California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 15, 2003

Student v. Napa Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1815-02 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz

Napa Valley Unified prevails: student with ADHD and a 504 plan found ineligible; Montana residential placement reimbursement denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A parent filed for due process against Napa Valley Unified School District. The student had attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and a Section 504 plan. She had left special education in first grade. In fifth grade at Donaldson Way Elementary, she had behavior problems for about three months, including two suspensions. During that time she was not taking her ADHD medication regularly. The school then put a behavior support plan in place, and her behavior improved. A private psychologist, Dr. Paula Solomon, diagnosed depression and recommended intensive treatment. The parent placed the student at Intermountain, a residential program in Montana, for sixth grade. She sought reimbursement for that placement, for the private assessment and for tutoring, plus compensatory education. The student argued she qualified as emotionally disturbed or other health impaired. Hearing Officer Jessica Katz found she qualified under neither category in either year. Her behavior problems were episodic, not long-term or marked. She earned top grades, made the honor roll and scored well above average on state tests, so her education was not adversely affected. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to Dr. Solomon's report because she did not talk to school staff or observe the student at school. The District's assessment in Montana was found thorough. There was no child find violation. Not having an Intermountain teacher at the IEP meeting caused no harm. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated eligibility when a student had diagnosed emotional conditions and ADHD but strong grades and test scores. The Hearing Officer required an adverse effect on educational performance. A private assessment that did not include input from school staff or observation at school carried little weight, and a working 504 plan and behavior plan defeated the child find claim.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1a. 2001-2002 (fifth grade): Did Student meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED)?

    Student's peer and teacher relationships, behavior and episodes of unhappiness did not occur over a long period of time or to a marked degree, and her strong grades and test scores showed no adverse effect on educational performance, so she did not qualify as ED.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1b. 2001-2002 (fifth grade): Did Student meet the eligibility criteria for special education as other health impaired (OHI) based on ADHD?

    Student's ADHD was addressed through general classroom changes, a 504 plan and a behavior support plan, and did not significantly harm her educational performance, so she did not qualify as OHI.

  3. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 2. If so, did the District offer Student a FAPE in 2001-2002 (including whether the District failed to assess when it suspected a disability)?

    Because Student was not eligible, no FAPE was owed; the District responded to her behavior with accommodations and a behavior support plan that worked, so it committed no procedural violation by not referring her for assessment.

  4. Issue 3. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education and/or is Mother entitled to reimbursement for a private assessment and after-school tutoring?

    With no eligibility and no FAPE obligation, Student was not entitled to compensatory education and Mother was not entitled to reimbursement.

  5. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 4. 2002-2003 (sixth grade): Did Student meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with ED and/or OHI?

    Circumstances had not changed by the August 2002 placement, and the District's thorough December 2002 assessment, which showed average to above-average achievement, supported its finding that Student was not eligible.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5. If so, did the District offer Student a FAPE in 2002-2003 (including whether the absence of an Intermountain teacher at the January 2003 IEP meeting was a procedural violation)?

    No FAPE was owed to a student who was not eligible; the IEP team met Education Code section 56341(b), and the absence of an Intermountain teacher caused no prejudice because the assessor had interviewed staff and the team had the Intermountain reports.

  7. Issue 6. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placement at Intermountain School in Montana?

    Because Student was not eligible for special education, Mother was not entitled to reimbursement for the Intermountain residential placement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3)(A)

People named in the decision

  • Laura Miller, director of special education, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Linda Barbour-Kambe, coordinator of special education; District witness, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Courtney Henderson, director of district instructional support, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Joe (Joseph) Silveira, fifth grade general education teacher, Donaldson Way Elementary School
  • Janis Sparks, principal (and former kindergarten teacher); District witness, Donaldson Way Elementary School
  • Donna Poninski, school psychologist, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Denise Struven, school psychologist; conducted December 2002 assessment, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Dr. Emily Jordan, school psychologist; conducted 1998 assessment; District witness, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Terry Schuster, behavior specialist who developed the behavior support plan, Napa Valley SELPA
  • Ms. Bell, cafeteria worker, Donaldson Way Elementary School
  • Ms. Bosson, third grade teacher, Donaldson Way Elementary School
  • Dr. Paula Solomon, licensed clinical psychologist; private assessor and expert witness for Student, True to Life Children's Services
  • Kathy Brandt, special education teacher, Intermountain Children's Home and Services
  • Tina Morrison, psychotherapist, Intermountain Children's Home and Services
  • Dr. Matteo, private therapist
  • Intermountain Children's Home and Services, private residential placement (Helena, Montana)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Napa, California, on June 26 and 27, and August 19-22, 27 and 28, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Jane Reid and Stan Zeigler. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf was her mother, Mother. Respondent Napa Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Sally Dutcher. Also present on the behalf of the District were Laura Miller, the District’s director of special education; Linda Barbour-Kambe, the coordinator of special education; and Courtney Henderson, the director of district instructional support.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Joe Silveira, fifth grade teacher; Donna Poninski, school psychologist; Denise Struven, school psychologist; Mother; FAMILY FRIEND, family friend; Dr. Paula Solomon, licensed clinical psychologist; Kathy Brandt, special education teacher from Intermountain Children’s Home (Intermountain); Tina Morrison, psychotherapist at Intermountain; and FAMILY FRIEND, family friend.

