California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 21, 2001

Student v. Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1829-01 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda

Fairfield-Suisun Unified must reimburse private speech assessment and therapy after its 2001 IEP lacked articulation and oral motor baselines.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 6 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a six-year-old with autism filed for due process against Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District. The case was limited to his articulation and oral motor speech services. The student had moved from a preschool special day class at Sheldon Elementary to a full-inclusion kindergarten at Oakbrook Elementary.

For 2000-2001, the Hearing Officer found procedural flaws in the articulation goals. The March 2000 objectives did not say where the student should be at each reporting period. The February 2001 objectives lacked success criteria and a method of evaluation. These flaws did not deny FAPE because the mother took an active part in IEP meetings. The student also made real progress with district speech therapists Christine Cabral and Carol Krusemark. For example, by May 2001 he could say the /l/ sound without a model about 70% of the time.

For 2001-2002, the July 2001 IEP denied FAPE in articulation and oral motor skills. It lacked valid present levels and baselines, even though updated assessment data were available. The Hearing Officer found that the offered therapist, Kathleen Deignan, was qualified. The District had to reimburse the parents for the Center for Speech Pathology assessment, because the District never assessed oral motor skills. It also had to reimburse the center's weekly 45-minute sessions. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 20 days, with a center representative, to write measurable goals with accurate baselines. Compensatory education was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled flawed IEP goals. Missing benchmarks in a past year were harmless where progress was documented. A new offer without accurate present levels or baselines failed the "designed to meet unique needs" test. Parents were reimbursed for a private assessment that covered an area the district never assessed.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content

    Issue 1. Did the District provide Student a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year with respect to the direct speech therapy component of his educational program?

    The articulation goals in the March 2000 IEP lacked interim progress points, and the February 2001 goals lacked success criteria and a method of evaluation. These flaws did not deny FAPE because the parent took full part and Student made meaningful progress under services that met his needs and followed his IEPs. The District prevailed.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year with respect to the offer of services to address his articulation and oral motor needs?

    The July 2001 IEP lacked valid present levels and baselines for articulation and oral motor skills. One baseline was outdated, and the oral motor objectives could not measure progress. The IEP was not designed to meet Student's needs and denied FAPE in those two areas.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is Kathleen Deignan appropriately qualified to provide speech and language services to Student?

    Through her credential, more than 30 years of experience, and autism-related training, Ms. Deignan was qualified to provide direct speech services and consultation, even though she did not know the term "discrete trial training."

  4. Issue 4a. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by the Center for Speech Pathology?

    Reimbursement was ordered because the parent had asked for a comprehensive assessment, the District never assessed oral motor skills, and the private assessment covered that area and was used by the District to write goals.

  5. Issue 4b. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language services provided by the Center for Speech Pathology from July 2000 to the date of this decision?

    Because the District denied FAPE in articulation and oral motor skills, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the private services, which were appropriate and produced progress. The provider did not have to be a certified nonpublic agency or coordinate with the District, although the center was in fact certified.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Compensatory education was denied. No FAPE denial occurred in 2000-2001. For 2001-2002, the parent wrongly refused the District's other appropriate language services, and reimbursement covered the deficient areas.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days after receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the parents for the cost of the Center for Speech Pathology assessment.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days after receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the parents for all Center for Speech Pathology speech services up to the date of the decision, not to exceed the cost of one 45-minute session during every school week.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting and invite a knowledgeable Center for Speech Pathology representative, paid a reasonable rate. The IEP must be updated with appropriate articulation and oral motor goals and objectives that include accurate baselines and measurable short-term objectives or benchmarks. Other language/communication goals must be updated if needed. The District is not required to contract with the center for future services.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)

People named in the decision

  • Karen Hanson, director of special education, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Kathleen Cruice, special day class teacher and speech-language pathologist; conducted March 2000 speech assessment, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District (Sheldon Elementary)
  • Christine Cabral, district speech-language therapist (Oct. 2000–Feb. 2001), Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Carol Krusemark, district speech-language pathologist; conducted May 2001 articulation assessment, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Stephanie Martin, behaviorist providing behavior support and aide oversight, Spectrum Center
  • Kathleen Deignan, district speech-language specialist offered for 2001-2002, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Lisa Franklin, speech-language specialist at July 2001 IEP meeting, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Ms. Udall, general education kindergarten teacher, Oakbrook Elementary
  • Danielle Shahan, private speech assessor, Center for Speech Pathology
  • Susan Faist, private speech pathologist, program director, witness for Student, Center for Speech Pathology
  • Center for Speech Pathology, private provider / certified nonpublic agency (speech assessment and therapy), Davis, California
  • Spectrum Center, behavioral services agency
  • Learning Advantage, private assessor

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Fairfield, California, on November 1, 2, 13, 14 and 20, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented by attorney Bob Varma. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER (Mrs. MOTHER). Respondent Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jan Tomsky. Also present on behalf of the District was Karen Hanson, director of special education for the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on December 21, 2001. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year with respect to the direct speech therapy component of his educational program?

2. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year with respect to the offer of services to address his articulation and oral motor needs?

3. Is Kathleen Deignan appropriately qualified to provide speech and language services to STUDENT?

4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following:

a. the assessment conducted by the Center for Speech Pathology?

b. the speech and language services provided by the Center for Speech Pathology from July 2000 to the date of this decision?

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS

For the 2000-2001 school year, the Petitioner contends that he was not provided a free and appropriate public education because his articulation goal and objectives were not appropriate, and the direct speech therapy failed to provide him with “measurable benefit.” For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner asserts that he has been denied a FAPE with regard to speech and language because his needs were not properly identified in the area of articulation and oral motor skills. According to Petitioner, his articulation and oral motor goals and objectives were not appropriate, and the District failed to offer a competent speech and language therapist.

As a remedy, Petitioner seeks reimbursement and a “bank of compensatory hours” from his choice of providers – the Center for Speech Pathology (CSP) – as well as reimbursement for a CSP assessment. Petitioner also requests an order that the CSP’s proposed goals and objectives be adopted.

The District argues that STUDENT’s articulation goal and objectives were appropriate and that they were appropriately implemented, and that STUDENT made real progress on those goals and objectives during the 2000-2001 school year.

