California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 2003
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1839-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Long Beach Unified denied FAPE to preschooler with autism for two years; must reimburse private ABA and fund compensatory services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
During the hearing, the parties settled the occupational therapy claims, and Petitioner withdrew all OT-related claims for prospective relief and compensatory education. No remand, court order or correction is noted.
Summary
The parents of a five-year-old boy with autism challenged Long Beach Unified's program from fall 2000 onward. He was placed first in a special day class (SDC) for emotionally disturbed students. He then moved to an autism SDC with about ten hours a week of applied behavior analysis (ABA) and one hour a week of speech therapy. In April 2002 his parents withdrew him to a private home ABA program run by the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE). They later added speech therapy from Kidstreet.
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in 2000-2001 and 2001-2002. IEP teams called for a functional analysis assessment of his hitting, biting and running away, but none was ever done. The team later dropped his behavior plan while the behaviors continued. The District also failed to prove that its ABA and speech services were adequate, properly supervised, or produced more than trivial progress. The May 2002 offer simply repeated that program. The November 2002 offer of an SDC plus 20 ABA hours was appropriate, except that it needed two hours a week of individual speech therapy and a transition plan. The parents lost their claim to be reimbursed for two independent assessments, because the District's assessments were appropriate.
The District must reimburse the LIFE and Kidstreet costs, amend the IEP, and pay for the transition. It must also fund up to ten hours a month of LIFE oversight and provide 65 hours of speech therapy.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP team's repeated call for a functional analysis assessment that never happened while serious behaviors continued. Ignoring that call meant the program did not follow the IEP and denied FAPE. It also shows compensatory relief aimed at past poor supervision rather than extra instruction hours.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by psychologist Dr. Mary Large and speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad (Kidstreet)?
The District's June 2000 psychoeducational assessment and its 2001 speech-language assessment identified the student's areas of need and were appropriate, so no reimbursement was owed for either independent assessment.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The initial emotional-disturbance SDC placement was inappropriate. The team-ordered functional analysis assessment was never done and the behavior plans were ineffective. ABA and speech services did not meet needs or produce more than trivial progress, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
The District never did the FAA and dropped the behavior plan in December 2001 while the behaviors continued. ABA lacked coordination, data analysis and supervision, and speech services were not increased despite little progress. FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Has the District failed to offer a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school and extended school year?
The May 2002 offer repeated the failed program and was not FAPE. The November 2002 offer of an SDC plus 20 ABA hours was appropriate except that it lacked two hours a week of individual speech therapy and a transition plan, so the IEP team must fix those gaps.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately obtained services from LIFE and Kidstreet and, if so, in what amount?
The parents reasonably rejected the District's offers, and the LIFE and Kidstreet services met the student's needs and gave educational benefit, so reimbursement is ordered according to proof.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If the District failed to provide or offer a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
No extra ABA instruction hours were awarded. To address poor past supervision, the District must fund LIFE oversight (up to 10 hours a month through the 2003-2004 ESY) and provide 65 hours of individual speech therapy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 20 calendar days of the decision. Francisco Chavez (LIFE) and Jane Haddad (Kidstreet) are to be invited at District expense as consultants.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to change speech and language services to two one-hour individual sessions per week.
- Develop a transition plan for a gradual move from LIFE and Kidstreet services to the District program: reduce private services as District services increase, exchange information, allow an ABA instructor chosen by Chavez and Haddad to accompany the student as the team deems appropriate, and finish within 25 school days of the parents' agreement to the amended IEP. Parents have up to 5 calendar days to accept or reject the amended IEP.
- District to pay all costs of LIFE and Kidstreet services connected with developing and carrying out the transition plan, including ABA and speech services during the transition period.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents for all amounts paid or owed to LIFE and Kidstreet for services through the date they accept or reject the amended IEP (or the fifth calendar day after it is communicated to the mother). Amount according to proof, due within 15 days of delivery of proof.
- Compensatory education. District to pay LIFE for continuing consultation and oversight services from Francisco Chavez (or a comparably qualified LIFE supervisor at no greater cost) through the end of the 2003-2004 extended school year, limited to 10 hours per month.
- Compensatory education. 65 hours of individual speech and language therapy, which District personnel may provide. The IEP team schedules the hours so as not to overwhelm the student.
- District must watch for recurring maladaptive behavior. If it recurs, the District must address it promptly, including a prompt functional analysis assessment and a behavior intervention plan as the IEP team deems necessary.
Total: 65 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Educ.; Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Alamo Heights Indep. Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, §§ 3001, 3052 (Hughes Bill); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Eric Larsson, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (psychologist), Minnesota; FEAT of Minnesota; LIFE board member
- Francisco Chavez, clinical case worker / ABA supervisor, private provider, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
- Carol Dygean, school psychologist (former District employee); administrator at September 2000 IEP, Long Beach Unified School District
- Michelle Morse, District administrator for infant and preschool special education programs, Long Beach Unified School District
- Jane Haddad, private speech-language pathologist; independent assessor, Kidstreet Institute (nonpublic agency)
- Mary Large, independent psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Mary Miranda, special day class teacher, Holmes Elementary, Long Beach Unified School District
- Suzanne Boyles, school psychologist (2001 reassessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Cynthia Norall, Ph.D., psychologist and program consultant; supervised home ABA, Comprehensive Autism Services and Education (CASE), nonpublic agency
- Sarah Turner, psychologist supervising home ABA program, Comprehensive Autism Services and Education (CASE)
- Suzanne Forbes, occupational therapist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Donna Jeffers, speech-language therapist (2001 assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Melissa de-Mayo, speech-language therapist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Susan Melly, SELPA administrator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Lisa Pate, school psychologist (initial psychoeducational assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Ellen Fabiano, speech and language specialist (initial assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Sally Kitter, occupational therapist assessor, referred by Harbor Regional Center
- Julian Anzures, speech-language pathologist assessor, Miller Children's Hospital, Long Beach Memorial Medical Center
- Charlotte Witsoe, educational psychologist assessor, referred by Harbor Regional Center
- B. J. Freeman, psychologist (training workshop)
- Anabel Macias, behavior assessor, California Psychcare
- Tim Pryor, supervisor of HRC-funded home ABA program, California Psychcare
- Harbor Regional Center, regional center
- Leaps & Bounds, early intervention program
- Sholeh Iravantchi, paralegal for Student's counsel, Russell, Mirkovich & Morrow
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Long Beach, California, on December 5, 10, 11, 12, 17, 18 and 19, 2002.
The Petitioner, STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner), was represented at the hearing by attorney Bruce Bothwell of the law firm Russell, Mirkovich & Morrow. Mr. Bothwell’s paralegal, Sholeh Iravantchi, accompanied him. The Petitioner’s mother, Ms. PARENT, was also present. The Respondent, Long Beach Unified School District (Respondent or District), was represented at the hearing by attorney Adam Newman of the law firm Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Karen Gilyard, another attorney in that firm, was present on the first morning of hearing only. Susan Melly, special education local plan area (SELPA) administrator, or Michelle Morse, District administrator for infant and preschool special education programs, also appeared on behalf of the District throughout the hearing.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Eric Larsson, a Minnesota-based psychologist; Francisco Chavez, Petitioner’s clinical case worker at Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE); Carol Dygean, a school psychologist formerly employed by the District; Michelle Morse; Jane Haddad, a speech pathologist with the nonpublic agency (NPA) Kidstreet Institute (Kidstreet); Mary Large, a psychologist who conducted two independent assessments of Petitioner; Mary Miranda, Petitioner’s teacher; Suzanne Boyles, a District psychologist; and Ms. PARENT.
The District called the following witnesses: Cynthia Norall, Ph.D., a psychologist and the principal of the NPA Comprehensive Autism Services and Education (CASE); Sarah Turner, another psychologist who worked with Petitioner through CASE; Suzanne Forbes, a District occupational therapist; Donna Jeffers, a District speech and language therapist; Melissa de-Mayo, another District speech and language therapist; and Susan Melly.
The oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Written closing arguments of the parties were submitted, and the record was closed on January 21, 2003.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
In the course of the hearing, the parties settled the Petitioner’s claims regarding the alleged failure of the District to offer or provide appropriate occupational therapy services. Petitioner withdrew all claims for prospective relief and compensatory education related to that alleged failure.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by psychologist Dr. Mary Large and speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad (Kidstreet)?
2. Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
3. Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
4. Has the District failed to offer a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school and extended school year?
5. If the District failed to provide or offer a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately obtained services from LIFE and Kidstreet and, if so, in what amount?
6. If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is five years six months old (DOB: [date redacted]). He currently lives with his mother, Ms. PARENT, and his two older sisters, SISTER 1 and SISTER 2.(footnote 2) The family lives within the geographical boundaries of the District. Ms. PARENT is a teacher for the District. STUDENT is eligible for special education on the basis of a diagnosis of autism. He has been receiving services at home since his parents withdrew him from the District’s program in April 2002.
When STUDENT was about eighteen months old, Ms. PARENT began to notice what she described as autistic-like behaviors, including lack of eye contact, inattention to others, speech delay and hyperactivity. He was referred to Harbor Regional Center (HRC) in early March 2000.
HRC referred STUDENT for an assessment on March 17, 2000, by occupational therapist Sally Kitter. From her assessment, including the results of the Bayley Scale of Infant Development, Revised – Second Edition (BSID-2) and the Receptive-Expressive Language Scales (REEL), Ms. Kitter concluded that STUDENT exhibited significant delays in social, language, and language-based cognitive skills. She also believed there were some sensory needs that affected his readiness to learn and some other “autistic-like behaviors” that warranted intervention. Ms. Kitter recommended that STUDENT be enrolled in a center-based program with sensory integration, speech and language and OT components.