The District called the following witnesses: Linda Barbour-Kambe; Emily Jordan, school psychologist; and Janis Sparks, principal at Donaldson Way Elementary School.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon final receipt of closing argument and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

2001-2002 School Year (Fifth Grade)

1. Did STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impaired (OHI)?

2. If so, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

3. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled in compensatory education and/or is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of a private assessment and/or the cost of providing tutoring to STUDENT after school?

2002-2003 School Year (Sixth Grade)

4. Did STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impaired (OHI)?

5. If so, did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE?

6. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placement at Intermountain School in Montana?

CONTENTIONS

The Petitioner contends that she was eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance and/or other health impaired, specifically attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), during her fifth grade school year, 2001-2002. She asserts that the District should have assessed her and found her eligible due to her excessive behavioral issues during the school year that adversely impacted her education. The Petitioner contends that Mother is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of a private assessment and the cost of tutoring during the 2001-2002 school year. The Petitioner further contends that she was also eligible for special education in 2002-2003 school year and that the District is responsible for reimbursement for the cost of her placement at Intermountain in Helena, Montana.

The District contends that STUDENT was not eligible for special education in either the 2001-2002 or the 2002-2003 school year. The District concedes that STUDENT has some behavioral problems; however, the District’s position is that her behavior does not adversely impact her educational performance. Therefore, the District contends that it is not responsible for the reimbursement for the privately retained assessment and the tutoring provided by Mother or STUDENT’s unilateral placement in Montana.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a twelve-year-old seventh grade student currently enrolled in Intermountain Children’s Home and Services (Intermountain) in Helena, Montana. STUDENT has been attending Intermountain since the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year (sixth grade). Prior to STUDENT’s placement at Intermountain, STUDENT attended Donaldson Way Elementary School within the Napa Valley Unified School District from kindergarten through fifth grade.

STUDENT is the only child of her adoptive mother, Mother. STUDENT was placed with Mother at approximately eighteen months old. Prior to the adoption finalization, STUDENT had unsupervised visits with her biological father and was molested during one of the visits. Following the molestation, the county social worker assisted Mother in getting services for STUDENT through the local regional center and the Napa Valley SELPA. STUDENT was found eligible for special education services in 1995 as a student with a specific learning disability, and had problems with impulsivity and attention. Her initial program consisted of placement in a special day class preschool program, which emphasized social skills, attending, and focusing. For the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT was placed in a regular education kindergarten classroom with support from the resource specialist in developing coping skills in different situations and in improving sharing and cooperative play skills.

In June 1997, a new individualized education program (IEP) was developed for STUDENT for her first grade year (1997-1998 school year). Mother chose to place STUDENT in a private school at the beginning of the school year. However, STUDENT’s placement was unsuccessful and she returned to the District in the late fall of 1997. In January 1998, the District conducted its triennial assessment of STUDENT and found that she no longer needed special education services. Mother disagreed with the initial finding and requested a second evaluation by a school psychologist Ph.D.. Mother agreed that she would accept the findings of the new assessment. Dr. Emily Jordan assessed STUDENT and found the she was no longer eligible for special education services because she no longer had a learning disability; however, Dr. Jordan recommended that the District implement a 504 plan to help STUDENT with her attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Mother agreed with the decision and signed the 504 plan on May 5, 1998.

For the next three years, STUDENT had occasional behavioral problems in school and was referred to the principal on approximately six occasions and was suspended three times during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years for a total of seven and a half days. On two occasions (in third and fourth grade), the school called the campus police to assist them with STUDENT’s behavior. Despite STUDENT’s sporadic behavioral problems, she consistently received high grades and made appropriate progress on the state standardized testing. Additionally, according to STUDENT’s report cards, she was placed on the honor roll due to her good grades and appropriate classroom behavior.

In fifth grade, STUDENT continued to excel academically in her class work and her state standardized achievement tests. She received all fours and fives (five is the highest grade) her entire school year for every subject. STUDENT was also on honor roll her first and third trimesters of school. She was not on honor roll her second trimester of fifth grade due to her behavior.

Joseph Silveira, STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher, attempted to correct STUDENT’s behavior through various types of classroom and performance modifications, including preferential seating, choice in class work performed, allowing her to tutor younger students, and making her leader during group activities on occasion. However, as the fifth grade progressed, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated during unstructured times (recess), while transitioning back into the classroom from recess or lunch, and when asked to perform academically in subjects in which she had little interest. STUDENT also refused to take her ADHD medications on a regular basis. (Footnote 1) Her behaviors included refusing to follow directions or comply with teacher’s requests, swearing, shutting down, and hitting other children on the playground. STUDENT was also suspended for two and a half days for twisting another child’s arm after STUDENT was called out in four-square. Because of the behaviors, the school held a meeting with STUDENT, Mother, Mr. Silveira, Janis Sparks (the school principal), and Terry Schuster (a behavior specialist from the Napa Valley SELPA) to discuss and develop a behavior support plan for STUDENT.

