California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 10, 1996

Student v. Conejo Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 180-96 · Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare

Hearing Officer finds 17-year-old with ADHD eligible as other health impaired; Conejo Valley Unified must hold IEP meeting.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision records that after the hearing the District moved to dismiss the case as moot, and the Hearing Officer denied the motion.

Summary

The maternal grandfather of a 17-year-old student filed for due process against Conejo Valley Unified School District, seeking a finding that the student was eligible for special education. The student attended Conejo Valley High School, a continuation school. By the end of eleventh grade he had earned only 16 credits. District IEP teams found him ineligible in 1987, 1993, 1994 and February 1996. In March 1996, however, the District gave him a Section 504 plan based on an attention deficit disorder diagnosis.

Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare found that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was the student's primary disability. He relied mainly on the testimony of treating psychiatrist Dr. Marilyn Kroplick and found the District's evidence less thorough. The student met the other health impairment criteria: limited alertness, caused by a chronic health problem, that harmed his educational performance. The District argued that his oppositional behavior was the real problem. Relying on Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg, the Hearing Officer found that the ADHD caused that behavior and was the primary cause of his school failure. He also denied a late District motion to dismiss the case as moot.

The family had not asked for specific remedies, so the Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days. The team must develop an IEP and a placement for the rest of 1996-97. The decision states that, at a minimum, the student needed a residential school specializing in ADHD and behavior modification. The District must invite Dr. Kroplick to at least two meetings at its own expense, and must also invite the student.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled ADHD under the other health impairment category. It treated ADHD as a chronic health problem that causes limited alertness. It also applied Wartenberg's primary-cause reasoning. As a result, oppositional behavior that grew out of ADHD did not defeat eligibility. The Hearing Officer also required the District to pay for an outside psychiatrist to take part in IEP meetings.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education? (Analyzed as whether Student meets the eligibility criteria for other health impairment, specific learning disability, or serious emotional disturbance under Education Code § 56339.)

    ADHD was the student's primary disability. It caused limited alertness due to a chronic health problem and was the primary cause of his poor educational performance, including his oppositional behavior, so he is eligible as other health impaired. The Hearing Officer did not reach the specific learning disability or serious emotional disturbance categories.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Student declared eligible for special education as a student with an other health impairment.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to (a) develop an appropriate IEP; (b) identify an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year; and (c) provide such other remedies as Student is entitled to. The decision states that, at the very least, Student requires an out-of-home (residential) placement in a school specializing in ADHD and behavior modification.
  • The District must invite Dr. Marilyn Kroplick to join the IEP team at District expense for at least two meetings, and must invite Student to join the team.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Capistrano Unified School Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995); U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, 18 IDELR 116 (1991); Letter to Cohen, 20 IDELR 73 (OSEP 1993); Education Code § 56339; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Letter to Parker, 18 IDELR 963 (OSEP 1991); Lyons v. Smith, 829 F.Supp. 414 (D.D.C. 1993)

People named in the decision

  • Marilyn N. Kroplick, M.D., treating child and adolescent psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Center for Attention Deficit Disorder, Encino
  • Arlene Gennette, second grade teacher (apparently), Lodera Elementary School
  • Amy Burns, assessor (1987 psychoeducational assessment), Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Sheldon Block, M.D., private psychiatrist
  • Susan Kuntz, school psychologist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Natalie Newman, licensed educational psychologist (private evaluation)
  • Lionel Margolin, M.D., Ph.D., private evaluator (psychiatric report)
  • Harold L. Burke, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist
  • Carol Parish, school psychologist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Ihab Soliman, M.D., psychiatrist, child development evaluator, UC Irvine Child Development Center
  • Jeffrey Lulow, Ph.D., private psychoeducational evaluator
  • Anna Mata, school psychologist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Al Frankfurter, special education teacher / tutor, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Jeffrey Lampos, guidance counselor, Conejo Valley High School
  • Rod Fujita, math and health teacher, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Lisa Moxley, ninth grade science teacher, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Jack Bannon, Associate Director of Special Education; District representative, Conejo Valley Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Thousand Oaks, California, on September 5 and 6 and October 1, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his maternal grandfather, GRANDFATHER. Respondent Conejo Unified School District was represented by Jack Bannon, Associate Director of Special Education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until November 10, 1996, for optional closing briefs. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Is STUDENT eligible for special education?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

After the conclusion of the hearing and during the period the record remained open for the submission of closing briefs only, the District moved to dismiss the case as "moot," asserting that "STUDENT has skipped several probation appointments and has moved to Arizona." GRANDFATHER replied that juvenile court had approved STUDENT's trip to Arizona, where his mother lives, that STUDENT's mother would ensure his return to California, and that STUDENT would appear in juvenile court.

The Hearing Officer denied the District's motion on three grounds: (1) it was far from clear that STUDENT had changed his residence from the District to his mother's home in Arizona; (2) the District's obligations to STUDENT, if any, might encompass events that occurred before the putative move to Arizona and survive such a move; and (3) the record was closed to the submission of additional evidence when the District alleged that STUDENT had moved.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is seventeen years old. To date, he has not been found eligible for special education.

