California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 18, 2004
Student v. Rialto Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1820-04 · Hearing Officer My T. Huynh
Rialto Unified violated stay put by withholding auditory-verbal therapy; must reimburse parents and provide 50 compensatory hours.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes an earlier due process case (SN02-01221), filed June 2002, which Petitioner voluntarily dismissed in summer 2004 after an Order to Show Cause for failure to prosecute. Petitioner then filed this action on substantially the same claims. No appeal or remand is noted.
Summary
The parents of a seven-year-old boy who is deaf and uses a cochlear implant filed for due process against Rialto Unified School District. Since 2001 the District had funded his placement at Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired, a nonpublic school. After a May 2002 IEP meeting the parents disagreed with, the District stopped auditory-verbal therapy (AVT) and oral motor therapy (OMT) and substituted general speech therapy. It never restored them, even after a November 2002 stay put order. The Hearing Officer first denied the District's motion to dismiss for lack of residency. The family had lived in Rialto for four and a half years. The Hearing Officer then held that stay put applied automatically once the parents disagreed. Withholding AVT denied a FAPE from May 2002 through the 2004 extended school year. Oralingua's Linda Hyde and certified therapist Kay Schneider showed that AVT, with its parent-training role, differs from speech therapy. The OMT violation did not deny a FAPE because speech therapy covered enough oral motor work. The May 2004 offer of a cochlear implant special day class at Henry School was appropriate except that it lacked AVT. A July 2004 settlement offer of a general education class at Boyd Elementary was not a FAPE. The District must reimburse the parents' AVT costs, provide 50 compensatory hours, and add AVT twice weekly to the IEP. The request for continued Oralingua placement was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows SEHO treating stay put as automatic once a parent disputes an IEP, even after an earlier stay put motion was denied as unnecessary. It also separates a specific therapy (AVT) from general speech services. And it refuses a private-placement remedy that has no connection to the service actually lost.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedResponsible agency
Issue Preliminary. District motion to dismiss on the ground that Student's parents did not reside within District boundaries (alleged Pomona residence).
Uncontradicted testimony and documents showed the family had lived in Rialto for four and a half years; the District offered no evidence, and the motion to dismiss was denied.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 1. Did the District deny Student a FAPE following the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting through the end of the 2002 ESY by failing to provide auditory-verbal therapy (AVT)?
Stay put applied automatically once parents disagreed with the May 2002 IEP; the District unilaterally ended AVT, causing lost educational opportunity and a denial of FAPE from May 16, 2002 through the 2002 ESY.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT?
The District knowingly disregarded the November 2002 stay put order requiring AVT; unrebutted expert testimony showed Student needed AVT, so the violation denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 3a. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT?
The continued failure to provide AVT under stay put denied FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEStay put
Issue 3b. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to provide oral motor therapy (OMT)?
The District violated stay put by not providing OMT, but substituted speech-language therapy (about 360 minutes per month) included adequate oral motor work, so there was no lost educational opportunity.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3c. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to address his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 IEP offer?
The Henry School cochlear implant SDC was an oral-communication setting with a low student-teacher ratio that met Student's needs, but the offer lacked necessary AVT; FAPE was denied from May 21, 2004 through the 2004 ESY only as to AVT.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4a. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year by addressing his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 IEP offer and the July 26, 2004 placement offer?
The July 26, 2004 settlement offer of a second-grade general education class with speech, auditory therapy and RSP was not a FAPE because Student needed a small SDC and AVT; the May 2004 IEP was inappropriate only because it lacked AVT.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue 4b. Has the District adhered to procedural safeguards in the development of the July 26, 2004 placement offer?
Because the July 26, 2004 offer failed on substantive grounds, the Hearing Officer did not decide the procedural claims.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 5a. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of AVT?
About two years of lost AVT warranted 50 hours of compensatory AVT in addition to ongoing AVT, to be provided within one year.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5b. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of OMT?
No compensatory OMT because adequate oral motor services were provided through speech therapy and FAPE was not denied.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5c. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of continued placement at Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired?
Prospective Oralingua placement denied: the District's program could be made appropriate by adding AVT, and the lost AVT had no connection to the requested placement, which the District had funded throughout.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6. If the District denied Student a FAPE, are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for AVT services?
Parent-funded certified AVT from Oralingua beginning June 2004 was appropriate and produced progress, so reimbursement was ordered until the District begins funding AVT.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days of receiving proof of payment, District shall reimburse parents for AVT services from Oralingua from June 2004 until the District begins paying for AVT services, which must be no later than October 1, 2004. Dollar amount not stated.
- Compensatory education. District shall immediately, but no later than October 1, 2004, begin providing 50 hours of AVT as compensatory education, to be completed within one year of the decision unless the parties agree otherwise in writing; this is in addition to the ongoing AVT and should minimally affect the school day (for example, after school).
- Order to provide or change services. District shall amend its May 21, 2004 IEP to include AVT by a certified auditory-verbal therapist, 30 minutes twice a week.
- If parents want a publicly funded program through Rialto Unified, they must make Student available for the services in the May 21, 2004 IEP (Henry School cochlear implant SDC) with AVT added, 30 minutes twice a week. All other requested relief, including continued Oralingua placement and compensatory OMT, was denied.
Total: 50 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Stacy G. v. Pasadena Ind. School Dist.; Thomas v. Cincinnati Bd. of Educ.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; School Comm. of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Todd v. Andrews; Alamo Heights Ind. School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager; District representative and witness, Rialto Unified School District / SELPA
- Barbara Mori, Ph.D., Director of student services, Rialto Unified School District
- Christopher Russell, Educational advocate for Student; witness
- Linda Hyde, Program director and former classroom teacher; witness for Student, Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired
- Kay Schneider (also spelled Kaye), Certified auditory-verbal therapist and teacher; witness for Student, Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired
- Lynette Wilson, General education teacher; District witness, Rialto Unified School District
- Tammy Hopkins, Speech-language pathologist; District witness, Rialto Unified School District
- Ivette McNally, School psychologist; District witness, Rialto Unified School District
- Patricia Balthazor, Audiologist; District witness, Rialto Unified School District
- Vera Hammar, Resource specialist program teacher; District witness, Rialto Unified School District
- Karen Rothwell-Vivian, Auditory-verbal therapy provider under 2001 IEP, Nonpublic agency
- Janine Murdock, Oral motor therapy provider under 2001 IEP, Nonpublic agency
- John Tracy Clinic, Private early childhood deafness clinic; provided OMT
- House Ear Institute, Private audiological testing provider
- Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired, Nonpublic school; also private AVT provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on August 5, 6, 17, 18, and 23, 2004, in Rialto, California before My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner (Petitioner or Student) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather and educational advocate Christopher Russell. Also appearing on Student’s behalf were his parents, Mother and Father. Respondent Rialto Unified School District (District) was represented by special education local plan area (SELPA) program manager Gail Lindberg. Director of student services Barbara Mori, Ph.D., also appeared for the District.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Mother; Christopher Russell; Gail Lindberg; Barbara Mori; Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired (Oralingua) program director Linda Hyde; and Oralingua teacher and therapist Kay Schneider. (Footnote 1)
The District called the following witnesses: teacher Lynette Wilson; speech and language pathologist Tammy Hopkins; Student’s Grandmother; school psychologist Ivette McNally; audiologist Patricia Balthazor; and resource specialist program teacher Vera Hammar.
The Hearing Officer called Father, as a witness.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon the completion of telephonic closing arguments on August 23, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
The District raised grounds for dismissal of this action based on its allegation that Petitioner’s parents did not and do not currently reside within the geographical boundaries of the District. The District asserted that Petitioner’s parents instead reside in Pomona, California and not within the District’s boundaries. Generally, the school district with responsibility for a child’s education is in that which his or her parent resides. Cal. Educ. Code § 48200; see 34 C.F.R. § 300.220. If it had been established that Petitioner’s parent’s residence was located somewhere other than within the District’s geographical boundaries, dismissal of some issues might have been warranted.
In response, Mother, testified that she and her husband, Father, have lived within the District’s boundaries for the past four and a half years. (Footnote 2) She stated that she, her husband, and Student live with her husband’s parents in Rialto. Petitioner also produced documentary evidence in the form of Mother’s driver’s license, and pay television and newspaper subscription bills with an address demonstrating residence within the District. (Pet. Ex. SS, TT and UU.) grandmother, Student’s grandmother, corroborated the above testimony and evidence by stating that Student’s family lives with her in Rialto. (Footnote 3) She further testified that Student’s family has resided continuously with her in Rialto for the past four and a half years.
Conversely, the District failed to produce any evidence to support its allegation regarding residency. During the course of the hearing, the District stated that it was searching for documents and witnesses to support its claim. The District called Grandmother as a witness to address this contention but her testimony did not support the District’s position. Moreover, the District never produced any documentary evidence indicating that Petitioner’s parents have lived anywhere outside the District’s boundaries in the past four and a half years.