The behavior support plan was implemented and STUDENT’s classroom participation increased and her behavior improved. Mother also developed her own incentive program, which included money, stickers, and privileges in the home to help STUDENT with completion of her schoolwork. STUDENT’s grades improved and her behaviors returned to more acceptable levels, with fewer referrals to the principal and no suspensions. Donaldson Way staff also worked with the middle school to develop a program for STUDENT for her sixth grade school year.

In addition to the services and accommodations provided to STUDENT during her enrollment in Donaldson Way, Mother provided STUDENT with numerous counseling and enrichment programs throughout the years. These programs included one-on-one counseling, piano, flute and trumpet lessons, girl scouts, nightly homework assistance from Mother, and tutoring from one of Mother’s retired teacher friends. Additionally, Mother enrolled STUDENT in behavior-based summer camp programs at U.C. Berkeley and Quest, as well as summer programs at Marine World and an equestrian summer camp.

While STUDENT was having a difficult time in her fifth grade school year, Mother contacted an educational consultant. The consultant advised her to obtain an independent assessment and referred Mother and STUDENT to Dr. Paula Solomon, who evaluated STUDENT in March and April 2002. Dr. Solomon is a licensed clinical psychologist and clinical director of True to Life Children’s services, a residential treatment center for emotionally disturbed adolescents. Dr. Solomon found that STUDENT continued to have ADHD, as well as intermittent explosive disorder and major depressive disorder. She recommended intensive treatment services and suggested that STUDENT would likely need a residential treatment program, but did not rule out a special day class or nonpublic school setting that included intensive therapy services.

Mother did not share this evaluation with the District until after she filed for due process and after she gave notice of STUDENT’s placement in residential treatment. After Mother filed for due process, the District developed an assessment plan and agreed to assess STUDENT in Montana at her residential placement. Denise Struven, a District school psychologist, conducted the assessment over several days in Montana in December 2002. An IEP meeting was held on January 31, 2003, to determine if STUDENT was eligible for special education and, if so, what placement would be appropriate. On the basis of Ms. Struven’s assessment, STUDENT’s prior school performance, and STUDENT’s school records, the District members of the IEP team (Laura Miller, director of special education; a special education teacher; Janis Sparks, principal and general education teacher; Denise Struven, school psychologist; Donna Poninski, school psychologist; and Sally Dutcher) determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.

Mother disagreed with the determination and explained to the IEP team that STUDENT was having problems outside of school and that those problems manifested themselves in her behaviors at school. Mother further explained to the IEP team that after placement at Intermountain, STUDENT was diagnosed with reactive attachment disorder and that for the first three months of placement, STUDENT was in a day coverage program rather than the regular classroom due to her behaviors. STUDENT was just transitioning into the regular classroom at Intermountain at the time of the IEP meeting. The District determined that despite Mother’s report regarding STUDENT, she did not qualify for special education because her emotional problems were not affecting her educational performance. Therefore, the matter proceeded to hearing to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

2001-2002 School Year (Fifth Grade)

1. Did STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impaired (OHI)?

A “child with a disability” means a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech and language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impaired, or specific learning disabilities and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A).) Therefore, for STUDENT to qualify as a child with a disability, she must fall within one of the categories listed above, and she must require special education and related services.

In the fifth grade, STUDENT was placed in a general education classroom with no special education services. She had a 504 plan in place to address her needs due to her ADHD. Mr. Silveira explained that he made accommodations in the classroom for STUDENT because she was a very bright student who often found the work unchallenging. Because STUDENT was such a strong reader, Mr. Silveira allowed STUDENT to read rather than do the classroom transition work. During the first trimester, STUDENT did very well both academically and behaviorally. She had only a few referrals to the principal’s office and those were for defiance in the classroom or poor behavior on the playground. During the second trimester, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated and she got in a few fights with her peers, causing her to be suspended. She also made an inappropriate comment to her music teacher and had to go to the principal’s office to work on reading or other homework during six music sessions. Due to her behavior problems, the school called a behavioral team meeting in February 2002 to develop a behavior support plan. Terry Shuster, a behaviorist from the Napa County SELPA, developed a plan and Mr. Silveira implemented it in his classroom resulting in STUDENT’s more appropriate behavior and positive school performance.

Petitioner contends that STUDENT is a student with an ED because she has a diagnosis of depression, intermittent explosive disorder, attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder. Further, Petitioner contends that her behaviors are extremely deep-rooted and pervasive and that the behaviors affected her educational performance in the fifth grade.

The District contends that it was not aware that STUDENT had a diagnosis of depression even though she did exhibit some behavioral problems. The District asserts that her behaviors did not manifest themselves over a long period of time or to a marked degree and did not adversely affect STUDENT’s educational performance in the fifth grade.

a. Emotional Disturbance

Emotional disturbance (ED) is defined as a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a student's educational performance:

1. An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; 2. An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; 3. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; 4. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression;

5. A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

(34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i).) The term ED does not apply to a child who is socially maladjusted unless it is determined that she has an ED. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii).)

Petitioner contends that she met three of the criteria to be eligible as a student with an emotional disturbance in the fifth grade: she had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships; she exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; and she exhibited inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances.