By mid-April of 2000, STUDENT was enrolled in the Leaps & Bounds program, where he was involved in an intensive program with speech and language and occupational therapy components. He gradually transitioned to the program and was eventually attending five times weekly by the time of his transition to the District.
At the request of HRC, STUDENT underwent a speech and language evaluation on April 14, 2000, by Julian Anzures, a licensed speech and language pathologist at Miller Children’s Hospital, part of Long Beach Memorial Medical Center. By history, STUDENT was said to have a repertoire of five-word approximations and no two-word combinations. Observation revealed that he had limited attention skills, was unable to follow simple directions, and could not identify a spoon in a field of two and three more than once in eight trials. Results of the Preschool Language Scale (PLS) and the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS) were suspect due to STUDENT’s limited attention and his probable unfamiliarity with the setting and process. The assessor’s impression was that STUDENT exhibited severe receptive and expressive language deficits, impaired social and attention skills, severely reduced selective and sustained attention skills, and stereotypical behaviors. The assessor recommended a developmental assessment to rule out autism, and outlined some basic program goals to address the identified areas of need.
The first District evaluation began on May 30, 2000, when speech and language specialist Ellen Fabiano conducted an informal assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language skills/needs.(Footnote 3) As a result of this assessment, Ms. Fabiano concluded that STUDENT suffered from significant communication deficits, including problems with auditory processing, articulation (possibly due to poor oral-motor control), expressive language and social language. Ms. Fabiano makes no recommendations in her report, deferring those until the IEP meeting.
School psychologist Lisa Pate conducted a psychoeducational assessment on June 16, 2000. Ms. Pate reviewed records, conducted a parent interview, and observed STUDENT at the District’s assessment center. She conducted no formal assessment or testing. Ms. Pate concluded that STUDENT had borderline cognitive ability and would benefit from peer models. She recommended a school-based placement with collaboration between the HRC and District programs. In her opinion, STUDENT needed a daily structured routine focused on functional daily living skills, academics, social interaction, and increasing STUDENT’s awareness of dangers in his environment.
STUDENT’s first IEP was developed at a meeting on July 20, 2000. (Ex. P) Ms. Pate and Ms. Fabiano presented their reports. The speech therapist from Leaps & Bounds shared the OT assessment report done in April by Sally Kitter. The District offered to place STUDENT in a special day class for emotionally disturbed students (ED/SDC) “to address his atypical behaviors and safety issues.” Speech and language therapy was to be provided in a small group for thirty minutes weekly and individually for thirty minutes weekly. Mr. and Ms. PARENT agreed to the placement on the condition that it could be reviewed at a reconvened IEP meeting if they were not satisfied with the placement.
Charlotte Witsoe, an educational psychologist, conducted an assessment of STUDENT in his home on July 24, 2000, on referral by HRC. According to her report, she was able to use the Mullen Scales of Early Learning (Mullen), the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (Vineland), the Childhood Autism Rating Scare (CARS), and her own observations to conclude that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for autism spectrum disorder (ASD). He scored within the substantially deficient range in language, social and overall mental functioning, the mildly deficient range in self-help skills, and the low average range in gross motor skills. His CARS score of thirty-four placed him within the mild to moderate range on the autism scale. Ms. Witsoe recommended an OT evaluation to assess STUDENT’s sensory needs.
STUDENT began his placement in the ED-SDC in the fall. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT’s aggressive and other maladaptive behaviors became a concern. According to his teacher, he required one-on-one assistance to keep him from lying on the floor, kicking and squirming. He was kicking and punching, throwing things, engaging in repetitive behaviors, not attending, and engaging in sensory-seeking behaviors. He was having similar difficulties during his speech and language sessions and appeared to be unable to imitate or follow directions. The speech and language therapist did not believe that he was able to benefit from the sessions. Ms. PARENT requested another IEP meeting.
The District convened another IEP meeting on September 26, 2000. Ms. PARENT expressed her concern that STUDENT was regressing. It was agreed that STUDENT’s placement should be changed to Mary Miranda’s SDC at Holmes Elementary (Holmes), where he would be served by an integrated and structured approach that would include applied behavioral analysis (ABA), discrete trial training (DTT), TEACCH methodologies, sensory integration and the use of a picture exchange communication system (PECS).(Footnote 4) Speech and language was to be delivered twice weekly for fifteen minutes in a small group and twice weekly for fifteen minutes individually. The team also recommended that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors be conducted after the new placement began.(Footnote 5) A District employee was to follow up regarding the status of the OT assessment.
The SDC for children on the autism spectrum was a new program developed by the District under the direction and guidance of Dr. Cynthia Norall. Dr. Norall is a licensed educational psychologist in California and a principal of Comprehensive Autism Services and Education (CASE), an organization that provides assessment and consulting services, including consultation on educational programs for children with autism. She holds a Ph.D. in education from the University of California at Santa Barbara. In addition to helping the District set up the program, Dr. Norall provided ongoing consultation and support.
STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued. Ms. PARENT, Michelle Morse and Ms. Miranda attended another IEP meeting on October 17, 2000, to develop an initial behavior plan and discuss an extended day option.(Footnote 6) The team agreed that STUDENT would attend that program when it began in about a month. The team again recommended that an FAA be done. However, the team went on to develop an interim behavior plan without waiting for the FAA.
In January 2001, STUDENT participated in a training workshop conducted by Dr. Norall and another psychologist, Dr. B. J. Freeman. STUDENT engaged in some maladaptive behaviors during the workshop, including crying, biting, and hitting. According to Ms. PARENT, the two psychologists suggested that STUDENT’s program might need to be changed to better address the maladaptive behaviors, but nothing was done immediately to address this obvious need.
In early April, the PARENTs sent a letter to the District asking for help with STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. Ms. PARENT complained that STUDENT was hitting and kicking people, throwing things, running away, climbing on tables and eating and licking dirt and other non-food items. An IEP meeting was convened on May 4, 2001, to discuss the parents’ concerns about behavior. Dr. Norall was present at the meeting. There was no discussion regarding the effectiveness of the behavior plan prepared by Ms. Morse at the October 2000 IEP meeting. The team agreed that on the two days per week that he left school to receive his clinic-based OT, he was to return home, rather than to school, to receive two hours of home-based one-on-one ABA to be provided by District staff. These services were to be in lieu of the same service that STUDENT would have received during his extended day program on those days.(Footnote 7)
STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued. He completed the regular 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY). Anabel Macias from California Psychcare conducted a behavior assessment in July 2001 that was funded by HRC. It was the assessor’s impression that STUDENT was becoming more aggressive as he was becoming stronger.
STUDENT’s annual IEP review was on July 20, 2001. Both of the PARENTs and a representative of HRC were present at the meeting. No psychologist attended, and no one was present from CASE. The team reviewed STUDENT’s progress toward his goals. The District offered to continue his placement and program through the end of the ESY. At the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, the entire ten hours of ABA was to be delivered in the home with five weekly sessions of two hours each. The PARENTs requested twice the amount of SL therapy based on “Links to Language” or some similar program and thirty to thirty-five hours per week of ABA to be provided by a “supervised agency, not necessarily [the District or its consultant].”
There was also discussion regarding the continuing maladaptive behaviors at the annual review meeting. According to Ms. Miranda, fifty-eight acts of aggression occurred on a single day just a week before the meeting. STUDENT’s parents were concerned about the behaviors, particularly because they had been informed that the home-based ABA program through HRC was about to end. They wanted more ABA. To address these concerns, the team drafted another behavior plan. There was no discussion regarding the previous behavior plan or its effectiveness. No FAA had been conducted.
STUDENT attended Ms. Miranda’s ESY program until early August. His maladaptive behaviors continued. He returned to Ms. Miranda’s SDC in September 2001. In the beginning of the year, STUDENT was receiving ten hours per week of one-on-one therapy at home from District personnel supervised by Dr. Norall. At about the same time, California Psychcare started providing STUDENT with eight hours per week of one-on-one ABA and two hours per week of supervision, funded by HRC. Tim Pryor supervised the HRC-funded program, which delivered services primarily on the weekend. There was no direct communication and little, if any, coordination between these two programs. STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued.
On August 17, 2001 Petitioner’s attorney wrote to the District to advise that the UCLA psychology department would be assessing the Petitioner and the parents would seek reimbursement from the District for the cost of that assessment. Ms. PARENT testified that the assessment was done in late August, but the Petitioner did not seek reimbursement for this assessment and neither party presented any other evidence regarding that assessment at the hearing.
Psychologist Mary Large conducted her first independent assessment of STUDENT on September 17, 2001. In her report dated October 12, 2001, Dr. Large concluded that STUDENT needed a program consisting of forty hours per week of individual, structured and sequential learning assistance of the type developed by Dr. Lovaas of U.C.L.A and delivered by qualified and experienced providers. She also believed that STUDENT needed sensory intervention strategies, two thirty-minute speech and language sessions per day using the Links to Language program, thirty minutes daily of clinic and home-based OT, and a sixty-minute monthly OT consultation. The parents did not provide Dr. Large’s report to the District members of the IEP team for its consideration.
STUDENT’s parents continued to be concerned about the continuing maladaptive behaviors and what they viewed as a lack of progress. Ms. PARENT asked about collaboration among the various providers and requested another IEP meeting to address those concerns. That meeting was on November 20, 2001. At the meeting Dr. Norall explained that there would be monthly clinic meetings attended by as many of the involved District staff as possible. However, the team eventually agreed that the collaboration should also include the staff of the HRC-funded program.
The District reassessed STUDENT in November and December 2001. District psychologist Suzanne Boyles conducted the psychoeducational component of the assessment. In addition to behavioral observations, a review of records and a parent interview, Ms. Boyles administered the Psychoeducational Profile, Revised (PEP-R) and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale (Vineland). Speech and language therapist Donna Jeffers interviewed the teacher, conducted observations of STUDENT in his classroom on two days one week apart, and administered the Nonspeech Test for Receptive and Expressive Language (NST). The NST was used as a reference tool only to estimate the age levels at which STUDENT’s language skills were clustered.
