California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 6, 2001

Student v. Beverly Hills Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1828-00 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour

Beverly Hills Unified must treat eighth grader as eligible and fund summer reading and compensatory services; vision therapy denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 14-year-old eighth grader filed for due process against Beverly Hills Unified School District. In elementary school he received speech-language and resource services. After fifth grade his parents withdrew him from special education. They believed resource help had not taught him to read, and the district had refused their request for a one-on-one reading tutor. In sixth and seventh grade he failed most classes and read at a second-grade level. In 2000 the parents asked to return him to special education. The district reassessed him, found his intelligence borderline, and ruled him ineligible.

Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour found him eligible under specific learning disability and speech or language impairment. She relied on a private psychologist's nonverbal IQ test, other test scores, and testimony from teachers and parents showing average ability. She also held that the district failed to identify and place him in sixth and seventh grade. The district's inadequate program had caused the withdrawal, and teachers had reported his failing grades. The Hearing Officer ordered an immediate summer reading program of five hours a day, with at least one hour one-on-one, plus a private reading assessment. She also ordered an IEP meeting to plan combined FAPE and compensatory services, and more summer reading programs until he reads at grade level. The district must repay $960 for the psychologist's assessment. Vision therapy and payment for the optometrist's evaluation were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a parent's withdrawal from special education that resulted from an inadequate district program: the district still had to identify and serve the student. It also shows a Hearing Officer rejecting a verbal IQ test for a student with known language deficits and crediting a nonverbal measure.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services, and thus entitled to an IEP and appropriate placement, under the category of specific learning disability or speech and language impaired from April 2000 through the present?

    Student showed average ability and a severe ability-achievement discrepancy caused by a processing disorder that regular education could not fix, and he scored at or below the seventh percentile on several language tests, so he was eligible under both specific learning disability and speech or language impairment.

  2. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide appropriate identification and placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?

    The parents' withdrawal from special education resulted from the District's failure to provide FAPE, and the District knew he was failing, so its failure to identify and place him in sixth and seventh grades denied him educational opportunity.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?

    Compensatory education was owed for all three years. The Hearing Officer rejected the requested three-year nonpublic school placement and five weekly hours of tutoring, ordered summer reading programs, and directed the IEP team to design an intensive plan of combined FAPE and compensatory services.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. If STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services, must the District provide him with vision therapy as a related service?

    Apart from the private optometrist's testing, the evidence did not show that visual deficits caused his reading problems. Vision therapy was not required for him to benefit from his education.

  5. Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private assessments performed by Dr. Robert Rome and Dr. Gary Etting?

    The District's WISC-III cognitive testing was not appropriate for a student with known language deficits, so Dr. Rome's $960 assessment must be reimbursed. The District's visual processing assessment was appropriate, so Dr. Etting's evaluation was not reimbursed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must provide a summer reading program of five hours per day, lasting until the fall semester begins. At least one of the five hours must be one-on-one reading assistance.
  • Order to assess. Before the summer reading program begins, the District must provide a private reading assessment to determine how best to provide the reading assistance.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Before the 2001-2002 school year begins, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop and implement a comprehensive plan of combined FAPE and compensatory education services. The plan must fully address eight listed considerations, including a small-class setting, intensive one-on-one reading and writing help, speech-language services, possible further assessment, a possible outside expert, avoiding unnecessary segregation, career interests, and his unknown rate of progress.
  • Compensatory education. Future IEPs must build in an appropriate compensatory education program unless the student is reading at grade level.
  • Compensatory education. The District must provide a summer reading program comparable to the first one in the summers after the freshman, sophomore, and junior years, unless he reaches grade-level reading first. Each program runs the entire summer but must accommodate a one-month family vacation. A comparable program follows the senior year if the IEP team finds he is not reading at grade level.
  • Reimbursement. The District must reimburse the parents $960 for Dr. Robert Rome's private assessment.

Total: $960 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts; Steldt v. School Board of the Riverdale School District; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320

People named in the decision

  • Cindy Brining, educational consultant for Student
  • Judy Van Brocklin, District coordinator of special education, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Dr. Robert Rome, clinical psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private practice; consulting psychologist, North Los Angeles Regional Center
  • Dr. Gary Etting, developmental optometrist; private vision assessor and witness for Student
  • Blenda Jeffry, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Jane Geletko, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Rita Bernard-Harris, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Janet Lambert, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Lori Schwartz, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Robert Bailey, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Kevin Kassebaum, regular education teacher, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Dr. Carl Goodman, director of nonpublic school; witness for Student, Summit View School
  • Linda DiNoble, resource specialist; assessor, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Kristin Miller, speech and language specialist; assessor, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Dee Dee Graves, program specialist, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Kristin Alford (a.k.a. Kristin Gildersleeve), school psychologist; assessor, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Karen Garland, program specialist, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Dr. Nancy Wolf, director of pupil services, Beverly Hills Unified School District
  • Sylvan Learning Center, private tutoring provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Beverly Hills, California, on February 27 and 28, March 29 and 30, April 26 and 27, and May 14, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham and educational consultant Cindy Brining. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER.(Footnote 1) Respondent Beverly Hills Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Trevin E. Sims of the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was Judy Van Brocklin, District coordinator of special education.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, Petitioner’s father; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Dr. Robert Rome, clinical psychologist; Dr. Gary Etting, doctor of optometry; STUDENT, Petitioner; Blenda Jeffry, regular education teacher; Jane Geletko, regular education teacher; Rita Bernard-Harris, regular education teacher; Janet Lambert, regular education teacher; Lori Schwartz, regular education teacher; Robert Bailey, regular education teacher; and Dr. Carl Goodman, director of Summit View School.

Both parties called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Linda Di Noble, District resource specialist; Kristin Miller, District speech and language specialist; Dee Dee Graves, District program specialist; Kevin Kassebaum, regular education teacher; Kristin Alford (a.k.a. Kristin Gildersleeve), District school psychologist; Karen Garland, District program specialist; and Dr. Nancy Wolf, District director of pupil services. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on May 31, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 2)

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services, and thus entitled to an individualized education program and appropriate placement, under the category of specific learning disability or speech and language impaired from April 2000 through the present?

2. Did the District fail to provide appropriate identification and placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000- 2001 school years?

4. If STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services, must the District provide him with vision therapy as a related service?

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private assessments performed by Dr. Robert Rome and Dr. Gary Etting?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District since prior to kindergarten. He attended the District’s Hawthorne Elementary School from kindergarten through the eighth grade. STUDENT is scheduled to begin ninth grade at Beverly Hills High School in the fall of 2001. He is not currently eligible for special education and related services.

