California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 29, 2004
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 180-04 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley
Los Angeles Unified prevails as Hearing Officer finds 13-year-old eligible as emotionally disturbed over his family's objection.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 13-year-old sixth grader, represented by his mother, filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. He argued that he did not qualify for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance and belonged in general education. Over several years, the District's IEP teams had found him eligible, most recently placing him in a special day class for emotionally disturbed students at Le Conte Middle School. Before the hearing, a superior court injunction barred the student from all District schools and facilities for three years. Because of that order, the Hearing Officer dismissed the request for a general education placement but kept the eligibility question. He also denied the family's requests to reconsider that ruling, to call two administrators as witnesses, and to postpone the hearing so a private psychologist could assess the student.
On eligibility, the Hearing Officer relied on years of IEP records, discipline reports, and testimony from the school psychologist, an assistant principal, and the student's teacher. That evidence showed a long-standing pattern of inappropriate behavior and poor relationships with peers and teachers. These problems were marked and hurt his schoolwork, even though his cognitive ability was high average to superior. The Hearing Officer did not find the denials by the student and his mother credible. The District prevailed. The Hearing Officer declined the District's request to order the family to interview at Linden Center, a nonpublic school, but strongly recommended that they do so.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the federal and California emotional disturbance criteria when a family argued the student was not eligible. The Hearing Officer weighed years of IEP records and staff testimony. The decision also shows that a court injunction can limit what placement relief a hearing officer may order.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Does STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED)?
The student meets two emotional disturbance criteria: inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, and an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers. Both were shown over a long period, to a marked degree, and adversely affect his educational performance, so he remains eligible as ED.
- Dismissed / withdrawnPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Is Petitioner entitled to a general education placement? (issue identified at the March 26, 2004 prehearing conference)
This issue was dismissed before the hearing because a superior court injunction barred the student from all District schools and facilities, so the Hearing Officer could not order a District placement. The motion to reconsider was denied for lack of new facts or law.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied. The Hearing Officer declined the District's request to order the student and mother to interview at Linden Center, because neither party asked for, or presented evidence on, whether that placement would provide FAPE. He strongly recommended that they attend the interview.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c); Baldwin v. Home Savings of America; Garcia v. Hejmadi
People named in the decision
- Peter Sansom, attorney for District, Lozano Smith
- Cynthia Shimizu, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Diane Kealoha, school psychologist (counselor and three-year psychoeducational assessor); District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Phyllis Siegel, assistant principal; District witness, Le Conte Middle School
- Craig Bachamp, special day class (ED) teacher; District witness, Le Conte Middle School
- Christine Zardenetta, principal (proposed Student witness, excluded), Le Conte Middle School
- Pat Trenhaile, special education coordinator, District E (proposed Student witness, excluded), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Diana Turin, teacher, Le Conte Middle School
- Mr. Lo, school staff member, Le Conte Middle School
- Connie Asnair, physical education teacher, Le Conte Middle School
- Patrick Hanson, after-school program teacher, Hollywood Stars after-school program
- Linden Center, nonpublic school offered by District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter proceeded to hearing in Los Angeles, California, on March 30 and 31, 2004, before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Peter Sansom of Lozano Smith. Also present on the behalf of the District was Cynthia Shimizu, due process specialist.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT and his mother. (Footnote 1) The District called the following witnesses: Diane Kealoha, District school psychologist; Phyllis Siegel, assistant principal for Le Conte Middle School; and Craig Bachamp, STUDENT’s teacher at Le Conte Middle School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties presented oral closing arguments via telephone on April 5, 2004. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Does STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED)? (Footnote 2)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that he is not eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. He maintains that he belongs in a general education placement within the District.
