California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 4, 1997
Student v. Gateway Unified School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 184-97, SN 684-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Gateway Unified and Shasta County Office of Education win on North Valley placement; student gets transition support and OT.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. The decision notes a prior SEHO decision in SN 880-94/884-94 (February 3, 1995), which ordered the student returned to the Buckeye SDC and denied compensatory education. This decision addresses only the period after February 1995.
Summary
The parent of a 15-year-old boy filed for hearing against Gateway Unified School District and the Shasta County Office of Education. The case was combined with an earlier district filing. The boy was eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed. He had Tourette syndrome and severe behavior problems. He had been on home-based independent study with one-to-one specialists from Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA), a nonpublic agency. The parent asked to reclassify him as mentally retarded based on a Children's Health Council assessment. The parent also sought BETA services, speech therapy, occupational therapy (OT), payment for dental work, classes at Central Valley High School, and compensatory education. The district proposed North Valley School, a nonpublic school.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote kept the emotional disturbance eligibility. She found the council's low test scores did not fit years of earlier testing or what staff had seen. She found the district's programs after February 1995 appropriate. The exception was a gap: the student had no services from mid-November 1996 until BETA resumed in spring 1997, apart from the time a substitute teacher served him. She held that North Valley was appropriate and was his least restrictive environment, and she rejected the large high school. She denied speech therapy, dental work, and compensatory education. The student won consultative OT and one-to-one support for at least 60 days while moving to North Valley. The district had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and place him within 20 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed one outside assessment that found mental retardation against years of consistent testing and staff observation. It also shows a Hearing Officer finding that a gap in services denied an appropriate education, yet declining compensatory education. She pointed to the district's ongoing efforts and to a new placement that met the student's needs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT appropriately identified as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) or should his special education eligibility criteria be changed to mildly to moderately mentally retarded?
Student still meets SED criteria; the Children's Health Council's low cognitive scores were likely depressed and conflicted with years of consistent testing and staff testimony, so eligibility stays SED.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Have the District and the COE failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?
The SDC, Dynamics nonpublic school, independent study, and Live Oak placements after February 1995 were appropriate, but Student was denied an appropriate education from November 16, 1996 until BETA resumed full-time services after April 1997 (excluding the substitute teacher's period), and APE was not provided.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does STUDENT require the services provided by the Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) or a similar program to benefit from his education?
Student needs one-to-one behavioral and academic support for at least 60 days while transitioning to North Valley; choice of agency is left to the District.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Does STUDENT require speech and language therapy to benefit from his education?
No witness testified Student needs speech therapy; the CHC pathologist said he would not qualify, his speech is understandable, and she recommended only teacher collaboration.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Does STUDENT require occupational therapy to benefit from his education?
Based on the uncontradicted CHC occupational therapist's testimony, which the District did not dispute, Student is entitled to consultative OT.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Is the District or the COE required to pay for STUDENT's dental work to replace his front teeth?
Replacing teeth is an excluded medical procedure and was not shown to be necessary for educational benefit, so neither agency must pay for it.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 7. Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
North Valley, a small, structured nonpublic school with behavioral, academic, and vocational programs, meets Student's needs and is his LRE; a comprehensive high school with class changes was not appropriate, but goals must be updated.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 8. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education was denied: the District reasonably relied on the SED identification, provided credentialed teachers, and made ongoing good-faith efforts, and North Valley meets Student's needs.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to (a) draft an IEP reflecting current functional levels from the Children's Health Council assessment; (b) draft goals and objectives, including APE and OT goals, based on those levels; (c) develop a plan to transition Student to North Valley; and (d) determine the level of consultative OT.
- Placement ordered. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, place Student at North Valley School and provide APE, one-to-one intervention services, and consultative OT.
- Order to provide or change services. Continue individual behavioral and academic support through BETA or a similar agency for at least 60 days after placement at North Valley.
- All other requests for relief denied, including compensatory education, speech therapy, payment for dental work, and reclassification.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Department of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56363; Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.1; 5 C.C.R. § 3030
People named in the decision
- Geralyn M. Clancy, attorney for Student (1997)
- Dale Mentink, attorney for Student (1995), Protection & Advocacy, Inc.
- Robert N. Varma, attorney, Far Northern Regional Center
- Wendy Bell, regional center case manager, Far Northern Regional Center
- Joan Day, regional center case manager, Far Northern Regional Center
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District and COE
- Donald B. Barber, director of special education, Gateway Unified School District
- Emily Davis, SELPA director, Shasta County SELPA
- Sheila Miller, assistant superintendent, Shasta County Office of Education
- F. Richard Ruderman, former SEHO Hearing Officer (SN 684-95)
- Mark Paxson, SEHO Hearing Officer in prior case SN 880-94/884-94
- Suzanne Cresswell, occupational and physical therapy evaluator (January 1996 report)
- Jean Hatch, SDC teacher, Buckeye Middle School
- Charles Herbert Shiro, treating psychiatrist
- Richard (Dick) Bishop, school psychologist; 1994 triennial assessor
- Kenneth J. Wahl, educational psychologist; 1994 academic assessment for District
- Ronnie Detrich, behavioral consultant; functional analysis assessment and behavior plan, Spectrum Center
- Roy Reddin, principal, Buckeye Middle School
- David E. Comings, physician, Tourette syndrome specialist, City of Hope National Medical Center
- Michael Mongold, clinical psychologist; staff trainer
- Frank J. Marone, founder, nonpublic agency; behavior assessment and plan; witness for Student, Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA)
- Susan Burkhardt, supervising psychologist for BETA specialists, BETA
- Larry Douglass, independent behavioral consultant; expert witness for Student
- Malinda Abel, advocate; witness for Student
- Linda Rasmussen, board member, Tourette Syndrome Association northern California chapter; witness for Student
- Ann Yancey, SDC teacher, Central Valley High School
- Ginny Rimpila, SDC teacher, Central Valley High School
- Sammi Ford, SDC teacher, Central Valley High School
- Jody Dougan, SDC teacher; former paraprofessional; independent study teacher Oct. 1995–Dec. 1996
- Nanci Emmons, RSP teacher at Live Oak, Shasta County court schools
- Bill Dehart, school psychologist (Live Oak)
- Michelle Fourre, school psychologist and counselor
- Laurleen Scholz, SDC teacher; independent study curriculum coordinator
- Roger Dee Schoonover, BETA recreation companion and implementation specialist; later District long-term substitute teacher
- Jesse Brewer, front desk supervisor, YMCA
- Art Taylor, owner and dean, nonpublic school, Dynamics Research Resource Skills Center
- Peter Emmons, principal, nonpublic school, North Valley School
- Amber Lee, high school teacher, North Valley School
- Cheryl Amber, assessment team coordinator, Children's Health Council
- Tina Guterman, neuropsychologist; CHC assessor, Children's Health Council
- Jane Rulifson, educational specialist; CHC assessor, Children's Health Council
- Judith Cunningham, speech-language pathologist; CHC assessor, Children's Health Council
- Winifred Schultz-Krohn, occupational therapist (OTR); CHC assessor, Children's Health Council
- Mary Cunningham, independent psychologist; 1990 assessment
- Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA), nonpublic agency providing one-to-one behavioral services
- Children's Health Council, nonpublic agency; 1997 triennial assessment
- Spectrum Center, nonpublic agency; behavioral consultation
- Dynamics Research Resource Skills Center, nonpublic school (prior placement)
- North Valley School, nonpublic school (ordered placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was convened before Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redding, California on April 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11, and May 20, 1997. In case SN 684-95, which was filed by the District, former Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman took the testimony of one witness by telephone on July 31, 1995, and convened the hearing in Redding on August 8, 1995. Prior to taking any testimony on that date, the parties agreed to mediate and, thereafter, the matter was taken off calendar and continued a number of times by agreement of the parties.
STUDENT was represented at hearing dates in 1997 by attorney Geralyn M. Clancy. (Footnote 1) Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER. Present for a portion of the hearing were attorney Robert N.Varma and case managers Wendy Bell and Joan Day of the Far Northern Regional Center. (Footnote 2) Educational consultant G. Robert Roice appeared at the hearing on behalf of Gateway Unified School District and the Shasta County Office of Education (COE). Also present was Donald B. Barber, District director of special education. Emily Davis, director of Shasta County SELPA, and Sheila Miller, assistant superintendent Shasta COE, appeared briefly on April 7, 1997.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. On June 16, 1997, written closing arguments were received from the parties. Thereafter, the matter was closed and submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Ms. Miller of the COE appeared at the time and place for hearing. The COE stipulated that it would provide adapted physical education (APE) to STUDENT beginning on April 21, 1997, for 40 minutes per week until STUDENT is placed in a classroom. The COE also stipulated that it would place STUDENT in a class operated by the COE if so ordered by the Hearing Officer. Ms. Miller then left the hearing.
ISSUES
(1) Is STUDENT appropriately identified as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) or should his special education eligibility criteria be changed to mildly to moderately mentally retarded?
(2) Have the District and the COE failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?
(3) Does STUDENT require the services provided by the Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) or a similar program to benefit from his education?
(4) Does STUDENT require speech and language therapy to benefit from his education?
(5) Does STUDENT require occupational therapy to benefit from his education?
(6) Is the District or the COE required to pay for STUDENT's dental work to replace his front teeth?
(7) Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
(8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 15-year-old young man. He is identified as eligible for special education as a seriously, emotionally disturbed student. STUDENT has been given a number of varying diagnoses including mildly to moderately mentally retarded, learning disabled (SLD), Tourette's Syndrome (TS), attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), chronic motor tic disorder, organic brain dysfunction, bipolar manic severe with psychotic features, depressive disorder, conduct disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). STUDENT has been treated with a number of medications to manage his behavior and to reduce tic and seizure activity and has been hospitalized several times. STUDENT has not attended school since June 1996. His IEP calls for 25 hours per week of independent study provided by an implementation specialist employed by Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA), a nonpublic agency. The District provides a credentialed teacher to develop materials, adapt curriculum, and meet weekly with the BETA specialist. Behavioral intervention plans have also been developed and implemented by BETA. When the hearing began in April 1997, STUDENT had not received services from BETA since November 1996. Ms. PARENT was implementing the independent study program under the direction of a District teacher. When the hearing reconvened in May 1997, BETA had employed a new specialist, who had met several times with STUDENT. In March 1996, the IEP team agreed to provide OT sessions and consultative APE to STUDENT and to incorporate goals and objectives set forth in the occupational and physical therapy evaluation report dated January 25, 1996, by Suzanne Cresswell. (District's Exhibits 44, 46, and 47) Other current goals and objectives, which have been continued since September 15, 1995, are to improve word comprehension, reading comprehension, elementary number concepts and computation, and behavioral skills and to demonstrate an understanding of the writing process. (District's Exhibit 43)
Ms. PARENT and her husband adopted STUDENT when he was 10 months old. (Footnote 3) STUDENT was diagnosed with craniosynostosis, an absence of the sutures separating the membranous bones of the skull. Corrective surgery took place at 14 months of age. STUDENT required a second surgery when he was two years old to remove an infected rubber tip that had been inserted to keep the suture open.
STUDENT was initially determined eligible for special education in 1987, when he was five years old, as a student with a serious emotional disturbance. He received special education services in several different special day classes (SDC) operated by the COE. In 1989, Shasta County Mental Health conducted an AB3632 assessment and determined that STUDENT was eligible for twice weekly individual and group therapy and treatment with medication because of a high level of activity, aggressive acting-out behavior, and poor attention and concentration. (District's Exhibit 6) In the fall of 1992, STUDENT enrolled in Buckeye Middle School as a fifth-grade student. Buckeye is in the Gateway District. He was placed in an SDC taught by Jean Hatch. From April 28, 1993, through June 8, 1993, STUDENT was hospitalized at Langley-Porter Psychiatric Institute in San Francisco, California, following a behavioral outburst at home. (District's Exhibit 11; STUDENT's Exhibits pages 177-181) STUDENT did not return to school for the remainder of the 1992-1993 school year. From July 9, 1993, through July 28, 1993, STUDENT was hospitalized at Sun Ridge Hospital in Yuba City, California, because of violent outbursts.
At the beginning of the 1993-1994 school year, STUDENT returned to the SDC taught by Ms. Hatch. His attendance was sporadic and he was hospitalized several times because of his behavior. From October 5, 1993, through October 27, 1993, STUDENT was hospitalized due to "agitation, obsessive behavior, argumentativeness, Tourette's Syndrome, and out-of-control behavior." (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 172-176) Another hospitalization at Sun Ridge occurred from October 30, 1993, through November 12, 1993, due to "explosive outbursts, aggressive, to mom, Tourette's Syndrome, hyperactive, needs medication adjustment." (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 167-170)
STUDENT's behavioral problems at school escalated in December 1993. On December 17, 1993, STUDENT was in his classroom without permission during a recess. When Ms. Hatch spoke to him about this, STUDENT "went crazy," left the classroom and the school campus, and proceeded to walk into traffic on Lake Boulevard, a large four-lane street, until persuaded to return to the campus by a school employee. STUDENT became agitated when informed that his mother had been called to pick him up from school. When Ms. PARENT arrived, STUDENT's behavior escalated and she physically restrained him on the floor for two to two and one-half hours. On the first day of STUDENT's return to school following the holiday recess, he became upset with another student and became agitated. Ms. PARENT was called to take STUDENT home at noon. At that time, the primary plan for dealing with STUDENT's behavior was to contact Ms. PARENT to take STUDENT home. On January 10, 1994, an IEP team met and developed a behavioral intervention plan. The plan was not implemented because STUDENT did not return to school for the remainder of the 1993-1994 school year. The District provided STUDENT with home instruction based on the recommendation of Charles Herbert Shiro, Ph.D., a psychiatrist who treated STUDENT during his hospitalizations at Sun Ridge. On January 24, 1994, STUDENT was hospitalized at Sun Ridge for a fourth time. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 163-166)
The IEP team met on January 21, March 7, and April 20, 1994. The purpose of one of the meetings was to discuss the results of STUDENT's triennial assessment, which was completed in March 1994 by Richard Bishop, school psychologist. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), STUDENT's verbal score was 78, his performance score was 57, and his full scale score was 65. On the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), a measure of academic achievement, STUDENT obtained the following standard scores: broad reading-97; broad mathematics-49; broad written language-75; and broad knowledge-83. Mr. Bishop concluded that
STUDENT is likely to do best in a school and classroom environment that: 1) is not overly stimulating; 2) has a small classroom population; 3) is highly structured; 4) provides consistent, predictable routine; 5) allows STUDENT to work at his level of academic skills development; 6) provides constant close adult supervision of all students as an integral part of its educational program; 7) has a readily available ‘quiet room' for STUDENT to go to calm himself when he becomes agitated; 8) provides a staff person, or persons, to help students like STUDENT to learn to control escalating behavior; 9) in general, provides a behavioral focus within its educational milieu. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 131, 134, and 152)
In a letter dated March 4, 1994, C. Herbert Shiro, M.D., who treated STUDENT at Sun Ridge, made the "primary" recommendation that "episodes of escalating behavior be identified and handled promptly primarily by isolating STUDENT from outside stimulation which would escalate his behavior at these times and also by one-to-one communication urging STUDENT to regain control of his behavior." (STUDENT's Exhibits page 161) In June 1994, Kenneth J. Wahl, Ed.Psy., assessed STUDENT's academic achievement for the District following a request by Ms. PARENT for an assessment. STUDENT's standard scores on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), a measure of academic achievement, included the following: basic reading-109; reading comprehension-86; listening comprehension-90; mathematics reasoning-62; numerical operations-52; and spelling-87. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 116) Dr. Wahl concluded that STUDENT's profile was typical of a student with a learning disability.