The District assessors concluded that STUDENT functioned cognitively in the delayed/borderline to average range, with strengths in visual perception. He showed gradual growth and increased readiness for acquisition of expressive and receptive language skills, articulation and pragmatics. Using the NST as a reference only, Ms. Jeffers estimated STUDENT’s receptive language skills to be in the fifteen- to twenty-two-month range and his expressive in the seventeen- to twenty-two-month range. The District’s multidisciplinary assessment did not include an FAA or any other focused analysis of the maladaptive behaviors that continued to interfere with STUDENT’s education.
The District held another IEP meeting on December 18, 2001, to discuss the results of the reassessments. Ms. Boyles and Dr. Sarah Turner, the CASE psychologist who took over the supervision of STUDENT’s home program, were present. The team reviewed STUDENT’s progress toward his goals. New goals were developed. Ms. PARENT requested an increase in ABA therapy, but STUDENT’s program was not changed. There was no discussion regarding the two behavior plans contained in earlier IEPs. However, the team dispensed with the behavior plan on the grounds that the maladaptive behaviors that were to have been targeted by the plan were reportedly no longer being seen. The IEP documents do not show that Ms. PARENT disputed that determination at the IEP meeting. However, at the hearing, Petitioner disputed the District’s claim that his maladaptive behaviors were no longer interfering with his education at the time.
As the 2001-2002 school year progressed, the District reported progress toward most of STUDENT’s goals. The Petitioner disputes that he was making any meaningful progress. On April 10, 2002, Petitioner’s attorney wrote to the District to state that STUDENT was starting a private ABA program through the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE) and would be withdrawn from the District’s program effective April 19, 2002. He also stated that STUDENT’s parents would be seeking reimbursement from the District for the cost of the LIFE program. STUDENT was withdrawn from the District program on April 26, 2002. Around that same time, he began his program with LIFE.
On May 29, 2002, about a month after STUDENT was withdrawn from the District’s placement, California Psychcare reported that STUDENT had made progress during his nine months of ABA in the HRC-funded home program. It reported increased skills across all domains with corresponding decreases in aggression and self-stimulation. That same day an IEP team meeting was convened “to review progress prior to parents’ unilateral placement in an in-home ABA program.” Mr. and Ms. PARENT were present. The District shared its belief that STUDENT had made “great progress” in its program. The parents disagreed.
By this time, STUDENT had gone without any speech and language services for over a month. He did not resume those services until November 4, 2002, when Kidstreet therapist Ms. Haddad started her program.
Both the District and Dr Large reassessed STUDENT in November. Dr. Large testified that STUDENT had made progress in many areas. She attributed all of the progress to the LIFE program. The District’s witnesses concluded that STUDENT had made little progress.
The last IEP meetings for STUDENT were on November 21 and 27, 2002. Little of substance happened at the meeting on November 21. The District reconvened the meeting on November 27, 2002. Petitioner’s parent and attorney attended. The result of the meeting was an offer by the District of continued placement in Ms. Miranda’s SDC at Holmes. The District also offered a substantial increase in speech and language services, to three times weekly for thirty minutes (one individual and two small-group sessions), twice the amount of ABA previously provided (ten hours in the extended day program and ten hours in the home), occupational therapy, modifications as necessary to help STUDENT with transition back into the school environment, and transportation. The offer also included an eight-week ESY.(Footnote 8) The offer was not accepted. STUDENT has remained in his LIFE program with speech and language services from Kidstreet.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by psychologist Dr. Mary Large, and by speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad and, if so, in what amount?
The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district “in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, . . . language function, general ability, academic performance, . . . and social and emotional status.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The purpose of this requirement is clear. The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).
A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the school district. The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
In this case, the Petitioner alleges that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. He seeks reimbursement for the October 12, 2001 psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Mary Large and for the August 6, 2002 speech and language assessment by Kidstreet speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad.
California law requires that a child be assessed “in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The assessments must determine the child’s unique educational needs so the IEP team can use the information to develop an IEP that includes a placement and related services designed to meet those needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(B).(Footnote 9)
Psychoeducational Assessment by Dr. Mary Large
School psychologist Lisa Pate conducted the District’s initial psychoeducational assessment in June 2000, two months before STUDENT’s third birthday and three months before he first entered a District program. She did not testify at the hearing. According to documents, she took a history from Ms. PARENT that included a description of STUDENT’s “autistic-like” behaviors. Those included lack of communication and social skills, inability to follow simple directions, lack of eye contact, and oral sensory seeking behaviors. She reviewed the April 14, 2000 speech and language assessment by Julian Anzures, the more recent speech and language assessment by the District, and the March 17, 2000 occupational therapy assessment by Sally Kitter. Ms. Pate did not report on any formal testing conducted by her. She did conduct a behavioral observation of STUDENT during which he attended to a multi-piece shape-matching game for about four minutes before throwing the pieces off the table and running to another area of the room to color.
The Petitioner criticizes the District’s assessment on the grounds that Ms. Pate did not personally conduct formal testing to measure STUDENT’s social and emotional developmental levels and needs. The evidence showed that there may have been formal procedures that could have been used by Ms. Pate to assess STUDENT’s developmental levels and needs. However, some of those had been done within ninety days prior to her assessment. Sally Kitter had administered the BSID-2, one of the tests used by Dr. Large and described by her as useful to obtain the child’s developmental functional level. Mr. Anzures had administered the GARS. Petitioner’s parents had expressed no reservations regarding the IEP team’s consideration of these reports. The Hearing Officer finds that it was not unreasonable for the District to rely on this information.
The Petitioner’s expert, Dr. Large, was critical of what she characterized as the District’s “cursory” assessment. But aside from her general criticism that the assessment did not include formal assessments, she did not identify any specific area of need that was not identified by the District’s assessment. Petitioner contends that the District would have discovered his various maladaptive behaviors had the District administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. However, it is clear from the evidence that the IEP team was well aware of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors by the time of the first IEP meeting on July 20, 2000. The records referred to his oral sensory seeking behaviors, such as licking ground water, his tendency to cry and escape when transitioning, his difficulties remaining seated without “physical assistance,” his lack of awareness of danger, and his tendency to throw objects. According to Ms. PARENT’s testimony, these were the predominant maladaptive behaviors before STUDENT began a District program.(Footnote 10) There was no evidence to suggest that the IEP team placed STUDENT into the ED/SDC because it believed he was emotionally disturbed. The evidence demonstrated that he was put there to deal with his behaviors.
The evidence persuaded the Hearing Officer that the District’s assessment by Ms. Pate met the statutory requirement that the child be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. It correctly identified STUDENT’s areas of need and was appropriate. No reimbursement is due to the Petitioner’s parents for the October 12, 2001 assessment by Dr. Mary Large.
Speech and Language Assessment by Jane Haddad
The speech and language assessment by Jane Haddad from Kidstreet was done on August 6, 2002. Petitioner argues that Ms. Haddad’s assessment was done due to the Petitioner’s disagreement with the assessment conducted by Donna Jeffers as part of the multidisciplinary assessment on November 27 and 28 and December 4, 2001. Again, the Petitioner contends that the District’s assessment was deficient because it did not assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. His specific argument is that the assessment did not include an appropriately administered formal assessment component to accurately determine STUDENT’s speech and language needs.
Ms. Jeffers testified that she spent two hours assessing STUDENT’s language skills and needs. Much of that time was spent observing STUDENT, but she also administered the NST as a reference. The NST results showed that STUDENT’s receptive language skills were clustered in the fifteen to twenty-two month range and his expressive language skills were clustered in the seventeen to twenty-one month range.
Ms. Haddad used the PLS-2 to assess STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language levels in August 2002.(Footnote 11) She concluded that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skill levels were both in the area of twelve months. Ms. Haddad was critical of Ms. Jeffers’ assessment because it did not include an assessment of developmental levels. She stated that Ms. Jeffers could have used an assessment based on the parent’s report to obtain developmental age levels. But she ultimately acknowledged that Ms. Jeffers did use the NST for this purpose.
Neither Ms. Haddad nor any other witness testified that the District’s assessments did not accomplish what they were required by law to accomplish: the identification of STUDENT’s areas of need. Although there was disagreement regarding STUDENT’s developmental levels, Ms. Haddad’s assessment identified the same basic areas of need that had been consistently identified by the IEP team on the basis of the information supplied by the District’s assessors, including Ms. Jeffers. The identification the child’s needs is the purpose of the requirement that the assessment include all areas related to the suspected disability. The District’s assessments appropriately served that purpose.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s speech and language assessment was appropriate. No reimbursement is due to the Petitioner’s parents for the assessment by Ms. Haddad.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345. The IEP must include, among other things, a statement of the special education and related services to be provided to meet the student’s needs that result from his or her disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. Id.; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. V. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Moreover, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the placement that is preferred by the parents but, rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).
