California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 19, 2001
Student v. Rio Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1810-00 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Rio Elementary must reimburse $32,674.52 for a home behavioral program after its preschool SDC offer denied FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a three-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Rio Elementary School District. They challenged the District's offer for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY). They also sought reimbursement for a home-based, one-on-one behavioral program from Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA). At a September 2000 IEP meeting, the District offered a preschool special day class (SDC) two hours a day, four days a week, plus speech-language therapy and occupational therapy. The Hearing Officer found that the District's assessment relied almost entirely on parent report. The IEP's present levels understated the child's severe deficits and left out his behaviors, attention problems and sensory issues. The IEP had no behavior goals and lacked specific goals for attention span. The Hearing Officer relied mainly on testimony from clinical psychologist Dr. Melanie Lennington and BECA's Janet Yi. He found the child was too distractible and noncompliant to benefit from a small-group SDC, so the offer denied a FAPE. He did not decide the procedural claims. He found that the BECA program met the child's needs and produced major gains. The parents had withheld information before the IEP meeting. Even so, the Hearing Officer refused to reduce reimbursement because the District would not have changed its SDC offer. The District must pay $32,674.52 for September 5, 2000 through August 1, 2001. The award excludes $4,499.60 in training costs incurred before the offer and the first supervision fee.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a preschool autism case under Rowley. An assessment built mostly on parent report, and present levels that understated severe deficits, undercut the District's SDC offer. The parents' lack of cooperation did not reduce reimbursement because it would not have changed the District's offer. Costs incurred before the District made its offer were excluded.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The September 19, 2000 offer of a 2-hour-a-day, 4-day-a-week preschool SDC with speech and OT denied FAPE. The present levels understated the child's deficits, the IEP had no behavior goals and too few attention goals, and the child's distractibility and behaviors would have kept him from benefiting from the SDC. The Hearing Officer did not decide the procedural claims.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the parents' costs of having STUDENT in a private program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The BECA home program met the child's needs and gave him educational benefit. The parents' lack of cooperation did not justify a reduction because the District would not have changed its SDC offer. The Hearing Officer awarded $32,674.52 but excluded pre-offer training costs and the first supervision installment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the District shall pay the parents $32,674.52 as reimbursement for the BECA program for September 5, 2000 through August 1, 2001, including 6 weeks of extended school year. Training costs ($4,499.60) and the first BECA supervision installment ($1,779.25) were not awarded. Reimbursement after the 2000-2001 school year and ESY was denied as outside the issues.
Total: $32,674.52 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Marina Ellis, special education teacher (proposed preschool SDC), Rio Elementary School District
- Lee Zinter, school psychologist, Rio Elementary School District
- David Lopez, assistant superintendent, Rio Elementary School District
- Illayne Kiel, speech and language specialist, Rio Elementary School District
- Fran Arner-Costello, special education coordinator (training and staff development), Ventura County SELPA
- Melanie Lennington, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Janet Yi, director/president and educational consultant; nonpublic agency provider, witness for Student, Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA)
- Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), nonpublic agency providing home-based behavioral program
- E. Cheryl Fletcher, private speech-language pathologist, Tri-Counties Regional Center referral
- Steven Graff, Ph.D., psychological evaluator, Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Robert Nopar, M.D., psychological/diagnostic evaluator, Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., private evaluator, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Lynn Koegel, Ph.D., parent training program director, UCSB Autism Research and Training Center
- Cynthia Carter, Ph.D., progress report author, UCSB Autism Research and Training Center
- Developmental Milestones, private developmental and OT evaluator
- Tri-Counties Regional Center, regional center providing Early Start and continuing speech and OT services
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on June 5, 6, July 24, 25, 31, August 1, and October 3 and 4, 2001, in Oxnard, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his attorney, Ralph Lewis. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER. Respondent Rio Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Nancy Stephens from the office of Filarsky and Watt LLP. Also present on behalf of the District was David Lopez, assistant superintendent for the District.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Marina Ellis, special education teacher; Lee Zinter, school psychologist for the District; David Lopez; Melanie Lennington, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; Janet Yi, director of Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA); and MOTHER. The District called the following witnesses: David Lopez; Illayne Kiel, speech and language specialist at the District; and Fran Arner-Costello, special education coordinator for the Ventura County SELPA.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the receipt of written closing arguments on November 16, 2001.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)
(1) Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
(2) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the parents’ costs of having STUDENT in a private program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner alleges that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. More specifically, the Petitioner alleges that the District failed to conduct a proper assessment, that the present levels of performance and goals and objectives listed by the District were inappropriate, and that his needs could not be met in the special day class (SDC) offered by the District. The Petitioner also alleges various procedural violations. The Petitioner’s parents seek reimbursement for their private placement of STUDENT in a BECA program. The District asserts that it offered a FAPE to the Petitioner for the 2000-2001 school year. The District also asserts that if the Hearing Officer determines a FAPE was not offered for the 2000-2001 school year, the Petitioner’s claim for reimbursement should be reduced or denied because of the conduct of the Petitioner’s parents.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], is eligible for special education services as a child with autism. STUDENT has received no services through the District.
STUDENT’s parents, concerned about STUDENT’s speech and language, presented him to the Tri-Counties Regional Center (TRC) for early intervention services through the Ventura County Early Start program in May 1999. (Pet. Ex. 2.) A worksheet completed by the parents indicated that STUDENT used only one word, “no.” (Pet. Ex. 3.)
By referral from TRC, a “developmental evaluation” was performed on STUDENT by Developmental Milestones on June 24, 1999. At the age of 22 months, STUDENT’s developmental age in mental and motor skills was found to be 14 months. Language was at 10 months, with cognition at 13 months. (Pet. Ex. 4.) Also by referral from TRC, speech and language evaluation was performed by E. Cheryl Fletcher, speech pathologist, on July 7, 1999. Ms. Fletcher concluded that STUDENT had profound delays in receptive and expressive language skills and communication skills, with play skills significantly restricted. He was functioning in receptive language at an age equivalent of 8 months. Expressively, his only word was “no,” and that word did not appear to be used in context. (Pet. Ex. 6.)
STUDENT’s mother consented to an individualized family service plan (IFSP) on July 20, 1999. (Pet. Ex. 5.) The IFSP provided for a 15-hour-per-month program that primarily consisted of 2 hours of speech and language per week, provided by Ms. Fletcher, and 1 hour of occupational therapy (OT) per week.
Psychological evaluation was performed through TRC on August 4, 1999. The report by the examiners Steven Graff, Ph.D., and Robert Nopar, M.D., states that STUDENT had qualitative impairment in social interaction, manifested by marked impairment in the use of multiple nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, body postures, and gestures to regulate social interaction. He had a qualitative impairment in communication, as manifested by a delay in, or total lack of, the development of spoken language, not accompanied by an attempt to compensate through alternative modes of communication, such as gestures or mime. He had restrictive, repetitive, and stereotyped patterns of behavior, interests, and activities, as manifested by stereotyped and repetitive motor mannerisms. The examiners commented that STUDENT was “very isolated in session and seemed to be very much in his own world, with very little interactivity with the rest of us.” They advised STUDENT’s parents that the type of services currently being received were appropriate. The report states that a program such as 35 to 40 hours per week of Lovaas discreet trial training (DTT) was “contraindicated by the scientific review of data of the Lovaas projects,” and that a “more holistic approach” might be a better way to serve STUDENT.(Footnote 3) (Pet. Ex. 8.)
Occupational therapy evaluation was performed on August 8, 1999, by Developmental Milestones. The report states that STUDENT cooperated well for his age during testing. He was found to be performing fine and gross motor skills close to age expectancy, but efficiency of motor control was poor. Compensatory motor patterns were effecting his skilled motor patterns. (Pet. Ex. 7.)
Following approval by TRC, STUDENT’s parent’s enrolled him in the “Koegel program” at the end of August 1999. This was a parent training program administered by Lynn Koegel, Ph.D., at the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB). (Pet. Ex. 11, 12.)
According to a memo by Ms. Fletcher dated August 27, 1999, STUDENT had been making some significant gains since commencing speech and language therapy with her in July. He was babbling more and was beginning to say an occasional word. The memo mentions that when therapy started, STUDENT’s mother had expressed a strong desire for intensive intervention, such as a discrete trial training by CARD (Center for Autism and Related Disorders) based on Lovaas-type therapy. The memo indicates that Ms. Fletcher did not believe the intensity of a CARD program was appropriate for a two-year-old child, although in the same memo Ms. Fletcher states “all current research suggests that it is the intensity of the program that makes the difference in the outcome for children like STUDENT. Communication is a core deficit for him and he continues to need intensive speech and language services.”(Footnote 4) (Pet. Ex. 11.)
