUDENT failed the CELF-R Screening Test. In summary, it was concluded that STUDENT had difficulty with receptive and expressive vocabulary, and some syntactical concepts, but her overall scores did not qualify her for special education services. The District did not do any audiology testing because it believed that STUDENT was having this done through her own doctor.

An IEP meeting was held on May 22, 1997. In attendance at the meeting, among others, were MOTHER, Mrs. Carter, Ms. Jensen and Dr. Lee. Dr. Lee testified that the staff was very concerned about STUDENT and wanted to get her help. She stated that the team concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as mentally retarded. Dr. Lee stated that MOTHER was very upset, and was unwilling to accept qualification of STUDENT as mentally retarded. The staff was disappointed by MOTHER’s decision, but understood. MOTHER stated that she did not accept qualification for special education under mental retardation because she did not believe STUDENT was mentally retarded. There was no discussion at the IEP meeting of possible placement or services. The IEP document stated that STUDENT did not qualify for services at that time (Student Exhibit 10).

STUDENT was in Karen Koon’s second grade class during the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT was behind the rest of the class when the year started. STUDENT was still doing mostly first-grade work rather than second-grade work. In fact, Ms. Koon graded STUDENT on a first grade level on her progress report so that STUDENT would not get discouraged (Student’s Exhibit 18). Ms. Koon stated that STUDENT tried very hard, but still had a difficult time understanding things. STUDENT was getting extra help in class from Linda Miller, a special day class aide. STUDENT also was seated in the front of the class to help her with her hearing. STUDENT never complained that she could not hear, and Ms. Koon did not recall noticing any signs that STUDENT was having trouble hearing. In spite of the modified curriculum, extra support from Ms. Miller, and STUDENT’s efforts, STUDENT still progressed slower than the rest of the class. Because the gap between STUDENT and her classmates was growing, Ms. Koon referred STUDENT for special education in January 1998. The District prepared an assessment plan, which MOTHER signed on January 21, 1998. The plan called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, and intellectual development. A second assessment plan was prepared and signed on February 2, 1998. This plan called for STUDENT to also be assessed in the area of speech and language. No audiological assessment was called for this year. Dr. Lee stated that the District was waiting for testing results from STUDENT’s doctors. Dr. Lee recalls that the District offered to do audiological testing, but MOTHER declined.

Ms. S. Byrd performed the speech and language evaluation. She administered the TOLD-P:2, a test of receptive and expressive language, the PPVT-R, a test of receptive vocabulary, and a narrative assessment (the same tests that had been administered in May 1997). On the TOLD-P:2 subtests, STUDENT scored in the 91st percentile in picture vocabulary, 75th percentile in word articulation, 50th percentile in oral vocabulary, 25th percentile in grammatic understanding and word discrimination, and in the 9th percentile in sentence imitation and grammatic completion. The areas of sentence imitation and grammatic completion were also STUDENT’s weakest areas when tested the previous year. On the composite scores, STUDENT received a quotient of 94 in spoken language, 100 in listening, 90 in speaking, 112 in semantics, 79 in syntax, and 100 in phonology. Syntax was STUDENT’s only weak area on the composites, again the same as the prior year. On the PPVT-R, STUDENT scored in the 34th percentile. This placed STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary in the low average range. On the narrative assessment, STUDENT’s story organization and inclusion of detail were marginal because of the omission of major events in the middle of the story. Overall, it was concluded that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were age-appropriate.

To test academic achievement, Cora Jensen administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery (WJ). STUDENT received standard scores of 86 in the reading cluster, 90 in the math cluster, and 88 in the written language cluster. All of these scores are in the average range. In the course of testing, Ms. Jensen noticed that STUDENT had trouble hearing when there was background noise. Ms. Jensen did not prepare a written report of the results of her testing.

Dr. Lee assessed STUDENT in the areas of intellectual development, psycho-motor development and social/adaptive behavior. She administered the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC), the Bender Test of Visual Motor Integration (Bender), and the House-Tree-Person Projective Drawings (Draw-a-Person). On the KABC, a test of cognitive ability, STUDENT received standard scores of 74 in sequential processing, 84 in simultaneous processing, 78 in mental processing, and 73 in nonverbal processing. Dr. Lee stated that the KABC cannot be compared directly to the WISC-III, even though both are tests of cognitive ability. However, Dr. Lee noted that the “mental processing” score (78) is roughly equivalent to the full scale IQ score on the WISC-III. In her report dated February 3, 1998, Dr. Lee noted that STUDENT continued to be very passive and not invested in testing, or in doing well. However, Dr. Lee concluded that STUDENT’s passivity, lack of investment in testing, and impulsive, nonreflective manner were not volitional, but were consistent with her overall delays. Dr. Lee went on the state that STUDENT had developed a style of covering up her inability, and responded to questions in a manner that indicated that she frequently did not understand what had been said, but did not seek to clarify the information. Dr. Lee also noted that STUDENT did get slightly higher scores on cognitive ability, but of greater concern was STUDENT’s lack of maturation as indicated by the Bender and the Draw-a-Person. Dr. Lee concluded that STUDENT needed intensive support to succeed in school. She recommended that the IEP team consider various options, including the possibility of qualifying STUDENT based upon her prior year’s IQ scores from the WISC-III.

The IEP meeting was held on February 27, 1998. MOTHER recalled that Dr. Lee read from her report. She did not recall any lengthy discussion about the test results. MOTHER remembered that Dr. Lee told her that STUDENT qualified for special education as mentally retarded. MOTHER declined because she did not believe STUDENT was mentally retarded. MOTHER asked if STUDENT would qualify as hearing impaired, and was told that the District would look into it and get back to her. MOTHER did not recall any discussion about parent’s rights at the meeting. Dr. Lee recalled reading her report at the meeting. She said there was a discussion of the test results and the possibility of going back to last year’s IQ scores to qualify STUDENT for special education. Dr. Lee said the team offered this option to MOTHER, who declined it. Dr. Lee stated that the team understood MOTHER’s refusal, but also was frustrated by it. Dr. Lee explained that it is her philosophy that the IEP team should respect the parent’s rights. The District has the option of overcoming a parent’s refusal of special education by requesting a due process hearing. However, Dr. Lee felt that this option should only be used in a very compelling case. She believed that STUDENT’s tests scores were only marginally qualifying and that the situation did not warrant going against the parent’s wishes. Dr. Lee also remembered discussing the parent’s due process rights with MOTHER. Dr. Lee pointed out where the rights were located, on the back of each page of the IEP form, and on the back of the “Parent Notice of Meeting” form (District Exhibit 58). Dr. Lee summarized the rights, emphasizing the team nature of the IEP process. Dr. Lee asked MOTHER to read the rights at her convenience and call if she had any questions.

Karen Koon and Cora Jensen also were in attendance at this meeting. Their recollections were roughly similar to Dr. Lee’s. Ms. Jensen recalled the District offering eligibility under mental retardation. She said she understood when MOTHER refused because many people feel “mentally retarded” is a derogatory label. Ms. Jensen felt that special education would have helped STUDENT, but that the ultimate decision was up to the parent. Ms. Koon also recalled the District offering to qualify STUDENT. She said that there really was not much discussion about qualifying, just that the test results showed STUDENT could qualify. Ms. Koon also felt that STUDENT would have benefitted from special education, but that MOTHER was concerned about STUDENT’s being stigmatized by the label “mentally retarded.” There was no discussion of possible placement, and the IEP form does not indicate that any services were offered. The form simply notes that “STUDENT does not qualify for special ed.” (Student Exhibit 15).

On the third quarter of the 1997-1998 progress report, Ms. Koon noted that STUDENT was progressing, but at a first grade level. STUDENT was reading at a high first grade level. It is also noted that there was discussion about STUDENT repeating the second grade. In the fourth quarter, Ms. Koon noted that STUDENT tried very hard, and was making steady progress. However, her rate of achievement made it difficult for her to keep up with the rest of the class (Student Exhibit 18). GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother, testified about the difficulty STUDENT had in school. She said that every night involved a lot of time spent on homework. GRANDMOTHER would help STUDENT with her homework, but often felt that STUDENT simply did not understand what she was supposed to be doing. She stated that STUDENT used to cry over her homework at least twice a week. STUDENT always blamed her hearing for her difficulty at school. GRANDMOTHER testified that she felt it was a good idea for STUDENT to repeat the second grade.

In May 1998, STUDENT took the Stanford Achievement Test, Ninth Edition (SAT 9). She scored in the 9th percentile in total reading, 12th percentile in word study skills, 10th percentile in reading vocabulary, 10th percentile in reading comprehension, 1st percentile in total math, and 1st percentile in problem solving. She also scored in the 3rd percentile in procedures, 15th percentile in language, and 7th percentile in spelling. The test level was “Primary 2” (District Exhibit 28). At the conclusion of the 1997-1998 school year, Ms. Koon and MOTHER decided that STUDENT would get tutoring over the summer, and the final decision about what grade she would go into would be made in September.