Under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, to be substantively appropriate, an educational program must have been designed to meet the student’s unique needs and prepare the student for employment and independent living, must have been reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, must have provided the student with education to the maximum extent possible (often referred to as least restrictive environment or LRE), and must have conformed with the student’s IEP. The school district has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA, including that it provided an appropriate educational placement for the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
Before addressing the claimed deficiencies in the District’s program, the Hearing Officer must determine STUDENT’s needs. There are no significant disputes regarding STUDENT’s deficits and areas of need during the 2000-2001 school year. He had difficulty attending and sitting still and needed to improve those learning readiness skills. He would engage in various maladaptive behaviors, including escape, tantrums, and oral sensory seeking behaviors (e.g. licking or eating nonfood objects). By the time of his September 2000 IEP, STUDENT was also squirming on the floor, punching, hitting and kicking others. These maladaptive behaviors that interfered with the learning process needed to be promptly and effectively addressed. By all accounts STUDENT was significantly delayed in all domains with the exception of his gross motor skills. He was essentially nonverbal and had no effective may to make known his needs or wants. He required assistance with basic language skills. STUDENT was not toilet trained and possessed few self-care or daily living skills. He needed to develop and improve those skills. He also needed close supervision at all times, particularly when around moving equipment, to protect him and others from risks from his lack of appreciation for dangers in his environment. Cognitively, he functioned in the fifteen-month range, with no appreciable matching or imitation skills. He needed to increase his abilities in those areas because they are building blocks for learning. Socially, STUDENT did not engage in purposeful play. While he would play parallel at times, his play was not imaginative and he would not notice peers playing nearby. He needed help with his social skills.
In summary, STUDENT’s unique educational needs included the need for behavioral supports and interventions to address the maladaptive behaviors that significantly interfered with his education.(Footnote 12) He needed some form of ABA program that focussed on the basic building blocks of learning, including learning readiness, communication, social skills, and daily living skills.(Footnote 13) He also needed speech and language therapy to provide specific training/instruction focused on that area of need. Finally, he needed the services to be provided in an environment with adequate supervision and controls to protect both STUDENT and others from the risk attendant to his lack of appreciation for danger.
Petitioner contends that the District’s programs did not appropriately address his unique needs for (1) behavioral supports and interventions; (2) ABA; and (3) speech and language therapy.
Initial Placement in ED/SDC
STUDENT’s first IEP was developed on July 20, 2000. It placed him in an SDC for emotionally disturbed children beginning in September 2000 and provided him with sixty minutes weekly of speech and language, thirty minutes in class and thirty minutes pull out. No other services were offered. The District did not defend the ED-SDC placement in this IEP. No witness was called to describe it in any detail. There was no testimony from which the Hearing Officer could conclude that it was appropriate. In fact, Carol Dygean, the former District psychologist who was the administrator at the September 2000 IEP meeting, conceded that it was not an appropriate placement. The Hearing Officer finds that the ED-SDC placement in the July 20, 2000 IEP was not appropriate and did not provide a FAPE.
The ED/SDC placement lasted for three weeks. For the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT remained in Mary Miranda’s SDC. The Petitioner’s allegations regarding the components of that placement will be discussed below.
Behavioral Support and Interventions
One of the factors that must be considered by the IEP team when developing the plan for the student is whether the student engages in behaviors that impede his or her learning or the learning of others. If there are such behaviors, the team must, when appropriate, consider appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies and supports to address the behavior. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).
If the IEP team determines that the instructional or behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective, an FAA is required. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3052(b). The FAA must be conducted by or under the direction of a person who has documented training in positive behavior intervention. Id. If the student exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of his or her IEP, a behavior intervention plan (BIP) is developed and becomes part of the IEP. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(f). A “serious behavior problem” refers to behaviors that are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(aa). The BIP is based upon the FAA. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3052(a). It is to include specific information about the targeted behaviors, goals and objectives specific to the BIP, and other information. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(f). Once the BIP is developed, a copy of the BIP is to be given not only to the parents, but also to all persons responsible for its implementation in the student’s educational and noneducational environments so it can be effectively implemented in a consistent manner across those environments. Id.
STUDENT did not do well in the ED-SDC. He became aggressive at times, punching, hitting and kicking others. He required one-on-one attention to control these and other maladaptive behaviors. His parents were concerned about loss of skills. On September 26, 2000, the IEP team met to change his placement to Mary Miranda’s SDC at Holmes and recommended that an FAA be conducted when STUDENT began that new placement.
When STUDENT first entered the District, he demonstrated multiple behaviors that were likely to interfere with his education. The IEP team was aware of the need for behavioral interventions. An FAA had been recommended at the September 2000 IEP. According to District psychologist Carol Dygean, who was the administrator of this IEP meeting, school psychologists act as behavior intervention case managers in the District and are qualified and authorized to conduct an FAA. Ms. Dygean testified that she agreed that an FAA should be done and expected that it would result in the development of a BIP. Mary Miranda testified that she spoke with Ms. Dygean about the FAA and that Ms. Dygean confirmed that she would arrange for it. Ms. Dygean agreed that one should have been done after STUDENT began attending the Holmes SDC. The FAA was not done. There was no behavior plan.
STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued. An October 17, 2000 IEP was convened, in part, to address behavior issues. Only Michelle Morse, Mary Miranda and Ms. PARENT attended. The only change that resulted from this IEP was the creation of an interim behavior plan. Michelle Morse wrote the plan. She also documented the continuing recommendation that an FAA be conducted. Ms. Miranda and Ms. Morse each claimed that the other was responsible for making arrangements for the FAA. It was clear that neither of those witnesses was qualified to plan or implement an FAA. Moreover, the District did not show that either of them was qualified to even develop an appropriate behavior plan. The District made no effort to show how or by whom the interim behavior plan was to be implemented to effectively address STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors.
According to Ms. Miranda, STUDENT continued to engage in maladaptive behaviors to varying degrees. Ms. PARENT testified that his behaviors, including aggression and repetitive sensory behaviors were increasing between October 2000 and January 2001. In January 2001 STUDENT participated in a training that was being conducted at a District office by Dr. Norall and Dr. B. J. Freeman, another psychologist who has extensive experience in the treatment of autistic children. STUDENT behaved so badly at the training that Drs. Norall and Freeman discussed a possible change to his program with Ms. PARENT. The District did nothing for months to follow up on this discussion.
According to Ms. PARENT and an April 4, 2001 progress report, the maladaptive behaviors continued. Ms. PARENT wrote to the District pleading for help with STUDENT’s behaviors. In her April 5, 2001 letter, STUDENT’s mother complained that he was continuing to climb on tables. He remained aggressive at times and would escape, throw things, eat dirt, lick objects, tantrum and bang his head against the floor. In that letter Ms. PARENT states that Ms. Miranda had confirmed that she was also seeing maladaptive behaviors at school, including aggression, throwing things, and escape. Ms. Miranda confirmed in her testimony that that these behaviors were a continuing problem and that STUDENT was also biting his fingernails and chewing on or eating parts of his clothing.
It was not until the regular school year was almost over that another IEP meeting was finally convened on May 4, 2001. For the first time, Dr. Norall was present at one of STUDENT’s IEP meetings. The team’s response to the problems with STUDENT’s behavior was to move four of STUDENT’s ten ABA hours from his extended day program to his home. STUDENT’s SDC placement and other services were not changed. STUDENT’s parents agreed. There was no documented discussion regarding the long-overdue FAA, and nothing was said about the effectiveness of the existing--and apparently ignored--behavior plan.
Cynthia Norall defended the District’s inaction. She testified that the many maladaptive behaviors that had been observed earlier were no longer being seen by the time of the May 2001 IEP meeting. She described STUDENT as a “different child” by this time in 2001. However, Dr. Norall’s conclusions about STUDENT’s progress are not supported by the weight of the evidence. As the above evidence establishes, STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued.
Dr. Norall also testified that the continuing concerns about STUDENT’s behavior around the time of the May 2001 IEP had to do with how he was doing in the home, not in school. She said that the transfer of four of his hours to the home was recommended to increase STUDENT’s ability to generalize his progress into the home environment. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the doctor’s testimony. Regardless of the doctor’s reasoning, the District’s response to the situation was weak and ineffective. There was no showing that the transfer of four hours of ABA time to the home environment was a change that was designed to meet STUDENT’s dire need for effective behavioral supports and intervention.
When asked about an FAA during her first day of testimony, Dr. Norall could not recall even being aware of the IEP team’s request for an FAA. Two weeks later when Dr. Norall resumed her testimony, she testified that she did not believe that STUDENT needed an FAA at all. She said that there was an ongoing and concerted effort to address STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors and that at least some of the strategies employed were outlined in her own behavior plan that she keeps in the program books of all clients. Dr. Norall testified that these behavioral interventions were effective. This testimony was also unpersuasive. The weight of the evidence showed that the District and its consultants failed to adequately address STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. An FAA was ordered by STUDENT’s IEP teams to help in developing an effective strategy for dealing with the maladaptive behaviors. With the exception of Dr. Norall, the District’s witnesses acknowledge that an FAA should have been done. Ms. Dygean testified that if the IEP team determined that FAA was not required, that recommendation would be recorded in an IEP. There was no such record. Dr. Norall had no authority to unilaterally overrule the IEP team and substitute her standard behavior plan. That would not only have subverted the authority specifically granted to the IEP team, it would also have run contrary to the requirement that a child’s program be individualized. Finally, the evidence demonstrated that Dr. Norall’s plan to deal with the behaviors was not effective.
The maladaptive behaviors continued after the May 2001 IEP and through the end of the ESY in August 2001. California Psychcare did a behavior assessment on July 13 and 16, 2001.(Footnote 14) At the time, Ms. PARENT was still complaining about frequent aggression, throwing things, escape, non-compliance, and tantrums, as well as a renewed obsession with closing doors and windows at home. She also saw him at school during this time. Ms. PARENT described STUDENT as “out of control” during his ESY. She observed him there screaming, hitting and biting. Ms. Miranda confirmed in her testimony that she was continuing to see the maladaptive behaviors at school during the ESY. On July 13, 2001, Ms. Miranda documented the highest number of incidents of aggression during group speech and circle at school. On the same day, she also documented fifty acts of escape and aggression during the two-hour home program.(Footnote 15)
STUDENT’s annual review IEP meeting was on July 20, 2001. In spite of the fact that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors were continuing to seriously interfere with his program, no representative of CASE and no school psychologist were present at the meeting. The reports by California Psychcare and Ms. Miranda regarding STUDENT’s persistent maladaptive behaviors were shared with the IEP team, but there was no evidence to suggest that the team reviewed the existing behavior plan and its effectiveness. Instead, Ms. Miranda wrote another behavior plan, again without the benefit of an FAA and without the participation of anyone who was qualified to develop a behavior plan. The District offered no evidence that this plan was designed to address STUDENT’s needs, and there was no evidence that it was actually used by anyone in any environment to any good effect.