At an IEP meeting in August 1994, the team drafted goals and objectives and adopted an interim behavioral intervention program. The District contracted with Ronnie Detrich, Ph.D., a behavioral consultant with the Spectrum Center in Berkeley, California, to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT, to observe him at school, and to develop a behavioral intervention program for him. (See District's Exhibit 16; STUDENT's Exhibit 17) The District also employed a second instructional assistant for Ms. Hatch's class. Dr. Detrich observed STUDENT on September 7 and 8, 1994, and spoke with his mother and a number of school employees to obtain information for the behavioral intervention plan. During Dr. Detrich's observations, STUDENT became agitated after lunch. On September 7, STUDENT was able to control his agitation. On September 8, STUDENT's agitation was not controllable and he left the school campus, walked along Lake Boulevard waving a stick, and entered the driveway of a private residence where he was physically restrained by the school's principal, Roy Reddin. The police were called and because they believed that STUDENT was a danger to himself, he was taken to Shasta County Mental Health. (See District's Exhibit 10) STUDENT did not return to Ms. Hatch's class and was then placed on "home and hospital" instruction.
On September 27, 1994, Dr. Schiro made the following recommendations:
...the patient requires a long term treatment plan including intensive behavioral therapy in order to provide social skills training, psycho-social support, amelioration of compulsive rituals and improved self esteem. A therapeutic program must address STUDENT's neuro-muscular impairment with a program which includes appropriate physical activity and specific training in social skills relevant to self care. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 163)
On September 30, 1994, the District requested a special education due process hearing. (Case No. SN 880-94) On October 3, 1994, Ms. PARENT requested a hearing on behalf of STUDENT. (Case No. 884-94) The hearing requests were consolidated. An incident of aggressive behavior by STUDENT against his mother and the home teacher occurred on October 25, 1994. STUDENT would not follow the teacher's instruction to write his name. STUDENT slapped and yelled at his mother, attempted to hit his teacher, banged his head on the wall, and bit a chair. (District's Exhibit 12) On November 17, 1994, STUDENT was seen by David E. Comings, M.D., director of the department of medical genetics, City of Hope National Medical Center. Dr. Comings is well known for diagnosing and treating persons with TS. Dr. Comings described STUDENT as a "bright boy" with "excellent academic skills." He diagnosed STUDENT with TS, ADHD, and OCD. Dr. Comings recommended that a "time-out" space be identified at school for STUDENT to allow him to "gather himself" and to calm down. Additional modifications suggested by Dr. Comings included allowing STUDENT to tape-record classes, to use a computer for homework, and to have a calculator available for his use in the classroom. Dr. Comings stated that STUDENT could be placed in a regular classroom if an appropriate medication regime could be determined. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 109)
On February 3, 1995, Hearing Officer Mark Paxson rendered a decision in Case No. SN 880-94/884-94, that ordered the District to convene an IEP meeting to develop a transition plan to reintroduce STUDENT to Ms. Hatch's SDC at Buckeye Middle School, to readmit STUDENT into Ms. Hatch's SDC, to take necessary steps to implement the behavioral intervention plan developed by Dr. Detrich, and to train school personnel regarding STUDENT's disability and implementation of the behavioral intervention plan. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 348-375)
The IEP team convened on March 17, 1995, to develop a transition plan to implement STUDENT's return to Ms. Hatch's SDC. The team met again on April 18, 1995. The team developed the transition plan and Ms. PARENT consented to an assessment of STUDENT's speech and language and to an assessment by an occupational therapist. The transition IEP includes goals and objectives to improve reading and math skills and to learn punctuation and capitalization rules and keyboarding. The transition plan states that two special aides would be hired by the District. The aides were to receive training, including use of physical restraint. The plan also delineates training for the staff by Michael Mongold, a clinical psychologist, and by the COE employees. The plan calls for STUDENT to be gradually reintegrated into the class. Additional components of the plan include:
alternative strategies for dealing with stress (including opportunities to ask for assistance, to talk out stress, to walk, time in a quiet area, change of academic activity and increased oral instruction.) Specialists aides will monitor STUDENT' level of stress and give STUDENT cue cards to help him signal when he needs help or a change of task. The behavior plan includes using classroom tangible reinforcers such as chips worth different points to be cashed in daily; and grab bag opportunities. Additional reinforcers that STUDENT responds to include crackers, stickers, basketball cards, and time to play basketball or to garden. STUDENT' academic subjects will follow previous IEP goals and objectives....STUDENT' behavior during structured academic and unstructured time will be charted by the specialists, monitored by the teacher and school psychologist, and summarized in a format to be sent home daily at first and then phased to weekly as needed. Social skills training will be provided by school psychologist and specialists. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 383-384) (See also pp. 35-38, 379-382, 513-518)
The record includes a number of reports of STUDENT's difficult behavior on return to the classroom, including the ones summarized below: On April 5, 1995, STUDENT had difficulty transitioning to reading from a break. He kicked a chair, cursed, and lifted a chair over his head as if he intended to throw it. Ms. Hatch removed the other students from the class. After a while, the aides were able to calm STUDENT and he went with them to shoot baskets. On the way back to class, STUDENT stood on a bench and twisted small branches off the tree. He again became agitated when encouraged to go to his class and kicked and cursed at his aides. Other students in the area were told to return to class. STUDENT then stated his intent to kill himself. The aides then physically assisted STUDENT off the bench and, when he refused to go to a designed quiet area, the aides physically restrained him. The aides were then able to guide STUDENT to the quiet room but again had to restrain him because he was kicking and yelling obscenities. STUDENT had a nosebleed and it was reported that he attempted to "snort out" blood on the school psychologist. After a while, STUDENT calmed down and returned to work. (District's Exhibit 63, pages 9-14)
On April 25, 1995, STUDENT was apparently disturbed by the noise from another student's blowing his noise. They exchanged a few words, and, when the encounter did not end, the aide told STUDENT to leave the room. He would not leave voluntarily. The two aides attempted to escort STUDENT down the ramp from the classroom; however, he wrapped his legs around a pole. The aides determined that it was necessary to use prone constraint with STUDENT because he continued to struggle with them and to use obscenities. After about 20 minutes, STUDENT was released and he sat in a chair. After a few minutes, STUDENT became agitated again, was threatening and cursing, and had to be restrained for another 20 minutes. STUDENT calmed down; however, as he re-entered the classroom, he again became agitated, disruptive, and threatening. The aides attempted to escort STUDENT outside but had to contain him to control him as he left the classroom because he was attempting to kick school staff as well as the railing of the ramp leading from the room. The record includes additional incident reports dated May 3, 4, 10, 17, 18, 23, 24, 25, 26, and 31. The incident reports include accounts of STUDENT screaming, swearing and calling people names, lunging and swinging at people, threatening to harm himself and his mother, hitting his face on the floor, punching himself and others in the groin area, running away and refusing to go home, and defying teachers and aides. Reports of STUDENT's appropriate and on-task behavior from April 3, 1995, to May 31, 1995, ranged from 14% of the day to 60% of the day. The number of times in one day that STUDENT's behavior required physical intervention ranged from zero to 14. (District's Exhibit 63) The parties concurred that STUDENT continued to have behavioral problems in Ms. Hatch's class and it was agreed that services would be obtained from BETA. .
In May 1995, Frank J. Marone, Ph.D., BETA, prepared a positive behavioral assessment report and intervention plan. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 546-558) He identified the following areas of concern: leaving designated areas; unacceptable physical behavior; unacceptable verbal behavior; procrastination/slow performance; and refusal of requests made by others. Each identified area of concern includes a description of the concern, its history, an ecological analysis, identification of antecedent and consequent events, impressions, analysis of meaning, and alternatives. The report also recommends interventions and long- and short-term behavioral objectives including setting up, maintaining, and using a calendar system to select, prepare for, and remember daily activities; constructing an activity schedule for 30-minute intervals; self-selecting 50% of the activities; participating in a self-monitoring system tracking behaviors; meeting weekly to discuss and plan activities; and determining how to secure equipment. Positive programming interventions include helping STUDENT to develop physical endurance, age-appropriate daily living skills, and to learn to avoid, suppress, and/or delay vocal tics. The plan also calls for assistance in developing social skills and coping skills. Reactive strategies identified in the plan include "waiting for restoration of a positive and constructive situation so that direct instruction, positive feedback, and other assistance can resume;. . . minimally intrusive, silent, physical or gestural interactions . . .to bring about restoration of a positive and constructive situation. . .; and, if additional reactive strategies should prove necessary, program personnel will develop these specific to individual situations that have arisen three times during the course of the intervention." (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 555-557)
On July 10, 1995, the District requested a hearing regarding STUDENT's educational program and placement. (SN 684-95) On July 31, 1995, Hearing Officer Ruderman took the testimony of Dr. Detrich by telephone. The hearing convened in Redding on August 8, 1995. The parties engaged in settlement discussions and the matter was taken off calendar. On August 17, 1995, the IEP team agreed to place STUDENT at the Dynamics Research Resource Skills Center, a nonpublic school (NPS) in Redding, for 181 school days and to provide him with "intervention" services from BETA for up to six hours per day. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 33-34)
Another IEP meeting was convened on September 15, 1995. The team reviewed a speech and language assessment and determined that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for speech and language. The team also reviewed results of an occupational therapy assessment. No treatment goals were recommended; however, the OT agreed to reevaluate STUDENT no later than February 2, 1996. The team drafted academic goals and objectives to improve word comprehension, reading comprehension, elementary number concepts and computation, and understanding of the writing process. The team also adopted behavioral goals drafted by Dr. Marone. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 27)
STUDENT attended Dynamics with his BETA specialist fairly successfully for a little more than one month; however, on Friday, October 13, 1995, STUDENT did not want to leave Dynamics to go home with his BETA specialist. STUDENT attempted to stab himself with a pencil and held a chair above his head. When Mr. Taylor, owner and dean of Dynamics, intervened, STUDENT turned his anger toward him. Mr. Taylor moved form the area and STUDENT followed him. The BETA specialist intercepted STUDENT, who then took several swings at him with his fist. STUDENT continued to challenge Mr. Taylor to fight. The BETA specialist then pushed STUDENT down on a couch and STUDENT began kicking him. STUDENT left the school and walked down Cypress Avenue, a wide street in Redding. He stepped into traffic at least one time and headed back toward the school with a beer bottle over his head. He was also yelling and cursing. When STUDENT arrived back at the school, he broke the bottle on a retaining wall in front of the school. He then left, found a rock, and was going toward a car with the rock. Another BETA specialist caught up with STUDENT and contained him. When STUDENT was calm, Ms. PARENT drove him home. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 641-642; testimony of Mr. Taylor)
The IEP team met on October 27, 1995. District members of the IEP team continued to recommend placement in a nonpublic school, APE, and a referral to mental health for an AB 3632 assessment. The District offered to place STUDENT at North Valley, an NPS located in Redding. Ms. PARENT rejected the District's proposal and requested that STUDENT be provided independent study. The IEP states that in "deference to the parent," the District agreed to contract with BETA to provide individual services to STUDENT for up to 25 hours per week under the supervision of a credentialed teacher provided by the District. Ms. PARENT agreed to monthly APE consultation and that STUDENT would continue to work on goals and objectives from the IEP dated September 15, 1995. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 24)
Several different BETA specialists worked with STUDENT. One was removed because he was alleged to have pushed STUDENT on a bed. Another quit because he felt that STUDENT was beyond his control. The next BETA specialist worked with STUDENT at his home until that arrangement was no longer feasible. They then worked at the Shasta College library until asked to leave. Reports from STUDENT's BETA specialists include numerous reports of behavioral outbursts. (See District's Exhibits 20 to 24) For example, reports dated September 26, 1995, and October 13, 1995, describe STUDENT as having a "full tantrum." (District's Exhibits 23 and 24) A report dated October 24, 1995, states that STUDENT "began vocalizing threats and profanity directed toward his mother." He also took several swings at the groin area of the BETA specialist. (District's Exhibit 20) On October 30, 1995, STUDENT kicked and attempted to tackle the specialist, and for two hours "hurled insults and other verbal barrages" at his mother and the specialist. (District's Exhibit 21)
At an IEP meeting on June 12, 1996, the team determined that STUDENT would be placed in a transition class at Live Oak, a public school. The transition class is for students transitioning from a restrictive placement to a less restrictive placement. Goals and objectives from the IEP dated September 15, 1995, continued. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 621-624) STUDENT attended Live Oak for one hour daily from June 18 to June 20, 1996, and for two hours each from June 24 to June 27, 1996. On July 1, 1996, STUDENT was sent home because of his behavior. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 631-633) An addendum to the IEP dated July 3, 1996, states that "all special education for academic subjects will be suspended for the Live Oak ESY ‘transition' period. Live Oak special education personnel will observe & assist the regular classroom teacher and BETA aide only when requested. This is being done at the request of BETA & the parent." (STUDENT's Exhibits page 21) On July 8 and 9, 1996, STUDENT attended school for a full day. On July 10, 1996, STUDENT's BETA specialist determined that STUDENT should go home following his refusal to follow directions. (District's Exhibits 25 and 26) STUDENT was not precluded from returning to Live Oak; however, Ms. PARENT withdrew STUDENT and he did not return. Thereafter, STUDENT received direct individual instruction from a BETA implementation specialist for a total of five hours daily.