During the summer of 1998, STUDENT was tutored by Chris McKenzie. At the end of the summer, Ms. McKenzie wrote a letter summarizing her work with STUDENT (Student Exhibit 19). She stated that STUDENT’s reading had improved, but that she still did not read easily and had to stop to figure words out phonetically, not always with success. STUDENT was reading mostly level-one books, and some level two. STUDENT still was having a lot of trouble with math. She simply did not seem to understand the concepts. STUDENT also seemed to have trouble with retention. Ms. McKenzie also noted that STUDENT’s attention span was short and that she tended to give up if something seemed hard. Ms. McKenzie concluded that STUDENT was not ready for the third grade. In September 1998, Marcia McEvoy, STUDENT’s teacher for the 1998-1999 school year, filled out a Student Retention Form. She noted that STUDENT had been receiving small-group and individualized instruction, seating close to the teacher, peer and cross age tutoring, and ability-level instruction. Despite these instructional efforts, STUDENT was below grade level in all areas. Ms. McEvoy recommended that STUDENT repeat the second grade. MOTHER concurred, and STUDENT repeated the grade, with Ms. McEvoy as her teacher. At the start of the year, STUDENT was not reading well and was having significant problems in math. In January 1999, Ms. McEvoy set up a student intervention team meeting to address STUDENT’s problems in class (District Exhibit 48). The student intervention team meeting form noted that STUDENT was working as hard as she could and that her math was then at grade level. It was noted that STUDENT was in a low reading group and saw Ms. Jensen every day for extra help. In spite of these efforts, STUDENT was still at the lowest level. Strategies and modifications suggested included a word list on horses (STUDENT’s favorite subject), work at the lowest instructional level, touch phonics with Ms. Jensen, and more reading at home. The student intervention team also noted that STUDENT’s parent would obtain an audiology report, and questioned whether STUDENT’s hearing would make her eligible for special education services. Ms. McEvoy explained that Ms. Jensen, the RSP teacher, would pull out regular education students to work with the special education students in the RSP class, space permitting. STUDENT was participating in this program, and was working with Ms. Jensen on reading and phonics. STUDENT worked with Ms. Jensen at least a couple days each week, sometimes daily. STUDENT also received assistance from an aide and small-group instruction in class. Ms. McEvoy testified that STUDENT had trouble with reading, sounding out words, and comprehension. STUDENT’s writing was below grade level. By the end of the year, Ms. McEvoy was concerned that STUDENT was still not ready for the third grade, and recommended summer school. On the 1998-1999 progress report, Ms. McEvoy noted that STUDENT was trying her best, and making progress. Her progress was slow but steady, and STUDENT’s loving personality made her delightful to work with. Because STUDENT was still behind at the end of the year, Ms. McEvoy recommended summer school (Student Exhibit 22).

Audiological testing was done in March 1999 (Student Exhibit 21). Testing on STUDENT’s right ear revealed 100% speech discrepancy at 65 decibels and a speech recognition threshold of 25 decibels. According to Robin Lipton, a speech pathologist who testified at the hearing, this indicated that STUDENT could not recognize speech below 25 decibels, and could not understand 100% of what was said until the sound level reached 65 decibels. Normal speech is approximately 25-30 decibels, and the sound of a vacuum cleaner is approximately 65 decibels.

SAT-9 testing was done in April 1999. The test level used was “Primary 2.” STUDENT showed significant improvement over 1998. She scored in the 19th percentile in total reading, 18th percentile in total math, 10th percentile in problem solving, 38 percentile in procedures, 60th percentile in language, and 15th percentile in spelling.(Footnote 4)

STUDENT advanced to the third grade for the 1999-2000 school year. Her teacher was William Dennett. STUDENT began the third grade as one of the lowest performing students in the class. Mr. Dennett was aware that STUDENT had repeated the second grade and had been referred for special education twice in the past. It was his understanding that the family did not want STUDENT in special education. Mr. Dennett did testing at the beginning of the year and found STUDENT low in all areas. STUDENT had particular trouble with reading comprehension and sequencing. She also was somewhat impulsive, and could be easily distracted. Mr. Dennett sat STUDENT so that he was always speaking directly to her, and paired her with good students to afford her extra help. STUDENT qualified for Title 1 services which entitled her to pull-out assistance in language arts. STUDENT received 30 minutes of pull-out assistance every day. Homework appeared to be more difficult for STUDENT than for other students. Mr. Dennett knew that STUDENT often took assignments home to get extra help. STUDENT had particular trouble with spelling, punctuation and capitalization. The quality of STUDENT’s written expression was one of the lowest in the class. She made progress in this area, but more in the quantity of her writing, than in the quality.

STUDENT tried very hard in Mr. Dennett’s class, but had concerns about her own abilities. On several occasions she confided to Mr. Dennett that she felt she was “dumb.” Mr. Dennett counseled her about these feelings 6 or 8 times during the year. If STUDENT did poorly on a test, she was always given the opportunity for a “re-do.” She would be allowed to take the test home and re-do it there and turn it in the next day. STUDENT was almost always willing to do a “re-do.” She was able to read orally at the third grade level, but struggled in comprehension. She had difficulty with sequencing, inferring answers from prior knowledge, and tended to give simplistic responses to questions about what she had read. Mr. Dennett also noticed that STUDENT may have had trouble with her hearing. When she was concentrating, she would direct her good ear to the speaker. He also noticed that she had difficulty hearing him if he spoke to her from the side of her bad ear. STUDENT also had trouble learning her multiplication tables. She often had to work on her multiplication tables during recess and lunch. Mr. Dennett did consider referring STUDENT for special education; however, he decided not to, in part, because he believed the family did not want STUDENT in special education. He also felt that STUDENT was on the right track. Mr. Dennett felt STUDENT made progress and did not regress in any area.

On STUDENT’s third-grade progress report, Mr. Dennett stated that although STUDENT tried hard, the work was difficult for her. He suggested that she continue to work on her reading and times tables at home. On the grade portion of the report, STUDENT showed little or no progress in many of the language arts areas. In the first quarter, she was rated as a “2" (developing) in decoding and word recognition, vocabulary and concept development, reading comprehension, and reading: literary response and analysis. STUDENT was still at a “2" in these areas at the end of the year. STUDENT did improve in the areas of writing strategies, writing applications, and spelling. She showed little or no improvement in grammar and language mechanics, receiving a “2" in all three quarters. For the third trimester, Mr. Dennett stated that STUDENT had made real progress, but was still one of the lower performing students in the class. Mr. Dennett did recommend that STUDENT progress to the fourth grade.

In April 2000, STUDENT took the SAT-9 test. She scored in the 17th percentile in total reading and the 22nd percentile in total math. She also scored in the 17th percentile in language and 22nd percentile in spelling.

MOTHER continued to be concerned about STUDENT’s progress at school. She felt that the parent-teacher conferences were very frustrating because she was told that STUDENT always tried hard, but was still behind. MOTHER was afraid that STUDENT would have to repeat the third grade.(Footnote 5) STUDENT continued to cry and struggle over her homework. Finally, MOTHER decided to have STUDENT evaluated by a private psychologist and other specialists.

In February 2000, STUDENT was examined by Laura Zaroff, a speech and language pathologist (Student Exhibit 27). Ms. Zaroff did not testify at the hearing. Among other tests, Ms. Zaroff performed audiological testing on STUDENT. In her report, Ms. Zaroff noted that STUDENT had a severe conductive hearing loss in her right her. Her speech discrimination in a quiet setting was excellent on the left and good on the right.

In January and February 2000, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Nancy Markel (Student Exhibit 26). Dr. Markel is a clinical neuropsychologist, whose curriculum vitae is part of the record as Student’s Exhibit 31. Dr. Markel reviewed the reports of the District’s testing in 1997 and 1998, and a speech and audiology report by Ms. Zaroff. Dr. Markel administered the WISC-III, the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI), the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-educational Battery-Revised (WJ-R), the Gray Oral Reading Test-3 (GORT-3), the California Verbal Learning Test-Children’s Version (CVLT-C), the Visual Aural Digit Span Test (VADS), and the Development Test of Visual Motor Integration, 4th Edition (VMI). During the testing, Dr. Markel noted that STUDENT was easily distracted, but could be redirected back to the task at hand. STUDENT also required instructions to be repeated at times. STUDENT appeared to put forth her best effort throughout the testing. On the WISC-III, STUDENT received a verbal IQ of 99, a performance IQ of 90, and a full scale IQ of 94. All are within the average range. In the performance area, STUDENT had great difficulty in the areas of block design (scaled score of 4), object assembly (scaled score of 6), and, to a lesser extent, coding (scaled score of 7). These scores indicated weak understanding of part-whole relationships and poor psychomotor speed when new learning is involved. STUDENT showed impulsivity in her approach to the written arithmetic test (scaled score of 5), block design multiple choice (scaled score of 5) and Elithorn Mazes (scaled score of 6). STUDENT also demonstrated problems with working memory, both auditory and visual, based on her scores on letter span (scaled score of 5) and spatial span (scaled score of 6). STUDENT’s scores on the CTONI confirmed her overall scores on the WISC-III. On the CTONI, STUDENT received a nonverbal IQ of 94, a pictorial nonverbal IQ of 96, and a geometric nonverbal IQ of 94. Again, these scores are all within the average range.