The failure by the District to appropriately address STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors that were interfering with his education continued for the entire 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. Early on, the IEP team appropriately ordered an FAA as the first step toward the development of a BIP. The District essentially did nothing to comply. It ignored an obvious and critical need. This failure to provide appropriate behavioral supports and interventions substantially contributed to the failure of the District’s program to confer an educational benefit on STUDENT. Furthermore, because the provided program did not include the appropriate intervention that was clearly contemplated by the IEP team when it ordered the FAA, it did not conform to the IEP.
ABA Program
STUDENT entered the District with minimal skills and the need for a program that focused on the basic building blocks of learning, including learning readiness, communication, social skills, and daily living skills. Petitioner contends that the ABA program provided by the District did not meet his unique needs. He asserts that he needed an entirely home-based ABA program with at least thirty-five to forty hours per week of intensive instruction. The District claims that its program, a thirty-hour per week combination of individual and small group instruction and home-based ABA, met the Petitioner’s needs.
Eric Larsson, Ph.D., testified for the Petitioner. He is a licensed psychologist in Minnesota and executive director of Families for Effective Autism Treatment (FEAT) of Minnesota. He holds a doctorate in developmental and child psychology from the University of Kansas and is currently an assistant professor of psychology and clinical faculty member at the University of Minnesota. Since 1995 Dr. Larsson has been part of the National Institute of Mental Health’s replication study of the UCLA Young Autism Project of O. Ivar Lovaas, Ph.D. Since 2000, he has been a member of the board of directors of the LIFE.
Dr. Larson testified that the amount of STUDENT’s allotted ABA time was inadequate. He believes that autistic children need an intensive program of at least thirty hours per week of ABA. He went further to state that it is entirely appropriate and “safe” to start an autistic child with forty hours per week. The doctor was also of the opinion that the SDC placement was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it was not sufficiently intensive, as described above, and because he believes that STUDENT did not have the skills at that time that would have enabled him to benefit from the group learning experience.
According to Dr. Larsson, it is not just the amount of ABA time that maximizes the results. It is also the way in which the program is designed and implemented. He explained that it is important to lay a strong foundation, starting with the fundamental building blocks of learning, such as attention, compliance, and other learning readiness skills. Behaviors that interfere with the learning process must be identified and addressed at the outset. Collaboration and consistency across all environments are essential. There must be parental involvement. Progress toward goals and objectives must be carefully monitored with direct measures and data collection, data analysis and program modifications as warranted. Additionally, because generalization is one of the goals of every program, the extent to which the learned skill is generalized should be part of the mastery criteria and data sheets. Dr. Larsson testified that the District’s ABA program did not have these attributes of a well-designed and implemented program. In essence, he believed that STUDENT required an ABA program of the kind studied by Lovaas in 1987, and believed to produce the most progress for the autistic child. Dr. Mary Large essentially agreed.
Cynthia Norall did not agree that STUDENT needed a program with thirty to forty hours of intensive ABA. She was of the opinion that the District’s program for STUDENT met his needs. She testified that the Holmes SDC program was a good one, at least in part because the teacher and staff used a variety of methodologies, including ABA, TEACCH, and PECS, and that these were used effectively to meet STUDENT’s needs. It also provided STUDENT with the opportunity to be with other children and to practice his skills in a more natural and less restrictive environment. She also stated that the school-based program supervised by CASE met STUDENT’s need for intensive one-on-one ABA therapy. According to Dr. Norall, that program was properly designed and implemented.
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the evidence that STUDENT’s part-time placement in an SDC was an appropriate part of his program and one that helped to meet his needs for improved communication and social skills. He was also persuaded, principally by Dr. Larsson, that STUDENT’s total program needed to be approximately thirty-five to forty hours per week and that there needed to be a significant amount of one-on-one ABA.
STUDENT received no ABA for almost three months. Thereafter, ten hours were provided. The District failed to offer persuasive evidence that the amount of ABA was enough to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide an educational benefit. The District also failed to convince the Hearing Officer that the ABA program that was provided was properly designed and implemented. There was insufficient proof that data were being properly collected, recorded and analyzed. The Hearing Officer has significant concerns about supervision. There was a wholly inadequate showing that Dr. Norall, who was the only witness arguably qualified to supervise the program during this school year, was sufficiently connected to the process to effectively and timely monitor the program and make adjustments as necessary. It took a coincidental display of maladaptive behavior in the plain sight of Dr. Norall and Dr. Freeman in January 2001 for Dr. Norall to recognize that something had to be done about STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors. This was months after the IEP team had requested an FAA, a request that Dr. Norall did not even acknowledge.
The District argued that its combined program of SDC and ABA provided an educational benefit to STUDENT as evidenced by the progress he made. However, there was inadequate evidence to support a finding that STUDENT made more than trivial progress. The evidence showed that there may have been minimal progress. STUDENT was able to attend for longer periods of time and would make more frequent, but only fleeting, eye contact. It did not establish that he made significant progress in most of the other targeted skills.(Footnote 16) The District did not carry its burden of establishing that STUDENT’s ABA program conferred an educational benefit of the kind contemplated by the law.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s combined SDC/ABA neither met STUDENT’s unique needs nor provided an appropriate educational benefit.
Speech and Language
The District offered thirty minutes weekly of individual speech and language therapy and thirty minutes weekly of small-group speech and language therapy. Petitioner claims that he required two hours weekly of individual speech and language therapy.
In support of his argument, Petitioner offered the testimony of Kidstreet speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad. Ms. Haddad testified that she would have recommended that STUDENT receive two sixty-minute individual speech therapy sessions per week when he first came into a District program due to the severity and range of his speech and language deficits, and also due to the fact that STUDENT has a language disorder that causes him to learn at a slower rate. She said that she is providing a higher level of services now (three one-hour sessions weekly) to make up for the inadequate level of services delivered prior to STUDENT’s enrollment in the Kidstreet program in November 2002.
The District spent little time directly defending its speech and language program that was provided during the 2000-2001 school year. Melissa de-Mayo, a District speech and language specialist who received her master’s degree in communicative disorders in December 2001, testified that the same level of services (sixty minutes weekly) offered by the District in the July 20, 2001 IEP was appropriate at that time. There is documentary evidence to show that STUDENT made some progress toward some of his speech and language goals during that school year. However, the evidence was insufficient to carry the District’s burden of establishing that the services provided were appropriate. STUDENT entered the program essentially nonverbal, using primarily gestures and leading adults toward objects to make his desires known. There was little evidence that STUDENT could do much more by the end of the 2000-2001 ESY.
The District did not offer sufficient evidence to establish that its speech and language services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Nor was the evidence sufficient to support a finding that the provided services conferred an educational benefit on STUDENT. STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year did not meet his unique critical need for behavioral supports and interventions, including an FAA and, more likely than not, a BIP. This failure doomed the rest of STUDENT’s program. Even the District’s witnesses complained that STUDENT’s continued maladaptive behaviors interfered with his learning in all environments and were a substantial factor that prevented him from benefiting from his education. The failure by the District to meet this need was underscored by the fact that the IEP team directed that the behavioral supports be provided. In failing to follow that direction, the provided program failed to conform to STUDENT’s IEP. In addition, the District’s ABA and speech and language components did not meet STUDENT’s needs and failed to confer a meaningful educational benefit. All of these deficiencies resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY.
Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
The evidence showed that STUDENT’s deficits and areas of need were essentially the same during the time that he was in the District’s program in the 2001-2002 school year as they were the prior year.
Behavioral Support and Interventions
Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT’s behavior became worse between the fall of 2001 and the winter of 2002. Ms. Miranda agreed that she continued to see the maladaptive behaviors after STUDENT’s return to Holmes in September 2001. Dr. Norall, who had just assumed responsibility for supervising the home-based program, also noted an increase in these behaviors at home. The doctor characterized the increase in problematic behaviors as an “extinction burst,” or a sharp increase due to the concerted effort under way to extinguish those behaviors. She also stated that the increase may have been related to STUDENT’s adjustment to the daily home-based program. However, the evidence did not support either of these opinions.
The District convened an IEP meeting on December 18, 2001.(Footnote 17) District psychologist Suzanne Boyles and CASE consultant Dr. Sarah Turner were both present. The purpose of the meeting is not specifically stated in the documents, but it appears to have been convened for the purpose of considering the District’s recent assessments.(Footnote 18) STUDENT’s progress toward goals was reviewed and new goals were developed. There was no discussion about past behavior plans, at least one of which should still have been in effect, and there were no changes to STUDENT’s program except one. The team dispensed with a behavior plan. Ms. PARENT agreed, but she did request an increase in the ABA services to twenty to thirty hours per week.
The IEP documents state that the team determined that a behavior plan was no longer necessary because STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors were no longer being seen. According to Ms. Boyle’s testimony, this decision was based on the teacher’s assessment. The IEP states that the decision was based on the report that on a single day, October 11, 2001, STUDENT committed no acts of aggression and attended to structured activities eighty-nine percent of the time. No documentation of this observation on October 11, 2001, was attached to the IEP or offered into evidence. This date, more than two months before the IEP meeting, falls during the time when most of the witnesses, including Dr. Norall, agreed the maladaptive behaviors were increasing. The IEP also suggests that the decision may have been based in part on absence of acts of aggression observed during the District’s assessment in late November and early December 2001.