On approximately November 18, 1996, BETA stopped providing services to STUDENT. In a letter dated December 16, 1996, BETA stated that it had not ceased providing services to STUDENT but was "in the process of evaluating STUDENT's progress and determining the necessary conditions of future success." The letter also states that the last specialist serving STUDENT had left BETA's employ and that BETA was in the process of recruiting and hiring a replacement. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 20) The District hired a substitute teacher who had previously served as a BETA recreation specialist to deliver STUDENT's independent study program. At some point in early 1997, Ms. PARENT began carrying out the provisions of the independent study program under the direction of a District special education teacher. As of April 1997, a new BETA specialist was hired and he continues to provide one-to-one services to STUDENT.
The parties agreed that the Children's Health Council (CHC), a nonpublic agency, would conduct STUDENT's triennial assessment. The assessment took place over a four-day period in January 1997 and included psychological, educational, speech and language, and OT evaluations. (See STUDENT's Exhibits pages 39-79 and below) The CHC team concluded that STUDENT has TS, an anxiety disorder not otherwise specified with obsessive compulsive features, and mild to moderate mental retardation. The team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a "small, structured, socially safe classroom with a low student-to-teacher ratio, one-to-one teaching, with students of similar cognitive functioning....Curriculum should be functional in nature with emphasis on community life skills and prevocational training. Language, reading, writing, and mathematics should be centered on this functional curriculum." The CHC recommended consultative OT services.In a letter dated March 24, 1997, Mr. Barber requested that Ms. PARENT consider allowing County Mental Health to conduct an AB3632 assessment of STUDENT. Permission has not been given. On February 24, 1997, Ms. Clancy requested a special education due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT. (SN 184-97). By agreement of the parties, the case filed on behalf of STUDENT, SN 184-97, and the District's case, SN 684-95, were consolidated and the matter proceeded to hearing on April 7, 1997. STUDENT seeks to continue services with BETA or another similar agency and to enroll in a combination of RSP and SDC classes at Central Valley, a comprehensive high school within the District. The District proposes to place STUDENT at North Valley, a certified nonpublic school in Redding.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE
STUDENT's Witnesses
Larry Douglass is an independent behavioral consultant. He testified that the general purpose of his consultations is to develop the most positive understanding of the reasons a student is having difficulty so that he can facilitate the student's education in the least restrictive environment. Mr. Douglass testified that he generally works with students with developmental disabilities and behavioral challenges. At the request of Ms. Clancy, Mr. Douglass met STUDENT and Ms. PARENT for about one hour at their home and observed the program at North Valley for four hours for the purpose of determining whether North Valley is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. While at North Valley, Mr. Douglass spoke with Mr. Emmons, a behavioral specialist, and Amber Lee, one of the high school teachers. Ms. Lee described to him how she individualizes the curriculum and the way in which she implements school rules. Mr. Douglass testified that Ms. Lee told him that the school achieves the greatest level of success for students who have been in a "desperate" state and who are living in a very structured group home. Mr. Douglass described everything at North Valley as "costed out." In other words, each behavior is worth something specific.
Mr. Douglass stated that the school employs time-out and that students are "timed out" in an area that is approximately eight feet by ten feet. Time-out is not administered in the "classical" manner. Students in time-out at North Valley are expected to "cognitively process rehearsal for the next time." According to Mr. Douglass, students remain in time-out until they can explain how to behave appropriately. Mr. Douglas expressed concerns about the way time-out is implemented at North Valley. He stated that students may be sent to time-out for any type of a behavioral problem. For example, a student who "talks back" to a teacher may be disciplined in the same way that a student who hits a teacher is disciplined. Mr. Douglass testified that during his observation of time-out, one student was placed in a prone position and an adult was sitting on the student's lower back. Mr. Douglass stated that as many as 10 students could be in time-out at one time. Mr. Douglass described North Valley's behavioral intervention program as "consequence based." The students know that an inappropriate behavior will result in specifically defined consequences. Mr. Douglass testified that the Hughes Bill requires teaching the student replacement behaviors.
Mr. Douglass testified that the basis of all behavior is communication and that it is important to gain an understanding of what the student is communicating through his/her behavior and to be creative in finding ways to alleviate the inappropriate behavior. Mr. Douglass testified that it is absolutely necessary to teach students in a positive way at all times. He expressed the opinion that something positive can always be said about whatever the student is doing. For example, if STUDENT gets out of his chair and goes to the back of the room, rather than telling him that he needs to sit down, the teacher should say, "I am glad you did not leave the room." Other responses may be, "I'm glad you did not hear him. I am glad you moved away." This approach differs from the approach at North Valley because it begins to descriptively frame that which is positive about a student, whereas North Valley reacts after-the-fact to something the student did. Mr. Douglass stated that making positive statements is also important for a student with low self-esteem.
Mr. Douglass concluded that North Valley is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT given his diagnosis of TS and an anxiety disorder. Mr. Douglass expressed the concern that STUDENT would be "stuck" in time-out because he would not be able to control his behavior, which is a manifestation of his disability. Mr. Douglass testified that STUDENT needs to be taught not to fear school. He also needs to develop functional reading and math skills and a system of self-monitoring.
Frank Marone, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist, licensed marriage, family and child counselor, and registered behavioral analyst. Ten years ago, Dr. Marone founded BETA , a certified nonpublic agency, to provide services for disabled children with challenging behaviors. Dr. Marone testified that BETA implementation specialists provide positive support to the student. Mr. Marone testified that before hiring someone to work with STUDENT, he would screen applicants in person and provide them with several opportunities to demonstrate how they would work with STUDENT. During the fist three days of employment, a supervisor works all day with the new specialist and demonstrates how to work with the student. On the second day, the specialist and the supervisor share responsibility for the student. On the third day, the specialist works with the student and the supervisor provides feedback to the specialist. The supervisor continues to monitor the specialist weekly and then tri-weekly. Dr. Marone testified that the specialist is encouraged to ask questions and seek clarification during weekly telephone conferences with the supervisor. The specialist is also required to mail weekly reports to the BETA central office. Dr. Marone testified that Susan Burkhardt, who supervised STUDENT's specialists, holds a Ph.D. in psychology and a Juris Doctorate degree, and is a licensed psychologist. Dr. Marone denied that any of the six specialists who have worked with STUDENT were let go for lack of performance.
Dr. Marone testified that BETA encourages persons to observe the program it provides; however, he expressed some concerns about the disruption to STUDENT's program that may be caused by observations by school district personnel. He stated that STUDENT does not like surprises and thinks that people come to stare at him. For this reason, he simply asked to be notified in advance of a visit by someone from the District so that the specialist could prepare STUDENT for the observation.
Dr. Marone testified that the BETA specialists constantly gathered data regarding STUDENT's behavior. The specialists noted whether STUDENT's behavior was "OK-not OK." STUDENT was also expected to self-monitor. The information was then sent to the supervisor to monitor. Dr. Marone testified that all of the data collected demonstrate that STUDENT's behavior improved during the period BETA was working with him. For example, the frequency and duration of crisis calls decreased; problem behaviors occurred less frequently; the outbursts were less "significant;" and all incidents were shorter in duration. STUDENT also engaged in more activities and for a longer period of time. Dr. Marone testified that he last observed STUDENT one month earlier and that he primarily relies on data from the specialist. Dr. Marone stated that BETA discontinued services to "evaluate conditions under which it might continue to provide services." He has now changed his opinion regarding some of the conditions that had to be met before BETA would continue provide services to STUDENT. Dr. Marone stated that he believes BETA can continue providing services to STUDENT. Dr. Marone testified that STUDENT's participation in a public school environment is component presently missing from his program.
Malinda Abel has advocated on STUDENT' behalf for three to four years. Ms. Abel testified that the initial behavioral intervention plan drafted by Dr. Detrich was to reduce the need to restrain STUDENT; however, the plan actually resulted in increased use of restraint. Ms. Abel did not recall the plan being modified. She stated that Dr. Detrich "implied" that elements of the behavioral intervention program were not being implemented consistently. Ms. Abel testified that Live Oak was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. For example, she did not believe that STUDENT was ready to self-monitor or that he had adequate coping skills to be successful. Ms. Abel testified that the actions of the school staff contributed to the escalation of STUDENT's behavior while at Live Oak. According to Ms. Abel, everyone at the IEP meeting agreed that the BETA specialist would take the lead and would be responsible for implementing the behavioral intervention plan. However, during the incident on July 1, 1995, Mr. Dehart told STUDENT that if he did not go to time-out that the police would be called and "was in STUDENT's face." Ms. Emmons continued to try to get STUDENT to self-evaluate even though he was becoming agitated. According to Ms. Abel, STUDENT found Ms. Emmons' presence intimidating.
Ms. Abel testified that it is important that STUDENT return to school. She testified that STUDENT's behavior improved while he was working with BETA. STUDENT accompanied her to Disneyland and Ms. Abel testified that she was impressed by his improved behavior. Ms. Abel testified that STUDENT has not been hospitalized since 1995 and that, on those occasions when the police were called by the District, STUDENT was released to his mother. On one occasion, he was held by mental health because of post-traumatic stress syndrome resulting from the incident at school. She noted that STUDENT has received rug burns and a bloody nose as a result of prone restraint implemented at the school. He also received bruises on his wrists from the police handcuffing him. Ms. Abel testified that BETA provides services for her own son who is autistic and developmentally disabled. In her opinion, her son's behavior has improved as a result of their services. On cross-examination, Ms. Abel testified that she has observed STUDENT restrained on two occasions. One observation was at her home and the other was at Far Northern Regional Center. She has not observed any of STUDENT's incidents at school and did not observe STUDENT at either Live Oak or Behavioral Resources.
Linda Rasmussen is on the board of directors of the northern California chapter of the Tourette Syndrome Association. She has a 15-year-old son diagnosed with TS. He is fully included in a regular education class with a full-time one-to-one aide provided by BETA. Ms. Rasmussen testified that the program has worked "extremely" well.
Testimony Regarding the Placement Proposed by STUDENT
Ann Yancey, SDC teacher at Central Valley High School, holds a teaching credential authorizing her to teach students with learning disabilities. Ms. Yancey's class has been proposed as a placement for STUDENT by his attorney. During the 1996-1997 school year, Ms. Yancey taught SDC social science, science, personal growth, driver's education, and English/reading classes. Ms. Yancey's classes generally have eight to nine students and one Instructional assistant. The students are developmentally delayed and some have ADHD. None of her students this year had a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Yancey testified that the typical behavioral problem she encounters is students talking back to her. Ms. Yancey testified that her classroom is located in a different wing than the other special education classes, which requires the students to transition from one wing to another. Ms. Yancey testified that the instructional program is individualized and that the average reading level of the students this past year was fourth grade. Some years, the students have had lower reading levels. Ms. Yancey testified that for social science, she adapts the regular high school history tests to the reading levels of her students. In science, she covers biology and physical science curriculums. The personal growth class is designed to help the students understand what is happening within themselves. She also covers drug and sex education.
Ginny Rimpila is an SDC teacher at Central Valley. Ms. Rimpila testified that her current students have moderate to severe disabilities. She testified that none of her students has behavioral problems and none requires a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Rimpila teaches in 90-minute blocks and addresses a life skills curriculum, toileting, feeding, cooking, and exercise. Ms. Rimpila testified that all of the students are mainstreamed for physical education and all but three of the students are mainstreamed for at least one other class.
Sammi Ford is an SDC teacher at Central Valley. She currently teaches mathematics, English/reading, and English. She has 13 students on her case load. Most of her students have learning disabilities. Two students have developmental disabilities but are high functioning and one or two of the students are seriously emotionally disturbed. Ms. Ford testified that all of the students need to be able to move from class to class, to work in groups, and to meet the requirements for high school graduation.
District's Witnesses
Richard (Dick) Bishop, school psychologist, has known STUDENT since 1992 and conducted his triennial assessment in March 1994. Mr. Bishop testified that STUDENT is not globally mentally retarded and that the only testing placing STUDENT in the retarded range was recent testing by CHC. Mr. Bishop testified that STUDENT's scores on verbal scales of intelligence testing fall well above the mentally retarded range. The retarded range would be below the second percentile, whereas STUDENT's scores fell in the sixteenth percentile. Mr. Bishop testified that the results of STUDENT's testing were consistent with a learning disability in mathematics. Mr. Bishop testified that other extensive prior assessments have also found STUDENT to function in the low average to below average range of intellectual functioning. For example, Mr. Bishop testified that Langley-Porter, which is known for its integrity, reliably diagnosed STUDENT as emotionally disturbed and did not find him to be mentally retarded. Mr. Bishop stated that Langley-Porter's assessment can be considered valid because, while at Langley-Porter, STUDENT was taken off all drugs and observed for six weeks before diagnosis and treatment recommendations were made. Mr. Bishop hypothesized that STUDENT obtained lower scores on CHC testing because the assessment was conducted over a short period of time, the assessors did not have time to establish rapport with STUDENT, and STUDENT may have been anxious. Several assessors noted STUDENT's concern that he may be removed from his home and institutionalized. Mr. Bishop also testified that when he assessed STUDENT, he utilized the WISC-R, which was the then-current edition of the WISC. Since then, the WISC-III is in use, and students generally score seven standard points lower than they scored on the WISC-R. Mr. Bishop testified that it is highly unlikely that STUDENT or any other student would score significantly higher on tests of achievement than on measures of cognition. According to Mr. Bishop, STUDENT's high achievement scores, particularly in reading, also call into question the validity of some of the low cognitive scores obtained on CHC's administration of the WISC-III. Mr. Bishop testified that STUDENT's reading scores and similarities subtests scores are not indicative of mental retardation. Mr. Bishop testified that STUDENT obtained cognitive scores that fall in the average range on the Ravens, Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, and the Kaufman.
Mr. Bishop testified that the District appropriately implemented Dr. Detrich's plan for STUDENT. In February 1995, the Hearing Officer ordered the District to provide one additional aide when STUDENT returned to Ms. Hatch's class. The District complied and then added another aide. Mr. Bishop testified that from what he knows about STUDENT, placement at the high school would not be appropriate. He stated that the staff does not have the background, expertise, or experience to address STUDENT's significant behavioral problems. STUDENT also requires a more intense program than is available at the high school.
Jean Hatch, SDC teacher at Buckeye Middle School, has more than 20 years of experience as a special education teacher. STUDENT was in Ms. Hatch's class for the fifth grade, during the 1992-1993 school year. He also was placed in her class for the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years. Ms. Hatch testified that STUDENT is not mentally retarded and that his profile is similar to that of other students with learning disabilities. Ms. Hatch testified that STUDENT is "as disturbed" as any other child she has seen. She testified that STUDENT had his ups and downs during the fifth grade. He was not aggressive, participated in the class, and went unassisted to physical education and lunch with his regular education peers. While in the fifth grade, STUDENT wrote an essay of several pages and submitted it to the principal's writing contest. He read the Indian in the Cupboard, which is at about a fifth-grade reading level, and was able to laugh at humorous parts of the story. Ms. Hatch testified that in the spring of 1993, STUDENT's behavior deteriorated somewhat. During the fall of 1993, when STUDENT was in the sixth grade, he did well in reading and social studies and his writing skills were "very good." Ms. Hatch testified that STUDENT's math skills were poor and he was unable to keep up due to sporadic school attendance. Ms. Hatch testified that in December 1993 she first realized that STUDENT could be aggressive.