STUDENT was evaluated by Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., at CARD on September 22, 1999. Dr. Granpesheeh concluded that STUDENT presented with some symptoms indicative of autism. She recommended 25 to 40 hours per week of one-on-one intensive behavioral intervention in the form of DTT. (Pet. Ex. 14.) Dr. Granpeesheh’s report notes that STUDENT exhibited various maladaptive behaviors, including non-compliance, tantruming that included crying, and aggression in the form of biting. He exhibited frequent self-stimulatory behaviors such as shaking his head, pushing his head in the corner of the sofa, jumping, repetitive motor activity, and verbal stimulatory behavior.(Footnote 5)
A “pre-intervention assessment” was performed at the UCSB Autism Research and Training Center on October 7, 1999. The January 11, 2000 report from Dr. Koegel states that STUDENT was exhibiting symptoms of autism, including communication delays, reduced social interaction, and some repetitive behaviors. He was using no expressive words or vocalizations. Dr. Koegel recommended that the primary focus of intervention should be “instating STUDENT’s intentful expressive words through a parent education model, using motivational procedures . . . including the use of choice, rewarding attempts, task variation, and natural and direct consequences.” The parents asked Dr. Koegel about a more structured program, but Dr. Koegel recommended “that he not be taught words and language in a drill format.” Dr. Koegel stated that “research suggests that this does not lead to as rapid gains as when motivational procedures are incorporated, and greater levels of disruptive behavior have been shown to occur. I feel that this is especially important with STUDENT, as we do not want him to engage in task avoidance.”(Footnote 6) (Pet. Ex. 1.)
STUDENT’s IFSP was updated on April 10, 2000, providing for the continuation of services until further review in July 2000. It was expected that upon reaching the age of 3 years, STUDENT would transition to a District program. (Pet. Ex. 16.)
On April 11, 2000, STUDENT’s mother made a written request to Ms. Zinter, the District’s school psychologist, to have STUDENT assessed for special education services. (Pet. Ex. 17.) Also on April 11, the TRC service coordinator made a written referral to Ms. Zinter at the District for STUDENT to receive preschool services. An unspecified “packet of information” was sent with the letter from TRC. (Pet. Ex. 18.)(Footnote 7)
On April 24, 2000, Ms. Zinter responded on behalf of the District by sending a preschool questionnaire to STUDENT’s parents. (Pet. Ex. 19.) When the parents met with Ms. Zinter on May 12, they were informed that because STUDENT’s third birthday would occur during summer recess, the assessment would have to be performed either within a few weeks or in early September. On May 19, the parents informed Ms. Zinter by letter that they preferred to have the assessment before September, to enable enough time for preparation between the assessment and the IEP. (Pet. Ex. 20.) On May 22, Ms. Zinter sent notice to STUDENT’s parents that they would receive an assessment plan within 15 days, and that an IEP meeting would be held within 50 days of receipt of the signed assessment plan, excluding school vacation days in excess of 5 days. (Pet. Ex. 21.) An assessment plan was signed by STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Zinter on June 6. The areas of assessment checked on the form were pre-academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development, and intellectual development. (Pet. Ex. 23.)
The District’s speech and language assessment consisted of an interview with STUDENT’s mother. The report dated June 6, 2000, states that the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3) was administered using parent report instead of direct observation.(Footnote 8) Based on parent report, STUDENT scored in the first percentile in auditory comprehension, expressive communication, and total language. STUDENT would make his needs known by gestures, usually pulling and pointing. He also would say “guh” to let his caregivers know when he wanted something. (Pet. Ex. 24.)
A multidisciplinary team report was signed by Ms. Zinter, bearing the date of June 20, 2000. The team members listed on the report were a school principal, school psychologist, preschool teacher, and speech/language specialist. Information used for the report was derived from an interview with STUDENT’s TRC service coordinator, developmental history (from unspecified sources), medical history (from unspecified sources), review of unspecified TRC records, review of unspecified previous assessment records, parent interview using a developmental checklist, developmental observation (by unspecified persons), and the PLS-3 (as administered by parent report). (Pet. Ex. 25.)
The team report states that “STUDENT’s performance during formal testing did appear to be adversely affected by his behavior. He has little interest in test items and needs much assistance to initiate a response to the items. He has difficulty following directions and tends to respond best to more functional test items and procedures. He did require many adaptations or modifications to the standardized procedures.”(Footnote 9) The report states that “STUDENT exhibits impairment in social interactions, communication (expressive language), and stereotypical patterns of behavior associated with Autism.” The report states that according to parent report and observation, STUDENT could, when prompted and willing, perform tasks consistent with cognitive skills associated with “mental representations” (age 18-24 months), and he demonstrated emerging skills in “preconceptual thought” (age 2-4 years). Motor imitation was limited. He could make request utterances.(Footnote 10) The team report concludes by recommending that the parents continue TRC services through the summer, that Dr. Graff complete his diagnosis, that OT evaluation be performed, that the parents investigate the continuum of placements available at the District, and that a meeting date be set, preferably in the first week of the 2000-2001 school year, to arrange a placement for STUDENT.
STUDENT’s mother testified that when she attended the assessment on June 20, 2000, she was informed for the first time that the District wanted to hold an IEP meeting promptly because Ms. Zinter was leaving for Florida within a few days. Until receiving that information, STUDENT’s mother did not know that a “time crunch” existed for completing an IEP. MOTHER responded that she could not have “her people” ready on such short notice, including the service providers who were familiar with STUDENT through working with him over the past year. MOTHER thought their presence would be important for the purpose of developing goals and objectives. According to MOTHER, Ms. Zinter’s response was that she did not know why the presence of other persons was so important, that she had never been to an IEP meeting with more than 5 people, and that she had already written a couple of goals that could be rewritten if STUDENT did not perform to them. MOTHER testified that she received a telephone call from Ms. Zinter at about 5:00 p.m. on June 20, asking if MOTHER could attend an IEP meeting the next day. MOTHER reponded by saying that due to child care issues and STUDENT’s service providers not being ready on such short notice, she could not attend.
An IEP meeting was held on June 22, 2000. STUDENT’s parents did not attend. Ms. Zinter testified that the IEP meeting was held for the purpose of confirming to the parents that STUDENT was eligible for services, describing his needs, and describing some possible programs. The June 22, 2000 IEP states that TRC and OT would complete their evaluations during the summer, and then final decisions on a program would be made at a September 2000 IEP meeting. The June 2000 IEP states that STUDENT would require placement in an SDC. Present levels of performance and goals and objectives were attached, with a written preface that the parents were concerned about appropriate goals and placement, and that the parents wanted “to do more exploration.” (Pet. Ex. 26.)
Further evaluations were completed during the summer of 2000. An evaluation by UCSB on June 30, 2000, using Bayley Scales and Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales showed that STUDENT, at age 2 years and 11 months, was performing at a developmental age equivalent of 15 months (Bayley). His communication domain was at an age equivalent of 10 months (Vineland). Socialization was at 11 months, daily living skills at 16 months, and motor skills at 28 months (Vineland). (Pet. Ex. 28.)
Occupational therapy assessment was performed on July 13, 2000. (Pet. Ex. 33.) The report states that STUDENT exhibited some sensory issues, especially in proprioceptive, tactile, and visual areas, and sensory-motor delays that “might impact his performance in the preschool setting.” School-based OT was recommended to help STUDENT function better in his anticipated preschool classroom setting. A very structured preschool program was recommended since transitioning from one activity to another and following adult command “seemed to be challenges for STUDENT.”
Also on July 13, 2000, Dr. Nopar undated his prior evaluation of STUDENT through TRC and completed his diagnosis, finding that STUDENT met the DSM-IV criteria for autism. (Pet. Ex. 45.)
STUDENT was evaluated by Janet Yi, educational consultant, at Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA) on July 17, 2000. (Pet. Ex. 46.) At that time, according to Ms. Yi’s report, STUDENT was receiving speech therapy for about 2 hours per week and OT for about 1 hour per week, and the parents were receiving 3 to 5 hours per week of training from the Autism Research Center at UCSB. Ms. Yi recommended a home-based one-to-one behavioral education program starting at 15 to 20 hours per week and increasing to 35 to 40 hours per week.(Footnote 11)
A 9-month progress report from Cynthia Carter, Ph.D., at UCSB, dated July 27, 2000, states that when STUDENT began the parent education program he was very removed socially from his siblings and parents. He engaged in nonverbal communications (placing his mother’s hand upon objects) and inappropriate behaviors (excessive tantrums and hitting) to get his needs met. He showed no intentful verbalizations, no receptive language, few initiation behaviors, very few occurrences of preverbal skills such as eye-contact or pointing, and no self-help skills. After 9 months of the parent education program, STUDENT was reportedly making clear verbal expressive attempts to obtain highly desired items and activities. He was using the verbal utterances “ah-gah,” “a-go,” and “no.” He was showing “greatly increased” receptive language, making eye contact when told “look at me” or when his name was called. He seemed to understand the directive “come here.” He could count to 12 and label printed numbers, label alphabet letters, name Pooh characters, and finish songs his mother would sing by mouthing the words. However, he did not use such words in a functional manner. For example, to obtain his Winnie the Pooh doll, he would use the utterance “a-gah,” even though he could label Pooh. He had developed some imitative skills such as clapping and smiling. Regarding social skills, he would seek out his sister or mother to play with him. He would seek out his mother when he needed help. He could do simple turn-taking by rolling a ball to a partner for a few turns. His eye contact was greatly increased, and he would often smile in response to a familiar adult smiling at him. He would spontaneously kiss his mother and another familiar adult. He still demonstrated non-compliant behaviors such as pinching and crying.