The Hearing Officer finds the District’s contention that Petitioner’s parents do not live within the District’s boundaries unconvincing. Petitioner offered the uncontradicted testimony of his Grandmother and documentary evidence reflecting Petitioner’s parents’ residency within the District’s boundaries for all times relevant to this action. The Hearing Officer finds Grandmother’s testimony to be credible because she testified without contradiction regarding where Petitioner’s parents live. Further, although Mother made knowingly false statements regarding her children, her testimony did not waiver with respect to her residency over the past four and one-half years. For the purposes of this procedural matter, the Hearing Officer found her testimony credible.
Because the undisputed evidence demonstrated that Student’s parents have lived within the geographical boundaries of the District for the last four and a half years, Student’s residency also was established within the District for this time period. Accordingly, the District was required to provide special education services for Student over the past four and a half years. See Cal. Educ. Code § 48200. The Hearing Officer thus determined that dismissal was not warranted based on the District’s mere assertions regarding Petitioner’s parents’ residency and denied the District’s motion to dismiss.
ISSUES
1. Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) following the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting through the end of the 2002 extended school year (ESY) by failing to provide auditory-verbal therapy (AVT)?
2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT?
3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to:
a. Provide AVT, b. Provide oral motor therapy (OMT), and c. Address his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) offer?
4. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year by:
a. Addressing his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 IEP offer and the July 26, 2004 placement offer and b. Adhering to procedural safeguards in the development of the July 26, 2004 placement offer? (Footnote 4)
5. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of:
a. AVT, b. OMT, and c. Continued placement at Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired?
6. If the District denied Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for AVT services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a seven-year-old boy who resides in the geographical boundaries of the District with his parents. He is eligible for special education and related services as a deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) student. At eighteen months of age, an otolarnygologist diagnosed Student with profound hearing loss. (Footnote 5) In response, his parents consulted with the John Tracy Clinic (Clinic), an educational and medical facility specializing in the treatment of early childhood deafness. At the Clinic, Student’s parents were instructed in techniques to work with Student and on his hearing loss. (Testimony of Mother.) Student and his mother attended the Clinic four days a week for over one year. In an attempt to limit his hearing loss, he also received hearing aides.
During this time, his parents also consulted the House Ear Institute (Institute) for hearing testing. At the Institute, Student received audiological testing that provided inconclusive results. It appeared that Student’s hearing ability fluctuated at various frequencies. (Testimony of Mother.) Nonetheless, he continued to lose his ability to hear and receive information verbally. He also exhibited difficulties in oral communication. Specifically, Student had delays in his speaking ability in the formation of both individual sounds and words. In response, the Clinic provided him with speech and language services including oral motor therapy (OMT). (Pet. Ex. A.) The OMT emphasized teaching him to manipulate his tongue to improve his ability to make sounds and words.
In fall 2000, after Student turned three years old, the District began providing special education programs and services for Student. (Pet. Ex. B.) Over the course of the school year, Student’s individualized education programs (IEPs) continued to provide OMT services from the Clinic for the school year and extended school year (ESY). (Pet. Ex. B.) In May 2001, the IEP team added services for auditory-verbal therapy (AVT) from Karen Rothwell-Vivian and OMT from Janine Murdock. (Pet. Ex. F.)
In summer 2001, Student’s parents visited Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired (Oralingua). Oralingua is a State-certified nonpublic school (NPS) specializing in the education of deaf and hard of hearing students of elementary-school age. (Testimony of Linda Hyde.) In September 2001, Student’s parents enrolled him in Oralingua’s special day class (SDC). Shortly thereafter, Student’s IEP team met to discuss the parents’ request to have him placed at Oralingua at the District’s expense. (Pet. Ex. F.) Following the completion of pending evaluations, the IEP team met on October 10, 2001, to discuss placement options. The District agreed with the parents’ request and placed Student at Oralingua for the 2001-2002 school year. (Pet. Ex. K.) In addition, the IEP provided that Student would receive OMT services for sixty minutes per month and AVT services for sixty minutes twice per week by non-public agencies (NPAs).
In February 2002, Student underwent surgery to insert a cochlear ear implant. (Footnote 6) Prior to the surgery, the efficacy of hearing aides with Student had been limited and inconsistent in helping him receive sound. After the implant, Student’s speech became clearer and he could differentiate various sounds. To date, Student has made steady improvement in his ability to listen and speak.
On May 15, 2002, Student’s IEP team met again to discuss possible placements for the upcoming 2002-2003 school year. (Pet. Ex. M.) The District offered continued placement at Oralingua and related services through August 31, 2002. The District further proposed to have Student attend the District’s new oral DHH class beginning September 3, 2002. In the event that the new oral DHH class was not open by September 3, 2002, the District offered to place Student at the San Bernardino City Unified School District’s DHH class. During the IEP meeting, a member of the IEP team recommended that Student’s OMT and AVT services be terminated and instead be replaced by speech and language therapy to be provided by Oralingua staff. (Footnote 7) (Pet. Ex. M-3.)
Student’s parents disagreed with the District’s offer of placement at the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. Instead, Student’s parents expressed their desire to have Student continue to attend Oralingua for the next school year. On June 4, 2002, Student’s parents filed for a due process hearing with the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) for an adjudication regarding the District’s May 15, 2002 IEP offer. (Footnote 8) The filing also included a request for stay put of the current program and services Student was receiving. (Footnote 9) The Hearing Office denied Petitioner’s motion as premature at that time. The Hearing Office cited the fact that the District, at that time, had taken no action to change Student’s current placement; thus an order for stay put was not necessary. (Pet. Ex. Y.) Around the same time, Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager, terminated the contracted services for Student’s AVT and OMT. (Testimony of Ms. Lindberg.) Relying on the discussions of the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting, she substituted speech and language (S&L) therapy in place of the terminated AVT and OMT services.
In November 2002, Petitioner filed another motion for stay put seeking the reinstitution of AVT and OMT services. (Pet. Ex. FF-2.) Because the District had discontinued the provision of the AVT and OMT services from the last agreed-upon IEP of October 10, 2002, the Hearing Office granted the motion for stay put and ordered the District to provide AVT and OMT services during the pendency of the due process proceedings, unless the parties agreed otherwise. However, the District has never reinstituted the AVT or OMT services. (Testimony of Ms. Lindberg.) Instead, the District did and still continues to fund Student’s placement at Oralingua. The District also continues to fund S&L therapy in three thirty-minute sessions per week. (Testimony of Ms. Lindberg.) By the date of the hearing, Student had attended Oralingua for nearly three years at the District’s expense and had received thrice weekly S&L services for two years. At Oralingua, he has received specialized instruction in small classrooms of no more than eight students with an emphasis on oral communication. (Testimony of Ms. Hyde.) During this time, Student developed improved listening and speaking skills. He also has gained confidence in social interactions. (Testimony of Mother.)
In April 2004, the District conducted a triennial assessment of Student. The assessment included a psychoeducational evaluation, a language speech and hearing assessment, and an oral motor therapy assessment. (Dist. Ex. 2.) Following completion of the assessments, the IEP team met again on May 21, 2004, to discuss the assessment and possible future placements for Student. (Pet. Ex. NN.) The assessments indicated that Student has a cognitive intelligence quotient score of 121, which is in the above average range. (Testimony of Ms. McNally.) Student also showed written language and reading ability within the average range. However, a score for his mathematical skills could not be obtained. Student failed to answer any of the calculation questions posed during the assessment. (Testimony of Ms. McNally.)
At the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting, the District proposed a placement in the District’s SDC for children with cochlear implant, S&L therapy, and audiology services for the period of May 21, 2004, through May 21, 2005. (Pet. Ex. NN.) Student’s parents disagreed with the District’s proposal, citing their belief that continued placement at Oralingua was necessary for Student’s educational progress. They also cited Student’s continuing need for AVT services, which was not included in the District’s offer, as a reason that the proposed placement was inappropriate for Student. Because the District refused to provide AVT services, Student’s parents took it upon themselves to pay for these services. Petitioner’s parents began paying out-of-pocket for AVT beginning in June 2004. (Testimony of Mother.)
On July 26, 2004, the District sent a settlement offer to Petitioner’s counsel and parents offering a different placement. (Footnote 10) (Pet. Ex. RR.) The offer proposed a placement in a District second-grade general education classroom at Boyd Elementary School, Student’s neighborhood school. It also included individual S&L therapy three times a week in thirty-minute sessions. The letter also offered auditory therapy two times per week in forty-minute sessions. Further, the offer included one hour of daily resource specialist program (RSP) services. Lastly, it provided for thirty minutes per week of outside consultation by an NPA. However, Petitioner did not accept the settlement offer.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) following the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting through the end of the 2002 extended school year (ESY) by failing to provide auditory-verbal therapy (AVT)?
Petitioner claims that the District denied him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) when the District terminated AVT services following the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting, in violation of the stay put provisions and a later stay put order issued by the Hearing Office. (Footnote 11) There is no dispute that the District properly provided Student with AVT and OMT services for the majority of the 2001-2002 school year until the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. Accordingly, Petitioner’s claim is limited to the period following the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting through the 2002 ESY.
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Cent. Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205.