Regarding the 2001-2002 school year, the District argues that the speech provider it offered, Ms. Kathleen Deignan, is more than qualified to provide speech therapy to autistic students such as STUDENT, and to provide speech consultation services to STUDENT’s other educational team members. The District also argues that STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor goals and objectives were appropriate during the 2001-2002 school year and Petitioner should not be reimbursed for his privately obtained speech therapy from CSP. Finally, the District argues that it properly assessed STUDENT, and therefore, STUDENT should not be reimbursed for the intake assessment he obtained from CSP.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a six-year-old child who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District. He receives special education and related services as a child with autism. STUDENT is currently in a full-inclusion program in a regular education kindergarten classroom at Oakbrook Elementary.

During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was enrolled at Sheldon Elementary School (“Sheldon”). On March 7, 2000, Kathleen Cruice, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, who is also a speech pathologist, conducted a speech assessment of STUDENT. The assessment was conducted because STUDENT’s speech was difficult to understand “due to low volume and syntax (sentence structure) errors.” The purpose of the assessment was to determine whether STUDENT could benefit from additional goals and objectives designed to improve his intelligibility. The Assessment of Phonological Processes (APP) was administered and a language sample was obtained and analyzed as part of the assessment. Ms. Cruice found that STUDENT’s “overall severity is rated as moderate.” She recommended that objectives be written to increase STUDENT’s MLU (mean length of utterance), to facilitate his use of appropriate syntax, and to improve articulation. District’s Exh. 54. She found, in pertinent part, that:

He omits one consonant in consonant sequences in 43% of occurrences on [the APP]. He substitutes /w/ for /l/ and initial /r/ and omits /l/ and /r/ in blends (Because both are later developing sounds, STUDENT’s productions should be monitored.) Observation of STUDENT’s spontaneous speech evidences similar consonant sequence omissions.

District’s Exh. 54.

On March 24, 2000, STUDENT’s IEP team met for his annual review. Ms. Cruice’s assessment was discussed. The team developed goals and corresponding objectives in sensory, motor development, social/emotional growth, language/communication, pre-academic development, and perceptual skills. In the area of language/communication, several new goals were added to improve STUDENT’s intelligibility. One of those intelligibility-targeted goals was in the area of articulation; that goal was “STUDENT will produce age appropriate sounds in connected speech.” Two corresponding short-term objectives were developed as follows:

Given pictures/objects and a model, STUDENT will produce the following consonant sequences in one-syllable words: fl, gl, sk, pl, kl, sl, sw with 80% accuracy.

Given pictures/objects and a model, STUDENT will produce the above consonant sequences in 2-3 word phrases with 80% accuracy.

District’s Exh. 52.

The IEP team discussed adding a speech and language services provider in addition to Ms. Cruice, who at that time implemented all of STUDENT’s language/communication goals in her special day class.(Footnote 2) It was the determination of the IEP team that, at that time, adding another, unfamiliar, service provider to implement STUDENT’s articulation goal and objectives was not in STUDENT’s best interest and that it would likely be disruptive for STUDENT. It was agreed that Ms. Cruice would be responsible for implementation of the new goal and corresponding objectives in the area of articulation. Ms. Cruice implemented STUDENT’s articulation goal and objective from March 2000 to October 2000. Testimony of Cruice and District’s Exh. 41.

On June 2, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss STUDENT’s placement during the upcoming school year (2000-2001). District’s Exh. 50. The team decided that STUDENT would remain in Ms. Cruice’s preschool special day class for the communicatively handicapped four days per week (120 minutes per day). STUDENT would also receive one-to-one discreet trial training with an instructional aide five days per week (150-240 minutes per day); direct occupational therapy services two days per week (45 minutes per session); occupational therapy consult; and consultation for behavioral services (12-22 hours per month). STUDENT was also provided with mainstreaming opportunities through integration in a regular preschool setting as well as reverse mainstreaming. (Footnote 3) STUDENT’s goals and objectives, including the language/communication goal related to articulation, were continued unchanged from the March 24, 2000 IEP. Petitioner consented to this IEP. District’s Exh. 50.

On June 8, 2000, Ms. Cruice prepared a report in which she tracked STUDENT’s progress toward attainment of his goals and objectives. With regard to STUDENT’s language/communication goal, “STUDENT will produce age appropriate sounds in connected speech,” she noted that STUDENT had made some progress and that she anticipated that STUDENT would meet this goal. She also wrote that:

STUDENT attends to the model and attempts to articulate his tongue. He imitates /sk/ in CVC words. /l/ blends are more difficult. /sw/ is produced by breaking it up.

District’s Exh. 49.

On June 23, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT to review extended year services for the summer of 2000. The team agreed upon an extended school year program that included one week of instruction after the end of the 1999-2000 school year, and an additional week of instruction prior to the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. District’s Exh. 47.

On September 6, 2000, the 2000-2001 school year began at Sheldon. During this school year, STUDENT was enrolled in Kathleen Cruice’s special day class, with increasing mainstreaming into the regular education kindergarten class.

On September 27, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss speech services for STUDENT. STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Cruice, requested the meeting. The IEP reflects, in pertinent part, as follows:

STUDENT’s teacher requested this meeting to discuss speech services. At STUDENT’s last annual review meeting on March 24, 2000, needs in the area of articulation were identified. A goal and objectives were written at that time to remediate the phonological process of cluster reduction. His IEP team felt that adding another service provider, at that time, might not be in STUDENT’s best interest. Since he attends a class taught by a Speech-Language Pathologist, it was agreed that articulation objectives could be met within his classroom program. DIS speech services were not recommended at the time of his annual review.

The makeup of STUDENT’s class for the 2000-01 school year has impacted his classroom teacher’s ability to work with STUDENT on articulation objectives. There are more students in this year’s class, and the level of activity is such that it distracts STUDENT from attending and focusing on the fine details needed for accurate articulation (e.g., tongue placement, manner of production, etc.) . . . The team agrees to add DIS Speech services for the articulation objectives.

District’s Exh. 41.

The IEP team agreed with Ms. Cruice’s recommendation and direct speech therapy was added to STUDENT’s IEP in the amount of 15-20 minutes, two times per week, to begin October 9, 2000. Ms. MOTHER expressed concern regarding whether the new provider (Christine Cabral) had experience working with children with Autism. The team agreed that Stephanie Martin, a behaviorist employed by the Spectrum Center, would provide training to the new speech service provider.(Footnote 4) It was also agreed that either Ms. Martin or Ms. Cruice would consult with the speech service provider “prior to initiating therapy.” STUDENT’s articulation goal and corresponding objectives developed at the March 24, 2000 IEP were continued and remained unchanged. District’s Exh. 41.