STUDENT’s mother testified that during the week of August 7, 2000, she received the District’s written IEP proposal dated June 22, 2000. She testified that the IEP proposal was promptly returned to the District with a note by her stating that the parents were not in agreement with the goals developed for STUDENT and that the parents were requesting an IEP meeting. (Pet. Ex. 26.)
STUDENT became a client of BECA and began receiving services on August 18, 2000. Ms. Yi wrote a report (Pet. Ex. 30) entitled “IEP Goal Recommendations” in preparation for the next IEP meeting, scheduled for September 19, 2000. The report states that STUDENT had been receiving BECA services consisting of one-to-one behavioral intervention in the home, approximately 24 hours per week. According to the portions of the BECA report regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance, STUDENT did not demonstrate understanding of instructions presented to him. He did not demonstrate the ability to receptively identify objects. Concerning expressive language, he could usually make a sound within 3 to 5 seconds after an adult’s model, but the vocalization was always something similar to “ago” or “again.” However, he had a variety of spontaneous vocalizations (9 are listed in the report) and he could spontaneously name letters of the alphabet and numbers. He could communicate basic desires of drink, balloon, and pretzel by using Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) icons in a one-to-one teaching setting. He could initiate 2 gross motor actions involving objects, such as hitting a drum. He could stack up to 4 blocks. He had begun matching 3-dimensional (3D) objects, such as a blue cup to a blue cup. He could independently complete peg and knob puzzles. He was not demonstrating functional play, although he would gather and hold his Winnie the Pooh and Teletubby figures and move them from location to location. He preferred to eat with his hands instead of using utensils. He could take off his socks and shoes and pull up/off his pants. He had limited fine motor control and hand/wrist strength. He had not yet fully acclimated to the one-to-one instructional setting, as he would often demonstrate avoidant behaviors such as getting out of his seat before completing a task, crying, or falling out of the chair when a request was made.
Ms. Yi’s recommendations were that STUDENT receive 40 hours per week of one-to-one behavioral education in the home setting. She recommended that STUDENT not attend school at the present time. She stated that school could be considered after STUDENT (a) acquired generalized imitation and observational learning skills, (b) could follow basic instructions, (c) could tolerate an increased amount of instructions, (d) used basic expressive language, (e) had acquired basic toy-play skills and had generalized that skill to several different settings, (f) was toilet trained, (g) demonstrated low levels of challenging and/or repetitive behaviors, and (h) demonstrated flexibility in transitioning between activities. Ms. Yi recommended that the home-based program focus on communication, language, pre-academics, motor development, self-help, play, and socialization. Six pages of goals and objectives were attached to the report.
Ms. Fletcher completed an updated speech and language evaluation on September 10, 2000. (Pet. Ex. 31.) Testing showed that STUDENT continued to present with a severe delay in receptive language skills. He could recognize some family names, respond to the gesture “come up” and respond to “no.” He would turn to his name consistently. He would respond to some routine commands such as “come,” “stop,” or “sit down.” He responded to visual and gestural cues such as an open hand gesture for help or give me. His play skills continued to be very restricted. He was able to sort at least 6 colors. He was starting to sort objects and match object to picture. He continued to have profound delays in expressive language. He was apparently using PECS as his primary method of communication in the speech and language sessions. Recommendations were to use PECS, increase communication attempts, increase receptive language skills, increase play repertoire, use visually structured teaching methods, develop turn-taking skills, and increase vocalizations through spontaneous imitation and in play.
An IEP meeting was held on September 19, 2000. (Pet. Ex. 39.) The District’s offer was 30 minutes of speech and language, 3 times per week (2 individual, 1 group setting); 60 minutes of OT, 1 time per week; and prekindergarten special day class (SDC), 2 hours per day, 4 days per week.
STUDENT’s parents attended the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting with their attorney. Their attached dissent states that the District and parents had presented reports from various providers. The parents had presented the goals and objectives from BECA. The parents thought that an SDC offer was inappropriate and that STUDENT required a “Lovaas type program,” specifically the one in place from BECA, for 40 hours of direct therapy per week, 5 hours per week of supervision, 1 hour per quarter of director or assistant director review, ½ hour per week of therapy team meeting, and supplies for the home program. The parents requested that the program be implemented 52 weeks per year. Additionally, the parents requested speech at 3 times per week for 50 minutes per session and OT once per week for 60 minutes.
STUDENT’s mother testified that she visited the District’s proposed SDC with Ms. Zinter on September 25, 2000. MOTHER’s opinion was that virtually everything she saw in that SDC would have been wrong for STUDENT. She elected to keep STUDENT in the BECA program throughout the 2000-2001 school year. TRC continued to provide and pay for speech and language and OT services.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District offer a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Under State and federal law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8).
The term “special education” means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services,” at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
The parameters for adequacy of a student’s IEP are set forth in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982). The United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-208.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires States to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
In summary, there are two overall categories of inquiry. One category of inquiry is substantive appropriateness. Under the IDEA , State law, and Rowley, the program the District has proposed for the 2001-2002 school year must have met the following four substantive requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for the Petitioner: (I) been designed to meet his unique needs, (II) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (III) comported with his IEP, and (IV) provided him an education in the least restrictive environment. The other category of inquiry is procedural appropriateness: Has the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?
Substantive Appropriateness
I. Did the District offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? A. STUDENT’s unique needs.
Before determining whether the District offered a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. As STUDENT approached his third birthday in July 2000, he had numerous deficits arising from his autism. STUDENT was functioning at a communication level of about 10 months, socialization level of about 11 months, and daily living skill level of about 16 months as measured by the Vineland administered at UCSB. He had little or no functional use of language. He had noncompliant behaviors such as pinching, crying, biting, and tantruming. He had a history of frequent self-stimulatory behaviors.
The District’s OT report (dated July 13, 2000) states that STUDENT had sensory “issues” in proprioceptive, tactile, and visual areas, and sensory-motor delays. The extent of those sensory issues is not quantified in the OT report. The District’s OT report states that transitioning from one activity to another and following adult commands “seemed to be challenges for STUDENT.” Despite the tenuous phraseology in the OT report, the evidence demonstrated that understanding and following adult commands were severe challenges for STUDENT.
STUDENT needed speech and language services to address his severe receptive and expressive language deficits. He needed services to address his socialization and daily living deficits. He needed services to address noncompliant behaviors. He needed services to address deficits in attention to task, transitioning from one activity to another, and understanding and following adult commands. He needed OT services to address his sensory issues regarding proprioceptive, tactile, and visual areas and sensory motor delays. He needed a placement and program with sufficient structure and intensity to enable him to benefit from the services.
B. The District’s program offer.
In response to STUDENT’s unique needs, the District initially developed the June 22, 2000 IEP at the meeting where STUDENT’s parents were not present. The proposed IEP confirmed that STUDENT was eligible for services as a child with speech and language deficits. The District offered placement in an SDC for preschool children. Present levels of performance were stated. Goals and objectives were attached in the areas of attention span, general knowledge, and communication skills. The June 22, 2000 IEP proposed by the District specifically states that the purpose of that IEP meeting was simply to document portions of the IEP, such as establishing eligibility and the need for an SDC, with further evaluations to occur over the summer and a placement to be determined in September 2000. The June 22, 2000 IEP also acknowledged that the parents were concerned about having appropriate goals, and that the parents wanted to do more exploration.
At the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting, the District’s offer was 30 minutes of speech and language, 3 times per week (2 individual, 1 group setting); 60 minutes of OT, 1 time per week; and prekindergarten SDC, 2 hours per day, 4 days per week. The IEP listed present levels of performance in cognitive level, academics/pre-academics, vocational skills/community access, motor abilities and/or recreation/leisure, self-help/domestic skills, communication skills, and social/emotional status. The IEP states that “STUDENT exhibits behaviors and needs related to his handicapping condition which require services and a setting in which he can progress in developmental areas.” The IEP states that training would be “determined for personnel.” The IEP states that STUDENT could participate in a small-group setting. Goals and objectives were listed for speech and language, OT, number readiness, functional play, and matching identical and nonidentical items.
C. Discussion
The Petitioner asserts that present levels of performance on the June 22, 2000 IEP were insufficiently stated, that goals and objectives were deficient and not measurable, and that the placement and services offered were insufficient to meet his unique needs. The District asserts that the purpose of the June 22, 2000 IEP was simply to document portions of the IEP, such as establishing the District’s position on eligibility and confirming that an SDC would be offered.