The procedural rights that extend to parents and students under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Under federal and State special education law, unless the public educational agency and the parent agree otherwise, a special education student is entitled remain in his or her present educational placement pending the completion of due process hearing procedures. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of the stay put provision is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. Stacy G. v. Pasadena Ind. Sch. Dist., 695 F.2d 949, 953 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2d Cir. 1982). A student’s “present educational placement” is generally the placement called for by the student’s last agreed-upon IEP which has been implemented prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Bd. of Educ., 918 F.2d 218 (6th Cir. 1990). Federal regulations make clear that stay put is a “procedural safeguard” that must be afforded a special education student involved in a dispute regarding his or her education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.514.
The parties both agree that the October 10, 2001 IEP was Student’s last agreed-upon IEP. Within that placement, Student was to receive AVT for sixty minutes, twice per week. He also was to receive OMT for sixty minutes, once a month. Initially, the services were provided by an NPA and paid for by the District. The October 10, 2001 IEP contemplated the services would be provided from October 2001 through October 2002. At the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting, a discussion arose regarding the continuing need to provide AVT and OMT services. According to the meeting notes, the parents requested that these services be terminated. Further, the notes indicate that Oralingua should instead provide S&L therapy services. (Pet. Ex. M.) In her testimony, Mother unequivocally denied that she or her husband made any request to end AVT services in lieu of S&L therapy services.
The parties agree that Student’s parents did not consent to the proposed change of placement or related services in the May 15, 2002 IEP. Nonetheless, Ms. Lindberg testified that she terminated funding for AVT and OMT services shortly thereafter. She instead instructed Oralingua to provide S&L services as reflected in the May 15, 2002 proposed IEP. She stated that she believed such actions were proper because Student’s parents were in agreement with this arrangement during the discussions of the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting.
Petitioner contends that Ms. Lindberg’s actions violated the stay put provisions of federal and State law. He argues that the District erred in terminating the AVT services and substituting non-specific S&L services. Mother credibly testified that she never agreed to end the AVT services. Further, Christopher Russell testified that after the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting, he filed a due process hearing request and sought stay put for the placement described in the October 10, 2001 IEP. (Footnote 12) (Pet. Ex. X.) The stay put motion was denied, at that time, as unnecessary because the Hearing Office was informed that the last agreed-upon services were continuing to be provided. (Pet. Ex. Y.) Following the initial denial of Petitioner’s stay put motion, Petitioner moved again for stay put in November 2002; this motion was granted. (Pet. Ex. FF.) At that time, it was clear that the District had terminated the AVT and OMT services and that the District was no longer providing services pursuant to the last agreed-upon IEP of October 10, 2001. The Hearing Office specifically ordered that AVT and OMT services be provided consistent with the October 10, 2001 IEP. Following the issuance of the November 2002 stay put order, Petitioner requested the District comply with the order and reinstate AVT and OMT services. Mr. Russell also testified that at the November 8, 2002 IEP meeting, he raised with the District the issue of the District’s failure to comply with the stay put order to no avail. (Pet. Ex. GG-7.)
The District asserts that it did not violate the procedural protections of stay put on several grounds. First, the District argues that Student’s parents requested the termination of AVT services at the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Lindberg testified that the IEP team discussed consolidating Student’s educational program and related services at Oralingua. At the time, Student was receiving AVT from an NPA in a different city. To cut down on the amount of travel to and from service providers, the IEP team agreed to have Student receive all his services at Oralingua. Ms. Lindberg added that the May 15, 2002 IEP document reflects the parent’s request for termination of AVT and substitution of S&L services. (Pet. Ex. M.)
The District also contends that it substantially complied with the stay put provisions for the majority of the 2001-2002 school year. The District points to Mother’s testimony that Student received AVT services until sometime after the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. Further, the District argues that it was not required to provide stay put for AVT services because the Hearing Office had denied Petitioner’s initial stay put motion. The District asserts that any responsibility for stay put was not required until the issuance of the November 2002 order granting Petitioner’s second motion for stay put. Under those circumstances, the District contends that it was not required to provide AVT services under the stay put provision until the receipt of the November 2002 order.
The Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District violated Student’s procedural rights under the stay put provision of the IDEA. It is undisputed that the District provided AVT and OMT services pursuant to the last agreed-upon IEP for the majority of the 2001-2002 school year until sometime after the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. However, once a disagreement arose between the parties regarding the May 15, 2002 IEP proposal, the stay put provision applied automatically and the District could not implement a change to Student’s existing educational program without parental consent. Stacy G., 695 F.2d at 953. At that time, federal and State law made it incumbent upon the District to maintain the previously agreed-to placement for Student. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). Included in that previous agreed-to placement was the provision of AVT services.
In spite of the District’s argument that Student’s parents requested termination of AVT and implementation of S&L services, there is no evidence that Student’s parents accepted this arrangement in lieu of Student’s existing IEP. The District offered no persuasive evidence that Student’s parents accepted the substitution of S&L services as an alternative to his existing program. Instead, the May 15, 2002 IEP indicates Student’s parents’ dissent with the proposed IEP. Additionally, shortly after the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting, Petitioner filed his due process request and initial stay put motion. Moreover, the District failed to file any response to the stay put motion or in any way assert that the parties had reached an alternative agreement regarding Student’s educational placement pending the resolution of the due process hearing. (Pet. Ex. Y.) In addition, the District failed to assert that the parties had made an alternative agreement in its response to the November 2002 motion for stay put. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents indicated clearly to the District that they were dissenting to the District’s proposed change in his program outlined in the May 15, 2002 IEP. The IEP document itself and the two motions for stay put demonstrated that Petitioner disagreed with the proposed change in placement and services including the cessation of AVT services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s argument that the parties had reached an agreement that varied from the placement afforded under stay put.
The Hearing Officer also finds unreasonable the District’s reliance on the denial of the first stay put motion to avoid continuing to provide AVT services. As mentioned previously, the stay put provision applies automatically; any subsequent order issued by the Hearing Office only serves to clarify a district’s obligation under the stay put provision. Further, at the time of the Hearing Office’s initial denial of the motion for stay put, it was understood that AVT services had not been discontinued. Under those circumstances, a stay put order had been deemed unnecessary. It was clear from the language of the Hearing Officer’s order that the denial of that stay put motion was contingent on the expectation that the District would comply with its ongoing obligation to provide the same placement and services until resolution of the due process proceedings. The District, nevertheless, terminated the AVT services. Once this was brought to the attention of the Hearing Office, the Hearing Office’s issuance of the November 2002 stay put order was necessary. Nonetheless, the District failed to comply with the November 2002 order and has yet to provide AVT as required by the stay put provision. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated the procedural safeguards guaranteed by the stay put provision under the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether this violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or infringement on the parent’s right to participation constituting a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. Petitioner contends that the District’s failure to comply with the stay put order and resulting loss of AVT services created a loss of educational opportunity for him. In support of that position, Petitioner offered the testimony of Oralingua program director Linda Hyde. (Footnote 13) Ms. Hyde testified that she served as Student’s classroom teacher during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY. She stated that Student had been receiving AVT services in her classroom until sometime after May 15, 2002. Moreover, she worked with Student on a daily basis during the school year. She described AVT as a therapy that teaches a DHH student to use listening skills to acquire language, listening skills, and speech. AVT emphasizes the student’s skill in developing additional focus and attention to improve listening. It also involves training the DHH student’s parent to serve as a “primary teacher and caseworker” for the student. Ms. Hyde added that S&L therapy does not encompass the same areas as AVT.
Oralingua certified auditory-verbal therapist Kaye Schneider added that general S&L therapy does not incorporate the parental role. (Footnote 14) She testified that she has served as Student’s auditory-verbal therapist over the past three years. She stated that AVT’s emphasis on parental participation is essential in the development of listening and speech for DHH students, such as Student. She concluded that the S&L services substituted by the District following the termination of AVT services did not serve the same function nor encompass the same areas of concern for Student. Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider testified that he required AVT services during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY. Moreover, they each stated that he continues to require AVT services presently.
The District failed to offer any evidence to rebut the alleged loss of educational opportunity as testified to by Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider. The District’s S&L pathologist Tammy Hopkins testified that she had no training or experience in the area of AVT. (Footnote 15) She was able only to give a brief description of the service but did not venture to provide any opinion as to its efficacy for Student. No other District witness testified as to whether Student suffered any loss of educational opportunity from the violation of the stay put provision.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student was deprived educational opportunity due to the District’s failure to comply with the procedural safeguards provided under the stay put provision of the IDEA. Petitioner provided the testimony of two qualified witnesses with extensive backgrounds in working with Student and DHH students. Both Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider have worked in the area of educating DHH students for over two decades. Moreover, Ms. Hyde worked with Student on a daily basis as his classroom teacher during the school year at issue. Ms. Schneider further explained that the S&L services substituted by the District, following the termination of AVT services, were not equivalent in substance. Both witnesses testified without contradiction that Student required AVT services from May 15, 2002, through the 2002 ESY. Conversely, the District failed to offer any evidence to challenge this evidence. Given the overwhelming undisputed evidence that Student required AVT services throughout this period, the Hearing Officer finds that he was deprived educational opportunity when the District discontinued AVT services after the May 15, 2002 IEP meeting. Therefore, the District denied Student a FAPE from May 16, 2002 through the 2002 ESY by failing to maintain AVT services pursuant to the provisions of stay put. (Footnote 16)
2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT?