Ms. Hatch testified that after the prior decision returning STUDENT to her class in the spring of 1994, she received training regarding TS and the use of physical restraint. Dr. Detrich provided additional training for the aides. Ms. Hatch testified that she gathered data documenting STUDENT's behavior to help Dr. Detrich devise ways to better meet STUDENT's needs. Ms. Hatch stated that Dr. Detrich was at her class many times. Ms. Hatch testified that when STUDENT returned to her class in the sixth grade, he would "blow up" at any time of the day. It also did not matter what activity he was engaged in or who was nearby. She was unable to identify a time, place, or activity that would "set off" STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT's incidents lasted from minutes to hours. Ms. Hatch described some of the modifications she made in her class to meet STUDENT's needs. She moved the classroom around and placed STUDENT in the front of the classroom; she provided him with choices; she changed her reward systems and curriculum; she offered STUDENT breaks; and she planned her curriculum to include STUDENT's preferred activities. Ms. Hatch testified that she changed reinforcers and included as rewards baseball and basketball cards provided by Ms. PARENT.
Ms. Hatch testified that she was very concerned about the effects of STUDENT's behavior on the other students. She stated that the students became upset when STUDENT was out of control. She had to evacuate all of the other students from the classroom up to five times a day because of STUDENT's behavior. One girl began wetting her pants and thought that STUDENT was possessed by the devil. Some students said that STUDENT was "crazy" and other students tried to justify his behavior. When STUDENT acted out, one student said he "didn't take his medicine." Another student said that STUDENT was misbehaving because his "guards were not with him." Ms. Hatch testified that the aides protected the other students in the class from harm; however, the aides and STUDENT's mother took his abuse on a number of occasions. STUDENT hit one aide with a closed fist. Another aide was cut. Ms. Hatch testified that the aides did all they could to do implement STUDENT's educational and behavioral programs and they never got angry or upset with STUDENT. Ms. Hatch testified that having STUDENT in her class was a "nightmare." She got home very late at night because of debriefings after school. Her physician put her on medical leave for two weeks because of high blood pressure and bleeding ulcers. The school psychologist could not complete assessments or work with other students because STUDENT required so much of her attention.
Ronnie Detrich, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, testified in July 1995 before former Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman. (Footnote 4) Dr. Detrich has served as a consultant to public schools through Spectrum, a nonpublic agency, for approximately seven years. Dr. Detrich's involvement with STUDENT included developing his functional analysis assessment, observing STUDENT, drafting a behavioral intervention plan (BIP), training staff, and attending IEPs. Dr. Detrich testified that he observed STUDENT name calling, swearing, striking an intervening adult, and leaving the school campus. He testified that STUDENT's misbehavior ranged from brief to long episodes. Dr. Detrich testified that STUDENT may misbehave when he misinterprets something or does not understand what is expected of him. When STUDENT returned to Ms. Hatch's class after the decision in the prior hearing, he did not have any significant behavioral episodes for approximately two weeks. The number of incidents increased, and, during the last month of school, STUDENT was having two to three crises per week. Dr. Detrich testified that all of STUDENT's behavior was challenging and not entirely predictable. His crises were likely to be more intense in the afternoon. Dr. Detrich testified that STUDENT required prone containment even after the plan was implemented. He testified that training to the Buckeye staff included strategies to employ with STUDENT, including physical management.
Dr. Detrich testified that the BIP was designed to prevent STUDENT's inappropriate behavior generally and to prevent crisis behavior from occurring. Some of the techniques included learning to identify when and what "set STUDENT off," adjusting the curriculum, providing STUDENT with choices; providing him with options to get out of stressful situations, and physically intervening when STUDENT posed a danger to himself or others. Dr. Detrich testified that the staff put out a good faith effort to implement the plan as written. He stated that to make the plan work better, ongoing adjustments needed to be made. Dr. Detrich testified that he had some concerns about whether appropriate curriculum modifications were being made, particularly because of the difficulty he had observed when STUDENT was required to do paper and pencil tasks.
Jody Dougan, SDC teacher, was a paraprofessional in Ms. Hatch's SDC when STUDENT was in the class. Ms. Dougan described STUDENT as a "likeable" young man during the fifth grade. He had friends, did his work, and participated in class. She did not find him to be aggressive; however, in March and April, he had some minor behavioral problems and his attendance was sporadic. At the beginning of the sixth grade, STUDENT's attendance was more sporadic and he began to perceverate. STUDENT's first violent incident at school occurred in December 1993 when he was disciplined for being in the class when he was not supposed to be. Ms. Dougan testified that STUDENT lunged at one student and began choking her. He also kicked her, screamed obscenities, and ran out of the class. He then attacked two other students, one in the groin area.
Ms. Dougan testified that Spectrum became involved with STUDENT's education in the fall of 1994. She stated that a behavioral intervention plan had not been developed earlier because STUDENT's behavior at school had not before been aggressive or out-of-control. Ms. Dougan stated the opinion that STUDENT's negative behaviors went unchecked and that the working relationship between Ms. PARENT and the school deteriorated after the fifth grade, which made it difficult for them to work together to address his behaviors. Ms. Dougan testified that when STUDENT returned to Buckeye as a result of the hearing decision in February 1995, the staff worked very hard to meet STUDENT's needs. They participated in training with Dr. Detrich and implemented his behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Dougan testified that on the 42 days STUDENT attended, he had 33 outbursts requiring restraint. Ms. Dougan testified that restraint was necessary to put STUDENT in a position of safety per the Spectrum plan. Ms. Dougan testified that Dr. Detrich came to the school and observed. The physical setting of the classroom was modified as were the curriculum, the rewards, and the availability of activities that STUDENT preferred.
Ms. Dougan served as STUDENT's independent study teacher from October 1995 to December 1996. She met weekly with STUDENT's BETA specialists and frequently with STUDENT. STUDENT's first specialist told her that STUDENT became violent and the specialist pushed him on the bed to control him. He left after working with STUDENT for one month. The second specialist also left after one to two months because Ms. PARENT criticized STUDENT and made it difficult for the specialist to implement BETA's positive intervention plan. Ms. Dougan testified that the second specialist also told her that he was not aware of STUDENT's behavioral problems when he was hired, did not receive any training in the use of restraint, and thought he could not handle STUDENT. STUDENT's third specialist told her that he had never seen a child stay mad for so long and that he had to restrain STUDENT for up to six hours. Ms. Dougan described her relationship with the BETA specialists as "adversarial." She stated that there was a general lack of open communication and it was clear to her that the specialists had been instructed to be very careful with what they told her. STUDENT's second specialist actually told her that he was asked by BETA not to share information with her. Ms. Dougan testified that she did not see any records that may have been maintained by the BETA specialists.
Ms. Dougan testified that STUDENT's primary need at this time is to get his behaviors under control. She believes that this can only happen when STUDENT's behaviors are dealt with in a consistent and structured environment, which cannot be accomplished on a regular high school campus. In her opinion, placing STUDENT on a regular campus will set him up for failure. Ms. Dougan testified that STUDENT's adaptive behavior is like that of a six- or seven-year-old. She stated that he does not recognize social boundaries and is not motivated by appropriately behaving peers. Ms. Dougan expressed the opinion that STUDENT's problems are not based on academic frustration. She believes that STUDENT seeks attention and power. For these reasons, Ms. Dougan also expressed concern for the safety of STUDENT because of the potential for the regular education students to retaliate against him.
Ms. Dougan testified that North Valley is a very appropriate placement for STUDENT. The school offers a predictable and extremely structured behavioral program and also has a strong life-skills component. Ms. Dougan testified that North Valley has a low student-to-teacher ratio and has a small number of students overall. North Valley serves a total of 60 students, whereas Central Valley has 1,100 students. Ms. Dougan testified that North Valley would be a "stepping stone" for STUDENT so that when he learns to manage his behavior, he can be transitioned to a less restrictive environment. Ms. Dougan stated that 40% of the students who attend North Valley transition back to a regular school campus. Ms. Dougan testified that North Valley serves students with a wide range of academic abilities and provides an individualized program to meet individual student's needs. Ms. Dougan testified that North Valley uses a cost-response system whereby students accrue points for good behavior and lose points for poor behavior. North Valley also has a token economy and students are evaluated daily on a level system. The school has daily contact with the parent and employs a full-time behavioral specialist to work with the parent and the child. Ms. Dougan's testimony regarding North Valley was based on a one and one-half hour observation and discussions with North Valley employees.
Nanci Emmons, RSP teacher for the Shasta County court schools, also has 10 years of experience as a teacher of SED students in an SDC. Ms. Emmons was STUDENT's RSP teacher at Live Oak. She both provided him with direct services and consulted and collaborated with his classroom teacher. Ms. Emmons testified that STUDENT did not appear to her to be mentally retarded. She stated that he reads well and, in conversation, demonstrates the ability to think abstractly. He also has good writing skills. Ms. Emmons testified that some of STUDENT's social skills are delayed and some are not. Ms. Emmons concluded that STUDENT has a learning disability in mathematics.Ms. Emmons testified that she implemented a "feelings" chart to facilitate discussions with STUDENT about his feelings and where he would like to be with his feelings. Ms. Emmons testified that on one occasion when she was going over goals and objectives with STUDENT, he became agitated. She stated that she was able to de-escalate the situation; however, she later received a note from BETA telling her not to discuss goals and objectives with STUDENT. Ms. Emmons expressed additional concerns about the BETA services. She stated that on a scale of zero to four, with four being high, the BETA specialist always rated STUDENT as a "four" regardless of the quality of STUDENT's work. For example, during the fist few days of class, STUDENT wrote several paragraphs daily in his journal and was given a "four." STUDENT continued to receive "fours" for his journal writing even though after several weeks, STUDENT's daily writing consisted of only a few sentences. Ms. Emmons also expressed concern that the BETA specialist provided STUDENT with the answers to his mathematics work. On one occasion when STUDENT did not want to do his work, she observed the specialist pointing to the correct answer in the mathematics work book so that all STUDENT had to do was circle the correct answer. Ms. Emmons testified that she also had to speak to the BETA specialist about speaking to STUDENT in an age-appropriate manner. Ms. Emmons stated that the specialist frequently said "We're doing our math." He also would hold STUDENT's water bottle for him and, in telling him how to tie his shoes, said, "Remember, take the snake [the shoelace]...." Ms. Emmons stated that the BETA plan was deficient in that the functional analysis assessment (FAA) did not establish a baseline of STUDENT's inappropriate behavior, which she stated is the very purpose of a FAA. The BETA plan also did not include teaching STUDENT appropriate skills and replacement behaviors. Ms. Emmons testified that the plan also lacked specific strategies to employ to deal with STUDENT's out-of-control behavior. BETA's plan was to let the BETA aide deal with it in an undefined positive manner.
Ms. Emmons testified that North Valley is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. She knows of other students making progress at North Valley. Ms. Emmons testified that the staff at North Valley is trained to implement behavioral intervention plans and the school also teaches its students age-appropriate skills. Ms. Emmons testified that regular high school staff generally do not deal with students who may require the use of physical restraint, whereas the staff at North Valley are trained to deal with assaultive students who may require the use of restraint. Ms. Emmons testified that all of the students at North Valley are placed there because of behavior that is intense, self-injurious, or assaultive.
Bill Dehart, school psychologist, testified regarding STUDENT's placement at Live Oak. He stated that the placement went well initially for STUDENT. STUDENT worked at a desk with his BETA specialist which was located away from the other students. Mr. Dehart testified that one day he was called to STUDENT's class. When he entered the room, desks were overturned, STUDENT and his BETA specialist were locked up together, and STUDENT had his fist back to hit the BETA specialist. Mr. Dehart told STUDENT that he would not hit anyone and that Mr. Dehart would call the police if STUDENT did. Mr. Dehart asked that the other students be removed from the classroom, but, instead, STUDENT and his specialist left the room and went outside to the top of the ramp leading from the classroom. Mr. Dehart testified that STUDENT kicked him as he went by. The BETA specialist informed Mr. Dehart that he was taking STUDENT home pursuant to BETA policy. Mr. Dehart testified that STUDENT was not precluded from returning to school but that he believed it was necessary to have a meeting to delineate the roles between BETA and the school.
Michelle Fourre, school psychologist and counselor, has been involved with STUDENT since 1994. Ms. Fourre testified that the behavioral plan developed by Dr. Detrich was fully implemented with STUDENT. The focus of the plan was to be proactive and always alert to STUDENT's warning signs that he was becoming agitated or frustrated. When those signs were observed, the task was shifted and STUDENT was given an opportunity to take a walk or talk out his frustration. Ms. Fourre testified that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior included being off-task and causing injury to himself or others. Off-task behavior included looking around the room, darting eyes, escalating silliness and giddiness, using bad language, and refusing to behave. Behavior with the potential to cause injury included threatening a student and aide with sharpened pencils, threatening to throw a chair at someone, and intentionally blowing blood from his nose onto his aide. Ms. Fourre testified that STUDENT threatened to kill himself and to kill his mother.He threatened to grab the groin and inflict injury to his aide. He also threatened to run away. Ms. Fourre testified that these incidents occurred during recess, activities STUDENT selected to do, and during academics. Ms. Fourre testified that she observed some tic behavior. STUDENT repeatedly turned his head to the side and said "hi." STUDENT told her that "rules don't apply to me. I come from a family of obnoxious kids" and that he would get his aides fired. Ms. Fourre testified that none of the other students in the SDC exhibited behaviors similar to STUDENT's and none of the students had to be restrained. Ms. Fourre testified that STUDENT's behavior was very disruptive to the other students, who had to be removed from class numerous times because of STUDENT's behavior. Classes near Ms. Hatch's were disrupted as well. They had to close their doors, windows, and drapes to help the students maintain focus. Students in other classes had difficulty understanding why a student was yelling obscenities and was being restrained.