The Hearing Officer agrees with the District that the June 22, 2000 IEP does not purport to be a complete program offer for the 2000-2001 school year. The June 22, 2000 IEP states that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services, that the District believed STUDENT would require an SDC, that further assessment would be completed during the summer, and that placement and final decisions on goals and objectives would be determined in September 2000.
The District’s actual program offer for the 2000-2001 school year is delineated in the September 19, 2000 IEP. Analysis of the September 19, 2000 IEP will determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
The Petitioner asserts that the assessment information used for the September 19, 2000 IEP was deficient. The Petitioner asserts that the present levels of performance and the goals and objectives stated in the September 19, 2000 IEP, although improved in comparison to the June 22, 2000 IEP, were still deficient. The Petitioner asserts that an SDC placement would have been inappropriate because the Petitioner did not have the requisite skills to benefit from the proposed SDC. The Petitioner also asserts that the intensity of the program offered by the District was insufficient to meet his unique needs.
Assessment. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320 provides, in part, that before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of a child with exceptional needs in special education instruction, the child shall be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. No single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Section 56320 envisions the use of tests and assessment materials that are administered by properly trained and qualified personnel and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used.
The District’s assessment plan dated June 6, 2000, provides for assessment in all areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability, including pre-academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, self-help/adaptive skills, psycho-motor development, language/speech/communication development, and intellectual development. (Pet. Ex. 23.)
After receiving consent to the assessment plan, the District developed its multidisciplinary team report dated June 20, 2000. The multidisciplinary team report was quite vague in identifying its sources of information. The “background information” section was derived from earlier reports. Most or all of the information in the multidisciplinary team report with respect to STUDENT’s current abilities and deficits appeared to have been gleaned from reporting by STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Zinter testified that she saw STUDENT for a total of about 3 hours as STUDENT was present in the room when she interviewed his mother.(Footnote 12) However, in reading the multidisciplinary team report, one cannot ascertain whether any of the statements in the report resulted from direct interaction with STUDENT or even from observation of STUDENT by Ms. Zinter or any other team member. No formal testing was listed except for the PLS-3, and that test was administered solely by parent reporting.(Footnote 13) The multidisciplinary team report cites the results of the District’s speech and language assessment dated June 7, 2000. Nothing on the June 7, 2000 speech and language report indicates that STUDENT was actually observed by the person conducting the assessment. The person writing the speech and language report emphasized in the report that the information was obtained by parent interview.
Although the multidisciplinary team report did not constitute a comprehensive assessment, the multidisciplinary team report and the June 22, 2000 IEP both state that further assessment through STUDENT’s TRC program would be performed during the summer of 2000. Further assessment was completed and considered at the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting. New reports available at the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting included the evaluation by UCSB on June 30, 2000, using Bayley Scales and Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales; the OT assessment performed on July 13, 2000; the July 13, 2000 report by Dr. Nopar, finding that STUDENT met the DSM-IV criteria for autism; the 9-month progress report from Cynthia Carter, Ph.D., at UCSB, dated July 27, 2000; and Ms. Fletcher’s speech and language evaluation dated September 10, 2000. The Hearing Officer finds that, collectively, those documents provided assessment in all areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability.(Footnote 14)
Present levels of performance. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 provides that for a preschool- age child, the written IEP shall list the present levels of the pupil’s educational performance, including, as appropriate, how the disability affects the child’s participation in appropriate activities.
Present levels of performance on the September 19, 2000 IEP are listed in the categories of cognitive level, academics/pre-academics, vocational skills/community access, motor abilities and/or recreation/leisure, self-help/domestic skills, communication skills, and social/emotional status.
For cognitive level, the IEP states that when assessed in June 2000, “STUDENT completed tasks associated with mental representations with some emerging skills at higher levels within the age of 2-4 years.” For academics/pre-academics, the IEP states: “emerging skills in one-to-one correspondence - rote counts to 12 - recites the alphabet - randomly names some letters when he desires - matches colors - does not name colors - beginning to sort by colors”; for vocational skills/community access: “clear expressive verbal attempt to obtain highly desired items - natural reinforcers are beneficial - seeking out parents to take him to bed - seeks out mom for help or when he has hurt himself - positive behavior support is effective”; for motor abilities and/or recreation/leisure: “likes a trampoline swing - climbs on playground equipment - turns cranks on mechanical toys - puts small objects in a container - makes scribbles with writing instrument”; for self-help/domestic: “pulls pants up/down from his knees - uses a fork - using a sippy cup to drink - brushes his own teeth with assistance of adult”; for communication skills: “receptively, recognizes some words, gestures and photos/pictures and some commands. Expressive communication skills include gestures, verbalizations, word approximations. Establishing play routines and joint attention”; for health: “no reported medical problems”; for social/emotional: “beginning to make transitions learning to make requests likes praise, hugs and sometimes tangible reinforcers reciprocal social interaction - greatly increased eye contact - beginning to smell in response [illegible] adult.” The present levels of performance further state that “STUDENT exhibits behaviors and needs related to his handicapping condition which require services and a setting in which he can progress in developmental areas.”
The September 19, 2000 IEP does not identify the sources of information used to describe the present levels of performance written on the IEP. Comparison of the language on the IEP to other documents indicates that the present levels of performance written on the IEP were derived from the multidisciplinary team report dated June 20, 2000; the 9-month progress report from Cynthia Carter, Ph.D., at UCSB, dated July 27, 2000; the report by Ms. Yi from BECA (provided by the parents) entilted “IEP Goal Recommendations”; and Ms. Fletcher’s speech and language evaluation dated September 10, 2000. Whether the present levels of performance incorporated information from the OT assessment performed on July 13, 2000, or the evaluation by UCSB on June 30, 2000, is unclear. The scales from the Bayley and the Vineland, applied in the UCSB evaluation, are not mentioned on the IEP.
The present levels of performance, as written in the September 19, 2000 IEP, fail to convey the severity of STUDENT’s deficits. Furthermore, some of STUDENT’s most severe deficits are not addressed in the present levels of performance. The nature and severity of STUDENT’s deficits were established by the above-referenced assessment reports, by the testimony of STUDENT’s mother, and by the testimony of other witnesses who have actually assessed STUDENT, provided services to STUDENT, and/or professionally observed STUDENT on multiple occasions, including Ms. Yi and Dr. Lennington.
For example, with respect to the severity of STUDENT’s deficits, the present levels of performance listed on the IEP state that STUDENT “recites the alphabet - randomly names some letters when he desires.” The assessment reports actually state that STUDENT can spontaneously name some letters of the alphabet, but nowhere do the reports state that he can recite the alphabet in order. The present levels of performance, quoting from the UCSB report dated July 27, 2000, state that STUDENT makes “clear expressive verbal attempts to seek out highly desired items.” The IEP does not indicate, however, that those “clear verbal expressive attempts” were, according to that same USCB report, limited to utterances such as “ah-gah,” “a-go,” and “no.” The IEP states that STUDENT’s “expressive communication skills include gestures, verbalizations, and word approximations.” However, the IEP does not state that, according to the July 27, 2000 UCSB report, STUDENT “does not use words in a functional manner.” The IEP does not state that, according to the September 10, 2000 report by Ms. Fletcher, STUDENT’s gestures are at the level of handing an item to someone to establish joint attention or taking a person’s hand and placing it on an object that he wants. The IEP does not mention that using the McArthur Communicative Development Inventory: Words and Gestures, as measured by Ms. Fletcher, STUDENT (at the age of 37 months) scored at the age equivalent of 11 months in “total gestures,” 12 months in “phrases understood,” 11 months in “words understood,” and 11 months in “words produced.”
In addition to understating the severity of STUDENT’s deficits, some of his deficits are not addressed. Notably missing from the present levels of performance listed on the September 19, 2000 IEP are references to STUDENT’s noncompliant behaviors such as pinching, biting, crying, or tantruming; his deficits in attending to task, transitioning from one activity to another, and following adult commands; and his sensory issues listed on the OT evaluation.
The present levels of performance listed on the IEP are deficient. Present levels of performance should be used as a baseline for establishing goals and objectives, and they are also relevant to determining an appropriate placement. Given the omissions and the understated nature of the present levels of performance listed on the September 19, 2000 IEP, doubt arises regarding whether the District’s members of the IEP team gave due consideration to all of STUDENT’s deficits and the severity of STUDENT’s deficits before writing the goals and objectives and recommending placement in the small-group setting of an SDC for 2 hours per day, 4 days per week. These matters will be addressed in further detail below.
Goals and objectives. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 provides that the IEP shall include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil’s needs resulting from the pupil’s disability and enabling the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum.
Goals and objectives are listed on the September 19, 2000 IEP for speech and language: following simple one-step tasks, receptively identifying objects, participating in routine speech/vocalizations games, imitating words with certain consonant sounds, gesturing or saying “hi” and “bye,” using PECS with the sentence strip to communicate his wants, pointing to objects on request; for OT: dressing and undressing, finger dexterity and hand/wrist strength; for number readiness: rote counting to 100; for functional play: playing with 10 different toys independently for up to 3 minutes; for matching: matching identical and nonidentical items and 3D to 2D items.