The District contends that STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT has exhibited both inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances and an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. The District further asserts that STUDENT has exhibited these characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree and that these characteristics are adversely affecting his educational performance. The District seeks an order from the Hearing Officer finding that STUDENT is eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance and requiring STUDENT and his mother to attend an interview at the Linden Center, a nonpublic school for emotionally disturbed students that the District has offered as a placement for STUDENT.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Motion to Reconsider
On March 26, 2004, a prehearing conference was conducted via telephone by the Hearing Officer for the purpose of clarifying the issues in this matter. During the conference, the following issues were presented for hearing: 1) Is Petitioner eligible for special education? and 2) Is Petitioner entitled to a general education placement? Petitioner sought an order from the Hearing Officer finding that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as an emotionally disturbed student and requiring the District to place STUDENT in a general education class within the District.
After the issues were clarified, the District brought an oral motion to dismiss this case on the grounds that the Hearing Officer could not order the relief requested by Petitioner in light of an injunction issued by the Superior Court of the County of Los Angeles which prohibited STUDENT from coming within 100 yards of any District school or facility for a period of three years from the date of the order. (Footnote 3) Specifically, the District asserted that even if the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner was not eligible for special education, he could not order the District to place STUDENT in any District school or facility while the court injunction was in effect. Petitioner argued that the order should not prevent the Hearing Officer from ordering such relief.
After considering the arguments raised by Petitioner and Respondent during the conference, the Hearing Officer issued a written order dated March 26, 2004, denying the District’s motion to dismiss issue one and granting the District’s motion to dismiss issue two. The Hearing Officer found that the injunction did not preclude the Hearing Officer from determining the issue of Petitioner’s eligibility for special education, but that it did preclude the Hearing Officer from ordering the District to place STUDENT in any District school or facility during the effective period of the court order. (Footnote 4)
On March 29, 2004, Petitioner filed a motion to reconsider the order issued by the Hearing Officer on March 26, 2004. Petitioner argued that the second issue regarding placement was important and needed to be addressed at the Hearing. Because the Hearing was scheduled to begin on March 30, 2004, and it was unlikely that the District would be able to submit a written response to Petitioner’s motion on March 29, 2004, the Hearing Officer issued a minute order stating that this motion would be addressed on the first day of hearing.
On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer heard oral arguments from Petitioner and Respondent on the motion to reconsider. Petitioner reiterated his argument that the second issue regarding placement was important and needed to be addressed at the Hearing. The District argued that Petitioner had not offered any new or different facts, circumstances or law which would justify reconsideration of the order. Specifically, the District asserted that Petitioner had not provided any evidence or legal authority suggesting that the Hearing Officer could order the District to place Petitioner in a District school or facility while the court injunction was in place.
There is no provision in special education law regarding reconsideration of orders by Hearing Officers. Generally, the Hearing Officer will reconsider an order upon motion that is timely made and based upon new or different facts, circumstances or law. Whether the facts, circumstances, or law are new or different may depend upon whether the moving party knew or should have known of them when the original motion was argued. (Baldwin v. Home Savings of America (1977) 59 Cal.App.4th 1192, 1199, 1199-1200; Garcia v. Hejmadi (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 674, 690.)
In the present case, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner presented no new or different facts, circumstances, or law in support of his motion for reconsideration. Moreover, Petitioner failed to present any evidence or legal authority suggesting that the Hearing Officer could order the District to place Petitioner in a District school or facility while the court injunction was in place. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion for reconsideration.
2. Motion to Exclude Witnesses
Prior to opening statements and the presentation of evidence, the Hearing Officer inquired as to the witnesses each party intended to present at hearing. Petitioner indicated that he intended to call himself; his mother; Phyllis Siegel, the assistant principal at Le Conte Middle School; Christine Zardenetta, the principal at Le Conte Middle School; and Pat Trenhaile, the special education coordinator for the District’s “District E,” which includes Le Conte Middle School.