Petitioner also asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT services pursuant to his last agreed-upon IEP. Further, Petitioner contends that even after the District received the November 2002 stay put order, the District continued to disregard his stay put rights, causing him to lose the benefit of AVT services. As discussed above, the failure to comply with the provision of stay put may give rise to a procedural violation constituting a denial of FAPE.
The District did not challenge Petitioner’s assertion regarding the failure to comply with the November 2002 stay put order. Moreover, it did not offer any persuasive evidence to rebut this claim. Ms. Lindberg testified that the District has not provided any AVT services to Student since May 2002. She conceded that she terminated the AVT services in May 2002, and has taken no actions to reinstate that service. She admitted she was aware of the November 2002 order and its provisions specifically directing the District to reinstitute AVT but chose not to obey the order. Moreover, the District never appealed the order or sought reconsideration of its findings. The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed procedural error in failing to comply with the stay put provision and the November 2002 stay put order requiring the continued provision of AVT services to Student.
The Hearing Officer now must determine if the procedural error denied Student a FAPE. The parties offered the same evidence regarding AVT services as described above. Specifically, Petitioner’s witnesses each testified that he required AVT services throughout the period from October 2001 to the present. Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider testified that they provided Student with S&L therapy during the time period of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY. As discussed above, the District offered no evidence to rebut the opinions of Petitioner’s witnesses. Given the expertise of Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider and their extensive interactions with Student during the period at issue, the Hearing Officer finds that there was compelling evidence that he did require AVT services during this period. The District did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut the testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses in this regard. Given the substantial evidence that Student required AVT services during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY, the Hearing Officer finds that the District caused Student to lose educational opportunity by failing to comply with the stay put provision, as required by the November 2002 stay put order. Therefore, the District’s failure to guarantee Petitioner’s procedural safeguards amounted to a denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY insofar as AVT services were not provided.
3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY?
Petitioner asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by not providing AVT and OMT services as required by stay put. Further, he contends that the District’s offer of placement at the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting is not appropriate to meet his unique needs. That offer contemplates a placement for the time period from May 21, 2004 through May 21, 2005. Although the offer primarily covers the following school year, the offer includes part of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY. For this reason, this contention will be addressed as part of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY.
a. Failure to Provide AVT
Petitioner again contends that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by not complying with the stay put provision and the November 2002 stay put order compelling the District to provide AVT and OMT services pursuant to the October 10, 2001 IEP. As discussed above, the District concedes that it failed to provide AVT services as provided for in the stay put order of November 2002. To date, the District has failed to provide such services in contravention of the stay put provision and the order of the Hearing Office. The Hearing Officer determines that this amounted to a procedural violation. Moreover, given that the parties offered no other evidence that distinguishes the 2003-2004 school year and ESY from the previous periods at issue, the Hearing Officer finds that Student also suffered a loss of educational opportunity from the District’s error. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to comply with the stay put provision and order denied Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY insofar as AVT services were not provided.
b. Failure to Provide Oral Motor Therapy (OMT)
Petitioner also asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to reinstate OMT services as required by the stay put requirements of federal and State law and as provided for in the November 2002 stay put order. Specifically, Petitioner contends that following the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting, the District improperly terminated OMT services and failed to reinstate those services pursuant to the stay put order of November 2002. As discussed above, the failure to comply with the stay put provisions of the IDEA may constitute a procedural violation resulting in a denial of FAPE.
In support of his position, Petitioner offered the testimony of Mother. She credibly stated that she never agreed to the termination of OMT services during the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting. She also testified that prior to June 2002, Student had been receiving OMT services pursuant to the last agreed-upon IEP of October 10, 2001. Following the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting, the OMT services were discontinued and Student has not received OMT services since. Mr. Russell also testified that despite the November 2002 stay put order, the District failed to reinstate OMT services for Student. Moreover, he added that he raised the issue of the failure to comply with the stay put order to the District to no avail.
The District failed to offer any persuasive evidence to rebut Petitioner’s evidence regarding the alleged failure to provide OMT services pursuant to the requirements of the stay put provision, as required by the November 2002 stay put order. In fact, Ms. Lindberg admitted that she unilaterally terminated OMT services at the end of May 2002. She also conceded that the District did not reinstitute OMT services following receipt of the November 2002 stay put order.
Given the unrebutted evidence provided by Petitioner, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed procedural error in not providing OMT services pursuant to the requirements of the stay put provision, as required by the stay put order of November 2002. Petitioner provided the undisputed testimony of Mother and Mr. Russell that the District terminated OMT services and did not comply with the stay put order. Further, the District did not refute the evidence that it failed to reinstitute OMT services in spite of Mr. Russell repeated request during meetings. Moreover, Ms. Lindberg admitted to the improper termination of OMT services and her failure to reinstitute those services following the receipt of the stay put order. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural violation in failing to comply with the stay put requirements of federal and State law and with the November 2002 stay put order as it applies to the provision of OMT services.
The Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether this procedural violation caused Petitioner to lose educational opportunity. Petitioner contends that he continued to require OMT services during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY and the failure to comply with the stay put order constituted a loss of educational opportunity for him. Mother testified that since early childhood, Student’s hearing disability had slowed his development of speech. From that time, OMT was provided to train his tongue to properly produce sounds and words to improve his speech. She noted that during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, Student continued to have deficits in the area of oral motor skills and required OMT services. Ms. Hyde also testified that Student required OMT services. She stated that during the time period in question, Student continued to have problems with his oral motor skills. She added that his annual goals provided for the improvement of oral motor skills. (Pet. Ex. LL-31.) In particular, the annual goals focused on the improvement of jaw stability, tongue tip elevation, and dissociation of the articulators. The goals indicated that the above areas were necessary to Student’s development of oral motor skills and improvement of his speech ability.
In response, the District did not rebut the above evidence regarding the loss of educational benefit. The District proffered only limited testimony from Ms. Hopkins. She testified that she had no opinion as to the necessity of OMT services for Student. She only stated that she was aware of past oral motor difficulties from a review of Student’s educational records. Despite the District’s failure to affirmatively challenge Petitioner’s assertions regarding a loss of educational opportunity from a denial of OMT services, the evidence did reveal that Student received some OMT services in the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Hyde testified that the S&L services Student received during the school year included aspects of OMT. She stated that although the S&L services had a different concentration and focus, it nonetheless provided an “adequate amount” of OMT and Student gained skills in the area.
The Hearing Officer determines that Student did not receive the amount of OMT he was entitled to under stay put. However, the District offered evidence that the speech and language services it substituted after May 2002 included some aspects of OMT. The substituted S&L services provided roughly 360 minutes of services per month. (Pet. Ex. M.) In contrast, Student’s stay put placement would have provided only sixty minutes per month of OMT services. (Pet. Ex. L.) Moreover, Ms. Hyde testified that the substituted services provided an adequate amount of OMT services and that Student made progress in this area. The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not lose educational opportunity because adequate OMT services were provided through speech therapy. Because the evidence establishes that Student received an adequate amount of OMT services, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not suffer any loss of educational opportunity regarding OMT service and therefore this error did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
c. Address his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) offer
In addition to the important procedural protections afforded special education students, the IDEA and California law provide for significant substantive rights for students entitled to special education. See 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which also is referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.
An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.
To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Rowley Court concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ., 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). (Footnote 17)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP. (Footnote 18)
In addition to the above general provisions required under the IDEA and Rowley, federal and State law impose further considerations for students eligible for special education under the category of DHH. Federal and State law require that districts consider the communication needs of the child and, in the case of a DHH student, consider the child’s language and communication needs, opportunities for direct communication with peers and professional personnel in the child’s language and communication mode, academic level, and full range of needs, including opportunities for direct instruction in the child’s language and communication mode. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(iv); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(4). State law also imposes an obligation that DHH students have an education in which their unique communication mode is respected, utilized, and developed to an appropriate level of proficiency. Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.5(b). (Footnote 19) Here, Petitioner claims that the District failed to address his unique needs in his May 21, 2004 IEP during the 2003-2004 school year. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that the District offered an inappropriate placement emphasizing sign language and failed to include AVT services.
Unique Needs
During the 2003-2004 school year, the parties generally agree that Student’s hearing disability affected his ability to acquire verbal language and express himself effectively. Student’s listening deficit manifests itself in his inability to detect particular sounds, identify single words, and understand long sentences. (Testimony of Ms. Hopkins.) With the cochlear implant, he has been able to increase his range of listening for sounds. However, Student still has difficulty listening to verbal communications, especially instructions. (Testimony of Ms. Hyde.) The parties also concur that Student has significant delays in his verbal communication ability. Ms. Hopkins testified that Student struggles to pronounce final consonant sounds, to articulate sequences of sounds, and to demonstrate fluency. She added that Student’s voice quality is hyper-nasal or high-pitched. Ms. Schneider testified similarly and added that Student’s lack of general age-appropriate vocabulary is indicative of expressive language difficulties. Because of these problems, Student has difficulty speaking words and sentences.