In October 2000, STUDENT began receiving direct speech services from Christine Cabral. Ms. Martin attended the first two direct speech sessions with Ms. Cabral, as required by the IEP. Additionally, Ms. Cruice, who had previously implemented STUDENT’s articulation goal, consulted with Ms. Cabral periodically. Testimony of Cruice. Ms. Cabral continued to provide STUDENT direct speech and language services to implement STUDENT’s language/communication goal and objectives related to articulation until February 2001. At that time she left the District on maternity leave. While she worked with STUDENT, she kept a service log that documented her work and STUDENT’s progress. Petitioner’s Exh. 430.

On February 13, 2001, Ms. Cabral drafted a speech therapist summary of IEP progress. Her summary states as follows:

STUDENT continues to be seen twice a week for articulation therapy. He is presently working on the production of [L] in isolation and in initial words like; lion, light, lamp. His goal is to produce [L] in consonant sequences in one syllable words and eventually in 2-3 word phrases. He is presently producing [L] in initial words 60% of the time with tactile, visual, and auditory stimulation. STUDENT enjoys speech and participates fully. He has made much progress with the production of [L] and it is recommended that he continue with direct speech services.

District’s Exh. 35.

On February 16, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team met for his annual review.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s goals and objectives were reviewed. In the area of language/communication, specifically in the area of articulation, STUDENT’s goal and the corresponding objectives were reviewed and revised based on the report prepared by Ms. Cabral.(Footnote 6) STUDENT’s long-term goal was to “improve articulation to age or developmentally appropriate levels” with two corresponding objectives: (1) target phoneme/process “[L] in the initial” (the baseline data reflects that STUDENT could articulate /l/ in the initial 60% of the time, with a model) and (2) target phoneme/process “consonant sequences fl, gl, pl, kl, sl (the baseline data reflects that STUDENT could articulate those consonant sequences 0% of the time). Ms. MOTHER signed the IEP indicating her agreement on February 23, 2001, and shortly thereafter, STUDENT began receiving direct speech services from speech pathologist Carol Krusemark.(Footnote 7)

Ms. Krusemark continued to provide STUDENT direct services until June 11, 2001. Ms. Krusemark kept a “student services log” in which she tracked her work with STUDENT on his articulation goal and objectives. District’s Exh. 66.

On March 1, 2001, Mrs. MOTHER requested an IEP meeting to “formally hear Ms. Stephanie Martins’ [sic] placement recommendation for the 2001-2002 school year, and to make a decision as an IEP team.” Mrs. MOTHER wanted STUDENT to attend a kindergarten class during the 2001-2002 school year at Oakbrook Elementary taught by a particular teacher by the name of Ms. Udall. The IEP team meeting was scheduled for March 30, 2001.

On March 9, 2001, prior to the IEP meeting, the District prepared a notice requesting permission for a student reevaluation. STUDENT’s triennial was due in October 2001. The notice to Mrs. MOTHER indicates that the District staff believed that (1) STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education, (2) STUDENT continued to need special education services, (3) STUDENT’s program modifications and/or additions could be made with current information, and (4) STUDENT’s present levels of performance and needs could be identified based on current information. The notice was signed by Ms. Kathleen Cruice, Carol Krusemark, Stephanie Martin, and a district psychologist. Mrs. MOTHER signed the notice on March 26, 2001, indicating that she agreed that “current data is sufficient and no additional testing is needed.” District’s Exh. 30.

On March 30, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team convened again to discuss his transition to kindergarten and his triennial review. The IEP provides for an increase in speech and language services, including consultation services to support the implementation of STUDENT’s language goals upon enrollment in Ms. Udall’s kindergarten class at Oakbrook.(Footnote 8) The IEP also added an additional hour per day of one-to-one instructional aide support, and provided for a period of two weeks during which the former and new aides would overlap to support STUDENT’s transition. District’s Exh. 27.

On May 10, 2001, the March 30, 2001 IEP meeting continued. One of the topics that the team discussed was provision of speech and language services for STUDENT after his transition to kindergarten. The IEP reflects, in pertinent part, that it was previously agreed that any major changes to STUDENT’s program would be filtered through the behaviorist, and that the speech therapist, who was the case manager, would address administrative changes. The IEP further reflects that speech therapy was also discussed. Two new language/communication goals were added to improve STUDENT’s conversational speech. The IEP reflects, in pertinent part, as follows:

The frequency of speech therapy was discussed. STUDENT’s current speech therapist feels that the articulation goals can be met with 2x/wk 25 min sessions . . . It was discussed that the consultation time for the speech therapist [be used to] assist both the [one-to-one instructional aide] and the general education teacher to address the language goals. The speech therapist feels that the lang. goals are very conducive to the [general education] setting. Mrs. MOTHER asked both the O.T. and the speech [therapist] to describe ways they motivate/interact with students. Both described some strategies and emphasized the need to individualize based on STUDENT’s unique needs. Mrs. MOTHER is concerned about STUDENT’s intelligibility. Ms. Udall shared how she models correct speech in her classroom and the collaboration with the speech therapist. It was suggested that [a more up to date] assessment in articulation be conducted to re-assess the appropriateness of the [articulation] goals. A meeting will be convened to review. Direct speech service time was decided to be 20-25 min. 2x/wk and progress discussed at the first reporting period. Mrs. MOTHER proposes that goals to increase conversational skills be included in the IEP. Goals were proposed and accepted by the IEP team.

District’s Exh. 23.

On May 16 and 21, 2001, Carol Krusemark conducted a speech assessment of STUDENT. She administered the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation-2 (GFTA-2). Her assessment found, in pertinent part, as follows:

STUDENT achieved a raw score of 25 on the GFTA-2. This score corresponds to a standard score of 77, an age equivalent of 3 years, 3 months, and the 10th percentile for his age. He substituted /v/ for final /b/ in bathtub, omitted medial /d/, substituted /d/ or /n/ for /j/, substituted /w/ for initial and medial /l/ singletons and initial /l/ blends, and omitted final /l/, substituted /w/ for initial /r/, substituted /f/ for voiceless /th/ and /d/ for voiced /th/, substituted /b/ for /v/, and /sw/ for initial /z/. He consistently marked l- and r-blends with consonant +/w/.