The District objected to Ms. Zardenetta and Ms. Trenhaile as witnesses. First, the District noted that it had not received a list of Petitioner’s witnesses at any time prior to the first day of hearing and was thus unprepared to examine these witnesses. Second, the District argued that the testimony of Ms. Zardenetta and Ms. Trenhaile would be duplicative because they did not have information that would be relevant to the determination of the issue of Petitioner’s eligibility for special education that could not be provided by witnesses that the District already intended to call. Specifically, the District maintained that Ms. Siegel, the assistant principal at Le Conte Middle School, and Craig Bachamp, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, would be testifying at the hearing and could provide more information regarding Petitioner’s behavior and his eligibility for special education than Ms. Zardenetta could. Finally, the District argued that Ms. Zardenetta and Ms. Trenhaile’s knowledge of Petitioner was limited, as neither of them has served as a member of Petitioner’s IEP team, assessed Petitioner, or provided instruction to him.
Petitioner conceded that neither Ms. Zardenetta nor Ms. Trenhaile were members of Petitioner’s IEP team and that neither of them had ever assessed Petitioner or provided instruction to him. But Petitioner argued that he should be allowed to call them as witnesses to answer questions concerning alleged false allegations made by the District to California Children’s Services regarding alleged neglect of STUDENT by his mother, including the question of why the District had not disciplined the staff members allegedly responsible for these false allegations.
The Hearing Officer took this motion under submission and indicated that a final determination regarding the testimony of these two witnesses would be made after he had had an opportunity to review the documentary evidence presented by each side and after he had heard testimony from the other witnesses.
After the District’s last witness testified, the Hearing Officer granted the District’s motion to exclude Ms. Zardenetta and Ms. Trenhaile as witnesses. The Hearing Officer found that the primary reason that Petitioner wanted to call these witnesses (to answer questions concerning alleged false allegations made by the District to California Children’s Services regarding alleged neglect of STUDENT by his mother) was not related to the issue presented for hearing, namely whether STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. The Hearing Officer further found that Petitioner had failed to establish that either of these witnesses had relevant information concerning the issue of Petitioner’s eligibility that was not readily available from the other witnesses called by Petitioner and Respondent and that the testimony of Ms. Zardenetta and Ms. Trenhaile would therefore be cumulative and duplicative. (Footnote 5) 3. Motion for Continuance
On the first day of hearing, after the parties presented their opening statements, Petitioner made an oral motion for a continuance of the hearing. Petitioner sought an indefinite continuance on the grounds that he wanted to locate and retain a psychologist to assess Petitioner for the purpose of providing additional evidence in support of his claim that he does not meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. Petitioner argued that he did not have sufficient time prior to the commencement of the hearing to locate and retain a psychologist for this purpose. Petitioner did not know how much time he would need for this purpose.
The District opposed the motion and argued that Petitioner had not demonstrated good cause for a continuance. The District noted that it was Petitioner, not the District, who requested this due process hearing and that Petitioner initially requested the hearing in December of 2003, approximately three and one-half months prior to the start of the hearing. The District noted that its position regarding Petitioner’s eligibility for special education as emotionally disturbed was clear at the time Petitioner initially filed for due process. The District further argued that any continuance would need to be at least four and more likely up to eight weeks in duration in order to allow Petitioner sufficient time to locate a psychologist, conduct the assessments, and obtain a written assessment report. During that time, the District argued, Petitioner would be without a placement, save the telephonic instruction that the District was currently offering him. The District maintained that a continuance would unnecessarily delay the determination of the issue of eligibility.
A continuance will be granted only upon a showing of good cause. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(f).) Speedy resolution of special education due process hearings is mandated by law, and “good cause” is construed narrowly in light of this mandate.
In this instance, the Hearing Officer found that good cause did not exist for a continuance. Specifically, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner had ample time to locate and retain a psychologist to assess STUDENT prior to the commencement of the hearing but that Petitioner had not taken any steps to do so at any time prior to the first day of the hearing. In addition, the likely length of the delay, combined with STUDENT’s current situation regarding the injunction, militated against such a continuance in this matter. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion for a continuance. (Footnote 6)
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Petitioner STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student in the sixth grade who is currently designated as eligible for special education and related services as a student with an emotional disturbance. He resides with his mother and three siblings. STUDENT’s cognitive ability is in the high average to superior range. As a result of his disability, however, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of academics, behavior, attention, and social skills and these deficits adversely affect his educational performance, particularly in the area of mathematics applications.