1. An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;

Throughout the hearing, contradictory evidence was presented regarding STUDENT’s ability to maintain satisfactory relationships. Mother testified that STUDENT has no real friends but that she desires to have a best friend. Ms. Bell, a cafeteria worker, testified that STUDENT often sat alone at lunchtime and that she did not seem to have many friends. Mother further explained that STUDENT does not understand feelings and wants to be in control of the group she is with. Mother also testified that STUDENT has had problems throughout elementary school building and maintaining friendships because she is too bossy and drives her friends away. (Footnote 2) Mr. Silveira and Ms. Sparks agreed that STUDENT had occasional problems with her peers during lunch and recess because she wanted to control whichever game was being played. Following the inappropriate interactions on the playground, STUDENT would occasionally have difficulty transitioning back into the classroom and would be loud and disruptive towards the other children. Mr. Silveira also testified that peer relationships frustrated STUDENT.

However, there was also testimony that STUDENT developed friends both in and out of school. FAMILY FRIEND, a family friend and STUDENT’s scout leader, testified that STUDENT was friends with her daughter outside of school and that her daughter would occasionally spend the night at the Family’s residence and would also talk on the telephone with STUDENT. She further testified that she took STUDENT and her daughter and some other friends to Marine World and Waterworld during the summer following fifth grade and before STUDENT was placed at Intermountain. In response to FAMILY FRIEND’S testimony, Mother explained that although STUDENT did have some friends, she was not welcome in most of her friends’ homes.

Mr. Silveira testified that STUDENT had natural leadership abilities and would incorporate those skills during cooperative group learning sessions. Mr. Silveira said that although STUDENT was not part of a “clique” she was part of a group of friends. He also stated that he believed she had a few good friends even though she would occasionally argue with the girls. Ms. Sparks testified that STUDENT seemed to have a group of friends and named several students that STUDENT “hung out” with during recess and lunch. (Footnote 3)

Very little evidence was presented that STUDENT had difficulty developing relationships with her teachers and principal although Mother did testify that STUDENT hated the principal, Ms. Sparks. However, there was much evidence to suggest that STUDENT developed positive and appropriate relationships with the school personnel.

Mr. Sliveira testified that he believed he and STUDENT had a good relationship and that she also got along really well with her former third grade teacher, Ms. Bosson. Because of the relationship with Ms. Bosson and STUDENT’s strong reading skills, as stated above, while STUDENT was in the fifth grade, she tutored some students in reading in Ms. Bosson’s third grade classroom. Mother also testified that Mr. Silveira attended at least one of STUDENT’s piano recitals.

Janis Sparks, Donaldson Way principal and STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher, testified that she believed she had a good relationship with STUDENT. She explained that STUDENT would come to her office to read to her through a campus-wide program that was implemented to encourage students to read with the principal. Ms. Sparks also explained that during the six sessions of music that STUDENT missed due to her misbehavior and inappropriate comments to the music teacher, STUDENT would come to her office and work on homework and reading.

On the basis of the evidence presented, STUDENT appears to have difficulty in social situations. She desperately wants to be included and have friends and seems to have been able to develop some relationships. The fact that STUDENT’s closest friend, FAMILY FRIEND’s daughter, is not from school, does not indicate that STUDENT cannot make friends. FAMILY FRIEND’s daughter would spend the night and the two girls would talk on the phone. They attended scouts and church together and went on occasional outings. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by FAMILY FRIEND’s testimony that STUDENT does have the ability to make friends even though she may not always act appropriately toward her friends. The Hearing Officer is also persuaded by both Mr. Silveira and Ms. Sparks that STUDENT also appeared to have some friends at school.

Further, STUDENT seemed to get along well with her teachers and principal despite Mother’s statement that STUDENT hated the principal. Even if STUDENT disliked the principal, Ms. Sparks persuasively testified that STUDENT had an appropriate relationship with her. STUDENT also maintained her relationship with Ms. Bosson from third grade through fifth grade, so much so that Ms. Bosson invited STUDENT into her classroom on a regular basis. The fact that Ms. Silveira attended one of STUDENT’s piano recitals also indicates that a relationship existed between STUDENT and her teacher. Although STUDENT did not seem to have “close” relationships, the Hearing Officer finds that she had an ability to maintain satisfactory peer and teacher relationships during the fifth grade.

2. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances

Petitioner asserts that she has exhibited inappropriate behaviors under normal circumstances at school, home, and in the community. Petitioner asserts that a child who cannot accept being “called out” during four-square and responds with violence and defiance, or a child who attempts to push her girlfriends down the stairs during a scouting event is a child who exhibits inappropriate behaviors under normal circumstances.

The District contends that although STUDENT was having some behavioral problems, they were not pervasive and over a long period of time, nor did they affect her education.

In the fifth grade, STUDENT had two suspensions. One suspension was for twisting a girl’s arm after STUDENT disagreed with her being called out in four-square. The second suspension was for a series of incidents in her music and regular classroom, including poking a student with a pencil, tearing up her sheet music, refusing to complete assignments for a substitute teacher, refusing to turn in a test and threatening to tear up the test, and refusing to leave the classroom with the principal. Moreover, reportedly, during the music class incident, STUDENT commented to another student that she wished her music teacher would die.