Ms. Fourre testified that the BETA behavioral plan was deficient because it did not establish any baselines for STUDENT's behavior. The lack of a baseline made it nearly impossible to determine whether STUDENT's behavior had improved or regressed. Ms. Fourre testified that STUDENT's BETA program has not prepared him for returning to school. He also has not been in a social mileau with age-appropriate peers for some time and, while working with BETA specialists, he has not been required to meet behavioral or academic expectations. Ms. Fourre testified that BETA discouraged her from observing STUDENT's program. She did observe STUDENT one time at the Shasta library after which BETA responded that the "psychologist lady should not observe STUDENT without prior arrangements and approval through Marrone." Ms. Fourre testified that STUDENT never appeared to be disturbed by her presence. He spoke to her, explained what he was doing, asked her to give a message to the school librarian, and told her that he missed her. Ms. Fourre testified that she observed STUDENT twice at the Shasta College library and once at his home when he was working with Roger Schoonover.
Ms. Fourre testified that she charted data on STUDENT for 42 days and concluded that the types of behavior he was exhibiting were consistent with a serious emotional disturbance. STUDENT demonstrated an inability to learn and to make and sustain peer and adult relationships, exhibited a pervasive mood of unhappiness, somatic complaints and unreasonable fears, and exhibited unusual behavior under normal circumstances. Ms. Fourre testified that the CHC diagnosis of mental retardation is inconsistent with the definition of mental retardation, which requires that significantly low cognitive function with delayed adaptive skills occur during the developmental period. Ms. Fourre testified that there are no indications that STUDENT's early development was delayed and that, prior to CHC, no other assessor had ever diagnosed STUDENT as mentally retarded. Ms. Fourre also testified that it is highly unlikely that a mentally retarded person would be able to consistently achieve at a high level in areas requiring abstract thinking.
Ms. Fourre observed the program at North Valley for two hours in March 1996. She testified that North Valley offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it can address his social, emotional, and behavioral needs in a small, safe setting. Ms. Fourre testified that she observed positive interactions between the students and staff. The teachers consistently implemented the daily point system and provided positive comments to students. Ms. Fourre testified that she has great concerns for STUDENT's safety at Central Valley. She stated that STUDENT misreads other students and could easily get into a confrontation with them. Central Valley has a large student population and STUDENT would be required to move from class to class throughout the day.
Laurleen Scholz, SDC teacher, has been the curriculum coordinator for STUDENT since January 6, 1997. Ms. Scholz provides materials and scripted lessons to be presented to STUDENT and goes over the lesson plans with the instructor. Ms. Scholz testified that she prepares lessons in math, reading, writing, language, social studies, science, and basic skills curriculum. She specifically uses the Saxon phonics program, which is at a second-grade level. For reading, STUDENT was reading White Fang, which is at the fourth-grade level. At the beginning of the hearing, Ms. PARENT was responsible for presenting the lessons to STUDENT. Ms. Scholz testified that a new BETA specialist began working with STUDENT on approximately April 17, 1997. From the information provided by Dr. Marone when he introduced the new BETA specialist to Ms. Scholz, she believes that he is neither a teacher nor does he have prior experience as an aide. Ms. Scholz expressed some concerns about the program the new BETA specialist is implementing thus far. For example, STUDENT has done about one-third of all of the work she has provided for him, whereas when Ms. PARENT was providing the instruction to STUDENT, he was able to complete all of his work. Ms. Scholz testified that the new BETA specialist told her that STUDENT could not do listening skills activities because he does not have a tape recorder; however, Ms. PARENT said that there is a tape recorder for STUDENT to use. Additionally, the BETA specialist stated that STUDENT's best subject is math, which generally is not true. Ms. Scholz thought that math lessons may have gone better than other subjects because the math program is totally scripted, whereas other subject areas are not. Ms. Scholz testified that Ms. PARENT was pleased with the way the BETA specialist handled the only behavioral incident that has occurred since the specialist has been working with STUDENT.
Ms. Scholz testified that STUDENT is not developmentally delayed or mentally retarded. In her experience, students who are mentally retarded may develop the rote skill of decoding words or doing math computation; however, the student would not also have the ability to apply the rote skill or to comprehend what he/she has read. In contrast, STUDENT has good comprehension skills. Ms. Scholz testified that STUDENT would benefit from full-time placement in an educational program. He would receive instruction from a certified teacher, do twice the work he is now doing, and would have opportunities for social interactions.
Donald Barber, District director of special education, testified that some of the ways the District has attempted to meet STUDENT's needs include hiring consultants to develop a behavioral intervention plan; implementing a behavioral intervention plan in Ms. Hatch's class; hiring and training aides to work with STUDENT; placing him in a nonpublic school; and by currently offering a nonpublic school capable of addressing his behavioral and educational needs. Mr. Barber testified that STUDENT's behavior has been so extreme at school that his teacher was unable to teach and went on stress leave, STUDENT's class was totally disrupted even though two additional adult aides were specifically assigned to STUDENT, and many teachers and parents expressed strong opinions that STUDENT should not attend school on a regular school campus. Mr. Barber testified that STUDENT has violently acted out in class and has attacked his mother and aides. He has also threatened to kill himself on a number of occasions. Mr. Barber testified that he understands that STUDENT has had outbreaks at home and in the community and has had to be restrained even while hospitalized.
Mr. Barber testified regarding his concerns about BETA. First, BETA never took a baseline of STUDENT's behaviors and then BETA reported that STUDENT's behavior had improved 90%. Mr. Barber stated that one of the reasons STUDENT and his BETA specialist were asked to leave the Shasta College library was that the BETA specialist was behaving inappropriately toward females at the college. Mr. Barber testified that STUDENT and the BETA specialist spent a lot of time at the Shasta Mall, where STUDENT was free to do as he pleased. Mr. Barber testified that while at the mall and under the supervision of the BETA specialist, someone hit STUDENT in the mouth and knocked out one of his teeth. Mr. Barber testified that BETA objected to the District's psychologist observing a session with STUDENT because her observation would "compromise the program." One BETA specialist accused another BETA specialist of actually doing STUDENT's work for him and failing to report behavioral problems. Mr. Barber testified that BETA fired both specialists and unilaterally withdrew from the contract with the District to provide services to STUDENT. Mr. Barber testified that BETA failed initially to inform the District that it had stopped providing services to STUDENT. Mr. Barber testified that BETA made a number of demands before it would resume working with STUDENT including that STUDENT obtain an interdistrict transfer; that he be provided access to a special education classroom that is neither an SDC nor a segregated site; that Ms. PARENT obtain counseling and training for two to three hours per week; and that STUDENT obtain representation from a different advocate and attorney. Mr. Barber testified that, according to Dr. Comings, who is an expert in TS, the BETA plan for dealing with STUDENT was inconsistent with appropriate methods for dealing with the behavior of students with TS. Mr. Barber testified that it is necessary to differentiate between tic behavior and antisocial behaviors. According to Dr. Comings, there is the need for positive behavioral intervention as well as the need for consequences for inappropriate behavior. Mr. Barber testified that there were many good aspects of the BETA approach including their use of positive reinforcement, redirection, distraction, offering choices, and one-to-one attention. However, according to Mr. Barber, the BETA plan does not set appropriate limits on STUDENT's behaviors, which results in STUDENT's being empowered to manipulate the system.
Art Taylor is the owner and dean of Dynamics Research Resource Skills Center. Mr. Taylor was dean of students at Shasta College. Included in his responsibilities at Dynamics is student discipline. His wife, who teaches at Dynamics, was employed as a special education teacher at Shasta High School. Mr. Taylor testified regarding the incident at Dynamics when STUDENT would not go home with his aide and was confrontational with Mr. Taylor. Mr.Taylor testified that he is concerned that STUDENT will hurt someone and stated that STUDENT is in need of help.
Roger Dee Schoonover holds two teaching credentials and worked with STUDENT as a recreation companion, as a BETA implementation specialist, and as an independent study teacher employed by the District. Mr. Schoonover testified that in September 1996, when he was hired by BETA as STUDENT's recreation companion, neither Mr. Marone nor anyone else from BETA provided him with comprehensive training to prepare him to work with STUDENT. Only the specialist leaving the position provided him with information about STUDENT and the training provided was inconsistent with BETA's positive behavioral approach. Mr. Schoonover testified that he has concerns about BETA including his observation that the former BETA specialist allowed STUDENT to eat all the time when STUDENT was supposed to be losing weight. The specialist also bought things for STUDENT and bribed him to behave. Mr. Schoonover testified that he believes that STUDENT's work was actually being done by the BETA specialist and that his suspicions were shared by Ms. PARENT and confirmed by STUDENT, who asked him, "Why won't the specialist let me do my work?" Mr. Schoonover related that the specialist told him that he and STUDENT went to the mall to look at women and baseball cards. Mr. Schoonover testified that BETA fired him when he confronted them about the inconsistencies in the program. The District employed Mr. Schoonover on December 1, 1996, as a long-term substitute teacher to work with STUDENT. Mr. Schoonover testified that he believes that STUDENT can control his behavior. Mr. Schoonover testified that the District recently informed him that he did not need to have any further contact with STUDENT.
Jesse Brewer is the front desk supervisor at the Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA). Mr. Brewer testified that STUDENT comes to the YMCA to "work out," play basketball, and swim. Mr. Brewer recalled only one occasion on which STUDENT's behavior had been unacceptable. In December 1996, Roger, who was STUDENT's aide at that time, asked Mr. Brewer to assist him in calming STUDENT down. Mr. Brewer described STUDENT as "very agitated." He was also swearing and would not go home when requested by Roger to do so. Mr. Brewer stated that he spoke with STUDENT for 45 minutes to one hour and finally told him he could chose between going home with Roger or having Mr. Brewer call the police. Mr. Brewer testified that STUDENT was frightening the other patrons. STUDENT had to be escorted away by the police, who handcuffed him.
Evidence regarding the assessment by the Children's Health Council
Cheryl Amber, clinical psychologist, is a doctoral candidate in clinical psychologist. For the past five years she has been the assessment team coordinator for CHC. Ms. Amber, herself, did not assess STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT did not have any behavioral problems during the CHC assessment and did manifest any symptoms of TS. She stated that STUDENT's medication seemed to be under control. She also expressed the opinion that STUDENT misbehaved while in the District because the District misunderstood what he was capable of doing and, therefore, made unrealistic demands of him. Ms. Amber testified that she did not agree with Dr. Comings' description of STUDENT as "bright."
Tina Guterman, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist with a speciality in child neuropsychology, conducted the neuropsychological portion of the CHC assessment, which took place over six hours on two days. Dr. Guterman described STUDENT's behavior during testing as compliant, cooperative, and docile. She stated that he appeared much younger than 15 years old. Dr. Guterman testified that it is necessary to consider the potential impact of STUDENT's brain damage when assessing his behavior. Dr. Guterman testified that it is not uncommon for frontal lobe brain impairments to affect behavior and, as the environment becomes more complex, for the person to experience increased difficulties.
On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III) administered by Dr. Guterman, STUDENT received standard scores of 62 on the verbal scale, 52 on the performance scale, and 53 on the full scale, placing him in the mild to moderate range of mental retardation. STUDENT's adaptive functioning, as measured on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, revealed communication and socialization skills at the moderate to mild range of mental retardation and daily living skills in the moderate to severe range of mental retardation. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 63-65) On the Test of Written Language-Third Edition (TOWL-3), STUDENT obtained standard scores of 70 on contextual conventions, 70 on contextual language, and 90 on story construction. The student creates a story. The subtest contextual conventions scores the student's use of punctuation, capitalization, and spelling. The subtest contextual language evaluates the student's essay for sentence and paragraph construction, complexity of language, and syntax. The subtest story construction evaluates the student's essay for theme development, characterization, and style. STUDENT received the following standard scores on the WIAT, a measure of academic skills: basic reading-97; reading comprehension-81; listening comprehension-69; mathematics reasoning-56; numerical operations-64; spelling-89. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 48)
Dr. Guterman testified that the results of her testing place STUDENT in the mild to moderate range of mental retardation, and his deficits in adaptive functioning are consistent with his cognitive functioning. According to Dr. Guterman, the fact that STUDENT may have met early developmental milestones does not preclude a later diagnosis of mental retardation, especially given the damage to the area of the brain that impacts cognitive, social, and emotional functioning. Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT's higher scores on measures of academic achievement in reading and rote linguistic skills are "relative strengths." Dr. Guterman concluded that STUDENT needs to be understood as a boy with mental retardation and a history of TS and not as a boy with the primary handicapping condition of emotional disturbance. In the report of her assessment, Dr. Guterman stated:
The overall structure of STUDENT' learning, home, and social environments should be geared toward a child with mental retardation and behavioral difficulties, rather than an SED adolescent. It appears that there has been a cumulative, negative effect on STUDENT' behavior and sense of self from years of being viewed and treated as a boy whose prominent problem is a psychological disturbance. Instead, STUDENT should be viewed as a boy whose primary handicap is long-standing, diffuse neurocognitive impairment, mental retardation, and Tourettes with secondary, associated problems of disinhibition, attention, and conduct.
(STUDENT's Exhibit 15, page 68)
Guterman testified that STUDENT has anxieties about his body that can cause him to panic or get disorganized. Additionally, when something bothers him, he tends to express the concern in somatic terms, which is something that he can understand. For example, STUDENT put his elbow on a table and clearly did not hurt it but preceded to act as if he had. Dr. Guterman stated that STUDENT fears he will be institutionalized. She believes that STUDENT is vulnerable and subject to being exploited. Dr. Guterman concluded that STUDENT should be placed with children with commensurate cognitive skills who may also have behavioral problems. He should not be placed with students who are seriously emotionally disturbed. Because of his needs, STUDENT requires a placement that is small, self-contained, highly structured, and predictable. Dr. Guterman testified that it would not be appropriate at this time to mainstream STUDENT or to place him on a campus that requires him to change classes on his own.
Jane Rulifson, educational specialist, performed the educational portion of the CHC assessment. Ms. Rulifson testified that STUDENT was cooperative during testing and that he behaved somewhat like a younger child. Ms. Rulifson testified that STUDENT's reading skills are higher than expected given his cognitive skills. Ms. Rulifson did not see any evidence of a learning disability. She recommended that STUDENT's educational program should focus on teaching him functional life skills. She did not believe that a program that focuses on behavior is appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Rulifson concluded that:
Intervention for STUDENT should be based on his reclassification and placement as a mentally retarded individual. Appropriate curriculum for him will focus on concrete, functionally-based real-life skills. Prevocational training should begin as soon as possible. Behavioral difficulties from the past should subside as those working with him recalibrate their expectations and he is provided with a safe environment in which to deal with the world consistent with his ability to understand it.