The Petitioner presented extensive testimony in criticism of the goals and objectives. Dr. Lennington characterized the goals and objectives on the September 19, 2000 IEP as much better defined, much more appropriate, and approaching being measurable in comparison to the goals and objectives on the June 22, 2000 IEP. However, Dr. Lennington testified that the goals and objectives on the September 19, 2000 IEP were still unacceptably vague.(Footnote 15)
As examples of the criticism by Dr. Lennington, a speech and language goal stated that STUDENT would receptively identify objects in 4 out of 5 trials over 5 days. The conditions wherein STUDENT would be accomplishing the task were not specified, nor was a method specified for measuring whether he actually knew what the identified objects were. In another speech and language goal, STUDENT would imitate simple one-step gross motor actions involving objects in 4 out of 5 trials over 5 days. The goal did not specify whether STUDENT would be doing the task while seated at a table or while walking. Another speech and language goal was for STUDENT to participate in routine speech/vocalization games in 4 out of 5 trials over 5 days. The term “routine speech/vocalization games” was not defined. Another speech and language goal stated that STUDENT would imitate words with “p,” “g,” “n,” and “h” sounds in 3 out of 5 trials over 5 days. The goal did not specify where the sound was in the particular word, and such distinctions were important developmentally, according to Dr. Lennington. A speech and language goal for gesturing stated that in 4 out of 5 trials over 5 days, STUDENT would gesture or say “hi” and “bye.” The goal did not indicate the pragmatics or environmental setting in which STUDENT would speak or gesture, nor were the terms “minimal prompts” and “physical prompts” defined in the short-term objectives. A goal regarding pointing to objects did not provide for the observer to know that STUDENT was actually discriminating between objects as opposed to simply pointing at random.
Ms. Kiel, a speech and language specialist at the District, testified on behalf of the District regarding how she would have implemented the goals and objectives in the September 19, 2000 IEP. She explained in detail the methods that she would have used to test STUDENT’s progress on the goals and objectives. However, Ms. Kiel did not satisfactorily explain how, given the way the goals and objectives were stated on the IEP, different therapists working with STUDENT at different stages of the school year would know that they were measuring STUDENT’s progress on particular goals and objectives in a consistent manner.
After considering the testimony of Ms. Kiel and Dr. Lenington, the Hearing Officer regards some, but not all, of the criticism by Dr. Lennington concerning goals and objectives to be warranted. Overall, the Hearing Officer finds that the degree of vagueness in the goals and objectives did not, by itself, rise to such a level that one should conclude the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
However, the Hearing Officer observes that other aspects of the of the goals and objectives listed in the September 19, 2000 IEP are more problematic than the vagueness described by Dr. Lennington. Ms. Zinter testified that STUDENT’s attention span was considered to be very short, about 1 to 5 minutes, but the Hearing Officer sees no mention of attention span in the present levels of performance. Ms. Ellis testified that the goal and short-term objectives for functional toy play up to 3 minutes would measure his attention span. However, the Hearing Officer sees no other goals or objectives that specifically address STUDENT’s attention span or attention to task. Although one could infer that STUDENT’s attention span would necessarily increase if he met other goals and objectives in the IEP, there are no other specific provisions for measurement of his progress with respect to attention span or attention to task. Given the severity of STUDENT’s attention deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP should have included additional and specific goals and objectives for attention span and attention to task. Such goals and objectives would be particularly important to STUDENT so that he could benefit from teaching, especially if the District intended to teach him in the small-group setting of an SDC, where STUDENT would be vulnerable to distraction by other persons and activities in the classroom.
The September 19, 2000 IEP states under present levels of performance that “STUDENT exhibits behaviors and needs related to his handicapping condition which require services and a setting in which he can progress in developmental areas.” However, no further details were listed under present levels of performance regarding STUDENT’s behavior. Ms. Zinter acknowledged in her testimony that STUDENT exhibited obvious behavior problems, such as biting. Other evidence showed that STUDENT had noncompliant behaviors such as pinching, crying, and tantruming. He had a history of frequent self-stimulatory behaviors. Given the degree of STUDENT’s behavior problems, behavioral intervention was one of STUDENT’s most important needs for the 2000-2001 school year. Appropriate behavior was important for facilitating STUDENT’s ability to learn, to attend, and to socialize with his peers. Comprehensive goals and objectives for behavior should have been included in STUDENT’s program. The September 19, 2000 IEP contained a goal and objective for following simple one-step instructions, but no goals and objectives were specifically written regarding behavior or transitions. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the September 19, 2000 IEP was deficient in the area of goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s behavior.
The Hearing Officer finds that in the areas of attention span, attention to task, and behaviors, the goals and objectives on the September 19, 2000 IEP were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
Placement and services. The September 19, 2000 IEP states that STUDENT is a “preschool student [who] can participate in activities in a small group setting.” No explanation for the basis of that statement is contained in the IEP. Relying on the premise that STUDENT could participate in a small-group setting, the District offered prekindergarten SDC, 2 hours per day, 4 days per week; 30 minutes of speech and language, 3 times per week (2 individual, 1 group setting); 60 minutes of OT, 1 time per week. The questions to be decided are whether STUDENT could successfully participate in the SDC proposed by the District, and whether the intensity of the services offered by the District was adequate.
The proposed SDC
The proposed SDC was described by the District’s witnesses. The afternoon SDC was the class that STUDENT would have attended.(Footnote 16) The class, taught by Ms. Ellis, had a picture schedule. The 2-hour sessions, 4 days per week, included sensory integration with items such as shaving cream and play dough, circle time, play time, tasks, simple activities, outside playtime, snack, music or circle time, with speech therapy and OT interspersed. As many as 5 or 6 children were in the class, including 2 children eligible under the category of autism. Individualized or one-on-two activities were performed at work centers or stations, including tasks for fine-motor skills, sensory exploration, puzzles, and computer time. The one-on-one assistants at the work stations used physical prompts, with the objective of having the children work toward independence from the prompts and assistance. Ms. Ellis utilized PECS to facilitate and develop communication. Given the staffing ratios in her class, Ms. Ellis estimated that in a typical day she would have been able to devote about 20 minutes of her own one-on-one instruction to STUDENT, depending on his attention and the attention to task of the other children. Ms. Ellis would have used positive reinforcers to motivate and encourage STUDENT. Ms. Ellis testified that her class would have been appropriate for STUDENT’s present levels of performance and goals and objectives on the IEP, especially since the class eventually had only two other children in attendance.
Mr. Lopez testified that in his opinion the District’s September 19, 2000 offer had all the components that STUDENT needed for an appropriate program. He testified that the offer provided for speech and language, OT, cognitive skill development, peer stimulation, all in a setting where STUDENT learns best through visual aids, repetitions, and play activity, with extensive positive reinforcement. Ms. Zinter testified that in the proposed SDC class taught by Ms. Ellis, Ms. Ellis effectively used visually structured teaching methods such as PECS and TEACH, and that STUDENT would benefit from those teaching methods. Ms. Ellis testified about her class and the teaching methods she uses. Ms. Arner-Costello, coordinator for training and staff development at Ventura County SELPA, testified regarding her positive impressions of Ms. Ellis’ class.(Footnote 17)
STUDENT’s skills as described by his expert witnesses
Ms. Yi testified that even at the present time, STUDENT could not learn in a group setting. She testified that in the BECA program, STUDENT is taught in a one-on-one setting with an instructor while both are seated at a table and chairs. Consistency is vital to the instructions. Even slight variations in instructions, such as “stomp” versus “stomp your feet” will prevent STUDENT from understanding the instruction. Frequent breaks are taken for play, such as trampoline, stringing beads, potato head, or other activities that he is now capable of doing and enjoys. The frequency of the breaks depends upon STUDENT’s tolerance to the task. His attention to task varies from 30 seconds for nonpreferred activities to 3 minutes for puzzles. Play breaks lasting 3 to 4 minutes may occur after instruction of 1 to 2 minutes at the table, although STUDENT may actually sit for up to 15 minutes for activities that he really enjoys, such as puzzles or matching. When STUDENT engages in inappropriate behaviors, either at play or during instruction, he is redirected by the instructor so that inappropriate behaviors will not become ingrained.
Ms. Yi testified regarding STUDENT’s high level of distractibility. According to Ms. Yi, STUDENT could not receive instruction from more than 1 foot away. In other words, when learning at a table-and-chair setting in the BECA program, the distance between STUDENT and the instructor was 1 foot. Under the BECA program, STUDENT was just recently being taught to scan a room and retrieve objects at greater distances; he was retrieving objects from up to 3 feet away. Because of his distractibility, he would sometimes do a task if only one person, besides the instructor, was in the room, but not if two other people were in the room. When distracted, STUDENT would not hear instruction from an adult, and he would forget his task.