STUDENT has attended District schools since kindergarten. In March of 2000, when STUDENT was in the second grade at Wilton Place Elementary, he was found to be eligible for special education and related services as a student with other health impairments (OHI), placed in a special day class (SDC), and offered designated instruction and services (DIS) in the form of counseling. The IEP of March 14, 2000, indicates that STUDENT was referred for assessment by the student success team and his mother because his educational progress appeared to be below expectation. According to the IEP, STUDENT was having difficulties following directions and staying on task and was disrespectful towards his teachers and authority figures. He was working at grade level in all areas except mathematics applications.
On August 2, 2000, the IEP team at Grant Elementary School, STUDENT’s school of attendance, found that STUDENT was not eligible under the category of OHI, as there was no indication of any medical impairments, and further found that he was not eligible under the category of specific learning disability because he was working at grade level in all areas except for mathematics applications. The team also determined that the SDC was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT and placed him in a general education setting for the entire school day. Finally, the IEP team noted that his behavior needed to be monitored, as he tended to be disruptive in class and sought negative attention. The IEP team recommended implementation of a behavior plan to address these behaviors.
On October 5, 2000, the IEP team at Overland Elementary School, STUDENT’s school of attendance, found STUDENT eligible for special education under the category of OHI due to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and also found him eligible for DIS counseling. (Footnote 7) STUDENT was placed in an SDC. The IEP generated at that meeting indicates that STUDENT continued to exhibit behavior problems including refusals to follow directions, disrespect towards teachers and other students, leaving the classroom without permission, attention seeking behavior, and refusal to take responsibility for his actions. A behavior support plan is included in the IEP to address these behaviors.
On June 15, 2001, the IEP team at 24th Street Elementary School, STUDENT’s school of attendance, determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance and a specific learning disability (SLD) and that STUDENT continued to be eligible for DIS counseling. At this time, STUDENT was 10 years old and in the third grade. The team noted continued behavior difficulties. The IEP team found that STUDENT required small group instruction to minimize distractions and placed him in an SDC for emotionally disturbed students. (Footnote 8)
On December 12, 2001, the IEP team met at Wilton Place Elementary School, STUDENT’s school of attendance, and recommended that STUDENT be mainstreamed for language arts for 45 minutes per day, to be increased in time as he continues to make progress.
On April 18, 2002, an IEP meeting was held at the request of STUDENT’s mother, who sought a more mainstreamed setting for STUDENT. The team agreed that STUDENT could be mainstreamed into a general education classroom for five hours per day, with the remainder of the school day in a resource specialist program (RSP) to obtain assistance in math.
STUDENT’s annual IEP review took place on June 20, 2002 at Wilton Place Elementary, his school of attendance. At this time he was eleven years old and in the fourth grade. The IEP indicates that STUDENT’s behavior had deteriorated over time in his mainstreamed setting and that he continued to display problematic behaviors such as interpersonal difficulties with peers, noncompliance with requests and classroom instruction, disruptions in class, and refusal to take responsibility for his actions. Academically, STUDENT is described as capable of grade-level work in language arts, but significantly behind in mathematics. The IEP team found that STUDENT would benefit from a well-structured environment with a smaller teacher to student ratio and recommended placement in a nonpublic school (NPS). According to the IEP document, STUDENT’s mother expressed an interest in visiting the NPS identified by the IEP team.
On June 18, 2003, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s three year review at Hancock Park Elementary, STUDENT’s school of attendance. The team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an emotionally disturbed class for the sixth grade. If such a class was not available, the team recommended placement at an NPS.
On September 2, 2003, an IEP meeting was held at Le Conte Middle School, STUDENT’s school of attendance, to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The IEP document indicates that STUDENT was placed in an ED program at that time. His mother advised the IEP team that an ED program was unnecessary and requested that STUDENT be placed in the SLD program at Burroughs Middle School, STUDENT’s school of residence. The IEP team found that STUDENT had not displayed any behaviors severe enough to warrant an ED placement and recommended that STUDENT begin attending an SLD class at Burroughs.