On the WJ-R, most of STUDENT’s scores were in the expected range given her IQ scores. However, there were notable exceptions. In the Basic Writing Skills cluster, STUDENT scored a 62.(Footnote 6) STUDENT also received a score of 68 on the punctuation and capitalization subtest, and a score of 66 on the usage subtest. STUDENT was given the GORT-3 to measure her reading rate accuracy and comprehension. Her standard score of 8 was low average, but within the expected range given her IQ. STUDENT did very poorly on the VMI (a test of visual-motor integration). Her standard score of 67 was in the 1st percentile, and considered moderately impaired.

STUDENT was given the CVLT-C to test her auditory acquisition and memory. STUDENT’s scores on the various trials and subtests were somewhat inconsistent. However, her scaled score on the total trials was a 39 (the mean is 50), which is mildly impaired. Her scores suggest that STUDENT was able to encode information into memory, but had mild difficulty retrieving this information from memory. On the VADS, STUDENT received relatively low scores in all areas, indicating that STUDENT’s learning was not strong in any particular modality. STUDENT did best with visual input and intersensory integration.

Dr. Markel diagnosed STUDENT as having a disorder of written expression and a learning disorder affecting visual-motor integration. Dr. Markel also was concerned about the possibility of an attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder because of STUDENT’s behaviors during the testing. Dr. Markel recommended further evaluation in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy and assistive technology. Dr. Markel believed that STUDENT would benefit from instruction in a small class, with a low student-to-teacher ratio. She also recommended repetition of material to improve learning, with care taken to avoid presenting too much information too quickly. Because of STUDENT’s short auditory attention span, she would benefit from shorter periods of instruction. In testimony, Dr. Markel was asked to compare her testing to the testing done by the District in 1997 and 1998. Dr. Markel could not explain the big difference in IQ scores, but believed that STUDENT’s reported extreme passivity and lack of investment in testing in 1997 and 1998 may have been a factor. Dr. Markel also believed that the passage of time, and the difference in STUDENT’s age could account for much of the discrepancy in results.

In September 2000, STUDENT underwent vision testing by Dr. Claude Valenti (Student Exhibit 28). However, Dr. Valenti did not testify. Dr. Donald Janiak testified regarding Dr. Valenti’s test results. Dr. Janiak has never examined STUDENT, was not present when the testing was done, and had not spoken to Dr. Valenti regarding the test results. Dr. Valenti administered the Southern California Visual Performance Scale. Dr. Janiak explained that this is a screening exam, rather than a full, comprehensive evaluation. STUDENT’s biggest problem areas were in tracking and locating skills. In particular, STUDENT scored poorly on pursuit (following a moving object) and convergence (the ability of both eyes to together as an object gets closer). STUDENT also scored in the unskilled range in saccadic (the ability of the eye to move from word to word on a page). However, Dr. Janiak explained that the scoring on this test is somewhat subjective. Dr. Valenti also administered the Reading Profile Visagraph version 2.10. Dr. Janiak testified that this test uses sensors to monitor eye movement while the subject is reading. The scoring is done by a computer and is completely objective. STUDENT was asked to read second-grade material. STUDENT did very poorly on this test. Many of the calculations had to be extrapolated because there were not enough “return sweeps” for proper scoring.(Footnote 7) Overall, STUDENT was operating at a less than first-grade level. This indicates a lag in visual-motor development of between two and three years. Dr. Janiak also stated that the Visagraph results should be compared to the results of cognitive testing, such as a WISC-3. This was not done in this case. In conclusion, Dr. Janiak stated that Dr. Valenti’s testing was limited, but it indicated that STUDENT needs a comprehensive evaluation in this area.

In October 2000, STUDENT underwent a speech and language assessment in October 2000 by Susan Berkowitz (Student Exhibit 29). Susan Berkowitz is a speech and language pathologist in private practice. She has a master’s in speech and audiology and a master’s in education. Ms. Berkowitz found STUDENT to be somewhat distractable during testing, and felt she tired easily. She saw some impulsivity in STUDENT’s testing, but overall STUDENT seemed to be making a good effort. Ms. Berkowitz administered the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-3 (CELF-3), the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test, the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL), and the Test of Written Language (TOWL-3).

The LAC is a test of phonological and metalinguistic awareness at the sound level. STUDENT performed at the fourth- to fifth-grade level, making only a few errors. The CELF-3 tests receptive and expressive language. STUDENT received a receptive language score of 82, and expressive language score of 57, and a total language score of 67. The mean on all three scales is 100. On the Expressive One Word Picture Test, STUDENT scored a 97. The CASL tests oral language processing systems of auditory comprehension, oral expression, and word retrieval; knowledge and use of words and grammatical structure; ability to use language for specific tasks requiring higher level cognitive functioning; and knowledge and use of language in communicative contexts. STUDENT demonstrated more difficulty with expressive language than with receptive language. Her weakest area was the expressive syntax task, on which she scored a 72, in the 3rd percentile. STUDENT scored in the 14th percentile on antonyms, also an expressive language task. Her other scores were in the 34th percentile on nonliteral language and the 42nd percentile in paragraph comprehension. The TOWL-3 evaluates linguistic, conventional and cognitive components of written language. STUDENT’s overall score was in the 7th percentile. She had particular trouble with spelling and style, scoring in the 5th and 2nd percentile respectively. STUDENT could not be scored on any of the spontaneous writing subtests because her writing sample was less than 40 words. In summary, Ms. Berkowitz concluded that STUDENT has a significant expressive language disorder.

She had marked difficulties with memory, retrieval, morphological and syntactical skills, and with organizational skills. STUDENT also had significant difficulty with all aspects of written language skills. Ms. Berkowitz recommended STUDENT receive speech and language therapy.

Ms. Berkowitz was asked to compare her testing to the testing done by the District in 1997 and 1998. First, Ms. Berkowitz noted that although STUDENT failed the CELF-3 screening test in 1997, the examiner had not administered the full CELF-3. Instead, STUDENT was given the TOLD-P:2. This test does not have as many subtests as the CELF-3, and is not as comprehensive. In addition, the same tests were given in both 1997 and 1998. Ms. Berkowitz stated that it is not considered “best practices” to give the same tests less than a year apart. However, STUDENT’s areas of weakness (sentence imitation and syntax) were the same in both 1997 and 1998. Furthermore, these areas of weakness continued to be areas of weakness for STUDENT in 2000; however, the gap between STUDENT and her peers had become wider by 2000. Ms. Berkowitz stated that the increased gap could be due to the passage of time. With a child STUDENT’s age, some of the weaknesses would simply not have been as apparent on testing at six or seven years old as they are at ten years old. Ms. Berkowitz stated that the biggest difference between the testing done in 1997 and 1998 and her testing was the scope.

During the summer of 2000, MOTHER decided to enroll STUDENT in the New Bridge school for the 2000-2001 school year. New Bridge is a certified nonpublic school located in Poway, California. MOTHER stated that, initially, she had intended to give the District the evaluations she had had done. She held off because she wanted all the assessments to be completed before she presented them. However, by the time Ms. Berkowitz completed her report in October 2000, STUDENT was already attending New Bridge. MOTHER chose New Bridge because she understood that it specialized in helping children with learning disabilities. Dr. Markel is familiar with the New Bridge school. She had visited the school within a few weeks of testifying. Dr. Markel stated that it is the kind of program she would have recommended for STUDENT. Dr. Markel stated that the school features small class sizes, a well-trained staff, programs appropriate to STUDENT’s needs, speech and language services on campus, and a minimum of distractions in the environment. Steven Mayo, the director of the New Bridge school, also testified. Mr. Mayo stated that the school serves students with disabilities in kindergarten through eighth grade. New Bridge is a transitional program. It specializes in taking children who are behind and teaching them to compensate for their disabilities, getting them to age-level performance, and then transitioning them back into their regular schools. This process usually takes two to three years. STUDENT did a two-week trial visit during the summer of 2000. As a result of this visit, Mr. Mayo decided that New Bridge would be an appropriate school for STUDENT. At the beginning of the year, Mr. Mayo, along with STUDENT’s phonics teacher and her regular education teacher, developed goals and objectives for STUDENT (Student Exhibit 34). The goals for STUDENT were as follows:

(1) By June 2001, STUDENT will write a 3-paragraph essay, edited in the final draft for spelling and grammar on 4/6 occasions as measured by work samples. (2) By June 2001, STUDENT will use learned strategies to encode and decode 3 syllable words with the vowel patterns: diphthongs, digraphs and consonant-le with 80% accuracy as measured by tests and work samples. (3) By June 2001, STUDENT will recognize and correct spelling errors in her written work 80% of the time as measured by first and final writing samples. (4) By June 2001, STUDENT will read from a variety of 5th grade materials with fluency and speed and no more than 3 miscues in 175 words, and answer comprehension questions with 80% accuracy as measured by teacher records. (5) By June 2001, STUDENT will multiply and divide 3 digit numbers by 2 digit numbers with 80% accuracy as measured by work samples.