STUDENT began to have learning difficulties in kindergarten. In the first and second grades, he received assistance from the District in a special reading program. In the third grade, the District assessed him and found him eligible for special education as speech impaired. The speech and language assessment noted that STUDENT had a delay in verbal language in the areas of articulation, expression, and language comprehension. At the end of third grade, the District placed STUDENT in a regular education classroom, and he began to receive speech and language therapy. In the fourth grade, he began to receive resource specialist services in addition to speech and language therapy. The District increased resource specialist services in the fifth grade. STUDENT’s fourth and fifth grade report cards and teacher progress reports noted that STUDENT continued to have a great deal of difficulty with reading and writing.

In the fifth grade, STUDENT’s parents became concerned about his lack of progress in reading. MOTHER visited his resource class and observed that he was involved in painting pictures rather than working on academic subjects. The parents believed that STUDENT was not learning the core curriculum that children learn in the fifth grade.

At an individualized educational program (IEP) meeting on May 11, 1998, at the end of fifth grade, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District provide him with additional services. They believed that while STUDENT had received resource specialist support for almost two years, he had made very minimal progress in reading. At the meeting, the District offered either resource specialist services at another school site or a special day class (SDC).

STUDENT’s parents testified that they visited the SDC classroom that the District offered, and believed that it was not appropriate for STUDENT. They saw students running around the classroom, and thought that the teacher was unable to control them. In addition, most of the children had physical disabilities, which STUDENT does not have. They also were not interested in a different resource specialist program because they believed that resource services had not helped STUDENT. Therefore, the parents refused the District’s offer. Instead, they requested that the District provide STUDENT with a one-on-one reading tutor.(Footnote 3) The District declined to do so.

Following the IEP meeting in May 1998, STUDENT’s parents decided to withdraw him from special education services. They testified that they did so because of their belief that resource specialist services were not helping STUDENT, and also because they felt that a stigma was attached to special education students. Their opinion was that it would be better to have STUDENT in regular education classes full time because he would at least be exposed to the core academic curriculum.

On June 12, 1998, the parents met with Dr. Nancy Wolf, the District’s director of pupil services, to inform her of their decision. Dr. Wolf prepared a written document stating that the parents desired to remove STUDENT from special education and also did not want him to receive any Section 504 modifications. Both parents signed this document. As a result, STUDENT was immediately removed from resource services. However, he continued to receive speech and language services until the end of fifth grade, when his parents also terminated those services.

In the sixth grade, during the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT received mostly failing grades in school. His mother testified that she did his homework, spending two to four hours with him each evening, because he was unable to do it on his own. Sixth grade teachers advised MOTHER that STUDENT performed poorly on exams because he had poor study skills and did not know how to read. They were aware that STUDENT’s parents did not want STUDENT in special education because they had been unhappy with the resource support services he had previously received. However, the sixth grade teachers met a couple of times during the year because they were concerned about STUDENT’s lack of progress in their classes.

In the seventh grade, during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT received all D’s and F’s in his academic classes. His seventh grade teachers testified that STUDENT had great difficulty with reading comprehension. These teachers held several meetings among themselves, and convened a child study team meeting with District personnel where they requested assistance from the District for STUDENT. The teachers also encouraged the PARENTS to reconsider placement in special education for STUDENT. In February 2000, the parents decided to visit the District’s SDC class again. This time, they felt that the middle school SDC classroom, a program for students with speech and language difficulties, would be appropriate for STUDENT. It appeared to them that the students were learning to read and write, and they also liked the SDC teacher.

After their visit to the SDC classroom, STUDENT’s parents informed the District that they had decided to accept its offer of placement in an SDC. However, the District advised them that since STUDENT’s prior IEP and testing had expired, it would need to reassess his eligibility for special education. School psychologist Kristin Alford, resource specialist Linda DiNoble, and speech and language specialist Kristin Miller assessed STUDENT in April 2000.(Footnote 4) Their test results found STUDENT to have borderline intelligence. Further, Ms. Alford determined that STUDENT’s achievement was not significantly discrepant from his borderline cognitive potential. She also found his expressive and receptive speech and language abilities to be commensurate with his borderline cognitive potential. At an IEP meeting held on May 2, 2000, the IEP team found STUDENT ineligible for special education services. The team recommended that STUDENT remain in regular education with modifications pursuant to Section 504.

Although MOTHER signed a Pupil Placement Summary at the IEP meeting on May 2, 2000, both of STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the District’s assessments that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Therefore, MOTHER took STUDENT to Dr. Robert Rome in October and November 2000 for a psychological-educational evaluation. Dr. Rome testified that he believed that a nonverbal test of intelligence was most appropriate for STUDENT because STUDENT had a lifelong history of communication deficits. Dr. Rome thus administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence - Third Edition (TONI) to STUDENT, in addition to other test instruments.(Footnote 5) Dr. Rome found STUDENT to have average intelligence and also found significant discrepancies between STUDENT’s average intelligence and his deficient skills in word recognition, reading passage comprehension, and dictation skills. In addition, Dr. Rome found significant discrepancies between STUDENT’s average intelligence and his scores in receptive and expressive language. Dr. Rome believed that STUDENT should be found eligible for special education based upon these significant discrepancies between his cognitive ability and achievement levels.

Additionally, Dr. Rome noted that STUDENT had vision and visual-perceptual deficits, and referred STUDENT to Dr. Gary Etting, a developmental optometrist. Dr. Etting performed a developmental optometric vision analysis and a visual processing evaluation in November 2000 and January 2001. According to Dr. Etting, STUDENT has difficulty in eye teaming skills, difficulties with eye movements, and problems with eye focusing skills. According to Dr. Etting, these difficulties interfere with STUDENT’s ability to process visual information quickly, accurately, and comfortably, which could impact STUDENT’s ability to read. Dr. Etting recommended that STUDENT receive vision therapy in order to remediate these deficits.

In the eighth grade, during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was placed in regular education with a Section 504 plan that provided for, among other things, modified grades and services from the District’s Reading Plus program. STUDENT continued to receive failing grades, and his eighth grade teachers testified that he continued to have severe reading difficulties.(Footnote 6)

On October 12, 2000, STUDENT’s parents requested a due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office. They dispute the District’s finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education, and contend that the District should have continued to provide placement and special education services for him during the sixth, seventh, and eighth grades. In addition, STUDENT’s parents request compensatory education for those three years, vision therapy for STUDENT, and reimbursement for the independent assessments by Dr. Rome and Dr. Etting.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services, and thus entitled to an individualized education program and appropriate placement, under the category of specific learning disability or speech and language impaired from April 2000 through the present?