Oral Communication vs. Sign Language
Although the parties agree about the areas considered problematic with Student, they disagree on what placement and services were appropriate to address these deficits. Petitioner claims that he required an SDC setting emphasizing oral communication. Ms. Hyde testified that Student is just beginning to become confident and skilled utilizing his cochlear implant. She stated that the insertion of a cochlear implant and Student’s emerging ability mandated that oral communication be his “primary mode of communication.” Ms. Schneider also testified that his education goals should strive towards oral communication. They both testified that Student should not be instructed in sign language. Instead, instruction should be limited to oral communication.
The District does not disagree that Student should receive his instruction orally. Ms. Hopkins testified that following her assessments in April 2004, she recommended that his instructions be in an oral format. Moreover, she stated that remediation of his listening and speaking deficits inherently entails using oral communication. District witness Patricia Balthazor also testified that related services offered to Student should emphasize oral communication. (Footnote 20) The District witnesses did not suggest that Student should be educated by using sign language. Given the lack of any dispute regarding the primary mode of communication for Student, the Hearing Officer finds that oral communication is a necessary aspect for addressing Student’s listening and speaking deficits.
SDC Setting
Petitioner also contends that he requires an SDC setting with a small number of children and low teacher-to-student ratio. He maintains that because of his need for individual attention, repetition, and time to develop social language, “mainstreaming” him in a general education classroom would not be consistent with his needs at this time. Petitioner offered the testimony of Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider to support his contention that a regular education classroom is not appropriate for him at this time. Ms. Hyde stated that Student is not ready for a regular education classroom. It was only recently that Student became confident and skilled in using his cochlear implant and following directions. She is concerned about the rate of instruction in a general education classroom being too fast for Student to follow. She also expressed concern about the tendency of general education classrooms to have less repetition than is required for Student. She observed that Student has not developed strategies that can compensate for the rigors of a general education classroom. Ms. Schneider testified similarly and added that Student has not acquired certain “common” knowledge that other children of his age possess. She explained that typical children without hearing disabilities gain vast amounts of information from overhearing conversations from other children and adults. DHH students such as Student do not readily acquire this “informal” or “common” knowledge. Without this information, Student is at a serious disadvantage in a general classroom environment and would likely experience confusion and frustration. She also stated that a second-grade regular education classroom with twenty students has too much activity to allow Student to receive necessary individual attention.
The District offered the testimony of Lynette Wilson, Ivette McNally, and Vera Hammar in support of its position that Student could make educational progress in a regular education setting. (Footnote 21) Ms. Wilson testified that she had no experience with students with cochlear implants but is willing to make any necessary accommodations to permit Student to learn in her classroom. Ms. McNally testified that she believes Student could attend a regular education classroom. She observed that he is a very bright and social boy. Moreover, he requires peer interactions with typically developing children. She concluded that Student could attend a regular education classroom with the addition of related services. Finally, Ms. Hammar testified that Student’s social and academic performance is sufficient for him to enter a second-grade classroom and make progress. In the past, she has worked with DHH students and has observed students similar to Student successfully make the transition to a regular education environment.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimonies of Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider persuasive. Both witnesses have extensive experience and training working with DHH students. Moreover, each has had extensive contact working with Student over the past three years. They each credibly testified as to Student’s current ability and his potential for transitioning to a regular education setting. On the other hand, the District’s witnesses were not persuasive. Both Ms. Hammar and Ms. Wilson have never met or observed Student. Ms. Hammar admitted that she had spent ninety minutes discussing Student with the IEP team after only an hour of reviewing his records. Moreover, Ms. Wilson had never heard of Student until a week before giving her testimony and never reviewed his educational records. Given their lack of first-hand knowledge of Student, the Hearing Officer gives their testimony less weight than those of Petitioner’s witnesses.
The Hearing Officer also finds the testimony of Ms. McNally not persuasive. She testified that Student would be able to attend a regular education classroom, yet at the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting, she and the other District members of the IEP team recommended an SDC with no regular education students as the proposed placement for Student. She failed to explain this inconsistency. The Hearing Officer finds that the drastic change in proposed settings is significant given that the District did not show any change in circumstances meriting the change in proposed placements. Specifically, the Henry School’s cochlear implant SDC is a restrictive environment with limited opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers. The evidence shows that Student would have been placed with only other cochlear implant children. However, two months later, the District concluded that Student could be mainstreamed nearly completely into a regular education setting with only an hour of daily RSP services under the July 26, 2004 placement offer. This inconsistency on the part of the District leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that the District does not understand Student’s current ability to learn in various mainstreaming settings.
Given the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is not ready to be integrated into a regular education setting. Instead, the Hearing Officer is convinced by Petitioner’s evidence that he requires an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio. Ms. Schneider and Ms. Hyde both persuasively testified that once Student’s listening and speaking deficits are sufficiently remediated, he should be in a position to transition fully into a regular education setting. Until then, the Hearing Officer finds that an SDC classroom with a small teacher-to-student ratio is a necessary aspect for addressing Student’s listening and speaking deficits.
AVT Services
Petitioner also claims that he continued to require AVT services to address his listening and speaking needs. As discussed above, both Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider testified that Student required AVT services from at least October 2001 to the present. Ms. Hyde emphasized the important role AVT serves in developing language for a DHH student with a cochlear implant. She stated that AVT services directly target Student’s language problems associated with his hearing loss. AVT aims to remediate weaknesses in auditory skills. Ms. Schneider agreed and added that the parental role in AVT is crucial for Student’s language development and assisting his parents to improve his oral communication skills. Ms. Hyde also testified that AVT is different from general S&L services in its focus and concentration. The added component of parental participation is needed to facilitate Student’s listening development in and out of school. Accordingly, general S&L services alone would not encompass areas problematic to Student.
The District did not rebut Petitioner’s claim that AVT services are required to meet his communication needs. As discussed above, the District offered only the testimony of Ms. Hopkins regarding necessity of the AVT services. Ms. Hopkins testified that she could not render an opinion with respect to the necessity of AVT. Instead, she stated that Student’s speaking and listening problems could be addressed in her S&L sessions in conjunction with the District’s overall placement program. Ms. Hopkins testified that she would have employed intensive articulation therapy with drills to assist Student in making correct sounds, words, and sentences. She also testified that she would have utilized auditory skills strategies to train Student in comprehending multi-step directions and longer communications.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student requires AVT services to address his language deficits. The Hearing Officer places great weight on the testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses in this area. Ms. Hyde testified that AVT is critical to assist Student in utilizing his cochlear implant. Further, Ms. Schneider explained thoroughly the necessity of parental participation in providing a consistent oral learning environment for Student. She described the value of Student’s parents’ role in developing oral language. Moreover, AVT’s reliance on Student’s parents is crucial to his oral language development. Both Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider have worked consistently with Student over the past three years. Each has over twenty-five years of work experience specializing in assisting DHH students.
On the other hand, the District failed to offer any persuasive evidence regarding AVT or the necessity of parental participation to remediate Student’s language deficits. Although Ms. Hopkins testified credibly regarding S&L services that would assist Student, she could not testify as to the need for AVT. Further, she did not render any opinion regarding the role of Student’s parents in providing a consistent environment for addressing Student’s listening deficits. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Hopkins admitted having only three years experience as a speech and language pathologist. She also conceded having limited work experience with DHH and cochlear implant students. Moreover, the District failed to provide any other witnesses or evidence to address this area of need. Instead, Ms. Balthazor testified that although she was not a certified auditory-verbal therapist, she considered AVT a recognized and accepted form of therapy used in working with DHH students. Given the great weight of Petitioner’s evidence regarding the need for AVT services coupled with the District’s failure to effectively rebut this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that AVT services are necessary to address Student’s listening deficits.
As discussed above, the parties agree that Student has deficits in the areas of listening and verbal communication associated with his hearing loss. The Hearing Officer finds that Student requires an educational setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio that utilizes oral communication as the primary mode of communication. The Hearing Officer also finds that Student requires related services in the form of AVT. Now, the Hearing Officer turns to determine whether the District’s May 2004 IEP was designed to meet these needs.
Designed to Meet Student’s Unique Needs
As noted above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student requires an educational setting that uses oral communication as its primary mode of communication and AVT, as a related service. Petitioner contends that the May 2004 IEP offer was not designed to meet his needs because the proposed placement did not use oral communication but is a sign language classroom. Further, Petitioner alleges that the placement did not provide for AVT services.
In contrast, the District asserts that the May 2004 IEP offer was designed to meet Student’s needs because the proposed SDC is an oral communication setting. Further, it contends that the proposed auditory oral therapy would have addressed Student’s language needs.
First, the Hearing Officer will review the District’s offer presented in the May 2004 IEP. (Pet. Ex. NN.) The May 2004 IEP offered Student placement in the cochlear implant SDC at the Henry School within the District. It also offered individual and group S&L therapy for thirty minutes twice a week. The IEP also noted that further services would be provided pending the outcome of assessments scheduled to take place following the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner challenged the appropriateness of the Henry School SDC placement only with regard to the mode of communication and provision of AVT services.