Mr. Mayo also taught STUDENT in the combined third and fourth-grade class at the beginning of the year. Mr. Mayo was transitioning a new teacher into STUDENT’s class, so he gradually reduced his teaching time during the year. STUDENT currently has two teachers, a primary teacher and a phonics teacher. Mr. Mayo has contact with both at least weekly. The class size is seven students to one teacher. STUDENT is getting speech and language services in her regular class (not pull-out services). In addition, STUDENT receives 40 minutes of phonics each day. At first, STUDENT was anxious about starting New Bridge, which is not unusual for new students. In STUDENT’s case, the anxiety level was higher, and lasted longer. STUDENT did become much more comfortable as the year progressed. STUDENT is now less timid in class and much more willing to speak out when she does not understand things. Mr. Mayo testified that, in general, STUDENT works very hard, and is willing to do things over and over until she gets them right.

Mr. Mayo stated that in class, STUDENT has demonstrated, among other things, memory problems, problems with audio processing overload, organizational problems, problems with multi-step instructions, and writing problems. Although STUDENT enjoys writing, it is a particularly weak area for her. She expresses good ideas, but has difficulty getting them down on paper. She tends to leave parts out of sentences. STUDENT’s teachers have also seen problems with attention. At this point, her teachers are not sure whether STUDENT’s attentional problems are due to audio processing overload, or a possible attention deficit disorder. Mr. Mayo has also observed some things that indicate to him that STUDENT may have trouble hearing. At times, STUDENT would cup her hand behind her good ear, especially when there is background noise. Overall, Mr. Mayo felt that STUDENT made good, steady progress toward all of her goals. Her anxiety level and self-esteem have improved. He feels that STUDENT can achieve age-level work, though it may never be automatic for her. STUDENT is also attending summer school at New Bridge.

At home, both GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER have noticed a change in STUDENT since she started New Bridge. GRANDMOTHER noticed that STUDENT gained confidence after starting at New Bridge. STUDENT now does her homework by herself, and seems to love school. There are no longer any long emotional nights spent working on homework. MOTHER testified to similar observations. She added that since STUDENT started at New Bridge, she seems to actually enjoy doing her homework. STUDENT filed her request for a due process hearing on September 18, 2000.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years because of the district’s failure to find her eligible for special education on or after September 18, 1997?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). However, as set forth in the “Procedural History” portion of this decision, a student must be eligible as a student with a disabilities before he or she is entitled to a FAPE. The District never made a formal offer of placement and services, so the only issue to be addressed for the three years in question is whether STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services during each of those years.

Under California special education law, a child is eligible for special education and related services if he or she meets the definition of a child with a disability, as set forth in the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i), and, as a result of the impairment, requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b). The disabilities identified in the IDEA are mental retardation; hearing, speech or language, visual, orthopedic, and other health impairments; emotional disturbance; autism; traumatic brain injury; and specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); see Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(a)-(j). The question of STUDENT’s eligibility will be examined separately for each year in question.

The 1997-1998 School Year

As background to this school year, it must be remembered that STUDENT was referred for special education by her first-grade teacher in April 1997. At the May 1997 IEP meeting, the District found that STUDENT was eligible under mental retardation based upon her low IQ scores. STUDENT’s mother declined eligibility under mental retardation. STUDENT was in Ms. Koon’s second-grade class during 1997-1998 school year. Ms. Koon referred STUDENT for special education in January 1998. Dr. Lee described the results of this meeting in her testimony:

The results once again were that the team offered qualification to STUDENT, but the only way was under the scores generated the previous year, which would have resulted in a label of either developmentally delayed, and therefore mentally retarded, or just mentally retarded, and MOTHER declined, and we understood, and so the team agreed that the finding was not qualification.(Footnote 8)

These facts are undisputed, and raise two questions. First, can a parent refuse special education eligibility? Second, having found eligibility, can the District come back now, and argue that STUDENT was never actually eligible for special education?

Dr. Lee, the District director of special education, stated that it is her opinion that the District must respect the sanctity of a parent’s right to refuse special education services. Was the District justified in accepting MOTHER’ refusal of services in this case?

California Education Code Section 56346 states, in part:

(a) No pupil shall be required to participate in all or part of any special education program unless the parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the individualized education program, and after this notice, consents, in writing, to all or part of the individualized education program. If the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized education program, then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil. (b) If the district, special education local plan area, or county office determines that the part of the proposed special education program to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil, a due process hearing shall be initiated pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500)...

Code Section 56346 implies that a parent has the right to refuse special education services, in whole or in part. However, the law anticipates that the District would have made an offer of an actual program, rather than mere eligibility. The law requires not just an offer, but a formal written offer setting forth both placement and services as well as the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable. The District could not avoid this responsibility simply because MOTHER expressed an unwillingness to accept its offer. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). As the Court in Union pointed out, this formal requirement of a written offer has an important purpose that is not merely technical; in this case, the written offer would have alerted MOTHER to the need to consider seriously whether STUDENT required special education, and whether the District’s offer was an appropriate placement under the IDEA. MOTHER stated that she did not even understand why the District had found STUDENT eligible under mental retardation. The District failed to make any offer of placement, much less a written offer. In fact, the IEP document does not even reflect that the team found STUDENT eligible. The District may believe strongly that the parent has the right to refuse services, and that the right should be respected, but the law requires that the parent be fully informed of what services are being offered and why the District is making that offer. Given the District’s failure to make any kind of appropriate offer, MOTHER’s refusal of services should not have been relied upon by the District, and will not shield the District from potential responsibility for its failure to provide special education services to STUDENT.

The District’s other argument related to this issue is that STUDENT was never really eligible for special education services because the District was able to successfully modify STUDENT’s regular education program such that her educational needs were effectively met.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Determining if a student’s IEP was reasonably calculated to provide a student with some educational benefit involves a case-by-case analysis of the facts. Each child's academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child's potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). As this is the basic standard for educating a child with a disability, there is no reason to believe that the law intended that a student who isn’t eligible deserves less.

In this case, STUDENT was unable to meet even the most basic standard of advancing from grade to grade. STUDENT had been referred for special education by her teachers in both 1997 and 1998. Both teachers stated that they referred STUDENT because they had each tried significant modifications to the curriculum and STUDENT still needed more help. In the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT was nominally in the second grade, but was still doing only first-grade work. STUDENT was also given preferential seating and additional assistance from a special education aide in class. Despite these modifications, STUDENT still had difficulty understanding concepts, and was progressing slower that the rest of the class. Dr. Lee, the school psychologist and director of special education, noted in the report of her assessment of STUDENT that STUDENT needed intensive support in order to succeed in school. Dr. Lee, Ms. Koon and Ms. Jensen all stated that they were frustrated by MOTHER’s refusal of special education at the 1998 IEP meeting. STUDENT’s difficulties were not due to a lack of effort and Ms. Koon repeatedly stated, as did all STUDENT’s teachers, that STUDENT tried very hard. STUDENT’s mother and grandmother testified that STUDENT worked long hours on her homework, and was frequently reduced to tears. Finally, at the end of 1997-1998 school year, the District decided that it might be best to retain STUDENT in the second grade. On the SAT-9 test given at the end of the year, STUDENT scored in the 9th percentile in total reading and in the 1st percentile in total math. STUDENT received private tutoring over the summer. In September, it was decided that STUDENT needed to repeat the second grade. Despite the extra assistance, modification of the program and private tutoring, STUDENT was not able to advance to the next grade. On the student retention form, it was noted that STUDENT had received small-group and individualized instruction, preferential seating, peer and cross-age tutoring, and ability-level instruction. STUDENT was still below grade level in all areas. For the 1997-1998 school year, the District was not able to meet STUDENT’s educational needs through modification of the regular curriculum.

The District found STUDENT eligible for special education for the 1997-1998 school year. Although MOTHER refused the eligibility, the District’s “offer” was so lacking in every aspect required by law that MOTHER had no way of understanding why the District found STUDENT eligible, or what placement and services she was refusing. In light of STUDENT’s significant academic struggles, and resulting lack of progress, STUDENT required special education instruction, services, or both, which could not be provided with modification of the regular education program. The combination of the District’s finding of eligibility, and STUDENT’s need for special education services, establishes that STUDENT was eligible for special education during the 1997-1998 school year.

The 1998-1999 School Year

During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT repeated the second grade. She was in Ms. McEvoy’s class. There was no additional referral for special education. The issues for this year are essentially the same as for the previous school year. Audiological testing was done in March 1999. However, the testing was very minimal in scope, and did nothing to show whether or not STUDENT had trouble hearing in class. In January 1999, a student intervention team meeting was held. It was noted that STUDENT was seeing Ms. Jensen, the RSP teacher, every day for extra assistance. STUDENT also received small-group instruction in class, as well as the assistance of an aide. STUDENT continued to work hard, but remained one of the lowest performing students in class. At the end of the year, Ms. McEvoy was concerned that STUDENT was still not ready for the third grade, and recommended summer school. SAT-9 testing done in April 1999 did show a significant improvement over the previous year. However, test level of this SAT 9 (Primary 2) was the same test level as the SAT 9 STUDENT took in 1998. Therefore, her improvement was less significant. In spite of all the services STUDENT was receiving in Ms. McEvoy’s class, STUDENT still tested in the 19th percentile in total reading and the 18th percentile in total math. Her language score improved dramatically to the 60th percentile.