Mother also testified that STUDENT displayed many extreme and abnormal behaviors outside of school during her fifth grade school year, including attempting to jump out of a moving vehicle, requesting that Mother just kill her, tearing her room apart in a rage on two or three occasions, and attempting to push two friends in scouts down the stairs. Although all these incidents are serious and unusual, Mother did not share any of this information with the District until STUDENT’s completion of the fifth grade year, and some were not shared until Mother testified at hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer found Mother’s testimony less persuasive.

Based on the evidence presented, both documentary and testimonial, STUDENT was having some behavioral problems; however, during the time frame of STUDENT’s two suspensions, she was not consistently taking her ADHD medication as prescribed by her family practitioner. STUDENT displayed inappropriate behaviors for about three months and she was also defiant towards teachers and peers. The Hearing Officer questions whether these were under normal circumstances as the evidence supports that she was not consistently taking her ADHD medication as prescribed. However, towards the end of the second trimester, STUDENT began routinely taking her medication and the District developed a behavior support plan and implemented it to address her inappropriate behaviors. By the third trimester, the inappropriate behaviors lessened and no more suspensions were warranted. Although Petitioner argues that her two isolated incidents with campus police during the third and fourth grade indicate that her behaviors have gone on for a long period of time, the Hearing Officer finds that her behaviors have not been pervasive and ongoing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did exhibit inappropriate behaviors; however, these were not under normal circumstances, nor were these behaviors over a long period of time or to a marked degree.

3. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression

Petitioner asserts that it was uncontradicted that STUDENT was depressed during fifth grade because she was initially diagnosed with depression by Dr. Jordan in the 1997-1998 school year (first grade), was again diagnosed in a summer program in UC Berkeley in 1998, and was also diagnosed by Dr. Matteo, STUDENT’s private therapist, in 2000. Further Petitioner asserts that during the behavior support plan meeting in February 2002, Ms. Silveira mentioned that STUDENT may be depressed. Petitioner also contends that Dr. Solomon’s assessment in March and April 2002 diagnosed STUDENT with depression. (Footnote 4)

District contends that STUDENT did not meet this criterion because she did not exhibit symptoms of depression over a long period of time or to a marked degree and her education was not adversely affected by her bouts of periodic depression. Furthermore, the District argues that a diagnosis of depression alone does not guarantee a child receive special education services due to an emotional disturbance because 34 C.F.R. Section 300.7(c)(4)(i) and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, Section 3030(i) require that the child’s education performance also be adversely affected by the depression.

Dr. Solomon assessed STUDENT in April 2002 and in her report prepared in the early summer of 2002, she diagnosed STUDENT with major depressive disorder. (Footnote 5) She met with STUDENT over a two-day period in March and April 2002, during which time Mother gave STUDENT a double dose of her ADHD medication to insure that she was able to attend to the assessment. She interviewed STUDENT and her mother and read materials supplied by Mother. She did not contact any school personnel or observe STUDENT in any educational or learning environment. Dr. Solomon gave STUDENT several tests, including academic and emotional tests.

Dr. Solomon gave STUDENT and Mother a series of personality and projective tests and explained the results in her evaluation. The Kovacs Children’s Depression Inventory indicated that underlying STUDENT’s agitation and flat affect was depression. A Trauma Symptom Checklist, a self-reported test, placed STUDENT on the average scale with the exception of the sexual concern or preoccupation scale, which placed her as elevated. The Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist was completed by Mother. It is a series of eight scales on which the parent is asked to rate his or her child. Mother rated STUDENT in the 98 percentile the somatic, withdrawn, anxious/depressed/social problems, thought problems, attention problems and aggressive behavior scales.

Dr. Solomon also gave STUDENT the Unfinished Sentence Test, which indicated that STUDENT was disconnected from her feelings but that she was also reflective at times. STUDENT was given a Roberts Apperception Test for Children, which indicated that STUDENT showed a limited trust in others to help her, limited problem solving skills, and feelings of depression. The Rorschach Ink Blot test, a highly unstructured test, indicated that STUDENT had internal chaos, disordered thinking, signs of depression, and significant cognitive disruption and perceptual distortion. Dr. Solomon explained in her report and testimony that STUDENT’s agitation, poor frustration tolerance, and anger were manifestations of her depression. Dr. Solomon’s findings did not consider STUDENT’s double dose of ADHD medication as a factor in the results, nor did Dr. Solomon talk with any of the school personnel to determine if STUDENT exhibited behaviors in the school setting similar to those in the testing environment.

Mother additionally testified that STUDENT seemed depressed during her fifth grade year. She explained that STUDENT would always wake up happy but her mood could change within the first half an hour of being awake. Ms. Bell testified that STUDENT seemed unhappy and would always sit by herself at lunch. Mr. Silveira also suggested at the behavior support team meeting that Mother take STUDENT to her doctor regarding possible depression.