It should be noted that beyond what is tested on this instrument, STUDENT was also observed to reduce medial blends to single consonants and inconsistently delete medial syllables. His production of vowels, even with a model, was inconsistent. These additional factors could also have an effect on his intelligibility in conversational speech.

District’s Exh. 18.

In late May 2000, STUDENT was involved in a minor behavioral incident during a direct speech therapy session with Ms. Krusemark. Afterwards, both Ms. Cruice and Ms. Martin, STUDENT’s behavioral specialist, consulted with Ms. Krusemark as to how address STUDENT’s behavioral problems, should any occur in the future. During the several months that Ms. Krusemark provided services to STUDENT, this was the only behavioral problem during direct speech therapy. Testimony of Krusemark.

On June 6, 2001, Mrs. MOTHER sent a letter to the District in which she expressed her concern regarding STUDENT’s current program, primarily related to an ongoing teachers strike.(Footnote 9) Mrs. MOTHER also warned that she had already “contacted the Center for Speech Pathology in Davis to do an initial intake of STUDENT and provide services at district expense” unless the District immediately remedied the situation (which apparently required an immediate end to the district-wide teacher’s strike). Mrs. MOTHER also demanded that Ms. Krusemark no longer provide STUDENT with direct speech and language services because of the behavioral incident (that she did not witness and that was immediately addressed by Ms. Martin).

On June 8 and June 12, 2001, STUDENT was assessed by Danielle Shahan at the Center for Speech Pathology. This private assessment was obtained by the Petitioner, upon a referral by the parents’ attorney, Bob Varma.(Footnote 10)

On June 15, 2001, the school year (and STUDENT’s preschool placement) ended at Sheldon.

On July 9, 2001, the school year commenced at Oakbrook School, and STUDENT began regular education kindergarten at this site. The following day, the IEP team met to discuss the current assessments and to discuss STUDENT’s speech and language needs and services. Carol Krusemark, the last direct speech and language service provider who worked with STUDENT, was not present at the meeting because she was on maternity leave. In Ms. Krusemark’s place was another speech and language specialist, Lisa Franklin. The privately obtained assessment from the Center for Speech Pathology was discussed at the hearing, as well as Ms. Krusemark’s assessment. STUDENT’s articulation goal and objectives were reviewed and updated. A goal and corresponding objectives targeting oral motor development were developed. The District’s offer of direct speech and language services was changed to 20 to 60 minutes per week of direct speech therapy (60 minutes each week during “full weeks”) and 10 to 30 minutes each week of consultation services. Mrs. MOTHER did not consent to the IEP.

On July 10, 2001, Mrs. MOTHER wrote another letter to the District in which she summarized her disagreement with the District’s speech and language offer. It read, in pertinent part, as follows:

As stated in today’s IEP, I am disagreeing with the district’s speech and language assessment of STUDENT. I am also disagreeing with the proposed goals and objectives, which were the same as the year before. Although you tried to change the goals and objectives for speech to fit the private assessment, they are still inappropriate. I am also disagreeing with the proposed speech and language therapist, Cathy Deignan. Ms. Deignan lacks the skills, knowledge and training necessary to work with ASD children. At a previous IEP, she stated that she had no idea what discrete trial was and wanted to know if we wanted her to learn how to do it.

I will be placing STUDENT in private speech and language after ten days of notice. I will be seeking district reimbursement for this service and for the assessment done by the Center for Speech Pathology.(Footnote 11)

District’s Exh. 9.

On August 3, 2001, STUDENT was assessed by the Learning Advantage. This private assessment was obtained by the Petitioner.(Footnote 12)

On August 15, 2001, Petitioner requested a due process hearing through the parents’ attorney, Bob Varma.

On October 16, 2001, following mediation, the IEP team met again. The District increased the offer of direct speech and language services to 90 minutes each week “to address language, oral motor, articulation.” The IEP further elaborates that the 30 minutes of weekly speech therapist consultation time would be used “to coordinate services, monitor progress, and consult with all service providers.” STUDENT’s oral motor goals and objectives and articulation goal and objectives were continued and remained unchanged. Mrs. MOTHER did not consent to the IEP.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year with respect to the direct speech therapy component of his educational program?

The issue with regard to the 2000-2001 school year is whether the direct speech therapy component of STUDENT’s program and the corresponding goals and objectives were both procedurally and substantively appropriate. As previously explained, STUDENT began receiving direct speech services to implement only his articulation goal in October 2000; prior to that (from March 2000 to October 2000), STUDENT’s special day class teacher implemented his articulation goal in the special day class setting – Ms. Cruice’s services for that period of time are not at issue.

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be (1) designed to meet the student's unique needs, (2) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (3) conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990). Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.

Were STUDENT’s direct speech services procedurally appropriate?STUDENT alleges that his articulation goals, developed at the March 2000 IEP and revised at the February 2001 IEP, were procedurally inappropriate. Again, the only issue is whether STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives implemented via direct speech therapy were appropriate under Rowley; the parties agreed that the rest of STUDENT’s numerous goals and objectives in the area of speech and language (as well as STUDENT’s other areas of need) that were implemented by other providers were in all respects appropriate. Additionally, it is not disputed that Ms. Cruice’s services, including her work with STUDENT on his articulation goal and objectives from March 2000 to October 2000, were appropriate.

STUDENT’s annual goal that was developed following Ms. Cruice’s assessment at the March 2000 IEP meeting was “STUDENT will produce age appropriate sounds in connected speech.” The corresponding short-term objectives were as follows:

Given pictures/objects and a model, STUDENT will produce the following consonant sequences in one-syllable words: fl, gl, sk, pl, kl, sl, sw with 80% accuracy.

Given pictures/objects and a model, STUDENT will produce the above consonant sequences in 2-3 word phrases with 80% accuracy.

At the February 2001 IEP, STUDENT’s articulation goal and objectives were reviewed and updated. A preformatted goal sheet was used to revise STUDENT’s articulation goal and short-term objectives. The form indicates that STUDENT’s annual goal was “to improve articulation to age or developmentally appropriate levels.” The corresponding short-term objectives were as follows:

Target phoneme/process: [L] in initial. Target date: 2-16-02 Baseline Data: 60% w/ model

Target phoneme/process: consonant sequences fl, gl, pl, kl, sl Target date: 2-16-02 Baseline Data: 0%

District’s Exh. 35.