Under California special education law, an individual with exceptional needs is one who meets the definition of a child with a disability, as set forth in the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i), and, as a result of the impairment, requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56026(a) and (b). The disabilities identified in the IDEA are mental retardation, hearing, speech or language, visual, emotional disturbance, orthopedic, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, and specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); see Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, §§ 3030(a)-(j).

Specific Learning Disability

Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability based upon a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement levels. He further contends that his severe discrepancy is due to a disorder in a basic psychological process involved in his understanding or use of written language, and that his discrepancy cannot be ameliorated in the regular education program. The District contends that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability because it alleges that he does not have a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement.

A specific learning disability is defined as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. §1401(26)(A); Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(1).

For a child to qualify for special education as having a specific learning disability, he or she must meet three requirements. First, there must be a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(a). Second, the severe discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using spoken or written language, and must not be primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(b)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b). A final requirement is that the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services”offered within the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).

1. Severe Discrepancy Based Upon Standardized Test Scores (Footnote 7)

When standardized tests are considered valid for a student, the method for demonstrating whether a severe discrepancy exists involves the following steps: 1. Compute into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement score and the ability test score to be compared. 2. Compute the difference between these common standard scores. 3. Compare this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).

A computed difference, which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, the adjustment not to exceed 4 common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data that may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate. Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).

The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by 15), adjusted by one standard error of measurement. That is, the computed difference must be at least 22.5 points, adjusted by the standard of error of measurement not to exceed 4 common standard points, or between 18.5 and 26.5 points.(Footnote 8) Such a computed difference indicates a severe discrepancy when the “discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.” Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).

Under this formula, the Hearing Officer must first evaluate the evidence regarding STUDENT’s cognitive ability. STUDENT’s IQ was assessed when he was in the third grade, the seventh grade, and the eighth grade. In the third grade, STUDENT took the Slosson Intelligence Test (Slosson) and achieved an IQ score of 98. The District also administered a Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) to STUDENT in March 1996, at the end of third grade, and he obtained a score of 93 on the verbal IQ portion of the test.

When STUDENT was in the seventh grade, school psychologist Kristin Alford administered the WISC-III to STUDENT, in which he obtained a verbal IQ score of 81. In addition, clinical psychologist Dr. Robert Rome administered the TONI to STUDENT when he was in the eighth grade. Dr. Rome found STUDENT to have an IQ score of 100. STUDENT also achieved a score of 91 on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary test (Peabody) administered by speech and language pathologist Kristin Miller in April 2000.(Footnote 9) All of these scores, with the exception of the score of 81 in the test administered by the District school psychologist, place STUDENT within the average range of intelligence. A score of 81 places STUDENT within the very low average range of intelligence.

In describing her finding that STUDENT has an IQ of 81, Ms. Alford disputed the validity of the other instruments administered to STUDENT. For example, she testified that she does not use the Slosson as an indicator of intelligence because it has no credibility and is used only as a screening device.(Footnote 10) She also testified that the TONI administered by Dr. Rome is an outdated and brief instrument that measures only splinter skills rather than critical thinking. Ms. Alford also testified that a child’s IQ can decline as the child advances in age because of higher critical thinking skills that children develop as they become older. Therefore, if a child does not develop these skills, his or her scores will regress when compared with other children of the same age. This may explain, according to Ms. Alford, STUDENT’s score of 93 on the WISC-III in the third grade and a score of 81 on the same test in the seventh grade.

In addition to disputing other test results, Ms. Alford testified that she considered other information in reaching her conclusions. She testified that she talked with STUDENT’s teachers and learned that he did not excel in any academic area. Had he excelled in some areas but not others, this may have indicated to her that STUDENT possessed a higher cognitive ability. In addition, when she watched him during her testing, she found that he appeared to be unable to conceive of tasks that required a higher level of reasoning. She also testified that the subtests on the WISC-III were generally in the same range as the IQ score of 81. According to Ms. Alford, all of these items corroborated her conclusion that the latest WISC-III test had correctly calculated STUDENT’s IQ score at 81.

In contrast to Ms. Alford’s testimony that STUDENT has a borderline IQ, Dr. Rome testified that he believes STUDENT to have average intelligence. Dr. Rome testified that, because of STUDENT’s history of communication deficits, he believed that an assessment with a major emphasis on language skills, such as the WISC-III, was not an appropriate assessment tool for STUDENT.(Footnote 11) He also testified that he noted STUDENT to have a wide range of scores in prior testing, from deficient to average, in areas requiring visual-motor coordination. He therefore decided to test STUDENT’s intelligence with the TONI, a nonverbal and nonmotor instrument. Dr. Rome testified that he recognized that the TONI does not measure a full intelligence scale but stated that it is a useful tool when other measures may be invalid.

It is also necessary for the Hearing Officer to review other relevant information that is available regarding STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. STUDENT’s parents testified that teachers have told them that STUDENT is intelligent, but that his only problem is that he cannot read. They further testified that he has no problem understanding when someone speaks with him orally, when he watches movies, and when he plays games on a computer. In addition, STUDENT testified that his mother helps him with his homework when reading and writing are involved. She reads to him, he tells her the answer, and she writes down his answer.

STUDENT’s sixth, seventh, and eighth grade teachers testified that, in spite of failing grades because of reading and writing difficulties, STUDENT appeared to understand what was discussed in class. For example, his sixth grade English teacher testified that STUDENT learned from listening in class, and was able to memorize lines for a play. His eighth grade history teacher testified that STUDENT’s participation in classroom discussions is comparable to that of the other children in her class. His eighth grade history teacher also testified that STUDENT participates in class and understands verbal prompts; she described him as an “intelligent young man.”

In reviewing the cognitive testing done by the District in April 2000, the Hearing Officer also relies upon the fact that STUDENT scored within the average range in areas unrelated to reading or writing skills. For example, on the Woodcock Johnson cognitive ability test, he achieved a score of 100 in auditory processing, 90 in visual processing, and 96 in fluid reasoning. In addition, on both the Wide Range Achievement Test - Third Edition and the Woodcock Johnson achievement tests, he obtained a score of 89 in math. Ms. Alford testified that these scores involve rote memorization rather than critical thinking skills and are not sole indicators of intelligence. The Hearing Officer does not rely upon these as sole indicators of STUDENT’s intelligence, however, but considers them additional indicators when viewing the totality of the evidence.