Oral Communication
Petitioner contends that the Henry School cochlear implant SDC is not designed to meet his needs because its primary mode of communication is sign language rather than oral communication. Ms. Schneider testified that she visited the SDC during the summer of 2004. She observed that the children in the SDC possessed minimal verbal communication skills. She recalled that the children had little communication with one another and the adult staff. She also saw adults using sign language with the children. Further, she observed adults removing the exterior mechanisms from the childrens’ cochlear implant during the course of their visits. Ms. Schneider stated that removal would be improper because it would deprive children with the implant from making use of the technology and disable their listening ability. Mother also visited the classroom and observed that the students used sign language with very little verbal communication. (Pet. Ex. VV.) Correspondingly, Petitioner contends that the District’s offer of the SDC was not designed to meet his need for an oral communication setting.
In response, the District asserts that the cochlear implant SDC is, in fact, an oral communication classroom. Ms. Lindberg testified that the SDC’s primary mode of communication is oral. She stated that she has visited the classroom between six to eight times. During those visits, she never observed any staff person disengage a cochlear implant. Moreover, Ms. Schneider, under cross-examination, conceded that her observations took place when a substitute teacher and not the regular instructor conducted the class. She admitted that she did not know how the classroom would operate under normal circumstances.
As noted above, the development and utilization of a DHH student’s primary mode of communication is necessary to provide a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(iv); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(4). It is undisputed that Student’s primary mode of communication is oral communication. As such, any program directed towards meeting his needs must advance Student’s learning and use of oral communication. The Hearing Officer finds that the Henry School cochlear implant SDC is an oral communication setting. Ms. Lindberg, as SELPA program manager, is aware of the special education placements available to the District. She testified credibly that the SDC is an oral environment. She has visited the classroom on at least six occasions. On the other hand, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to the testimonies of Mother and Ms. Schneider given their admissions regarding their visits. Specifically, Mother’s notes from her visit, drafted at that time, indicate that the SDC teacher attempted to give instructions verbally. (Pet. Ex. VV.) If these instructions were not understood, visual cues were attempted with the students. Mother’s notes directly contradict her testimony that sign language was the primary mode of communication. Moreover, Ms. Schneider conceded that she did not visit the SDC under normal conditions and her opinions may have been different had she observed the classroom when its regular instructor was present. Given Ms. Lindberg’s persuasive testimony and the admissions of Petitioner’s witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that the Henry School cochlear implant SDC is designed to meet Student’s need for a setting with oral language as the primary mode of communication.
SDC Setting
As noted above, the Hearing Officer also has found that Student requires an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio to address his listening and speaking needs. Petitioner did not challenge that the District’s offer for an SDC setting was not proper to meet this need. The Hearing Officer received undisputed testimony that the Henry School SDC has only a handful of students. Mother testified to only observing three children in the classroom. Ms. Schneider stated that she saw two children during her visit. Ms. Lindberg testified that the proposed placement has only three students. The witnesses agreed that all of the children at the proposed placement were DHH students with a cochlear implant. The witnesses also testified consistently that the class included at least one teacher.
The undisputed facts indicate that had Student enrolled in the classroom, there would have been no more than four children. Further, the SDC cochlear implant class would have had at least one teacher. At minimum, Student would have attended a classroom with no more than a one-to-four teacher-to-student ratio. There was no dispute by the parties that this number of students and staff would have permitted Student to receive individual attention and repetition in the setting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Henry School’s SDC cochlear implant class is designed to address Student’s need for an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio.
AVT Services
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has determined that Student requires AVT to address his listening needs. Petitioner claims that the District’s May 2004 IEP offer was not designed to meet his needs because it lacked AVT services. He asserts that the IEP simply did not provide for AVT services and thus the offer was not designed to meet his needs.
The District did not dispute that it failed to include AVT services within the May 2004 IEP offer. The District instead presented evidence that individual and group S&L therapy was designated in the offer. However, as established above, general S&L therapy does not provide the equivalent to AVT services.
Given the convincing evidence presented by Petitioner of the lack of AVT services, and his need for AVT, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer a program designed to meet all of his unique needs. Although the District included S&L therapy services, these services were not tailored to address Student’s need for a consistent environment for auditory learning. Specifically, the S&L services do not contain the parental role essential for Student to acquire listening skills. Without this crucial element, Student’s needs cannot be met. Here, the May 2004 IEP offer did not provide for AVT services and, therefore, was not designed to meet Student’s AVT needs.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
With regard to whether the May 2004 proposed IEP is reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit, Petitioner challenged only the mode of communication used in the SDC and the omission of AVT services. The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to include AVT services in the May 2004 IEP offer. In its present form, this offer cannot meet all of Student’s unique needs without the inclusion of AVT services. However, the program is substantially designed to meet Student’s needs for an oral communication SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio. Because the offer lacked necessary AVT services, the program is not reasonably calculated to provide Student some educational benefit insofar as his listening needs are concerned.
Conformed to the IEP
Except with regard to the provision of AVT and OMT services discussed above, Petitioner did not assert any failure to provide services as indicated in Student’s IEP for the time period at issue. This element of FAPE is not a contention because the May 2004 proposed IEP has not yet been implemented. ****
In summary, the District denied Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to comply with the stay put provision to continue providing AVT services. The District did not deny Student a FAPE with respect to its failure to comply with the stay put provision regarding OMT services. As discussed above, Student did not suffer a loss of educational opportunity from the District’s error. Further, the District substantially developed a program designed to meet Student’s needs at the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting. However, the offer failed to include AVT services that were necessary to address Student’s deficits. The Hearing Officer determines that Student was denied a FAPE from May 21, 2004 through the 2004 ESY insofar as AVT services were not provided.
4. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year?
As noted above, the District intended the July 26, 2004 placement offer as a settlement proposal. During the hearing, Ms. Lindberg represented that the settlement proposal was offered as an additional alternative placement for Petitioner to supplement the earlier IEP developed on May 21, 2004. She explained that both the May 21, 2004 IEP offer and July 26, 2004 settlement offer were available to Petitioner for the upcoming school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will consider the July 26, 2004 settlement proposal as a supplemental and alternative option available to the Petitioner.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year on both procedural and substantive grounds. (Footnote 22) As mention previously, Petitioner challenges the appropriateness of the May 21, 2004 IEP offer on the grounds that it fails to include AVT services and provide a placement with oral communication as the primary mode of communication. Petitioner claims that the July 26, 2004 offer is substantively defective because it is not designed to meet his unique needs for a small SDC setting and AVT services. Petitioner further claims that the July 26, 2004 offer violated procedural safeguards because it was developed outside the IEP meeting process. As further procedural violations, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to include parental participation in the process and to develop goals as part of the July 26, 2004 program offer. He also claims the July 26, 2004 placement offer failed to provide a formal written IEP offer consistent with the requirements of Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994).
Substantive Appropriateness a. Addressing his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 IEP offer and the July 26, 2004 placement offer
Unique Needs
The parties agree that Student’s needs did not change significantly between the time of the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting and the District’s additional offer of placement on July 26, 2004. The parties agree that Student’s hearing disability continues to affect his ability to acquire verbal language and express himself effectively. Student’s listening deficit manifests itself in his inability to detect particular sounds, identify single words, and understand long sentences. With the cochlear implant, he has been able to increase his range of listening for sounds. However, Student still has difficulty listening to verbal communications, especially instructions. The parties also concur that Student has significant delays in his verbal communication ability. He struggles to pronounce final consonant sounds, articulate sequences of sounds, and acquire fluency. Student’s lack of general age-appropriate vocabulary is indicative of expressive language difficulties. Because of these problems, Student has difficulty speaking words and sentences.
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer also has determined that Student requires an SDC educational setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio and oral language as the primary mode of communication. Further, the Hearing Officer also has found that Student requires AVT services to address his listening deficits. Now, the Hearing Officer turns to the question of whether the District’s placement offers were designed to meet the above needs.
Designed to Meet Student’s Unique Needs
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that the May 21, 2004 IEP was substantially designed to meet Student’s needs with the exception of omitted necessary AVT services. Now, the Hearing Officer will review the July 26, 2004 settlement offer. (Pet. Ex. RR.) The July 26, 2004 proposal consists of a one-page document offering the following: (1) placement in a second-grade general education classroom at Boyd Elementary School in the District, (2) individual speech therapy three times per week for thirty minutes each session at Boyd, (3) auditory therapy two times per week for forty minutes each session from an NPA at Boyd, (4) RSP one hour per day for math remediation at Boyd, and (5) NPA therapist consultation thirty minutes per week. The proposed placement supplemented the previous May 21, 2004 IEP and was to begin immediately upon agreement by Student’s parents.