During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in the eleventh grade at Conejo Valley High School, a continuation high school in the District. Attendance records indicate that STUDENT had been absent or late to school on numerous occasions during the 1994-95 school year. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 22.) STUDENT was absent 119 days and late on another 36 days during the 1995-96 school year. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 21.) At the end of that year, he had earned 16 high school credits. (Testimony of Jack Bannon and GRANDFATHER.)

STUDENT resides with his maternal grandparents within the District. His mother lives in Arizona. STUDENT's father, divorced from STUDENT's mother, MOTHER has had little contact with him. STUDENT's stepfather, from whom the mother is now divorced, was alternatingly indifferent and verbally abusive to STUDENT. (Testimony of GRANDFATHER and MOTHER.)

SUMMARY OF DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE (FOOTNOTE 1)

At age 4, while attending Montessori Children's World in Torrance, California, for the 1983-84 school year, STUDENT "made good progress in all areas ... but his emotions and discipline [left] much to be desired." (Petitioner's Exhibit B-1.) The following year at the same school, STUDENT had trouble staying in his seat and talked constantly. Notwithstanding, he did well on most of his school work. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-2.) In the 1985-86 school year STUDENT, then age 6, was viewed by his teacher as bright but slow to get his work done. He had a "lot of energy," but needed to learn to channel it into constructive activity. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-3.)

Toward the end of the 1985-86 school year, when his current grade level was approximately 1.8, STUDENT was administered the Stanford Achievement Test. He scored between 2 and 5 on grade level equivalents for all categories except listening, on which he received a 1.6. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-4.)

For his second grade year, STUDENT transferred to Lodera Elementary School within the District. In February 1987, Ms. Arlene Gennette (apparently STUDENT's teacher), noted "[that] at times STUDENT becomes very actively involved in the learning process -- particularly in a verbal way." She also noted poor work habits and playground problems. In particular, she noted that he exhibited the following:

Symptoms of hyperactivity: drums, hums, sings, makes noises, throws paper bits in and out of the rest room, moving constantly, falls off chair, wanders around the room. Denied he engaged in such activity when observed breaking school rules. Seems out of control most of the time. Argumentative with ...

playground aides. None of the above seems to affect STUDENT. He even denied any problem and seems non-remorseful.

(Petitioner's Exhibit B, pp. 6-8)

At the end of the 1986-87 school year, the District conducted a psychoeducational assessment at the request of STUDENT's mother, MOTHER. The assessment concluded that STUDENT was a "cute, talkative 7-year-old boy of superior intellectual functioning" whose verbal scores were in the gifted range. Ms. Amy Burns, who conducted the assessment, observed STUDENT in his classroom, where she noted that he was "very distractible, not on task, looking around the room, moving in his seat, and did not follow the teacher's instructions." On the Burke's Behavior Rating Scale, STUDENT scored Very Serious on Poor Attention and Excessive Resistance and Serious on Poor Ego Strength, Poor Sense of Identity, Poor Impulse Control, and Poor Anger Control. Ms. Burns found no significant discrepancy between aptitude and achievement as measured by standardized tests. Under "clinical impressions," Ms. Burns identified STUDENT's problems as immaturity, poor emotional control, low self-esteem, feelings of insecurity, and need for support. She did not find a basis for recommending STUDENT for special education. She did recommend a structured classroom to minimize auditory and visual distractions and clear rules with consistent consequences.

(Petitioner's Exhibits B, pp. 9-13) The IEP team that convened after the assessment found STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the specific learning disability category. (Petitioner's Exhibit B, pp. 15-16)

After STUDENT's second grade year at Lodera, his educational history was marked by frequent changes in schools as his family moved to Arizona, back to the District, then to Maryland, and then back again to the District. (Testimony of mother and grandfather; Joint Exhibit 1) During STUDENT's 1990-91 school year at Westlake Hills Elementary School within the District, STUDENT was suspended on at least four occasions for acts that included threatening another student, "extortion," fighting, and "use of profanity with the intent to shock."

(Petitioner's Exhibits B, pp. 25- 28) STUDENT's seventh grade was spent in Maryland and at a private school in California. STUDENT's conduct during 1992-93 in the eighth grade at Coloma Intermediate School within the District was marked by misbehavior ranging from classroom disturbances (speaking out, making noises, and throwing spitballs) to stealing a can of pop and jabbing other students with pins.

(Petitioner's Exhibit B, pp. 35-43)

In the middle of his eighth grade year, STUDENT transferred to Los Cerritos Middle School, also within the District. At about the same time, STUDENT was seen by Dr. Sheldon Block, a psychiatrist, who made a diagnosis of attention deficit disorder (ADD) and prescribed Prozac. (Testimony of grandfather; Petitioner's Exhibit A-8 and B-5)

GRANDFATHER sent a letter to the principal of Los Cerritos reporting that STUDENT had been diagnosed with attention deficit disorder and enclosing material on the subject. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-61)

