California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 23, 2003

Pasadena Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1832-03 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour

Pasadena Unified's blended inclusion preschool offer for a four-year-old with autism upheld; District may implement the IEP.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions an earlier SEHO decision dated March 24, 2003, between the same parties, and a stay put order keeping the CARD home program in place while this case was pending.

Summary

Pasadena Unified School District asked for a hearing to confirm that its June 11, 2003 IEP offer gave a four-and-a-half-year-old girl with autism a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for 2003-2004. The offer was clarified in a July 17, 2003 letter. The student was in a 40-hour-per-week home discrete trial therapy program run by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). She also attended a private regular preschool part-time. The District offered a blended inclusion preschool class at Allendale Elementary with 12 typical peers and 5 children with disabilities, plus general and special education teachers and aides. Services included speech-language therapy, OT monitoring, daily floortime, a transition aide for the first semester, and ABA supervision.

The parents represented themselves and raised five procedural claims. Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour rejected all five. She found the parents understood that Allendale was offered and that the team included proper general and special education teachers. The District had no duty to invite private providers or share reports before the meeting. The law also did not require the IEP to name the floortime provider. On substance, she found the present levels and goals appropriate and the program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Neither the home program nor a regular class with only an aide was the LRE. The District may implement the IEP and must place the student within 30 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case for a preschooler moving from an intensive home ABA program to school. It held that a clarification letter can make an offer clear under Union v. Smith. It also held that a blended inclusion class can be the LRE when a regular class with only an aide would not give enough support.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District make a clear written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?

    The IEP and the July 17, 2003 clarification letter clearly offered the Allendale blended inclusion preschool class, and the parents' own testimony showed they understood the offer.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2. Did the District invite the appropriate regular education and special education teachers to the IEP meeting?

    Kristin Enriquez attended as the special education teacher and Mirell O'Brien, who holds general and special education credentials, attended as the regular education teacher, so the team was properly made up.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to invite STUDENT's current service providers to the IEP meeting?

    Shapiro did not require inviting a private preschool teacher who had seen the child only two or three times; not inviting the private speech therapist caused no harm because her recommendations were adopted; and the parents could have invited CARD staff themselves.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to provide copies of assessments, progress reports, and proposed goals and objectives to her parents prior to the IEP meeting?

    No law required giving these documents before the meeting; the parents received the reports at the meeting and the IEP shortly afterward.

  5. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 5. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to identify the provider for its proposed floortime program at the IEP meeting?

    Education Code section 56345(a) requires the IEP to state the services offered but not the name of the person who will provide them.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue a. Was the District's proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique individual needs? (including the parents' challenge to present levels of performance and goals)

    The language-rich blended inclusion class, speech-language therapy, floortime, OT monitoring, transition DTT aide and ABA supervision addressed her social, language and communication needs, and the present levels and ten goals were appropriate.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue b. Was the District's proposed placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit under Rowley.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue c. Did the District's proposed placement comport with STUDENT's IEP?

    It was undisputed that the District was willing to provide the placement, services and goals in the June 2003 IEP.

  9. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue d. Did the District's proposed placement provide STUDENT education in the LRE?

    Neither the home DTT program nor a regular preschool class with only a one-on-one aide was the LRE; the blended inclusion class gave access to typical peers along with the special education supports she needed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District is entitled to place the student in the preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale Elementary School with the related services listed in the June 11, 2003 IEP.
  • Placement ordered. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the District shall place the student in the Allendale preschool blended inclusion classroom, with all related services, under the June 11, 2003 IEP.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Honig v. Doe; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Alyson Beecher, District program specialist; District designated administrator at the IEP meeting; wrote the July 17, 2003 clarification letter, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Nora D'Angiola, District speech/language/hearing specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Lisa Agajanian, District child development specialist (floortime provider), Pasadena Unified School District
  • Lisa Serby, District occupational therapist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Debra Holland, District preschool special education teacher, Allendale blended inclusion class, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Valentin Sanchez, District preschool regular education teacher, Allendale blended inclusion class, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Kristin Enriquez, District autism specialist and inclusion support provider; special education teacher at the IEP meeting, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Joan Madden, District school nurse, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Mirell O'Brien, District resource specialist; regular education teacher at the IEP meeting, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Rita Snell, District physical therapist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • William Bernhardt, District school psychologist; proposed ABA supervisor, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Hope Hendricks-Bacon, Private (nonpublic agency) speech-language therapist, Nonpublic agency
  • Shelli Lewis-Gonzales, Counsel for student at the June 11, 2003 IEP meeting (did not appear at hearing)
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Private agency providing home-based DTT/ABA program
  • Lanterman Regional Center, Regional center that assessed the student
  • Center for Developing Kids, Private occupational therapy provider
  • Westminster Children's Center, Nonpublic preschool the student attended earlier
  • Pasadena Progressive Montessori School, Private regular education preschool
  • Lake Avenue Church School, Private regular education preschool

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Pasadena, California, on November 12, 13, 14, and 18, 2003.

Petitioner Pasadena Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Alexa Jackowski of the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was Alyson Beecher, District program specialist. Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. (Footnote 1)

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Nora D’Angiola, District speech/language/hearing specialist; Lisa Agajanian, District child development specialist; Lisa Serby, District occupational therapist; Debra Holland, District preschool special education teacher; Kristin Enriquez, District autism specialist and inclusion support provider; Joan Madden, District school nurse; Alyson Beecher, District program specialist; Mirell O’Brien, District resource specialist; Rita Snell, District physical therapist; William Bernhardt, District school psychologist; and Valentin Sanchez, District preschool regular education teacher.

Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, and FATHER, STUDENT’s father.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the District’s brief on December 8, 2003, and Student’s brief on December 10, 2003, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year at an individualized education program (IEP) meeting held on June 11, 2003, and clarified in a letter dated July 17, 2003?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four-and-one-half-year-old child who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. She lives within the boundaries of the District with her parents and younger sister.

When STUDENT was thirteen months of age, her parents began to notice that she was no longer developing appropriately. According to her parents, STUDENT did not notice other people, did not respond to her mother, became isolated, did not maintain eye contact, was unable to use or understand language, and had tantrums. In July 2001, when STUDENT was two years old, her parents contacted Lanterman Regional Center (Regional Center) to request services to address STUDENT’s continuing developmental delays. A Regional Center psychologist assessed STUDENT and diagnosed her with pervasive developmental disorder. The Regional Center also assessed STUDENT in the areas of occupational therapy (OT) and speech and language.

Following the Regional Center assessments, STUDENT began to receive OT at the Center for Developing Kids because of deficits in her tactile, vestibular, proprioceptive, and auditory systems. At the same time, she began to attend Westminster Children’s Center, a nonpublic preschool, five days per week, and to receive speech and language services with a nonpublic speech and language therapist.

After two months of attending Westminster Children’s Center, STUDENT’s parents withdrew her from school because they felt that she was not benefiting from the program. They had also recently learned of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) and contacted that agency for an assessment. In October 2001, CARD assessed STUDENT, found her eligible for services on the basis of a diagnosis of autistic disorder, and recommended a fifteen- to twenty-hour-per-week home-based program.