On December 9, 2003, the IEP team met again at Le Conte to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The IEP document indicates that the team erred in changing his placement from Le Conte to Burroughs and that he must remain at Le Conte in the ED program “per District mandate.” The behavior support plan attached to the IEP document indicates that STUDENT continued to engage in problematic behavior, including fabricating lies about teachers in order to get them in trouble. According to the IEP document, STUDENT’s mother also decided to remove him from DIS counseling at this time.
On or about January 28, 2004, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. (Footnote 9)
On March 3, 2004, the Superior Court of the County of Los Angeles issued a temporary restraining order (TRO) prohibiting Petitioner from coming within 100 yards of all District schools and facilities housing District personnel, including Le Conte Middle School, Petitioner’s most recent school of attendance. The District obtained the TRO after Petitioner allegedly threatened to bomb the school on February 19, 2004. The court set a hearing date of March 24, 2004, at which time it would determine if an injunction should be issued against STUDENT.
On March 18, 2004, an IEP meeting was held to discuss placement for STUDENT. (Footnote 10) The IEP team recommended a social-emotional evaluation and AB 3632 county mental health services for STUDENT. The IEP team further recommended placement at Linden Center, an NPS. Pending acceptance at Linden Center, the team recommended that STUDENT receive instruction via tele-teaching, which would consist of four classes five days a week, with each class fifty minutes in length. Finally, the team determined that if STUDENT was not enrolled at Linden Center within 60 days, another IEP meeting would be held.
On March 24, 2004, the Superior Court of the County of Los Angeles issued an injunction prohibiting Petitioner from coming within 100 yards of all District schools and facilities for a period of three years from the date of issuance of the order.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Does STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), a “child with a disability” means a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech and language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impaired, or specific learning disabilities and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A).) Therefore, for STUDENT to qualify as a student with a disability, he must fall within one of the categories above, and he must require special education and related services.
Emotional disturbance is defined as a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a student’s educational performance:
1. An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors;
2. An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;
3. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances;
4. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression;
5. A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
(34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i).) (Footnote 11)
Petitioner contends that he does not meet any of the above-referenced criteria to be eligible as a student with an emotional disturbance. The District contends that he meets two of the criteria: 1) he has exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; and 2) he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships.
1. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances
The evidence presented by the District in the form of documentary exhibits and witness testimony establishes a pattern of inappropriate types of behavior and feelings by STUDENT under normal circumstances, to a marked degree, and over a period of several years. STUDENT’s IEP documents from March of 2000 to the present contain numerous references to his inappropriate behaviors such as verbally (and sometimes physically) abusing and provoking peers and teachers, refusing to comply with teacher and staff requests and classroom instruction, exposing himself to other students, bringing a recording device to school to record students and teachers, stealing school materials, leaving class without permission, and failing to take responsibility for his own actions. The District’s evidence also includes several suspension notices and office referrals for conduct such as making a false 911 call, threatening/attempting to cause injury to another person, disruption/willful defiance, telling a teacher to “shut up,” hitting another student, and making a bomb threat. His teachers’ responses on the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) administered in March of 2003 indicate that he has clinically significant problems in the areas of aggression and withdrawal and at-risk problems in the areas of hyperactivity, conduct, depression, attention, social skills, leadership, and study skills.
Craig Bachamp was STUDENT’s teacher in an ED special day class at Le Conte for approximately two months before the court enjoined STUDENT from attending District schools in February 2004. He testified that during this time STUDENT regularly engaged in inappropriate behavior such as talking about inappropriate subjects (such as sex) during class instruction, misdirecting class lessons, distracting other students, instigating verbal and physical confrontations with other students both in class and in the halls, obsessing about violence and the military, cursing and yelling at teachers and administrators, and repeatedly denying responsibility for his actions. He further testified that in January of this year STUDENT threatened to rape a female aide in his class after the aide reprimanded him for failing to listen to her instructions. On February 19th of this year, STUDENT told Mr. Bachamp that he was going to bomb the school. (Footnote 12) Mr. Bachamp testified that when he referred STUDENT to the office for making the bomb threat, STUDENT realized the seriousness of the situation and tried to “backpedal” by claiming that he was talking about making a movie when he mentioned the bomb. But it was clear to Mr. Bachamp that STUDENT was not talking about making a movie when he mentioned the bomb.