During the same year, teacher evaluations prepared for a new psychoeducational assessment reported that STUDENT "speaks out constantly," "lacks focus," is distractible, has trouble controlling impulses, and "will intrude on a person's personal space ... [without being] aware of others emotional reactions to him." He resists instructions to be quiet. He does little homework. (Petitioner's Exhibit B, pp. 53-58) The assessment conducted by Susan Kuntz identified no significant discrepancy between "academic achievement and cognitive ability."(FOOTNOTE 2) (Petitioner's Exhibit B, pp. 70-78) Ms. Kuntz' report acknowledged Dr. Block's diagnosis. Ms. Kuntz said little more about attention deficit disorder except that MOTHER reported that Prozac caused STUDENT dizzy spells and light headedness and that Dr. Block had referred STUDENT to a specialist who confirmed that STUDENT suffered an attention deficit and would prescribe further medication "to assist STUDENT with his tasks." In the IEP dated January 5, 1993, the IEP team found STUDENT ineligible for special education, noting that he did not meet the eligibility criteria "as learning handicapped." (Petitioner's Exhibit B-67)

During the eighth grade, STUDENT was suspended for acts of misconduct. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-69) At the end of his eighth grade year STUDENT ranked 332 out of a class of 334. He had apparently earned no middle school credits. (Petitioner's Exhibit B-66)

At this point in his educational history, the diagnoses and testing of STUDENT increased as his family, particularly his grandfather, aggressively pursued an answer to STUDENT's troubles in school. In a report prepared for STUDENT's family dated January 4, 1993, Natalie Newman, licensed educational psychologist, described the results of her testing, which included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III). At the time of testing, Ms. Newman was unaware that Ms. Kuntz had administered an earlier version of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, the WISC-R, approximately one month earlier.(footnote 3) STUDENT's I.Q. results improved from a Verbal I.Q. of 107, a Performance I.Q. of 100, and a Full-Scale I.Q. of 104 on Ms. Kuntz' test to a Verbal I.Q. of 114, a Performance I.Q. of 111, and a Full-Scale I.Q. of 113 on Ms. Newman's test. The scores Ms. Newman obtained on the WISC-III when compared with STUDENT's Written Expression Score of 85 and Total Writing Score of 85 on the Wexler Individual Achievement Test led her to conclude that STUDENT suffered a developmental expressive writing disorder. She called for special education intervention; therapy to help STUDENT in dealing with authority; and further evaluation of STUDENT's ADD. She concluded: "The examiner does not mean to imply that ADHD is the genesis of all of STUDENT's problems. But the likelihood is that a good number of his academic and behavioral difficulties are related to this."

(Petitioner's Exhibit A, pp. 11-16)

In a report dated August 30, 1993, Lionel Margolin, M.D., Ph.D., described his interviews with STUDENT and those who had treated him and his review of reports on STUDENT. Dr. Margolin diagnosed STUDENT as suffering from attention deficit hyperactive disorder, conduct disorder, and depression.(footnote 4) Dr. Margolin indicated that STUDENT has a severe emotional disturbance and must be placed in a closed residential setting. At the current time he is receiving neither adequate educational nor psychological treatment. Without both, there seems to be little question that the prognosis is extremely poor.... STUDENT does have the ability to evoke compassion in people rather than anger and rejection. This gives rise to the expectation that if he does receive adequate educational placement at this time, his prognosis would be vastly improved.

(Petitioner's Exhibit A, pp. 22-29)

In a report dated March 10, 1994, Harold L. Burke, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, described the tests he administered to STUDENT, his interviews with STUDENT and his family, and his review of other information on STUDENT. Dr. Burke's findings included the following:

It is highly likely that STUDENT does have neurologically-based ADHD, given the high reliability and validity of the TOVA [Test of Variables of Attention] and the VIGIL and the ASQ-P [Abbreviated Symptom Questionnaire, Parent Version], the long clinical history of concentration difficulties, hyperactivity, distractibility, temper tantrums, emotional lability and the clinical observations cited above.

In his Summary and Recommendations, Dr. Burke indicated that "STUDENT appears to have ADHD. However, he also meets the criteria of Conduct Disorder, the symptoms of which can be a manifestation of ADHD." Dr. Burke recommended that STUDENT "be immediately placed in a residential treatment program," and noted that STUDENT's "relationship with his mother appears to be so poor and he appears to be so able to manipulate his grandparents that it is unlikely that he can be successfully cured in this current home environment." (Petitioner's Exhibit A, pp. 18-21)

In a report dated May 5, 1994, District psychologist Carol Parish reviewed STUDENT's record and administered achievement, perceptual, and socio-emotional tests. She concluded that STUDENT's achievement and perceptual motor abilities were adequate and that he did not meet the criteria for seriously emotionally disturbed.

Specifically, Ms. Parish found that STUDENT had the ability to learn; could build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships; denied delusions, hallucinations, and severe anxiety; did not present a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; and did not suffer physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. Her report referenced, but did not discuss, Dr. Margolin's report. She called for a determination of whether STUDENT had ADD and suggested that accommodations in a regular education program might benefit him. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 8)

During the IEP meeting of June 14, 1994, the team found STUDENT ineligible for special education and specifically rejected the request that STUDENT be found eligible as seriously emotionally disturbed or other health impaired. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 4)

In a brief one-page letter dated February 1, 1996, Ihab Soliman, M.D., board certified psychiatrist, child and adolescence specialist for the Department of Pediatrics, Division of Child Development, University of California, Irvine, wrote that "STUDENT was evaluated at the UCI Child Development Center and he clearly meets the criteria for ADD combined type. The evaluation included pertinent history and rating scales as well as a clinical investigation." (Petitioner's Exhibit A-44.) Dr. Soliman noted that STUDENT could qualify for special education under the category of other health impaired.