In addition, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Rome regarding his test results very credible. Dr. Rome has been a clinical psychologist since 1984. In addition to his current private practice, he has been a consulting psychologist for the North Los Angeles Regional Center (NLARC) for the past three years where he performs an average of five psychological assessments of individuals with developmental disabilities per week. Dr. Rome testified that one-half of the assessments he performs relate to educational issues, including the issue of eligibility for special education. At NLARC, he also supervises seven psychologists who perform assessments and regularly attends IEP meetings. In addition, earlier in his career, Dr. Rome worked as a school psychologist for six years and a consulting psychologist for twelve years for various private schools.

On the basis of STUDENT’s standardized test scores of intelligence, the Hearing Officer finds that he has an average IQ. Every test but one since the third grade has placed him in the average range. In reaching the conclusion that STUDENT has average intelligence, the Hearing Officer additionally gives great weight to the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, all of whom described him as being able to understand the class material as long as the material did not require any reading comprehension or written expression. In addition, the detailed, thoughtful testimony of STUDENT’s parents that he is able to understand oral conversations, movies, and computer games at home was very persuasive.

The Hearing Officer must next evaluate the evidence with respect to STUDENT’s achievement level. Resource specialist Linda DiNoble administered the Woodcock Johnson Revised Psycho-Educational Battery - Achievement and Cognitive tests (Woodcock Johnson) to STUDENT in the seventh grade. His scores on those tests included 68 in reading comprehension, 67 in letter-word identification, 66 in passage comprehension, 66 in broad written language, 62 in broad reading, 62 in basic writing skills, and 53 in dictation. In addition, Dr. Rome administered the Test of Adolescent and Adult Language - Third Edition (TOAL), in which STUDENT scored 61 in reading, 57 in general language, 55 in vocabulary, 50 in writing, and 50 in written language. According to Dr. Rome, STUDENT has the ability to form concepts, but is unable to put them on paper.

In addition to test scores, other evidence in the record reveals information regarding STUDENT’s achievement levels in reading and writing. The testing done by Ms. DiNoble in April 2000 found STUDENT, who was in the seventh grade at the time of the testing, to have reading and writing skills at a second grade level. Further, STUDENT was failing almost all of his academic subjects because of his inability to read and write. Every sixth, seventh, and eighth grade teacher who testified at the hearing reported that STUDENT has severe deficits in reading comprehension and written expression. STUDENT’s parents also testified that STUDENT was unable to do his homework because of his inability to comprehend his reading assignments and write his responses.

The combination of STUDENT’s achievement test scores and information provided by his teachers and parents thus indicates that STUDENT has very low achievement in the areas of reading comprehension and written expression. In comparing STUDENT’s 90-range IQ, as indicated previously, with his 60 or lower range of achievement, the results indicate that he meets the severe discrepancy requirement of at least a 22.5 point difference between intelligence and achievement.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT meets the first criterion for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. His standardized test scores demonstrate that he has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement.

2. Disorder in Basic Psychological Processes

As indicated previously, the second requirement for eligibility based upon a specific learning disability is that the disability must involve a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations. 20 U.S.C. §1401(26)(A); Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(1). In addition, the disorder must not primarily be the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(b)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b).

The Hearing Officer must thus determine if STUDENT’s difficulties in reading and writing are due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using written language.

A review of the evidence reveals that STUDENT obtained his lowest subtest score of 53 in dictation on the Woodcock Johnson. According to Dr. Rome, the dictation subtest is a written test of concept formation. Dr. Rome also testified that STUDENT’s scores of 62 in writing skills and 66 in broad written language on the same test indicate that although STUDENT has the knowledge required to respond to a problem, he is unable to express this knowledge in writing.

In addition to these test scores, several witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s processing difficulties. Ms. Alford testified that STUDENT’s seventh grade technical arts teacher told her that STUDENT could not pass written tests due to the fact that he could not understand many written concepts. Further, STUDENT’s seventh grade science teacher testified that she believed that STUDENT had difficulty understanding most written work. Resource specialist Ms. DiNoble also testified that she believes that STUDENT has limited ability to process information and takes longer to learn than other children.

The Hearing Officer concludes that, when taken together, STUDENT’s test scores, the testimony of Dr. Rome, and the testimony of his teachers indicate that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy between ability and achievement is due to a disorder in his ability to understand and use written language, resulting in severe difficulties with reading and writing. In particular, the evidence reveals that STUDENT has a disorder in the basic psychological processes involving cognitive abilities, particularly in the areas of conceptualization and expression. Moreover, the District did not dispute the evidence presented regarding the existence of a processing disorder, and did not argue that STUDENT does not have a processing disorder. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s difficulties with reading and written expression are due to a disorder in a basic psychological process involved in understanding and using written language.

Secondly, the Hearing Officer must determine if there is any evidence that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy is primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. The only evidence relating to this issue came from Ms. Alford, who testified that STUDENT’s difficulties with reading and writing may be caused by the fact that two languages are spoken in his home. Because STUDENT’s mother speaks to him sometimes in Farsi and sometimes in English, Ms. Alford’s opinion was that this impacts his ability to learn English.(Footnote 12) However, in spite of her testimony, Ms. Alford acknowledged that his dual-language home was not the primary reason for STUDENT’s difficulties with learning. In addition, Dr. Rome testified that because he believes that STUDENT has never learned to read in Farsi, the fact that Farsi is spoken in his home would have no impact upon his learning in English.

The Hearing Officer finds that, based upon the undisputed testimony that STUDENT speaks only English at home and at school, the fact that Farsi is sometimes spoken in his home does not appear to be the reason for STUDENT’s learning difficulties. The overwhelming evidence is that STUDENT has extremely low standardized test scores, grades, and abilities in the areas of reading and written expression. There is no evidence that the fact that STUDENT is fortunate enough to be raised in a bilingual home is a basis for being seven grade levels behind in reading.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that test results demonstrate that STUDENT has a disorder in the basic psychological processes involved in understanding and using written language, in particular in the area of cognitive abilities, including conceptualization and expression. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy is not primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage.

3. Ameliorated Through Regular Education

As indicated above, the final requirement for eligibility as a child with a specific learning disability is that the severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).

The evidence establishes that STUDENT has been in a regular education program since the sixth grade and has recently received Section 504 accommodations, including grade modifications and instruction in the Reading Plus program. In spite of this assistance, STUDENT continues to read at a second grade level. His teachers testified that he is failing his academic subjects because he cannot read or write. In fact, his teachers were concerned that STUDENT was not succeeding in regular education and tried to convince his parents to place him back in special education. In addition, both District speech and language therapist, Ms. Miller, and the resource specialist, Ms. DiNoble, testified that they believed that STUDENT needed special education in order to benefit from his education.