Ms. Yi believed that in an SDC group setting, STUDENT would be unable to receive instructions by the teacher from across the room, and probably not from more than a foot away. The SDC setting would be further complicated by the distraction of noise from other children. Even street noise was a distraction to STUDENT. Ms. Yi testified that if one attempted to teach STUDENT in a group of two students, the distractions would prevent STUDENT from learning. He cannot yet “filter out” extraneous noise that he would encounter even in a group of 2 students. Ms. Yi testified that children like STUDENT are “in their own world,” and one has to organize STUDENT’s environment in a manner that enables him to learn.(Footnote 19)
Ms. Yi testified that STUDENT is unable to model the behavior of other children. He does not yet have the skills to successfully interact with other children. He will take the hand of a child but does not know how to say “hi.” Such skills, according to Ms. Yi, need to be taught to STUDENT in discrete steps and then generalized into functional skills, because STUDENT does not learn simply by being in the presence of other children. He does not learn by observation, except in a table-chair face-to-face situation. His instructors are recently trying to generalize what STUDENT has learned by trying tasks away from the table and chair in different areas of the room. STUDENT is taught by several instructors in the BECA program, and it is hoped that attending to different instructors will assist him in generalization. After the BECA program started in August 2000, the instructors had a “long road,” according to Ms. Yi, simply to get STUDENT to the point where he understood that the instructor was doing something that the instructor wanted him to imitate.
Ms. Yi testified that regarding toy play, STUDENT needed to be actively taught how to play with toys. Even for a toy he had mastered at the table, he would need to learn to maintain the task of playing with the toy before he could do it in an SDC situation such as during circle time. Dr. Lennington observed STUDENT in February (45 minutes), August (3 ½ to 4 hours), and October (1 hour) 2001. Dr. Lennington testified that for the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT could not participate in a preschool or small-group setting. She testified that most of his skills were below the equivalent of a one-year-old child, and that one-year-old children are not sent to preschool to participate in group activities. According to Dr. Lennington, STUDENT was and remains highly distractible. Dr. Lennington testified that STUDENT would not have been capable of attending to task at the work stations described in Ms. Ellis’ SDC. He would have been unable to perform tasks independently. Sounds that would be insignificant to typical peers would have been highly distracting to STUDENT and would have interfered with his ability to learn. He was easily frustrated and would have been more easily frustrated in a group setting with 2 or more children. Dr. Lennington predicted that STUDENT would have shown frustration in an SDC by tantruming, including hitting, biting, pulling hair, kicking, and trying to escape. He frequently sought sensory input by activities such as jumping and rolling on the floor. His communication skills were emergent at best. He would have been unable to follow commands such as lining up with a group or sitting down. He would not have been able to indicate if his diaper needed to be changed. His delays in processing were so significant that he always would have been behind the group.
Findings
Although the District demonstrated that Ms. Ellis had an excellent class, the District was not persuasive in showing that placing STUDENT in an SDC would have met his needs. The District did not show that it adequately recognized the severity of STUDENT’s deficits. The District’s failure to acknowledge and confront the severity of STUDENT’s deficits was manifested in several instances, including the cursory nature of the multidisciplinary team report that appeared to be based almost entirely on parent reporting; the present levels of performance stated on the September 19, 2000 IEP that tended to understate STUDENT’s deficits and failed to mention his attention deficits, distractibility, behavior problems, and OT sensory issues; and the goals and objectives proposed in the September 19, 2000 IEP that failed to provide goals and objectives regarding behavior interventions and failed to sufficiently state goals and objectives for attention span and attention to task.
The Hearing Officer finds that placement in an SDC for two hours per day would not have met STUDENT’s needs. The weight of the evidence shows that STUDENT’s deficits with respect to attention span, attention to task, high distractibilty, understanding and following commands and instructions, and noncompliant behaviors would have prevented him from deriving meaningful benefit from the proposed SDC. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of the Petitioner’s experts that a more intensive and structured program in a highly controlled environment was needed.
In weighing the testimony of the Petitioner’s expert witnesses and the District’s expert witnesses, the Hearing Officer considered several factors. The Petitioner’s expert witnesses demonstrated that through their personal observations of STUDENT and other sources of information, they had good knowledge of STUDENT’s needs. Additionally, Dr. Lennington is an expert in autism. She has extensive experience in working specifically with children on the autism spectrum. Although Ms. Yi’s academic credentials do not include a masters degree or Ph.D., she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology from UCLA, and she has extensive experience working with children on the autism spectrum. She was especially knowledgeable about STUDENT’s needs, having worked with him for an entire year. The testimony of Dr. Lennington and Ms. Yi was logical and well-supported by the facts in STUDENT’s case. For example, Dr. Lennington and Ms. Yi both emphasized the importance of early intervention for children with autism, and they emphasized that in STUDENT’s case intervention needed to be intensive. In support of those statements, Ms. Yi testified regarding her opinion that with typical children, each waking moment is a learning opportunity. She testified that because of the severity of STUDENT’s deficits, he is often “in his own world,” meaning that if left on his own, STUDENT is capable of only minimal interaction with his environment in a manner that would enable him to learn. Similarly, Dr. Lennington testified that 8 to 10 hours per week of instruction to STUDENT in an SDC setting, with its various distractions, would be of no benefit. She testified that since an autistic child such as STUDENT does not learn simply by being awake, STUDENT needs an intensive program consisting of 35 to 40 hours per week of instruction given in a manner where STUDENT could attend and comprehend, such as the BECA program.
The District’s expert witnesses included Ms. Ellis (the proposed SDC teacher), Ms. Zinter (the District’s school psychologist), Ms. Kiel (speech and language), and Ms. Arner-Costello (special education coordinator for the Ventura County SELPA). Except for Ms. Zinter, none of the District’s experts had formally observed STUDENT. Ms. Ellis and Ms. Kiel appeared to have only cursory knowledge about STUDENT and his needs. Ms. Arner-Costello was not called to testify about STUDENT. The District had ample opportunity to assess STUDENT prior to the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting. However, the District chose to utilize that assessment opportunity by relying almost entirely on the reporting of STUDENT’s parents and other providers. This left Ms. Zinter as the only available expert for the District who had formally observed STUDENT. The Hearing Officer considered the force of Ms. Zinter’s opinions to be greatly diminished by the vague content of her multidisciplinary team report and the omissions in the present levels of performance and the goals and objectives in the September 19, 2000, IEP. Ms. Zinter testified about the positive features of Ms. Ellis’ SDC and about the importance of teaching generalized skills to STUDENT in a group setting, but she did not persuasively address the question of whether STUDENT as an individual, given his distractibility, attention, and behavior problems, would be able to attend, learn, and benefit in an 8-hour-per-week SDC-based program.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT’s deficits with respect to attention span, attention to task, high distractibilty, understanding and following commands and instructions, and noncompliant behaviors would have prevented him from deriving meaningful benefit from the proposed SDC.
II. Was the District’s program offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with with some educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the program offered by the District was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Given the deficiencies in the District’s program offer as discussed above, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s program offer was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Furthermore, since STUDENT received no services from the District during the 2000-2001 school year, there could be no showing that STUDENT actually received a program through the District that was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
III. Did the District’s program comport with the IEP?
STUDENT has not received services from the District. There is no issue regarding whether the District’s program comported with the IEP.
Did the District offer to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment?
There are no issues regarding least restrictive environment.
Procedural Appropriateness
The procedural violations alleged by the Petitioner are not addressed by the Hearing Officer, as their resolution would not affect the outcome of this Decision.
Issue No. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the parents’ costs of having STUDENT in a private program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The Hearing Officer has found that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. As a remedy, the Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the private services obtained during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. The Petitioner began receiving BECA services on August 18, 2000. The District asserts that even if the Hearing Officer finds a denial of FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, the request for reimbursement should be reduced or denied because of the failure of the Petitioner’s parents to work cooperatively in the IEP process and because of the unreasonable cost of the BECA program.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.
The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
In ruling on the reimbursement issue, the Hearing Officer will consider whether the BECA services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit, and whether reimbursement should be reduced or denied because of the alleged failure of the Petitioner’s parents to work cooperatively in the IEP process.(Footnote 20)
I. Discussion.
A. Did the BECA services address STUDENT’s needs and provide him with educational benefit?
The first question to be addressed is whether the BECA services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit for purposes of satisfying the standard in Alamo Heights and Florence, supra.
The BECA program received by STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year was described in detail by the testimony of Ms. Yi and MOTHER. The program was developed for STUDENT after assessing his needs and stating goals and objectives. The program consisted of intensive one-on-one positive behavioral intervention in the home, which included but was not entirely limited to DTT methods. The instructors, including the parents, were trained by BECA in a three-day training course. The instructors were trained in prompting strategies, reductive prompting, redirection of behaviors, DTT, and positive reinforcers. A chief strategy of the program was to teach STUDENT in discrete steps, and then gradually generalize his skills. The program was heavily driven by data from each session, and the instructors were trained in collecting and recording data. Petitioner’s Exhibit 43 consisted of 3 large volumes of log entries. The log entries were used to monitor and record STUDENT’s progress and to provide information for the adjustment of his program as necessary. Ms. Yi remained on call throughout the program to resolve problems, such as the need for program changes, after consulting with her supervisor. BECA had one or more licensed psychologists on staff. STUDENT’s program was started at 20 hours per week, and the hours gradually increased thereafter.