In a psychoeducational report dated April 4, 1996, Jeffrey Lulow, Ph.D., reviewed the results of his testing of STUDENT for disparity between intelligence and achievement, physiographic skills, and personality and emotional state. Dr. Lulow found the likely presence of ADHD and a mathematics disorder. The math disorder diagnosis was based on STUDENT's WISC-III I.Q. scores of 108, 107, and 108, and his standard score of 89 on the Math Composite of the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement. (Petitioner's Exhibit A, pp. 31-44)

Anna Mata, school psychologist for the District, wrote a report dated January 12, 1996, entitled "Assessment of Classroom Performance and Review of STUDENT's Records." The purpose of the report was to "address parent requests for evaluation for special education services for her son STUDENT." The report was not a special education assessment but a review of school-generated records. Ms. Mata's report did not reference the evaluations obtained by STUDENT's family, nor did it discuss special education eligibility criteria. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 5) It referred STUDENT's eligibility to the IEP team and suggested that STUDENT might take the California Proficiency Examination or attend adult education.

During the IEP meeting of February 2, 1996, the team once again found STUDENT ineligible for special education. (Respondent's Exhibit Tab 1)

In a plan dated March 8, 1996, the District found STUDENT eligible for services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The plan reads in pertinent part:

STUDENT was evaluated at the UCI Child Development Center and according to Dr. Ihab Soliman, STUDENT clearly meets the criteria for ADD combined type. Parent, grandparents, and a review of educational history supported the diagnosis. STUDENT is an outgoing, personable, socially responsive 16-year-old adolescent who demonstrates the academic skills to be able to function adequately within the normal classroom setting. However, impaired work ethic and disregard for productivity associated with attention problems and misbehaviors, have hindered academic success. STUDENT has completed 16 credits toward graduation and has met minimum competency requirements in reading.

(Respondent's Exhibit Tab 19)

In a letter dated May 9, 1996, Marilyn N. Kroplick, M.D., child and adolescent psychiatrist and medical director of the Center for Attention Deficit Disorder, Encino, California, diagnosed STUDENT as having ADD. She wrote that she based her diagnosis on meetings with STUDENT and a review of his educational and medical records. Dr. Kroplick explained that ADD is a deficit response to inhibition that causes STUDENT "low frustration tolerance, impulsive actions, inattentiveness, and difficulty in following directions, sustaining motivation, planning and achieving long-term goals, monitoring results and self-correcting his mistakes." Dr. Kroplick referenced STUDENT's results on the Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA) and STUDENT's history of educational testing and classroom conduct. She cited tests conducted by the National Institute of Mental Health in 1990 using brain scans to establish that ADD subjects "have a limited energy consumption or reduced glucose metabolism in the pre-frontal and pre-motor cortices, the areas controlling attention and impulsivity." Dr. Kroplick recommended "a more intense special educational setting, monitoring of [STUDENT's] medications and behavior therapy." (Petitioner's Exhibit A-45)

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses (footnote 5)

Dr. Kroplick supplemented her letter of May 9, 1996. She testified that she had treated STUDENT in weekly sessions beginning in May 1996. According to Dr. Kroplick, STUDENT suffered impaired alertness of ADHD from at least the second grade. She based this conclusion on her meetings with STUDENT and a review of his records. She offered the opinion that STUDENT's ADHD, which she testified is his primary disorder, is chronic and very severe, resulting in long-term depression with attendant oppositional defiance and conduct disorder. Dr. Kroplick is currently prescribing Prozac and Dexidrene for STUDENT. She cannot be certain that he takes his medicine on a regular basis. Dr. Kroplick emphasized that STUDENT cannot defer gratification or plan for his future. According to Dr. Kroplick, STUDENT's rebellion arises out of his inability to comply with adult expectations and has led to unsatisfactory friendships and increasing contacts with criminal elements. In Dr. Kroplick's opinion, STUDENT's inappropriate behavior and manifestations of depression indicate that he is seriously emotionally disturbed. She sees STUDENT in a downward spiral that has the potential to result in serious criminal conduct and imprisonment. She restated her conclusion that STUDENT's ADHD is a biologically based condition producing involuntary problems with attention, agitation, impulsivity, and motivation. According to Dr. Kroplick, STUDENT's misconduct, including the symptoms of oppositional defiance disorder and conduct disorder, arises out of STUDENT's frustrations with his inability to control himself and to meet parental and educational expectations. For STUDENT to have any chance of recouping his education and overcoming his oppositionalism, Dr. Kroplick stated that STUDENT must have a school that specializes in ADHD and behavior modifications. Dr. Kroplick suggested several private schools in California but indicated that a locked facility such as those operated in Utah might prove necessary.

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT was hyperactive from birth, although she did not appreciate the nature and extent of the problem until he began attending preschool. According to MOTHER, STUDENT's attention deficit/hyperactivity problems preceded her divorce from STUDENT's father and the various changes in STUDENT's family life. She described being asked to pick up STUDENT from preschool because he could not control his hyperactivity. She indicated that STUDENT is now a teenager who cannot sleep, fidgets constantly, watches TV all night, and sometimes bangs his fists against the walls out of frustration. She reports that STUDENT is so sick of school that he sometimes literally throws up at the prospect of it.