There is nothing in the facts that would suggest that STUDENT’s eligibility for special education did not continue through the 1998-1999 school year. The District continues to argue that it was able to successfully modify STUDENT’s regular education program such that her educational needs were effectively met without special education. For the 1998-1999 school year, the evidence establishes that the District was again unable to meet STUDENT’s education needs with modification of the regular education program. STUDENT did advance to the third grade at the conclusion of the year. However, the Supreme Court in Rowley specifically rejected the notion that advancing from grade to grade in a regular public school system is the sole test of an appropriate public education. During this school year, STUDENT was repeating the second grade, receiving a high level of assistance during the year, and was still barely able to advance to the next grade. In spite of all of the help provided, STUDENT did not make up any ground on her classmates. She started the year as one of the lowest performing students, and ended the year as one of the lowest performing student. When a student repeats a grade, she should end up as one of the higher students in her class, not one of the lower. Considering STUDENT’s minimal progress, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not able to provide her with an appropriate education through modification of the regular program.

STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education during the 1998-1999 school year on the basis of the District’s finding of eligibility in 1998. In addition, STUDENT continued to need special education and related services to benefit from her education. The 1999-2000 School Year

STUDENT was in Mr. Dennett’s third-grade class during 1999-2000 school year. She was evaluated by Dr. Nancy Markel in January and February 2000. Counsel for Student argues that Dr. Markel’s report supports a finding that STUDENT qualified for special education under the category of specific learning disability (SLD). Dr. Lee, on behalf of the District, testified that Dr. Markel’s report did not establish eligibility under SLD.

California Education Code § 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas:

(1) Oral expression;

(2) Listening comprehension;

(3) Written expression;

(4) Basic reading skills;

(5) Reading comprehension;

(6) Mathematics calculation;

(7) Mathematics reasoning.

(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.

(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(B), or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(C)). California Code of Regulations Section 3030(j)(4)(A) sets forth the method by which to establish a severe discrepancy for students for whom standardized tests are considered invalid. There was no credible testimony that the use of standardized tests was invalid in assessing STUDENT's ability or achievement. Furthermore, Dr. Lee testified that she had no reason to believe that Dr. Markel’s testing was invalid, nor does the District argue that this testing was invalid. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT's standardized assessment scores on Dr. Markel’s testing were valid and could have been appropriately used to determine whether she qualified for special education services. Therefore, to determine if a severe discrepancy existed, STUDENT's scores on standardized intellectual testing can be compared with her scores on achievement testing. When standardized tests are considered valid, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:

[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. A computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, the adjustment not to exceed 4 common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).

In this case, STUDENT’s testing demonstrated a severe discrepancy in the area of written expression. On Dr. Markel’s testing, STUDENT received IQ scores on the WISC-III of 99 on Verbal, 90 on Performance, and a full scale IQ of 94. STUDENT was also given the CTONI, another test of cognitive ability. On this test, she received IQ scores of 94 for Nonverbal, 96 for Pictorial Nonverbal, and 94 for Geometric Nonverbal. The similarity of scores within each test, and between the two tests supports the conclusion that these tests presented an accurate representation of STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. Dr. Lee was asked how these tests could be valid and show an IQ so much higher than what she found when she tested STUDENT in 1997 and 1998. She stated that there were numerous factors that could explain the change. One factor was what she called “examiner effect.” She stated that studies had shown that the examiner’s interaction with the testee, though not violating any of the protocols of the test, could have a significant effect on how the testee performed. In this case, “examiner effect” may have contributed to the significant increase in STUDENT’s tested IQ. Dr. Lee noted that in 1997 and 1998 STUDENT seemed extremely passive and not invested in testing or in doing well. In fact Dr. Lee concluded that STUDENT’s behavior in 1997 might have artificially depressed her IQ score. This description of STUDENT is quite different from that provided by all of her teachers, as well as the other assessors. STUDENT is always described as very hard working, and always appearing to be very interested in doing well at school and in testing. Although STUDENT has been described as having trouble with attention and impulsivity, effort has never been a question, except in relation to Dr. Lee’s testing. For some reason, Dr. Lee and STUDENT did not establish a good rapport in both 1997 and 1998. Because of this lack of rapport, STUDENT was extremely passive, displayed a lack of effort, and was not invested in doing well on the testing. This behavior resulted in artificially low IQ scores. Therefore, it appears that “examiner effect” accounts, at least in part, for the significant increase in STUDENT’s tested IQ.

On her achievement testing, STUDENT scored in the expected range in almost all areas. The notable exception is in the area of written expression, specifically in the area of writing skills. On the Basic Writing Skills Cluster, STUDENT received a score of 62. The mean for this test is 100, with a standard deviation of 15. Therefore, STUDENT’s score on the Basic Writing Skills Cluster is 32 points, more that two standard deviations below her full scale IQ score of 94. STUDENT also did poorly on the supplemental tests in Punctuation and Capitalization, with a score of 68; and in Usage, with a score of 66. Both of theses tests are in the area of writing skills. These scores are both more than one-and-a-half standard deviations below STUDENT’s full scale IQ score. The District, and Dr. Lee, argued that “writing skills” is not a proper category for comparison with respect to SLD eligibility. Dr. Lee points out that the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-educational Batter-Revised (WJ-R) has a Battery Cluster titled “written expression,” the same title used in the statute. “Writing skills” is not specifically listed in the statute as one of the academic areas for comparison. Therefore, the District argues that only the scores on the WJ-R “written expression” cluster can be considered in assessing the academic area of written expression. However, the District offers no legal support for this argument, nor is the argument logical. The statute refers to “written expression” as an academic area. This description gives the term “written expression” a broad meaning that encompasses all areas of writing. Writing skills is one part of the broader academic area of written expression. There is no reason to believe that the legislature intended that the term “written expression,” as used in the statute, was intended to refer only to the WJ-R battery cluster by the same name.

STUDENT’s scores in writing skills on the WJ-R were consistently one-and-one-half standard deviations or more below her full scale IQ score of 94. Writing skills is an aspect of the academic area of written expression. This discrepancy has been corroborated by other assessment data. STUDENT’s IQ score was corroborated by the results of the CTONI. STUDENT’s teachers have consistently rated her writing skills as one of her weakest areas. On Ms. McEvoy’s 1998-1999 progress report, she rated STUDENT’s writing skills as “S-,” or the low end of a developing skill. In the 1999-2000 school year, Mr. Dennett stated that the quality of STUDENT’s written expression was one of the lowest in class. Furthermore, he stated that the quality did not really improve during the year, though the quantity did. Therefore, STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and her achievement in the academic area of written expression.

The second part of the test requires that the discrepancy be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. Basic psychological processes include attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, and conceptualization and expression. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(1)). Testing indicated that STUDENT suffered from disorders in the areas of auditory processing, visual-motor skills, and possibly attention. STUDENT’s scores on the CVLT-C, a test of auditory acquisition and memory, placed her in the mildly impaired range. This indicated a problem with STUDENT’s auditory processing. STUDENT scored very poorly, in the 1st percentile, on the VMI. This indicates a significant impairment in STUDENT’s visual-motor skills. STUDENT has repeatedly been described as having problems with attention and impulsivity. It is not clear whether STUDENT’s attention problems are a result of her auditory processing disorder, an attention deficit disorder, or both. Dr. Markel stated that STUDENT’s problems in written expression are likely a result of the combination of the above disorders. No evidence was presented that suggested any other possible cause of STUDENT’s deficiency in written expression. In fact, the evidence suggests that STUDENT’s environment had, if anything, a positive effect on her education. Dr. Lee testified that STUDENT’s home environment appeared to be supportive of, and beneficial to, her academic achievement.

The final part of the standard requires that the discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Here, as in the past years, the District argues that it was able to address STUDENT’s discrepancy through modifications made within her regular instruction. However, the evidence shows that STUDENT, though making progress, still struggled in the same basic areas and actually lost ground during the 1999-2000 school year when compared to her peers. During the third grade, STUDENT was receiving pull-out assistance in language arts for thirty minutes every day. In addition, Mr. Dennett spent a significant amount of time with STUDENT in class, gave her preferential seating, and teamed her with good students who could provide her with additional help. STUDENT also was permitted to take home assignments and tests so that she could get extra assistance. Furthermore, as all of her other teachers had stated, STUDENT continued to try hard. In spite of all these measures, STUDENT still struggled. She had trouble with her multiplication tables, trouble with reading comprehension, trouble with sequencing, and trouble with written expression. On several occasions, STUDENT confided to Mr. Dennett that she felt “dumb.” Mr. Dennett even considered referring STUDENT for special education. He did not, in part because he knew she had been referred twice before, and he thought that STUDENT’s family did not want her in special education.