Thereafter, in February 2002, STUDENT began a home-based, one-on-one discrete trial therapy (DTT) program with CARD for fifteen hours per week. By June 2002, CARD had increased STUDENT’s home program to forty hours per week, although during some weeks she received fewer than forty hours. She also continued to receive weekly OT and speech and language services.

In April 2002, shortly before STUDENT’s third birthday, STUDENT’s parents contacted the District to request educational services for her. The District performed a preschool psychoeducational assessment to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services. STUDENT scored in the mild to moderate range on the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, and the assessment team agreed that she exhibited qualitative impairments in social interaction, communication, and repetitive and stereotypic behaviors consistent with a diagnosis of autism.

On June 12, 2002, following this assessment, the District convened an IEP team meeting to discuss the assessment findings and recommendations. In addition to both parents, a District psychological consultant, a District resource specialist, a District speech/language/hearing specialist, a District school nurse, a District occupational therapist, STUDENT’s Regional Center representative, STUDENT’s CARD clinical supervisor, STUDENT’s CARD case supervisor, and STUDENT’s nonpublic speech and language therapist attended the meeting. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT met the eligibility requirements for special education and related services on the basis of her diagnosis of autism. The District members of the team then recommended ten hours per week of school-based DTT services in a District sensory motor special day class (SDC), twice weekly District-based individual and small group speech and language services, twice weekly District-based OT services, and weekly OT services with a nonpublic agency (NPA). The IEP team also developed goals and objectives in the areas of pragmatics, receptive/expressive language, articulation, cognitive, general knowledge, emotion/behavior, play, social, self-help, fine motor, organization of behavior, and safety/awareness.

The parents did not consent to the proposed placement or related services and on July 9, 2002, submitted a written disagreement to the proposed IEP. The parents indicated that they disagreed with the proposed goals and objectives, the proposed classroom placement, the amount of DTT services, the use of a District DTT provider, and the amount of speech and language services. As a result of their disagreement with the District’s offer, the parents continued to provide STUDENT with her home-based DTT program with CARD. In August 2002, both parties requested due process hearings with the Hearing Office to seek a determination of the appropriateness of the District’s offer.

On December 4, 2002, one week before the consolidated due process hearing was scheduled to begin, the District convened an additional IEP meeting. The purpose of the meeting was to modify the District’s recommended classroom placement because the parents had recently informed the District that STUDENT’s present levels of performance had changed since the IEP meeting held in June 2002. A District principal, program specialist, preschool teacher, counsel, occupational therapist, and school psychologist attended the meeting. Neither STUDENT’s parents nor her counsel attended the meeting. At the meeting, the District recommended placement in a blended inclusion preschool classroom at its Allendale Elementary School (Allendale).

Thereafter, a hearing convened in December 2002 and January 2003 regarding the appropriateness of both the June 2002 and December 2002 District offers. On March 24, 2003, the Hearing Office issued a Decision, finding that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE from the time of the IEP meeting on June 12, 2002, through the second IEP meeting date of December 4, 2002. However, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer of December 4, 2002, was not appropriate because the District had failed to assess STUDENT’s needs prior to its recommendation of placement in a blended inclusion classroom. The Hearing Officer thus concluded that STUDENT was entitled to District-paid placement in her home-based CARD program from December 4, 2002, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year. Following the Hearing Office Decision, STUDENT continued in her CARD program and continued to receive private speech and language services.

In May and June 2003, the District again conducted a battery of psychoeducational assessments of STUDENT to determine placement and services for the upcoming 2003-2004 school year. This transdisciplinary assessment included an observation of STUDENT’s home-based DTT program as well as cognitive, language and communication, sensory-motor, social/emotional and play, and self-help assessments. The District assessors concluded that STUDENT was a visual learner, was below age level in receptive and expressive language, exhibited sensory seeking and avoidance behaviors, was below age level in social and socialization domains, was below age level in communication, and was below age level in the daily living skills domain.

At the same time that the District was conducting its assessment, STUDENT’s parents placed her in a regular education preschool classroom at Pasadena Progressive Montessori School. STUDENT attended school two mornings per week accompanied by a one-on-one aide from CARD.

On June 11, 2003, following its assessments, the District again convened an IEP meeting to discuss placement and services for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. In addition to both parents, the following people attended the meeting: Alyson Beecher, District program specialist; Kristin Enriquez, District autism specialist and inclusion support provider; Mirell O’Brien, District resource specialist; Rita Snell, District physical therapist; Joan Madden, District school nurse; William Bernhardt, District school psychologist; Lisa Serby, District occupational therapist; Nora D’Angiola, District speech/language/hearing specialist; Shelli Lewis-Gonzales, counsel for STUDENT; and Alexa Jackowski, District counsel.

The team members again agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services due to her diagnosis of autism. The District members of the IEP team then offered STUDENT the following designated instruction and services: two sixty-minute per week individual speech and language sessions by an NPA provider, one thirty-minute per week small group speech and language session by a District provider, thirty minutes per week of “direct/monitor” OT services by a District provider, one sixty-minute per day session of floortime services by a District provider, six sixty-minute sessions per month of applied behavior analysis (ABA) supervision by a District provider for the first semester, four sixty-minute sessions per month of ABA supervision for the remainder of the school year, and a transition DTT aide in the classroom for the first semester to help STUDENT transition from her home-based to school-based program. (Footnote 2)

With regard to classroom placement, the team discussed the District’s various preschool blended inclusion classrooms. (Footnote 3) The IEP states, “Allendale PK Blended Inclusion site was recommended by PUSD team (which is a strongly language-based classroom with an emphasis also on early literacy).” The District members of the IEP team also developed ten goals and objectives in the areas of socialization, classroom readiness, auditory processing/receptive language, speech and articulation, expressive language and speech, and pragmatics and social communication. At the conclusion of the meeting, the parents advised the District that they would review the IEP document at home and submit written comments within one to two weeks.

On June 26, 2003, STUDENT’s parents sent the District a document entitled, “Comments and Disagreement to IEP for STUDENT - June 11, 2003.” The parents stated that they disagreed with the proposed IEP because: it was improper for Ms. Enriquez to attend the meeting as both the regular education and special education teacher; the District had failed to invite STUDENT’s current service providers to the meeting; the District failed to provide the parents with copies of assessment reports, goals and objectives, and a speech and language progress report prior to the meeting; the present levels of performance and goals and objectives were not appropriate for STUDENT; and some of the statements and findings in the assessment reports were not correct. The parents also stated that they objected to the proposed placement because the District had not offered a specific classroom and had not identified the floortime provider.

On July 17, 2003, Ms. Beecher sent the parents a letter to “supplement and clarify” the IEP developed at the meeting on June 11, 2003. Ms. Beecher stated in her letter that the District’s offer included placement in the blended inclusion general education preschool classroom at Allendale, individual clinic-based speech and language services to be provided by an NPA for two sixty-minute sessions per week, small group school-based speech and language services to be provided by a District speech pathologist for one thirty-minute session per week, direct monitoring school-based OT services to be provided by a District occupational therapist for thirty-minutes per week, school-based floortime services to be provided by a District floortime specialist for one sixty-minute session per day, a District aide trained in DTT methodology to be placed in the blended inclusion classroom for the first semester to assist STUDENT with the transition from a home-based to a school-based program, and school-based supervision of STUDENT’s ABA services and DTT aide by a District supervisor. (Footnote 4) The parents did not respond to Ms. Beecher’s letter and did not sign and return the IEP to the District.