Ms. Yi testified that the BECA program addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit. She testified that STUDENT’s team met weekly during the 2000-2001 school year to discuss the program and to review the log book data and STUDENT’s progress. The log books showed each item that STUDENT has mastered and the date accomplished. Using the log books and her own knowledge of STUDENT, Ms. Yi testified concerning the differences in STUDENT’s skills from when he started the program in August 2000 compared to his skills when she testified on July 31, 2001. She testified that STUDENT’s most obvious progress was in vocal language. After being able to only make unreliable utterances as described above, STUDENT progressed to imitating 2-syllable words and 2-word phrases upon instruction. He had just started working on 3-syllable words and 3-word sentences. He had also developed a functional use of oral language to the degree that he was not relying exclusively on PECS to communicate his needs. He would speak: “I want pretzel”; “I want juice”; “I want hamburger.” However, he would only spontaneously ask for an item if he first saw it physically present in the room.
Regarding improvement of other skills in addition to vocal language, Ms. Yi testified that STUDENT’s imitation skills were initially unreliable and erratic. By the summer of 2001, he had improved to the degree that he could imitate with gross motor actions almost anything given to him. He had developed the ability to build with blocks and tinker toys. In self-help skills, he had learned to put on his shirt, socks, and shoes. He had learned to drink from a straw. A potty-training procedure had started. Initially, he could receptively identify almost no objects, but by July 2001 he could receptively identify over 40 items. The skill of receptively identifying objects was starting to be generalized, where he would retrieve the items from up to 3 feet away. His receptive language was initially nil, but by July 2001 he could receptively understand 11 instructions, including “stomp,” “clap,” and “touch your head.” He had become proficient at matching. At first, he could sort by color, but he learned to sort 3D items from 3D items, 2D items from 2D items, and 3D items from 2D items. He learned to sort 4 or 5 piles of 5 or 6 objects in each pile, such as shoes, beans, and cups. He learned to assemble 24-piece jigsaw puzzles. His aggressive behaviors became reduced from several incidents per day to perhaps 1 or 2 per week.
Although STUDENT made significant progress in many areas during the 2000-2001 school year, not all of that progress is necessarily attributable to BECA. Through TRC, STUDENT was also receiving speech and language services from Ms. Fletcher twice a week, and he was receiving OT services. Apportionment of STUDENT’s progress during the 2000-2001 school year between TRC services and BECA services would be difficult, if not impossible. The hours of the BECA program far exceeded the speech and language and OT services through TRC, but the expertise of the TRC service providers could also be considered in comparison to the 3-day training of the BECA instructors. Accurate apportionment is unnecessary, however, for purposes of determining reimbursement, so long as the Petitioner has demonstrated that the BECA services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit.
MOTHER testified regarding what she considered to be dramatic gains in STUDENT directly attributable to the BECA program. She testified that during the previous year (1999-2000) STUDENT had essentially gone nowhere under the Koegel program. According to MOTHER’s perspective, the only accomplishment under the Koegel program was that STUDENT was being trained for an automatic word oral response, specifically, “a-go.” She testified that Ms. Yi came to her home in July and did an assessment. MOTHER was told that if she used the program, MOTHER would have to recruit and hire about 5 teachers and put them through a 3-day training course. She began the recruitment, the aides were trained beginning on August 18, and the program started on or about August 21. MOTHER testified that from August 21 through the September 19 IEP meeting date she saw the most wonderful things in STUDENT. He was suddenly being asked to participate in activities that he found interesting. With the log and data books, she had a complete roadmap with benchmarks in each area of need. In MOTHER’s words, they “started rolling big-time with BECA.” Her description of the gains in STUDENT that she attributes to BECA are similar to the gains described by Ms. Yi.
The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT received services from TRC throughout the 1999-2000 school year concurrently with the Koegel program. The TRC services rendered in the 1999-2000 school year were very similar to the TRC services provided in the 2000-2001 school year. However, STUDENT’s overall gains in the 2000-2001 school year were dramatic compared to the relatively meager gains described by MOTHER during the prior year. The primary difference in programs for the 2 school years was the implementation of the BECA program for 2000-2001.
Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the BECA program was a major factor in the progress that STUDENT made during the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the BECA program addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit for purposes of reimbursement.
B. Should the Petitioner’s reimbursement be reduced or denied because of the alleged failure of the Petitioner’s parents to work cooperatively in the IEP process?
The District asserts that the parents were uncooperative during the IEP process, and that reimbursement should, therefore, be reduced or denied. The District’s assertion that STUDENT’s parents were uncooperative during the IEP process has merit.
An IEP “team” is intended by the IDEA to include parents and District personnel. The input of the parents, if available, is important to the process. Ms. Zinter testified about how she had difficulties getting information from MOTHER. She testified about delays and/or failures by MOTHER to complete and return the developmental history questionnaire and the developmental observation checklist. She testified about problems scheduling the June and September IEP meetings. She testified about MOTHER’s failing to provide information to the District prior to the September 2000 IEP meeting that would have alerted the District to the fact that STUDENT’s parents were not interested in an SDC and would be demanding the BECA program. She testified about how information regarding assessments of STUDENT and goals and objectives recommended by BECA were not produced by the Petitioner’s parents until the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting was in progress. The District’s witnesses testified concerning the failure of the Petitioner’s parents to reply to Mr. Lopez’s September 26, 2001 letter. Mr. Lopez’s letter had reiterated the District’s SDC offer and invited MOTHER’s input on modifying the goals and objectives. The letter also invited STUDENT’s parents to visit San Miguel School, a county program for preschool children with disabilities.(Footnote 21) The testimony of Ms. Zinter on those matters was not refuted by the Petitioner’s parents.
The Petitioner’s parents added nothing constructive to the IEP process by withholding information from the District until the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting regarding their preference for placement and their supporting documentation. Such an attitude, whether chosen by the Petitioner’s parents or by their attorney, serves no constructive purpose in terms of the concept of an IEP “team.”
However, although the Petitioner’s parents demonstrated lack of cooperation during the IEP process, there is no reason to believe that the District, even with full cooperation from the parents, would have varied from its offer of an SDC-based placement. When the September 19, 2000 IEP meeting concluded, the District had been fully informed regarding the parents’ demand for placement, and the District knew that an SDC-based offer was contrary to what the parents were seeking. Fine-tuning or revision of the goals and objectives stated in the IEP, as offered in Mr. Lopez’s September 26, 2000 letter, would not have resulted in changing the fundamental nature of the SDC placement. Furthermore, a change in the goals and objectives would not have made the small-group setting of an SDC appropriate for STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year. The District, according to the evidence, never offered to deviate from an SDC placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the conduct of the Petitioner’s parents does not merit a reduction in reimbursement.
II. The amount of reimbursement.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the BECA program for the 2000-2001 school year. Furthermore, on the basis of Dr. Lennington’s testimony that STUDENT required services 50 to 52 weeks per year with a continuous break in services of no more than 1 week to avoid regression, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the BECA program during the extended school year in the summer of 2001.
Mr. Lopez testified that the 2000-2001 school year covered the period from September 5, 2000, through June 22, 2001. Pursuant to the provisions of Title 5, C.C.R., Sec. 3043, the Hearing Officer finds that the extended school year for STUDENT would have consisted of 30 days of instruction, equivalent to 6 weeks of BECA services. Accordingly, the applicable reimbursement period, including the extended school year, is found to be September 5, 2000, through August 1, 2001.
The Petitioner presented a detailed ledger of the costs incurred for the BECA program. (Pet. Ex. 51). The ledger shows that BECA supervision costs averaged about $1,200.00 per month. Instructors were paid at varying rates of either $9.00 per hour or $12.50 per hour. All of the instructors’ time is itemized on a daily basis in the ledger.
The ledger itemizes the costs for 59 weeks commencing from August 2000. The applicable reimbursement period from September 5, 2000, through August 1, 2001, coincides with weeks 4 through 50 on the ledger. The cost of services to be reimbursed for that period is found to be $32,674.52. Reimbursement for the first installment of BECA supervision listed on week 4 is not awarded. The first installment for BECA supervision ($1,779.25) is considered by the Hearing Officer to be more properly attributable to the BECA supervisor’s evaluation of services rendered prior to week 4.
Reimbursement for training costs ($4,499.60) on August 18, 19, and 20, 2000, is not awarded. The training costs are considered by the Hearing Officer to have been incurred by the Petitioner’s parents at their own risk. The parents elected to commit themselves to the BECA program before the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, before the District made a program offer at the IEP meeting in September 2000, and before the parents even disclosed to the District that they did not believe an SDC-based program would be appropriate.