The District also points to STUDENT’s April 2000 SAT-9 scores as proof that she made more than a year’s progress in the third grade. The District argues that if STUDENT made only a year’s progress, her standard scores on the SAT-9 should have been the same in April 1999 and in April 2000. Because STUDENT’s standard score went up in all areas, STUDENT had made more than one year’s progress. However, when the percentile scores are compared, it demonstrates that STUDENT lost ground in the reading and language categories when compared to her classmates. STUDENT’s total reading score dropped from the 19th percentile in 1999 to the 17th percentile in 2000. Most dramatically, STUDENT’s language score dropped from the 60th percentile in 1999 to the 17th percentile in 2000. This testing corroborates Dr. Markel’s testimony that, because STUDENT had not received special education services in past years, the gap between STUDENT and her peers had widened since 1998, and would continue to widen. Even after repeating the second grade, and with all the extra help the District provided, STUDENT was only, as Mr. Dennett put it, keeping her head above water. A student who is keeping his or her head above water is not necessarily making adequate progress - he or she is simply not drowning. The pattern of the previous two years, combined with the widening gap as demonstrated by the SAT-9 testing, establishes that the District was not able to successfully address STUDENT’s severe discrepancies through modification within her regular instruction.

Testing demonstrated a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of written expression. This discrepancy was the result of the combination of an auditory processing disorder, a disorder of visual-motor skills, and possibly an attentional disorder. The District was not able to correct this discrepancy through services offered within the regular instructional program. The hearing officer finds that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category SLD for the 1999-2000 school year.

STUDENT also received speech and language, and audiological testing during the 1999-2000 school year. The examiner who performed this assessment, Lora Zaroff, did not testify. Nothing is known of her qualifications. Robin Lipton, a speech pathologist with the District, did testify. She attempted to interpret the audiological results contained in Ms. Zaroff’s testing. However, Ms. Lipton is not an audiologist. Furthermore, she became somewhat confused in her description of the results of the audiological tests. Finally, these tests were performed in a controlled situation, and have little relevance to how well STUDENT was able to hear in a classroom setting. In addition, the speech and language assessment was very limited in scope. In light of the foregoing factors, the report of Laura Zaroff is given little weight. The evidence is not sufficient to establish the presence of any other qualifying impairment during the 1999-2000 school year.

For the reasons set forth above, STUDENT was eligible for special education during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years. The District failed to make any offer of special education placement or services in any of those years. Therefore, STUDENT was denied a free and appropriate education during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years.

Issue Number 2:Was STUDENT eligible for special education during the 2000-2001 school year?

As stated in the previous section, STUDENT was eligible for special education during the 1999-2000 school year under the category SLD. As STUDENT’s disability was not being effectively addressed by the District, there is no reason to believe that STUDENT did not continue to be eligible under this category during the 2000-2001 school year. Additional testing was done in September and October 2000 that gives rise to the possibility of eligibility in other categories. Specifically, STUDENT was assessed in the areas of speech and language, and vision.

California Education Code Section 56333 states that the following requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a speech or language disability:

A pupil shall be assessed as having a language or speech disorder which makes him or her eligible for special education and related services when he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services.

This disability can be established by meeting the following criteria:

Language Disorder. The pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when he or she meets one of the following criteria: (A) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan...5 C.C.R. § 3030(c)(4).

Susan Berkowitz performed the speech and language evaluation. The District does not contest the actual results of the testing. Dr. Lee stated that she believed that Ms. Berkowitz did a very good job in her evaluation. Furthermore, Dr. Lee stated that a disability in the area of expressive language would be consistent with her own testing in 1997 and 1998. Dr. Lee stated that such a disability was consistent with STUDENT’s achieving a higher IQ score on the KABC in 1998 than she did on the WISC-3 in 1997. The District does contend that the report, on its own, does not meet the criteria set forth above. Although the District concedes that the testing establishes a severe discrepancy (more than 1.5 standard deviations, in the area of expressive language as shown on the CELF-3(Footnote), the District points out that the law requires that the severe discrepancy appear on at least two standardized tests. It contends that Ms. Berkowitz’s report failed to demonstrate a severe discrepancy in expressive language on a second test. Much of the testing Ms. Berkowitz performed was in the area of written language. On the TOWL-3, a test of written language, STUDENT scored in the 5th percentile in spelling and 2nd percentile in style. Her overall written language quotient was in the 7th percentile. Although these results further corroborate Dr. Markel’s conclusion, that STUDENT has a disorder affecting written expression, they do not establish a disability in the area of expressive language. Education Code Section 56333 addresses spoken language only, not written language. However, Ms. Berkowitz did administer the CASL an assessment of spoken language. On the syntax subtest, STUDENT scored in the 3rd percentile. The subtest score is consistent with STUDENT’s past speech and language testing in 1997 and 1998. Testing in both of those years showed that STUDENT was weak in the area of syntax. The score also serves as a second standardized test showing a severe discrepancy in one of the specified areas. The District argues that the score should not be considered because Ms. Berkowitz did not give all of the CASL’s subtests. Ms. Berkowitz explained that this was the last test given and that STUDENT was becoming restive. There is no evidence to support the District’s argument that the failure to give all of the subtests negates the results of the subtests actually given.

Robin Lipton, the District’s speech pathologist, did testify regarding Ms. Berkowitz’s report. However, Ms. Lipton stated that she is not familiar with the CASL, and looked only at the protocols provided by STUDENT. She stated that only subtest scores were given, not a total score. She did confirm that the CASL is a test of expressive language. Ms. Lipton’s testimony does not support the District’s argument. First, Ms. Lipton stated that she is unfamiliar with the CASL. Second, she offered no opinion as to whether the subtest scores that were reported were valid. Ms. Berkowitz however did state that the test results of the CASL were valid. The subtest score in syntax relates directly to one of the areas of language development set forth in the regulations, is a measure of expressive language, and demonstrates a severe discrepancy in that area. The previous analysis of STUDENT’s performance, or lack thereof, during the preceding three years in the regular education program establishes that STUDENT’s education was adversely affected by her disabilities, and that she required special education services in order to benefit from her education. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the report of Susan Berkowitz establishes that STUDENT had a qualifying disability that affected her ability to use spoken language.

STUDENT also was assessed in the area of a vision impairment by Dr. Claude Valenti. To qualify for special education based upon a vision impairment, the pupil must have a visual impairment which, even with correction, affects a pupil’s educational performance. 5 C.F.R. 3030((d). Dr. Valenti did not testify. Although the testing did indicate that STUDENT had a severe impairment in the area of visual-motor development, Dr. Janiak stated that the testing was limited in scope and that STUDENT needed a more comprehensive evaluation in this area. Given the limited nature of the testing, and the fact that the doctor who performed the testing did not testify, the results are not enough to establish a qualifying disability in the area of visual impairment.

STUDENT continued to be qualified for special education under the category of SLD during the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT also qualified for special education under the category of a speech and language disorder in that school year.

Issue Number 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and transportation costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the New Bridge School during the 2000-2001 school year?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) Because of the District’s failure to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years, STUDENT’s mother has satisfied the first part of the test set forth above.

To determine whether the STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement of STUDENT at the New Bridge School, it must also be determined whether the placement was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School District, Four v. Carter (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, the Court held that parents may receive reimbursement for their unilateral placement even if the placement does not meet certain requirements of the IDEA. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the child’s IEP, and need not provide a placement that is certified by the state. Moreover, the parents’ unilateral placement is not required to be in the least restrictive environment. However, while the parents’ placement need not be an exact proper placement under the IDEA, the placement still must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. (Florence v. Carter, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) In this case, there does not appear to be any real dispute that the placement at New Bridge School was appropriate. Mr. Dennett, STUDENT’s third grade teacher, reviewed the goals and objectives formulated for STUDENT by New Bridge. He stated that they appeared to be appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Markel stated that she had visited New Bridge, and felt it was the kind of program she would have recommended for STUDENT. Dr. Lee stated that there was nothing about the New Bridge School that she disapproved of. She stated that she wished the District could educate its students in groups of seven. In its closing argument, the District notes that New Bridge may not be the least restrictive environment, but this is not part of the standard for a unilateral placement. In addition, STUDENT appears to have made progress at New Bridge. Mr. Mayo testified that STUDENT has progressed toward her goals in all areas. MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER both noted a significant change in STUDENT’s confidence, and in her attitude toward both school and homework. STUDENT no longer cries over her homework at night. She works on her homework without assistance, and seems to actually enjoy it. STUDENT’s placement at the New Bridge School was a proper placement under the IDEA.