The evidence thus establishes that although STUDENT has been in regular education for the past three years, and has received Section 504 accommodations during the past year, his severe discrepancy has not been ameliorated. He continues to read at the same second grade level at which he read prior to returning to the regular education program. Therefore, STUDENT’s severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy, based upon standardized test scores between his average cognitive abilities and his borderline and deficient scores in reading comprehension and written expression. The Hearing Officer further finds that this severe discrepancy is due to a disorder in the basic psychological process involved in understanding and using written language, and that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy is not primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through instruction in a regular education program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability from April 2000 through the present. Because STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services, he is entitled to an IEP and appropriate placement.

4. Determination By the IEP Team

As an alternative to the above-described method of determining eligibility based upon a specific learning disability, a decision regarding eligibility may be made by an IEP team. The IEP team may find that a specific learning disability exists after reviewing the following information:

1. Data obtained from standardized assessment instruments;

2. Information provided by parent;

3. Information provided by the pupil’s present teacher;

4. Evidence of the pupil’s performance in the regular and/or special education classroom obtained from observations, work samples, and group test scores; 5. Consideration of the pupil’s age, particularly for young children; and 6. Any additional relevant information.

Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(C).

This provision authorizes an IEP team to take a broader look at a child based upon criteria other than test scores. Instead of relying solely upon assessments performed by school psychologists and other staff, the law invites an IEP team to examine a student’s situation from an overall perspective. In this case, the IEP team should have looked at STUDENT’s situation with the above-listed criteria in mind. In doing so, the team would have observed that STUDENT was a child with the ability to perform eighth grade work who was reading at a second grade level.

Had the IEP team spoken with STUDENT’s regular education teachers, it would have realized that STUDENT was able to participate in class, but was not able to read class material. The team thus would have learned that STUDENT’s failing grades reflected his inability to read. In addition, had the team spoken with STUDENT’s parents, it would have learned that STUDENT was able to do his homework as long as it did not involve reading. In viewing the total picture of STUDENT’s academic situation, the IEP team should have determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and required assistance in order to benefit from his education.

Based upon the criterion listed above, the IEP team should have found STUDENT eligible for special education as having a specific learning disability. Since it failed to do so, the Hearing Officer also finds STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability on the basis of the information that was available to the IEP team.

Speech and Language Impaired

STUDENT contends that he is also eligible for special education services under the category of speech and language impaired.

A student has an expressive or receptive language disorder if he or she scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the seventh percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(c)(4)(A).

In February 1996, when STUDENT was in the third grade, a speech and language assessment by Ms. Miller found a delay in verbal language in the area of articulation, and functional weaknesses in all areas of expressive and receptive verbal language. Test results showed that STUDENT scored in the 60 to mid-70 range in the areas of spoken language, listening, speaking, semantics, syntax, and phonology.

In April 2000, when STUDENT was in the seventh grade, Ms. Miller administered the Adolescent Word Test, as well as other speech and language assessments.(Footnote 13) Although she did not test STUDENT in all of the same areas as in the third grade, she gave him a score of 72 on the Adolescent Word Test, and subtest scores of 78 in synonyms, 77 in signs of the times, and 72 in brand names. According to Ms. Miller’s test results, these scores placed STUDENT in the fifth percentile in brand names, the seventh percentile in synonyms and signs of the times, and the third percentile in the overall test results. In addition, on the oral language subtest of the Woodcock Johnson administered by Ms. DiNoble in the seventh grade, STUDENT obtained a score of 76, which placed him in the fifth percentile.

Dr. Rome also administered the TOAL, a speech and language assessment, to STUDENT when he was in the eighth grade. Dr. Rome scored STUDENT at the third percentile in listening, the second percentile in speaking, the first percentile in spoken language, and less than the first percentile in receptive and expressive language, grammar, general language, written language, and vocabulary.

The evidence thus indicates that STUDENT scored at or below the seventh percentile in two or more standardized tests administered by Ms. Miller, Ms. DiNoble, and Dr. Rome. Ms. Miller’s testing found STUDENT to be at or below the seventh percentile in the area of semantics as assessed by the Adolescent Word Test. Ms. DiNoble found STUDENT to be at the fifth percentile in oral language, and Dr. Rome found STUDENT to be at or below the seventh percentile in numerous areas related to language development.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes on the basis of the foregoing evidence that STUDENT is also eligible for special education and related services as speech and language impaired. His most recent speech and language test scores by both the District speech and language assessor and Dr. Rome demonstrate that STUDENT is below the seventh percentile for his chronological age in several areas of language development. Therefore, he is also entitled to an IEP and appropriate placement on this basis.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District fail to provide appropriate identification and placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge, that meet the standard of the state education agency, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

In addition, a child’s entitlement to special education does not depend upon the vigilance of his or her parents. Rather, it is the responsibility of the IEP team to ascertain the child’s educational needs, respond to deficiencies, and place him or her accordingly. M.C. v. Central Regional School District (3rd Cir. 1996) 81 F.3d 389, cert. den. 519 U.S. 866 (1996).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA requires specialized instruction and related services that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and confer educational benefit. Id. at 201. The Court also emphasized compliance with procedures set forth in the IDEA. As the Court in Rowley declared, “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” Id. at 205-206. Indeed, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

Petitioner argues that the District failed to appropriately identify him for special education and provide him with appropriate placement during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years when he was in the sixth and seventh grades. The District contends that it had no obligation to identify and place STUDENT during those years because his parents elected to withdraw him from special education.

The Hearing Officer must therefore determine whether the District had an obligation to identify and place STUDENT in special education during the sixth and seventh grades in light of the fact that his parents withdrew him from the program at the end of fifth grade. The record establishes that STUDENT’s parents withdrew him because they were disillusioned with the resource services that the District had provided, as he was still struggling in school and had not improved his reading abilities. Further, when his parents requested additional assistance in the form of one-on-one reading assistance, the District failed to provide this service and offered only additional resource time or a special day class. As a result, his parents were frustrated and did not know how to respond to the District’s offer other than to withdraw him from special education.

The evidence establishes that the decision of STUDENT’s parents to remove STUDENT from special education was the direct result of the District’s failure to provide him with a FAPE. The District argues that the parents are at fault for the lack of services to STUDENT during the sixth and seventh grades because they decided to remove him from the program. However, the evidence establishes that the District failed to provide sufficient resource support services that would teach STUDENT to read beyond the second grade level.(Footnote 14) The parents did not make the situation worse by removing STUDENT. In fact, they had correctly concluded that the District was not going to provide their son with a FAPE, and behaved reasonably under the circumstances. It was the District’s failure to provide a FAPE, and not the parents’ actions, that was the primary cause of STUDENT’s removal from special education. See Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497; Steldt v. School Board of the Riverdale School District (W.D. Wisc. 1995) 885 F. Supp. 1192, 1197.