The evidence as a whole established that STUDENT did not appear unhappy during the 2001-2002 school year. According to Ms. Sparks, STUDENT did have periodic situational behavior problems that were more persistent during the second trimester when she was not consistently taking her medication. The District asserts that although STUDENT had bouts of depression or sadness during her fifth grade year, they seemed to be episodic. Mr. Silveira testified that generally STUDENT was a happy, energetic, well-mannered girl during the first and third trimesters of school. Mr. Silveira testified that STUDENT had a good sense of humor and that she was generally polite with teachers and staff at Donaldson Way. Ms. Sparks also testified that STUDENT was generally happy and energetic during fifth grade with the exception of the second trimester. Ms. Sparks testified that she was a very talented and capable student and that he often saw her “giggling” on the playground with other girls.

Based on the information that the District had during the 2001-2002 school year, the District did not have any indication that STUDENT had a diagnosis of depression, nor did STUDENT exhibit ongoing depressive behaviors throughout the school year. As indicated above, Mother did not share any of the information regarding STUDENT’s prior or recent diagnoses of depression with the District, nor did she share any information about STUDENT’s behaviors in the home, at scouts, or at church. However, even if Mother had shared the information, STUDENT was not exhibiting any traditional signs of depression in school such as lethargy, sleepiness, low energy, or preoccupation; rather, she displayed inappropriate acting out behaviors.

Furthermore, no evidence was presented to contradict the fact that STUDENT’s medications for ADHD were unstable and changing during STUDENT’s difficult months of fifth grade and that this may have been a contributing factor to her inappropriate behaviors. Moreover, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Dr. Solomon’s report, as she failed to interview any school staff or observe STUDENT in any educational setting to determine if STUDENT’s depression adversely affected her education. Dr. Solomon also failed to consider STUDENT’s double dosage of medication at the time of the assessment and Mother’s excessively negative scores on the parent-reported behavior scale. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT may have had a some bouts of sadness or unhappiness, these were not to a marked degree it was not pervasive in the school setting nor did it occur over a long period of time.

Conclusion

STUDENT has failed to meet the criteria for any of the elements required to be eligible for special education due to an emotional disturbance during the 2001-2002 school year. Although STUDENT may have had some problems with peers and may have exhibited some depressive behaviors, these were generally confined to the second trimester of fifth grade. Each behavior may have seemed significant at the time, but they were episodic and not to a marked degree or over a period of more than a few months. Further, despite STUDENT’s relationship and behavioral troubles, she continued to excel academically.

In fact, during STUDENT’s entire academic career at Donaldson Way, she received average and above average marks. During her fifth grade year, STUDENT received all fours and fives on her report card (five being the highest grade). She also received all Satisfactory marks for effort and attitude for learning. In the teacher’s comments section, Mr. Silveira made the following observations: “bright, articulate and capable student,” “demonstrates strong academic skills and ability,” “a capable reader and talented writer,” “demonstrates a higher order thinking skills,” and “continues to make progress in meeting grade level standards.” STUDENT was also placed on honor roll during her first and third trimesters of fifth grade. Because she was a very strong reader, she also assisted younger students who had reading challenges.

STUDENT’s superior academic skills were also evident on the District and State achievement tests. STUDENT consistently scored in the average and above average range in all SAT 9 subject areas tested in each grade. In the fifth grade, STUDENT scored in the 83rd percentile rank for reading, 87th percentile rank for mathematics, 83rd percentile rank in language, and the 57th percentile rank in spelling on the SAT 9. STUDENT also scored at or above grade level on the District second trimester language and math assessments.

Although Mother asserted that STUDENT did not deserve her grades because STUDENT did not produce average and above average schoolwork, there is no indication that STUDENT’s grades were “pity grades.” To the contrary, according to STUDENT’s previous report cards and her SAT 9 scores from previous years, STUDENT consistently received high marks and consistently made progress on her State standardized testing.

In summary, any problems that STUDENT encountered during fifth grade did not adversely affect her education. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not qualify for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance during the 2001-2002 school year.

b. Other Health Impaired (OHI)

Petitioner contends that during her fifth grade year she met special education eligibility under the category of other health impaired (OHI) because of her attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Under federal law, other health impaired is defined as having limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment. Further this alertness must adversely affect the child’s educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a).) Under federal law, ADHD is included within the category of OHI. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).) In addition, to qualify under OHI, State law recognizes ADHD as an eligible condition if the student otherwise qualifies as either SLD or ED. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339.)

Neither party disputes that STUDENT has been diagnosed with ADHD and that she has exhibited the symptoms of impulsivity, short attention span, and impatience in the school setting, including some tantrumming behaviors. Additionally, STUDENT has had a 504 plan since the first grade due to her diagnosis of ADHD. However, no evidence was presented to show that STUDENT exhibited “limited strength, vitality, or alertness” in the school setting; to the contrary, her teachers described her as bright energetic and an eager learner.

STUDENT’s ADHD has been successfully treated with medication for the most part. Her documented behavior and social problems occurred when STUDENT did not take her medications at school as directed. STUDENT had six major tantrums during her entire time at Donaldson Way (and none during fifth grade), with at least three of them (during second, third, and fourth grade) directly related to her failure to take medications prescribed for her ADHD.