Considering STUDENT’s long history of significant maladaptive behaviors, it does not appear to the Hearing Officer that there was adequate information provided to the IEP team on December 18, 2001, to justify its decision to eliminate the behavior plan from STUDENT’s IEP. There was no evidence that Ms. PARENT complained to the IEP team that STUDENT’s behaviors continued to be a problem but she testified at the hearing that the behaviors were ongoing. Other evidence corroborates that testimony. On December 18, 2001, the same day as this IEP meeting, one of STUDENT’s paraeducators documented that STUDENT was “more aggressive than usual,” crying, hitting, and constantly trying to leave.
Ms. PARENT testified that there was an increase in the maladaptive behaviors beginning in January or February 2002. There were instances of the behaviors documented in the ABA logs in January, February and March 2002. Dr. Norall testified that she was aware of the increase in these behaviors during early 2002. When asked her opinion about STUDENT’s need for behavioral interventions at the time the IEP team dispensed with the behavior plan, she qualified her agreement with the team’s decision by stating that she did not believe that one was required in the school setting, though STUDENT continued to need those interventions in the home. The Hearing Officer found the doctor’s testimony to be unpersuasive. The evidence showed that STUDENT continued to need behavioral interventions across all environments.
Aside from the entries in the ABA logs for the home program that CASE supervised, Dr. Norall’s notes of the March 21, 2002 clinic meeting show that she was also aware of some continuing maladaptive behaviors at both home and school during the month prior to STUDENT’s withdrawal. On April 17, 2002, Ms. Miranda recorded nine attempts by STUDENT to escape a structured activity by rolling on the ground, three acts of aggression outward or toward objects and one act of aggression toward another individual, all in the school environment. A few days later, STUDENT was withdrawn from the SDC at Holmes.
The evidence showed that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continued, perhaps with some periodic abatement, throughout the 2001-2002 school year while he was at Holmes. The District did nothing to comply with the IEP team’s request for an FAA. The order stood until December 18, 2001, when the IEP team dispensed with the FAA and behavior interventions altogether. The evidence showed that this was done when the need for effective behavioral support and interventions still existed. The evidence also showed that the need continued, and remained unmet, during the rest of the year. For a second year, the District failed to meet a critical need for behavioral interventions. That continuing failure substantially interfered with STUDENT’s education and prevented him from receiving educational benefit.
ABA Program
STUDENT began the 2001-2002 school year receiving the same ten hours of ABA that he had been receiving the prior year, except that all of the hours were being delivered to him at his home through District staff supervised by Drs. Norall and Turner (CASE). At about the same time, STUDENT began to receive an additional eight hours per week of ABA, delivered on weekends, and two hours of supervision weekly from California Psychcare, funded by HRC.
Dr. Norall testified that she was satisfied that STUDENT had about a fifty-hour-per-week program while both the District and HRC were providing home-based ABA.(Footnote 19) If, in fact, STUDENT’s need for an ABA program was satisfied by the combined services of the District and HRC, STUDENT would be unable to show that he suffered any compensable loss as a result of the District’s failure to provide all of the components of his program.(Footnote 20) However, the District did not prove that STUDENT’s ABA program was designed to meet his unique needs and implemented in a way that was calculated to confer an educational benefit on him during the 2001-2002 school year.
The Petitioner’s evidence showed that professionals and independent organizations, such as the national Research Council, recommend a minimum average of twenty-five to thirty-five hours per week of ABA.(Footnote 21) As with the prior year, Dr. Norall stated the program met STUDENT’s needs as evidenced by his progress, but the evidence did not support that view. Apart from the conclusory statements of the District’s witnesses, there was inadequate evidence of significant progress by STUDENT during his time in the District’s program. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to carry its burden to show that the ABA program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and implemented in a way that was calculated to confer an educational benefit.
The evidence showed that there was no adequate collaboration among the various providers of ABA services during the 2001-2002 school year. The two home-based ABA programs went forward with no apparent coordination for at least a month when Ms. PARENT complained about the lack of collaboration.(Footnote 22) Finally, at an IEP meeting on November 20, 2001, the team, including Drs. Norall and Turner, agreed to collaborate with California Psychcare. Monthly clinic meetings were to be held. Consistent with good practice, the meetings should have included as many of the professionals working with STUDENT as could attend. However, the evidence showed that there was minimal properly documented collaboration among the District providers and none involving California Psychcare.
At most, four clinic meetings were held during the 2001-2002 school year before STUDENT was removed in April 2002. It was not always clear who attended these, but it is certain that no one involved in STUDENT’s HRC-funded ABA program attended any clinic meeting, and there was no evidence that they were invited. There was no clinic meeting at all in December 2002 or January 2003. Dr. Norall explained that this was because there was an IEP meeting in December, and she was sick in January. These excuses did not constitute persuasive evidence that the clinic meeting were not required. The lack of collaboration was even apparent to and a concern of Ms. Miranda. She testified that she was worried about STUDENT’s apparent loss of skills in her class in March 2002. She attended a clinic meeting on March 21 and stated her opinion that she thought STUDENT would do better if there were more effective collaboration.
There was no significant disagreement between the parties regarding the importance of recording clear data to track STUDENT’s progress, or lack of progress, toward his goals and objectives. The professional who oversees the program should be reviewing the data to make informed judgements regarding necessary adjustments to the program. The data are also helpful to inform the instructors/trainers regarding the status of the child’s program. The District failed to show that data were properly gathered, recorded and analyzed. As with the analysis of the 2000-2001 school year, most of Dr. Norall’s testimony about the quality of the home-based ABA program and about her efforts to analyze performance data and adjust the program as necessary was based on generalities and unsupported by specific documentation. If the log books and other pertinent documents had been regularly reviewed by a qualified program supervisor, the lack of consistent progress toward goals and objectives—or the absence of any evidence of consistent progress—would have been apparent and changes would have been made to address the lack of effectiveness.
Because the District failed to establish through the evidence that the ABA program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that it was not. The Hearing Officer also finds that the ABA program for the 2001-2002 school year was not implemented in a way that was reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit.
Speech and Language
STUDENT continued to receive sixty minutes of speech and language therapy weekly (thirty minutes individual and thirty minutes group) throughout the 2001-2002 school year. Melissa de-Mayo testified that this was an adequate level of service when she recommended it in July 2001 for the following year. She said that her recommendation that STUDENT receive only thirty-minute sessions was based on STUDENT’s short attention span and her desire to not overwhelm him. She did not attend the December 2001 IEP meeting and does not know how or why the team decided to maintain the same level of service, but she agrees that it was an appropriate level. She did not say why she agreed.
Ms. de-Mayo provided the speech and language services during the year. She said that at times she would spend most of the session just trying to redirect and refocus STUDENT on the therapy goals. This testimony indicates that on those occasions only a small portion of the thirty minutes would actually be used for instruction. Ms. de-Mayo described STUDENT’s progress toward his speech and language goals as slow but steady.
Donna Jeffers is a qualified speech and language therapist with a certificate of clinical competency who has been with the District for sixteen years. She conducted the November 2001 speech and language assessment of STUDENT and attended the December 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Jeffers testified that the services offered in the December 2001 IEP were sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. That opinion was based on a report by Ms. de-Mayo that STUDENT had made progress toward his speech and language goals with that same level of service. However, the Hearing Officer found no report in the evidence that clearly demonstrated that STUDENT was making real progress. It appears from the documents and testimony that the team’s review of STUDENT’s progress towards speech and language goals was actually based on the November 20, 2001 report of Ms. Miranda, who attended the IEP meeting. Her report covers only three of the five speech and language goals from the July 2001 IEP. On those, achievement is either not reported in terms that can be used to gauge progress toward the benchmark or the progress is clearly de minimus.
Jane Haddad testified that STUDENT should have been receiving more services. She explained that services should not be limited based on the child’s short attention span. She did not state how much of the services he should have been receiving, but only that he should have been receiving more, based in part on the lack of documented progress toward annual goals.
There was another speech and language progress report by Ms. de-Mayo in March 2002. It reported on the five goals that had been carried over from the July 2001 IEP and on the two new goals developed at the December meeting. This report notes progress for some goals, but fails to provide a measure. It appears to show regression on at least one goal. Ms. Miranda also did another progress report that month that covers three of the same speech and language goal and a PECS goal that Ms. de-Mayo did not report on. There was no clear progress reported on any of them. In spite of this lack of documented, meaningful progress, the IEP team noted “great progress in all developmental areas” at the May 29, 2002 IEP meeting to review STUDENT’s progress for the year.
The District failed to meet its burden to establish that the speech and language services were appropriate. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that at the time of the July 2001 IEP meeting, the speech and language services offered were appropriate. He finds that at the time of the December 2001 IEP meeting, the available information indicated that STUDENT was not making meaningful progress toward his annual speech and language goals. Services should have been increased at that time. They were not. That lack of meaningful progress continued through the 2001-2002 school year until STUDENT’s removal in April. The level of service provided during that year was not adequate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide a meaningful educational benefit.
The District’s program failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for behavioral supports, ABA, and speech and language services during the 2001-2002 school year. These failures combined to deny STUDENT a meaningful educational benefit.
Issue No. 4: Did the District fail to offer a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner for the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year?
May 29, 2002 IEP
The May 29, 2002 IEP was intended by the District to constitute its offer to STUDENT from that date until December 18, 2002. The placement and services offered to STUDENT in that IEP were the same as those that had been provided during the 2001-2002 school year.
There was nothing in the evidence to indicate that STUDENT’s deficits and areas of need were not the same on May 29, 2002, as they were during that 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the three areas under consideration and was not reasonably calculated to confer an educational benefit, particularly with regard to STUDENT’s need for behavioral interventions. The District made no effort to show that there was a sufficient change of circumstances to justify a further inquiry regarding this offer that was conveyed less than six weeks later after STUDENT was withdrawn from the District program. It appears from the evidence that the District convened the IEP meeting and conveyed the offer to reaffirm its confidence in the program from which his parents had withdrawn STUDENT. The only conclusion supported by the evidence is that the offered program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for appropriate behavioral supports, ABA and speech and language therapy and was not reasonably calculated to confer an educational benefit.