In considering whether to order reimbursement, and if so how much, the actions of both parties must be considered. Town of Burlington, 471 U.S. at 373. The District argues that, with respect to reimbursement, the courts have made a distinction between a unilateral parental transfer made after consultation with the school system and a transfer made truly unilaterally, bereft of any attempt to achieve a mediated compromise. Ash v. Lake Oswego School District, 980 F.2d 585, 589 (9th Cir. 1992). Such a distinction need not be made in this case, because this is not a case of a truly unilateral transfer. The District had twice referred STUDENT for assessments for special education eligibility. In spite of finding eligibility at two IEP meetings, the District never made any offer of placement and services. The District had constant access to STUDENT during the years following her last IEP, and was as aware as STUDENT’s parents of her struggles in school. The District had repeated opportunities to offer STUDENT a FAPE, and failed to do so. On the other hand, MOTHER had obtained evaluations that showed that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and a language disability. She did not share these reports with the District. Instead, she placed STUDENT in a private school. Was MOTHER obligated to share these new evaluations with the District and allow it a third chance to offer an appropriate placement? Under the facts of this case, the answer is no. MOTHER testified that she was becoming increasingly frustrated over STUDENT’s situation. Year after year, she was being told by STUDENT’s teachers that STUDENT always tried hard, but was always one of the lowest performing students in class. STUDENT continued to cry over her homework at night. At two IEP meetings, the IEP team had told MOTHER that STUDENT qualified for special education, but offered no services, and presented MOTHER with IEP forms that said STUDENT was not eligible for services. Under these circumstance, it was not unreasonable for MOTHER to unilaterally enroll STUDENT in a private school without giving the District another opportunity to develop an appropriate program. After considering the actions of both parties, it is found that the evidence does not support a reduction in the amount of reimbursement.

STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the full cost of tuition at the New Bridge School for the 2000-2001 school year in the amount of $11,750. The District also shall reimburse the STUDENT for the cost of transportation. STUDENT shall be reimbursed for mileage of 146 miles for each day STUDENT actually attended school during the 2000-2001 school year at the rate the District reimburses its employees.(Footnote 10) Testimony established that STUDENT attended New Bridge on 179 days during that school year.

STUDENT currently is attending the summer program at New Bridge. Although MOTHER has not specifically requested reimbursement for these extended school year services, she did introduce evidence as to the cost of this program. Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1999); compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2) (1999). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:

Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.

The evidence presented does not establish that STUDENT needed ESY services to provide her with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. MOTHER stated that she enrolled STUDENT in the summer program at New Bridge because Mr. Mayo recommended it. Mr. Mayo told her that it was a general policy to recommend summer school for all New Bridge students. Mr. Mayo explained that the length of summer made it necessary for all students to take extra time in the fall to catch up to where they had been at the end of the prior year. Summer school reduced that “catch up” time. MOTHER stated that there was nothing about STUDENT’s needs in particular that made summer school necessary. The evidence does not establish that STUDENT is a student whose limited capacity would make it impossible or unlikely that the she would attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected without summer school. Therefore, summer school was not required to prevent serious regression, and reimbursement is not appropriate(Footnote 11).

Issue Number 4: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments of Dr. Nancy Markel, Susan Berkowitz and Dr. Claude Valenti?

A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show that its evaluation was appropriate at a due process hearing. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

In this case, the District evaluated STUDENT in 1997 and 1998. In 1998, it assessed STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, and speech and language. As a result of the 1998 assessments, considered with the results of the 1997 assessments, the District found STUDENT eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation. STUDENT’s mother disagreed with this conclusion and declined eligibility. No further assessments were performed until MOTHER obtained the IEEs in 2000, for which she seeks reimbursement. The District argues that the lapse of two years between the District’s assessments and the STUDENT’s assessments makes it difficult to argue that the IEEs were obtained because of disagreement with the District’s assessments. There is no requirement that an IEE be obtained within a certain time after the District’s assessments. However, there must be a causal connection. In this case, despite the passage of time, a causal connection does exist. MOTHER disagreed with the results of the District’s assessments in 1998. She disagreed with the conclusion that STUDENT was mentally retarded. MOTHER testified that she believed STUDENT was hearing impaired and might have had a learning disability. For two years MOTHER allowed the District to try to address STUDENT’s educational problems through modification of the regular education program. In addition, STUDENT had to repeat the second grade during the 1998-1999 school year. MOTHER testified that she became increasingly frustrated by being told at each parent-teacher conference that STUDENT tried very hard, but was always one of the lowest performing students in class. Finally, after consultation with STUDENT’s uncle, MOTHER decided to obtain her own assessments in January 2000. Not withstanding the passage of time, MOTHER’s decision to obtain IEEs was directly related to her disagreement with the results of the District’s testing done in 1997 and 1998.

The second part of the test for reimbursement of an IEE is that District must be unable to show that its evaluation was appropriate. For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and be tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(d) requires that aptitude and achievement tests are selected to ensure that a student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills do not affect the accuracy of the results. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a). There has been no allegation that the District’s testing was done in a discriminatory manner. Each group of testing must be looked at individually to ensure that the results were valid.

Dr. Lee, the school psychologist, performed the cognitive testing. In 1998 she administered the KABC, the Bender and the Draw-a-Person tests. She testified that the results were valid, and were basically consistent with the results of the testing done in 1997. Dr. Markel testified that she had never administered the KABC and was only familiar with it through her reading. Dr. Markel was unable to state that the results of Dr. Lee’s testing were invalid. She did question the dramatic change in STUDENT’s IQ between 1998 and 2000, but was unable to explain the cause of the change. She speculated that STUDENT’s reported behavior during testing could have been a factor. Dr. Lee was also unable to explain the change in IQ, but she agreed that STUDENT’s behavior during testing and her interaction with the tester may have been factors. The tests Dr. Lee administered were validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and the results were valid based upon the protocols.

Ms. Jensen, who administered the WJ in 1998, stated that her test results were valid. STUDENT alleges that the testing was not done according to the test instructions. Specifically, STUDENT argues that the tests were performed in a noisy environment. Ms. Jensen testified that she performed her testing in the RSP classroom, with other students present. However, there was no evidence that the environment was actually noisy. Ms. Jensen did say it was not always quiet in the RSP room, but she had no specific recollections about STUDENT’s testing in particular. There is no substantial evidence that shows that the environment STUDENT was tested in was noisy. Furthermore, the results of the testing were consistent with those of the achievement testing done in 1997. Dr. Markel stated that the results also were fairly consistent with the results she obtained in 2000. The WJ was validated for the specific purpose for which it was used.

One of the biggest questions with respect to the appropriateness of Dr. Lee’s and Ms. Jensen’s testing in 1998 involves the overall results: Why did Dr. Markel’s testing establish a learning disability, and the 1998 testing did not? Dr. Markel stated that if STUDENT had a learning disability in 2000, she had one in 1998, but that it may have looked different in 1998. Dr. Markel, Dr. Lee and Ms. Jensen all agreed that, as a child ages, the same disability may show up differently on testing. It was explained that a diagnosis of a learning disability requires a gap between ability and achievement. This gap may exist in a student in the first grade, but because the expectations are lower, the gap may not appear in testing. As the child ages, and the expectations change, the gap will become more evident in testing. Dr. Markel stated that the difference in results may have been due to time and age.

The evidence establishes that the testing done by Dr. Lee and Ms. Jensen in 1998 met the requirements set forth in Education Code Section 56320. The results, though different from those obtained by Dr. Markel in 2000, were valid. Because the District’s testing was valid, STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Markel’s testing.

Speech and language testing was also done in 1998. The testing was performed by S. Byrd. Although S. Byrd did not testify, Robin Lipton, a District speech pathologist, did testify regarding the testing done in 1998. Ms. Lipton testified that the testing appeared valid, and the report accurately reflected the protocols. Ms. Berkowitz, who performed the speech and language assessment of STUDENT in 2000, also testified regarding the prior testing. She noted that the TOLD-P:2 and PPVT-R were given in both 1997 and 1998. She stated it was not considered best practices to give the same tests less than one year apart. This may have affected the results of the testing. In addition, the District presented no evidence as to the qualifications of S. Byrd. Although the report is valid based on the protocols, there was no evidence presented that the testing was performed in accordance with the test instructions. The District has failed to establish that its speech and language assessment performed in 1998 met the requirements of Education Code Section 56320. Moreover, as stated earlier, the District has no complaint with the evaluation performed by Susan Berkowitz, for which STUDENT seeks reimbursement. Dr. Lee testified that she believed Ms. Berkowitz did a very good job. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Susan Berkowitz’s assessment.

STUDENT also seeks reimbursement for the vision testing done by Dr. Claude Valenti. The District did not perform vision testing in 1998. MOTHER testified that she obtained this evaluation on the recommendation of Dr. Markel, who based her recommendation on the results of her testing. Prior to Dr. Markel’s testing, there was no evidence of a possible vision impairment. STUDENT was given the VMI in 1997, and received a score only slightly below her age equivalent. This score is markedly different from the one STUDENT received on the same test in 2000. Again, Dr. Markel stated that the simple passage of time could explain the differences in results. If there was evidence that the District failed to assess STUDENT in an area of suspected disability, reimbursement may be appropriate. In this case, there was no evidence of a suspected vision impairment until Dr. Markel’s testing in 2000. The District was not provided with the results of Dr. Markel’s testing until April 2001, well after Dr. Valenti’s testing had been performed. Because of the lack of evidence of a vision impairment during 1997-2000, STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Valenti’s assessment.

After consideration of all the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is only entitled to reimbursement for the assessment performed by Susan Berkowitz.