GRANDFATHER, STUDENT's grandfather, confirmed much of STUDENT's history as related in the documentary evidence and through the testimony of Dr. Kroplick and MOTHER. GRANDFATHER indicated that STUDENT has written notes talking of suicide.

Respondent's Witnesses

The witnesses for the School District paint a different portrait of STUDENT. Ms. Carol Parish, school psychologist, cited the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt given when STUDENT was in the eighth grade as support for the proposition that STUDENT has no serious ADHD. She also cited the Burke's Behavior Rating Scales given when STUDENT was in the ninth grade as support for the conclusion that STUDENT has neither ADHD nor a serious emotional disturbance. Ms. Parish also explained that the District views ADHD as a medical diagnosis for which it does not conduct assessments. According to Ms. Parish, the District awaits a report from a physician before taking action on an ADHD diagnosis. Her opinion is that STUDENT has primarily an oppositional defiance disorder.

Susan Kuntz, school psychologist, portrayed STUDENT's problems as primarily motivational. She acknowledged that she has no expertise in ADHD.

Mr. Al Frankfurter, special education teacher, testified that he tutored STUDENT and worked with Anna Mata on the Assessment of Classroom Performance and Review of STUDENT Records, dated January 12, 1996. Mr. Frankfurter found that he could work well with STUDENT despite STUDENT's defiance, if STUDENT's assignments were broken into small units with detailed instructions and rewarded with an opportunity to use calligraphy thereafter. Based on his experience with other students suffering from ADD, Mr. Frankfurter concluded that STUDENT's problems do not arise from ADD but rather from a failure to show up and participate in school.

Dr. Jeffrey Lampos, a guidance counselor at Conejo Valley High School, testified that Conejo Valley High School is a continuation high school that offers students such as STUDENT an opportunity to complete their education at their own pace. According to Dr. Lampos, STUDENT is in control; he does only those things that he wishes to do.

Mr. Rod Fujita testified that he taught STUDENT in his math and health classes. During these classes, according to Mr. Fujita, STUDENT needed constant reminders to stay on task and tended to socialize. Mr. Fujita noted that STUDENT has many friends with whom he talked during class.

Lisa Moxley taught STUDENT ninth grade science. She testified that while STUDENT asked good questions and volunteered answers, he completed very few projects. According to Ms. Moxley, he socialized extensively during the class.

ANALYSIS

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, (DSM-IV) identifies the "essential feature of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder [as] a persistent pattern of inattention and/or hyperactivity-impulsivity that is more frequent and severe than is typically observed in individuals at a comparable level of development." (Footnote 6) For a diagnosis of ADHD, the DSM-IV requires "some hyperactive-impulsive or inattentive symptoms that cause impairment ... before age 7 years."(footnote 7) (DSM-IV, p. 78)

According to the DSM-IV:

Individuals with this disorder may fail to give close attention to details or may make careless mistakes in school work or other tasks.... Work is often messy and performed carelessly and without considered thought.

Individuals often have difficulty sustaining attention in tasks or play activities and find it hard to persist with tasks until completion.... They often appear as if their mind is elsewhere or as if they are not listening or did not hear what has just been said.... There may be frequent shifts from one uncompleted activity to another. Individuals diagnosed with this disorder may begin a task, move on to another, then turn to yet something else, prior to completing any one task. They do not follow through on requests or instructions and fail to complete school work, chores, or other duties.

(DSM-IV, p. 78)

The hyperactivity of ADHD is manifested by:

fidgetiness or squirming in one's seat ..., by not remaining seated when expected to do so ..., by excessive running or climbing in situations where it is inappropriate ..., by having difficulty playing or engaging quietly in leisure activities ..., by appearing to be often "on the go" or as if "driven by a motor"..., or by talking excessively....

[School- age children] have difficulty remaining seated, get up frequently, and squirm in, or hang on to the edge of their seat. They fidget with objects, tap their hands, and shake their feet or legs excessively. They often get up from the table during meals, while watching television, or while doing homework; they talk excessively; they make excessive noises during quiet activity.

(DSM-IV, p. 79)

The impulsivity of ADHD manifests itself as:

impatience, difficulty in delaying responses, blurting out answers before questions have been completed ..., difficulty awaiting one's turn ..., and frequently interrupting or intruding on others to the point of causing difficulties in social, academic, or occupational settings....

(DSM-IV, p. 79)

Features associated with ADHD may include:

low frustration tolerance, temper outbursts, bossiness, stubbornness, excessive and frequent insistence that requests be met, mood lability, demoralization, dysphoria, rejection by peers, and poor self-esteem. Academic achievement is often impaired and devalued, typically leading to conflict with family and school authorities. Inadequate self-application to tasks that requires sustained effort is often interpreted by others as indicating laziness, a poor sense of responsibility, and oppositional behavior.

Family relationships are often characterized by resentment and antagonizism, especially because variability in the individual's symptomatic status often leads parents to believe that all the troublesome behavior is willful.