November 27, 2002 IEP
The District’s pending offer of a placement was contained in the November 27, 2002 IEP. That IEP provided for continued placement in the Holmes SDC, ninety minutes weekly of speech and language therapy (one thirty-minute individual session and two thirty-minute small group sessions), occupational therapy (already agreed upon), and twenty hours of ABA per week (ten at school and ten at home) to be provided by District staff. The IEP also offers ESY, transportation and modifications as necessary to help STUDENT to transition back into a school-based program. The IEP does not include a behavior intervention plan.
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
There is considerable dispute concerning whether or not STUDENT has made any real progress since he left the District’s program and, if so, to what that progress is attributable. There does not appear to be any significant disagreement regarding STUDENT’s deficits and areas of need at the time of the November 27, 2002 IEP meeting. They were the same as those previously identified with two possible changes. The Hearing Officer will address whether or not there was a continuing need for behavioral supports to address maladaptive behaviors. He will also examine STUDENT’s need for a plan to ensure a successful transition back into a District program in the event such a return occurs.
At the time of the November 2002 IEP, STUDENT had not attended a District program since his withdrawal in April 2002. Until November 2002 he was served only through the LIFE ABA program. According to Mr. Chavez, the early work in STUDENT’s home program focused on increasing his attention levels and decreasing the maladaptive behaviors. Mr. Chavez testified that aggression, escape, and other maladaptive behaviors that were impediments to STUDENT’s learning have been eliminated and are no longer an issue. Ms. PARENT agreed. However, there was some evidence that causes the Hearing Officer to be concerned that these behaviors could reoccur, at least occasionally. Ms. PARENT admits that STUDENT will still tantrum up to twice per month. STUDENT was evaluated by an occupational therapist in late July and was found to be essentially out of control on that day. When District staff observed STUDENT in his home on November 20, 2002, some avoidance behavior was observed.
Ms. PARENT and Mr. Chavez would be in the best position to know whether or not STUDENT continued to need any specific behavioral intervention in late November 2002. They testified that he did not and that the behaviors that significantly interfered with his learning were no longer a problem. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by their testimony that STUDENT no longer needed any particular behavioral intervention to address maladaptive behaviors. However, the Hearing Officer is also mindful of the risk to STUDENT and others if STUDENT is returned to a District placement where these behaviors were at one time a substantial factor and those behaviors return. Therefore, if STUDENT returns to a District program, the District must be vigilant against the return of those behaviors. If any appears, it must be addressed properly and effectively.(Footnote 23)
If STUDENT is returned to a District program, he will require a gradual transition that is calculated to minimize the stress to him. To that end, his current needs include the need for an appropriate transition plan. The Hearing Officer found the recommendations of Mr. Chavez regarding the need for a gradual transition to be sound. The Hearing Officer also finds that the development and implementation of an appropriate transition will require the cooperation and participation of not only STUDENT’s family and District personnel, but also personnel form both LIFE and Kidstreet.
ABA Program
According to Mr. Chavez and Ms. PARENT, STUDENT made substantial progress in the LIFE program by December, after eight months. The maladaptive behaviors that had been a significant impediment to STUDENT’s learning had by then been under control. By the time a transition from STUDENT’s current program to a District program could be implemented, he will have had approximately eleven months of intensive ABA from LIFE. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Mr. Chavez and Ms. PARENT that STUDENT now truly is a different child than he was when he struggled in the District’s program during prior years. With his improved attention and almost no behaviors to interfere with his focus, STUDENT should be able to obtain a greater benefit from the ABA services offered. The Hearing Officer also considers the fact that the District has offered twenty hours of ABA, twice the amount previously provided. This amount of ABA is close to the average minimum recommended by the National Research Council.
The Hearing Officer believes that the ABA component of the District’s offer is fairly viewed in the broader context of the instructional component that includes the morning SDC placement. STUDENT would spend his mornings, another twenty hours per week, in Ms. Miranda’s SDC, where he would have additional one-on-one and small-group attention. The total instructional component of STUDENT’s program will be forty hours without taking speech and language and occupational therapy services into account. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Mr. Chavez, Ms. PARENT, and, to some extent, Dr. Large, that STUDENT is ready to learn in and benefit from the classroom experience. The law has a strong preference in favor of educating disabled children with peers. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the preference should be followed in STUDENT’s case.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the totality of the record that the District’s current offer of a forty-hour program, excluding speech and language and occupational therapy DIS, is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The evidence supports the finding that STUDENT will receive an educational benefit from the offered placement in Ms. Miranda’s SDC and that the ABA component of the District’s offer, if properly implemented, will provide an appropriate intensive element to the overall program and meet STUDENT’s ABA needs.(Footnote 24) The Hearing Officer finds that the ABA program component of the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with a meaningful educational benefit.
Speech and Language
The District has offered twice the amount of small-group speech and language therapy that had been provided in the past but the individual therapy offer is not changed. Ms. Haddad is currently providing services for three hours per week, at least in part to make up for the inadequate services provided by the District in the past. For the purposes of this determination, the Hearing Officer is concerned only about an appropriate level of service to meet STUDENT’s current needs and to provide a meaningful educational benefit.(Footnote 25)
Ms. Haddad was both a qualified and credible witness. She has a master’s degree in speech pathology and has been a licensed speech and language pathologist and certified as clinically competent in California since 1996. According to Ms. Haddad, STUDENT has a language disorder that causes him to learn at a slower rate. His language deficits are still significant. She confirms that STUDENT is attending well and making good progress at Kidstreet with his one-hour sessions. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Jane Haddad that STUDENT’s current needs require two one-hour sessions weekly of individual speech and language therapy. The Hearing Officer believes that more individual instruction will allow him to better focus on his speech and language goals.
The District’s current offer fails to provide an appropriate level of individual therapy. It is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and confer a meaningful educational benefit. The IEP should be amended to provide for two sixty-minute individual sessions per week. District personnel may provide the service. The Hearing Officer finds that with the required change, STUDENT’s unique needs for speech and language therapy will be met and he will receive the necessary educational benefit.
Transition
The current IEP offer includes an offer to modify the program as necessary to accommodate STUDENT’s transition back to a District program. The Hearing Officer finds that a gradual transition is necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. However, the IEP does not contain an appropriate transition plan. One will have to be developed. The plan should be the result of a collaborative effort involving STUDENT’s parents and District, LIFE, and Kidstreet personnel. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Mr. Chavez that the plan should also provide for the direct participation of LIFE and Kidstreet personnel in the transition process. The Hearing Officer believes that LIFE in particular will need to play a significant role in an appropriate transition. Finally, the transition needs to be completed within a reasonable period of time, not to exceed twenty-five school days.
The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of the inadequate speech and language services and the absence of a specific transition plan, the District’s December 2002 offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to confer an appropriate educational benefit. The IEP team should be allowed an opportunity to correct the deficiencies. STUDENT’s parents should then be allowed to reconsider the District’s offer as amended.
Issue No. 5: If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately obtained services from LIFE and Kidstreet and, if so, in what amount?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Burlington does not require that the placement or services chosen by the parent be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s, the parent’s placement must meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student with educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
The Hearing Officer has found that the District denied a FAPE to STUDENT during the entire time that he was in a District program. It was reasonable that Mr. and Ms. PARENT were frustrated by April 2002 by which time the District had consistently failed to appropriately meet their son’s unique needs for nineteen months. The Hearing Officer also finds that the PARENT’s rejections of the District’s May 2002 and the December 2002 offers were also reasonable. Neither of those offers were offers of a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the LIFE program and the additional speech and language services provided by Kidstreet did address STUDENT’s needs and provide an educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the services rendered by LIFE and Kidstreet according to proof to be submitted to the District.
Issue No. 6: If the District failed to provide or offer a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.
ABA
The Hearing Officer cannot determine from the record that an award of additional ABA instructional hours is required to compensate STUDENT for his past loss of educational opportunity. According to Mr. Chavez and Ms. PARENT, STUDENT had made substantial progress in the LIFE program by December. He will undoubtedly have made even more progress by the time a transition can be effected. The record did persuade the Hearing Officer that the District’s ABA program was deficient in substantial part due to improper or ineffective implementation of the program.(Footnote 26) The Hearing Officer will seek to address that deficiency in the ABA compensatory education award.
Mr. Chavez testified that he is able to effectively manage STUDENT’s workshop program with a monthly meeting, but he is also directly involved in the training and overall supervision of the instructors. Clinical case supervision requires a ninety-minute session weekly in the Lovaas clinic. The Hearing Officer believes that STUDENT is entitled to receive ongoing LIFE assistance that will provide oversight and consultation services regarding STUDENT’s program. It is intended that these services will provide STUDENT with an added level of supervision of his ongoing program while providing STUDENT’s parents with an informed voice with which to advocate for their son. As a compensatory education award, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must pay for continuing consultation and oversight services from Mr. Chavez or another comparably qualified LIFE supervisor through the end of the 2003-2004 extended school year. The nature and level of the services provided shall be determined by STUDENT’s parents, but the total number of hours shall not exceed ten hours per month.
Speech and Language
Jane Haddad testified that STUDENT should have been receiving two hours per week of individual therapy when he first presented to the District. She is currently providing three hours weekly to make up for some of the losses from the earlier years.(Footnote 27) Ms. Haddad reports that STUDENT is attending and progressing well on his current schedule of three one-hour sessions per week. The Hearing Officer has already determined that two hours of weekly individual therapy is required to meet STUDENT’s current needs.