As stated above, STUDENT excelled academically. Despite her diagnosis of ADHD and her frequent refusal to take her medication, she was always able to do well in school. There may have been some slight variations in the quality of her schoolwork or in her test scores, which may have been attributable to her short attention span or impatience, but this did not hinder her overall educational performance in school.

Additionally, due to STUDENT’s behavioral challenges in the fifth grade and because she had a 504 plan, a behavior support team meeting was held at which a behavior support plan was developed and implemented in STUDENT’s fifth grade classroom. Mr. Silveira testified that he was able to make modifications for STUDENT so that she would not be embarrassed to take her medication, and he utilized the behavior support plan to give her positive reinforcement to avoid the negative behaviors. From the evidence presented, there is no indication that STUDENT’s ADHD could not be addressed through general classroom modifications and a behavior support plan. Further, there is no evidence that STUDENT’s educational performance was adversely affected by her ADHD to any significant degree. Moreover, as noted above, STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance, nor does she have a specific learning disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not qualify for special education under the category of OHI.

The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner was not eligible for special education in either the ED or OHI category during the 2001-2002 school year, and that her needs were adequately addressed in a regular education classroom. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b).)

2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Because STUDENT was not eligible for special education, during the 2001-2002 school year, the District was not required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Education Code §56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Education Code § 56000 et seq.) In this case, STUDENT is not a child with a disability requiring special education and related services.

Petitioner additionally argues that the District committed procedural violations because it failed to conduct an evaluation when it suspected or had reason to suspect that she was a child with a disability as required by 20 U.S.C. Section 1412 (a)(3)(A). The District contends that STUDENT was excelling academically so there was no reason to suspect that she needed special education services.

Petitioner contends that the District should have assessed STUDENT during the fifth grade because she had several serious behavior incidents including two suspensions. She also had a 504 plan for her ADHD that was not effective because STUDENT failed to consistently take her medications to treat her ADHD.

The District asserts that all the behavioral incidents were dealt with through referrals to the principal and that general accommodations were made to help STUDENT cope in school. Additionally, STUDENT had a 504 plan in place to assist STUDENT with difficulties associated with her ADHD. The District contends that upon noticing STUDENT’s behavioral decline, it convened a behavior support team and a behavior support plan was developed and implemented. Because the behavior plan was effective, there was no need to take the next step and make a referral for an assessment. Additionally, Mother never requested that the District assess STUDENT for special education and she did not share information regarding STUDENT’s behavior at home or in the scouts with the District. Moreover, the District argues that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. She was receiving behavioral supports and services through the regular education program that were sufficient to assist STUDENT to advance academically and maintain controllable behavior.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the District’s argument. When there were some signs that the District may need to conduct an assessment, the District took steps to address her behaviors and made accommodations in the classroom. They then determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance or other health impaired. The Hearing Officer finds that no procedural violations were committed that resulted in a loss of educational opportunity.

3. Is STUDENT entitled in compensatory education and or is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of a private assessment and/or cost of providing tutoring to STUDENT after school?

Because the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not entitled to special education and that the District was not required to provide a FAPE in accordance with the IDEA and State law, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education. Further, Mother is also not entitled to reimbursement for services that she obtained for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year.

2002-2003 School Year (Sixth Grade)

4. Did STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impaired (OHI)?

Petitioner contends that she was eligible for special education during the 2002-2003 school year at the time she was unilaterally placed by her mother at Intermountain in Helena, Montana. Petitioner asserts that she qualified for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance and/or other health impaired due to her diagnosis of ADHD.

The District asserts that Petitioner did not qualify for special education because she did not meet the eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance or other health impaired.

On July 15, 2002, Mother notified the District via letter that she was giving her ten-day notice of unilateral placement in accordance with 20 U.S.C. Section 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I)(bb). On August 16, 2002, STUDENT was placed at Intermountain, a program designed to work with severely emotionally disturbed children who have failed in multiple group home placements in the past. Mother explained that following receipt of Dr. Solomon’s psychological evaluation and report, she requested that the consultants find STUDENT a placement.

Mother also testified that there was no one big incident that led to STUDENT’s removal from regular education and placement in Montana. In fact, STUDENT was doing well over the summer and FAMILY FRIEND took STUDENT on outings with her daughter and other peers to Marine World and Waterworld just before STUDENT left in August 2002.

As found above, the Hearing Officer concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with an ED or OHI during the 2001-2002 school year. From the uncontroverted testimony of Mother, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no change of circumstances between the end of 2001-2002 school year and the time that Mother placed STUDENT at Intermountain. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes STUDENT was not eligible as ED or OHI when Mother placed STUDENT at Intermountain in August 2002.

This conclusion is further supported by the District’s assessment. After Mother filed for due process, the District and Mother agreed to have Denise Struven, District school psychologist, fly to Montana to conduct a thorough assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Struven conducted her assessment over three days in early December 2002. The parties agreed to hold an IEP meeting on January 30, 2003, to discuss whether STUDENT was eligible for special education services and, if so, to develop and implement an IEP.