(STUDENT's Exhibit 14, page 52)
The speech and language portion of CHC's assessment was conducted by Judith Cunningham, licensed speech and language pathologist. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-R (PPVT-R), which assesses single word receptive vocabulary, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 90. On the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Upper Extension (EOW-UE), which measures single word expressive vocabulary knowledge and the ability to recall specific words, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 89. STUDENT's receptive language score as measured by the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-3 (CELF-3) was 50 and his expressive language score was 88. Ms. Cunningham testified that STUDENT has slow auditory processing skills and that his receptive language skills are not as high as his expressive language skills. She noted that STUDENT did well formulating sentences from words provided to him and responded well to visual aides. Ms. Cunningham concluded that STUDENT's interpretation of linguistic concepts and relationships is weak; his auditory processing of linguistic information is slow; his pragmatic language skill with peers is deficient; and his ability to think abstractly about language, make inferences about meaning, and think flexibly about words is significantly delayed. She also stated that STUDENT's speech is characterized by poor articulation skills "largely the result of the absence of his front teeth" and that "STUDENT will need complete dentition in the form of false teeth, a bridge or retainer in order to correctly articulate the sounds of his language." (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 72, 75) She described STUDENT's articulation skills as "imprecise" but "understandable." Ms. Cunningham expressed concern that STUDENT could be made the brunt of jokes by his peers. Ms. Cunningham testified STUDENT will not benefit from speech and language until his teeth are replaced; however, once his teeth are replaced, STUDENT will require instruction on how to keep his tongue behind his teeth. Ms. Cunningham stated that without further testing, STUDENT would not meet eligibility criteria for speech and language services based solely on her assessment; however, collaboration between a speech pathologist and the classroom teacher could be helpful.
Winifred Schultz-Krohnn, registered occupational therapist (OTR), conducted CHC's occupation therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Schultz-Krohnn described STUDENT as "cooperative" and stated that he completed all the tasks she asked him to do. Ms. Schultz-Krohnn testified that STUDENT lacks strategies to complete academic assignments and does not read social cues well. She suggested that a one-to-one aide could help STUDENT by alerting him to what he needs to attend. She recommended consultative OT based on the results of testing that found significant deficits in both motor and sensory processing abilities. She also recommended that an occupational therapist work with STUDENT's teacher to develop strategies to teach him. (STUDENT's Exhibits page 79)
Testimony Regarding the Placement Proposed by the District
Peter Emmons has been the principal of North Valley School for 13 years. Mr. Emmons testified that North Valley is a certified nonpublic school that serves approximately 60 students, ages 11 through 16, who have failed in other educational settings primarily because of their behavior. The campus is located on an acre site and includes five academic classrooms, auto mechanics and cabinet making shops, a commercial kitchen, swimming pool, and basketball courts. Students participate in academic classes, vocational training, and physical education classes. There is an intramural sports program set up with another school. Mr. Emmons testified that all of the teachers hold special education and multiple subject teaching credentials and all the staff have a minimum of 80 hours of training in behavioral management techniques and crisis intervention. They also receive one hour of weekly training regarding the program, its structure, and behavioral intervention. The school has several full-time behavior management specialists who collect, monitor, and evaluate data regarding a student's behavior and develop and reevaluate behavioral intervention plans. Also on the school staff are case managers who monitor the students and work with the parents to help them follow through with behavioral strategies in the home environment. Mr. Emmons testified that the parents are contacted weekly for a minimum of 15 minutes. Each class has approximately 12 students, a teacher and two aides. The school employs four job coaches and three vocational specialists.
Students' cognitive abilities range from moderately mentally retarded to above average.Mr. Emmons testified that about 80% of the students at North Valley are designated as SED and approximately 40% are designated mentally retarded or learning disabled. Mr. Emmons testified that he read the CHC assessment report regarding STUDENT. Based on that information, he concluded that about six to nine students at North Valley have cognitive profiles similar to STUDENT. All the students have some behavioral problems and there are students identified with TS and ADHD. Mr. Emmons testified that North Valley follows the state framework curriculum toward meeting the requirements for high school graduation. Students are assessed at the end of each quarter of instruction, and parents and teachers conference on the student's achievement. The program also has a day treatment program for students with mental illnesses. This program was not currently being recommended for STUDENT. Mr. Emmons testified that the average stay at North Valley for students who are not significantly emotionally disturbed is 16 to 18 months. Mr. Emmons testified that the students' employment rate is very good and that 30% of the students who have attended North Valley are employed two years after graduating from high school. Mr. Emmons testified that North Valley offers students a predictable, structured, and consistent environment that is designed to put students in control of their behaviors.
A primary goal for at North Valley is to help the students become "employable." To reach that goal, the school creates an environment that teaches the students and allows them to practice behavior that is expected by employers. Those skills include communication, problem solving, working in groups, appropriate social skills, and punctuality. Students have the opportunity to practice the skills at jobs within the school, in community service work, and at paid jobs in the community. Community services work includes collecting samples and providing data to the county's water quality program, building a hiking trail, planting for an erosion control program, and working at a tree farm.
Mr. Emmons testified that the students progress through a level system and their behavior is charted daily. The students receive "logical and natural" consequences for their behavior. In his opinion, students need to learn appropriate behavior and to be accountable for their behavior to develop self-esteem and to be successful in the real world. Mr. Emmons testified that physical restraint of students occurs only if the student attacks someone and there is imminent chance of injury. Mr. Emmons described general intervention steps employed by North Valley staff. If the student is acting inappropriately or disrupting the class, the first step is "planned ignoring" so that the student is not given attention for misbehaving. If the student's behavior does not stop, a staff persons gets in closer proximity to the student. The next step is for the staff person to verbally redirect the student. The student is then informed that he/she is not earning points while the misbehavior continues. The student is next warned that if the misbehavior does not stop, he/she will be sent to time-out. If the misbehavior continues, the student is told to go to time-out. If the student has not responded in 30 seconds, two staff members escort the student to the time-out. When the student has determined a better way to deal with his/her behavior, the student returns to class. Mr. Emmons testified that some students go to time-out on their own to "vent" until they have learned better techniques to control their behavior. Students' work and behavior are evaluated hourly including time on task, quality and quantity of work, participation, following instruction and rules, peer relationships, and acceptance of direction by the staff. The students are on a level system with one being the lowest level and four the highest level. Each level has accompanying rewards, and points accumulated daily are rewarded with school currency. Even a student who earns only one point receives a commensurate amount of school currency. Mr. Emmons testified that any day a student is on level three, the student may spend his earnings at the school store which has low fat treats and other items requested by the students. Mr. Emmons testified that every Friday the school has an assembly at which students of the week and month are honored, all students who have demonstrated positive behavior are praised, students who earn paychecks are noted, and at which there is a drawing for credit at the student store from among all of the students who have achieved level 4 status.
Mr. Emmons testified that the recommendations of Ms. Guterman in the CHC report and the IEP goals and objectives could all be implemented at North Valley. A speech therapist is available weekly at North Valley and OT could be provided by contracting with the District or the COE. Mr. Emmons testified that nothing in the CHC report indicates that STUDENT requires a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan; however, if an individual plan is necessary to meet STUDENT's needs, Mr. Emmons testified that it would be carefully developed after gathering qualitative and quantitative information regarding STUDENT's behavior, antecedents and consequences of his behavior, and then determining what motivates STUDENT. Mr. Emmons testified that if STUDENT's behavior puts others at risk or is very disruptive to the program, Mr. Emmons would provide STUDENT the opportunity to remove himself to a "time-out" room where he would remain just long enough to figure out what he did and how he could better deal with it. Mr. Emmons testified that a staff person is always "on duty" in the time-out room when a student is there and that students generally spend five to ten minutes in the time-out room. Mr. Emmons tesified that one-to-one supervision to coach STUDENT could be available, if necessary, until he is able to function independently in the classroom. Mr. Emmons testified that a one-to-one aide would not be helpful if the aide served as a "buffer" for STUDENT. Mr. Emmons testified that from what he knows about STUDENT, he would propose that STUDENT receive three to four periods of instruction focusing on his relative academic strengths and weaknesses and that he work two periods in some sort of community service.
Mr. Emmons testified that one of STUDENT's former BETA specialists contacted him a few days before the hearing to inquire about employment at North Valley, where he had previously worked. The person told Mr. Emmons that he was frustrated with the program for STUDENT because he was not able to set limits on his behavior and that he thought North Valley would be a good placement for STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Is STUDENT appropriately identified as a student who is seriously emotionallydisturbed (SED) or should his special education eligibility criteria be changed to mildly to moderately mentally retarded?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); California Education Code § 56000. "Children with disabilities" includes children who are mentally retarded and children who, because of a serious emotional disturbance, require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A); California Education Code § 56026(a-b). The educational definition of a student with mental retardation is "a pupil has significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive functioning and manifested during the developmental period." Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030 (h). The federal regulations implementing IDEA set forth at 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9) the criteria that must be met to satisfy eligibility for special education because of a serious emotional disturbance:
(I) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance-- (A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; (D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal of school problems. (ii) The term includes children who are schizophrenic. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.
California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be "exhibited in several situations." Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(I).
STUDENT contends that his eligibility criteria for special education should be changed from SED to mental retardation based on the results of the CHC assessment. The District contends that STUDENT is appropriately designated as seriously emotionally disturbed.
STUDENT's disabilities are complex and he is not easily placed in one particular eligibility criteria. He has been given numerous diagnoses, including learning disabled, SED, conduct disordered, and recently, mentally retarded. STUDENT also has organic brain damage, ADHD and TS. For purposes of special education eligibility, STUDENT has been designed SED and learning disabled. The initial determination of SED was made in 1987. STUDENT was eligible for AB 3632 services based on his SED diagnosis in 1989 by County Mental Health. Langley-Porter assessors found that STUDENT suffered from severely impaired reality testing. (Petitioner's Exhibits page 180) Langley-Porter also recognized STUDENT's limited intellectual ability but did not give him a diagnosis of mental retardation. STUDENT has been hospitalized at least four times at Sun Ridge for behavioral outbursts and has been diagnosed with depression.
As to whether STUDENT continues to meet eligibility criteria for special education because of a serious emotional disturbance, the testimony of everyone who has worked with STUDENT establishes that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. He also demonstrates inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances as testified to by District staff and supported by voluminous records of his behavior at school, at the YMCA, and at other locations in the community. Some examples of STUDENT's behavior include going into a rage when it is time to go home with his mother or a BETA specialist. He has also become so agitated with the noise made by another student that he assaulted his one-to-one specialist. STUDENT was given a diagnosis of depression by Langley-Porter. CHC assessors and other persons working with STUDENT related incidents of his general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Ms. Rulifson described STUDENT's tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. There is no dispute that STUDENT's severe behavioral problems have existed over a long period of time and are observed at home, in the community, and at school. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT continues to qualify for special education because of a serious emotional disturbance under the criteria set forth above.
District witnesses uniformly testified that STUDENT is not mentally retarded. These witnesses included school psychologist, Mr. Bishop, who assessed STUDENT in 1994; Ms. Fourre, another psychologist who has worked with STUDENT since 1994; Ms. Hatch, STUDENT's classroom teacher for three years; Ms. Emmons, his RSP teacher during the summer of 1996; and his two independent study teachers. The District witnesses concluded that STUDENT is not mentally retarded based on their firsthand knowledge of STUDENT and his demonstrated abilities to read, write, communicate, learn information, and think abstractly. The witnesses testified that STUDENT's ability to read is more than simply the rote task of decoding words or a splinter skill as described by CHC. District witnesses testified that STUDENT is able to understand and enjoy what he reads. It has been reported that STUDENT independently reads at home for pleasure. District witnesses also testified that it is highly unusual for a student to obtain scores on tests of academic achievement that are higher than the student's scores on measures of cognitive ability. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Comings described STUDENT as "bright" and that mental retardation was not included in the diagnoses given by Sun Ridge or by Langley-Porter, where STUDENT was hospitalized for extended periods. Moreover, independent assessors, as well as District assessors, have found that STUDENT's cognitive abilities fall within the borderline or above range. ( For example, see the results of an assessment done in 1990 by Mary Cunningham, Ph.D.) Dr. Cunningham's report states that STUDENT's cognitive abilities fell in the borderline range of functioning. She concluded that STUDENT met eligibility criteria as SLD and that his behavioral problems were a direct result of his organic impairment. (Petitioner's Exhibits pages 198-212)
The only assessment placing STUDENT in the mild to moderate mentally retarded range is the recent CHC assessment. Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT should be viewed first as a young man with mental retardation and secondarily as one with behavioral problems. However, CHC's assessment also shows that STUDENT performed significantly higher on measures of academic achievement than would be expected given the scores CHC obtained on measures of his cognitive ability. STUDENT's scores in reading, spelling, story construction, and word attack exceed his cognitive abilities. His receptive and expressive language scores also fell above CHC's measure of STUDENT's cognitive abilities.
Some of the reasons STUDENT's scores on CHC testing were lower may be attributed to the medication he was taking (testimony of Dr. Guterman), the anxiety he expressed (testimony of Ms. Rulifson and Mr. Bishop), and the fact that all students have scored seven points lower on the WIS-III than they did on the WISC-R (testimony of Mr. Bishop). Additionally, STUDENT has been assessed a significant number of times and each assessment has found that his cognitive abilities fall above the mentally retarded range. STUDENT performs academic tasks, especially reading, at levels that are higher than expected for a student with mental retardation. Moreover, STUDENT is seen by all of the witnesses who have worked with him as having cognitive abilities higher than reported by CHC. All of these reasons support the conclusion that the scores obtained by Dr. Guterman were depressed. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the consistency of prior testing and the testimony of a number of witnesses who have worked with STUDENT for the past three years that STUDENT's designation should not be changed to mental retardation.
Although it is not necessary to change STUDENT's special education eligibility designation, it is important for the IEP team to recognize the complexity of STUDENT's disabilities and to take all of his needs into consideration when developing an appropriate program for him.
ISSUE NO. 2: Have the District and the COE failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services. STUDENT's scores have fallen more consistently in the borderline range of intellectual functioning.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Special education law also requires that a student is educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.