(DSM-IV, pp. 80-81)

ADHD must be distinguished from Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) and Conduct Disorder (CD). The DSM-IV defines the essential feature of Oppositional Defiant Disorder as "a recurrent pattern of negativistic, defiant, disobedient, and hostile behavior toward authority figures that persist for at least six months ... and is characterized by the frequent occurrence of at least four of the following behaviors: losing temper ..., arguing with adults ..., actively defying or refusing to comply with the requests or rules of adults ..., deliberately doing things that will annoy other people ..., blaming others for his or her own mistakes or misbehavior ..., being touchy or easily annoyed by others ..., being angry and resentful ..., or being spiteful or vindictive...." (DSM-IV, p. 91)

The essential feature of Conduct Disorder is defined by the DSM-IV as "a repetitive and persistent pattern of behavior in which the basic rights of others or major age appropriate social norms or rules are violated." Conduct disorder can include real or threatened physical harm to others, property theft or damage, deceit, and serious rule violations. (DSM-IV, p. 85)

However, ADHD is frequently accompanied by secondary oppositionalism, including ODD and CD, that develops as the person struggles with the frustration of ADHD and the inability to conform satisfactorily to family and school expectations. (DSM-IV, p. 78)

STUDENT's mother testified that he showed hyperactive symptoms from birth. As early as age 5, STUDENT had trouble staying in his seat at school and talked constantly. His second grade teacher noted symptoms of hyperactivity that included humming, drumming, and moving constantly. At age 7, STUDENT's scored Very Serious on Poor Attention and Serious on Poor Impulse Control on the Burke's Behavior Rating Scale. When he was in the eighth grade, STUDENT was diagnosed as ADD by Dr. Block. Teacher evaluations the following year noted that STUDENT spoke out constantly, was distractible, and had trouble controlling his impulses. In 1993 Dr. Margolin diagnosed STUDENT as suffering from ADHD. In 1994 Dr. Burke concluded it highly likely that STUDENT suffered ADHD based on tests that measure attention and on STUDENT's long history of concentration difficulties, hyperactivity, and distractibility. Dr. Soliman's diagnosis of ADD, while unexplained in his letter, adds weight to the diagnosis of ADHD. Dr. Kroplick offered her diagnosis of ADHD based on her expertise in the field, three months of weekly meetings with STUDENT, and a comprehensive review of his records. Dr. Kroplick did not seek to diminish the extent of STUDENT's oppositional defiance and conduct disorder or his risk of becoming a criminal. The Hearing Officer found her expertise, thoroughness, and candor particularly persuasive.

The District presented no testimony or documentary evidence of comparable thoroughness or sophistication to refute a finding of ADHD. Carol Parish cited the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt for her view that STUDENT has no serious ADHD. The results of the Bender reveal only immaturity, poor emotional control, and poor interpersonal relationships. How or whether the Bender might reveal the presence or absence of an ADHD problem was never explained at the hearing. The Burke's test, as noted above, indicates that poor attention is a major problem for STUDENT.

Ms. Parish asserted that STUDENT's primary problem is ODD.

Certainly, there is substantial evidence, including results of the Burke's and the testimony of Dr. Kroplick, that STUDENT suffers Oppositional Defiant Disorder or possibly Conduct Disorder. However, the record does not reflect a defiant preschooler growing into an indifferent or cruel teenager. The record reveals a child who had severe problems attending to academic tasks and literally could not sit still becoming an increasingly alienated and rebellious youth.

Mr. Frankfurter offered only a broad generalization that STUDENT was not ADD based on his work with ADD students. Dr. Lampos testified that STUDENT is always in control. The District's witnesses also suggested that STUDENT's problems may grow primarily out of an unstable home life. The record is not persuasive on this point.(footnote 8) In any case, a diagnosis of ADHD is based on the symptoms and early onset, not on possible primary or contributing causes. Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that the District found STUDENT eligible for services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act on the grounds that he suffers ADD, combined type.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence in the record overwhelmingly establishes that STUDENT's primary disability is ADHD. However, the inquiry does not end here. ADHD is not listed in federal or state law as one of the disabilities which establishes eligibility for special education.

The U.S. Department of Education takes the position that children with ADD who require special education can satisfy existing eligibility criteria for services under the categories of other health impaired (OHI), specific learning disability (SLD), or serious emotional disturbance (SED). U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, 18 IDELR 116 (1991); see also 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(1). California has adopted a comparable approach. California law states that a student whose educational performance is "adversely affected" by ADHD is eligible for special education if he demonstrates a need by satisfying eligibility criteria in the categories of other health impaired, specific learning disability, or serious emotional disturbance. Education Code § 56339(a).

The issue becomes whether STUDENT satisfies the eligibility criteria for one of these three categories.

1. Does STUDENT Meet the Criteria for Eligibility Under the "Other Health Impairment" (OHI) Category?

A student is eligible for special education if he has an "other health impairment" and, by reason thereof, needs special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1). According to the federal regulations, OHI means "having limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems ... that adversely affects child's education performance." 34 C.F.R.

§ 300.7(b)(8).(footnote 9) See also Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(f).

There is a dearth of case law lending guidance as to how to apply this regulation to children with ADD or ADHD.(footnote 10) According to the U.S. Department of Education:

the criterion [of "limited alertness"] must be viewed in terms of its effect on educational performance. The fact that a child with ADD may experience heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, in conjunction with limited alertness to academic tasks, would not automatically preclude a determination that the child is eligible for services under the OHI category. Rather, if evaluators determine that a child's heightened alertness to environmental stimuli results in limited alertness with respect to educational performance, the "limited alertness" criterion of the OHI category would be satisfied.