The evidence also establishes that the District had knowledge that STUDENT was continuing to struggle in school during the sixth and seventh grades. STUDENT’s sixth grade teachers testified that they met periodically during the year to discuss STUDENT. One of the teachers also notified the principal of STUDENT’s reading and writing difficulties. When STUDENT moved to the seventh grade, he continued to struggle in school and continued to read at a second grade level. STUDENT’s seventh grade teachers all testified that he was failing their classes because of his difficulty with reading and writing. In addition, the teachers asked the parents to place STUDENT back in special education. They also notified District personnel that STUDENT was failing their classes because he could not read.

After hearing the concerns of the teachers, and considering their own observations that STUDENT was failing his classes, his parents decided to accept the District’s offer of placement in an SDC. They notified the District in February 2000, in the middle of his seventh grade year, that they wanted STUDENT back in special education.

Following the parents’ request, the District ultimately decided to reassess STUDENT for special education eligibility in April 2000, at the end of seventh grade. However, the evidence pertaining to STUDENT’s continuing struggles in school was available to the District much earlier. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s difficulties in sixth and seventh grades were similar to his difficulties in earlier years. In spite of this knowledge, District personnel did not appropriately identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and did not provide appropriate placement for him during the sixth and seventh grades. They also did not reassess STUDENT for special education until two months after his parents notified them that they desired to place him in an SDC.

In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to appropriately identify STUDENT as eligible for special education and provide appropriate placement for him during the sixth and seventh grades. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during those years constitutes a prejudicial procedural error that resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?

As a currently eligible student, STUDENT is entitled to a FAPE for the 2001-2001 school year and thereafter so long as he remains eligible for special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. As an eligible student with a severe learning disability and speech and language impairment wrongly denied appropriate special education services from the 1998-1999 school year through the present, STUDENT is also entitled to compensatory education to overcome lost educational opportunity.

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1496. The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. The purpose of compensatory education is “to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. In crafting appropriate relief, a hearing officer has broad latitude. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 359. Because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Id. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d at 1486; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1396.

Petitioner seeks compensatory education for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years in the form of either placement in a state-certified, nonpublic school for three years or, in the alternative, one-on-one educational therapy by a qualified educational therapist for five hours per week for three years. Given the Hearing Officer’s findings that the District failed to appropriately identify and place STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, and that it improperly failed to find him eligible for the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District shall provide STUDENT with a FAPE and with compensatory educational services for its failure to appropriately educate STUDENT for those years.

While the District’s liability to STUDENT for a FAPE and compensatory education is clear, the appropriate remedies to be awarded are not. Dr. Rome testified that a program such as the one at Summit View School, a state-certified, nonpublic school, might be most appropriate to remediate STUDENT’s reading difficulties because of its small, intimate setting.(Footnote 15) According to Dr. Rome, a small setting is most appropriate because of the low student-to-teacher ratio, which would permit STUDENT to have individualized attention when he requires it. However, Dr. Rome acknowledged that the District also has services that can benefit STUDENT. Karen Garland, District program specialist, testified that the District could meet STUDENT’s needs as specified by Dr. Rome in an SDC class.(Footnote 16) In addition, the District has teachers who have been trained in Lindamood-Bell reading techniques.

With regard to services provided by a one-on-one educational therapist, both parents testified that STUDENT’s reading improved a great deal during a two-month period in which they provided him with a one-on-one private reading tutor for one hour per day.(Footnote 17) In addition to the private tutor, STUDENT attended Sylvan Learning Center (Sylvan) during the summer of 1999 in eleven one-on-one sessions per month. Testing following Sylvan assistance demonstrated that STUDENT improved from second to third grade level in vocabulary, from first to second grade level in reading comprehension, and from first to second grade level in total reading. Further, written comments from his Sylvan tutor indicated that STUDENT had learned some phonics skills that would increase his ability to decode difficult words and ultimately increase his reading comprehension.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not establish that STUDENT requires the restrictive setting of a state-certified nonpublic school for three years. The only evidence in support of that request is the testimony of Dr. Rome, who acknowledged that similar services could be provided by the District. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed remedy of five hours per week of a one-on-one educational aide for three years is not adequate for STUDENT. Although the evidence confirms that STUDENT progressed in his reading skills with the assistance of a one-on-one tutor for three hours per week while at Sylvan, his request for three years of this type of service ignores the realities of life for a high school freshman. It is unlikely that STUDENT will enjoy spending extra hours at school each day while his friends are enjoying nonschool activities. To force STUDENT to participate in many extra hours of school could result in his becoming disenchanted with school and could result in his desire to quit school before he is able to learn to read. Additionally, leaving school with a severe reading deficiency could very well negatively affect his future.

Given the inadequacies of the proposed remedies for the 2001-2002 school year and beyond, either in terms of FAPE or compensatory education, the Hearing Officer has no alternative but to order temporary services, set forth criteria based on the record, and return the matter to the IEP team to develop appropriate remedies.

The Hearing Officer recognizes that, at a minimum, STUDENT needs intensive remedial reading services if he is to succeed in reading at grade level by the time he graduates from high school. In addition, the Hearing Officer recognizes that STUDENT needs a program for the 2001-2002 school year that is more than the minimum required to provide a FAPE. In order to compensate him for time lost, and because school days are already very long for high school students, STUDENT needs an intensive program during the regular school day that constitutes a combination of both FAPE and compensatory education. Therefore, when planning a program for STUDENT for the next four years, the IEP team should keep the following goals in mind: Based on the available information, it is reasonable to expect that STUDENT will read at grade level by the time he graduates from high school; STUDENT is entitled to services above and beyond a FAPE in order to meet this goal; and the program required for STUDENT to meet this goal shall be primarily delivered during the regular school day, with one to two hours per week permitted outside of the regular school day.

In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that FAPE and compensatory education services for STUDENT must begin immediately. Therefore, within 15 days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT with a summer reading program of five hours per day, which shall last until the fall semester begins. At least one of these hours shall be one-on-one reading assistance. During the period that precedes the beginning of the summer reading program, the District shall provide STUDENT with a private reading assessment to determine how best to provide this reading assistance.

The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT requires a comparable summer reading program for the following three summers as part of his compensatory education unless he has achieved grade level reading prior to that time. He may also need a comparable summer reading program following his senior year in high school if he is not reading at grade level by that time.