In his closing argument, the Petitioner requested reimbursement for the BECA program through the date of this Decision. The Petitioner’s request is denied. Reimbursement has been awarded through the end of the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. The period thereafter was not at issue in this matter. The Hearing Officer has made no findings regarding STUDENT’s needs for the 2001-2002 school year, and no findings are made regarding the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year.
ORDERS
1. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this decision, the District shall pay to the Petitioner’s parents the sum of $32,674.52 as reimbursement for the BECA program, covering the period from September 5, 2000, through the August 1, 2001.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue No. 1: Did the District offer a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the parents’ costs of having STUDENT in a private program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: December 19, 2001 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. The issues listed here differ slightly in wording from the issues as stated by the parties. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis. 3. Neither Dr. Graff nor Dr. Nopar testified at the due process hearing. Their generally stated opinion regarding Lovaas-type programs did not include analysis of why such a program would or would not have been appropriate for STUDENT. Their report, written more than one full year prior to the commencement of the 2000-2001 school year, does not address the question of what an appropriate program for STUDENT would have been for the 2000-2001 school year. 4. Ms. Fletcher did not testify at the due process hearing. Her August 27, 1999 report offers no opinion regarding whether a Lovaas-type program would be appropriate for a 3-year-old child, and her opinions do not include consideration of STUDENT’s needs as they existed one full year after she wrote the report. 5. Dr. Granpeesheh did not testify at the due process hearing. Dr. Granpesheeh recommended a CARD program consisting of the Lovaas-type DTT services disfavored in the report of Ms. Fletcher and the joint report of Dr. Graff and Dr. Nopar. As with the other reports, Dr. Granpesheeh’s September 1999 report makes no assertions regarding an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year. 6. Dr. Koegel did not testify at the due process hearing. In her report, Dr. Koegel expressed a preference for her own therapy approach. The evidence presented at the hearing, discussed herein, allows for a comparison of STUDENT’s gains after one year of Dr. Koegel’s program versus the subsequent gains displayed by STUDENT after one year of the BECA program utilizing Lovaas-type DTT therapy. 7. In the summer of 1999, STUDENT’s parents had been communicating with the District regarding the scheduling of an IEP meeting for September 1999. (Pet. Ex. 9, 13.) There is no definitive evidence in the record regarding the District’s involvement, if any, in STUDENT’s programs from September 1999 to April 2000. 8. The PLS-3 is a standardized test. (Testimony of Dr. Lennington.) 9. The basis for these comments regarding “formal testing” is unknown. No formal tests were listed except for the PLS-3, and that test was administered solely through questioning of the parent by the speech and language specialist. There is no indication elsewhere in the team report that anyone from the mutidisciplinary team actually attempted to test STUDENT directly. 10. The team report does not specify that the “observations” were actually made by someone or anyone from the multidisciplinary team. 11. Ms. Yi testified that she is the president of BECA and an educational consultant for BECA. She testified that she has extensive experience working with children on the autistic spectrum, dating to her involvement in autism projects at UCLA for about 10 years where she learned and implemented Lovaas-type therapy methods utilizing DTT. She testified that BECA currently services about 30 children within the pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) spectrum, including children on the autistic spectrum. She testified that BECA follows the tenants of the Lovaas research from the 1980's. She testified that BECA has one or more licensed psychologists on staff and that BECA is licensed as a nonpublic agency by the California Department of Education to provide services to children with special needs. Ms. Arner-Costello, special education coordinator for the Ventura County SELPA, testified that districts within the SELPA sometimes offer DTT for students on the autistic spectrum. She testified that nonpublic agencies who are currently servicing the Ventura County SELPA for Lovaas-type or DTT programs include, among others, CARD and BECA. 12. Ms. Zinter testified regarding her qualifications as an expert witness. She received her bachelor’s degree in psychology from Humbolt State University in 1984. She received her masters degree in school psychology, P.P.S., in 1985, from Humbolt State University. She has been a school psychologist since 1985. She commenced working for the District in August 1999. For the two years prior to working at the District, she worked for the California Department of Education at the diagnostic center in Fresno as an in-house field-team assessment specialist. She received extensive training while employed at the diagnostic center, including training in assessment and autism. She has worked at several other school districts as a school psychologist and/or director of special education. 13. The results of the PSL-3 as a standardized test were invalid, according to Dr. Lennington, because the test was administered solely by interviewing the parent instead of directly testing STUDENT. The District’s speech and language expert, Ms. Kiel, testified that the PLS-3 is a standardized test, but that she did not know whether the PLS-3 manual considered parent reporting to be a standardized administration of the test. 14. The Hearing Officer makes no finding regarding whether a district can meet its legal obligation to assess a child in all areas related to the suspected disability by relying heavily on reports from nondistrict sources. Resolution of that question would not be pertinent to this decision. Of more concern to the Hearing Officer is the fact that STUDENT was presented to the District on multiple occasions for assessment in June 2000, yet the record consistently shows the District’s assessment team had little or no interaction with STUDENT. 15. Dr. Lennington testified regarding her qualifications as an expert witness. She received a B.S. degree in occupational therapy from Ohio State University. She received a masters degree from the California School of Professional Psychology in 1991. She received her Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the California School of Professional Psychology in 1993. She is licensed in California as a clinical psychologist, and is self-employed. The primary areas of her practice include psychodiagnostic assessments of individuals from ages 2 years to 21 years and providing family and individual therapy. She testified her referrals come from schools, parents, regional centers, and other colleagues. About 80 percent of her current private practice involves children with autism. She estimated that in the past 4 months, she had performed almost 100 psychoeducational assessments on preschool children with autism. She tracks children’s progress and makes educational recommendations. She estimated that in the past 2 years she had observed about 75 special education classrooms related to preschool children with the diagnosis of autism. She had seen about 40 or 50 more classes where her children were placed with typical peers. The majority of classrooms observed by her were in public schools. She testified regarding the various types of programs she has recommended for students with autism, and she testified that she does not always recommend DTT. She has had positions conducting psychodiagnostic assessments at the UCLA infant and preschool clinic and psychodiagnostic assessment of children at the age of 3 months to 4 years in a research study. She had no involvement with Dr. Lovaas or his program at UCLA. She had concurrent employments at the Julianne Singer Center as the director of clinical assessments on young children, including children with autism, and as supervisor in the child abuse prevention program. She also worked at St. Johns Child Study Center in a similar capacity as above, and at other clinics. 16. The District’s witnesses described how Ms. Ellis initially taught a morning SDC and an afternoon SDC that were very similar. However, as the needs of the children in her afternoon SDC changed, the structure of the afternoon SDC was changed during the fall of 2000 to be more appropriate to the needs of her students with autism. The District’s witnesses testified that if STUDENT had enrolled in the District’s program, accommodations to the afternoon SDC would have been promptly implemented. For purposes of analysis, the testimony of the District’s witnesses on that point is considered to be accurate. 17. The 2000-2001 school year provided Ms. Ellis with her first experience as an SDC teacher. The Petitioner was critical of Ms. Ellis’ qualifications and lack of experience. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Ellis to be knowledgeable about her profession, and all of the evidence presented regarding her class demonstrated that she was a dedicated, skilled, and effective SDC teacher. However, while other pupils may have shown good progress under the teaching of Ms. Ellis, it does not necessarily follow that STUDENT had the necessary skills to benefit from being in Ms. Ellis’ SDC class. 18. The “present time” was the date of Ms. Yi’s testimony, July 31, 2001. 19. This is consistent with the statement in the August 9, 1999 report by Dr. Graff and Dr. Nopar, who stated that STUDENT was “very isolated in session and appeared to be very much in his own world, with very little interactivity with the rest of us.” 20. The District argued that the cost of the BECA program was unreasonable and would be unfairly burdensome to the District. Although equitable considerations may be weighed, no legal authority was cited that specifically includes reasonableness of cost and burden to a district as factors to consider in reimbursement. Despite the assertions of unreasonable cost by the District, Ms. Arner-Costello (special education coordinator for the Ventura County SELPA) testified that BECA has contracts with the SELPA and/or Districts within the SELPA to provide DTT services to children with autism. Ms. Arner-Costello testified that preschool students within the SELPA who receive DTT services for autism have been placed, on occasion, in 30- to 40-hour-per-week programs. Such placements are made, according to Ms. Arner-Costello, when the family “absolutely insists on it” or it is “forced” through mediation or hearing. Thus, districts within the SELPA provide programs similar to STUDENT’s program using nonpublic providers. The District has not shown that the cost of STUDENT’s BECA program was unreasonable or that provision of such a program to STUDENT would be unduly burdensome to the District. 21. MOTHER did visit San Miguel School in October 2000 with Ms. Zinter, March 2001 with Dr. Lennington, and May 2001 with Ms. Yi. Mr. Lopez testified that the District never made a formal offer for placement at San Miguel School, but that MOTHER knew San Miguel School was available for consideration. There was no evidence that the Petitioner requested placement at San Miguel School.