Phyllis Siegel, the assistant principal at Le Conte, first met STUDENT in October 2003 when he was transferred to her school. Her testimony regarding STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors was similar to that of Mr. Bachamp. She stated that STUDENT displayed inappropriate behavior toward his first teacher at Le Conte, Diana Turin. Specifically, he called her names, including “drug addict,” and frequently left her class without permission. In October of 2003, while on suspension from school, STUDENT came to school dressed in military clothing and wearing a belt with fake bullets on it. He called 911 and told the police that a teacher had a gun at school. Officers responded to the school and STUDENT was cited by the school police officer for making a false 911 call. According to Ms. Siegel, STUDENT also told her that he wished she were dead, threatened to kill Mr. Lo, a school staff member, and scratched and kicked a teacher when the teacher tried to break up a fight between STUDENT and another student.
Diane Kealoha, the District’s school psychologist, provided counseling to STUDENT approximately once a week from October 2002 to June 2003. She also conducted a psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT for his three-year review in May 2003. She testified that STUDENT engaged in a pattern of inappropriate behavior during this time, which included pulling his pants down in the school yard during recess on at least three different occasions, running out of class, refusing to complete assigned tasks, threatening other students, talking back to teachers, making sexually loaded statements to fellow students, and denying inappropriate behavior even when it was directly observed by a teacher or staff member. Ms. Kealoha testified that STUDENT was unable to consistently engage in appropriate alternative behaviors despite the existence of a behavior support plan. (Footnote 13) She reviewed prior IEPs and noted that STUDENT’s problematic behavior has been fairly consistent for several years. Finally, Ms. Kealoha testified that, based upon her recent conversations with Phyllis Siegel, the assistant principal at Le Conte, it appeared that STUDENT’s behavior was escalating. Specifically, she cited STUDENT’s 911 call and his threats to bomb the school, rape an aide, and kill teachers. She opined that STUDENT is emotionally disturbed and in need of mental health services and a nonpublic school placement with a small number of students and teachers trained to address students with extreme behaviors.
During his testimony, STUDENT denied any inappropriate behavior at school and specifically denied calling 911 to report a teacher with a gun or making threats to bomb the school or rape an aide. He asserted that his comments regarding a bomb at the school were in relation to a movie that he wanted to make. He maintained that teachers and staff frequently harass him at the school and went on to state that he does not have to listen to teachers or staff when they are harassing him or lying. He intimated that teachers and other school staff conspire to make false allegations against him and that they are trying to “get” him and his mother. Specifically, he accused Mr. Bachamp and his aide of lying about the threats he made to bomb the school and rape the aide and also claimed that the school police officer lied about the 911 call to the police. At one point during his testimony, STUDENT remarked that one of his former teachers at Le Conte hates himself and is suicidal. During her testimony, STUDENT’s mother described STUDENT as an outgoing and sensitive child who enjoys school, dislikes violence, and listens to and obeys most of the teachers and staff at school. Like STUDENT, she characterized the allegations made against STUDENT by school staff as false, including the allegations of making threats to bomb the school and rape an aide.