In addition to the foregoing, the IEP team shall keep in mind that STUDENT’s summer reading program is part of his compensatory education. In addition, compensatory education is also part of the program to be provided to him during the regular school year. In developing an appropriate, practical, and intensive remedial plan for STUDENT, the IEP team must carefully and fully address the following considerations:

1. STUDENT’s need for a small-class setting.

2. STUDENT’s need for intensive one-on-one assistance with reading and writing.

3. STUDENT’s need for speech and language services.

4. The possible need for further assessment if STUDENT continues to have difficulty in learning to read and write.

5. The possible need for an outside expert to contribute ideas on learning strategies for STUDENT and to help design a remedial program for him.

6. STUDENT’s reluctance to be unnecessarily segregated from regular education students.

7. STUDENT’s career aspirations and interests.

8. The fact that STUDENT’s potential rate and extent of progress are as yet unknown.

ISSUE NO. 4: If STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services, must the District provide him with vision therapy as a related service?

As indicated previously, the IDEA and State special education law provide that children with disabilities have the right to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

Petitioner contends that he requires vision therapy as proposed by developmental optometrist Dr. Gary Etting. In his visual assessment, Dr. Etting recommended that STUDENT receive an individualized program of twenty-four to thirty-six one-hour sessions of optometric vision therapy to remediate the visual dysfunctions that interfere with his ability to process visual information. The District contends that STUDENT does not require vision therapy because STUDENT’s teachers and his resource specialist never observed STUDENT to have eye teaming or eye tracking problems or to have difficulty maintaining his place when reading.

The Hearing Officer must first examine the relevant evidence pertaining to any alleged visual dysfunction. Dr. Rome testified that he referred STUDENT to Dr. Etting because he noticed that when reading and writing, STUDENT appeared to skip letters and whole words. Dr. Etting administered a variety of tests to STUDENT, and concluded that STUDENT suffers from eye teaming difficulties, eye tracking problems, and focusing troubles.(Footnote 18) According to Dr. Etting, these visual deficits can result in, among other things, slow visual processing speed, difficulty with copying, and reduced ability to sustain visually demanding tasks. Dr. Etting testified that, when reading or writing, STUDENT does not see complete words, fatigues quickly, skips words or lines, confuses words that look similar, cannot perform close visual work for more than twenty minutes at a time, and has difficulty reproducing what he visualizes.

Ms. Alford, the District’s school psychologist, testified that she did not see any visual problems in the tests that she administered. If she had observed any problems, she would have tested further. In fact, she believed that STUDENT’s score of 90 on the Woodcock Johnson visual processing subtest indicated a strength in that area, causing her to see no need for further testing in the area of visual processing. In addition, STUDENT obtained a score of 80 on the District-administered Berry Visual Motor Integration Test (VMI). Ms. Alford described this score as demonstrating no visual motor problems. In contrast, Dr. Etting described this score as significantly delayed, and testified that it would prompt him to administer additional testing.

In addition, resource specialist Ms. DiNoble testified that she had attended an optometry class, where she learned to assess eye tracking problems. Although she did not assess STUDENT for vision problems, she watched his eyes while he was reading and never observed any eye tracking problems. Further, although STUDENT’s teachers all testified about his difficulties with reading and writing, none noted any visual processing problems. Only one teacher noted difficulty with copying from the blackboard but did not state that she believed this to be related to visual processing problems. In fact, STUDENT’s eighth grade English teacher testified that he believed that STUDENT’s difficulties in copying words related to his difficulties with reading.

On the basis of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require vision therapy in order to benefit from his education. While the evidence is overwhelming that STUDENT has great difficulty with reading and writing, the only evidence that these difficulties are related to visual problems is from the testing done by Dr. Etting on two separate occasions. In the visual testing administered by the District, Dr. Etting described the VMI score as requiring additional testing and not necessarily conclusive of a visual processing disorder. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT scored an average score of 90 on the Woodcock Johnson visual processing subtest. In addition, none of the teachers or the resource specialist who worked with STUDENT on a daily basis noted any visual difficulties. In fact, Ms. DiNoble specifically looked for such difficulties and did not observe any. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is not required under the IDEA to provide STUDENT with vision therapy as a related service.

ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private assessments performed by Dr. Robert Rome and Dr. Gary Etting?

Federal and State special education law provides that before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states that a school district’s assessment must be conducted by qualified persons and must not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. In addition, assessment materials must meet the following criteria: administered in the pupil’s primary language, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; administered by trained personnel except that intellectual testing must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist; tailored to assess specific areas of educational need; administered to best ensure that tests administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produce results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude or achievement level; no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate program; the pupil is assessed in all areas of suspected disability; and the assessment is conducted by persons knowledgeable of that disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b).

In the present case, the District school psychologist, resource specialist, and speech and language specialist assessed STUDENT in April 2000. It is undisputed that the District’s assessments were conducted by qualified persons; were not discriminatory; were in STUDENT’s primary language; were administered by trained personnel, including a school psychologist for intellectual testing; were not based upon a single procedure used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate program; were not improperly administered to a student with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills; and were conducted by persons knowledgeable of STUDENT’s disability.

However, the Hearing Officer must determine if the District’s assessments were validated for the specific purpose for which they were used and were tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Dr. Rome testified that he administered the TONI to STUDENT because of STUDENT’s history of a speech and language impairment. However, in spite of the District’s knowledge, as indicated previously, that STUDENT had delays in verbal language abilities, it administered the WISC-III to him with its subtests that require verbal abilities.

According to Dr. Rome, the WISC-III requires the ability to follow verbal directions and requires verbal abilities in six of the twelve subtests. Ms. Alford did not dispute Dr. Rome’s conclusions regarding the verbal abilities required by the WISC-III. Instead, she testified that she did not believe that STUDENT performed poorly in the verbal areas tested on the WISC-III. Ms. Alford testified that, because there was no significant scatter among STUDENT’s subtest scores, she did not believe that a nonverbal assessment was indicated. However, Dr. Rome testified that he decided to administer the nonverbal TONI because of the scatter among STUDENT’s subtest scores. STUDENT’s digit span score of a 4, his lowest score, requires verbal abilities, according to Dr. Rome. The District’s WISC-III test results indicate a significant scatter, from a low of a 4 in digit span to a high of an 8 in information and picture arrangement. Other scores were in the 5, 6, and 7 range.

The Hearing Officer concludes that, based upon STUDENT’s history of speech and language difficulties, and the finding that he continues to be eligible as speech and language impaired, the District inappropriately assessed him with an instrument that required verbal abilities. Although the District did not disagree that the WISC-III requires verbal abilities, it disputed the need for an alternative assessment. However, the evidence reveals that STUDENT had a number of low subtest scores in areas requiring verbal abilities.