Kidstreet has been providing STUDENT with what amounts to an hour per week of therapy to make up for past losses. STUDENT will have received approximately five months of those additional services by the time a transition to a District speech and language program can be accomplished. The Hearing Officer finds that a reasonable compensatory education award for STUDENT’s loss of speech and language services would be approximately equal to one hour of individual speech and language therapy per week for the time that STUDENT was receiving inadequate services from the District, less the time that he has been receiving what amounts to compensatory services from Ms. Haddad. The Hearing Officer awards sixty-five hours of individual speech and language therapy. District personnel may provide the services, which are to be used as determined by the IEP team, with reasonable consideration to the opinions of Ms. Haddad and a careful view toward not overwhelming STUDENT with services.
CONCLUSION
The District repeatedly failed to address the Petitioner’s unique needs for behavior support and intervention. It also failed to provide appropriate ABA and speech and language services. Because the Hearing Officer believes that the District’s November 2002 offer of a placement and services is appropriate, subject to a change to the speech and language services and the addition of a transition plan, the District will be ordered to convene an IEP meeting to make those changes. The Hearing Officer also believes that the development of an appropriate transition plan will require input for the professionals who have been responsible for STUDENT’s programs in recent months. For that reason, the Order will require that Mr. Chavez and Ms. Haddad be invited to participate in the development process at the expense of the District. To ensure that the participation of Mr. Chavez and Ms. Haddad is efficient and effective, the Hearing Officer will require that information be exchanged as necessary to accomplish the transition objective.
The Hearing Officer considers it important that the transition plan provide for a gradual move from STUDENT’s current programs to the District’s program, but he also recognizes that the transition should be completed within a reasonable period of time. The parties offered no evidence that assists the Hearing Officer to determine a reasonable time. The Hearing Officer believes that the parties should be able to complete the transition process within approximately five school weeks.
The Petitioner’s parents should have a reasonable opportunity to consider the District’s offer of an IEP that has been amended in conformity with the Hearing Officer’s Order. The Hearing Officer finds that five calendar days is a reasonable time for the Petitioner’s parents to consider the offer and to agree or disagree with it.
The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the services rendered by LIFE and Kidstreet. In addition to the obligation to pay that reimbursement, the District should be required to assume responsibility for payment of the expenses related to the participation of LIFE and Kidstreet in the transition process, including the cost of ABA and speech and language services rendered by those agencies in the course of the transition. If the Petitioner’s parents agree with the new IEP offer, reimbursement will be due for services rendered on or before the date that the Petitioner’s parents agree to the new IEP. The District will concurrently assume responsibility for the cost of ongoing services rendered in connection with the transition.
The reasonable compensatory education award requires that the District pay for additional services to be rendered in the future by Mr. Chavez through the end of the ESY for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer chose Mr. Chavez because he has experience supervising the Petitioner’s ABA program and the Petitioner’s mother has expressed her preference for LIFE as a provider of services. However, in the event that Mr. Chavez is unavailable or unwilling to provide the service, the Petitioner’s parent should be allowed to select an alternative provider who is comparably qualified, but the expense to the District shall not be greater because of the change.
ORDER
1. The District shall convene an IEP meeting within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision. Francisco Chavez and Jane Haddad shall be invited to attend at District expense as consultants to the team. The IEP team shall:
(a) amend the IEP to change the speech and language services from the current services to two one-hour individual speech and language sessions per week; and (b) develop a transition plan to provide for a gradual and facilitated transition of STUDENT from his current program to the District’s program, as amended. The IEP team shall carefully consider the opinions of Mr. Chavez and Ms. Haddad in the development of the plan. The transition plan shall:
(i) provide for the gradual reduction of LIFE and Kidstreet services and corresponding increases in District-provided services; (ii) allow Mr. Chavez and Ms. Haddad to provide the District information that will help to insure a smooth transition, preserve the benefit of past gains, and avoid wasted effort; (iii) require the District to provide to Mr. Chavez and Ms. Haddad information that is reasonably likely to assist them with their transition efforts; (iv) provide that an ABA instructor, selected by Mr. Chavez, and Ms. Haddad may accompany STUDENT to the District’s program as the IEP team deems appropriate to ease his transition; and (v) provide for the completion of the transition process within twenty-five school days of the parents’ agreement to the IEP as amended.
2. For the purpose of determining the District’s reimbursement obligation, Petitioner’s parents, or either of them, shall have a reasonable period of time, not to exceed five calendar days, within which to consider and indicate their agreement or disagreement with the IEP as amended in conformity with this Order.
3. The District shall pay all of the costs for services rendered by LIFE and Kidstreet in connection with the development and implementation of the transition plan referred to in paragraph 1 of this Order, including the cost of ABA and speech and language services provided by those agencies during the transition period.
4. The District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents for all amounts paid by them or that they are personally obligated to pay to LIFE and Kidstreet for services rendered on or before the date on which the parents indicate their agreement or disagreement with the IEP as amended in conformity with this Order. If neither parent indicates agreement or disagreement with the IEP as amended, the District’s obligation to reimburse shall apply to services rendered on or before the fifth calendar day following actual communication of the proposed IEP to Petitioner’s mother. The amount of the reimbursement shall be according to proof submitted to the District by the parents and shall be due within fifteen days of the delivery of such proof.
5. As compensatory education, the District will pay LIFE for the cost of the continuing consultation and oversight services from Mr. Chavez through the end of the 2003-2004 extended school year. The District’s obligation shall be limited to ten hours per month.
6. As further compensatory education, the District shall provide sixty-five hours of individual speech and language therapy to the Petitioner. The IEP team shall determine the scheduling of these additional hours with a view toward avoiding overwhelming the Petitioner with services.
7. The District shall be alert for the recurrence of maladaptive behavior that has the potential to interfere with the Petitioner’s education. If such behavior recurs, the District shall promptly and effectively address the behavior, including the prompt completion of a functional analysis assessment and the development of a behavior intervention plan as deemed necessary by the IEP team.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue No. 1: Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by psychologist Dr. Mary Large and speech and language pathologist Jane Haddad (Kidstreet)?
The Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: Has the District failed to offer a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school and extended school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 5: If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately obtained services from LIFE and Kidstreet and, if so, in what amount?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 6: If the District failed to provide or offer a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated February 25, 2003 ____________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues have been organized by the Hearing Officer to facilitate adjudication. 2. STUDENT’s father, Mr. PARENT, also lived in the home until approximately November 2001. He still spends a significant part of the day in the home with STUDENT.
3. The report of the assessment explains that no formal assessment was possible because STUDENT did not adequately attend to pictures or objects. 4. Discrete trial training is a form of applied behavioral analysis. The acronym TEACCH stands for Treatment and Education of Autistic and related Communication-handicapped Children. It is an instructional method that emphasizes structure in a visually enhanced and language reduced environment.
5. A functional analysis assessment (FAA), often referred to as a Hughes Bill assessment, is a systematic analysis of specifically identified maladaptive behaviors that significantly interfere with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. When the instructional and behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective, a functional analysis assessment must be conducted. Upon review of the results of the FAA, the IEP team develops a behavior intervention plan (BIP), if necessary. The authority for the requirement is discussed below.
6. The meeting was also purportedly called to address several biting incidents during which another child bit STUDENT.
7. It was also reported at this meeting that HRC would be funding some additional home-based ABA. As discussed below, the record showed that the HRC-funded services did not begin until the fall of 2001. 8. During the meeting, there was nothing written in the IEP document about ABA. However, later that same day, the District sent a note to Ms. PARENT and her attorney advising them that the team had inadvertently omitted the ABA services from the offer. 9. Assessment might also be to determine eligibility. That was not an issue here. 10. Ms. PARENT testified that the aggressive behaviors did not become a problem until after STUDENT entered a District program. 11. Mr. Anzures could not administer this test to STUDENT in April 2000 due to STUDENT’s poor attention. 12. Within weeks of his enrollment, the IEP team determined that STUDENT needed an FAA, and probably a BIP to address his behaviors across all environments. 13. Consistent with the terminology used by the parties, the Hearing Officer refers to the various programs provided to STUDENT (other than the SDC, speech and language, and occupational therapy) as ABA programs. 14. This assessment was under contract with HRC. It was not an FAA.
15. Ms. Miranda was also providing the home-based ABA at the time. 16. The inclusion in IEP documents of descriptions of STUDENT’s progress as “tremendous” or “great” are not convincing evidence, even when the parents sign the IEPs. 17. There were IEP meetings on October 23 and November 20, 2001, that did not result in any change to STUDENT’s program.
18. It may also have been convened in the hope that Petitioner would produce a report from the independent assessment requested by him in August 2001. 19. The Hearing Officer estimates that STUDENT was receiving closer to thirty-eight hours per week of class and home instruction, excluding speech and language and occupational therapy. 20. Likewise, there would be no loss to parents of a child whose needs were met through services rendered at no cost to the parents.
21. Dr. Larsson testified that he has recommended a minimum of thirty hours per week, but he considers forty hours to be safe and appropriate. The National Research Council has recommended twenty-five hours per week. 22.Dr. Norall denied that there was such a complaint, but her notes dated October 26, 2001, confirm such a discussion. 23. The District would be expected to use generally accepted methodologies and qualified staff. 24. Proper implementation should include qualified staff, proper data recordation and analysis, collaboration with consistency across environments, and adequate supervision. Collaboration will require the full participation and cooperation of STUDENT’s family. 25. Past losses will be addressed below.
26. It appeared from the evidence that the CASE consultants, particularly Dr. Norall, devoted too little time and effort to the management and supervision of STUDENT’s program. 27. It may be that STUDENT’s levels of performance were depressed when he began his therapy with Ms. Haddad because he had gone without speech and language services for at least six months. However, the Hearing Officer does not consider that to be a significant factor for the purpose of devising an appropriate compensatory education award.