On August 25, 2003, the District filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. (Footnote 5) The District seeks a determination that the program that it offered STUDENT at the IEP meeting on June 11, 2003, as clarified in the letter from Ms. Beecher dated July 17, 2003, offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE.

In September 2003, STUDENT’s parents removed her from Pasadena Progressive Montessori School and placed her at Lake Avenue Church School (Lake Avenue). She currently attends Lake Avenue three mornings per week in a regular education preschool classroom. She also continues to receive home-based DTT services from CARD pursuant to a stay put Order from the Hearing Office and twice weekly speech and language services from a nonpublic speech and language specialist.

CONTENTIONS

The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year at an IEP meeting held on June 11, 2003, as clarified in its letter dated July 17, 2003.

STUDENT disagrees that the District offered her a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year at either the IEP meeting held on June 11, 2003, or in its letter dated July 17, 2003. She contends that the District’s offer was not appropriate because of the following alleged procedural violations of special education law: 1) the District failed to specify the classroom that it offered STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year; 2) the District failed to invite the appropriate general education and special education teachers to the IEP meeting; 3) the District failed to invite STUDENT’s current service providers to the IEP meeting; 4) the District failed to provide copies of assessments, progress reports, and proposed goals and objectives to her parents prior to the IEP meeting; and 5) the District failed to identify the provider for its proposed floortime program. In addition, STUDENT contends that the District’s proposed placement was substantively flawed because the District relied upon incorrect present levels of performance, developed inappropriate goals and objectives, and failed to offer her a placement in the LRE. (Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 school year at an individualized education program meeting held on June 11, 2003, and clarified in a letter dated July 17, 2003?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian; meet the standards of the State educational agency; include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education; and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).

Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir.1988). The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988). The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. Id.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir.1996). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir.1997).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir.1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir.1990).

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE is generally twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.

PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS

1. Did the District make a clear written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?

A procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir.1994), cert den., 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). As the Ninth Circuit stated in Union, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.”

The Union court further explained that a formal, written offer alerts the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement is appropriate under the IDEA, would allow the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services,” and would help the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Id. at 1526.

STUDENT argues that the District’s proposed offer of placement in her IEP of June 2003 violated her procedural rights because it was not a clear, written offer of placement in accordance with the requirements of Union and Rowley. According to STUDENT, the District’s offer was improper because the District allegedly discussed several preschool blended inclusion programs at the IEP meeting but did not specify which classroom it was offering STUDENT. However, a review of the evidence reveals that the District proposed a clear, written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year, and that the parents understood and rejected the proposed placement.

As discussed previously, the District convened an IEP meeting on June 11, 2003, to discuss STUDENT’s proposed program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year. Both of STUDENT’s parents and STUDENT’s counsel attended the meeting. In addition to background information regarding STUDENT and her parents, the seventeen-page IEP document contains a discussion of her eligibility for special education and related services, proposed designated instruction and services, a discussion of goals achieved from her IEP from the previous year, a discussion of program options, ten goals and objectives, methods of reporting progress toward goals, a discussion of her medical condition, a discussion of accommodations and modifications, and six pages of “additional information.” Included within the “additional information” is a discussion of each assessor’s report to the team, a discussion of questions or concerns raised by the parents and STUDENT’s counsel, a discussion of the goals and objectives, an overview of the services offered, and a discussion of the reason for the District team members’ rejection of a home-based DTT program for STUDENT.

On page 2B, the IEP states that the parties considered a general education class, designated instruction and services, resource specialist program, and an SDC, and that the District recommended a blended inclusion prekindergarten classroom at Allendale. On page 6D, the IEP states:

Placement options were discussed. Alyson said the team is looking at a Blended Inclusion setting (12 typically developing children & 5 special needs children, with Regular Ed & Special Ed teachers & special ed aide). Kristen discussed General Ed classroom placement saying she feels that STUDENT would require more support & specifically specialized support from a Special Ed teacher, rather than from an aide. Alyson named the blended inclusion preschool sites. Allendale PK Blended Inclusion site was recommended by PUSD team (which is a strongly language-based classroom, with an emphasis also on early literacy).

District program specialist Ms. Beecher corroborated the team’s discussion of the language contained in the IEP document. She testified that although the parties discussed other preschool blended inclusion classrooms within the District, the District clearly offered the Allendale program to STUDENT’s parents at the IEP meeting. District resource specialist Mirell O’Brien similarly testified that the District described its blended inclusion preschool programs at the meeting and recommended the Allendale program to the parents.

On June 26, 2003, following the meeting, STUDENT’s parents submitted to the District, “Comments and Disagreement to IEP for STUDENT - June 11, 2003.” With regard to the placement offer, the parents wrote, “We will observe the district’s classrooms. We do not know which one is being offered and which location is being offered. When asked 3 different times what is the specific class offered we were told all of them. We were told that the classes are each a little different. A list of locations and class rooms were not provided in the IEP.”

On July 17, 2003, after receiving the parents’ written disagreement to the IEP, Ms. Beecher sent the parents a letter “to supplement and clarify the [IEP] developed for your daughter” and to “respond to your correspondence of June 25, 2003, concerning STUDENT’s IEP.” She testified that she decided to send the clarification letter because she wanted to specifically describe the program offered, as it appeared that the District’s offer was not clear to the parents. With regard to the District’s placement recommendation, the letter stated, “STUDENT’s IEP team recommended the following placement and services, to start in the 2003-2004 school year, beginning September 4, 2003: Placement in the blended inclusion general education preschool class at Allendale Elementary School.” The letter then described the program, including the number of teachers and aides, the maximum number of students, the opportunities for interacting with typically-developing peers, the hours of the classroom day, and the instruction methodologies utilized. The letter also stated, “Your letter also states that you are willing to view several District classrooms, however, only the blended inclusion classroom at Allendale Elementary has been offered. This is the same classroom that you visited recently with STUDENT’s CARD therapist.”

Although STUDENT’s parents argue that they did not understand that the District was offering the placement at Allendale, their testimony indicates they in fact did understand the offer. MOTHER testified that she had observed the Allendale classroom, as well as other District classrooms discussed at the meeting. She also testified that she “assumed” that the District offered the Allendale classroom in June 2003 but did not agree that this placement was appropriate for STUDENT. Moreover, she testified that she clearly understood that the District was offering Allendale in July 2003 when she received the clarification letter from Ms. Beecher.

FATHER testified that he did not understand that the District had offered Allendale because everyone at the meeting was speaking at the same time and he had difficulty following the discussion. For that reason, he decided to take the IEP home to review it. He testified that after the meeting, he understood that the District had offered Allendale because he read the statement regarding placement on page 6D of the IEP, and because he and his wife discussed the Allendale placement offer following the meeting.