The Hearing Officer generally found the testimony of STUDENT and his mother to lack credibility. STUDENT’s denials of wrongdoing during his testimony are consistent with his prior denials of inappropriate behavior that were both described by the District witnesses during testimony and set forth in IEP documents going back several years. To find STUDENT’s testimony credible, the Hearing Officer would have to conclude that all three of the District’s witnesses were lying and that the IEP documents, suspension notices, and reports from prior years are replete with false allegations of inappropriate behavior. The evidence simply does not support such a conclusion. As to MOTHER, the Hearing Officer does not doubt that she cares deeply for her son and wants him to succeed in school. The evidence presented at hearing, however, suggests that she continues to reinforce STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors by failing to discipline him herself and/or failing to support discipline, positive behavior plans, and DIS counseling recommended by the District. Specifically, her testimony that all of the District’s witnesses were lying and that they had fabricated the behavioral incidents at issue in this hearing was not credible and will only serve to reinforce STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. The testimony of MOTHER further suggests that STUDENT is adept at manipulating his mother into accepting his version of events that transpire at school over the school’s version of events. If this pattern continues, it is unlikely that STUDENT will be able to learn appropriate behaviors and accept responsibility for his own actions.
Finally, the evidence supports a finding that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior adversely affects his educational performance. Specifically, Mr. Bachamp testified that STUDENT’s behaviors in class frequently cause him to miss instruction and result in STUDENT completing only fifty to seventy-five percent of most assignments. Ms. Kealoha testified that STUDENT is a very bright and capable student, but that his behavior continues to impact his ability to access his curriculum. His more recent IEPs indicate that he has turned in very few assignments and is not meeting grade level standards in math applications and computations.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence overwhelmingly supports a finding that STUDENT has exhibited and continues to exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and that said behavior adversely affects his educational performance.
2. An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers
STUDENT testified that he considers approximately twelve of his classmates at Le Conte to be his friends. He met approximately one third of these twelve friends in August of 2003 and he met the remainder during the last two months he was at Le Conte. He testified that he plays basketball with these friends during P.E. and also talks with some of them about movie making, which is one of STUDENT’s interests. According to STUDENT, he typically does not engage in after school activities with his friends due to other obligations, including violin lessons and participation in an after school program called Hollywood Stars, which he described as similar to the YMCA. He testified that he also speaks with some of his friends by telephone during the weekends.
STUDENT also testified that he has had good relationships with two of his teachers at school and his teacher at Hollywood Stars. Specifically, he stated that he is friends with his P.E. teacher, Connie Asnair, and with another teacher named John, whose last name he could not recall. He also considers Patrick Hanson, his teacher at Hollywood Stars, to be a friend. He testified that he and Mr. Hanson frequently talk about movie making with each other. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that STUDENT is very outgoing, likes to make friends, likes his teachers, and is eager to participate in group activities both in school and at his after-school program.
The District’s witnesses painted a much different picture of STUDENT’s interpersonal relationships with peers. Mr. Bachamp testified that while he observed a few positive relationships between STUDENT and his peers, the bulk of the interactions were negative. He noted that the other students see STUDENT as someone who threatens them, gets them into trouble or plays with them and then turns on them. Ms. Siegel testified that she has sat with STUDENT and other students at lunch and that STUDENT and the other students did not appear to like each other. She stated that the other students would call STUDENT names such as “Michael Jackson—child molester.” Ms. Kealoha testified that during the time she provided counseling to him, STUDENT did not have any friends that he played with at school, after school, or at home. According to Ms. Kealoha, STUDENT’s attention seeking behavior at school, as described above, prevented him from building or maintaining satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers because his behavior would disturb or frighten them. Specifically, STUDENT’s behavior would provoke some children, who would push back at him or tease him, while others wouldn’t trust him because he would deny his behavior and blame other students. She also indicated that STUDENT might have a different definition of what constitutes a friend than most people. She stated that for STUDENT, an acquaintance could be a friend, even though he might not engage in social or recreational activities with them outside of the school environment.
The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT’s behavior also prevented him from building or maintaining satisfactory interpersonal relationships with teachers. Mr. Bachamp testified that he did not observe any satisfactory relationships between STUDENT and his teachers or other school staff. He observed STUDENT cursing, yelling, instigating arguments, and talking back to teachers and administrators. He also overheard STUDENT describing another teacher as crazy and suggesting that the teacher had a drug problem. Ms. Kealoha testified that STUDENT would often begin to develop an appropriate relationship with a new teacher, but that as he became more comfortable with that teacher, he would become more disrespectful, which would impede the development of the relationship.