To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, comport with the IEP, and must also be provided in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 5)
The first requirement of an appropriate placement is that the instruction and services must be designed to meet the unique and individual needs of the student. The psychologists and psychiatrists who assessed STUDENT from 1993 to 1994--Mr. Bishop, who conducted STUDENT's triennial assessment, Dr. Shiro, STUDENT's treating psychiatrist, and Dr. Comings, an expert in TS--generally made similar recommendations regarding STUDENT's educational needs. Their recommendations included: a small, highly structured class; a consistent and predictable routine; behavioral intervention strategies; a staff person to support STUDENT and to help him learn to control his behavior; appropriate academic instruction with modifications that include allowing STUDENT to make choices; social skills training; and an isolated location where STUDENT can gain control of his behavior. (STUDENT's Exhibits pages 109, 131, 134, 152, 163; 348-375; and testimony of Mr. Bishop)
The evidence establishes that to meet these recommendations, the District took a number of steps during the spring of the 1995 school year, including developing a transition plan to gradually transition STUDENT back into Ms. Hatch's class; providing staff training; hiring aides; providing choices for STUDENT; designating a quiet area or other activity to allow STUDENT to gain control over his behavior; implementing Dr. Detrich's behavioral intervention plan; providing social skills training; and providing reinforcers for good behavior; (Petitioner's Exhibits 383-384; testimony of Mr. Bishop; Dr. Detrich; Ms. Hatch; and Ms. Dougan.) Ms. Hatch and Ms. Dougan also testified that they provided STUDENT with appropriate academic instruction and made numerous modifications to the classroom and curriculum to address STUDENT's needs. The District also obtained an additional behavioral intervention plan from Dr. Marone. Of the persons who had observed STUDENT in Ms. Hatch's class, only Dr. Detrich expressed some concerns about the way in which the program was implemented. It appears from listening to the tape of Dr. Detrich's testimony, that his concern about STUDENT's program in Ms. Hatch's class was limited to whether certain curriculum modifications had been made appropriately. He specifically noted that STUDENT seemed to have difficulty and become agitated when asked to do paper and pencil tasks.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of the classroom teacher, the aide, and other school personnel who regularly observed the program provided for STUDENT that the District provided to STUDENT a program designed to meet his needs. As to whether STUDENT should have been asked to participate in fewer paper and pencil tasks, the Hearing Officer notes that records of STUDENT's behavioral problems provide more than adequate documentation that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior occurs in a variety of settings and when engaged in a great variety of activities. For example, Mr. Schoonover and Mr. Brewer described STUDENT's agitation and out-of-control behavior when engaging in a recreation activity. Mr. Taylor and other witnesses described STUDENT's acting out behavior when he did not want to go home with a particular person. Ms. Fourre compiled a record of the time and place and activities in which STUDENT's misbehavior occurred while he was placed at Live Oak. Her testimony establishes that the misbehaviors occurred while STUDENT was engaged in a great variety of activities. Therefore, based on all of the evidence regarding STUDENT's behavior, the Hearing Officer concludes that the fact that STUDENT may have been asked to participate in paper and paper tasks does not render an appropriate placement inappropriate.
The evidence establishes that the program was also designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. During 1993 and 1994 STUDENT was hospitalized a number of times and his school attendance was sporadic. He also has a long history of behavioral problems which, according to the testimony of Ms. Hatch and Ms. Dougan, were escalating at school. The transition plan was designed to help facilitate STUDENT's gradual re-entry into a school program with the goal of his attending school on a regular and full-time basis. The behavioral intervention plan and the additional services provided by the two aides were designed to improve STUDENT's behavior so that he would be able to remain in school and to participate in the educational curriculum. Ms. Hatch testified extensively regarding the modifications that she made to the physical design of the classroom, to STUDENT's academic plan, to the behavioral program, and to positive reinforcers for STUDENT. Ms. Hatch, Dr. Detrich, and Ms. Dougan all testified persuasively that staff training was designed to provide additional information to the staff so that they could better understand STUDENT and so that they could implement the behavioral intervention plan. All of the steps described above were taken to improve STUDENT's ability to participate successfully in school and, thereby, allow him to benefit from his education.
There is no dispute that the instruction, services, program, and placement provided by the District comport with STUDENT's IEP. There also is no dispute that during the spring of the 1994-1995 school year, Ms. Hatch's SDC was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. His sporadic school attendance and his academic and behavioral needs precluded him from placement in a regular class with supplementary services. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's placement from the time of the prior hearing decision until the end of the 1994-1995 school year comports with STUDENT's IEP, was designed to meet his needs and to allow him to receive educational benefit, and, therefore, was appropriate.
STUDENT had continue to exhibit behavioral problems toward the end of school and during the summer. Because the parent expressed concerns about continuing with the behavioral program designed by Spectrum, the District agreed to contract with another nonpublic agency--BETA--to provide services for STUDENT. After the District filed for a due process hearing, the parties agreed to place STUDENT at Dynamics, a nonpublic school located in Redding. Dynamics is a small school with approximately 60 students. The students who attend Dynamics have not been successful in a larger school setting. A credentialed special education teacher with a great deal of experience in teaching in public school is available to meet the academic needs of the special education students. When STUDENT entered Dynamics, it appeared that the components of an appropriate placement were in place. Mr. Taylor, Mr. Bishop, and others testified that Dynamics has a good reputation for working with students with difficult behaviors. Mr. Taylor testified that he has been successful with "his" students and that the District refers many students to dynamics. The District also funded a one-to-one "implementation specialist" from BETA to attend school with STUDENT, and a new behavioral intervention plan with goals and objectives developed by Dr. Marone of BETA were included in STUDENT's IEP. The IEP also contained goals and objectives to address STUDENT's academic needs. The Hearing Officer finds that placement at Dynamics with a one-to-one specialist and a behavioral intervention plan was consistent with recommendations of the persons who have assessed STUDENT and was designed to address his most significant needs at that time--to be in a small school environment with a program to meet his academic and behavioral needs. The provision of a one-to-one aide was also consistent with recommendations made by the assessors and meets the need for STUDENT to have someone available to help learn to get his behavior under control.
As to whether the placement was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, the testimony of all of the witnesses establishes that in order for STUDENT to be successful in school, it was necessary for his behavior to be under better control. To improve STUDENT's behavior, a one-to-one specialist from BETA was provided by a contract between BETA and the District. The specialist helped to focus STUDENT to task, to provide him choices of activities, to help him identify when he was becoming agitated or losing control, and to generally support his placement in an educational environment. STUDENT has continued to have deficits in academic areas and requires special education instruction and modification to the curriculum and instructional methodology to benefit from his instruction. According to the testimony of Mr. Taylor and Mr. Barber, all of these components were available at Dynamics. Mr. Taylor testified that his wife, Ms. Taylor, is a special education teacher and the BETA specialist also was available to make modifications to the educational program to meet STUDENT's needs. The small, structured program as described by Mr. Taylor and Mr. Barber also was designed to help STUDENT reach the goal of improving his behavior so that he would be able to be educated at the public school. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the program provided at Dynamics was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
There is no dispute that the placement comported with STUDENT's IEP. As to whether Dynamics offered the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, the evidence established that STUDENT had not achieved success while attending school in the larger middle school environment. Numerous assessors and STUDENT's teachers had recommended that he be placed in a small, structured educational environment. Based on STUDENT's lack of success in a public school environment prior to his placement at Dynamics, the Hearing Officer finds that the nonpublic school provided the appropriate level of restrctiveness for STUDENT at that time. It is noted also that STUDENT was represented by counsel when it was agreed that he would be placed in a nonpublic school with one-to-one assistance provided by a BETA specialist. The parties also specifically agreed to Dynamics. Therefore, because the placement was designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit, conformed to his IEP, and also meets LRE requirements, the Hearing Officer concludes that Dynamics with one-to-one services provided by BETA was an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Unfortunately, a behavioral incident resulted in Dynamics' refusal to continue providing services to STUDENT. At the request of STUDENT's parent, and with some reluctance on the part of the District, STUDENT's placement for the remainder of the school year was independent study with one-to-one instruction provided by BETA specialists. The services were provided individually, the educational program was designed by a credentialed teacher from the District, and the behavioral program was under the guidance of BETA. Larry Douglass testified on behalf of STUDENT regarding the importance of providing him with positive behavioral intervention. Dr. Marone of BETA testified that the BETA specialists provided positive support for STUDENT.Based on the difficulty STUDENT encountered during the two previous attempts to educate STUDENT in a school placement, the Hearing Officer concludes that the provision of a positive and individualized program was designed to meet his needs at that time. While on independent study, STUDENT received academic instruction and behavioral support. The ultimate goal was to provide sufficient positive support so that STUDENT could be returned to a less restrictive placement and, therefore, the program was designed to provide him with educational benefit.
STUDENT's next placement was at Live Oak during the summer of 1996. As to whether the summer school program at Live Oak offered STUDENT an appropriate placement, it must first be determined whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT's need. The Live Oak program STUDENT attended was designed for students who are transitioning from a restrictive placement to a less restrictive placement. According to the testimony of Ms. Fourre, Ms. Emmons, and Mr. Barber, students having behavioral or other problems that resulted in residential or other restrictive placements are placed in the Live Oak transition class when they are ready to begin transitioning to a public school placement. The program at Live Oak has a level system monitoring the students' behavior. When a student achieves the highest level and is able to sustain himself or herself at that level for a certain period of time, the student is able to leave the program for a less restrictive program. According to everyone who testified regarding STUDENT's needs, at the time he was placed at Live Oak, he continued to require individual support to help him learn to gain control over his behavior and special education instruction to meet his academic needs, particularly in mathematics. At Live Oak, STUDENT's BETA specialist provided him with one-to-one instruction and support, particularly to implement positive behavioral programming. The RSP teacher, Ms. Emmons, testified that she provided direct instruction to STUDENT, monitored his educational program, and consulted and collaborated with the teacher regarding meeting STUDENT's goals and objectives and academic needs. The placement also offered a structured environment with a small number of students. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Live Oak was designed to meet STUDENT's individual needs.
To be appropriate, the program also must also have been designed to provide him with educational benefit Ms. Fourre and others testified that one of STUDENT's needs was to improve his behavior, particularly so that he could be educated in a school setting. The program at Live Oak provided special education instruction to allow him to progress academically in his areas of deficit. STUDENT's placement at Live Oak was designed to provide him with successful experiences in a structured environment with behavioral support and academic instruction so that he could be educated in an SDC on a comprehensive high school campus. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement was designed to allow STUDENT to benefit from his instruction. There is no dispute that the placement conformed with STUDENT's IEP. Because STUDENT had been receiving one-to-one instruction for an extended period of time and had not participated in an educational program on a school campus since the fall of 1995, the Hearing Officer finds that Live Oak was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT at that time.
STUDENT was not precluded from attending Live Oak; however, Ms. PARENT removed him from Live Oak in July 1996. Because the parties were unable to agree on another school placement for STUDENT, the District resumed STUDENT's one-to-one program with BETA. Ms. Scholz, the current curriculum coordinator for the independent study program, testified that she provides materials and scripted lessons in math, reading, writing, language, social studies, science, and basic skills. Ms. Dougan performed similar tasks when she was the independent study teacher. The program is designed to be provided for five hours daily; however, because of a dispute between the District and BETA (BETA unilaterally discontinued providing STUDENT's services in the middle of November), STUDENT has not received the services to which he is entitled for a period of time. The District initially provided a credentialed substitute teacher to implement the program for STUDENT. Ms. PARENT then delivered the program with direction from Ms. Scholz. BETA provided another specialist in April, who began meeting with STUDENT on a limited basis. Apparently there was a planned transition period to allow the BETA specialist and STUDENT to become familiar with each other and to allow STUDENT to gradually get accustomed to a longer instructional period. STUDENT has also not received APE services called for in his IEP. Because of the lack of services for STUDENT during the period from November 16, 1996, until BETA resumed a full-time program for STUDENT sometime after April 1997, (excluding the period Roger Schoonover was providing services to STUDENT), STUDENT did not receive an appropriate education.
ISSUE NO. 3: Does STUDENT require the services provided by the Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) or a similar program to benefit from his education?
The District and/or the COE may be required to provide STUDENT with individual services from BETA if the instruction and services are necessary for him to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Education Code § 56363.
The determination of whether STUDENT requires the services provided by BETA must be made in light of the fact that STUDENT will be enrolled in North Valley pursuant to the decision below in Issue No. 7. North Valley has a low student-to-teacher ratio and a behavioral component that is already in place. On the other hand, STUDENT has not been in an educational setting for a number of years and one-to-one behavioral intervention and academic support has been recommended by STUDENT's former teacher, by Mr. Douglass, and by CHC. The Hearing Officer accepts their recommendations that STUDENT requires one-to-one support, particularly when transitioning to a new program, since it is well documented that transitions are difficult for him. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires one-to-one support to transition to North Valley for at least 60 days after his placement is made. As to whether the services must be provided by BETA, the choice of an NPA to provide one-to-one services is at the discretion of the District.
ISSUE NO. 4: Does STUDENT require speech and language therapy to benefit from his education?
The District and/or the COE may be required to provide STUDENT with the DIS of speech and language therapy if the services are necessary for him to benefit educationally. Education Code § 56363. Neither Ms. Cunningham, the only speech and language therapist to testify, nor any of the other witnesses testified that STUDENT requires DIS speech and language therapy to benefit from his education. Testing administered by Ms. Cunningham of the CHC did identify deficits in auditory processing, pragmatic skills, thinking abstractly about language, and making inferences; however, Ms. Cunningham testified that STUDENT would not qualify for speech and language therapy based solely on the results of her testing. Moreover, to address the deficits she identified, Ms. Cunningham recommended that a speech and language therapist collaborate with STUDENT's teacher regarding the implications of his deficits in the classroom setting. CHC adopted her recommendation and did not recommend DIS speech and language therapy. A prior speech and language assessment by the District, as well as the testimony of numerous witnesses, establishes that expressive language is a strength for STUDENT and, therefore, there is no evidence that he requires speech and language therapy in the area of expressive language. The evidence also is not persuasive that STUDENT requires therapy to address "imprecise" articulation. Ms. Cunningham testified that STUDENT's speech is understandable and that therapy to address articulation at this time would not be beneficial. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENT requires speech and language therapy to benefit from his education.
ISSUE NO. 5: Does STUDENT require occupational therapy to benefit from his education?
The District and/or the COE may be required to provide STUDENT with OT if the services are required to allow him to benefit from his education. Education Code § 56363. Winifred Schultz-Krohn, OTR, testified that STUDENT has significant deficits in both motor and sensory processing abilities and concluded that STUDENT requires OT to address these deficits. Specifically, Ms. Schultz-Krohn recommended OT on a consultative basis to both the school and to home. In the report of her assessment, Ms. Schultz-Krohn stated that OT consultation is needed "to provide suggestions regarding dexterity and motor planning skills related to functional daily living tasks. Occupational Therapy consultation should also address the selection of activities within STUDENT' pre-vocational and vocational program that will foster dexterity and in-hand manipulation. Occupational therapy consultation should also address environmental modifications necessary to the pre-vocational and vocational training program." (STUDENT's Exhibits page 79) The CHC team adopted the recommendations of Ms. Schultz-Krohn. Ms. Schultz-Krohn was the only occupational therapist to testify at the hearing and none of the other witnesses contradicted her recommendations. Moreover, in the closing argument of the District and the COE, Mr. Roice stated that there is no dispute on this issue and that STUDENT's IEP dated March 21, 1996, which was agreed to by the parties, calls for OT. (District's Exhibit 46) (Footnote 6) Therefore, based on the undisputed testimony of Ms. Schultz-Krohn, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to have consultative OT provided for by the District and the COE.