SDC Setting
Petitioner asserts that the July 26, 2004 settlement offer of an alternative placement is not designed to meet his unique needs because it is not an SDC setting with a small teacher-to-student ratio. As determined above, the Hearing Officer found that Student requires an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio to address his needs. The Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimonies of Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider regarding Student’s need for individual attention and repetition to develop listening and speaking skills. Both testified persuasively that a regular education setting would not be conducive for Student to make educational progress. The Hearing Officer did not find the District’s witnesses persuasive as to this area of need. As discussed above, the District’s contention that Student is now capable of attending a regular school setting was not supported by persuasive evidence. Instead, the District’s witnesses had scant knowledge of Student’s unique needs and limited experience working with children with cochlear implants, such as Student.
Here, it is undisputed that the District offered a regular school setting for Student in the July 26, 2004 placement offer. Given that the Hearing Officer found that Student requires an SDC setting with a small teacher-to-student ratio, the District’s general education classroom with nearly twenty students cannot be said to be designed to meet Student’s need in this area. The District’s proposal would not provide the necessary individual attention or repetition Student requires to benefit from his education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the general education classroom proposed by the District in its July 26, 2004 settlement offer is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs.
AVT Services
Petitioner also contends that the July 26, 2004 placement offer is not designed to meet his need for AVT services. Petitioner points to the offer’s complete absence of AVT services. Although there are offers of individual speech therapy and auditory therapy, Petitioner claims that these are not designed to meet his needs for AVT services. Petitioner’s witness, Ms. Schneider, testified that for AVT services to be effective, a certified auditory-verbal therapist should conduct them. She is a certified auditory-verbal therapist and explained that a certified therapist has undergone the educational coursework and demonstrated the requisite hours of training to earn accreditation. She added that AVT services could not simply “be performed by anyone,” including speech therapists.
The District offered no evidence to rebut this testimony. As discussed above, Ms. Hopkins testified that she could provide general S&L therapy for Student but had no expertise in the area of AVT. Instead, she testified that individual S&L therapy for thirty minutes three times a week would in conjunction with the other offered services be sufficient to meet Student’s needs. Patricia Balthazor also testified that the proposed auditory therapy was sufficient to meet Student’s needs. She added that consultation services provided by her, coupled with the other proposed services would provide the necessary services to address Student’s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include AVT services in the July 26, 2004 placement offer. Moreover, the proposed related services offered are not equivalent to AVT services. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Schneider’s testimony that Student requires AVT services, a specific therapy distinct from other therapies for students with speech and listening deficits. On the other hand, the District failed to provide any persuasive evidence from either Ms. Hopkins or Ms. Balthazor that the proposed services would encompass the area of need addressed by AVT services. The District did not produce any evidence that the proposed S&L, auditory therapy, or consultation could address the problem areas covered by AVT services. Ms. Balthazor’s testimony reinforces the need for certified AVT services given her admission that certified AVT services are not within the purview of general S&L or auditory therapy. Both Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Hopkins testified generally as to the efficacy of their respective proposed services, but the District could not demonstrate convincingly that these services could serve to substitute for AVT. Thus, the District’s July 26, 2004 offer is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs because it fails to include AVT services.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found that the settlement offer’s proposed placement within a general education classroom with nearly twenty other children does not meet Student’s need for an SDC with a low teacher-to-student ratio. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found above that given the District’s failure to include AVT services, the program is not designed to meet Student’s AVT needs. These failures support a finding that the program is not reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.
Conforms to the IEP
Petitioner did not assert any failure to provide services as indicated in his IEP for the time period at issue. **** In summary, the District did not develop a program to meet Student’s needs for an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio and AVT services in the July 26, 2004 alternative offer. The offer instead proposed to place Student in a general education setting not suited for his deficits. The alternative proposal also failed to include AVT services that are necessary to address Student’s needs. Thus, the July 26, 2004 proposed offer for the 2004-2005 school year is not an offer of FAPE.
Procedural Appropriateness b. Adhering to procedural safeguards in the development of the July 26, 2004 placement offer
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer noted that that it was the intention of the District that the placement proposal outlined in the July 26, 2004 offer was a settlement offer and not an IEP offer. Although the District sought a determination by the Hearing Officer as to its appropriateness substantively to provide for Student’s educational needs, it was not intended to circumvent the IEP process or act as a substitute. Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied Student a FAPE on substantive grounds based on its failure to provide an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio and to include necessary AVT services in the July 26, 2004 placement offer. Given the substantive deficiencies, Petitioner has established that the District’s July 26, 2004 placement offer does not constitute an offer of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer refrains from reaching determinations regarding the remaining alleged procedural violations regarding the failure to develop a placement within the IEP process, to include goals, and to ensure the rights of parental participation.
**** As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that for the 2004-2005 school year, the May 21, 2004 IEP offer substantially provided a FAPE with the exception of the failure to include AVT services. The District also supplemented this IEP offer with an alternative placement in the settlement offer of July 26, 2004. The District failed to include an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio and omitted providing AVT services in its July 26, 2004 proposed offer. These errors demonstrate that the District did not design a program to meet Student’s unique needs in the July 26, 2004 placement offer. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District thus far has not offered Student an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 regular school year insofar as the May 21, 2004 IEP offer failed to include AVT services.
5. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such relief as it determines appropriate. Lester H. v. K. Gihool and the Chester Upland Sch. Dist., 916 F.2d 865 (3d Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Ind. Sch. Dist. Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D. Mass. 1996). “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 34 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994).
Here, Petitioner seeks compensatory education for denials of FAPE in the form of AVT, OMT, and prospective placement at Oralingua. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied Student a FAPE in failing to comply with its obligation under the stay put provision. Specifically, the District improperly terminated AVT and OMT services after May 2002. Further, the Hearing Officer found that the May 21, 2004 proposed IEP did not offer Student a FAPE because it lacked AVT services. Finally, the Hearing Officer determined that the District’s July 26, 2004 placement offer failed to constitute a FAPE because it was not designed to meet Student’s needs for an SDC setting with a low teacher-to-student ratio and AVT services.
a. AVT
As demonstrated above, the District failed to comply with its obligations under the stay put provisions of federal and State law. Specifically, the District improperly terminated AVT services following the disagreement over the May 21, 2002 IEP offer. In November 2002, the Hearing Office ordered the District to reinstate these services under stay put. Despite the stay put order and reminders by the Petitioner in subsequent meetings, the District continued to disregard this important procedural safeguard. Moreover, the District has yet to provide these services to date. Although the District attempted to substitute other services in place of the required AVT services, it does not excuse its obligation to comply with federal and State law.
The Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s failure to comply with the stay put provisions was a denial of FAPE. Petitioner asserts that this has been an ongoing denial since May 2002. AVT services were only recently procured by Petitioner’s parents and paid for out-of-pocket by them. However, Student’s parent’s procurement of these services does not abridge the District’s ongoing duty to provide AVT services pursuant to stay put. Compensatory education does not necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Student W., 34 F.3d at 1497. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the loss of these services for approximately two years must be addressed. In determining a remedy, the Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of certified auditory-verbal therapist Kay Schneider. Ms. Schneider testified that Student continues to require thirty minutes twice a week of AVT services. Because he continues to have needs in this area, Ms. Schneider also testified that Student lost two years of AVT.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Schneider’s testimony and recommendation. Because Student will be receiving AVT services as part of his education program, the Hearing Officer finds that an additional fifty hours will serve as sufficient compensatory education when coupled with his regular AVT services. Given the totality of the circumstances in this case, taking into consideration the length of the deprivation and resulting loss of educational opportunity, the Hearing Officer finds that the foregoing services are reasonably calculated to enable Student to progress to the level of functioning he would have attained had the appropriate services been provided in a timely manner.
The District shall begin to provide the compensatory education services as soon as possible and shall provide all of the services by no later than one year from the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree, in writing, otherwise. The District shall implement the compensatory education services in a manner that ensures that they have minimal impact on Student’s school day and ability to participate in his educational program. For instance, the IEP team may consider providing the additional AVT services after the conclusion of the school day.
b. OMT
Because the evidence established that Student received an adequate amount of services to address his OMT needs, the Hearing Officer found above that there was no denial of FAPE in this regard. Therefore, a compensatory education award is not warranted and Petitioner’s request for OMT services is denied.
c. Continued placement at Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to prospective placement at Oralingua for the 2004-2005 school year as compensatory education. He maintains that the programs and related services offered by Oralingua are meeting his needs and providing him with educational benefit. Petitioner also contends that Oralingua is the least restrictive environment in which his needs can be effectively met. The District contends that Oralingua is not an appropriate placement for Student because he has not made adequate progress in the three years he has attended Oralingua, and it is not the least restrictive environment for him.
Education Code section 56505.2(b) provides that the Hearing Officer shall consider sections 56365, 56365.5, 56366, and 56366.1 during a due process hearing concerning an issue of placement of an individual with exceptional needs in an NPS such as Oralingua. (Footnote 23) Section 56365, subdivision (a), generally provides that services required by the student shall be provided by an NPS when no appropriate public education program is available. As determined above, the Hearing Officer found that the May 21, 2004 IEP failed to offer Student a FAPE because it lacked AVT services. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District could offer Student a FAPE by amending the May 21, 2004 IEP offer to include the missing AVT services as described by Ms. Schneider. Specifically, the District’s proposed program at the Henry School cochlear implant SDC can be made appropriate for Student by the addition of AVT services in the amount of thirty minutes twice per week. As discussed above, Ms. Schneider credibly testified that this amount would be adequate to allow Student to make educational progress. This augmented offer would allow the District to correct its previous error and bring its offer in conformity with section 56365, subdivision (a).