The IEP document, the District letter dated July 17, 2003, and the testimony of both District witnesses and STUDENT’s parents demonstrate that the parents understood that, for the 2003-2004 school year, the District was offering STUDENT a placement in a preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale. STUDENT’s argument that the District did not offer Allendale at the meeting is not supported by the overwhelming evidence that the parents reviewed the IEP, discussed the Allendale placement after the meeting, and understood the placement offer in the letter from Ms. Beecher.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer thus finds that the District met the Union court’s requirement that a formal written offer of placement be communicated to the parents. The District formally offered STUDENT a placement at Allendale and put its proposed placement in writing, as required by Union. Therefore, as a result of its proposed placement offer, the District did not commit any procedural violations that resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

2. Did the District invite the appropriate regular education and special education teachers to the IEP meeting?

An IEP team must include all of the following individuals: one or both parents, a representative selected by the parents, or both; at least one regular education teacher if the pupil is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment; at least one special education teacher of the pupil, or if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil; a representative of the district, special education local plan area, or county office of education; an individual who conducted an assessment of the pupil or is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the pupil and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations; at the discretion of the parent or the district, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related service personnel, as appropriate, and whenever appropriate, the individual with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).

STUDENT argues that the District failed to comply with this legal requirement in that one District representative, Kristin Enriquez, attended the IEP meeting in June 2003 in the capacity of both regular education and special education teacher. However, a review of the evidence reveals that Kristen Enriquez attended the IEP meeting as a special education teacher and that Mirell O’Brien attended the IEP meeting as a regular education teacher.

Ms. Enriquez testified that she currently holds a California professional clear specialist instruction certificate in special education that allows her to work with preschool children with severe disabilities. She has also taught special education students since 1997. She testified that she attended the IEP meeting in June 2003 as the special education teacher only.

Furthermore, Ms. O’Brien testified that she currently holds a California multiple subject credential that allows her to teach regular education classes and a special education credential that allows her to teach special education classes. She testified that she has taught students since 1976, primarily special education students, but that she has also taught in an inclusion classroom with regular education students, and that she did her student teaching in a regular education classroom. (Footnote 7) She also testified that she attended STUDENT’s IEP meeting as a regular education teacher and that she often represents the District’s preschool regular education classrooms at IEP meetings.

The evidence thus reveals that Ms. Enriquez is a credentialed special education teacher, and that Ms. O’Brien is a credentialed general education and special education teacher. (Footnote 8) In addition, Ms. Beecher, who attended the meeting as the District’s designated administrator, testified that she holds a California professional clear multiple subject teaching credential and has taught in a blended inclusion classroom with special education and regular education students. Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team was properly constituted with both a special education and a regular education teacher.

In sum, the District did not commit a procedural violation that resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process as a result of the composition of the IEP team.

3. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to invite STUDENT’s current service providers to the IEP meeting?

As discussed in the above section, either the District or the parents may invite to an IEP meeting other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related service personnel, as appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).

STUDENT argues that the District should have invited to the IEP meeting in June 2003 her then-current preschool teacher, her NPA speech and language therapist, and her CARD service providers. STUDENT relies upon Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District No. 69, 317 F.3d 1072, 1077 (9th Cir.2003) in support of her argument. Although the Shapiro case held that a district must invite the child’s current teacher to an IEP meeting, that holding does not apply to a child who is not yet enrolled in a special education program. As the Ninth Circuit stated, “For a child with a disability who is being considered for placement in special education, the teacher could be the child’s regular teacher, or a teacher qualified to provide education in the type of program in which the child may be placed, or both.” Id. at 1077.

STUDENT’s parents argue that she had a regular education teacher at Pasadena Progressive Montessori School at the time of the IEP meeting in June 2003, and that the District should have invited this teacher to the meeting. However, it is undisputed that STUDENT had only begun to attend this school a few days prior to the IEP meeting and that she attended only two mornings a week. Therefore, at the time of the IEP meeting, she had attended only two or three school sessions. Moreover, Ms. Beecher testified credibly that she did not invite this teacher to the meeting because she believed that a teacher who has seen a student in a classroom only two or three times would have very little knowledge of that student’s abilities.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Shapiro case did not require the attendance of STUDENT’s preschool teacher at the IEP meeting in June 2003. As STUDENT had just begun to attend a regular education preschool classroom, she did not have a teacher who was familiar with her special education needs. As stated by the Shapiro court, for a child who is being considered for placement in special education, the District could properly invite to an IEP meeting the teacher who is qualified to provide education in the type of program in which the child may be placed. (Footnote 9) As Ms. Beecher, Ms. Enriquez, and Ms. O’Brien are all credentialed and experienced preschool special education teachers who have taught in special education, regular education and inclusion classrooms, they are teachers who are qualified to provide education in the classroom proposed for STUDENT. The District thus had no obligation to invite to the meeting STUDENT’s private school teacher who had seen her in class for only a few hours.

STUDENT also argues that the District had an obligation to invite her NPA speech and language therapist to the meeting according to the Shapiro case. However, as will be discussed below, the District developed appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT in the speech and language area based in part upon the progress report of the NPA therapist. The District also completely adopted the recommendation of STUDENT’s speech and language therapist that she receive two hours per week of individual speech and language therapy and weekly group speech and language therapy, and that she be placed in a structured, language-based classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT suffered no prejudice from the District’s decision not to invite her private speech and language therapist to the IEP meeting.

Finally, STUDENT’s parents argue that the District had an obligation to invite STUDENT’s CARD therapist to the IEP meeting. However, as discussed above, either the parents or the District may invite to an IEP meeting other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. Had the parents wanted CARD representatives to attend the meeting, they could have invited them. (Footnote 10) The District was under no obligation to invite these representatives to the meeting.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s decision not to invite STUDENT’s current teacher, her NPA speech and language therapist, and her CARD representatives to her IEP meeting in June 2003 did not amount to a procedural violation that resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

4. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to provide copies of assessments, progress reports, and proposed goals and objectives to her parents prior to the IEP meeting?

An IEP is a written statement determined in a meeting of an IEP team that includes, among other things, measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). Districts are required to give parents a copy of the IEP at no cost to the parent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(i).

In addition, upon completion of the administration of tests and other assessment materials, an IEP team meeting, including the parents, shall be scheduled to determine eligibility for special education and to discuss the assessment and educational recommendations. A copy of the assessment report and the documentation of determination of eligibility shall be given to the parents. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(a).

STUDENT contends that the District was required to provide her parents with a copy of the assessments, progress reports, and the District’s proposed goals and objectives prior to the IEP meeting. However, she cites no authority for this argument. As indicated by the foregoing statutory law, parents are entitled to a copy of the IEP and of assessments conducted by District personnel. It is undisputed that the parents received copies of all assessment reports and a copy of STUDENT’s speech and language progress report during the meeting and a copy of STUDENT’s IEP shortly after the IEP meeting. Therefore, as the District had no obligation to provide these copies prior to the meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that it committed no procedural violations that resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

5. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to identify the provider for its proposed floortime program at the IEP meeting?