State law (consistent with the IDEA) requires that an IEP contain, among other things, the present levels of a student’s performance (including how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum) and measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to meeting the student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). The purpose of short-term objectives or benchmarks is to provide a mechanism for a child’s teachers and parents to monitor the child’s progress – or lack thereof – in special education over the course of the year. See 34 C.F.R. § 300, Appendix A to Part 300 of the Federal Regulations.(Footnote 13)

Regarding the March 2000 annual goal and objectives, Petitioner argues that the short-term objectives lack information describing the amount of progress STUDENT was expected to make within specified segments of the year. Petitioner argues that the February 2001 revised goal and objectives lack success criteria and the method of evaluation, and are written on a preformatted goal sheet.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed some of the procedural errors alleged by the Petitioner. With regard to the March 2000 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the articulation goal and objectives, indeed, do not contain specific information about where STUDENT is expected to progress at the three reporting periods during the year, and are therefore procedurally inappropriate. The February 2001 IEP articulation goal and objectives lack required success criteria and the method of evaluation.(Footnote 14)

The next question is whether the procedural violations – lack of specific information about where STUDENT is expected to progress at each reporting period during the year and the failure to include success criteria and the method of evaluation – require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. As developed above, a procedural violation requires a finding that a student has been denied a FAPE if the violation resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or it seriously infringed on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

The evidence established that the procedural errors did not seriously infringe on Mrs. MOTHER’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Mrs. MOTHER was an active member of STUDENT’s IEP team during the relevant time period. She attended multiple IEP team meetings at which STUDENT’s numerous language/communication goals and objectives were discussed.

Moreover (as discussed in more detail below), the procedural errors did not result in loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. STUDENT made meaningful progress on his goals and objectives because of direct services provided by qualified speech specialists during the school year. STUDENT was unable to articulate /l/ as of March 2000, and by May of 2001, STUDENT was able to spontaneously (without a model) articulate the /l/ sound up to 70% of the time, and was consistently “marking” /l/ in blends. Because STUDENT made meaningful progress on his goals and objectives over the course of the period at issue (October 2000 through June 2001) despite the fact that the pertinent objectives did not include information about where STUDENT was supposed to be at each reporting interval during that period, there was no prejudice to STUDENT. Similarly, the failure to include “success criteria” or the “method of evaluation” in the February 2001 revised articulation goal did not result in prejudice to STUDENT because his progress was appropriately documented by Ms. Krusemark on a daily basis in her service log. STUDENT was also assessed by Ms. Krusemark in May 2001. Her articulation-only assessment also tracks STUDENT’s progress.

Because the procedural errors did not seriously infringe on Mrs. MOTHER’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process and did not result in lack of educational opportunity to STUDENT, they did not result in a denial of a FAPE.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that while the articulation goal and objectives that were developed at the March 2000 IEP and revised at the February 2001 IEP team meeting were flawed, the flaws did not seriously infringe on Mrs. MOTHER’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, nor did they result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.

Were STUDENT’s direct speech services substantively appropriate?

The next question is whether STUDENT’s direct speech services were substantively appropriate. As discussed above, in order to be substantively appropriate under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives/direct speech services must have (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (3) conformed to STUDENT’s March 2000 and February 2001 IEPs. Each of these factors will be discussed below.

-Were STUDENT’s direct speech services designed to meet his unique needs?

The first factor to be determined is whether STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 15) STUDENT’s primary allegation is that the assessment administered by Ms. Cruice in March of 2000 identified a significant deficit in the area of the /l/ sound in isolation, and that STUDENT’s IEP did not address the /l/ sound. That assessment revealed that STUDENT was unable to articulate /l/ spontaneously 100% of the time. STUDENT’s articulation goals focused primarily on STUDENT’s use of /l/ in consonant sequences – the short-term objective that was developed was, “given pictures/objects and a model, STUDENT will produce the following consonant sequences in one-syllable words: fl, gl, sk, pl, kl, sl, sw with 80% accuracy.”

Susan Faist, a private speech pathologist, testified that given Ms. Cruice’s assessment in March 2000, she should have drafted a separate short-term objective dealing only with /l/ in isolation. The team actually added a separate objective in February 2001 to address /l/ in isolation. Ms. Cruice testified at length regarding STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives. She explained that it was not necessary to draft a separate short-term objective for /l/ in isolation because a speech specialist who read and implemented the short-term goal regarding /l/ in consonant sequences (or “blends”) would necessarily work on the /l/ sound in isolation.

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Cruice’s testimony persuasive; the short-term objectives developed at the March 2000 IEP meeting were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because they necessarily included development of the /l/ sound in isolation. This conclusion is further supported by the fact that Ms. Cabral, who implemented the short-term objective in question, spent a significant portion of her time with STUDENT working on tongue placement and /l/ in isolation, in addition to /l/ in consonant sequences or blends. Testimony of Cruice and Petitioner’s Exh. 430-431. She did this before STUDENT’s short-term objectives were revised at the February 2001 IEP to specifically include /l/ in the initial.

The Hearing Officer similarly finds that the articulation goal and objectives that were revised at the February 2001 IEP meeting were also designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation needs. They were updated based upon valid information provided both by Ms. Cruice, who had implemented the previous articulation goal from March 2000 to October 2000, and by STUDENT’s initial direct service provider, who worked with STUDENT from October 2000 to February 2001, two times each week. Ms. Cabral kept a student service log that kept track of her work with STUDENT. Before she left the District, from the information she collected and her twice-weekly observations of STUDENT, she prepared a report. In that report, she describes STUDENT’s progress on his articulation short-term objectives. On the basis of her report, the team – which included Ms. Cruice and Ms. Deignan, two speech pathologists – revised STUDENT’s articulation objectives to reflect STUDENT’s progress. Consonant sequences without /l/ were eliminated, and only /l/ blends were identified, and /l/ in isolation– specifically at the beginning of words – was identified as a separate objective. Non-/l/ blends were eliminated based on Ms. Cruice’s data from the previous June.(Footnote 16) The IEP team properly reviewed existing data, appropriately revised STUDENT’s short-term objectives, and developed adequate articulation short-term objectives that were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives were designed to meet his unique needs.

-Were STUDENT’s direct speech services reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

The next question is whether STUDENT’s direct speech services during the 2000-2001 school year were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Again, the frequency and duration of STUDENT’s direct speech services are not at issue.

Petitioner generally argues that STUDENT failed to show sufficient progress for the approximately 14-month period beginning in March 2000, when an articulation goal was first added to STUDENT’s extensive program.