Letter to Cohen, 20 IDELR 73 (OSEP 1993).

The Hearing Officer relies on the plain language of the regulation as informed by the OSEP letter to evaluate the facts of this case.

a. Limited Strength, Vitality or Alertness

Dr. Kroplick testified that STUDENT suffers a slowing in key portions of the brain that regulate attention and that his hyperactivity is the brain's attempt to compensate for attention deficiencies. The result of the process and the brain's efforts at compensation is limited alertness and distractibility. Dr. Kroplick also testified that STUDENT's case is one of the most severe she has seen. STUDENT's educational record is replete with evidence of his difficulty remaining alert to the task at hand. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT suffers limited alertness.

b. Due to Chronic or Acute Health Problems

Dr. Kroplick testified that ADHD is neurochemical disorder of the brain with which one is probably born. ADHD is a condition diagnosed by physicians. ADHD is regularly treated in part with medication prescribed by a physician, often a pediatric psychiatrist. ADHD is therefore a health problem.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT was hyperactive from birth.

School records indicate that STUDENT suffered ADHD without remission from at least as early as second grade. The evidence, therefore, establishes that STUDENT's limited alertness is due to a health problem that is chronic in nature.

c. Adversely Affects Educational Performance

Unlike specific learning disability or serious emotional disturbance, the OHI category contains no criteria for determining adverse educational effect.

The record indicates that STUDENT has earned only 16 credits out of the 165 credits typical for a student completing the junior year of high school. He had a comparable disaster in middle school. Certainly, STUDENT's educational performance has been so poor as to be construed as adverse.

The question is whether STUDENT's ADHD should be viewed as the cause of his problem. Ms. Newman found evidence of a developmental expressive writing disorder and Dr. Lulow found presence of mathematics disorder. The tests conducted by Ms. Newman and Dr. Lulow do not appear to establish a specific learning disability. They do, however, point to the struggle STUDENT experiences as a result of his limited ability to concentrate, and they identify important areas in which his ADHD causes problems.

The other substantial factor contributing to STUDENT's dismal academic record has been his oppositionalism. Almost all of those who have evaluated STUDENT have found evidence of it. At various times STUDENT has been suspended, tardy or absent. He has failed to turn in work. During 1995-96, STUDENT attended school so seldom it is fair to say that he all but dropped out.

STUDENT's failure to attend and participate in school is not an immediate result of his attention deficit or hyperactivity. Rather, the evidence indicates that STUDENT's inability to conform to school expectations engendered in him a growing rebelliousness and a devaluing of education from at least his middle school years. In other words, STUDENT's ADHD caused his oppositionalism, which in turn has been a substantial contributing cause of STUDENT's educational predicament. This, then, is a case of mixed causation.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal addressed a comparable question of mixed causation in Capistrano v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995). In that case the court confronted "the question of whether the reason Jeremy Wartenberg did poorly in school was misbehavior or a learning disability." Jeremy Wartenberg suffered a mild attention deficit with related impulsivity and a conduct disorder. The Hearing Officer at the administrative level found that the two could not be separated and that Jeremy's misconduct (including dangerous and violent physical attacks, setting of fires, shoplifting and lying) was primarily caused by his attention deficit rather than his conduct disorder. Based on this finding, the Hearing Officer ruled that Jeremy was entitled to remedies based on his overall condition. The Ninth Circuit concluded as a matter of law that the Hearing Officer had decided the matter correctly.

The court reasoned that 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(10), which defines specific learning disability, settles cases of mixed causation involving specific learning disabilities. The court cited language in 34 CFR 300.7(10) denying eligibility when the learning problem is "primarily the result of" certain specified "non-covered" causes for the proposition that other cases of mixed causation involving specific learning disabilities must be resolved in favor of the student. Thus, where the student's learning problem is caused "primarily" by a specific learning disability, "he would not lose coverage simply because there existed a secondary cause that was not covered." Under such circumstances, the court indicated that a hearing officer or judge should not sort out causes and allocate remedies based on the percentages the various causes played in the educational problem.(footnote 11)

The OHI definition contained in federal and state regulations does not contain language confining eligibility to instances where the health impairment is the primary as opposed to secondary cause of the adverse educational performance. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer reads a "primary cause" requirement into the provision in deference to the broader reasoning in Wartenberg and the policies of the IDEA and its regulations as discussed in Wartenberg.

STUDENT suffers a severe case of ADHD. The pattern of his oppositionalism is most reasonably viewed as his response to his inability to comply with educational expectations. There is a clear correlation between his attention deficit-impulsivity and his oppositionalism. While his conduct can be construed as willful in a sense, his oppositionalism takes primarily the form of passive resistance to school rules and educational requirements that his mental processes do not allow him to meet. Unlike Jeremy Wartenberg, whose conduct disorder and mild learning difficulty were arguably only remotely connected, STUDENT is a young man whose negative behavior to date is largely a series of self-defeating reactions to an attention deficit-impulsivity condition he cannot yet control. In effect, STUDENT is attempting to escape the pain of educational frustration and defeat. The Hearing Officer finds that ADHD is the primary cause of STUDENT's school problems, including his inability to pay attention and sit still in class, his writing and math deficiencies, and his growing oppositionalism to school. The ADHD is, therefore, the original and primary cause of the adverse effect upon his education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT meets all the eligibility criteria for OHI and is eligible for special education.