An IEP is a written statement determined in an IEP meeting that must include, among other things, the present levels of performance of the pupil; measurable annual goals and objectives; the specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil; a statement of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the pupil; the projected date for the beginning of the services and modifications; the anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those services and modifications; appropriate objective criteria for determining whether the annual goals are being achieved; a statement of how the pupil’s progress towards the annual goals will be measured; and a statement of how the pupil’s parents will be regularly informed of the pupil’s progress towards the annual goals. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a).

STUDENT’s parents contend that the District improperly failed to identify the provider for its proposed floortime program for STUDENT at the IEP meeting in June 2003. A review of the IEP and of Ms. Beecher’s letter of July 17, 2003, indicates that the District proposed sixty minutes per day of floortime activity to build socialization and play skills. The document states that this service was to be provided at school by a District floortime specialist.

It is undisputed that neither the IEP document nor the clarification letter specifies the identity of the District’s floortime specialist. However, STUDENT cites no authority for her contention that the District is obligated to provide her with this information. As indicated in California Education Code section 56345(a), districts are obligated to specify the specific educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil. The California Education Code does not require a district to specify the identity of a service provider.

The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s failure to specify the identity of its proposed floortime specialist did not constitute a procedural violation that resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the procedural safeguards of the IDEA and State law and committed no procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.

SUBSTANTIVE REQUIREMENTS

As discussed above, in addition to the procedural requirements of the IDEA and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a substantive FAPE that is reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit. However, a school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 198-200. To determine whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir.1987). If the District’s proposed program would have addressed STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, comported with her IEP, and provided for education in the least restrictive environment, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.

Therefore, when taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision require that an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, (3) conform to the student’s IEP, and (4) provide for education in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.

a. Was the District’s proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique individual needs?

What Are STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

As stated above, the Hearing Officer must initially determine if the District’s offer in June 2003 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must first determine what STUDENT’s unique needs are. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT has autism. They also do not dispute that STUDENT’s general areas of deficits are in the areas of socialization, receptive and expressive language, and communication. The parties agree that STUDENT has difficulties in interacting with peers, understanding language without visual cues, expressing herself in intelligible words and phrases, and initiating conversations with peers and adults. There is also no dispute that STUDENT requires special instruction in order to address her unique needs. The only dispute relates to the type of instruction that she requires.

Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has unique needs in the areas of socialization, receptive and expressive language, and communication.

Was the District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

It must next be determined if the District’s proposed placement in the Allendale preschool blended inclusion program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of socialization, receptive and expressive language, and communication. The evidence reveals that although the parties agreed that these were STUDENT’s unique needs, they disagreed that the offer of placement in the preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale, and the proposed related services, were designed to meet these needs.

Allendale Placement

Several District witnesses described the Allendale preschool blended inclusion classroom. Debra Holland and Valentin Sanchez, the Allendale preschool blended inclusion special education and regular education teachers, testified that their classroom contains a total of twelve regular education students, five special education students, a regular education teacher and aide, and a special education teacher and aide. They testified that the teachers and aides work cooperatively as a team. They further testified that Ms. Holland advises the team regarding modifications of the curriculum, while both teachers plan lessons that incorporate students’ goals and objectives, and all team members meet regularly to discuss student progress.

District program specialist Ms. Beecher, who testified that she visits the Allendale classroom regularly, described the classroom as a team model approach where STUDENT would have her needs met but would not become too dependent upon the adults in the classroom. She testified that this was important because the District had a concern that STUDENT had made progress with her DTT program, but that she had become very dependent upon prompts and had learned in a rote manner. She also testified that one of the benefits of the classroom is that the children are role models for each other, something that would further benefit STUDENT. In addition, Ms. Beecher testified that the Allendale classroom has a ratio of one adult to four children, a ratio that would provide “wonderful” support for STUDENT.

On the basis of his assessment and home observation of STUDENT, District school psychologist Dr. Bernhardt described her as a “star” that would fit in well in the Allendale classroom. He described her as an enthusiastic learner who will play and interact with her peers and will develop good bonds with her teachers and aides. STUDENT’s parents agreed that STUDENT has made a great deal of progress during the last year and that she has begun to learn socialization and communication skills with her sister and her cousins. Dr. Bernhardt also described the one-to-four adult to student ratio as “excellent” for STUDENT. (Footnote11)

With regard to language opportunities in the Allendale blended inclusion classroom, District speech/language/hearing specialist Ms. D’Angiola described the classroom as a language-rich program. According to Ms. D’Angiola, the classroom has a strong emphasis on language in the curriculum, and the teachers incorporate the speech and language needs of the students into the classroom routine. Ms. D’Angiola further testified that the classroom also meets the challenges of a natural setting for language use, an area of need for STUDENT. Ms. Beecher, who previously taught in a blended inclusion classroom, testified that STUDENT’s language would blossom in this classroom, and that she would also develop her language skills by interacting and playing with other children.

Although STUDENT’s parents do not dispute the composition of the Allendale classroom, they both testified that they believe that the classroom is inappropriate for STUDENT because she needs to be only with children without disabilities. Because the classroom contains other children with disabilities, the parents believe that STUDENT will mimic the inappropriate behaviors of the children with disabilities.

Related Services

In addition to the description of the classroom, District witnesses testified regarding the related services offered to STUDENT. Lisa Agajanian, District child development specialist, testified that she provides direct floortime service to students at Allendale. She described floortime as an activity that provides spontaneous emotional and social support that works at the students’ own level and through their own interests. According to Ms. Agajanian, floortime is less rote and more generalized than DTT and other more structured interventions for children with autism. She further testified that during floortime activities, STUDENT would learn reciprocity with peers, learn to generalize socialization skills, and learn communication exchanges.

Moreover, according to Ms. Beecher, STUDENT had reached a certain level with DTT services and needed to learn the spontaneous language and socialization skills that she would receive from floortime. Dr. Bernhardt, who has worked with a variety of methodologies for young children with autism for more than twenty years, also described floortime as child-directed teaching where instruction is based upon a child’s expressed interests rather than a teacher-directed strategy such as DTT. He testified that STUDENT has had a lot of teacher-directed DTT and would now derive more meaning from a child-directed instruction such as floortime. He also testified that research supports the use of a variety of methodologies for young children with autism, and that STUDENT would benefit from beginning a new methodology.

With regard to a one-on-one DTT aide for the first semester, both Ms. Beecher and Dr. Bernhardt testified that with such an aide, STUDENT would be able to transition from her very structured home-based DTT program to a less structured classroom setting. If STUDENT had problems, the aide, who would be familiar with STUDENT’s DTT program, would be there to coach the staff and to assist STUDENT with any difficulties. Dr. Bernhardt also testified that his job as STUDENT’s ABA supervisor would be to ensure that the aide assists STUDENT appropriately with the transition as well as to facilitate ongoing communication between school and home.

With respect to speech and language services, Ms. D’Angiola testified that she recommended two hours per week of individual speech and language therapy with STUDENT’s current NPA provider and one thirty-minute per week session of small group speech and language therapy at school. Her reason for making this recommendation was to provide STUDENT with assistance with pragmatics and social communication, important areas of need for her that would supplement the social interaction that she will receive in the classroom.