The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s assertion that STUDENT made no progress during the period in question is incorrect – STUDENT made meaningful progress in the area of articulation, specifically, and intelligibility, generally. STUDENT was not able to produce the /l/ sound without a model as of March 2000 in isolation or in blends, nor was he able to “mark” the /l/ sound in blends.(Footnote 17) Testimony of Cruice. Ms. Cabral’s data and her report reveal that STUDENT made slow but steady progress – he was able to produce “[l] in initial words 60% of the time with tactile visual, and auditory stimulation.” STUDENT was able to spontaneously (without a model) produce the /l/ sound over 70 percent of the time after working with Ms. Krusemark from February 2001 to May 2001 (although her data reveal a great amount of variability in STUDENT’s performance from session to session, this is common with autistic students). Testimony of Krusemark. Ms. Krusemark’s assessment on May 16, 2001, showed that STUDENT had made progress on /l/ blends – she found that he had consistently “marked” the /l/ in /l/ blends. Both private assessments obtained by the parents in 2001 indicated that STUDENT was marking /l/ blends, showing progress in this emerging area of need.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s direct speech services were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

-Did STUDENT’s direct speech services comport with his IEPs?

The next question is whether STUDENT’s direct speech services comported with the March 2000 and February 2001 IEPs. The Hearing Officer finds, based on the great weight of the evidence, that STUDENT’s program did comport with his IEPs. The student service logs kept by Ms. Cabral and Ms. Krusemark establish that both speech specialists implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives during the period at issue, including short-term objectives regarding STUDENT’s use of /l/ blends and /l/ in isolation. All of the Petitioner’s arguments in that regard are unavailing.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s direct services were appropriate. While there were procedural problems with his goals and objectives, those procedural flaws did not result in prejudice to STUDENT. Because STUDENT’s direct speech services were designed to meet his unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his IEPs, the District provided STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 school year.

ISSUE NO. 2: Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year with respect to the offer of services to address his articulation and oral motor needs?

STUDENT disputes the appropriateness of the speech and language services offered by the District in the July 2001 IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. Only STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor goals and objectives were at issue; the Petitioner stipulated that all of STUDENT’s other goals and objectives were appropriate.

As discussed above, to be substantively appropriate under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, STUDENT’s IEP must have (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation and oral motor needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP.

Was the July 2001 IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation and oral motor needs?

The first question is whether the July 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation and oral motor needs. In regard to STUDENT’s articulation needs, the articulation annual goal remained the same: “to improve articulation to age or developmentally appropriate levels.” The /l/ in the initial, medial and final position in words were all identified at the top of the preformatted goal sheet; these apparently are to be read in conjunction with STUDENT’s annual goal, i.e., STUDENT’s annual goal was to improve articulation to age or developmentally appropriate levels with regard to /l/ in the initial, medial and final position in words. The corresponding short-term objectives were as follows:

Target phoneme/process: spontaneous /l/ in isolation 100% accuracy. Baseline data: unknown.

Target phoneme/process: spontaneous /l/ initial position in words. 80% accuracy. Baseline data: 60% w/ model.

Target phoneme/process: spontaneous /l/ final position in words 80% accuracy. Baseline data: unknown.

Target phoneme/process: spontaneous /l/ medial position in words 80% accuracy. Baseline data: unknown.

District’s Exh. 10.

In the area of oral motor, a goal and corresponding objectives were also developed based on the parents’ privately obtained assessment. District’s Exhs. 10 and 17. The long-term goal was “STUDENT will improve oral motor skills to strengthen the articulators and improve intelligibility.” The team also drafted short-term objectives in relation to STUDENT’s production of vowel sounds in words. Those short-term objectives called for STUDENT to produce vowel sounds in words with a model 80% of the time in the therapy setting, and then spontaneously 80% of the time in the therapy setting. The purported “present level of performance” was that STUDENT displays “decreased lip strength, decreased rounding and protrusion” and “decreased accuracy for rapid tongue movements.”(Footnote 18)

With regard to STUDENT’s articulation goal and objectives, Petitioner alleges (in pertinent part) that there are no baseline data in three of the objectives and that on another, the baseline information is inaccurate. There is also no statement regarding STUDENT’s present level of performance, according to Petitioner. Finally, Petitioner alleges that STUDENT’s present levels of performance on his newly proposed oral motor goal are not measurable and are not correlated with his short-term objectives.

As discussed above, State law (consistent with the IDEA) requires that an IEP contain, among other things, the present levels of a student’s performance and measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to meeting the student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a).

The Hearing Officer finds that the July 2001 IEP is not designed to meet STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor needs because the IEP lacks valid present levels of performance in those areas. As discussed above, State law and the IDEA require that an IEP include present levels of performance – this information is necessary to determine whether STUDENT is making progress towards his objectives, and ultimately, his annual goal. The corresponding goals and objectives are similarly not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. All but one of STUDENT’s articulation objectives lack a baseline. The single articulation objective with a baseline is not indicative of where STUDENT was as of July 2001; on the objective “/l/ initial position in words,” the IEP reflects “60% w/ model.” This baseline was carried forward from the February 2001 IEP and was not updated with current information.(Footnote 19) The proposed oral motor goal and objectives are inadequate and are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because there is no baseline information and therefore no way to gauge STUDENT’s progress on his short-term objectives.(Footnote 20)

Because the July 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor needs, STUDENT’s IEP was not appropriate – it failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in those two narrow areas.(Footnote 21) Therefore, it is not necessary to determine whether the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, or whether STUDENT’s services comported with his IEP.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the July 2001 IEP, in the area of articulation and oral motor only, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique articulation and oral motor needs. As such, the IEP failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE with regard to his articulation and oral motor needs.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is Kathleen Deignan appropriately qualified to provide speech and language services to STUDENT?

Petitioner refused all speech and language service from the District after the July 10, 2001 IEP team meeting. Part of the District’s offer in that regard was for the speech and language specialist, specifically identified as Kathleen Deignan, to provide direct speech and language services to STUDENT for a total of 20-60 minutes each week (60 minutes each full, non-holiday week) to implement STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor goals. Ms. Deignan was also to provide STUDENT’s educational team with 10-30 minutes a week of consultation time. During this consultation time Ms. Deignan was to generally consult with the rest of STUDENT’s educational team about their implementation of STUDENT’s other speech and language goals. Testimony of Deignan.