The Hearing Officer thus finds that the WISC-III, with its many verbal components, was not validated for the specific purpose for which it was used and was not tailored to assess specific areas of STUDENT’s educational need. Therefore, the District’s cognitive assessment of STUDENT was not appropriate, and his parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Rome’s independent assessment. The parents submitted an invoice from Dr. Rome in the amount of $960 for his assessment. Therefore, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS in the amount of $960.

Petitioner also contends that the District failed to assess him in the area of a suspected visual processing disorder as determined by Dr. Etting. However, the evidence establishes that the District administered the Bender Gestalt Visual Motor Test, the VMI, and the Woodcock Johnson visual processing subtest. As discussed previously, District witnesses testified that, from these test results and their observations, they did not find STUDENT to have a visual processing disorder. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of visual processing. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s vision assessments were appropriate in that they complied in all respects with California Education Code § 56320. Therefore, reimbursement for Petitioner’s independent assessment by Dr. Etting is denied.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT with a summer reading program of five hours per day. At least one of those five hours shall be one-on-one reading assistance. During the period that precedes the beginning of the summer reading program, the District shall provide STUDENT with a private reading assessment to determine how best to provide the reading assistance.

2. The District shall convene an IEP meeting prior to the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to develop and implement a comprehensive plan of combined FAPE and compensatory education services for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. In developing the plan, the IEP team shall carefully and fully address the eight considerations itemized above in Issue No. 3.

3. In preparing IEP programs for subsequent years, the IEP team shall build in an appropriate compensatory education program for STUDENT unless he is reading at grade level.

4. As part of an award of compensatory education for STUDENT, the District shall provide him with a summer reading program comparable to Order No. 1, for the summers following his freshman, sophomore, and junior years in high school, unless STUDENT has achieved grade- level reading prior to that time. The summer reading program shall be for the entire length of the summer, but must accommodate a one-month family vacation. If the IEP team determines that STUDENT is not reading at grade level during his senior year in high school, the District shall also provide STUDENT with a comparable summer reading program following his senior year in high school.

5. The District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the private assessment by Dr. Robert Rome in the amount of $960.

6. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services, and thus entitled to an individualized education program and appropriate placement, under the category of specific learning disability or speech impaired from April 2000 through the present? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District fail to provide appropriate identification and placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

4. If STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services, must the District provide him with vision therapy as a related service? Respondent prevailed on this issue.

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private assessments performed by Dr. Robert Rome and Dr. Gary Etting?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the private assessment by Dr. Robert Rome. Respondent prevailed to the extent that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the private assessment by Dr. Gary Etting.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 6, 2001 ____________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1.Petitioner’s father was present only during the first day of hearing. 2.For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has reorganized Petitioner’s statement of the issues. 3.STUDENT’s parents have provided some one-on-one tutoring in reading for him from a private tutor and from the Sylvan Learning Center. They testified that they observed STUDENT making progress in reading with one-on-one assistance. 4.Ms. Alford and Ms. DiNoble performed the following tests: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition; Wide Range Achievement Test - Third Edition; Bender Gestalt Visual Motor Test; Berry Visual Motor Integration Test; Projective Testing: Draw a Person, Draw a Family, Sentence Completion; Woodcock Johnson Revised Psycho-Educational Battery - Achievement; and Woodcock Johnson Revised Psycho-Educational Battery - Cognitive Ability. Ms. Miller performed the following tests: Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, One Word Expressive Picture Vocabulary Test, and Adolescent Word Test. 5.Dr. Rome performed the following tests: Test of Nonverbal Intelligence - Third Edition - Form B; Wide Range Achievement Test - Revision 3 - Arithmetic subtest; Woodcock-Johnson Revised Tests of Academic Achievement (Letter-Word Identification), Passage Comprehension, and Dictation subtests; Test of Adolescent and Adult Language - Third Edition; and Wepman Auditory Discrimination Test. 6.Although STUDENT received modified grades of C in many classes, his teachers testified that, without modification, all of his grades would have been failing grades. 7.Alternative means of testing are required where traditional, standardized test scores do not appropriately assess a student. See Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(B) 8.An article in California School Psychologist calls into question this practice. Helm and Johnson, Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California’s Title 5 Regulations, 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). At the hearing, the parties did not argue that the method presented in this article should apply. Therefore, the traditional method of reading Cal. Code Regs., Title 5, § 3030(j) will be applied here. 9.Dr. Rome testified that a Peabody score correlates highly with intelligence. This was not disputed by the District. 10.Program specialist Karen Garland also testified that she believes that the Slosson is used as a screening device and tends to inflate scores. 11.In her testimony, Ms. Alford acknowledged that language deficits can deflate WISC-III scores. However, she did not see such deficits in STUDENT’s test scores. She also testified that, had she seen a TONI score in the 100 range, she would have administered additional testing in order to corroborate this score. 12.Several of STUDENT’s teachers testified that they did not hear him speaking any language other than English at school. In addition, the testimony of Ms. Alford and Dr. Rome was that they understood that STUDENT responds to his mother in English. 13.Ms. Miller testified that the Adolescent Word Test measures abilities in the area of semantics. 14.Ms. DiNoble testified that she believed that STUDENT was making progress in school with resource support. However, testing in the seventh grade demonstrated that STUDENT continued to read at a second grade level. 15.Dr. Carl Goodman, director of Summit View School, testified that his school specializes in students with average or higher IQs with learning disabilities. Its reading programs use multi-sensory techniques such as those utilized by Lindamood-Bell and Wilson methodologies. The maximum class size is twelve students with one teacher and one or two teachers assistants. The school also provides small, pull-out groups for direct instruction in remedial areas 16.STUDENT testified that he did not want to be placed either in a nonpublic school or an SDC class. However, both Ms. Garland and Dr. Goodman testified that many children are initially reluctant to enter these programs, but eventually adjust after they benefit from the instruction provided. 17.Although STUDENT spent five hours with the tutor, only one hour of the day was one-on-one. 18.Dr. Etting administered the Berry Test of Visual Motor Integration, the Groffman Tracing Test, the Wold Sentence Copy Test, the Wold Digit Coding Test, the Piaget Left/Right Test, the Gardner Left/Right Reversals Test, the Span of Perception, the SUNY Gross Motor Test, the Wachs Visual Thinking Tasks, the Visagraph, and the Gardner Test of Visual-Perceptual Abilities Revised (non-motor). 19.As indicated previously, STUDENT’s primary language is English.