Finally, District occupational therapist Lisa Serby testified that her assessment of STUDENT found that STUDENT seeks out some movement, seeks and avoids certain sounds, and has good fine motor skills with the exception of writing in a rote manner. She testified that she did not propose any OT goals and objectives at the IEP meeting because STUDENT’s fine motor skills were above age level and her sensory processing skills were good. She testified that the few concerns that she noted in STUDENT could be addressed with classroom modifications and accommodations. For that reason, she recommended no direct services but instead recommended thirty minutes per week of direct OT monitoring in the classroom.

Findings

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the preschool blended inclusion program at Allendale offers STUDENT an appropriate program. As indicated by the undisputed evidence, the program offers STUDENT a small classroom with a total of seventeen students, twelve of whom are regular education students, and a one-to-three or one-to-four adult-to-student ratio. In addition, the program offers STUDENT a language-rich curriculum in which she can improve her expressive and receptive language and communication deficits. Furthermore, she will receive individual and group speech and language services that will enable her to continue to improve her receptive language, speech and articulation, expressive language, and pragmatics and social communication.

With regard to her social needs, the evidence reveals that the program at Allendale would provide STUDENT with opportunities for social and play interactions with peers, conversational exchanges with peers, and turn taking with peers. The proposed floortime activities will also provide her with the opportunity to interact with peers and to improve communication with peers and adults. (Footnote 12) In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed OT monitoring is sufficient to uncover any OT-related difficulties that STUDENT may experience in school as the undisputed testimony revealed no ongoing deficits in this area.

The Hearing Officer thus finds that the proposed placement and related services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of socialization, expressive and receptive language, and communication. (Footnote 13) Parents’ Disagreement With the IEP

Although the Hearing Officer found the District’s offer to be appropriate, she will nonetheless address the parents’ disagreement with the goals and objectives in the IEP. STUDENT argues that the District’s proposed placement at Allendale, and its proposed related services, are inappropriate for her because the District incorrectly determined her present levels of performance. As a result, according to STUDENT, the District developed inappropriate goals and objectives for her for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 14)

As discussed above, prior to the IEP meeting, the District performed a transdisciplinary assessment of STUDENT in the areas of cognitive, language and communication, sensory-motor, social/emotional and plays, and self-help. Following this assessment, the District members of the IEP team determined STUDENT’s present levels of performance and developed ten goals and objectives for her in the areas of social, classroom readiness, auditory processing/receptive language, speech and articulation, expressive language and speech, and pragmatics and social communication.

Social Goals and Objectives

The evidence reveals that the District members of the IEP team developed three goals and objectives for her in the social area. The District described STUDENT’s present levels of social performance as failing to interact with her sister, recently beginning to participate in a school program, participating in cause/effect activities independently when playing alone, playing in basic imaginative play activities when alone, and failing to interact with age-appropriate peers. As a result of these levels, the District proposed the following social goals: participating in a cause/effect play sequence, taking turns with a peer, participating in an imaginative play activity with at least one other child, and participating in a conversation of a topic of interest with an age-appropriate peer.

The overwhelming evidence supports the appropriateness of the levels of performance and the goals and objectives developed by the District in the social area. With regard to interacting with her sister, both Dr. Bernhardt and Ms. Enriquez noted that STUDENT did not approach her sister for any type of social interaction during the time that they observed her in her home program immediately prior to the IEP meeting. Although MOTHER testified that STUDENT has recently begun playing with her sister, she did not dispute that STUDENT did not interact with her sister at the time of the IEP meeting. She also acknowledged that STUDENT does not yet initiate interactions with other children. With regard to play activities, Ms. Enriquez observed STUDENT enjoying imaginative play and toys, although she noted that she played alone. MOTHER corroborated the testimony of Ms. Enriquez in that she has observed STUDENT in her current preschool playing alone and failing to initiate activities with other children. In his assessment of her, Dr. Bernhardt also noted that STUDENT spontaneously explored the toys in the assessment room appropriately but did not initiate any tasks.

Ms. Beecher testified that the parents advised her at the IEP meeting that STUDENT had already met part of the first socialization goal of participating in a cause/effect play sequence and taking turns with a peer. As a result, according to Ms. Beecher, the District modified that goal to apply at school only because it determined that STUDENT needed to learn these skills at school even if she has already mastered them at home. The parents did not dispute that STUDENT needed to learn these skills at school.

On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer thus finds that the District developed appropriate social goals and objectives that are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique social needs of interacting, playing, and communicating with other children.

Classroom Readiness Goals and Objectives

Next, the evidence reveals that the District developed three goals and objectives in the area of classroom readiness. In this area, the District described STUDENT’s present level of performance as recently beginning to participate in a school program. As a result, the team developed three classroom readiness goals: sitting for a classroom activity presented to a whole group, while attending to the adult presenting the information; raising her hand before providing an answer to a question; and successfully transitioning from one activity to another by following a peer or by following teacher direction. It is undisputed that STUDENT had been attending preschool for only one week at the time of the IEP meeting and that she had not yet learned these classroom readiness skills. Moreover, Dr. Bernhardt testified that these are skills that STUDENT will need to learn in order to be successful in a school environment. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District developed appropriate goals and objectives in the area of classroom readiness on the basis of the undisputed evidence that STUDENT had not yet developed those skills that she needed for successful transition to preschool. In sum, the proposed goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of classroom readiness.

Language and Communication Goals and Objectives

Finally, the evidence reveals that the District developed four goals and objectives in the areas of auditory processing/receptive language, speech and articulation, expressive language and speech, and pragmatics and social communication. In these areas, the District described STUDENT’s present levels of performance as requiring repetition of commands, requiring visual cues, having difficulties with “wh” questions, imitating sounds, having poor intelligibility with spontaneous utterances, having a fast rate of speed, using short utterances with immature grammar, using misarticulations, having difficulties elaborating ideas verbally, responding rather than initiating a conversation, and having difficulty with a topic of conversation. As a result of these present levels of performance, the District developed four language-related goals and objectives: responding to specific questions based on spoken material, increasing intelligibility of connected speech while producing developmentally appropriate sounds in spontaneous utterances, using complete five- to six-word utterances with appropriate morphological markers and syntax in daily speech, and engaging in a conversation with peers and adults while displaying appropriate pragmatic skills.

The Hearing Officer finds that these eleven areas of present levels of performance and four goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in the assessment of District speech/language/hearing specialist Ms. D’Angiola and in a progress report from June 2003 by Hope Hendricks-Bacon, STUDENT’s NPA speech and language therapist. For example, Ms. D’Angiola found that STUDENT had restricted spontaneous conversational skills, attended to less relevant pieces of information in a verbal message, could not answer simple “yes/no” and “what/what . . . doing” questions when visual cues were not provided, had difficulty with “wh” questions without visual cues, could not repeat more than three-word utterances without omitting and distorting words, had impaired intelligibility of connected speech, had an increased rate of speech that affected her intelligibility, often used incomplete utterances and immature grammar, made tangential comments and responses that affected the quality of her conversations, showed a lower quality of spontaneous use of language for social communication, and showed a preference to respond rather than initiate a conversation.