Petitioner generally alleges that Ms. Deignan is not appropriately qualified, in large part, because she was not readily familiar with the term “discrete trial training” at an IEP meeting in the spring of 2001. Ms. Deignan testified that while she was not familiar with the term, she was familiar with the concept. She further explained that she has used discrete-trial-like methods when she has provided direct services to other students she has served.

Ms. Deignan testified at length regarding her credentials and her continuing education and experience that qualify her to work with autistic students like STUDENT. Ms. Deignan has a bachelor’s degree in communicative disorders, has completed over 75 units of graduate work, and holds a “clear life” credential as a speech and language specialist. She has worked as a speech and language specialist for over thirty years, implementing goals and objectives in all areas of need, including syntax, semantics, pragmatics, oral-motor and articulation (STUDENT’s areas of need in the language/communication service area). She has attended numerous workshops over the years, many related specifically to the provision of services to children with autism. District’s Exh. 62. Ms. Deignan also described recent experience serving children with autism.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Deignan, because of her considerable experience and appropriate education, is adequately qualified to provide direct speech and language services to STUDENT, as well as consultation services to the rest of STUDENT’s educational team.

ISSUE NO. 4 (a): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by the Center for Speech Pathology?

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the speech and language evaluation that was obtained from CSP. Pursuant to State and federal law, a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the local educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b).

The District argues that reimbursement should not be awarded because (1) its assessment was appropriate, (2) the parents did not seek the independent assessment because they “disagreed” with the District’s assessment, and (3) the independent assessment’s validity was not established.(Footnote 22)

The evidence established that Mrs. MOTHER asked for a comprehensive assessment at an IEP meeting and that she generally disagreed with the District’s proposed articulation-only assessment. Testimony of MOTHER. The District members of the IEP team essentially talked Mrs. MOTHER out of a comprehensive speech and language assessment; they explained that it was not necessary because STUDENT was being assessed on an ongoing basis by all members of his educational team. The evidence also established that STUDENT should have been assessed in the area of oral motor functioning – the assessment performed by the CSP was used by the District members of the IEP team in July 2001 to develop a new oral motor goal and corresponding objectives. The assessment performed by CSP addressed STUDENT’s oral motor functioning, an area in which the District had never assessed STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that Mrs. MOTHER is entitled to reimbursement for the CSP assessment because Mrs. MOTHER requested a comprehensive assessment, the District failed to assess STUDENT’s oral motor needs, and the assessment procured by Mrs. MOTHER addressed STUDENT’s oral motor functioning.

ISSUE NO. 4 (b): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language services provided by the Center for Speech Pathology from July 2000 to the date of this decision?

STUDENT seeks reimbursement for the speech and language services obtained from the Center for Speech Pathology. STUDENT began receiving services, one time each week, forty-five minutes per session, shortly after the July 10, 2001 IEP meeting.

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court’s decision in Burlington:

The rationale behind Burlington’s holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an “empty victory.” [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if “appropriate relief” in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, “the child’s right to a free appropriate public education, the parent’s right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.” [Footnote omitted.]

Id. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.

As developed above, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE with regard to STUDENT’s articulation and oral motor needs during the 2001-2002 school year. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement (and other relief, if appropriate) for the private services they obtained from CSP if those services were appropriate.

The District argues that STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement because there was no evidence presented at the hearing that CSP is a certified nonpublic agency, because CSP failed to consult and coordinate its services with the District, and because the CSP failed to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of articulation. None of the District’s arguments are availing.

First, there is no requirement under the law that private services for which a parent seeks reimbursement must be provided by a State-certified nonpublic agency. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993). In any event, CSP is a State-certified nonpublic agency, according to the State’s official website.(Footnote 23) Second, there is no requirement under the law that the CSP’s failure to coordinate its services with the District operates as a bar to reimbursement, even though all agree that coordination would have been ideal for STUDENT.

Third, the Hearing Officer finds that the services provided by the CSP were appropriate in that they addressed STUDENT’s oral motor and articulation needs. Susan Faist, the director of the program (who testified that CSP is a State-certified nonpublic agency) explained that CSP developed and sought to implement goals based on its assessment (all of them could not be implemented because STUDENT’s parents could only afford to pay for one forty-five minute session each week). Ms. Faist testified that STUDENT has made progress in the area of oral motor in the time that he has been served by the CSP. Ms. Faist’s testimony in that regard was not seriously disputed. The Petitioner is therefore entitled to reimbursement for the services he obtained from CSP up to the date of this decision.

In sum, because the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year in the area of articulation and oral motor functioning only, and STUDENT received appropriate services from a State-certified nonpublic agency that partially addressed those areas, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for those services.

ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e) (1991) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). On the basis of the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id.

With regard to the 2000-2001 school year, because it has been determined above that the District actually provided STUDENT with a FAPE with regard to his direct speech services during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory services – there is nothing to recompense. Petitioner’s request for compensatory education for a FAPE denial during the 2000-2001 school year is therefore denied.

With regard to the present (2001-2002) school year, as discussed above, STUDENT’s July 2001 IEP failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in only two narrow areas within the language/communication sphere: articulation and oral motor. Petitioner obtained private services from CSP for which he will be reimbursed, as discussed above. The rest of STUDENT’s comprehensive program offered by the District was appropriate, including numerous other language/communication goals and objectives. Petitioner wrongfully rejected these other language/communication services because Petitioner incorrectly believed that Ms. Deignan was not appropriately qualified to provide services to STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory language/communication services for the 2001-2002 school year. First, Petitioner incorrectly refused all appropriate language/communication services. Second, he has received private services (for which he will now be reimbursed) that addressed the area in which the District’s offer was deficient. Under these circumstances, no compensatory services are warranted.(Footnote 24)

ORDER

1. Within 30 calendar days after receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the MOTHERs for the cost of the CSP assessment and all of the CSP speech services up to the date of this decision (but not to exceed the cost of one 45-minute session during every school week).

2. Within 20 calendar days of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting. The District shall invite to the meeting a representative from CSP, who shall be paid a reasonable rate for his or her time. The CSP representative shall be sufficiently knowledgeable about the specific services provided by CSP since July 2001, and STUDENT’s progress, such that STUDENT’s speech and language goals and objectives can be updated, as needed. The District is not required to contract with CSP to provide future language/communication services to STUDENT. STUDENT’s IEP shall be updated to conform with the findings made in this Decision and shall include, at a minimum, the following characteristics:

a. Updated, appropriate articulation and oral motor goals and objectives, which shall include accurate statements regarding STUDENT’s baseline and appropriate measurable short-term objectives or benchmarks. STUDENT’s other language/communication goals and objectives shall be updated, if needed.