Ms. Struven assessed STUDENT in December 2002. (Footnote 6) Ms. Struven gave STUDENT a series of academic and social/emotional tests and explained those results in her testimony and her report. She also interviewed STUDENT and several staff members at Intermountain. Ms. Struven gave STUDENT the Draw-a-Person Test, which indicated that STUDENT tends towards emotional dominance, impulsivity, and can be self-oriented and self-conscience. In the Family Drawing Test, STUDENT omitted herself, indicating a feeling of being left out and a lack of interaction between family members. The Sentence Completion Test indicated that STUDENT is attached to her mother, enjoys certain aspects of her life, is fairly positive about others, and is aware that her behavior and choices she has made are affecting her school placement.

STUDENT was given the Roberts Apperception Test. In the adaptive section, STUDENT’s stories reflected average and above average ability to reach out and help others but she was below average in the area of supporting others by giving them assistance. In the clinical section of the test, her scores indicated elevated areas of aggression, depression, and rejection.

In the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), a self-reported test, STUDENT scored in the at-risk range on the emotional symptom index. She was in the average range on the social maladjustment composite and in the at-risk range on the clinical maladjustment composite. Ms. Struven also gave the BASC to Mr. Silveira, STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher, who reported that STUDENT was in the average range on the behavioral symptom index, the internalizing problem composite, the school problems composite, the areas of typicality and withdrawal, and on the adaptive skills composite. Mr. Silveira rated STUDENT in the at-risk range on the externalizing problems composite. Ms. Brandt, STUDENT’s sixth grade teacher at Intermountain, also completed the BASC and found STUDENT in the at-risk range on the behavioral symptom index, the internalizing problem composite, in the area of withdrawal, and the adaptive skill composite. Ms. Brandt placed STUDENT in the average range on the externalizing problems composite and in the area of typicality.

Ms. Struven also gave the BASC to Mother who rated STUDENT in the clinically significant range on all areas. It was also noted that due to Mother’s excessively negative scores, the computer printout noted the scores should be looked at with extreme caution. Additionally, Ms. Struven administered an academic test, the Woodcock Johnson III Test of Achievement, on which STUDENT scored in the average to above average range in all areas. An IEP meeting was held on January 31, 2003 to discuss Ms. Struven’s assessment. No one from Intermountain was present at the IEP meeting, although Ms. Struven had met with many members of the staff and included their comments in her assessment report. Additionally, all reports from Intermountain were presented to the IEP team. Ms. Struven recommended that STUDENT remain ineligible for special education because her education was not adversely affected by her behaviors. Mother did not dispute the appropriateness of the assessment, only the findings. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment was thorough and appropriate in accordance with California Code Section 56320.

Finally, although STUDENT had a rather difficult adjustment period at Intermountain, she began making progress and was once again developing friendships and performing at grade level academically. The Hearing Officer concludes that based on the above information, STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with an ED or OHI during the 2002-2003 school year.

5. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Because STUDENT was not eligible for special education, during the 2002-2003 school year, the District was not required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Education Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Education Code § 56000 et seq.) In this case, STUDENT is not a child with a disability requiring special education and related services.

Petitioner also alleges that a procedural violation was committed by the District because the District failed to have one of STUDENT’s Intermountain teachers present at the January 2003 IEP meeting. Under California Code of Regulations Section 3030, a determination of eligibility requires the convening of an IEP team as set forth in California Code Section 56341(b), and the District met these requirements. Section 56341(b)(2) requires at least one general education teacher of the pupil. Section 56341(b)(3) requires at least one special education teacher of the pupil, or if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil. Neither section specifically states that the teacher must be the student’s present teacher. Additionally, Section 56341(b)(6) states that at the discretion of the parent or the District, other individuals with knowledge of the pupil may be invited to be a member of the IEP team. Someone from Intermountain could have been invited to give input; however, Ms. Struven had interviewed several staff members and included their concerns in her assessment. Additionally, according to the District’s closing brief, the District had copies of all the Intermountain reports to date.

The Hearing Officer finds that the lack of a teacher from Intermountain had minimal effect and that STUDENT did not suffer any prejudice by their lack of participation, nor was any evidence presented that the determination of eligibility would have differed had one of STUDENT’s teachers participated in the IEP team meeting.

6. Is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the private placement at Intermountain?

Because the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not entitled to receive special education services and that the District was not required to provide a FAPE in accordance with the IDEA and State law, Mother is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placement at Intermountain during the 2002-2003 school year.

ORDERS

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505 (i).

Date: October 15, 2003 ______________________________________Jessica Katz, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

Mr. Silveira testified that STUDENT did not like taking her medications because she was embarrassed to leave the class and did not want the other students to know that she was on medications. He also testified that STUDENT told him that occasionally the medications did not make her feel good.

2 Mother testified that when STUDENT was originally eligible for special education, one of her goals was to work on social interactions with peers.

3 Mother testified that STUDENT was not friends with, nor did she like, any of the girls that Ms. Sparks mentioned.

4 This report was not shared with the District until after Mother filed for due process in August 2002.

5 Dr. Solomon has been working with troubled adolescents for approximately twenty-two years and has had a private practice conducting psychological assessments for the past seven years.

6 Ms. Morrison testified that STUDENT was off all medication after six weeks of being placed at Intermountain; therefore, she was not medicated during Ms. Struven’s assessment.