In addition, Ms. Hendricks-Bacon noted that STUDENT could not recognize and sequence some sounds into simple three-phoneme words, had unintelligible speech when using novel utterances, omitted all but content words, frequently reversed word order, had difficulty in the area of spontaneous verbal communication, and at times was completely in her own world and merely echoed words rather than engaging communicatively. In her progress report, Ms. Hendricks-Bacon recommended that STUDENT be placed in a structured, language-based classroom and that she receive two hours of weekly individual speech and language therapy in addition to group speech and language therapy.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the uncontradicted testimony of Ms. D’Angiola and the uncontradicted progress report of Ms. Hendricks-Bacon that STUDENT has difficulty responding to questions, has problems in developing appropriate sounds, uses inappropriate syntax, has poor intelligibility, and does not converse with peers and adults. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District developed appropriate language and communication goals and objectives that were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of language and communication.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance and developed goals and objectives that were appropriate for her and were designed to meet her unique needs as identified in her assessment and progress reports.

In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed offer of a preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale, with two sixty-minute sessions per week of individual speech and language therapy with STUDENT’s current NPA provider, one thirty-minute session per week of District-provided small group speech and language therapy, thirty minutes per week of direct/monitor OT, sixty minutes per day of floortime services, a transition one-on-one DTT aide for the first semester, six sixty-minute per month sessions of ABA supervision for the first semester, and four sixty-minute per month sessions of ABA supervision for the remainder of the school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.

b. Was the District’s proposed placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Second, the Hearing Officer must also determine if the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year was reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of socialization, receptive and expressive language, and communication by providing her with educational services in a preschool, language-rich, blended inclusion classroom that includes daily floortime services to assist with socialization and play needs, individual and small group speech and language therapy to help with receptive and expressive language and communication needs, and a one-on-one DTT aide and ABA supervision to help STUDENT with the transition from her home-based to school-based program. The Hearing Officer also concluded that the IEP team drafted appropriate goals and objectives in the areas of social, classroom readiness, auditory processing/receptive language, speech and articulation, expressive language and speech, and pragmatics and social communication that would address STUDENT’s areas of identified need.

In addition, the District’s witnesses who have observed and assessed STUDENT all testified that she would benefit both socially and in her language development by placement in the blended inclusion classroom at Allendale. According to these witnesses, the individualized attention and the emphasis on language and social development in that classroom will provide STUDENT with academic benefit. Accordingly, on the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

c. Did the District’s proposed placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District was willing to provide the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2003.

d. Did the District’s proposed placement provide STUDENT education in the LRE?

As discussed above, the final element of a FAPE is that the student must be educated in the “least restrictive environment.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.550 et seq; Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550 defines LRE as the education of children with disabilities in the same classrooms as children without disabilities, to the maximum extent possible. In addition, 34 C.F.R. § 300.550 permits the removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment only if the nature and severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The District argues that its proposed placement provides STUDENT with education in the LRE because it affords her opportunities that she does not have in her home program to interact with peers. In contrast, STUDENT contends that the District’s offer of a preschool blended inclusion classroom with five other children with disabilities is not the least restrictive environment for her as she needs to be in a regular education classroom with no supports other than a one-on-one aide. (Footnote 15) With regard to this contention, the District argues that STUDENT is not yet ready to move directly from her home-based program to a regular education classroom with only the support of a one-on-one aide, as that placement does not provide her with sufficient supports to succeed in preschool.

District witnesses testified regarding their opinions that neither STUDENT’s DTT program nor a regular education classroom with a one-on-one aide was the LRE for STUDENT. With regard to the DTT program, Dr. Bernhardt testified that a forty-hour per week DTT program is not an LRE for STUDENT because it does not provide her with socialization instruction in various settings throughout the day and does not provide her with the opportunity to generalize the social and language skills that she has learned from her CARD program. Ms. Enriquez further testified that STUDENT needs the supports of a blended inclusion program to increase her interaction with other children, something that she does not receive from her current CARD program.

In contrast to the District witnesses, MOTHER and FATHER testified that they believe that the CARD program constitutes the LRE for STUDENT because STUDENT has learned to generalize socialization skills through the program. For example, STUDENT’s parents testified that they take her to church, the zoo, parks, and restaurants, and that she has learned to behave appropriately in such places only as a result of the CARD program. In addition, they testified that, as a result of CARD intervention, STUDENT has recently begun to play with her cousins and her sister. However, MOTHER admitted that STUDENT still has trouble in conversations with people and described her language skills as “not normal.”

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the parents’ testimony that a restrictive one-on-one program from CARD is the LRE for STUDENT. As discussed above, in June 2003 STUDENT had needs in socialization and communication areas. Although the parents testified credibly that STUDENT has improved somewhat in these areas as a result of her CARD program, they acknowledge that she still has deficits in socialization and communication and had such deficits at the time of the IEP meeting. Moreover, it is undisputed that the home-based CARD program does not provide her with opportunities for socialization and communication with other children. The Hearing Officer is also persuaded by the testimony of District personnel who are familiar with both the CARD program and the District program that her CARD program does not provide STUDENT with the ability to socialize in a variety of settings or to generalize the skills that she has learned to the classroom. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that a forty-hour per week CARD program is not an education in the LRE for STUDENT. (Footnote 16)

With regard to a regular education placement with a one-on-one aide, District witnesses testified that they do not believe that this type of program is the LRE for STUDENT at the current time. Ms. Beecher testified that because of STUDENT’s socialization and language needs, she requires a credentialed special education teacher with a lot of training and understanding of early childhood development. According to Ms. Beecher, there are subtle issues that arise in a child with autism, and a special education teacher can adapt and modify the curriculum according to those subtleties. Ms. Beecher further testified that Allendale is the LRE for STUDENT because it will allow her to interact with typically-developing peers while providing her with the supports that she needs.

In addition, Dr. Bernhardt, Ms. Enriquez, and Ms. O’Brien all testified that a general education classroom is not sufficient for STUDENT’s needs at the present time. Dr. Bernhardt testified that if STUDENT engages in inappropriate behavior, the special education teacher is there to intervene and correct the behavior. Ms. Enriquez testified that STUDENT needs a classroom with a special education teacher who will help her transition and fade from her heavily-prompted DTT program, a classroom that provides access to peers, and sufficient supports to succeed in school. In addition, Ms. O’Brien testified that the Allendale program sounded like the “best of everything” for STUDENT because it included typical peers, special education support, DTT training, and transition support. She testified that STUDENT would benefit from having a credentialed special education teacher and a structured program because she is not yet ready to move directly from her intense home-based program to a more loosely-structured regular education classroom.

STUDENT’s parents dispute that the blended inclusion program is the LRE for her, and instead contend that she should be in a regular education classroom with a one-on-one aide. Both parents testified that STUDENT imitates other children and will learn inappropriate behaviors by imitating children with disabilities. In addition, MOTHER testified that in STUDENT’s current nonpublic preschool classroom, STUDENT is able to do everything that that the other children do, and that STUDENT actually performs better academically than the other children. However, STUDENT’s mother acknowledged that STUDENT still needs help to understand stories that the teacher reads, and she described STUDENT as “not yet normal.”