Because STUDENT suffers an OHI, it is unnecessary to address whether or not he has a specific learning disability or a serious emotional disturbance.

2. What Remedies Is STUDENT Entitled to?

As a student with OHI, STUDENT is entitled to a free appropriate education at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000 and § 56040. Given the severe and long-standing nature of his disability, STUDENT may be entitled to other relief as well. See, e.g., Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994). A hearing officer has broad latitude to craft appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(2); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). However, the Petitioner never requested specific remedies. The hearing focused almost exclusively on the question of eligibility. The various schools and facilities cited as placement options for STUDENT were merely touched upon. Sufficient evidence was not presented to justify ordering any of them. Therefore, it becomes necessary to order an IEP team meeting to address STUDENT's educational needs.

In this case, the IEP team should not meet without some guidance. The testimony of Dr. Kroplick, supported by the testimony of STUDENT's mother and grandfather, and the urgent recommendations in the reports from Dr. Margolin and Dr. Burke lead to the conclusion that, at the very least, STUDENT requires an out-of-home (residential) placement in a school that specializes in ADHD and behavior modification.

The Hearing Officer believes it unlikely that without the participation on the IEP team of Dr. Kroplick, who appears to have won STUDENT's confidence, STUDENT will participate willingly in further educational efforts. The long history of disagreement between the parties, the apparent dearth of information possessed by the District about ADHD, and the District's view that it needs a physician to guide it in such matters also argue in favor of Dr. Kroplick's active participation on the IEP team. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team must include Dr. Kroplick, at District expense. See Letter to Parker, 18 IDELR 963 (OSEP 1991). Since placing STUDENT may require several IEP team meetings, the Hearing Officer further concludes that Dr. Kroplick should be invited at District expense for a least two meetings of the IEP team.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT is seventeen years old. He must therefore be invited to the IEP team meeting as well. 34 C.F.R. 344(c) and note 2 thereto.

ORDER

1. STUDENT is eligible for special education as a student with an other health impairment.

2. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team. The IEP team shall (a) develop an appropriate IEP for STUDENT; (b) identify an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year; and (c) provide such other remedies as STUDENT is entitled to.

3. The District shall invite Dr. Kroplick to join the IEP team at District expense for at least two meetings. The District shall also invite STUDENT to join the team.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: Petitioner prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

________________________________ Edwin Villmoare Chief Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The testimony offered by the parties, with the exception of the testimony of Dr. Marilyn Kroplick, M.D., was somewhat disjointed and of limited relevance. On the other hand, the documentary evidence presented by the parties contains a relatively straightforward history of STUDENT's educational problems. For this reason, the documentary evidence is reviewed before the testimony is reviewed. 2. STUDENT's scores on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-R (WISC-R) were Verbal I.Q. 131, Performance I.Q. 105, and Full Scale I.Q. 121. STUDENT's lowest achievement scores were 103 on the Math Cluster of the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test and 103 on the Spelling Section of the Wide Range Achievement Test. 3. Prior to writing her report, Ms. Newman learned of Ms. Kuntz' testing from STUDENT. She acknowledged this event in her report.

4. ADD is a variation of ADHD. Hyperactivity is a typical concomitant of attention deficit. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, pp. 78-85. Experts often use ADD and ADHD interchangeably. 5. In addition to the witnesses discussed below, Petitioner called several District officials who had little direct knowledge of this case and supplied no relevant testimony. For this reason, their testimony is not discussed. 6. The DSM-IV is widely relied upon by parties to special education cases to define and characterize mental disabilities.

7. The U.S. Department of Education estimates that 3% to 5% of school age children suffer ADHD. U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, 18 IDELR 116 (1991). According to the DSM-IV, the ratio of male to female suffering ADHD is estimated in the range from4:1 to 9:1 8. The Hearing Officer notes that the District has had educational responsibility for Student for six out of the last nine years . (Joint Exhibit 1) 9. Examples of such health problems given in the federal regulations include asthma and epilepsy. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8).

10. There appears to be just one case on point. In Lyons v. Smith, 829 F.Supp. 414(D. D. C. 1993), the court found that a child with ADHD who had "superior" academic performance did not qualify as OHI. The case is distinguishable in that STUDENT has not achieved superior academic performance.

11. In a robust dissent, Judge Ferguson asserted that the record established only that Jeremy's attention deficit disorder caused his learning disability but not that the learning disability caused his behavioral problems. Judge Ferguson argued that a school district should not be responsible for a child whose learning disability is not the cause of his educational failure. Neither the court nor Judge Ferguson fully addressed the relationship of Jeremy's conduct disorder to his attention deficit disorder. In the instant case, the hearing officer finds that STUDENT's ADHD is the cause of his oppositionalism and that together his ADD and his oppositionalism caused his school problems, as discussed in the text below. The oppositionalism is not a separate unrelated cause, but a related result, a link in the causal chain that produces STUDENT's educational problems