Further, for the Hearing Officer to award prospective placement as a compensatory education remedy, there must be some nexus between the services sought by the parent and the service denied by the District. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985). As established above, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to comport with the stay put provision and order in terminating AVT services after May 2002. However, during all times relevant to this case and to the present, the District has continued to fund Student’s placement at Oralingua. There is no dispute that this placement provided Student with some educational benefit. Given the evidence presented, Student only lost educational opportunities relating to the omission of AVT services. Petitioner has not offered any other evidence of lost educational opportunity justifying placement at Oralingua. Because no nexus exists between loss of AVT services and the request for placement at Oralingua, the award of placement at Oralingua as compensatory education would not be proper and is, therefore, denied.
6. If the District denied Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for AVT services?
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs of obtaining AVT services beginning in June 2004. When a school district denies a child a FAPE, the child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the placement or services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents’ placement still must meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement be designed to address the child’s needs and be reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993). Reimbursement may be awarded, however, even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Id. at 14.
To qualify for reimbursement, the parents’ services must at the very least have been designed to address Student’s needs and have been reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Petitioner has the burden of proving that the parents’ services were appropriate and that reimbursement is warranted.
As discussed above, the District denied Student a FAPE from May 2002 to the end of the 2004 ESY by failing to comply with the stay put provisions and terminating AVT services. Mother testified that she recently procured AVT services personally and is paying for the services out-of-pocket. She stated that in June 2004 she contracted with Oralingua to provide AVT services. Ms. Schneider testified that she is providing Student with thirty minutes, twice a week of certified AVT services. Petitioner presented uncontested evidence that Student is making educational progress with Oralingua’s AVT services. Ms. Hyde and Ms. Schneider both testified that he is making substantial progress with this service.
The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with Student’s certified AVT services until the District begins paying for AVT services as ordered in this Decision. The parties do not dispute that the certified AVT services currently being provided to Student are designed to meet his need and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in this area. In light of Student’s progress in his area of need, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the AVT services procured by Student’s parents from June 2004 until the District begins paying for AVT services as ordered in this Decision.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the costs of AVT services from Oralingua from June 2004 until the District begins paying for AVT services, which can be no later than October 1, 2004.
2. The District shall immediately, but no later than October 1, 2004, provide fifty hours of AVT services as compensatory education within a year of the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise. This amount is in addition to the amount provided for in Paragraph 3 below.
3. The District shall amend its May 21, 2004 IEP to include AVT services by a certified auditory-verbal therapist, for thirty minutes, twice a week.
4. If Student’s parents want him to be provided a publicly-funded educational program through Rialto Unified School District, they must make him available for the special education services outlined in the District’s May 21, 2004 IEP with the inclusion of AVT services for thirty minutes, twice a week.
5. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statue.
1. Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) following May 15, 2002 IEP meeting through the end of the 2002 extended school year (ESY) by failing to provide auditory-verbal therapy (AVT)? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide AVT? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to:
a. Provide AVT, b. Provide oral motor therapy (OMT), and c. Address his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) offer. Petitioner prevailed on Issue 3(a). The District prevailed on Issue 3(b). The District substantially prevailed on Issue 3(c) except to the extent that the District failed to offer AVT services.
4. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year by:
a. Addressing his unique needs in the May 21, 2004 IEP offer and the July 26, 2004 placement offer, and b. Adhering to procedural safeguards in the development of the July 26, 2004 placement offer? Petitioner prevailed on Issue 4(a). Issue 4(b) was not decided.
5. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of:
a. AVT, b. OMT, and c. Continued placement at Oralingua School for the Hearing Impaired? Petitioner prevailed on Issue 5(a). The District prevailed on Issues 5(b) and 5(c).
6. If the District denied Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for AVT services? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: October 18, 2004 My T. Huynh, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
Ms. Schneider testified telephonically without objection from the District.
2 Following Mother’s initial testimony, she admitted that she had given knowingly false testimony regarding her children. Initially, she testified that Student was her only child and that her husband, Father, has another child living in Pomona. However, she later testified that this was false. She recanted this portion of her testimony and stated that the child living in Pomona is actually hers from a prior relationship. She stated that she falsely testified about this child because of fear surrounding her former boyfriend, the father of this child, and his history of violence against her and this child. She added that she did not testify truthfully because she did not want any information regarding the location of herself or her other child made available for the former boyfriend to use in locating them. She apologized to the Hearing Officer and stated that all other portions of her testimony had been truthful.
3 In order to avoid confusion, the Hearing Officer hereafter refers to Student’s mother as “Mother” and Student’s grandmother as “Grandmother.”
4 The District indicated on the second of day of hearing that it wanted a determination of the appropriateness of the July 26, 2004 settlement offer. Petitioner agreed and added additional issues regarding the procedural appropriateness of the offer. The District indicated that the July 26, 2004 offer was intended to supplement the existing offer proposed by the District during the May 21, 2004 IEP meeting.
5 Otolaryngologists are physicians trained in the medical and surgical management and treatment of patients with diseases and disorders of the ear, nose, throat (ENT), and related structures of the head and neck. They are commonly referred to as ENT physicians.
6 A cochlear implant is a small, complex electronic device that can help to provide a sense of sound to a person who is profoundly deaf or severely hard of hearing. The implant is surgically placed under the skin behind the ear. An implant does not restore or create normal hearing. Instead, under the appropriate conditions, it can give a deaf person a useful auditory understanding of the environment and help him or her to understand speech.
7 There is a factual disagreement between the parties as to who made the recommendation for the termination of AVT and OMT services. The Hearing Officer discusses this disagreement and its impact on the issues below.
8 The Hearing Office assigned a case number of SN02-01221 following the receipt of Petitioner’s due process request. The matter remained off calendar for nearly two years as the parties attempted to resolve the action via mediation and settlement negotiations. In summer 2004, the Hearing Office issued an Order to Show Cause why that matter should not be dismissed for failure to prosecute the action. (Pet. Ex. MM.) Petitioner, by and through his advocate, was unable to meet the deadline to bring his action in compliance with the Order to Show Cause and voluntarily dismissed case number SN02-01221. (Testimony of Christopher Russell.) Shortly thereafter, Petitioner filed the current action alleging substantially the same claims.
9 Under federal and State special education law, unless the public educational agency and the parent agree otherwise, a special education student must remain in his or her present educational placement pending completion of due process hearing procedures. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly known as stay put and automatically goes into effect as soon as a due process hearing is requested.
10 Typically, settlement offers are not admitted as evidence or considered by the Hearing Officer in adjudicating due process actions. However, the parties stipulated that the July 26, 2004 settlement offer letter be admitted into evidence. Further, the District requested that the Hearing Officer adjudicate the appropriateness of the proposed placement delineated in the settlement offer letter; Petitioner did not oppose this request.
11Although the undisputed facts are that the District terminated both OMT and AVT services in May 2002, Petitioner sought to raise the issue of OMT only for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY.
12 The Hearing Officer notes that the request for due process and stay put did not mention the matter of AVT and OMT services.
13 Over the past twenty-five years, Ms. Hyde has served as a classroom teacher, speech therapist, and staff supervisor at Oralingua. She received her bachelor’s degree from the University of Redlands. She also holds teaching credentials for general education and speech communication.
14 Ms. Schneider holds a master’s degree in special education. She has served as a teacher, administrator, and certified auditory-verbal therapist. She has worked at Oralingua with its DHH students since 1969.
15 Ms. Hopkins holds a master’s degree in communicative disorders. She has worked as a speech pathologist for the past three years.
16 The parties did not dispute that Student was eligible for special education and related services for the extended school years during the summers of 2002-2004. His difficulties required consistent programming that reached beyond the regular school year and encompasses the ESY. The parties agree that his placements included programs and services previously during to the ESY.
17 Furthermore, the amended IDEA includes additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE that are not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).
18 Federal and State law also require that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. Petitioner does not contend that his educational placements have not been in the least restrictive environment as required by law.
19 Language or communication mode means the method of communication used by DHH students that may include the use of sign language or spoken language, with or without visual cues. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026.2.
20 Ms. Balthazor holds a master’s degree in audiology and speech sciences. She has worked with DHH students in California since 1978. Further, she has helped educate children with cochlear implants since 1992.
21 Ms. Wilson has been an elementary school teacher for thirty years. She holds a master’s degree in general education with a specialization in reading. She holds a general education LIFE credential. Ms. Hammar holds a master’s degree in special education. She has worked as an RSP teacher for the past six years.
22 Because this Decision is issued at the outset of the 2004-2005 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that a determination of whether FAPE has been offered for the 2005 ESY would be premature and unnecessary. Moreover, Petitioner did not raise any issues as to the 2005 ESY. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer refrains from evaluating the appropriateness of the District’s offer beyond its application for the 2004-2005 regular school year.
23 The Hearing Officer notes that section 56365.5 has been repealed.