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the overwhelming evidence that STUDENT is not yet ready to move from her highly structured, home-based DTT program to a preschool regular education classroom with no supports other than a one-on-one aide. The Hearing Officer is further persuaded by the evidence that STUDENT needs a special education teacher to assist her with the transition from a DTT program to a preschool classroom, the opportunity to interact with typically-developing peers while receiving support from teachers and aides, and support to fade from her intense, home-based program to a preschool classroom. With regard to the issue of mimicking children with disabilities, the Hearing Officer is also persuaded that STUDENT will have a special education teacher, a special education aide, and a one-on-one DTT aide to teach her appropriate behaviors as necessary. In addition, with regard to STUDENT’s ability to progress in her current preschool program, the parents testified credibly that STUDENT has made progress in this program. However, it is also undisputed that STUDENT continues to require assistance with socialization and communication skills. (Footnote 17) The Hearing Officer is thus persuaded by the evidence that the LRE for STUDENT is not a regular education classroom with only the support of a one-on-one aide.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing evidence the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement provides STUDENT education in the LRE because it provides her with the ability to participate in communication and socialization activities with nondisabled peers while receiving the necessary supports to do so.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed offer in its IEP of June 2003 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, conforms to STUDENT’s IEP, and provides STUDENT with education in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year.

ORDER

1. The District is entitled to place STUDENT in the preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale Elementary School with the related services enumerated in the IEP of June 11, 2003.

2. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall place STUDENT in the preschool blended inclusion classroom at Allendale Elementary School, with all related services, pursuant to the IEP of June 11, 2003.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: December 23, 2003 ___________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Please note the correct spelling of the name of STUDENT’s father.

2 Dr. Bernhardt and Lisa Agajanian, District child development specialist, described floortime services as spontaneous social and emotional support activities for children with autism that are based upon a child’s expressed interests rather than upon a teacher-directed activity.

3. Several District witnesses described a preschool blended inclusion classroom as a mixture of several children with disabilities and a larger number of regular education children. The classroom includes a regular education teacher and aide and a special education teacher and aide. According to District program specialist Alyson Beecher, this environment allows children to be role models for each other, allows individual support as needed for the children with disabilities, allows for a variety of teaching methodologies, and prepares children for kindergarten.

4. Ms. Beecher testified that the IEP incorrectly stated on the first page that the District proposed sixty minutes per week of floortime activities. However, page 6D of the IEP correctly stated that the amount of time offered was sixty minutes per day. Ms. Beecher also noted the correction in her letter of July 17, 2003.

5. STUDENT had previously filed a request for due process hearing in this matter on August 1, 2003, but withdrew her action prior to the District’s filing. Neither party presented any evidence regarding the reason for this withdrawal.

6. During the prehearing telephone conference held in this matter, STUDENT also identified as a procedural violation the District’s alleged failure to provide the parents with an “accurate and updated” copy of parents’ procedural rights to her parents. However, at the hearing, the parents were unable to identify the manner in which the procedural rights were not “accurate and updated.” As a result, this Decision will not address that alleged violation. At the hearing, the parents also contended that the District had failed to pay CARD pursuant to a Hearing Office stay-put Order. However, the Hearing Officer granted the District’s motion excluding evidence pertaining to payment for CARD services as that allegation is unrelated to the District’s issue of whether or not it offered a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year.

7. In her closing brief, STUDENT asserts that Ms. O’Brien testified that she has never been employed as a teacher. However, Ms. O’Brien testified that she began teaching in 1976, that she taught children with severe and emotional disturbances in the 1980’s, and that she taught in inclusion classrooms in the early 1990’s.

8. During the course of the hearing, FATHER alleged that Ms. O’Brien does not have current teaching credentials because he could not locate her name on the website for the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing. However, Ms. O’Brien submitted copies of her current teaching credentials, indicating that she is a currently credentialed regular education and special education teacher.

9. In her closing brief, STUDENT contends that while it is true that she was being considered for special education in the District, she is actually a child who has been receiving special education because of her CARD services. However, it is undisputed by all witnesses who testified regarding the CARD program that CARD therapists and supervisors are not credentialed teachers and do not provide special education services to students.

10. In fact, Ms. Enriquez testified that STUDENT’s CARD therapist had advised her that both the CARD therapist and the CARD supervisor planned to attend the meeting. In any event, both Ms. Enriquez and Dr. Bernhardt testified that they observed STUDENT’s home program and provided information to the IEP team that they had obtained from STUDENT’s CARD therapist.

11. Both Ms. Beecher and Dr. Bernhardt noted that during the time that STUDENT’s proposed DTT aide is in the classroom, the ratio will actually be an even better ratio of one adult to three students.

12. STUDENT contends that the District’s floortime program is not appropriate for STUDENT because the District has “no evaluation data, self-generated or otherwise, on the effectiveness of its preferred program for teaching autistic children.” However, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the uncontradicted testimony of the District witnesses that this type of program is effective to address STUDENT’s deficits in communication and socialization.

13. In her closing brief, STUDENT submits an extensive discussion from a case entitled Zachary Deal v. Hamilton County Department of Education (no citation provided). Although the judge in that case compared the CARD program with the TEACCH program and found the CARD program more beneficial for young children with autism, no one presented evidence at the hearing that the District in this case offered STUDENT instruction in the TEACCH program. Therefore, that case does not apply here.

14. The parents appear to confuse the goals and objectives developed for STUDENT with the assessment of her unique needs. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that the District appropriately determined STUDENT’s unique needs and developed a program to address those needs. Moreover, although the parents argue that STUDENT has made progress as a result of her CARD program, and thus should continue in the program, STUDENT is not entitled to the best program available. She is entitled only to an appropriate program that meets her unique needs. The Hearing Officer determined on the basis of the evidence presented that the District developed such a program. In any event, the Hearing Officer will discuss the appropriateness of the present levels of performance and goals and objectives in this section.

15. STUDENT argues that the LRE for her is either a one-on-one, forty-hour per week, home-based DTT program with CARD or a regular education classroom with a one-on-one aide. Although these two placements are contradictory as a DTT program is very restrictive and a regular education program is not restrictive, the Hearing Officer will address both arguments in this section of the Decision.

16. STUDENT contends that at the IEP meeting, the District failed to even consider the CARD program as a possible related service for her. However, the IEP states, “Kristen explained that the reason that the District was not recommending an in-home program was that STUDENT had developed good academic skills and needed opportunities to generalize those skills. STUDENT may also benefit from opportunities to be surrounded by positive peer models. Nora said STUDENT needs to move away from scripted learned language structures into the use of functional language for social communication.” In addition, several District witnesses testified credibly that the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s progress in her CARD program at the meeting. STUDENT’s disagreement with the District’s refusal to agree to provide her with a CARD program does not mean that the District did not consider the program. The evidence indicates that it did. STUDENT also argues that the District refused to consider the CARD program because of cost considerations. However, she presented no evidence to support this argument.

17. Although the District’s offer must generally be judged based upon information available to the District at the time of the offer in June 2003, information regarding current functioning may be relevant in assessing STUDENT’s unique needs at the time of the offer. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir.1999). The parents’ testimony confirms that although STUDENT has made some improvements in functioning since June 2003, she continues to have similar socialization and communication deficits to those that she had at the time of the IEP meeting.