However, the District does have an obligation to assess a student in all areas of suspected disability. Education Code § 56320(f). There is evidence that STUDENT has not been assessed in all areas. First, STUDENT has never had a proper assessment in the area of her hearing impairment. Specifically, STUDENT needs to have an evaluation that addresses her ability to hear in a classroom setting. In addition, the recent testing has indicated other areas that need to be assessed. Dr. Valenti’s report indicates the need for a full assessment with respect to a possible vision impairment. Dr. Markel concluded that STUDENT needed to be assessed for possible occupational therapy, assistive technology and for a possible attention deficit disorder. On the basis of this evidence, STUDENT needs the following areas:

• Hearing assessment • Vision assessment • Occupational therapy assessment(Footnote 12)

• Assistive technology assessment • Evaluation for an attention deficit disorder(Footnote 13)

Issue Number 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the STUDENT is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.

It has been established that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years. Dr. Markel’s testing showed that this denial has resulted in STUDENT’s having basic writing skills at a 1.3 grade equivalent. Her basic reading skills were only at a 2.3 grade equivalent. Of all the areas tested, only STUDENT’s math skills were at the third grade level. STUDENT was supposed to be entering the fourth grade. In addition, STUDENT had already repeated the second grade, so her age-equivalent peers would have been entering the fifth grade. Furthermore, the results of the CELF-3 found STUDENT’s total language skills (receptive and expressive combined) at an age equivalent of less than five years old. STUDENT was ten years old when she took this test. This evidence establishes that the past denials of a FAPE have left STUDENT from 2.6 to 3.6 years behind her age-equivalent peers in most academic areas. More significantly, STUDENT’s total language skills are over five years behind those of her peers. In addition, Susan Berkowitz testified that STUDENT is at an age when she needs to solidify her basic skills and begin learning strategies to deal with her disabilities. Ms. Berkowitz stated that if a student is still learning her basic skills in middle school, it may be too late for her ever to catch up with her peers. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concluded that STUDENT now requires an intensive program to allow her the chance to eventually be able to do age-equivalent work. STUDENT requires instruction that is highly structured, in a class with a small student-teacher ratio. STUDENT will require preferential seating in the classroom. STUDENT’s teacher should be trained in teaching students with auditory processing disorders as well as expressive language disorders. There should be continual review of previously learned material. Information must not be presented too quickly. Visual cues and prompts should accompany auditory information. STUDENT also needs speech-language therapy. However, it is preferable that this service be provided through an integrated program in her regular education classroom. Because of STUDENT’s numerous impairments, pull-out services could be confusing for her, and she might have difficulty later because of having missed information during the pull-out session. In STUDENT’s case, the goal of compensatory education is for her to be able to perform age-appropriate work while being educated with her typically developing peers.

The evidence has established that the New Bridge School is currently providing STUDENT with a program that meets the needs identified above. The curriculum at New Bridge is designed to provide STUDENT with an intensive program that will give her the opportunity to be able to perform age-appropriate work. Furthermore, it appears that STUDENT went through a somewhat difficult transition when she started at New Bridge. Therefore, much of the benefit STUDENT can derive from the New Bridge program is still in the future. The program at New Bridge may go beyond what would be required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE; however, as compensatory education, continued placement at New Bridge is appropriate to help STUDENT overcome the District’s failure to provide her with an appropriate education for three years.

STUDENT’s needs have not been properly addressed for three years. Unfortunately, these years were particularly important to STUDENT’s future ability to benefit from her education. The result is that STUDENT is now significantly behind her peers. Therefore, it is very important that STUDENT get as much benefit as possible from her instruction at New Bridge. The “catch up” time that all students experience in the fall will be detrimental to STUDENT’s ability to meet her goals. For this reason, STUDENT’s attendance in the 2001 summer program at New Bridge is an appropriate part of STUDENT’s compensatory education.

The District shall continue to fund STUDENT’s placement at the New Bridge School for the 2001-2002 school year, including the cost of transportation. The District shall also reimburse STUDENT for the cost of the 2001 summer program at New Bridge. The District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop appropriate goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year. The assessments by Dr. Markel and Susan Berkowitz shall be used by the IEP team as the current assessments in the areas of academic achievement, intellectual ability, and speech and language. The IEP team shall include STUDENT’s current teachers from the New Bridge School. The team shall also consider the new assessments described in the previous section of this order, and determine whether these assessments justify additional services or therapies. Any additional services and therapies shall be provided in such a way as not to interfere with STUDENT’s program at the New Bridge School.

At the completion of the 2001-2002 school year, an IEP meeting shall be convened to consider STUDENT’s placement for 2002-2003 school year. The team shall consider all relevant evidence, and obtain new evaluations if necessary. The IEP team shall determine whether it is appropriate to transition STUDENT back into the District for the 2002-2003 school year, or whether a third year at the New Bridge School is required to meet STUDENT’s educational needs. The team also will consider whether STUDENT should attend the 2002 summer session at New Bridge. In evaluating STUDENT’s needs, the team will keep in mind the overall goal of having STUDENT eventually be able to do age-equivalent work. This goal is based upon the evidence currently available. STUDENT’s progress in school and the results of future testing may make this goal either too ambitious, or not ambitious enough. The IEP team must reassess this goal, as necessary, using all the evidence at its disposal.

STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for special education and related services during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years. The District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during each of those years. STUDENT is currently eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability and as a student with a speech and language impairment.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT $11,750 as the cost of STUDENT’s tuition at the New Bridge School for the 2000-2001 school year.

2. Within thirty calendar days of date of this decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT for the cost of transporting STUDENT to and from the New Bridge School during the 2000-2001 school year. Reimbursement shall be for a total of 26,134(Footnote 14) miles at the rate the District reimburses its employees.

3. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, STUDENT shall submit to the District proof of the cost of tuition and the transportation mileage for STUDENT’s 2001 summer program at the New Bridge School. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT for these costs. Reimbursement for transportation shall be at the rate the District reimburses its employees.

4. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, STUDENT shall submit to the district proof of the costs of Susan Berkowitz speech-language assessment of STUDENT. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT for this cost.

5. The District shall pay all tuition and transportation mileage for STUDENT’s placement at the New Bridge School for the 2001-2002 school year. If STUDENT has already paid some of these costs, STUDENT shall submit proof of payment to the District. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT for these costs.

6. Within fifteen days of the date of this decision, the district shall develop an assessment plan to assess STUDENT as follows: Hearing assessment Vision assessment Occupational therapy assessment Assistive technology assessment Evaluation for an attention deficit disorder

7. Within 50 days of receipt by the District of the parent’s assent to the assessment plan, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT at the New Bridge School for the 2001-2002 school year. If the results of the assessments indicate that additional services and/or therapies are required, the IEP shall arrange for these services and/or therapies to be provided in such a way as to not interfere with STUDENT’s program at the New Bridge School.

8. All of STUDENT's other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998, 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years due to the district’s failure to find her eligible for special education on or after September 18, 1997?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

2. Was STUDENT eligible for special education during the 2000-2001 school year?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

3. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for tuition and transportation costs in connection with STUDENT attending New Bridge School during the 2000-2001 school year?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments of Dr. Nancy Markel, Susan Berkowitz and Dr. Claude Valenti?

STUDENT only prevailed on this issue as to reimbursement for Susan Berkowitz’s assessment.

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: August 31, 2001 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the parties’ statements of the issues. 3.Some of these tests were administered by Dr. Lee while others were administered by Cora Jensen, the RSP teacher at Descanso. 4.It should be noted that the test level is the same level given in the previous year. The improvement shown must be viewed in this context 5.Mr. Dennett testified that he never told MOTHER that he was considering holding STUDENT back. He said he would never retain a student who had just repeated the previous grade, as STUDENT had. 6.This score is made up from her score on dictation (78) and proofing (59). 7.A “return sweep” is the movement of the eye from the end of a line of text back to the begginning of the next line. A lack of return sweeps indicated that STUDENT’s eyes were not making this transition in a single sweep. 8.The subsequent testing by Dr. Markel casts significant doubt upon the accuracy of the District’s testing which led to the conclusion that STUDENT was mentally retarded. However, the ultimate decision on eligibility is made by the IEP team, and is not just a matter of the results of testing. The fact that the IEP team found STUDENT eligible on the basis of mental retardation is what is significant here. 9.STUDENT received an expressive language score of 57, and a total language score of 67. The expressive language score is more than two standard deviations below the mean of 100. 10. This mileage was arrived at by review of the milage chart contained in Student Exhibit 35. 11.This finding relates to reimbursement for summer school as a requirement to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. Whether reimbursement for summer school may be appropriate as a part of compensatory education will be discussed later in this decision. 12.Dr. Markel recommended an occupational therapy assessment to address STUDENT’s visual-motor integration functioning. 13.All of STUDENT’s teachers and examiners have noted problems with attention and distractability. It is unclear whether this is due to an attention deficit disorder or to some other cause. A full evaluation is necessary to determine that cause of the attentional problems. 14. This rather large figure was arrived at through an evaluation of Student Exhibit 35. This exhibit contains actual odometer readings for the trips to and from New Bridge. A sample of these readings was used to arrive at an average daily milage of 144 miles. Testimony established that STUDENT attended New Bridge on 179 days during the 2000-2001 school year. 144 miles times 179 days equals 26,134 total miles for the year.