Finally, all of the District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers adversely affects his educational performance. Each witness testified that STUDENT’s attention seeking behavior not only draws negative reactions from peers and teachers, but also results in STUDENT missing classroom instruction, failing to complete assignments, and failing to progress academically in accordance with his ability.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers under normal circumstances, over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and that said behavior adversely affects his educational performance.
****
The evidence established that STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. Specifically, he meets the following two criteria: 1) he exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; and 2) he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships. In addition, he exhibits these behaviors under normal circumstances, over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and said behavior adversely affects his educational performance. Finally, the evidence established that STUDENT requires special education and related services.
The Hearing Officer declines to issue an order requiring STUDENT and his mother to attend an interview at the Linden Center, as neither party requested a determination by the Hearing Officer as to whether placement at the Linden Center would constitute a free, appropriate public education for STUDENT and, in any event, neither party presented sufficient evidence to enable the Hearing Officer to make such a determination. Without such a determination, it would be inappropriate for the Hearing Officer to issue such an order. That being said, the Hearing Officer strongly recommends that Petitioner and his mother attend an interview at the Linden Center in order to learn more about that placement and seriously consider placing STUDENT at the Linden Center or another nonpublic school that will meet his unique needs and provide him with educational benefit. The injunction currently bars STUDENT from attending any District school for a period of three years. The Hearing Officer is concerned that STUDENT’s current placement (telephonic instruction at home) will not provide him with the instructional assistance and behavioral support that he needs and that the longer he remains in this status quo, the greater the likelihood that he will regress both academically and behaviorally.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: April 29, 2004 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
STUDENT testified by telephone pursuant to a stipulation between the parties that was approved by the Hearing Officer.
2 The issue is not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing. Since Petitioner contends that he is not eligible for special education and the District contends that he is only eligible under the category of ED, the issue was narrowed to whether Petitioner is eligible under that one category.
3 The District sought the injunction after Petitioner made a bomb threat to his teacher at school. This incident is discussed in greater detail in the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law section of this Decision.
4 The Hearing Officer further noted that if he found Petitioner ineligible for special education, the Hearing Officer would not be able to rule on Petitioner’s placement or any other issues because the Hearing Office’s jurisdiction extends only to students who are eligible for special education
5 During the course of the hearing, the Hearing Officer reviewed the documentary evidence submitted by both sides to determine the nature and extent of these witnesses’ roles in observing and/or evaluating STUDENT’s behavior. The Hearing Officer found no indication in the documentary evidence that either witness had any significant role in these areas.
6 The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner may locate and retain a psychologist to assess him at Petitioner’s expense at any time and that the District is required to consider the results of any such assessment with respect to the provision of a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner. The results of such an assessment may also be presented as evidence at a due process hearing but would not, however, be considered as evidence for purposes of this hearing and Decision as the evidentiary record has already closed. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c).)
7 The IEP of October 5, 2000 indicates that STUDENT’s mother disagreed with these findings
8 The IEP of June 15, 2001, indicates that STUDENT’s mother disagreed with this placement but agreed that he could remain there until the end of the month. According to the IEP, she wanted STUDENT placed in a general education class for the 2001-2002 school year.
9 Petitioner’s mother initially prepared a request for due process hearing on December 16, 2003, but the Hearing Office first received a request on January 28, 2004.
10 STUDENT’s mother did not attend this IEP meeting.
11 The term ED does not apply to a child who is socially maladjusted unless it is determined that he has an ED. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii).)
12 According to Mr. Bachamp, STUDENT made the following statements to him: “I am going to put a bomb in this school.” “All I need is the gas for the last part of the bomb.” “This school is going to blow up.” The bomb may already be here.” “I am just telling you to let you know.”
13 The targeted behaviors included refusing to follow directions or begin activities, showing disrespect to peers and teachers, leaving room without permission, teasing and mimicking peers and authority figures, and yelling in the classroom.