3. All Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year with respect to the direct speech therapy component of his educational program? -The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Has the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year with respect to the offer of services to address his articulation and oral motor needs? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Is Kathleen Deignan appropriately qualified to provide speech and language services to STUDENT? -The District prevailed on this issue.

4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following:

a. the assessment conducted by the Center for Speech Pathology? -The Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.

b. the speech and language services provided by the Center for Speech Pathology from July 2000 to the date of this decision? -The Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

-The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date:

Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion held on the first hearing day. 2. The instructional aid, supervised by Ms. Martin, also worked on STUDENT’s language/communication goals. 3. The IEP reflects that STUDENT would have increasing mainstreaming opportunities with the ultimate goal of integration. This was achieved; STUDENT is now fully integrated into the regular education setting at his new school (with substantial supports, including a 1:1 aide). 4. Stephanie Martin has, since 1999, served STUDENT by providing behavior support and training across environments, curricular adaptation and modification, and oversight of STUDENT’s instructional assistant. 5. Prior to the meeting, Ms. Cruice, Mrs. MOTHER and Ms. Martin met to “informally review progress, prioritize needed skills, and to draft new objectives.” They had also met before earlier IEPs. District’s Exh. 35.Ms. Cabral did not attend the meeting, because she was no longer providing services to STUDENT and had left the District. However, two speech and language pathologists, Kathleen Cruice and Kathleen Deignan, were in attendance, and the IEP team did have the benefit of Ms. Cabral’s report as well as Ms. Cruice’s experiences working with STUDENT and her discussions with Ms. Cabral. Kathy Deignan was in attendance because it was anticipated that she would provide STUDENT with speech services during the 2001-2002 school year, when STUDENT transitioned to a full inclusion program at his home school, Oakbrook. 6. Ms. Cabral did not attend the meeting, because she was no longer providing services to STUDENT and had left the District. However, two speech and language pathologists, Kathleen Cruice and Kathleen Deignan, were in attendance, and the IEP team did have the benefit of Ms. Cabral’s report as well as Ms. Cruice’s experiences working with STUDENT and her discussions with Ms. Cabral. Kathy Deignan was in attendance because it was anticipated that she would provide STUDENT with speech services during the 2001-2002 school year, when STUDENT transitioned to a full inclusion program at his home school, Oakbrook. 7. Ms. Krusemark’s student service log reflects that the first time she provided direct speech and language services to STUDENT was on February 26, 2001. 8. The IEP reflects that speech and language services related to articulation, along with consultation services, were added to the IEP and accepted by the parent. 9. One of Ms. MOTHER’s concerns was that STUDENT was not receiving the speech and language services from his special day class teacher, Kathy Cruice. She states that STUDENT had been receiving “more than one hour of time” of speech services in Ms. Cruice’s class Monday through Thursday. Kathy Cruice was no longer providing services to STUDENT because she was on strike. The Hearing Officer notes that these services were not at issue in the present hearing. 10. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for this privately obtained assessment. 11. As described above, Mrs. MOTHER, upon the recommendation of her attorney, had already obtained the assessment from the Center for Speech Pathology at this point. 12. Petitioner is not seeking reimbursement for this privately obtained assessment 13. Appendix A of the regulations accompanying the new Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400-1485, regarding the purpose of annual goals and short-term objectives (or benchmarks), states as follows:

Each annual goal must include either short-term objectives or benchmarks. The purpose of both is to enable a child’s teacher(s), parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP, to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward achievement of the annual goal. 14. Petitioner’s other arguments with regard to the February 2001 IEP are unavailing. Nothing prevents a District from using pre-formatted goal sheets, as long as they are appropriately individualized. Moreover, the IEP contains present levels of performance. 15. It was not disputed that both the amount and frequency of direct speech services provided by Ms. Cabral and Ms. Krusemark from October 2000 through June 2001 was appropriate. 16. Although that data also indicate that STUDENT’s had met his goal with regard to the blend /sl/, Ms. Cruice explained that had not met this objective at that time. In any event, her work with STUDENT from March to October 2000, as previously explained, was not at issue in the present hearing. 17. “Marking” occurs when a student replaces a sound with another incorrect sound in a blend. For instance, in the consonant blend “bl” as in the word “blend,” a student may “mark” the /l/ sound with a /w/ sound, thus mispronouncing the word “blend”as “bwend.” If the same student completely omitted /l/, as was the case with STUDENT in March 2000, he or she would pronounce the word “bend.” Marking is an improvement over outright omission, according to the testimony of Ms. Cruice and Ms. Krusemark. 18. This information came directly from the CSP assessment report. 19. Updated information was available. Ms. Krusemark, who was not in attendance, had recently assessed STUDENT and she had provided services to STUDENT for several months, as discussed earlier in this decision. Additionally, STUDENT’s parent had obtained a private assessment that contained information. 20. Moreover, what are described as short-term objectives are really annual goals. They are not “benchmarks,” as the District asserts, because there is no indication where STUDENT is supposed to be at each of the three identified reporting intervals. The purported short-term objectives also do not appear to be closely related to the long-term goal, “to improve oral motor skills,” because they involve only the production of vowel sounds. Testimony of Faist. 21. As held above, during the previous year, the procedural errors in STUDENT’s articulation goals and objectives did not actually result in prejudice to STUDENT and therefore did not deny STUDENT a FAPE in the area of articulation. In contrast, for the current year, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in the areas of articulation and oral motor skills. The goals and objectives in those two areas were not appropriate and there were no present levels of performance. Faced with an IEP that failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in the areas of articulation and oral motor skills, Mrs. MOTHER was not required to accept the District’s speech services related to those two areas. 22. Petitioner was not required under the law to establish that his privately obtained assessment was valid. 23. The State Department of Education maintains a website and an interactive data base where certified non-public schools and agencies are listed. CSP is listed as a certified non-public agency. See, http://www2.otan.dni.us/npsa/npsa_search.taf. 24. Petitioner also requested as compensatory relief that the District be required to contract with CSP to provide STUDENT with prospective language/communication services. While nothing prevents the District from contracting with a State-certified NPA such as CSP if it so chooses, such an order is not warranted nor necessary in thepresent case; the District has provided STUDENT witth an otherwise comprehensive and successful program.