ISSUE NO. 6: Is the District or the COE required to pay for STUDENT's dental work to replace his front teeth?
STUDENT contends that the District or the COE is required to pay for his dental work to replace his missing front teeth so that his speech will be more intelligible and so that he will be more employable. The District and the COE contend that they are not required to pay for replacement teeth for STUDENT because medical costs are not services for which an educational agency is responsible.
The list of related services set forth in Education Code § 56363(b) does not include dental work; however, the list is not exhaustive and a student may be entitled to services that are not listed when those services are necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Federal special education law specifically excludes medical services from the list of services that an educational agency may be required to provide unless those services are for diagnostic and evaluation purposes. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363.1 also states that "a district, special education local plan area, or county office is not required to purchase medical equipment for an individual pupil." There was no evidence that replacing teeth is anything other than a medical procedure or that it is a diagnostic or evaluative procedure. Moreover, Ms. Cunningham, CHC speech and language pathologist, who testified that STUDENT's articulation skills are "imprecise" and that he may be made the "brunt" of jokes by his peers because of his missing teeth, also testified that STUDENT's speech is understandable. Neither Ms. Cunningham nor any other witness testified that replacing STUDENT's missing front teeth is necessary to allow him to benefit rom his education. Because replacing teeth is a medical procedure and is not necessary to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education, neither the District nor the COE is required to fund the procedure. Therefore, STUDENT's request that the District or the COE pay for STUDENT's dental work is denied.
ISSUE NO. 7: Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Pursuant to Rowley and the IDEA, an appropriate placement must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, be designed to provide the student with educational benefit, and comport with the student's IEP. The placement must also satisfy least restrictive environment requirements.
The most recent assessment of STUDENT was completed in January 1997 by CHC. (See STUDENT's Exhibits pages 39-79) The results of testing revealed significant deficits in math skills and deficits in reading and writing. STUDENT's adaptive and social skills are also delayed. He functions at about a six- or seven-year-old level and able to do some daily living skills independently and requiring assistance with others such as tying his shoes. District witnesses did not dispute STUDENT's functional levels. During testimony and in the assessment report, CHC assessors made recommendations for meeting STUDENT's educational needs. CHC's recommendations include placing STUDENT in a small, structured, socially safe classroom with a low student-to-teacher ratio, one-to-one teaching, and with students of similar cognitive functioning. Ms. Rulifson concluded that to be appropriate the curriculum should be functional and address prevocational and functional living skills. Language, reading, writing, and mathematics should be centered on this functional curriculum. (Testimony of Ms. Rulifson, Ms. Amber, and Dr. Guterman; STUDENT's Exhibits page 45) Ms. Rulifson testified that STUDENT's education should focus on functionally-based real-life skills and prevocational training. Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT requires a small, self-contained, highly structured, and predictable placement. The recommendations of District witnesses were very similar. In general, all of the witnesses made similar recommendations regarding STUDENT's educational needs. The recommendations of the District and STUDENT's witnesses primarily differed on the issue of the appropriate amount of focus to place on addressing STUDENT's behavioral needs. CHC assessors expressed the opinion that when STUDENT receives academic instruction at a level commensurate with his abilities, his behavioral problems will diminish. District witnesses generally testified that STUDENT's primary need is to gain control over his inappropriate behavior. For example, Ms. Dougan, who was STUDENT's independent study teacher until December 1996, testified that STUDENT's primary need is to get his behaviors under control. The Hearing Officer gives more weight to District witnesses on the issue of the need to provide STUDENT with a program focusing on behavioral issues because the District witnesses have been directly involved in providing an educational program for STUDENT, whereas witnesses from CHC have only met STUDENT in a testing environment and have neither observed him in an educational environment nor provided him with direct services.
Therefore, based on the recommendations as discussed above, it is concluded that STUDENT requires a small, structured and consistent placement with a low student-to-teacher ratio and opportunities for one-to-one instruction. STUDENT's program must also provide consistent and positive behavioral intervention that will help him gain control over his behavior, academic instruction at an appropriate level, and curriculum that includes development of functional living and prevocational skills.
Turning to the first requirement of an appropriate placement--whether North Valley is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs--CHC assessors did not offer any opinion regarding North Valley. The testimony of Mr. Emmons, principal of North Valley, Ms. Dougan, and Ms. Fourre, establishes that North Valley offers a program designed to meet STUDENT's needs. The school has a low student-to-teacher ratio. Each class of about 12 students has a teacher and two aides. North Valley offers academic instruction and places a great deal of emphasis on development of real life skills and skills that are necessary to become employed. Mr. Emmons provided extensive testimony regarding the vocational component of the program. The teachers at North Valley are credentialed, and all the staff have received training in implementing behavioral interventions. Based on the observations of witnesses, it is concluded that the program at North Valley would provide a consistent behavioral intervention program that is predictable and highly structured. The student population at North Valley includes students with cognitive skills similar to STUDENT's. All of the students have failed at prior placements, just as STUDENT has failed at his prior school placements. All the students have behavioral needs. One of the concerns expressed by many witnesses was the need for coordination between home and school. North Valley provides ongoing feedback and contact with the parent to help them provide consistent behavioral strategies in the home environment. Based on the North Valley provided by Mr. Emmons and District witnesses who have observed North Valley, the Hearing Officer finds that the program is designed to meet STUDENT's needs and conforms with the recommendations of CHC assessors.
Mr. Douglass observed at North Valley on behalf of STUDENT and concluded that it may not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. His primary concern was whether the behavioral program offers sufficient positive support for STUDENT and whether he would spend too much time in "time-out" for behavior that is a manifestation of his disability. Ms. Fourre, who also observed at North Valley, testified that she observed a great deal of positive interaction between staff and students. She observed teachers praising students. Mr. Emmons also testified persuasively regarding the ways in which students receive positive support. Students at North Valley receive ongoing monitoring and rewards for positive behavior. They may earn school money that entitles them to purchase items at the school store. They also receive certain privileges based on maintaining appropriate behavior and are praised at weekly assemblies. The Hearing Officer finds that North Valley's behavioral program will provide positive support for STUDENT.
The second requirement for an appropriate placement is that it must be designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. STUDENT's programs in the past have attempted to meet his needs so that he will benefit educationally. The programs have each focused primarily on one element of his needs. For example, improving his behavior or providing him with individual instruction. North Valley offers a program designed to address all of STUDENT's needs--behavioral, academic, social, and vocational--and is a safe, structured environment. With all of the components in place, including ongoing parental involvement, the Hearing Officer finds that North Valley is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
The final requirement of an appropriate placement is that it must comport with STUDENT's IEP. The last agreed-upon goals and objectives for STUDENT call for improvement of reading, math, word comprehension, written language, number concepts and computation, APE, and behavior. These goals and objectives continue to be generally designed to address STUDENT's deficits. Placement at North Valley comports with the IEP in that instruction is available in all of the academic areas, and North Valley provides a behavioral intervention program to meet behavioral goals. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that placement offered by the District comports with STUDENT's IEP; however, because STUDENT's goals and objectives were last revised in September 1995, it is necessary that the goals and objectives be revised by the IEP team to reflect the results of contemporary assessment information.
As to whether North Valley offers the least restrictive placement for STUDENT, witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT and the District all agree that STUDENT needs to return to a school environment. It is STUDENT's position that he should be placed on a comprehensive high school campus. The testimony of District witnesses, which was not disputed, establishes that Central Valley, a comprehensive high school campus, has a large student population of over 1,000 students. The program requested by STUDENT would require his moving to a number of classes located in different wings of the campus. He would not always be with the same students because some of the classes requested on his behalf would be within the RSP program and others would be in the SDC program. CHC and all of the persons who have worked with STUDENT testified that he has difficulty making transitions. In fact, the first behavioral intervention program developed for STUDENT specifically targeted strategies for his successful transition from lunch to the classroom. Dr. Guterman of CHC testified that a placement requiring STUDENT to change classes would not be appropriate. Moreover, his prior three placements in an educational setting were not successful. Finally, a number of District witnesses that have provided services to STUDENT testified that to place him on a comprehensive high school campus would be "setting him up for failure." The testimony of these witnesses, including Ms. Fourre, and Ms. Dougan, must be given considerable weight because they have worked with STUDENT and have observed him in several different school placements. The Hearing Officer notes that North Valley is located within Redding, STUDENT's city of residence. Based on STUDENT's last unsuccessful experience on a comprehensive school campus and the fact that he has not been in any structured educational program for over one year, the Hearing Officer finds that the least restrictive environment for STUDENT at this time is North Valley.
Because North Valley is designed to meet STUDENT's needs and to provide him with educational benefit and also satisfies least restrictive environment requirements, the Hearing Officer concludes that placement at North Valley is appropriate for STUDENT.
ISSUE NO. 8: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
The Supreme Court in Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358, determined that parents may be entitled to compensation for expenses they have incurred in educating their child when the school district failed to provide their child with an appropriate education. In this case, STUDENT's parent is not seeking monetary reimbursement for services she provided. Another form of relief for denial of appropriate special education services is compensatory education. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F3d 1489. (See also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(2)). STUDENT contends that he is entitled to compensatory education because of the District's failure to provide him with an appropriate education. (Footnote 7)
The request for compensatory education on behalf of STUDENT was made on several grounds. First, it is asserted that STUDENT did not receive an appropriate education because the District misidentified him as a seriously emotionally disturbed student rather than a student with mental retardation. District witnesses all testified that STUDENT is not mentally retarded. Most of these witnesses have worked with STUDENT directly and over a period of time. Moreover, until CHC, numerous assessors from the District, as well as independent assessors, have reached the same conclusion that STUDENT is SED and is not mentally retarded. STUDENT is a young man with many diagnoses and many needs. The District cannot now be faulted for relying on the one consistent finding by many professionals that STUDENT is SED. The second ground for seeking compensatory education is the District's failure to provide a special education teacher for STUDENT. During the fourth, fifth, and sixth grades, STUDENT was placed in Ms. Hatch's SDC. When STUDENT was placed at Dynamics and at Live Oak, there were special education teachers assigned to work with him. While STUDENT has received one-to-one services through BETA, the District provided a credentialed teacher to direct the program and to meet weekly with the BETA specialist and STUDENT. There was no evidence that the District teacher failed to perform those duties. Moreover, from the testimony of a number of District witnesses, including Ms. Fourre, it was BETA and not the District that placed restrictions on the District employees' contact with BETA and STUDENT. For example, the summer school agreement pertaining to STUDENT's placement at Live Oak sets out BETA's position regarding who would provide the services to STUDENT. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT contradicted the testimony of District witnesses.
Much of STUDENT's education has taken place through the independent study program at the request of Ms. PARENT and through mediated agreements. (See STUDENT's Exhibits page 623) At least one nonpublic school placement was made in agreement with STUDENT's prior counsel. The evidence establishes that the District has made attempts to continue providing STUDENT with an appropriate education and hired BETA at the request of the parent and counsel. The Hearing Officer notes that the parent and current counsel continue to request services for STUDENT from BETA and it is disingenuous of them to complain now that the placement and program provided by the District through BETA were inappropriate. The Hearing Officer notes also that the BETA program became STUDENT's stay-put placement, that Ms. PARENT pulled STUDENT out of his last appropriate school placement, and that the parties were unable to agree on an alternative placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures.
It was determined above that, except for a period of time when BETA was not providing services and the District had not employed the substitute teacher, STUDENT has been offered an appropriate placement. The District has made ongoing efforts to provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT, whose many varying disabilities, including a serious emotional disturbance, has extensive educational and behavioral needs. The Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is not an appropriate remedy, given all of the above circumstances. Moreover, North Valley offers a comprehensive program that is designed to meet STUDENT's needs and there was no evidence that STUDENT would benefit from additional services. Therefore, Petitioner's request for compensatory education is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Have the District and the COE failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE)? The District and the COE substantially prevailed on this issue.
(2) Is STUDENT appropriately identified as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) or should his special education eligibility criteria be changed to mildly to moderately mentally retarded? The District and the COE prevailed on this issue.
(3) Does STUDENT require the services provided by the Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) or a similar program to benefit from his education? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(4) Does STUDENT require speech and language therapy to benefit from his education? The District and the COE prevailed on this issue.
(5) Does STUDENT require occupational therapy to benefit from his education? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(6) Is the District or the COE required to pay for STUDENT's dental work to replace his front teeth? The District and the COE prevailed on this issue.
(7) Is the District's proposed placement at North Valley School an appropriate placement for STUDENT? The District and the COE prevailed on this issue.
(8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
The District and the COE prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to:
(a) draft an IEP document that reflects STUDENT's current functional levels as determined by the Children's Health Council's assessment;
(b) draft goals and objectives, including goals and objectives for APE and OT, based on STUDENT's current functional levels as determined by the Children's Health Council's assessment;
(c) develop a plan to transition STUDENT to North Valley; and (d) determine the level of consultative OT services STUDENT requires.
(2) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall place STUDENT at North Valley and shall provide him with APE, one-to-one intervention services, and consultative OT.
(3) The District shall continue to provide STUDENT with individual behavioral and academic support through BETA or a similar agency for a minimum of 60 days following his placement at North Valley.
(4) All other requests for relief are denied.
DATED: August 4, 1997 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Attorney Dale Mentink of Protection & Advocacy, Inc. represented STUDENT at the hearing in 1995.
2. Ms. Day replaced Ms. Bell as STUDENT's case manager during the course of the hearing.
3. STUDENT's adoptive father died when STUDENT was 18 months old.
4. A tape of Dr. Detrich's testimony was provided to the parties when the hearing reconvened in 1997. The Hearing Officer reviewed the tape of Dr. Detrich's testimony.
5. Because a decision regarding STUDENT's placement was made in February 1995 as the result of a special education due process hearing, this decision only addresses the provision of FAPE to STUDENT after February.
6. The IEP dated March 21, 1996, actually states that 12 sessions of OT would be provided over a two-month period and that STUDENT's need for ongoing OT would be evaluated at the end of the two months. There is no indication on subsequent IEP documents whether the District and/or the COE agreed to continue providing OT.
7. The Hearing Officer's decision in SN 880-94/884-94, which was rendered February 3, 1995, addressed the issue of STUDENT's entitlement to compensatory education. The Hearing Officer in that case determined that STUDENT was not entitled to compensatory education. This decision addresses STUDENT's entitlement to compensatory education for the period of time following the decision on February 3, 1995.
